1% better

More Trillion Dollar IPOs, Anthropic $3T, Zuck's Price War, China Ends Open Source?, Trump Accounts

The All-In podcast discusses the unprecedented trillion-dollar IPO rush, with SpaceX, Anthropic, and OpenAI potentially all going public. The conversation...

1h 42m

Summary published by , updated .

All-In Podcast

Key Takeaway

When token costs are rising exponentially, implement strict ROI tracking immediately. At 8090, token costs doubled every 45 days while productivity gains remained under 5%. The solution: pause aggressive AI spending, audit what's actually delivering value, and deploy forward-deployed engineers to work with department heads on systematic process improvement rather than letting individual contributors 'vibe code' their way to astronomical bills.

Episode Overview

The All-In podcast discusses the unprecedented trillion-dollar IPO rush, with SpaceX, Anthropic, and OpenAI potentially all going public. The conversation shifts to the economics of AI adoption, exploring whether enterprise token spending will deliver sustainable ROI or if companies are in an unsustainable 'experimental phase' that will face a reckoning when CFOs demand proof of earnings improvement.

Main Insights

The Token Spend Reckoning is Coming

Chamath reveals that at his company, token costs are doubling every 45 days while productivity gains remain at 5% maximum. His CTO explained they've "effectively already asymptoted" - meaning they need exponentially more tokens for diminishing returns. This pattern suggests many companies will face a similar reckoning where unsustainable AI spending must be justified with hard ROI data.

The Frontier Lab Revenue Explosion is Unprecedented

If Anthropic ends 2026 with over $100 billion in revenue as predicted, they could potentially 3-5x again the following year, meaning $200 billion in incremental revenue - "incomprehensible in the history of Silicon Valley and the world." This is driven by intelligence being the largest total addressable market ever seen, with millions of independent customers making simultaneous buying decisions.

Enterprise vs. Consumer AI Revenue Models Have Different Risk Profiles

Enterprise revenue looks impressive but faces a brittle future because sophisticated buyers will eventually demand ROI proof. Consumer revenue, with "tens of millions of buyers at a much smaller price point," provides a safer harbor because it's insulated from the "vicissitudes of an ROI discussion." This may explain why OpenAI's consumer focus could be strategic rather than a distraction.

Bottom-Up AI Adoption Creates Unprecedented Demand

Unlike previous enterprise software that affected specific departments, AI tools are being adopted simultaneously across every function. When everyone in a 1,000-person organization spends $200-$400/month on tokens, it's only 3-4% of their salary. This bottom-up adoption pattern explains the explosive revenue growth that traditional top-down enterprise sales could never achieve.

The 95% Token Cost Reduction Changes Everything

When Chamath experienced a 95% reduction in token costs through alternative providers, his usage behavior completely transformed - moving from daily to hourly agent runs, and from one task to three parallel tasks. This demonstrates Jevons' paradox: as efficiency improves and costs drop, total consumption increases dramatically rather than decreasing.

Notable Quotes

"I sat down with my CTO today and I said, 'How are we doing on token spend?' And he said the most incredible thing. He said, 'Right now, our token costs are doubling every 45 days.' And I was like, 'Ugh.' And he said, 'Yeah.' And I said, 'Well, what is the downstream productivity?' And he said, 'maybe 5% max.'"

Chamath Palihapitiya

"The actual ROI was somewhere between zero and 2%. So I don't know. I mean I think that enterprise looks really good. The problem is that very smart investors like Brad and Gavin and others at some point will start asking companies what's your ROI? What's the actual EPS lift?"

Chamath Palihapitiya

"Intelligence is the largest TAM we've ever seen in the history of the world. These guys are penetrating it. So yes, the super sophisticated companies, the 8090 and Chimath are helping optimize their token spend that are early adopters. 100% that's occurring, but it's not really changing the trajectory that the Frontier Labs are on."

Brad Gerstner

"We're talking from a 100 billion to 300 billion. 200 billion of incremental revenue is incomprehensible in the history of Silicon Valley. And just the fact that we're even talking anywhere close to this tells us something different is going on here."

Brad Gerstner

"When you have unlimited tokens as an exercise, which is going to come to everybody, eventually everybody's going to learn how to drop the price by 95%. And when you start doing hourly tasks and then you wake up in the morning and like 14 jobs have been done, you're like, 'Wait a second. This is completely different.'"

Chamath Palihapitiya

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Implement ROI Tracking for AI Spending Now

    Before your token costs spiral, establish clear metrics for productivity gains versus AI spending. Track the specific business outcomes (cost savings, revenue increases, time saved) against your monthly token bills. If you can't articulate a clear ROI that exceeds your cost of capital, pause experimentation and focus only on proven use cases.

  • 2
    Deploy Forward-Deployed Engineers to Departments

    Following Uber's model, embed engineers within non-technical departments (legal, HR, marketing, operations) to work with department heads who understand process and systems thinking. These 'agentic pods' systematically identify and build AI solutions rather than letting individual contributors experiment randomly with token-heavy approaches.

  • 3
    Explore Alternative Token Providers for 95% Cost Reduction

    Investigate open-source models, alternative API providers like Open Router, decentralized networks like Bittensor, or inference-optimized platforms. Once you reduce costs by 90-95%, you can dramatically increase usage (moving from daily to hourly agent runs, or from one task to three parallel tasks) while maintaining similar budgets.

  • 4
    Pressure Test Your 'Good Enough' Threshold

    Systematically evaluate whether you truly need the latest frontier models or if 90-95% performance from cheaper alternatives suffices for your use cases. Like the iPhone upgrade cycle, identify the point where incremental improvements no longer justify the premium cost, then route appropriate tasks to appropriately-priced models.

Guides that reference this episode

See how this episode fits with recommendations from other leading podcasts.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

All right, everybody. Welcome back. All right, everybody. Welcome back. Number one podcast in the world. It's Number one podcast in the world. It's Number one podcast in the world. It's July Allin episode 280. Freeberg is on a July Allin episode 280. Freeberg is on a July Allin episode 280. Freeberg is on a little vacay. We'll leave it at that. little vacay. We'll leave it at that. little vacay. We'll leave it at that. And uh yeah, bestie Brad is here. How And uh yeah, bestie Brad is here. How And uh yeah, bestie Brad is here. How you doing, Brad? you doing, Brad? you doing, Brad? >> I'm doing great. I'm do vacay in maybe >> I'm doing great. I'm do vacay in maybe >> I'm doing great. I'm do vacay in maybe Idaho or somewhere. Jal, Idaho or somewhere. Jal, Idaho or somewhere. Jal, >> I know. Who knows? Who knows? >> I know. Who knows? Who knows? >> I know. Who knows? Who knows? >> Who know? It could be anywhere. He could >> Who know? It could be anywhere. He could >> Who know? It could be anywhere. He could be anywhere. I mean, there's lots of be anywhere. I mean, there's lots of be anywhere. I mean, there's lots of things. He could be in plenty of places. things. He could be in plenty of places. things. He could be in plenty of places. And uh looks like you are yeah somewhere And uh looks like you are yeah somewhere And uh looks like you are yeah somewhere in the northeast. I'll leave it at that. in the northeast. I'll leave it at that. in the northeast. I'll leave it at that. You having a little uh vacay for You having a little uh vacay for You having a little uh vacay for yourself this week? yourself this week? yourself this week? >> Very pat I'm in my flag room. Very >> Very pat I'm in my flag room. Very >> Very pat I'm in my flag room. Very patriotic room here. patriotic room here. patriotic room here. >> Very nice. >> Very nice. >> Very nice. >> You know where I work on the east coast >> You know where I work on the east coast >> You know where I work on the east coast in the summertime in the summertime in the summertime >> and uh spent some time in DC this week >> and uh spent some time in DC this week >> and uh spent some time in DC this week >> and uh it's been a great week. Been a >> and uh it's been a great week. Been a >> and uh it's been a great week. Been a great week celebrating America 250. great week celebrating America 250. great week celebrating America 250. >> Great. And you're going to be out of >> Great. And you're going to be out of >> Great. And you're going to be out of there for the by the by the second week there for the by the by the second week there for the by the by the second week of August. Yes. So I have it August 10th of August. Yes. So I have it August 10th of August. Yes. So I have it August 10th through the 30th. I'm good. through the 30th. I'm good. through the 30th. I'm good. >> Exact. Exactly. >> Exact. Exactly. >> Exact. Exactly. Jason Jason Jason B&B. B&B. B&B. >> Oh, absolutely. >> Oh, absolutely. >> Oh, absolutely. >> You You don't know the half of it, man. >> You You don't know the half of it, man. >> You You don't know the half of it, man. I am on a summer bender. I'm like, I am on a summer bender. I'm like, I am on a summer bender. I'm like, "Where's your Where's your vacation?" "Where's your Where's your vacation?" "Where's your Where's your vacation?" >> By the way, where are you? Where are you >> By the way, where are you? Where are you >> By the way, where are you? Where are you right now? right now? right now? >> I am in Paris. I did uh about eight >> I am in Paris. I did uh about eight >> I am in Paris. I did uh about eight interviews for at the Rays conference. interviews for at the Rays conference. interviews for at the Rays conference. They'll be coming out uh in the all-in They'll be coming out uh in the all-in They'll be coming out uh in the all-in feed. And of course, tackling from the feed. And of course, tackling from the feed. And of course, tackling from the factory. Look at him. You're working in factory. Look at him. You're working in factory. Look at him. You're working in the factory. Chimath Polyhapatia. It's the factory. Chimath Polyhapatia. It's the factory. Chimath Polyhapatia. It's going to be a hot software summer for going to be a hot software summer for going to be a hot software summer for Chimath. How's your hot software summer Chimath. How's your hot software summer Chimath. How's your hot software summer gone? gone? gone? >> It's good. Selling enterprise software >> It's good. Selling enterprise software >> It's good. Selling enterprise software is hard, but it's good. is hard, but it's good. is hard, but it's good. >> Chamat's like, "Man, I was such a dick >> Chamat's like, "Man, I was such a dick >> Chamat's like, "Man, I was such a dick to all my CEOs in the SAS period." And to all my CEOs in the SAS period." And to all my CEOs in the SAS period." And now you know, now you know, now you know, >> I went to Geneva. Shout out to Markov. I >> I went to Geneva. Shout out to Markov. I >> I went to Geneva. Shout out to Markov. I went to Geneva. He works out of Europe, went to Geneva. He works out of Europe, went to Geneva. He works out of Europe, sees all his European customers, and he sees all his European customers, and he sees all his European customers, and he had a dinner in Geneva, which I joined. had a dinner in Geneva, which I joined. had a dinner in Geneva, which I joined. And then me, Jensen, Brad Smith, Anthony And then me, Jensen, Brad Smith, Anthony And then me, Jensen, Brad Smith, Anthony Tan from Grab, and a bunch of other Tan from Grab, and a bunch of other Tan from Grab, and a bunch of other folks folks folks were put on this UN Commission for AI were put on this UN Commission for AI were put on this UN Commission for AI >> that Mark is the co-chairman of. When >> that Mark is the co-chairman of. When >> that Mark is the co-chairman of. When you see Mark Beni off in action, man, you see Mark Beni off in action, man, you see Mark Beni off in action, man, this guy is a master. this guy is a master. this guy is a master. >> Holy >> Holy >> Holy >> He is the empasario of empisarios. Yeah. >> He is the empasario of empisarios. Yeah. >> He is the empasario of empisarios. Yeah. >> You see how he's built such a ginormous >> You see how he's built such a ginormous >> You see how he's built such a ginormous business. It's impressive. It's business. It's impressive. It's business. It's impressive. It's impressive. impressive. impressive. >> What is a commission by the United >> What is a commission by the United >> What is a commission by the United Nations for AI? What is their what is Nations for AI? What is their what is Nations for AI? What is their what is their uh calling? their uh calling? their uh calling? >> Open source. No, but no, I mean it's >> Open source. No, but no, I mean it's >> Open source. No, but no, I mean it's like the United Nations actually do like the United Nations actually do like the United Nations actually do anything. Do they actually anything. Do they actually anything. Do they actually It's so funny. Yeah. I mean, Anthropic It's so funny. Yeah. I mean, Anthropic It's so funny. Yeah. I mean, Anthropic was there too. Some one of the was there too. Some one of the was there too. Some one of the co-founders, Tom Brown, I think was his co-founders, Tom Brown, I think was his co-founders, Tom Brown, I think was his name. name. name. >> Yeah, >> Yeah, >> Yeah, >> that's good. >> that's good. >> that's good. >> Was the Anthropic guy running around >> Was the Anthropic guy running around >> Was the Anthropic guy running around saying, "It's the end of the world. It's saying, "It's the end of the world. It's saying, "It's the end of the world. It's the end of the world." the end of the world." the end of the world." >> No, no, no. He was he was very awesome. >> No, no, no. He was he was very awesome. >> No, no, no. He was he was very awesome. Tom's awesome. Tom's awesome. Tom's awesome. >> In fairness to him, he wears >> In fairness to him, he wears >> In fairness to him, he wears it on his sleeve, which is like, "Hey, it on his sleeve, which is like, "Hey, it on his sleeve, which is like, "Hey, we really believe we're doing the right we really believe we're doing the right we really believe we're doing the right thing, thing, thing, >> right?" and just trust us and I think >> right?" and just trust us and I think >> right?" and just trust us and I think the future's open source for all these the future's open source for all these the future's open source for all these countries. countries. countries. >> Well, we're going to get into that. >> Well, we're going to get into that. >> Well, we're going to get into that. That's on the docket for sure. But let's That's on the docket for sure. But let's That's on the docket for sure. But let's start with the IPO update. You know, start with the IPO update. You know, start with the IPO update. You know, there's a trillion dollar IPO rush to there's a trillion dollar IPO rush to there's a trillion dollar IPO rush to the exits and you know, this was a big the exits and you know, this was a big the exits and you know, this was a big topic of discussion, Brad, at the topic of discussion, Brad, at the topic of discussion, Brad, at the liquidity summit last month. And we'd liquidity summit last month. And we'd liquidity summit last month. And we'd never seen a trillion dollar IPO. We had never seen a trillion dollar IPO. We had never seen a trillion dollar IPO. We had one this year already. SpaceX trading one this year already. SpaceX trading one this year already. SpaceX trading right about where it went public. So, it right about where it went public. So, it right about where it went public. So, it was priced, I guess, to perfection. was priced, I guess, to perfection. was priced, I guess, to perfection. and theoretically going to see two more. and theoretically going to see two more. and theoretically going to see two more. Uh Brad has the inside information, so Uh Brad has the inside information, so Uh Brad has the inside information, so I'll try to get it at him. Open AAI and I'll try to get it at him. Open AAI and I'll try to get it at him. Open AAI and Anthropic are slated to go out. Let's uh Anthropic are slated to go out. Let's uh Anthropic are slated to go out. Let's uh just go quickly over what happened with just go quickly over what happened with just go quickly over what happened with SpaceX. It ran up to $200 a share. Uh SpaceX. It ran up to $200 a share. Uh SpaceX. It ran up to $200 a share. Uh it's been down a bit. It's at $150 a it's been down a bit. It's at $150 a it's been down a bit. It's at $150 a share. As I said, that's right at the share. As I said, that's right at the share. As I said, that's right at the IPO price. So, it's trading at that two IPO price. So, it's trading at that two IPO price. So, it's trading at that two trillion market cap. Currently, seventh trillion market cap. Currently, seventh trillion market cap. Currently, seventh largest company in the world. And largest company in the world. And largest company in the world. And Anthropic confidentially filed on June Anthropic confidentially filed on June Anthropic confidentially filed on June 1st. I I don't know why they call this 1st. I I don't know why they call this 1st. I I don't know why they call this confidential filing when it immediately confidential filing when it immediately confidential filing when it immediately comes out. Uh but I guess the comes out. Uh but I guess the comes out. Uh but I guess the information is confidential. Poly market information is confidential. Poly market information is confidential. Poly market says 65% chance Anthropics IPO will says 65% chance Anthropics IPO will says 65% chance Anthropics IPO will happen this year on light volume 360K. happen this year on light volume 360K. happen this year on light volume 360K. And uh two weeks ago, Gavin Baker, And uh two weeks ago, Gavin Baker, And uh two weeks ago, Gavin Baker, another bestie, said he thinks they're another bestie, said he thinks they're another bestie, said he thinks they're going to end 2026 with over a hundred going to end 2026 with over a hundred going to end 2026 with over a hundred billion dollars in revenue and very billion dollars in revenue and very billion dollars in revenue and very profitable. He said a couple of us profitable. He said a couple of us profitable. He said a couple of us guests on the program that he thinks it guests on the program that he thinks it guests on the program that he thinks it would trade at three trillion right now would trade at three trillion right now would trade at three trillion right now if it went public. Chimath, you made a if it went public. Chimath, you made a if it went public. Chimath, you made a great call on the pod. You said, "Hey, great call on the pod. You said, "Hey, great call on the pod. You said, "Hey, good idea for Elon to get out first." good idea for Elon to get out first." good idea for Elon to get out first." What are the chances here, Chimoth, that What are the chances here, Chimoth, that What are the chances here, Chimoth, that these other two get out this year or these other two get out this year or these other two get out this year or maybe in like, you know, say 9 months in maybe in like, you know, say 9 months in maybe in like, you know, say 9 months in the in the first quarter of next year? the in the first quarter of next year? the in the first quarter of next year? We'll start there. We'll start there. We'll start there. >> Well, I think that these are all great >> Well, I think that these are all great >> Well, I think that these are all great businesses. I think the question is what businesses. I think the question is what businesses. I think the question is what is the market clearing price? And I is the market clearing price? And I is the market clearing price? And I think that's more of a function of think that's more of a function of think that's more of a function of how much appetite how much appetite how much appetite the markets have to absorb new issues the markets have to absorb new issues the markets have to absorb new issues and at what scale. That's number one. and at what scale. That's number one. and at what scale. That's number one. And I think that's mostly determined by And I think that's mostly determined by And I think that's mostly determined by price. price. price. So I think anthropic and open AI are So I think anthropic and open AI are So I think anthropic and open AI are probably in two different places. The probably in two different places. The probably in two different places. The last time we heard from OpenAI, last time we heard from OpenAI, last time we heard from OpenAI, their cash burn was still quite high their cash burn was still quite high their cash burn was still quite high just because of the diffuse nature of just because of the diffuse nature of just because of the diffuse nature of their business and more reliance on their business and more reliance on their business and more reliance on consumer than enterprise. I think Brad consumer than enterprise. I think Brad consumer than enterprise. I think Brad mentioned it in one of the pods that mentioned it in one of the pods that mentioned it in one of the pods that Anthropic may actually be accidentally Anthropic may actually be accidentally Anthropic may actually be accidentally profitable. I think he said something profitable. I think he said something profitable. I think he said something like that. like that. like that. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Let me tell you something really >> Let me tell you something really >> Let me tell you something really interesting. I sat down with my CTO interesting. I sat down with my CTO interesting. I sat down with my CTO today and I said, "How are we doing on today and I said, "How are we doing on today and I said, "How are we doing on token spend?" And he said the most token spend?" And he said the most token spend?" And he said the most incredible thing. He said, "Right now, incredible thing. He said, "Right now, incredible thing. He said, "Right now, our token costs are doubling every 45 our token costs are doubling every 45 our token costs are doubling every 45 days." days." days." >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> And I was like, "Gh." And he said, >> And I was like, "Gh." And he said, >> And I was like, "Gh." And he said, "Yeah." And I said, 'Well, what is the "Yeah." And I said, 'Well, what is the "Yeah." And I said, 'Well, what is the downstream productivity? And he said, downstream productivity? And he said, downstream productivity? And he said, maybe 5% max. maybe 5% max. maybe 5% max. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> And I said, okay, so my costs are >> And I said, okay, so my costs are >> And I said, okay, so my costs are doubling every 45 days. My upside is doubling every 45 days. My upside is doubling every 45 days. My upside is essentially flat. And he said, essentially flat. And he said, essentially flat. And he said, basically, and I said, well, explain why basically, and I said, well, explain why basically, and I said, well, explain why that is. and he said, "Honestly, what that is. and he said, "Honestly, what that is. and he said, "Honestly, what we're finding out is that we're finding out is that we're finding out is that you need to use a lot more tokens you need to use a lot more tokens you need to use a lot more tokens to get to this next to get to this next to get to this next iteration of improvement because we've iteration of improvement because we've iteration of improvement because we've effectively already asmmptoted." effectively already asmmptoted." effectively already asmmptoted." And I said, "So, what should we do?" And And I said, "So, what should we do?" And And I said, "So, what should we do?" And he said, "Honestly, we have we have to he said, "Honestly, we have we have to he said, "Honestly, we have we have to figure this out." And so, we're going to figure this out." And so, we're going to figure this out." And so, we're going to take a step back and try to figure out take a step back and try to figure out take a step back and try to figure out what to do. I don't know how many other what to do. I don't know how many other what to do. I don't know how many other companies will actually go through this companies will actually go through this companies will actually go through this reckoning now, but the point is reckoning now, but the point is reckoning now, but the point is everybody in the next three or four everybody in the next three or four everybody in the next three or four years will for sure go through it. So, I years will for sure go through it. So, I years will for sure go through it. So, I suspect that if you can get out now, you suspect that if you can get out now, you suspect that if you can get out now, you should get out now before should get out now before should get out now before all of that starts to seep into the all of that starts to seep into the all of that starts to seep into the water table water table water table because I think that's probably what because I think that's probably what because I think that's probably what allows you to get out at a huge price allows you to get out at a huge price allows you to get out at a huge price and and raise a huge amount of money. and and raise a huge amount of money. and and raise a huge amount of money. >> All right, Brad, you are uh well >> All right, Brad, you are uh well >> All right, Brad, you are uh well invested and well known for being invested and well known for being invested and well known for being invested in these two uh next IPOs, so invested in these two uh next IPOs, so invested in these two uh next IPOs, so you probably have some good insights you probably have some good insights you probably have some good insights since you talk to them on a regular since you talk to them on a regular since you talk to them on a regular basis. chances they get out in the next basis. chances they get out in the next basis. chances they get out in the next six to nine months. Both of them, you'd six to nine months. Both of them, you'd six to nine months. Both of them, you'd say 100% chance, unless there's some say 100% chance, unless there's some say 100% chance, unless there's some outside event, you know, blockade of outside event, you know, blockade of outside event, you know, blockade of Taiwan, some black swan event that we're Taiwan, some black swan event that we're Taiwan, some black swan event that we're not anticipating. What do you think the not anticipating. What do you think the not anticipating. What do you think the chances are they're public when we're chances are they're public when we're chances are they're public when we're sitting here and I'm skiing in Hokkaido? sitting here and I'm skiing in Hokkaido? sitting here and I'm skiing in Hokkaido? >> Yeah, I think I think it's very high. >> Yeah, I think I think it's very high. >> Yeah, I think I think it's very high. But let me let me first say, you know, But let me let me first say, you know, But let me let me first say, you know, the SpaceX IPO where we were also the SpaceX IPO where we were also the SpaceX IPO where we were also investors and we also bought in the IPO. investors and we also bought in the IPO. investors and we also bought in the IPO. I mean, it was textbook. It was a hugely I mean, it was textbook. It was a hugely I mean, it was textbook. It was a hugely successful IPO. They raised $75 billion successful IPO. They raised $75 billion successful IPO. They raised $75 billion at 1.75 trillion. Okay, so it went out at 1.75 trillion. Okay, so it went out at 1.75 trillion. Okay, so it went out below where we are today. It's up 25%. below where we are today. It's up 25%. below where we are today. It's up 25%. You know, and let's call it on 35 You know, and let's call it on 35 You know, and let's call it on 35 billion of forward revenue. So if you billion of forward revenue. So if you billion of forward revenue. So if you think about that revenue multiple, it's think about that revenue multiple, it's think about that revenue multiple, it's trading at 2 trillion on roughly 35 trading at 2 trillion on roughly 35 trading at 2 trillion on roughly 35 billion of of forward revenue. It's an billion of of forward revenue. It's an billion of of forward revenue. It's an incredible achievement. I think it was incredible achievement. I think it was incredible achievement. I think it was textbook. I think Anthropic and OpenAI textbook. I think Anthropic and OpenAI textbook. I think Anthropic and OpenAI were watching very closely because were watching very closely because were watching very closely because frankly we had not had an IPO of that frankly we had not had an IPO of that frankly we had not had an IPO of that size and to Elon's credit and to the size and to Elon's credit and to the size and to Elon's credit and to the team's credit Brett and Gwen they really team's credit Brett and Gwen they really team's credit Brett and Gwen they really pioneered some really smart and pioneered some really smart and pioneered some really smart and interesting things as part of that IPO. interesting things as part of that IPO. interesting things as part of that IPO. So, you know, you heard from Gavin So, you know, you heard from Gavin So, you know, you heard from Gavin Anthropics rumored to be, you know, Anthropics rumored to be, you know, Anthropics rumored to be, you know, trending over a 100red billion in trending over a 100red billion in trending over a 100red billion in revenue compared to the 35, right? If revenue compared to the 35, right? If revenue compared to the 35, right? If they exit the year at 100, they exit the year at 100, they exit the year at 100, that means their gap revenue next year that means their gap revenue next year that means their gap revenue next year could be well over a 100red. So, based could be well over a 100red. So, based could be well over a 100red. So, based on the SpaceX success, I think it would on the SpaceX success, I think it would on the SpaceX success, I think it would be a blockbuster IPO. And I think SpaceX be a blockbuster IPO. And I think SpaceX be a blockbuster IPO. And I think SpaceX has shown them the way on things like has shown them the way on things like has shown them the way on things like the total raise, pricing, liquidity, the total raise, pricing, liquidity, the total raise, pricing, liquidity, inclusion into the indexes, how to do inclusion into the indexes, how to do inclusion into the indexes, how to do the lock up. Like I think they've gone the lock up. Like I think they've gone the lock up. Like I think they've gone to school. to school. to school. >> It was a staged release in terms of >> It was a staged release in terms of >> It was a staged release in terms of getting out of the lockup. It has to hit getting out of the lockup. It has to hit getting out of the lockup. It has to hit certain milestones and some of those are certain milestones and some of those are certain milestones and some of those are time time time >> early inclusion in the index raise $75 >> early inclusion in the index raise $75 >> early inclusion in the index raise $75 billion like you know billion like you know billion like you know >> the early inclusion in the index. Let me >> the early inclusion in the index. Let me >> the early inclusion in the index. Let me have you unpack that for a second cuz have you unpack that for a second cuz have you unpack that for a second cuz people said, "Hey, maybe this feels people said, "Hey, maybe this feels people said, "Hey, maybe this feels >> unfair that they should be forced to buy >> unfair that they should be forced to buy >> unfair that they should be forced to buy it." What's your take on that? Is that it." What's your take on that? Is that it." What's your take on that? Is that just like just like just like >> haters going to hate or is there >> haters going to hate or is there >> haters going to hate or is there something to that? I think there was something to that? I think there was something to that? I think there was legitimate concern, right? This legitimate concern, right? This legitimate concern, right? This >> is legitimate concern. Yeah, >> is legitimate concern. Yeah, >> is legitimate concern. Yeah, >> the legitimate concern is that a company >> the legitimate concern is that a company >> the legitimate concern is that a company that had not been through the process of that had not been through the process of that had not been through the process of being vetted post IPO, there's a lot of being vetted post IPO, there's a lot of being vetted post IPO, there's a lot of volatility. You've seen that chart Jason volatility. You've seen that chart Jason volatility. You've seen that chart Jason that the the peak to trough draw down in that the the peak to trough draw down in that the the peak to trough draw down in the 6 months post IPO is 50%. We've seen the 6 months post IPO is 50%. We've seen the 6 months post IPO is 50%. We've seen a pretty big draw down here from the a pretty big draw down here from the a pretty big draw down here from the peak to trough peak to trough peak to trough >> as well. So you don't want to jam it >> as well. So you don't want to jam it >> as well. So you don't want to jam it into an index at the peak and then have into an index at the peak and then have into an index at the peak and then have a 30% draw down on top of people which a 30% draw down on top of people which a 30% draw down on top of people which often happens in IPOs cuz people get often happens in IPOs cuz people get often happens in IPOs cuz people get excited it runs ahead of itself. But excited it runs ahead of itself. But excited it runs ahead of itself. But they didn't do that here. There was fear they didn't do that here. There was fear they didn't do that here. There was fear that that was going to happen. So both that that was going to happen. So both that that was going to happen. So both the the exchanges and the indexes, they the the exchanges and the indexes, they the the exchanges and the indexes, they looked at this and they made some looked at this and they made some looked at this and they made some modifications because the the other side modifications because the the other side modifications because the the other side of the argument is it's so damn big and of the argument is it's so damn big and of the argument is it's so damn big and important that it needs to be part of important that it needs to be part of important that it needs to be part of the index. Right. the index. Right. the index. Right. >> Right. And so the reason the rules had >> Right. And so the reason the rules had >> Right. And so the reason the rules had previously existed is because most previously existed is because most previously existed is because most companies coming public were younger, companies coming public were younger, companies coming public were younger, earlier, less tested, less revenues, earlier, less tested, less revenues, earlier, less tested, less revenues, less profitable, all the things weren't less profitable, all the things weren't less profitable, all the things weren't as important in the overall scheme of as important in the overall scheme of as important in the overall scheme of things. So I think that they pioneered things. So I think that they pioneered things. So I think that they pioneered some really smart things. It's worked some really smart things. It's worked some really smart things. It's worked well. it's traded well and so I think well. it's traded well and so I think well. it's traded well and so I think that that provides a bit of a blueprint that that provides a bit of a blueprint that that provides a bit of a blueprint for anthropic but just in in in terms of for anthropic but just in in in terms of for anthropic but just in in in terms of the enthusiasm the enthusiasm the enthusiasm is an alttimeter is a fidelity as a tro is an alttimeter is a fidelity as a tro is an alttimeter is a fidelity as a tro an enthusiastic buyer of anthropic based an enthusiastic buyer of anthropic based an enthusiastic buyer of anthropic based upon the things we know today around upon the things we know today around upon the things we know today around profitability and model improvement and profitability and model improvement and profitability and model improvement and revenue growth etc. Yes, everybody would revenue growth etc. Yes, everybody would revenue growth etc. Yes, everybody would be pig piling in. everybody would be be pig piling in. everybody would be be pig piling in. everybody would be trying to get into the top of the book trying to get into the top of the book trying to get into the top of the book and you know uh the the last I heard you and you know uh the the last I heard you and you know uh the the last I heard you know again rumored that they would like know again rumored that they would like know again rumored that they would like to get out this year on open AI to get out this year on open AI to get out this year on open AI everybody knows that anthropic kind of everybody knows that anthropic kind of everybody knows that anthropic kind of passed open AI on a revenue trajectory passed open AI on a revenue trajectory passed open AI on a revenue trajectory but I will tell you open AAI's kind of but I will tell you open AAI's kind of but I will tell you open AAI's kind of got its swagger and mojo back it's got its swagger and mojo back it's got its swagger and mojo back it's coming out you know just today with a coming out you know just today with a coming out you know just today with a whole new set of models we know GPT6 whole new set of models we know GPT6 whole new set of models we know GPT6 you know there's a lot of talk of that you know there's a lot of talk of that you know there's a lot of talk of that coming out within the next 30 days a coming out within the next 30 days a coming out within the next 30 days a whole new generation of models whole new generation of models whole new generation of models I think their revenue has really ticked I think their revenue has really ticked I think their revenue has really ticked back up. The most recent kind of rumors back up. The most recent kind of rumors back up. The most recent kind of rumors I see on Twitter is around $70 billion I see on Twitter is around $70 billion I see on Twitter is around $70 billion text the year. So just as a reminder 70 text the year. So just as a reminder 70 text the year. So just as a reminder 70 billion may not be over a hundred billion may not be over a hundred billion may not be over a hundred billion that's rumored and anthropic, billion that's rumored and anthropic, billion that's rumored and anthropic, but it's still twice uh you know where but it's still twice uh you know where but it's still twice uh you know where where the revenue of SpaceX is at. So where the revenue of SpaceX is at. So where the revenue of SpaceX is at. So can they get out at over a trillion on can they get out at over a trillion on can they get out at over a trillion on that type of revenue growth being one of that type of revenue growth being one of that type of revenue growth being one of the two frontier premier labs? I think the two frontier premier labs? I think the two frontier premier labs? I think the answer to that is yes. Um, I'm not the answer to that is yes. Um, I'm not the answer to that is yes. Um, I'm not sure there's a huge race between the two sure there's a huge race between the two sure there's a huge race between the two of them to get out first. I think of them to get out first. I think of them to get out first. I think they'll both go out when it's when it's they'll both go out when it's when it's they'll both go out when it's when it's time. I think OpenAI has a little bit time. I think OpenAI has a little bit time. I think OpenAI has a little bit more complexity just associated with the more complexity just associated with the more complexity just associated with the corporate restructuring that they have corporate restructuring that they have corporate restructuring that they have to go through, etc. So, I would be to go through, etc. So, I would be to go through, etc. So, I would be surprised if they go out before surprised if they go out before surprised if they go out before Anthropic, but the fact of the matter is Anthropic, but the fact of the matter is Anthropic, but the fact of the matter is I don't know. But today, as I sit here I don't know. But today, as I sit here I don't know. But today, as I sit here today, Altimter would be a buyer at today, Altimter would be a buyer at today, Altimter would be a buyer at scale and at size in both of those IPOs. scale and at size in both of those IPOs. scale and at size in both of those IPOs. at three trillion, are you a buyer or at three trillion, are you a buyer or at three trillion, are you a buyer or are you a hey, you know, it's obviously are you a hey, you know, it's obviously are you a hey, you know, it's obviously going to trade up and down and I there's going to trade up and down and I there's going to trade up and down and I there's no rush because you I think were the one no rush because you I think were the one no rush because you I think were the one who said on the pot or might have been who said on the pot or might have been who said on the pot or might have been at liquidity live when I asked you point at liquidity live when I asked you point at liquidity live when I asked you point blank, hey, should retail get involved blank, hey, should retail get involved blank, hey, should retail get involved in SpaceX? What's your thoughts? And you in SpaceX? What's your thoughts? And you in SpaceX? What's your thoughts? And you were like, hey, listen, it's a 4% float, were like, hey, listen, it's a 4% float, were like, hey, listen, it's a 4% float, 5% float. It's going to trade up and 5% float. It's going to trade up and 5% float. It's going to trade up and down, but you know, a year from now, it down, but you know, a year from now, it down, but you know, a year from now, it might be trading at the same basic might be trading at the same basic might be trading at the same basic price. It's it's going to be priced not price. It's it's going to be priced not price. It's it's going to be priced not to perfection, which it seems to have to perfection, which it seems to have to perfection, which it seems to have been, but you I think your position was been, but you I think your position was been, but you I think your position was it's going to be priced reasonably. it's going to be priced reasonably. it's going to be priced reasonably. There'll be plenty of time to get in. There'll be plenty of time to get in. There'll be plenty of time to get in. You don't have to like, you know, panic You don't have to like, you know, panic You don't have to like, you know, panic about getting your shares. Yeah. about getting your shares. Yeah. about getting your shares. Yeah. >> Yeah. I once a company's valued at over >> Yeah. I once a company's valued at over >> Yeah. I once a company's valued at over a trillion dollars, like the get-rich a trillion dollars, like the get-rich a trillion dollars, like the get-rich quick schemes are over, quick schemes are over, quick schemes are over, >> right? Like that you and I share a deep >> right? Like that you and I share a deep >> right? Like that you and I share a deep passion, Jason. We got to get retail passion, Jason. We got to get retail passion, Jason. We got to get retail investors. We got to get the citizens of investors. We got to get the citizens of investors. We got to get the citizens of the United States in on these value the United States in on these value the United States in on these value creating opportunities earlier, right? creating opportunities earlier, right? creating opportunities earlier, right? The accredited investor laws are insane The accredited investor laws are insane The accredited investor laws are insane that we have in this country and keeps that we have in this country and keeps that we have in this country and keeps people from participating in these people from participating in these people from participating in these things, but it is what it is, right? So, things, but it is what it is, right? So, things, but it is what it is, right? So, they're coming public at over a trillion they're coming public at over a trillion they're coming public at over a trillion dollars. I still think there's a lot of dollars. I still think there's a lot of dollars. I still think there's a lot of meat on the bone on SpaceX, on meat on the bone on SpaceX, on meat on the bone on SpaceX, on Anthropic, on Open AI, but you're not Anthropic, on Open AI, but you're not Anthropic, on Open AI, but you're not going to have things that are I don't going to have things that are I don't going to have things that are I don't expect that they're going to be priced expect that they're going to be priced expect that they're going to be priced in a way where you're going to get a 50 in a way where you're going to get a 50 in a way where you're going to get a 50 to 100% durable bounce out of the IPOs. to 100% durable bounce out of the IPOs. to 100% durable bounce out of the IPOs. If so, that would mean they were If so, that would mean they were If so, that would mean they were probably mispriced right into the IPO. probably mispriced right into the IPO. probably mispriced right into the IPO. But I do think that these things can be But I do think that these things can be But I do think that these things can be compounders. They're going to compound compounders. They're going to compound compounders. They're going to compound at the rate they compound revenue. And I at the rate they compound revenue. And I at the rate they compound revenue. And I think all of these companies are going think all of these companies are going think all of these companies are going to compound revenue at well over 30% for to compound revenue at well over 30% for to compound revenue at well over 30% for the next many years. the next many years. the next many years. >> And 30% a year for just so people >> And 30% a year for just so people >> And 30% a year for just so people understand that this is high growth in understand that this is high growth in understand that this is high growth in public markets on very large revenue public markets on very large revenue public markets on very large revenue numbers already. You know, growing 30% numbers already. You know, growing 30% numbers already. You know, growing 30% when you have 100 million revenue is one when you have 100 million revenue is one when you have 100 million revenue is one thing. Growing 30%, you know, when you thing. Growing 30%, you know, when you thing. Growing 30%, you know, when you got a 10 billion or 100 billion, you got a 10 billion or 100 billion, you got a 10 billion or 100 billion, you know, this is this becomes a different know, this is this becomes a different know, this is this becomes a different uh task. So let's talk a little bit uh task. So let's talk a little bit uh task. So let's talk a little bit about these two companies, Chimoth, and about these two companies, Chimoth, and about these two companies, Chimoth, and what the public's going to perceive them what the public's going to perceive them what the public's going to perceive them as. Chat GPT seem to be the as. Chat GPT seem to be the as. Chat GPT seem to be the public brand, the consumer brand for, public brand, the consumer brand for, public brand, the consumer brand for, you know, large language models. It's you know, large language models. It's you know, large language models. It's the AI for, you know, people who are the AI for, you know, people who are the AI for, you know, people who are doing their homework or mom and dad are doing their homework or mom and dad are doing their homework or mom and dad are trying to fix the dishwasher, whatever. trying to fix the dishwasher, whatever. trying to fix the dishwasher, whatever. And then Claude took the lane of, hey, And then Claude took the lane of, hey, And then Claude took the lane of, hey, we're going to be the one for corporate. we're going to be the one for corporate. we're going to be the one for corporate. And it did seem like OpenAI got very And it did seem like OpenAI got very And it did seem like OpenAI got very distracted with Sora and you know Disney distracted with Sora and you know Disney distracted with Sora and you know Disney relationship. We're going to make a puck relationship. We're going to make a puck relationship. We're going to make a puck with Johnny I everything consumer. Then with Johnny I everything consumer. Then with Johnny I everything consumer. Then they realize oh wow the revenue seems to they realize oh wow the revenue seems to they realize oh wow the revenue seems to be an enterprise first. be an enterprise first. be an enterprise first. Is that going to wind up being the the Is that going to wind up being the the Is that going to wind up being the the big mistake when we look at it? they big mistake when we look at it? they big mistake when we look at it? they kind of gave the Google position, the kind of gave the Google position, the kind of gave the Google position, the high growth position to Claude and high growth position to Claude and high growth position to Claude and Anthropic and they took the Yahoo Anthropic and they took the Yahoo Anthropic and they took the Yahoo position or do you think they'll catch position or do you think they'll catch position or do you think they'll catch up on the enterprise or maybe they up on the enterprise or maybe they up on the enterprise or maybe they should just go back to trying to be the should just go back to trying to be the should just go back to trying to be the consumer version? What how how are these consumer version? What how how are these consumer version? What how how are these going to be positioned a year from now? going to be positioned a year from now? going to be positioned a year from now? How's the public going to look at them? How's the public going to look at them? How's the public going to look at them? >> The problem with enterprise revenue is >> The problem with enterprise revenue is >> The problem with enterprise revenue is at some point the person that's spending at some point the person that's spending at some point the person that's spending it has to see an ROI. I asked Fable five it has to see an ROI. I asked Fable five it has to see an ROI. I asked Fable five high high high >> and props new model. Yeah, >> and props new model. Yeah, >> and props new model. Yeah, >> anthropics new model. I first asked it, >> anthropics new model. I first asked it, >> anthropics new model. I first asked it, what is the lift of the S&P 500 earnings what is the lift of the S&P 500 earnings what is the lift of the S&P 500 earnings per share growth since 2024 from AI? And per share growth since 2024 from AI? And per share growth since 2024 from AI? And they answered, oh, it's 50%. So then I they answered, oh, it's 50%. So then I they answered, oh, it's 50%. So then I looked through it and I said, well, no, looked through it and I said, well, no, looked through it and I said, well, no, you're including the money that Nvidia you're including the money that Nvidia you're including the money that Nvidia makes from selling chips to Amazon. So I makes from selling chips to Amazon. So I makes from selling chips to Amazon. So I said, okay. I asked a different said, okay. I asked a different said, okay. I asked a different question, which is, then what was the question, which is, then what was the question, which is, then what was the EPS growth of the S&P 493? And the EPS growth of the S&P 493? And the EPS growth of the S&P 493? And the answer was 9%. And I said, "Okay, well answer was 9%. And I said, "Okay, well answer was 9%. And I said, "Okay, well that's different." And I said, "Unpack that's different." And I said, "Unpack that's different." And I said, "Unpack that." And that." And that." And the overwhelming majority of that was the overwhelming majority of that was the overwhelming majority of that was from pricing power from pricing power from pricing power sitting on top of inflation. sitting on top of inflation. sitting on top of inflation. And then the other 3% was from buybacks. And then the other 3% was from buybacks. And then the other 3% was from buybacks. And so the answer as far as And so the answer as far as And so the answer as far as all publicly available data was that the all publicly available data was that the all publicly available data was that the actual ROI was somewhere between zero actual ROI was somewhere between zero actual ROI was somewhere between zero and 2%. and 2%. and 2%. >> So I don't know. I mean I think that >> So I don't know. I mean I think that >> So I don't know. I mean I think that enterprise looks really good. The enterprise looks really good. The enterprise looks really good. The problem is that very smart investors problem is that very smart investors problem is that very smart investors like Brad and Gavin and others at some like Brad and Gavin and others at some like Brad and Gavin and others at some point will start asking companies what's point will start asking companies what's point will start asking companies what's your ROI? What's the actual EPS lift? your ROI? What's the actual EPS lift? your ROI? What's the actual EPS lift? And if the answer is, well, I don't And if the answer is, well, I don't And if the answer is, well, I don't really know or I'm not sure really know or I'm not sure really know or I'm not sure and you know, you don't necessarily have and you know, you don't necessarily have and you know, you don't necessarily have the pricing power to continue to raise the pricing power to continue to raise the pricing power to continue to raise prices. prices. prices. Enterprise is probably a little bit more Enterprise is probably a little bit more Enterprise is probably a little bit more brittle because there are fewer buyers brittle because there are fewer buyers brittle because there are fewer buyers and they're more demanding. Consumer on and they're more demanding. Consumer on and they're more demanding. Consumer on the other hand then all of a sudden the other hand then all of a sudden the other hand then all of a sudden becomes an incredible safe harbor becomes an incredible safe harbor becomes an incredible safe harbor because you have tens of millions of because you have tens of millions of because you have tens of millions of buyers and having those two orders of buyers and having those two orders of buyers and having those two orders of magnitude more buyers at a much smaller magnitude more buyers at a much smaller magnitude more buyers at a much smaller price point inoculates you from the price point inoculates you from the price point inoculates you from the vicissitudes of an ROI discussion. vicissitudes of an ROI discussion. vicissitudes of an ROI discussion. >> So it all really depends on what the >> So it all really depends on what the >> So it all really depends on what the actual ROI is of this money being spent. actual ROI is of this money being spent. actual ROI is of this money being spent. I think that we're in the phase of just I think that we're in the phase of just I think that we're in the phase of just being astonished, as Brad said, about being astonished, as Brad said, about being astonished, as Brad said, about the scale of the revenue growth. the scale of the revenue growth. the scale of the revenue growth. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> But at some point, you'd have to be an >> But at some point, you'd have to be an >> But at some point, you'd have to be an idiot not to ask, well, who is paying idiot not to ask, well, who is paying idiot not to ask, well, who is paying you this? And can they sustain paying it you this? And can they sustain paying it you this? And can they sustain paying it to you? I just don't know what the to you? I just don't know what the to you? I just don't know what the answer to that question is. And at some answer to that question is. And at some answer to that question is. And at some point, it may not be now, point, it may not be now, point, it may not be now, >> at some point, people will have to >> at some point, people will have to >> at some point, people will have to answer that question. and you're answer that question. and you're answer that question. and you're spending million dollars a year on spending million dollars a year on spending million dollars a year on tokens tokens tokens >> and that million dollar a year is >> and that million dollar a year is >> and that million dollar a year is doubling and tripling and quadrupling. doubling and tripling and quadrupling. doubling and tripling and quadrupling. At some point you're going to have to At some point you're going to have to At some point you're going to have to show an ROI that's show an ROI that's show an ROI that's >> above the risk-free rate of return >> above the risk-free rate of return >> above the risk-free rate of return otherwise you're going to have um some otherwise you're going to have um some otherwise you're going to have um some angry investors on your hands angry investors on your hands angry investors on your hands >> and our discussion here for the last >> and our discussion here for the last >> and our discussion here for the last couple of weeks on the pod has centered couple of weeks on the pod has centered couple of weeks on the pod has centered around that and the industry has around that and the industry has around that and the industry has responded on the place where all the CTO responded on the place where all the CTO responded on the place where all the CTO CEOs and capital allocators hang out CEOs and capital allocators hang out CEOs and capital allocators hang out which is X.com formerly known as which is X.com formerly known as which is X.com formerly known as Twitter. Here's Pine, the CTO of Uber. Twitter. Here's Pine, the CTO of Uber. Twitter. Here's Pine, the CTO of Uber. And so when you ask like how are they And so when you ask like how are they And so when you ask like how are they getting getting getting how are they getting the ROI out of how are they getting the ROI out of how are they getting the ROI out of this? People are now bringing that this? People are now bringing that this? People are now bringing that conversation front and center and conversation front and center and conversation front and center and they're explaining it on X and he talked they're explaining it on X and he talked they're explaining it on X and he talked remember Uber was also the one that ran remember Uber was also the one that ran remember Uber was also the one that ran through all their tokens in the first through all their tokens in the first through all their tokens in the first quarter. So then on the other side of quarter. So then on the other side of quarter. So then on the other side of the business which is legal, operations, the business which is legal, operations, the business which is legal, operations, marketing, customer support, HR and marketing, customer support, HR and marketing, customer support, HR and procurement which he lists here. He says procurement which he lists here. He says procurement which he lists here. He says in this you know today 99% of our in this you know today 99% of our in this you know today 99% of our engineers use AI tools. Okay great right engineers use AI tools. Okay great right engineers use AI tools. Okay great right it's everybody's you know doing vibe it's everybody's you know doing vibe it's everybody's you know doing vibe coding and has coding assistance. Uh coding and has coding assistance. Uh coding and has coding assistance. Uh more than 70% of pull requests are more than 70% of pull requests are more than 70% of pull requests are attributed to local or cloud agents. Our attributed to local or cloud agents. Our attributed to local or cloud agents. Our engineers have built 200 agentic skills. engineers have built 200 agentic skills. engineers have built 200 agentic skills. So how are bringing agentic AI beyond So how are bringing agentic AI beyond So how are bringing agentic AI beyond engineering and what they've decided to engineering and what they've decided to engineering and what they've decided to do is essentially he talks about these do is essentially he talks about these do is essentially he talks about these agentic pods and this to me seems agentic pods and this to me seems agentic pods and this to me seems directionally how this should be done directionally how this should be done directionally how this should be done which is you find engineers and you uh which is you find engineers and you uh which is you find engineers and you uh as as we uh talked about forward as as we uh talked about forward as as we uh talked about forward deployed engineers fancy way of saying deployed engineers fancy way of saying deployed engineers fancy way of saying put an engineer put them into put an engineer put them into put an engineer put them into departments and have them work with the departments and have them work with the departments and have them work with the department heads who understand systems department heads who understand systems department heads who understand systems thinking how their process is done and thinking how their process is done and thinking how their process is done and um he uh he says he's making basically um he uh he says he's making basically um he uh he says he's making basically long and short of it is they're making long and short of it is they're making long and short of it is they're making massive massive progress on the massive massive progress on the massive massive progress on the operational side of the business. So operational side of the business. So operational side of the business. So Brad, you're pretty familiar with Uber Brad, you're pretty familiar with Uber Brad, you're pretty familiar with Uber and have been a long supporter of that. and have been a long supporter of that. and have been a long supporter of that. This is a company that knows how to This is a company that knows how to This is a company that knows how to deploy technology pretty well and deploy technology pretty well and deploy technology pretty well and they're an operations machine run by an they're an operations machine run by an they're an operations machine run by an operations machine. DAR, operations machine. DAR, operations machine. DAR, >> they should report the EPS gains >> they should report the EPS gains >> they should report the EPS gains attributable to AI. attributable to AI. attributable to AI. >> Yeah. Well, I mean, and this first step >> Yeah. Well, I mean, and this first step >> Yeah. Well, I mean, and this first step seems like they're really being seems like they're really being seems like they're really being thoughtful about this first. Hey, this thoughtful about this first. Hey, this thoughtful about this first. Hey, this token spend got out of control with the token spend got out of control with the token spend got out of control with the developers. we're going to need to pause developers. we're going to need to pause developers. we're going to need to pause this and look at it. And then second, this and look at it. And then second, this and look at it. And then second, here's how it's going to lower cost and here's how it's going to lower cost and here's how it's going to lower cost and create more efficiency. So Brad, create more efficiency. So Brad, create more efficiency. So Brad, >> let's talk about that side of it. Not >> let's talk about that side of it. Not >> let's talk about that side of it. Not just token maxing with the developers just token maxing with the developers just token maxing with the developers hitting the slot machine of like, okay, hitting the slot machine of like, okay, hitting the slot machine of like, okay, let's see if this pull request and let's let's see if this pull request and let's let's see if this pull request and let's see if if this produces the right code see if if this produces the right code see if if this produces the right code or not to these departments in a more or not to these departments in a more or not to these departments in a more strategic way. It's not just the person strategic way. It's not just the person strategic way. It's not just the person who works in HR, you know, using cloud who works in HR, you know, using cloud who works in HR, you know, using cloud code or perplexity or whatever and code or perplexity or whatever and code or perplexity or whatever and trying to vibe code something. This is trying to vibe code something. This is trying to vibe code something. This is hey we're sending engineering in to work hey we're sending engineering in to work hey we're sending engineering in to work with your top systems architect and with your top systems architect and with your top systems architect and we're going to you know try to find that we're going to you know try to find that we're going to you know try to find that ROI. Yeah. ROI. Yeah. ROI. Yeah. >> Yes. I you know first I would say >> Yes. I you know first I would say >> Yes. I you know first I would say Chimath is right. The only question is Chimath is right. The only question is Chimath is right. The only question is on what time frame. There's no doubt on what time frame. There's no doubt on what time frame. There's no doubt that there there's a lot of money being that there there's a lot of money being that there there's a lot of money being spent today that is in the experimental spent today that is in the experimental spent today that is in the experimental bucket right where I I think there bucket right where I I think there bucket right where I I think there probably isn't direct ROI Chimat to your probably isn't direct ROI Chimat to your probably isn't direct ROI Chimat to your point but I think we're so early nobody point but I think we're so early nobody point but I think we're so early nobody cares. I think we're so early in terms cares. I think we're so early in terms cares. I think we're so early in terms of enterprise adoption. Remember the of enterprise adoption. Remember the of enterprise adoption. Remember the total addressable market here is every total addressable market here is every total addressable market here is every single small, medium, large company on single small, medium, large company on single small, medium, large company on the planet. And so we've never seen the planet. And so we've never seen the planet. And so we've never seen revenue growth like this because we've revenue growth like this because we've revenue growth like this because we've never seen a TAM like this. And if you never seen a TAM like this. And if you never seen a TAM like this. And if you look at the distribution of revenues look at the distribution of revenues look at the distribution of revenues across these businesses, it's not like across these businesses, it's not like across these businesses, it's not like it's concentrated with four or five it's concentrated with four or five it's concentrated with four or five customers. There are millions of customers. There are millions of customers. There are millions of customers independently economically customers independently economically customers independently economically making the decision that is rational for making the decision that is rational for making the decision that is rational for them every day that it makes sense like them every day that it makes sense like them every day that it makes sense like Pine at Uber and of course they're Pine at Uber and of course they're Pine at Uber and of course they're trying to find things on both right now trying to find things on both right now trying to find things on both right now mostly the cost side cost takeouts to mostly the cost side cost takeouts to mostly the cost side cost takeouts to justify the investments that they're justify the investments that they're justify the investments that they're making in you know in tokens but I think making in you know in tokens but I think making in you know in tokens but I think we're on the verge of breakthroughs in we're on the verge of breakthroughs in we're on the verge of breakthroughs in intelligence that's going to intelligence that's going to intelligence that's going to dramatically change the revenue side of dramatically change the revenue side of dramatically change the revenue side of the equation for a lot of these the equation for a lot of these the equation for a lot of these businesses breakthroughs in life businesses breakthroughs in life businesses breakthroughs in life sciences breakthroughs in in product sciences breakthroughs in in product sciences breakthroughs in in product innovation etc where they could not innovation etc where they could not innovation etc where they could not divorce themselves from this even if divorce themselves from this even if divorce themselves from this even if they wanted to. For example, Jensen Hang they wanted to. For example, Jensen Hang they wanted to. For example, Jensen Hang has talked many times that all of his has talked many times that all of his has talked many times that all of his design work all of his design work now design work all of his design work now design work all of his design work now at Nvidia is using AI to design the next at Nvidia is using AI to design the next at Nvidia is using AI to design the next generation chip. The machine is building generation chip. The machine is building generation chip. The machine is building the machine. So you can't get rid of the machine. So you can't get rid of the machine. So you can't get rid of that even if you wanted to. and tiny that even if you wanted to. and tiny that even if you wanted to. and tiny intelligence advantages at the frontier intelligence advantages at the frontier intelligence advantages at the frontier where he sits are required. Like there's where he sits are required. Like there's where he sits are required. Like there's no way I don't think that Jensen is no way I don't think that Jensen is no way I don't think that Jensen is going to use anything but the best going to use anything but the best going to use anything but the best models that he can to build out those models that he can to build out those models that he can to build out those capabilities. So I just think that we're capabilities. So I just think that we're capabilities. So I just think that we're not going to see that in the next few not going to see that in the next few not going to see that in the next few years. You're going to see it under the years. You're going to see it under the years. You're going to see it under the hood, of course, but that occurred at hood, of course, but that occurred at hood, of course, but that occurred at Snowflake. There was tons of Snowflake. There was tons of Snowflake. There was tons of optimization that occurred at Snowflake, optimization that occurred at Snowflake, optimization that occurred at Snowflake, but the revenue continued unabated. but the revenue continued unabated. but the revenue continued unabated. their revenue growth continued under their revenue growth continued under their revenue growth continued under beta because they further penetrate beta because they further penetrate beta because they further penetrate penetrated use cases f further penetrated use cases f further penetrated use cases f further penetrated the enterprise. So let me be penetrated the enterprise. So let me be penetrated the enterprise. So let me be provocative here. If these guys end a provocative here. If these guys end a provocative here. If these guys end a year over a 100red billion, I think that year over a 100red billion, I think that year over a 100red billion, I think that they're on a revenue trajectory that they're on a revenue trajectory that they're on a revenue trajectory that they could 3 to 5x again next year. they could 3 to 5x again next year. they could 3 to 5x again next year. We've never seen anything like this. We've never seen anything like this. We've never seen anything like this. Never. Never. Never. >> You're saying 100 to 300. 100. >> You're saying 100 to 300. 100. >> You're saying 100 to 300. 100. And Jason, like you and I have talked And Jason, like you and I have talked And Jason, like you and I have talked about this. Our minds were blown. If a about this. Our minds were blown. If a about this. Our minds were blown. If a company could go from 100 million Yeah. company could go from 100 million Yeah. company could go from 100 million Yeah. to 300 million, we're talking from a 100 to 300 million, we're talking from a 100 to 300 million, we're talking from a 100 billion to 300 billion. 200 billion of billion to 300 billion. 200 billion of billion to 300 billion. 200 billion of incremental revenue is incomprehensible incremental revenue is incomprehensible incremental revenue is incomprehensible in the history of Silicon Valley. Okay. in the history of Silicon Valley. Okay. in the history of Silicon Valley. Okay. And just the fact that we're even the And just the fact that we're even the And just the fact that we're even the world in the history. world in the history. world in the history. >> Yeah. In the history of the world. So >> Yeah. In the history of the world. So >> Yeah. In the history of the world. So the fact that we're even talking the fact that we're even talking the fact that we're even talking anywhere close to this tells us anywhere close to this tells us anywhere close to this tells us something different is going on here. I something different is going on here. I something different is going on here. I think the thing that's different is that think the thing that's different is that think the thing that's different is that intelligence is the largest TAM we've intelligence is the largest TAM we've intelligence is the largest TAM we've ever seen in the history of the world. ever seen in the history of the world. ever seen in the history of the world. These guys are penetrating it. So yes, These guys are penetrating it. So yes, These guys are penetrating it. So yes, the super sophisticated companies, the the super sophisticated companies, the the super sophisticated companies, the 8090 and Chimath are helping optimize 8090 and Chimath are helping optimize 8090 and Chimath are helping optimize their token spend that are early their token spend that are early their token spend that are early adopters. 100% that's occurring, but adopters. 100% that's occurring, but adopters. 100% that's occurring, but it's not really changing the trajectory it's not really changing the trajectory it's not really changing the trajectory that the Frontier Labs are on. that the Frontier Labs are on. that the Frontier Labs are on. >> Yeah. And one of the interesting things >> Yeah. And one of the interesting things >> Yeah. And one of the interesting things about this technology that's really about this technology that's really about this technology that's really unique, we talk about intelligence on unique, we talk about intelligence on unique, we talk about intelligence on demand. When you would make a piece of demand. When you would make a piece of demand. When you would make a piece of software or you had some technological software or you had some technological software or you had some technological innovation, it would typically acrue to, innovation, it would typically acrue to, innovation, it would typically acrue to, I don't know, one group of people in an I don't know, one group of people in an I don't know, one group of people in an organization. You know, maybe two groups organization. You know, maybe two groups organization. You know, maybe two groups of people, right? Excel comes out. Okay. of people, right? Excel comes out. Okay. of people, right? Excel comes out. Okay. Yeah, the accounting department's having Yeah, the accounting department's having Yeah, the accounting department's having a field day with it, but it's not really a field day with it, but it's not really a field day with it, but it's not really affecting human resources or marketing. affecting human resources or marketing. affecting human resources or marketing. Okay. Yeah, maybe it trickles down Okay. Yeah, maybe it trickles down Okay. Yeah, maybe it trickles down eventually. Every single person in every eventually. Every single person in every eventually. Every single person in every single organization is playing with single organization is playing with single organization is playing with these tools. So if everybody's playing these tools. So if everybody's playing these tools. So if everybody's playing with it, everybody's trying to apply it with it, everybody's trying to apply it with it, everybody's trying to apply it all at the same time. It's kind of like, all at the same time. It's kind of like, all at the same time. It's kind of like, you know, you got a thousand person you know, you got a thousand person you know, you got a thousand person organization. People are spending 200 a organization. People are spending 200 a organization. People are spending 200 a month. Okay. Yeah, Chimath, they double month. Okay. Yeah, Chimath, they double month. Okay. Yeah, Chimath, they double it every, you know, x number of months. it every, you know, x number of months. it every, you know, x number of months. Okay. Yeah. Now they're spending $400 a Okay. Yeah. Now they're spending $400 a Okay. Yeah. Now they're spending $400 a month per person. Okay. They're spending month per person. Okay. They're spending month per person. Okay. They're spending $5,000. Well, if the average salary is $5,000. Well, if the average salary is $5,000. Well, if the average salary is 100 150k at this organization, it's only 100 150k at this organization, it's only 100 150k at this organization, it's only an incremental 3, four% on top of their an incremental 3, four% on top of their an incremental 3, four% on top of their salary. So the way I look at it is did salary. So the way I look at it is did salary. So the way I look at it is did it make that person three, four, five it make that person three, four, five it make that person three, four, five times more effective at their job? And I times more effective at their job? And I times more effective at their job? And I think the answer is yes. So that's why think the answer is yes. So that's why think the answer is yes. So that's why there's so much token maxing going on. there's so much token maxing going on. there's so much token maxing going on. And it's also a bottom up type product. And it's also a bottom up type product. And it's also a bottom up type product. You can just get into this product for You can just get into this product for You can just get into this product for 20 bucks a month and you know no CIO or 20 bucks a month and you know no CIO or 20 bucks a month and you know no CIO or CTO is like oh no you can't spend 20 CTO is like oh no you can't spend 20 CTO is like oh no you can't spend 20 bucks a month at your corporate card for bucks a month at your corporate card for bucks a month at your corporate card for this technology. So it when a bottomup this technology. So it when a bottomup this technology. So it when a bottomup technology hits everybody at the same technology hits everybody at the same technology hits everybody at the same time that's what would explain this time that's what would explain this time that's what would explain this revenue ramp that we're all having a revenue ramp that we're all having a revenue ramp that we're all having a hard time adjusting to. It applies to hard time adjusting to. It applies to hard time adjusting to. It applies to every single person like who is it every single person like who is it every single person like who is it impacted by the technology is my impacted by the technology is my impacted by the technology is my question to you Chimoth like in what question to you Chimoth like in what question to you Chimoth like in what organization you're working with with organization you're working with with organization you're working with with 8090 is there a department that says 8090 is there a department that says 8090 is there a department that says yeah the intelligence on demand not for yeah the intelligence on demand not for yeah the intelligence on demand not for us we don't need it us we don't need it us we don't need it >> well it's less it's less about being >> well it's less it's less about being >> well it's less it's less about being dismissive that way it's more that dismissive that way it's more that dismissive that way it's more that regulators and other people won't regulators and other people won't regulators and other people won't necessarily allow to use it the way you necessarily allow to use it the way you necessarily allow to use it the way you want want want >> okay so finance HIPPA yeah there's HR >> okay so finance HIPPA yeah there's HR >> okay so finance HIPPA yeah there's HR data you're not allowed to to to put data you're not allowed to to to put data you're not allowed to to to put that to work just yet what I'm finding that to work just yet what I'm finding that to work just yet what I'm finding is is is once you start using this and getting once you start using this and getting once you start using this and getting some gains it's very addictive and we some gains it's very addictive and we some gains it's very addictive and we were sitting here Brad I don't know were sitting here Brad I don't know were sitting here Brad I don't know maybe in January and I got that open maybe in January and I got that open maybe in January and I got that open claw bug claw bug claw bug >> and then you know I started playing with >> and then you know I started playing with >> and then you know I started playing with this Hermes Hermes agent which is not a this Hermes Hermes agent which is not a this Hermes Hermes agent which is not a French company by the way they just use French company by the way they just use French company by the way they just use you know French names is Nuvo research you know French names is Nuvo research you know French names is Nuvo research or whatever it is I started playing with or whatever it is I started playing with or whatever it is I started playing with that it's a very peculiar piece of that it's a very peculiar piece of that it's a very peculiar piece of software but it's very open piece of software but it's very open piece of software but it's very open piece of software so I went to open router I got software so I went to open router I got software so I went to open router I got my own keys I've been playing with GLM my own keys I've been playing with GLM my own keys I've been playing with GLM Then uh I talked a little bit about Then uh I talked a little bit about Then uh I talked a little bit about BitSensor on the program known as Tao, BitSensor on the program known as Tao, BitSensor on the program known as Tao, dollar sign TAO. It's a it's a crypto dollar sign TAO. It's a it's a crypto dollar sign TAO. It's a it's a crypto project. Somebody who is creating a project. Somebody who is creating a project. Somebody who is creating a subnet that is putting GLM 5.2 and other subnet that is putting GLM 5.2 and other subnet that is putting GLM 5.2 and other models available at really cheap prices. models available at really cheap prices. models available at really cheap prices. So I all of a sudden experienced because So I all of a sudden experienced because So I all of a sudden experienced because they gave me an API key having my token they gave me an API key having my token they gave me an API key having my token cost go down 95%. cost go down 95%. cost go down 95%. And when you have unlimited tokens as an And when you have unlimited tokens as an And when you have unlimited tokens as an exercise, which is going to come to exercise, which is going to come to exercise, which is going to come to everybody, eventually everybody's going everybody, eventually everybody's going everybody, eventually everybody's going to learn how to drop the price by 95%. to learn how to drop the price by 95%. to learn how to drop the price by 95%. And it's going to happen as well because And it's going to happen as well because And it's going to happen as well because people like rock with inference. This is people like rock with inference. This is people like rock with inference. This is all inference, right? This is what all inference, right? This is what all inference, right? This is what people are using. They're they they're people are using. They're they they're people are using. They're they they're they're using they're using they're using inference to do this. Well, inference is inference to do this. Well, inference is inference to do this. Well, inference is being impacted like three or four being impacted like three or four being impacted like three or four different ways. The software is getting different ways. The software is getting different ways. The software is getting better. Open source at the same time. better. Open source at the same time. better. Open source at the same time. you're going to have distributed you're going to have distributed you're going to have distributed networks like Tao and uh you're going to networks like Tao and uh you're going to networks like Tao and uh you're going to have better you know chipsets from Grock have better you know chipsets from Grock have better you know chipsets from Grock and Cerebras etc. All that's happening and Cerebras etc. All that's happening and Cerebras etc. All that's happening at the same time once I got down to 95% at the same time once I got down to 95% at the same time once I got down to 95% cheaper I started setting my agents cheaper I started setting my agents cheaper I started setting my agents instead of doing daily runs to doing instead of doing daily runs to doing instead of doing daily runs to doing hourly runs then I took my agents from hourly runs then I took my agents from hourly runs then I took my agents from doing one task and I broke them up into doing one task and I broke them up into doing one task and I broke them up into three agents and have them doing three three agents and have them doing three three agents and have them doing three different things on the hour. And when different things on the hour. And when different things on the hour. And when you start doing hourly tasks and then you start doing hourly tasks and then you start doing hourly tasks and then you wake up in the morning and like 14 you wake up in the morning and like 14 you wake up in the morning and like 14 jobs have been done, you're like, "Wait jobs have been done, you're like, "Wait jobs have been done, you're like, "Wait a second. This is completely different." a second. This is completely different." a second. This is completely different." As one example, I have it has all the As one example, I have it has all the As one example, I have it has all the all-in episodes, all the This Week in all-in episodes, all the This Week in all-in episodes, all the This Week in startups episodes, and we set these startups episodes, and we set these startups episodes, and we set these crown jobs to go find what the new crown jobs to go find what the new crown jobs to go find what the new trends are in technology. I have a trend trends are in technology. I have a trend trends are in technology. I have a trend spotting agent running every hour, spotting agent running every hour, spotting agent running every hour, >> informing me of the top three or four >> informing me of the top three or four >> informing me of the top three or four trends, and I just give it words. Really trends, and I just give it words. Really trends, and I just give it words. Really does change your thinking. when costs go does change your thinking. when costs go does change your thinking. when costs go down, what do you think the tokens are down, what do you think the tokens are down, what do you think the tokens are going to cost, Brad? And you know, next going to cost, Brad? And you know, next going to cost, Brad? And you know, next year, year, year, >> yeah, we've se we we we've seen 90% >> yeah, we've se we we we've seen 90% >> yeah, we've se we we we've seen 90% reductions in the price to tokens for reductions in the price to tokens for reductions in the price to tokens for each of the last two and a half years. each of the last two and a half years. each of the last two and a half years. We've talked a lot about Jeban's We've talked a lot about Jeban's We've talked a lot about Jeban's paradox, which I think you you're paradox, which I think you you're paradox, which I think you you're referencing here, which is you're going referencing here, which is you're going referencing here, which is you're going to use a hell of a lot more when it to use a hell of a lot more when it to use a hell of a lot more when it happens. I think the central debate happens. I think the central debate happens. I think the central debate right now in AI is the one that Chimath right now in AI is the one that Chimath right now in AI is the one that Chimath keeps pointing us back in the direction keeps pointing us back in the direction keeps pointing us back in the direction of which is for 18 months since the of which is for 18 months since the of which is for 18 months since the deepseek moment right when the deepseek deepseek moment right when the deepseek deepseek moment right when the deepseek moment happened the markets fell 40%. moment happened the markets fell 40%. moment happened the markets fell 40%. And there was a reason for that. Many And there was a reason for that. Many And there was a reason for that. Many started arguing that the frontier models started arguing that the frontier models started arguing that the frontier models were screwed, that open- source was were screwed, that open- source was were screwed, that open- source was going to kill them, that they were going to kill them, that they were going to kill them, that they were closing the intelligence gap, that model closing the intelligence gap, that model closing the intelligence gap, that model routing was going to make it easier routing was going to make it easier routing was going to make it easier easier to route these tasks to cheap easier to route these tasks to cheap easier to route these tasks to cheap tokens. But despite all of those tokens. But despite all of those tokens. But despite all of those arguments, and now we're 18 months into arguments, and now we're 18 months into arguments, and now we're 18 months into this, and I had this back and forth with this, and I had this back and forth with this, and I had this back and forth with Gurley a lot. I love open source. I want Gurley a lot. I love open source. I want Gurley a lot. I love open source. I want all the competition in the world. Let's all the competition in the world. Let's all the competition in the world. Let's be very clear. But despite all of those be very clear. But despite all of those be very clear. But despite all of those arguments, the facts in the field are arguments, the facts in the field are arguments, the facts in the field are just the opposite. The share of economic just the opposite. The share of economic just the opposite. The share of economic value, right? There's this quote, value, right? There's this quote, value, right? There's this quote, there's this tweet this week from Jesse there's this tweet this week from Jesse there's this tweet this week from Jesse Zang that we ought to pull up here. You Zang that we ought to pull up here. You Zang that we ought to pull up here. You know, the economic value, the share of know, the economic value, the share of know, the economic value, the share of wallet is actually increasing to the wallet is actually increasing to the wallet is actually increasing to the Frontier Labs while the share of tokens, Frontier Labs while the share of tokens, Frontier Labs while the share of tokens, these commodity tokens is obviously these commodity tokens is obviously these commodity tokens is obviously going up, you know, to the other guys. going up, you know, to the other guys. going up, you know, to the other guys. And I had a little back and forth this And I had a little back and forth this And I had a little back and forth this week with Nikesh on this kind of trying week with Nikesh on this kind of trying week with Nikesh on this kind of trying to sus out why is that the case, right? to sus out why is that the case, right? to sus out why is that the case, right? Because what people would have thought Because what people would have thought Because what people would have thought is, oh, cheaper, pretty damn good. 90% is, oh, cheaper, pretty damn good. 90% is, oh, cheaper, pretty damn good. 90% is good enough to do all these tasks is good enough to do all these tasks is good enough to do all these tasks that you're talking about, Jason. So, that you're talking about, Jason. So, that you're talking about, Jason. So, nobody's going to use the anthropics and nobody's going to use the anthropics and nobody's going to use the anthropics and the open AIs of the world. But despite the open AIs of the world. But despite the open AIs of the world. But despite that, it looks like their share of that, it looks like their share of that, it looks like their share of wallet has gone up. wallet has gone up. wallet has gone up. >> I think it's not that. I think it's more >> I think it's not that. I think it's more >> I think it's not that. I think it's more that when the iPhone was a novelty, that when the iPhone was a novelty, that when the iPhone was a novelty, everybody would keep upgrading because everybody would keep upgrading because everybody would keep upgrading because you expected that the new price was you expected that the new price was you expected that the new price was worth it. And then at some point there's worth it. And then at some point there's worth it. And then at some point there's a moment and you can debate when it a moment and you can debate when it a moment and you can debate when it happened where people said, you know happened where people said, you know happened where people said, you know what, I'm just going to keep the old what, I'm just going to keep the old what, I'm just going to keep the old phone cuz it's good enough and I just phone cuz it's good enough and I just phone cuz it's good enough and I just don't see the difference. And I think don't see the difference. And I think don't see the difference. And I think that there's going to be a moment like that there's going to be a moment like that there's going to be a moment like that. Like when I use Fable 5, the that. Like when I use Fable 5, the that. Like when I use Fable 5, the problem is that it's nerfed on a bunch problem is that it's nerfed on a bunch problem is that it's nerfed on a bunch of things that I would normally of things that I would normally of things that I would normally research. You know, I was with somebody research. You know, I was with somebody research. You know, I was with somebody this weekend and he was telling me about this weekend and he was telling me about this weekend and he was telling me about some health thing and I put it into some health thing and I put it into some health thing and I put it into Fable and I was like, it won't answer Fable and I was like, it won't answer Fable and I was like, it won't answer you. I'm like, okay. So, I think that you. I'm like, okay. So, I think that you. I'm like, okay. So, I think that everybody will get to a point, they'll everybody will get to a point, they'll everybody will get to a point, they'll get to it at different times where they get to it at different times where they get to it at different times where they just say, you know what, like it just say, you know what, like it just say, you know what, like it shouldn't really matter what model I'm shouldn't really matter what model I'm shouldn't really matter what model I'm using. If I get an answer that I think using. If I get an answer that I think using. If I get an answer that I think is reasonable and I can kind of go about is reasonable and I can kind of go about is reasonable and I can kind of go about my day separately. I think when the my day separately. I think when the my day separately. I think when the corporate CFO gets involved, it'll be an corporate CFO gets involved, it'll be an corporate CFO gets involved, it'll be an entirely different conversation entirely different conversation entirely different conversation altogether. I think that what I can tell altogether. I think that what I can tell altogether. I think that what I can tell you after this UN commission that I you after this UN commission that I you after this UN commission that I joined with Ben off and Jensen and Brad joined with Ben off and Jensen and Brad joined with Ben off and Jensen and Brad Smith, there is not a single country in Smith, there is not a single country in Smith, there is not a single country in the world that is not trying to figure the world that is not trying to figure the world that is not trying to figure out its own sovereign AI strategy. And I out its own sovereign AI strategy. And I out its own sovereign AI strategy. And I don't think they believe using a closed don't think they believe using a closed don't think they believe using a closed source American model is the answer. And source American model is the answer. And source American model is the answer. And so, you know, we I think we have to keep so, you know, we I think we have to keep so, you know, we I think we have to keep in mind there's trends. One is just in mind there's trends. One is just in mind there's trends. One is just geographic penetration of humans and geographic penetration of humans and geographic penetration of humans and there are still many many many more there are still many many many more there are still many many many more people that don't use it than do which people that don't use it than do which people that don't use it than do which is an upside and an opportunity for is an upside and an opportunity for is an upside and an opportunity for everybody. everybody. everybody. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> And then the second is there is going to >> And then the second is there is going to >> And then the second is there is going to be the experimentation as you said that be the experimentation as you said that be the experimentation as you said that needs to transition to ongoing needs to transition to ongoing needs to transition to ongoing repeatable usage repeatable usage repeatable usage and then the third is that all of that and then the third is that all of that and then the third is that all of that then needs to plug into the existing then needs to plug into the existing then needs to plug into the existing regulatory infrastructure that we use as regulatory infrastructure that we use as regulatory infrastructure that we use as societies to run the world. And I think societies to run the world. And I think societies to run the world. And I think when you put all of these things when you put all of these things when you put all of these things together, it's not clear to me who wins together, it's not clear to me who wins together, it's not clear to me who wins except that you're going to have a lot except that you're going to have a lot except that you're going to have a lot of diversity of choice. Certain of diversity of choice. Certain of diversity of choice. Certain countries, I can tell you after this countries, I can tell you after this countries, I can tell you after this week, week, week, >> have no desire to subjugate themselves >> have no desire to subjugate themselves >> have no desire to subjugate themselves to any technical risk and so they're to any technical risk and so they're to any technical risk and so they're willing to spend the money to have their willing to spend the money to have their willing to spend the money to have their own. Now we can argue and debate whether own. Now we can argue and debate whether own. Now we can argue and debate whether that country has any chance but they that country has any chance but they that country has any chance but they would rather take an open source model would rather take an open source model would rather take an open source model like Nvidia's actually and stand up like Nvidia's actually and stand up like Nvidia's actually and stand up their own stack soup to nuts for their their own stack soup to nuts for their their own stack soup to nuts for their own people and their own companies own people and their own companies own people and their own companies inside of their own country inside of their own country inside of their own country >> and if the models are 99% as good or 95% >> and if the models are 99% as good or 95% >> and if the models are 99% as good or 95% as good there's going to be a claim that as good there's going to be a claim that as good there's going to be a claim that some countries make which is it's just some countries make which is it's just some countries make which is it's just good enough. good enough. good enough. >> That's the question. That's the >> That's the question. That's the >> That's the question. That's the question. And then separately there are question. And then separately there are question. And then separately there are companies who will not have the earnings companies who will not have the earnings companies who will not have the earnings growth to justify this without going on growth to justify this without going on growth to justify this without going on some long protracted carveout of cost. some long protracted carveout of cost. some long protracted carveout of cost. And most companies, you know this, And most companies, you know this, And most companies, you know this, they just don't do it. They don't have they just don't do it. They don't have they just don't do it. They don't have the nerve to do it. They're not capable the nerve to do it. They're not capable the nerve to do it. They're not capable of it. You know, you wrote that famous of it. You know, you wrote that famous of it. You know, you wrote that famous essay to Zuck. He was pressured into essay to Zuck. He was pressured into essay to Zuck. He was pressured into finally doing it. Absent to very few finally doing it. Absent to very few finally doing it. Absent to very few companies, most people just allow the companies, most people just allow the companies, most people just allow the problems to compound. So, I just don't problems to compound. So, I just don't problems to compound. So, I just don't see a world where when you get clobbered see a world where when you get clobbered see a world where when you get clobbered over the head, over the head, over the head, you don't look at other ways of just you don't look at other ways of just you don't look at other ways of just displacing cost. And if it's like Coke displacing cost. And if it's like Coke displacing cost. And if it's like Coke Pepsi kind of a thing and Pepsi is 1/ Pepsi kind of a thing and Pepsi is 1/ Pepsi kind of a thing and Pepsi is 1/ 1,000th the cost of Coke, I don't know. 1,000th the cost of Coke, I don't know. 1,000th the cost of Coke, I don't know. I just think it's a it's a risk that I I just think it's a it's a risk that I I just think it's a it's a risk that I think has to be managed in the think has to be managed in the think has to be managed in the perception of the market participants perception of the market participants perception of the market participants and the underwriters. To add to that, and the underwriters. To add to that, and the underwriters. To add to that, uh, Brad, just open source is very hard uh, Brad, just open source is very hard uh, Brad, just open source is very hard to implement when compared to just to implement when compared to just to implement when compared to just firing up Claude and having Claude firing up Claude and having Claude firing up Claude and having Claude already approved in your organization. already approved in your organization. already approved in your organization. The number of steps it took me in order The number of steps it took me in order The number of steps it took me in order to, and I I'm pretty familiar with to, and I I'm pretty familiar with to, and I I'm pretty familiar with technology. It took me hours to technology. It took me hours to technology. It took me hours to configure my new setup to get onto this configure my new setup to get onto this configure my new setup to get onto this bid sensor network to get open router bid sensor network to get open router bid sensor network to get open router going. And to your point, Jimoth, it going. And to your point, Jimoth, it going. And to your point, Jimoth, it does dynamically route now. So, I'm does dynamically route now. So, I'm does dynamically route now. So, I'm dynamically routing and I'm, you know, dynamically routing and I'm, you know, dynamically routing and I'm, you know, GLM 5.2 too. And then if I fall back to GLM 5.2 too. And then if I fall back to GLM 5.2 too. And then if I fall back to Claude, but which Claude am I going to Claude, but which Claude am I going to Claude, but which Claude am I going to fall back to? And here's another piece fall back to? And here's another piece fall back to? And here's another piece of evidence to your point, Schmoth. of evidence to your point, Schmoth. of evidence to your point, Schmoth. There are some organizations that just There are some organizations that just There are some organizations that just aren't capable of this. They don't have aren't capable of this. They don't have aren't capable of this. They don't have the the team that, you know, does this the the team that, you know, does this the the team that, you know, does this naturally. We just talked about the CTO naturally. We just talked about the CTO naturally. We just talked about the CTO of Uber. Now, let's talk about another of Uber. Now, let's talk about another of Uber. Now, let's talk about another CTO. Andy Fang is the CTO of Door Dash. CTO. Andy Fang is the CTO of Door Dash. CTO. Andy Fang is the CTO of Door Dash. Shout out to Stanley. And so he, as you Shout out to Stanley. And so he, as you Shout out to Stanley. And so he, as you can see here in this uh tweet, I a lot can see here in this uh tweet, I a lot can see here in this uh tweet, I a lot of people listening to All-In over the of people listening to All-In over the of people listening to All-In over the last couple weeks are coming out and as last couple weeks are coming out and as last couple weeks are coming out and as I said explaining what they're doing to I said explaining what they're doing to I said explaining what they're doing to address this exact issue. He says, "Hey, address this exact issue. He says, "Hey, address this exact issue. He says, "Hey, with our internal coding benchmarks, with our internal coding benchmarks, with our internal coding benchmarks, we're able to confidently in introduce we're able to confidently in introduce we're able to confidently in introduce openweight models into our AI code openweight models into our AI code openweight models into our AI code review without degrading code quality. review without degrading code quality. review without degrading code quality. Have the frontier model fable from Have the frontier model fable from Have the frontier model fable from anthropic to do the hardest work, anthropic to do the hardest work, anthropic to do the hardest work, delegate lower level work to Kimmy 2.6 delegate lower level work to Kimmy 2.6 delegate lower level work to Kimmy 2.6 and they are now releasing their and they are now releasing their and they are now releasing their benchmark." So another group releasing benchmark." So another group releasing benchmark." So another group releasing their benchmarks and saying hey we know their benchmarks and saying hey we know their benchmarks and saying hey we know this is an issue the CTO has been this is an issue the CTO has been this is an issue the CTO has been charged to your point Chimath again CFO charged to your point Chimath again CFO charged to your point Chimath again CFO says hey make sure this is profitable we says hey make sure this is profitable we says hey make sure this is profitable we get the ROI they put that on the CTO get the ROI they put that on the CTO get the ROI they put that on the CTO here's another CTO from another leading here's another CTO from another leading here's another CTO from another leading tech organization that knows how to tech organization that knows how to tech organization that knows how to implement this yeah implement this yeah implement this yeah >> the really interesting thing we have to >> the really interesting thing we have to >> the really interesting thing we have to forecast right now is what happens in an forecast right now is what happens in an forecast right now is what happens in an earnings miss earnings miss earnings miss and I think what happens in a in a and I think what happens in a in a and I think what happens in a in a moment where for whatever reason maybe moment where for whatever reason maybe moment where for whatever reason maybe there's just an externality that there there's just an externality that there there's just an externality that there are a series of earnings misses. are a series of earnings misses. are a series of earnings misses. >> Where are people going to look? And I >> Where are people going to look? And I >> Where are people going to look? And I just think that people find it very just think that people find it very just think that people find it very difficult to lay off other people. I difficult to lay off other people. I difficult to lay off other people. I think it's much much easier to cut other think it's much much easier to cut other think it's much much easier to cut other costs. And I think that the more costs. And I think that the more costs. And I think that the more successful these companies get in a very successful these companies get in a very successful these companies get in a very quick amount of time without really quick amount of time without really quick amount of time without really proving the ROI, I just think the bigger proving the ROI, I just think the bigger proving the ROI, I just think the bigger the risk is. It's complicated. the game the risk is. It's complicated. the game the risk is. It's complicated. the game on the field when you're working with on the field when you're working with on the field when you're working with these enterprises and just trying to these enterprises and just trying to these enterprises and just trying to explain it to them is I think that explain it to them is I think that explain it to them is I think that they're they're getting smarter quickly they're they're getting smarter quickly they're they're getting smarter quickly is what I would say. is what I would say. is what I would say. >> I would just say I I I think that >> I would just say I I I think that >> I would just say I I I think that Chimath's absolutely right about the Chimath's absolutely right about the Chimath's absolutely right about the sovereign uh stacks that are going to sovereign uh stacks that are going to sovereign uh stacks that are going to get built around the world. This is not get built around the world. This is not get built around the world. This is not either or. We are going to have open either or. We are going to have open either or. We are going to have open source and we are going to have frontier source and we are going to have frontier source and we are going to have frontier intelligence. Um, the preponderance of intelligence. Um, the preponderance of intelligence. Um, the preponderance of the tokens today are already shifting the tokens today are already shifting the tokens today are already shifting toward cheaper, lower uh uh uh lagging toward cheaper, lower uh uh uh lagging toward cheaper, lower uh uh uh lagging models out of open AAI or lagging models models out of open AAI or lagging models models out of open AAI or lagging models out of anthropic or or the other out of anthropic or or the other out of anthropic or or the other frontier labs that are out there. frontier labs that are out there. frontier labs that are out there. Obviously, we you know, we talk about Obviously, we you know, we talk about Obviously, we you know, we talk about those two. SpaceX has released an those two. SpaceX has released an those two. SpaceX has released an incredible model, you know, in the last incredible model, you know, in the last incredible model, you know, in the last two days. Meta's out with, you know, a two days. Meta's out with, you know, a two days. Meta's out with, you know, a terrific model today. So, Gemini is terrific model today. So, Gemini is terrific model today. So, Gemini is still in the hunt. So, there are lots of still in the hunt. So, there are lots of still in the hunt. So, there are lots of choice. The meta thing was really choice. The meta thing was really choice. The meta thing was really intense because I thought okay you know intense because I thought okay you know intense because I thought okay you know we talked about the game theory which we talked about the game theory which we talked about the game theory which was Mark should scorch the earth with was Mark should scorch the earth with was Mark should scorch the earth with open source. I think they flubbed that open source. I think they flubbed that open source. I think they flubbed that play play play >> but then I think he is now said he's >> but then I think he is now said he's >> but then I think he is now said he's going to create a price war and so if going to create a price war and so if going to create a price war and so if you look at the tweet or the quote there you look at the tweet or the quote there you look at the tweet or the quote there was a post Jason I don't know Nick if was a post Jason I don't know Nick if was a post Jason I don't know Nick if you can find it you can find it you can find it >> I got it >> I got it >> I got it >> announcing it he was basically like hey >> announcing it he was basically like hey >> announcing it he was basically like hey guys I'm going to give you the same guys I'm going to give you the same guys I'm going to give you the same quality at like 1/100th of the cost. Now quality at like 1/100th of the cost. Now quality at like 1/100th of the cost. Now again, again, again, >> there's a lot between here and there. >> there's a lot between here and there. >> there's a lot between here and there. There's a lot of enterprise distribution There's a lot of enterprise distribution There's a lot of enterprise distribution that's required and you know this that's required and you know this that's required and you know this there's been a couple of misfires there's been a couple of misfires there's been a couple of misfires before, but I thought it was interesting before, but I thought it was interesting before, but I thought it was interesting that the vector of challenge was on that the vector of challenge was on that the vector of challenge was on cost. cost. cost. >> Yeah. Here's the Mark Zuckerberg tweet. >> Yeah. Here's the Mark Zuckerberg tweet. >> Yeah. Here's the Mark Zuckerberg tweet. Just sorry I queued up for you there, Just sorry I queued up for you there, Just sorry I queued up for you there, Brad. And he's at D, that was his old Brad. And he's at D, that was his old Brad. And he's at D, that was his old handle back when he was in college, fd. handle back when he was in college, fd. handle back when he was in college, fd. And he's done more tweets today over And he's done more tweets today over And he's done more tweets today over this Muse Spark announcement than he's this Muse Spark announcement than he's this Muse Spark announcement than he's done in his history. So he's getting done in his history. So he's getting done in his history. So he's getting into the X.com conversation. Quote, into the X.com conversation. Quote, into the X.com conversation. Quote, "Today we're releasing new Spark 1.1, a "Today we're releasing new Spark 1.1, a "Today we're releasing new Spark 1.1, a strong agentic encoding model at a very strong agentic encoding model at a very strong agentic encoding model at a very low price. It's available through our low price. It's available through our low price. It's available through our new meta model API and in meta AI." So new meta model API and in meta AI." So new meta model API and in meta AI." So he's coming out saying, "Hey, we got the he's coming out saying, "Hey, we got the he's coming out saying, "Hey, we got the strongest agentic tool here. Please come strongest agentic tool here. Please come strongest agentic tool here. Please come use it." He also wants to have his own use it." He also wants to have his own use it." He also wants to have his own essentially, essentially, essentially, you know, he he wants to jump into not you know, he he wants to jump into not you know, he he wants to jump into not the hosting space, but he wants to the hosting space, but he wants to the hosting space, but he wants to provide tokens as well. So again, I provide tokens as well. So again, I provide tokens as well. So again, I think we're going to have a tremendous think we're going to have a tremendous think we're going to have a tremendous amount of selection. The competition is amount of selection. The competition is amount of selection. The competition is great for America, but I think if you great for America, but I think if you great for America, but I think if you look at the things people are doing, let look at the things people are doing, let look at the things people are doing, let me give you an example. The premium me give you an example. The premium me give you an example. The premium workload, Jason, you talked about workload, Jason, you talked about workload, Jason, you talked about summarizing a document may take 20,000 summarizing a document may take 20,000 summarizing a document may take 20,000 cheap tokens to do. Of course, shoot cheap tokens to do. Of course, shoot cheap tokens to do. Of course, shoot that to a lagging model or an open that to a lagging model or an open that to a lagging model or an open source model, but if you're talking source model, but if you're talking source model, but if you're talking about replacing a software engineer for about replacing a software engineer for about replacing a software engineer for 2 hours, that may take 2 million 2 hours, that may take 2 million 2 hours, that may take 2 million expensive tokens. And the consequence of expensive tokens. And the consequence of expensive tokens. And the consequence of using something that's 95% as good is using something that's 95% as good is using something that's 95% as good is really high, right? Because you have a really high, right? Because you have a really high, right? Because you have a longunning task and if the task breaks longunning task and if the task breaks longunning task and if the task breaks early or it breaks in the middle or early or it breaks in the middle or early or it breaks in the middle or breaks at the end, there's a huge cost breaks at the end, there's a huge cost breaks at the end, there's a huge cost to that. So to that. So to that. So >> you still burn the tokens, right? You >> you still burn the tokens, right? You >> you still burn the tokens, right? You and back to this analogy I was using, and back to this analogy I was using, and back to this analogy I was using, they're pulling the slot machine and you they're pulling the slot machine and you they're pulling the slot machine and you lose lose lose >> and the time and the compute. So if an >> and the time and the compute. So if an >> and the time and the compute. So if an AI agent is replacing a $200 an hour AI agent is replacing a $200 an hour AI agent is replacing a $200 an hour consultant, right? Take that as an consultant, right? Take that as an consultant, right? Take that as an example. So, three consulting firms, example. So, three consulting firms, example. So, three consulting firms, they're competing. They need the they're competing. They need the they're competing. They need the smartest consultant. It they're charging smartest consultant. It they're charging smartest consultant. It they're charging 200 bucks an hour. The difference 200 bucks an hour. The difference 200 bucks an hour. The difference between spending three bucks on a cheap between spending three bucks on a cheap between spending three bucks on a cheap model or 15 bucks on an expensive model model or 15 bucks on an expensive model model or 15 bucks on an expensive model to replace a $200 an hour consultant, to replace a $200 an hour consultant, to replace a $200 an hour consultant, it's just irrelevance. That inference it's just irrelevance. That inference it's just irrelevance. That inference cost difference is irrelevance if you're cost difference is irrelevance if you're cost difference is irrelevance if you're getting something that's bulletproof for getting something that's bulletproof for getting something that's bulletproof for 15 bucks. And so, I think that's what 15 bucks. And so, I think that's what 15 bucks. And so, I think that's what we're seeing play out. The best evidence we're seeing play out. The best evidence we're seeing play out. The best evidence for all of this is just revenue growth, for all of this is just revenue growth, for all of this is just revenue growth, >> right? We can sit here and speculate all >> right? We can sit here and speculate all >> right? We can sit here and speculate all day long as to revenue, not from day long as to revenue, not from day long as to revenue, not from Anthropic and Open AAI, but from their Anthropic and Open AAI, but from their Anthropic and Open AAI, but from their customers. customers. customers. >> I'm no I'm talking about what is >> I'm no I'm talking about what is >> I'm no I'm talking about what is anthropic revenue growth compared to anthropic revenue growth compared to anthropic revenue growth compared to OpenAI compared to the open source OpenAI compared to the open source OpenAI compared to the open source models. Millions of independent actors models. Millions of independent actors models. Millions of independent actors are choosing every single day. The open are choosing every single day. The open are choosing every single day. The open source companies are growing, right? But source companies are growing, right? But source companies are growing, right? But they're growing selling something that they're growing selling something that they're growing selling something that is really, really cheap. And there's a is really, really cheap. And there's a is really, really cheap. And there's a there there's room in every single there there's room in every single there there's room in every single market for premium products, for market for premium products, for market for premium products, for mid-tier products, and for commodity mid-tier products, and for commodity mid-tier products, and for commodity products. And I think we see a lot of products. And I think we see a lot of products. And I think we see a lot of this token growth. People are this token growth. People are this token growth. People are speculating that the that the speculating that the that the speculating that the that the intelligence gap between that commodity intelligence gap between that commodity intelligence gap between that commodity stuff and the frontier stuff is going to stuff and the frontier stuff is going to stuff and the frontier stuff is going to collapse to the point that people won't collapse to the point that people won't collapse to the point that people won't pay for the frontier stuff. There is no pay for the frontier stuff. There is no pay for the frontier stuff. There is no evidence of that on the field today. It evidence of that on the field today. It evidence of that on the field today. It may develop over the course of the next may develop over the course of the next may develop over the course of the next couple years, but it's not on the field couple years, but it's not on the field couple years, but it's not on the field today. today. today. >> Yeah. Yeah. And just to give people an >> Yeah. Yeah. And just to give people an >> Yeah. Yeah. And just to give people an idea, we we keep mentioning what idea, we we keep mentioning what idea, we we keep mentioning what sovereigns are doing. To give you the sovereigns are doing. To give you the sovereigns are doing. To give you the specifics on that, the UAE very famously specifics on that, the UAE very famously specifics on that, the UAE very famously has their own has their own has their own uh Abu Dhabi Technology Innovation uh Abu Dhabi Technology Innovation uh Abu Dhabi Technology Innovation Institute shipping Falcon. You probably Institute shipping Falcon. You probably Institute shipping Falcon. You probably have heard about that. The Saudis have have heard about that. The Saudis have have heard about that. The Saudis have Humane and they're doing their own Humane and they're doing their own Humane and they're doing their own models that are Arabic LLMs. And then models that are Arabic LLMs. And then models that are Arabic LLMs. And then this week, Japan is investing$6 billion this week, Japan is investing$6 billion this week, Japan is investing$6 billion dollars in a consortium. It's called the dollars in a consortium. It's called the dollars in a consortium. It's called the Neoterra Neoterra Neoterra Neoter. Neo T r a consortium and they're Neoter. Neo T r a consortium and they're Neoter. Neo T r a consortium and they're doing that and skipping ahead to doing that and skipping ahead to doing that and skipping ahead to physical AI i.e. robotics. Okay. Joining physical AI i.e. robotics. Okay. Joining physical AI i.e. robotics. Okay. Joining the conversation here, the one, the only the conversation here, the one, the only the conversation here, the one, the only Saxy Pooh Sax bringing you into the Saxy Pooh Sax bringing you into the Saxy Pooh Sax bringing you into the discussion talking a little bit here discussion talking a little bit here discussion talking a little bit here about the debate that we started here on about the debate that we started here on about the debate that we started here on the podcast getting ROI from tokens. the podcast getting ROI from tokens. the podcast getting ROI from tokens. Where are the tokens going to acrue to Where are the tokens going to acrue to Where are the tokens going to acrue to open source versus the frontier models? open source versus the frontier models? open source versus the frontier models? Bunch of CTO's chiming in on X this week Bunch of CTO's chiming in on X this week Bunch of CTO's chiming in on X this week in the last couple days. is in fact in the last couple days. is in fact in the last couple days. is in fact talking about how they're managing talking about how they're managing talking about how they're managing intelligent routing first to open source intelligent routing first to open source intelligent routing first to open source models then falling back to Fable and models then falling back to Fable and models then falling back to Fable and the Frontier models. How do you think the Frontier models. How do you think the Frontier models. How do you think this is playing out? And if you're an this is playing out? And if you're an this is playing out? And if you're an investor in the space, how do you think investor in the space, how do you think investor in the space, how do you think about the frontier models and their about the frontier models and their about the frontier models and their growth when you have uh you know CFOs growth when you have uh you know CFOs growth when you have uh you know CFOs coming in and saying hey justify this coming in and saying hey justify this coming in and saying hey justify this cost and do you have a cheaper solution cost and do you have a cheaper solution cost and do you have a cheaper solution and what is that cheaper solution? Well, and what is that cheaper solution? Well, and what is that cheaper solution? Well, look, I think that enterprise CTO's look, I think that enterprise CTO's look, I think that enterprise CTO's would like to shift their token would like to shift their token would like to shift their token consumption to cheaper models for the consumption to cheaper models for the consumption to cheaper models for the obvious reason that that would be more obvious reason that that would be more obvious reason that that would be more efficient and they are seeing their efficient and they are seeing their efficient and they are seeing their compute cost or their token cost is compute cost or their token cost is compute cost or their token cost is skyrocketing right now. So, everyone's skyrocketing right now. So, everyone's skyrocketing right now. So, everyone's trying to figure out how do we put the trying to figure out how do we put the trying to figure out how do we put the brakes on this or at least control it, brakes on this or at least control it, brakes on this or at least control it, you know, make sure we're getting ROI. you know, make sure we're getting ROI. you know, make sure we're getting ROI. You also have the AI sovereignty issue You also have the AI sovereignty issue You also have the AI sovereignty issue that we discussed last week that Alex that we discussed last week that Alex that we discussed last week that Alex Karp talked about where they're worried Karp talked about where they're worried Karp talked about where they're worried about giving up the secret sauce or the about giving up the secret sauce or the about giving up the secret sauce or the alpha in their business to a frontier alpha in their business to a frontier alpha in their business to a frontier lab that may one day be competing with lab that may one day be competing with lab that may one day be competing with them. So there's no question that them. So there's no question that them. So there's no question that enterprises would like to diversify. enterprises would like to diversify. enterprises would like to diversify. They would like to get off of these They would like to get off of these They would like to get off of these frontier models when they can. The frontier models when they can. The frontier models when they can. The problem is I think in most cases they problem is I think in most cases they problem is I think in most cases they don't have the technical ability to do don't have the technical ability to do don't have the technical ability to do it. I mean Coinbase figured out how to it. I mean Coinbase figured out how to it. I mean Coinbase figured out how to do it. Door Dash figured out how to do do it. Door Dash figured out how to do do it. Door Dash figured out how to do it, which is to say they built a token it, which is to say they built a token it, which is to say they built a token routing system, a layer of middleware routing system, a layer of middleware routing system, a layer of middleware that allows them to sort of send that allows them to sort of send that allows them to sort of send frontier task to frontier models and frontier task to frontier models and frontier task to frontier models and non-frontier task to more mundane non-frontier task to more mundane non-frontier task to more mundane models. But I don't think your average models. But I don't think your average models. But I don't think your average enterprise has the technical capability enterprise has the technical capability enterprise has the technical capability to do that. So I think this is a case of to do that. So I think this is a case of to do that. So I think this is a case of the spirit is willing but the flesh is the spirit is willing but the flesh is the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak. I mean they are willing they would weak. I mean they are willing they would weak. I mean they are willing they would like to diversify off of these closed like to diversify off of these closed like to diversify off of these closed models but they are unable to do it and models but they are unable to do it and models but they are unable to do it and so this is why the share of wallet of so this is why the share of wallet of so this is why the share of wallet of closed models it actually increased. I closed models it actually increased. I closed models it actually increased. I think that opensource went from 19% last think that opensource went from 19% last think that opensource went from 19% last year to 11% this year. So open source as year to 11% this year. So open source as year to 11% this year. So open source as a share of enterprise spending is a share of enterprise spending is a share of enterprise spending is actually decreasing. Now I don't think actually decreasing. Now I don't think actually decreasing. Now I don't think that means that usage is decreasing. I that means that usage is decreasing. I that means that usage is decreasing. I think usage is skyrocketing in both think usage is skyrocketing in both think usage is skyrocketing in both these categories. It also may be the these categories. It also may be the these categories. It also may be the case that because the whole point of case that because the whole point of case that because the whole point of using an open model is you just pay for using an open model is you just pay for using an open model is you just pay for the compute cost. You don't have to pay the compute cost. You don't have to pay the compute cost. You don't have to pay a lab. So it may be the case that it's a lab. So it may be the case that it's a lab. So it may be the case that it's hard to measure that usage in terms of hard to measure that usage in terms of hard to measure that usage in terms of spend. But nonetheless, I mean anyone spend. But nonetheless, I mean anyone spend. But nonetheless, I mean anyone who's saying that these closed models who's saying that these closed models who's saying that these closed models are gonna lose or are somehow losing, are gonna lose or are somehow losing, are gonna lose or are somehow losing, you're just not seeing it in the data. you're just not seeing it in the data. you're just not seeing it in the data. Like Brad's saying the revenue is Like Brad's saying the revenue is Like Brad's saying the revenue is skyrocketing and I think the most you skyrocketing and I think the most you skyrocketing and I think the most you can say is that enterprises that are can say is that enterprises that are can say is that enterprises that are technically capable would like to technically capable would like to technically capable would like to gravitate towards hybrid architectures gravitate towards hybrid architectures gravitate towards hybrid architectures but at the same time it takes technical but at the same time it takes technical but at the same time it takes technical expertise and it is just phenomenally expertise and it is just phenomenally expertise and it is just phenomenally convenient whether you're a developer or convenient whether you're a developer or convenient whether you're a developer or an enterprise just to go with the an enterprise just to go with the an enterprise just to go with the frontier labs and that's why their frontier labs and that's why their frontier labs and that's why their revenue is skyrocketing. revenue is skyrocketing. revenue is skyrocketing. >> It is the easiest choice. It's the most >> It is the easiest choice. It's the most >> It is the easiest choice. It's the most refined Yeah. most refined product's refined Yeah. most refined product's refined Yeah. most refined product's there's Yeah. And there's one other there's Yeah. And there's one other there's Yeah. And there's one other thing here as well and this was thing here as well and this was thing here as well and this was discussed in a really interesting blog discussed in a really interesting blog discussed in a really interesting blog post by the founder of Decagon which is post by the founder of Decagon which is post by the founder of Decagon which is enabling enabling enabling AI powered customer support for AI powered customer support for AI powered customer support for enterprises and what the founder said is enterprises and what the founder said is enterprises and what the founder said is look open models are great when you know look open models are great when you know look open models are great when you know exactly what you're trying to do why exactly what you're trying to do why exactly what you're trying to do why they're smaller cheaper models but you they're smaller cheaper models but you they're smaller cheaper models but you have to do post training you have to have to do post training you have to have to do post training you have to have the data set and you have to know have the data set and you have to know have the data set and you have to know exactly what you're going to use them exactly what you're going to use them exactly what you're going to use them for. Totally. But if you don't know for. Totally. But if you don't know for. Totally. But if you don't know exactly what you're going to use them exactly what you're going to use them exactly what you're going to use them for, you want the most powerful general for, you want the most powerful general for, you want the most powerful general intelligence that you can get. Right? So intelligence that you can get. Right? So intelligence that you can get. Right? So what he said is that for mature use what he said is that for mature use what he said is that for mature use cases, yeah, you want to go open, but cases, yeah, you want to go open, but cases, yeah, you want to go open, but for immature use cases, which are all for immature use cases, which are all for immature use cases, which are all the new things people are discovering the new things people are discovering the new things people are discovering right now, you're just going to want to right now, you're just going to want to right now, you're just going to want to use the most capable general model that use the most capable general model that use the most capable general model that you can. And then once you figure out you can. And then once you figure out you can. And then once you figure out what the workflow is and what the what the workflow is and what the what the workflow is and what the workload is going to be and exactly what workload is going to be and exactly what workload is going to be and exactly what you're trying to accomplish, then you you're trying to accomplish, then you you're trying to accomplish, then you can use a small highly trained model. can use a small highly trained model. can use a small highly trained model. And I think he said And I think he said And I think he said >> optimize in the post to get the game >> optimize in the post to get the game >> optimize in the post to get the game >> for customer support. Your model doesn't >> for customer support. Your model doesn't >> for customer support. Your model doesn't need to know physics, you know, for need to know physics, you know, for need to know physics, you know, for example, example, example, >> and so you don't need that capability, >> and so you don't need that capability, >> and so you don't need that capability, but enterprise are still trying to but enterprise are still trying to but enterprise are still trying to figure out exactly what all these figure out exactly what all these figure out exactly what all these workflows are going to do. So I think workflows are going to do. So I think workflows are going to do. So I think that's another factor which is to say that's another factor which is to say that's another factor which is to say that you know it depends on the use case that you know it depends on the use case that you know it depends on the use case and how mature that use case is and you and how mature that use case is and you and how mature that use case is and you really want the most powerful frontier really want the most powerful frontier really want the most powerful frontier models that you can at the discovery of models that you can at the discovery of models that you can at the discovery of all the potential for the technology. all the potential for the technology. all the potential for the technology. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And then let me just wrap up then >> And then let me just wrap up then >> And then let me just wrap up then there's one other interesting post that there's one other interesting post that there's one other interesting post that I saw was by Nesh Aurora who also said I saw was by Nesh Aurora who also said I saw was by Nesh Aurora who also said that what he's seeing is yeah that what he's seeing is yeah that what he's seeing is yeah enterprises would like to diversify. enterprises would like to diversify. enterprises would like to diversify. They would like what he called model They would like what he called model They would like what he called model fungeibility. They would love to fungeibility. They would love to fungeibility. They would love to commoditize these models, right? And commoditize these models, right? And commoditize these models, right? And just hot swap them. just hot swap them. just hot swap them. >> Yeah. Headless is the term being used, >> Yeah. Headless is the term being used, >> Yeah. Headless is the term being used, right? Yeah. right? Yeah. right? Yeah. >> Yeah. That'd be ideal for enterprises is >> Yeah. That'd be ideal for enterprises is >> Yeah. That'd be ideal for enterprises is you sort of swap out the model for the you sort of swap out the model for the you sort of swap out the model for the cheapest one that gets your task done. cheapest one that gets your task done. cheapest one that gets your task done. But then what do you do about memory? But then what do you do about memory? But then what do you do about memory? What do you do about context? What do What do you do about context? What do What do you do about context? What do you do about history? And what he said you do about history? And what he said you do about history? And what he said is no one's really figured out a way to is no one's really figured out a way to is no one's really figured out a way to abstract that stuff away from the model abstract that stuff away from the model abstract that stuff away from the model yet. And again, this goes to the yet. And again, this goes to the yet. And again, this goes to the technical challenge of creating this technical challenge of creating this technical challenge of creating this middleware layer that would do the most middleware layer that would do the most middleware layer that would do the most efficient token routing. It's well, you efficient token routing. It's well, you efficient token routing. It's well, you know, it doesn't work unless you can know, it doesn't work unless you can know, it doesn't work unless you can make all of that context and memory and make all of that context and memory and make all of that context and memory and history fully portable to the cheaper history fully portable to the cheaper history fully portable to the cheaper model that you want to basically hot model that you want to basically hot model that you want to basically hot swap to, swap to, swap to, >> which means you have to have some >> which means you have to have some >> which means you have to have some technical ability sachs. And the people technical ability sachs. And the people technical ability sachs. And the people with technical ability, the tip of the with technical ability, the tip of the with technical ability, the tip of the spear, the 1% of people deploying this spear, the 1% of people deploying this spear, the 1% of people deploying this technology are starting to figure that technology are starting to figure that technology are starting to figure that out. Here's another proof point and some out. Here's another proof point and some out. Here's another proof point and some more evidence. This is Ali the founder more evidence. This is Ali the founder more evidence. This is Ali the founder uh of data bricks I think a company uh of data bricks I think a company uh of data bricks I think a company you're very familiar with Brad and what you're very familiar with Brad and what you're very familiar with Brad and what he realized when you start taking apart he realized when you start taking apart he realized when you start taking apart the harness and you start looking at the the harness and you start looking at the the harness and you start looking at the skills you look at the memory and all skills you look at the memory and all skills you look at the memory and all this acruant that you put around your this acruant that you put around your this acruant that you put around your tasks he said we find that the same tasks he said we find that the same tasks he said we find that the same model using the same model not using model using the same model not using model using the same model not using open source versus open AI or or claude open source versus open AI or or claude open source versus open AI or or claude we found that for the same model the we found that for the same model the we found that for the same model the choice of harness can significantly save choice of harness can significantly save choice of harness can significantly save costs by about 2x. So they found with costs by about 2x. So they found with costs by about 2x. So they found with GLM 5.2 that this performs extremely GLM 5.2 that this performs extremely GLM 5.2 that this performs extremely well and that their tasks literally are well and that their tasks literally are well and that their tasks literally are getting cut in half using the same model getting cut in half using the same model getting cut in half using the same model but with a different harness. And that but with a different harness. And that but with a different harness. And that rings true to me. I once you've built rings true to me. I once you've built rings true to me. I once you've built one of these agents and I was talking one of these agents and I was talking one of these agents and I was talking about one earlier I'm running every hour about one earlier I'm running every hour about one earlier I'm running every hour on the hour to find trends. I asked it on the hour to find trends. I asked it on the hour to find trends. I asked it to please start optimizing it. And when to please start optimizing it. And when to please start optimizing it. And when I optimized it, it was like 80% less I optimized it, it was like 80% less I optimized it, it was like 80% less token use. And now in these apps, you token use. And now in these apps, you token use. And now in these apps, you can go to your analytic stacks and you can go to your analytic stacks and you can go to your analytic stacks and you can actually see your token use by hour, can actually see your token use by hour, can actually see your token use by hour, by job, and across which models you're by job, and across which models you're by job, and across which models you're using. This is really sophisticated and using. This is really sophisticated and using. This is really sophisticated and hard for for a consumer to do of the hard for for a consumer to do of the hard for for a consumer to do of the technology, but it's definitely a trend. technology, but it's definitely a trend. technology, but it's definitely a trend. >> So with that harness that he was using, >> So with that harness that he was using, >> So with that harness that he was using, is that something they built in house? is that something they built in house? is that something they built in house? >> Yes, I think it's um >> Yes, I think it's um >> Yes, I think it's um >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Okay, got it. So they they basically >> Okay, got it. So they they basically >> Okay, got it. So they they basically creat creat creat >> Yeah. in front of these and that it can >> Yeah. in front of these and that it can >> Yeah. in front of these and that it can multiplex different harnesses and models multiplex different harnesses and models multiplex different harnesses and models for different tasks. So he's not only for different tasks. So he's not only for different tasks. So he's not only routing to the right LLM, he's routing routing to the right LLM, he's routing routing to the right LLM, he's routing to the right harness and people don't to the right harness and people don't to the right harness and people don't even know what skills are. People don't even know what skills are. People don't even know what skills are. People don't even know what the memory is at this even know what the memory is at this even know what the memory is at this point there. That's all abstracted into point there. That's all abstracted into point there. That's all abstracted into the claw product or the perplexity the claw product or the perplexity the claw product or the perplexity product etc. Yeah, there'll be a massive product etc. Yeah, there'll be a massive product etc. Yeah, there'll be a massive business. There already is. All these business. There already is. All these business. There already is. All these inference clouds, you know, the base 10s inference clouds, you know, the base 10s inference clouds, you know, the base 10s of the world, the fireworks of the of the world, the fireworks of the of the world, the fireworks of the world, every single hyperscaler in the world, every single hyperscaler in the world, every single hyperscaler in the world is going to do this. They're all world is going to do this. They're all world is going to do this. They're all going to provide, you know, tools that going to provide, you know, tools that going to provide, you know, tools that allow you to achieve some level of model allow you to achieve some level of model allow you to achieve some level of model fungeibility. The big question is at the fungeibility. The big question is at the fungeibility. The big question is at the end of the day, we're going to have it's end of the day, we're going to have it's end of the day, we're going to have it's going to be very heterogeneous, but what going to be very heterogeneous, but what going to be very heterogeneous, but what is the mix between these two? I again is the mix between these two? I again is the mix between these two? I again think the TAM is so damn big here that think the TAM is so damn big here that think the TAM is so damn big here that you're going to have huge open-source you're going to have huge open-source you're going to have huge open-source use cases, sovereign use cases, etc. use cases, sovereign use cases, etc. use cases, sovereign use cases, etc. You're going to have plenty of room for You're going to have plenty of room for You're going to have plenty of room for the frontier labs. I Let me throw the frontier labs. I Let me throw the frontier labs. I Let me throw something out. I'd like to get your something out. I'd like to get your something out. I'd like to get your opinion on. you know to a certain extent opinion on. you know to a certain extent opinion on. you know to a certain extent there's this implied assumption in the there's this implied assumption in the there's this implied assumption in the world that uh there's going to be this world that uh there's going to be this world that uh there's going to be this convergence of intelligence right and if convergence of intelligence right and if convergence of intelligence right and if you look at the benchmarks today seems you look at the benchmarks today seems you look at the benchmarks today seems like everybody you know on the like everybody you know on the like everybody you know on the benchmarks they are converging but yet benchmarks they are converging but yet benchmarks they are converging but yet if you look at the revenue distribution if you look at the revenue distribution if you look at the revenue distribution it's not converging at all one of the it's not converging at all one of the it's not converging at all one of the questions I have will the model router questions I have will the model router questions I have will the model router itself be smart enough to overcome David itself be smart enough to overcome David itself be smart enough to overcome David the inherent intelligence advantages of the inherent intelligence advantages of the inherent intelligence advantages of the generalized of the frontier labs the the generalized of the frontier labs the the generalized of the frontier labs the non One consensus argument might be that non One consensus argument might be that non One consensus argument might be that intelligence is not converging at all intelligence is not converging at all intelligence is not converging at all that c super intelligence becomes fully that c super intelligence becomes fully that c super intelligence becomes fully self uh uh uh you know recursive and as self uh uh uh you know recursive and as self uh uh uh you know recursive and as it becomes recursive you actually extend it becomes recursive you actually extend it becomes recursive you actually extend the lead because the smarter your model the lead because the smarter your model the lead because the smarter your model gets the more revenue you get the more gets the more revenue you get the more gets the more revenue you get the more compute you can buy the more compute you compute you can buy the more compute you compute you can buy the more compute you can buy the better the model is that you can buy the better the model is that you can buy the better the model is that you can build so I think there's a chance can build so I think there's a chance can build so I think there's a chance that over the course of the next 2 to 3 that over the course of the next 2 to 3 that over the course of the next 2 to 3 years as we take on much more complex years as we take on much more complex years as we take on much more complex agentic tasks asks that the distance agentic tasks asks that the distance agentic tasks asks that the distance between the frontier and everybody else between the frontier and everybody else between the frontier and everybody else doesn't converge. It actually extends. doesn't converge. It actually extends. doesn't converge. It actually extends. We shall see. But, you know, I think We shall see. But, you know, I think We shall see. But, you know, I think there's this implicit assumption in all there's this implicit assumption in all there's this implicit assumption in all the arguments today that everything's the arguments today that everything's the arguments today that everything's converging. I'm not I'm not sure that converging. I'm not I'm not sure that converging. I'm not I'm not sure that we've really run that to ground. Another we've really run that to ground. Another we've really run that to ground. Another piece of evidence to put in uh to this piece of evidence to put in uh to this piece of evidence to put in uh to this mix. I interviewed Anton, the CEO of mix. I interviewed Anton, the CEO of mix. I interviewed Anton, the CEO of Lovable. Lovable is an app that or a Lovable. Lovable is an app that or a Lovable. Lovable is an app that or a service that allows you to vibe code, service that allows you to vibe code, service that allows you to vibe code, you know, different pieces of software. you know, different pieces of software. you know, different pieces of software. They've got a really interesting take on They've got a really interesting take on They've got a really interesting take on that. They went from 100 to 600 million that. They went from 100 to 600 million that. They went from 100 to 600 million in revenue over the last two years. They in revenue over the last two years. They in revenue over the last two years. They went from zero to 350 in the first two went from zero to 350 in the first two went from zero to 350 in the first two years of the company. Products been out years of the company. Products been out years of the company. Products been out I think roughly for like 30 months. Then I think roughly for like 30 months. Then I think roughly for like 30 months. Then I also spoke to uh the CEO of 11 Labs, I also spoke to uh the CEO of 11 Labs, I also spoke to uh the CEO of 11 Labs, Matti. And I asked both of them point Matti. And I asked both of them point Matti. And I asked both of them point blank, are you guys uh you know your blank, are you guys uh you know your blank, are you guys uh you know your major customers of you know the the major customers of you know the the major customers of you know the the Frontier models? Yes. They're spending Frontier models? Yes. They're spending Frontier models? Yes. They're spending tens of millions of dollars with those tens of millions of dollars with those tens of millions of dollars with those frontier models. I asked them, hey, are frontier models. I asked them, hey, are frontier models. I asked them, hey, are you concerned about data leakage and you concerned about data leakage and you concerned about data leakage and them compete, you know, releasing them compete, you know, releasing them compete, you know, releasing competing products? 11 Labs is doing competing products? 11 Labs is doing competing products? 11 Labs is doing voice and obviously Claude code, you voice and obviously Claude code, you voice and obviously Claude code, you know, is an obvious competitor to know, is an obvious competitor to know, is an obvious competitor to lovable. Are you going to make your own lovable. Are you going to make your own lovable. Are you going to make your own models? Both of them said that they're models? Both of them said that they're models? Both of them said that they're working essentially on their own models. working essentially on their own models. working essentially on their own models. Those are major customers of the Those are major customers of the Those are major customers of the Frontier Labs who they want to get off Frontier Labs who they want to get off Frontier Labs who they want to get off of the Frontier models and they want to of the Frontier models and they want to of the Frontier models and they want to have their own proprietary model. The have their own proprietary model. The have their own proprietary model. The the ability to create verticalized the ability to create verticalized the ability to create verticalized models is getting easier and easier models is getting easier and easier models is getting easier and easier every six months or so. So that's going every six months or so. So that's going every six months or so. So that's going to be another trend to look for is these to be another trend to look for is these to be another trend to look for is these verticalized models for voice, verticalized models for voice, verticalized models for voice, verticalized models for building code. verticalized models for building code. verticalized models for building code. And uh we're going to see uh people stop And uh we're going to see uh people stop And uh we're going to see uh people stop using the Frontier Labs and these are using the Frontier Labs and these are using the Frontier Labs and these are major major eight and nine figure major major eight and nine figure major major eight and nine figure customers. I think they're going to just customers. I think they're going to just customers. I think they're going to just run for the hills and only use the run for the hills and only use the run for the hills and only use the Frontier models. Frontier models. Frontier models. >> But Jason, the counterpoint there is 11 >> But Jason, the counterpoint there is 11 >> But Jason, the counterpoint there is 11 Labs. I love Maddie. Labs. I love Maddie. Labs. I love Maddie. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Do you really think he's going to use an >> Do you really think he's going to use an >> Do you really think he's going to use an inferior model? He's got to be have the inferior model? He's got to be have the inferior model? He's got to be have the best voice voice agent in the world. And best voice voice agent in the world. And best voice voice agent in the world. And if the best voice agent in the world is if the best voice agent in the world is if the best voice agent in the world is given to him by using the Frontier Labs, given to him by using the Frontier Labs, given to him by using the Frontier Labs, can he afford in a competitive can he afford in a competitive can he afford in a competitive marketplace to say, "I'm going to use marketplace to say, "I'm going to use marketplace to say, "I'm going to use the cheaper version, the thing that I the cheaper version, the thing that I the cheaper version, the thing that I built for myself, even though it's not built for myself, even though it's not built for myself, even though it's not as good as the other thing." If he as good as the other thing." If he as good as the other thing." If he builds something better, I totally agree builds something better, I totally agree builds something better, I totally agree with you, which is what he believes he's with you, which is what he believes he's with you, which is what he believes he's doing. He believes he's making a better doing. He believes he's making a better doing. He believes he's making a better version. Yeah. So that's the question version. Yeah. So that's the question version. Yeah. So that's the question that I just, you know, put on the table that I just, you know, put on the table that I just, you know, put on the table whether or not you're going to see this whether or not you're going to see this whether or not you're going to see this convergence, whether it in fact is that convergence, whether it in fact is that convergence, whether it in fact is that easy. I don't think it's that easy, but easy. I don't think it's that easy, but easy. I don't think it's that easy, but we shall see. we shall see. we shall see. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> It may come down to how discreet and >> It may come down to how discreet and >> It may come down to how discreet and sort of predictive the use is. So like sort of predictive the use is. So like sort of predictive the use is. So like Decagon, the customer support AI Decagon, the customer support AI Decagon, the customer support AI company, they said that 90% of their company, they said that 90% of their company, they said that 90% of their usage now is being sent to open models, usage now is being sent to open models, usage now is being sent to open models, but those are open models that they've but those are open models that they've but those are open models that they've had the opportunity to post train on and had the opportunity to post train on and had the opportunity to post train on and do a huge amount of customization based do a huge amount of customization based do a huge amount of customization based on all of their learnings and all of the on all of their learnings and all of the on all of their learnings and all of the data that they've gotten. So again, it data that they've gotten. So again, it data that they've gotten. So again, it comes back to maturity of the use case. comes back to maturity of the use case. comes back to maturity of the use case. If you know exactly what you're trying If you know exactly what you're trying If you know exactly what you're trying to do, it's probably easier. But, you to do, it's probably easier. But, you to do, it's probably easier. But, you know, I don't think that's most know, I don't think that's most know, I don't think that's most enterprises, though. And maybe there's enterprises, though. And maybe there's enterprises, though. And maybe there's going to be a pattern where, you know, going to be a pattern where, you know, going to be a pattern where, you know, all the immature use cases, which is to all the immature use cases, which is to all the immature use cases, which is to say, all the things you're figuring out, say, all the things you're figuring out, say, all the things you're figuring out, you're just going to want to use the you're just going to want to use the you're just going to want to use the most powerful model possible. And then most powerful model possible. And then most powerful model possible. And then once it gets really well defined, maybe once it gets really well defined, maybe once it gets really well defined, maybe you start moving some of those workloads you start moving some of those workloads you start moving some of those workloads to post-trained open models, to post-trained open models, to post-trained open models, >> purpose-built models. Yeah. >> purpose-built models. Yeah. >> purpose-built models. Yeah. >> Yeah. Purpose-built. Yeah, it could be >> Yeah. Purpose-built. Yeah, it could be >> Yeah. Purpose-built. Yeah, it could be something like that. something like that. something like that. >> That's kind of what's happening with the >> That's kind of what's happening with the >> That's kind of what's happening with the people who are the tip of the spear. people who are the tip of the spear. people who are the tip of the spear. They're working on the routing of the They're working on the routing of the They're working on the routing of the jobs. They're working on the harness and jobs. They're working on the harness and jobs. They're working on the harness and they want to be independent and have they want to be independent and have they want to be independent and have that AI sovereignty we talked about last that AI sovereignty we talked about last that AI sovereignty we talked about last week. Speaking week. Speaking week. Speaking >> well, but just to take on Brad's point >> well, but just to take on Brad's point >> well, but just to take on Brad's point for a second, I actually agree with what for a second, I actually agree with what for a second, I actually agree with what I think you're saying, Brad, which is I think you're saying, Brad, which is I think you're saying, Brad, which is the market today seems to be pushing the market today seems to be pushing the market today seems to be pushing towards duopoly or it has become a towards duopoly or it has become a towards duopoly or it has become a duopoly. Certainly measured in terms of duopoly. Certainly measured in terms of duopoly. Certainly measured in terms of revenue. If you're to look at market revenue. If you're to look at market revenue. If you're to look at market share based on token revenue, there's share based on token revenue, there's share based on token revenue, there's only two companies making meaningful only two companies making meaningful only two companies making meaningful revenue. Anthropics at what 60some revenue. Anthropics at what 60some revenue. Anthropics at what 60some billion ARR open AAI at 40ome billion billion ARR open AAI at 40ome billion billion ARR open AAI at 40ome billion ARR. I don't know if anybody else even ARR. I don't know if anybody else even ARR. I don't know if anybody else even registers and it may be the case that registers and it may be the case that registers and it may be the case that the more tokens the more tokens the more tokens that Anthropic and OpenAI produce, I that Anthropic and OpenAI produce, I that Anthropic and OpenAI produce, I mean we got to remember every token that mean we got to remember every token that mean we got to remember every token that they're serving up is on behalf of a use they're serving up is on behalf of a use they're serving up is on behalf of a use case, right? So they themselves are case, right? So they themselves are case, right? So they themselves are learning from that and they're getting learning from that and they're getting learning from that and they're getting better at then providing whatever better at then providing whatever better at then providing whatever offering that is and so who knows like offering that is and so who knows like offering that is and so who knows like the gap may be growing. A year ago it the gap may be growing. A year ago it the gap may be growing. A year ago it seemed like we had five major labs you seemed like we had five major labs you seemed like we had five major labs you know now it seems like there's a top two know now it seems like there's a top two know now it seems like there's a top two and then everybody else. So I mean look and then everybody else. So I mean look and then everybody else. So I mean look I could see AI easily becoming another I could see AI easily becoming another I could see AI easily becoming another tech market that becomes a duopoly tech market that becomes a duopoly tech market that becomes a duopoly >> which which by the way is the trend. The >> which which by the way is the trend. The >> which which by the way is the trend. The historical trend is like monopoly or historical trend is like monopoly or historical trend is like monopoly or duopoly in most tech categories for duopoly in most tech categories for duopoly in most tech categories for better or worse. better or worse. better or worse. >> Yeah. In this case though, however, >> Yeah. In this case though, however, >> Yeah. In this case though, however, we're using revenue as the metric to we're using revenue as the metric to we're using revenue as the metric to determine the winner. Keep in mind when determine the winner. Keep in mind when determine the winner. Keep in mind when you're doing open source, those are dark you're doing open source, those are dark you're doing open source, those are dark tokens. Those don't come up as revenue. tokens. Those don't come up as revenue. tokens. Those don't come up as revenue. So, we don't know the utilization that's So, we don't know the utilization that's So, we don't know the utilization that's occurring at Door Dash when they're occurring at Door Dash when they're occurring at Door Dash when they're using an open- source model. We do know using an open- source model. We do know using an open- source model. We do know their fable and their anthropic spend, their fable and their anthropic spend, their fable and their anthropic spend, right? And because we see that in the right? And because we see that in the right? And because we see that in the anthropic revenue ramp, the more they anthropic revenue ramp, the more they anthropic revenue ramp, the more they deploy these things on their own deploy these things on their own deploy these things on their own hardware, using commoditized hardware, hardware, using commoditized hardware, hardware, using commoditized hardware, using the NeoClouds, you don't see that. using the NeoClouds, you don't see that. using the NeoClouds, you don't see that. It doesn't come up as revenue. It comes It doesn't come up as revenue. It comes It doesn't come up as revenue. It comes up as free. The only thing you're paying up as free. The only thing you're paying up as free. The only thing you're paying for there is the hosting cost, you know, for there is the hosting cost, you know, for there is the hosting cost, you know, and that's that will come up on Nvidia's and that's that will come up on Nvidia's and that's that will come up on Nvidia's balance sheet. So the gains you'll see balance sheet. So the gains you'll see balance sheet. So the gains you'll see there will be Cerebrris, there will be Cerebrris, there will be Cerebrris, Neoclouds, Caruso Cloud, etc. So keep Neoclouds, Caruso Cloud, etc. So keep Neoclouds, Caruso Cloud, etc. So keep just keep that in mind when we're having just keep that in mind when we're having just keep that in mind when we're having this discussion. Let's talk a little bit this discussion. Let's talk a little bit this discussion. Let's talk a little bit back to sovereignty here. The CCP back to sovereignty here. The CCP back to sovereignty here. The CCP said that they might or there's a report said that they might or there's a report said that they might or there's a report out according to Reuters. Reuters out according to Reuters. Reuters out according to Reuters. Reuters generally does a good job of this. They generally does a good job of this. They generally does a good job of this. They dropped a couple of anonymously sourced dropped a couple of anonymously sourced dropped a couple of anonymously sourced reports about AI in China. And these reports about AI in China. And these reports about AI in China. And these were published about 15 minutes apart were published about 15 minutes apart were published about 15 minutes apart the big scoop that CCP officials, the big scoop that CCP officials, the big scoop that CCP officials, Chinese Communist Party, are reportedly Chinese Communist Party, are reportedly Chinese Communist Party, are reportedly considering restricting overseas access considering restricting overseas access considering restricting overseas access to China's top models. So two Chinese to China's top models. So two Chinese to China's top models. So two Chinese regulators met with Alibaba, Bite Dance regulators met with Alibaba, Bite Dance regulators met with Alibaba, Bite Dance and Z.AI. They are the ones who are and Z.AI. They are the ones who are and Z.AI. They are the ones who are doing GLM 5.2 that we keep referencing. doing GLM 5.2 that we keep referencing. doing GLM 5.2 that we keep referencing. They're discussing limiting access to They're discussing limiting access to They're discussing limiting access to the top open and closed models outside the top open and closed models outside the top open and closed models outside of China. Why are they doing this? Well, of China. Why are they doing this? Well, of China. Why are they doing this? Well, they're they're making uh any theft or they're they're making uh any theft or they're they're making uh any theft or leaks of AI research a national security leaks of AI research a national security leaks of AI research a national security offense and they want to control who can offense and they want to control who can offense and they want to control who can fund Chinese AI AI labs. And we saw this fund Chinese AI AI labs. And we saw this fund Chinese AI AI labs. And we saw this with Manis which was a Chinese company with Manis which was a Chinese company with Manis which was a Chinese company tried to go to Singapore. the CCP pulled tried to go to Singapore. the CCP pulled tried to go to Singapore. the CCP pulled those employees from Singapore back to those employees from Singapore back to those employees from Singapore back to China. And so here is their main China. And so here is their main China. And so here is their main concern. The quote is that they're concern. The quote is that they're concern. The quote is that they're concerned about Mythos. Chinese concerned about Mythos. Chinese concerned about Mythos. Chinese authorities are deeply worried about the authorities are deeply worried about the authorities are deeply worried about the potential for Mythos to exploit software potential for Mythos to exploit software potential for Mythos to exploit software vulnerabilities and that Washington vulnerabilities and that Washington vulnerabilities and that Washington might deploy a model against Chinese might deploy a model against Chinese might deploy a model against Chinese interest. Saxs, last week I proposed the interest. Saxs, last week I proposed the interest. Saxs, last week I proposed the reverse to you in your previous position reverse to you in your previous position reverse to you in your previous position as Zar of AI. Do you think the United as Zar of AI. Do you think the United as Zar of AI. Do you think the United States should be banning those models? States should be banning those models? States should be banning those models? Now we have the opposite. China saying Now we have the opposite. China saying Now we have the opposite. China saying potentially according to these reports potentially according to these reports potentially according to these reports allegedly that they might restrict them. allegedly that they might restrict them. allegedly that they might restrict them. So explain the game on the field here. So explain the game on the field here. So explain the game on the field here. If you're going to look into what If you're going to look into what If you're going to look into what China's thinking, why would they want us China's thinking, why would they want us China's thinking, why would they want us to not have those open source models and to not have those open source models and to not have those open source models and and how is this chessboard development? and how is this chessboard development? and how is this chessboard development? >> Well, last week I explained why it would >> Well, last week I explained why it would >> Well, last week I explained why it would be harmful to the US to ban open models. be harmful to the US to ban open models. be harmful to the US to ban open models. So if you're China and you want to harm So if you're China and you want to harm So if you're China and you want to harm the US, maybe you would want to. I mean, the US, maybe you would want to. I mean, the US, maybe you would want to. I mean, it does kind of make sense it does kind of make sense it does kind of make sense >> because our our companies are benefiting >> because our our companies are benefiting >> because our our companies are benefiting a lot from all this R&D that they're a lot from all this R&D that they're a lot from all this R&D that they're doing. Now, at the end of the day, I doing. Now, at the end of the day, I doing. Now, at the end of the day, I think the story is probably a little bit think the story is probably a little bit think the story is probably a little bit overstated. I think there are a few overstated. I think there are a few overstated. I think there are a few Chinese models that were open source Chinese models that were open source Chinese models that were open source that have gone closed source, but I that have gone closed source, but I that have gone closed source, but I don't think they're all I'd be don't think they're all I'd be don't think they're all I'd be surprised, let's put it that way, if surprised, let's put it that way, if surprised, let's put it that way, if they all went closed. So, for example, they all went closed. So, for example, they all went closed. So, for example, the number one model in China, as I the number one model in China, as I the number one model in China, as I understand it, is bite dances model, understand it, is bite dances model, understand it, is bite dances model, which is already closed. That's kind of which is already closed. That's kind of which is already closed. That's kind of like their chat GPT equivalent and it's like their chat GPT equivalent and it's like their chat GPT equivalent and it's always been closed. Then you've got always been closed. Then you've got always been closed. Then you've got Alibaba's Quen, which was open and now I Alibaba's Quen, which was open and now I Alibaba's Quen, which was open and now I think is going closed, and ZepO, which think is going closed, and ZepO, which think is going closed, and ZepO, which has GLM 5.2, too, which we've talked has GLM 5.2, too, which we've talked has GLM 5.2, too, which we've talked about a couple weeks ago because it about a couple weeks ago because it about a couple weeks ago because it seemed to be catching up to what was seemed to be catching up to what was seemed to be catching up to what was then commercially available as the then commercially available as the then commercially available as the American frontier at certain tasks. They American frontier at certain tasks. They American frontier at certain tasks. They I think are going closed too after I think are going closed too after I think are going closed too after having been open. And so this is I think having been open. And so this is I think having been open. And so this is I think the tactic is you stay open until you the tactic is you stay open until you the tactic is you stay open until you catch the frontier or you get close to catch the frontier or you get close to catch the frontier or you get close to it and then there's a really compelling it and then there's a really compelling it and then there's a really compelling incentive to go close because you want incentive to go close because you want incentive to go close because you want to capture all the value for yourself to capture all the value for yourself to capture all the value for yourself >> which by the way is exactly what Sam >> which by the way is exactly what Sam >> which by the way is exactly what Sam Alman did famously at OpenAI. Not only Alman did famously at OpenAI. Not only Alman did famously at OpenAI. Not only did they go from a nonprofit to a did they go from a nonprofit to a did they go from a nonprofit to a for-profit, they went from open models for-profit, they went from open models for-profit, they went from open models to closed models. So, it's exactly to closed models. So, it's exactly to closed models. So, it's exactly paralleling what Sam realized 3 years paralleling what Sam realized 3 years paralleling what Sam realized 3 years ago. Yeah. ago. Yeah. ago. Yeah. >> I mean, in a way, that was what I think >> I mean, in a way, that was what I think >> I mean, in a way, that was what I think Meta's original strategy was was that Meta's original strategy was was that Meta's original strategy was was that Llama was going to be open, but then Llama was going to be open, but then Llama was going to be open, but then they actually they've sort of backed they actually they've sort of backed they actually they've sort of backed away from open a little bit. But this is away from open a little bit. But this is away from open a little bit. But this is kind of an obvious strategy, right? is kind of an obvious strategy, right? is kind of an obvious strategy, right? is is that if you want to catch up, you go is that if you want to catch up, you go is that if you want to catch up, you go open. Because by the way, you're not open. Because by the way, you're not open. Because by the way, you're not going to make any meaningful revenue on going to make any meaningful revenue on going to make any meaningful revenue on on closed anyway because you're not on closed anyway because you're not on closed anyway because you're not close enough to the frontier. So why close enough to the frontier. So why close enough to the frontier. So why would anyone buy your product, but if would anyone buy your product, but if would anyone buy your product, but if you go open, you get the developer you go open, you get the developer you go open, you get the developer community on your side. So community on your side. So community on your side. So >> and you get utilization, more people use >> and you get utilization, more people use >> and you get utilization, more people use it, which in AI gives you reinforcement it, which in AI gives you reinforcement it, which in AI gives you reinforcement learning. Yeah. Sex. learning. Yeah. Sex. learning. Yeah. Sex. >> Well, having having spent some time in >> Well, having having spent some time in >> Well, having having spent some time in DC this week, I and and and talking with DC this week, I and and and talking with DC this week, I and and and talking with both the White House and Treasury, etc. both the White House and Treasury, etc. both the White House and Treasury, etc. on this topic. What I can tell you is on this topic. What I can tell you is on this topic. What I can tell you is while there may be some, you know, while there may be some, you know, while there may be some, you know, debates about regulation of US models, debates about regulation of US models, debates about regulation of US models, the one thing there's absolute agreement the one thing there's absolute agreement the one thing there's absolute agreement on is doing everything to stay ahead of on is doing everything to stay ahead of on is doing everything to stay ahead of China. And, you know, and and the China. And, you know, and and the China. And, you know, and and the president all the way up to the president all the way up to the president all the way up to the president very interested how far are we president very interested how far are we president very interested how far are we ahead of China? What are the things we ahead of China? What are the things we ahead of China? What are the things we need to do to stay ahead of China? It is need to do to stay ahead of China? It is need to do to stay ahead of China? It is a unifying force in Washington. And the a unifying force in Washington. And the a unifying force in Washington. And the idea that we were going to kind of take idea that we were going to kind of take idea that we were going to kind of take our frontier labs off the field, off the our frontier labs off the field, off the our frontier labs off the field, off the playing field while letting Chinese open playing field while letting Chinese open playing field while letting Chinese open source models run free, you know, and on source models run free, you know, and on source models run free, you know, and on top of that distilling our models. I top of that distilling our models. I top of that distilling our models. I will tell you GL GLM 5.2 has watermarks will tell you GL GLM 5.2 has watermarks will tell you GL GLM 5.2 has watermarks from mythos all over it, right? So we from mythos all over it, right? So we from mythos all over it, right? So we know they were distilling, etc. And I know they were distilling, etc. And I know they were distilling, etc. And I think the US government's going to take think the US government's going to take think the US government's going to take steps against distillation, which they steps against distillation, which they steps against distillation, which they should do. So I think that you know should do. So I think that you know should do. So I think that you know China doing this in some ways I don't China doing this in some ways I don't China doing this in some ways I don't think it hurts the United States. The think it hurts the United States. The think it hurts the United States. The United States can spin up open source United States can spin up open source United States can spin up open source models. We've got Reflection spinning models. We've got Reflection spinning models. We've got Reflection spinning one up. Obviously we got the good work one up. Obviously we got the good work one up. Obviously we got the good work going on at Nvidia with their open going on at Nvidia with their open going on at Nvidia with their open source models. The labs I've talked to a source models. The labs I've talked to a source models. The labs I've talked to a couple of the frontier labs about open couple of the frontier labs about open couple of the frontier labs about open source models. I said why aren't you source models. I said why aren't you source models. I said why aren't you guys making open source models? They're guys making open source models? They're guys making open source models? They're like there's not a lot of demand for it. like there's not a lot of demand for it. like there's not a lot of demand for it. If there was a lot of demand for it we'd If there was a lot of demand for it we'd If there was a lot of demand for it we'd make it. And so I think the US is in a make it. And so I think the US is in a make it. And so I think the US is in a good position. And I think this is good position. And I think this is good position. And I think this is probably more chess playing by China probably more chess playing by China probably more chess playing by China than actual threats because it would than actual threats because it would than actual threats because it would hurt them a lot more than it would uh hurt them a lot more than it would uh hurt them a lot more than it would uh hurt us. hurt us. hurt us. >> Yeah. And then to just back up your >> Yeah. And then to just back up your >> Yeah. And then to just back up your point, Saxs, about when you're behind, point, Saxs, about when you're behind, point, Saxs, about when you're behind, go open and then once you catch up, go open and then once you catch up, go open and then once you catch up, start tighten things up. That's exactly start tighten things up. That's exactly start tighten things up. That's exactly what they did with Android, right? what they did with Android, right? what they did with Android, right? Google released Android. At a certain Google released Android. At a certain Google released Android. At a certain point, they were like, in order to use point, they were like, in order to use point, they were like, in order to use Android in the license, you have to Android in the license, you have to Android in the license, you have to include Google Search, you got to use include Google Search, you got to use include Google Search, you got to use Google Drive, you got to use Chrome. and Google Drive, you got to use Chrome. and Google Drive, you got to use Chrome. and they started tightening it up. So, it's they started tightening it up. So, it's they started tightening it up. So, it's not really an open- source project at not really an open- source project at not really an open- source project at this point. this point. this point. >> Just, by the way, I think the absolute >> Just, by the way, I think the absolute >> Just, by the way, I think the absolute best thing that could happen best thing that could happen best thing that could happen >> for America in terms of winning the AI >> for America in terms of winning the AI >> for America in terms of winning the AI race against China is if China somehow race against China is if China somehow race against China is if China somehow sprouted their own doomer community. sprouted their own doomer community. sprouted their own doomer community. >> Yes, >> Yes, >> Yes, >> we need uh like a Chinese yud over >> we need uh like a Chinese yud over >> we need uh like a Chinese yud over there. there. there. >> We got to get their poom up. We got to >> We got to get their poom up. We got to >> We got to get their poom up. We got to get their poom up. get their poom up. get their poom up. >> Exactly. We need a lot more people over >> Exactly. We need a lot more people over >> Exactly. We need a lot more people over there freaking out about, you know, job there freaking out about, you know, job there freaking out about, you know, job loss or RSI or whatever. loss or RSI or whatever. loss or RSI or whatever. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> That'd be the best thing that could ever >> That'd be the best thing that could ever >> That'd be the best thing that could ever happen to us is if they start cracking happen to us is if they start cracking happen to us is if they start cracking down on their labs in the same way that down on their labs in the same way that down on their labs in the same way that the doomers want to do over here. the doomers want to do over here. the doomers want to do over here. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Brad, let me just say just one comment. >> Brad, let me just say just one comment. >> Brad, let me just say just one comment. I mean, look, I I agree with you that I mean, look, I I agree with you that I mean, look, I I agree with you that >> from the president on down, everyone >> from the president on down, everyone >> from the president on down, everyone wants to win the AI race. And in fact, wants to win the AI race. And in fact, wants to win the AI race. And in fact, that was, you know, in the big AI policy that was, you know, in the big AI policy that was, you know, in the big AI policy speech the president gave about one year speech the president gave about one year speech the president gave about one year ago. That was the whole thrust of the ago. That was the whole thrust of the ago. That was the whole thrust of the speech was declaring that we were in an speech was declaring that we were in an speech was declaring that we were in an AI race and America had to win it. I AI race and America had to win it. I AI race and America had to win it. I think the big risk is more that and this think the big risk is more that and this think the big risk is more that and this would not be at like the top level. You would not be at like the top level. You would not be at like the top level. You know, I think if the president could know, I think if the president could know, I think if the president could make every single decision, it'd be make every single decision, it'd be make every single decision, it'd be perfect. The issue is at a lower level perfect. The issue is at a lower level perfect. The issue is at a lower level in the bureaucracy, do people somehow do in the bureaucracy, do people somehow do in the bureaucracy, do people somehow do things that are counterproductive? Maybe things that are counterproductive? Maybe things that are counterproductive? Maybe they think it's going to help us in the they think it's going to help us in the they think it's going to help us in the race against China, but they end up race against China, but they end up race against China, but they end up doing something that's hamfisted, they doing something that's hamfisted, they doing something that's hamfisted, they just like ban something or without, you just like ban something or without, you just like ban something or without, you know, really truly understand all the know, really truly understand all the know, really truly understand all the implications of it. So, I think there's implications of it. So, I think there's implications of it. So, I think there's no question that the administration no question that the administration no question that the administration wants to win the AI race. The president wants to win the AI race. The president wants to win the AI race. The president definitely does and at the top levels definitely does and at the top levels definitely does and at the top levels they will all make smart decisions. The they will all make smart decisions. The they will all make smart decisions. The question is whether at lower levels of question is whether at lower levels of question is whether at lower levels of the bureaucracy, you can get mistakes the bureaucracy, you can get mistakes the bureaucracy, you can get mistakes being made. And then you have the being made. And then you have the being made. And then you have the influence of Congress, whatever they influence of Congress, whatever they influence of Congress, whatever they want to do. Those guys, they're more want to do. Those guys, they're more want to do. Those guys, they're more responsive, I think, in a way to like responsive, I think, in a way to like responsive, I think, in a way to like the doomer community that's creating a the doomer community that's creating a the doomer community that's creating a lot of political pressure right now. lot of political pressure right now. lot of political pressure right now. >> Well, and the throttle, you know, >> Well, and the throttle, you know, >> Well, and the throttle, you know, paradoxically, to all of this might not paradoxically, to all of this might not paradoxically, to all of this might not be the software, might not be the chips, be the software, might not be the chips, be the software, might not be the chips, it might be energy. Yeah, Chimath. I it might be energy. Yeah, Chimath. I it might be energy. Yeah, Chimath. I mean, when you look at your data center mean, when you look at your data center mean, when you look at your data center projects and the other ones that are projects and the other ones that are projects and the other ones that are going out there, if we need more tokens, going out there, if we need more tokens, going out there, if we need more tokens, if people need more inference, we have a if people need more inference, we have a if people need more inference, we have a gating factor in the United States, gating factor in the United States, gating factor in the United States, which is which is energy. There's a an which is which is energy. There's a an which is which is energy. There's a an analysis that my team put together which analysis that my team put together which analysis that my team put together which I think is quite staggering. If you just I think is quite staggering. If you just I think is quite staggering. If you just look at the load growth that's expected look at the load growth that's expected look at the load growth that's expected between now and 2050, between now and 2050, between now and 2050, we are about three entire California's we are about three entire California's we are about three entire California's worth of energy short. And that's just worth of energy short. And that's just worth of energy short. And that's just assuming regular consumption of devices assuming regular consumption of devices assuming regular consumption of devices and cars and fridges and televisions and and cars and fridges and televisions and and cars and fridges and televisions and computers. computers. computers. So yeah, we have a we have an enormous So yeah, we have a we have an enormous So yeah, we have a we have an enormous problem in the United States with problem in the United States with problem in the United States with respect to electrons. respect to electrons. respect to electrons. >> Yeah. And if you put Taiwan into the mix >> Yeah. And if you put Taiwan into the mix >> Yeah. And if you put Taiwan into the mix here where the chips are coming out of, here where the chips are coming out of, here where the chips are coming out of, I had a really big wakeup call and there I had a really big wakeup call and there I had a really big wakeup call and there was a Wall Street Journal article about was a Wall Street Journal article about was a Wall Street Journal article about this. The amount of LNG, which is what this. The amount of LNG, which is what this. The amount of LNG, which is what Taiwan runs on, is like they have two or Taiwan runs on, is like they have two or Taiwan runs on, is like they have two or three weeks of it. China decides to three weeks of it. China decides to three weeks of it. China decides to blockade Taiwan, they're going to run blockade Taiwan, they're going to run blockade Taiwan, they're going to run out of energy immediately. So this is out of energy immediately. So this is out of energy immediately. So this is energy both in China and Taiwan and in energy both in China and Taiwan and in energy both in China and Taiwan and in the United States. It's all dependent on the United States. It's all dependent on the United States. It's all dependent on that. We have to get nuclear running, that. We have to get nuclear running, that. We have to get nuclear running, more solar running, more batteries, more more solar running, more batteries, more more solar running, more batteries, more of everything. And uh that is obviously of everything. And uh that is obviously of everything. And uh that is obviously a regulatory challenge here in the a regulatory challenge here in the a regulatory challenge here in the United States. All right, let's talk United States. All right, let's talk United States. All right, let's talk about your time in DC. Brad Gersonner about your time in DC. Brad Gersonner about your time in DC. Brad Gersonner went to DC, everybody. And uh huge went to DC, everybody. And uh huge went to DC, everybody. And uh huge huge congrats, Brad. you've been uh huge congrats, Brad. you've been uh huge congrats, Brad. you've been uh harping on about this um you know uh harping on about this um you know uh harping on about this um you know uh accounts now called Trump accounts, the accounts now called Trump accounts, the accounts now called Trump accounts, the Invest America accounts and um tell us Invest America accounts and um tell us Invest America accounts and um tell us what happened in DC this week cuz I what happened in DC this week cuz I what happened in DC this week cuz I think you finally have the number one think you finally have the number one think you finally have the number one app in the world Trump accounts is the app in the world Trump accounts is the app in the world Trump accounts is the number one app in the world. number one app in the world. number one app in the world. Congratulations and a bunch of Congratulations and a bunch of Congratulations and a bunch of announcements. So what what what's the announcements. So what what what's the announcements. So what what what's the contours of the announcement and uh contours of the announcement and uh contours of the announcement and uh maybe you could take us behind the maybe you could take us behind the maybe you could take us behind the scenes. There it is. Trump accounts, the scenes. There it is. Trump accounts, the scenes. There it is. Trump accounts, the official app number one in top official app number one in top official app number one in top downloads. Your kids can invest in the downloads. Your kids can invest in the downloads. Your kids can invest in the future. future. future. >> This has been, you know, a four-year >> This has been, you know, a four-year >> This has been, you know, a four-year mission in the making thanks to you mission in the making thanks to you mission in the making thanks to you guys. You were early supporters, guys. You were early supporters, guys. You were early supporters, backers. We talked about it on here. backers. We talked about it on here. backers. We talked about it on here. And, you know, founders are crazy. And And, you know, founders are crazy. And And, you know, founders are crazy. And you guys probably looked at what I was you guys probably looked at what I was you guys probably looked at what I was working on and and and thought, you're working on and and and thought, you're working on and and and thought, you're nuts. You're wasting your time on this. nuts. You're wasting your time on this. nuts. You're wasting your time on this. And so, you know, when it got signed And so, you know, when it got signed And so, you know, when it got signed into law last year, that's a huge moment into law last year, that's a huge moment into law last year, that's a huge moment in a founder journey that it's like in a founder journey that it's like in a founder journey that it's like getting your first round of funding getting your first round of funding getting your first round of funding maybe like, okay, we actually this thing maybe like, okay, we actually this thing maybe like, okay, we actually this thing is going to happen. But on July 4th of is going to happen. But on July 4th of is going to happen. But on July 4th of this year, the app went live, right? So this year, the app went live, right? So this year, the app went live, right? So that means millions of accounts got that means millions of accounts got that means millions of accounts got created, the accounts got funded. And to created, the accounts got funded. And to created, the accounts got funded. And to celebrate that and to really kind of celebrate that and to really kind of celebrate that and to really kind of take the next step forward, take the next step forward, take the next step forward, you know, we designed a joint bell you know, we designed a joint bell you know, we designed a joint bell ringing first in history between the ringing first in history between the ringing first in history between the NYSE and NASDAQ from the Oval Office. NYSE and NASDAQ from the Oval Office. NYSE and NASDAQ from the Oval Office. That was incredible. We had hundreds That was incredible. We had hundreds That was incredible. We had hundreds CEOs there, kids there, families that CEOs there, kids there, families that CEOs there, kids there, families that were impacted. were impacted. were impacted. And the president really, you know, kind And the president really, you know, kind And the president really, you know, kind of laid out that this is much bigger of laid out that this is much bigger of laid out that this is much bigger than just a program to give a few people than just a program to give a few people than just a program to give a few people some accounts. This is really about some accounts. This is really about some accounts. This is really about making every child a capitalist. In making every child a capitalist. In making every child a capitalist. In fact, the president suggested that we're fact, the president suggested that we're fact, the president suggested that we're going to autocreate uh accounts for all going to autocreate uh accounts for all going to autocreate uh accounts for all 50 million kids or upwards of 70 million 50 million kids or upwards of 70 million 50 million kids or upwards of 70 million kids under the age of 18. So he called kids under the age of 18. So he called kids under the age of 18. So he called on us to get the accounts open faster on us to get the accounts open faster on us to get the accounts open faster for more people to have more impact to for more people to have more impact to for more people to have more impact to make sure no child is left behind. make sure no child is left behind. make sure no child is left behind. >> Brad, just slow down because a lot of >> Brad, just slow down because a lot of >> Brad, just slow down because a lot of people don't even know what a Trump people don't even know what a Trump people don't even know what a Trump account is. Just explain the what it is account is. Just explain the what it is account is. Just explain the what it is and then you should contrast it to like and then you should contrast it to like and then you should contrast it to like a 529 account and some of these other a 529 account and some of these other a 529 account and some of these other things. things. things. >> Great. So, as you guys know, >> Great. So, as you guys know, >> Great. So, as you guys know, the idea was very simple. $1,000 for the idea was very simple. $1,000 for the idea was very simple. $1,000 for every child at birth that could compound every child at birth that could compound every child at birth that could compound for their life in a privatelyowned for their life in a privatelyowned for their life in a privatelyowned investment account. So you're born, you investment account. So you're born, you investment account. So you're born, you get a social security number and you get get a social security number and you get get a social security number and you get an investment account. And if you do an investment account. And if you do an investment account. And if you do that, you start with $1,000 and somebody that, you start with $1,000 and somebody that, you start with $1,000 and somebody matches that and you save 10 bucks a matches that and you save 10 bucks a matches that and you save 10 bucks a week, that's $50,000 at age 18. And the week, that's $50,000 at age 18. And the week, that's $50,000 at age 18. And the idea idea idea >> and that's invested in the S&P 500. >> and that's invested in the S&P 500. >> and that's invested in the S&P 500. >> S&P 500. So when these accounts are >> S&P 500. So when these accounts are >> S&P 500. So when these accounts are created, created, created, all that money goes into the S&P 500. all that money goes into the S&P 500. all that money goes into the S&P 500. There's no cost. It's a free account for There's no cost. It's a free account for There's no cost. It's a free account for the lifetime of the recipient. And that the lifetime of the recipient. And that the lifetime of the recipient. And that was packaged into the Invest America was packaged into the Invest America was packaged into the Invest America Act, which was passed into law a year Act, which was passed into law a year Act, which was passed into law a year ago as part of the reconciliation bill. ago as part of the reconciliation bill. ago as part of the reconciliation bill. So that's what actually occurred on July So that's what actually occurred on July So that's what actually occurred on July 4th of this year. All those accounts 4th of this year. All those accounts 4th of this year. All those accounts were created for all of these kids. were created for all of these kids. were created for all of these kids. That's the reason the Trump account app That's the reason the Trump account app That's the reason the Trump account app is number one in the app store because is number one in the app store because is number one in the app store because parents started hearing about this and parents started hearing about this and parents started hearing about this and saying, "Whoa, I need to go download and saying, "Whoa, I need to go download and saying, "Whoa, I need to go download and get this set up for my child." We had get this set up for my child." We had get this set up for my child." We had over a million and a half counts created over a million and a half counts created over a million and a half counts created in the first 24 hours after the launch in the first 24 hours after the launch in the first 24 hours after the launch of this. We had over a billion dollars of this. We had over a billion dollars of this. We had over a billion dollars of deposits. So, I was contributing of deposits. So, I was contributing of deposits. So, I was contributing money into the accounts of my nieces, my money into the accounts of my nieces, my money into the accounts of my nieces, my nephews, my kids, friends, kids. Every nephews, my kids, friends, kids. Every nephews, my kids, friends, kids. Every account h app has a QR code. Jason, so account h app has a QR code. Jason, so account h app has a QR code. Jason, so somebody can just send you the QR code somebody can just send you the QR code somebody can just send you the QR code for your kid. You double you Apple Pay for your kid. You double you Apple Pay for your kid. You double you Apple Pay on your phone, double click and you send on your phone, double click and you send on your phone, double click and you send them 25 or 50 bucks. So that is kind of them 25 or 50 bucks. So that is kind of them 25 or 50 bucks. So that is kind of the the most essential part of it. But the the most essential part of it. But the the most essential part of it. But we also had a bunch of announcements we also had a bunch of announcements we also had a bunch of announcements around philanthrop around philanthrop around philanthrop when you're 18, 19, 20 years old and when you're 18, 19, 20 years old and when you're 18, 19, 20 years old and start putting it towards school or you start putting it towards school or you start putting it towards school or you can roll it into your IRA, can roll it into your IRA, can roll it into your IRA, >> Roth IRA, I guess your your your >> Roth IRA, I guess your your your >> Roth IRA, I guess your your your retirement account. Obviously, Michael retirement account. Obviously, Michael retirement account. Obviously, Michael and Susan Dell were the were the anchors and Susan Dell were the were the anchors and Susan Dell were the were the anchors here. Over $6 billion, $250 for each of here. Over $6 billion, $250 for each of here. Over $6 billion, $250 for each of 25 million children, primarily lower and 25 million children, primarily lower and 25 million children, primarily lower and middle inome kids. SpaceX's president, middle inome kids. SpaceX's president, middle inome kids. SpaceX's president, Gwen Shotwell, she joined the party, put Gwen Shotwell, she joined the party, put Gwen Shotwell, she joined the party, put $350 million in her SpaceX shares, uh, $350 million in her SpaceX shares, uh, $350 million in her SpaceX shares, uh, and for children of lower income and for children of lower income and for children of lower income communities. So, with this, there's a communities. So, with this, there's a communities. So, with this, there's a device or some way to do it. So, you can device or some way to do it. So, you can device or some way to do it. So, you can target specific communities by geo uh, target specific communities by geo uh, target specific communities by geo uh, or by, I guess, their net worth. Um, or by, I guess, their net worth. Um, or by, I guess, their net worth. Um, >> no, it's it's just zip code and age. Zip >> no, it's it's just zip code and age. Zip >> no, it's it's just zip code and age. Zip code and age. code and age. code and age. >> Zip code and age. Okay. And then Micron >> Zip code and age. Okay. And then Micron >> Zip code and age. Okay. And then Micron put in 250 million up to a,000 per put in 250 million up to a,000 per put in 250 million up to a,000 per employee. So that seems to be a really employee. So that seems to be a really employee. So that seems to be a really interesting way to do this. Like you can interesting way to do this. Like you can interesting way to do this. Like you can do an employee I'm sorry, an employer do an employee I'm sorry, an employer do an employee I'm sorry, an employer contribution. contribution. contribution. >> And Brad Brad did it for all kids in >> And Brad Brad did it for all kids in >> And Brad Brad did it for all kids in Indiana, I think. Right. Indiana, I think. Right. Indiana, I think. Right. >> Correct. All kids. >> Correct. All kids. >> Correct. All kids. >> Brad, this is a big number here. I This >> Brad, this is a big number here. I This >> Brad, this is a big number here. I This is a big announcement. is a big announcement. is a big announcement. Brad, the guy who complains when we make Brad, the guy who complains when we make Brad, the guy who complains when we make him buy in for 10K after 10 p.m. at the him buy in for 10K after 10 p.m. at the him buy in for 10K after 10 p.m. at the poker game and who like rage quits the poker game and who like rage quits the poker game and who like rage quits the game when he loses $6,000. game when he loses $6,000. game when he loses $6,000. Somehow Brad dropped $100 million. Somehow Brad dropped $100 million. Somehow Brad dropped $100 million. I mean, oh my god. Let's get a round of I mean, oh my god. Let's get a round of I mean, oh my god. Let's get a round of applause and a golf clap. Brad, this is applause and a golf clap. Brad, this is applause and a golf clap. Brad, this is I mean, I I've never heard of you doing I mean, I I've never heard of you doing I mean, I I've never heard of you doing any philanthropy. Like, sometimes you any philanthropy. Like, sometimes you any philanthropy. Like, sometimes you show up with a bottle of wine to the show up with a bottle of wine to the show up with a bottle of wine to the game, but this is a big number. This is game, but this is a big number. This is game, but this is a big number. This is a big decision for you, huh? a big decision for you, huh? a big decision for you, huh? Well, I think this will become the Well, I think this will become the Well, I think this will become the largest direct philanthropic platform in largest direct philanthropic platform in largest direct philanthropic platform in the history of the country. We told the the history of the country. We told the the history of the country. We told the president, we think we can raise a president, we think we can raise a president, we think we can raise a hundred billion dollars in the first 12 hundred billion dollars in the first 12 hundred billion dollars in the first 12 months. And so the scale of the months. And so the scale of the months. And so the scale of the philanthropy, the nature of the philanthropy, the nature of the philanthropy, the nature of the philanthropy directly to America's kids philanthropy directly to America's kids philanthropy directly to America's kids without a charitable middleman that's without a charitable middleman that's without a charitable middleman that's directing who gets what and and how it's directing who gets what and and how it's directing who gets what and and how it's distributed. So you think about the distributed. So you think about the distributed. So you think about the people who now are, you know, we're 10 people who now are, you know, we're 10 people who now are, you know, we're 10 billion or a h 100red billion. How do billion or a h 100red billion. How do billion or a h 100red billion. How do they give that money away at scale they give that money away at scale they give that money away at scale effectively? Now we have a platform they effectively? Now we have a platform they effectively? Now we have a platform they can do that with. It goes directly into can do that with. It goes directly into can do that with. It goes directly into the accounts. The money can't be taken the accounts. The money can't be taken the accounts. The money can't be taken out until the kids are 18. out until the kids are 18. out until the kids are 18. for for for >> there was a bunch of noise about how >> there was a bunch of noise about how >> there was a bunch of noise about how some people won't do it because it's some people won't do it because it's some people won't do it because it's called Trump accounts called Trump accounts called Trump accounts and that some people said, you know, and that some people said, you know, and that some people said, you know, this is going to create this weird class this is going to create this weird class this is going to create this weird class divide by people who divide by people who divide by people who had TDS and refused to give their kids had TDS and refused to give their kids had TDS and refused to give their kids because I think your website or because I think your website or because I think your website or something said something like 13 million something said something like 13 million something said something like 13 million bucks by the time they're 50. And you bucks by the time they're 50. And you bucks by the time they're 50. And you know, I tweeted something to the effect know, I tweeted something to the effect know, I tweeted something to the effect of that is an irresponsible amount of of that is an irresponsible amount of of that is an irresponsible amount of money to not give a kid because you money to not give a kid because you money to not give a kid because you don't like the fact that it's called a don't like the fact that it's called a don't like the fact that it's called a Trump account. It's it's it's patently Trump account. It's it's it's patently Trump account. It's it's it's patently insane. insane. insane. >> If you go on Blue Sky, which is like the >> If you go on Blue Sky, which is like the >> If you go on Blue Sky, which is like the open- source uh lib TDS um social open- source uh lib TDS um social open- source uh lib TDS um social network, people are like just put one, network, people are like just put one, network, people are like just put one, you know, y'all trust those Trump you know, y'all trust those Trump you know, y'all trust those Trump accounts. I sure as hell don't. And so accounts. I sure as hell don't. And so accounts. I sure as hell don't. And so there's a bunch of people. there's a bunch of people. there's a bunch of people. >> Speak to that. Yeah, speak to that for >> Speak to that. Yeah, speak to that for >> Speak to that. Yeah, speak to that for one second. Mike. one second. Mike. one second. Mike. >> So, I would say this, you know, it was >> So, I would say this, you know, it was >> So, I would say this, you know, it was the enabling legislation is the Invest the enabling legislation is the Invest the enabling legislation is the Invest America Act. Um, a lot of people, a lot America Act. Um, a lot of people, a lot America Act. Um, a lot of people, a lot of Democrats call them Invest America of Democrats call them Invest America of Democrats call them Invest America accounts. They're officially Trump accounts. They're officially Trump accounts. They're officially Trump accounts. And the facts on the ground accounts. And the facts on the ground accounts. And the facts on the ground are that parents aren't listening to are that parents aren't listening to are that parents aren't listening to that noise. The parents who are signing that noise. The parents who are signing that noise. The parents who are signing up for this are across the income up for this are across the income up for this are across the income spectrum, across the economic spectrum. spectrum, across the economic spectrum. spectrum, across the economic spectrum. They're across the political spectrum. They're across the political spectrum. They're across the political spectrum. They know and understand that their They know and understand that their They know and understand that their first responsibility is making sure first responsibility is making sure first responsibility is making sure their kids have a connection to the their kids have a connection to the their kids have a connection to the American dream, have savings for their American dream, have savings for their American dream, have savings for their life. But yes, they are called Trump life. But yes, they are called Trump life. But yes, they are called Trump accounts. And I I've I've read some of accounts. And I I've I've read some of accounts. And I I've I've read some of that blowback. But the president that blowback. But the president that blowback. But the president himself, let me just make this case very himself, let me just make this case very himself, let me just make this case very strongly. There's nobody who I've talked strongly. There's nobody who I've talked strongly. There's nobody who I've talked to about this over the last two years to about this over the last two years to about this over the last two years who cares more about every child getting who cares more about every child getting who cares more about every child getting an account than the president himself. an account than the president himself. an account than the president himself. In fact, that occupied a lot of a lot of In fact, that occupied a lot of a lot of In fact, that occupied a lot of a lot of our conversation over lunch. He said, our conversation over lunch. He said, our conversation over lunch. He said, "How do we get more people autoenrolled "How do we get more people autoenrolled "How do we get more people autoenrolled in this faster? I want every kid to have in this faster? I want every kid to have in this faster? I want every kid to have the shot to have this. I don't want the shot to have this. I don't want the shot to have this. I don't want anybody being left out and left behind anybody being left out and left behind anybody being left out and left behind because their parents are too busy because their parents are too busy because their parents are too busy working two jobs or because their working two jobs or because their working two jobs or because their parents may have an issue with it being parents may have an issue with it being parents may have an issue with it being called a Trump account." So, the called a Trump account." So, the called a Trump account." So, the president is pushing us very hard and president is pushing us very hard and president is pushing us very hard and the Treasury Secretary, the Treasury Secretary, the Treasury Secretary, he gave you instructions. He gave you an he gave you instructions. He gave you an he gave you instructions. He gave you an order that he wants you to autocreate order that he wants you to autocreate order that he wants you to autocreate the accounts. This is a brilliant move. the accounts. This is a brilliant move. the accounts. This is a brilliant move. He know we know the social security He know we know the social security He know we know the social security numbers of people who are under 18. He numbers of people who are under 18. He numbers of people who are under 18. He told you get to work and automatically told you get to work and automatically told you get to work and automatically create the accounts. Are you going to do create the accounts. Are you going to do create the accounts. Are you going to do what the President Trump has commanded what the President Trump has commanded what the President Trump has commanded you to do, Brad? Are you going to you to do, Brad? Are you going to you to do, Brad? Are you going to autocreate them, Brad, or are you going autocreate them, Brad, or are you going autocreate them, Brad, or are you going to disobey the president? to disobey the president? to disobey the president? >> We we we our intention is to get all 50 >> We we we our intention is to get all 50 >> We we we our intention is to get all 50 to 70 million accounts created over the to 70 million accounts created over the to 70 million accounts created over the course of the next 90 days using all of course of the next 90 days using all of course of the next 90 days using all of this data. But you know, listen, we got this data. But you know, listen, we got this data. But you know, listen, we got to work through Treasury, the White to work through Treasury, the White to work through Treasury, the White House, Social Security, etc. They're House, Social Security, etc. They're House, Social Security, etc. They're definitely definitely definitely >> You also got to get through Elizabeth >> You also got to get through Elizabeth >> You also got to get through Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders and Roan who Warren and Bernie Sanders and Roan who Warren and Bernie Sanders and Roan who are going to try to stop you. Are they are going to try to stop you. Are they are going to try to stop you. Are they going to try to stop you from doing going to try to stop you from doing going to try to stop you from doing this? Are they giving you blowback this? Are they giving you blowback this? Are they giving you blowback because they don't want to give Trump because they don't want to give Trump because they don't want to give Trump the win, which is totally but the win, which is totally but the win, which is totally but >> No, listen. I I I I'll give credit where >> No, listen. I I I I'll give credit where >> No, listen. I I I I'll give credit where credit is due. You know, Cy Booker's credit is due. You know, Cy Booker's credit is due. You know, Cy Booker's come out and supported these. And Gavin come out and supported these. And Gavin come out and supported these. And Gavin Newsome, Governor Wes Moore, you know, Newsome, Governor Wes Moore, you know, Newsome, Governor Wes Moore, you know, John Federman, Senator from John Federman, Senator from John Federman, Senator from Pennsylvania. So there are plenty of Pennsylvania. So there are plenty of Pennsylvania. So there are plenty of Democrats who are able to get over that Democrats who are able to get over that Democrats who are able to get over that hurdle. But you bring up a good point hurdle. But you bring up a good point hurdle. But you bring up a good point and I said this on CNBC yesterday. On and I said this on CNBC yesterday. On and I said this on CNBC yesterday. On the one hand, you have Bernie and the one hand, you have Bernie and the one hand, you have Bernie and Mandami. They want to take and tax all Mandami. They want to take and tax all Mandami. They want to take and tax all these corporations. They want to control these corporations. They want to control these corporations. They want to control all that money in Washington and decide all that money in Washington and decide all that money in Washington and decide who gets it. Right? It's a very who gets it. Right? It's a very who gets it. Right? It's a very dependent on Washington model. On the dependent on Washington model. On the dependent on Washington model. On the other side, you have the president in other side, you have the president in other side, you have the president in this administration and frankly a lot of this administration and frankly a lot of this administration and frankly a lot of Democrats who are more in the orthodoxy, Democrats who are more in the orthodoxy, Democrats who are more in the orthodoxy, closer to the center, who say, "No, closer to the center, who say, "No, closer to the center, who say, "No, let's set up a private account for every let's set up a private account for every let's set up a private account for every kid in America. Let's fund them. Let's kid in America. Let's fund them. Let's kid in America. Let's fund them. Let's not make them dependent. Let's make them not make them dependent. Let's make them not make them dependent. Let's make them independent of the government to build independent of the government to build independent of the government to build wealth on their own, financial literacy wealth on their own, financial literacy wealth on their own, financial literacy on their own, more likely to graduate on their own, more likely to graduate on their own, more likely to graduate from high school, start a business, buy from high school, start a business, buy from high school, start a business, buy a home." Those are two very different a home." Those are two very different a home." Those are two very different worldviews for America. And I think the worldviews for America. And I think the worldviews for America. And I think the antidote to more socialism is more antidote to more socialism is more antidote to more socialism is more capitalism. And as I told the president, capitalism. And as I told the president, capitalism. And as I told the president, this is more capitalism. this is more capitalism. this is more capitalism. >> Saxs, if this succeeds, and Brad does as >> Saxs, if this succeeds, and Brad does as >> Saxs, if this succeeds, and Brad does as he's been instructed by the president, he's been instructed by the president, he's been instructed by the president, we're going to go from 50% of people we're going to go from 50% of people we're going to go from 50% of people owning equities in the country to as owning equities in the country to as owning equities in the country to as much as 70 maybe even 75% of the country much as 70 maybe even 75% of the country much as 70 maybe even 75% of the country having access and for the first time having access and for the first time having access and for the first time being part of equity nation. What's your being part of equity nation. What's your being part of equity nation. What's your thoughts on this, Sachs? Look, I think thoughts on this, Sachs? Look, I think thoughts on this, Sachs? Look, I think that's a great thing and I think that that's a great thing and I think that that's a great thing and I think that this is a tremendous new philanthropic this is a tremendous new philanthropic this is a tremendous new philanthropic platform and that's really important platform and that's really important platform and that's really important especially in this time of growing anger especially in this time of growing anger especially in this time of growing anger and backlash and populism against and backlash and populism against and backlash and populism against billionaires and people questioning billionaires and people questioning billionaires and people questioning whether the system is rigged and whether whether the system is rigged and whether whether the system is rigged and whether they can be successful in America, they can be successful in America, they can be successful in America, whether they will be able to be part of whether they will be able to be part of whether they will be able to be part of it. This is a really important antidote it. This is a really important antidote it. This is a really important antidote to that. But I almost think that the to that. But I almost think that the to that. But I almost think that the philanthropic aspect maybe has gotten philanthropic aspect maybe has gotten philanthropic aspect maybe has gotten almost too too much attention because almost too too much attention because almost too too much attention because people are naturally attracted to the people are naturally attracted to the people are naturally attracted to the freebies and the part that I think freebies and the part that I think freebies and the part that I think hasn't gotten enough attention or all hasn't gotten enough attention or all hasn't gotten enough attention or all the the comments I saw on CPA Twitter, the the comments I saw on CPA Twitter, the the comments I saw on CPA Twitter, you know, where all these accountants you know, where all these accountants you know, where all these accountants were talking about what an unbelievable were talking about what an unbelievable were talking about what an unbelievable I guess you could say estate planning I guess you could say estate planning I guess you could say estate planning strategy this is or basically strategy this is or basically strategy this is or basically >> less advantaged. Yeah. like a wealth >> less advantaged. Yeah. like a wealth >> less advantaged. Yeah. like a wealth management technique, whatever you want management technique, whatever you want management technique, whatever you want to call it, like planning for the to call it, like planning for the to call it, like planning for the future. And there's never been anything future. And there's never been anything future. And there's never been anything like this before. They were basically like this before. They were basically like this before. They were basically saying this is like in the top three, saying this is like in the top three, saying this is like in the top three, you know, there's certain things that you know, there's certain things that you know, there's certain things that you just have to do, like if your you just have to do, like if your you just have to do, like if your employer offers a matching 401k, you employer offers a matching 401k, you employer offers a matching 401k, you have to do it because otherwise it's have to do it because otherwise it's have to do it because otherwise it's just you're losing out on free money and just you're losing out on free money and just you're losing out on free money and if you don't do a health savings account if you don't do a health savings account if you don't do a health savings account or you don't max out your Roth IRA, or you don't max out your Roth IRA, or you don't max out your Roth IRA, there's just certain things you have to there's just certain things you have to there's just certain things you have to do because they're so tax advantaged or do because they're so tax advantaged or do because they're so tax advantaged or you're getting free money, right? And in you're getting free money, right? And in you're getting free money, right? And in this case, you're getting both. There is this case, you're getting both. There is this case, you're getting both. There is the opportunity for, frankly, the free the opportunity for, frankly, the free the opportunity for, frankly, the free money for your kids, right? But also, money for your kids, right? But also, money for your kids, right? But also, the tax advantage is huge. So, let's the tax advantage is huge. So, let's the tax advantage is huge. So, let's just go through this, and Brad, correct just go through this, and Brad, correct just go through this, and Brad, correct me if I get any of this wrong. So, you me if I get any of this wrong. So, you me if I get any of this wrong. So, you can donate up to $5,000 a year to your can donate up to $5,000 a year to your can donate up to $5,000 a year to your kid as long as they're under 18. And kid as long as they're under 18. And kid as long as they're under 18. And it's not just you, it's any friends and it's not just you, it's any friends and it's not just you, it's any friends and family or others can contribute as well, family or others can contribute as well, family or others can contribute as well, which is new. And then they get taxfree which is new. And then they get taxfree which is new. And then they get taxfree compounding till they're 18. And your compounding till they're 18. And your compounding till they're 18. And your employer can contribute up to $2,500 employer can contribute up to $2,500 employer can contribute up to $2,500 taxfree. So at a minimum, you should go taxfree. So at a minimum, you should go taxfree. So at a minimum, you should go to your employer and say, "Sign up for to your employer and say, "Sign up for to your employer and say, "Sign up for this and if you have to take $2,500 out this and if you have to take $2,500 out this and if you have to take $2,500 out of my salary and make it a donation to of my salary and make it a donation to of my salary and make it a donation to my kid's Trump account because then my kid's Trump account because then my kid's Trump account because then that's a huge tax savings, right? that's a huge tax savings, right? that's a huge tax savings, right? Neither side has to pay tax on it." So, Neither side has to pay tax on it." So, Neither side has to pay tax on it." So, you know, like Brad said, this is you know, like Brad said, this is you know, like Brad said, this is basically like an IRA. You get taxfree basically like an IRA. You get taxfree basically like an IRA. You get taxfree compounding. Then when the kid turns 18, compounding. Then when the kid turns 18, compounding. Then when the kid turns 18, they can get access to it and they can they can get access to it and they can they can get access to it and they can do a a rollover into an IRA or into a do a a rollover into an IRA or into a do a a rollover into an IRA or into a Roth IRA, which is even better because Roth IRA, which is even better because Roth IRA, which is even better because when the Roth IRA matures, you don't pay when the Roth IRA matures, you don't pay when the Roth IRA matures, you don't pay tax on the money that gets distributed tax on the money that gets distributed tax on the money that gets distributed out of it. Where whereas with a out of it. Where whereas with a out of it. Where whereas with a traditional IRA, all the taxes get traditional IRA, all the taxes get traditional IRA, all the taxes get deferred until the end. The difference deferred until the end. The difference deferred until the end. The difference is that when you do a IRA to a Roth IRA is that when you do a IRA to a Roth IRA is that when you do a IRA to a Roth IRA conversion, you're supposed to pay taxes conversion, you're supposed to pay taxes conversion, you're supposed to pay taxes at that point. And I saw one really at that point. And I saw one really at that point. And I saw one really clever CPA say that well the best way to clever CPA say that well the best way to clever CPA say that well the best way to do this is wait till your kid is do this is wait till your kid is do this is wait till your kid is actually not a dependent anymore. Like actually not a dependent anymore. Like actually not a dependent anymore. Like so maybe they're in college or they just so maybe they're in college or they just so maybe they're in college or they just graduated from college and they're in graduated from college and they're in graduated from college and they're in like the 0% tax bracket because they're like the 0% tax bracket because they're like the 0% tax bracket because they're not making any money and then do the not making any money and then do the not making any money and then do the conversion. And so you'll be able to conversion. And so you'll be able to conversion. And so you'll be able to convert the Trump account very cheaply convert the Trump account very cheaply convert the Trump account very cheaply into a Roth IRA and now they're going to into a Roth IRA and now they're going to into a Roth IRA and now they're going to have $2 to $300,000 potentially in that have $2 to $300,000 potentially in that have $2 to $300,000 potentially in that account that they can then do tax-free account that they can then do tax-free account that they can then do tax-free investing for the rest of their life or investing for the rest of their life or investing for the rest of their life or they could potentially start a company they could potentially start a company they could potentially start a company with that. Other things you can do with with that. Other things you can do with with that. Other things you can do with an IRA is you can use part of the money an IRA is you can use part of the money an IRA is you can use part of the money on a down payment for the first home on a down payment for the first home on a down payment for the first home purchase or if you get into a health purchase or if you get into a health purchase or if you get into a health emergency, you can use money for that. emergency, you can use money for that. emergency, you can use money for that. So, there's all these things. You're So, there's all these things. You're So, there's all these things. You're allowed to distribute money out of an allowed to distribute money out of an allowed to distribute money out of an IRA without incurring a penalty. But IRA without incurring a penalty. But IRA without incurring a penalty. But generally speaking, the point of an IRA generally speaking, the point of an IRA generally speaking, the point of an IRA is to save for retirement. And this is is to save for retirement. And this is is to save for retirement. And this is where I think it gets really amazing is where I think it gets really amazing is where I think it gets really amazing is because if you start with $200 to because if you start with $200 to because if you start with $200 to $300,000 at age 18, you'll be at $10 $300,000 at age 18, you'll be at $10 $300,000 at age 18, you'll be at $10 million plus by age 60 if you just let million plus by age 60 if you just let million plus by age 60 if you just let it compound. I mean, there there's it compound. I mean, there there's it compound. I mean, there there's ranges. ranges. ranges. >> Nepo babies we're creating here. We're >> Nepo babies we're creating here. We're >> Nepo babies we're creating here. We're going to have a lot of rich kids with going to have a lot of rich kids with going to have a lot of rich kids with trust funds. trust funds. trust funds. >> Yeah. So this is like this is all you >> Yeah. So this is like this is all you >> Yeah. So this is like this is all you have to do to make sure that your kid is have to do to make sure that your kid is have to do to make sure that your kid is protected for retirement is if you and protected for retirement is if you and protected for retirement is if you and your family and your friends and your your family and your friends and your your family and your friends and your employer can just contribute to their employer can just contribute to their employer can just contribute to their Trump accounts. Trump accounts. Trump accounts. >> Like that that's like that's way better >> Like that that's like that's way better >> Like that that's like that's way better than social security. than social security. than social security. >> Brad, I have an idea. I have to go sell >> Brad, I have an idea. I have to go sell >> Brad, I have an idea. I have to go sell some enterprise software so I have to some enterprise software so I have to some enterprise software so I have to leave. But I'm I'm really proud of you. leave. But I'm I'm really proud of you. leave. But I'm I'm really proud of you. I think this is incredible. You should I think this is incredible. You should I think this is incredible. You should convince OpenAI and Anthropic to give convince OpenAI and Anthropic to give convince OpenAI and Anthropic to give the equity of those companies if this is the equity of those companies if this is the equity of those companies if this is going to be as big as you say 100 going to be as big as you say 100 going to be as big as you say 100 billion, 300 billion, zillion, trillion, billion, 300 billion, zillion, trillion, billion, 300 billion, zillion, trillion, put it into the uh accounts of every put it into the uh accounts of every put it into the uh accounts of every kid. kid. kid. >> Can you just explain how that works >> Can you just explain how that works >> Can you just explain how that works against the $5,000 limit? against the $5,000 limit? against the $5,000 limit? >> I got to go. Love you guys. See you >> I got to go. Love you guys. See you >> I got to go. Love you guys. See you later. All right. Good luck on the sales later. All right. Good luck on the sales later. All right. Good luck on the sales call. call. call. >> Yeah. Always be closing. Chimath. Always >> Yeah. Always be closing. Chimath. Always >> Yeah. Always be closing. Chimath. Always be Chimath closing. APC. be Chimath closing. APC. be Chimath closing. APC. >> Chamath always be closing. You know, >> Chamath always be closing. You know, >> Chamath always be closing. You know, again, David and Jamant, as we build out again, David and Jamant, as we build out again, David and Jamant, as we build out the platform at scale, so imagine now the platform at scale, so imagine now the platform at scale, so imagine now you have 50 million accounts that are you have 50 million accounts that are you have 50 million accounts that are opened, opened, opened, we do we I I've said on CNBC, you know, we do we I I've said on CNBC, you know, we do we I I've said on CNBC, you know, I've obviously talked with Daario and I've obviously talked with Daario and I've obviously talked with Daario and Sam and Elon and others about making Sam and Elon and others about making Sam and Elon and others about making those donations. I I don't like this those donations. I I don't like this those donations. I I don't like this idea of shaking down our companies, idea of shaking down our companies, idea of shaking down our companies, taking their shares, and then putting taking their shares, and then putting taking their shares, and then putting them in some government slush fund that them in some government slush fund that them in some government slush fund that perhaps Bernie or AOC or somebody's perhaps Bernie or AOC or somebody's perhaps Bernie or AOC or somebody's going to control in the future. I've going to control in the future. I've going to control in the future. I've said I it's got to be voluntary and said I it's got to be voluntary and said I it's got to be voluntary and number two it should go into citizen number two it should go into citizen number two it should go into citizen accounts right privately held in citizen accounts right privately held in citizen accounts right privately held in citizen accounts at Capound for their life and accounts at Capound for their life and accounts at Capound for their life and so you asked the question David how does so you asked the question David how does so you asked the question David how does it happen given the limits that you have it happen given the limits that you have it happen given the limits that you have you know the $5,000 per child that's why you know the $5,000 per child that's why you know the $5,000 per child that's why you have to have so you know 50 million you have to have so you know 50 million you have to have so you know 50 million accounts opened right because then you accounts opened right because then you accounts opened right because then you can take uh dollars in at scale but we can take uh dollars in at scale but we can take uh dollars in at scale but we can also set up a poolled account David can also set up a poolled account David can also set up a poolled account David where it can be distributed over time so where it can be distributed over time so where it can be distributed over time so you distribute it to all the kids you distribute it to all the kids you distribute it to all the kids subject to the limits that you have subject to the limits that you have subject to the limits that you have today and then any remainder you can today and then any remainder you can today and then any remainder you can distribute to the 3 and a half million distribute to the 3 and a half million distribute to the 3 and a half million kids that are going to be born next year kids that are going to be born next year kids that are going to be born next year or the 3 and a half million kids born or the 3 and a half million kids born or the 3 and a half million kids born the year after that or the three and a the year after that or the three and a the year after that or the three and a half million kids born after that. We half million kids born after that. We half million kids born after that. We are on a trajectory now that we're going are on a trajectory now that we're going are on a trajectory now that we're going to have over a 100red million of these to have over a 100red million of these to have over a 100red million of these counts set up over the next decade. counts set up over the next decade. counts set up over the next decade. Okay? So we could have 70 million today Okay? So we could have 70 million today Okay? So we could have 70 million today and then you're going to add 3.7 million and then you're going to add 3.7 million and then you're going to add 3.7 million a year. So you're going to be at a 100 a year. So you're going to be at a 100 a year. So you're going to be at a 100 million private individual accounts that million private individual accounts that million private individual accounts that are compounding for people's lives that are compounding for people's lives that are compounding for people's lives that anybody can donate money into that the anybody can donate money into that the anybody can donate money into that the people themselves. I think one of the people themselves. I think one of the people themselves. I think one of the things that gets lost is moms and dads things that gets lost is moms and dads things that gets lost is moms and dads or somebody working their summer job put or somebody working their summer job put or somebody working their summer job put in 10 bucks, put in a hundred bucks, put in 10 bucks, put in a hundred bucks, put in 10 bucks, put in a hundred bucks, put it, you know, into these accounts. They it, you know, into these accounts. They it, you know, into these accounts. They get to see it on their phone. You know, get to see it on their phone. You know, get to see it on their phone. You know, this is when we started this, my sons this is when we started this, my sons this is when we started this, my sons and I designed this app and it's and I designed this app and it's and I designed this app and it's basically what we ended up with. It's a, basically what we ended up with. It's a, basically what we ended up with. It's a, you know, Joe and you know, Joe and you know, Joe and >> shout out to Vlad at Robin Hood helped >> shout out to Vlad at Robin Hood helped >> shout out to Vlad at Robin Hood helped you with it. Yeah, you with it. Yeah, you with it. Yeah, >> Vlad and and Joe have implemented a more >> Vlad and and Joe have implemented a more >> Vlad and and Joe have implemented a more elegant version of this, but every kid elegant version of this, but every kid elegant version of this, but every kid owns a little bit of Nvidia, a little owns a little bit of Nvidia, a little owns a little bit of Nvidia, a little bit of Microsoft, a little bit of Apple. bit of Microsoft, a little bit of Apple. bit of Microsoft, a little bit of Apple. Imagining opening up that account, Imagining opening up that account, Imagining opening up that account, David, in middle school or high school David, in middle school or high school David, in middle school or high school to the money page, and now you're to the money page, and now you're to the money page, and now you're getting excited that you're seeing, oh getting excited that you're seeing, oh getting excited that you're seeing, oh man, I'm in the game. I have ownership. man, I'm in the game. I have ownership. man, I'm in the game. I have ownership. And while you reference what it could be And while you reference what it could be And while you reference what it could be for families who can contribute $5,000, for families who can contribute $5,000, for families who can contribute $5,000, obviously Michael Dell and I and Gwen obviously Michael Dell and I and Gwen obviously Michael Dell and I and Gwen and everybody else, we're focused on the and everybody else, we're focused on the and everybody else, we're focused on the 50% of Americans who feel left out and 50% of Americans who feel left out and 50% of Americans who feel left out and left behind who would otherwise have left behind who would otherwise have left behind who would otherwise have zero. If you do the math on this over zero. If you do the math on this over zero. If you do the math on this over the course of the next 15 years, you the course of the next 15 years, you the course of the next 15 years, you could have somewhere between two and could have somewhere between two and could have somewhere between two and four trillion dollars added to the four trillion dollars added to the four trillion dollars added to the accounts of families and kids who would accounts of families and kids who would accounts of families and kids who would have otherwise had zero. have otherwise had zero. have otherwise had zero. We talk a lot. Go ahead. We talk a lot. Go ahead. We talk a lot. Go ahead. >> We we we talk a lot. >> We we we talk a lot. >> We we we talk a lot. >> See, the philanthropy piece is it it >> See, the philanthropy piece is it it >> See, the philanthropy piece is it it basically the way the the philanthropic basically the way the the philanthropic basically the way the the philanthropic aspect works is that other people aspect works is that other people aspect works is that other people philanthropists can contribute towards philanthropists can contribute towards philanthropists can contribute towards that $5,000 per kid, right? Is that that $5,000 per kid, right? Is that that $5,000 per kid, right? Is that >> So, you know, when Gwen Shotwell >> So, you know, when Gwen Shotwell >> So, you know, when Gwen Shotwell contributes 2 million shares of SpaceX contributes 2 million shares of SpaceX contributes 2 million shares of SpaceX to 2 million kids, each kid's getting a to 2 million kids, each kid's getting a to 2 million kids, each kid's getting a share of stock share of stock share of stock >> 150 bucks. So now >> 150 bucks. So now >> 150 bucks. So now >> that's counting against their $5,000 >> that's counting against their $5,000 >> that's counting against their $5,000 limit. limit. limit. So that's what makes it compelling is So that's what makes it compelling is So that's what makes it compelling is okay look every every family that can okay look every every family that can okay look every every family that can afford to do the 5,000 should because afford to do the 5,000 should because afford to do the 5,000 should because it's just like so compelling from a tax it's just like so compelling from a tax it's just like so compelling from a tax and saving standpoint but then even for and saving standpoint but then even for and saving standpoint but then even for families who can't families who can't families who can't >> there are going to be beneficiaries of >> there are going to be beneficiaries of >> there are going to be beneficiaries of philanthropists who just want to give philanthropists who just want to give philanthropists who just want to give this type of direct giving and it seems this type of direct giving and it seems this type of direct giving and it seems to me this is so much more efficient and to me this is so much more efficient and to me this is so much more efficient and so much better than the whole NGO so much better than the whole NGO so much better than the whole NGO industrial complex where industrial complex where industrial complex where >> absolutely where they take% for their >> absolutely where they take% for their >> absolutely where they take% for their offices than their salaries. offices than their salaries. offices than their salaries. >> Yeah, they're just drifting. >> Yeah, they're just drifting. >> Yeah, they're just drifting. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> One of the numbers I saw was kind of >> One of the numbers I saw was kind of >> One of the numbers I saw was kind of amazing is again, it just goes back to amazing is again, it just goes back to amazing is again, it just goes back to the power of compounding is that if a the power of compounding is that if a the power of compounding is that if a Trump account had been maxed out and you Trump account had been maxed out and you Trump account had been maxed out and you have the standard market rate of return have the standard market rate of return have the standard market rate of return that we've had for say the past 30 that we've had for say the past 30 that we've had for say the past 30 years, then by age 28, that kid will be years, then by age 28, that kid will be years, then by age 28, that kid will be a millionaire. a millionaire. a millionaire. >> Incredible. >> Incredible. >> Incredible. >> That's right. That's right. All the >> That's right. That's right. All the >> That's right. That's right. All the numbers you hear me quote, the $50,000 numbers you hear me quote, the $50,000 numbers you hear me quote, the $50,000 and the $200,000, it doesn't assume and the $200,000, it doesn't assume and the $200,000, it doesn't assume maxing, you know. That just assumes maxing, you know. That just assumes maxing, you know. That just assumes people are adding $50 a month because people are adding $50 a month because people are adding $50 a month because I've been focused as Michael and others I've been focused as Michael and others I've been focused as Michael and others have really on the families who who have really on the families who who have really on the families who who don't have the capacity to save today. don't have the capacity to save today. don't have the capacity to save today. We're getting all of them into the game. We're getting all of them into the game. We're getting all of them into the game. And the president directed us. He said, And the president directed us. He said, And the president directed us. He said, "Listen, we have 529 accounts that "Listen, we have 529 accounts that "Listen, we have 529 accounts that already help the top 10%." That's not already help the top 10%." That's not already help the top 10%." That's not who we're focused on. This is about the who we're focused on. This is about the who we're focused on. This is about the main street agenda. This is about all main street agenda. This is about all main street agenda. This is about all the families that he ran for that feel the families that he ran for that feel the families that he ran for that feel left out and left behind and we're left out and left behind and we're left out and left behind and we're reconnecting them to the American dream reconnecting them to the American dream reconnecting them to the American dream through uh universal ownership. They all through uh universal ownership. They all through uh universal ownership. They all have their own account. They all have a have their own account. They all have a have their own account. They all have a private account on their phone. Um it's private account on their phone. Um it's private account on their phone. Um it's a gamecher for the country. It's the a gamecher for the country. It's the a gamecher for the country. It's the largest change to our social contract largest change to our social contract largest change to our social contract since 1935 and social security. And since 1935 and social security. And since 1935 and social security. And importantly, I think it couldn't come at importantly, I think it couldn't come at importantly, I think it couldn't come at a better time. You know, we have this we a better time. You know, we have this we a better time. You know, we have this we have this fight for have this fight for have this fight for >> just every employer should be signed up >> just every employer should be signed up >> just every employer should be signed up to be, you know, employer that can to be, you know, employer that can to be, you know, employer that can contribute because again you could take contribute because again you could take contribute because again you could take that $2,500 that $2,500 that $2,500 and hopefully look it's additive and and hopefully look it's additive and and hopefully look it's additive and that it's not just a substitute but even that it's not just a substitute but even that it's not just a substitute but even if it's just a substitute and JCAL your if it's just a substitute and JCAL your if it's just a substitute and JCAL your employer takes $2500 bucks out of your employer takes $2500 bucks out of your employer takes $2500 bucks out of your salary and puts it in your kids Trump salary and puts it in your kids Trump salary and puts it in your kids Trump account then you it's reducing your account then you it's reducing your account then you it's reducing your taxable income so it's a no-brainer taxable income so it's a no-brainer taxable income so it's a no-brainer >> if you're a profitable company your >> if you're a profitable company your >> if you're a profitable company your employees are going to love you yeah employees are going to love you yeah employees are going to love you yeah >> yeah but I think every employee is going >> yeah but I think every employee is going >> yeah but I think every employee is going to want to and every employer should do to want to and every employer should do to want to and every employer should do it because it's the tax savings for it because it's the tax savings for it because it's the tax savings for both, right? So, both, right? So, both, right? So, >> the tax savings here is huge. >> the tax savings here is huge. >> the tax savings here is huge. >> Yeah. So, just off of the mechanics of >> Yeah. So, just off of the mechanics of >> Yeah. So, just off of the mechanics of it, I just want to maybe level up here it, I just want to maybe level up here it, I just want to maybe level up here for a second. for a second. for a second. >> Yeah. I have been >> Yeah. I have been >> Yeah. I have been often critical. I call balls and strikes often critical. I call balls and strikes often critical. I call balls and strikes and I can tell you in detail the things and I can tell you in detail the things and I can tell you in detail the things that I have a problem with this that I have a problem with this that I have a problem with this administration and their actions they've administration and their actions they've administration and their actions they've done and I have done it here on the pod. done and I have done it here on the pod. done and I have done it here on the pod. I want to address the people who are I want to address the people who are I want to address the people who are negging this and specifically negging it negging this and specifically negging it negging this and specifically negging it because it has the name Trump accounts because it has the name Trump accounts because it has the name Trump accounts on it which I told you at the poker game on it which I told you at the poker game on it which I told you at the poker game call them Trump accounts. I don't know call them Trump accounts. I don't know call them Trump accounts. I don't know if that was like an obvious thing or I if that was like an obvious thing or I if that was like an obvious thing or I was the person who told you to do it. was the person who told you to do it. was the person who told you to do it. I'm not taking any credit here but I I'm not taking any credit here but I I'm not taking any credit here but I remember that conversation where I was remember that conversation where I was remember that conversation where I was like just call him Trump accounts. Like like just call him Trump accounts. Like like just call him Trump accounts. Like if whatever criticism you have of Trump, if whatever criticism you have of Trump, if whatever criticism you have of Trump, however valid you may feel it is. This however valid you may feel it is. This however valid you may feel it is. This has nothing to do with Donald Trump and has nothing to do with Donald Trump and has nothing to do with Donald Trump and how you feel about him. Put your TDS on how you feel about him. Put your TDS on how you feel about him. Put your TDS on the side. Put your valid criticisms on the side. Put your valid criticisms on the side. Put your valid criticisms on the side. In this country, we have a the side. In this country, we have a the side. In this country, we have a K-shaped recovery going on. We have K-shaped recovery going on. We have K-shaped recovery going on. We have immense tension between the halves and immense tension between the halves and immense tension between the halves and the have nots. We to the point at which the have nots. We to the point at which the have nots. We to the point at which people actually believe that socialism people actually believe that socialism people actually believe that socialism and communism is a better operating and communism is a better operating and communism is a better operating system than the best operating system system than the best operating system system than the best operating system humanity has ever created, which is humanity has ever created, which is humanity has ever created, which is called democracy plus capitalism, right? called democracy plus capitalism, right? called democracy plus capitalism, right? And kids love love capitalism. They love And kids love love capitalism. They love And kids love love capitalism. They love building businesses. But we are in an building businesses. But we are in an building businesses. But we are in an existential moment right now. If these existential moment right now. If these existential moment right now. If these kids believe, young kids, and there's a kids believe, young kids, and there's a kids believe, young kids, and there's a couple of generations of them right now couple of generations of them right now couple of generations of them right now who do not believe in America anymore, who do not believe in America anymore, who do not believe in America anymore, while we're sitting here on the 250 50th while we're sitting here on the 250 50th while we're sitting here on the 250 50th anniversary of this amazing experiment anniversary of this amazing experiment anniversary of this amazing experiment known as America, this is the most known as America, this is the most known as America, this is the most American thing you can do. So, put aside American thing you can do. So, put aside American thing you can do. So, put aside your TDS, put aside your valid your TDS, put aside your valid your TDS, put aside your valid criticisms and embrace this and give the criticisms and embrace this and give the criticisms and embrace this and give the flowers to Brad, to the people donating flowers to Brad, to the people donating flowers to Brad, to the people donating like Michael and Susan Dell and Gwen. like Michael and Susan Dell and Gwen. like Michael and Susan Dell and Gwen. This is beautiful. This is the most This is beautiful. This is the most This is beautiful. This is the most beautiful beautiful beautiful gift I've ever seen to a country and gift I've ever seen to a country and gift I've ever seen to a country and this could be something that's a this could be something that's a this could be something that's a unifying principle that brings us back unifying principle that brings us back unifying principle that brings us back together as a country that everybody together as a country that everybody together as a country that everybody gets to participate in capitalism and gets to participate in capitalism and gets to participate in capitalism and this is the number one way to do it this is the number one way to do it this is the number one way to do it which is to let kids on their smartphone which is to let kids on their smartphone which is to let kids on their smartphone instead of saying you know what mandami instead of saying you know what mandami instead of saying you know what mandami is right I should get a free bus ride I is right I should get a free bus ride I is right I should get a free bus ride I should get a free I should get free should get a free I should get free should get a free I should get free pizza and we should take Ken Griffin's pizza and we should take Ken Griffin's pizza and we should take Ken Griffin's and and sees his, you know, penthouse and and sees his, you know, penthouse and and sees his, you know, penthouse and pay out of ter. all that, you and pay out of ter. all that, you and pay out of ter. all that, you know, and we have we have CEOs getting know, and we have we have CEOs getting know, and we have we have CEOs getting shot and and their homes firebombed. shot and and their homes firebombed. shot and and their homes firebombed. Well, you know what? If you're one of Well, you know what? If you're one of Well, you know what? If you're one of those CEOs, you've done incredibly well. those CEOs, you've done incredibly well. those CEOs, you've done incredibly well. There was something called the giving There was something called the giving There was something called the giving pledge where they pushed, you know, pledge where they pushed, you know, pledge where they pushed, you know, affluent people at the TED conference affluent people at the TED conference affluent people at the TED conference for decades, Bill Gates and everybody, for decades, Bill Gates and everybody, for decades, Bill Gates and everybody, Warren Buffett, everybody was pushing Warren Buffett, everybody was pushing Warren Buffett, everybody was pushing for this. This is like the perfect for this. This is like the perfect for this. This is like the perfect version of the giving pledge because version of the giving pledge because version of the giving pledge because you're not just saying, "I'm giving away you're not just saying, "I'm giving away you're not just saying, "I'm giving away my wealth by the time I die." You're my wealth by the time I die." You're my wealth by the time I die." You're very strategically saying every single very strategically saying every single very strategically saying every single person in America gets to be part of the person in America gets to be part of the person in America gets to be part of the best part of America which is best part of America which is best part of America which is entrepreneurship and everybody will be entrepreneurship and everybody will be entrepreneurship and everybody will be part of the equity nation. And my final part of the equity nation. And my final part of the equity nation. And my final point is one of the happiest countries point is one of the happiest countries point is one of the happiest countries in the world is Australia. If you've in the world is Australia. If you've in the world is Australia. If you've ever gone to Australia, everybody feels ever gone to Australia, everybody feels ever gone to Australia, everybody feels safe. And we have a a large number of safe. And we have a a large number of safe. And we have a a large number of people in this country who do not feel people in this country who do not feel people in this country who do not feel safe. And the reason they don't feel safe. And the reason they don't feel safe. And the reason they don't feel safe is because they don't think their safe is because they don't think their safe is because they don't think their kids are safe. to the point at which kids are safe. to the point at which kids are safe. to the point at which people do not want to have kids in this people do not want to have kids in this people do not want to have kids in this country because they feel the system is country because they feel the system is country because they feel the system is just too hard. This could change that if just too hard. This could change that if just too hard. This could change that if people feel, hey, kids have a shot and I people feel, hey, kids have a shot and I people feel, hey, kids have a shot and I don't have to worry about my kids. I I don't have to worry about my kids. I I don't have to worry about my kids. I I worry about my kids and I'm affluent. I worry about my kids and I'm affluent. I worry about my kids and I'm affluent. I can't imagine being a single parent and can't imagine being a single parent and can't imagine being a single parent and what anxiety you must have as a single what anxiety you must have as a single what anxiety you must have as a single mother or father and you're and you're mother or father and you're and you're mother or father and you're and you're making minimum wage and you're behind, making minimum wage and you're behind, making minimum wage and you're behind, you know, the eightball for your entire you know, the eightball for your entire you know, the eightball for your entire life and now your kids are set. That's life and now your kids are set. That's life and now your kids are set. That's all people want. That's the only thing a all people want. That's the only thing a all people want. That's the only thing a parent wants is to make sure their kids parent wants is to make sure their kids parent wants is to make sure their kids have a better future. That was the have a better future. That was the have a better future. That was the promise of this country and somehow it promise of this country and somehow it promise of this country and somehow it went off the rails for the last two went off the rails for the last two went off the rails for the last two generations. This puts it back on the generations. This puts it back on the generations. This puts it back on the rails. This is super annuation funds in rails. This is super annuation funds in rails. This is super annuation funds in Australia. In Australia, people are Australia. In Australia, people are Australia. In Australia, people are extremely happy. The reason they're extremely happy. The reason they're extremely happy. The reason they're happy is they're forced to put 14K a happy is they're forced to put 14K a happy is they're forced to put 14K a year or whatever it is 12 or 14% I think year or whatever it is 12 or 14% I think year or whatever it is 12 or 14% I think of their income into essentially a 401k of their income into essentially a 401k of their income into essentially a 401k that they get to direct to a certain that they get to direct to a certain that they get to direct to a certain extent. It's forced savings. This does extent. It's forced savings. This does extent. It's forced savings. This does the same thing the same thing the same thing >> at at a a very basic level. This could >> at at a a very basic level. This could >> at at a a very basic level. This could replace social security. This replaces replace social security. This replaces replace social security. This replaces the giving pledge. And I just want to the giving pledge. And I just want to the giving pledge. And I just want to say Brad, you know, a lot of my friends say Brad, you know, a lot of my friends say Brad, you know, a lot of my friends got involved in politics. Some of them got involved in politics. Some of them got involved in politics. Some of them on this very program, a lot of people. on this very program, a lot of people. on this very program, a lot of people. It's very divisive. You threaded the It's very divisive. You threaded the It's very divisive. You threaded the needle here. It was a master class in needle here. It was a master class in needle here. It was a master class in balancing these two balancing these two balancing these two crazy parties and and the divisiveness crazy parties and and the divisiveness crazy parties and and the divisiveness in this country. I just want to give you in this country. I just want to give you in this country. I just want to give you as your friend your flowers. This is as your friend your flowers. This is as your friend your flowers. This is just absolutely outstanding what you did just absolutely outstanding what you did just absolutely outstanding what you did and and you have been incredibly humble and and you have been incredibly humble and and you have been incredibly humble in your approach to this. This would not in your approach to this. This would not in your approach to this. This would not have happened without you, Brad. This is have happened without you, Brad. This is have happened without you, Brad. This is this is your legacy of everything you've this is your legacy of everything you've this is your legacy of everything you've done in your life. Lots of success and done in your life. Lots of success and done in your life. Lots of success and I've seen it up close and personal. This I've seen it up close and personal. This I've seen it up close and personal. This is is is a million times x everything you've done a million times x everything you've done a million times x everything you've done in your whole life. You'll be in your whole life. You'll be in your whole life. You'll be remembered for this. This is remembered for this. This is remembered for this. This is architecture. architecture. architecture. >> Should be as big as social security. I >> Should be as big as social security. I >> Should be as big as social security. I mean, it's a new platform. It's like an mean, it's a new platform. It's like an mean, it's a new platform. It's like an entire new entire new entire new >> It's not because it's philanthropy, but >> It's not because it's philanthropy, but >> It's not because it's philanthropy, but it's also it's also it's also >> retirement savings. I mean, right? And >> retirement savings. I mean, right? And >> retirement savings. I mean, right? And everything in between everything in between everything in between >> and this is not static. We This is >> and this is not static. We This is >> and this is not static. We This is dynamic. dynamic. dynamic. >> We can add to this. There could be other >> We can add to this. There could be other >> We can add to this. There could be other features. features. features. >> I'm seeing a lot of people in the >> I'm seeing a lot of people in the >> I'm seeing a lot of people in the comments say, "Why stop at age 18? Why comments say, "Why stop at age 18? Why comments say, "Why stop at age 18? Why can't you I mean, you have the Trump can't you I mean, you have the Trump can't you I mean, you have the Trump >> account roll over into a IRA or Roth IRA >> account roll over into a IRA or Roth IRA >> account roll over into a IRA or Roth IRA after age 18, but why can't you keep it after age 18, but why can't you keep it after age 18, but why can't you keep it going and then people can keep that going and then people can keep that going and then people can keep that $5,000 contribution going? And you know, $5,000 contribution going? And you know, $5,000 contribution going? And you know, it doesn't mean we take away it doesn't mean we take away it doesn't mean we take away >> exactly >> exactly >> exactly >> retirement benefits that are owed to >> retirement benefits that are owed to >> retirement benefits that are owed to current social security recipients, current social security recipients, current social security recipients, >> but sunset it. But at a certain point, >> but sunset it. But at a certain point, >> but sunset it. But at a certain point, you could just say that, hey, the next you could just say that, hey, the next you could just say that, hey, the next generation is going to be on this generation is going to be on this generation is going to be on this platform rather than the old one, and it platform rather than the old one, and it platform rather than the old one, and it would be a lot better. would be a lot better. would be a lot better. >> A lot more efficient than government not >> A lot more efficient than government not >> A lot more efficient than government not running it, right, Sax? running it, right, Sax? running it, right, Sax? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> We don't want the government running >> We don't want the government running >> We don't want the government running this. this. this. >> Let me ask you a question about this, >> Let me ask you a question about this, >> Let me ask you a question about this, Brad, because I I do see one thing that Brad, because I I do see one thing that Brad, because I I do see one thing that people say, which is what if your kid people say, which is what if your kid people say, which is what if your kid turns 18 and then they just want to blow turns 18 and then they just want to blow turns 18 and then they just want to blow the money, the money, the money, >> you know? How do you trust? How do you >> you know? How do you trust? How do you >> you know? How do you trust? How do you trust that they're going to put it to trust that they're going to put it to trust that they're going to put it to good use, you know, as opposed to good use, you know, as opposed to good use, you know, as opposed to >> I don't know, you know, >> I don't know, you know, >> I don't know, you know, >> yolo >> yolo >> yolo >> yolo and whatever. >> yolo and whatever. >> yolo and whatever. >> As you know, these things are always >> As you know, these things are always >> As you know, these things are always political trade-offs and balances. And I political trade-offs and balances. And I political trade-offs and balances. And I wanted them to have to compound until wanted them to have to compound until wanted them to have to compound until they were 30, right? Because I figured they were 30, right? Because I figured they were 30, right? Because I figured by 30, you were a little bit more, you by 30, you were a little bit more, you by 30, you were a little bit more, you know, uh uh mentally uh developed on on know, uh uh mentally uh developed on on know, uh uh mentally uh developed on on financial issues. But, you know, the financial issues. But, you know, the financial issues. But, you know, the argument ultimately came, you're old argument ultimately came, you're old argument ultimately came, you're old enough to vote, you're old enough to enough to vote, you're old enough to enough to vote, you're old enough to fight a war. if I if by 18 we don't fight a war. if I if by 18 we don't fight a war. if I if by 18 we don't allow you to have control of your own allow you to have control of your own allow you to have control of your own money. So that's where a political, you money. So that's where a political, you money. So that's where a political, you know, uh consensus was built, David. But know, uh consensus was built, David. But know, uh consensus was built, David. But the other thing, remember, is they can the other thing, remember, is they can the other thing, remember, is they can only take up to 25% out to buy a home, only take up to 25% out to buy a home, only take up to 25% out to buy a home, start a business, go to college. The start a business, go to college. The start a business, go to college. The rest rolls into an IRA, and there are rest rolls into an IRA, and there are rest rolls into an IRA, and there are built-in penalties for early withdrawal built-in penalties for early withdrawal built-in penalties for early withdrawal in an IRA. So they're disincentives for in an IRA. So they're disincentives for in an IRA. So they're disincentives for people to pull out. But let's be clear, people to pull out. But let's be clear, people to pull out. But let's be clear, we have to do a much better job in our we have to do a much better job in our we have to do a much better job in our education, our public education system, education, our public education system, education, our public education system, leveraging this as the platform. You leveraging this as the platform. You leveraging this as the platform. You know, if a kid doesn't have any money, know, if a kid doesn't have any money, know, if a kid doesn't have any money, it's hard to get excited about learning it's hard to get excited about learning it's hard to get excited about learning about money. But if a kid's in the game about money. But if a kid's in the game about money. But if a kid's in the game and has 12,000 bucks in the seventh and has 12,000 bucks in the seventh and has 12,000 bucks in the seventh grade, now you got my attention. I own a grade, now you got my attention. I own a grade, now you got my attention. I own a little bit of Nike. I own a little bit little bit of Nike. I own a little bit little bit of Nike. I own a little bit of Apple. I own a little bit of Nvidia. of Apple. I own a little bit of Nvidia. of Apple. I own a little bit of Nvidia. Let's talk about that. How did it get Let's talk about that. How did it get Let's talk about that. How did it get there? How did it compound? If I added there? How did it compound? If I added there? How did it compound? If I added 50 bucks a month, what does it turn 50 bucks a month, what does it turn 50 bucks a month, what does it turn into? All of these things will now be into? All of these things will now be into? All of these things will now be present on every child's phone in present on every child's phone in present on every child's phone in America. 37 states require financial America. 37 states require financial America. 37 states require financial literacy. Every state should build this literacy. Every state should build this literacy. Every state should build this into the curriculum. We're working with into the curriculum. We're working with into the curriculum. We're working with a lot of states on that. You know, we a lot of states on that. You know, we a lot of states on that. You know, we haven't talked about that. We have about haven't talked about that. We have about haven't talked about that. We have about 25 states who are going to add money 25 states who are going to add money 25 states who are going to add money into the accounts of the kids in their into the accounts of the kids in their into the accounts of the kids in their states. So, you got states. So, you got states. So, you got >> states are going to do it. >> states are going to do it. >> states are going to do it. >> States state action. Oklahoma, West >> States state action. Oklahoma, West >> States state action. Oklahoma, West Virginia, you know, Indiana, etc. So Virginia, you know, Indiana, etc. So Virginia, you know, Indiana, etc. So that's also sweeping the country where that's also sweeping the country where that's also sweeping the country where the states are looking at programs they the states are looking at programs they the states are looking at programs they already have where they're spending already have where they're spending already have where they're spending money for kids that are ineffective money for kids that are ineffective money for kids that are ineffective and they're saying instead of continuing and they're saying instead of continuing and they're saying instead of continuing to spend money on these things that to spend money on these things that to spend money on these things that aren't working, why not just block grant aren't working, why not just block grant aren't working, why not just block grant the money directly to the kids the money directly to the kids the money directly to the kids >> because we >> because we >> because we give the kids the money more likely to give the kids the money more likely to give the kids the money more likely to graduate, more likely to, you know, to graduate, more likely to, you know, to graduate, more likely to, you know, to buy a home, start a business, etc. So, I buy a home, start a business, etc. So, I buy a home, start a business, etc. So, I think that we're, as I said in in the think that we're, as I said in in the think that we're, as I said in in the oval, this is day one, and I am fully oval, this is day one, and I am fully oval, this is day one, and I am fully committed to the next decade, as is my committed to the next decade, as is my committed to the next decade, as is my partner in crime on this, Michael and partner in crime on this, Michael and partner in crime on this, Michael and Susan Dell. I appreciate your guys's Susan Dell. I appreciate your guys's Susan Dell. I appreciate your guys's comments on on on the legacy of this. It comments on on on the legacy of this. It comments on on on the legacy of this. It has been the most profound work and kind has been the most profound work and kind has been the most profound work and kind of honor of my life. and standing in the of honor of my life. and standing in the of honor of my life. and standing in the Oval Office with my two sons who are Oval Office with my two sons who are Oval Office with my two sons who are really my two co-founders on this. We really my two co-founders on this. We really my two co-founders on this. We draft, you know, we made the sketch of draft, you know, we made the sketch of draft, you know, we made the sketch of this at our kitchen table in at the in this at our kitchen table in at the in this at our kitchen table in at the in the fall of 2020. That's where the the fall of 2020. That's where the the fall of 2020. That's where the conversation started. Lincoln's been conversation started. Lincoln's been conversation started. Lincoln's been with me in every single meeting with with me in every single meeting with with me in every single meeting with every congressman, senator, president, every congressman, senator, president, every congressman, senator, president, former president, etc. The president former president, etc. The president former president, etc. The president shouted him out uh you know, again when shouted him out uh you know, again when shouted him out uh you know, again when we were there. That journey as a father we were there. That journey as a father we were there. That journey as a father with my kids with my kids with my kids >> has been like the payback has been >> has been like the payback has been >> has been like the payback has been really extraordinary. Other thing that's really extraordinary. Other thing that's really extraordinary. Other thing that's notable here and again like you got to notable here and again like you got to notable here and again like you got to call balls and strikes and give credit call balls and strikes and give credit call balls and strikes and give credit where credit is due. Joe Jebia joined where credit is due. Joe Jebia joined where credit is due. Joe Jebia joined this administration. A lot of people in this administration. A lot of people in this administration. A lot of people in the tech industry are like oh you know the tech industry are like oh you know the tech industry are like oh you know oh you joined the Trump administration oh you joined the Trump administration oh you joined the Trump administration whatever you know. Okay there's some whatever you know. Okay there's some whatever you know. Okay there's some criticism. He's an incredible worldass criticism. He's an incredible worldass criticism. He's an incredible worldass designer. I was talking to producer Nick designer. I was talking to producer Nick designer. I was talking to producer Nick our producer here also happens to show our producer here also happens to show our producer here also happens to show the same last name as me. He signed up the same last name as me. He signed up the same last name as me. He signed up for this right? He's doing well but you for this right? He's doing well but you for this right? He's doing well but you know his his wife signed up for it. The know his his wife signed up for it. The know his his wife signed up for it. The software is fantastic. Let's pause for a software is fantastic. Let's pause for a software is fantastic. Let's pause for a second. second. second. The American government has made The American government has made The American government has made exceptional software and this all got exceptional software and this all got exceptional software and this all got done in Trump's first 18 months, immense done in Trump's first 18 months, immense done in Trump's first 18 months, immense credit for this. This is like of all credit for this. This is like of all credit for this. This is like of all the, you know, challenges this the, you know, challenges this the, you know, challenges this presidency has had and the Iran war and presidency has had and the Iran war and presidency has had and the Iran war and other issues. We made great software. other issues. We made great software. other issues. We made great software. The American government because of Joe The American government because of Joe The American government because of Joe Jebia makes kickass software. Like just Jebia makes kickass software. Like just Jebia makes kickass software. Like just also major shout out to him and you know also major shout out to him and you know also major shout out to him and you know he could be doing whatever he wants. he could be doing whatever he wants. he could be doing whatever he wants. He's, you know, he's done incredibly He's, you know, he's done incredibly He's, you know, he's done incredibly well as the co-founder of Airbnb and well as the co-founder of Airbnb and well as the co-founder of Airbnb and he's doing this like that. That's a real he's doing this like that. That's a real he's doing this like that. That's a real patriotic thing to do. I I I'm just over patriotic thing to do. I I I'm just over patriotic thing to do. I I I'm just over the moon with this. I think it's the moon with this. I think it's the moon with this. I think it's fantastic. fantastic. fantastic. >> The dream team you had like Michael >> The dream team you had like Michael >> The dream team you had like Michael Dell, myself, Vlad Tennv, Joe Gabia, Dell, myself, Vlad Tennv, Joe Gabia, Dell, myself, Vlad Tennv, Joe Gabia, >> the Treasury Secretary, Luke Pettit at >> the Treasury Secretary, Luke Pettit at >> the Treasury Secretary, Luke Pettit at the Treasury talking basically every day the Treasury talking basically every day the Treasury talking basically every day for the last year. And our objective was for the last year. And our objective was for the last year. And our objective was not we want to build the best thing that not we want to build the best thing that not we want to build the best thing that that the government's ever launched. We that the government's ever launched. We that the government's ever launched. We wanted to build one of the best consumer wanted to build one of the best consumer wanted to build one of the best consumer products period that's ever been products period that's ever been products period that's ever been launched. Mission accomplished launched. Mission accomplished launched. Mission accomplished >> and there's any Silicon Valley consumer >> and there's any Silicon Valley consumer >> and there's any Silicon Valley consumer company would be thrilled with the company would be thrilled with the company would be thrilled with the numbers that we're seeing, the ratings numbers that we're seeing, the ratings numbers that we're seeing, the ratings that we're seeing, the engagement that that we're seeing, the engagement that that we're seeing, the engagement that we're seeing. So, we're seeing. So, we're seeing. So, >> you know, it's been fun doing it with >> you know, it's been fun doing it with >> you know, it's been fun doing it with that incredible team. And, you know, that incredible team. And, you know, that incredible team. And, you know, everybody's in this for the right everybody's in this for the right everybody's in this for the right mission as well. And so, I agree with mission as well. And so, I agree with mission as well. And so, I agree with you, Jason. It's rare that government you, Jason. It's rare that government you, Jason. It's rare that government recruits or embraces uh you know, that recruits or embraces uh you know, that recruits or embraces uh you know, that that that mission. And I think the that that mission. And I think the that that mission. And I think the tent's getting a heck of a lot bigger. tent's getting a heck of a lot bigger. tent's getting a heck of a lot bigger. It is bipartisan. It is bipartisan. It is bipartisan. It's bipartisan in support. You know, It's bipartisan in support. You know, It's bipartisan in support. You know, this is important. What Governor uh uh this is important. What Governor uh uh this is important. What Governor uh uh Moore from Maryland said yesterday. He Moore from Maryland said yesterday. He Moore from Maryland said yesterday. He said, "Republicans and Democrats have said, "Republicans and Democrats have said, "Republicans and Democrats have been trying to do something that looks been trying to do something that looks been trying to do something that looks like this, feels like this for 40 years. like this, feels like this for 40 years. like this, feels like this for 40 years. This guy got it done. Give him credit. This guy got it done. Give him credit. This guy got it done. Give him credit. This is great for America, great for our This is great for America, great for our This is great for America, great for our kids, and especially on the 250th kids, and especially on the 250th kids, and especially on the 250th anniversary. You know, you're standing anniversary. You know, you're standing anniversary. You know, you're standing in the Oval Office looking at the in the Oval Office looking at the in the Oval Office looking at the original Declaration of Independence and original Declaration of Independence and original Declaration of Independence and you realize what people laid down for you realize what people laid down for you realize what people laid down for this experiment and then I I read this this experiment and then I I read this this experiment and then I I read this chatter in my feeds about Mandami and chatter in my feeds about Mandami and chatter in my feeds about Mandami and others literally wanting to set this others literally wanting to set this others literally wanting to set this great experiment on fire. great experiment on fire. great experiment on fire. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Right. Wanting to burn the place down >> Right. Wanting to burn the place down >> Right. Wanting to burn the place down because they they think they have a because they they think they have a because they they think they have a better formula. No, the answer is better formula. No, the answer is better formula. No, the answer is evolving and doubling down on the evolving and doubling down on the evolving and doubling down on the formula that has worked for 250 years. formula that has worked for 250 years. formula that has worked for 250 years. And rather than making all these kids And rather than making all these kids And rather than making all these kids socialists, we get them all into the socialists, we get them all into the socialists, we get them all into the game of capitalism, they become owners, game of capitalism, they become owners, game of capitalism, they become owners, owners and shareholders in America. So owners and shareholders in America. So owners and shareholders in America. So that's what we got accomplished and uh that's what we got accomplished and uh that's what we got accomplished and uh >> appreciate the chance to talk about it. >> appreciate the chance to talk about it. >> appreciate the chance to talk about it. >> Listen, incredible Brad and um you know, >> Listen, incredible Brad and um you know, >> Listen, incredible Brad and um you know, just amazing to watch you do it. And if just amazing to watch you do it. And if just amazing to watch you do it. And if you if you if you if you really think you if you if you if you really think you if you if you if you really think about it, the tech industry I needs to about it, the tech industry I needs to about it, the tech industry I needs to win and capitalists and creators and the win and capitalists and creators and the win and capitalists and creators and the makers, the people who build stuff. This makers, the people who build stuff. This makers, the people who build stuff. This is our chance to say here's an example is our chance to say here's an example is our chance to say here's an example of something that helps the people at of something that helps the people at of something that helps the people at the bottom, right? And I talked a bunch the bottom, right? And I talked a bunch the bottom, right? And I talked a bunch about um the minimum wage here. We got a about um the minimum wage here. We got a about um the minimum wage here. We got a $7 minimum wage. Like we we need to $7 minimum wage. Like we we need to $7 minimum wage. Like we we need to address that as well. These are the address that as well. These are the address that as well. These are the things that if we address what people things that if we address what people things that if we address what people are scared about, what people who are are scared about, what people who are are scared about, what people who are who don't have what we all have here, uh who don't have what we all have here, uh who don't have what we all have here, uh if we have empathy for those people and if we have empathy for those people and if we have empathy for those people and we actually care about them and we give we actually care about them and we give we actually care about them and we give them a path to believe in the American them a path to believe in the American them a path to believe in the American dream, they will take that path dream, they will take that path dream, they will take that path >> we have to give them a better path than >> we have to give them a better path than >> we have to give them a better path than these socialist lunatics. And this is so these socialist lunatics. And this is so these socialist lunatics. And this is so much of a better path. Let's do it much of a better path. Let's do it much of a better path. Let's do it again. Let's do another one of these again. Let's do another one of these again. Let's do another one of these things. Let's keep growing this spirit things. Let's keep growing this spirit things. Let's keep growing this spirit of getting everybody in the country to of getting everybody in the country to of getting everybody in the country to have equity uh in these great companies. have equity uh in these great companies. have equity uh in these great companies. That's that's why the entire world is That's that's why the entire world is That's that's why the entire world is trying to replicate what we do here. trying to replicate what we do here. trying to replicate what we do here. Every single country I go to wants to Every single country I go to wants to Every single country I go to wants to recreate Silicon Valley. recreate Silicon Valley. recreate Silicon Valley. >> We're not we're not stopping here. And >> We're not we're not stopping here. And >> We're not we're not stopping here. And um David to your point where you know um David to your point where you know um David to your point where you know whether it's the AI companies uh or whether it's the AI companies uh or whether it's the AI companies uh or frankly whether it's the Intel shares or frankly whether it's the Intel shares or frankly whether it's the Intel shares or whether it's the Tik Tok fee I now have whether it's the Tik Tok fee I now have whether it's the Tik Tok fee I now have a a place where all of those wins a a place where all of those wins a a place where all of those wins achieved by this administration can go achieved by this administration can go achieved by this administration can go they ought to go directly to all the they ought to go directly to all the they ought to go directly to all the citizens you know the country into their citizens you know the country into their citizens you know the country into their accounts and compound for a lifetime. accounts and compound for a lifetime. accounts and compound for a lifetime. And then as far as people over the age And then as far as people over the age And then as far as people over the age of 18 there's certainly a lot of talk of 18 there's certainly a lot of talk of 18 there's certainly a lot of talk about that as well. um not again as about that as well. um not again as about that as well. um not again as social security is a sacred promise by social security is a sacred promise by social security is a sacred promise by both parties. Nobody's going to change both parties. Nobody's going to change both parties. Nobody's going to change that. But there's a huge opportunity to that. But there's a huge opportunity to that. But there's a huge opportunity to have a supplement here. Why shouldn't have a supplement here. Why shouldn't have a supplement here. Why shouldn't people, you know, between 20 and 30 or people, you know, between 20 and 30 or people, you know, between 20 and 30 or 20 and 40 also have a Trump account that 20 and 40 also have a Trump account that 20 and 40 also have a Trump account that they can begin on a supplemental basis they can begin on a supplemental basis they can begin on a supplemental basis adding dollars that they own and adding dollars that they own and adding dollars that they own and control? Remember the big difference control? Remember the big difference control? Remember the big difference between this and social security. Social between this and social security. Social between this and social security. Social Security takes 12.4% 4% of my W2 income Security takes 12.4% 4% of my W2 income Security takes 12.4% 4% of my W2 income and puts it into something akin to the and puts it into something akin to the and puts it into something akin to the black hole of government. I don't own black hole of government. I don't own black hole of government. I don't own it. I don't control it. If I ask a room it. I don't control it. If I ask a room it. I don't control it. If I ask a room of 3,000 people how much they've of 3,000 people how much they've of 3,000 people how much they've contributed, they have no idea. If I contributed, they have no idea. If I contributed, they have no idea. If I die, I don't have title. It doesn't pass die, I don't have title. It doesn't pass die, I don't have title. It doesn't pass to my heirs, etc. So, it's really not to my heirs, etc. So, it's really not to my heirs, etc. So, it's really not mine. But if we created a supplemental mine. But if we created a supplemental mine. But if we created a supplemental IRA, it doesn't even require new IRA, it doesn't even require new IRA, it doesn't even require new legislation, I don't think. It's just legislation, I don't think. It's just legislation, I don't think. It's just expanding the age. These these are IAS expanding the age. These these are IAS expanding the age. These these are IAS after the age of 18, right? then people after the age of 18, right? then people after the age of 18, right? then people could start building supplemental wealth could start building supplemental wealth could start building supplemental wealth and participate in these gains. And so and participate in these gains. And so and participate in these gains. And so there's a lot of conversations going on there's a lot of conversations going on there's a lot of conversations going on about that as well. And and so we're not about that as well. And and so we're not about that as well. And and so we're not done, but uh it was a hell of a done, but uh it was a hell of a done, but uh it was a hell of a milestone on the 250th birthday of milestone on the 250th birthday of milestone on the 250th birthday of America to ring the bell in the oval and America to ring the bell in the oval and America to ring the bell in the oval and to to watch all these kids get their to to watch all these kids get their to to watch all these kids get their accounts lit up. It was pretty special. accounts lit up. It was pretty special. accounts lit up. It was pretty special. What I think is really cool about the What I think is really cool about the What I think is really cool about the Trump accounts, I'm I think it's an Trump accounts, I'm I think it's an Trump accounts, I'm I think it's an amazing philanthropic platform, but in amazing philanthropic platform, but in amazing philanthropic platform, but in addition to that, it's an amazing addition to that, it's an amazing addition to that, it's an amazing platform for middle class family platform for middle class family platform for middle class family planning. That's the point I'm trying to planning. That's the point I'm trying to planning. That's the point I'm trying to make is all the CPAs that I'm seeing make is all the CPAs that I'm seeing make is all the CPAs that I'm seeing talking about this are saying this is talking about this are saying this is talking about this are saying this is like one of the greatest things ever. like one of the greatest things ever. like one of the greatest things ever. And if I could only tell my clients to And if I could only tell my clients to And if I could only tell my clients to do one thing, this would be the one do one thing, this would be the one do one thing, this would be the one thing. thing. thing. >> Finally, something for the middle class, >> Finally, something for the middle class, >> Finally, something for the middle class, right? This is what people have been right? This is what people have been right? This is what people have been asking for. Hey, let's get something for asking for. Hey, let's get something for asking for. Hey, let's get something for the middle class. Let's get something the middle class. Let's get something the middle class. Let's get something for the, you know, for the, you know, for the, you know, >> Yeah. And I I think the market gap, bra, >> Yeah. And I I think the market gap, bra, >> Yeah. And I I think the market gap, bra, correct me if I'm wrong, but basically correct me if I'm wrong, but basically correct me if I'm wrong, but basically the the market gap that was created here the the market gap that was created here the the market gap that was created here is that you can't get an IRA, which is is that you can't get an IRA, which is is that you can't get an IRA, which is basically a tax advantage uh savings basically a tax advantage uh savings basically a tax advantage uh savings account until you have your first job, account until you have your first job, account until you have your first job, right? And get earnings, right? And get earnings, right? And get earnings, >> which would be for most people at age 22 >> which would be for most people at age 22 >> which would be for most people at age 22 plus. So for that first 22 years, plus. So for that first 22 years, plus. So for that first 22 years, >> you're not your kids can't have an IRA, >> you're not your kids can't have an IRA, >> you're not your kids can't have an IRA, right? right? right? >> Correct. And you're effectively giving >> Correct. And you're effectively giving >> Correct. And you're effectively giving every child at birth correct IRA. every child at birth correct IRA. every child at birth correct IRA. >> You know, it's a Trump account has >> You know, it's a Trump account has >> You know, it's a Trump account has certain rules. It's actually it's better certain rules. It's actually it's better certain rules. It's actually it's better than an IRA. than an IRA. than an IRA. >> Better than an IRA. >> Better than an IRA. >> Better than an IRA. >> It's better than an IRA because with an >> It's better than an IRA because with an >> It's better than an IRA because with an with an IRA, your employer can't with an IRA, your employer can't with an IRA, your employer can't contribute 2500 bucks taxfree, can they? contribute 2500 bucks taxfree, can they? contribute 2500 bucks taxfree, can they? I mean, I mean, I mean, >> I don't think so. and philanthropists >> I don't think so. and philanthropists >> I don't think so. and philanthropists can't contribute to it and moms and dads can't contribute to it and moms and dads can't contribute to it and moms and dads and but the most important thing you and but the most important thing you and but the most important thing you know like I I I say this you know know like I I I say this you know know like I I I say this you know Buffett's like the secret is to find a Buffett's like the secret is to find a Buffett's like the secret is to find a really small snowball on a really long really small snowball on a really long really small snowball on a really long hill okay but the size of the hill in hill okay but the size of the hill in hill okay but the size of the hill in this country we've cut off the the first this country we've cut off the the first this country we've cut off the the first third of the hill forever nobody saves third of the hill forever nobody saves third of the hill forever nobody saves anything until they're 25 anything until they're 25 anything until they're 25 >> okay the easiest compounding in the >> okay the easiest compounding in the >> okay the easiest compounding in the world the the easiest compounding in the world the the easiest compounding in the world the the easiest compounding in the world is between zero and 5. All right. world is between zero and 5. All right. world is between zero and 5. All right. Listen, this has been amazing. Listen, this has been amazing. Listen, this has been amazing. >> Yeah. Because their dependence, frankly, >> Yeah. Because their dependence, frankly, >> Yeah. Because their dependence, frankly, they're still on mom and dad. they're still on mom and dad. they're still on mom and dad. >> Exactly. So, you you you pick up the >> Exactly. So, you you you pick up the >> Exactly. So, you you you pick up the first third of life. first third of life. first third of life. >> Incredible, right? In in compounding. >> Incredible, right? In in compounding. >> Incredible, right? In in compounding. And so, it's a And so, it's a And so, it's a >> it's really remarkable. Let's go. Uh I >> it's really remarkable. Let's go. Uh I >> it's really remarkable. Let's go. Uh I mean, amazing job. All right. We'll see mean, amazing job. All right. We'll see mean, amazing job. All right. We'll see you all next time. Bye-bye. you all next time. Bye-bye. you all next time. Bye-bye. >> We'll let your winners ride. We open sourced it to the fans and We open sourced it to the fans and they've just gone crazy with it. they've just gone crazy with it. they've just gone crazy with it. >> Love you. Queen of >> Love you. Queen of >> Love you. Queen of >> your besties are gone. besties are gone. >> That is my dog taking notice your >> That is my dog taking notice your >> That is my dog taking notice your driveways. >> Oh man, myasher will meet me. We should >> Oh man, myasher will meet me. We should all just get a room and just have one all just get a room and just have one all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy cuz they're all useless. big huge orgy cuz they're all useless. big huge orgy cuz they're all useless. It's like this like sexual tension that It's like this like sexual tension that It's like this like sexual tension that they just need to release something they just need to release something they just need to release something else. >> Your feet. >> Your feet. >> We need to get merch. >> We need to get merch. >> We need to get merch. >> I'm going all in.