That’s a Weird Thing to Lie About | This American Life | Episode 855
This episode examines lies that seem unnecessary, from everyday social fictions to elaborate online hoaxes and political falsehoods. Casey, an autistic...
1h 2mSummary published by 1% Better, updated .
Key Takeaway
Replace reflexive praise with truthful appreciation. When someone takes a risk—an interview, a presentation, or a hard conversation—do not say they “did great” if that is not accurate. Instead, name what is undeniably true: “Thank you for being open,” “I appreciate the effort,” or “That took courage.” This preserves kindness without asking either person to pretend, and it creates a clearer foundation for trust.
Episode Overview
This episode examines lies that seem unnecessary, from everyday social fictions to elaborate online hoaxes and political falsehoods. Casey, an autistic advocate of “radical honesty with tact,” offers practical alternatives to white lies; reporter Liz Flock recounts exposing two intertwined online identities; Masha Gessen describes the “power lie” as an authoritarian tactic; and producer Ike Sriskandarajah considers when playful family deception becomes exhausting.
Main Insights
1. Offer accurate appreciation instead of automatic praise
Casey proposes a practical alternative to telling a weak interviewee that they “did a good job.” Thank them for doing something genuinely difficult—being open, vulnerable, and willing to make the effort—without making a claim about their performance that may not be true. This keeps the interaction kind while making your words more trustworthy.
2. Practice radical honesty with tact
Casey describes her approach as “radical honesty with tact”: making a serious effort to tell the truth while considering how to say it constructively. Her response to nieces worried about being fat was not blunt judgment or false reassurance, but a conversation about their bodies and whether there is anything wrong with being fat. The implication is that honesty can be compassionate when it addresses the real concern beneath the question.
3. Treat safety and privacy as legitimate exceptions
Casey does not frame honesty as absolute disclosure. She lied to a dangerous husband about a domestic-violence survivor’s location because he was not entitled to information that could endanger someone. She also withheld an embarrassing reason for being late because it was irrelevant and private, distinguishing protective boundaries from deception for personal advantage.
4. Verify identity before amplifying a compelling online story
Liz Flock initially reported on Amina Arraf because the blog’s story fit a real context of Syrian activists facing repression. Doubts began with a simple question—had anyone actually met Amina in person?—and were resolved through concrete checks including a reused photograph, IP-address research, linked addresses, and connected online accounts. Emotional resonance and apparent plausibility are not substitutes for independent verification.
5. Notice when a lie asks you to reject visible reality
Masha Gessen distinguishes ordinary lies meant to avoid embarrassment or gain an advantage from a “power lie” or “bully lie.” The latter can be plainly contradicted by evidence, but its function is to force people to choose between their own observations and the liar’s asserted reality. Recognizing that coercive function helps explain why fact-checking alone may not resolve it.
6. Do not let a false persona borrow credibility from vulnerable people
Tom McMaster’s fictional Syrian lesbian blogger attracted attention, advocacy, and fear because the persona represented people genuinely at risk under Assad’s regime. After the hoax was exposed, Syrian activists worried it would create a boy-who-cried-wolf effect and give the government material to discredit real accounts of repression. False stories can impose costs far beyond the people immediately deceived.
7. Small social phrases can be understood as signals, not literal claims
Casey says many autistic people experience pleasantries such as “Let’s do this again soon” as confusing because they can sound literally false. She has learned to interpret them as a cultural structure rather than necessarily an intent to deceive: friendly noises that signal, “I want you to see me as friend.” Understanding the social function can reduce friction, while still leaving room to choose more literal language yourself.
8. Watch for gradual normalization, not only dramatic turning points
Gessen says political shifts toward authoritarianism are usually gradual, so waiting for one definitive event can obscure what is happening. She suggests watching both measurable markers, such as consistently ignoring unfavorable court decisions, and softer shifts in consensus, such as institutions “obeying in advance.” The practical habit is to track patterns over time rather than treating each incident as isolated.
9. Playful lying needs consent and clear limits
Ike enjoys absurd fabrications, a habit he learned from his father, but his wife Emma explains that repeated non-answers made ordinary shared decisions difficult. Her objection was not only to any one joke; it was the accumulation of having to parse whether she was receiving real information. In close relationships, humor works better when others do not have to constantly audit reality.
10. Ask why a story feels so satisfying before trusting it
In retrospect, Liz says Amina’s writing “played for emotion” and confirmed a hopeful Western narrative about the Arab Spring: democracy rising and oppressive forces falling. That emotional fit helped make the hoax persuasive despite clues that later seemed glaring. When a story perfectly rewards your hopes, fears, or worldview, treat that satisfaction as a prompt to check more carefully.
Frameworks or Models
Radical Honesty with Tact
1) Start from a commitment to say what is true. 2) Identify the real concern or value beneath the interaction rather than delivering a blunt verdict. 3) State a truthful, relevant observation with care—for example, appreciate someone’s vulnerability rather than falsely praising their performance. 4) Withhold or misdirect information only where safety, privacy, or protection from harm justifies it.
Power Lie / Bully Lie
1) Make a claim that may be visibly or easily demonstrably false. 2) Do not offer evidence or seek to persuade through argument. 3) Force observers to choose between their direct experience and the speaker’s asserted reality. 4) Use that choice to demonstrate power and sort people into those who comply and those cast as enemies.
Notable Quotes
"the honest thing is you know coming to do this to have these conversations and be open and vulnerable is a big thing and I really appreciate that you did it and that you made the effort thank you for that that's honest"
"honesty she says is the only way to vulnerability and intimacy"
"there's no defense against this lie because the point of the LIE is to assert power to show I can say what I want when I want to"
"the power likee conjures a different reality the demands that you choose between your experience and the bully demands are you going to insist that you're wet from the rain or give in and say that the sun is shining"
"I just need you to tell me straight so we can move on from this"
Action Items
Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.
-
1
Use one truthful appreciation today
In your next feedback conversation, replace generic praise with a specific truthful acknowledgment of effort, courage, preparation, or openness.
-
2
Create a privacy-and-safety boundary sentence
Prepare language for questions you should not answer, such as: “I’m not comfortable sharing that,” or “That information is private.” Use it instead of inventing an unnecessary explanation.
-
3
Run a two-source check before sharing a charged story
Before reposting a story that provokes strong emotion or confirms your beliefs, look for independent reporting, original evidence, or direct confirmation of the identity and central claim.
-
4
Set a joking boundary with people close to you
Ask whether playful falsehoods are enjoyable or disruptive in your household or team. Agree that decisions, plans, and emotionally important questions receive clear, literal answers.
Guides that reference this episode
See how this episode fits with recommendations from other leading podcasts.
Go deeper
Full Transcript
Read or copy the complete episode transcript.