Full Transcript
Read or copy the complete episode transcript.
[music] [music] Hey everybody, welcome to the 10% Hey everybody, welcome to the 10% Hey everybody, welcome to the 10% Happier podcast. I'm your host Dan Happier podcast. I'm your host Dan Happier podcast. I'm your host Dan Harris. Today we're talking about Harris. Today we're talking about Harris. Today we're talking about Buddhist communication strategies. Buddhist communication strategies. Buddhist communication strategies. You've heard me say this before maybe uh You've heard me say this before maybe uh You've heard me say this before maybe uh but I think about it all the time. The but I think about it all the time. The but I think about it all the time. The fact that we're talking to each other fact that we're talking to each other fact that we're talking to each other all day every day, most of us. And and all day every day, most of us. And and all day every day, most of us. And and yet very few of us are ever taught how yet very few of us are ever taught how yet very few of us are ever taught how to have successful uh communications. to have successful uh communications. to have successful uh communications. Uh, turns out the Buddha uh had a lot to Uh, turns out the Buddha uh had a lot to Uh, turns out the Buddha uh had a lot to say about this and we're going to talk say about this and we're going to talk say about this and we're going to talk about the Buddhists uh communication about the Buddhists uh communication about the Buddhists uh communication strategies with uh Sharon Salsburg. strategies with uh Sharon Salsburg. strategies with uh Sharon Salsburg. We're going to talk about such questions We're going to talk about such questions We're going to talk about such questions as um how do you deal with difficult as um how do you deal with difficult as um how do you deal with difficult people? Is it ever okay to gossip? Uh people? Is it ever okay to gossip? Uh people? Is it ever okay to gossip? Uh how can you be kind without being a how can you be kind without being a how can you be kind without being a doormat? Um uh are white lies ever okay doormat? Um uh are white lies ever okay doormat? Um uh are white lies ever okay even if they're motivated by kindness? even if they're motivated by kindness? even if they're motivated by kindness? There's a lot of uh juicy stuff in here. There's a lot of uh juicy stuff in here. There's a lot of uh juicy stuff in here. Um uh Sharon Salsberg uh is a legend in Um uh Sharon Salsberg uh is a legend in Um uh Sharon Salsberg uh is a legend in the um meditation community. Uh she's the um meditation community. Uh she's the um meditation community. Uh she's one of the co-founders of the Insight one of the co-founders of the Insight one of the co-founders of the Insight Meditation Society, which is a very Meditation Society, which is a very Meditation Society, which is a very well-known now 50-year-old uh Buddhist well-known now 50-year-old uh Buddhist well-known now 50-year-old uh Buddhist uh retreat center in Barry, uh retreat center in Barry, uh retreat center in Barry, Massachusetts. She's also written 13 Massachusetts. She's also written 13 Massachusetts. She's also written 13 books, including Real Happiness uh and books, including Real Happiness uh and books, including Real Happiness uh and her landmark work uh loving kindness. her landmark work uh loving kindness. her landmark work uh loving kindness. Uh, and Sharon has uh, very generously Uh, and Sharon has uh, very generously Uh, and Sharon has uh, very generously agreed to teach a uh, live 8-week series agreed to teach a uh, live 8-week series agreed to teach a uh, live 8-week series on what's known as the eight-fold path, on what's known as the eight-fold path, on what's known as the eight-fold path, which is one of the principal and which is one of the principal and which is one of the principal and foundational Buddhist lists. She will be foundational Buddhist lists. She will be foundational Buddhist lists. She will be teaching this on my meditation app, the teaching this on my meditation app, the teaching this on my meditation app, the 10% with Dan Harris meditation app, 10% with Dan Harris meditation app, 10% with Dan Harris meditation app, starting on July 12th. And, uh, it'll be starting on July 12th. And, uh, it'll be starting on July 12th. And, uh, it'll be every Sunday, a live hourlong session every Sunday, a live hourlong session every Sunday, a live hourlong session uh, over the course of eight weeks. And uh, over the course of eight weeks. And uh, over the course of eight weeks. And if you miss the sessions, you can always if you miss the sessions, you can always if you miss the sessions, you can always watch them um uh on demand. Afterwards, watch them um uh on demand. Afterwards, watch them um uh on demand. Afterwards, these sessions will be uh deep dives these sessions will be uh deep dives these sessions will be uh deep dives into the uh uh eight-fold path uh by a a into the uh uh eight-fold path uh by a a into the uh uh eight-fold path uh by a a true master. And uh on each session, she true master. And uh on each session, she true master. And uh on each session, she will guide a meditation and then talk a will guide a meditation and then talk a will guide a meditation and then talk a little bit about one aspect of the little bit about one aspect of the little bit about one aspect of the eight-fold path and then take your eight-fold path and then take your eight-fold path and then take your questions. So, it's an opportunity not questions. So, it's an opportunity not questions. So, it's an opportunity not only to learn from but also to be in only to learn from but also to be in only to learn from but also to be in dialogue with an incredible Buddhist dialogue with an incredible Buddhist dialogue with an incredible Buddhist teacher. All that said, we'll be talking teacher. All that said, we'll be talking teacher. All that said, we'll be talking to Sharon Salsberg uh about uh what's to Sharon Salsberg uh about uh what's to Sharon Salsberg uh about uh what's called Write Speech after this quick called Write Speech after this quick called Write Speech after this quick break. I was playing around this morning break. I was playing around this morning break. I was playing around this morning with the new Rosetta Stone Sapphire app, with the new Rosetta Stone Sapphire app, with the new Rosetta Stone Sapphire app, which is really cool and really which is really cool and really which is really cool and really intuitive, really easy to use. I was intuitive, really easy to use. I was intuitive, really easy to use. I was learning some basic Japanese in learning some basic Japanese in learning some basic Japanese in anticipation of a trip that we haven't anticipation of a trip that we haven't anticipation of a trip that we haven't even planned yet, but my family and I even planned yet, but my family and I even planned yet, but my family and I have been fantasizing about going to have been fantasizing about going to have been fantasizing about going to Tokyo. And I was playing around with the Tokyo. And I was playing around with the Tokyo. And I was playing around with the Rosetta Stone Sapphire app and very Rosetta Stone Sapphire app and very Rosetta Stone Sapphire app and very quickly it was having me say things in quickly it was having me say things in quickly it was having me say things in Japanese. It was I was talking about a Japanese. It was I was talking about a Japanese. It was I was talking about a little boy drinking tea and it checks little boy drinking tea and it checks little boy drinking tea and it checks your pronunciation and you can't move on your pronunciation and you can't move on your pronunciation and you can't move on if unless you pronounce the words if unless you pronounce the words if unless you pronounce the words correctly. It's really cool, really correctly. It's really cool, really correctly. It's really cool, really intuitive and it took me further than I intuitive and it took me further than I intuitive and it took me further than I was expecting to go just sitting on my was expecting to go just sitting on my was expecting to go just sitting on my couch. Rosetta Stone, which is the couch. Rosetta Stone, which is the couch. Rosetta Stone, which is the trusted leader in language learning for trusted leader in language learning for trusted leader in language learning for over 30 years, just launched Rosetta over 30 years, just launched Rosetta over 30 years, just launched Rosetta Stone Sapphire. It's a new app that Stone Sapphire. It's a new app that Stone Sapphire. It's a new app that combines its proven immersion method combines its proven immersion method combines its proven immersion method with the latest innovations in with the latest innovations in with the latest innovations in technology to help you learn faster, technology to help you learn faster, technology to help you learn faster, personalize your lessons, and have more personalize your lessons, and have more personalize your lessons, and have more fun along the way. It's not fun along the way. It's not fun along the way. It's not one-sizefits-all. Most language apps one-sizefits-all. Most language apps one-sizefits-all. Most language apps teach you the same generic topics. teach you the same generic topics. teach you the same generic topics. Sapphire helps you focus on what you Sapphire helps you focus on what you Sapphire helps you focus on what you actually want to talk about. Whether actually want to talk about. Whether actually want to talk about. Whether it's football or travel or work or it's football or travel or work or it's football or travel or work or family or your favorite hobbies, your family or your favorite hobbies, your family or your favorite hobbies, your time matters, so your learning should, time matters, so your learning should, time matters, so your learning should, too. If you want to take your language too. If you want to take your language too. If you want to take your language skills to the next level, don't wait to skills to the next level, don't wait to skills to the next level, don't wait to try Rosetta Stone Sapphire. 10% happier try Rosetta Stone Sapphire. 10% happier try Rosetta Stone Sapphire. 10% happier listeners can get 20% off their Rosetta listeners can get 20% off their Rosetta listeners can get 20% off their Rosetta Stone Sapphire subscription. When they Stone Sapphire subscription. When they Stone Sapphire subscription. When they sign up today, you'll get unlimited sign up today, you'll get unlimited sign up today, you'll get unlimited access to all 25 Rosetta Stone access to all 25 Rosetta Stone access to all 25 Rosetta Stone languages, plus the new Sapphire languages, plus the new Sapphire languages, plus the new Sapphire learning tools. Visit learning tools. Visit learning tools. Visit rosetta.com/happier rosetta.com/happier rosetta.com/happier to redeem your 20% off. That's to redeem your 20% off. That's to redeem your 20% off. That's rosettastone.com/happhappier rosettastone.com/happhappier rosettastone.com/happhappier and start learning a language for real. and start learning a language for real. and start learning a language for real. Sharon Salsburg, welcome back to the Sharon Salsburg, welcome back to the Sharon Salsburg, welcome back to the show. Thank you so much. It's great to show. Thank you so much. It's great to show. Thank you so much. It's great to be with you. be with you. be with you. >> I think you may be one of, if not the >> I think you may be one of, if not the >> I think you may be one of, if not the most frequent guest on this show. So, most frequent guest on this show. So, most frequent guest on this show. So, >> Oh, shucks. >> Oh, shucks. >> Oh, shucks. >> Always awesome to have you. >> Always awesome to have you. >> Always awesome to have you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Before we get into uh >> Before we get into uh >> Before we get into uh the Buddhist uh recommendations for the Buddhist uh recommendations for the Buddhist uh recommendations for communicating effectively with other communicating effectively with other communicating effectively with other human beings, um let me just step back human beings, um let me just step back human beings, um let me just step back and ask you a a broader question. This and ask you a a broader question. This and ask you a a broader question. This advice on effective communication is advice on effective communication is advice on effective communication is delivered as part of what's known as the delivered as part of what's known as the delivered as part of what's known as the eight-fold path. eight-fold path. eight-fold path. What is the eight-fold path? What is the eight-fold path? What is the eight-fold path? >> Well, the eight-fold path is actually a >> Well, the eight-fold path is actually a >> Well, the eight-fold path is actually a framework. Uh it's meant to be a framework. Uh it's meant to be a framework. Uh it's meant to be a practical, we would say actionable practical, we would say actionable practical, we would say actionable framework for moving from suffering to framework for moving from suffering to framework for moving from suffering to the end of suffering. Moving from the end of suffering. Moving from the end of suffering. Moving from constriction and limitation to life constriction and limitation to life constriction and limitation to life that's more expansive and open. It's that's more expansive and open. It's that's more expansive and open. It's moving from in a way isolation to to moving from in a way isolation to to moving from in a way isolation to to freedom and connection. freedom and connection. freedom and connection. >> So those are lofty terms, freedom and >> So those are lofty terms, freedom and >> So those are lofty terms, freedom and connection. Yeah. connection. Yeah. connection. Yeah. >> How would they play out in a in a in a >> How would they play out in a in a in a >> How would they play out in a in a in a generic human life? generic human life? generic human life? >> Well, there are different aspects to the >> Well, there are different aspects to the >> Well, there are different aspects to the the eight-fold path. Like I think if the eight-fold path. Like I think if the eight-fold path. Like I think if you're experiencing you're experiencing you're experiencing loneliness, uh, alienation, loneliness, uh, alienation, loneliness, uh, alienation, if you have a sense that your life is if you have a sense that your life is if you have a sense that your life is maybe built on a kind of cultural maybe built on a kind of cultural maybe built on a kind of cultural deception, deception, deception, like maybe all your life you thought uh like maybe all your life you thought uh like maybe all your life you thought uh endless accumulation would keep you safe endless accumulation would keep you safe endless accumulation would keep you safe and keep change from happening. Cuz and keep change from happening. Cuz and keep change from happening. Cuz that's in a way what we're conditioned that's in a way what we're conditioned that's in a way what we're conditioned to, what we're taught. If you're brought to, what we're taught. If you're brought to, what we're taught. If you're brought up to believe it's a doggy dog world and up to believe it's a doggy dog world and up to believe it's a doggy dog world and you shouldn't help anybody else cuz you shouldn't help anybody else cuz you shouldn't help anybody else cuz they're not going to help you. And if they're not going to help you. And if they're not going to help you. And if you're brought up to believe that you're brought up to believe that you're brought up to believe that strength is vengefulness and loving strength is vengefulness and loving strength is vengefulness and loving kindness or compassion are stupid and kindness or compassion are stupid and kindness or compassion are stupid and will make you weak or sentimental, then will make you weak or sentimental, then will make you weak or sentimental, then we need to unpack all that and and we need to unpack all that and and we need to unpack all that and and realize I do want to be happy. I want a realize I do want to be happy. I want a realize I do want to be happy. I want a fulfilled life. I want not to feel so fulfilled life. I want not to feel so fulfilled life. I want not to feel so burdened by loneliness and all of those burdened by loneliness and all of those burdened by loneliness and all of those things. But how? You know, and that's things. But how? You know, and that's things. But how? You know, and that's why even though the concepts are lofty, why even though the concepts are lofty, why even though the concepts are lofty, they're really meant to be like, let's they're really meant to be like, let's they're really meant to be like, let's experiment with this and let's try this experiment with this and let's try this experiment with this and let's try this and are you different? Are you better? and are you different? Are you better? and are you different? Are you better? Do you feel more fulfilled? And so on. Do you feel more fulfilled? And so on. Do you feel more fulfilled? And so on. So, it's a very practical approach. So, it's a very practical approach. So, it's a very practical approach. >> Do you have to be a Buddhist to practice >> Do you have to be a Buddhist to practice >> Do you have to be a Buddhist to practice this aspect of Buddhism? this aspect of Buddhism? this aspect of Buddhism? >> No. In fact, one of the things I've >> No. In fact, one of the things I've >> No. In fact, one of the things I've enjoyed about the eight-fold path and enjoyed about the eight-fold path and enjoyed about the eight-fold path and and uh it's also embedded you as you and uh it's also embedded you as you and uh it's also embedded you as you know in the four noble truths that know in the four noble truths that know in the four noble truths that there's suffering in life. There's a there's suffering in life. There's a there's suffering in life. There's a reason for that. There are causes reason for that. There are causes reason for that. There are causes there's an end a possible end or there's an end a possible end or there's an end a possible end or sessation and there is the path the sessation and there is the path the sessation and there is the path the eight-fold path. It's a marker of non eight-fold path. It's a marker of non eight-fold path. It's a marker of non sectarianism actually like I remember sectarianism actually like I remember sectarianism actually like I remember when at the insight meditation society when at the insight meditation society when at the insight meditation society uh years and years ago we brought over uh years and years ago we brought over uh years and years ago we brought over kind of the patriarch of our lineage kind of the patriarch of our lineage kind of the patriarch of our lineage Mahazi Sadov from Burma and people would Mahazi Sadov from Burma and people would Mahazi Sadov from Burma and people would ask him you know like is it worth ask him you know like is it worth ask him you know like is it worth following this other teacher or this following this other teacher or this following this other teacher or this other approach or this other faith or other approach or this other faith or other approach or this other faith or you know what about going here and what you know what about going here and what you know what about going here and what about combining and what about doing about combining and what about doing about combining and what about doing this and and rather than saying, "Yeah, this and and rather than saying, "Yeah, this and and rather than saying, "Yeah, we got the goods and everyone else is we got the goods and everyone else is we got the goods and everyone else is inferior or anything like that," he inferior or anything like that," he inferior or anything like that," he would just say, "Look to see if the would just say, "Look to see if the would just say, "Look to see if the eight-fold path is there." Look to see eight-fold path is there." Look to see eight-fold path is there." Look to see if it if it seems to you another mark of if it if it seems to you another mark of if it if it seems to you another mark of the eight-fold path is that it's the eight-fold path is that it's the eight-fold path is that it's holistic. It covers like our inner life holistic. It covers like our inner life holistic. It covers like our inner life and disciplines like with mindfulness and disciplines like with mindfulness and disciplines like with mindfulness and concentration. It also covers things and concentration. It also covers things and concentration. It also covers things that are very practical and day-to-day that are very practical and day-to-day that are very practical and day-to-day like livelihood and and the way we speak like livelihood and and the way we speak like livelihood and and the way we speak to one another. So he would say look to to one another. So he would say look to to one another. So he would say look to see if there's a genuinely holistic path see if there's a genuinely holistic path see if there's a genuinely holistic path there that's going to be integrated there that's going to be integrated there that's going to be integrated that's going to have these different that's going to have these different that's going to have these different elements and if so it's good you know elements and if so it's good you know elements and if so it's good you know and so it wasn't a sense of like uh and so it wasn't a sense of like uh and so it wasn't a sense of like uh we're better or you know you've got to we're better or you know you've got to we're better or you know you've got to stay within the confines the languaging stay within the confines the languaging stay within the confines the languaging of Buddhism or anything like that said of Buddhism or anything like that said of Buddhism or anything like that said look for these elements and then you look for these elements and then you look for these elements and then you know it's okay. know it's okay. know it's okay. >> You mentioned the four noble truths. Um, >> You mentioned the four noble truths. Um, >> You mentioned the four noble truths. Um, let me see if I can provide a little let me see if I can provide a little let me see if I can provide a little context here and and then but please context here and and then but please context here and and then but please fact check me because I'm you you know fact check me because I'm you you know fact check me because I'm you you know more way more about this than I do. But more way more about this than I do. But more way more about this than I do. But the Buddha after he got enlightened, you the Buddha after he got enlightened, you the Buddha after he got enlightened, you know, according to the to the legend, he know, according to the to the legend, he know, according to the to the legend, he got enlightened when he was 36 after got enlightened when he was 36 after got enlightened when he was 36 after spending uh his early life as a as a am spending uh his early life as a as a am spending uh his early life as a as a am I you're making a face about 36. Was I I you're making a face about 36. Was I I you're making a face about 36. Was I wrong? wrong? wrong? >> I was checking. 35 I think. >> I was checking. 35 I think. >> I was checking. 35 I think. >> 35. Okay. >> 35. Okay. >> 35. Okay. >> 35. >> 35. >> 35. >> No, I was I had to calculate cuz he left >> No, I was I had to calculate cuz he left >> No, I was I had to calculate cuz he left home at 29. home at 29. home at 29. >> Right. Right. and he spent six years >> Right. Right. and he spent six years >> Right. Right. and he spent six years doing those other things. So, doing those other things. So, doing those other things. So, >> so up until 29, he was this, you know, >> so up until 29, he was this, you know, >> so up until 29, he was this, you know, this spoiled prince who lived this this spoiled prince who lived this this spoiled prince who lived this incredible life. And then he had a bit incredible life. And then he had a bit incredible life. And then he had a bit of a a spiritual experience where he of a a spiritual experience where he of a a spiritual experience where he realized, you know, life is is um you realized, you know, life is is um you realized, you know, life is is um you know, he is going to end in death and know, he is going to end in death and know, he is going to end in death and and illness and old age and um and these and illness and old age and um and these and illness and old age and um and these things are non-negotiable. And so, he things are non-negotiable. And so, he things are non-negotiable. And so, he goes off on a spiritual quest and he goes off on a spiritual quest and he goes off on a spiritual quest and he lives for six years and he like beats lives for six years and he like beats lives for six years and he like beats the out of himself. He does what's the out of himself. He does what's the out of himself. He does what's called self-mortification. and he called self-mortification. and he called self-mortification. and he doesn't eat. He like stands on one foot doesn't eat. He like stands on one foot doesn't eat. He like stands on one foot all day, does all these crazy meditative all day, does all these crazy meditative all day, does all these crazy meditative practices until he realizes, well, no, practices until he realizes, well, no, practices until he realizes, well, no, there's there's got to be a middle path there's there's got to be a middle path there's there's got to be a middle path between, you know, self-mortification between, you know, self-mortification between, you know, self-mortification and self-indulgence. And that's when he and self-indulgence. And that's when he and self-indulgence. And that's when he uh gets enlightened. And after he gets uh gets enlightened. And after he gets uh gets enlightened. And after he gets enlightened at age 35, not age 36, um he enlightened at age 35, not age 36, um he enlightened at age 35, not age 36, um he um uh goes and finds some of his former um uh goes and finds some of his former um uh goes and finds some of his former uh meditation buddies and he delivers uh uh meditation buddies and he delivers uh uh meditation buddies and he delivers uh this this diagnosis of the human this this diagnosis of the human this this diagnosis of the human condition called the four noble truths. condition called the four noble truths. condition called the four noble truths. The first is life is suffering, which is The first is life is suffering, which is The first is life is suffering, which is a bit of a me mistransation. It just a bit of a me mistransation. It just a bit of a me mistransation. It just means life is bumpy if you're living it means life is bumpy if you're living it means life is bumpy if you're living it without wisdom. Um uh the second is uh without wisdom. Um uh the second is uh without wisdom. Um uh the second is uh the the cause of the bumpiness, the the the cause of the bumpiness, the the the cause of the bumpiness, the cause of our sufferings is uh is craving cause of our sufferings is uh is craving cause of our sufferings is uh is craving or thirst wanting things to be a or thirst wanting things to be a or thirst wanting things to be a specific way in a world where specific way in a world where specific way in a world where everything's changing all the time. The everything's changing all the time. The everything's changing all the time. The third is there's a way out of this. And third is there's a way out of this. And third is there's a way out of this. And the fourth noble truth is actually a the fourth noble truth is actually a the fourth noble truth is actually a list within a list and that's the list within a list and that's the list within a list and that's the eight-fold path which is basically the eight-fold path which is basically the eight-fold path which is basically the Buddha's cookbook or recipe for Buddha's cookbook or recipe for Buddha's cookbook or recipe for enlightenment. a aka a healthy life. So, enlightenment. a aka a healthy life. So, enlightenment. a aka a healthy life. So, is all of that reasonably accurate? is all of that reasonably accurate? is all of that reasonably accurate? >> It is. And I don't know if uh you know, >> It is. And I don't know if uh you know, >> It is. And I don't know if uh you know, but I'm about to embark on writing a but I'm about to embark on writing a but I'm about to embark on writing a book on suffering in the end of book on suffering in the end of book on suffering in the end of suffering or dooka and the end of duka. suffering or dooka and the end of duka. suffering or dooka and the end of duka. And I like the word bumpiness because And I like the word bumpiness because And I like the word bumpiness because the uh the word dooka and pi it doesn't the uh the word dooka and pi it doesn't the uh the word dooka and pi it doesn't just mean suffering although that's a just mean suffering although that's a just mean suffering although that's a very common translation. It's also very common translation. It's also very common translation. It's also insecurity, distress, unease. And the insecurity, distress, unease. And the insecurity, distress, unease. And the example they use, of course, is a example they use, of course, is a example they use, of course, is a chariot because they're all about chariot because they're all about chariot because they're all about chariots. And uh the axle and the wheel chariots. And uh the axle and the wheel chariots. And uh the axle and the wheel are not aligned. So it is like a a bumpy are not aligned. So it is like a a bumpy are not aligned. So it is like a a bumpy ride. So that that's a great way of ride. So that that's a great way of ride. So that that's a great way of saying it. saying it. saying it. >> In your conversation uh with my >> In your conversation uh with my >> In your conversation uh with my colleague, our senior producer, Marissa colleague, our senior producer, Marissa colleague, our senior producer, Marissa Schneiderman, and she gave me notes on Schneiderman, and she gave me notes on Schneiderman, and she gave me notes on your conversation in order to prepare me your conversation in order to prepare me your conversation in order to prepare me for this conversation with you. There for this conversation with you. There for this conversation with you. There was a line that she said that you like was a line that she said that you like was a line that she said that you like from the Buddha, something about from the Buddha, something about from the Buddha, something about abandoning the unskillful. Can you say abandoning the unskillful. Can you say abandoning the unskillful. Can you say more about that? more about that? more about that? >> I mean, that's another way of describing >> I mean, that's another way of describing >> I mean, that's another way of describing the eight-fold path. It's like what do the eight-fold path. It's like what do the eight-fold path. It's like what do we do to have a happier, more fulfilled we do to have a happier, more fulfilled we do to have a happier, more fulfilled life? Like what do we actually do? And life? Like what do we actually do? And life? Like what do we actually do? And so, um, this is long, long been one of so, um, this is long, long been one of so, um, this is long, long been one of my favorite passages from the Buddha my favorite passages from the Buddha my favorite passages from the Buddha where he said, "Abandon the unskillful." where he said, "Abandon the unskillful." where he said, "Abandon the unskillful." And the unskillful or the unh wholesome And the unskillful or the unh wholesome And the unskillful or the unh wholesome are those habits you know um are those habits you know um are those habits you know um that we get lost in. It's not just the that we get lost in. It's not just the that we get lost in. It's not just the appearance of the habits of mind but appearance of the habits of mind but appearance of the habits of mind but it's the ways we get lost. We get it's the ways we get lost. We get it's the ways we get lost. We get overwhelmed by greed or anger or overwhelmed by greed or anger or overwhelmed by greed or anger or delusion something like that. Um he said delusion something like that. Um he said delusion something like that. Um he said abandon the unskillful. abandon the unskillful. abandon the unskillful. You can abandon the unskillful. If it You can abandon the unskillful. If it You can abandon the unskillful. If it were not possible I would not ask you to were not possible I would not ask you to were not possible I would not ask you to do it. And if abandoning the unskillful do it. And if abandoning the unskillful do it. And if abandoning the unskillful were to lead to more limitation or were to lead to more limitation or were to lead to more limitation or unhappiness and and uh disconnection, I unhappiness and and uh disconnection, I unhappiness and and uh disconnection, I would not ask you to do it. But because would not ask you to do it. But because would not ask you to do it. But because it leads to happiness and fulfillment, it leads to happiness and fulfillment, it leads to happiness and fulfillment, so I say abandon that which is so I say abandon that which is so I say abandon that which is unskillful. And then he went on to say unskillful. And then he went on to say unskillful. And then he went on to say cultivate the good. Which you know in cultivate the good. Which you know in cultivate the good. Which you know in our minds would be like loving kindness our minds would be like loving kindness our minds would be like loving kindness or compassion, generosity. Cultivate the or compassion, generosity. Cultivate the or compassion, generosity. Cultivate the good. You can cultivate the good. If it good. You can cultivate the good. If it good. You can cultivate the good. If it were not possible, I would not ask you were not possible, I would not ask you were not possible, I would not ask you to do it. And then that last section as to do it. And then that last section as to do it. And then that last section as well. But I lived, as I told Marissa, I well. But I lived, as I told Marissa, I well. But I lived, as I told Marissa, I lived for a long time boyed up by the lived for a long time boyed up by the lived for a long time boyed up by the Buddha thinks I can do it. Buddha thinks I can do it. Buddha thinks I can do it. >> If it were not possible, I would not ask >> If it were not possible, I would not ask >> If it were not possible, I would not ask you to do it. And I took that so to you to do it. And I took that so to you to do it. And I took that so to heart in the midst of all of my heart in the midst of all of my heart in the midst of all of my uncertainty and insecurity and fear and uncertainty and insecurity and fear and uncertainty and insecurity and fear and everything I was really marked by, you everything I was really marked by, you everything I was really marked by, you know, in those days. And and it's like, know, in those days. And and it's like, know, in those days. And and it's like, wow, he thinks I can do it. So step by wow, he thinks I can do it. So step by wow, he thinks I can do it. So step by step, let's put it into practice. step, let's put it into practice. step, let's put it into practice. >> You've told the story many times, but >> You've told the story many times, but >> You've told the story many times, but can you just give us a little bit more can you just give us a little bit more can you just give us a little bit more context on, you know, how you came to context on, you know, how you came to context on, you know, how you came to Buddhism and and you said you were Buddhism and and you said you were Buddhism and and you said you were marked by things like insecurity, etc., marked by things like insecurity, etc., marked by things like insecurity, etc., etc., uh, I I have to say, having known etc., uh, I I have to say, having known etc., uh, I I have to say, having known you for a little while, you came by it you for a little while, you came by it you for a little while, you came by it honestly. honestly. honestly. >> Yeah. I uh went to college when I was 16 >> Yeah. I uh went to college when I was 16 >> Yeah. I uh went to college when I was 16 and having skipped two grades as a and having skipped two grades as a and having skipped two grades as a product of the New York City public product of the New York City public product of the New York City public school system. And in my sophomore year school system. And in my sophomore year school system. And in my sophomore year of college, I took an Asian philosophy of college, I took an Asian philosophy of college, I took an Asian philosophy course because there was a philosophy course because there was a philosophy course because there was a philosophy requirement and I looked at that requirement and I looked at that requirement and I looked at that schedule and I thought, "Oh, that fits schedule and I thought, "Oh, that fits schedule and I thought, "Oh, that fits nicely. That's like on Tuesday or nicely. That's like on Tuesday or nicely. That's like on Tuesday or something." So, I chose that one. And it something." So, I chose that one. And it something." So, I chose that one. And it totally changed my life in two ways. One totally changed my life in two ways. One totally changed my life in two ways. One was uh in in learning about Buddhism, was uh in in learning about Buddhism, was uh in in learning about Buddhism, they talked about of course the four they talked about of course the four they talked about of course the four noble truths and the Buddha talking noble truths and the Buddha talking noble truths and the Buddha talking about suffering. And for many people about suffering. And for many people about suffering. And for many people that's kind of a bummer of a message, that's kind of a bummer of a message, that's kind of a bummer of a message, you know, but for me it was like so you know, but for me it was like so you know, but for me it was like so enveloping. It was so inclusive. It's enveloping. It was so inclusive. It's enveloping. It was so inclusive. It's like I like many people had had a very like I like many people had had a very like I like many people had had a very traumatic and painful childhood. And traumatic and painful childhood. And traumatic and painful childhood. And like for many people, my family was one like for many people, my family was one like for many people, my family was one where this was never ever spoken about. where this was never ever spoken about. where this was never ever spoken about. and I don't know what to do with all of and I don't know what to do with all of and I don't know what to do with all of those feelings inside of me. And I heard those feelings inside of me. And I heard those feelings inside of me. And I heard that there is suffering in life. And it that there is suffering in life. And it that there is suffering in life. And it was like for the first time in my life, was like for the first time in my life, was like for the first time in my life, I didn't feel so alone and I didn't feel I didn't feel so alone and I didn't feel I didn't feel so alone and I didn't feel so different and kind of cast aside, you so different and kind of cast aside, you so different and kind of cast aside, you know, and I thought, "Wow, I belong. You know, and I thought, "Wow, I belong. You know, and I thought, "Wow, I belong. You know, it's not just me. It's not that know, it's not just me. It's not that know, it's not just me. It's not that I'm weird, you know, this is this is I'm weird, you know, this is this is I'm weird, you know, this is this is part of life." And and then I heard in part of life." And and then I heard in part of life." And and then I heard in the context of that class that there the context of that class that there the context of that class that there were practices and methods that if you were practices and methods that if you were practices and methods that if you wanted to do them, they're called wanted to do them, they're called wanted to do them, they're called meditation. You could be a lot happier. meditation. You could be a lot happier. meditation. You could be a lot happier. And I was going to college in Buffalo, And I was going to college in Buffalo, And I was going to college in Buffalo, New York. Looked around Buffalo. New York. Looked around Buffalo. New York. Looked around Buffalo. Couldn't see it anywhere. This is 1969, Couldn't see it anywhere. This is 1969, Couldn't see it anywhere. This is 1969, 1970. 1970. 1970. And so I did this completely outrageous, And so I did this completely outrageous, And so I did this completely outrageous, almost unthinkable thing looking back. almost unthinkable thing looking back. almost unthinkable thing looking back. I, you know, I'd grown up in New York I, you know, I'd grown up in New York I, you know, I'd grown up in New York City, went to college in Buffalo. I'd City, went to college in Buffalo. I'd City, went to college in Buffalo. I'd never even been to California and I'd never even been to California and I'd never even been to California and I'd created an independent study project. I created an independent study project. I created an independent study project. I said I want to go to India and study said I want to go to India and study said I want to go to India and study meditation. So they said okay and off I meditation. So they said okay and off I meditation. So they said okay and off I went. I left in uh 1970 you know the went. I left in uh 1970 you know the went. I left in uh 1970 you know the beginning of that fall semester. I uh beginning of that fall semester. I uh beginning of that fall semester. I uh looked around India. I didn't really looked around India. I didn't really looked around India. I didn't really find I wanted something very practical. find I wanted something very practical. find I wanted something very practical. Wasn't interested in a belief system or Wasn't interested in a belief system or Wasn't interested in a belief system or becoming a Buddhist or assuming an becoming a Buddhist or assuming an becoming a Buddhist or assuming an identity or rejecting anything else. I identity or rejecting anything else. I identity or rejecting anything else. I wanted to know how to do it. How should wanted to know how to do it. How should wanted to know how to do it. How should I really put this into practice? And it I really put this into practice? And it I really put this into practice? And it took a long time to find and it actually took a long time to find and it actually took a long time to find and it actually uh was in large measure because I heard uh was in large measure because I heard uh was in large measure because I heard Dan Gleman way back when give a talk in Dan Gleman way back when give a talk in Dan Gleman way back when give a talk in New Delhi at a yoga conference. He at New Delhi at a yoga conference. He at New Delhi at a yoga conference. He at the time was a graduate student at the time was a graduate student at the time was a graduate student at Harvard studying meditation and Harvard studying meditation and Harvard studying meditation and psychology. And for some reason he was psychology. And for some reason he was psychology. And for some reason he was invited to give a talk at this invited to give a talk at this invited to give a talk at this conference. And at the end of the talk conference. And at the end of the talk conference. And at the end of the talk he said that he was going to go to this he said that he was going to go to this he said that he was going to go to this town called Bgaya which is where the town called Bgaya which is where the town called Bgaya which is where the Buddha was enlightened and he was going Buddha was enlightened and he was going Buddha was enlightened and he was going to do this 10day immersive retreat in to do this 10day immersive retreat in to do this 10day immersive retreat in meditation meditation meditation that was considered a very practical that was considered a very practical that was considered a very practical direct transmission of these tools. And direct transmission of these tools. And direct transmission of these tools. And I thought that's it. That's what I'm I thought that's it. That's what I'm I thought that's it. That's what I'm looking for. And it was what I was looking for. And it was what I was looking for. And it was what I was looking for. So I followed him along looking for. So I followed him along looking for. So I followed him along with you know all these other people. We with you know all these other people. We with you know all these other people. We followed him to Bodga Gaya and and did followed him to Bodga Gaya and and did followed him to Bodga Gaya and and did this intensive meditation retreat this intensive meditation retreat this intensive meditation retreat together and that was the beginning. together and that was the beginning. together and that was the beginning. >> I love that story and just to say Dan >> I love that story and just to say Dan >> I love that story and just to say Dan Gleman who was referenced there Gleman who was referenced there Gleman who was referenced there sometimes known as Daniel Gleman uh went sometimes known as Daniel Gleman uh went sometimes known as Daniel Gleman uh went on to write the seminal book emotional on to write the seminal book emotional on to write the seminal book emotional intelligence and has been on this show intelligence and has been on this show intelligence and has been on this show many many times. I can drop some links many many times. I can drop some links many many times. I can drop some links to his prior appearances in the show to his prior appearances in the show to his prior appearances in the show notes. But you know, I just that that notes. But you know, I just that that notes. But you know, I just that that story and all of the karma and kismmet story and all of the karma and kismmet story and all of the karma and kismmet and coincidence and happen stance that and coincidence and happen stance that and coincidence and happen stance that goes into it. Um, you know, it's it it's goes into it. Um, you know, it's it it's goes into it. Um, you know, it's it it's for me very consequential because for me very consequential because for me very consequential because without you having taken a flyer and without you having taken a flyer and without you having taken a flyer and gone to India and then running into Dan gone to India and then running into Dan gone to India and then running into Dan Gleman and then going to Bo Gaia and Gleman and then going to Bo Gaia and Gleman and then going to Bo Gaia and where you met you know Joseph Goldstein where you met you know Joseph Goldstein where you met you know Joseph Goldstein and and and and and and >> you know that that all led to that was a >> you know that that all led to that was a >> you know that that all led to that was a big stream. There were many streams big stream. There were many streams big stream. There were many streams through which Buddhism arrived in through which Buddhism arrived in through which Buddhism arrived in America. But that is a big one and uh America. But that is a big one and uh America. But that is a big one and uh and it is the form of Buddhism that that and it is the form of Buddhism that that and it is the form of Buddhism that that that later you know ended up in in in on that later you know ended up in in in on that later you know ended up in in in on my desk and that spoke to me and and so my desk and that spoke to me and and so my desk and that spoke to me and and so yeah it's a it is of of a genuine karmic yeah it's a it is of of a genuine karmic yeah it's a it is of of a genuine karmic moment. No no no question. moment. No no no question. moment. No no no question. >> Well even when I when I said it was the >> Well even when I when I said it was the >> Well even when I when I said it was the beginning I thought well maybe not for beginning I thought well maybe not for beginning I thought well maybe not for Joseph. He'd already been there for Joseph. He'd already been there for Joseph. He'd already been there for years. years. years. So, So, So, >> but one of the key causes and conditions >> but one of the key causes and conditions >> but one of the key causes and conditions for what what totally for the the for what what totally for the the for what what totally for the the massive like to use a type of word I massive like to use a type of word I massive like to use a type of word I don't normally use but like the massive don't normally use but like the massive don't normally use but like the massive blessing of of of insight meditation blessing of of of insight meditation blessing of of of insight meditation into into the American consciousness. into into the American consciousness. into into the American consciousness. >> Yeah. Just back to the eight-fold path, >> Yeah. Just back to the eight-fold path, >> Yeah. Just back to the eight-fold path, Sharon, as I understand it, there are Sharon, as I understand it, there are Sharon, as I understand it, there are three kind of uh and you referenced this three kind of uh and you referenced this three kind of uh and you referenced this a little bit earlier, but there are a little bit earlier, but there are a little bit earlier, but there are three kind of baskets of uh there um so three kind of baskets of uh there um so three kind of baskets of uh there um so there are eight entries in the there are eight entries in the there are eight entries in the eight-fold path obviously, but there are eight-fold path obviously, but there are eight-fold path obviously, but there are they can be grouped into three distinct they can be grouped into three distinct they can be grouped into three distinct baskets. One is the kind of baskets. One is the kind of baskets. One is the kind of philosophical understanding, the other philosophical understanding, the other philosophical understanding, the other is um an ethical conduct in the world is um an ethical conduct in the world is um an ethical conduct in the world and the third is you know how you and the third is you know how you and the third is you know how you practice in your own mind. We chose practice in your own mind. We chose practice in your own mind. We chose right speech which is um what we're right speech which is um what we're right speech which is um what we're going to talk about today and that's in going to talk about today and that's in going to talk about today and that's in the ethical conduct or sometimes in in the ethical conduct or sometimes in in the ethical conduct or sometimes in in the language of poly in which the the language of poly in which the the language of poly in which the Buddhist teachings were written down. Um Buddhist teachings were written down. Um Buddhist teachings were written down. Um it's called sila s i l a um and I'm it's called sila s i l a um and I'm it's called sila s i l a um and I'm interested in uh right speech or uh wise interested in uh right speech or uh wise interested in uh right speech or uh wise speech depending on how you um want to speech depending on how you um want to speech depending on how you um want to translate the the way the uh the Buddha translate the the way the uh the Buddha translate the the way the uh the Buddha talked about it. Um, I'm interested in talked about it. Um, I'm interested in talked about it. Um, I'm interested in it because um, and I'll probably have it because um, and I'll probably have it because um, and I'll probably have said this in the introduction, but we said this in the introduction, but we said this in the introduction, but we spend most of our days in conversation. spend most of our days in conversation. spend most of our days in conversation. It is kind of like the principal unit of It is kind of like the principal unit of It is kind of like the principal unit of exchange for homo sapiens. And yet, exchange for homo sapiens. And yet, exchange for homo sapiens. And yet, we're almost never, most of us taught we're almost never, most of us taught we're almost never, most of us taught how to do it. And I find it endlessly how to do it. And I find it endlessly how to do it. And I find it endlessly fascinating that the Buddha had real fascinating that the Buddha had real fascinating that the Buddha had real advice for doing so. advice for doing so. advice for doing so. >> Yeah. And I should also say uh what just >> Yeah. And I should also say uh what just >> Yeah. And I should also say uh what just came into my mind that my colleague my came into my mind that my colleague my came into my mind that my colleague my friend Sylvia Bourstein whom I know you friend Sylvia Bourstein whom I know you friend Sylvia Bourstein whom I know you you've recently spoken to calls it the you've recently spoken to calls it the you've recently spoken to calls it the eight-fold dot eight-fold dot eight-fold dot because um it's it's a little bit because um it's it's a little bit because um it's it's a little bit circular. We think of a path as very circular. We think of a path as very circular. We think of a path as very linear like you start here and then you linear like you start here and then you linear like you start here and then you go to the middle place then you're at go to the middle place then you're at go to the middle place then you're at the end. You never go back unless you're the end. You never go back unless you're the end. You never go back unless you're heading back. Uh but on this path you heading back. Uh but on this path you heading back. Uh but on this path you don't want to go backwards. But um you don't want to go backwards. But um you don't want to go backwards. But um you know we revisit elements of it all the know we revisit elements of it all the know we revisit elements of it all the time. And so in terms of those three time. And so in terms of those three time. And so in terms of those three divisions classically it starts with divisions classically it starts with divisions classically it starts with like right uh intention or right thought like right uh intention or right thought like right uh intention or right thought right view. And that's considered almost right view. And that's considered almost right view. And that's considered almost like this is worth trying. This is worth like this is worth trying. This is worth like this is worth trying. This is worth experimenting with. Um there's cause and experimenting with. Um there's cause and experimenting with. Um there's cause and effect. There's possibility of happiness effect. There's possibility of happiness effect. There's possibility of happiness here. But it's not like a a clarified here. But it's not like a a clarified here. But it's not like a a clarified view like I really get in a whole view like I really get in a whole view like I really get in a whole different way how the universe works and different way how the universe works and different way how the universe works and you know what makes me happy and what you know what makes me happy and what you know what makes me happy and what doesn't that comes much later and in doesn't that comes much later and in doesn't that comes much later and in practical terms when we speak about the practical terms when we speak about the practical terms when we speak about the path sometimes we do start with sila path sometimes we do start with sila path sometimes we do start with sila because that's what we can do because that's what we can do because that's what we can do >> right now we don't realize that we >> right now we don't realize that we >> right now we don't realize that we wouldn't even try I mean why would you wouldn't even try I mean why would you wouldn't even try I mean why would you you know think about let me try to be you know think about let me try to be you know think about let me try to be more truthful more truthful more truthful you you know, unless there was some you you know, unless there was some you you know, unless there was some inkling that yeah, it's it's so much inkling that yeah, it's it's so much inkling that yeah, it's it's so much suffering to feel, you know, like I told suffering to feel, you know, like I told suffering to feel, you know, like I told these lies and did I tell enough and did these lies and did I tell enough and did these lies and did I tell enough and did I lie to the right people and what a I lie to the right people and what a I lie to the right people and what a burden, you know, maybe I want a burden, you know, maybe I want a burden, you know, maybe I want a clearer, simpler way of being. And so it clearer, simpler way of being. And so it clearer, simpler way of being. And so it doesn't have to be fully formed that doesn't have to be fully formed that doesn't have to be fully formed that kind of right view, but there's kind of right view, but there's kind of right view, but there's something that has us say, let's let's something that has us say, let's let's something that has us say, let's let's try this. Let's try putting this into try this. Let's try putting this into try this. Let's try putting this into action. And so often when the uh action. And so often when the uh action. And so often when the uh eight-fold path is taught uh people will eight-fold path is taught uh people will eight-fold path is taught uh people will start with those elements of of sila cuz start with those elements of of sila cuz start with those elements of of sila cuz that's what we do. But traditionally you that's what we do. But traditionally you that's what we do. But traditionally you actually start with right view actually start with right view actually start with right view >> support for today's episode comes from >> support for today's episode comes from >> support for today's episode comes from square and they've got big news. During square and they've got big news. During square and they've got big news. During Square's by-anual releases event, they Square's by-anual releases event, they Square's by-anual releases event, they launched a wave of innovative new tools launched a wave of innovative new tools launched a wave of innovative new tools to help local businesses run faster, to help local businesses run faster, to help local businesses run faster, smarter, and more profitably. From AI smarter, and more profitably. From AI smarter, and more profitably. From AI that answers your toughest business that answers your toughest business that answers your toughest business questions to tech that simplifies food questions to tech that simplifies food questions to tech that simplifies food orders and tracks every dollar, it's all orders and tracks every dollar, it's all orders and tracks every dollar, it's all live and it's built for businesses like live and it's built for businesses like live and it's built for businesses like yours. Whether you're starting fresh or yours. Whether you're starting fresh or yours. Whether you're starting fresh or scaling fast, Square helps you keep up scaling fast, Square helps you keep up scaling fast, Square helps you keep up and get ahead. And right now, listeners and get ahead. And right now, listeners and get ahead. And right now, listeners get up to $200 off Square hardware when get up to $200 off Square hardware when get up to $200 off Square hardware when you sign up at square.com/go/happier. you sign up at square.com/go/happier. you sign up at square.com/go/happier. That's sq.com/go/happier. Visit Square to get started because the Visit Square to get started because the right tools make all the difference. I right tools make all the difference. I right tools make all the difference. I can tell you as a small business owner can tell you as a small business owner can tell you as a small business owner myself, you need the right tools. You myself, you need the right tools. You myself, you need the right tools. You need the right allies. You don't want to need the right allies. You don't want to need the right allies. You don't want to be focused on making sure that all the be focused on making sure that all the be focused on making sure that all the payments are going smoothly. farm that payments are going smoothly. farm that payments are going smoothly. farm that out to somebody who's got a lot of out to somebody who's got a lot of out to somebody who's got a lot of experience on that side so that you can experience on that side so that you can experience on that side so that you can focus on the inspiration that got you focus on the inspiration that got you focus on the inspiration that got you interested in the business in the first interested in the business in the first interested in the business in the first place. Square launched its most powerful place. Square launched its most powerful place. Square launched its most powerful tools yet, designed to give local tools yet, designed to give local tools yet, designed to give local businesses a competitive edge without businesses a competitive edge without businesses a competitive edge without the complexity. If you're ready to sell the complexity. If you're ready to sell the complexity. If you're ready to sell smarter, run faster, and stress less. smarter, run faster, and stress less. smarter, run faster, and stress less. Right now, you can get up to $200 off Right now, you can get up to $200 off Right now, you can get up to $200 off Square hardware at Square hardware at Square hardware at square.com/go/happier. square.com/go/happier. square.com/go/happier. That's sq a.com/go/happier. Run your business smarter with Square. Run your business smarter with Square. Get started today. A few months ago, one Get started today. A few months ago, one Get started today. A few months ago, one of our sponsors, Lisa, sent one of my of our sponsors, Lisa, sent one of my of our sponsors, Lisa, sent one of my teammates, one of our younger staffers, teammates, one of our younger staffers, teammates, one of our younger staffers, Hayden, a guy in his mid20s who's living Hayden, a guy in his mid20s who's living Hayden, a guy in his mid20s who's living in New York City, and did not have a in New York City, and did not have a in New York City, and did not have a great mattress. And then he got this great mattress. And then he got this great mattress. And then he got this beautiful new mattress from one of our beautiful new mattress from one of our beautiful new mattress from one of our sponsors, Lisa, and he's been sleeping sponsors, Lisa, and he's been sleeping sponsors, Lisa, and he's been sleeping like a champ. and I think I've noticed like a champ. and I think I've noticed like a champ. and I think I've noticed that his work has gotten even better as that his work has gotten even better as that his work has gotten even better as a result of that. If you're interested a result of that. If you're interested a result of that. If you're interested in a new mattress, Hayden and I can in a new mattress, Hayden and I can in a new mattress, Hayden and I can heartily recommend Lisa. Summer is one heartily recommend Lisa. Summer is one heartily recommend Lisa. Summer is one of my favorite times of year, but it can of my favorite times of year, but it can of my favorite times of year, but it can also be full of chaos between travel, also be full of chaos between travel, also be full of chaos between travel, family activities, work commitments, and family activities, work commitments, and family activities, work commitments, and trying to enjoy the longer days. It can trying to enjoy the longer days. It can trying to enjoy the longer days. It can feel like there's no time to truly feel like there's no time to truly feel like there's no time to truly unwind. One thing that can help you keep unwind. One thing that can help you keep unwind. One thing that can help you keep it all going is getting a better sleep it all going is getting a better sleep it all going is getting a better sleep on a mattress from Lisa. Lisa has a on a mattress from Lisa. Lisa has a on a mattress from Lisa. Lisa has a lineup of beautifully crafted mattresses lineup of beautifully crafted mattresses lineup of beautifully crafted mattresses tailored to how you sleep. Each mattress tailored to how you sleep. Each mattress tailored to how you sleep. Each mattress is designed with specific sleep is designed with specific sleep is designed with specific sleep positions and feel preferences in mind. positions and feel preferences in mind. positions and feel preferences in mind. From one night, you'll feel the From one night, you'll feel the From one night, you'll feel the difference. Just take the Lisa Sleep difference. Just take the Lisa Sleep difference. Just take the Lisa Sleep quiz and you'll find your perfect match quiz and you'll find your perfect match quiz and you'll find your perfect match in 2 minutes or less. Go to lisa.com for in 2 minutes or less. Go to lisa.com for in 2 minutes or less. Go to lisa.com for 30% off select mattresses. Plus, get an 30% off select mattresses. Plus, get an 30% off select mattresses. Plus, get an extra $50 off with the promo code extra $50 off with the promo code extra $50 off with the promo code happier. Exclusive for my listeners. happier. Exclusive for my listeners. happier. Exclusive for my listeners. That's le ea.com That's le ea.com That's le ea.com promo code happier for 30% off select promo code happier for 30% off select promo code happier for 30% off select mattresses plus an extra $50 off. And mattresses plus an extra $50 off. And mattresses plus an extra $50 off. And when you use our code, you are when you use our code, you are when you use our code, you are supporting our show, which we supporting our show, which we supporting our show, which we appreciate. Lisa.com, promo code appreciate. Lisa.com, promo code appreciate. Lisa.com, promo code happier. In the CILA package, there's happier. In the CILA package, there's happier. In the CILA package, there's right livelihood. So, it's like what right livelihood. So, it's like what right livelihood. So, it's like what what kind of job should you be doing? what kind of job should you be doing? what kind of job should you be doing? There's right um action, uh which I There's right um action, uh which I There's right um action, uh which I think is explanator, self-explanatory, think is explanator, self-explanatory, think is explanator, self-explanatory, and then right speech. And uh like I and then right speech. And uh like I and then right speech. And uh like I said, I find I find that's what I I I said, I find I find that's what I I I said, I find I find that's what I I I chose this as the focus with you because chose this as the focus with you because chose this as the focus with you because I I think it's so interesting that that I I think it's so interesting that that I I think it's so interesting that that you can you there's good advice on offer you can you there's good advice on offer you can you there's good advice on offer and that you can practice it. It's and that you can practice it. It's and that you can practice it. It's actually a set of skills. Um and and as actually a set of skills. Um and and as actually a set of skills. Um and and as you like to teach it, there really like you like to teach it, there really like you like to teach it, there really like four questions to ask yourself before four questions to ask yourself before four questions to ask yourself before you open your mouth. Let's start with you open your mouth. Let's start with you open your mouth. Let's start with question number one. What what is that? question number one. What what is that? question number one. What what is that? uh is it true what you're saying but uh is it true what you're saying but uh is it true what you're saying but there are levels to that you know I know there are levels to that you know I know there are levels to that you know I know um you've also worked with uh Dan um you've also worked with uh Dan um you've also worked with uh Dan Clareman and Mud Taniskar uh who are Clareman and Mud Taniskar uh who are Clareman and Mud Taniskar uh who are amazing uh communications experts and amazing uh communications experts and amazing uh communications experts and I've seen that uh some of the even I've seen that uh some of the even I've seen that uh some of the even formulaic kind of tools of modern formulaic kind of tools of modern formulaic kind of tools of modern communication communication communication understanding um really reflect this understanding um really reflect this understanding um really reflect this this question of is it true? So for this question of is it true? So for this question of is it true? So for example, you know, when a communications example, you know, when a communications example, you know, when a communications person will suggest using eye language person will suggest using eye language person will suggest using eye language and not you language, not just being and not you language, not just being and not you language, not just being accusatory and laying all of one's accusatory and laying all of one's accusatory and laying all of one's response and reactions on the other response and reactions on the other response and reactions on the other person. I've actually seen Dan and person. I've actually seen Dan and person. I've actually seen Dan and Modita work in that way with people and Modita work in that way with people and Modita work in that way with people and it was very touching. uh they've come to it was very touching. uh they've come to it was very touching. uh they've come to the insight meditation society in the the insight meditation society in the the insight meditation society in the past, worked with staff and I saw one past, worked with staff and I saw one past, worked with staff and I saw one exchange that was something like a staff exchange that was something like a staff exchange that was something like a staff person saying to another staff person um person saying to another staff person um person saying to another staff person um basically you're a terrible person and basically you're a terrible person and basically you're a terrible person and you know you don't pay attention to you know you don't pay attention to you know you don't pay attention to others and you're uh you're reckless and others and you're uh you're reckless and others and you're uh you're reckless and whatever. And by continually having the whatever. And by continually having the whatever. And by continually having the person go back and use eye language, not person go back and use eye language, not person go back and use eye language, not as they would say disguised you as they would say disguised you as they would say disguised you language, but eye language, it came to I language, but eye language, it came to I language, but eye language, it came to I was so hoping to be closer to you. And was so hoping to be closer to you. And was so hoping to be closer to you. And when you walked by me with lunch tray or when you walked by me with lunch tray or when you walked by me with lunch tray or something like that and you didn't sit something like that and you didn't sit something like that and you didn't sit down and you didn't even look at me, I down and you didn't even look at me, I down and you didn't even look at me, I just thought, "Wow, you know, maybe it's just thought, "Wow, you know, maybe it's just thought, "Wow, you know, maybe it's not going to happen." And I was like so not going to happen." And I was like so not going to happen." And I was like so disappointed and and as I was witnessing disappointed and and as I was witnessing disappointed and and as I was witnessing this this whole exchange I thought wow this this whole exchange I thought wow this this whole exchange I thought wow that's actually the truth of what that's actually the truth of what that's actually the truth of what somebody was going through and it's not somebody was going through and it's not somebody was going through and it's not that in every context we want to be that that in every context we want to be that that in every context we want to be that vulnerable vulnerable vulnerable but I thought you know truthfulness is but I thought you know truthfulness is but I thought you know truthfulness is not just the surface level of not not just the surface level of not not just the surface level of not telling a blatant lie it's really going telling a blatant lie it's really going telling a blatant lie it's really going deep within to see what's the truth of deep within to see what's the truth of deep within to see what's the truth of my experience in this moment and do I my experience in this moment and do I my experience in this moment and do I want to express it? So I really like want to express it? So I really like want to express it? So I really like that aspect of it. And of course there that aspect of it. And of course there that aspect of it. And of course there is the more surface level as well which is the more surface level as well which is the more surface level as well which is still very significant. Um I often do is still very significant. Um I often do is still very significant. Um I often do tell the story about um tell the story about um tell the story about um once I was uh staying in a house in once I was uh staying in a house in once I was uh staying in a house in Western Mass and a friend of ours had Western Mass and a friend of ours had Western Mass and a friend of ours had gone to India alone without her husband gone to India alone without her husband gone to India alone without her husband to do this retreat but she didn't want to do this retreat but she didn't want to do this retreat but she didn't want her mother to know that she'd gone alone her mother to know that she'd gone alone her mother to know that she'd gone alone and uh so she basically lied to her and uh so she basically lied to her and uh so she basically lied to her mother and said I'm going with my mother and said I'm going with my mother and said I'm going with my husband and we'll be back in this and husband and we'll be back in this and husband and we'll be back in this and that date and here's a phone number you that date and here's a phone number you that date and here's a phone number you can call if you ever, you know, want to can call if you ever, you know, want to can call if you ever, you know, want to try to reach me. That was the phone try to reach me. That was the phone try to reach me. That was the phone number of the house I was in. So, just a number of the house I was in. So, just a number of the house I was in. So, just a few days before our friend was few days before our friend was few days before our friend was returning, the mother called and uh my returning, the mother called and uh my returning, the mother called and uh my friend whose house it was who answered friend whose house it was who answered friend whose house it was who answered the phone forgot that he was supposed to the phone forgot that he was supposed to the phone forgot that he was supposed to lie. And so this woman said, "Have you lie. And so this woman said, "Have you lie. And so this woman said, "Have you heard from my daughter or her husband?" heard from my daughter or her husband?" heard from my daughter or her husband?" And he said, "Oh yeah, he was just here And he said, "Oh yeah, he was just here And he said, "Oh yeah, he was just here for dinner." And then he remembered. And for dinner." And then he remembered. And for dinner." And then he remembered. And so he quickly said, well, he went to so he quickly said, well, he went to so he quickly said, well, he went to India with her and he didn't stay as India with her and he didn't stay as India with her and he didn't stay as long. So he came back and right away uh long. So he came back and right away uh long. So he came back and right away uh she really felt she was not being told she really felt she was not being told she really felt she was not being told the truth. So we everybody hung up and the truth. So we everybody hung up and the truth. So we everybody hung up and then she called a neighbor and asked then she called a neighbor and asked then she called a neighbor and asked them to call us to see, you know, maybe them to call us to see, you know, maybe them to call us to see, you know, maybe we would tell her the truth even if we we would tell her the truth even if we we would tell her the truth even if we wouldn't tell her herself the truth. And wouldn't tell her herself the truth. And wouldn't tell her herself the truth. And so these strangers started calling us so these strangers started calling us so these strangers started calling us and we had to lie to everybody else. And and we had to lie to everybody else. And and we had to lie to everybody else. And then we realized she was going to call then we realized she was going to call then we realized she was going to call around to other numbers she had. So we around to other numbers she had. So we around to other numbers she had. So we had to start calling people and saying, had to start calling people and saying, had to start calling people and saying, you know, this is this woman's going to you know, this is this woman's going to you know, this is this woman's going to call, you have to lie, and this is what call, you have to lie, and this is what call, you have to lie, and this is what you have to say. And it just kept you have to say. And it just kept you have to say. And it just kept getting more and more and more getting more and more and more getting more and more and more complicated. And right in the middle of complicated. And right in the middle of complicated. And right in the middle of that, ironically, we started getting that, ironically, we started getting that, ironically, we started getting these anonymous obscene phone calls. And these anonymous obscene phone calls. And these anonymous obscene phone calls. And you know, normally you might just say, you know, normally you might just say, you know, normally you might just say, "Well, I'm not going to answer the phone "Well, I'm not going to answer the phone "Well, I'm not going to answer the phone for a while." But in this case, we had for a while." But in this case, we had for a while." But in this case, we had to answer the phone in case it was to answer the phone in case it was to answer the phone in case it was someone we had to lie to. And then someone we had to lie to. And then someone we had to lie to. And then finally, whoever was talking to her finally, whoever was talking to her finally, whoever was talking to her couldn't bear it anymore. And she said, couldn't bear it anymore. And she said, couldn't bear it anymore. And she said, "I'm going to tell you the truth. She "I'm going to tell you the truth. She "I'm going to tell you the truth. She went to India without him. She's fine. went to India without him. She's fine. went to India without him. She's fine. She's coming back like tomorrow or She's coming back like tomorrow or She's coming back like tomorrow or something." You know, it's really it's something." You know, it's really it's something." You know, it's really it's really okay. And the woman had been lied really okay. And the woman had been lied really okay. And the woman had been lied to so much. It's like she didn't know to so much. It's like she didn't know to so much. It's like she didn't know what to believe anymore. She didn't know what to believe anymore. She didn't know what to believe anymore. She didn't know what was true. And even stranger, it's what was true. And even stranger, it's what was true. And even stranger, it's like we hardly knew it was true anymore like we hardly knew it was true anymore like we hardly knew it was true anymore because we've gotten so engaged in this because we've gotten so engaged in this because we've gotten so engaged in this web of deception. So even on that uh web of deception. So even on that uh web of deception. So even on that uh blatant level, I think the tool we have, blatant level, I think the tool we have, blatant level, I think the tool we have, which really is a blessing, is just which really is a blessing, is just which really is a blessing, is just self-reflection like how does this make self-reflection like how does this make self-reflection like how does this make me feel? And what's the consequence of me feel? And what's the consequence of me feel? And what's the consequence of living in this way? saying what would living in this way? saying what would living in this way? saying what would happen if I chose to skillfully tell the happen if I chose to skillfully tell the happen if I chose to skillfully tell the truth in these circumstances. truth in these circumstances. truth in these circumstances. >> Just to go back and underline I >> Just to go back and underline I >> Just to go back and underline I language. Um that is the letter I language. Um that is the letter I language. Um that is the letter I language in so speaking in your own language in so speaking in your own language in so speaking in your own experience as opposed to quote unquote experience as opposed to quote unquote experience as opposed to quote unquote you language which is often accusatory. you language which is often accusatory. you language which is often accusatory. You're a dirt bag. Whatever. I have You're a dirt bag. Whatever. I have You're a dirt bag. Whatever. I have trouble with you when you do X is um trouble with you when you do X is um trouble with you when you do X is um often a much more skillful way to often a much more skillful way to often a much more skillful way to communicate and as you pointed out communicate and as you pointed out communicate and as you pointed out really and a broad understanding of really and a broad understanding of really and a broad understanding of truth is a more truthful way to truth is a more truthful way to truth is a more truthful way to communicate. So but but then you went on communicate. So but but then you went on communicate. So but but then you went on to tell the story about how lying can be to tell the story about how lying can be to tell the story about how lying can be disastrous. Um, I completely I disastrous. Um, I completely I disastrous. Um, I completely I completely buy your argument and I think completely buy your argument and I think completely buy your argument and I think everybody listening will buy your everybody listening will buy your everybody listening will buy your argument that if you're even 3% mindful argument that if you're even 3% mindful argument that if you're even 3% mindful while you're lying, you'll see that it while you're lying, you'll see that it while you're lying, you'll see that it doesn't feel good. Um, but are there not doesn't feel good. Um, but are there not doesn't feel good. Um, but are there not circumstances where a white lie makes circumstances where a white lie makes circumstances where a white lie makes sense? My wife, who always looks good no sense? My wife, who always looks good no sense? My wife, who always looks good no matter what she's wearing, but say matter what she's wearing, but say matter what she's wearing, but say hypothetically she was wearing an outfit hypothetically she was wearing an outfit hypothetically she was wearing an outfit that I didn't like. This has never that I didn't like. This has never that I didn't like. This has never happened. But just say she was wearing happened. But just say she was wearing happened. But just say she was wearing an outfit that I didn't like and she an outfit that I didn't like and she an outfit that I didn't like and she asked me how she looked. What is wrong asked me how she looked. What is wrong asked me how she looked. What is wrong with me saying you look great so I can with me saying you look great so I can with me saying you look great so I can get us out the door and we're not late get us out the door and we're not late get us out the door and we're not late to the party? to the party? to the party? >> Well, there are questions of uh >> Well, there are questions of uh >> Well, there are questions of uh intention, you know, which is always a intention, you know, which is always a intention, you know, which is always a crucial crucial kind of factor in in crucial crucial kind of factor in in crucial crucial kind of factor in in looking at ethical conduct which we can looking at ethical conduct which we can looking at ethical conduct which we can talk about. But there's also you talk about. But there's also you talk about. But there's also you reminded me and I was very amused by reminded me and I was very amused by reminded me and I was very amused by that. Um, you know, I've had many that. Um, you know, I've had many that. Um, you know, I've had many conversations with friends where conversations with friends where conversations with friends where somebody uh may present their creative somebody uh may present their creative somebody uh may present their creative work to you and you really think it it's work to you and you really think it it's work to you and you really think it it's terrible or not very good and what do terrible or not very good and what do terrible or not very good and what do you say? So, we practice like um someone you say? So, we practice like um someone you say? So, we practice like um someone told me once they say I couldn't be more told me once they say I couldn't be more told me once they say I couldn't be more surprised surprised surprised or you must be very proud of that rather or you must be very proud of that rather or you must be very proud of that rather than saying I don't know about that. But than saying I don't know about that. But than saying I don't know about that. But again, you know, context is also very again, you know, context is also very again, you know, context is also very important. It's like if someone is important. It's like if someone is important. It's like if someone is sincerely asking you for feedback, sincerely asking you for feedback, sincerely asking you for feedback, that's a different thing. And then then that's a different thing. And then then that's a different thing. And then then saying it as much and you know, not like saying it as much and you know, not like saying it as much and you know, not like you're a terrible writer, you know, but you're a terrible writer, you know, but you're a terrible writer, you know, but I found myself I found myself I found myself uh a little lost here. or I wonder if uh a little lost here. or I wonder if uh a little lost here. or I wonder if there's a way you could say it or you there's a way you could say it or you there's a way you could say it or you know I so much yearned to know what your know I so much yearned to know what your know I so much yearned to know what your experience really was in this moment and experience really was in this moment and experience really was in this moment and what was going on inside or you know what was going on inside or you know what was going on inside or you know there are ways of offering feedback that there are ways of offering feedback that there are ways of offering feedback that are a little more encouraging than you are a little more encouraging than you are a little more encouraging than you know this is a waste of time. Um, but know this is a waste of time. Um, but know this is a waste of time. Um, but then there there are just these sort of then there there are just these sort of then there there are just these sort of more more more uh detached things, you know, like uh detached things, you know, like uh detached things, you know, like you're not really being asked for you're not really being asked for you're not really being asked for feedback. You're being asked for praise feedback. You're being asked for praise feedback. You're being asked for praise and and maybe you can't get there, you and and maybe you can't get there, you and and maybe you can't get there, you know, in an honest way. But it's fun to know, in an honest way. But it's fun to know, in an honest way. But it's fun to imagine what you would say. And then if imagine what you would say. And then if imagine what you would say. And then if somebody said it's me, I start thinking, somebody said it's me, I start thinking, somebody said it's me, I start thinking, huh, they didn't like what I did. I huh, they didn't like what I did. I huh, they didn't like what I did. I guess they're just trying to, you know, guess they're just trying to, you know, guess they're just trying to, you know, find a way of cushioning the blow or find a way of cushioning the blow or find a way of cushioning the blow or something like that. I remember I sent something like that. I remember I sent something like that. I remember I sent my brother, who you also know and are my brother, who you also know and are my brother, who you also know and are friends with, um I sent him a version of friends with, um I sent him a version of friends with, um I sent him a version of of my forthcoming book several years ago of my forthcoming book several years ago of my forthcoming book several years ago that was sort of long and baggy and that was sort of long and baggy and that was sort of long and baggy and self-indulgent and he wrote back, "You self-indulgent and he wrote back, "You self-indulgent and he wrote back, "You put your full self into this. [laughter] put your full self into this. [laughter] put your full self into this. [laughter] >> It's perfect. >> It's perfect. >> It's perfect. >> That's great." >> That's great." >> That's great." >> So, but you you said something before >> So, but you you said something before >> So, but you you said something before that I want to pick up on that that that I want to pick up on that that that I want to pick up on that that intention matters here. you know, this intention matters here. you know, this intention matters here. you know, this has actually like become a contentious has actually like become a contentious has actually like become a contentious issue in intent. Um, in in in some issue in intent. Um, in in in some issue in intent. Um, in in in some progressive circles there, the argument progressive circles there, the argument progressive circles there, the argument is it's impact that matters, not your is it's impact that matters, not your is it's impact that matters, not your intent. Um, I personally actually I'm intent. Um, I personally actually I'm intent. Um, I personally actually I'm not sure I fully agree with that, but not sure I fully agree with that, but not sure I fully agree with that, but um, you know, how would you think of um, you know, how would you think of um, you know, how would you think of one's intention in the context of right one's intention in the context of right one's intention in the context of right speech? speech? speech? >> Well, I had a a great conversation once >> Well, I had a a great conversation once >> Well, I had a a great conversation once with Anu Gupta. I don't know if you know with Anu Gupta. I don't know if you know with Anu Gupta. I don't know if you know his work. Yeah, he's been on the show. his work. Yeah, he's been on the show. his work. Yeah, he's been on the show. >> Yeah. Yes. So, uh asking him that very >> Yeah. Yes. So, uh asking him that very >> Yeah. Yes. So, uh asking him that very question because it's true in social question because it's true in social question because it's true in social justice framing uh impact is much more justice framing uh impact is much more justice framing uh impact is much more important than intention. But you can't important than intention. But you can't important than intention. But you can't deny that in terms of classical deny that in terms of classical deny that in terms of classical Buddhism, intention is really key. And Buddhism, intention is really key. And Buddhism, intention is really key. And and he was uh he readily reconciled and he was uh he readily reconciled and he was uh he readily reconciled those those points of view. And the those those points of view. And the those those points of view. And the framework I usually use is an action. framework I usually use is an action. framework I usually use is an action. Something we do, something we say, Something we do, something we say, Something we do, something we say, something we hold back from doing or something we hold back from doing or something we hold back from doing or saying, which is also a kind of action saying, which is also a kind of action saying, which is also a kind of action has different elements to it. And the has different elements to it. And the has different elements to it. And the first is intention or motivation. And first is intention or motivation. And first is intention or motivation. And that is a crucial distinction. You know, that is a crucial distinction. You know, that is a crucial distinction. You know, if I was picking up an object and if I was picking up an object and if I was picking up an object and handing it to you, all anybody sees is handing it to you, all anybody sees is handing it to you, all anybody sees is my hand moving down and picking up my hand moving down and picking up my hand moving down and picking up something and moving it forward. But something and moving it forward. But something and moving it forward. But what is in my heart? What is the what is in my heart? What is the what is in my heart? What is the intention? you know, maybe I'm giving it intention? you know, maybe I'm giving it intention? you know, maybe I'm giving it to you cuz I like you and I want you to to you cuz I like you and I want you to to you cuz I like you and I want you to have it or maybe I don't like you and I have it or maybe I don't like you and I have it or maybe I don't like you and I think you're not going to be able to think you're not going to be able to think you're not going to be able to figure it out. You know, it's going to figure it out. You know, it's going to figure it out. You know, it's going to drive you crazy here. You know, so it's drive you crazy here. You know, so it's drive you crazy here. You know, so it's like the same smile and the same like the same smile and the same like the same smile and the same gesture, but it's coming from a totally gesture, but it's coming from a totally gesture, but it's coming from a totally different place. And so it's a potent different place. And so it's a potent different place. And so it's a potent potent form of a seed that we're potent form of a seed that we're potent form of a seed that we're planting. But the next aspect of an planting. But the next aspect of an planting. But the next aspect of an action is you could say the skillfulness action is you could say the skillfulness action is you could say the skillfulness of the execution. It's mindfulness in of the execution. It's mindfulness in of the execution. It's mindfulness in context. It's uh cultural context. It's context. It's uh cultural context. It's context. It's uh cultural context. It's cultural sensitivity. cultural sensitivity. cultural sensitivity. It's understanding like maybe I'm giving It's understanding like maybe I'm giving It's understanding like maybe I'm giving you this object out of a very good you this object out of a very good you this object out of a very good intention. I don't want to throw it to intention. I don't want to throw it to intention. I don't want to throw it to you or maybe I only have one and there you or maybe I only have one and there you or maybe I only have one and there 50 people in the room. Maybe it's best 50 people in the room. Maybe it's best 50 people in the room. Maybe it's best done privately. We have to really pay done privately. We have to really pay done privately. We have to really pay attention to where we are and who we're attention to where we are and who we're attention to where we are and who we're talking to and you know what's the talking to and you know what's the talking to and you know what's the context and and that's sort of where the context and and that's sort of where the context and and that's sort of where the impact part uh comes alive. you know impact part uh comes alive. you know impact part uh comes alive. you know that we need that sort of sensitivity that we need that sort of sensitivity that we need that sort of sensitivity and awareness. Um, and those two things and awareness. Um, and those two things and awareness. Um, and those two things are not antithetical to one another. are not antithetical to one another. are not antithetical to one another. They're just different. And I often They're just different. And I often They're just different. And I often emphasize that difference because in emphasize that difference because in emphasize that difference because in teaching loving kindness meditation so teaching loving kindness meditation so teaching loving kindness meditation so much a great fear and it's a reasonable much a great fear and it's a reasonable much a great fear and it's a reasonable fear people express is well I to develop fear people express is well I to develop fear people express is well I to develop a more loving heart doesn't mean I have a more loving heart doesn't mean I have a more loving heart doesn't mean I have to say yes. I have to give them more to say yes. I have to give them more to say yes. I have to give them more money. I have to let them move back in. money. I have to let them move back in. money. I have to let them move back in. and I have to let them keep hurting me and I have to let them keep hurting me and I have to let them keep hurting me and the answer is no. You know, you can and the answer is no. You know, you can and the answer is no. You know, you can come from a very and genuinely come from a very and genuinely come from a very and genuinely compassionate motivation. But I call it compassionate motivation. But I call it compassionate motivation. But I call it your best guess of how to behave in that your best guess of how to behave in that your best guess of how to behave in that moment in that context most skillfully moment in that context most skillfully moment in that context most skillfully could be strong boundary or feeling or could be strong boundary or feeling or could be strong boundary or feeling or being kind of fierce, you know, and it being kind of fierce, you know, and it being kind of fierce, you know, and it might be gentle, it might be strong, you might be gentle, it might be strong, you might be gentle, it might be strong, you know, it just depends. And that's know, it just depends. And that's know, it just depends. And that's discernment and wisdom hopefully and discernment and wisdom hopefully and discernment and wisdom hopefully and understanding. But that doesn't mean understanding. But that doesn't mean understanding. But that doesn't mean you're not coming from a compassionate you're not coming from a compassionate you're not coming from a compassionate place. And so that is a model I use place. And so that is a model I use place. And so that is a model I use endlessly in in trying to describe like endlessly in in trying to describe like endlessly in in trying to describe like yeah loving kindness doesn't consign us, yeah loving kindness doesn't consign us, yeah loving kindness doesn't consign us, you know, to being a doormat. It frees you know, to being a doormat. It frees you know, to being a doormat. It frees us because we can use discernment how we us because we can use discernment how we us because we can use discernment how we think we should behave or speak or think we should behave or speak or think we should behave or speak or respond in a certain moment. And it's respond in a certain moment. And it's respond in a certain moment. And it's always good, I think, to know your always good, I think, to know your always good, I think, to know your intention. intention. intention. >> Then in the context of white lies, if >> Then in the context of white lies, if >> Then in the context of white lies, if your intent, if your intention is to be your intent, if your intention is to be your intent, if your intention is to be compassionate, a lot of people think, compassionate, a lot of people think, compassionate, a lot of people think, well, then why can't I tell the white well, then why can't I tell the white well, then why can't I tell the white lie? lie? lie? >> You might be able to. You know, it's >> You might be able to. You know, it's >> You might be able to. You know, it's also true though that sometimes also true though that sometimes also true though that sometimes that those are consequential and you that those are consequential and you that those are consequential and you don't necessarily want it to unfold. don't necessarily want it to unfold. don't necessarily want it to unfold. It's like what if you told your wife she It's like what if you told your wife she It's like what if you told your wife she looked great and she went out and bought looked great and she went out and bought looked great and she went out and bought 15 more outfits just like that one. You 15 more outfits just like that one. You 15 more outfits just like that one. You know, depending again, it's it's very know, depending again, it's it's very know, depending again, it's it's very contextual. You know, you might just contextual. You know, you might just contextual. You know, you might just say, "Yeah, you know, it's great." Or say, "Yeah, you know, it's great." Or say, "Yeah, you know, it's great." Or you might say, "Wow, you know, uh it's you might say, "Wow, you know, uh it's you might say, "Wow, you know, uh it's good, but you know what I really liked good, but you know what I really liked good, but you know what I really liked was what you wore yesterday." I don't was what you wore yesterday." I don't was what you wore yesterday." I don't know, something like that. I've just know, something like that. I've just know, something like that. I've just really personally where I've because really personally where I've because really personally where I've because I've done enough I'm not I'm by no means I've done enough I'm not I'm by no means I've done enough I'm not I'm by no means an advanced meditation practitioner, but an advanced meditation practitioner, but an advanced meditation practitioner, but I've done enough practice to have a I've done enough practice to have a I've done enough practice to have a decent mindfulness quotient. Uh, it just decent mindfulness quotient. Uh, it just decent mindfulness quotient. Uh, it just feels so terrible when I lie that feels so terrible when I lie that feels so terrible when I lie that I just tell the truth, but I try to be I just tell the truth, but I try to be I just tell the truth, but I try to be tell the truth kindly. tell the truth kindly. tell the truth kindly. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> You know, like, you know what? I >> You know, like, you know what? I >> You know, like, you know what? I actually I don't love that, but I, you actually I don't love that, but I, you actually I don't love that, but I, you know, I recognize that I'm not I don't know, I recognize that I'm not I don't know, I recognize that I'm not I don't have um sophisticated fashion taste. So, have um sophisticated fashion taste. So, have um sophisticated fashion taste. So, if you if you like it, I'm good with it. if you if you like it, I'm good with it. if you if you like it, I'm good with it. But, you know, I like the outfit you But, you know, I like the outfit you But, you know, I like the outfit you tried on right before it, you know. So tried on right before it, you know. So tried on right before it, you know. So there's I think there are way I think there's I think there are way I think there's I think there are way I think that personally I think there are ways that personally I think there are ways that personally I think there are ways generally to avoid the white lie. generally to avoid the white lie. generally to avoid the white lie. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> First of four questions we've covered >> First of four questions we've covered >> First of four questions we've covered it. Is it true? What is the second of it. Is it true? What is the second of it. Is it true? What is the second of the four questions? the four questions? the four questions? >> Is it helpful? You know they say that to >> Is it helpful? You know they say that to >> Is it helpful? You know they say that to make a commitment to say that which is make a commitment to say that which is make a commitment to say that which is true doesn't mean that you want to blurt true doesn't mean that you want to blurt true doesn't mean that you want to blurt out everything that comes into your out everything that comes into your out everything that comes into your head. you know, and um maybe somebody head. you know, and um maybe somebody head. you know, and um maybe somebody doesn't need to hear that, you know, you doesn't need to hear that, you know, you doesn't need to hear that, you know, you didn't think their book was great or, didn't think their book was great or, didn't think their book was great or, you know, uh maybe you know, uh maybe you know, uh maybe uh it's worth being restrained. Maybe uh it's worth being restrained. Maybe uh it's worth being restrained. Maybe it's worth saying something later. Maybe it's worth saying something later. Maybe it's worth saying something later. Maybe it's worth noting anything at all. Like it's worth noting anything at all. Like it's worth noting anything at all. Like if somebody is about to give a talk, a if somebody is about to give a talk, a if somebody is about to give a talk, a public talk, and you know, they're public talk, and you know, they're public talk, and you know, they're they're pretty anxious about speaking, they're pretty anxious about speaking, they're pretty anxious about speaking, you know, maybe that's not the time to you know, maybe that's not the time to you know, maybe that's not the time to say, you know, I heard this great talk say, you know, I heard this great talk say, you know, I heard this great talk by this other person, and that's going by this other person, and that's going by this other person, and that's going to be hard to beat, not helpful. And to be hard to beat, not helpful. And to be hard to beat, not helpful. And again, it comes back to motivation. again, it comes back to motivation. again, it comes back to motivation. Like, what do you want? That's something Like, what do you want? That's something Like, what do you want? That's something I've often said if I was going into an I've often said if I was going into an I've often said if I was going into an organization or a company to teach and organization or a company to teach and organization or a company to teach and I'd say before a major meeting, before a I'd say before a major meeting, before a I'd say before a major meeting, before a big conversation, big conversation, big conversation, something like that, ask yourself, what something like that, ask yourself, what something like that, ask yourself, what do I really want to see come out of do I really want to see come out of do I really want to see come out of this? You know, do I want to be helpful? this? You know, do I want to be helpful? this? You know, do I want to be helpful? Do I want a resolution? Do I want a resolution? Do I want a resolution? Do I want to mentor somebody? Do I want Do I want to mentor somebody? Do I want Do I want to mentor somebody? Do I want to grind them into dust? Do I want do I to grind them into dust? Do I want do I to grind them into dust? Do I want do I want to be seen as right and superior? want to be seen as right and superior? want to be seen as right and superior? Um, you know, take a look. And that Um, you know, take a look. And that Um, you know, take a look. And that that's one way of really coming back to that's one way of really coming back to that's one way of really coming back to see what your intention is. And if it is see what your intention is. And if it is see what your intention is. And if it is genuinely to be helpful, then that again genuinely to be helpful, then that again genuinely to be helpful, then that again kind of contours what we say or if we'll kind of contours what we say or if we'll kind of contours what we say or if we'll say something and how we'll say it. your say something and how we'll say it. your say something and how we'll say it. your nextdoor neighbor uh and our mutual nextdoor neighbor uh and our mutual nextdoor neighbor uh and our mutual friend Joseph. Joseph, he has this whole friend Joseph. Joseph, he has this whole friend Joseph. Joseph, he has this whole rap he likes to go deliver around the rap he likes to go deliver around the rap he likes to go deliver around the ancient poly term uh s papa lapa um ancient poly term uh s papa lapa um ancient poly term uh s papa lapa um which is uh translated as useless which is uh translated as useless which is uh translated as useless speech. speech. speech. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> And and we we do this all day long. Many >> And and we we do this all day long. Many >> And and we we do this all day long. Many of us um just say we just say stuff for of us um just say we just say stuff for of us um just say we just say stuff for the sake of saying it. Um, social media the sake of saying it. Um, social media the sake of saying it. Um, social media has put this on steroids. And Joseph has put this on steroids. And Joseph has put this on steroids. And Joseph says, "If you're looking underneath the says, "If you're looking underneath the says, "If you're looking underneath the intention when you're about to say intention when you're about to say intention when you're about to say something useless, often it's look at something useless, often it's look at something useless, often it's look at me." That to me is like if you're asking me." That to me is like if you're asking me." That to me is like if you're asking us to look at our intentions before we us to look at our intentions before we us to look at our intentions before we speak, it can be a very humbling thing speak, it can be a very humbling thing speak, it can be a very humbling thing if we're willing to be honest with if we're willing to be honest with if we're willing to be honest with ourselves. ourselves. ourselves. >> Well, there's also I think that's very >> Well, there's also I think that's very >> Well, there's also I think that's very very true. And it's there also ways very true. And it's there also ways very true. And it's there also ways where um if we have the um inspiration where um if we have the um inspiration where um if we have the um inspiration you know, we make some experiments. It's you know, we make some experiments. It's you know, we make some experiments. It's like uh when we started teaching in this like uh when we started teaching in this like uh when we started teaching in this country and the retreats we were country and the retreats we were country and the retreats we were offering were all uh still pretty much offering were all uh still pretty much offering were all uh still pretty much that way silent. You know, you speak to that way silent. You know, you speak to that way silent. You know, you speak to a teacher um which is pretty a teacher um which is pretty a teacher um which is pretty circumscribed. You know, you're not circumscribed. You know, you're not circumscribed. You know, you're not talking about the last movie you saw talking about the last movie you saw talking about the last movie you saw hopefully. You know, you're talking hopefully. You know, you're talking hopefully. You know, you're talking about your your practice and your about your your practice and your about your your practice and your internal experience and you may not internal experience and you may not internal experience and you may not speak to anyone else for that 10day speak to anyone else for that 10day speak to anyone else for that 10day period. But I you know sat with you period. But I you know sat with you period. But I you know sat with you Pandit say for example in 1984 for 3 Pandit say for example in 1984 for 3 Pandit say for example in 1984 for 3 months he was the only person I talked months he was the only person I talked months he was the only person I talked to uh and so you know when you're about to uh and so you know when you're about to uh and so you know when you're about to embark in a period of silence if you to embark in a period of silence if you to embark in a period of silence if you choose to it might be you know 2 days 3 choose to it might be you know 2 days 3 choose to it might be you know 2 days 3 days 7 days whatever it is and often as days 7 days whatever it is and often as days 7 days whatever it is and often as people come on to retreat it's the people come on to retreat it's the people come on to retreat it's the single most disquing you know single most disquing you know single most disquing you know uncomfortable thing to think about and uncomfortable thing to think about and uncomfortable thing to think about and people come and say I don't know if I people come and say I don't know if I people come and say I don't know if I can be silent for two days and uh my can be silent for two days and uh my can be silent for two days and uh my partner doesn't think I can be silent or partner doesn't think I can be silent or partner doesn't think I can be silent or once somebody came and said they're once somebody came and said they're once somebody came and said they're doing a bedding pool in my office cuz doing a bedding pool in my office cuz doing a bedding pool in my office cuz they don't think I can be silent and they don't think I can be silent and they don't think I can be silent and almost always really at the end of the almost always really at the end of the almost always really at the end of the experience. It's one of the single most experience. It's one of the single most experience. It's one of the single most beautiful aspects of having been there. beautiful aspects of having been there. beautiful aspects of having been there. It's like for once in our lives we don't It's like for once in our lives we don't It's like for once in our lives we don't have to present ourselves as interesting have to present ourselves as interesting have to present ourselves as interesting or amusing or disturbed or anything. we or amusing or disturbed or anything. we or amusing or disturbed or anything. we can just be with ourselves, but we're can just be with ourselves, but we're can just be with ourselves, but we're afraid in general. We're not most of us afraid in general. We're not most of us afraid in general. We're not most of us brought up to be a friend of silence. brought up to be a friend of silence. brought up to be a friend of silence. And so, um, sometimes that useless kind And so, um, sometimes that useless kind And so, um, sometimes that useless kind of speech is it's just a way of filling of speech is it's just a way of filling of speech is it's just a way of filling in the gap so that we're not just being. in the gap so that we're not just being. in the gap so that we're not just being. >> Okay. So, we've done is it true. Is >> Okay. So, we've done is it true. Is >> Okay. So, we've done is it true. Is there more to say about is it helpful or there more to say about is it helpful or there more to say about is it helpful or should we move on to the third question? should we move on to the third question? should we move on to the third question? Honestly, I was thinking about um the Honestly, I was thinking about um the Honestly, I was thinking about um the experience you describe of having a 360 experience you describe of having a 360 experience you describe of having a 360 review. review. review. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Which you can describe better than I. >> Which you can describe better than I. >> Which you can describe better than I. And so it seemed from what I've heard And so it seemed from what I've heard And so it seemed from what I've heard about it when what I've heard you talk about it when what I've heard you talk about it when what I've heard you talk about it is that it really uh provoked about it is that it really uh provoked about it is that it really uh provoked some, you know, great introspection and some, you know, great introspection and some, you know, great introspection and uh tremendous change. And I know that uh tremendous change. And I know that uh tremendous change. And I know that your your next book is going to cover your your next book is going to cover your your next book is going to cover that, you know, in some way. But that that, you know, in some way. But that that, you know, in some way. But that would be an example of something, you would be an example of something, you would be an example of something, you know, that uh it's a little bit like know, that uh it's a little bit like know, that uh it's a little bit like embarking on a period of silence. It's embarking on a period of silence. It's embarking on a period of silence. It's having a certain kind of audacity, you having a certain kind of audacity, you having a certain kind of audacity, you know, to step outside of one's comfort know, to step outside of one's comfort know, to step outside of one's comfort zone and and experiment with a different zone and and experiment with a different zone and and experiment with a different way of giving and receiving um speech. way of giving and receiving um speech. way of giving and receiving um speech. So, I don't know if you want to say So, I don't know if you want to say So, I don't know if you want to say anything about that. Well, very briefly, anything about that. Well, very briefly, anything about that. Well, very briefly, as you mentioned, I had a 360 review. as you mentioned, I had a 360 review. as you mentioned, I had a 360 review. Uh, this the first one I had was in Uh, this the first one I had was in Uh, this the first one I had was in 2018, so quite a while ago. Um, but it 2018, so quite a while ago. Um, but it 2018, so quite a while ago. Um, but it was very humbling experience. I actually was very humbling experience. I actually was very humbling experience. I actually remember sending the results to you remember sending the results to you remember sending the results to you because they were they were quite harsh. because they were they were quite harsh. because they were they were quite harsh. 39 pages, first 11 pages were like 39 pages, first 11 pages were like 39 pages, first 11 pages were like positive stuff and the rest of it was positive stuff and the rest of it was positive stuff and the rest of it was just straight beat down. There are four just straight beat down. There are four just straight beat down. There are four major buckets of kind of emotional major buckets of kind of emotional major buckets of kind of emotional unavailability. unavailability. unavailability. Um a stubbornness, um a dismissiveness, Um a stubbornness, um a dismissiveness, Um a stubbornness, um a dismissiveness, a kind of black and white thinking, a kind of black and white thinking, a kind of black and white thinking, overcommitment. overcommitment. overcommitment. I can't remember all the things, but I can't remember all the things, but I can't remember all the things, but that those are the basic areas. And uh I that those are the basic areas. And uh I that those are the basic areas. And uh I remember coming to your apartment and remember coming to your apartment and remember coming to your apartment and talking to you about it afterwards. I talking to you about it afterwards. I talking to you about it afterwards. I was totally distraught, but it it it was totally distraught, but it it it was totally distraught, but it it it yes, it's an audacious thing to do to yes, it's an audacious thing to do to yes, it's an audacious thing to do to ask for that level of feedback. I don't ask for that level of feedback. I don't ask for that level of feedback. I don't actually think that it's it's for actually think that it's it's for actually think that it's it's for everyone. Um I it's a it's often used in everyone. Um I it's a it's often used in everyone. Um I it's a it's often used in a corporate context and if it if you a corporate context and if it if you a corporate context and if it if you don't have good coaching to go with it, don't have good coaching to go with it, don't have good coaching to go with it, it can backfire. Um I happen to have it can backfire. Um I happen to have it can backfire. Um I happen to have good coaching and also just know a lot good coaching and also just know a lot good coaching and also just know a lot of really wise people like you who can of really wise people like you who can of really wise people like you who can help me with it. The 360 reviewers, the help me with it. The 360 reviewers, the help me with it. The 360 reviewers, the people um it's an anonymous survey of people um it's an anonymous survey of people um it's an anonymous survey of the people you work with. Then in my the people you work with. Then in my the people you work with. Then in my case, I added in um like my wife and my case, I added in um like my wife and my case, I added in um like my wife and my brother and and and Joseph and um and so brother and and and Joseph and um and so brother and and and Joseph and um and so it was like a personal and professional it was like a personal and professional it was like a personal and professional 360 review to get a panoramic sense of 360 review to get a panoramic sense of 360 review to get a panoramic sense of my strengths and weaknesses and and um my strengths and weaknesses and and um my strengths and weaknesses and and um the reviewers, the people who were the reviewers, the people who were the reviewers, the people who were surveyed. um they were actually engaging surveyed. um they were actually engaging surveyed. um they were actually engaging in right speech even though a lot of in right speech even though a lot of in right speech even though a lot of what they said was some of it was harsh what they said was some of it was harsh what they said was some of it was harsh and maybe actually some of it crossed and maybe actually some of it crossed and maybe actually some of it crossed the line uh to wrong speech and that it the line uh to wrong speech and that it the line uh to wrong speech and that it was unkind which we will get to soon but was unkind which we will get to soon but was unkind which we will get to soon but it was certainly solicited. I was asking it was certainly solicited. I was asking it was certainly solicited. I was asking for their feedback and they were giving for their feedback and they were giving for their feedback and they were giving it. They weren't talking you know crap it. They weren't talking you know crap it. They weren't talking you know crap behind my back. They were they were behind my back. They were they were behind my back. They were they were giving me feedback in a in a in a giving me feedback in a in a in a giving me feedback in a in a in a context where I asked for it context where I asked for it context where I asked for it >> and so it was helpful in in the end. >> and so it was helpful in in the end. >> and so it was helpful in in the end. Right. Yes, deeply I would say Right. Yes, deeply I would say Right. Yes, deeply I would say uh right below uh right below uh right below the the the birth of our son and and our marriage as birth of our son and and our marriage as birth of our son and and our marriage as you know the most important thing that you know the most important thing that you know the most important thing that has happened to me as a as an adult. It has happened to me as a as an adult. It has happened to me as a as an adult. It provoked an enormous amount of change provoked an enormous amount of change provoked an enormous amount of change and drove me way deeper into your your and drove me way deeper into your your and drove me way deeper into your your personal Baywick, Sharon Salsberg of personal Baywick, Sharon Salsberg of personal Baywick, Sharon Salsberg of loving kindness um and and a supporter loving kindness um and and a supporter loving kindness um and and a supporter of but I not as I it it forced me to of but I not as I it it forced me to of but I not as I it it forced me to engage much more deeply with those um engage much more deeply with those um engage much more deeply with those um practices which has been just practices which has been just practices which has been just incalculable in its in its impact. incalculable in its in its impact. incalculable in its in its impact. We've talked before on this show about We've talked before on this show about We've talked before on this show about why one Skin really stands out as a why one Skin really stands out as a why one Skin really stands out as a skinincare company. It's not hyper just skinincare company. It's not hyper just skinincare company. It's not hyper just fancy packaging. It's real science. The fancy packaging. It's real science. The fancy packaging. It's real science. The founding team are longevity researchers founding team are longevity researchers founding team are longevity researchers who asked a deceptively simple question. who asked a deceptively simple question. who asked a deceptively simple question. If many visible signs of aging, like If many visible signs of aging, like If many visible signs of aging, like wrinkles, fine lines, and loss of wrinkles, fine lines, and loss of wrinkles, fine lines, and loss of elasticity are driven by zombie cells, elasticity are driven by zombie cells, elasticity are driven by zombie cells, what if you could actually reduce those what if you could actually reduce those what if you could actually reduce those cells to slow down the aging process cells to slow down the aging process cells to slow down the aging process instead of just covering it up? That instead of just covering it up? That instead of just covering it up? That research led to OS1, one Skin's research led to OS1, one Skin's research led to OS1, one Skin's proprietary peptide. It's the first proprietary peptide. It's the first proprietary peptide. It's the first ingredient proven to switch off those ingredient proven to switch off those ingredient proven to switch off those damaging scinesscent cells, actually damaging scinesscent cells, actually damaging scinesscent cells, actually slowing skin aging directly at the slowing skin aging directly at the slowing skin aging directly at the source. This is serious science that source. This is serious science that source. This is serious science that fits easily into my existing routine. fits easily into my existing routine. fits easily into my existing routine. And every time I use one skin, I'm And every time I use one skin, I'm And every time I use one skin, I'm giving my skin deeper hydration, barrier giving my skin deeper hydration, barrier giving my skin deeper hydration, barrier support, and visibly healthier skin support, and visibly healthier skin support, and visibly healthier skin longterm. My wife and I have both tried longterm. My wife and I have both tried longterm. My wife and I have both tried and enjoyed OS1. And this is not just my and enjoyed OS1. And this is not just my and enjoyed OS1. And this is not just my experience or our experience. One Skin's experience or our experience. One Skin's experience or our experience. One Skin's results are backed by four peer-reviewed results are backed by four peer-reviewed results are backed by four peer-reviewed clinical studies, over 10,000 five-star clinical studies, over 10,000 five-star clinical studies, over 10,000 five-star reviews, and they've been recognized by reviews, and they've been recognized by reviews, and they've been recognized by Bloomberg as a leader in skin longevity. Bloomberg as a leader in skin longevity. Bloomberg as a leader in skin longevity. Born from over a decade of longevity Born from over a decade of longevity Born from over a decade of longevity research, OneSkin is helping you unlock research, OneSkin is helping you unlock research, OneSkin is helping you unlock your healthiest skin now and as you age. your healthiest skin now and as you age. your healthiest skin now and as you age. For a limited time, try One Skin with For a limited time, try One Skin with For a limited time, try One Skin with 15% off using code happier at 15% off using code happier at 15% off using code happier at onkin.co/happier. onkin.co/happier. onkin.co/happier. That's 15% off when you go to onkin.co That's 15% off when you go to onkin.co That's 15% off when you go to onkin.co co and use the code happier. After your co and use the code happier. After your co and use the code happier. After your purchase, they'll ask you where you purchase, they'll ask you where you purchase, they'll ask you where you heard about them. Please support our heard about them. Please support our heard about them. Please support our show and let them know that we sent you. show and let them know that we sent you. show and let them know that we sent you. So, question number three. So, we again, So, question number three. So, we again, So, question number three. So, we again, just to reset, four questions to ask uh just to reset, four questions to ask uh just to reset, four questions to ask uh yourself if you're trying to engage in yourself if you're trying to engage in yourself if you're trying to engage in right speech. Is it true? Is it helpful? right speech. Is it true? Is it helpful? right speech. Is it true? Is it helpful? The third is, is it timely? Is this the The third is, is it timely? Is this the The third is, is it timely? Is this the right time to say the thing? right time to say the thing? right time to say the thing? >> Yeah. And I think that's very connected >> Yeah. And I think that's very connected >> Yeah. And I think that's very connected to is it helpful? It's like um to is it helpful? It's like um to is it helpful? It's like um uh if you if you have a friend or an uh if you if you have a friend or an uh if you if you have a friend or an acquaintance who just got a really acquaintance who just got a really acquaintance who just got a really difficult diagnosis and it may not be difficult diagnosis and it may not be difficult diagnosis and it may not be the time and it may not be that helpful the time and it may not be that helpful the time and it may not be that helpful to um give them advice, you know, and a to um give them advice, you know, and a to um give them advice, you know, and a lot of people who are feeling that kind lot of people who are feeling that kind lot of people who are feeling that kind of vulnerability and you know, of vulnerability and you know, of vulnerability and you know, everything the fear and everything that everything the fear and everything that everything the fear and everything that that goes with that kind of situation uh that goes with that kind of situation uh that goes with that kind of situation uh often tell me they feel a little often tell me they feel a little often tell me they feel a little bombarded you know by advice and uh I bombarded you know by advice and uh I bombarded you know by advice and uh I use the example in in something I'd use the example in in something I'd use the example in in something I'd written of uh Randas who was also at my written of uh Randas who was also at my written of uh Randas who was also at my very first retreat in 1971 and I've been very first retreat in 1971 and I've been very first retreat in 1971 and I've been a friend ever since and after his stroke a friend ever since and after his stroke a friend ever since and after his stroke which was a very very significant which was a very very significant which was a very very significant stroke. I remember he was in in the stroke. I remember he was in in the stroke. I remember he was in in the rehab hospital and then he was still rehab hospital and then he was still rehab hospital and then he was still living in California and I went to visit living in California and I went to visit living in California and I went to visit him in California and his living room him in California and his living room him in California and his living room was piled high with you know things was piled high with you know things was piled high with you know things people had sent and it was beautiful. It people had sent and it was beautiful. It people had sent and it was beautiful. It was really a a gesture you know based on was really a a gesture you know based on was really a a gesture you know based on how much he had given the world and how how much he had given the world and how how much he had given the world and how he was held and the kind of regard he he was held and the kind of regard he he was held and the kind of regard he was held in. But sometimes there would was held in. But sometimes there would was held in. But sometimes there would be these notes that accompanied the be these notes that accompanied the be these notes that accompanied the whatever and it would say like take 15 whatever and it would say like take 15 whatever and it would say like take 15 drops of this and you'll definitely be drops of this and you'll definitely be drops of this and you'll definitely be walking again. And and I could feel his walking again. And and I could feel his walking again. And and I could feel his internal experience of that was pressure internal experience of that was pressure internal experience of that was pressure and it sort of translated into like will and it sort of translated into like will and it sort of translated into like will you still love me if it doesn't work? you still love me if it doesn't work? you still love me if it doesn't work? Will you still be here with me or will Will you still be here with me or will Will you still be here with me or will you see me as having failed you in some you see me as having failed you in some you see me as having failed you in some way? And when I was there visiting him, way? And when I was there visiting him, way? And when I was there visiting him, one of those arrived and it was a bottle one of those arrived and it was a bottle one of those arrived and it was a bottle of Ganjis water, water from the Ganis of Ganjis water, water from the Ganis of Ganjis water, water from the Ganis River. And I had a note that said River. And I had a note that said River. And I had a note that said something like, "Take 15 drops of this something like, "Take 15 drops of this something like, "Take 15 drops of this and you'll you'll be okay within two and you'll you'll be okay within two and you'll you'll be okay within two weeks." And I said, "Don't drink that. weeks." And I said, "Don't drink that. weeks." And I said, "Don't drink that. >> Whatever you do, don't drink that. >> Whatever you do, don't drink that. >> Whatever you do, don't drink that. You'll get color if you drink that." you You'll get color if you drink that." you You'll get color if you drink that." you know, like for God's sake, you know, so know, like for God's sake, you know, so know, like for God's sake, you know, so um it's the way, you know, like when um it's the way, you know, like when um it's the way, you know, like when someone seems to be in their most someone seems to be in their most someone seems to be in their most vulnerable spot, is that the time or is vulnerable spot, is that the time or is vulnerable spot, is that the time or is that going to be helpful in the end to that going to be helpful in the end to that going to be helpful in the end to impose that kind of pressure which is impose that kind of pressure which is impose that kind of pressure which is really just about you, you know, like I really just about you, you know, like I really just about you, you know, like I saved you in in some way. So again, it's saved you in in some way. So again, it's saved you in in some way. So again, it's really important to look at intention really important to look at intention really important to look at intention and to look at at context to try to and to look at at context to try to and to look at at context to try to figure that out. Just for context on Ram figure that out. Just for context on Ram figure that out. Just for context on Ram Das for people who don't know who he is, Das for people who don't know who he is, Das for people who don't know who he is, he's a great spiritual teacher and he's a great spiritual teacher and he's a great spiritual teacher and writer. He is perhaps most famous for uh writer. He is perhaps most famous for uh writer. He is perhaps most famous for uh his book Be Here Now, but there are some his book Be Here Now, but there are some his book Be Here Now, but there are some documentaries on him that are on Netflix documentaries on him that are on Netflix documentaries on him that are on Netflix that are worth watching and he did have that are worth watching and he did have that are worth watching and he did have a stroke and um really handled it with a stroke and um really handled it with a stroke and um really handled it with uncommon grace. Um in terms of uncommon grace. Um in terms of uncommon grace. Um in terms of timeliness, there's another tool from timeliness, there's another tool from timeliness, there's another tool from the aforementioned Dan Clerman and Muda the aforementioned Dan Clerman and Muda the aforementioned Dan Clerman and Muda Nisker who are great communications Nisker who are great communications Nisker who are great communications coach coaches in the Buddhist tradition. coach coaches in the Buddhist tradition. coach coaches in the Buddhist tradition. um that I found really helpful um you um that I found really helpful um you um that I found really helpful um you know when I'm talking to somebody who is know when I'm talking to somebody who is know when I'm talking to somebody who is in you know extremist they're there's in you know extremist they're there's in you know extremist they're there's something big going on they've gotten a something big going on they've gotten a something big going on they've gotten a diagnosis or they've made a big mistake diagnosis or they've made a big mistake diagnosis or they've made a big mistake and they feel under siege um uh instead and they feel under siege um uh instead and they feel under siege um uh instead of or or they're just anxious about of or or they're just anxious about of or or they're just anxious about something instead of moving into advice something instead of moving into advice something instead of moving into advice which is generally is not generally what which is generally is not generally what which is generally is not generally what people want uh what generally what I people want uh what generally what I people want uh what generally what I think people want and what I certainly think people want and what I certainly think people want and what I certainly want in these exper in these moments is want in these exper in these moments is want in these exper in these moments is um just to be seen and heard uh um just to be seen and heard uh um just to be seen and heard uh validated. A tool that I learned from validated. A tool that I learned from validated. A tool that I learned from Dan and and Muda is uh reflective Dan and and Muda is uh reflective Dan and and Muda is uh reflective listening where you uh simply listen to listening where you uh simply listen to listening where you uh simply listen to what somebody's saying and then repeat what somebody's saying and then repeat what somebody's saying and then repeat back the the bones of what they've said back the the bones of what they've said back the the bones of what they've said to you, the kind of headline version in to you, the kind of headline version in to you, the kind of headline version in your own words. Um and and that really your own words. Um and and that really your own words. Um and and that really is just giving people this incredible is just giving people this incredible is just giving people this incredible gift of of of feeling like they're seen gift of of of feeling like they're seen gift of of of feeling like they're seen and heard. So anyway, does does that and heard. So anyway, does does that and heard. So anyway, does does that feel like an appropriate thing to say? feel like an appropriate thing to say? feel like an appropriate thing to say? in this context in this context in this context >> it does I think very much so and I tell >> it does I think very much so and I tell >> it does I think very much so and I tell a story somewhere uh which was also from a story somewhere uh which was also from a story somewhere uh which was also from a million years ago you know it's like a million years ago you know it's like a million years ago you know it's like living in India there's just this array living in India there's just this array living in India there's just this array of spiritual gurus and perspectives and of spiritual gurus and perspectives and of spiritual gurus and perspectives and methodologies and somebody came to me methodologies and somebody came to me methodologies and somebody came to me once this young man and he said I'm once this young man and he said I'm once this young man and he said I'm thinking of bringing my father um to thinking of bringing my father um to thinking of bringing my father um to India to meet this one particular guru India to meet this one particular guru India to meet this one particular guru whom I I'd also met and he said to me whom I I'd also met and he said to me whom I I'd also met and he said to me what do you think and I said, "Well, you what do you think and I said, "Well, you what do you think and I said, "Well, you know, it's sort of like a a hard place. know, it's sort of like a a hard place. know, it's sort of like a a hard place. It's a hard city. It'll be incredibly It's a hard city. It'll be incredibly It's a hard city. It'll be incredibly hot. There'll be bugs if he may not like hot. There'll be bugs if he may not like hot. There'll be bugs if he may not like the food. He might get sick." And the food. He might get sick." And the food. He might get sick." And anyway, Guru is a little weird. You anyway, Guru is a little weird. You anyway, Guru is a little weird. You know, it's like the scene is is uh know, it's like the scene is is uh know, it's like the scene is is uh strange and it might not work, but he strange and it might not work, but he strange and it might not work, but he didn't listen to me and he went and did didn't listen to me and he went and did didn't listen to me and he went and did it anyway. And it turned out the father it anyway. And it turned out the father it anyway. And it turned out the father fell totally in love with the guru and fell totally in love with the guru and fell totally in love with the guru and became like a disciple of the guru and became like a disciple of the guru and became like a disciple of the guru and became a teacher in the guru's lineage. became a teacher in the guru's lineage. became a teacher in the guru's lineage. like I couldn't have been more wrong. like I couldn't have been more wrong. like I couldn't have been more wrong. Um, and I thought back to that moment, Um, and I thought back to that moment, Um, and I thought back to that moment, you know, where I was like, why was I you know, where I was like, why was I you know, where I was like, why was I inter, you know, lacing my view, my inter, you know, lacing my view, my inter, you know, lacing my view, my experience instead of, as you said, just experience instead of, as you said, just experience instead of, as you said, just listening, saying, well, what is it you listening, saying, well, what is it you listening, saying, well, what is it you hope for, you know, and and what's he hope for, you know, and and what's he hope for, you know, and and what's he like, you know, is he um the kind of like, you know, is he um the kind of like, you know, is he um the kind of person that you think would would take person that you think would would take person that you think would would take offense at at this or, you know, just offense at at this or, you know, just offense at at this or, you know, just like actually having a genuine like actually having a genuine like actually having a genuine communication communication communication Uh, I just sort of laid out well my Uh, I just sort of laid out well my Uh, I just sort of laid out well my experience was, you know, like this and experience was, you know, like this and experience was, you know, like this and I'm sure it won't be won't be okay. I'm sure it won't be won't be okay. I'm sure it won't be won't be okay. >> Why do you think it is that we rush to >> Why do you think it is that we rush to >> Why do you think it is that we rush to advice to to or rush to fix advice to to or rush to fix advice to to or rush to fix um or rush to pontificate in these um or rush to pontificate in these um or rush to pontificate in these moments? Is it is it some unease that moments? Is it is it some unease that moments? Is it is it some unease that we're covering up for? we're covering up for? we're covering up for? >> Well, no doubt. You know, I mean, I >> Well, no doubt. You know, I mean, I >> Well, no doubt. You know, I mean, I think we're also we tend to be rather think we're also we tend to be rather think we're also we tend to be rather self-p preoccupied rather than self-p preoccupied rather than self-p preoccupied rather than connecting. You know, it's like we meet connecting. You know, it's like we meet connecting. You know, it's like we meet somebody and and largely what's going on somebody and and largely what's going on somebody and and largely what's going on in our minds is what do they think of in our minds is what do they think of in our minds is what do they think of me? You know, the day they like me, do me? You know, the day they like me, do me? You know, the day they like me, do they like me more than they've ever they like me more than they've ever they like me more than they've ever liked anyone before? Oh no, I said liked anyone before? Oh no, I said liked anyone before? Oh no, I said something stupid. They hate me. you something stupid. They hate me. you something stupid. They hate me. you know, instead of actually uh in a way know, instead of actually uh in a way know, instead of actually uh in a way kind of emptying and being there and kind of emptying and being there and kind of emptying and being there and taking them in and noticing. And uh one taking them in and noticing. And uh one taking them in and noticing. And uh one of the detriments to being so self-p of the detriments to being so self-p of the detriments to being so self-p preoccupied is that we lose the capacity preoccupied is that we lose the capacity preoccupied is that we lose the capacity to be surprised by people, you [snorts] to be surprised by people, you [snorts] to be surprised by people, you [snorts] know, and just to have that kind of oh know, and just to have that kind of oh know, and just to have that kind of oh that's interesting and oh boy, that's that's interesting and oh boy, that's that's interesting and oh boy, that's unexpected. I wouldn't have thought unexpected. I wouldn't have thought unexpected. I wouldn't have thought that. And you know, because there's not that. And you know, because there's not that. And you know, because there's not necessarily genuine connection going on. necessarily genuine connection going on. necessarily genuine connection going on. So, I mean, I think in in the case of So, I mean, I think in in the case of So, I mean, I think in in the case of just kind of reciting advice, you know, just kind of reciting advice, you know, just kind of reciting advice, you know, it's it's about being seen as right, you it's it's about being seen as right, you it's it's about being seen as right, you know, and having the correct opinion know, and having the correct opinion know, and having the correct opinion and, you know, maybe being remembered as and, you know, maybe being remembered as and, you know, maybe being remembered as the one who warned you off against doing the one who warned you off against doing the one who warned you off against doing that thing or whatever. And and it's a that thing or whatever. And and it's a that thing or whatever. And and it's a pretty lonely way of being in the end pretty lonely way of being in the end pretty lonely way of being in the end because we're not actually connecting in because we're not actually connecting in because we're not actually connecting in in a genuine way. in a genuine way. in a genuine way. Fourth question is I think the thorniest Fourth question is I think the thorniest Fourth question is I think the thorniest in some ways. So just to reset again uh in some ways. So just to reset again uh in some ways. So just to reset again uh is it true? Is it helpful? Is it timely? is it true? Is it helpful? Is it timely? is it true? Is it helpful? Is it timely? The fourth is is it kind? So I have a The fourth is is it kind? So I have a The fourth is is it kind? So I have a million questions for you about this, million questions for you about this, million questions for you about this, but but why don't you just set the but but why don't you just set the but but why don't you just set the table? table? table? >> Well, I would go back to that model that >> Well, I would go back to that model that >> Well, I would go back to that model that I I was talking about of the intention I I was talking about of the intention I I was talking about of the intention behind an action and then our best guess behind an action and then our best guess behind an action and then our best guess of what's most skillful in that moment of what's most skillful in that moment of what's most skillful in that moment in time. in time. in time. as a way of expressing something because as a way of expressing something because as a way of expressing something because um we can look at what our motive is. um we can look at what our motive is. um we can look at what our motive is. It's like do I want to be seen as right? It's like do I want to be seen as right? It's like do I want to be seen as right? Do I want to try to be helpful? Do I Do I want to try to be helpful? Do I Do I want to try to be helpful? Do I want to um extend some compassion? This want to um extend some compassion? This want to um extend some compassion? This person's going through something really person's going through something really person's going through something really hard, you know, and do I just want to hard, you know, and do I just want to hard, you know, and do I just want to acknowledge that in in terms of, you acknowledge that in in terms of, you acknowledge that in in terms of, you know, is that my intention is to say know, is that my intention is to say know, is that my intention is to say you're not so alone in some way, you you're not so alone in some way, you you're not so alone in some way, you know? So the kindness is embedded in the know? So the kindness is embedded in the know? So the kindness is embedded in the intention. One of the things I'm sort of intention. One of the things I'm sort of intention. One of the things I'm sort of liking these days out of current maybe liking these days out of current maybe liking these days out of current maybe pop psychology is the distinction pop psychology is the distinction pop psychology is the distinction between being kind and being nice, between being kind and being nice, between being kind and being nice, >> you know. And so the nice part would >> you know. And so the nice part would >> you know. And so the nice part would have to do with that second aspect of have to do with that second aspect of have to do with that second aspect of action which is the the expression or or action which is the the expression or or action which is the the expression or or the manifestation the skillful or the manifestation the skillful or the manifestation the skillful or unskillful manifestation of of the unskillful manifestation of of the unskillful manifestation of of the intention in that moment. And so maybe intention in that moment. And so maybe intention in that moment. And so maybe there is a time when it feels most there is a time when it feels most there is a time when it feels most appropriate appropriate appropriate um to be strong, you know, and and not um to be strong, you know, and and not um to be strong, you know, and and not to just try to please the other person, to just try to please the other person, to just try to please the other person, but hopefully in a skillful way to say but hopefully in a skillful way to say but hopefully in a skillful way to say what we feel we have to say or or to what we feel we have to say or or to what we feel we have to say or or to have a strong boundary or to say no or have a strong boundary or to say no or have a strong boundary or to say no or or whatever it might be. And and the the or whatever it might be. And and the the or whatever it might be. And and the the kindness is still there and that we're kindness is still there and that we're kindness is still there and that we're not trying to harm somebody. We're not not trying to harm somebody. We're not not trying to harm somebody. We're not trying to hurt anybody perhaps. And yet, trying to hurt anybody perhaps. And yet, trying to hurt anybody perhaps. And yet, you know, what seems most appropriate is you know, what seems most appropriate is you know, what seems most appropriate is uh is not saying yes and being sweet and uh is not saying yes and being sweet and uh is not saying yes and being sweet and being meek or something like that. being meek or something like that. being meek or something like that. >> There's another uh classic Sharon story >> There's another uh classic Sharon story >> There's another uh classic Sharon story that's coming to mind uh that's not that's coming to mind uh that's not that's coming to mind uh that's not fully apppropo because it's it's not fully apppropo because it's it's not fully apppropo because it's it's not it's not on speech. it's not on speech. it's not on speech. uh it's not totally on point on the uh it's not totally on point on the uh it's not totally on point on the subject of speech but I think it is subject of speech but I think it is subject of speech but I think it is illuminating in this context that that illuminating in this context that that illuminating in this context that that you early on in your days in India and you early on in your days in India and you early on in your days in India and you were still young and new to the you were still young and new to the you were still young and new to the practice and uh you were listening to practice and uh you were listening to practice and uh you were listening to some teachers talking about the some teachers talking about the some teachers talking about the importance of kindness and you said importance of kindness and you said importance of kindness and you said something to the effect of like what if something to the effect of like what if something to the effect of like what if I go out on the street and and here in I go out on the street and and here in I go out on the street and and here in India and there there are pickpockets India and there there are pickpockets India and there there are pickpockets all over the place what do I do should I all over the place what do I do should I all over the place what do I do should I let them pick my pick my pockets and the let them pick my pick my pockets and the let them pick my pick my pockets and the teacher said no you should very teacher said no you should very teacher said no you should very compassionately smack them with your compassionately smack them with your compassionately smack them with your umbrella umbrella umbrella And And And >> okay, I'm going to tell you what really >> okay, I'm going to tell you what really >> okay, I'm going to tell you what really happened. happened. happened. >> Okay. Okay. >> Okay. Okay. >> Okay. Okay. >> Cuz that that is one of my stories and >> Cuz that that is one of my stories and >> Cuz that that is one of my stories and and one of my experiences. And it's so and one of my experiences. And it's so and one of my experiences. And it's so funny cuz we're talking about, you know, funny cuz we're talking about, you know, funny cuz we're talking about, you know, a long time ago. I mean, the Insight a long time ago. I mean, the Insight a long time ago. I mean, the Insight Meditation Society just celebrated its Meditation Society just celebrated its Meditation Society just celebrated its 50th anniversary and we were in India 50th anniversary and we were in India 50th anniversary and we were in India before then, you know. So, um, so I hear before then, you know. So, um, so I hear before then, you know. So, um, so I hear this story, you know, and people say say this story, you know, and people say say this story, you know, and people say say it in all kinds of different ways. So it in all kinds of different ways. So it in all kinds of different ways. So what actually happened was I'd gone to what actually happened was I'd gone to what actually happened was I'd gone to Baya and Kolkata maybe six or seven Baya and Kolkata maybe six or seven Baya and Kolkata maybe six or seven hours away by from one another by train. hours away by from one another by train. hours away by from one another by train. So I'd gone to Kolkata for some reason So I'd gone to Kolkata for some reason So I'd gone to Kolkata for some reason with this friend of mine. We were with this friend of mine. We were with this friend of mine. We were heading back to Gaia to board Gaia and heading back to Gaia to board Gaia and heading back to Gaia to board Gaia and going to the train station in Kolkata going to the train station in Kolkata going to the train station in Kolkata there was uh something going on in the there was uh something going on in the there was uh something going on in the street. there was some kind of riot. So street. there was some kind of riot. So street. there was some kind of riot. So we couldn't get a cab or something like we couldn't get a cab or something like we couldn't get a cab or something like that. And the only means of that. And the only means of that. And the only means of transportation we could find to get back transportation we could find to get back transportation we could find to get back to the train station was a rickshaw. And to the train station was a rickshaw. And to the train station was a rickshaw. And in Kolkata in those days, I don't know in Kolkata in those days, I don't know in Kolkata in those days, I don't know about now, the rick shores were not men about now, the rick shores were not men about now, the rick shores were not men on bicycles, they were men running. So on bicycles, they were men running. So on bicycles, they were men running. So you were in this carriage and and this you were in this carriage and and this you were in this carriage and and this guy was pulling you along running. So, guy was pulling you along running. So, guy was pulling you along running. So, he's going down these dark side streets he's going down these dark side streets he's going down these dark side streets and alleyways and um this very large, and alleyways and um this very large, and alleyways and um this very large, very drunken man came out of the shadows very drunken man came out of the shadows very drunken man came out of the shadows and stopped him and went to grab me to and stopped him and went to grab me to and stopped him and went to grab me to pull me off. And I thought, "Oh my god, pull me off. And I thought, "Oh my god, pull me off. And I thought, "Oh my god, you know, I'm going to be raped. I'm you know, I'm going to be raped. I'm you know, I'm going to be raped. I'm going to be murdered." Um, and the going to be murdered." Um, and the going to be murdered." Um, and the person I was with, the man I was with, person I was with, the man I was with, person I was with, the man I was with, managed to shove him aside and got the managed to shove him aside and got the managed to shove him aside and got the guy to start running again. So we got to guy to start running again. So we got to guy to start running again. So we got to the train station got you know after the the train station got you know after the the train station got you know after the train ride got back to BGA and went to train ride got back to BGA and went to train ride got back to BGA and went to see this teacher mana and I was still see this teacher mana and I was still see this teacher mana and I was still very shaken up by it and I told him the very shaken up by it and I told him the very shaken up by it and I told him the whole story and he said to me oh Sharon whole story and he said to me oh Sharon whole story and he said to me oh Sharon with all the loving kindness in your with all the loving kindness in your with all the loving kindness in your heart you should have taken your heart you should have taken your heart you should have taken your umbrella and hit that man over the head. umbrella and hit that man over the head. umbrella and hit that man over the head. So that's what happened and uh you know So that's what happened and uh you know So that's what happened and uh you know uh the I knew you were going to tell uh the I knew you were going to tell uh the I knew you were going to tell that story you know in some fashion when that story you know in some fashion when that story you know in some fashion when you started speaking and um you know of you started speaking and um you know of you started speaking and um you know of course a lot of times we hit people over course a lot of times we hit people over course a lot of times we hit people over the head and and we think well it was the head and and we think well it was the head and and we think well it was coming from a loving place but was it coming from a loving place but was it coming from a loving place but was it really you know so there we have the really you know so there we have the really you know so there we have the ability uh for introspection and for ability uh for introspection and for ability uh for introspection and for really self-reflection really self-reflection really self-reflection see where we're coming from but we don't see where we're coming from but we don't see where we're coming from but we don't as you know you know that mistake is so as you know you know that mistake is so as you know you know that mistake is so fundamental that from loving kindness fundamental that from loving kindness fundamental that from loving kindness we're just going to be so uh doormat we're just going to be so uh doormat we're just going to be so uh doormat like you know that it it's just not the like you know that it it's just not the like you know that it it's just not the way it works. way it works. way it works. >> Is it kind? The injunction toward >> Is it kind? The injunction toward >> Is it kind? The injunction toward kindness in our speech does not mean we kindness in our speech does not mean we kindness in our speech does not mean we shouldn't speak up for what we believe shouldn't speak up for what we believe shouldn't speak up for what we believe in in a political context online or IRL. in in a political context online or IRL. in in a political context online or IRL. We shouldn't go to a protest. we We shouldn't go to a protest. we We shouldn't go to a protest. we shouldn't um have firm words with our shouldn't um have firm words with our shouldn't um have firm words with our spouse or our child or um the um spouse or our child or um the um spouse or our child or um the um proverbial obnoxious uncle. Um it's it's proverbial obnoxious uncle. Um it's it's proverbial obnoxious uncle. Um it's it's about like what is in your heart as about like what is in your heart as about like what is in your heart as you're doing this? Are you are are you you're doing this? Are you are are you you're doing this? Are you are are you being firm and maybe even slightly harsh being firm and maybe even slightly harsh being firm and maybe even slightly harsh from the from a mind of of loving from the from a mind of of loving from the from a mind of of loving kindness? kindness? kindness? >> Exactly. you know, and and what an >> Exactly. you know, and and what an >> Exactly. you know, and and what an amazing thing that we can look back amazing thing that we can look back amazing thing that we can look back hopefully without a lot of judgment um hopefully without a lot of judgment um hopefully without a lot of judgment um to see our intention. You know, if to see our intention. You know, if to see our intention. You know, if you're full of judgment and shame and you're full of judgment and shame and you're full of judgment and shame and that's not going to really work either. that's not going to really work either. that's not going to really work either. Uh but to understand, you know, we have Uh but to understand, you know, we have Uh but to understand, you know, we have lots of different kinds of conditioning lots of different kinds of conditioning lots of different kinds of conditioning and and things will come up. We don't and and things will come up. We don't and and things will come up. We don't have to necessarily follow them out and have to necessarily follow them out and have to necessarily follow them out and live by them, but you know, we can see live by them, but you know, we can see live by them, but you know, we can see them and abandon that which is them and abandon that which is them and abandon that which is unskillful and cultivate the good. And I unskillful and cultivate the good. And I unskillful and cultivate the good. And I mean, what a breathtaking potential for mean, what a breathtaking potential for mean, what a breathtaking potential for human life. human life. human life. >> Okay. Well, here's here's the really >> Okay. Well, here's here's the really >> Okay. Well, here's here's the really juicy question, though. Is it ever okay juicy question, though. Is it ever okay juicy question, though. Is it ever okay to gossip? to gossip? to gossip? >> Probably we will, you know, [laughter] >> Probably we will, you know, [laughter] >> Probably we will, you know, [laughter] I and I've heard people say that it's I and I've heard people say that it's I and I've heard people say that it's it's like a tribal ritual. It's good. it's like a tribal ritual. It's good. it's like a tribal ritual. It's good. you know, you kind of find your people. you know, you kind of find your people. you know, you kind of find your people. But I think it's so interesting to But I think it's so interesting to But I think it's so interesting to look at not only the intention but also look at not only the intention but also look at not only the intention but also the um the um the um the nature of the gossip. It's like I've the nature of the gossip. It's like I've the nature of the gossip. It's like I've you know I use the example sometimes of you know I use the example sometimes of you know I use the example sometimes of like you're about to say something about like you're about to say something about like you're about to say something about someone else that's really belittling. someone else that's really belittling. someone else that's really belittling. It's true but it's it's belittling. And It's true but it's it's belittling. And It's true but it's it's belittling. And sometimes like I ask myself or or we can sometimes like I ask myself or or we can sometimes like I ask myself or or we can ask ourselves like why what would be the ask ourselves like why what would be the ask ourselves like why what would be the result of turning this person against result of turning this person against result of turning this person against this other person or you know what would this other person or you know what would this other person or you know what would be the good of this person knowing this be the good of this person knowing this be the good of this person knowing this about this other person and sometimes we about this other person and sometimes we about this other person and sometimes we just practice restraint but you don't just practice restraint but you don't just practice restraint but you don't have to be like holier than thou or have to be like holier than thou or have to be like holier than thou or uptight or or anything. you can be uptight or or anything. you can be uptight or or anything. you can be relaxed in your speech, but or you know relaxed in your speech, but or you know relaxed in your speech, but or you know what would it be like if you said what would it be like if you said what would it be like if you said something about another person and then something about another person and then something about another person and then they walked in the room like two and a they walked in the room like two and a they walked in the room like two and a half minutes later like what would that half minutes later like what would that half minutes later like what would that feel like? And and and realizing just feel like? And and and realizing just feel like? And and and realizing just cuz something is ordinary or cuz something is ordinary or cuz something is ordinary or conventional or familiar doesn't mean it conventional or familiar doesn't mean it conventional or familiar doesn't mean it brings us anything, you know, that's brings us anything, you know, that's brings us anything, you know, that's that's worth having in terms of our our that's worth having in terms of our our that's worth having in terms of our our fulfillment or our our happiness in fulfillment or our our happiness in fulfillment or our our happiness in life. So, it's not bad to pay attention life. So, it's not bad to pay attention life. So, it's not bad to pay attention to to to those elements as well. those elements as well. those elements as well. >> But I do want to go back to something >> But I do want to go back to something >> But I do want to go back to something you said a moment ago and I didn't pick you said a moment ago and I didn't pick you said a moment ago and I didn't pick up on it and I want to pick up on it up on it and I want to pick up on it up on it and I want to pick up on it now, which is you didn't say this, but now, which is you didn't say this, but now, which is you didn't say this, but I'm going to say it because because I'm I'm going to say it because because I'm I'm going to say it because because I'm pretty sure you you will say it or would pretty sure you you will say it or would pretty sure you you will say it or would have said it. Nobody's expecting have said it. Nobody's expecting have said it. Nobody's expecting perfection here. The the the point is to perfection here. The the the point is to perfection here. The the the point is to bring some curiosity and introspection bring some curiosity and introspection bring some curiosity and introspection both in the moment when you can remember both in the moment when you can remember both in the moment when you can remember um and exposef facto uh if you can um um and exposef facto uh if you can um um and exposef facto uh if you can um you know bear it. But the point is not you know bear it. But the point is not you know bear it. But the point is not to shame yourself. You you are it if you to shame yourself. You you are it if you to shame yourself. You you are it if you take this seriously you are likely to take this seriously you are likely to take this seriously you are likely to see some things that are unflattering see some things that are unflattering see some things that are unflattering but the shame is not going to help. As I but the shame is not going to help. As I but the shame is not going to help. As I once heard a great teacher whose once heard a great teacher whose once heard a great teacher whose initials are Sharon Salsberg say, uh, initials are Sharon Salsberg say, uh, initials are Sharon Salsberg say, uh, the mind filled with shame cannot learn. the mind filled with shame cannot learn. the mind filled with shame cannot learn. And, um, so I often call in my And, um, so I often call in my And, um, so I often call in my scatological way shame. Um, I often call scatological way shame. Um, I often call scatological way shame. Um, I often call it, um, the psychic constipation like it, um, the psychic constipation like it, um, the psychic constipation like nothing can move through if you're just nothing can move through if you're just nothing can move through if you're just stuck in a story of I'm a bad person. I stuck in a story of I'm a bad person. I stuck in a story of I'm a bad person. I I of course I said that thing because my I of course I said that thing because my I of course I said that thing because my intention is to belittle to and to self intention is to belittle to and to self intention is to belittle to and to self arrandise. So yeah, just say a little arrandise. So yeah, just say a little arrandise. So yeah, just say a little bit more about why shame is not helpful. bit more about why shame is not helpful. bit more about why shame is not helpful. >> Yeah, that was actually a quotation uh >> Yeah, that was actually a quotation uh >> Yeah, that was actually a quotation uh from Eve Aman who said just that the from Eve Aman who said just that the from Eve Aman who said just that the brain filled with shame cannot learn. brain filled with shame cannot learn. brain filled with shame cannot learn. And um it's really true, you know, like And um it's really true, you know, like And um it's really true, you know, like uh even some people going back to our uh even some people going back to our uh even some people going back to our initial conversation, some people in initial conversation, some people in initial conversation, some people in describing the eight-fold path don't describing the eight-fold path don't describing the eight-fold path don't like that term right, you know, right like that term right, you know, right like that term right, you know, right speech, right action, right livelihood. speech, right action, right livelihood. speech, right action, right livelihood. And yet that that is the classical And yet that that is the classical And yet that that is the classical translation. They don't like right translation. They don't like right translation. They don't like right because of the likelihood of somebody because of the likelihood of somebody because of the likelihood of somebody then judging themselves and blaming then judging themselves and blaming then judging themselves and blaming themselves and I'm all wrong and it's so themselves and I'm all wrong and it's so themselves and I'm all wrong and it's so terrible. But right in a sense just you terrible. But right in a sense just you terrible. But right in a sense just you could say it means onward leading, you could say it means onward leading, you could say it means onward leading, you know, rather than being stuck. You could know, rather than being stuck. You could know, rather than being stuck. You could say it means being in harmony with how say it means being in harmony with how say it means being in harmony with how things are. And uh there's nothing wrong things are. And uh there's nothing wrong things are. And uh there's nothing wrong with wanting to be happy, you know, cuz with wanting to be happy, you know, cuz with wanting to be happy, you know, cuz it doesn't mean wanting um endless it doesn't mean wanting um endless it doesn't mean wanting um endless pleasure or uh domination over others. pleasure or uh domination over others. pleasure or uh domination over others. It means genuine kind of happiness. And It means genuine kind of happiness. And It means genuine kind of happiness. And and when we align ourselves with the and when we align ourselves with the and when we align ourselves with the things that will help bring it, it first things that will help bring it, it first things that will help bring it, it first of all our own happiness in that sense of all our own happiness in that sense of all our own happiness in that sense gives us resilience and an ability to gives us resilience and an ability to gives us resilience and an ability to help others which we don't have if we help others which we don't have if we help others which we don't have if we just feel broken and overwhelmed and just feel broken and overwhelmed and just feel broken and overwhelmed and exhausted all of the time. So we work on exhausted all of the time. So we work on exhausted all of the time. So we work on those things that will build that those things that will build that those things that will build that capacity up. And it's it's good for us, capacity up. And it's it's good for us, capacity up. And it's it's good for us, it's good for others. And that's what's it's good for others. And that's what's it's good for others. And that's what's right, you know, is to orient ourselves right, you know, is to orient ourselves right, you know, is to orient ourselves toward that. And and wanting that is not toward that. And and wanting that is not toward that. And and wanting that is not greed, which people often ask me, you greed, which people often ask me, you greed, which people often ask me, you know, isn't that selfish to want to be know, isn't that selfish to want to be know, isn't that selfish to want to be happy? And I say, no, it's not greed. happy? And I say, no, it's not greed. happy? And I say, no, it's not greed. It's science. It's science. It's science. You know, if I have all this material You know, if I have all this material You know, if I have all this material goods and I never share anything, I feel goods and I never share anything, I feel goods and I never share anything, I feel I never have enough. You know, that's I never have enough. You know, that's I never have enough. You know, that's not a happy state. not a happy state. not a happy state. And you know, why not see that And you know, why not see that And you know, why not see that generosity produces happiness? and then generosity produces happiness? and then generosity produces happiness? and then embark on a path or if I spent all my embark on a path or if I spent all my embark on a path or if I spent all my time just time just time just uh disparaging others. I really do think uh disparaging others. I really do think uh disparaging others. I really do think we live in a culture of disparagement in we live in a culture of disparagement in we live in a culture of disparagement in terms of speech where we're taught you terms of speech where we're taught you terms of speech where we're taught you will feel better about yourself if you will feel better about yourself if you will feel better about yourself if you just put others down. um you know we see just put others down. um you know we see just put others down. um you know we see it again and again like I don't watch it again and again like I don't watch it again and again like I don't watch much reality TV for example you know but much reality TV for example you know but much reality TV for example you know but occasionally in someone's house someone occasionally in someone's house someone occasionally in someone's house someone will have something on and I remember will have something on and I remember will have something on and I remember watching this cooking show and it was watching this cooking show and it was watching this cooking show and it was just terrible you know instead of just terrible you know instead of just terrible you know instead of somebody you know being dismissed with somebody you know being dismissed with somebody you know being dismissed with you know that was a really good sule but you know that was a really good sule but you know that was a really good sule but I think you could have made it more I think you could have made it more I think you could have made it more interesting with more spice or something interesting with more spice or something interesting with more spice or something like that it was like take your knives like that it was like take your knives like that it was like take your knives and go and it was like you don't deserve and go and it was like you don't deserve and go and it was like you don't deserve to be alive, you know, and we call that to be alive, you know, and we call that to be alive, you know, and we call that entertainment. So, we've got lots of entertainment. So, we've got lots of entertainment. So, we've got lots of conditioning about what happens if you conditioning about what happens if you conditioning about what happens if you make a mistake, what happens if you're make a mistake, what happens if you're make a mistake, what happens if you're not number one, you know, how should you not number one, you know, how should you not number one, you know, how should you feel about yourself? And uh it's a lot feel about yourself? And uh it's a lot feel about yourself? And uh it's a lot of work, but it's the most liberating of work, but it's the most liberating of work, but it's the most liberating work of all to realize we can see these work of all to realize we can see these work of all to realize we can see these things within ourselves, not as bad or things within ourselves, not as bad or things within ourselves, not as bad or wrong, but painful. and out of wrong, but painful. and out of wrong, but painful. and out of compassion for ourselves embark on a compassion for ourselves embark on a compassion for ourselves embark on a path um that's more fulfilling, you path um that's more fulfilling, you path um that's more fulfilling, you know, and is happier. know, and is happier. know, and is happier. >> Abandoning the unskillful. >> Abandoning the unskillful. >> Abandoning the unskillful. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> How do we remember right speech when >> How do we remember right speech when >> How do we remember right speech when we're in the middle of a conversation we're in the middle of a conversation we're in the middle of a conversation with a difficult person? with a difficult person? with a difficult person? >> Well, there's also practice. We can >> Well, there's also practice. We can >> Well, there's also practice. We can practice when we're not in the heat of practice when we're not in the heat of practice when we're not in the heat of a, you know, a conversation with a a, you know, a conversation with a a, you know, a conversation with a difficult person. Uh because the more we difficult person. Uh because the more we difficult person. Uh because the more we practice any skill in a kind of boring practice any skill in a kind of boring practice any skill in a kind of boring somewhat boring ordinary time, it is a somewhat boring ordinary time, it is a somewhat boring ordinary time, it is a little bit like going to the gym and little bit like going to the gym and little bit like going to the gym and you're building up that strength so that you're building up that strength so that you're building up that strength so that when things are harder, more when things are harder, more when things are harder, more complicated, more demanding, then it's complicated, more demanding, then it's complicated, more demanding, then it's more familiar. So I would suggest that more familiar. So I would suggest that more familiar. So I would suggest that like make it a habit. So one of the like make it a habit. So one of the like make it a habit. So one of the things I decided in the beginning of the things I decided in the beginning of the things I decided in the beginning of the pandemic, you know, I was in Barry, pandemic, you know, I was in Barry, pandemic, you know, I was in Barry, Mass. the center was closed. All my Mass. the center was closed. All my Mass. the center was closed. All my travel plans were dashed. And so I travel plans were dashed. And so I travel plans were dashed. And so I decided I was going to undertake these decided I was going to undertake these decided I was going to undertake these practices just to, you know, make it a practices just to, you know, make it a practices just to, you know, make it a more enriched and and useful time. So more enriched and and useful time. So more enriched and and useful time. So one of the practices I decided on was one of the practices I decided on was one of the practices I decided on was that I wasn't going to write an email that I wasn't going to write an email that I wasn't going to write an email and just press send because it is a and just press send because it is a and just press send because it is a medium of communication medium of communication medium of communication which can so often lead to which can so often lead to which can so often lead to misunderstanding and confusion. and it's misunderstanding and confusion. and it's misunderstanding and confusion. and it's so tur and so I thought I was going to so tur and so I thought I was going to so tur and so I thought I was going to write an email read it again put myself write an email read it again put myself write an email read it again put myself in the position of the recipient and in the position of the recipient and in the position of the recipient and then decide if I wanted to edit it or or then decide if I wanted to edit it or or then decide if I wanted to edit it or or just send it and you know this is all just send it and you know this is all just send it and you know this is all these years later I still do that and these years later I still do that and these years later I still do that and most of the time I edit it you know most of the time I edit it you know most of the time I edit it you know because it's the nature of of that sort because it's the nature of of that sort because it's the nature of of that sort of medium so we can undertake practices of medium so we can undertake practices of medium so we can undertake practices of speech in one form or another and of speech in one form or another and of speech in one form or another and bring them to bear and just experiment bring them to bear and just experiment bring them to bear and just experiment with them and then when you're in the with them and then when you're in the with them and then when you're in the heat, you know, of a conversation with a heat, you know, of a conversation with a heat, you know, of a conversation with a difficult person, the simplest thing difficult person, the simplest thing difficult person, the simplest thing usually as a mirror for our feelings is usually as a mirror for our feelings is usually as a mirror for our feelings is the body, you know, what am I feeling? the body, you know, what am I feeling? the body, you know, what am I feeling? What sensations are coming up? And that What sensations are coming up? And that What sensations are coming up? And that becomes our feedback system. So, I also becomes our feedback system. So, I also becomes our feedback system. So, I also often tell the story about a friend of often tell the story about a friend of often tell the story about a friend of mine who described herself as the kind mine who described herself as the kind mine who described herself as the kind of person who could basically never say of person who could basically never say of person who could basically never say no. She had a very hard time saying no no. She had a very hard time saying no no. She had a very hard time saying no in all these different situations. So in all these different situations. So in all these different situations. So she said like she'd be at work and she'd she said like she'd be at work and she'd she said like she'd be at work and she'd be asked to do things that really were be asked to do things that really were be asked to do things that really were not her job, but she she would feel like not her job, but she she would feel like not her job, but she she would feel like she had to say yes. And so in her she had to say yes. And so in her she had to say yes. And so in her meditation practice, in her meditation meditation practice, in her meditation meditation practice, in her meditation practice, one of the things she did was practice, one of the things she did was practice, one of the things she did was consciously bring up those kinds of consciously bring up those kinds of consciously bring up those kinds of situations. And you know, she'd imagine situations. And you know, she'd imagine situations. And you know, she'd imagine somebody asking her something and she somebody asking her something and she somebody asking her something and she really studied what happened in her body really studied what happened in her body really studied what happened in her body because the the feeling of which is because the the feeling of which is because the the feeling of which is really panic came up in her stomach really panic came up in her stomach really panic came up in her stomach before the thought, oh, maybe they won't before the thought, oh, maybe they won't before the thought, oh, maybe they won't like me anymore if I say no. And so she like me anymore if I say no. And so she like me anymore if I say no. And so she studied that feeling and that became her studied that feeling and that became her studied that feeling and that became her feedback feedback system. So that when feedback feedback system. So that when feedback feedback system. So that when she was at work and she would be asked she was at work and she would be asked she was at work and she would be asked that very kind of question and she'd that very kind of question and she'd that very kind of question and she'd feel that very thing that was her signal feel that very thing that was her signal feel that very thing that was her signal to say I'll have to get back to you. And to say I'll have to get back to you. And to say I'll have to get back to you. And then once she had some space she could then once she had some space she could then once she had some space she could actually say no. So the body will reveal actually say no. So the body will reveal actually say no. So the body will reveal a lot of things and that can be our a lot of things and that can be our a lot of things and that can be our signal like maybe don't answer right signal like maybe don't answer right signal like maybe don't answer right away you know or maybe say you need some away you know or maybe say you need some away you know or maybe say you need some time to think about something or to say time to think about something or to say time to think about something or to say well you know I think of whatever you're well you know I think of whatever you're well you know I think of whatever you're proposing proposing proposing uh differently do you want to hear what uh differently do you want to hear what uh differently do you want to hear what you know my perspective is or something you know my perspective is or something you know my perspective is or something you know it'll just help guide us you know it'll just help guide us you know it'll just help guide us >> this has been a great conversation I'm >> this has been a great conversation I'm >> this has been a great conversation I'm completely unsurprised by that fact Um completely unsurprised by that fact Um completely unsurprised by that fact Um before I let you go though, can you just before I let you go though, can you just before I let you go though, can you just talk a little bit about this event talk a little bit about this event talk a little bit about this event you're doing on uh the 10% uh app, this you're doing on uh the 10% uh app, this you're doing on uh the 10% uh app, this 8week series of live events uh around 8week series of live events uh around 8week series of live events uh around the eight-fold path. Uh I'm super the eight-fold path. Uh I'm super the eight-fold path. Uh I'm super excited and super grateful to you for excited and super grateful to you for excited and super grateful to you for for doing it. But uh yeah, talk talk a for doing it. But uh yeah, talk talk a for doing it. But uh yeah, talk talk a little bit about uh why you wanted to do little bit about uh why you wanted to do little bit about uh why you wanted to do it and what it will be. it and what it will be. it and what it will be. >> I am doing uh several things for that >> I am doing uh several things for that >> I am doing uh several things for that app. Uh I'm doing some uh I'm doing that app. Uh I'm doing some uh I'm doing that app. Uh I'm doing some uh I'm doing that series. I'm uh ultimately doing a course series. I'm uh ultimately doing a course series. I'm uh ultimately doing a course uh with Andy Gonzalez from the Holistic uh with Andy Gonzalez from the Holistic uh with Andy Gonzalez from the Holistic Life Foundation which is especially Life Foundation which is especially Life Foundation which is especially designed for people who care for other designed for people who care for other designed for people who care for other people in some way. Um the eight-fold people in some way. Um the eight-fold people in some way. Um the eight-fold path is is like our living legacy. You path is is like our living legacy. You path is is like our living legacy. You know, it is the actionable part of what know, it is the actionable part of what know, it is the actionable part of what we can do. You know, it's it's one thing we can do. You know, it's it's one thing we can do. You know, it's it's one thing to feel sense of dissatisfaction in your to feel sense of dissatisfaction in your to feel sense of dissatisfaction in your life or uh things could be better and life or uh things could be better and life or uh things could be better and it's another thing to feel creative and it's another thing to feel creative and it's another thing to feel creative and uh that you have agency and that there uh that you have agency and that there uh that you have agency and that there are things you can experiment with and are things you can experiment with and are things you can experiment with and try out. So that's really the eight-fold try out. So that's really the eight-fold try out. So that's really the eight-fold path and that will be uh eight different path and that will be uh eight different path and that will be uh eight different sessions. Yes, eight different sessions sessions. Yes, eight different sessions sessions. Yes, eight different sessions uh all live on Sundays through uh all live on Sundays through uh all live on Sundays through throughout the summer and um uh if you throughout the summer and um uh if you throughout the summer and um uh if you miss it, you can watch it on uh on miss it, you can watch it on uh on miss it, you can watch it on uh on replay and we're going to turn it into a replay and we're going to turn it into a replay and we're going to turn it into a course on the eight-fold path by Sharon course on the eight-fold path by Sharon course on the eight-fold path by Sharon Salsburg. But she's also creating Salsburg. But she's also creating Salsburg. But she's also creating another course with our mutual friend another course with our mutual friend another course with our mutual friend Andy Gonzalez um around uh specifically Andy Gonzalez um around uh specifically Andy Gonzalez um around uh specifically uh a uh meditation and content aimed at uh a uh meditation and content aimed at uh a uh meditation and content aimed at people who are caregivers which honestly people who are caregivers which honestly people who are caregivers which honestly is most of us uh whether you're a parent is most of us uh whether you're a parent is most of us uh whether you're a parent or you have an aging parent or you um as or you have an aging parent or you um as or you have an aging parent or you um as you move through the day uh you you are you move through the day uh you you are you move through the day uh you you are many of us um there are moments where we many of us um there are moments where we many of us um there are moments where we are caregivers for friends who need help are caregivers for friends who need help are caregivers for friends who need help or maybe we're volunteers or um Yeah. or maybe we're volunteers or um Yeah. or maybe we're volunteers or um Yeah. Any and or we're in a caregiving Any and or we're in a caregiving Any and or we're in a caregiving profession. There are lots of uh use profession. There are lots of uh use profession. There are lots of uh use cases for this this second course you cases for this this second course you cases for this this second course you will also be creating for us. Anyway, will also be creating for us. Anyway, will also be creating for us. Anyway, Sharon, you're the best. Thank you for Sharon, you're the best. Thank you for Sharon, you're the best. Thank you for doing this. doing this. doing this. >> Thank you so much. >> Thank you so much. >> Thank you so much. >> Thank you so much to everybody who works >> Thank you so much to everybody who works >> Thank you so much to everybody who works so hard to make this show. 10% Happier so hard to make this show. 10% Happier so hard to make this show. 10% Happier is produced by Tara Anderson and Eleanor is produced by Tara Anderson and Eleanor is produced by Tara Anderson and Eleanor Vasili. Our recording and engineering is Vasili. Our recording and engineering is Vasili. Our recording and engineering is handled by the great folks over at Pod handled by the great folks over at Pod handled by the great folks over at Pod People. [music] Lauren Smith is our People. [music] Lauren Smith is our People. [music] Lauren Smith is our managing producer. Marissa Schneiderman managing producer. Marissa Schneiderman managing producer. Marissa Schneiderman is our senior producer. DJ Kashmir is is our senior producer. DJ Kashmir is is our senior producer. DJ Kashmir is our executive producer and Nick Thorburn our executive producer and Nick Thorburn our executive producer and Nick Thorburn of the great indie rock band Islands of the great indie rock band Islands of the great indie rock band Islands wrote our [music] theme. One last thing wrote our [music] theme. One last thing wrote our [music] theme. One last thing I want to say before you go. If you I want to say before you go. If you I want to say before you go. If you enjoy this show, please do me/ us a enjoy this show, please do me/ us a enjoy this show, please do me/ us a solid. Follow the show and leave a solid. Follow the show and leave a solid. Follow the show and leave a rating and a review on whatever platform rating and a review on whatever platform rating and a review on whatever platform you watch [music] or listen to us on. It you watch [music] or listen to us on. It you watch [music] or listen to us on. It only takes a minute. It's free and it only takes a minute. It's free and it only takes a minute. It's free and it really helps new people find us [music] really helps new people find us [music] really helps new people find us [music] and spread uh the good news that the and spread uh the good news that the and spread uh the good news that the mind is trainable. Thank you. Sincerely, mind is trainable. Thank you. Sincerely, mind is trainable. Thank you. Sincerely, [music] I mean it. Thank you.