If humans go to Mars, what happens to evolution? - Scott Solomon
Moving to Mars isn't just a technological challenge—it's an evolutionary gamble. The combination of reduced gravity, intense radiation exposure, and isolation will fundamentally alter human biology. Start preparing now: the evolutionary changes we'll see on Mars could happen faster than we think, dr
1h 22mKey Takeaway
Moving to Mars isn't just a technological challenge—it's an evolutionary gamble. The combination of reduced gravity, intense radiation exposure, and isolation will fundamentally alter human biology. Start preparing now: the evolutionary changes we'll see on Mars could happen faster than we think, driven by mutation rates up to 100x higher than on Earth. The key insight? Space exploration is as much about biological adaptation as it is about engineering.
Episode Overview
This episode explores the biological and evolutionary implications of human space settlement, particularly on Mars. Dr. Scott Solomon, an evolutionary biologist, discusses how the extreme environment of space—from microgravity to cosmic radiation—fundamentally changes the human body. He examines the NASA CHAPEA Mars simulation experiment, the physiological effects of space travel (muscle atrophy, bone loss, vision changes, 'space brain'), and how Mars colonization would represent the first time humans knowingly place themselves in an environment that guarantees biological divergence. The conversation covers historical human evolution examples like Homo floresiensis (the 'hobbit' species), the challenges of growing food in space, and why the mutation rate from radiation exposure could dramatically accelerate evolutionary changes in a Mars population.
Key Insights
Space Travel Causes Immediate Bodily Changes
Astronauts experience rapid physiological changes in space: muscles weaken (especially lower body), bones lose density as the body absorbs calcium and potassium, blood volume decreases, and fluids redistribute causing 'moon face' and 'chicken legs.' The body interprets increased fluid in the head as too much total fluid, triggering a reduction in blood plasma and red blood cell production, often resulting in anemia upon return to Earth.
The Island Rule Predicts Human Evolution on Mars
Historical examples like Homo floresiensis show that isolated populations on resource-limited islands evolve dramatic size changes. Mars colonists would face similar isolation pressures. With one-third Earth's gravity and limited resources, evolutionary pressures could favor smaller body sizes over generations, similar to how both humans and elephants miniaturized on the island of Flores.
Radiation Accelerates Mutation and Evolution
Beyond Earth's protective magnetosphere (the Van Allen radiation belts), galactic cosmic rays cause DNA damage that accelerates mutation rates. While mutations increase cancer risk and can cause cognitive impairment ('space brain'), they also provide the raw material for evolutionary adaptation. This means Mars colonists could evolve faster than any human population in history—but at the cost of significant suffering and death from harmful mutations.
Mars Settlement Would Be Humanity's First Intentional Divergence
For most of human history, multiple human species coexisted. Mars colonization would be the first time our species knowingly creates conditions that guarantee biological divergence from Earth humans. The combination of different gravity, radiation exposure, isolation, and potentially different nutrition would create evolutionary pressures unlike anything experienced by staying on Earth.
Microgravity Effects Can't Be Fully Replicated by Exercise
Despite astronauts exercising 2 hours daily with resistance equipment, this only minimizes—not eliminates—the deconditioning from weightlessness. The global effect of gravity on spine, organs, lymphatic system, circulation, and reproductive organs cannot be fully replicated by targeted exercise, meaning even well-conditioned astronauts struggle when re-entering a gravity environment.
Notable Quotes
"For most of our species history, there were multiple types of human on this planet and we interacted with them."
"This will be the first time in history that a species will knowingly place itself in an environment that almost guarantees biological divergence."
"We're talking about a very different level of extreme when we talk about how extreme the environment is on Mars. You could walk outside and breathe oxygen in Antarctica, right? Your blood doesn't boil if there's a leak in your habitat the way it would on Mars."
"The very first time one of these [Geiger counters] was sent up on a satellite, it's clicking, clicking, clicking, the rate is getting higher, and then all of a sudden it just stops. It turned out there was so much radiation, it was just overwhelming the sensors of the counter."
"You're talking about a lot of suffering. You're talking about a lot of death."
Action Items
-
1
Understand the Full Scope of Space's Effects on Your Body
Before considering space travel, research the comprehensive physiological changes: muscle atrophy, bone density loss, vision deterioration, fluid redistribution, blood volume reduction, and potential cognitive impairment. These aren't temporary inconveniences—they're fundamental biological responses that require months of recovery and may have permanent effects.
-
2
Consider the Evolutionary Timeline for Space Settlement
If involved in space colonization planning, factor in that meaningful evolutionary adaptation requires multiple generations (decades to centuries) and comes with significant costs in human suffering from harmful mutations. Short-term technological solutions for radiation shielding and artificial gravity may be more humane than relying on natural selection.
-
3
Study Analog Environments for Space Preparation
Learn from Mars analog studies like the NASA CHAPEA experiment or Mars Desert Research Station. These simulations reveal the psychological and social challenges of isolation and confinement that complement the physiological challenges, helping us understand what life in space would actually be like beyond the engineering challenges.
-
4
Prioritize Radiation Protection Technology
For anyone working on space exploration, recognize that radiation exposure (particularly galactic cosmic rays beyond Earth's magnetosphere) is perhaps the most serious long-term health challenge. Invest in and advocate for advanced radiation shielding technology rather than accepting high mutation rates as inevitable.