Full Transcript
Read or copy the complete episode transcript.
I want to be scared, you know, I don't I want to be scared, you know, I don't want to feel like a lunatic watching want to feel like a lunatic watching want to feel like a lunatic watching these stocks get more cheaper thinking these stocks get more cheaper thinking these stocks get more cheaper thinking the expected forward returns are growing the expected forward returns are growing the expected forward returns are growing up. I may be kind of missing out here up. I may be kind of missing out here up. I may be kind of missing out here this week. this week. this week. >> pressure test? >> pressure test? >> pressure test? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Find tell me something negative, but I >> Find tell me something negative, but I >> Find tell me something negative, but I haven't been able to find one that is haven't been able to find one that is haven't been able to find one that is like a quantitative metric. The like a quantitative metric. The like a quantitative metric. The underlying fundamentals are improving. underlying fundamentals are improving. underlying fundamentals are improving. Uh and stocks Nvidia's actually has we Uh and stocks Nvidia's actually has we Uh and stocks Nvidia's actually has we record this record this record this at its lowest forward PE of the last 10 at its lowest forward PE of the last 10 at its lowest forward PE of the last 10 years. The market 100% thinks they're years. The market 100% thinks they're years. The market 100% thinks they're significantly overvalued. >> Gavin, [music] it's only been 2 months >> Gavin, [music] it's only been 2 months like the model release cycles, the gap like the model release cycles, the gap like the model release cycles, the gap between our podcast episodes are between our podcast episodes are between our podcast episodes are shortening. shortening. shortening. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> We're basically you and I are basically >> We're basically you and I are basically >> We're basically you and I are basically on a model release cadence at this on a model release cadence at this on a model release cadence at this point. point. point. >> Well, I was I was sensitive to criticism >> Well, I was I was sensitive to criticism >> Well, I was I was sensitive to criticism that um that um that um that I think somebody pointed out that that I think somebody pointed out that that I think somebody pointed out that um our podcasts were coincident with um our podcasts were coincident with um our podcasts were coincident with like like like local market peaks. local market peaks. local market peaks. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> And nobody can say that after this. >> And nobody can say that after this. >> And nobody can say that after this. >> What's on your mind? It's been a crazy >> What's on your mind? It's been a crazy >> What's on your mind? It's been a crazy crazy month. crazy month. crazy month. >> Yeah, I would describe >> Yeah, I would describe >> Yeah, I would describe um um um July as 2022 July as 2022 July as 2022 in a month. in a month. in a month. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> There are some fundamental negatives >> There are some fundamental negatives >> There are some fundamental negatives which you which we should talk. which you which we should talk. which you which we should talk. But like on on the whole, the balance of But like on on the whole, the balance of But like on on the whole, the balance of fundamentals I think is improving fundamentals I think is improving fundamentals I think is improving significantly. Loads of AI names are significantly. Loads of AI names are significantly. Loads of AI names are down 50 60% from their highs. We'll call down 50 60% from their highs. We'll call down 50 60% from their highs. We'll call it 40 to 60% in a month in a straight it 40 to 60% in a month in a straight it 40 to 60% in a month in a straight line. line. line. And I asked you before we started, And I asked you before we started, And I asked you before we started, you've you've been out here for the you've you've been out here for the you've you've been out here for the summer. Have you heard a single negative summer. Have you heard a single negative summer. Have you heard a single negative quantitative metric about AI? quantitative metric about AI? quantitative metric about AI? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> A single instance of deceleration. >> A single instance of deceleration. >> A single instance of deceleration. >> Nothing. >> Nothing. >> Nothing. >> Nothing. >> Nothing. >> Nothing. In fact, every metric is accelerating. In fact, every metric is accelerating. In fact, every metric is accelerating. >> And to your point, not just blind >> And to your point, not just blind >> And to your point, not just blind optimism from people excited about AI. optimism from people excited about AI. optimism from people excited about AI. Here's some data that they can show you Here's some data that they can show you Here's some data that they can show you and from their different vantage points. and from their different vantage points. and from their different vantage points. >> Absolutely. I mean, however you cut it, >> Absolutely. I mean, however you cut it, >> Absolutely. I mean, however you cut it, whether you cut whether you cut whether you cut GPU availability, whether you cut GPU GPU availability, whether you cut GPU GPU availability, whether you cut GPU retail pricing, retail pricing, retail pricing, I mean, whether you cut like the spot I mean, whether you cut like the spot I mean, whether you cut like the spot price of DRAM this month, price of DRAM this month, price of DRAM this month, token growth, token growth, token growth, everything is actually accelerated. everything is actually accelerated. everything is actually accelerated. And I do think a big part of the problem And I do think a big part of the problem And I do think a big part of the problem is is is one, the market does not have visibility one, the market does not have visibility one, the market does not have visibility into Anthropic, OpenAI, and then I would into Anthropic, OpenAI, and then I would into Anthropic, OpenAI, and then I would say these open-source inference clouds say these open-source inference clouds say these open-source inference clouds that monetize inference here in America, that monetize inference here in America, that monetize inference here in America, Fireworks, Baseten, Model together. Fireworks, Baseten, Model together. Fireworks, Baseten, Model together. >> [snorts] >> [snorts] >> [snorts] >> And the picture looks very different >> And the picture looks very different >> And the picture looks very different when you see that. Because open-source when you see that. Because open-source when you see that. Because open-source is accelerated massively because of GLM is accelerated massively because of GLM is accelerated massively because of GLM 5.2 KiB K3. 5.2 KiB K3. 5.2 KiB K3. And then, you know, Neurotron continues And then, you know, Neurotron continues And then, you know, Neurotron continues to kind of chug along. We had a great, to kind of chug along. We had a great, to kind of chug along. We had a great, you know, very small American you know, very small American you know, very small American open-source model release. OpenAI has open-source model release. OpenAI has open-source model release. OpenAI has accelerated. accelerated. accelerated. Anthropic continues to grow Anthropic continues to grow Anthropic continues to grow really strongly really strongly really strongly and is almost certainly pumping out and is almost certainly pumping out and is almost certainly pumping out significant amounts of free cash flow. significant amounts of free cash flow. significant amounts of free cash flow. And I just think if, you know, there's And I just think if, you know, there's And I just think if, you know, there's this chart that everybody looks at of this chart that everybody looks at of this chart that everybody looks at of semiconductor cash flow going like this semiconductor cash flow going like this semiconductor cash flow going like this and hyperscale cash and hyperscale cash and hyperscale cash free cash flow going like that, free cash flow going like that, free cash flow going like that, and is you're missing these private and is you're missing these private and is you're missing these private companies. And then, I also think that companies. And then, I also think that companies. And then, I also think that that chart, that chart, that chart, um, um, um, misses something very important, which misses something very important, which misses something very important, which is just that you have everyone in '24 is just that you have everyone in '24 is just that you have everyone in '24 and '25 thought, even if you were really and '25 thought, even if you were really and '25 thought, even if you were really bullish, you thought that GPU prices, if bullish, you thought that GPU prices, if bullish, you thought that GPU prices, if you were really bullish, you thought you were really bullish, you thought you were really bullish, you thought they would to price around a GPU would, they would to price around a GPU would, they would to price around a GPU would, you know, decline slowly. You know, if you know, decline slowly. You know, if you know, decline slowly. You know, if you're bearish, you thought it would you're bearish, you thought it would you're bearish, you thought it would decline precipitously. decline precipitously. decline precipitously. I I think anyone in 24 or 25 I I think anyone in 24 or 25 I I think anyone in 24 or 25 thought that the prices of old GPUs thought that the prices of old GPUs thought that the prices of old GPUs would still be would be going vertical would still be would be going vertical would still be would be going vertical in 2026. in 2026. in 2026. Yeah, and so everybody thought hey, Yeah, and so everybody thought hey, Yeah, and so everybody thought hey, we're going to be smart. We're going to we're going to be smart. We're going to we're going to be smart. We're going to sign these long-term contracts. sign these long-term contracts. sign these long-term contracts. And to some degree like a lot of the And to some degree like a lot of the And to some degree like a lot of the deal clouds had to do that because they deal clouds had to do that because they deal clouds had to do that because they needed an off-take agreement to finance needed an off-take agreement to finance needed an off-take agreement to finance the GPUs. the GPUs. the GPUs. And so essentially you have the And so essentially you have the And so essentially you have the contracted base of installed compute contracted base of installed compute contracted base of installed compute trading at a massive discount trading at a massive discount trading at a massive discount to the current spot market. to the current spot market. to the current spot market. And And And has those has those has those contracts roll off and compute gets contracts roll off and compute gets contracts roll off and compute gets repriced higher. repriced higher. repriced higher. It's spot could decline and compute will It's spot could decline and compute will It's spot could decline and compute will still get repriced higher. still get repriced higher. still get repriced higher. You know, I think you're going to see a You know, I think you're going to see a You know, I think you're going to see a lot of acceleration that's going to lot of acceleration that's going to lot of acceleration that's going to answer these ROI questions. answer these ROI questions. answer these ROI questions. You've started to see that this quarter You've started to see that this quarter You've started to see that this quarter if we look at operating cash flow, not if we look at operating cash flow, not if we look at operating cash flow, not free cash flow. Operating cash flow free cash flow. Operating cash flow free cash flow. Operating cash flow from Microsoft, Meta, and Amazon has from Microsoft, Meta, and Amazon has from Microsoft, Meta, and Amazon has reported accelerated from 28 to 32. reported accelerated from 28 to 32. reported accelerated from 28 to 32. There were some actually pretty big There were some actually pretty big There were some actually pretty big unusual items now like these unusual items now like these unusual items now like these hyperscalers they always seem to have hyperscalers they always seem to have hyperscalers they always seem to have like like like billions of dollars of legal expenses billions of dollars of legal expenses billions of dollars of legal expenses that are unusual. that are unusual. that are unusual. Mostly fines to the EU. Mostly fines to the EU. Mostly fines to the EU. But there was an unusual amount of But there was an unusual amount of But there was an unusual amount of one-timers this one-timers this one-timers this this quarter. If you adjust for that, we this quarter. If you adjust for that, we this quarter. If you adjust for that, we went from 28 to 35 and that's that's a went from 28 to 35 and that's that's a went from 28 to 35 and that's that's a that's a material acceleration at this that's a material acceleration at this that's a material acceleration at this scale. scale. scale. And that's really before And that's really before And that's really before like they start to light up the Rubins like they start to light up the Rubins like they start to light up the Rubins which will come at a meaningful premium which will come at a meaningful premium which will come at a meaningful premium before these contracts reprice. It's before these contracts reprice. It's before these contracts reprice. It's been a it's been a it's been a been a it's been a it's been a been a it's been a it's been a challenging month that it's almost um challenging month that it's almost um challenging month that it's almost um you know, like is it helpful to kind of you know, like is it helpful to kind of you know, like is it helpful to kind of like walk through the month? How we got like walk through the month? How we got like walk through the month? How we got here? You know, so first there's Meta is here? You know, so first there's Meta is here? You know, so first there's Meta is going to rent out compute. And this is going to rent out compute. And this is going to rent out compute. And this is seen as like very bearish. They have seen as like very bearish. They have seen as like very bearish. They have excess capacity. They're going to cut excess capacity. They're going to cut excess capacity. They're going to cut CapEx. CapEx. CapEx. This is a disaster. This is not at all This is a disaster. This is not at all This is a disaster. This is not at all what it was. They just reported. They what it was. They just reported. They what it was. They just reported. They didn't cut CapEx. What it was is they didn't cut CapEx. What it was is they didn't cut CapEx. What it was is they saw SpaceX have a big installed base of saw SpaceX have a big installed base of saw SpaceX have a big installed base of compute compute compute and sell some big trading optimized and sell some big trading optimized and sell some big trading optimized clusters into the market at a truly clusters into the market at a truly clusters into the market at a truly massive premium to these contracted massive premium to these contracted massive premium to these contracted rates. rates. rates. And And And you know, at least the at least at least you know, at least the at least at least you know, at least the at least at least analysts like that, they saw an analysts like that, they saw an analysts like that, they saw an opportunity. There's a lot of opportunity. There's a lot of opportunity. There's a lot of speculation they're going to raise speculation they're going to raise speculation they're going to raise capital. So, like capital. So, like capital. So, like you know, maybe what they're thinking is you know, maybe what they're thinking is you know, maybe what they're thinking is like, "Hey, we will show on a small like, "Hey, we will show on a small like, "Hey, we will show on a small chunk of capacity that we can generate chunk of capacity that we can generate chunk of capacity that we can generate really strong IRRs. Then we'll go raise really strong IRRs. Then we'll go raise really strong IRRs. Then we'll go raise equity capital and and we'll and we'll equity capital and and we'll and we'll equity capital and and we'll and we'll be off to the and we'll be off to the be off to the and we'll be off to the be off to the and we'll be off to the races and probably raise CapEx." races and probably raise CapEx." races and probably raise CapEx." It doesn't look like what that's what It doesn't look like what that's what It doesn't look like what that's what they're doing. But nevertheless, the they're doing. But nevertheless, the they're doing. But nevertheless, the market sold off because it interpreted market sold off because it interpreted market sold off because it interpreted this very negatively. this very negatively. this very negatively. And And And I was really sure it wasn't negative. I was really sure it wasn't negative. I was really sure it wasn't negative. You know, there's a lot of telemetry You know, there's a lot of telemetry You know, there's a lot of telemetry into Meta's CapEx plans. None of that into Meta's CapEx plans. None of that into Meta's CapEx plans. None of that telemetry had shifted at all. If telemetry had shifted at all. If telemetry had shifted at all. If anything, it was, you know, continuing anything, it was, you know, continuing anything, it was, you know, continuing to or continued to get more aggressive. to or continued to get more aggressive. to or continued to get more aggressive. And then shortly after that, they And then shortly after that, they And then shortly after that, they released their best model in a long released their best model in a long released their best model in a long time, use 1.1, which is actually really time, use 1.1, which is actually really time, use 1.1, which is actually really a very good model. I mean, it was a very good model. I mean, it was a very good model. I mean, it was overshadowed by Grok 4.5, overshadowed by Grok 4.5, overshadowed by Grok 4.5, but it was a good model. but it was a good model. but it was a good model. Um way better than anything in two Um way better than anything in two Um way better than anything in two years. So, just years. So, just years. So, just no chance they're taking their foot off no chance they're taking their foot off no chance they're taking their foot off the gas. Then Kimi comes out. the gas. Then Kimi comes out. the gas. Then Kimi comes out. And then there's this huge freak out And then there's this huge freak out And then there's this huge freak out about open source. And at the same time, about open source. And at the same time, about open source. And at the same time, this silica data this silica data this silica data token index kind of dips and flattens. token index kind of dips and flattens. token index kind of dips and flattens. And the two are connected. What the And the two are connected. What the And the two are connected. What the silica data token index captures is mix. silica data token index captures is mix. silica data token index captures is mix. And they don't see all the tokens, but And they don't see all the tokens, but And they don't see all the tokens, but because of GLM 5.2 and and and and then because of GLM 5.2 and and and and then because of GLM 5.2 and and and and then Kimi, all of it took a while to layer Kimi, all of it took a while to layer Kimi, all of it took a while to layer in. in. in. There's kind of a There's kind of a There's kind of a a mix shift in this data from more a mix shift in this data from more a mix shift in this data from more expensive frontier tokens, which expensive frontier tokens, which expensive frontier tokens, which probably have an inference margin probably have an inference margin probably have an inference margin we can debate whether it's 80, 90, or we can debate whether it's 80, 90, or we can debate whether it's 80, 90, or 95. 95. 95. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> But super high. >> But super high. >> But super high. Towards open source tokens. Towards open source tokens. Towards open source tokens. And for whatever reason, the market And for whatever reason, the market And for whatever reason, the market thought this was negative, but the thought this was negative, but the thought this was negative, but the reality is a token is a token, and you reality is a token is a token, and you reality is a token is a token, and you need the exact same amount of compute need the exact same amount of compute need the exact same amount of compute to make a token all else equal. Takes to make a token all else equal. Takes to make a token all else equal. Takes the same amount of flops, the same the same amount of flops, the same the same amount of flops, the same amount of memory, amount of memory, amount of memory, the same amount of watts. Now, tokens the same amount of watts. Now, tokens the same amount of watts. Now, tokens are not equal, but broadly speaking, are not equal, but broadly speaking, are not equal, but broadly speaking, all open source taking all open source taking all open source taking share does is kind of share does is kind of share does is kind of take margin dollars take margin dollars take margin dollars out of the out of the out of the uh frontier model layer uh frontier model layer uh frontier model layer and effectively by and effectively by and effectively by thereby, you know, there there is thereby, you know, there there is thereby, you know, there there is elasticity, thereby driving token elasticity, thereby driving token elasticity, thereby driving token demand. demand. demand. You need more demand for compute. And You need more demand for compute. And You need more demand for compute. And the margins, you know, Anthropic and the margins, you know, Anthropic and the margins, you know, Anthropic and open source, they all run on the same open source, they all run on the same open source, they all run on the same underlying cloud providers underlying cloud providers underlying cloud providers who charge the same amount of compute. who charge the same amount of compute. who charge the same amount of compute. You know, so you're literally just um You know, so you're literally just um You know, so you're literally just um taking margin from frontier models and taking margin from frontier models and taking margin from frontier models and essentially driving more margin dollars essentially driving more margin dollars essentially driving more margin dollars into the AI infrastructure layer. And into the AI infrastructure layer. And into the AI infrastructure layer. And like I think that's like I think that's like I think that's >> That was the catalyst. This this >> That was the catalyst. This this >> That was the catalyst. This this combination of things. combination of things. combination of things. >> Well, yeah, then it kept it it's it's >> Well, yeah, then it kept it it's it's >> Well, yeah, then it kept it it's it's like Jenson is the world's largest like Jenson is the world's largest like Jenson is the world's largest supporter of open source. supporter of open source. supporter of open source. Do we really And he's like a super Do we really And he's like a super Do we really And he's like a super idealistic guy. He's a patriotic idealistic guy. He's a patriotic idealistic guy. He's a patriotic American. American. American. I think he always does what's right. I think he always does what's right. I think he always does what's right. But is it does it really stand to reason But is it does it really stand to reason But is it does it really stand to reason that Jenson would be the world's biggest that Jenson would be the world's biggest that Jenson would be the world's biggest supporter of open source if it was bad supporter of open source if it was bad supporter of open source if it was bad for his business? for his business? for his business? >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> He'd still support if it was the right >> He'd still support if it was the right >> He'd still support if it was the right thing for the world. thing for the world. thing for the world. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> But maybe it wouldn't be a signature >> But maybe it wouldn't be a signature >> But maybe it wouldn't be a signature issue. issue. issue. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And by the way, I think open source is >> And by the way, I think open source is >> And by the way, I think open source is really important to world where there's really important to world where there's really important to world where there's just one or two dominant for tier just one or two dominant for tier just one or two dominant for tier bottles that charge like bottles that charge like bottles that charge like 90% margins. 90% margins. 90% margins. It's not good for humans. It might not It's not good for humans. It might not It's not good for humans. It might not be good for society. And I think we want be good for society. And I think we want be good for society. And I think we want a lot of bottles as we've discussed a lot of bottles as we've discussed a lot of bottles as we've discussed before. before. before. So then it's like, okay, the market So then it's like, okay, the market So then it's like, okay, the market digests that comes through with it. Then digests that comes through with it. Then digests that comes through with it. Then China has a DUV machine and this causes, China has a DUV machine and this causes, China has a DUV machine and this causes, you know, everybody said these baskets you know, everybody said these baskets you know, everybody said these baskets has caused a huge sell off in semi-cap has caused a huge sell off in semi-cap has caused a huge sell off in semi-cap equipment. equipment. equipment. And then we get to what I think is And then we get to what I think is And then we get to what I think is in a lot of ways, in a lot of ways, in a lot of ways, um um um like the real concern, which is real like the real concern, which is real like the real concern, which is real yields have gone up, which makes sense, yields have gone up, which makes sense, yields have gone up, which makes sense, you know, we're investing a lot you know, we're investing a lot you know, we're investing a lot to fund this investment and for sure to fund this investment and for sure to fund this investment and for sure credit is an increasing part of it even credit is an increasing part of it even credit is an increasing part of it even if the majority is still funded over if the majority is still funded over if the majority is still funded over what the majority is still funded out of what the majority is still funded out of what the majority is still funded out of operating cash flows. operating cash flows. operating cash flows. And so real yields go up and spreads And so real yields go up and spreads And so real yields go up and spreads widen. Meta Meta priced, um widen. Meta Meta priced, um widen. Meta Meta priced, um a bond last week and, you know, it it it a bond last week and, you know, it it it a bond last week and, you know, it it it did not price where you would think a did not price where you would think a did not price where you would think a meta bond would price. And this just meta bond would price. And this just meta bond would price. And this just shows that the credit market shows that the credit market shows that the credit market >> And the media CDS was was blowing >> And the media CDS was was blowing >> And the media CDS was was blowing >> All of these CD CDS for everybody is is >> All of these CD CDS for everybody is is >> All of these CD CDS for everybody is is blowing out. blowing out. blowing out. And, you know, very smart private And, you know, very smart private And, you know, very smart private capital people just like that, hey, this capital people just like that, hey, this capital people just like that, hey, this is just exactly is just exactly is just exactly what you would expect. These are just what you would expect. These are just what you would expect. These are just banks, you know, kind of hedging banks, you know, kind of hedging banks, you know, kind of hedging hedging their commitments. But hedging their commitments. But hedging their commitments. But nonetheless, it doesn't look good and nonetheless, it doesn't look good and nonetheless, it doesn't look good and these are undeniable facts. CDS is up, these are undeniable facts. CDS is up, these are undeniable facts. CDS is up, spreads are widened, real yield real spreads are widened, real yield real spreads are widened, real yield real yields are up. yields are up. yields are up. And that is that would be really really And that is that would be really really And that is that would be really really scary if we needed debt scary if we needed debt scary if we needed debt to finance this build out. to finance this build out. to finance this build out. And that's where I think it's this And that's where I think it's this And that's where I think it's this differential between spot and contract differential between spot and contract differential between spot and contract pricing for the installed base of pricing for the installed base of pricing for the installed base of compute is so important. compute is so important. compute is so important. >> Ramp is the only platform built to make >> Ramp is the only platform built to make >> Ramp is the only platform built to make your finance team leaner, faster, and your finance team leaner, faster, and your finance team leaner, faster, and better, saving businesses 5% annually better, saving businesses 5% annually better, saving businesses 5% annually [music] on average, so you can stay [music] on average, so you can stay [music] on average, so you can stay focused on growth. Ramp customers grew focused on growth. Ramp customers grew focused on growth. Ramp customers grew revenue 3.2 times faster than the revenue 3.2 times faster than the revenue 3.2 times faster than the average American business. [music] Visa, average American business. [music] Visa, average American business. [music] Visa, Foursquare, Cursor, Stripe, Notion, Foursquare, Cursor, Stripe, Notion, Foursquare, Cursor, Stripe, Notion, 11:FS, Shopify, and 70,000 other 11:FS, Shopify, and 70,000 other 11:FS, Shopify, and 70,000 other businesses all run on Ramp. Mine does, businesses all run on Ramp. Mine does, businesses all run on Ramp. Mine does, [music] too, and so should yours. Learn [music] too, and so should yours. Learn [music] too, and so should yours. Learn more at ramp.com/invest. more at ramp.com/invest. more at ramp.com/invest. >> The best AI and software companies from >> The best AI and software companies from >> The best AI and software companies from OpenAI to Cursor to Perplexity use OpenAI to Cursor to Perplexity use OpenAI to Cursor to Perplexity use WorkOS to become enterprise-ready WorkOS to become enterprise-ready WorkOS to become enterprise-ready overnight, not in months. Visit overnight, not in months. Visit overnight, not in months. Visit workos.com [music] to skip the workos.com [music] to skip the workos.com [music] to skip the unglamorous infrastructure work and unglamorous infrastructure work and unglamorous infrastructure work and focus on your product. focus on your product. focus on your product. >> Felix by Rogo is a personal finance >> Felix by Rogo is a personal finance >> Felix by Rogo is a personal finance agent that turns a single prompt into agent that turns a single prompt into agent that turns a single prompt into finished client-ready [music] work using finished client-ready [music] work using finished client-ready [music] work using your firm's own templates, contacts, and your firm's own templates, contacts, and your firm's own templates, contacts, and standards. Send Felix an email like, standards. Send Felix an email like, standards. Send Felix an email like, [music] "Take these comments and turn [music] "Take these comments and turn [music] "Take these comments and turn them for me." Or, "Update my tracker them for me." Or, "Update my tracker them for me." Or, "Update my tracker with the context of these emails." Or, with the context of these emails." Or, with the context of these emails." Or, "Run the ability to [music] pay math on "Run the ability to [music] pay math on "Run the ability to [music] pay math on this buyer." And Felix sends back this buyer." And Felix sends back this buyer." And Felix sends back finished PowerPoint decks, Excel models, finished PowerPoint decks, Excel models, finished PowerPoint decks, Excel models, and sourced [music] research. Felix and sourced [music] research. Felix and sourced [music] research. Felix works the way your team already does, works the way your team already does, works the way your team already does, delivering work quickly and accurately delivering work quickly and accurately delivering work quickly and accurately around the clock. Learn more at around the clock. Learn more at around the clock. Learn more at rogo.ai/felix. rogo.ai/felix. rogo.ai/felix. [music] [music] [music] >> It's so important to understand what the >> It's so important to understand what the >> It's so important to understand what the financing will be like for the next 6 financing will be like for the next 6 financing will be like for the next 6 months or something. months or something. months or something. >> The degree to which this buildout is >> The degree to which this buildout is >> The degree to which this buildout is going to require credit. going to require credit. going to require credit. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> Which would be the classic like capital >> Which would be the classic like capital >> Which would be the classic like capital cycle, and then we start to overextend cycle, and then we start to overextend cycle, and then we start to overextend ourselves with debt, and that's where ourselves with debt, and that's where ourselves with debt, and that's where things get dicey. things get dicey. things get dicey. >> 100% to the, you know, debt-fueled >> 100% to the, you know, debt-fueled >> 100% to the, you know, debt-fueled buildouts, you know, they demand buildouts, you know, they demand buildouts, you know, they demand immediate repayment. Yeah. So, if supply immediate repayment. Yeah. So, if supply immediate repayment. Yeah. So, if supply and demand get a little bit out of and demand get a little bit out of and demand get a little bit out of whack, things can unwind very, very, whack, things can unwind very, very, whack, things can unwind very, very, very quickly. That's what happened to very quickly. That's what happened to very quickly. That's what happened to the internet. the internet. the internet. And so, And so, And so, if if if one believes as I do, rightly or one believes as I do, rightly or one believes as I do, rightly or wrongly, and I'm like, after this month, wrongly, and I'm like, after this month, wrongly, and I'm like, after this month, I'm super open, I'm super open, I'm super open, you know, I'm I'm looking like I've been you know, I'm I'm looking like I've been you know, I'm I'm looking like I've been pressure testing all of these, and like, pressure testing all of these, and like, pressure testing all of these, and like, I really went deep on credit because, I really went deep on credit because, I really went deep on credit because, hey, this is real, it's undeniable. hey, this is real, it's undeniable. hey, this is real, it's undeniable. And if we need credit to fund this And if we need credit to fund this And if we need credit to fund this buildout, buildout, buildout, this is like a significant negative. this is like a significant negative. this is like a significant negative. >> [snorts] >> [snorts] >> [snorts] >> And >> And >> And if you model it out, if you model it out, if you model it out, has has has if you look at the amount of gigawatts if you look at the amount of gigawatts if you look at the amount of gigawatts that are supposed to come out that are supposed to come out that are supposed to come out in consensus estimates in consensus estimates in consensus estimates for hyperscalers, they're effectively for hyperscalers, they're effectively for hyperscalers, they're effectively modeled and these are gigawatts of modeled and these are gigawatts of modeled and these are gigawatts of Blackwell and Rubin. Blackwell and Rubin. Blackwell and Rubin. Rubin being Nvidia's next chip, Rubin being Nvidia's next chip, Rubin being Nvidia's next chip, Blackwell being the current chip. Blackwell being the current chip. Blackwell being the current chip. They are essentially modeled They are essentially modeled They are essentially modeled to monetize roughly at the rate of to monetize roughly at the rate of to monetize roughly at the rate of Ampere, Ampere, Ampere, which is two generations behind. Not at which is two generations behind. Not at which is two generations behind. Not at Hopper, but Ampere. So, there's 1.3 Hopper, but Ampere. So, there's 1.3 Hopper, but Ampere. So, there's 1.3 trillion and 1.3 to 1.4 trillion in trillion and 1.3 to 1.4 trillion in trillion and 1.3 to 1.4 trillion in hyperscale operating cash flow. hyperscale operating cash flow. hyperscale operating cash flow. If you just assume that they If you just assume that they If you just assume that they they're not I I think it's very unlikely they're not I I think it's very unlikely they're not I I think it's very unlikely they monetize at the rate of Ampere and they monetize at the rate of Ampere and they monetize at the rate of Ampere and we can we can go into why. Some of it we can we can go into why. Some of it we can we can go into why. Some of it comes from just, you know, seeing what comes from just, you know, seeing what comes from just, you know, seeing what is happening on the ground with demand is happening on the ground with demand is happening on the ground with demand here for real quantitative metrics. here for real quantitative metrics. here for real quantitative metrics. But, like, let's just say they monetize But, like, let's just say they monetize But, like, let's just say they monetize at a discount to current Blackwells. at a discount to current Blackwells. at a discount to current Blackwells. Then it's more like 2 trillion of Then it's more like 2 trillion of Then it's more like 2 trillion of operating cash flow operating cash flow operating cash flow and that kind of takes 700 billion of and that kind of takes 700 billion of and that kind of takes 700 billion of credit demand out. Um credit demand out. Um credit demand out. Um and, you know, and then obviously these, and, you know, and then obviously these, and, you know, and then obviously these, you know, ironically, has, you know, you know, ironically, has, you know, you know, ironically, has, you know, that improves all the credit ratios, has that improves all the credit ratios, has that improves all the credit ratios, has these installed bases of compute these installed bases of compute these installed bases of compute reprice. reprice. reprice. We're going to continue accelerating. We're going to continue accelerating. We're going to continue accelerating. Consensus is modeling in a deceleration, Consensus is modeling in a deceleration, Consensus is modeling in a deceleration, which I think is unlikely. which I think is unlikely. which I think is unlikely. Um then the credit metrics look better Um then the credit metrics look better Um then the credit metrics look better and then all of a sudden and then all of a sudden and then all of a sudden it gets easier to finance with credit. it gets easier to finance with credit. it gets easier to finance with credit. Now, Now, Now, whether they whether they they choose to whether they whether they they choose to whether they whether they they choose to do that or not, we'll see, but this this do that or not, we'll see, but this this do that or not, we'll see, but this this is all a little bit, um you know, I is all a little bit, um you know, I is all a little bit, um you know, I think we spoke think we spoke think we spoke >> 2 months ago. >> 2 months ago. >> 2 months ago. >> No, but the time before that about kind >> No, but the time before that about kind >> No, but the time before that about kind of the risks of a Blackwell air pocket of the risks of a Blackwell air pocket of the risks of a Blackwell air pocket where you're spending where you're spending where you're spending hundreds of billions of dollars on hundreds of billions of dollars on hundreds of billions of dollars on Blackwells. they're mostly being used Blackwells. they're mostly being used Blackwells. they're mostly being used for trading initially. Trading does not for trading initially. Trading does not for trading initially. Trading does not generate, you know, a return. generate, you know, a return. generate, you know, a return. And that this could be a risk. And And that this could be a risk. And And that this could be a risk. And we actually really saw that kind of it, we actually really saw that kind of it, we actually really saw that kind of it, you know, in the first quarter. you know, in the first quarter. you know, in the first quarter. And And And I think one reason, you know, like to I think one reason, you know, like to I think one reason, you know, like to the podcast two months ago, the podcast two months ago, the podcast two months ago, I I got comfortable with that risk was I I got comfortable with that risk was I I got comfortable with that risk was just that you were seeing such just that you were seeing such just that you were seeing such incredible things out of Anthropic. incredible things out of Anthropic. incredible things out of Anthropic. And then it's like, "Okay, well, the And then it's like, "Okay, well, the And then it's like, "Okay, well, the market's kind of going to look past market's kind of going to look past market's kind of going to look past this." this." this." And it did look past it in April, in And it did look past it in April, in And it did look past it in April, in May, in June. May, in June. May, in June. And then in July, because of this kind And then in July, because of this kind And then in July, because of this kind of confluence of things, stopped looking of confluence of things, stopped looking of confluence of things, stopped looking past it. past it. past it. Just as the operating cash flow Just as the operating cash flow Just as the operating cash flow started to really accelerate. And it's started to really accelerate. And it's started to really accelerate. And it's this is just a fact. It is accelerating this is just a fact. It is accelerating this is just a fact. It is accelerating at big scale. at big scale. at big scale. Um Um Um and you know, like Microsoft, they and you know, like Microsoft, they and you know, like Microsoft, they brought out a huge slug of capacity in brought out a huge slug of capacity in brought out a huge slug of capacity in the month of June. That didn't even show the month of June. That didn't even show the month of June. That didn't even show up in the second quarter. up in the second quarter. up in the second quarter. So essentially, what this So essentially, what this So essentially, what this all comes down to is do you believe that all comes down to is do you believe that all comes down to is do you believe that the kind of the kind of the kind of quantitative demand signals quantitative demand signals quantitative demand signals seeing on the ground here in Silicon seeing on the ground here in Silicon seeing on the ground here in Silicon Valley from from private companies are Valley from from private companies are Valley from from private companies are going to continue such that going to continue such that going to continue such that the installed base of compute reprices the installed base of compute reprices the installed base of compute reprices higher as contracts roll off. higher as contracts roll off. higher as contracts roll off. >> Operating cash flows go up. >> Operating cash flows go up. >> Operating cash flows go up. >> Yeah, operating cash flows go up and you >> Yeah, operating cash flows go up and you >> Yeah, operating cash flows go up and you can fund this out of most of this out of can fund this out of most of this out of can fund this out of most of this out of operating cash flows. Maybe all of it. operating cash flows. Maybe all of it. operating cash flows. Maybe all of it. Like if it reprices at current rates, Like if it reprices at current rates, Like if it reprices at current rates, you could probably fund all of it for you could probably fund all of it for you could probably fund all of it for the next several years. the next several years. the next several years. It's so it's it's been a it has been a It's so it's it's been a it has been a It's so it's it's been a it has been a very un- very un- very un- usual episode in the market. usual episode in the market. usual episode in the market. And And And you know, in some ways, the fact that you know, in some ways, the fact that you know, in some ways, the fact that and we should talk about what the and we should talk about what the and we should talk about what the fundamentals are that are getting better fundamentals are that are getting better fundamentals are that are getting better that I'm talking about. that I'm talking about. that I'm talking about. You know, technicians would say it's You know, technicians would say it's You know, technicians would say it's actually in '22, actually in '22, actually in '22, okay, the market is worried about a okay, the market is worried about a okay, the market is worried about a recession, recession, recession, rates going up, rates going up, rates going up, you know, inflation. That's what the you know, inflation. That's what the you know, inflation. That's what the market was worried about in '22. You market was worried about in '22. You market was worried about in '22. You knew exactly what it was. Okay, deep knew exactly what it was. Okay, deep knew exactly what it was. Okay, deep seek, you know what it's worried about. seek, you know what it's worried about. seek, you know what it's worried about. Liberation day, you know what it's Liberation day, you know what it's Liberation day, you know what it's worried about. Uh there's something very worried about. Uh there's something very worried about. Uh there's something very clear and it in a weird way that's that clear and it in a weird way that's that clear and it in a weird way that's that is comforting reassuring. And here, you is comforting reassuring. And here, you is comforting reassuring. And here, you know, we talked about a lot of specific know, we talked about a lot of specific know, we talked about a lot of specific things, but it just feels all those things, but it just feels all those things, but it just feels all those specific things with the exception of specific things with the exception of specific things with the exception of credit credit credit like are are just kind of ridiculous. like are are just kind of ridiculous. like are are just kind of ridiculous. Um it's to the fact that it is still Um it's to the fact that it is still Um it's to the fact that it is still going down. going down. going down. You know, a technician would say, "Hey, You know, a technician would say, "Hey, You know, a technician would say, "Hey, that's that's that's that's a little scary. You know, it's that's a little scary. You know, it's that's a little scary. You know, it's definitionally the bullet you don't see definitionally the bullet you don't see definitionally the bullet you don't see that gets you." You know, I think we've that gets you." You know, I think we've that gets you." You know, I think we've talked before about how like I think the talked before about how like I think the talked before about how like I think the three most important words in investing three most important words in investing three most important words in investing aren't margin of safety, but I don't aren't margin of safety, but I don't aren't margin of safety, but I don't know. But just, you know, I've you've you've But just, you know, I've you've you've been out here for 2 months. I've been been out here for 2 months. I've been been out here for 2 months. I've been out here, you know, out here, you know, out here, you know, I literally spoke to a company this I literally spoke to a company this I literally spoke to a company this morning who rented a cluster of several morning who rented a cluster of several morning who rented a cluster of several and this is one of, you know, kind of and this is one of, you know, kind of and this is one of, you know, kind of sexiest startups that people want to be sexiest startups that people want to be sexiest startups that people want to be in business with. in business with. in business with. And they had rented a cluster of several And they had rented a cluster of several And they had rented a cluster of several thousand block wells. thousand block wells. thousand block wells. And we'll just call it, you know, And we'll just call it, you know, And we'll just call it, you know, somewhere in the mid $2 per GPU hour. somewhere in the mid $2 per GPU hour. somewhere in the mid $2 per GPU hour. They're renting the exact same cluster, They're renting the exact same cluster, They're renting the exact same cluster, exact same size cluster, exact same size cluster, exact same size cluster, essentially identical in every way, essentially identical in every way, essentially identical in every way, B200s. Said, "No no differences." B200s. Said, "No no differences." B200s. Said, "No no differences." And they're hoping And they're hoping And they're hoping 7 months later 7 months later 7 months later to pay just under $4. to pay just under $4. to pay just under $4. Like you know, just you hear this today. Like you know, just you hear this today. Like you know, just you hear this today. And that's And that's And that's like that's pretty crazy because again, like that's pretty crazy because again, like that's pretty crazy because again, you would just you would expect a really you would just you would expect a really you would just you would expect a really like a gentle decline in prices would be like a gentle decline in prices would be like a gentle decline in prices would be bullish. bullish. bullish. Instead, you know, we're up, you know, Instead, you know, we're up, you know, Instead, you know, we're up, you know, depending on the starting point depending on the starting point depending on the starting point 50 to 60% in 6 or 7 months. 50 to 60% in 6 or 7 months. 50 to 60% in 6 or 7 months. And it just there've been so many And it just there've been so many And it just there've been so many anecdotes like that. Like I think one of anecdotes like that. Like I think one of anecdotes like that. Like I think one of the inference clouds the inference clouds the inference clouds I think it was based in I'm not sure. I think it was based in I'm not sure. I think it was based in I'm not sure. They went on a podcast and they They went on a podcast and they They went on a podcast and they essentially said essentially said essentially said we are planning to pay 100% more we are planning to pay 100% more we are planning to pay 100% more for Blackwell's when our contract for Blackwell's when our contract for Blackwell's when our contract expires. And that just means that expires. And that just means that expires. And that just means that essentially all the hyperscalers are essentially all the hyperscalers are essentially all the hyperscalers are under running. under running. under running. And I haven't like my main kind of And I haven't like my main kind of And I haven't like my main kind of mission out here this week mission out here this week mission out here this week >> It's like pressure test? >> It's like pressure test? >> It's like pressure test? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Find tell me something negative, you >> Find tell me something negative, you >> Find tell me something negative, you know? Like you know, the question I know? Like you know, the question I know? Like you know, the question I asked you, have you is there one asked you, have you is there one asked you, have you is there one negative quantitative metric you've negative quantitative metric you've negative quantitative metric you've you've heard? Has been what I've been you've heard? Has been what I've been you've heard? Has been what I've been asking everyone. asking everyone. asking everyone. >> The main thing people are saying is the >> The main thing people are saying is the >> The main thing people are saying is the Anthropic like the third-party data Anthropic like the third-party data Anthropic like the third-party data suggests that the Anthropic like curve suggests that the Anthropic like curve suggests that the Anthropic like curve started to started to started to go off of its trajectory a little bit. go off of its trajectory a little bit. go off of its trajectory a little bit. That's like the only thing that I That's like the only thing that I That's like the only thing that I >> I think I think that's I think that may >> I think I think that's I think that may >> I think I think that's I think that may very well be true, but then you have very well be true, but then you have very well be true, but then you have OpenAI and open source massively OpenAI and open source massively OpenAI and open source massively accelerating. accelerating. accelerating. And if you look at the sub And if you look at the sub And if you look at the sub it is not accelerating. Maybe I don't it is not accelerating. Maybe I don't it is not accelerating. Maybe I don't know that it looks the same. I think it know that it looks the same. I think it know that it looks the same. I think it may have accelerated. Like I think open may have accelerated. Like I think open may have accelerated. Like I think open source is a little bit of a source is a little bit of a source is a little bit of a you know, they talk about dark matter in you know, they talk about dark matter in you know, they talk about dark matter in the universe. Like open source is kind the universe. Like open source is kind the universe. Like open source is kind of dark matter to the public markets. of dark matter to the public markets. of dark matter to the public markets. You know, it's hard for public markets You know, it's hard for public markets You know, it's hard for public markets to measure it. to measure it. to measure it. But like if you just track what these But like if you just track what these But like if you just track what these inference clouds are saying inference clouds are saying inference clouds are saying and you know, these are people saying and you know, these are people saying and you know, these are people saying things on podcasts or people saying things on podcasts or people saying things on podcasts or people saying things in meetings things in meetings things in meetings they're not you know, audited financials they're not you know, audited financials they're not you know, audited financials but like demand is clearly accelerating but like demand is clearly accelerating but like demand is clearly accelerating which makes sense cuz you had this huge which makes sense cuz you had this huge which makes sense cuz you had this huge capability leap which you learn 5.2 and capability leap which you learn 5.2 and capability leap which you learn 5.2 and KBK3 KBK3 KBK3 which I think we're going to see which I think we're going to see which I think we're going to see continue. I think you're going to see continue. I think you're going to see continue. I think you're going to see Nvidia bring Neobtron steadily closer to Nvidia bring Neobtron steadily closer to Nvidia bring Neobtron steadily closer to the frontier. It has been a very like the frontier. It has been a very like the frontier. It has been a very like it's been a hubbly it's been a hubbly it's been a hubbly challenging month and but just challenging month and but just challenging month and but just it's also like wow, I've kind of it's also like wow, I've kind of it's also like wow, I've kind of pressure tested every assumption. pressure tested every assumption. pressure tested every assumption. The underlying fundamentals are The underlying fundamentals are The underlying fundamentals are improving. improving. improving. Uh and stocks Nvidia's actually as we Uh and stocks Nvidia's actually as we Uh and stocks Nvidia's actually as we record this record this record this at its lowest forward PE of the last 10 at its lowest forward PE of the last 10 at its lowest forward PE of the last 10 years. years. years. >> Crazy. >> Crazy. >> Crazy. >> The only time the Sibbys have been >> The only time the Sibbys have been >> The only time the Sibbys have been cheaper were liberation day deep seek cheaper were liberation day deep seek cheaper were liberation day deep seek and that was and that was and that was those were kind of uh V bottoms. those were kind of uh V bottoms. those were kind of uh V bottoms. Um Um Um >> And that means to you just that the >> And that means to you just that the >> And that means to you just that the market thinks they're significantly over market thinks they're significantly over market thinks they're significantly over earning? earning? earning? >> Yeah, the market 100% thinks they're >> Yeah, the market 100% thinks they're >> Yeah, the market 100% thinks they're significantly over earning. significantly over earning. significantly over earning. And you And you And you we need to be humble. we need to be humble. we need to be humble. >> Maybe they are. >> Maybe they are. >> Maybe they are. >> Maybe they are. >> Maybe they are. >> Maybe they are. Um Um Um but like my kind of mission out here but like my kind of mission out here but like my kind of mission out here this week was to look this week was to look this week was to look for negative data points as hard as I for negative data points as hard as I for negative data points as hard as I could. I normally come to Silicon Valley could. I normally come to Silicon Valley could. I normally come to Silicon Valley and you know, there's a mixture of like and you know, there's a mixture of like and you know, there's a mixture of like okay, here's here's something negative, okay, here's here's something negative, okay, here's here's something negative, here's something positive, da da da. On here's something positive, da da da. On here's something positive, da da da. On balance, it's positive, you know, tech balance, it's positive, you know, tech balance, it's positive, you know, tech it creates value over time. it creates value over time. it creates value over time. But I haven't been able to find one that But I haven't been able to find one that But I haven't been able to find one that is like a quantitative metric. Other is like a quantitative metric. Other is like a quantitative metric. Other like that that Anthropic third-party like that that Anthropic third-party like that that Anthropic third-party data, I would say that seems to be a data, I would say that seems to be a data, I would say that seems to be a hotly contested by the um hotly contested by the um hotly contested by the um by the Anthropic shareholders who are by the Anthropic shareholders who are by the Anthropic shareholders who are like like like >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> who are bound or kind of like chopping >> who are bound or kind of like chopping >> who are bound or kind of like chopping at the bit to tell you what they know. at the bit to tell you what they know. at the bit to tell you what they know. They're also very scared they're not They're also very scared they're not They're also very scared they're not going to get an IPO allocation going to get an IPO allocation going to get an IPO allocation >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> if it gets back to the company that >> if it gets back to the company that >> if it gets back to the company that they're the ones who said, "Actually they're the ones who said, "Actually they're the ones who said, "Actually things are great." You know, you can things are great." You know, you can things are great." You know, you can just see Anthropic shareholders just see Anthropic shareholders just see Anthropic shareholders like they want to be like, "It's not like they want to be like, "It's not like they want to be like, "It's not true." You know. true." You know. true." You know. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> I mean, it's hard for me to believe that >> I mean, it's hard for me to believe that >> I mean, it's hard for me to believe that um um um open source and open AI have accelerated open source and open AI have accelerated open source and open AI have accelerated to the extent they did and but yeah, to the extent they did and but yeah, to the extent they did and but yeah, Anthropic is clearly, you know, kind of Anthropic is clearly, you know, kind of Anthropic is clearly, you know, kind of in the in the in the in the pole position. And oh, by the in the pole position. And oh, by the in the pole position. And oh, by the way, you know, Grok and Cursor have way, you know, Grok and Cursor have way, you know, Grok and Cursor have also, you can see from third-party data, also, you can see from third-party data, also, you can see from third-party data, like July was a pretty transformational like July was a pretty transformational like July was a pretty transformational month with um month with um month with um Grock 4.5 Grock builds coming out. So, Grock 4.5 Grock builds coming out. So, Grock 4.5 Grock builds coming out. So, it has been a tricky month and um and I have I have a friend um and I have I have a friend um I have a friend at Fidelity I have a friend at Fidelity I have a friend at Fidelity who just says the way to have navigated who just says the way to have navigated who just says the way to have navigated like the last 3 years like the last 3 years like the last 3 years is just do the dumbest, most superficial is just do the dumbest, most superficial is just do the dumbest, most superficial thing as quickly as possible and just thing as quickly as possible and just thing as quickly as possible and just cycle between them. cycle between them. cycle between them. >> What is that? What is that now? >> What is that? What is that now? >> What is that? What is that now? >> Well, that's just that has been to cut >> Well, that's just that has been to cut >> Well, that's just that has been to cut risk risk risk all month in response to these all month in response to these all month in response to these kind of narratives that just kind of narratives that just kind of narratives that just like factually except for credit like factually except for credit like factually except for credit are not true and the work we've done are not true and the work we've done are not true and the work we've done makes me think that credit just isn't makes me think that credit just isn't makes me think that credit just isn't going to matter has this reprice. Let's going to matter has this reprice. Let's going to matter has this reprice. Let's just say you do need credit just say you do need credit just say you do need credit to like build the flops we eat. Well, if to like build the flops we eat. Well, if to like build the flops we eat. Well, if credit's not there, it just means the credit's not there, it just means the credit's not there, it just means the flops that are there flops that are there flops that are there are going to be even more valuable cuz are going to be even more valuable cuz are going to be even more valuable cuz there is an interesting like essay that there is an interesting like essay that there is an interesting like essay that got sent sent to me. got sent sent to me. got sent sent to me. You know, I think we've talked before You know, I think we've talked before You know, I think we've talked before about Mike Mauboussin's theory that like about Mike Mauboussin's theory that like about Mike Mauboussin's theory that like a breakdown of diversity is kind of what a breakdown of diversity is kind of what a breakdown of diversity is kind of what leads leads leads you know, to bubbles and crashes. you know, to bubbles and crashes. you know, to bubbles and crashes. And essentially everyone I know in the And essentially everyone I know in the And essentially everyone I know in the public equity investment business, public equity investment business, public equity investment business, whether retail or institutional whether retail or institutional whether retail or institutional everything immediately, every piece of everything immediately, every piece of everything immediately, every piece of news gets fed into Claude. news gets fed into Claude. news gets fed into Claude. And Claude Claude code, sometimes, you And Claude Claude code, sometimes, you And Claude Claude code, sometimes, you know, a Claude agent know, a Claude agent know, a Claude agent and you know, Claude it's probabilistic. and you know, Claude it's probabilistic. and you know, Claude it's probabilistic. There's probably not that much variation There's probably not that much variation There's probably not that much variation in the way it's interpreting this news. in the way it's interpreting this news. in the way it's interpreting this news. It's uh it's almost like we're back to It's uh it's almost like we're back to It's uh it's almost like we're back to um um um you know, in stock market terms you know, in stock market terms you know, in stock market terms like the like there's never really been like the like there's never really been like the like there's never really been this way in the stock market before, but this way in the stock market before, but this way in the stock market before, but people talk about the fragmentation of people talk about the fragmentation of people talk about the fragmentation of media and how it used to be like Walter media and how it used to be like Walter media and how it used to be like Walter Cronkite was the only voice of truth and Cronkite was the only voice of truth and Cronkite was the only voice of truth and now we don't have that anymore. now we don't have that anymore. now we don't have that anymore. It's like Claude It's like Claude It's like Claude is kind of Walter Cronkite for the stock is kind of Walter Cronkite for the stock is kind of Walter Cronkite for the stock market and everybody just believes market and everybody just believes market and everybody just believes >> Whatever it says. >> Whatever it says. >> Whatever it says. >> Whatever it says. [laughter] >> Whatever it says. [laughter] >> Whatever it says. [laughter] And this is leading to like And this is leading to like And this is leading to like >> really and and by the way, it's really >> really and and by the way, it's really >> really and and by the way, it's really smart, smart, smart, but it's not but it's not but it's not always right. It's not always right. It's not always right. It's not um it's interpretation isn't always um it's interpretation isn't always um it's interpretation isn't always correct. And with the stock market, you correct. And with the stock market, you correct. And with the stock market, you are fundamentally dealing about, you are fundamentally dealing about, you are fundamentally dealing about, you know, a probabilistic Bayesian know, a probabilistic Bayesian know, a probabilistic Bayesian interpretation of the future. interpretation of the future. interpretation of the future. And so it just it feels like And so it just it feels like And so it just it feels like in the market, there is this in the market, there is this in the market, there is this Here's this piece of news. It gets fed Here's this piece of news. It gets fed Here's this piece of news. It gets fed through Claude. Claude interpreted this through Claude. Claude interpreted this through Claude. Claude interpreted this way. way. way. 90 a huge chunk of people 90 a huge chunk of people 90 a huge chunk of people trade on Claude's view. trade on Claude's view. trade on Claude's view. Um Um Um And so you've seen stuff. There's this And so you've seen stuff. There's this And so you've seen stuff. There's this guy uh TBU, TBU. He's like part of like guy uh TBU, TBU. He's like part of like guy uh TBU, TBU. He's like part of like the autonomous semiconductor mafia, but the autonomous semiconductor mafia, but the autonomous semiconductor mafia, but he posted this amazing chart of Japanese he posted this amazing chart of Japanese he posted this amazing chart of Japanese capacitor stocks. capacitor stocks. capacitor stocks. And he said we've had a capacitor an And he said we've had a capacitor an And he said we've had a capacitor an entire capacitor cycle in 6 weeks. And entire capacitor cycle in 6 weeks. And entire capacitor cycle in 6 weeks. And it's true, you know, the stocks like it's true, you know, the stocks like it's true, you know, the stocks like whether they double, triple, or whether they double, triple, or whether they double, triple, or quadruple, I don't know, but like quadruple, I don't know, but like quadruple, I don't know, but like vertical. vertical. vertical. And then whoosh, you know what I mean? And then whoosh, you know what I mean? And then whoosh, you know what I mean? Like the actual fundamentals haven't Like the actual fundamentals haven't Like the actual fundamentals haven't even hit. And yet you've already had even hit. And yet you've already had even hit. And yet you've already had what probably would have normally been a what probably would have normally been a what probably would have normally been a 3-year cycle 3-year cycle 3-year cycle in like 6 weeks. in like 6 weeks. in like 6 weeks. >> What's your sense of being out here >> What's your sense of being out here >> What's your sense of being out here especially it makes me especially especially it makes me especially especially it makes me especially curious about this, the innovation that curious about this, the innovation that curious about this, the innovation that is going on here to improve the is going on here to improve the is going on here to improve the efficiency and every aspect of serving efficiency and every aspect of serving efficiency and every aspect of serving inference, of training models, et inference, of training models, et inference, of training models, et cetera, and how that will affect like cetera, and how that will affect like cetera, and how that will affect like public markets over time. Like have you public markets over time. Like have you public markets over time. Like have you learned anything interesting about like learned anything interesting about like learned anything interesting about like the long lead time innovation type stuff the long lead time innovation type stuff the long lead time innovation type stuff that has you especially excited or or that has you especially excited or or that has you especially excited or or curious? curious? curious? >> Yeah, I am very curious. It was >> Yeah, I am very curious. It was >> Yeah, I am very curious. It was like all there seemed to be like all there seemed to be like all there seemed to be like a lot of people seem to feel like like a lot of people seem to feel like like a lot of people seem to feel like they're very close they're very close they're very close to solving continual learning and to solving continual learning and to solving continual learning and sample-efficient learning, which we've sample-efficient learning, which we've sample-efficient learning, which we've talked about before. And it is possible talked about before. And it is possible talked about before. And it is possible that if those are solved that, you know, that if those are solved that, you know, that if those are solved that, you know, could that be like a temporary like kind could that be like a temporary like kind could that be like a temporary like kind of like discontinuity? of like discontinuity? of like discontinuity? You know, it demand if it's that of, you You know, it demand if it's that of, you You know, it demand if it's that of, you know, having to like I think somebody know, having to like I think somebody know, having to like I think somebody told me that the uh told me that the uh told me that the uh like I was traded on effectively 20 like I was traded on effectively 20 like I was traded on effectively 20 billion tokens, and then it's like these billion tokens, and then it's like these billion tokens, and then it's like these models are traded on 300 trillion models are traded on 300 trillion models are traded on 300 trillion tokens. And if, you know, you could tokens. And if, you know, you could tokens. And if, you know, you could trade something on 10 trillion tokens trade something on 10 trillion tokens trade something on 10 trillion tokens and then let it out into the world and and then let it out into the world and and then let it out into the world and learn sample efficiently, learn sample efficiently, learn sample efficiently, you know, that that doesn't sound good you know, that that doesn't sound good you know, that that doesn't sound good for trading demand, but like trading as for trading demand, but like trading as for trading demand, but like trading as a percentage of a percentage of a percentage of semiconductor demand and compute semiconductor demand and compute semiconductor demand and compute is going to asymptote to something not is going to asymptote to something not is going to asymptote to something not approaching zero, but very small. But I approaching zero, but very small. But I approaching zero, but very small. But I would say that is the most kind of would say that is the most kind of would say that is the most kind of interesting, and you know, who knows if interesting, and you know, who knows if interesting, and you know, who knows if it's long horizon or short horizon. it's long horizon or short horizon. it's long horizon or short horizon. You know, SSI says that they're going to You know, SSI says that they're going to You know, SSI says that they're going to come out, you know, with their their come out, you know, with their their come out, you know, with their their model in in August. You know, there's model in in August. You know, there's model in in August. You know, there's this whole generation of new labs that this whole generation of new labs that this whole generation of new labs that are focused on this. are focused on this. are focused on this. >> And this would be good for the world. >> And this would be good for the world. >> And this would be good for the world. >> This would be amazing for the world, >> This would be amazing for the world, >> This would be amazing for the world, yeah. This would be awesome for the yeah. This would be awesome for the yeah. This would be awesome for the world. world. world. >> Yeah, we all want we want this, right? >> Yeah, we all want we want this, right? >> Yeah, we all want we want this, right? >> Yeah, we want this. It would be amazing >> Yeah, we want this. It would be amazing >> Yeah, we want this. It would be amazing for the world, and it's just it's hard for the world, and it's just it's hard for the world, and it's just it's hard for me to believe that that would for me to believe that that would for me to believe that that would actually be negative for AI actually be negative for AI actually be negative for AI infrastructure demand. But again, trying infrastructure demand. But again, trying infrastructure demand. But again, trying to be really, really open-minded. I I to be really, really open-minded. I I to be really, really open-minded. I I would say that was probably would say that was probably would say that was probably like the biggest like what what do we like the biggest like what what do we like the biggest like what what do we call it? Scientific or technical call it? Scientific or technical call it? Scientific or technical takeaway. takeaway. takeaway. But it's just, you know, it's also But it's just, you know, it's also But it's just, you know, it's also >> We still don't know. >> We still don't know. >> We still don't know. >> Well, yeah, and also like Nvidia is >> Well, yeah, and also like Nvidia is >> Well, yeah, and also like Nvidia is heavily involved with heavily involved with heavily involved with all of these startups. all of these startups. all of these startups. >> So, what would like if I was forced to >> So, what would like if I was forced to >> So, what would like if I was forced to if If just forced to come up with if If just forced to come up with if If just forced to come up with the set of circumstances that would the set of circumstances that would the set of circumstances that would really switch you around and get you really switch you around and get you really switch you around and get you really scared. really scared. really scared. Is it would it just be Is it would it just be Is it would it just be that this operating cash flow thing that this operating cash flow thing that this operating cash flow thing doesn't play out and therefore we just doesn't play out and therefore we just doesn't play out and therefore we just need to debt finance this whole thing? need to debt finance this whole thing? need to debt finance this whole thing? >> cash flow does not continue to >> cash flow does not continue to >> cash flow does not continue to accelerate. That that would be negative. accelerate. That that would be negative. accelerate. That that would be negative. Um it that to some degree is going to be Um it that to some degree is going to be Um it that to some degree is going to be a function of how Anthropic, Open AI, a function of how Anthropic, Open AI, a function of how Anthropic, Open AI, Grok Cursor, we should call it Grok, and Grok Cursor, we should call it Grok, and Grok Cursor, we should call it Grok, and open source open source open source you know, if like if there was a pretty you know, if like if there was a pretty you know, if like if there was a pretty dramatic like dramatic like dramatic like contraction in GPU prices that was kind contraction in GPU prices that was kind contraction in GPU prices that was kind of sustained, I mean the market would of sustained, I mean the market would of sustained, I mean the market would react to that instantly. That would be react to that instantly. That would be react to that instantly. That would be worrisome. If it started to get to be worrisome. If it started to get to be worrisome. If it started to get to be really easy to get GPUs, really easy to get GPUs, really easy to get GPUs, I mean have you heard anyone say they I mean have you heard anyone say they I mean have you heard anyone say they have too many GPUs? have too many GPUs? have too many GPUs? >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> Like not not a single person. And it's >> Like not not a single person. And it's >> Like not not a single person. And it's not like it's the opposite. It sounds not like it's the opposite. It sounds not like it's the opposite. It sounds like a drug market or something. It like a drug market or something. It like a drug market or something. It really does. It's just wild. But yeah, I really does. It's just wild. But yeah, I really does. It's just wild. But yeah, I mean I think there's a long list of mean I think there's a long list of mean I think there's a long list of pretty obvious things. You know, if like pretty obvious things. You know, if like pretty obvious things. You know, if like Anthropic, Open AI, if the sum of these Anthropic, Open AI, if the sum of these Anthropic, Open AI, if the sum of these labs labs labs plateaus or you know, starts to decline, plateaus or you know, starts to decline, plateaus or you know, starts to decline, that's really negative unless it's just that's really negative unless it's just that's really negative unless it's just because open source tokens because open source tokens because open source tokens are not growing the pie and taking are not growing the pie and taking are not growing the pie and taking share. Uh and I do really think the share. Uh and I do really think the share. Uh and I do really think the future is like multi multi model. future is like multi multi model. future is like multi multi model. Yeah, I think particularly for the AI Yeah, I think particularly for the AI Yeah, I think particularly for the AI natives, they're going to want natives, they're going to want natives, they're going to want to take an open source model. It's got, to take an open source model. It's got, to take an open source model. It's got, you know, all these inference clouds you know, all these inference clouds you know, all these inference clouds have got really good at um you know, at have got really good at um you know, at have got really good at um you know, at supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement learning. So you can take your data, learning. So you can take your data, learning. So you can take your data, customize an open source model, and then customize an open source model, and then customize an open source model, and then get something that you can get something that you can get something that you can put behind a router, and the router put behind a router, and the router put behind a router, and the router routes it to often first your model, and routes it to often first your model, and routes it to often first your model, and then Claude, a frontier model, whatever, then Claude, a frontier model, whatever, then Claude, a frontier model, whatever, Claude, Grok, um checks it, and you can Claude, Grok, um checks it, and you can Claude, Grok, um checks it, and you can in a lot of cases get slightly better in a lot of cases get slightly better in a lot of cases get slightly better outcomes outcomes outcomes at half the cost. at half the cost. at half the cost. But again, that half the cost, I think a But again, that half the cost, I think a But again, that half the cost, I think a lot of people hear that, they're like, lot of people hear that, they're like, lot of people hear that, they're like, "That's bad for AI demand." It's "That's bad for AI demand." It's "That's bad for AI demand." It's actually not at all because the cost the actually not at all because the cost the actually not at all because the cost the user pays has user pays has user pays has you know, it's just a function of the you know, it's just a function of the you know, it's just a function of the margin on the tokens, and you're margin on the tokens, and you're margin on the tokens, and you're literally just shifting literally just shifting literally just shifting tokens from really expensive tokens with tokens from really expensive tokens with tokens from really expensive tokens with like 90% gross margins to tokens with like 90% gross margins to tokens with like 90% gross margins to tokens with maybe, let's call it a 30% gross margin. maybe, let's call it a 30% gross margin. maybe, let's call it a 30% gross margin. And that's where the savings are coming And that's where the savings are coming And that's where the savings are coming from, but the tokens cost the same from, but the tokens cost the same from, but the tokens cost the same amount of compute amount of compute amount of compute to produce. to produce. to produce. And then also all these things are kind And then also all these things are kind And then also all these things are kind of happening of happening of happening at kind of um at different cycle times. at kind of um at different cycle times. at kind of um at different cycle times. You know, all these, you know, big You know, all these, you know, big You know, all these, you know, big public companies are like, "Oh my god, public companies are like, "Oh my god, public companies are like, "Oh my god, my AI spend is 20x. I've burned my my AI spend is 20x. I've burned my my AI spend is 20x. I've burned my budget in 3 months." So, they set up a budget in 3 months." So, they set up a budget in 3 months." So, they set up a router, router, router, and that actually cuts their AI spend, and that actually cuts their AI spend, and that actually cuts their AI spend, but it doesn't really impact. It may but it doesn't really impact. It may but it doesn't really impact. It may actually increase the amount of tokens actually increase the amount of tokens actually increase the amount of tokens that they are generating just by that they are generating just by that they are generating just by shifting them to these cheaper shifting them to these cheaper shifting them to these cheaper open-source tokens, and that's just more open-source tokens, and that's just more open-source tokens, and that's just more compute. compute. compute. So, you know, a company getting smarter So, you know, a company getting smarter So, you know, a company getting smarter about which model to use for which task, about which model to use for which task, about which model to use for which task, that you know, that may lead to a a a that you know, that may lead to a a a that you know, that may lead to a a a stabilization of their spend or even a stabilization of their spend or even a stabilization of their spend or even a decline, but it actually has nothing to decline, but it actually has nothing to decline, but it actually has nothing to do with the amount of do with the amount of do with the amount of you know, GPU compute hours you know, GPU compute hours you know, GPU compute hours they are effectively consuming they are effectively consuming they are effectively consuming behind behind behind you know, these the these model layers you know, these the these model layers you know, these the these model layers of this router. The GPU compute hours of this router. The GPU compute hours of this router. The GPU compute hours probably are going up as you, you know, probably are going up as you, you know, probably are going up as you, you know, shift to these cheaper tokens you can shift to these cheaper tokens you can shift to these cheaper tokens you can use more of. So, and then, you know, that's happening So, and then, you know, that's happening to like a cutting-edge of public to like a cutting-edge of public to like a cutting-edge of public companies, companies, companies, and then you have this whole wave of AI and then you have this whole wave of AI and then you have this whole wave of AI natives, and natives, and natives, and like they're leading into this so hard, like they're leading into this so hard, like they're leading into this so hard, and they're not hiring and they're not hiring and they're not hiring humans. They're just really putting it humans. They're just really putting it humans. They're just really putting it mostly into tokens. And so, they're not mostly into tokens. And so, they're not mostly into tokens. And so, they're not slowing down. And then you have slowing down. And then you have slowing down. And then you have companies on the East Coast of America companies on the East Coast of America companies on the East Coast of America who have like barely adopted AI, who have like barely adopted AI, who have like barely adopted AI, companies, you know, broadly speaking, companies, you know, broadly speaking, companies, you know, broadly speaking, on other, you know, not on the coast who on other, you know, not on the coast who on other, you know, not on the coast who maybe aren't as cutting and then Europe maybe aren't as cutting and then Europe maybe aren't as cutting and then Europe who's like just trying to figure out how who's like just trying to figure out how who's like just trying to figure out how to regulate AI, to regulate AI, to regulate AI, >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> before using it. >> before using it. >> before using it. >> Yeah, so just like there's kind of these >> Yeah, so just like there's kind of these >> Yeah, so just like there's kind of these differential differential kind of waves differential differential kind of waves differential differential kind of waves of adoption all happening at the same of adoption all happening at the same of adoption all happening at the same time. time. time. But the thought I can't get out of my But the thought I can't get out of my But the thought I can't get out of my mind is like I think I said it maybe mind is like I think I said it maybe mind is like I think I said it maybe last time, but just Yoc's estimate like last time, but just Yoc's estimate like last time, but just Yoc's estimate like I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, 500,000 people in the world, 250,000 500,000 people in the world, 250,000 500,000 people in the world, 250,000 maybe are using a genetic AI. maybe are using a genetic AI. maybe are using a genetic AI. And we're in a cute compute shortage. And we're in a cute compute shortage. And we're in a cute compute shortage. That's That's That's Do you know there's seven or eight Do you know there's seven or eight Do you know there's seven or eight billion people on the planet? billion people on the planet? billion people on the planet? What happens when we go from 500,000 What happens when we go from 500,000 What happens when we go from 500,000 >> to 1% >> to 1% >> to 1% >> 100 billion, you know, to 500 billion? >> 100 billion, you know, to 500 billion? >> 100 billion, you know, to 500 billion? And then I do think it's it it it is And then I do think it's it it it is And then I do think it's it it it is interesting, you know, a lot of people interesting, you know, a lot of people interesting, you know, a lot of people are just like, okay, well, you know, I I are just like, okay, well, you know, I I are just like, okay, well, you know, I I do think it's like helpful to post on X do think it's like helpful to post on X do think it's like helpful to post on X to see the pushback. to see the pushback. to see the pushback. And a lot of people are saying, well, And a lot of people are saying, well, And a lot of people are saying, well, you know, where you know, where you know, where fundamentally is the Okay, we accept fundamentally is the Okay, we accept fundamentally is the Okay, we accept your argument that hyperscalers are your argument that hyperscalers are your argument that hyperscalers are under earning in this compute re-prices. under earning in this compute re-prices. under earning in this compute re-prices. Are their operating cash flows going to Are their operating cash flows going to Are their operating cash flows going to accelerate and maybe we can fund this, accelerate and maybe we can fund this, accelerate and maybe we can fund this, but like but like but like who Where is that operating going to who Where is that operating going to who Where is that operating going to come from? Where is the customer? come from? Where is the customer? come from? Where is the customer? And kind of definitionally it has to And kind of definitionally it has to And kind of definitionally it has to either come from, you know, faster either come from, you know, faster either come from, you know, faster economic growth through productivity economic growth through productivity economic growth through productivity kind of Satya's comments like either kind of Satya's comments like either kind of Satya's comments like either we're going to start growing 10% or we're going to start growing 10% or we're going to start growing 10% or we're not. we're not. we're not. Or labor substitution. Or labor substitution. Or labor substitution. And for sure, I think in a lot of these And for sure, I think in a lot of these And for sure, I think in a lot of these AI natives, AI natives, AI natives, you're seeing labor substitution, but you're seeing labor substitution, but you're seeing labor substitution, but not because they're not because they're not because they're firing people, they're just not hiring firing people, they're just not hiring firing people, they're just not hiring nearly as many humans. You know, the nearly as many humans. You know, the nearly as many humans. You know, the gross profit dollars per FTE and you gross profit dollars per FTE and you gross profit dollars per FTE and you know, A16Z iconic, a bunch of companies know, A16Z iconic, a bunch of companies know, A16Z iconic, a bunch of companies that have done this work, that have done this work, that have done this work, you know, they're you know, they're you know, they're you know, they're you know, they're you know, they're they're vertical they're vertical they're vertical uh particularly relative to uh particularly relative to uh particularly relative to past generations of startups. past generations of startups. past generations of startups. And then it is interesting, you know, And then it is interesting, you know, And then it is interesting, you know, like are you kind of doing any surveys like are you kind of doing any surveys like are you kind of doing any surveys of of of your companies that their tokens bid your companies that their tokens bid your companies that their tokens bid relative to labor spend? relative to labor spend? relative to labor spend? >> Oh, yeah. I mean, it's always reported >> Oh, yeah. I mean, it's always reported >> Oh, yeah. I mean, it's always reported as a percent of percent tokens as a as a percent of percent tokens as a as a percent of percent tokens as a percent of like total comp spend or percent of like total comp spend or percent of like total comp spend or something like that. something like that. something like that. >> what are the ranges you've seen? >> what are the ranges you've seen? >> what are the ranges you've seen? >> I mean, like in the really pill >> I mean, like in the really pill >> I mean, like in the really pill companies, like it gets really high. companies, like it gets really high. companies, like it gets really high. 20%, 25%, something like that. 20%, 25%, something like that. 20%, 25%, something like that. >> Well, >> Well, >> Well, our our our our your our friend Dylan Patel at our your our friend Dylan Patel at our your our friend Dylan Patel at Jasper Jasper Jasper >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> So, he's an ASI maxi, but he's at 30%. >> So, he's an ASI maxi, but he's at 30%. >> So, he's an ASI maxi, but he's at 30%. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Uh >> Uh >> Uh >> He probably that's probably the highest >> He probably that's probably the highest >> He probably that's probably the highest one I've heard. one I've heard. one I've heard. >> Uh I've actually heard a 50. >> Uh I've actually heard a 50. >> Uh I've actually heard a 50. And there's 25 trillion dollars in And there's 25 trillion dollars in And there's 25 trillion dollars in knowledge work. And so, let's you know, knowledge work. And so, let's you know, knowledge work. And so, let's you know, let's say that that's you know, let's let's say that that's you know, let's let's say that that's you know, let's take your 20% number. take your 20% number. take your 20% number. That's 5 trillion and that either comes That's 5 trillion and that either comes That's 5 trillion and that either comes out of labor substitution or faster out of labor substitution or faster out of labor substitution or faster economic growth. economic growth. economic growth. And we really, really, really want to And we really, really, really want to And we really, really, really want to have, you know, humans it to come from have, you know, humans it to come from have, you know, humans it to come from faster economic growth. faster economic growth. faster economic growth. >> One interesting thing I heard this >> One interesting thing I heard this >> One interesting thing I heard this morning from one of the great like morning from one of the great like morning from one of the great like leading technology CEOs has founded leading technology CEOs has founded leading technology CEOs has founded several companies that if you look at several companies that if you look at several companies that if you look at the founder letting controlled companies the founder letting controlled companies the founder letting controlled companies and adjust for some of the like COVID and adjust for some of the like COVID and adjust for some of the like COVID era, you know, over hiring, like era, you know, over hiring, like era, you know, over hiring, like nobody's really laying people off. Like nobody's really laying people off. Like nobody's really laying people off. Like these are the people that would probably these are the people that would probably these are the people that would probably be most quick to adopt AI to you know, be most quick to adopt AI to you know, be most quick to adopt AI to you know, become more efficient or whatever. Like become more efficient or whatever. Like become more efficient or whatever. Like they're not really doing jack aside like they're not really doing jack aside like they're not really doing jack aside like huge scale layoffs, which probably tells huge scale layoffs, which probably tells huge scale layoffs, which probably tells you something about where they think you something about where they think you something about where they think there will be lots of opportunity to there will be lots of opportunity to there will be lots of opportunity to still have people plus still have people plus still have people plus >> 100% >> 100% >> 100% well, the bull case well, the bull case well, the bull case >> So, growth not labor not labor growth. >> So, growth not labor not labor growth. >> So, growth not labor not labor growth. >> the bull case and you know, you've seen >> the bull case and you know, you've seen >> the bull case and you know, you've seen charts from Cognition, Ramp and Stripe charts from Cognition, Ramp and Stripe charts from Cognition, Ramp and Stripe that the companies that are spending the that the companies that are spending the that the companies that are spending the most on AI are growing growing most on AI are growing growing most on AI are growing growing meaningfully faster. meaningfully faster. meaningfully faster. >> Yeah, I love that cognition index. >> Yeah, I love that cognition index. >> Yeah, I love that cognition index. >> Yeah, the cognition index is wild. Now, >> Yeah, the cognition index is wild. Now, >> Yeah, the cognition index is wild. Now, all the skeptics will point out all the skeptics will point out all the skeptics will point out rightfully, it's not really controlling rightfully, it's not really controlling rightfully, it's not really controlling for industry, but then if like you dig for industry, but then if like you dig for industry, but then if like you dig down into it, down into it, down into it, you know, I think one of them gave an you know, I think one of them gave an you know, I think one of them gave an example of I forget if it was a plumber example of I forget if it was a plumber example of I forget if it was a plumber or an HVAC contractor, but like, you or an HVAC contractor, but like, you or an HVAC contractor, but like, you know, and everybody who's a blue-collar know, and everybody who's a blue-collar know, and everybody who's a blue-collar workers doing great cuz of AI. workers doing great cuz of AI. workers doing great cuz of AI. By the way, something that I think we By the way, something that I think we By the way, something that I think we should touch on and we we could do it should touch on and we we could do it should touch on and we we could do it now or later now or later now or later is just everybody is citing these LTAs. is just everybody is citing these LTAs. is just everybody is citing these LTAs. So, that we're everything is at a So, that we're everything is at a So, that we're everything is at a shortage. Everything is at a shortage shortage. Everything is at a shortage shortage. Everything is at a shortage right now. You know, if if there's right now. You know, if if there's right now. You know, if if there's weakness, it's just cuz we can't weakness, it's just cuz we can't weakness, it's just cuz we can't energize the gigawatts fast enough. The energize the gigawatts fast enough. The energize the gigawatts fast enough. The gigawatts are going to get energized gigawatts are going to get energized gigawatts are going to get energized like it, you know, regulatory policy is like it, you know, regulatory policy is like it, you know, regulatory policy is moving in a in a good way. You the moving in a in a good way. You the moving in a in a good way. You the turbine manufacturers, the diesel gen turbine manufacturers, the diesel gen turbine manufacturers, the diesel gen set manufacturers, you know, they're set manufacturers, you know, they're set manufacturers, you know, they're ramping up. ramping up. ramping up. >> You're you're you're ripping >> You're you're you're ripping >> You're you're you're ripping turbines off old airplanes and, you turbines off old airplanes and, you turbines off old airplanes and, you know, reconditioning them and then know, reconditioning them and then know, reconditioning them and then repurposing them. There's crazy things repurposing them. There's crazy things repurposing them. There's crazy things happening. Capitalism is very, very good happening. Capitalism is very, very good happening. Capitalism is very, very good at this. at this. at this. But I do think one of the most important But I do think one of the most important But I do think one of the most important questions in the market questions in the market questions in the market and like a transition of the market that and like a transition of the market that and like a transition of the market that like I got wrong like I got wrong like I got wrong is we are shifting, particularly for is we are shifting, particularly for is we are shifting, particularly for particularly for memory more than particularly for memory more than particularly for memory more than anything else, anything else, anything else, from, you know, crushing numbers from, you know, crushing numbers from, you know, crushing numbers in in the short term in in the short term in in the short term to they are trading short-term upside to they are trading short-term upside to they are trading short-term upside for these, you know, what do they call for these, you know, what do they call for these, you know, what do they call them? Supply chain agreements, long-term them? Supply chain agreements, long-term them? Supply chain agreements, long-term agreements, LTAs, agreements, LTAs, agreements, LTAs, where they essentially, you know, agree where they essentially, you know, agree where they essentially, you know, agree there's there's many flavors, but the there's there's many flavors, but the there's there's many flavors, but the customer prepays customer prepays customer prepays and it's, you know, there's a floor and and it's, you know, there's a floor and and it's, you know, there's a floor and a ceiling. a ceiling. a ceiling. And this comes back to the And this comes back to the And this comes back to the point about labor because, you know, a point about labor because, you know, a point about labor because, you know, a lot of people after lot of people after lot of people after um um um you know, after kind of like firing, you know, after kind of like firing, you know, after kind of like firing, you know, too many people, you know, too many people, you know, too many people, were, you know, you during during COVID, were, you know, you during during COVID, were, you know, you during during COVID, were really reluctant to lay people off. were really reluctant to lay people off. were really reluctant to lay people off. And that, you know, they talked about And that, you know, they talked about And that, you know, they talked about labor hoarding if you remember a few labor hoarding if you remember a few labor hoarding if you remember a few years ago. You remember this? years ago. You remember this? years ago. You remember this? I'm just I'm just I'm just Let's just think about the game theory Let's just think about the game theory Let's just think about the game theory of breaking an LTA. of breaking an LTA. of breaking an LTA. So, there's four companies that like So, there's four companies that like So, there's four companies that like matter at scale. There's Amazon with matter at scale. There's Amazon with matter at scale. There's Amazon with their trade ups. their trade ups. their trade ups. There's Google with their TPUs. There's Google with their TPUs. There's Google with their TPUs. There's [snorts] AMD. And then there's There's [snorts] AMD. And then there's There's [snorts] AMD. And then there's Nvidia, who's like much bigger than Nvidia, who's like much bigger than Nvidia, who's like much bigger than everybody else combined. You know, let's everybody else combined. You know, let's everybody else combined. You know, let's just say it's 2027. just say it's 2027. just say it's 2027. It's very important to realize memory is It's very important to realize memory is It's very important to realize memory is The more memory you put The more memory you put The more memory you put with flop for a given unit of compute, with flop for a given unit of compute, with flop for a given unit of compute, the more tokens you get out. It's the the more tokens you get out. It's the the more tokens you get out. It's the single most important thing you could do single most important thing you could do single most important thing you could do to increase kind of token output per to increase kind of token output per to increase kind of token output per unit of compute. And then that obviously unit of compute. And then that obviously unit of compute. And then that obviously definitionally actually lowers costs, definitionally actually lowers costs, definitionally actually lowers costs, which is why the demand hasn't responded which is why the demand hasn't responded which is why the demand hasn't responded at all negatively. There's been no at all negatively. There's been no at all negatively. There's been no elasticity just because it's like kind elasticity just because it's like kind elasticity just because it's like kind of the only It's the axis that is of the only It's the axis that is of the only It's the axis that is dominating all others. dominating all others. dominating all others. Um And this is like at some level like a Um And this is like at some level like a Um And this is like at some level like a giant Game of Thrones or Imposters giant Game of Thrones or Imposters giant Game of Thrones or Imposters between these companies. between these companies. between these companies. And okay, it's 2027. And okay, it's 2027. And okay, it's 2027. You're like or 2028. You're vaguely You're like or 2028. You're vaguely You're like or 2028. You're vaguely tempted to break one of these LTAs. Try tempted to break one of these LTAs. Try tempted to break one of these LTAs. Try and get a lower price. and get a lower price. and get a lower price. But to a large degree, market shares are But to a large degree, market shares are But to a large degree, market shares are I think for the next several years are I think for the next several years are I think for the next several years are going to be determined by supply by going to be determined by supply by going to be determined by supply by supply chain allocations and kind of supply chain allocations and kind of supply chain allocations and kind of what you have what you have what you have kind of pre-purchased. kind of pre-purchased. kind of pre-purchased. So, if you break the LTA So, if you break the LTA So, if you break the LTA and you And this is This is assuming and you And this is This is assuming and you And this is This is assuming we're not in a severe oversupply we're not in a severe oversupply we're not in a severe oversupply situation. situation. situation. And but all the logic almost the game And but all the logic almost the game And but all the logic almost the game theory even holds in a severe oversupply theory even holds in a severe oversupply theory even holds in a severe oversupply situation. If you break your LTA situation. If you break your LTA situation. If you break your LTA and then in the next and then in the next and then in the next two or three years for any reason two or three years for any reason two or three years for any reason leverage shifts back to the memory guys, leverage shifts back to the memory guys, leverage shifts back to the memory guys, you're out of business. It's over. you're out of business. It's over. you're out of business. It's over. You know, like let's let's just say You know, like let's let's just say You know, like let's let's just say Google breaks an LTA. You know, there's Google breaks an LTA. You know, there's Google breaks an LTA. You know, there's there's an over there's an over supply there's an over there's an over supply there's an over there's an over supply of making this up in 28, 29. of making this up in 28, 29. of making this up in 28, 29. They break their LTAs. Well, if they're They break their LTAs. Well, if they're They break their LTAs. Well, if they're breaking their LTAs, it probably means, breaking their LTAs, it probably means, breaking their LTAs, it probably means, you know, you're over supply, prices are you know, you're over supply, prices are you know, you're over supply, prices are coming down. And then, you know, coming down. And then, you know, coming down. And then, you know, capacity that naturally contracts. capacity that naturally contracts. capacity that naturally contracts. Well, Well, Well, like what do you think's going to happen like what do you think's going to happen like what do you think's going to happen to Google's allocations? And then, you to Google's allocations? And then, you to Google's allocations? And then, you know, this is a cyclical industry and know, this is a cyclical industry and know, this is a cyclical industry and over supply is followed by under supply. over supply is followed by under supply. over supply is followed by under supply. What do you think they think is going to What do you think they think is going to What do you think they think is going to happen to their allocations next time? happen to their allocations next time? happen to their allocations next time? So, I just think given that this is like So, I just think given that this is like So, I just think given that this is like the access around which kind of the access around which kind of the access around which kind of everything is revolving, everything is revolving, everything is revolving, man, like you might blow up your entire man, like you might blow up your entire man, like you might blow up your entire business business business and your franchise by breaking an LTA. and your franchise by breaking an LTA. and your franchise by breaking an LTA. And that was never the case before, you And that was never the case before, you And that was never the case before, you know, Apple, who cares, you know, know, Apple, who cares, you know, know, Apple, who cares, you know, they're buying they don't have a they're buying they don't have a they're buying they don't have a competitor. competitor. competitor. They're the over they're overwhelmingly They're the over they're overwhelmingly They're the over they're overwhelmingly the largest purchaser. They know they the largest purchaser. They know they the largest purchaser. They know they can do whatever this is, you know, going can do whatever this is, you know, going can do whatever this is, you know, going back three, four, five years. They know back three, four, five years. They know back three, four, five years. They know they can do whatever they want with no they can do whatever they want with no they can do whatever they want with no consequences cuz their volume is so big, consequences cuz their volume is so big, consequences cuz their volume is so big, you know, that even if they like super you know, that even if they like super you know, that even if they like super screw Hynix, Micron will of course take screw Hynix, Micron will of course take screw Hynix, Micron will of course take them. them. them. This is this is just different, you This is this is just different, you This is this is just different, you know, you have at least four players. know, you have at least four players. know, you have at least four players. Then you have all the startups. You're Then you have all the startups. You're Then you have all the startups. You're an investor in Etched. an investor in Etched. an investor in Etched. And And And if you break an LTA, if you break an LTA, if you break an LTA, and that they just say, "Okay, fine. You and that they just say, "Okay, fine. You and that they just say, "Okay, fine. You know what? Great. You broke the price know what? Great. You broke the price know what? Great. You broke the price agreement. agreement. agreement. We're going to break the volume We're going to break the volume We're going to break the volume agreement. And, you know, screw you. agreement. And, you know, screw you. agreement. And, you know, screw you. We're going to give the volume to your We're going to give the volume to your We're going to give the volume to your competitor." competitor." competitor." You just you just lost share, you know? You just you just lost share, you know? You just you just lost share, you know? That's so I think the That's so I think the That's so I think the the you know, it like I think, you know, the you know, it like I think, you know, the you know, it like I think, you know, Nvidia's dominance I think is uh like I think like I think the current environment they state to the current environment they state to the current environment they state to which it favors Nvidia, which it favors Nvidia, which it favors Nvidia, like it is a hard for me to understand like it is a hard for me to understand like it is a hard for me to understand why it's trading at such a low multiple. why it's trading at such a low multiple. why it's trading at such a low multiple. You know, in other words, like if you You know, in other words, like if you You know, in other words, like if you need to be able to finance the chips and need to be able to finance the chips and need to be able to finance the chips and you do, nothing's more financeable than you do, nothing's more financeable than you do, nothing's more financeable than an Nvidia GPU. Nothing. an Nvidia GPU. Nothing. an Nvidia GPU. Nothing. If you need to get, you know, land and If you need to get, you know, land and If you need to get, you know, land and power, power, power, well, they're doing a very good job of well, they're doing a very good job of well, they're doing a very good job of playing that chess game and and playing that chess game and and playing that chess game and and matchmaking. matchmaking. matchmaking. And then they've kind of rolled out this And then they've kind of rolled out this And then they've kind of rolled out this really clever, you know, new business really clever, you know, new business really clever, you know, new business model, which I would describe as kind of model, which I would describe as kind of model, which I would describe as kind of like a credit wrapper like a credit wrapper like a credit wrapper um with a revenue share if GPU prices um with a revenue share if GPU prices um with a revenue share if GPU prices are above a floor. Yeah. Um and this are above a floor. Yeah. Um and this are above a floor. Yeah. Um and this could lead to them like having a really could lead to them like having a really could lead to them like having a really giant cloud business effectively through giant cloud business effectively through giant cloud business effectively through royalties really quickly. royalties really quickly. royalties really quickly. And it is another way of kind of And it is another way of kind of And it is another way of kind of alleviating this um alleviating this um alleviating this um you know, cash flow mismatch. Like, hey, you know, cash flow mismatch. Like, hey, you know, cash flow mismatch. Like, hey, we're making all the cash. we're making all the cash. we're making all the cash. Yeah, and and like Yeah, and and like Yeah, and and like this isn't this isn't really vendor this isn't this isn't really vendor this isn't this isn't really vendor financing cuz they're not loading them financing cuz they're not loading them financing cuz they're not loading them the money. Somebody else is loading the money. Somebody else is loading the money. Somebody else is loading the GPU buyer the money. So, it's not the GPU buyer the money. So, it's not the GPU buyer the money. So, it's not quite vendor it's not vendor financing. quite vendor it's not vendor financing. quite vendor it's not vendor financing. It's um It's um It's um it's, you know, they're still making it's, you know, they're still making it's, you know, they're still making equity investments, but it's not it's equity investments, but it's not it's equity investments, but it's not it's not like you're just putting money into not like you're just putting money into not like you're just putting money into someone someone someone in return for them, you know, you know, in return for them, you know, you know, in return for them, you know, you know, and then some of that money, you know, and then some of that money, you know, and then some of that money, you know, is used to buy your chips, even though, is used to buy your chips, even though, is used to buy your chips, even though, you know, Nvidia said that they write you know, Nvidia said that they write you know, Nvidia said that they write into all their into all their into all their you know, equity investments that um you you know, equity investments that um you you know, equity investments that um you know, the money can't be used to buy know, the money can't be used to buy know, the money can't be used to buy Nvidia chips, but obviously money is Nvidia chips, but obviously money is Nvidia chips, but obviously money is fungible. fungible. fungible. And um And um And um >> Funny thing. >> Funny thing. >> Funny thing. >> What's that? >> What's that? >> What's that? >> like a funny little thing. >> like a funny little thing. >> like a funny little thing. >> Yes. [laughter] >> Yes. [laughter] >> Yes. [laughter] Um Um Um Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But, you know, I think at some level it But, you know, I think at some level it But, you know, I think at some level it probably makes everybody feel better. probably makes everybody feel better. probably makes everybody feel better. Um Um Um >> What would you do if you were the memory >> What would you do if you were the memory >> What would you do if you were the memory like if you were the CEO of Hynix? like if you were the CEO of Hynix? like if you were the CEO of Hynix? >> I'd do the exact same thing Nvidia's >> I'd do the exact same thing Nvidia's >> I'd do the exact same thing Nvidia's doing right now. doing right now. doing right now. >> Which is? >> Which is? >> Which is? >> I I would be going >> I I would be going >> I I would be going >> I say, all right, I'm going to say >> I say, all right, I'm going to say >> I say, all right, I'm going to say >> be going to the buyers of GPUs, Radeon, >> be going to the buyers of GPUs, Radeon, >> be going to the buyers of GPUs, Radeon, and whoever and whoever and whoever and say, I'll participate in the Nvidia and say, I'll participate in the Nvidia and say, I'll participate in the Nvidia credit wrapper. Now, their business is credit wrapper. Now, their business is credit wrapper. Now, their business is just inherently less stable and just inherently less stable and just inherently less stable and predictable, predictable, predictable, but in some way, and maybe they just put but in some way, and maybe they just put but in some way, and maybe they just put up some cash up front, so it's like up some cash up front, so it's like up some cash up front, so it's like they're not on the hook. You know what I they're not on the hook. You know what I they're not on the hook. You know what I mean? I'm just making this up. mean? I'm just making this up. mean? I'm just making this up. But like, But like, But like, do something like you can because you do something like you can because you do something like you can because you have money now, have money now, have money now, and credit markets are revolting. and credit markets are revolting. and credit markets are revolting. There many, you know, like, you know, There many, you know, like, you know, There many, you know, like, you know, the the the the the the people, I'm sure the, you know, our people, I'm sure the, you know, our people, I'm sure the, you know, our friends at, you know, Blackstone and friends at, you know, Blackstone and friends at, you know, Blackstone and Apollo are suggesting some variant of Apollo are suggesting some variant of Apollo are suggesting some variant of this to the memory companies. But hey, this to the memory companies. But hey, this to the memory companies. But hey, we will like we will like we will like put up some amount of money from our put up some amount of money from our put up some amount of money from our cash flow today, and then it's gone. cash flow today, and then it's gone. cash flow today, and then it's gone. It's, you know, surety It's, you know, surety It's, you know, surety uh that they, you know, makes the the uh that they, you know, makes the the uh that they, you know, makes the the the person who's extending the debt feel the person who's extending the debt feel the person who's extending the debt feel better, better, better, but we want but we want but we want a some sort of a cut a some sort of a cut a some sort of a cut of the ongoing revenues as well. Right. of the ongoing revenues as well. Right. of the ongoing revenues as well. Right. Like that is like 100% what I would do. Like that is like 100% what I would do. Like that is like 100% what I would do. And it's almost like a logical extension And it's almost like a logical extension And it's almost like a logical extension of, you know, the LTAs where they're of, you know, the LTAs where they're of, you know, the LTAs where they're kind of trading upside for durability. kind of trading upside for durability. kind of trading upside for durability. Here, you know, you can Here, you know, you can Here, you know, you can you know, you can effectively get a you know, you can effectively get a you know, you can effectively get a royalty on recurring revenues. And that royalty on recurring revenues. And that royalty on recurring revenues. And that is that is what Nvidia is doing. And I is that is what Nvidia is doing. And I is that is what Nvidia is doing. And I do think that is very misunderstood. do think that is very misunderstood. do think that is very misunderstood. And I think it would serve Nvidia well And I think it would serve Nvidia well And I think it would serve Nvidia well to really to really to really explain this. One, they're really explain this. One, they're really explain this. One, they're really bullish on AI. bullish on AI. bullish on AI. Um Um Um Essentially, every time they haven't Essentially, every time they haven't Essentially, every time they haven't taken an equity stake in something, it's taken an equity stake in something, it's taken an equity stake in something, it's been a mistake. been a mistake. been a mistake. You know, I mean, You know, I mean, You know, I mean, they've taken equity stakes in they've taken equity stakes in they've taken equity stakes in everything essentially except the memory everything essentially except the memory everything essentially except the memory companies that for a long while companies that for a long while companies that for a long while Anthropic that they took an equity stake Anthropic that they took an equity stake Anthropic that they took an equity stake in Anthropic. But like, why not if you in Anthropic. But like, why not if you in Anthropic. But like, why not if you have cash flow and you're bullish on AI? have cash flow and you're bullish on AI? have cash flow and you're bullish on AI? And Jensen because he sees every lab. He And Jensen because he sees every lab. He And Jensen because he sees every lab. He knows all the advances, you know, like knows all the advances, you know, like knows all the advances, you know, like all these continual learning labs, you all these continual learning labs, you all these continual learning labs, you know, safe superintelligence is now know, safe superintelligence is now know, safe superintelligence is now working with them. working with them. working with them. You know, he he sees everything and like You know, he he sees everything and like You know, he he sees everything and like what he sees makes him bullish. Um what he sees makes him bullish. Um what he sees makes him bullish. Um So, what have some equity upside So, what have some equity upside So, what have some equity upside and then two, have a revenue share and then two, have a revenue share and then two, have a revenue share and you're generating hundreds of and you're generating hundreds of and you're generating hundreds of billions of dollars of billions of dollars of billions of dollars of um um um of free cash flow um and a helping of free cash flow um and a helping of free cash flow um and a helping to kind of bridge, you know, what what to kind of bridge, you know, what what to kind of bridge, you know, what what is clearly kind of a gap at least, you is clearly kind of a gap at least, you is clearly kind of a gap at least, you know, given everybody's gone free cash know, given everybody's gone free cash know, given everybody's gone free cash flow negative flow negative flow negative until the operating cash flow until the operating cash flow until the operating cash flow accelerates enough that you can accelerates enough that you can accelerates enough that you can internally fund this. internally fund this. internally fund this. It's almost like I mean it's um It's almost like I mean it's um It's almost like I mean it's um very opportunistic and it like very opportunistic and it like very opportunistic and it like significant and in a good way significant and in a good way significant and in a good way and it significantly increases their and it significantly increases their and it significantly increases their revenue per gigawatt. And then it also revenue per gigawatt. And then it also revenue per gigawatt. And then it also strengthens their competitive position. strengthens their competitive position. strengthens their competitive position. You know, that's you know, you and I, we You know, that's you know, you and I, we You know, that's you know, you and I, we both have startups, but okay, that's both have startups, but okay, that's both have startups, but okay, that's that's that's great. Use that startups that's that's great. Use that startups that's that's great. Use that startups chip. Um chip. Um chip. Um well, what prices are they paying big well, what prices are they paying big well, what prices are they paying big atomic to me? Higher than Nvidia and all atomic to me? Higher than Nvidia and all atomic to me? Higher than Nvidia and all these guys. What prices are they paying these guys. What prices are they paying these guys. What prices are they paying for um HBM D-Ram? Higher. Um for um HBM D-Ram? Higher. Um for um HBM D-Ram? Higher. Um Can you finance those chips easily at Can you finance those chips easily at Can you finance those chips easily at the same rate as Nvidia? No. And so it's the same rate as Nvidia? No. And so it's the same rate as Nvidia? No. And so it's always like, you know, there's there's a always like, you know, there's there's a always like, you know, there's there's a real burden, particularly real burden, particularly real burden, particularly if you use HBM D-Ram, like you're just if you use HBM D-Ram, like you're just if you use HBM D-Ram, like you're just you're in the crosshairs of this. Um you're in the crosshairs of this. Um you're in the crosshairs of this. Um unless like actually you you know, maybe unless like actually you you know, maybe unless like actually you you know, maybe actually like they made really different actually like they made really different actually like they made really different architectural choices. Everything that's architectural choices. Everything that's architectural choices. Everything that's happening happening happening is actually pretty good for hip. Just is actually pretty good for hip. Just is actually pretty good for hip. Just are going back to game theory. are going back to game theory. are going back to game theory. Entropic Entropic Entropic if they had been as aggressive on if they had been as aggressive on if they had been as aggressive on compute as OpenAI had been, they would compute as OpenAI had been, they would compute as OpenAI had been, they would have run away with it. have run away with it. have run away with it. And so now OpenAI is back in the game. I And so now OpenAI is back in the game. I And so now OpenAI is back in the game. I think Grok is in the game. Those are the think Grok is in the game. Those are the think Grok is in the game. Those are the companies on the Pareto frontier. companies on the Pareto frontier. companies on the Pareto frontier. >> And they have the compute. >> And they have the compute. >> And they have the compute. >> And do you think >> And do you think >> And do you think after watching that after watching that after watching that anyone is going to let off the gas? anyone is going to let off the gas? anyone is going to let off the gas? Cuz you just you know, it was Cuz you just you know, it was Cuz you just you know, it was I think 4 months ago that Dario was I think 4 months ago that Dario was I think 4 months ago that Dario was talking about how talking about how talking about how you know, it was a real it was a really you know, it was a real it was a really you know, it was a real it was a really thoughtful commentary, but he's like, thoughtful commentary, but he's like, thoughtful commentary, but he's like, it's really, really hard because, you it's really, really hard because, you it's really, really hard because, you know, if you buy too much compute, you know, if you buy too much compute, you know, if you buy too much compute, you could go bankrupt at the scale of these could go bankrupt at the scale of these could go bankrupt at the scale of these things. things. things. But if you don't buy enough, you could But if you don't buy enough, you could But if you don't buy enough, you could lose. lose. lose. Well, Well, Well, >> We saw it happen. >> We saw it happen. >> We saw it happen. >> OpenAI just got back into the game, and >> OpenAI just got back into the game, and >> OpenAI just got back into the game, and now SpaceX is in the game in a big way now SpaceX is in the game in a big way now SpaceX is in the game in a big way of Grok 4.5 and Cursor. of Grok 4.5 and Cursor. of Grok 4.5 and Cursor. And like, after watching that, from a And like, after watching that, from a And like, after watching that, from a game theory perspective, is anybody game theory perspective, is anybody game theory perspective, is anybody going to back off anytime soon, going to back off anytime soon, going to back off anytime soon, especially if it can be funded out of especially if it can be funded out of especially if it can be funded out of operating cash flow? operating cash flow? operating cash flow? >> Vanta automates security and compliance >> Vanta automates security and compliance >> Vanta automates security and compliance for over 16,000 fast-moving companies for over 16,000 fast-moving companies for over 16,000 fast-moving companies like Ramp, Cursor, and Harvey, keeping like Ramp, Cursor, and Harvey, keeping like Ramp, Cursor, and Harvey, keeping them audit ready around the clock. It's them audit ready around the clock. It's them audit ready around the clock. It's the number one agentic trust platform, the number one agentic trust platform, the number one agentic trust platform, [music] [music] [music] and it now helps companies like yours and it now helps companies like yours and it now helps companies like yours watch for the risks that show up between watch for the risks that show up between watch for the risks that show up between audits across your [music] vendors, your audits across your [music] vendors, your audits across your [music] vendors, your AI tools, and your whole environment. AI tools, and your whole environment. AI tools, and your whole environment. Every new tool your team signs up for, Every new tool your team signs up for, Every new tool your team signs up for, every vendor that turns on AI features every vendor that turns on AI features every vendor that turns on AI features is an opportunity for something to go is an opportunity for something to go is an opportunity for something to go wrong, [music] wrong, [music] wrong, [music] and most security programs weren't built and most security programs weren't built and most security programs weren't built for AI's pace of growth. The Vanta agent for AI's pace of growth. The Vanta agent for AI's pace of growth. The Vanta agent works like a 24/7 [music] works like a 24/7 [music] works like a 24/7 [music] GRC engineer in the background finding GRC engineer in the background finding GRC engineer in the background finding issues, drafting fixes for you, and issues, drafting fixes for you, and issues, drafting fixes for you, and cutting vendor assessment time by up to cutting vendor assessment time by up to cutting vendor assessment time by up to 50%. 50%. 50%. Whether you're [music] a fast-growing Whether you're [music] a fast-growing Whether you're [music] a fast-growing startup or a global enterprise, Vanta startup or a global enterprise, Vanta startup or a global enterprise, Vanta helps you earn and prove trust. helps you earn and prove trust. helps you earn and prove trust. Invest Like the Best listeners get a Invest Like the Best listeners get a Invest Like the Best listeners get a special offer for $1,000 off at special offer for $1,000 off at special offer for $1,000 off at vanta.com/invest. Ridgeline is the first end-to-end system Ridgeline is the first end-to-end system of record with embedded AI for of record with embedded AI for of record with embedded AI for investment management [music] firms, investment management [music] firms, investment management [music] firms, running portfolio accounting, running portfolio accounting, running portfolio accounting, reconciliation, reporting, trading, and reconciliation, reporting, trading, and reconciliation, reporting, trading, and compliance compliance >> [music] >> on one unified platform. >> on one unified platform. >> on one unified platform. Firms are moving off legacy technology Firms are moving off legacy technology Firms are moving off legacy technology and onto Ridgeline because of how far and onto Ridgeline because of how far and onto Ridgeline because of how far ahead Ridgeline's AI features are ahead Ridgeline's AI features are ahead Ridgeline's AI features are compared [music] to anything else in compared [music] to anything else in compared [music] to anything else in investment management software. investment management software. investment management software. I've been hearing from a lot of I've been hearing from a lot of I've been hearing from a lot of investment managers about AI, and they investment managers about AI, and they investment managers about AI, and they fall roughly into two camps, with some fall roughly into two camps, with some fall roughly into two camps, with some unsure of where to even start, and unsure of where to even start, and unsure of where to even start, and others convinced they can build their others convinced they can build their others convinced they can build their own order management system over a own order management system over a own order management system over a weekend. [music] weekend. [music] weekend. [music] The reality is that running an The reality is that running an The reality is that running an investment firm will always require investment firm will always require investment firm will always require governance controls and a single source governance controls and a single source governance controls and a single source of truth for your data, and no amount of of truth for your data, and no amount of of truth for your data, and no amount of AI enthusiasm changes [music] that AI enthusiasm changes [music] that AI enthusiasm changes [music] that requirement. Ridgeline is built on requirement. Ridgeline is built on requirement. Ridgeline is built on exactly that foundation, which is why I exactly that foundation, which is why I exactly that foundation, which is why I believe that firms that come out ahead believe that firms that come out ahead believe that firms that come out ahead in the AI era will be the ones running in the AI era will be the ones running in the AI era will be the ones running on Ridgeline's unified [music] platform. on Ridgeline's unified [music] platform. on Ridgeline's unified [music] platform. If you're serious about your firm's AI If you're serious about your firm's AI If you're serious about your firm's AI strategy, Ridgeline should be part of strategy, Ridgeline should be part of strategy, Ridgeline should be part of that conversation. You can request a that conversation. You can request a that conversation. You can request a demo at ridgeline.ai. [music] demo at ridgeline.ai. [music] demo at ridgeline.ai. [music] >> Have you met anyone in your travels out >> Have you met anyone in your travels out >> Have you met anyone in your travels out here that you would say is like way more here that you would say is like way more here that you would say is like way more bullish than you, and if so, what do bullish than you, and if so, what do bullish than you, and if so, what do they believe that you don't? they believe that you don't? they believe that you don't? >> I mean, essentially everyone out here is >> I mean, essentially everyone out here is >> I mean, essentially everyone out here is more bullish than me, man. more bullish than me, man. more bullish than me, man. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> I like >> I like >> I like You know, I read this thing that You know, I read this thing that You know, I read this thing that Dworkesh wrote, and I was like Dworkesh wrote, and I was like Dworkesh wrote, and I was like >> The 3x compute price thing or whatever? >> The 3x compute price thing or whatever? >> The 3x compute price thing or whatever? >> Yeah, well, he was I forget what it was. >> Yeah, well, he was I forget what it was. >> Yeah, well, he was I forget what it was. >> No, no, it was like 15x or something. >> No, no, it was like 15x or something. >> No, no, it was like 15x or something. >> Yeah, but no, but just basically that um >> Yeah, but no, but just basically that um >> Yeah, but no, but just basically that um you know, renting an H100 for a year you know, renting an H100 for a year you know, renting an H100 for a year would cost $250,000. would cost $250,000. would cost $250,000. You know, um the salary You know, um the salary You know, um the salary >> that's 15x the current spot or >> that's 15x the current spot or >> that's 15x the current spot or something. Yeah. something. Yeah. something. Yeah. >> Exactly. Like, wow, you know, that was >> Exactly. Like, wow, you know, that was >> Exactly. Like, wow, you know, that was just like that just like that just like that >> in my book. >> in my book. >> in my book. >> That wasn't in my >> That wasn't in my >> That wasn't in my you know, forget my like Bayesian you know, forget my like Bayesian you know, forget my like Bayesian probability space of expected outcomes. probability space of expected outcomes. probability space of expected outcomes. That wasn't even in my That wasn't even in my That wasn't even in my >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> considered but dismissed as totally >> considered but dismissed as totally >> considered but dismissed as totally unlikely outcomes. unlikely outcomes. unlikely outcomes. You know, and then that guy is, you You know, and then that guy is, you You know, and then that guy is, you know, he's very Dworkesh, he's a very know, he's very Dworkesh, he's a very know, he's very Dworkesh, he's a very smart guy, he's very plugged in. smart guy, he's very plugged in. smart guy, he's very plugged in. And um And um And um and you know, and then he pointed out and you know, and then he pointed out and you know, and then he pointed out that like, hey, the you know, something that like, hey, the you know, something that like, hey, the you know, something like I think he just said margins on like I think he just said margins on like I think he just said margins on compute are going up, the amount of compute are going up, the amount of compute are going up, the amount of compute is going up, compute is going up, compute is going up, and inference margin's going up, and if and inference margin's going up, and if and inference margin's going up, and if you multiply those three, that's how you multiply those three, that's how you multiply those three, that's how you're getting this crazy acceleration you're getting this crazy acceleration you're getting this crazy acceleration in the sum of the labs plus open source, in the sum of the labs plus open source, in the sum of the labs plus open source, although obviously open source the although obviously open source the although obviously open source the margins on open source are not margins on open source are not margins on open source are not really going up. But I mean really going up. But I mean really going up. But I mean >> So, everyone's more [laughter] bullish >> So, everyone's more [laughter] bullish >> So, everyone's more [laughter] bullish >> Yeah, yeah, I like you know, I just >> Yeah, yeah, I like you know, I just >> Yeah, yeah, I like you know, I just I look at what's happening in the stock I look at what's happening in the stock I look at what's happening in the stock market and I feel like a foolish market and I feel like a foolish market and I feel like a foolish optimist. optimist. optimist. And then when I talk to people And then when I talk to people And then when I talk to people whether it's people at the labs, whether whether it's people at the labs, whether whether it's people at the labs, whether anyone in this ecosystem anyone in this ecosystem anyone in this ecosystem like I'm like bearish relative to like I'm like bearish relative to like I'm like bearish relative to essentially everyone. essentially everyone. essentially everyone. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> Which is just a strange state of >> Which is just a strange state of >> Which is just a strange state of affairs. What do you make of the DUV affairs. What do you make of the DUV affairs. What do you make of the DUV news out of China where I've seen news out of China where I've seen news out of China where I've seen reactions really along a spectrum of reactions really along a spectrum of reactions really along a spectrum of like this is the equivalent of like what like this is the equivalent of like what like this is the equivalent of like what ASML had in 2001 or something. ASML had in 2001 or something. ASML had in 2001 or something. Or like no, this is actually the first Or like no, this is actually the first Or like no, this is actually the first bit of news in a a new story for how we bit of news in a a new story for how we bit of news in a a new story for how we should think about the global supply of should think about the global supply of should think about the global supply of cutting-edge compute. cutting-edge compute. cutting-edge compute. >> I think both could be true. >> I think both could be true. >> I think both could be true. You know, it's just like um You know, it's just like um You know, it's just like um like let's just make an analogy. Like like let's just make an analogy. Like like let's just make an analogy. Like let's just say let's just say let's just say a DUV machine was a jet turbine and now a DUV machine was a jet turbine and now a DUV machine was a jet turbine and now like an EUV machine is like warp drive. like an EUV machine is like warp drive. like an EUV machine is like warp drive. Um you know, or what whatever it's going Um you know, or what whatever it's going Um you know, or what whatever it's going to be, you know, a to be, you know, a to be, you know, a DUV machine is like a propeller plane DUV machine is like a propeller plane DUV machine is like a propeller plane EUV is like a jet turbine. EUV is like a jet turbine. EUV is like a jet turbine. Um Um Um but like they didn't have it before but like they didn't have it before but like they didn't have it before and and and now they allegedly do. now they allegedly do. now they allegedly do. And that is like a phase transition, you And that is like a phase transition, you And that is like a phase transition, you know, you it's like know, you it's like know, you it's like you've gone from like liquid to solid. you've gone from like liquid to solid. you've gone from like liquid to solid. Now that solid that you know, jet Now that solid that you know, jet Now that solid that you know, jet engine, prop plane, whatever is 25 years engine, prop plane, whatever is 25 years engine, prop plane, whatever is 25 years behind but still it's important and I behind but still it's important and I behind but still it's important and I don't think should be dismissed, but I don't think should be dismissed, but I don't think should be dismissed, but I also also also you know, it's kind of you know, it's kind of you know, it's kind of >> funny you just see this in the stock >> funny you just see this in the stock >> funny you just see this in the stock market, you know, it's like the stock market, you know, it's like the stock market, you know, it's like the stock market massively overreacts and then market massively overreacts and then market massively overreacts and then like if this ever hits ASML's orders, like if this ever hits ASML's orders, like if this ever hits ASML's orders, maybe it hits it in 5 years and like the maybe it hits it in 5 years and like the maybe it hits it in 5 years and like the market has forgotten about it, got market has forgotten about it, got market has forgotten about it, got worried about it, forgotten about it, worried about it, forgotten about it, worried about it, forgotten about it, got worried about it, forgotten about it got worried about it, forgotten about it got worried about it, forgotten about it multiple times um along the way. Um so I multiple times um along the way. Um so I multiple times um along the way. Um so I do think that was probably an do think that was probably an do think that was probably an overreaction, but we shouldn't dismiss overreaction, but we shouldn't dismiss overreaction, but we shouldn't dismiss that either. that either. that either. And if you're China, like this is like And if you're China, like this is like And if you're China, like this is like really important to you. really important to you. really important to you. Um and they're Um and they're Um and they're you know, there are some reports that you know, there are some reports that you know, there are some reports that like an EV machine had been smuggled like an EV machine had been smuggled like an EV machine had been smuggled into China. into China. into China. Um Um Um and I mean, what a feat of espionage cuz and I mean, what a feat of espionage cuz and I mean, what a feat of espionage cuz those things are like giant machines. those things are like giant machines. those things are like giant machines. They're They're They're they're [laughter] huge. Um I don't know they're [laughter] huge. Um I don't know they're [laughter] huge. Um I don't know if that's true. You know, there's some if that's true. You know, there's some if that's true. You know, there's some noise about it, but um noise about it, but um noise about it, but um you know, China, they're really really you know, China, they're really really you know, China, they're really really good. They're really really smart. They good. They're really really smart. They good. They're really really smart. They work brutally hard. work brutally hard. work brutally hard. And you know, they see this is super And you know, they see this is super And you know, they see this is super important for them as a country. important for them as a country. important for them as a country. Um Um Um but are they going to go from the year but are they going to go from the year but are they going to go from the year 2001 2001 2001 to 2026 to 2026 to 2026 or even 2000 and you know, 30? or even 2000 and you know, 30? or even 2000 and you know, 30? Are they going to it it cuz it really is Are they going to it it cuz it really is Are they going to it it cuz it really is it is it is it is >> It's a learning by doing. >> It's a learning by doing. >> It's a learning by doing. >> It's it's a learning by doing. >> It's it's a learning by doing. >> It's it's a learning by doing. And you kind of have to Yeah, if like And you kind of have to Yeah, if like And you kind of have to Yeah, if like like you can't you can't accelerate the like you can't you can't accelerate the like you can't you can't accelerate the doing. You can't you can't teleport into doing. You can't you can't teleport into doing. You can't you can't teleport into the future. You actually have to go the future. You actually have to go the future. You actually have to go through those learning cycles. through those learning cycles. through those learning cycles. So, So, So, is it significant? Yes. Did the market is it significant? Yes. Did the market is it significant? Yes. Did the market overreact? Probably. But like I think a overreact? Probably. But like I think a overreact? Probably. But like I think a lot of lot of lot of like I think it's it's very hard as an like I think it's it's very hard as an like I think it's it's very hard as an American American American to really understand what is happening to really understand what is happening to really understand what is happening in China and like have in China and like have in China and like have like total conviction and clarity, you like total conviction and clarity, you like total conviction and clarity, you know, like for know, like for know, like for for better or worse, like we are for better or worse, like we are for better or worse, like we are decoupling. And decoupling. And decoupling. And um just that is a process that is been set just that is a process that is been set in motion. in motion. in motion. And at this point it almost feels like And at this point it almost feels like And at this point it almost feels like it's kind of self-reinforcing on each it's kind of self-reinforcing on each it's kind of self-reinforcing on each side. side. side. And you know, that's that's unfortunate. And you know, that's that's unfortunate. And you know, that's that's unfortunate. Um Um Um but but but we are where we are. And they're not we are where we are. And they're not we are where we are. And they're not they're not going to stop, neither are they're not going to stop, neither are they're not going to stop, neither are we. we. we. >> Any commentary on like every other >> Any commentary on like every other >> Any commentary on like every other company in America? Like I feel like company in America? Like I feel like company in America? Like I feel like right now it is 10 companies, couple right now it is 10 companies, couple right now it is 10 companies, couple private. private. private. >> Well, that that last month, I mean, >> Well, that that last month, I mean, >> Well, that that last month, I mean, everything but AI was vertical. everything but AI was vertical. everything but AI was vertical. And I do think open you know, open And I do think open you know, open And I do think open you know, open source getting closer to the frontier source getting closer to the frontier source getting closer to the frontier and companies like Fireworks making it and companies like Fireworks making it and companies like Fireworks making it really easy to customize a model such really easy to customize a model such really easy to customize a model such that you can get that you can get that you can get in some cases better than frontier for in some cases better than frontier for in some cases better than frontier for performance for meaningfully lower cost. performance for meaningfully lower cost. performance for meaningfully lower cost. That is a godsend for the software That is a godsend for the software That is a godsend for the software industry. industry. industry. And it's also a godsend for all these And it's also a godsend for all these And it's also a godsend for all these like, you know, there's there's a lot of like, you know, there's there's a lot of like, you know, there's there's a lot of AI natives and like all these AI AI natives and like all these AI AI natives and like all these AI natives, you know, it's like our friend natives, you know, it's like our friend natives, you know, it's like our friend Vashria, I think he said 2 years ago, Vashria, I think he said 2 years ago, Vashria, I think he said 2 years ago, I've never seen more companies go from I've never seen more companies go from I've never seen more companies go from like being founded like being founded like being founded to like $50 million a year in revenue to like $50 million a year in revenue to like $50 million a year in revenue and generating cash flow in like and generating cash flow in like and generating cash flow in like whatever it is, 9 months. whatever it is, 9 months. whatever it is, 9 months. And it's hard to know if any of them are And it's hard to know if any of them are And it's hard to know if any of them are durable because like back then, like durable because like back then, like durable because like back then, like it's like, hey, you know, these are a it's like, hey, you know, these are a it's like, hey, you know, these are a lot of people would dismiss them as chat lot of people would dismiss them as chat lot of people would dismiss them as chat GPT wrappers. GPT wrappers. GPT wrappers. Well, now with open source, you've Well, now with open source, you've Well, now with open source, you've actually you you've generated some data actually you you've generated some data actually you you've generated some data that's unique to your your use case, that's unique to your your use case, that's unique to your your use case, whatever your vertical you're going whatever your vertical you're going whatever your vertical you're going after has a wrapper is. Fireworks, they after has a wrapper is. Fireworks, they after has a wrapper is. Fireworks, they did come out with a really cool product did come out with a really cool product did come out with a really cool product called Nexus. called Nexus. called Nexus. And if you're using cloud code, open AI And if you're using cloud code, open AI And if you're using cloud code, open AI codex, grok build, codex, grok build, codex, grok build, it is literally three lines of code, it is literally three lines of code, it is literally three lines of code, like 20 words. like 20 words. like 20 words. And um Fireworks adjust your data And um Fireworks adjust your data And um Fireworks adjust your data kind of, you know, they can RL a model kind of, you know, they can RL a model kind of, you know, they can RL a model and then there's a router that sends the and then there's a router that sends the and then there's a router that sends the query and they've had amazing results. query and they've had amazing results. query and they've had amazing results. Um and this is kind of the solution Um and this is kind of the solution Um and this is kind of the solution for every AI native and that's why you for every AI native and that's why you for every AI native and that's why you saw, saw, saw, you know, Harvey you know, Harvey you know, Harvey uh before it was acquired, um Cursor uh before it was acquired, um Cursor uh before it was acquired, um Cursor leads so heavily into this. Harvey, leads so heavily into this. Harvey, leads so heavily into this. Harvey, Legora, all of them. Because if you can Legora, all of them. Because if you can Legora, all of them. Because if you can go from just using one, two, two three go from just using one, two, two three go from just using one, two, two three frontier models to use a frontier models to use a frontier models to use a >> Whatever's optimal. >> Whatever's optimal. >> Whatever's optimal. >> those frontier bottles for whatever it >> those frontier bottles for whatever it >> those frontier bottles for whatever it is, 30% is, 30% is, 30% 60% 60% 60% of your token consumption and then use of your token consumption and then use of your token consumption and then use your own RL bottle, all of a sudden your own RL bottle, all of a sudden your own RL bottle, all of a sudden you're not a rapper. You're way more you're not a rapper. You're way more you're not a rapper. You're way more defensible. defensible. defensible. Um Um Um >> I was so interested by that cursor thing >> I was so interested by that cursor thing >> I was so interested by that cursor thing that came out. I think it was cursor that came out. I think it was cursor that came out. I think it was cursor where it's sort of like a AI speed where it's sort of like a AI speed where it's sort of like a AI speed running like what we've learned amongst running like what we've learned amongst running like what we've learned amongst humans, which is you could use the humans, which is you could use the humans, which is you could use the frontier model to plan and then farm out frontier model to plan and then farm out frontier model to plan and then farm out tasks to the dumber models. tasks to the dumber models. tasks to the dumber models. >> 100% >> 100% >> 100% >> And and it's 15 times more efficient or >> And and it's 15 times more efficient or >> And and it's 15 times more efficient or whatever the metric was. whatever the metric was. whatever the metric was. >> It it it may be that like >> It it it may be that like >> It it it may be that like if this is like super ironic, if this is like super ironic, if this is like super ironic, um um um but it may be that like lower margin but it may be that like lower margin but it may be that like lower margin open source tokens that are just open source tokens that are just open source tokens that are just a little bit behind the frontier and you a little bit behind the frontier and you a little bit behind the frontier and you know, we have a we have friends who know, we have a we have friends who know, we have a we have friends who believe that you know, frontier believe that you know, frontier believe that you know, frontier [clears throat] [clears throat] [clears throat] once a frontier model hits RSI once a frontier model hits RSI once a frontier model hits RSI it will actually have a dramatically it will actually have a dramatically it will actually have a dramatically lower cost lower cost lower cost >> to serve the local >> to serve the local >> to serve the local >> at at every >> at at every >> at at every at every level of intelligence by kind at every level of intelligence by kind at every level of intelligence by kind of distilling this and then there's no of distilling this and then there's no of distilling this and then there's no place for open source. I would say place for open source. I would say place for open source. I would say that's like a that's like a that's like a you know, a um you know, a um you know, a um Anthropic Anthropic Anthropic OpenAI Grok maximalist view. And you OpenAI Grok maximalist view. And you OpenAI Grok maximalist view. And you know, we should we shouldn't dismiss know, we should we shouldn't dismiss know, we should we shouldn't dismiss anything. I don't know or really anything. I don't know or really anything. I don't know or really important. Anything is possible. Like important. Anything is possible. Like important. Anything is possible. Like you know, we we we would have like be be you know, we we we would have like be be you know, we we we would have like be be very humble. I particularly want to be very humble. I particularly want to be very humble. I particularly want to be humble after the month I've had. humble after the month I've had. humble after the month I've had. But that doesn't seem that likely to be But that doesn't seem that likely to be But that doesn't seem that likely to be and and and >> Why? >> Why? >> Why? >> Well, >> Well, >> Well, um um um one because there are so many of these one because there are so many of these one because there are so many of these AI natives that have actually AI natives that have actually AI natives that have actually generated a decent amount of domain generated a decent amount of domain generated a decent amount of domain specific proprietary data. specific proprietary data. specific proprietary data. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And kind of before like >> And kind of before like >> And kind of before like open source had this moment to these open source had this moment to these open source had this moment to these inference clouds and these routers inference clouds and these routers inference clouds and these routers really developed like you kind of didn't really developed like you kind of didn't really developed like you kind of didn't have a choice. Like whatever the terms have a choice. Like whatever the terms have a choice. Like whatever the terms of service were, you accepted them. But of service were, you accepted them. But of service were, you accepted them. But if you can now kind of get off that if you can now kind of get off that if you can now kind of get off that treadmill, treadmill, treadmill, um that gives you a degree of um that gives you a degree of um that gives you a degree of independence, independence, independence, maybe durability, safety. But kind of maybe durability, safety. But kind of maybe durability, safety. But kind of going back to your point, it may be that going back to your point, it may be that going back to your point, it may be that these cheaper tokens these cheaper tokens these cheaper tokens just just just massively inflate the value of the most massively inflate the value of the most massively inflate the value of the most cutting-edge frontier tokens. cutting-edge frontier tokens. cutting-edge frontier tokens. Because if like today if you have I you Because if like today if you have I you Because if like today if you have I you know I'm going to make this up, you know I'm going to make this up, you know I'm going to make this up, you know, 120 IQ open-source models, know, 120 IQ open-source models, know, 120 IQ open-source models, um and they're really cheap to run, um and they're really cheap to run, um and they're really cheap to run, well, doesn't that make a 160 IQ model well, doesn't that make a 160 IQ model well, doesn't that make a 160 IQ model that can orchestrate them that can orchestrate them that can orchestrate them more valuable? And so just we talked more valuable? And so just we talked more valuable? And so just we talked last time about how last time about how last time about how I've been really surprised that you know I've been really surprised that you know I've been really surprised that you know so much of the economic returns have so much of the economic returns have so much of the economic returns have accrued to the frontier. accrued to the frontier. accrued to the frontier. Now that that is changing with what Now that that is changing with what Now that that is changing with what we're seeing with these kind of we're seeing with these kind of we're seeing with these kind of inference clouds. Um inference clouds. Um inference clouds. Um together, Modal, um together, Modal, um together, Modal, um uh Base 10 in a very cash-efficient way. uh Base 10 in a very cash-efficient way. uh Base 10 in a very cash-efficient way. What's shocking about those business What's shocking about those business What's shocking about those business models models models is they're growing almost as fast as the is they're growing almost as fast as the is they're growing almost as fast as the frontier labs in the early days, frontier labs in the early days, frontier labs in the early days, but burning very little cash. but burning very little cash. but burning very little cash. Like it's it's pretty extraordinary, you Like it's it's pretty extraordinary, you Like it's it's pretty extraordinary, you know, from like you know look to go back know, from like you know look to go back know, from like you know look to go back to silly SaaS metrics like the you know to silly SaaS metrics like the you know to silly SaaS metrics like the you know the rule of 40 perspective. Like the rule of 40 perspective. Like the rule of 40 perspective. Like these are crazy numbers. these are crazy numbers. these are crazy numbers. >> Do you think there's a lot of >> Do you think there's a lot of >> Do you think there's a lot of instruction in just like the instruction in just like the instruction in just like the distribution of pay inside of an distribution of pay inside of an distribution of pay inside of an organization? Like the CEO makes X times organization? Like the CEO makes X times organization? Like the CEO makes X times more than the median person at a company more than the median person at a company more than the median person at a company and maybe that's frontier tokens versus, and maybe that's frontier tokens versus, and maybe that's frontier tokens versus, you know, open-source tokens. you know, open-source tokens. you know, open-source tokens. >> Absolutely. Yeah. >> Absolutely. Yeah. >> Absolutely. Yeah. >> Something simple like we can >> Something simple like we can >> Something simple like we can >> Yeah, it may be that what we discussed >> Yeah, it may be that what we discussed >> Yeah, it may be that what we discussed last time where you know frontier tokens last time where you know frontier tokens last time where you know frontier tokens I think they may lose a like the pie is I think they may lose a like the pie is I think they may lose a like the pie is growing really really fast. growing really really fast. growing really really fast. They may continue to capture the They may continue to capture the They may continue to capture the overwhelming majority of economic value, overwhelming majority of economic value, overwhelming majority of economic value, but kind of not all of it the way they but kind of not all of it the way they but kind of not all of it the way they have been, and open source tokens might have been, and open source tokens might have been, and open source tokens might be the majority of token source tokens be the majority of token source tokens be the majority of token source tokens processed. processed. processed. It just again, going back, that's great It just again, going back, that's great It just again, going back, that's great for infrastructure demand because a for infrastructure demand because a for infrastructure demand because a token is a token and it token is a token and it token is a token and it takes the same amount of flops, takes the same amount of flops, takes the same amount of flops, watts, watts, watts, space, cooling to make. space, cooling to make. space, cooling to make. >> What's the worst thing that could happen >> What's the worst thing that could happen >> What's the worst thing that could happen in AI? Is it regulatory? Is it some sort in AI? Is it regulatory? Is it some sort in AI? Is it regulatory? Is it some sort of like of like of like >> I think regulatory has to be the biggest >> I think regulatory has to be the biggest >> I think regulatory has to be the biggest risk. risk. risk. Um Um Um I mean, it's the most obvious risk. I mean, it's the most obvious risk. I mean, it's the most obvious risk. And so that was kind of one reason I was And so that was kind of one reason I was And so that was kind of one reason I was excited to be here this week excited to be here this week excited to be here this week was to just like was to just like was to just like I I I I want to be scared, you know? I like I I want to be scared, you know? I like I I want to be scared, you know? I like I don't I don't want to feel like a don't I don't want to feel like a don't I don't want to feel like a lunatic, you know, watching these stocks lunatic, you know, watching these stocks lunatic, you know, watching these stocks relative to um you know, get more relative to um you know, get more relative to um you know, get more cheaper thinking the expected forward cheaper thinking the expected forward cheaper thinking the expected forward returns are going up. returns are going up. returns are going up. You know, while you know, You know, while you know, You know, while you know, it feels like the on the ground it feels like the on the ground it feels like the on the ground fundamentals have like pretty materially fundamentals have like pretty materially fundamentals have like pretty materially improved. improved. improved. Um Um Um in July relative to even June, but I in July relative to even June, but I in July relative to even June, but I still came come away thinking like still came come away thinking like still came come away thinking like you know, regulation, it just has to be you know, regulation, it just has to be you know, regulation, it just has to be the biggest risk. Like you just can't the biggest risk. Like you just can't the biggest risk. Like you just can't ignore New York ignore New York ignore New York making a data center moratorium. making a data center moratorium. making a data center moratorium. It just like we are we're living in this It just like we are we're living in this It just like we are we're living in this weird weird weird post-factual, post-logical political post-factual, post-logical political post-factual, post-logical political world. world. world. It It It you know, you know, you know, and I mean, I think the AI industry it and I mean, I think the AI industry it and I mean, I think the AI industry it has done a has done a has done a terrible job terrible job terrible job of PR, and I do think they're of PR, and I do think they're of PR, and I do think they're >> it at least realizes that now. >> it at least realizes that now. >> it at least realizes that now. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Maybe if not fixed it, it realizes it. >> Maybe if not fixed it, it realizes it. >> Maybe if not fixed it, it realizes it. >> Yeah, but like kind of the narrative in >> Yeah, but like kind of the narrative in >> Yeah, but like kind of the narrative in Washington, you know, that that that the Washington, you know, that that that the Washington, you know, that that that the political narrative, you know, I think political narrative, you know, I think political narrative, you know, I think amongst a lot of ordinary Americans is amongst a lot of ordinary Americans is amongst a lot of ordinary Americans is like data centers, like data centers, like data centers, they're going to raise your electricity they're going to raise your electricity they're going to raise your electricity prices, they're going to take all your prices, they're going to take all your prices, they're going to take all your water, and they're going to take your water, and they're going to take your water, and they're going to take your job. job. job. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> And the reality is like given the deals >> And the reality is like given the deals >> And the reality is like given the deals that are being cut now, when a data that are being cut now, when a data that are being cut now, when a data center goes in, electricity prices center goes in, electricity prices center goes in, electricity prices actually generally go down for everyone actually generally go down for everyone actually generally go down for everyone around there because of behind the meter around there because of behind the meter around there because of behind the meter deals. deals. deals. This is that like data center pledge This is that like data center pledge This is that like data center pledge that kind of Trump asked people to to that kind of Trump asked people to to that kind of Trump asked people to to sign. Generally, the data center sign. Generally, the data center sign. Generally, the data center developer, you know, it used to be they developer, you know, it used to be they developer, you know, it used to be they just had to build a like, you know, just had to build a like, you know, just had to build a like, you know, whatever. They had to get the police whatever. They had to get the police whatever. They had to get the police department or the fire departments like, department or the fire departments like, department or the fire departments like, you know, new trucks and new cars and, you know, new trucks and new cars and, you know, new trucks and new cars and, you know, new body armor or whatever. you know, new body armor or whatever. you know, new body armor or whatever. Now, it's like, well, we're going to Now, it's like, well, we're going to Now, it's like, well, we're going to build you a hospital, a school, a new build you a hospital, a school, a new build you a hospital, a school, a new police station, and a fire station. And police station, and a fire station. And police station, and a fire station. And we're going to lower your power bills. we're going to lower your power bills. we're going to lower your power bills. How does that sound? And by the way, the How does that sound? And by the way, the How does that sound? And by the way, the jobs are ongoing because it turns out jobs are ongoing because it turns out jobs are ongoing because it turns out that you kind of need these plumbers, that you kind of need these plumbers, that you kind of need these plumbers, electricians, you know, electricians, you know, electricians, you know, HVAC contractors. And this is like data HVAC contractors. And this is like data HVAC contractors. And this is like data centers are like centers are like centers are like are in a lot of ways the best thing to are in a lot of ways the best thing to are in a lot of ways the best thing to happen happen happen for blue-collar wages in my lifetime. for blue-collar wages in my lifetime. for blue-collar wages in my lifetime. And yet, you have the Democrats who And yet, you have the Democrats who And yet, you have the Democrats who ostensibly ostensibly ostensibly represent the, you know, the blue, you represent the, you know, the blue, you represent the, you know, the blue, you know, these blue-collar workers know, these blue-collar workers know, these blue-collar workers taking their jobs away. taking their jobs away. taking their jobs away. Um Um Um And so, um And so, um And so, um it it also like it it also like it it also like it's it's just kind of wild how like, it's it's just kind of wild how like, it's it's just kind of wild how like, what is the phrase? Like a lie can go what is the phrase? Like a lie can go what is the phrase? Like a lie can go around the world around the world around the world >> Faster than the truth gets out of bed, >> Faster than the truth gets out of bed, >> Faster than the truth gets out of bed, yeah. yeah. yeah. >> Yeah, faster than truth gets out of bed. >> Yeah, faster than truth gets out of bed. >> Yeah, faster than truth gets out of bed. But an author made a mistake in a book But an author made a mistake in a book But an author made a mistake in a book and overestimated the amount of water and overestimated the amount of water and overestimated the amount of water usage in data centers by 10,000 X. Not a usage in data centers by 10,000 X. Not a usage in data centers by 10,000 X. Not a little bit. Like not one order of little bit. Like not one order of little bit. Like not one order of magnitude. Not two orders of magnitude. magnitude. Not two orders of magnitude. magnitude. Not two orders of magnitude. Not three, you know? Not three, you know? Not three, you know? Um Um Um and um and um and um she's admitted that mistake many times. she's admitted that mistake many times. she's admitted that mistake many times. I was completely wrong. I was completely wrong. I was completely wrong. It's like been super debugged. It's like been super debugged. It's like been super debugged. >> uh Popeye effect. Did you Did you hear >> uh Popeye effect. Did you Did you hear >> uh Popeye effect. Did you Did you hear that example? that example? that example? >> No. >> No. >> No. >> The the, you know, Popeye eats spinach. >> The the, you know, Popeye eats spinach. >> The the, you know, Popeye eats spinach. The reason was same deal in an academic The reason was same deal in an academic The reason was same deal in an academic in an academic book. They placed the in an academic book. They placed the in an academic book. They placed the decimal two things wrong. So, spinach decimal two things wrong. So, spinach decimal two things wrong. So, spinach does not have more iron than everything does not have more iron than everything does not have more iron than everything else. It was just this one source and else. It was just this one source and else. It was just this one source and then that propagated through people then that propagated through people then that propagated through people still say it has more iron. still say it has more iron. still say it has more iron. >> I literally had I thought it had more >> I literally had I thought it had more >> I literally had I thought it had more iron. [laughter] I mean that's wild. iron. [laughter] I mean that's wild. iron. [laughter] I mean that's wild. That's wild. I literally thought spinach That's wild. I literally thought spinach That's wild. I literally thought spinach had more iron. had more iron. had more iron. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> That's amazing. >> That's amazing. >> That's amazing. >> Yeah, you learn something new every day. >> Yeah, you learn something new every day. >> Yeah, you learn something new every day. >> Same thing though. >> Same thing though. >> Same thing though. >> Uh yeah, it's the same thing and it's >> Uh yeah, it's the same thing and it's >> Uh yeah, it's the same thing and it's just just just So somebody just needs to tell the So somebody just needs to tell the So somebody just needs to tell the truth. Like like I I feel like the truth. Like like I I feel like the truth. Like like I I feel like the industry and I thought like jeez, maybe industry and I thought like jeez, maybe industry and I thought like jeez, maybe if nobody else is going to do it like if nobody else is going to do it like if nobody else is going to do it like I'll do it. Like there needs to be some I'll do it. Like there needs to be some I'll do it. Like there needs to be some sort of foundation. Maybe it's a pack sort of foundation. Maybe it's a pack sort of foundation. Maybe it's a pack that runs ads during the final four, that runs ads during the final four, that runs ads during the final four, during the NFL games, during college during the NFL games, during college during the NFL games, during college football games. football games. football games. >> Here's the virtues. >> Here's the virtues. >> Here's the virtues. >> World Series. >> World Series. >> World Series. Here's what a data center does. Your Here's what a data center does. Your Here's what a data center does. Your power a data center that signed this power a data center that signed this power a data center that signed this pledge in your community. pledge in your community. pledge in your community. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Your power prices are going to go down. >> Your power prices are going to go down. >> Your power prices are going to go down. They're almost certainly going to They're almost certainly going to They're almost certainly going to um um um you know you know you know like contribute to the community in a like contribute to the community in a like contribute to the community in a material way. You're going to see a material way. You're going to see a material way. You're going to see a massive influx of super high paying blue massive influx of super high paying blue massive influx of super high paying blue collar jobs collar jobs collar jobs that are going to persist and I think a that are going to persist and I think a that are going to persist and I think a lot of people thought that they were one lot of people thought that they were one lot of people thought that they were one time and they're just not. Like there's time and they're just not. Like there's time and they're just not. Like there's for sure a spike and then that moves to for sure a spike and then that moves to for sure a spike and then that moves to the next data center but there is an the next data center but there is an the next data center but there is an ongoing kind of ongoing kind of ongoing kind of you know, need for kind of RMA and then you know, need for kind of RMA and then you know, need for kind of RMA and then upgrades at these data centers and and upgrades at these data centers and and upgrades at these data centers and and technology is changing. So you're going technology is changing. So you're going technology is changing. So you're going to have more jobs, you're going to have to have more jobs, you're going to have to have more jobs, you're going to have cheaper power. cheaper power. cheaper power. You're going to have a wealthier You're going to have a wealthier You're going to have a wealthier community. Um there's going to be no community. Um there's going to be no community. Um there's going to be no impact on on water, no impact on the impact on on water, no impact on the impact on on water, no impact on the environment. You know, and it's easy to environment. You know, and it's easy to environment. You know, and it's easy to build the data center 10 miles out of build the data center 10 miles out of build the data center 10 miles out of town, you know. town, you know. town, you know. And so like that story needs to be told And so like that story needs to be told And so like that story needs to be told along with, you know, like there are you along with, you know, like there are you along with, you know, like there are you know, we we we we we heard a we we heard know, we we we we we heard a we we heard know, we we we we we heard a we we heard a story I think we talked about it last a story I think we talked about it last a story I think we talked about it last time about how AI is increasingly really time about how AI is increasingly really time about how AI is increasingly really saving lives, curing rare diseases. saving lives, curing rare diseases. saving lives, curing rare diseases. Like we um Like we um Like we um you know, I think I can't remember if it you know, I think I can't remember if it you know, I think I can't remember if it was I I think it was at ASCO this year. was I I think it was at ASCO this year. was I I think it was at ASCO this year. You know, the kind of vibe, you know, You know, the kind of vibe, you know, You know, the kind of vibe, you know, the the vibe was like hey, we've this is the the vibe was like hey, we've this is the the vibe was like hey, we've this is the most scientific breakthroughs we've the most scientific breakthroughs we've the most scientific breakthroughs we've ever seen ever seen ever seen at a single conference. at a single conference. at a single conference. And for sure some of that is due to AI. And for sure some of that is due to AI. And for sure some of that is due to AI. And so we need to like tell those And so we need to like tell those And so we need to like tell those stories. Like, you know, if you have a stories. Like, you know, if you have a stories. Like, you know, if you have a sick child, you know, a sick parent, uh sick child, you know, a sick parent, uh sick child, you know, a sick parent, uh a sick loved one, like a sick loved one, like a sick loved one, like AI meaningfully increases the odds AI meaningfully increases the odds AI meaningfully increases the odds of them recovering. of them recovering. of them recovering. Like if we just we we need it's Like if we just we we need it's Like if we just we we need it's everybody needs to tell this. And I everybody needs to tell this. And I everybody needs to tell this. And I think people out here think people out here think people out here it's all of this is so blindingly it's all of this is so blindingly it's all of this is so blindingly obvious to them obvious to them obvious to them that they they that they they that they they >> seems everyone else already knows. >> seems everyone else already knows. >> seems everyone else already knows. >> They they can't Yeah, they can't process >> They they can't Yeah, they can't process >> They they can't Yeah, they can't process that this is a that this is a that this is a true but wildly divergent view true but wildly divergent view true but wildly divergent view from most Americans. And so like I think the industry really And so like I think the industry really needs to tell its story better. needs to tell its story better. needs to tell its story better. Cuz this is Cuz this is Cuz this is like like like New York, it just feels like it's the New York, it just feels like it's the New York, it just feels like it's the first of many and even in some of these first of many and even in some of these first of many and even in some of these deep red states, they're super deep red states, they're super deep red states, they're super pro-growth. pro-growth. pro-growth. They're just like, "Hey, you guys are They're just like, "Hey, you guys are They're just like, "Hey, you guys are not doing a good job telling your story. not doing a good job telling your story. not doing a good job telling your story. Then we can't we can't tell your story. Then we can't we can't tell your story. Then we can't we can't tell your story. If you tell your story though, we can If you tell your story though, we can If you tell your story though, we can retell it, but like you're the experts." retell it, but like you're the experts." retell it, but like you're the experts." Um you know, if you like Um you know, if you like Um you know, if you like like something I've if you do not speak like something I've if you do not speak like something I've if you do not speak your own truth, no one else will. your own truth, no one else will. your own truth, no one else will. >> [clears throat] >> [clears throat] >> [clears throat] >> Yeah. What have we missed with >> Yeah. What have we missed with >> Yeah. What have we missed with >> I think something that is missing from >> I think something that is missing from >> I think something that is missing from all of this conversation about compute all of this conversation about compute all of this conversation about compute is what is going to happen when you put is what is going to happen when you put is what is going to happen when you put these SRAM-based accelerators that are these SRAM-based accelerators that are these SRAM-based accelerators that are not constrained not constrained not constrained by HBM DRAM and are often made on older by HBM DRAM and are often made on older by HBM DRAM and are often made on older nodes that are not competing nodes that are not competing nodes that are not competing with like the latest and greatest GPUs. with like the latest and greatest GPUs. with like the latest and greatest GPUs. You can whether you there's when you You can whether you there's when you You can whether you there's when you disaggregate Fritz, there's people talk disaggregate Fritz, there's people talk disaggregate Fritz, there's people talk about prefill and decode, but decode has about prefill and decode, but decode has about prefill and decode, but decode has two parts, attention and feed forward two parts, attention and feed forward two parts, attention and feed forward network, and like the ultimate holy network, and like the ultimate holy network, and like the ultimate holy grail is if you could do pre-fill grail is if you could do pre-fill grail is if you could do pre-fill on one chip. on one chip. on one chip. Um it probably doesn't have HBM DRAM. Do Um it probably doesn't have HBM DRAM. Do Um it probably doesn't have HBM DRAM. Do the attention on a super high-powered the attention on a super high-powered the attention on a super high-powered chip with HBM DRAM, and then do the feed chip with HBM DRAM, and then do the feed chip with HBM DRAM, and then do the feed forward network on one of these SRAM forward network on one of these SRAM forward network on one of these SRAM chips. chips. chips. But like But like But like the ROI on adding these SRAM the ROI on adding these SRAM the ROI on adding these SRAM accelerators, accelerators, accelerators, uh uh uh to the existing install base of compute to the existing install base of compute to the existing install base of compute and and new compute. and and new compute. and and new compute. But like what we're seeing is like But like what we're seeing is like But like what we're seeing is like you do better. You just can't beat SRAM you do better. You just can't beat SRAM you do better. You just can't beat SRAM in particular for that feed forward in particular for that feed forward in particular for that feed forward network. And And you just almost you network. And And you just almost you network. And And you just almost you can't, no matter how much you try to get can't, no matter how much you try to get can't, no matter how much you try to get the ratio of compute to HBM DRAM the ratio of compute to HBM DRAM the ratio of compute to HBM DRAM to SRAM on the chip correct. Like the to SRAM on the chip correct. Like the to SRAM on the chip correct. Like the workloads are always changing, and workloads are always changing, and workloads are always changing, and there's different workloads. there's different workloads. there's different workloads. And like And like And like being able to disaggregate it to these being able to disaggregate it to these being able to disaggregate it to these three parts, three parts, three parts, uh uh uh like I think this is like I think this is like I think this is this is going to be really really this is going to be really really this is going to be really really positive for the ROI of AI. positive for the ROI of AI. positive for the ROI of AI. >> For some reason I just thought of a >> For some reason I just thought of a >> For some reason I just thought of a funny question, which I love their funny question, which I love their funny question, which I love their framing of Game of Thrones versus all framing of Game of Thrones versus all framing of Game of Thrones versus all these people. Can you imagine a player these people. Can you imagine a player these people. Can you imagine a player that is not currently on everyone's mind that is not currently on everyone's mind that is not currently on everyone's mind becoming relevant at like the major Game becoming relevant at like the major Game becoming relevant at like the major Game of Thrones scale? Like that could be of Thrones scale? Like that could be of Thrones scale? Like that could be like Micron all of a sudden, you know, like Micron all of a sudden, you know, like Micron all of a sudden, you know, it'd be like a sample answer to the it'd be like a sample answer to the it'd be like a sample answer to the question of someone that becomes as question of someone that becomes as question of someone that becomes as important as Anthropic, OpenAI, important as Anthropic, OpenAI, important as Anthropic, OpenAI, Microsoft, Amazon, you know, Nvidia, Microsoft, Amazon, you know, Nvidia, Microsoft, Amazon, you know, Nvidia, SpaceX. SpaceX. SpaceX. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. So like a dark horse Game of Thrones So like a dark horse Game of Thrones So like a dark horse Game of Thrones player? player? player? >> that come to mind. >> that come to mind. >> that come to mind. Um Um Um like Li Bu is probably a dark horse. like Li Bu is probably a dark horse. like Li Bu is probably a dark horse. Um I do think um Lin at Fireworks, she is I do think um Lin at Fireworks, she is like a like a like a just an absolute killer. just an absolute killer. just an absolute killer. Um I think Um I think Um I think uh you know, our friend Scott Wool. uh you know, our friend Scott Wool. uh you know, our friend Scott Wool. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> You know, cognition is kind of like uh >> You know, cognition is kind of like uh >> You know, cognition is kind of like uh >> Here, here to that one. >> Here, here to that one. >> Here, here to that one. >> Yes. >> Yes. >> Yes. Uh uh Uh uh Uh uh I think those are I think those are I think those are uh the most obvious names. uh the most obvious names. uh the most obvious names. >> What about SpaceX? What's it been like >> What about SpaceX? What's it been like >> What about SpaceX? What's it been like watching that be digested by public watching that be digested by public watching that be digested by public markets at least initially? markets at least initially? markets at least initially? >> Uh uh >> Uh uh >> Uh uh >> Do you think the market understands it >> Do you think the market understands it >> Do you think the market understands it as a company? The most important new as a company? The most important new as a company? The most important new company to be public? company to be public? company to be public? >> It doesn't really feel like it >> It doesn't really feel like it >> It doesn't really feel like it it does because it's kind of like such a it does because it's kind of like such a it does because it's kind of like such a it's such a it's such a it's such a like everything to me is like everything to me is like everything to me is the fundamentals have gotten better the fundamentals have gotten better the fundamentals have gotten better since it IPO'd. Like Rock 4.5, the since it IPO'd. Like Rock 4.5, the since it IPO'd. Like Rock 4.5, the Cursor acquisition. Cursor acquisition. Cursor acquisition. You know, Cursor You know, Cursor You know, Cursor uh has clearly accelerated meaningfully. uh has clearly accelerated meaningfully. uh has clearly accelerated meaningfully. And then they have showed that they And then they have showed that they And then they have showed that they could, you know, they've they've showed could, you know, they've they've showed could, you know, they've they've showed over the last 3 years they could bring over the last 3 years they could bring over the last 3 years they could bring out more compute faster than anyone out more compute faster than anyone out more compute faster than anyone at lower prices. And now we know that at lower prices. And now we know that at lower prices. And now we know that they could even adjusting for the spot they could even adjusting for the spot they could even adjusting for the spot first contract gap, like their big first contract gap, like their big first contract gap, like their big advantage was they came into the market advantage was they came into the market advantage was they came into the market you know, and just hit those spot highs. you know, and just hit those spot highs. you know, and just hit those spot highs. Uh uh Uh uh Uh uh And in a strange way, like one of the And in a strange way, like one of the And in a strange way, like one of the more bullish things for compute more bullish things for compute more bullish things for compute is like, you know, they put a vast is like, you know, they put a vast is like, you know, they put a vast amount of compute into the market amount of compute into the market amount of compute into the market overnight. overnight. overnight. And it wasn't even really a blip. And it wasn't even really a blip. And it wasn't even really a blip. It was like the market just It was like the market just It was like the market just utterly absorbed it, you know? Like just utterly absorbed it, you know? Like just utterly absorbed it, you know? Like just the free trade didn't sold out at all. the free trade didn't sold out at all. the free trade didn't sold out at all. Uh uh Uh uh Uh uh But you know, a you know, a Substack But you know, a you know, a Substack But you know, a you know, a Substack writer Wolfund Fund AI, writer Wolfund Fund AI, writer Wolfund Fund AI, they think that SpaceX is going to try they think that SpaceX is going to try they think that SpaceX is going to try and bring out 8 gigawatts of compute. and bring out 8 gigawatts of compute. and bring out 8 gigawatts of compute. I will never bet against Elon. But I mean But I mean that would be a truly incredible feat. that would be a truly incredible feat. that would be a truly incredible feat. And they are And they are And they are rates have gone up since they signed rates have gone up since they signed rates have gone up since they signed those last contracts, not down. those last contracts, not down. those last contracts, not down. And they're monetizing at something like And they're monetizing at something like And they're monetizing at something like 50 billion a gig. 50 billion a gig. 50 billion a gig. And ConsenSys estimates for next year And ConsenSys estimates for next year And ConsenSys estimates for next year are 73 billion. So, forget Starlink V3. are 73 billion. So, forget Starlink V3. are 73 billion. So, forget Starlink V3. Forget Starlink direct to cell. Grok 4.5 Forget Starlink direct to cell. Grok 4.5 Forget Starlink direct to cell. Grok 4.5 and Cursor, the sum of that probably and Cursor, the sum of that probably and Cursor, the sum of that probably hits a $10 billion ARR pretty quickly. hits a $10 billion ARR pretty quickly. hits a $10 billion ARR pretty quickly. For For For Forget all of that. Um Forget all of that. Um Forget all of that. Um you know, forget like the core base you know, forget like the core base you know, forget like the core base Starlink business. Starlink business. Starlink business. If they bring out anywhere near that, If they bring out anywhere near that, If they bring out anywhere near that, the ConsenSys estimate is 73 billion. the ConsenSys estimate is 73 billion. the ConsenSys estimate is 73 billion. And that's 8 gigs at 50 billion a gig. And that's 8 gigs at 50 billion a gig. And that's 8 gigs at 50 billion a gig. And obviously, that would not all be lit And obviously, that would not all be lit And obviously, that would not all be lit up at the beginning of '27. up at the beginning of '27. up at the beginning of '27. And it seems very implausible to me. And it seems very implausible to me. And it seems very implausible to me. Like, I almost don't believe the Funder Like, I almost don't believe the Funder Like, I almost don't believe the Funder report. report. report. Um but but you it To this day, the only companies you it To this day, the only companies you it To this day, the only companies that have brought out more than 500 that have brought out more than 500 that have brought out more than 500 megawatts megawatts megawatts of power of power of power in a year are the hyperscalers, in a year are the hyperscalers, in a year are the hyperscalers, Coreweave, Crusoe, and SpaceX. Coreweave, Crusoe, and SpaceX. Coreweave, Crusoe, and SpaceX. And SpaceX has kind of brought out the And SpaceX has kind of brought out the And SpaceX has kind of brought out the most the fastest at the lowest cost. most the fastest at the lowest cost. most the fastest at the lowest cost. And then And then And then people do actually really like their people do actually really like their people do actually really like their clusters. clusters. clusters. Um but again, it's kind of like the market but again, it's kind of like the market is going to need to see that. is going to need to see that. is going to need to see that. >> That would not be the market's >> That would not be the market's >> That would not be the market's interpretation of SpaceX today. interpretation of SpaceX today. interpretation of SpaceX today. >> No, no. >> No, no. >> No, no. Um Um Um and it does feel like, you know, there's and it does feel like, you know, there's and it does feel like, you know, there's this There's There's a big New York this There's There's a big New York this There's There's a big New York hedge fund short case on it. hedge fund short case on it. hedge fund short case on it. And I think they think, you know, oh, And I think they think, you know, oh, And I think they think, you know, oh, the spot price for compute's going to go the spot price for compute's going to go the spot price for compute's going to go down 90% and, you know, down 90% and, you know, down 90% and, you know, you're going to bring out all this you're going to bring out all this you're going to bring out all this You're going to bring all this on all You're going to bring all this on all You're going to bring all this on all this compute. It's not going to this compute. It's not going to this compute. It's not going to generate, you know, nearly as much generate, you know, nearly as much generate, you know, nearly as much revenue as you think. Maybe, but also revenue as you think. Maybe, but also revenue as you think. Maybe, but also want to be really clear like want to be really clear like want to be really clear like Like, I have seen those I have seen Like, I have seen those I have seen Like, I have seen those I have seen Yolt's companies, you know, do really Yolt's companies, you know, do really Yolt's companies, you know, do really impressive things over the year. Pretty impressive things over the year. Pretty impressive things over the year. Pretty the Funder AI report of 8 gigawatts at the Funder AI report of 8 gigawatts at the Funder AI report of 8 gigawatts at 18 months. 18 months. 18 months. I'm I'm just quoting that cuz it's I'm I'm just quoting that cuz it's I'm I'm just quoting that cuz it's public. It's available to everyone. public. It's available to everyone. public. It's available to everyone. Ooh, like that. Ooh, like that. Ooh, like that. >> yeah. >> yeah. >> yeah. >> That Yes. >> That Yes. >> That Yes. Um Um Um you know, I think one of Elon's phrases you know, I think one of Elon's phrases you know, I think one of Elon's phrases is we specialize in making the is we specialize in making the is we specialize in making the impossible late. impossible late. impossible late. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> I've never heard that. That's great. >> I've never heard that. That's great. >> I've never heard that. That's great. >> Yeah. Um it you know, there's like kind >> Yeah. Um it you know, there's like kind >> Yeah. Um it you know, there's like kind of a lot of truth to that. Yeah, yeah. of a lot of truth to that. Yeah, yeah. of a lot of truth to that. Yeah, yeah. Um Um Um but I just think but I just think but I just think very little is built in very little is built in very little is built in from my perspective to that stock for the amount of compute for the amount of compute that they might be able to bring on. And that they might be able to bring on. And that they might be able to bring on. And again, I don't think it's anywhere near again, I don't think it's anywhere near again, I don't think it's anywhere near eight. eight. eight. Um and it's going to be really hard and Um and it's going to be really hard and Um and it's going to be really hard and energizing these GPUs is really hard. energizing these GPUs is really hard. energizing these GPUs is really hard. But they've been good at it and it But they've been good at it and it But they've been good at it and it doesn't feel like that's in estimates or doesn't feel like that's in estimates or doesn't feel like that's in estimates or really in people's thinking. really in people's thinking. really in people's thinking. >> I'm thinking about that funny meme that >> I'm thinking about that funny meme that >> I'm thinking about that funny meme that says SpaceX, the data center company? says SpaceX, the data center company? says SpaceX, the data center company? >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> You said yes, >> You said yes, >> You said yes, absolutely. absolutely. absolutely. Um and then I would also just say like Um and then I would also just say like Um and then I would also just say like from from from Yeah, I did spend a lot of time at Yeah, I did spend a lot of time at Yeah, I did spend a lot of time at Starbase and Starbase and Starbase and um um um orbital compute feels more real every orbital compute feels more real every orbital compute feels more real every day. day. day. >> Pretty cool to see that Starship landing >> Pretty cool to see that Starship landing >> Pretty cool to see that Starship landing the other day. the other day. the other day. >> Pretty cool to see the Starship landing >> Pretty cool to see the Starship landing >> Pretty cool to see the Starship landing and then it's you know, it is funny. and then it's you know, it is funny. and then it's you know, it is funny. There's our friends at Benchmark. They There's our friends at Benchmark. They There's our friends at Benchmark. They funded Star Cloud and funded Star Cloud and funded Star Cloud and I don't know last time Star Cloud is an I don't know last time Star Cloud is an I don't know last time Star Cloud is an orbital compute company that like SpaceX orbital compute company that like SpaceX orbital compute company that like SpaceX is kind of partnering with. is kind of partnering with. is kind of partnering with. Um they're going to I think let them use Um they're going to I think let them use Um they're going to I think let them use the Starlink laser technology, which is the Starlink laser technology, which is the Starlink laser technology, which is really important for orbital compute. really important for orbital compute. really important for orbital compute. And like but I do think that's like kind And like but I do think that's like kind And like but I do think that's like kind of a good sanity check. of a good sanity check. of a good sanity check. Last time I checked, you know, the Last time I checked, you know, the Last time I checked, you know, the Benchmark guys were pretty smart. Benchmark guys were pretty smart. Benchmark guys were pretty smart. And they're not And they're not And they're not coming from the Elon ecosystem at all. coming from the Elon ecosystem at all. coming from the Elon ecosystem at all. And they chose to fund an orbital And they chose to fund an orbital And they chose to fund an orbital compute company compute company compute company at like you know, a decent valuation at like you know, a decent valuation at like you know, a decent valuation without the internal launch that SpaceX without the internal launch that SpaceX without the internal launch that SpaceX gets. gets. gets. And that's just to me that's a good And that's just to me that's a good And that's just to me that's a good like, "Hey, am am I like, "Hey, am am I like, "Hey, am am I >> crazy?" >> crazy?" >> crazy?" >> Am I crazy? And it's like, well, maybe >> Am I crazy? And it's like, well, maybe >> Am I crazy? And it's like, well, maybe I'm crazy and maybe Elon's crazy and I'm crazy and maybe Elon's crazy and I'm crazy and maybe Elon's crazy and maybe Benchmark is also crazy and maybe maybe Benchmark is also crazy and maybe maybe Benchmark is also crazy and maybe the SpaceX engineers are also crazy. the SpaceX engineers are also crazy. the SpaceX engineers are also crazy. But man, that just doesn't seem that But man, that just doesn't seem that But man, that just doesn't seem that probable to me. probable to me. probable to me. And I mean, we we should say should we And I mean, we we should say should we And I mean, we we should say should we say whose offices we're in? say whose offices we're in? say whose offices we're in? >> Yeah, we're sitting in the middle of the >> Yeah, we're sitting in the middle of the >> Yeah, we're sitting in the middle of the famous table. famous table. famous table. >> Yes, this is their famous table. >> Yes, this is their famous table. >> Yes, this is their famous table. [laughter] Yes, this is their famous [laughter] Yes, this is their famous [laughter] Yes, this is their famous table for their famous dinners. Um so table for their famous dinners. Um so table for their famous dinners. Um so thank you Benchmark. Thank you Benchmark thank you Benchmark. Thank you Benchmark thank you Benchmark. Thank you Benchmark for this episode. Yes, thanks Eric. Um for this episode. Yes, thanks Eric. Um for this episode. Yes, thanks Eric. Um and and she we should thank them all. and and she we should thank them all. and and she we should thank them all. >> Um Eric Eric coordinated for me so he >> Um Eric Eric coordinated for me so he >> Um Eric Eric coordinated for me so he gets a special shout out. gets a special shout out. gets a special shout out. >> Thank you, Eric. >> Thank you, Eric. >> Thank you, Eric. >> Thank you all of the partners. >> Thank you all of the partners. >> Thank you all of the partners. >> Thank you, Eric. Well, you know, just >> Thank you, Eric. Well, you know, just >> Thank you, Eric. Well, you know, just you know, we will see where all of these you know, we will see where all of these you know, we will see where all of these stocks are in a year. stocks are in a year. stocks are in a year. And the great thing is, you know, time And the great thing is, you know, time And the great thing is, you know, time will tell. will tell. will tell. You know, people are going to be right You know, people are going to be right You know, people are going to be right or wrong. or wrong. or wrong. You know, the future's probabilistic, You know, the future's probabilistic, You know, the future's probabilistic, but we are at like it's an exciting but we are at like it's an exciting but we are at like it's an exciting moment. moment. moment. >> Well, if we keep doing this on the the >> Well, if we keep doing this on the the >> Well, if we keep doing this on the the model release cycle, I'll see you in a model release cycle, I'll see you in a model release cycle, I'll see you in a couple weeks. couple weeks. couple weeks. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> Yeah, it's crazy. >> Yeah, it's crazy. >> Yeah, it's crazy. >> As always a blast to do with you. >> You know how small advantages compound >> You know how small advantages compound over time? That's true [music] in over time? That's true [music] in over time? That's true [music] in investing and just as true in how you investing and just as true in how you investing and just as true in how you run your company. Your spending system run your company. Your spending system run your company. Your spending system is your capital allocation strategy. is your capital allocation strategy. is your capital allocation strategy. Ramp makes it smarter by default. Better Ramp makes it smarter by default. Better Ramp makes it smarter by default. Better data, better decisions, better economics data, better decisions, better economics data, better decisions, better economics over time. See how [music] at over time. See how [music] at over time. See how [music] at ramp.com/invest. ramp.com/invest. ramp.com/invest. As your business grows, Vanta scales As your business grows, Vanta scales As your business grows, Vanta scales with you, automating compliance and with you, automating compliance and with you, automating compliance and giving you a single source of truth for giving you a single source of truth for giving you a single source of truth for security and risk. Learn more [music] at security and risk. Learn more [music] at security and risk. Learn more [music] at vanta.com/invest. vanta.com/invest. vanta.com/invest. Ridgeline is redefining asset management Ridgeline is redefining asset management Ridgeline is redefining asset management technology as a true partner, [music] technology as a true partner, [music] technology as a true partner, [music] not just a software vendor. They've not just a software vendor. They've not just a software vendor. They've helped firms 5x in scale, enabling helped firms 5x in scale, enabling helped firms 5x in scale, enabling faster growth, smarter operations, and a faster growth, smarter operations, and a faster growth, smarter operations, and a competitive edge. Visit competitive edge. Visit competitive edge. Visit ridgelineapps.com ridgelineapps.com ridgelineapps.com to see what they can unlock for your to see what they can unlock for your to see what they can unlock for your firm. firm. firm. >> [music] >> [music] >> [music] >> The best AI and software companies from >> The best AI and software companies from >> The best AI and software companies from OpenAI to Cursor to Perplexity use Work OpenAI to Cursor to Perplexity use Work OpenAI to Cursor to Perplexity use Work OS to become enterprise ready overnight, OS to become enterprise ready overnight, OS to become enterprise ready overnight, not in months. not in months. not in months. >> [music] >> [music] >> [music] >> Visit workos.com to skip the unglamorous >> Visit workos.com to skip the unglamorous >> Visit workos.com to skip the unglamorous infrastructure work and focus on your infrastructure work and focus on your infrastructure work and focus on your product.