Full Transcript
Read or copy the complete episode transcript.
people really feel that the system people really feel that the system doesn't work because it actually doesn't doesn't work because it actually doesn't doesn't work because it actually doesn't work. First of all, the stock market work. First of all, the stock market work. First of all, the stock market doesn't really have a whole lot to do doesn't really have a whole lot to do doesn't really have a whole lot to do with the economy. Anybody who's looks at with the economy. Anybody who's looks at with the economy. Anybody who's looks at the stock market and thinks it's telling the stock market and thinks it's telling the stock market and thinks it's telling you something [music] about the economy, you something [music] about the economy, you something [music] about the economy, you're being misled. So, for the entire you're being misled. So, for the entire you're being misled. So, for the entire 2010s and into the 2020s, we've been 2010s and into the 2020s, we've been 2010s and into the 2020s, we've been sitting here watching the US government sitting here watching the US government sitting here watching the US government get broker and broker and broker, get broker and broker and broker, get broker and broker and broker, stupider and stupider and stupider. stupider and stupider and stupider. stupider and stupider and stupider. >> From an investor standpoint, how do you >> From an investor standpoint, how do you >> From an investor standpoint, how do you think about this? Now, when I evaluate the economy right Now, when I evaluate the economy right now, I see distress despite the stock now, I see distress despite the stock now, I see distress despite the stock market hitting all-time highs. Now, I market hitting all-time highs. Now, I market hitting all-time highs. Now, I look primarily at US debt, money look primarily at US debt, money look primarily at US debt, money printing, inflation to build my printing, inflation to build my printing, inflation to build my thinking. But I know you have a thinking. But I know you have a thinking. But I know you have a different take on what really drives the different take on what really drives the different take on what really drives the economy. So, what signals do you look economy. So, what signals do you look economy. So, what signals do you look at? And when you look, do you see an at? And when you look, do you see an at? And when you look, do you see an economy in trouble right now? economy in trouble right now? economy in trouble right now? Yeah, I mean we've seen an economy Yeah, I mean we've seen an economy Yeah, I mean we've seen an economy that's been in trouble for quite some that's been in trouble for quite some that's been in trouble for quite some time and it looks like it's resilient time and it looks like it's resilient time and it looks like it's resilient simply because of the fact it hasn't simply because of the fact it hasn't simply because of the fact it hasn't fallen off. You know the it's either fallen off. You know the it's either fallen off. You know the it's either it's we're given an either or either the it's we're given an either or either the it's we're given an either or either the economy collapses tomorrow or everything economy collapses tomorrow or everything economy collapses tomorrow or everything must be fine and you know like anything must be fine and you know like anything must be fine and you know like anything else in life it's usually the truth is else in life it's usually the truth is else in life it's usually the truth is somewhere in the middle. So what I look somewhere in the middle. So what I look somewhere in the middle. So what I look at is I look at financial information I at is I look at financial information I at is I look at financial information I get u you know look at you know the get u you know look at you know the get u you know look at you know the yield curve is a good place to start but yield curve is a good place to start but yield curve is a good place to start but there are many other curves that are there are many other curves that are there are many other curves that are just as helpful and just as insightful. just as helpful and just as insightful. just as helpful and just as insightful. Now, someone who doesn't know the yield Now, someone who doesn't know the yield Now, someone who doesn't know the yield curve, if that's where you start, give curve, if that's where you start, give curve, if that's where you start, give me like a quick primer on that. me like a quick primer on that. me like a quick primer on that. >> The yield curve is nothing more than >> The yield curve is nothing more than >> The yield curve is nothing more than Treasury yields plotted in a line from Treasury yields plotted in a line from Treasury yields plotted in a line from from shortest maturity to longest from shortest maturity to longest from shortest maturity to longest maturity. What you normally want to see maturity. What you normally want to see maturity. What you normally want to see in a generally healthy environment or in a generally healthy environment or in a generally healthy environment or what's what's indicated to be a healthy what's what's indicated to be a healthy what's what's indicated to be a healthy environment is an upward sloping curve. environment is an upward sloping curve. environment is an upward sloping curve. Not steeply upward sloping, but somewhat Not steeply upward sloping, but somewhat Not steeply upward sloping, but somewhat upward sloping because that tells you upward sloping because that tells you upward sloping because that tells you the marketplace is thinking generally the marketplace is thinking generally the marketplace is thinking generally positive future. um money rates will be positive future. um money rates will be positive future. um money rates will be a little bit higher the further out in a little bit higher the further out in a little bit higher the further out in time you go which is what you would time you go which is what you would time you go which is what you would expect to happen in a financial system expect to happen in a financial system expect to happen in a financial system and if now if rates are nominally at a and if now if rates are nominally at a and if now if rates are nominally at a relatively decent level historic level relatively decent level historic level relatively decent level historic level with an upward sloping curve you think with an upward sloping curve you think with an upward sloping curve you think okay everything's good that's the okay everything's good that's the okay everything's good that's the marketplace saying I'm happy don't marketplace saying I'm happy don't marketplace saying I'm happy don't really want to own too many treasuries really want to own too many treasuries really want to own too many treasuries they got upward sloping which means they got upward sloping which means they got upward sloping which means higher rates in the future that's the higher rates in the future that's the higher rates in the future that's the base case ideal case if it doesn't look base case ideal case if it doesn't look base case ideal case if it doesn't look like that then you got to figure out why like that then you got to figure out why like that then you got to figure out why that is what is what is reshaping the that is what is what is reshaping the that is what is what is reshaping the curve or twisting and distorting it out curve or twisting and distorting it out curve or twisting and distorting it out of that ideal position. And it could be of that ideal position. And it could be of that ideal position. And it could be a number of different things. If we're a number of different things. If we're a number of different things. If we're going into an inflationary period, what going into an inflationary period, what going into an inflationary period, what you would expect to find is that the you would expect to find is that the you would expect to find is that the yield curve would steepen out, which is yield curve would steepen out, which is yield curve would steepen out, which is this gets into the interest rate this gets into the interest rate this gets into the interest rate fallacy. And what's contrary to most fallacy. And what's contrary to most fallacy. And what's contrary to most people's perceptions because they're people's perceptions because they're people's perceptions because they're what they're taught is that higher rates what they're taught is that higher rates what they're taught is that higher rates are restriction and therefore that's are restriction and therefore that's are restriction and therefore that's anti-inflation and lower rates are anti-inflation and lower rates are anti-inflation and lower rates are stimulus and therefore that's, you know, stimulus and therefore that's, you know, stimulus and therefore that's, you know, likely inflationary because you hear likely inflationary because you hear likely inflationary because you hear that all the time, the Fed lower rates, that all the time, the Fed lower rates, that all the time, the Fed lower rates, that's going to be inflationary. That's that's going to be inflationary. That's that's going to be inflationary. That's exactly the opposite. exactly the opposite. exactly the opposite. >> Okay, I bang that drum hard. So this is >> Okay, I bang that drum hard. So this is >> Okay, I bang that drum hard. So this is one of the reasons that you're so one of the reasons that you're so one of the reasons that you're so interesting to me. I I I want to interesting to me. I I I want to interesting to me. I I I want to understand what's true. So walk me understand what's true. So walk me understand what's true. So walk me through as somebody who I look at the through as somebody who I look at the through as somebody who I look at the deficit spending and I go we're going to deficit spending and I go we're going to deficit spending and I go we're going to be money burning because you have to be money burning because you have to be money burning because you have to that money has to come from somewhere. that money has to come from somewhere. that money has to come from somewhere. And so now we're assuming we can't just And so now we're assuming we can't just And so now we're assuming we can't just sell all the debt that we want to sell. sell all the debt that we want to sell. sell all the debt that we want to sell. The Fed's gonna have to step in. The The Fed's gonna have to step in. The The Fed's gonna have to step in. The Fed's going to have to swallow up some Fed's going to have to swallow up some Fed's going to have to swallow up some of that. The Fed's going to lower rates. of that. The Fed's going to lower rates. of that. The Fed's going to lower rates. Uh stimulate the economy. get the cheap Uh stimulate the economy. get the cheap Uh stimulate the economy. get the cheap money flowing so that people can um keep money flowing so that people can um keep money flowing so that people can um keep everything moving. So when I look at everything moving. So when I look at everything moving. So when I look at that, the story seems right. You get that, the story seems right. You get that, the story seems right. You get cheap, easy money into the economy, it's cheap, easy money into the economy, it's cheap, easy money into the economy, it's going to be inflationary. So what am I going to be inflationary. So what am I going to be inflationary. So what am I getting wrong? Is there something else getting wrong? Is there something else getting wrong? Is there something else that's really driving it or what? that's really driving it or what? that's really driving it or what? Historically speaking, during Historically speaking, during Historically speaking, during depressionary periods, interest rates depressionary periods, interest rates depressionary periods, interest rates are low and interest rates that we can are low and interest rates that we can are low and interest rates that we can see are low because people want safety see are low because people want safety see are low because people want safety and liquidity. You go back to the 1930s, and liquidity. You go back to the 1930s, and liquidity. You go back to the 1930s, which is the clearest example. 1930s, which is the clearest example. 1930s, which is the clearest example. 1930s, you had too many parallels to what we're you had too many parallels to what we're you had too many parallels to what we're we're experiencing today. All the same we're experiencing today. All the same we're experiencing today. All the same types of stuff. You got a, you know, a types of stuff. You got a, you know, a types of stuff. You got a, you know, a big crash and then a depression big crash and then a depression big crash and then a depression afterwards with with lingering afterwards with with lingering afterwards with with lingering unemployment. Yet, the government went unemployment. Yet, the government went unemployment. Yet, the government went completely insane. You had the New Deal, completely insane. You had the New Deal, completely insane. You had the New Deal, which a lot of people said at the time which a lot of people said at the time which a lot of people said at the time was going to lead to skyrocketing was going to lead to skyrocketing was going to lead to skyrocketing interest rates and out of control interest rates and out of control interest rates and out of control inflation. The Federal Reserve, you inflation. The Federal Reserve, you inflation. The Federal Reserve, you know, hiked its reserve requirements in know, hiked its reserve requirements in know, hiked its reserve requirements in 36 and 37. So, there was the same type 36 and 37. So, there was the same type 36 and 37. So, there was the same type of setup, but it never actually of setup, but it never actually of setup, but it never actually happened. And the reason was because the happened. And the reason was because the happened. And the reason was because the banking system had broken down so much banking system had broken down so much banking system had broken down so much and deflationary money became so and deflationary money became so and deflationary money became so entrenched that the banking system entrenched that the banking system entrenched that the banking system financial participants wealthy financial participants wealthy financial participants wealthy individuals wanted safety and liquidity. individuals wanted safety and liquidity. individuals wanted safety and liquidity. So no matter how irresponsible the FDR's So no matter how irresponsible the FDR's So no matter how irresponsible the FDR's new deal got to be and how how fiscally new deal got to be and how how fiscally new deal got to be and how how fiscally reckless the government got became, you reckless the government got became, you reckless the government got became, you know, there was no need to bail out the know, there was no need to bail out the know, there was no need to bail out the treasury market because there was treasury market because there was treasury market because there was endless demand for safety and liquidity. endless demand for safety and liquidity. endless demand for safety and liquidity. And unfortunately safety and liquidity And unfortunately safety and liquidity And unfortunately safety and liquidity means US government debt uh and other means US government debt uh and other means US government debt uh and other government other forms of sovereign debt government other forms of sovereign debt government other forms of sovereign debt too. I mean, we wish that wasn't the too. I mean, we wish that wasn't the too. I mean, we wish that wasn't the case. And it's not really about the case. And it's not really about the case. And it's not really about the government so much is that historically government so much is that historically government so much is that historically speaking, government debt markets are speaking, government debt markets are speaking, government debt markets are the deepest and most mature. And what the deepest and most mature. And what the deepest and most mature. And what really matters more so when we talk really matters more so when we talk really matters more so when we talk about safety is the liquidity about safety is the liquidity about safety is the liquidity characteristics more than say the credit characteristics more than say the credit characteristics more than say the credit profile of the issuer. profile of the issuer. profile of the issuer. >> Okay? Meaning a ton of people are buying >> Okay? Meaning a ton of people are buying >> Okay? Meaning a ton of people are buying the debt. No worries. I put some money the debt. No worries. I put some money the debt. No worries. I put some money in, I'll be able to get it back out. in, I'll be able to get it back out. in, I'll be able to get it back out. >> Exactly. I can sell it tomorrow at a >> Exactly. I can sell it tomorrow at a >> Exactly. I can sell it tomorrow at a price that I'm reasonably assured that I price that I'm reasonably assured that I price that I'm reasonably assured that I know what it is today. That becomes very know what it is today. That becomes very know what it is today. That becomes very important when you talk about treasuries important when you talk about treasuries important when you talk about treasuries and other government bonds as and other government bonds as and other government bonds as collateral, which is an important part collateral, which is an important part collateral, which is an important part of the monetary system, this Euro dollar of the monetary system, this Euro dollar of the monetary system, this Euro dollar system. But in depressionary periods, system. But in depressionary periods, system. But in depressionary periods, that demand for safety overwhelms every that demand for safety overwhelms every that demand for safety overwhelms every other consideration. So for the entire other consideration. So for the entire other consideration. So for the entire 2010s and into the 2020s, we've been 2010s and into the 2020s, we've been 2010s and into the 2020s, we've been sitting here watching the US government sitting here watching the US government sitting here watching the US government get broker and broker and broker, get broker and broker and broker, get broker and broker and broker, stupider and stupider and stupider. And stupider and stupider and stupider. And stupider and stupider and stupider. And yet whatever despite all of the yet whatever despite all of the yet whatever despite all of the proclamations that bond vigilantism was proclamations that bond vigilantism was proclamations that bond vigilantism was going to come back roaring into the going to come back roaring into the going to come back roaring into the system, that the Fed needed to bail out system, that the Fed needed to bail out system, that the Fed needed to bail out the Treasury market, it never once the Treasury market, it never once the Treasury market, it never once happened. And the reason was because of happened. And the reason was because of happened. And the reason was because of depression economics. demand for safety depression economics. demand for safety depression economics. demand for safety overrode every other consideration and overrode every other consideration and overrode every other consideration and continued year after year after year. So continued year after year after year. So continued year after year after year. So in depressionary periods that demand for in depressionary periods that demand for in depressionary periods that demand for safety becomes paramount which means safety becomes paramount which means safety becomes paramount which means that interest rates on instruments like that interest rates on instruments like that interest rates on instruments like government bonds stay lower throughout government bonds stay lower throughout government bonds stay lower throughout the deflation deflationary period which the deflation deflationary period which the deflation deflationary period which is again contrary to what people are is again contrary to what people are is again contrary to what people are taught. People are taught low rates are taught. People are taught low rates are taught. People are taught low rates are stimulus when historically speaking low stimulus when historically speaking low stimulus when historically speaking low rates are a sign that money is tight and rates are a sign that money is tight and rates are a sign that money is tight and the conditions are more depression than the conditions are more depression than the conditions are more depression than not. Japan, another perfect example, not. Japan, another perfect example, not. Japan, another perfect example, throughout the 1990s and into the 2000s, throughout the 1990s and into the 2000s, throughout the 1990s and into the 2000s, same thing. You had a depressionary case same thing. You had a depressionary case same thing. You had a depressionary case where JGB yields absolutely plunged and where JGB yields absolutely plunged and where JGB yields absolutely plunged and then stayed there for decade after then stayed there for decade after then stayed there for decade after decade because of the the paramount to decade because of the the paramount to decade because of the the paramount to demand for safety and liquidity. And demand for safety and liquidity. And demand for safety and liquidity. And then the opposite is the is is true too. then the opposite is the is is true too. then the opposite is the is is true too. You go to the 1970s and the great You go to the 1970s and the great You go to the 1970s and the great inflation. What were interest rates inflation. What were interest rates inflation. What were interest rates doing in in the great inflation? They doing in in the great inflation? They doing in in the great inflation? They were going up. Because in an were going up. Because in an were going up. Because in an inflationary period where you have inflationary period where you have inflationary period where you have nominal opportunities in the real nominal opportunities in the real nominal opportunities in the real economy, the last thing you want to own economy, the last thing you want to own economy, the last thing you want to own is some kind of safe and liquid is some kind of safe and liquid is some kind of safe and liquid government bond. You're going to sell government bond. You're going to sell government bond. You're going to sell that thing and chase the nominal that thing and chase the nominal that thing and chase the nominal opportunities in the real economy. In opportunities in the real economy. In opportunities in the real economy. In fact, you have to because on a real fact, you have to because on a real fact, you have to because on a real basis, the only way to generate returns basis, the only way to generate returns basis, the only way to generate returns that are sufficient to make a profit is that are sufficient to make a profit is that are sufficient to make a profit is to go into the real economy to ditch to go into the real economy to ditch to go into the real economy to ditch your safety and find something else. So your safety and find something else. So your safety and find something else. So interest rates tend to rise during interest rates tend to rise during interest rates tend to rise during inflationary periods, the interest rates inflationary periods, the interest rates inflationary periods, the interest rates that we watch and we see. So that's the that we watch and we see. So that's the that we watch and we see. So that's the starting point. So you look at the yield starting point. So you look at the yield starting point. So you look at the yield curve that should be modestly upward curve that should be modestly upward curve that should be modestly upward sloping. If it starts to go up in the sloping. If it starts to go up in the sloping. If it starts to go up in the long end, that's not a sign that the, long end, that's not a sign that the, long end, that's not a sign that the, you know, the the world is um is trying you know, the the world is um is trying you know, the the world is um is trying to fight inflation. That's a sign that to fight inflation. That's a sign that to fight inflation. That's a sign that the market expects inflation to happen. the market expects inflation to happen. the market expects inflation to happen. Or it could be a better sign. Uh if the Or it could be a better sign. Uh if the Or it could be a better sign. Uh if the nominal yields or the yield curve starts nominal yields or the yield curve starts nominal yields or the yield curve starts to steepen out, that could be a sign the to steepen out, that could be a sign the to steepen out, that could be a sign the market is thinking, hey, we did it. We market is thinking, hey, we did it. We market is thinking, hey, we did it. We finally we finally achieved liftoff and finally we finally achieved liftoff and finally we finally achieved liftoff and we're into a recovery period and some we're into a recovery period and some we're into a recovery period and some legitimate economic growth. So growth legitimate economic growth. So growth legitimate economic growth. So growth expectations are rising because that's expectations are rising because that's expectations are rising because that's what a long run yield actually is. A what a long run yield actually is. A what a long run yield actually is. A long run yield isn't the Fed. It's long run yield isn't the Fed. It's long run yield isn't the Fed. It's growth and inflation expectations growth and inflation expectations growth and inflation expectations through time with the Fed and central through time with the Fed and central through time with the Fed and central banks having some limited influence on banks having some limited influence on banks having some limited influence on the yield curve. So when we're trying to the yield curve. So when we're trying to the yield curve. So when we're trying to figure out what this what the what the figure out what this what the what the figure out what this what the what the situation might be today and therefore situation might be today and therefore situation might be today and therefore where the system is going tomorrow, you where the system is going tomorrow, you where the system is going tomorrow, you start with something like the yield start with something like the yield start with something like the yield curve and see what the shape is and how curve and see what the shape is and how curve and see what the shape is and how it's changing because the the shape and it's changing because the the shape and it's changing because the the shape and the changes in shape actually give you a the changes in shape actually give you a the changes in shape actually give you a clue what the market is thinking about clue what the market is thinking about clue what the market is thinking about probabilities of how things will evolve probabilities of how things will evolve probabilities of how things will evolve through time. through time. through time. >> Now are you saying that the real vibe of >> Now are you saying that the real vibe of >> Now are you saying that the real vibe of the economy right now is depressionary the economy right now is depressionary the economy right now is depressionary that people are um in a like pure fear that people are um in a like pure fear that people are um in a like pure fear mode? It's see that's again it's it's mode? It's see that's again it's it's mode? It's see that's again it's it's not an either or. There's always not an either or. There's always not an either or. There's always gradation and and shades of gray here. gradation and and shades of gray here. gradation and and shades of gray here. So yes, what we're saying is that the So yes, what we're saying is that the So yes, what we're saying is that the yield curve which is at a historically yield curve which is at a historically yield curve which is at a historically it's still at a relatively low nominal it's still at a relatively low nominal it's still at a relatively low nominal level which I know people don't it's level which I know people don't it's level which I know people don't it's it's higher than it was than in 2010s it's higher than it was than in 2010s it's higher than it was than in 2010s but when you line it up you know a chart but when you line it up you know a chart but when you line it up you know a chart that shows history rates are still that shows history rates are still that shows history rates are still pretty low. And when you have a yield pretty low. And when you have a yield pretty low. And when you have a yield curve that has been flattening out at a curve that has been flattening out at a curve that has been flattening out at a low nominal level, that tells you low nominal level, that tells you low nominal level, that tells you there's more fear, more more demand for there's more fear, more more demand for there's more fear, more more demand for safety than there is um the idea that safety than there is um the idea that safety than there is um the idea that we're going into an inflationary period we're going into an inflationary period we're going into an inflationary period with exceptional economic growth with exceptional economic growth with exceptional economic growth opportunities. So a low flat curve is a opportunities. So a low flat curve is a opportunities. So a low flat curve is a sign that there is a persistent bid for sign that there is a persistent bid for sign that there is a persistent bid for safety, which again explains why despite safety, which again explains why despite safety, which again explains why despite all of the inflationary rhetoric over all of the inflationary rhetoric over all of the inflationary rhetoric over the 2020s, again, the government's the 2020s, again, the government's the 2020s, again, the government's deficits haven't mattered even though deficits haven't mattered even though deficits haven't mattered even though they've gotten completely ridiculous. they've gotten completely ridiculous. they've gotten completely ridiculous. The demand for safety continues to be The demand for safety continues to be The demand for safety continues to be there year after year after year, which there year after year after year, which there year after year after year, which is one of the things that should grab is one of the things that should grab is one of the things that should grab people's attention. You should start people's attention. You should start people's attention. You should start asking yourself, if the 2020s didn't asking yourself, if the 2020s didn't asking yourself, if the 2020s didn't break the Treasury market for either break the Treasury market for either break the Treasury market for either inflation or fiscal reasons, why? What inflation or fiscal reasons, why? What inflation or fiscal reasons, why? What the hell must be what must be happening? the hell must be what must be happening? the hell must be what must be happening? What must the uh the bond market be What must the uh the bond market be What must the uh the bond market be seeing that continues to keep up this seeing that continues to keep up this seeing that continues to keep up this this safety bid year after year after this safety bid year after year after this safety bid year after year after year? We'll get back to the show in a year? We'll get back to the show in a year? We'll get back to the show in a second. But first, let's talk about that second. But first, let's talk about that second. But first, let's talk about that hard conversation that you keep hard conversation that you keep hard conversation that you keep avoiding. You know the one. Sitting down avoiding. You know the one. Sitting down avoiding. You know the one. Sitting down and being honest about what happens to and being honest about what happens to and being honest about what happens to the people you love if you're gone the people you love if you're gone the people you love if you're gone tomorrow. Most people won't have it. tomorrow. Most people won't have it. tomorrow. Most people won't have it. [music] Feels morbid, so they keep [music] Feels morbid, so they keep [music] Feels morbid, so they keep putting it off. Protecting my wife putting it off. Protecting my wife putting it off. Protecting my wife matters more to me than almost anything. matters more to me than almost anything. matters more to me than almost anything. No matter what happens, I want her taken No matter what happens, I want her taken No matter what happens, I want her taken care of. And I know that avoiding a hard care of. And I know that avoiding a hard care of. And I know that avoiding a hard conversation is not going to help my conversation is not going to help my conversation is not going to help my family or yours. It just leaves them to family or yours. It just leaves them to family or yours. It just leaves them to figure it out alone without you. That's figure it out alone without you. That's figure it out alone without you. That's where Ethos comes in. Ethos makes where Ethos comes in. Ethos makes where Ethos comes in. Ethos makes getting life insurance fast and easy, getting life insurance fast and easy, getting life insurance fast and easy, 100% online. You can get a quote in 100% online. You can get a quote in 100% online. You can get a quote in seconds, apply in minutes, and get same seconds, apply in minutes, and get same seconds, apply in minutes, and get same day coverage. There's no medical exam. day coverage. There's no medical exam. day coverage. There's no medical exam. You just answer a few health questions You just answer a few health questions You just answer a few health questions online. You can get up to $3 million in online. You can get up to $3 million in online. You can get up to $3 million in coverage, and some policies are as low coverage, and some policies are as low coverage, and some policies are as low as $30 a month. Life insurance through as $30 a month. Life insurance through as $30 a month. Life insurance through Ethos helps provide financial security Ethos helps provide financial security Ethos helps provide financial security and helps protect the people who depend and helps protect the people who depend and helps protect the people who depend on you. Take 10 minutes to get covered on you. Take 10 minutes to get covered on you. Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through Ethos. today with life insurance through Ethos. today with life insurance through Ethos. Get your free quote at ethos.com/impact. Get your free quote at ethos.com/impact. Get your free quote at ethos.com/impact. [music] Application times may vary, rate times Application times may vary, rate times may vary. Now, let's get back to the may vary. Now, let's get back to the may vary. Now, let's get back to the show. Okay, this this is so interesting. show. Okay, this this is so interesting. show. Okay, this this is so interesting. All right. Uh it does feel like we have All right. Uh it does feel like we have All right. Uh it does feel like we have a tale of two economies. When you first a tale of two economies. When you first a tale of two economies. When you first said there are parallels to the 30s, I said there are parallels to the 30s, I said there are parallels to the 30s, I actually thought you misspoke and I was actually thought you misspoke and I was actually thought you misspoke and I was about to be like, "Wait, do you mean the about to be like, "Wait, do you mean the about to be like, "Wait, do you mean the late 20s?" late 20s?" late 20s?" >> Then as you went on obviously I realized >> Then as you went on obviously I realized >> Then as you went on obviously I realized you really do mean the 30s. So given you really do mean the 30s. So given you really do mean the 30s. So given that a lot of people myself included are that a lot of people myself included are that a lot of people myself included are screaming AI bubble like yo this is screaming AI bubble like yo this is screaming AI bubble like yo this is getting crazy where the for anybody that getting crazy where the for anybody that getting crazy where the for anybody that knows what a cape ratio is like a cape knows what a cape ratio is like a cape knows what a cape ratio is like a cape ratio is basically over a 10-year period ratio is basically over a 10-year period ratio is basically over a 10-year period what's the typical distance between what what's the typical distance between what what's the typical distance between what they're actually the company's actually they're actually the company's actually they're actually the company's actually making and then what their stock sells making and then what their stock sells making and then what their stock sells for 16 to 17 is like the normal for 16 to 17 is like the normal for 16 to 17 is like the normal multiplier we're like 44 so we're like multiplier we're like 44 so we're like multiplier we're like 44 so we're like way out over our skis. So I look at that way out over our skis. So I look at that way out over our skis. So I look at that and I'm like uhoh this is euphoria. This and I'm like uhoh this is euphoria. This and I'm like uhoh this is euphoria. This is exuberance. is exuberance. is exuberance. But you're saying, "Well, hold on. Even But you're saying, "Well, hold on. Even But you're saying, "Well, hold on. Even with the 30% inflation that we saw from with the 30% inflation that we saw from with the 30% inflation that we saw from like 2020 to now, people are still just, like 2020 to now, people are still just, like 2020 to now, people are still just, hold on. I I need safety. I want to be hold on. I I need safety. I want to be hold on. I I need safety. I want to be in bonds." Um, is is it because asset in bonds." Um, is is it because asset in bonds." Um, is is it because asset owners are seeing one story and the owners are seeing one story and the owners are seeing one story and the person on the street is seeing something person on the street is seeing something person on the street is seeing something different? Like, help me understand why. different? Like, help me understand why. different? Like, help me understand why. I can very easily give you a narrative I can very easily give you a narrative I can very easily give you a narrative that this is euphoria. people way out that this is euphoria. people way out that this is euphoria. people way out over their skis, but yet you're seeing over their skis, but yet you're seeing over their skis, but yet you're seeing 1930s like we're in the depression 1930s like we're in the depression 1930s like we're in the depression parallels. parallels. parallels. >> Yeah, it's first of all, the stock >> Yeah, it's first of all, the stock >> Yeah, it's first of all, the stock market doesn't really have a whole lot market doesn't really have a whole lot market doesn't really have a whole lot to do with the economy. Anybody who's to do with the economy. Anybody who's to do with the economy. Anybody who's looks at the stock market and thinks looks at the stock market and thinks looks at the stock market and thinks it's telling you something about the it's telling you something about the it's telling you something about the economy, you're being misled. I know economy, you're being misled. I know economy, you're being misled. I know it's it's because we're told endlessly. it's it's because we're told endlessly. it's it's because we're told endlessly. I mean, I I've been doing this a long I mean, I I've been doing this a long I mean, I I've been doing this a long time and I remember back in school, time and I remember back in school, time and I remember back in school, that's what we're told that the stock that's what we're told that the stock that's what we're told that the stock market is the preeminent discounting market is the preeminent discounting market is the preeminent discounting mechanism for financial macroeconomic mechanism for financial macroeconomic mechanism for financial macroeconomic information. And it's complete information. And it's complete information. And it's complete It's a story spun by Wall Street. And It's a story spun by Wall Street. And It's a story spun by Wall Street. And it's a story spun by Wall Street to it's a story spun by Wall Street to it's a story spun by Wall Street to justify how the stock market took over justify how the stock market took over justify how the stock market took over as the preeminent form of savings. So if as the preeminent form of savings. So if as the preeminent form of savings. So if you look at the cape ratio, and I'm glad you look at the cape ratio, and I'm glad you look at the cape ratio, and I'm glad you brought that up because it's a you brought that up because it's a you brought that up because it's a perfect simple illustration of this this perfect simple illustration of this this perfect simple illustration of this this phenomena. Somewhere around the early phenomena. Somewhere around the early phenomena. Somewhere around the early 1980s, something substantial changed and 1980s, something substantial changed and 1980s, something substantial changed and something structural changed. It was something structural changed. It was something structural changed. It was with you know technology things advanced with you know technology things advanced with you know technology things advanced and eventually what ended up happening and eventually what ended up happening and eventually what ended up happening is people stopped saving money in the is people stopped saving money in the is people stopped saving money in the way that they had before which is you way that they had before which is you way that they had before which is you put your money in a bank and you get a put your money in a bank and you get a put your money in a bank and you get a CD or something like that some kind of CD or something like that some kind of CD or something like that some kind of interest bearing deposit you started you interest bearing deposit you started you interest bearing deposit you started you started speculating in equities and then started speculating in equities and then started speculating in equities and then suddenly that speculating in equities suddenly that speculating in equities suddenly that speculating in equities became the norm became the norm became the norm >> and as more and people started piling >> and as more and people started piling >> and as more and people started piling money into equities because that's just money into equities because that's just money into equities because that's just what you did and a lot of it was passive what you did and a lot of it was passive what you did and a lot of it was passive you know you most of the most of you know you most of the most of you know you most of the most of people's exposure to equities is through people's exposure to equities is through people's exposure to equities is through retirement accounts which you don't retirement accounts which you don't retirement accounts which you don't really direct you put your money with really direct you put your money with really direct you put your money with your employer or some annuity and they your employer or some annuity and they your employer or some annuity and they they put the money in the market for they put the money in the market for they put the money in the market for you. So the more people who saved in the you. So the more people who saved in the you. So the more people who saved in the stock market, the more money flowed into stock market, the more money flowed into stock market, the more money flowed into the stock market regardless of what the the stock market regardless of what the the stock market regardless of what the conditions were in the financial system conditions were in the financial system conditions were in the financial system or the real economy, which meant that or the real economy, which meant that or the real economy, which meant that valuations kept getting stretched valuations kept getting stretched valuations kept getting stretched further and further and further. Not further and further and further. Not further and further and further. Not because that people were necessarily because that people were necessarily because that people were necessarily overoptimistic, though I do agree with overoptimistic, though I do agree with overoptimistic, though I do agree with you, the AI bubble is definitely a you, the AI bubble is definitely a you, the AI bubble is definitely a bubble. But in general terms, the bubble. But in general terms, the bubble. But in general terms, the broader stock market continues to grow broader stock market continues to grow broader stock market continues to grow further and further away from the real further and further away from the real further and further away from the real economy because it just it's just a economy because it just it's just a economy because it just it's just a function of people putting more money function of people putting more money function of people putting more money into the stock market. So all the rising into the stock market. So all the rising into the stock market. So all the rising indexes really tell you is that more indexes really tell you is that more indexes really tell you is that more people are putting their retirement people are putting their retirement people are putting their retirement savings in equities and nothing really savings in equities and nothing really savings in equities and nothing really apart from that. So you can have a apart from that. So you can have a apart from that. So you can have a situation where you have an economy that situation where you have an economy that situation where you have an economy that absolutely sucks. I mean we heard the absolutely sucks. I mean we heard the absolutely sucks. I mean we heard the vibe session for the last couple years. vibe session for the last couple years. vibe session for the last couple years. Now everybody talks about a K-shaped Now everybody talks about a K-shaped Now everybody talks about a K-shaped economy. That's an alarm bell. It's a economy. That's an alarm bell. It's a economy. That's an alarm bell. It's a clue that tells you something isn't clue that tells you something isn't clue that tells you something isn't right here. So you can have that, you right here. So you can have that, you right here. So you can have that, you know, lackluster economy, stagflation, know, lackluster economy, stagflation, know, lackluster economy, stagflation, whatever you hell you want to call it. whatever you hell you want to call it. whatever you hell you want to call it. It's not a good economy. It's it's It's not a good economy. It's it's It's not a good economy. It's it's really a depression economy because a really a depression economy because a really a depression economy because a depression isn't about the negative depression isn't about the negative depression isn't about the negative numbers. is about the lack of upside, numbers. is about the lack of upside, numbers. is about the lack of upside, which is a K-shaped economy. But you can which is a K-shaped economy. But you can which is a K-shaped economy. But you can have a K-shaped economy at the same time have a K-shaped economy at the same time have a K-shaped economy at the same time the stock market's hitting record highs the stock market's hitting record highs the stock market's hitting record highs because those two things don't really because those two things don't really because those two things don't really relate to one another. And the reason relate to one another. And the reason relate to one another. And the reason why we have a depression economy is that why we have a depression economy is that why we have a depression economy is that the inflation that you talk about was the inflation that you talk about was the inflation that you talk about was really front-loaded as a phase shift in really front-loaded as a phase shift in really front-loaded as a phase shift in 2021 and 2022, which meant that prices 2021 and 2022, which meant that prices 2021 and 2022, which meant that prices zoomed ahead back then while incomes lag zoomed ahead back then while incomes lag zoomed ahead back then while incomes lag way behind. So in a sense what ended up way behind. So in a sense what ended up way behind. So in a sense what ended up happening is we faking impoverished the happening is we faking impoverished the happening is we faking impoverished the vast majority of people on the on the vast majority of people on the on the vast majority of people on the on the planet. You know all working people who planet. You know all working people who planet. You know all working people who didn't have any kind of u any kind of didn't have any kind of u any kind of didn't have any kind of u any kind of access to financial assets found access to financial assets found access to financial assets found themselves suddenly far behind. Well in themselves suddenly far behind. Well in themselves suddenly far behind. Well in that kind of situation where you're that kind of situation where you're that kind of situation where you're making people poor for nothing that they making people poor for nothing that they making people poor for nothing that they did you don't really expect to have a did you don't really expect to have a did you don't really expect to have a wellfounded well-grounded sustainable wellfounded well-grounded sustainable wellfounded well-grounded sustainable economic boom that comes out of that. We economic boom that comes out of that. We economic boom that comes out of that. We still have to figure out where the still have to figure out where the still have to figure out where the bottom is, where the equilibrium is from bottom is, where the equilibrium is from bottom is, where the equilibrium is from the pandemic and the lockdowns. We made the pandemic and the lockdowns. We made the pandemic and the lockdowns. We made people poor and that's what they're people poor and that's what they're people poor and that's what they're really complaining about. It's not really complaining about. It's not really complaining about. It's not really about prices. It's about the lack really about prices. It's about the lack really about prices. It's about the lack of jobs and the lack of incomes. If you of jobs and the lack of incomes. If you of jobs and the lack of incomes. If you want to really look at statistics that want to really look at statistics that want to really look at statistics that show the depression economy, take the show the depression economy, take the show the depression economy, take the establishment survey, payrolls, just establishment survey, payrolls, just establishment survey, payrolls, just payrolls, which is the most over it's payrolls, which is the most over it's payrolls, which is the most over it's it's it's overstated, the most it's it's overstated, the most it's it's overstated, the most optimistic look at the labor market. You optimistic look at the labor market. You optimistic look at the labor market. You take the payroll number and put it put take the payroll number and put it put take the payroll number and put it put it against the trend from the 2010s it against the trend from the 2010s it against the trend from the 2010s which was not a good trend to begin which was not a good trend to begin which was not a good trend to begin with. What you see is that first of all with. What you see is that first of all with. What you see is that first of all payroll started to come back after the payroll started to come back after the payroll started to come back after the lockdowns and the pandemic. Some people lockdowns and the pandemic. Some people lockdowns and the pandemic. Some people called it recovery. It really wasn't. called it recovery. It really wasn't. called it recovery. It really wasn't. But then around 2022 and 2023 the trend But then around 2022 and 2023 the trend But then around 2022 and 2023 the trend started to change. And then you get into started to change. And then you get into started to change. And then you get into 24 and 25 and now the trend is sideways 24 and 25 and now the trend is sideways 24 and 25 and now the trend is sideways to lower. Now it's not just sideways to to lower. Now it's not just sideways to to lower. Now it's not just sideways to lower, it's sideways to lower millions lower, it's sideways to lower millions lower, it's sideways to lower millions of jobs short of where that trend was. of jobs short of where that trend was. of jobs short of where that trend was. So at best we got as close to 5 million So at best we got as close to 5 million So at best we got as close to 5 million payrolls in 2024 and since then the payrolls in 2024 and since then the payrolls in 2024 and since then the trend continues to go up but payroll trend continues to go up but payroll trend continues to go up but payroll growth has completely stopped. In fact growth has completely stopped. In fact growth has completely stopped. In fact payrolls have been sight in 2025 there payrolls have been sight in 2025 there payrolls have been sight in 2025 there was 180,000 payrolls total for the was 180,000 payrolls total for the was 180,000 payrolls total for the entire year. That's the payroll growth entire year. That's the payroll growth entire year. That's the payroll growth according to establishment for an entire according to establishment for an entire according to establishment for an entire year economy of this size. I remember a year economy of this size. I remember a year economy of this size. I remember a couple years ago when 180,000 was a bad couple years ago when 180,000 was a bad couple years ago when 180,000 was a bad month. Now 180,000 for an entire year. month. Now 180,000 for an entire year. month. Now 180,000 for an entire year. So you look at where payrolls are versus So you look at where payrolls are versus So you look at where payrolls are versus the trend. It's 8 million jobs short, the trend. It's 8 million jobs short, the trend. It's 8 million jobs short, which means that's 8 million people who which means that's 8 million people who which means that's 8 million people who aren't working that probably should be. aren't working that probably should be. aren't working that probably should be. Maybe you make an adjustment for Maybe you make an adjustment for Maybe you make an adjustment for demographic shifts or something like demographic shifts or something like demographic shifts or something like that, but it's not 8 million. So we have that, but it's not 8 million. So we have that, but it's not 8 million. So we have people who are impoverished by the 2021 people who are impoverished by the 2021 people who are impoverished by the 2021 2022 supply shock phase shift. You know, 2022 supply shock phase shift. You know, 2022 supply shock phase shift. You know, prices went up faster than incomes. Then prices went up faster than incomes. Then prices went up faster than incomes. Then you had companies who realized they you had companies who realized they you had companies who realized they didn't need as many people, not because didn't need as many people, not because didn't need as many people, not because of AI, just because the economy never of AI, just because the economy never of AI, just because the economy never recovered. So you have fewer people recovered. So you have fewer people recovered. So you have fewer people working, less income, money that they're working, less income, money that they're working, less income, money that they're getting, their income doesn't go nearly getting, their income doesn't go nearly getting, their income doesn't go nearly as far as it did. It's the recipe for as far as it did. It's the recipe for as far as it did. It's the recipe for exactly the type of environment where exactly the type of environment where exactly the type of environment where people would want to own US treasuries people would want to own US treasuries people would want to own US treasuries even though the US government completely even though the US government completely even though the US government completely goes insane. But it's it's tough for the goes insane. But it's it's tough for the goes insane. But it's it's tough for the regular person on the street to untangle regular person on the street to untangle regular person on the street to untangle all this information because they're not all this information because they're not all this information because they're not watching this. What they hear is the GDP watching this. What they hear is the GDP watching this. What they hear is the GDP report. They see the stock market. They report. They see the stock market. They report. They see the stock market. They listen to Jay Powell go on and on about listen to Jay Powell go on and on about listen to Jay Powell go on and on about how the how strong and resilient the how the how strong and resilient the how the how strong and resilient the economy is. as if he doesn't have a economy is. as if he doesn't have a economy is. as if he doesn't have a vested interest in lying to your face vested interest in lying to your face vested interest in lying to your face about it because he's the one that about it because he's the one that about it because he's the one that everybody blames when the economy is everybody blames when the economy is everybody blames when the economy is poor and somewhat rightly so. So, it's poor and somewhat rightly so. So, it's poor and somewhat rightly so. So, it's it's very hard for people. They feel it's very hard for people. They feel it's very hard for people. They feel something. They feel something is wrong, something. They feel something is wrong, something. They feel something is wrong, but they don't really know what it is but they don't really know what it is but they don't really know what it is because nothing in the mainstream has because nothing in the mainstream has because nothing in the mainstream has set them up to be able to to really set them up to be able to to really set them up to be able to to really decipher the language of macroeconomics decipher the language of macroeconomics decipher the language of macroeconomics and financial conditions. and financial conditions. and financial conditions. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. You gave two really interesting things You gave two really interesting things You gave two really interesting things that I want to drill down on. So, that I want to drill down on. So, that I want to drill down on. So, they're mechanisms. Mechanism number they're mechanisms. Mechanism number they're mechanisms. Mechanism number one, you said something changed in the one, you said something changed in the one, you said something changed in the 80s. Uh it sounded like I'm going to put 80s. Uh it sounded like I'm going to put 80s. Uh it sounded like I'm going to put my own words to it. You tell me what I my own words to it. You tell me what I my own words to it. You tell me what I get wrong here. So 80s mechanism is a get wrong here. So 80s mechanism is a get wrong here. So 80s mechanism is a cultural narrative takes hold that says cultural narrative takes hold that says cultural narrative takes hold that says just save in the stock market because just save in the stock market because just save in the stock market because the vast majority of people that are the vast majority of people that are the vast majority of people that are saving in the stock market can't saving in the stock market can't saving in the stock market can't distangle all of these signals. They're distangle all of these signals. They're distangle all of these signals. They're just like, nah, just put it in. And just like, nah, just put it in. And just like, nah, just put it in. And they're not watching cape ratios. And so they're not watching cape ratios. And so they're not watching cape ratios. And so as they get crazier and crazier, they're as they get crazier and crazier, they're as they get crazier and crazier, they're like, well, well, everybody's telling me like, well, well, everybody's telling me like, well, well, everybody's telling me the stock market's doing great. I'm just the stock market's doing great. I'm just the stock market's doing great. I'm just going to keep doing what I'm doing. And going to keep doing what I'm doing. And going to keep doing what I'm doing. And so that becomes a cultural behavior that so that becomes a cultural behavior that so that becomes a cultural behavior that I'll parallel to Japan. So I talked to I'll parallel to Japan. So I talked to I'll parallel to Japan. So I talked to my audience a lot about Japan. So Japan my audience a lot about Japan. So Japan my audience a lot about Japan. So Japan goes from two nuclear bombs to being the goes from two nuclear bombs to being the goes from two nuclear bombs to being the strongest economy in the world briefly strongest economy in the world briefly strongest economy in the world briefly in the 80s. Bubble bursts in '89. They in the 80s. Bubble bursts in '89. They in the 80s. Bubble bursts in '89. They they were like the equivalent of putting they were like the equivalent of putting they were like the equivalent of putting your hand on the stove, getting burned, your hand on the stove, getting burned, your hand on the stove, getting burned, and for the next 30 years being like, and for the next 30 years being like, and for the next 30 years being like, I'm not going to use the stove. So, no I'm not going to use the stove. So, no I'm not going to use the stove. So, no matter how much stimulus the government matter how much stimulus the government matter how much stimulus the government tried to pour in by holding rates low, tried to pour in by holding rates low, tried to pour in by holding rates low, they just couldn't get inflation going they just couldn't get inflation going they just couldn't get inflation going again because people are like, "I'm again because people are like, "I'm again because people are like, "I'm paying off my debt. I'm saving money. paying off my debt. I'm saving money. paying off my debt. I'm saving money. I'm not buying stuff. Forget that. I I'm not buying stuff. Forget that. I I'm not buying stuff. Forget that. I live through that. I'm not doing that live through that. I'm not doing that live through that. I'm not doing that again." So, you've got these two again." So, you've got these two again." So, you've got these two different reactions. You've got America, different reactions. You've got America, different reactions. You've got America, maybe the West, more generalized, just maybe the West, more generalized, just maybe the West, more generalized, just plowing cash into the stock market. It plowing cash into the stock market. It plowing cash into the stock market. It keeps going up. They're not really keeps going up. They're not really keeps going up. They're not really paying attention. Okay. So, if I got paying attention. Okay. So, if I got paying attention. Okay. So, if I got that mechanism right, then we've got the that mechanism right, then we've got the that mechanism right, then we've got the next one that I want to better next one that I want to better next one that I want to better understand, which is what exactly caused understand, which is what exactly caused understand, which is what exactly caused mechanistically the inflation? Uh, I mechanistically the inflation? Uh, I mechanistically the inflation? Uh, I think you're pegging it more to 21 and think you're pegging it more to 21 and think you're pegging it more to 21 and 22, but what mechanistically created 22, but what mechanistically created 22, but what mechanistically created that if it wasn't government debts and that if it wasn't government debts and that if it wasn't government debts and money printing? money printing? money printing? >> What caused it was the imbalance between >> What caused it was the imbalance between >> What caused it was the imbalance between supply and demand? It was a classic supply and demand? It was a classic supply and demand? It was a classic supply shock case and we've seen this supply shock case and we've seen this supply shock case and we've seen this throughout history. In fact, nobody I throughout history. In fact, nobody I throughout history. In fact, nobody I mean nobody remembers it in the US cuz mean nobody remembers it in the US cuz mean nobody remembers it in the US cuz we haven't seen one since the early we haven't seen one since the early we haven't seen one since the early 1950s, but we had three of them in 1950s, but we had three of them in 1950s, but we had three of them in succession 40s and 50s. It's the same succession 40s and 50s. It's the same succession 40s and 50s. It's the same thing. What ends up happening is you get thing. What ends up happening is you get thing. What ends up happening is you get a rush of demand and supply is not able a rush of demand and supply is not able a rush of demand and supply is not able to respond to it quickly, which makes to respond to it quickly, which makes to respond to it quickly, which makes perfect sense when you think about what perfect sense when you think about what perfect sense when you think about what was going on in 21 and 22. You had an was going on in 21 and 22. You had an was going on in 21 and 22. You had an economy and a global system that was economy and a global system that was economy and a global system that was hindered by the lockdowns and emergency hindered by the lockdowns and emergency hindered by the lockdowns and emergency COVID and pandemic measures especially COVID and pandemic measures especially COVID and pandemic measures especially in the labor market where you had a in the labor market where you had a in the labor market where you had a sudden increase in demand which wasn't sudden increase in demand which wasn't sudden increase in demand which wasn't really an increase in demand. It was really an increase in demand. It was really an increase in demand. It was sort of the demand you know everything sort of the demand you know everything sort of the demand you know everything got shut down in 2020. So we were got shut down in 2020. So we were got shut down in 2020. So we were operating at a low level and demand operating at a low level and demand operating at a low level and demand started to come back more quickly than started to come back more quickly than started to come back more quickly than supply was able to um supply was able to supply was able to um supply was able to supply was able to um supply was able to service it. So what ends up happening is service it. So what ends up happening is service it. So what ends up happening is simple economics. You line up a supply simple economics. You line up a supply simple economics. You line up a supply and demand curve against each other. and demand curve against each other. and demand curve against each other. What happens when demand goes up and What happens when demand goes up and What happens when demand goes up and supply is fixed and supply is relatively supply is fixed and supply is relatively supply is fixed and supply is relatively inelastic. The only way that to inelastic. The only way that to inelastic. The only way that to reconcile that in simple economics is reconcile that in simple economics is reconcile that in simple economics is prices go up which they did. So that was prices go up which they did. So that was prices go up which they did. So that was the supply restraints in 21 and 22 were the supply restraints in 21 and 22 were the supply restraints in 21 and 22 were were the vast majority of the reason why were the vast majority of the reason why were the vast majority of the reason why consumer prices went up as much as they consumer prices went up as much as they consumer prices went up as much as they did and that's why consumer prices did and that's why consumer prices did and that's why consumer prices largely since then have plateaued in in largely since then have plateaued in in largely since then have plateaued in in sort of like a new paradigm. So you see sort of like a new paradigm. So you see sort of like a new paradigm. So you see this big phase shift in 21 and 22 which this big phase shift in 21 and 22 which this big phase shift in 21 and 22 which is consistent with a supply shock and is consistent with a supply shock and is consistent with a supply shock and then prices kind of level off. um then prices kind of level off. um then prices kind of level off. um they're never going to go back to where they're never going to go back to where they're never going to go back to where they were in 2019 because that's they were in 2019 because that's they were in 2019 because that's completely impossible. You can never go completely impossible. You can never go completely impossible. You can never go backward. But it is consistent with a backward. But it is consistent with a backward. But it is consistent with a supply shock case that we see through supply shock case that we see through supply shock case that we see through our history. It's basically a phase our history. It's basically a phase our history. It's basically a phase shift. And the problem is and what we're shift. And the problem is and what we're shift. And the problem is and what we're really what was supposed to have really what was supposed to have really what was supposed to have happened is that first of all, prices happened is that first of all, prices happened is that first of all, prices weren't supposed to be that imbalance. weren't supposed to be that imbalance. weren't supposed to be that imbalance. But assuming that they were, the point But assuming that they were, the point But assuming that they were, the point of the government stimulus, you know, of the government stimulus, you know, of the government stimulus, you know, the government payments was that, okay, the government payments was that, okay, the government payments was that, okay, we're going to try to give people some we're going to try to give people some we're going to try to give people some temporary relief from higher prices and temporary relief from higher prices and temporary relief from higher prices and the higher costs of interfering in the the higher costs of interfering in the the higher costs of interfering in the economy. And then they would be able to economy. And then they would be able to economy. And then they would be able to over time their incomes would rise over time their incomes would rise over time their incomes would rise faster than prices after the supply faster than prices after the supply faster than prices after the supply shock and after the phase shift so that shock and after the phase shift so that shock and after the phase shift so that incomes would rebalance and renormalize incomes would rebalance and renormalize incomes would rebalance and renormalize at a higher price level. But the problem at a higher price level. But the problem at a higher price level. But the problem is that never happened. So instead, for is that never happened. So instead, for is that never happened. So instead, for the vast majority of people, you got the the vast majority of people, you got the the vast majority of people, you got the phase shift where prices went up. And phase shift where prices went up. And phase shift where prices went up. And then of course, yes, they continue to go then of course, yes, they continue to go then of course, yes, they continue to go up, but they they've gone up at a much up, but they they've gone up at a much up, but they they've gone up at a much slower rate since then. Um, and you take slower rate since then. Um, and you take slower rate since then. Um, and you take away the the rental component and really away the the rental component and really away the the rental component and really it's were back in the 2010s all over it's were back in the 2010s all over it's were back in the 2010s all over again. But after the phase shift, you again. But after the phase shift, you again. But after the phase shift, you know, incomes were the key was always know, incomes were the key was always know, incomes were the key was always labor and incomes. Incomes were supposed labor and incomes. Incomes were supposed labor and incomes. Incomes were supposed to rise a little bit over time, but to rise a little bit over time, but to rise a little bit over time, but incomes were supposed to rise not to incomes were supposed to rise not to incomes were supposed to rise not to just where prices were, but to then go just where prices were, but to then go just where prices were, but to then go above them. And that was the expectation above them. And that was the expectation above them. And that was the expectation that we were given in 2022 when that we were given in 2022 when that we were given in 2022 when everybody said we had a red-hot everybody said we had a red-hot everybody said we had a red-hot recovery. We really didn't. But the uh recovery. We really didn't. But the uh recovery. We really didn't. But the uh the phase shift in the effect on the phase shift in the effect on the phase shift in the effect on consumer prices made it seem like that consumer prices made it seem like that consumer prices made it seem like that was a legitimate pathway forward. In was a legitimate pathway forward. In was a legitimate pathway forward. In fact, a lot of people bought into it and fact, a lot of people bought into it and fact, a lot of people bought into it and companies bought into it. Amazon, some companies bought into it. Amazon, some companies bought into it. Amazon, some of the big tech companies, they bought of the big tech companies, they bought of the big tech companies, they bought into this idea that that was going to be into this idea that that was going to be into this idea that that was going to be the way that the government had the way that the government had the way that the government had engineered the perfect solution to the engineered the perfect solution to the engineered the perfect solution to the pandemic and the lockdowns. What it pandemic and the lockdowns. What it pandemic and the lockdowns. What it really did was created created this really did was created created this really did was created created this impoverishment and lack of recovery impoverishment and lack of recovery impoverishment and lack of recovery because once you realize as a business because once you realize as a business because once you realize as a business um you know nominal your nominal um you know nominal your nominal um you know nominal your nominal revenues are rising but you're not revenues are rising but you're not revenues are rising but you're not actually selling more goods, you don't actually selling more goods, you don't actually selling more goods, you don't actually need to rehire the workforce actually need to rehire the workforce actually need to rehire the workforce that you had beforehand. So not only do that you had beforehand. So not only do that you had beforehand. So not only do you have incomes that were insufficient you have incomes that were insufficient you have incomes that were insufficient to pay for the supply shock and the rise to pay for the supply shock and the rise to pay for the supply shock and the rise in prices, you also have businesses in prices, you also have businesses in prices, you also have businesses saying, especially in the car business, saying, especially in the car business, saying, especially in the car business, perfect illustration, we're making less perfect illustration, we're making less perfect illustration, we're making less cars but making more money per car. Why cars but making more money per car. Why cars but making more money per car. Why do we need to hire all the workers back do we need to hire all the workers back do we need to hire all the workers back that we let go during the pandemic? And that we let go during the pandemic? And that we let go during the pandemic? And so in business and industry after so in business and industry after so in business and industry after industry, this is where we get into the industry, this is where we get into the industry, this is where we get into the what I said before about the what I said before about the what I said before about the establishment survey. Jobs never establishment survey. Jobs never establishment survey. Jobs never recovered. So incomes could never recovered. So incomes could never recovered. So incomes could never recover. And if incomes never recovered, recover. And if incomes never recovered, recover. And if incomes never recovered, spending doesn't really recover. And so spending doesn't really recover. And so spending doesn't really recover. And so there's no pathway forward for there's no pathway forward for there's no pathway forward for generalized income through the economy. generalized income through the economy. generalized income through the economy. And this is not just a US phenomenon. And this is not just a US phenomenon. And this is not just a US phenomenon. This is the entire world. There's no This is the entire world. There's no This is the entire world. There's no pathway forward for incomes to pathway forward for incomes to pathway forward for incomes to renormalize to higher price levels. And renormalize to higher price levels. And renormalize to higher price levels. And so we've been stuck for the last several so we've been stuck for the last several so we've been stuck for the last several years trying to negotiate a system where years trying to negotiate a system where years trying to negotiate a system where people are impoverished and they know it people are impoverished and they know it people are impoverished and they know it but they don't know why they're but they don't know why they're but they don't know why they're impoverished and why nothing seems to be impoverished and why nothing seems to be impoverished and why nothing seems to be going in the right direction. So me going in the right direction. So me going in the right direction. So me mechanistically we had this supply shock mechanistically we had this supply shock mechanistically we had this supply shock phase shift that made people poor made phase shift that made people poor made phase shift that made people poor made their purchasing power go down. It their purchasing power go down. It their purchasing power go down. It looked like inflation and money looked like inflation and money looked like inflation and money printing, but it was only temporary printing, but it was only temporary printing, but it was only temporary because it was more so the basic because it was more so the basic because it was more so the basic imbalance between supply and demand in imbalance between supply and demand in imbalance between supply and demand in the economy that was engineered by the economy that was engineered by the economy that was engineered by really stupid, ill-thoughtout, really stupid, ill-thoughtout, really stupid, ill-thoughtout, ill-conceived government policies ill-conceived government policies ill-conceived government policies related to the pandemics, the lockdowns, related to the pandemics, the lockdowns, related to the pandemics, the lockdowns, and then the opening up afterward. and then the opening up afterward. and then the opening up afterward. >> Okay. So, if we wanted to navigate that >> Okay. So, if we wanted to navigate that >> Okay. So, if we wanted to navigate that moment well and not end up here, and moment well and not end up here, and moment well and not end up here, and we'll get to we are here and so what do we'll get to we are here and so what do we'll get to we are here and so what do we do about it? if we had wanted to we do about it? if we had wanted to we do about it? if we had wanted to avoid that. It's basically you you just avoid that. It's basically you you just avoid that. It's basically you you just can't lock down because you create this can't lock down because you create this can't lock down because you create this um one thing I think you implied but um one thing I think you implied but um one thing I think you implied but didn't quite state and I want to make didn't quite state and I want to make didn't quite state and I want to make sure that I understand it perfectly is sure that I understand it perfectly is sure that I understand it perfectly is that um by doing the lockdowns you made that um by doing the lockdowns you made that um by doing the lockdowns you made it impossible to make the things that it impossible to make the things that it impossible to make the things that people want to buy. And so you've you've people want to buy. And so you've you've people want to buy. And so you've you've crushed the supply side but the demand crushed the supply side but the demand crushed the supply side but the demand side either held flat or actually went side either held flat or actually went side either held flat or actually went up because people are sitting at home. up because people are sitting at home. up because people are sitting at home. They've got a STEMI check and now they They've got a STEMI check and now they They've got a STEMI check and now they want to buy something, but people can't want to buy something, but people can't want to buy something, but people can't make new stuff. And so now you have more make new stuff. And so now you have more make new stuff. And so now you have more money chasing not only the same goods, money chasing not only the same goods, money chasing not only the same goods, you have more money chasing fewer goods. you have more money chasing fewer goods. you have more money chasing fewer goods. Boom. You get that phase shift that Boom. You get that phase shift that Boom. You get that phase shift that you're talking about in terms of the you're talking about in terms of the you're talking about in terms of the jump that comes out somewhere around jump that comes out somewhere around jump that comes out somewhere around 30%. 30%. 30%. Would have been fine had the jobs Would have been fine had the jobs Would have been fine had the jobs recovered, but the jobs didn't recover. recovered, but the jobs didn't recover. recovered, but the jobs didn't recover. Now clearly the jobs didn't recover. you Now clearly the jobs didn't recover. you Now clearly the jobs didn't recover. you were very articulate about because were very articulate about because were very articulate about because people realize, oh well, nominally, people realize, oh well, nominally, people realize, oh well, nominally, meaning relatively, um, not in real meaning relatively, um, not in real meaning relatively, um, not in real terms, but relatively, I'm making more terms, but relatively, I'm making more terms, but relatively, I'm making more money per car was the example that you money per car was the example that you money per car was the example that you used. Um, and therefore, I'm making more used. Um, and therefore, I'm making more used. Um, and therefore, I'm making more nominal dollars with fewer employees, nominal dollars with fewer employees, nominal dollars with fewer employees, fewer cars sold. Cool. I'm good. And so fewer cars sold. Cool. I'm good. And so fewer cars sold. Cool. I'm good. And so people started saying, well, I'm doing people started saying, well, I'm doing people started saying, well, I'm doing all these layoffs because of AI. But in all these layoffs because of AI. But in all these layoffs because of AI. But in reality, I'm doing these layoffs because reality, I'm doing these layoffs because reality, I'm doing these layoffs because the economy hasn't recovered. And so I the economy hasn't recovered. And so I the economy hasn't recovered. And so I don't have the renormalized demand and I don't have the renormalized demand and I don't have the renormalized demand and I can sort of mask it with the inflated can sort of mask it with the inflated can sort of mask it with the inflated dollars. And so me I'm just going to dollars. And so me I'm just going to dollars. And so me I'm just going to keep moving forward. The K-shaped keep moving forward. The K-shaped keep moving forward. The K-shaped economy starts going farther and farther economy starts going farther and farther economy starts going farther and farther apart. Uh and now we have pitchforks apart. Uh and now we have pitchforks apart. Uh and now we have pitchforks sort of looming at the edges as the sort of looming at the edges as the sort of looming at the edges as the people who are now 30% underwater plus people who are now 30% underwater plus people who are now 30% underwater plus the call it 8 million people that should the call it 8 million people that should the call it 8 million people that should be working but aren't. And that's how be working but aren't. And that's how be working but aren't. And that's how we've ended up here. we've ended up here. we've ended up here. >> That's kind of the generalized overview. >> That's kind of the generalized overview. >> That's kind of the generalized overview. And yeah, you can see any number of And yeah, you can see any number of And yeah, you can see any number of example. I mean, a perfect example example. I mean, a perfect example example. I mean, a perfect example you're talking about block Jack Dorsey's you're talking about block Jack Dorsey's you're talking about block Jack Dorsey's company made a huge fuss a couple of company made a huge fuss a couple of company made a huge fuss a couple of months ago when he said we're laying off months ago when he said we're laying off months ago when he said we're laying off what was it 40 or 50% of our workforce what was it 40 or 50% of our workforce what was it 40 or 50% of our workforce and everybody's oh my god he's doing it and everybody's oh my god he's doing it and everybody's oh my god he's doing it because of AI and he he the company because of AI and he he the company because of AI and he he the company block did reference AI but what they're block did reference AI but what they're block did reference AI but what they're really saying is look we hired too many really saying is look we hired too many really saying is look we hired too many people back in 21 and 22. In fact, people back in 21 and 22. In fact, people back in 21 and 22. In fact, Dorsey admitted we hired for two Dorsey admitted we hired for two Dorsey admitted we hired for two companies cuz we thought there was going companies cuz we thought there was going companies cuz we thought there was going to be a legitimate recovery because to be a legitimate recovery because to be a legitimate recovery because that's what everybody said and it looked that's what everybody said and it looked that's what everybody said and it looked like that was going to be the pathway like that was going to be the pathway like that was going to be the pathway forward. We realized that wasn't true. forward. We realized that wasn't true. forward. We realized that wasn't true. And eventually, I mean, you can hang on And eventually, I mean, you can hang on And eventually, I mean, you can hang on a little while because most employers a little while because most employers a little while because most employers do. There's there's usually a lag in do. There's there's usually a lag in do. There's there's usually a lag in time before you realize the economy time before you realize the economy time before you realize the economy isn't what you think it is because you isn't what you think it is because you isn't what you think it is because you hold out hope, okay, maybe this year hold out hope, okay, maybe this year hold out hope, okay, maybe this year will be the year that it turns around. will be the year that it turns around. will be the year that it turns around. But eventually you go long enough where But eventually you go long enough where But eventually you go long enough where it doesn't turn around. You hired too it doesn't turn around. You hired too it doesn't turn around. You hired too many people a couple years ago, you many people a couple years ago, you many people a couple years ago, you start getting you start making start getting you start making start getting you start making adjustments. And so that's what really adjustments. And so that's what really adjustments. And so that's what really happened in the labor market. You know, happened in the labor market. You know, happened in the labor market. You know, people started hearing about the people started hearing about the people started hearing about the establishment survey turned negative in establishment survey turned negative in establishment survey turned negative in 2025. At the margins, businesses were 2025. At the margins, businesses were 2025. At the margins, businesses were realized. Amazon another perfect realized. Amazon another perfect realized. Amazon another perfect example. they staffed up tremendously in example. they staffed up tremendously in example. they staffed up tremendously in 21 and 22 and since then uh the level of 21 and 22 and since then uh the level of 21 and 22 and since then uh the level of employees especially in the United employees especially in the United employees especially in the United States at Amazon has been either you States at Amazon has been either you States at Amazon has been either you know worldwide it's a little bit higher know worldwide it's a little bit higher know worldwide it's a little bit higher but in the United States it's been but in the United States it's been but in the United States it's been trending lower because businesses trending lower because businesses trending lower because businesses realize we hired way too many people realize we hired way too many people realize we hired way too many people back then we don't have anything for back then we don't have anything for back then we don't have anything for them to do we got a little bit more them to do we got a little bit more them to do we got a little bit more nominal revenue but now we need to nominal revenue but now we need to nominal revenue but now we need to readjust to the economy that we have not readjust to the economy that we have not readjust to the economy that we have not the one that we were promised or the one the one that we were promised or the one the one that we were promised or the one we would like and in that process that we would like and in that process that we would like and in that process that adjustment process it makes it even adjustment process it makes it even adjustment process it makes it even worse because people who are who are worse because people who are who are worse because people who are who are very who are at least aware of the, you very who are at least aware of the, you very who are at least aware of the, you know, the impoverishment and the and the know, the impoverishment and the and the know, the impoverishment and the and the disparity between income and prices now disparity between income and prices now disparity between income and prices now become even more aware of it as they see become even more aware of it as they see become even more aware of it as they see job opportunities diminishing and job opportunities diminishing and job opportunities diminishing and disappearing all over the place. So, the disappearing all over the place. So, the disappearing all over the place. So, the K-shaped economy narrative isn't K-shaped economy narrative isn't K-shaped economy narrative isn't actually a narrative. It's a way to actually a narrative. It's a way to actually a narrative. It's a way to describe the situation in a way that's describe the situation in a way that's describe the situation in a way that's at least familiar enough for people at least familiar enough for people at least familiar enough for people without having all of these details without having all of these details without having all of these details filled in. But that's really where we filled in. But that's really where we filled in. But that's really where we are. And to you know what you said are. And to you know what you said are. And to you know what you said earlier how the original problem here earlier how the original problem here earlier how the original problem here original sin if you want to call it that original sin if you want to call it that original sin if you want to call it that was that the lockdowns I mean I you know was that the lockdowns I mean I you know was that the lockdowns I mean I you know once you interfere with the economy in once you interfere with the economy in once you interfere with the economy in that way you're going to get into the that way you're going to get into the that way you're going to get into the law of unintended consequences that's law of unintended consequences that's law of unintended consequences that's just the way it is in a complex system just the way it is in a complex system just the way it is in a complex system you can never predict how it's going to you can never predict how it's going to you can never predict how it's going to go and if it starts to go in one go and if it starts to go in one go and if it starts to go in one direction and go too far in one direction and go too far in one direction and go too far in one direction there's really nothing you can direction there's really nothing you can direction there's really nothing you can do about it but by interfering in such a do about it but by interfering in such a do about it but by interfering in such a big way they set in train you know a set big way they set in train you know a set big way they set in train you know a set of they set in motion a train of events of they set in motion a train of events of they set in motion a train of events that led to all of these imbalances is that led to all of these imbalances is that led to all of these imbalances is because that's what happens when you because that's what happens when you because that's what happens when you interfere in a natural system. Any interfere in a natural system. Any interfere in a natural system. Any interference will lead to some kind of interference will lead to some kind of interference will lead to some kind of distortion which is really what the distortion which is really what the distortion which is really what the supply shock in the in the uh the phase supply shock in the in the uh the phase supply shock in the in the uh the phase shift in prices was. It was a distortion shift in prices was. It was a distortion shift in prices was. It was a distortion in the economy. Is the economy telling in the economy. Is the economy telling in the economy. Is the economy telling you we were being we're being distorted you we were being we're being distorted you we were being we're being distorted here and this is going to be a big here and this is going to be a big here and this is going to be a big problem. So the problem is you know problem. So the problem is you know problem. So the problem is you know whether or not you're sympathetic to the whether or not you're sympathetic to the whether or not you're sympathetic to the lockdowns and whether or not that was lockdowns and whether or not that was lockdowns and whether or not that was that was a necessary thing that had to that was a necessary thing that had to that was a necessary thing that had to happen for the pandemic. as far as from happen for the pandemic. as far as from happen for the pandemic. as far as from an economics perspective, a purely an economics perspective, a purely an economics perspective, a purely economics perspective, there was really economics perspective, there was really economics perspective, there was really no way going back after that. no way going back after that. no way going back after that. >> Okay. Well, if the a lot of companies >> Okay. Well, if the a lot of companies >> Okay. Well, if the a lot of companies anyway did the rehiring in an anyway did the rehiring in an anyway did the rehiring in an anticipatory fashion, so hey, we're anticipatory fashion, so hey, we're anticipatory fashion, so hey, we're going to bounce back. So, I'm going to going to bounce back. So, I'm going to going to bounce back. So, I'm going to hire now, bring people back in. So, a hire now, bring people back in. So, a hire now, bring people back in. So, a lot of people came back into the lot of people came back into the lot of people came back into the workforce, but something stopped that workforce, but something stopped that workforce, but something stopped that from solving the problem. So why by from solving the problem. So why by from solving the problem. So why by bringing all of those people in did that bringing all of those people in did that bringing all of those people in did that not sort of restimulate the economy not sort of restimulate the economy not sort of restimulate the economy because now they've got a job again and because now they've got a job again and because now they've got a job again and presumably they've got money but they presumably they've got money but they presumably they've got money but they were never able to um go back to p or were never able to um go back to p or were never able to um go back to p or they didn't go back to purchasing enough they didn't go back to purchasing enough they didn't go back to purchasing enough that the economy reormalized. Why not? that the economy reormalized. Why not? that the economy reormalized. Why not? >> Just simply because it wasn't enough >> Just simply because it wasn't enough >> Just simply because it wasn't enough people um the number of people who were people um the number of people who were people um the number of people who were let go during the lockdowns and the let go during the lockdowns and the let go during the lockdowns and the number of people who were brought back number of people who were brought back number of people who were brought back after them just never normalized. Yeah. after them just never normalized. Yeah. after them just never normalized. Yeah. You look at it again, you have to you You look at it again, you have to you You look at it again, you have to you have to keep in you have to keep in mind have to keep in you have to keep in mind have to keep in you have to keep in mind population growth and expansion. So population growth and expansion. So population growth and expansion. So while there is nominally more jobs now while there is nominally more jobs now while there is nominally more jobs now than there was in 20, you know, uh 20 than there was in 20, you know, uh 20 than there was in 20, you know, uh 20 early 2020 just before the lockdowns, early 2020 just before the lockdowns, early 2020 just before the lockdowns, it's nowhere near enough. Again, that's it's nowhere near enough. Again, that's it's nowhere near enough. Again, that's where the trend line becomes important where the trend line becomes important where the trend line becomes important because you need at least 2 million jobs because you need at least 2 million jobs because you need at least 2 million jobs every year just to absorb new entrance every year just to absorb new entrance every year just to absorb new entrance into the marketplace. into the marketplace. into the marketplace. >> So if you're you know what is that six >> So if you're you know what is that six >> So if you're you know what is that six years ago? So six years you should have years ago? So six years you should have years ago? So six years you should have at least probably you know two and a at least probably you know two and a at least probably you know two and a half million but just to be safe we'll half million but just to be safe we'll half million but just to be safe we'll say 2 million. So 6 years you should say 2 million. So 6 years you should say 2 million. So 6 years you should have 12 million more jobs when we only have 12 million more jobs when we only have 12 million more jobs when we only have about 7 million more jobs. It's have about 7 million more jobs. It's have about 7 million more jobs. It's actually more it's worse than that. But actually more it's worse than that. But actually more it's worse than that. But when you look at some of the other when you look at some of the other when you look at some of the other statistics like the household survey statistics like the household survey statistics like the household survey it's more like 10 or 11 million jobs it's more like 10 or 11 million jobs it's more like 10 or 11 million jobs short. But either way the point stands. short. But either way the point stands. short. But either way the point stands. You have two basic problems. Uh people You have two basic problems. Uh people You have two basic problems. Uh people who no now they can no longer buy as who no now they can no longer buy as who no now they can no longer buy as much as they did with the same amount of much as they did with the same amount of much as they did with the same amount of income. That's the phase shift in income. That's the phase shift in income. That's the phase shift in prices. So you want to go buy a car. prices. So you want to go buy a car. prices. So you want to go buy a car. Well, it's 30% more expensive, which Well, it's 30% more expensive, which Well, it's 30% more expensive, which means some people are no longer able to means some people are no longer able to means some people are no longer able to afford a car because their incomes afford a car because their incomes afford a car because their incomes didn't go up by 30%. That's number one, didn't go up by 30%. That's number one, didn't go up by 30%. That's number one, incomes don't go far enough to you for incomes don't go far enough to you for incomes don't go far enough to you for you for more people to be able to buy you for more people to be able to buy you for more people to be able to buy the same stuff that they used to buy the same stuff that they used to buy the same stuff that they used to buy before. And the second thing is people before. And the second thing is people before. And the second thing is people can't buy anything when they're not can't buy anything when they're not can't buy anything when they're not working. Yes, the government's, you working. Yes, the government's, you working. Yes, the government's, you know, gave you a bit of a transfer there know, gave you a bit of a transfer there know, gave you a bit of a transfer there for a couple years, but those transfers for a couple years, but those transfers for a couple years, but those transfers ended up running out. And after those ended up running out. And after those ended up running out. And after those transfers ran out, what happened? There transfers ran out, what happened? There transfers ran out, what happened? There was no jobs available, so you couldn't was no jobs available, so you couldn't was no jobs available, so you couldn't get to work. So you've got people who get to work. So you've got people who get to work. So you've got people who can't buy as much as they did before and can't buy as much as they did before and can't buy as much as they did before and at the same time you've got millions of at the same time you've got millions of at the same time you've got millions of people who aren't working that should be people who aren't working that should be people who aren't working that should be working and that that amount of marginal working and that that amount of marginal working and that that amount of marginal missing activity explains why we never missing activity explains why we never missing activity explains why we never really got to a full recovery. But really got to a full recovery. But really got to a full recovery. But because it doesn't look like the typical because it doesn't look like the typical because it doesn't look like the typical traditional recession period. Businesses traditional recession period. Businesses traditional recession period. Businesses have been stuck in this weird limbo have been stuck in this weird limbo have been stuck in this weird limbo where they're trying to figure out well where they're trying to figure out well where they're trying to figure out well where's the right level of business? It where's the right level of business? It where's the right level of business? It doesn't look like a recession say like doesn't look like a recession say like doesn't look like a recession say like we went through in 2001 where you just h we went through in 2001 where you just h we went through in 2001 where you just h you know fire a bunch of people we go you know fire a bunch of people we go you know fire a bunch of people we go through a downturn and come back on the through a downturn and come back on the through a downturn and come back on the other side. It's been this slowm moving other side. It's been this slowm moving other side. It's been this slowm moving kind of train wreck where a few kind of train wreck where a few kind of train wreck where a few businesses here figure, well, I'm going businesses here figure, well, I'm going businesses here figure, well, I'm going to stop hiring. I'm not going to hire to stop hiring. I'm not going to hire to stop hiring. I'm not going to hire anybody because I don't have anything anybody because I don't have anything anybody because I don't have anything for them to do. Couple businesses over for them to do. Couple businesses over for them to do. Couple businesses over here think, well, I've got too many here think, well, I've got too many here think, well, I've got too many employees. I'm going to let one or two employees. I'm going to let one or two employees. I'm going to let one or two go. You don't get the mass waves of go. You don't get the mass waves of go. You don't get the mass waves of unemployment that looks like a unemployment that looks like a unemployment that looks like a traditional recession, yet you get all traditional recession, yet you get all traditional recession, yet you get all the problems that you would associate the problems that you would associate the problems that you would associate with recession that in under because with recession that in under because with recession that in under because it's these unique circumstances that it's these unique circumstances that it's these unique circumstances that created it. So, we have this kind of created it. So, we have this kind of created it. So, we have this kind of quasi recessionary environment, which quasi recessionary environment, which quasi recessionary environment, which again gets back to the original again gets back to the original again gets back to the original discussion. Why is there so much demand discussion. Why is there so much demand discussion. Why is there so much demand for safety and liquidity? Because we're for safety and liquidity? Because we're for safety and liquidity? Because we're in this weird type of period or weird in this weird type of period or weird in this weird type of period or weird type of situation where it's neither type of situation where it's neither type of situation where it's neither growth nor the end of the world. It's growth nor the end of the world. It's growth nor the end of the world. It's kind of somewhere in the middle. And I kind of somewhere in the middle. And I kind of somewhere in the middle. And I think most people, like I said, perceive think most people, like I said, perceive think most people, like I said, perceive that there's something wrong here. We that there's something wrong here. We that there's something wrong here. We feel like we've been left behind because feel like we've been left behind because feel like we've been left behind because they have been left behind. And nothing they have been left behind. And nothing they have been left behind. And nothing is changing. That's the other part of is changing. That's the other part of is changing. That's the other part of this. When you think about moving this. When you think about moving this. When you think about moving forward, forward, forward, >> it's been how many years now and nothing >> it's been how many years now and nothing >> it's been how many years now and nothing has changed. I mean, you hear about the has changed. I mean, you hear about the has changed. I mean, you hear about the no higher economy. It's been no higher no higher economy. It's been no higher no higher economy. It's been no higher since really around 22 and 23. That's since really around 22 and 23. That's since really around 22 and 23. That's several years without really big-time several years without really big-time several years without really big-time job opportunities, which leads to all job opportunities, which leads to all job opportunities, which leads to all sorts of other consequences, not just in sorts of other consequences, not just in sorts of other consequences, not just in the macroeconomic realm. And you got, the macroeconomic realm. And you got, the macroeconomic realm. And you got, you know, socialism, you got political you know, socialism, you got political you know, socialism, you got political dis upheaval and things like that dis upheaval and things like that dis upheaval and things like that because people really feel that the because people really feel that the because people really feel that the system doesn't work because it actually system doesn't work because it actually system doesn't work because it actually doesn't work. But not being able to be doesn't work. But not being able to be doesn't work. But not being able to be able to not being able to identify why able to not being able to identify why able to not being able to identify why it doesn't work leads to all of these it doesn't work leads to all of these it doesn't work leads to all of these other, you know, confusing uh confusing other, you know, confusing uh confusing other, you know, confusing uh confusing topics and confusing takeaways. We'll be topics and confusing takeaways. We'll be topics and confusing takeaways. We'll be right back to the show, but right now right back to the show, but right now right back to the show, but right now let's talk about why you're running your let's talk about why you're running your let's talk about why you're running your business on hard mode. Right now, your business on hard mode. Right now, your business on hard mode. Right now, your company is sitting on the answers to company is sitting on the answers to company is sitting on the answers to your biggest problems. The data exists, your biggest problems. The data exists, your biggest problems. The data exists, the patterns exist, you just can't get the patterns exist, you just can't get the patterns exist, you just can't get to them fast enough. That's what to them fast enough. That's what to them fast enough. That's what Netswuite Next solves. Netswuite is the Netswuite Next solves. Netswuite is the Netswuite Next solves. Netswuite is the AI powered business management suite AI powered business management suite AI powered business management suite trusted by over 43,000 trusted by over 43,000 trusted by over 43,000 customers. And Netswuite Next is their customers. And Netswuite Next is their customers. And Netswuite Next is their next massive leap. AI built into next massive leap. AI built into next massive leap. AI built into everything. It automatically surfaces everything. It automatically surfaces everything. It automatically surfaces customer insights throughout your day customer insights throughout your day customer insights throughout your day before you even think to ask. AI agents before you even think to ask. AI agents before you even think to ask. AI agents work alongside you to handle routine work alongside you to handle routine work alongside you to handle routine work and solve problems. And it's work and solve problems. And it's work and solve problems. And it's customized for a wide range of customized for a wide range of customized for a wide range of industries. Whether your company earns industries. Whether your company earns industries. Whether your company earns millions or hundreds of millions, this millions or hundreds of millions, this millions or hundreds of millions, this is where your business meets AI. For the is where your business meets AI. For the is where your business meets AI. For the first time ever, you can try Netswuite first time ever, you can try Netswuite first time ever, you can try Netswuite next for free. If your revenues are at next for free. If your revenues are at next for free. If your revenues are at least in the seven figures, just go to least in the seven figures, just go to least in the seven figures, just go to netswuite.ai/ netswuite.ai/ netswuite.ai/ theory. Built for every industry, ready theory. Built for every industry, ready theory. Built for every industry, ready for every boardroom. And now, let's get for every boardroom. And now, let's get for every boardroom. And now, let's get back to the show. Okay, so we are where back to the show. Okay, so we are where back to the show. Okay, so we are where we are. Is socialism the answer or is we are. Is socialism the answer or is we are. Is socialism the answer or is there a better way out of this there a better way out of this there a better way out of this conundrum? conundrum? conundrum? >> Socialism is never the answer. Let's be >> Socialism is never the answer. Let's be >> Socialism is never the answer. Let's be honest about that. It always makes it honest about that. It always makes it honest about that. It always makes it worse. But you can understand and not to worse. But you can understand and not to worse. But you can understand and not to not to have too much sympathy, but you not to have too much sympathy, but you not to have too much sympathy, but you can understand where this is coming can understand where this is coming can understand where this is coming from. And let me throw a couple of from. And let me throw a couple of from. And let me throw a couple of statistics out there. The National statistics out there. The National statistics out there. The National Association of Realtors to really drive Association of Realtors to really drive Association of Realtors to really drive home this point about people being left home this point about people being left home this point about people being left behind and too many people being left behind and too many people being left behind and too many people being left behind. the K-shaped economy. Every behind. the K-shaped economy. Every behind. the K-shaped economy. Every economy is K-shaped, but an economy economy is K-shaped, but an economy economy is K-shaped, but an economy that's healthy has fewer people in the that's healthy has fewer people in the that's healthy has fewer people in the bottom than the top. An economy that's bottom than the top. An economy that's bottom than the top. An economy that's unhealthy has got more people in the unhealthy has got more people in the unhealthy has got more people in the bottom and more people moving from the bottom and more people moving from the bottom and more people moving from the top to the bottom. And so in a situation top to the bottom. And so in a situation top to the bottom. And so in a situation like that, the National Association of like that, the National Association of like that, the National Association of Realtors, uh, the biggest realtor firm Realtors, uh, the biggest realtor firm Realtors, uh, the biggest realtor firm in the US, they're the ones that put out in the US, they're the ones that put out in the US, they're the ones that put out the resale numbers every month. So every the resale numbers every month. So every the resale numbers every month. So every time you hear, you know, housing sales time you hear, you know, housing sales time you hear, you know, housing sales where that's comes from the N. They do where that's comes from the N. They do where that's comes from the N. They do an annual survey. And last year, the an annual survey. And last year, the an annual survey. And last year, the annual survey that came out in November, annual survey that came out in November, annual survey that came out in November, one of the things that they found was one of the things that they found was one of the things that they found was that the median age of first-time home that the median age of first-time home that the median age of first-time home buyers was 40. 40. buyers was 40. 40. buyers was 40. 40. >> Damn. >> Damn. >> Damn. >> First-time home buyer. 40. So, what that >> First-time home buyer. 40. So, what that >> First-time home buyer. 40. So, what that tells you is that the situation in the tells you is that the situation in the tells you is that the situation in the economy, not just in the 20120s, but economy, not just in the 20120s, but economy, not just in the 20120s, but also goes back to the 2010s. This really also goes back to the 2010s. This really also goes back to the 2010s. This really goes back to 2008. Um, income has been goes back to 2008. Um, income has been goes back to 2008. Um, income has been so weak, the labor market has been so so weak, the labor market has been so so weak, the labor market has been so insufficient, and you know, credit insufficient, and you know, credit insufficient, and you know, credit financing has been so unavailable. It financing has been so unavailable. It financing has been so unavailable. It now makes for the average the average now makes for the average the average now makes for the average the average young person a house is out of reach and young person a house is out of reach and young person a house is out of reach and it feels like it's out of reach. So in it feels like it's out of reach. So in it feels like it's out of reach. So in that situation where you can't afford a that situation where you can't afford a that situation where you can't afford a house until you're 40. You can't afford house until you're 40. You can't afford house until you're 40. You can't afford a new car because a car is 35% more a new car because a car is 35% more a new car because a car is 35% more expensive than it was in 2019 and your expensive than it was in 2019 and your expensive than it was in 2019 and your income is nowhere near that. Nobody is income is nowhere near that. Nobody is income is nowhere near that. Nobody is hiring. Careers don't start. You don't hiring. Careers don't start. You don't hiring. Careers don't start. You don't have any pathway forward. You can have any pathway forward. You can have any pathway forward. You can understand where the where the appeal of understand where the where the appeal of understand where the where the appeal of socialism is coming from because the socialism is coming from because the socialism is coming from because the socialist is telling you, "Look, this socialist is telling you, "Look, this socialist is telling you, "Look, this economy sucks. They're all lying to you. economy sucks. They're all lying to you. economy sucks. They're all lying to you. Look at those fat cats on Wall Street. Look at those fat cats on Wall Street. Look at those fat cats on Wall Street. They keep getting richer and richer and They keep getting richer and richer and They keep getting richer and richer and richer while your life sucks more and richer while your life sucks more and richer while your life sucks more and more and more and there is no end in more and more and there is no end in more and more and there is no end in sight to it. And furthermore, if you sight to it. And furthermore, if you sight to it. And furthermore, if you understand what the socialists are understand what the socialists are understand what the socialists are actually saying, talking about Marxist actually saying, talking about Marxist actually saying, talking about Marxist theory, Markx appears like he predicted theory, Markx appears like he predicted theory, Markx appears like he predicted a lot of this. If you know anything a lot of this. If you know anything a lot of this. If you know anything about Markx, what he was saying back in about Markx, what he was saying back in about Markx, what he was saying back in the 1800s, what he said was capitalism the 1800s, what he said was capitalism the 1800s, what he said was capitalism always needs endless endless new markets always needs endless endless new markets always needs endless endless new markets to exploit. you know using the language to exploit. you know using the language to exploit. you know using the language of the socialist and eventually of the socialist and eventually of the socialist and eventually capitalism would reach would get to a capitalism would reach would get to a capitalism would reach would get to a point where it has exploited all the new point where it has exploited all the new point where it has exploited all the new markets. It's innovated as far as you markets. It's innovated as far as you markets. It's innovated as far as you know creating new products. It can't go know creating new products. It can't go know creating new products. It can't go into a new land because everything has into a new land because everything has into a new land because everything has been con conquered by capitalism. And been con conquered by capitalism. And been con conquered by capitalism. And once capitalism gets to its end stage, once capitalism gets to its end stage, once capitalism gets to its end stage, this is a term you hear a lot these this is a term you hear a lot these this is a term you hear a lot these days, endstage capitalism or late stage days, endstage capitalism or late stage days, endstage capitalism or late stage capitalism. Once it gets to its end capitalism. Once it gets to its end capitalism. Once it gets to its end stage, the capitalist who only cares stage, the capitalist who only cares stage, the capitalist who only cares about increasing the profits will have about increasing the profits will have about increasing the profits will have to turn inward. Which means instead of to turn inward. Which means instead of to turn inward. Which means instead of exploiting new markets, we're going to exploiting new markets, we're going to exploiting new markets, we're going to start exploiting workers. And when the start exploiting workers. And when the start exploiting workers. And when the capitalist starts exploiting workers in capitalist starts exploiting workers in capitalist starts exploiting workers in endstage capitalism, what ends up endstage capitalism, what ends up endstage capitalism, what ends up happening? They start cutting wages. happening? They start cutting wages. happening? They start cutting wages. They start cutting jobs. They make They start cutting jobs. They make They start cutting jobs. They make housing and cars unaffordable. And housing and cars unaffordable. And housing and cars unaffordable. And everything that the Marxists have been everything that the Marxists have been everything that the Marxists have been preaching for years and years and years preaching for years and years and years preaching for years and years and years sounds a hell of a lot like most sounds a hell of a lot like most sounds a hell of a lot like most people's everyday lived experience. So people's everyday lived experience. So people's everyday lived experience. So you put the economy up against this you put the economy up against this you put the economy up against this Marxist doctrine, and then you got Marxist doctrine, and then you got Marxist doctrine, and then you got everybody, you know, mainstream everybody, you know, mainstream everybody, you know, mainstream political people saying, "Well, the political people saying, "Well, the political people saying, "Well, the stock market's great." you can stock market's great." you can stock market's great." you can understand where this is coming from understand where this is coming from understand where this is coming from because nobody is telling the truth because nobody is telling the truth because nobody is telling the truth because most people don't know what the because most people don't know what the because most people don't know what the actual truth is. So it really does start actual truth is. So it really does start actual truth is. So it really does start with economic depressionary conditions with economic depressionary conditions with economic depressionary conditions which is why you should always start which is why you should always start which is why you should always start with the yield curve in the bond market with the yield curve in the bond market with the yield curve in the bond market because the bond market has been telling because the bond market has been telling because the bond market has been telling you this from the very beginning with you this from the very beginning with you this from the very beginning with low interest rates depression economics. low interest rates depression economics. low interest rates depression economics. The reason why there's so much safety The reason why there's so much safety The reason why there's so much safety and liquidity demand despite the fact and liquidity demand despite the fact and liquidity demand despite the fact the government go cra go goes completely the government go cra go goes completely the government go cra go goes completely crazy and that's the reason why the crazy and that's the reason why the crazy and that's the reason why the government goes crazy because they're government goes crazy because they're government goes crazy because they're trying to chase the uh trying to do trying to chase the uh trying to do trying to chase the uh trying to do something about depression conditions to something about depression conditions to something about depression conditions to begin with. But the the bond market told begin with. But the the bond market told begin with. But the the bond market told you there's no economic growth. There's you there's no economic growth. There's you there's no economic growth. There's limited upside. The situation is not limited upside. The situation is not limited upside. The situation is not good. It's not changing. It's not good. It's not changing. It's not good. It's not changing. It's not getting any better. And so the getting any better. And so the getting any better. And so the inevitable consequences were never going inevitable consequences were never going inevitable consequences were never going to stay strictly macroeconomic or to stay strictly macroeconomic or to stay strictly macroeconomic or financial volatility. That's another financial volatility. That's another financial volatility. That's another thing Mark said too. Mark said when you thing Mark said too. Mark said when you thing Mark said too. Mark said when you get to endstage capitalism, there'll be get to endstage capitalism, there'll be get to endstage capitalism, there'll be more and more frequent crises. So, as more and more frequent crises. So, as more and more frequent crises. So, as far as most people on the street are far as most people on the street are far as most people on the street are concerned, especially young people, concerned, especially young people, concerned, especially young people, young people have been absolutely young people have been absolutely young people have been absolutely screwed by this. They have very little screwed by this. They have very little screwed by this. They have very little future and very little hope because the future and very little hope because the future and very little hope because the economy doesn't work. Um, so for young economy doesn't work. Um, so for young economy doesn't work. Um, so for young people, you can see where this is coming people, you can see where this is coming people, you can see where this is coming from. It looks like the Marxists were from. It looks like the Marxists were from. It looks like the Marxists were right because the economy that I live in right because the economy that I live in right because the economy that I live in is nothing like what I keep hearing is nothing like what I keep hearing is nothing like what I keep hearing about from all the people that I'm about from all the people that I'm about from all the people that I'm supposed to trust, including, you know, supposed to trust, including, you know, supposed to trust, including, you know, the stock market on Wall Street. If the the stock market on Wall Street. If the the stock market on Wall Street. If the stock market says the economy is robust stock market says the economy is robust stock market says the economy is robust and booming, which it doesn't, but and booming, which it doesn't, but and booming, which it doesn't, but that's what people believe, and this is that's what people believe, and this is that's what people believe, and this is a boom, give me something else. Give me a boom, give me something else. Give me a boom, give me something else. Give me something kind of give me a radical something kind of give me a radical something kind of give me a radical change. I'll sign up for this because change. I'll sign up for this because change. I'll sign up for this because this just sucks and it's not changing this just sucks and it's not changing this just sucks and it's not changing anytime soon. anytime soon. anytime soon. >> Okay, so one of the best uh explanations >> Okay, so one of the best uh explanations >> Okay, so one of the best uh explanations as to why people are feeling the pull as to why people are feeling the pull as to why people are feeling the pull toward socialism I've ever heard. Very toward socialism I've ever heard. Very toward socialism I've ever heard. Very well played. Um why then are they wrong? well played. Um why then are they wrong? well played. Um why then are they wrong? In big picture terms, we've heard this In big picture terms, we've heard this In big picture terms, we've heard this argument from them repeatedly throughout argument from them repeatedly throughout argument from them repeatedly throughout history. And that's the that's the history. And that's the that's the history. And that's the that's the positive message in all this. We've been positive message in all this. We've been positive message in all this. We've been through we've been here before. We've through we've been here before. We've through we've been here before. We've done this. Uh history is circular, not done this. Uh history is circular, not done this. Uh history is circular, not linear. We go through these cycles. We linear. We go through these cycles. We linear. We go through these cycles. We go through periods where capitalism go through periods where capitalism go through periods where capitalism looks like it's gone. It's going to hit looks like it's gone. It's going to hit looks like it's gone. It's going to hit to the end stage. The 1930s, perfect to the end stage. The 1930s, perfect to the end stage. The 1930s, perfect example. The last time we had a major example. The last time we had a major example. The last time we had a major flirtation with communism and socialism flirtation with communism and socialism flirtation with communism and socialism in the US was in the 1930s for in the US was in the 1930s for in the US was in the 1930s for understandable reasons. All the same understandable reasons. All the same understandable reasons. All the same reasons. It looked like the, you know, reasons. It looked like the, you know, reasons. It looked like the, you know, the uh predictions that Markx made were the uh predictions that Markx made were the uh predictions that Markx made were coming true. You know, the economy fell coming true. You know, the economy fell coming true. You know, the economy fell off a cliff and it never really came off a cliff and it never really came off a cliff and it never really came back, at least, you know, World War II. back, at least, you know, World War II. back, at least, you know, World War II. And by then, you know, World War II just And by then, you know, World War II just And by then, you know, World War II just made it even worse. It looked like Markx made it even worse. It looked like Markx made it even worse. It looked like Markx was right. But then what happened after was right. But then what happened after was right. But then what happened after World War II? What happened after World World War II? What happened after World World War II? What happened after World War II is the system reset itself. It War II is the system reset itself. It War II is the system reset itself. It got past all of the imbalances that led got past all of the imbalances that led got past all of the imbalances that led into the Great Collapse and the Great into the Great Collapse and the Great into the Great Collapse and the Great Depression. We got the monetary system Depression. We got the monetary system Depression. We got the monetary system back on some some kind of solid and back on some some kind of solid and back on some some kind of solid and stable format. And suddenly it unleashed stable format. And suddenly it unleashed stable format. And suddenly it unleashed this title wave of prosperity. And when this title wave of prosperity. And when this title wave of prosperity. And when you're going through the upswing in you're going through the upswing in you're going through the upswing in these long-term global cycles, the title these long-term global cycles, the title these long-term global cycles, the title wave of prosperity that becomes wave of prosperity that becomes wave of prosperity that becomes paramount in people's minds. And so paramount in people's minds. And so paramount in people's minds. And so socialism, what do we need socialism socialism, what do we need socialism socialism, what do we need socialism for? We have a legitimate economic boom for? We have a legitimate economic boom for? We have a legitimate economic boom that is creating widespread prosperity. that is creating widespread prosperity. that is creating widespread prosperity. Living standards are rising not just a Living standards are rising not just a Living standards are rising not just a little bit but noticeably all over the little bit but noticeably all over the little bit but noticeably all over the world. So what ends up happening, we go world. So what ends up happening, we go world. So what ends up happening, we go through these cycles. You go through the through these cycles. You go through the through these cycles. You go through the downswing, people necessarily and quite downswing, people necessarily and quite downswing, people necessarily and quite naturally look for alternative solutions naturally look for alternative solutions naturally look for alternative solutions because they don't know we're in a because they don't know we're in a because they don't know we're in a long-term downswing and they don't see long-term downswing and they don't see long-term downswing and they don't see any pathway out of it when the pathway any pathway out of it when the pathway any pathway out of it when the pathway out of it is just, you know, a little out of it is just, you know, a little out of it is just, you know, a little bit out of reach. But once we get to the bit out of reach. But once we get to the bit out of reach. But once we get to the the end of that downswing of the cycle, the end of that downswing of the cycle, the end of that downswing of the cycle, socialism people will forget about socialism people will forget about socialism people will forget about socialism because that you you'll get socialism because that you you'll get socialism because that you you'll get you'll get into a period another period you'll get into a period another period you'll get into a period another period a long run period where we recreate the a long run period where we recreate the a long run period where we recreate the prosperity that we've seen time and time prosperity that we've seen time and time prosperity that we've seen time and time again. I think there's this idea that again. I think there's this idea that again. I think there's this idea that globalization is something that we globalization is something that we globalization is something that we invented in the latter half of the 20th invented in the latter half of the 20th invented in the latter half of the 20th century and that's not the case. We've century and that's not the case. We've century and that's not the case. We've gone through these long long run cycles, gone through these long long run cycles, gone through these long long run cycles, multi-deade cycles repeatedly throughout multi-deade cycles repeatedly throughout multi-deade cycles repeatedly throughout the last couple hundred years and they the last couple hundred years and they the last couple hundred years and they look generally the same despite the look generally the same despite the look generally the same despite the changes in technology and the you know changes in technology and the you know changes in technology and the you know the gloss and the the facades of them. the gloss and the the facades of them. the gloss and the the facades of them. They're basically the same types of They're basically the same types of They're basically the same types of behavior, the same types of trends and behavior, the same types of trends and behavior, the same types of trends and the same types of developments. Um, so the same types of developments. Um, so the same types of developments. Um, so you get it's no fun to go through the you get it's no fun to go through the you get it's no fun to go through the downswing, but we've been in the downswing, but we've been in the downswing, but we've been in the downside for ever since, you know, downside for ever since, you know, downside for ever since, you know, August of 2007. So we're 20 years closer August of 2007. So we're 20 years closer August of 2007. So we're 20 years closer to getting out of it, which is the to getting out of it, which is the to getting out of it, which is the positive message here. The problem is positive message here. The problem is positive message here. The problem is >> the clock is ticking. You know, that's >> the clock is ticking. You know, that's >> the clock is ticking. You know, that's you we're 20 years into it, but also we you we're 20 years into it, but also we you we're 20 years into it, but also we got 20 years where people are really got 20 years where people are really got 20 years where people are really pissed off and thinking, you know, pissed off and thinking, you know, pissed off and thinking, you know, enough is enough here. So can we get to enough is enough here. So can we get to enough is enough here. So can we get to the upside of that cycle before the upside of that cycle before the upside of that cycle before something really breaks down and leads something really breaks down and leads something really breaks down and leads to, you know, longer term structural to, you know, longer term structural to, you know, longer term structural problems? All right, I'm going to problems? All right, I'm going to problems? All right, I'm going to speedrun the last time that we got speedrun the last time that we got speedrun the last time that we got ourselves out of this. Tell me if I get ourselves out of this. Tell me if I get ourselves out of this. Tell me if I get anything wrong and then tell me what we anything wrong and then tell me what we anything wrong and then tell me what we do this time because the setup is uh do this time because the setup is uh do this time because the setup is uh different enough. It doesn't seem different enough. It doesn't seem different enough. It doesn't seem self-evident to me. So, World War II self-evident to me. So, World War II self-evident to me. So, World War II goes like this. Hey Europe, you're doing goes like this. Hey Europe, you're doing goes like this. Hey Europe, you're doing great. Sorry, going to smash you in the great. Sorry, going to smash you in the great. Sorry, going to smash you in the face. World War I and World War II. By face. World War I and World War II. By face. World War I and World War II. By the end of it, you guys are exhausted. the end of it, you guys are exhausted. the end of it, you guys are exhausted. You're wildly in debt. Everything in You're wildly in debt. Everything in You're wildly in debt. Everything in your manufacturing base is broken. But your manufacturing base is broken. But your manufacturing base is broken. But hey, America comes out of it with all of hey, America comes out of it with all of hey, America comes out of it with all of your gold. You owe America a ton of your gold. You owe America a ton of your gold. You owe America a ton of money. uh and we have an industrial base money. uh and we have an industrial base money. uh and we have an industrial base the likes of which we have never seen the likes of which we have never seen the likes of which we have never seen before and we are now going to even before and we are now going to even before and we are now going to even though we have roughly the same kind of though we have roughly the same kind of though we have roughly the same kind of debt that we have now which is just debt that we have now which is just debt that we have now which is just completely irresponsible uh we're going completely irresponsible uh we're going completely irresponsible uh we're going to do yield curve control so we're going to do yield curve control so we're going to do yield curve control so we're going to artificially hold the interest rates to artificially hold the interest rates to artificially hold the interest rates below inflation so that we can inflate below inflation so that we can inflate below inflation so that we can inflate the debt away but the key post World War the debt away but the key post World War the debt away but the key post World War II was that the growth rate of the real II was that the growth rate of the real II was that the growth rate of the real economy was one widespread prosperity so economy was one widespread prosperity so economy was one widespread prosperity so workingass middle class They're workingass middle class They're workingass middle class They're thriving, so their growth rate is faster thriving, so their growth rate is faster thriving, so their growth rate is faster than the inflation rate. So, everybody than the inflation rate. So, everybody than the inflation rate. So, everybody is loving life and and we absolutely is loving life and and we absolutely is loving life and and we absolutely boom really up until the 70s when we boom really up until the 70s when we boom really up until the 70s when we start hitting some hiccups. But just a start hitting some hiccups. But just a start hitting some hiccups. But just a real run of prosperity. The US real run of prosperity. The US real run of prosperity. The US establishes itself as the people that establishes itself as the people that establishes itself as the people that buy everything the world over. So, buy everything the world over. So, buy everything the world over. So, everybody else leverages our prosperity everybody else leverages our prosperity everybody else leverages our prosperity to export things to us. So, we get an to export things to us. So, we get an to export things to us. So, we get an incredible life. They get money. They incredible life. They get money. They incredible life. They get money. They get to rebuild Marshall Plan, all of get to rebuild Marshall Plan, all of get to rebuild Marshall Plan, all of that. And we come out the other side and that. And we come out the other side and that. And we come out the other side and large swaths of the world are doing so large swaths of the world are doing so large swaths of the world are doing so well that it was like awesome. We reset well that it was like awesome. We reset well that it was like awesome. We reset this bad boy. We're in good shape. Now, this bad boy. We're in good shape. Now, this bad boy. We're in good shape. Now, uh do we have to go through all the uh do we have to go through all the uh do we have to go through all the bombings? Like must we bomb them all? bombings? Like must we bomb them all? bombings? Like must we bomb them all? Like uh China is the manufacturer. It's Like uh China is the manufacturer. It's Like uh China is the manufacturer. It's not us. So how do we reset today? not us. So how do we reset today? not us. So how do we reset today? >> Yeah, that's the I don't think the the >> Yeah, that's the I don't think the the >> Yeah, that's the I don't think the the key to me to getting out of the Great key to me to getting out of the Great key to me to getting out of the Great Depression era. wasn't necessarily World Depression era. wasn't necessarily World Depression era. wasn't necessarily World War II. Except that World War II kind of War II. Except that World War II kind of War II. Except that World War II kind of speeded up the process a bit because, speeded up the process a bit because, speeded up the process a bit because, you know, by necessity, we had to start you know, by necessity, we had to start you know, by necessity, we had to start thinking about what the other side would thinking about what the other side would thinking about what the other side would look like. And because the old system look like. And because the old system look like. And because the old system had been smashed so much, it was much had been smashed so much, it was much had been smashed so much, it was much easier. There was there was less easier. There was there was less easier. There was there was less hysteresus to get through to to restart hysteresus to get through to to restart hysteresus to get through to to restart and reset the system. What I think was and reset the system. What I think was and reset the system. What I think was the key was resetting the monetary the key was resetting the monetary the key was resetting the monetary system that allowed um allowed for the system that allowed um allowed for the system that allowed um allowed for the risk-taking behavior. You know, the risk-taking behavior. You know, the risk-taking behavior. You know, the Keynesians call it animal spirits, and Keynesians call it animal spirits, and Keynesians call it animal spirits, and there's a lot of truth to that. But the there's a lot of truth to that. But the there's a lot of truth to that. But the risk-taking behavior that was absent in risk-taking behavior that was absent in risk-taking behavior that was absent in the 1930s came roaring back in the the 1930s came roaring back in the the 1930s came roaring back in the 1950s. And a large part for what you 1950s. And a large part for what you 1950s. And a large part for what you just said. I would add to it that the just said. I would add to it that the just said. I would add to it that the biggest part of that was um the US biggest part of that was um the US biggest part of that was um the US became the buyer and therefore the most became the buyer and therefore the most became the buyer and therefore the most prosperous system, which allowed it to prosperous system, which allowed it to prosperous system, which allowed it to create collateral, which which is, you create collateral, which which is, you create collateral, which which is, you know, collateral is an incredibly know, collateral is an incredibly know, collateral is an incredibly important part of any modern society important part of any modern society important part of any modern society because risk-taking, nobody nobody does because risk-taking, nobody nobody does because risk-taking, nobody nobody does blind risk. I mean when you when you blind risk. I mean when you when you blind risk. I mean when you when you borrow money for a house your house is borrow money for a house your house is borrow money for a house your house is the collateral. When you buy a car your the collateral. When you buy a car your the collateral. When you buy a car your car is the collateral. So essentially car is the collateral. So essentially car is the collateral. So essentially the US leveraged position not just to the US leveraged position not just to the US leveraged position not just to you know do um you know uh to prosper you know do um you know uh to prosper you know do um you know uh to prosper itself but it created enormous amounts itself but it created enormous amounts itself but it created enormous amounts of collateral in all different kinds of of collateral in all different kinds of of collateral in all different kinds of ways that allowed for monetary expansion ways that allowed for monetary expansion ways that allowed for monetary expansion to grease the wheels of things that were to grease the wheels of things that were to grease the wheels of things that were finally moving in the right direction. finally moving in the right direction. finally moving in the right direction. So that's kind of the general outline So that's kind of the general outline So that's kind of the general outline that we should look for moving forward that we should look for moving forward that we should look for moving forward is get to a situation where we have we is get to a situation where we have we is get to a situation where we have we have enough I hope this doesn't happen have enough I hope this doesn't happen have enough I hope this doesn't happen where we have to destroy the old system where we have to destroy the old system where we have to destroy the old system in order to get to a new system because in order to get to a new system because in order to get to a new system because there have been periods in history where there have been periods in history where there have been periods in history where that's not been the case that you know that's not been the case that you know that's not been the case that you know eventually human ingenuity takes over. eventually human ingenuity takes over. eventually human ingenuity takes over. We figure out the problems that we need We figure out the problems that we need We figure out the problems that we need to figure out. Yes, it takes us a long to figure out. Yes, it takes us a long to figure out. Yes, it takes us a long time because we're not as ingenious as time because we're not as ingenious as time because we're not as ingenious as we think we are. Plus there's always we think we are. Plus there's always we think we are. Plus there's always institutional inertia which is always institutional inertia which is always institutional inertia which is always something you have to overcome. something you have to overcome. something you have to overcome. Essentially institutions don't want to Essentially institutions don't want to Essentially institutions don't want to change. they don't want to get with a change. they don't want to get with a change. they don't want to get with a program. They're going to resist change program. They're going to resist change program. They're going to resist change at all cost whether it's to their at all cost whether it's to their at all cost whether it's to their detriment or not. They don't care. detriment or not. They don't care. detriment or not. They don't care. Especially true of bureaucracies. But Especially true of bureaucracies. But Especially true of bureaucracies. But you have the all of these frictions and you have the all of these frictions and you have the all of these frictions and going in one direction. At the same going in one direction. At the same going in one direction. At the same time, you got in ingenuity and time, you got in ingenuity and time, you got in ingenuity and innovation going in the other direction. innovation going in the other direction. innovation going in the other direction. And hopefully you end up with more And hopefully you end up with more And hopefully you end up with more ingenuity, more opportunity, more people ingenuity, more opportunity, more people ingenuity, more opportunity, more people who sense the opportunity and try to who sense the opportunity and try to who sense the opportunity and try to take advantage of it. That leads to take advantage of it. That leads to take advantage of it. That leads to overcoming all of the past frictions and overcoming all of the past frictions and overcoming all of the past frictions and resetting the system. what that looks resetting the system. what that looks resetting the system. what that looks like in you know where we are today. I like in you know where we are today. I like in you know where we are today. I think it looks like something more like think it looks like something more like think it looks like something more like a digital currency system where we have a digital currency system where we have a digital currency system where we have competing digital currencies because one competing digital currencies because one competing digital currencies because one of the things that um you have to of the things that um you have to of the things that um you have to understand here in in the uh middle 20 understand here in in the uh middle 20 understand here in in the uh middle 20 in the middle of 20th century the Euro in the middle of 20th century the Euro in the middle of 20th century the Euro dollar systems role in all of that was dollar systems role in all of that was dollar systems role in all of that was absolutely critical and vital because absolutely critical and vital because absolutely critical and vital because what essentially created not quite from what essentially created not quite from what essentially created not quite from scratch but almost from scratch was scratch but almost from scratch was scratch but almost from scratch was money mobility. It allows money mobility. It allows money mobility. It allows >> the vast majority of humanity does not >> the vast majority of humanity does not >> the vast majority of humanity does not know what the Euro dollar system is. Can know what the Euro dollar system is. Can know what the Euro dollar system is. Can you give a quick primer? you give a quick primer? you give a quick primer? >> Well, the Euro dollar is the money we >> Well, the Euro dollar is the money we >> Well, the Euro dollar is the money we all use whether we whether we know it or all use whether we whether we know it or all use whether we whether we know it or not. That is the it is the global not. That is the it is the global not. That is the it is the global reserve currency. Not the US dollar, the reserve currency. Not the US dollar, the reserve currency. Not the US dollar, the Euro dollar. And the Euro dollar is Euro dollar. And the Euro dollar is Euro dollar. And the Euro dollar is ledger money. And ledger money is ledger money. And ledger money is ledger money. And ledger money is nothing more than banks keeping track of nothing more than banks keeping track of nothing more than banks keeping track of who owes what and who owns what. That's who owes what and who owns what. That's who owes what and who owns what. That's why if you think about what a bank is, why if you think about what a bank is, why if you think about what a bank is, it's not a vault with cash in it. In it's not a vault with cash in it. In it's not a vault with cash in it. In fact, there there's no cash in banks any fact, there there's no cash in banks any fact, there there's no cash in banks any even. Nobody even uses ATMs anymore. even. Nobody even uses ATMs anymore. even. Nobody even uses ATMs anymore. Banks are nothing more than glorified Banks are nothing more than glorified Banks are nothing more than glorified bookkeepers because that we use a we've bookkeepers because that we use a we've bookkeepers because that we use a we've been moving to a ledger money system for been moving to a ledger money system for been moving to a ledger money system for centuries and in the latter half of the centuries and in the latter half of the centuries and in the latter half of the 19th century banks started to perfect 19th century banks started to perfect 19th century banks started to perfect ledger money which made it easier for ledger money which made it easier for ledger money which made it easier for money to move from A to B because money to move from A to B because money to move from A to B because instead of instead of you having to take instead of instead of you having to take instead of instead of you having to take physical currency out of a bank vault, physical currency out of a bank vault, physical currency out of a bank vault, get on your horse and ride across the get on your horse and ride across the get on your horse and ride across the state to pay somebody off for a good state to pay somebody off for a good state to pay somebody off for a good that you're buying from them and take that you're buying from them and take that you're buying from them and take the currency with you and then have that the currency with you and then have that the currency with you and then have that person take that currency and put it and person take that currency and put it and person take that currency and put it and deposit it in their bank, you know, on deposit it in their bank, you know, on deposit it in their bank, you know, on the other side of the state. Wouldn't it the other side of the state. Wouldn't it the other side of the state. Wouldn't it be easier if your bank over here could be easier if your bank over here could be easier if your bank over here could just send a telegraph message to the just send a telegraph message to the just send a telegraph message to the bank over here and say, "I'm crediting bank over here and say, "I'm crediting bank over here and say, "I'm crediting you X number of dollars. You can you can you X number of dollars. You can you can you X number of dollars. You can you can take them in any any at any time you take them in any any at any time you take them in any any at any time you wish." And then the the ledger money wish." And then the the ledger money wish." And then the the ledger money that we're creating is also useful for that we're creating is also useful for that we're creating is also useful for the bank over here and the bank over the bank over here and the bank over the bank over here and the bank over here. You end up getting what's what's here. You end up getting what's what's here. You end up getting what's what's called a network effect where the more called a network effect where the more called a network effect where the more banks and financial institutions got banks and financial institutions got banks and financial institutions got involved in this ledger money network, involved in this ledger money network, involved in this ledger money network, the more mobile money would become. So the more mobile money would become. So the more mobile money would become. So now you can just sit in your house and now you can just sit in your house and now you can just sit in your house and you can order goods from China because you can order goods from China because you can order goods from China because there's a ledger money system behind it there's a ledger money system behind it there's a ledger money system behind it that you don't know about or really even that you don't know about or really even that you don't know about or really even aware of that allows money to move from aware of that allows money to move from aware of that allows money to move from A to B that at the end of this somebody A to B that at the end of this somebody A to B that at the end of this somebody over in China is perfectly happy with over in China is perfectly happy with over in China is perfectly happy with what they're getting in return which is what they're getting in return which is what they're getting in return which is really nothing more than a number on a really nothing more than a number on a really nothing more than a number on a paper to send you some cheap product paper to send you some cheap product paper to send you some cheap product through the mail and everybody gets paid through the mail and everybody gets paid through the mail and everybody gets paid at every stop along the supply chain at every stop along the supply chain at every stop along the supply chain using the same ledger money. So money using the same ledger money. So money using the same ledger money. So money becomes mobile to the point that we can becomes mobile to the point that we can becomes mobile to the point that we can have a hyperefficient uh economic have a hyperefficient uh economic have a hyperefficient uh economic system. That's an important point about system. That's an important point about system. That's an important point about it. And the Euro dollar system, this it. And the Euro dollar system, this it. And the Euro dollar system, this ledger money system developed out of the ledger money system developed out of the ledger money system developed out of the banks because banks were really the only banks because banks were really the only banks because banks were really the only specialized institutions that could specialized institutions that could specialized institutions that could operate this type of payment network, operate this type of payment network, operate this type of payment network, which is really all it really it really which is really all it really it really which is really all it really it really is just a payment network. And so you is just a payment network. And so you is just a payment network. And so you have this payment network that devol have this payment network that devol have this payment network that devol that evolved on national lines. But that evolved on national lines. But that evolved on national lines. But after World War II, it led to this to after World War II, it led to this to after World War II, it led to this to speeding up of the evolution into, you speeding up of the evolution into, you speeding up of the evolution into, you know, with alongside telecommunications know, with alongside telecommunications know, with alongside telecommunications innovations. Um, you had this speeding innovations. Um, you had this speeding innovations. Um, you had this speeding up of the process where now you don't up of the process where now you don't up of the process where now you don't just have banks in a in a in a region of just have banks in a in a in a region of just have banks in a in a in a region of a country or in a in a single country. a country or in a in a single country. a country or in a in a single country. Now you have international banks that Now you have international banks that Now you have international banks that are able to communicate with each other are able to communicate with each other are able to communicate with each other and to pay to pay for things one or and to pay to pay for things one or and to pay to pay for things one or transfer funds uh between each other transfer funds uh between each other transfer funds uh between each other using a common system and a common using a common system and a common using a common system and a common denomination. They call it US dollar, denomination. They call it US dollar, denomination. They call it US dollar, but it's really euro dollar. And the but it's really euro dollar. And the but it's really euro dollar. And the term Euro dollar in its earliest days, term Euro dollar in its earliest days, term Euro dollar in its earliest days, it's not it has nothing to do with it's not it has nothing to do with it's not it has nothing to do with Europe necessarily or the European Europe necessarily or the European Europe necessarily or the European common currency, which makes it kind of common currency, which makes it kind of common currency, which makes it kind of um confusing. This developed long before um confusing. This developed long before um confusing. This developed long before the European com the euro was ever the European com the euro was ever the European com the euro was ever invented or came into being. But the invented or came into being. But the invented or came into being. But the Euro dollar simply meant these were US Euro dollar simply meant these were US Euro dollar simply meant these were US dollars that were on deposit outside the dollars that were on deposit outside the dollars that were on deposit outside the UI, outside the United States. So euro UI, outside the United States. So euro UI, outside the United States. So euro simply means offshore. So Euro dollar is simply means offshore. So Euro dollar is simply means offshore. So Euro dollar is offshore dollars. And that's because you offshore dollars. And that's because you offshore dollars. And that's because you had these international banks that that had these international banks that that had these international banks that that had created essentially a payment had created essentially a payment had created essentially a payment network that spanned most of the entire network that spanned most of the entire network that spanned most of the entire world. And it came to span the entire world. And it came to span the entire world. And it came to span the entire world that allowed money to be mobile world that allowed money to be mobile world that allowed money to be mobile from almost anywhere on the planet. You from almost anywhere on the planet. You from almost anywhere on the planet. You could get on a plane tomorrow and go to could get on a plane tomorrow and go to could get on a plane tomorrow and go to some other place in the in the world. some other place in the in the world. some other place in the in the world. You stick your credit card in a machine You stick your credit card in a machine You stick your credit card in a machine and it's going to work. And nobody stops and it's going to work. And nobody stops and it's going to work. And nobody stops and thinks about how that actually and thinks about how that actually and thinks about how that actually works. Well, that's the magic of the works. Well, that's the magic of the works. Well, that's the magic of the Euro dollar. And the problem is the Euro Euro dollar. And the problem is the Euro Euro dollar. And the problem is the Euro dollar system broke down in August 9th dollar system broke down in August 9th dollar system broke down in August 9th of 2007 and has never been able to go of 2007 and has never been able to go of 2007 and has never been able to go back to where it was before largely back to where it was before largely back to where it was before largely because of risk-taking animal spirits because of risk-taking animal spirits because of risk-taking animal spirits and the depression economics that we and the depression economics that we and the depression economics that we went through. But the Euro dollar system went through. But the Euro dollar system went through. But the Euro dollar system is begging to be replaced. And once it's is begging to be replaced. And once it's is begging to be replaced. And once it's replaced and done so probably in an replaced and done so probably in an replaced and done so probably in an organic and smart way, you we can get organic and smart way, you we can get organic and smart way, you we can get back into a situation where there is no back into a situation where there is no back into a situation where there is no longer this this hyper demand for safety longer this this hyper demand for safety longer this this hyper demand for safety and liquidity. We're going to stop, and liquidity. We're going to stop, and liquidity. We're going to stop, we're going to stop putting all of our we're going to stop putting all of our we're going to stop putting all of our savings in either chasing AI bubbles or, savings in either chasing AI bubbles or, savings in either chasing AI bubbles or, you know, stuck in safe returns in US you know, stuck in safe returns in US you know, stuck in safe returns in US treasuries. People will start seeing treasuries. People will start seeing treasuries. People will start seeing opportunity in the real economy because opportunity in the real economy because opportunity in the real economy because they can trust that it's actually real. they can trust that it's actually real. they can trust that it's actually real. And once people start investing in the And once people start investing in the And once people start investing in the real economy, again, it unlocks all of real economy, again, it unlocks all of real economy, again, it unlocks all of the, you know, the the waiting the, you know, the the waiting the, you know, the the waiting prosperity and innovation that have been prosperity and innovation that have been prosperity and innovation that have been stuck behind this depression economics stuck behind this depression economics stuck behind this depression economics for a couple of decades now. Yeah, for a couple of decades now. Yeah, for a couple of decades now. Yeah, that's kind of an idealistic view of the that's kind of an idealistic view of the that's kind of an idealistic view of the future, but it's not an unrealistic one future, but it's not an unrealistic one future, but it's not an unrealistic one because again, like I've said, we've because again, like I've said, we've because again, like I've said, we've been here before. The only real question been here before. The only real question been here before. The only real question is whether or not we have enough time is whether or not we have enough time is whether or not we have enough time left to achieve it, you know, before left to achieve it, you know, before left to achieve it, you know, before something really breaks down. something really breaks down. something really breaks down. >> Okay, I'm going to try to put a layer of >> Okay, I'm going to try to put a layer of >> Okay, I'm going to try to put a layer of simplicity on that. Um, and tell me if I simplicity on that. Um, and tell me if I simplicity on that. Um, and tell me if I go wrong because we were talking about go wrong because we were talking about go wrong because we were talking about this in the context of we're coming out this in the context of we're coming out this in the context of we're coming out of World War II. we have this thing, the of World War II. we have this thing, the of World War II. we have this thing, the Euro dollar, that greases the wheels, Euro dollar, that greases the wheels, Euro dollar, that greases the wheels, allows money to move, and that becomes allows money to move, and that becomes allows money to move, and that becomes part of how we get this global part of how we get this global part of how we get this global prosperity. And that most people just prosperity. And that most people just prosperity. And that most people just don't understand how it works. Now, um I don't understand how it works. Now, um I don't understand how it works. Now, um I I can't remember if you've said this I can't remember if you've said this I can't remember if you've said this before uh or if it's just been said or before uh or if it's just been said or before uh or if it's just been said or if I fever dreamed this, but I've I have if I fever dreamed this, but I've I have if I fever dreamed this, but I've I have in my head that the Euro dollar system in my head that the Euro dollar system in my head that the Euro dollar system can be thought of as like the can be thought of as like the can be thought of as like the respiratory of the global monetary respiratory of the global monetary respiratory of the global monetary system. and that literally in some cases system. and that literally in some cases system. and that literally in some cases overnight. So the vast majority and it's overnight. So the vast majority and it's overnight. So the vast majority and it's if I'm not mistaken it's trillions of if I'm not mistaken it's trillions of if I'm not mistaken it's trillions of dollars uh every night that sort of dollars uh every night that sort of dollars uh every night that sort of comes into existence and then gets comes into existence and then gets comes into existence and then gets cleared in the morning. And so it's a cleared in the morning. And so it's a cleared in the morning. And so it's a massive amount of money where people go, massive amount of money where people go, massive amount of money where people go, hey, I'm going to trust you for this hey, I'm going to trust you for this hey, I'm going to trust you for this amount of money. I know you're good for amount of money. I know you're good for amount of money. I know you're good for it tomorrow morning. Sometimes it's 30, it tomorrow morning. Sometimes it's 30, it tomorrow morning. Sometimes it's 30, 60, 90 days, but it's a very very 60, 90 days, but it's a very very 60, 90 days, but it's a very very shortterm quote unquote lending. And so shortterm quote unquote lending. And so shortterm quote unquote lending. And so money is being created and destroyed money is being created and destroyed money is being created and destroyed constantly. And that creation and constantly. And that creation and constantly. And that creation and destruction allows us to move things destruction allows us to move things destruction allows us to move things around using trust. And in an around using trust. And in an around using trust. And in an inflationary environment, um that trust inflationary environment, um that trust inflationary environment, um that trust begins to diminish and people aren't begins to diminish and people aren't begins to diminish and people aren't sure like are you worth this credit? Uh sure like are you worth this credit? Uh sure like are you worth this credit? Uh is there something hiding somewhere that is there something hiding somewhere that is there something hiding somewhere that I don't know which is why this is I don't know which is why this is I don't know which is why this is happening in 2007208 where people happening in 2007208 where people happening in 2007208 where people realize whoa you were hiding bad debt realize whoa you were hiding bad debt realize whoa you were hiding bad debt that I didn't realize? Your collateral that I didn't realize? Your collateral that I didn't realize? Your collateral was not what I thought it was. And so was not what I thought it was. And so was not what I thought it was. And so now everybody's like, "Yo, I'm Japan. I now everybody's like, "Yo, I'm Japan. I now everybody's like, "Yo, I'm Japan. I I've been burned by this and now I'm I've been burned by this and now I'm I've been burned by this and now I'm terrified." And so you get sort of terrified." And so you get sort of terrified." And so you get sort of constricted breathing, if you will, in constricted breathing, if you will, in constricted breathing, if you will, in the Euro dollar market. And I believe the Euro dollar market. And I believe the Euro dollar market. And I believe though this is the first time I'm though this is the first time I'm though this is the first time I'm hearing it, the reason that you're hearing it, the reason that you're hearing it, the reason that you're saying that this could be a digital saying that this could be a digital saying that this could be a digital asset of some kind is if the digital asset of some kind is if the digital asset of some kind is if the digital asset is basically provably there, we asset is basically provably there, we asset is basically provably there, we overcome some of the fractional lending, overcome some of the fractional lending, overcome some of the fractional lending, bad debt kind of trouble that we got bad debt kind of trouble that we got bad debt kind of trouble that we got burned by in 2007. burned by in 2007. burned by in 2007. And so you're prognosticating that this And so you're prognosticating that this And so you're prognosticating that this new system would need to have trust new system would need to have trust new system would need to have trust baked in basically so I don't have to baked in basically so I don't have to baked in basically so I don't have to trust you. I just look at the ledger and trust you. I just look at the ledger and trust you. I just look at the ledger and I know that thing is like that money I know that thing is like that money I know that thing is like that money exists and so we're good. How close did exists and so we're good. How close did exists and so we're good. How close did I get? That's exactly it. And I think I get? That's exactly it. And I think I get? That's exactly it. And I think that's a really good analogy talking that's a really good analogy talking that's a really good analogy talking about like oxygen. Uh because money is about like oxygen. Uh because money is about like oxygen. Uh because money is not the import, you know, money is not not the import, you know, money is not not the import, you know, money is not the issue here. Money is not the most the issue here. Money is not the most the issue here. Money is not the most most important thing. It's a tool that most important thing. It's a tool that most important thing. It's a tool that allows the commercial system to thrive allows the commercial system to thrive allows the commercial system to thrive when it works really well. But when you when it works really well. But when you when it works really well. But when you you know when their money isn't there you know when their money isn't there you know when their money isn't there when you money and money needs to move when you money and money needs to move when you money and money needs to move it needs to be mobile which is why the it needs to be mobile which is why the it needs to be mobile which is why the Euro dollar system thrived as much as it Euro dollar system thrived as much as it Euro dollar system thrived as much as it was because it was focused on mobility was because it was focused on mobility was because it was focused on mobility >> and it's you know you have somebody who >> and it's you know you have somebody who >> and it's you know you have somebody who has funds say in Switzerland who has you has funds say in Switzerland who has you has funds say in Switzerland who has you know and then you have somebody on the know and then you have somebody on the know and then you have somebody on the other side of the world who has an other side of the world who has an other side of the world who has an opportunity to build a factory in opportunity to build a factory in opportunity to build a factory in Singapore in a system that's fractured Singapore in a system that's fractured Singapore in a system that's fractured and fragmented that person in Singapore and fragmented that person in Singapore and fragmented that person in Singapore never gets to build a factory because never gets to build a factory because never gets to build a factory because they can't connect to the person in they can't connect to the person in they can't connect to the person in Switzerland who has the money that would Switzerland who has the money that would Switzerland who has the money that would allow them to build the factory but allow them to build the factory but allow them to build the factory but suddenly you have a fluid mobile system suddenly you have a fluid mobile system suddenly you have a fluid mobile system where the euro dollar functions really where the euro dollar functions really where the euro dollar functions really well. Suddenly that money that's sitting well. Suddenly that money that's sitting well. Suddenly that money that's sitting there pulled up in Switzerland becomes there pulled up in Switzerland becomes there pulled up in Switzerland becomes available for good real economy available for good real economy available for good real economy opportunities in other parts of the opportunities in other parts of the opportunities in other parts of the world and suddenly it allows it unlocks world and suddenly it allows it unlocks world and suddenly it allows it unlocks the ability of the system to thrive the ability of the system to thrive the ability of the system to thrive instead of being held back by lack of instead of being held back by lack of instead of being held back by lack of money and lack of commitment. It's now money and lack of commitment. It's now money and lack of commitment. It's now fully fl I mean we've got money flowing fully fl I mean we've got money flowing fully fl I mean we've got money flowing from here there we can take it from from here there we can take it from from here there we can take it from wherever money is to where it really wherever money is to where it really wherever money is to where it really needs to be and of course it's a messier needs to be and of course it's a messier needs to be and of course it's a messier process than that but idealistically process than that but idealistically process than that but idealistically speaking that's what ends up happening. speaking that's what ends up happening. speaking that's what ends up happening. So if we deprive the system of that So if we deprive the system of that So if we deprive the system of that mobility, a lot of that mobility because mobility, a lot of that mobility because mobility, a lot of that mobility because trust is baked into money whether we trust is baked into money whether we trust is baked into money whether we like it or not. Trust is at the core of like it or not. Trust is at the core of like it or not. Trust is at the core of every single form of money that humans every single form of money that humans every single form of money that humans have ever have ever used. And the trust have ever have ever used. And the trust have ever have ever used. And the trust is really kind of simple. It's really am is really kind of simple. It's really am is really kind of simple. It's really am I getting something that if I get it I getting something that if I get it I getting something that if I get it that I'll be able to use it someplace that I'll be able to use it someplace that I'll be able to use it someplace some other time because we you know we some other time because we you know we some other time because we you know we could always do a barter system and could always do a barter system and could always do a barter system and barter is incredibly inefficient. So barter is incredibly inefficient. So barter is incredibly inefficient. So what overcomes that trust is okay I get what overcomes that trust is okay I get what overcomes that trust is okay I get something that I perceive of as valuable something that I perceive of as valuable something that I perceive of as valuable and useful but so does the person over and useful but so does the person over and useful but so does the person over here and the person over here and the here and the person over here and the here and the person over here and the person over here. If everybody looks at person over here. If everybody looks at person over here. If everybody looks at this this thing and says this thing I this this thing and says this thing I this this thing and says this thing I trust it. I think it's whatever what trust it. I think it's whatever what trust it. I think it's whatever what what we all think it is whether it's a what we all think it is whether it's a what we all think it is whether it's a ledger entry or whether it's a piece you ledger entry or whether it's a piece you ledger entry or whether it's a piece you know gold a piece of gold or just some know gold a piece of gold or just some know gold a piece of gold or just some kind of rock or something. If we all kind of rock or something. If we all kind of rock or something. If we all believe that this thing is what we want believe that this thing is what we want believe that this thing is what we want it to be a medium of exchange then the it to be a medium of exchange then the it to be a medium of exchange then the I'll I'll accept that money readily I'll I'll accept that money readily I'll I'll accept that money readily because I know that when I have it I can because I know that when I have it I can because I know that when I have it I can use it at all these different places to use it at all these different places to use it at all these different places to get what I want to get. But when that get what I want to get. But when that get what I want to get. But when that trust breaks down like you said in Tom trust breaks down like you said in Tom trust breaks down like you said in Tom in 2007 and 2008 suddenly the money in 2007 and 2008 suddenly the money in 2007 and 2008 suddenly the money doesn't flow. it doesn't become as doesn't flow. it doesn't become as doesn't flow. it doesn't become as available and it starts to lead to all available and it starts to lead to all available and it starts to lead to all these drags and frictions on the real these drags and frictions on the real these drags and frictions on the real economy and real system. So we can get economy and real system. So we can get economy and real system. So we can get the problem is you can't go backwards. the problem is you can't go backwards. the problem is you can't go backwards. It's not backwards compatible. Once It's not backwards compatible. Once It's not backwards compatible. Once people realize the risk that we're people realize the risk that we're people realize the risk that we're building up in the system, we couldn't building up in the system, we couldn't building up in the system, we couldn't just say you know the Fed couldn't just just say you know the Fed couldn't just just say you know the Fed couldn't just wave its hand and say oh we did a bunch wave its hand and say oh we did a bunch wave its hand and say oh we did a bunch of QE we can go back to way the way of QE we can go back to way the way of QE we can go back to way the way things were in 2005 that the banking things were in 2005 that the banking things were in 2005 that the banking sector as you pointed out uh what was it sector as you pointed out uh what was it sector as you pointed out uh what was it Japan they burned their hand on the Japan they burned their hand on the Japan they burned their hand on the stove. That's exactly what happened. stove. That's exactly what happened. stove. That's exactly what happened. Bear Sterns was abs Bear Sterns was the Bear Sterns was abs Bear Sterns was the Bear Sterns was abs Bear Sterns was the moment the Euro dollar system touched moment the Euro dollar system touched moment the Euro dollar system touched the stove because Bear Sterns created a the stove because Bear Sterns created a the stove because Bear Sterns created a shock wave through the banking system shock wave through the banking system shock wave through the banking system because up until that point it was sort because up until that point it was sort because up until that point it was sort of like of like of like >> uh this is all kind of theoretical. >> uh this is all kind of theoretical. >> uh this is all kind of theoretical. Yeah, things things seem to be going bad Yeah, things things seem to be going bad Yeah, things things seem to be going bad when Bear Sterns it actually failed. when Bear Sterns it actually failed. when Bear Sterns it actually failed. Yeah, it was sold to JP Morgan from but Yeah, it was sold to JP Morgan from but Yeah, it was sold to JP Morgan from but from the perspective of Wall Street and from the perspective of Wall Street and from the perspective of Wall Street and bank managers what it said was failure bank managers what it said was failure bank managers what it said was failure and being wiped out are a real and being wiped out are a real and being wiped out are a real possibility. So everybody touched the possibility. So everybody touched the possibility. So everybody touched the stove in 2008 and said we can't ever be stove in 2008 and said we can't ever be stove in 2008 and said we can't ever be in that situation again. Unfortunately, in that situation again. Unfortunately, in that situation again. Unfortunately, by pulling back and becoming riskaverse by pulling back and becoming riskaverse by pulling back and becoming riskaverse and only wanted to own safe and liquid and only wanted to own safe and liquid and only wanted to own safe and liquid instruments, it deprived the economy of instruments, it deprived the economy of instruments, it deprived the economy of mobility and funds and availability mobility and funds and availability mobility and funds and availability which led to this depressionary these which led to this depressionary these which led to this depressionary these depressionary conditions. So how do we depressionary conditions. So how do we depressionary conditions. So how do we get out of that is to reestablish trust get out of that is to reestablish trust get out of that is to reestablish trust in the system. And reestablishing trust in the system. And reestablishing trust in the system. And reestablishing trust in the system is incredibly difficult. in the system is incredibly difficult. in the system is incredibly difficult. It's it seems like a very simple thing It's it seems like a very simple thing It's it seems like a very simple thing when you have it, but when it's lost, when you have it, but when it's lost, when you have it, but when it's lost, it's incredibly difficult to get back. it's incredibly difficult to get back. it's incredibly difficult to get back. Just ask any any country or economy that Just ask any any country or economy that Just ask any any country or economy that goes through a hyperinflationary goes through a hyperinflationary goes through a hyperinflationary collapse. How do you get out of it? It's collapse. How do you get out of it? It's collapse. How do you get out of it? It's really difficult to reestablish trust. really difficult to reestablish trust. really difficult to reestablish trust. And it's no different on the And it's no different on the And it's no different on the deflationary side is a hyperinflation deflationary side is a hyperinflation deflationary side is a hyperinflation side. So, in many ways, it it really is side. So, in many ways, it it really is side. So, in many ways, it it really is like we're looking at a new brand new like we're looking at a new brand new like we're looking at a new brand new system. But you don't want to just system. But you don't want to just system. But you don't want to just impose a brand new system on the current impose a brand new system on the current impose a brand new system on the current system that we have, especially if system that we have, especially if system that we have, especially if they're kind of incompatible because they're kind of incompatible because they're kind of incompatible because that leads all sorts of messiness. It that leads all sorts of messiness. It that leads all sorts of messiness. It leads to the same type of situation and leads to the same type of situation and leads to the same type of situation and distortions that we just talked about distortions that we just talked about distortions that we just talked about with the pandemic and lockdowns. What with the pandemic and lockdowns. What with the pandemic and lockdowns. What would what would be the ideal solution would what would be the ideal solution would what would be the ideal solution is that many many generations of is that many many generations of is that many many generations of cryptocurrencies from now and I'm not cryptocurrencies from now and I'm not cryptocurrencies from now and I'm not talking about, you know, meme coins or talking about, you know, meme coins or talking about, you know, meme coins or something like that or even really something like that or even really something like that or even really Bitcoin. We're really talking more about Bitcoin. We're really talking more about Bitcoin. We're really talking more about stable coins, but some type of digital stable coins, but some type of digital stable coins, but some type of digital ledger that's decentralized that doesn't ledger that's decentralized that doesn't ledger that's decentralized that doesn't depend upon banks because banks are no depend upon banks because banks are no depend upon banks because banks are no longer willing to trust each other. So longer willing to trust each other. So longer willing to trust each other. So we have some kind of decentralized we have some kind of decentralized we have some kind of decentralized ledger system that that proves itself in ledger system that that proves itself in ledger system that that proves itself in terms of function as well as terms of function as well as terms of function as well as reliability. Suddenly people start reliability. Suddenly people start reliability. Suddenly people start trusting the system again. Um sentiment trusting the system again. Um sentiment trusting the system again. Um sentiment changes. You get out of what the changes. You get out of what the changes. You get out of what the Japanese called for decades the Japanese called for decades the Japanese called for decades the deflationary mindset. It wasn't really deflationary mindset. It wasn't really deflationary mindset. It wasn't really deflationary mindset. It's the scar deflationary mindset. It's the scar deflationary mindset. It's the scar tissue from everybody saw their hand tissue from everybody saw their hand tissue from everybody saw their hand like I'm burn my hand in 1990. I'm not like I'm burn my hand in 1990. I'm not like I'm burn my hand in 1990. I'm not going to do that again. Once you get going to do that again. Once you get going to do that again. Once you get past that, sentiment loosens up. past that, sentiment loosens up. past that, sentiment loosens up. Risk-taking. animal spirits start to Risk-taking. animal spirits start to Risk-taking. animal spirits start to take over and it leads to this, you take over and it leads to this, you take over and it leads to this, you know, the 1950s all over again. At least know, the 1950s all over again. At least know, the 1950s all over again. At least what we hope is the 1950s all over what we hope is the 1950s all over what we hope is the 1950s all over again. That's the overview of how we get again. That's the overview of how we get again. That's the overview of how we get out of where we are today into where we out of where we are today into where we out of where we are today into where we could be tomorrow. There's just a lot of could be tomorrow. There's just a lot of could be tomorrow. There's just a lot of a lot of wiggle room in there and a lot a lot of wiggle room in there and a lot a lot of wiggle room in there and a lot of problems that need to be solved of problems that need to be solved of problems that need to be solved first. Yeah. Okay. That one because it's first. Yeah. Okay. That one because it's first. Yeah. Okay. That one because it's so unknown, that one is a little bit so unknown, that one is a little bit so unknown, that one is a little bit scary. So, we have to contend right now scary. So, we have to contend right now scary. So, we have to contend right now with where things are at in this moment. with where things are at in this moment. with where things are at in this moment. um like from an investor standpoint, how um like from an investor standpoint, how um like from an investor standpoint, how do you think about this? Are you like, do you think about this? Are you like, do you think about this? Are you like, "Well, I'm going to ride the bubble "Well, I'm going to ride the bubble "Well, I'm going to ride the bubble while I can and I'm going to as I get while I can and I'm going to as I get while I can and I'm going to as I get the gains, I'm going to um rebalance out the gains, I'm going to um rebalance out the gains, I'm going to um rebalance out of the high-risk stuff into the safety of the high-risk stuff into the safety of the high-risk stuff into the safety and liquidity of the bond market." Like, and liquidity of the bond market." Like, and liquidity of the bond market." Like, how how do you navigate this reality how how do you navigate this reality how how do you navigate this reality knowing the future remains a bunch of knowing the future remains a bunch of knowing the future remains a bunch of question marks? question marks? question marks? >> Well, that's it. I mean, that's why >> Well, that's it. I mean, that's why >> Well, that's it. I mean, that's why there's so much demand for safety and there's so much demand for safety and there's so much demand for safety and liquidity. It's not just in bonds. I liquidity. It's not just in bonds. I liquidity. It's not just in bonds. I mean, why is gold gone vertical? At mean, why is gold gone vertical? At mean, why is gold gone vertical? At least, you know, up until earlier this least, you know, up until earlier this least, you know, up until earlier this year, gold went vertical because a lot year, gold went vertical because a lot year, gold went vertical because a lot of people around the entire world, China of people around the entire world, China of people around the entire world, China is a big one, could sense that the uh is a big one, could sense that the uh is a big one, could sense that the uh system is breaking down. It doesn't seem system is breaking down. It doesn't seem system is breaking down. It doesn't seem to work. Therefore, you want some kind to work. Therefore, you want some kind to work. Therefore, you want some kind of asset that historically speaking has of asset that historically speaking has of asset that historically speaking has been a something that's able to bridge been a something that's able to bridge been a something that's able to bridge from A to B because that's what we're from A to B because that's what we're from A to B because that's what we're really talking about. We are stuck in A. really talking about. We are stuck in A. really talking about. We are stuck in A. We're not going to get out of A anytime We're not going to get out of A anytime We're not going to get out of A anytime soon. We can see B. We can see the soon. We can see B. We can see the soon. We can see B. We can see the possibility of reaching B and B would be possibility of reaching B and B would be possibility of reaching B and B would be really, really good. We can also see C, really, really good. We can also see C, really, really good. We can also see C, which would be really, really bad. But which would be really, really bad. But which would be really, really bad. But between A and B and ABC, there's going between A and B and ABC, there's going between A and B and ABC, there's going to be a whole lot of uncertainty in to be a whole lot of uncertainty in to be a whole lot of uncertainty in between. That's the allure of gold and between. That's the allure of gold and between. That's the allure of gold and other other instruments that act in the other other instruments that act in the other other instruments that act in the same way. Safe haven demand. Um so when same way. Safe haven demand. Um so when same way. Safe haven demand. Um so when you're looking at this level of you're looking at this level of you're looking at this level of uncertainty, understanding what the uncertainty, understanding what the uncertainty, understanding what the risks are, where we actually are, not risks are, where we actually are, not risks are, where we actually are, not just following along with the mainstream just following along with the mainstream just following along with the mainstream narrative about how everything is fine narrative about how everything is fine narrative about how everything is fine and we're, you know, and we're, you know, and we're, you know, the economy is resilient and strong and the economy is resilient and strong and the economy is resilient and strong and uh all that kind of stuff. You really uh all that kind of stuff. You really uh all that kind of stuff. You really you really do want to be I'm not saying you really do want to be I'm not saying you really do want to be I'm not saying you do I'm not saying you want to sit you do I'm not saying you want to sit you do I'm not saying you want to sit out the marketplace. I'm not saying you out the marketplace. I'm not saying you out the marketplace. I'm not saying you don't want to own stocks or you don't don't want to own stocks or you don't don't want to own stocks or you don't want to own risky assets. But you want want to own risky assets. But you want want to own risky assets. But you want to be mindful when you do. Always to be mindful when you do. Always to be mindful when you do. Always understanding that this uncertainty by understanding that this uncertainty by understanding that this uncertainty by its very nature is unpredictable. And its very nature is unpredictable. And its very nature is unpredictable. And unpredictable means that it can show up unpredictable means that it can show up unpredictable means that it can show up tomorrow and be something that you were tomorrow and be something that you were tomorrow and be something that you were not prepared for. Which is one reason not prepared for. Which is one reason not prepared for. Which is one reason why you want to have some kind of why you want to have some kind of why you want to have some kind of allocation to safe havens and safety. allocation to safe havens and safety. allocation to safe havens and safety. Whatever that actually means. It depends Whatever that actually means. It depends Whatever that actually means. It depends on your own individual circumstances. on your own individual circumstances. on your own individual circumstances. But that's the reason why again But that's the reason why again But that's the reason why again depression economics the reason why depression economics the reason why depression economics the reason why safety becomes in is such in such demand safety becomes in is such in such demand safety becomes in is such in such demand during depression economics is because during depression economics is because during depression economics is because of the uncertainty. Now the uncertainty of the uncertainty. Now the uncertainty of the uncertainty. Now the uncertainty leads toward um you know probabilities leads toward um you know probabilities leads toward um you know probabilities that are skewing to the downside rather that are skewing to the downside rather that are skewing to the downside rather than the upside. In fact that's the than the upside. In fact that's the than the upside. In fact that's the that's the single biggest thing which that's the single biggest thing which that's the single biggest thing which distinguishes depressionary conditions. distinguishes depressionary conditions. distinguishes depressionary conditions. It's not the negative numbers. When you It's not the negative numbers. When you It's not the negative numbers. When you say the term depression I just did a say the term depression I just did a say the term depression I just did a video on this. When you say depression, video on this. When you say depression, video on this. When you say depression, a lot of people think what you're saying a lot of people think what you're saying a lot of people think what you're saying is it's a big recession because you is it's a big recession because you is it's a big recession because you think, you know, 1930s you had the great think, you know, 1930s you had the great think, you know, 1930s you had the great collapse between 29 and 32. And so collapse between 29 and 32. And so collapse between 29 and 32. And so that's what you're talking about when that's what you're talking about when that's what you're talking about when you talk about a depression. No, the you talk about a depression. No, the you talk about a depression. No, the depression was not 29 to 32. It was 32 depression was not 29 to 32. It was 32 depression was not 29 to 32. It was 32 to 41. It was the lack of upside. And to 41. It was the lack of upside. And to 41. It was the lack of upside. And when you have a situation where there's when you have a situation where there's when you have a situation where there's a lack of upside in the real commercial a lack of upside in the real commercial a lack of upside in the real commercial system, not talking about financial system, not talking about financial system, not talking about financial upside, but in the real commercial upside, but in the real commercial upside, but in the real commercial system, that's a high degree of system, that's a high degree of system, that's a high degree of uncertainty that leads to more frequent uncertainty that leads to more frequent uncertainty that leads to more frequent downside cases than maybe you're downside cases than maybe you're downside cases than maybe you're prepared for. So under depressionary prepared for. So under depressionary prepared for. So under depressionary depressionary conditions, demand for depressionary conditions, demand for depressionary conditions, demand for safety, which is multiaceted, becomes safety, which is multiaceted, becomes safety, which is multiaceted, becomes it's it never leaves your thinking. I'm it's it never leaves your thinking. I'm it's it never leaves your thinking. I'm not saying you don't want to put all not saying you don't want to put all not saying you don't want to put all your money into gold or all your money your money into gold or all your money your money into gold or all your money into bonds, but you do want to at least into bonds, but you do want to at least into bonds, but you do want to at least have some idea or at least some some uh have some idea or at least some some uh have some idea or at least some some uh some good good useful handle on how some good good useful handle on how some good good useful handle on how you're going to protect yourself from you're going to protect yourself from you're going to protect yourself from that uncertainty knowing that the that uncertainty knowing that the that uncertainty knowing that the uncertainty is always there. Don't fall uncertainty is always there. Don't fall uncertainty is always there. Don't fall into the trap where you fool yourself into the trap where you fool yourself into the trap where you fool yourself into thinking GDP is positive. The into thinking GDP is positive. The into thinking GDP is positive. The payroll report was looked pretty good, payroll report was looked pretty good, payroll report was looked pretty good, therefore nothing could be possibly therefore nothing could be possibly therefore nothing could be possibly wrong because that's really not the wrong because that's really not the wrong because that's really not the case. There's both shortrun as well as case. There's both shortrun as well as case. There's both shortrun as well as long run changes that are taking place long run changes that are taking place long run changes that are taking place and we really have no idea how those are and we really have no idea how those are and we really have no idea how those are going to how those are going to play out going to how those are going to play out going to how those are going to play out over time. over time. over time. >> Speaking of that, so you painted a >> Speaking of that, so you painted a >> Speaking of that, so you painted a picture a decentralized future where we picture a decentralized future where we picture a decentralized future where we reboot the system with a new kind of reboot the system with a new kind of reboot the system with a new kind of ledger that people can really trust. I ledger that people can really trust. I ledger that people can really trust. I want to contrast that with what I think want to contrast that with what I think want to contrast that with what I think China is doing and I'll be very curious China is doing and I'll be very curious China is doing and I'll be very curious to see if you have the same read. So, to see if you have the same read. So, to see if you have the same read. So, China recently clamped down on paper China recently clamped down on paper China recently clamped down on paper gold trading and the way that I gold trading and the way that I gold trading and the way that I interpret that is they are trying to get interpret that is they are trying to get interpret that is they are trying to get a bunch of gold physically present in a bunch of gold physically present in a bunch of gold physically present in China. So, they know that there's still China. So, they know that there's still China. So, they know that there's still appetite for gold among uh the Chinese appetite for gold among uh the Chinese appetite for gold among uh the Chinese population, but if they can't trade population, but if they can't trade population, but if they can't trade paper, then they're going to buy the paper, then they're going to buy the paper, then they're going to buy the physical asset. China as a um central physical asset. China as a um central physical asset. China as a um central bank has been hoovering up gold in bank has been hoovering up gold in bank has been hoovering up gold in massive quantities, but I imagine the massive quantities, but I imagine the massive quantities, but I imagine the Chinese people could do a lot more. Um Chinese people could do a lot more. Um Chinese people could do a lot more. Um China could very easily turn that into a China could very easily turn that into a China could very easily turn that into a one-way valve so that gold gets into the one-way valve so that gold gets into the one-way valve so that gold gets into the country but can't get back out. Uh for country but can't get back out. Uh for country but can't get back out. Uh for people that don't know, gold works in a people that don't know, gold works in a people that don't know, gold works in a very similar fashion to uh reserve very similar fashion to uh reserve very similar fashion to uh reserve banking in that you don't necessarily banking in that you don't necessarily banking in that you don't necessarily need you you definitely don't need a need you you definitely don't need a need you you definitely don't need a onetoone uh gold bar for every paper onetoone uh gold bar for every paper onetoone uh gold bar for every paper trading on it. So you can get into, you trading on it. So you can get into, you trading on it. So you can get into, you know, whatever 10 to one, whatever the know, whatever 10 to one, whatever the know, whatever 10 to one, whatever the real number is, um, on that. And so if real number is, um, on that. And so if real number is, um, on that. And so if I'm China and I'm like, I want to get I'm China and I'm like, I want to get I'm China and I'm like, I want to get out from under the dollar. I want the out from under the dollar. I want the out from under the dollar. I want the yuan to be the reserve currency, but I yuan to be the reserve currency, but I yuan to be the reserve currency, but I know I'm going to have to do something know I'm going to have to do something know I'm going to have to do something to reset the system. So I'm going to get to reset the system. So I'm going to get to reset the system. So I'm going to get enough gold that I could peg it, even if enough gold that I could peg it, even if enough gold that I could peg it, even if it's not one to one, but I could peg it it's not one to one, but I could peg it it's not one to one, but I could peg it to the yuan and over time take over the to the yuan and over time take over the to the yuan and over time take over the status as the reserve currency. even if status as the reserve currency. even if status as the reserve currency. even if they had to partner with another country they had to partner with another country they had to partner with another country to say, "Listen, we're going to hold the to say, "Listen, we're going to hold the to say, "Listen, we're going to hold the gold in some sort of corridor where it's gold in some sort of corridor where it's gold in some sort of corridor where it's not physically in China, but it's like not physically in China, but it's like not physically in China, but it's like in different places with a partner in different places with a partner in different places with a partner country or something." Um, country or something." Um, country or something." Um, am I crazy or do you see them grappling am I crazy or do you see them grappling am I crazy or do you see them grappling with the same thing that you're talking with the same thing that you're talking with the same thing that you're talking about where we need a reset system? Um, about where we need a reset system? Um, about where we need a reset system? Um, but they're just looking backwards but they're just looking backwards but they're just looking backwards instead of forwards to a new technology. instead of forwards to a new technology. instead of forwards to a new technology. >> Well, the Chinese are an interesting >> Well, the Chinese are an interesting >> Well, the Chinese are an interesting position because they're one of the position because they're one of the position because they're one of the biggest u they're on they're one of the biggest u they're on they're one of the biggest u they're on they're one of the big they're one of the ones who have the big they're one of the ones who have the big they're one of the ones who have the biggest downside from the dollar system. biggest downside from the dollar system. biggest downside from the dollar system. is and not I'm not talking about is and not I'm not talking about is and not I'm not talking about politics. I'm talking about the economic politics. I'm talking about the economic politics. I'm talking about the economic consequences. China's in a lot more consequences. China's in a lot more consequences. China's in a lot more trouble than people think uh people trouble than people think uh people trouble than people think uh people realize. They have a banking crisis and realize. They have a banking crisis and realize. They have a banking crisis and a property crisis that are going on in a property crisis that are going on in a property crisis that are going on in parallel and it's getting really dicey parallel and it's getting really dicey parallel and it's getting really dicey over there in the real economy. In fact, over there in the real economy. In fact, over there in the real economy. In fact, the 5-year plan that just came out just the 5-year plan that just came out just the 5-year plan that just came out just completely omitted their employment um completely omitted their employment um completely omitted their employment um employment targets for the next 5 years employment targets for the next 5 years employment targets for the next 5 years because they're not really sure they can because they're not really sure they can because they're not really sure they can actually hit them. But setting that actually hit them. But setting that actually hit them. But setting that aside, um that that just creates um some aside, um that that just creates um some aside, um that that just creates um some kind of u the Chinese have had the they kind of u the Chinese have had the they kind of u the Chinese have had the they have the the biggest interest in trying have the the biggest interest in trying have the the biggest interest in trying to do something different. The problem to do something different. The problem to do something different. The problem for them is they can't because when for them is they can't because when for them is they can't because when you're talking about a reserve currency, you're talking about a reserve currency, you're talking about a reserve currency, it's not as simple as pegging a currency it's not as simple as pegging a currency it's not as simple as pegging a currency to a gold bar because you got to to a gold bar because you got to to a gold bar because you got to remember what made the Euro dollar remember what made the Euro dollar remember what made the Euro dollar system and a reserve currency. This is system and a reserve currency. This is system and a reserve currency. This is true of any reserve currency. What it is true of any reserve currency. What it is true of any reserve currency. What it is is its mobility. Gold by its very nature is its mobility. Gold by its very nature is its mobility. Gold by its very nature is not mobile. to have a currency become is not mobile. to have a currency become is not mobile. to have a currency become truly mobile, which means it has to be truly mobile, which means it has to be truly mobile, which means it has to be available as many places as possible and available as many places as possible and available as many places as possible and it has to be acceptable as many places it has to be acceptable as many places it has to be acceptable as many places as possible. And those two things do not as possible. And those two things do not as possible. And those two things do not describe anything of China, whether it describe anything of China, whether it describe anything of China, whether it be finance or money. So the Chinese be finance or money. So the Chinese be finance or money. So the Chinese realize they have zero chance of realize they have zero chance of realize they have zero chance of creating a reserve currency. Even if creating a reserve currency. Even if creating a reserve currency. Even if they could create a currency that could they could create a currency that could they could create a currency that could theoretically be available, not many theoretically be available, not many theoretically be available, not many people are going to want to take it, people are going to want to take it, people are going to want to take it, which kind of undermines the entire which kind of undermines the entire which kind of undermines the entire point of a reserve currency. So what the point of a reserve currency. So what the point of a reserve currency. So what the Chinese are really trying to do is make Chinese are really trying to do is make Chinese are really trying to do is make the best of a bad situation. So they're the best of a bad situation. So they're the best of a bad situation. So they're building up their gold reserves. So and building up their gold reserves. So and building up their gold reserves. So and part of it is just mechanical. Uh one of part of it is just mechanical. Uh one of part of it is just mechanical. Uh one of the reasons they're building up gold the reasons they're building up gold the reasons they're building up gold reserves is because they have tons of reserves is because they have tons of reserves is because they have tons of dollars coming into the country. Ever dollars coming into the country. Ever dollars coming into the country. Ever since 2024, they made a a tactical since 2024, they made a a tactical since 2024, they made a a tactical strategy to basically dump their excess strategy to basically dump their excess strategy to basically dump their excess production on the rest of the world. In production on the rest of the world. In production on the rest of the world. In order to save employment, the Chinese order to save employment, the Chinese order to save employment, the Chinese Chinese internal economy has come Chinese internal economy has come Chinese internal economy has come becomes an increasingly a mess leads to becomes an increasingly a mess leads to becomes an increasingly a mess leads to this imbalance between supply and this imbalance between supply and this imbalance between supply and demand. which is why China's been demand. which is why China's been demand. which is why China's been suffering from deflationary uh suffering from deflationary uh suffering from deflationary uh deflationary conditions since 2023 deflationary conditions since 2023 deflationary conditions since 2023 because they produce way too much for because they produce way too much for because they produce way too much for them to be able to absorb for the them to be able to absorb for the them to be able to absorb for the internal demand. So they take the rest internal demand. So they take the rest internal demand. So they take the rest of their excess production and just of their excess production and just of their excess production and just fling it around the rest of the world fling it around the rest of the world fling it around the rest of the world charging whatever they can charge which charging whatever they can charge which charging whatever they can charge which means among other things when you're means among other things when you're means among other things when you're selling more goods to the rest of the selling more goods to the rest of the selling more goods to the rest of the world you've got a lot of more dollars world you've got a lot of more dollars world you've got a lot of more dollars coming back because every almost coming back because every almost coming back because every almost everything is traded in dollars and it everything is traded in dollars and it everything is traded in dollars and it doesn't have to be dollars you could doesn't have to be dollars you could doesn't have to be dollars you could invoice in euros you're going to end up invoice in euros you're going to end up invoice in euros you're going to end up with dollars anyway because dollars are with dollars anyway because dollars are with dollars anyway because dollars are the the the reserve currency. So they the the the reserve currency. So they the the the reserve currency. So they have a flood, an absolutely biblical have a flood, an absolutely biblical have a flood, an absolutely biblical flood of dollars available to China. You flood of dollars available to China. You flood of dollars available to China. You got to do something with them. Now, got to do something with them. Now, got to do something with them. Now, normally what happened in the in the normally what happened in the in the normally what happened in the in the 1990s and 2000s when they had a flood of 1990s and 2000s when they had a flood of 1990s and 2000s when they had a flood of dollars coming in, they took those dollars coming in, they took those dollars coming in, they took those dollars and reinvested them internally dollars and reinvested them internally dollars and reinvested them internally in the Chinese economy. They built in the Chinese economy. They built in the Chinese economy. They built factories, they built roads, they built factories, they built roads, they built factories, they built roads, they built glittering cities, they they tried to glittering cities, they they tried to glittering cities, they they tried to transform the the country from a transform the the country from a transform the the country from a subsistence agriculture one to a modern subsistence agriculture one to a modern subsistence agriculture one to a modern industrial society. And they were industrial society. And they were industrial society. And they were partially trans they were partially partially trans they were partially partially trans they were partially successful. They got kind of halfway successful. They got kind of halfway successful. They got kind of halfway through the system before 2008 hit. But through the system before 2008 hit. But through the system before 2008 hit. But these days they have the export boom. these days they have the export boom. these days they have the export boom. They got dollars available but really no They got dollars available but really no They got dollars available but really no appetite to do anything with them. So appetite to do anything with them. So appetite to do anything with them. So when in many ways they're buying gold when in many ways they're buying gold when in many ways they're buying gold because what else are they going to do because what else are they going to do because what else are they going to do with the money that they have? They with the money that they have? They with the money that they have? They don't want to put it in they don't want don't want to put it in they don't want don't want to put it in they don't want to invest it locally which is as much a to invest it locally which is as much a to invest it locally which is as much a commentary on the situation in the commentary on the situation in the commentary on the situation in the Chinese economy as anything else. So and Chinese economy as anything else. So and Chinese economy as anything else. So and they don't want to buy in US treasuries they don't want to buy in US treasuries they don't want to buy in US treasuries because yeah that's there's a political because yeah that's there's a political because yeah that's there's a political thing there. you can't buy more thing there. you can't buy more thing there. you can't buy more treasuries because we're we're at war treasuries because we're we're at war treasuries because we're we're at war with we're at war with the United States with we're at war with the United States with we're at war with the United States or at least we're no we're no longer or at least we're no we're no longer or at least we're no we're no longer strategic allies. So gold is the perfect strategic allies. So gold is the perfect strategic allies. So gold is the perfect solution because it gives you the idea solution because it gives you the idea solution because it gives you the idea or gives you the possibility of of being or gives you the possibility of of being or gives you the possibility of of being owning a safe haven at the same time you owning a safe haven at the same time you owning a safe haven at the same time you know during uncertain period but it's know during uncertain period but it's know during uncertain period but it's also potentially useful if you actually also potentially useful if you actually also potentially useful if you actually have to. So gold is for them um it's a have to. So gold is for them um it's a have to. So gold is for them um it's a it's a pretty good bridge solution for it's a pretty good bridge solution for it's a pretty good bridge solution for where they are uh where they are today where they are uh where they are today where they are uh where they are today in the conditions that they have. But as in the conditions that they have. But as in the conditions that they have. But as far as replacing the dollar, they gave far as replacing the dollar, they gave far as replacing the dollar, they gave up on that a long time ago. We're up on that a long time ago. We're up on that a long time ago. We're talking more than 10 years ago. There talking more than 10 years ago. There talking more than 10 years ago. There was a flirtation with making the yuan was a flirtation with making the yuan was a flirtation with making the yuan more like the euro dollar, which would more like the euro dollar, which would more like the euro dollar, which would be offshore focused and elastic. That be offshore focused and elastic. That be offshore focused and elastic. That was around 2010 and 2011. They created was around 2010 and 2011. They created was around 2010 and 2011. They created CNH, which is offshore yuan in Hong CNH, which is offshore yuan in Hong CNH, which is offshore yuan in Hong Kong. But they realized very quickly Kong. But they realized very quickly Kong. But they realized very quickly that wasn't going to work. And again, that wasn't going to work. And again, that wasn't going to work. And again, the bigger problem for them is to make a the bigger problem for them is to make a the bigger problem for them is to make a reserve currency workable, it has to be reserve currency workable, it has to be reserve currency workable, it has to be available everywhere and it has to be available everywhere and it has to be available everywhere and it has to be acceptable everywhere. China doesn't acceptable everywhere. China doesn't acceptable everywhere. China doesn't want to make the yuan available want to make the yuan available want to make the yuan available everywhere because that would mean it everywhere because that would mean it everywhere because that would mean it would be outside of author the would be outside of author the would be outside of author the authorities's control. And [snorts] as authorities's control. And [snorts] as authorities's control. And [snorts] as far as being acceptable everywhere, far as being acceptable everywhere, far as being acceptable everywhere, that's just never going to happen that's just never going to happen that's just never going to happen because one of the underappreciated because one of the underappreciated because one of the underappreciated parts of the euro dollar and any reserve parts of the euro dollar and any reserve parts of the euro dollar and any reserve currency system, it's not just it's not currency system, it's not just it's not currency system, it's not just it's not just currency, whether it's ledger just currency, whether it's ledger just currency, whether it's ledger currency or physical paper or, you know, currency or physical paper or, you know, currency or physical paper or, you know, gold nuggets or gold coins. It's also gold nuggets or gold coins. It's also gold nuggets or gold coins. It's also the all the stuff that comes along with the all the stuff that comes along with the all the stuff that comes along with it. I'm talking about um um uh uh it. I'm talking about um um uh uh it. I'm talking about um um uh uh arbitration, contract, respect for law. arbitration, contract, respect for law. arbitration, contract, respect for law. Uh that is incredibly important. The Uh that is incredibly important. The Uh that is incredibly important. The system that's in place that actually uh system that's in place that actually uh system that's in place that actually uh that that uh arbitrates disputes. that that uh arbitrates disputes. that that uh arbitrates disputes. Nobody's going to want to own a Chinese Nobody's going to want to own a Chinese Nobody's going to want to own a Chinese yuan because if you get in a dispute in yuan because if you get in a dispute in yuan because if you get in a dispute in yuan terms with a Chinese stateowned yuan terms with a Chinese stateowned yuan terms with a Chinese stateowned company, who's going to win? Doesn't company, who's going to win? Doesn't company, who's going to win? Doesn't matter what contract you have. One of matter what contract you have. One of matter what contract you have. One of the secrets behind the Euro dollar the secrets behind the Euro dollar the secrets behind the Euro dollar system, it's been able to hold on hold system, it's been able to hold on hold system, it's been able to hold on hold on as long as it has, is because on as long as it has, is because on as long as it has, is because whatever you think about the US legal whatever you think about the US legal whatever you think about the US legal system, and it's far from perfect, the system, and it's far from perfect, the system, and it's far from perfect, the respect for contracts and contract law respect for contracts and contract law respect for contracts and contract law is right at the center of everything. is right at the center of everything. is right at the center of everything. So, if you have a contract with the US So, if you have a contract with the US So, if you have a contract with the US government, chances are the US government, chances are the US government, chances are the US government is going to have to obey the government is going to have to obey the government is going to have to obey the contract because the independent courts contract because the independent courts contract because the independent courts will back that up. You're not going to will back that up. You're not going to will back that up. You're not going to have the same type of uh same type of have the same type of uh same type of have the same type of uh same type of leverage and leeway with the Chinese leverage and leeway with the Chinese leverage and leeway with the Chinese system. In fact, we know that because system. In fact, we know that because system. In fact, we know that because with the uh developers that have with the uh developers that have with the uh developers that have defaulted over the last couple years, defaulted over the last couple years, defaulted over the last couple years, whether it be Everrand or some of the whether it be Everrand or some of the whether it be Everrand or some of the other ones, um the Chinese have other ones, um the Chinese have other ones, um the Chinese have repeatedly repeatedly torn up contracts, repeatedly repeatedly torn up contracts, repeatedly repeatedly torn up contracts, repeatedly tried to move bankruptcy repeatedly tried to move bankruptcy repeatedly tried to move bankruptcy proceedings inside of mainland China. proceedings inside of mainland China. proceedings inside of mainland China. So, I mean, point is and the reserve So, I mean, point is and the reserve So, I mean, point is and the reserve currency, China does not will not allow currency, China does not will not allow currency, China does not will not allow the currency to be elastic enough that the currency to be elastic enough that the currency to be elastic enough that it's available where it needs to be it's available where it needs to be it's available where it needs to be everywhere to be reserve currency and everywhere to be reserve currency and everywhere to be reserve currency and nobody's going to want a Chinese yuan nobody's going to want a Chinese yuan nobody's going to want a Chinese yuan anyway. So they have given up on the anyway. So they have given up on the anyway. So they have given up on the idea of a reserve currency and instead idea of a reserve currency and instead idea of a reserve currency and instead are trying to trying to deal with a are trying to trying to deal with a are trying to trying to deal with a situation that they have as best as they situation that they have as best as they situation that they have as best as they possibly can. possibly can. possibly can. >> Jeeoff, this has been insanely >> Jeeoff, this has been insanely >> Jeeoff, this has been insanely educational. I can't thank you enough educational. I can't thank you enough educational. I can't thank you enough for your time. Uh I've watched a lot of for your time. Uh I've watched a lot of for your time. Uh I've watched a lot of your content. It is an absolute your content. It is an absolute your content. It is an absolute embarrassment of riches. Where can embarrassment of riches. Where can embarrassment of riches. Where can people follow along with you, connect people follow along with you, connect people follow along with you, connect with you online? with you online? with you online? >> Just find me at Eurodoll University, >> Just find me at Eurodoll University, >> Just find me at Eurodoll University, whether it's at YouTube or Eurodollun whether it's at YouTube or Eurodollun whether it's at YouTube or Eurodollun University, which is our website. University, which is our website. University, which is our website. >> I love it, man. I can't recommend it >> I love it, man. I can't recommend it >> I love it, man. I can't recommend it highly enough. Boys and girls, if you highly enough. Boys and girls, if you highly enough. Boys and girls, if you have not already, be sure to subscribe. have not already, be sure to subscribe. have not already, be sure to subscribe. And until next time, my friends, be And until next time, my friends, be And until next time, my friends, be legendary. Take care. Peace. If you like legendary. Take care. Peace. If you like legendary. Take care. Peace. If you like this conversation, check out this this conversation, check out this this conversation, check out this episode to learn more. episode to learn more. episode to learn more. >> I think there's a small group of power >> I think there's a small group of power >> I think there's a small group of power structures that sit above countries that structures that sit above countries that structures that sit above countries that are running the show. There's no are running the show. There's no are running the show. There's no political solution in the West. There's political solution in the West. There's political solution in the West. There's no democracy. It's all a lie. The no democracy. It's all a lie. The no democracy. It's all a lie. The government is a distraction. The left government is a distraction. The left government is a distraction. The left versus the right is a complete versus the right is a complete versus the right is a complete distraction. You need a theatrical.