1% better

Howard Marks: how I make money while you worry about a market crash

Howard Marks, co-founder of Oaktree Capital Management, discusses his evolution on AI, the principles of second-level thinking, making major investment...

44m

Summary published by , updated .

My First Million

Key Takeaway

When markets crash and everyone sees terrible news, successful investors overcome fear not by ignoring it, but by acting despite trepidation. True investing courage isn't fearlessness—it's acknowledging uncertainty while still taking action. As Howard Marks explains: invest during crises because if you wait until there's nothing to fear, the opportunity has passed. Build your 'ark before the flood' by preparing capital when things look good, not when panic sets in.

Episode Overview

Howard Marks, co-founder of Oaktree Capital Management, discusses his evolution on AI, the principles of second-level thinking, making major investment decisions during the 2008 financial crisis, the importance of humility in investing, and lessons from his 39-year partnership with Bruce Karsh and relationship with Warren Buffett.

Main Insights

AI's Unprecedented Autonomy Changes Everything

Unlike all previous technological innovations that were tools to increase productivity, AI possesses autonomy—the ability to complete tasks without explicit instructions on how to do them. This quality, combined with AI's unpredictability about future capabilities, makes it fundamentally different from anything we've seen before, including the internet or computers.

Second-Level Thinking Requires Variant Perception

To achieve superior investment returns, you must see something different from the consensus—a variant perception. This means either believing the market overstates a company's quality, growth rate, or deserved valuation multiple. However, having insight and the ability to maintain variant perceptions that prove correct cannot easily be taught—it's more innate talent than learned skill.

Act Despite Fear, Not Without It

During the 2008 Lehman bankruptcy, Oaktree invested $7 billion despite having 'absolutely no confidence' the world wouldn't melt down. The key insight: if the financial world melts down and you invest, it doesn't matter; but if you don't invest and the world doesn't melt down, you failed your job. A battle hero isn't someone who's unafraid—it's someone who's afraid but acts anyway.

Great Partnerships Need Shared Values and Complementary Skills

A successful long-term partnership requires two elements: shared values (ethics, risk tolerance, priorities) and complementary skills where each partner excels at what the other cannot do. The partnership thrives when both partners appreciate what the other brings and recognize they need each other. Financial maximization shouldn't drive the relationship—mutual respect should.

Humility Prevents Catastrophic Mistakes

No sentence starting with 'I could be wrong, but...' or 'I don't know, but...' ever got anyone into trouble. The dangerous sentences begin with 'I'm 100% convinced that...' As Mark Twain said, 'It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for certain that just ain't true.' Betting with absolute certainty on an 80/20 proposition when the 20 materializes creates catastrophic losses.

Notable Quotes

"If you wait until you have nothing to be afraid about, probably the opportunity has passed."

Howard Marks

"There's never been anything with the quality of autonomy. The idea that you can give it a job and not tell it how to do it, and it'll figure it out. Is really unique."

Howard Marks

"A battle hero is not somebody who's unafraid. It's somebody who's afraid, but does it anyway."

Howard Marks

"There is only one success—to live your life your own way."

Christopher Morley (quoted by Howard Marks)

"It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for certain that just ain't true."

Mark Twain (quoted by Howard Marks)

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Develop Second-Level Thinking Through Self-Awareness

    Actively work to identify variant perceptions—areas where you see value differently than the market consensus. Question why you might be right when others are wrong. Study your own strengths, weaknesses, and what makes you happy to find work that plays to your advantages.

  • 2
    Build Your Ark Before the Flood

    Prepare capital and resources during good times for inevitable crises. When you sense potential opportunities ahead, raise funds and build relationships before the crisis hits. You can't raise money during a crisis when news is terrible, so anticipate and prepare in advance.

  • 3
    Practice Intentional Decision-Making

    Stop letting others (friends, society, parents) make your decisions. Think through choices for yourself by asking: Does this play to my strengths? Does it avoid my weaknesses? Will it make me happy? Make decisions with intention rather than drifting unconsciously through life.

  • 4
    Act Against Your Own Interest to Build Credibility

    When opportunities seem poor, be willing to raise smaller funds or pass on deals even if you could capitalize on past success. Speaking against your own short-term interest and admitting limitations builds long-term trust and credibility with partners and investors.

Guides that reference this episode

See how this episode fits with recommendations from other leading podcasts.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

If you wait until you have nothing to be If you wait until you have nothing to be afraid about, probably the opportunity afraid about, probably the opportunity afraid about, probably the opportunity has passed. >> Howard, it's good to see you again. We >> Howard, it's good to see you again. We had a lot of fun last time and we were had a lot of fun last time and we were had a lot of fun last time and we were like, "Look, I don't know if other like, "Look, I don't know if other like, "Look, I don't know if other people are going to like that, but we people are going to like that, but we people are going to like that, but we loved that." And then over a million loved that." And then over a million loved that." And then over a million people listened to the last one. And so, people listened to the last one. And so, people listened to the last one. And so, this morning I was reading you wrote this morning I was reading you wrote this morning I was reading you wrote this blog post about how you changed this blog post about how you changed this blog post about how you changed your mind about AI. You You had written your mind about AI. You You had written your mind about AI. You You had written I don't know, a couple months back about I don't know, a couple months back about I don't know, a couple months back about the possibility of an AI bubble and then the possibility of an AI bubble and then the possibility of an AI bubble and then as as as a good thinker tends to do, you got new a good thinker tends to do, you got new a good thinker tends to do, you got new facts, you sort of reassessed the facts, you sort of reassessed the facts, you sort of reassessed the situation, you wrote a new post about situation, you wrote a new post about situation, you wrote a new post about AI. Do you want to summarize the story AI. Do you want to summarize the story AI. Do you want to summarize the story of how you you changed your mind on AI? of how you you changed your mind on AI? of how you you changed your mind on AI? >> Uh well, the story's very simple. I have >> Uh well, the story's very simple. I have >> Uh well, the story's very simple. I have this son named Andrew. He's a VC. this son named Andrew. He's a VC. this son named Andrew. He's a VC. He's dealing with AI AI every day. His He's dealing with AI AI every day. His He's dealing with AI AI every day. His companies use AI, some of them create companies use AI, some of them create companies use AI, some of them create AI, etc. Uh I had written the first memo AI, etc. Uh I had written the first memo AI, etc. Uh I had written the first memo around December 9th, as I recall, and around December 9th, as I recall, and around December 9th, as I recall, and then in early February he said, "Dad, so then in early February he said, "Dad, so then in early February he said, "Dad, so much has happened. You have to update much has happened. You have to update much has happened. You have to update the memo." And so, I I rewrote the memo the memo." And so, I I rewrote the memo the memo." And so, I I rewrote the memo entirely. entirely. entirely. >> You I was read I was rereading one of >> You I was read I was rereading one of >> You I was read I was rereading one of your old books. your old books. your old books. And uh you repeat this phrase a bunch, And uh you repeat this phrase a bunch, And uh you repeat this phrase a bunch, which is like, it's important to be which is like, it's important to be which is like, it's important to be rational and you can't get seduced into rational and you can't get seduced into rational and you can't get seduced into thinking something is a good idea thinking something is a good idea thinking something is a good idea because that's when smart people can because that's when smart people can because that's when smart people can make bad decisions, when you get make bad decisions, when you get make bad decisions, when you get emotional about something. But then when emotional about something. But then when emotional about something. But then when I was reading part two, I was reading it I was reading part two, I was reading it I was reading part two, I was reading it and I was like, "Howard, and I was like, "Howard, and I was like, "Howard, you sound a little seduced. You sound a you sound a little seduced. You sound a you sound a little seduced. You sound a little seduced. You sound like you're little seduced. You sound like you're little seduced. You sound like you're into this. into this. into this. Are you at all approaching this in an Are you at all approaching this in an Are you at all approaching this in an emotional way, you think?" emotional way, you think?" emotional way, you think?" >> It It depends on your definition of >> It It depends on your definition of >> It It depends on your definition of emotional. I emotional. I emotional. I upgraded my opinion of AI and its upgraded my opinion of AI and its upgraded my opinion of AI and its potential because it's potential because it's potential because it's um ability to talk about its own um ability to talk about its own um ability to talk about its own strengths and weaknesses, strengths and weaknesses, strengths and weaknesses, to use humor to use humor to use humor to to to put information in the context of me. put information in the context of me. put information in the context of me. To use what it knows about me. And you To use what it knows about me. And you To use what it knows about me. And you know, this is really uh know, this is really uh know, this is really uh uh exceptional stuff. uh exceptional stuff. uh exceptional stuff. There's a quality to AI There's a quality to AI There's a quality to AI uh or more than one quality, which uh uh or more than one quality, which uh uh or more than one quality, which uh are unprecedented, in my opinion. are unprecedented, in my opinion. are unprecedented, in my opinion. The first The first The first the obvious one is autonomy. the obvious one is autonomy. the obvious one is autonomy. All the other technological innovations All the other technological innovations All the other technological innovations from the railroad to from the railroad to from the railroad to computers, to the internet, etc., were computers, to the internet, etc., were computers, to the internet, etc., were all tools or uh things to speed up uh all tools or uh things to speed up uh all tools or uh things to speed up uh and increase productivity. and increase productivity. and increase productivity. There's never been anything with the There's never been anything with the There's never been anything with the quality of autonomy. quality of autonomy. quality of autonomy. The idea The idea The idea that it you can that it you can that it you can give it a job give it a job give it a job and not tell it how to do it, and it'll and not tell it how to do it, and it'll and not tell it how to do it, and it'll figure it out. figure it out. figure it out. Is really unique. And the it what comes Is really unique. And the it what comes Is really unique. And the it what comes with that yeah, of course, is this with that yeah, of course, is this with that yeah, of course, is this nagging concern nagging concern nagging concern that it may take over. So, that's that's that it may take over. So, that's that's that it may take over. So, that's that's really important. The other thing really important. The other thing really important. The other thing and this is not uh and this is not uh and this is not uh kind of uh quantifiable is kind of uh quantifiable is kind of uh quantifiable is there's never been anything, in my there's never been anything, in my there's never been anything, in my opinion so unpredictable. opinion so unpredictable. opinion so unpredictable. I don't think anybody knows the shape of I don't think anybody knows the shape of I don't think anybody knows the shape of the future. So, I I have never had that the future. So, I I have never had that the future. So, I I have never had that sense before. sense before. sense before. I never say I never thought that that I never say I never thought that that I never say I never thought that that the internet, for example was uh beyond the internet, for example was uh beyond the internet, for example was uh beyond comprehension or beyond prediction. comprehension or beyond prediction. comprehension or beyond prediction. >> Do you think that >> Do you think that >> Do you think that AI will be able to do what you do? And I AI will be able to do what you do? And I AI will be able to do what you do? And I know you talk about this in the the know you talk about this in the the know you talk about this in the the memo. memo. memo. And I got to be honest, when I read it I And I got to be honest, when I read it I And I got to be honest, when I read it I I you know, I almost felt like you know, I you know, I almost felt like you know, I you know, I almost felt like you know, you read stories about Warren Buffett you read stories about Warren Buffett you read stories about Warren Buffett reading the Moody's manual page by page reading the Moody's manual page by page reading the Moody's manual page by page 800 companies and trying to digest that 800 companies and trying to digest that 800 companies and trying to digest that information. Well, information. Well, information. Well, AI can do that in in a heartbeat, right? AI can do that in in a heartbeat, right? AI can do that in in a heartbeat, right? Like you know, a lot of the things that Like you know, a lot of the things that Like you know, a lot of the things that that go into making investment decisions that go into making investment decisions that go into making investment decisions it can do very well, very fast. it can do very well, very fast. it can do very well, very fast. And then also it's advancing so fast. And then also it's advancing so fast. And then also it's advancing so fast. So, you know, whatever we thought it So, you know, whatever we thought it So, you know, whatever we thought it could do 3 years ago is laughable could do 3 years ago is laughable could do 3 years ago is laughable compared to what it can do today. And as compared to what it can do today. And as compared to what it can do today. And as you pointed out, even 3 months ago. So, you pointed out, even 3 months ago. So, you pointed out, even 3 months ago. So, I guess in your heart of hearts, do you I guess in your heart of hearts, do you I guess in your heart of hearts, do you think, you know, in the in the future think, you know, in the in the future think, you know, in the in the future the next Howard Marks is not a not a the next Howard Marks is not a not a the next Howard Marks is not a not a human, but but maybe a human with AI or human, but but maybe a human with AI or human, but but maybe a human with AI or just AI? just AI? just AI? >> Everything I say on the subject I >> Everything I say on the subject I >> Everything I say on the subject I preface with I'm no expert, but I think preface with I'm no expert, but I think preface with I'm no expert, but I think I told the story in the memo about the I told the story in the memo about the I told the story in the memo about the fact that indexation uh put a lot of fact that indexation uh put a lot of fact that indexation uh put a lot of people out of the equity business people out of the equity business people out of the equity business because uh you know, it it disclosed because uh you know, it it disclosed because uh you know, it it disclosed that they couldn't do that they couldn't do that they couldn't do uh what they claimed to do. And most uh what they claimed to do. And most uh what they claimed to do. And most active equity investors underperformed active equity investors underperformed active equity investors underperformed the averages. the averages. the averages. And uh AI [clears throat] will unfrock And uh AI [clears throat] will unfrock And uh AI [clears throat] will unfrock or defrock another group of people whose or defrock another group of people whose or defrock another group of people whose talents are not as great as as they talents are not as great as as they talents are not as great as as they purport. purport. purport. I used to say about computers, you know, I used to say about computers, you know, I used to say about computers, you know, when I went to school and learned about when I went to school and learned about when I went to school and learned about computers, uh all they could do computers, uh all they could do computers, uh all they could do was read was read was read remember remember remember add, subtract, and compare. add, subtract, and compare. add, subtract, and compare. They could do it with a lot of data. They could do it with a lot of data. They could do it with a lot of data. They could do it really fast. They could They could do it really fast. They could They could do it really fast. They could do it without making do it without making do it without making arithmetic mistakes. They could do it arithmetic mistakes. They could do it arithmetic mistakes. They could do it without making emotional mistakes. without making emotional mistakes. without making emotional mistakes. So, while the list was limited So, while the list was limited So, while the list was limited it was still better than most people. it was still better than most people. it was still better than most people. Now, what's the list Now, what's the list Now, what's the list for AI? Is the list for AI unlimited for AI? Is the list for AI unlimited for AI? Is the list for AI unlimited or or or limited? That's that's a big part of the limited? That's that's a big part of the limited? That's that's a big part of the question right there. question right there. question right there. Uh I don't I don't know the answer. I Uh I don't I don't know the answer. I Uh I don't I don't know the answer. I Maybe you do. Maybe you do. Maybe you do. Um and then Um and then Um and then is there anything left that AI can't do? is there anything left that AI can't do? is there anything left that AI can't do? And one example is I think we've helped And one example is I think we've helped And one example is I think we've helped our clients our clients our clients over the years by not investing with bad over the years by not investing with bad over the years by not investing with bad people. people. people. And sometimes you talk to people And sometimes you talk to people And sometimes you talk to people and and and for undefinable reasons you just say, for undefinable reasons you just say, for undefinable reasons you just say, you know what? you know what? you know what? It doesn't feel right. As as somebody It doesn't feel right. As as somebody It doesn't feel right. As as somebody said to me, the hair on your back on said to me, the hair on your back on said to me, the hair on your back on your neck goes up. your neck goes up. your neck goes up. And if that's true And if that's true And if that's true and if AI doesn't have hair on its neck and if AI doesn't have hair on its neck and if AI doesn't have hair on its neck then maybe there's a role left for then maybe there's a role left for then maybe there's a role left for experienced investors with judgment. experienced investors with judgment. experienced investors with judgment. I I believe so. I I believe so. I I believe so. First of all, there will always be First of all, there will always be First of all, there will always be things for which there is no history to things for which there is no history to things for which there is no history to train on. train on. train on. And to the extent that that And to the extent that that And to the extent that that a certain big percentage of what AI does a certain big percentage of what AI does a certain big percentage of what AI does is knowing history and recognizing is knowing history and recognizing is knowing history and recognizing and extrapolating patterns. and extrapolating patterns. and extrapolating patterns. There will always be stuff There will always be stuff There will always be stuff for which there is no history. for which there is no history. for which there is no history. There are just some people who have a There are just some people who have a There are just some people who have a better understanding of the probability better understanding of the probability better understanding of the probability distribution that defines future events. distribution that defines future events. distribution that defines future events. >> I was reading this book on Steve Cohen. >> I was reading this book on Steve Cohen. >> I was reading this book on Steve Cohen. And there was this part where they were And there was this part where they were And there was this part where they were describing how he was kind of like the describing how he was kind of like the describing how he was kind of like the man at a very young age. They were like, man at a very young age. They were like, man at a very young age. They were like, he can just feel the ticker. He just he can just feel the ticker. He just he can just feel the ticker. He just like is in tune and in flow with it. And like is in tune and in flow with it. And like is in tune and in flow with it. And I was like, oh, that's beautiful, but I was like, oh, that's beautiful, but I was like, oh, that's beautiful, but like this I can't replicate that. And I like this I can't replicate that. And I like this I can't replicate that. And I was always curious about that because I was always curious about that because I was always curious about that because I think in one of your books, I think you think in one of your books, I think you think in one of your books, I think you had said something like, I can't make I had said something like, I can't make I had said something like, I can't make I can make someone better, but I don't can make someone better, but I don't can make someone better, but I don't think I can make them great. Can you think I can make them great. Can you think I can make them great. Can you talk to that about like what it is that talk to that about like what it is that talk to that about like what it is that makes someone who is a good investor makes someone who is a good investor makes someone who is a good investor good, but also how the average person good, but also how the average person good, but also how the average person could get better? Like or do you believe could get better? Like or do you believe could get better? Like or do you believe that's not that's not even possible that that's not that's not even possible that that's not that's not even possible that you just you have it or you don't? you just you have it or you don't? you just you have it or you don't? >> Well, in in my first book, The Most >> Well, in in my first book, The Most >> Well, in in my first book, The Most Important Thing Important Thing Important Thing Columbia, which published the book Columbia, which published the book Columbia, which published the book Uh, were talking about the They said, Uh, were talking about the They said, Uh, were talking about the They said, "Well, write us a sample chapter." "Well, write us a sample chapter." "Well, write us a sample chapter." So, I sat down and I wrote a chapter So, I sat down and I wrote a chapter So, I sat down and I wrote a chapter that I had never even thought about. that I had never even thought about. that I had never even thought about. And it turned out to be the first And it turned out to be the first And it turned out to be the first chapter in the book and it says, chapter in the book and it says, chapter in the book and it says, >> On this show, we have spent hours >> On this show, we have spent hours >> On this show, we have spent hours talking to some of the best investors talking to some of the best investors talking to some of the best investors alive. Well, lucky for you, the team at alive. Well, lucky for you, the team at alive. Well, lucky for you, the team at HubSpot, they have pulled out the HubSpot, they have pulled out the HubSpot, they have pulled out the principles that matter most and turned principles that matter most and turned principles that matter most and turned it into a very simple, easy-to-read it into a very simple, easy-to-read it into a very simple, easy-to-read wealth guide. wealth guide. wealth guide. It's 35 principles from the top It's 35 principles from the top It's 35 principles from the top investors. We're talking guys who have investors. We're talking guys who have investors. We're talking guys who have been on the pod like Howard Marks, been on the pod like Howard Marks, been on the pod like Howard Marks, Monish Pabrai, Morgan Housel, Cathie Monish Pabrai, Morgan Housel, Cathie Monish Pabrai, Morgan Housel, Cathie Wood, and a ton others. So, these are Wood, and a ton others. So, these are Wood, and a ton others. So, these are all their frameworks, their mental all their frameworks, their mental all their frameworks, their mental models, their rules, basically how to models, their rules, basically how to models, their rules, basically how to play the long game, and how to avoid play the long game, and how to avoid play the long game, and how to avoid ruin. You can get it in the link below. ruin. You can get it in the link below. ruin. You can get it in the link below. >> The most important thing is second-level >> The most important thing is second-level >> The most important thing is second-level thinking. Second-level thinking thinking. Second-level thinking thinking. Second-level thinking basically says, "If you don't see basically says, "If you don't see basically says, "If you don't see anything different from everybody else, anything different from everybody else, anything different from everybody else, you can't possibly be superior. So, to you can't possibly be superior. So, to you can't possibly be superior. So, to be superior, be superior, be superior, you have to at some point see something you have to at some point see something you have to at some point see something different from other people." What's different from other people." What's different from other people." What's called a variant perception. called a variant perception. called a variant perception. That you have to either think that the That you have to either think that the That you have to either think that the the the that the consensus of investors the the that the consensus of investors the the that the consensus of investors overstates the quality of the company, overstates the quality of the company, overstates the quality of the company, the growth rate of the company, the the growth rate of the company, the the growth rate of the company, the earning power of the company, or or earning power of the company, or or earning power of the company, or or maybe the multiple it deserves. And you maybe the multiple it deserves. And you maybe the multiple it deserves. And you have to have this variant perception and have to have this variant perception and have to have this variant perception and you have to bet you have to bet you have to bet on your perception. And you have to be on your perception. And you have to be on your perception. And you have to be right. right. right. So, that's for that's second-level So, that's for that's second-level So, that's for that's second-level thinking. I say in the book and when thinking. I say in the book and when thinking. I say in the book and when people ask me, I say, people ask me, I say, people ask me, I say, "Can you teach me to be a second-level "Can you teach me to be a second-level "Can you teach me to be a second-level thinker?" And the answer is no. I I said thinker?" And the answer is no. I I said thinker?" And the answer is no. I I said I say in the book, "I don't know." Uh, I say in the book, "I don't know." Uh, I say in the book, "I don't know." Uh, but I think it's I think it's more of no but I think it's I think it's more of no but I think it's I think it's more of no than yes. Because I what I say is, "I than yes. Because I what I say is, "I than yes. Because I what I say is, "I can teach you the importance of being a can teach you the importance of being a can teach you the importance of being a second-level thinker like I just have in second-level thinker like I just have in second-level thinker like I just have in this chapter, this chapter, this chapter, but I can't but I can't but I can't tell you how to have perceptions tell you how to have perceptions tell you how to have perceptions that are at odds with the consensus of that are at odds with the consensus of that are at odds with the consensus of investors and correct. You know, in investors and correct. You know, in investors and correct. You know, in basketball there's a saying you can't basketball there's a saying you can't basketball there's a saying you can't coach height. coach height. coach height. And I think there's something called And I think there's something called And I think there's something called insight. insight. insight. And I think some people have it and I And I think some people have it and I And I think some people have it and I don't know if AI can have it because don't know if AI can have it because don't know if AI can have it because when you know, when you talk about when you know, when you talk about when you know, when you talk about artificial general intelligence and and artificial general intelligence and and artificial general intelligence and and AGI is when a computer AGI is when a computer AGI is when a computer or AI can do everything that a human can or AI can do everything that a human can or AI can do everything that a human can do. do. do. Can it do that? Can it do that? Can it do that? Don't know. Don't know. Don't know. And that when I talk about the the And that when I talk about the the And that when I talk about the the the mysteries of AI, that's that's a big the mysteries of AI, that's that's a big the mysteries of AI, that's that's a big one of them. Are there things it can't one of them. Are there things it can't one of them. Are there things it can't won't be able to do even when it reaches won't be able to do even when it reaches won't be able to do even when it reaches full flower? full flower? full flower? >> Can you think back to some of the >> Can you think back to some of the >> Can you think back to some of the biggest calls that you've had? How biggest calls that you've had? How biggest calls that you've had? How strong did that feel? Did you still have strong did that feel? Did you still have strong did that feel? Did you still have doubt or was it 100% conviction? I'm doubt or was it 100% conviction? I'm doubt or was it 100% conviction? I'm curious to hear what it feels like. curious to hear what it feels like. curious to hear what it feels like. >> Great. I think in our last episode we >> Great. I think in our last episode we >> Great. I think in our last episode we talked about the day Lehman went under, talked about the day Lehman went under, talked about the day Lehman went under, you know, September 15th maybe of '08. you know, September 15th maybe of '08. you know, September 15th maybe of '08. And we had thought that there was going And we had thought that there was going And we had thought that there was going to be a mess and we had raised it in the to be a mess and we had raised it in the to be a mess and we had raised it in the distressed debt world, the biggest fund distressed debt world, the biggest fund distressed debt world, the biggest fund in history prior to '07 was our '02 fund in history prior to '07 was our '02 fund in history prior to '07 was our '02 fund which was 2 and 1/2 billion and in which was 2 and 1/2 billion and in which was 2 and 1/2 billion and in '07-'08 we raised 11 billion '07-'08 we raised 11 billion '07-'08 we raised 11 billion for for for a distressed debt fund because we a distressed debt fund because we a distressed debt fund because we thought that that there was a lot of thought that that there was a lot of thought that that there was a lot of distress coming. distress coming. distress coming. And we had it on the shelf, it wasn't it And we had it on the shelf, it wasn't it And we had it on the shelf, it wasn't it was for deployment was for deployment was for deployment when the stuff hit the fan. And Lehman when the stuff hit the fan. And Lehman when the stuff hit the fan. And Lehman goes under which I think qualifies as goes under which I think qualifies as goes under which I think qualifies as saying the stuff has hit the fan. But saying the stuff has hit the fan. But saying the stuff has hit the fan. But people are talking about the end of the people are talking about the end of the people are talking about the end of the world. world. world. And all the financial institutions are And all the financial institutions are And all the financial institutions are going to melt down and everything having going to melt down and everything having going to melt down and everything having to do with money is going to atomize. to do with money is going to atomize. to do with money is going to atomize. So, So, So, we were faced with the question. we were faced with the question. we were faced with the question. Do you the money? Do you the money? Do you the money? And there's no pattern recognition And there's no pattern recognition And there's no pattern recognition for the end of the world. for the end of the world. for the end of the world. And there's no, you know, And there's no, you know, And there's no, you know, in the in the pandemic, in the in the pandemic, in the in the pandemic, a Harvard epidemiologist a Harvard epidemiologist a Harvard epidemiologist said, "When we make decisions, we have said, "When we make decisions, we have said, "When we make decisions, we have data, data, data, analogies to past experience, and analogies to past experience, and analogies to past experience, and supposition." supposition." supposition." Well, at the time of the Lehman Well, at the time of the Lehman Well, at the time of the Lehman bankruptcy, we had no data bankruptcy, we had no data bankruptcy, we had no data and no prior experience. and no prior experience. and no prior experience. We only had supposition. We only had supposition. We only had supposition. So, this is an interesting question. Can So, this is an interesting question. Can So, this is an interesting question. Can AI have engaged in this kind of AI have engaged in this kind of AI have engaged in this kind of thinking? thinking? thinking? And what we said is And what we said is And what we said is that if the world if the financial world that if the world if the financial world that if the world if the financial world melts down melts down melts down and we invest, and we invest, and we invest, doesn't matter. doesn't matter. doesn't matter. But if But if But if we don't invest and the financial world we don't invest and the financial world we don't invest and the financial world doesn't melt down, then we didn't do our doesn't melt down, then we didn't do our doesn't melt down, then we didn't do our job. So, we have to do it. job. So, we have to do it. job. So, we have to do it. And we invested on that basis. And And we invested on that basis. And And we invested on that basis. And Bruce, Bruce, Bruce, who runs those funds, invested an who runs those funds, invested an who runs those funds, invested an average of $450 million a week for 15 average of $450 million a week for 15 average of $450 million a week for 15 weeks, $7 billion weeks, $7 billion weeks, $7 billion On that, well, was it only on that? We On that, well, was it only on that? We On that, well, was it only on that? We also on quantitative measures, assuming also on quantitative measures, assuming also on quantitative measures, assuming the world doesn't melt down, we were the world doesn't melt down, we were the world doesn't melt down, we were getting great bargains. getting great bargains. getting great bargains. We were buying cup the debt of companies We were buying cup the debt of companies We were buying cup the debt of companies where we would break even where we would break even where we would break even if companies that had been bought out by if companies that had been bought out by if companies that had been bought out by private equity guys two, three, four private equity guys two, three, four private equity guys two, three, four years earlier, if they ended up being years earlier, if they ended up being years earlier, if they ended up being worth worth worth a fifth or a fourth of what they had a fifth or a fourth of what they had a fifth or a fourth of what they had paid, we would still be okay. paid, we would still be okay. paid, we would still be okay. So, So, So, that was pretty easy that was pretty easy that was pretty easy quantitatively. But we we were quantitatively. But we we were quantitatively. But we we were absolutely not confident. absolutely not confident. absolutely not confident. >> You weren't confident? >> You weren't confident? >> You weren't confident? >> No. >> No. >> No. >> I thought you were going to say the the >> I thought you were going to say the the >> I thought you were going to say the the opposite of that. opposite of that. opposite of that. >> No, but I mean, we we're the kind of >> No, but I mean, we we're the kind of >> No, but I mean, we we're the kind of people people people who always say, who always say, who always say, I could be wrong or it could work in a I could be wrong or it could work in a I could be wrong or it could work in a in a way that's never been seen before. in a way that's never been seen before. in a way that's never been seen before. And so And so And so we all we always I wrote a memo we all we always I wrote a memo we all we always I wrote a memo three or four years ago three or four years ago three or four years ago called taking the temperature about the called taking the temperature about the called taking the temperature about the five major calls five major calls five major calls macro calls that I made macro calls that I made macro calls that I made in the last in the last in the last well in the last 26 years and they're well in the last 26 years and they're well in the last 26 years and they're all all all with some doubt. with some doubt. with some doubt. When the markets are crashing When the markets are crashing When the markets are crashing why are they crashing? why are they crashing? why are they crashing? They're crashing because the news is They're crashing because the news is They're crashing because the news is terrible. terrible. terrible. I read the same newspapers. I read the same newspapers. I read the same newspapers. I watch the same shows on TV. I'm I watch the same shows on TV. I'm I watch the same shows on TV. I'm I'm attached to the same news feeds. I I'm attached to the same news feeds. I I'm attached to the same news feeds. I see the terrible news. see the terrible news. see the terrible news. It looks terrible to me. It looks terrible to me. It looks terrible to me. I overcome it in some way and conclude I overcome it in some way and conclude I overcome it in some way and conclude no, I should invest. no, I should invest. no, I should invest. But But But I'm not immune I'm not immune I'm not immune to have what everybody else is reading. to have what everybody else is reading. to have what everybody else is reading. If you do these things without If you do these things without If you do these things without any any any trepidation trepidation trepidation you know, maybe there's something wrong you know, maybe there's something wrong you know, maybe there's something wrong with you. with you. with you. But you know, people who look at But you know, people who look at But you know, people who look at the world probabilistically the world probabilistically the world probabilistically and admit to and admit to and admit to uh uh uh ignorance and uncertainty ignorance and uncertainty ignorance and uncertainty can't act can't act can't act without trepidation. without trepidation. without trepidation. >> Hey, can you tell me about raising $11 >> Hey, can you tell me about raising $11 >> Hey, can you tell me about raising $11 billion cuz you said that like very billion cuz you said that like very billion cuz you said that like very casually like so we raised an $11 casually like so we raised an $11 casually like so we raised an $11 billion fund and that's like if I just billion fund and that's like if I just billion fund and that's like if I just said hey, I just turned water into wine. said hey, I just turned water into wine. said hey, I just turned water into wine. I think for for for most people I think for for for most people I think for for for most people so I'm just actually curious. How does so I'm just actually curious. How does so I'm just actually curious. How does that happen? Is that is that you go to that happen? Is that is that you go to that happen? Is that is that you go to people and you say hey, we think the people and you say hey, we think the people and you say hey, we think the world's you make a really persuasive world's you make a really persuasive world's you make a really persuasive case. Are you using a pitch deck? Is case. Are you using a pitch deck? Is case. Are you using a pitch deck? Is this just prior relationships? Are you this just prior relationships? Are you this just prior relationships? Are you selling upside? Are you selling safety selling upside? Are you selling safety selling upside? Are you selling safety against downside and fear? Like what against downside and fear? Like what against downside and fear? Like what what actually goes in what actually goes in what actually goes in to raising $11 billion like that? to raising $11 billion like that? to raising $11 billion like that? >> So there's a list of things. >> So there's a list of things. >> So there's a list of things. Number one, certainly prior experience. Number one, certainly prior experience. Number one, certainly prior experience. Relationships. People have, you know, we Relationships. People have, you know, we Relationships. People have, you know, we started this business in 1988. started this business in 1988. started this business in 1988. And And And so, we're talking about 20 years later. so, we're talking about 20 years later. so, we're talking about 20 years later. And in the 80 in the 20 years, we And in the 80 in the 20 years, we And in the 80 in the 20 years, we managed a lot of money and had very good managed a lot of money and had very good managed a lot of money and had very good results for a lot of people. And so, you results for a lot of people. And so, you results for a lot of people. And so, you can work on that reservoir of goodwill. can work on that reservoir of goodwill. can work on that reservoir of goodwill. Number two, that this strategy is Number two, that this strategy is Number two, that this strategy is particularly well suited for crisis. particularly well suited for crisis. particularly well suited for crisis. And we had managed money through a few And we had managed money through a few And we had managed money through a few crises, crises, crises, 1991 and 01 02, 1991 and 01 02, 1991 and 01 02, and done and done and done exceptionally well. So, we were able to exceptionally well. So, we were able to exceptionally well. So, we were able to convince people that number one, so many convince people that number one, so many convince people that number one, so many of your investments are set up for of your investments are set up for of your investments are set up for prosperity, prosperity, prosperity, this is a good way to hedge it by making this is a good way to hedge it by making this is a good way to hedge it by making an investment that will do particularly an investment that will do particularly an investment that will do particularly well if if the stuff hits the fan. But well if if the stuff hits the fan. But well if if the stuff hits the fan. But we were also able to call attention to we were also able to call attention to we were also able to call attention to flaws flaws flaws in the environment. in the environment. in the environment. The things that gave rise to the global The things that gave rise to the global The things that gave rise to the global financial crisis, we could talk about financial crisis, we could talk about financial crisis, we could talk about and we could point out. And you know, and we could point out. And you know, and we could point out. And you know, the fact that the market the fact that the market the fact that the market was not acting as a disciplinarian, was not acting as a disciplinarian, was not acting as a disciplinarian, which is its main job. Main job is to is which is its main job. Main job is to is which is its main job. Main job is to is to, you know, people come in and say, "I to, you know, people come in and say, "I to, you know, people come in and say, "I want money for this, this, and this." want money for this, this, and this." want money for this, this, and this." And the market's job is to say, "No, And the market's job is to say, "No, And the market's job is to say, "No, that doesn't make any sense. That's a that doesn't make any sense. That's a that doesn't make any sense. That's a stupid idea. We're not going to invest stupid idea. We're not going to invest stupid idea. We're not going to invest in that." That's the job. And sometimes in that." That's the job. And sometimes in that." That's the job. And sometimes the market doesn't do that job. And when the market doesn't do that job. And when the market doesn't do that job. And when the market doesn't do that job, then the market doesn't do that job, then the market doesn't do that job, then dumb ideas get financed. dumb ideas get financed. dumb ideas get financed. And And And and when they turn out to be dumb, and when they turn out to be dumb, and when they turn out to be dumb, people lose money. people lose money. people lose money. So, I think we were able to convince So, I think we were able to convince So, I think we were able to convince people that some dumb things were people that some dumb things were people that some dumb things were happening. And then, of course, there's happening. And then, of course, there's happening. And then, of course, there's great respect for for Bruce Karsh, for great respect for for Bruce Karsh, for great respect for for Bruce Karsh, for the investing he's done of over the the investing he's done of over the the investing he's done of over the years. I think those are the main years. I think those are the main years. I think those are the main reasons reasons reasons why we were able to do it. why we were able to do it. why we were able to do it. And by the way, you hit the nail on the And by the way, you hit the nail on the And by the way, you hit the nail on the head. We did it in advance of the head. We did it in advance of the head. We did it in advance of the crisis. crisis. crisis. The best time to invest is in a crisis. The best time to invest is in a crisis. The best time to invest is in a crisis. You can't raise money during the crisis You can't raise money during the crisis You can't raise money during the crisis because the news is so terrible. because the news is so terrible. because the news is so terrible. So, you know, my wife and I have a So, you know, my wife and I have a So, you know, my wife and I have a favorite movie we watched called uh Spy favorite movie we watched called uh Spy favorite movie we watched called uh Spy Game Game Game with Robert Redford. with Robert Redford. with Robert Redford. And uh And uh And uh he says in the Red- Redford says, "When he says in the Red- Redford says, "When he says in the Red- Redford says, "When did Noah build the ark?" did Noah build the ark?" did Noah build the ark?" Before the flood. Before the flood. Before the flood. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> You got to build the ark before the >> You got to build the ark before the >> You got to build the ark before the flood. You have to have some sense that flood. You have to have some sense that flood. You have to have some sense that the that there may be a flood. But, one the that there may be a flood. But, one the that there may be a flood. But, one other point. other point. other point. In the in the prior 20 years, In the in the prior 20 years, In the in the prior 20 years, there had been these occasions when we there had been these occasions when we there had been these occasions when we thought there was going to be a great thought there was going to be a great thought there was going to be a great investment opportunity. investment opportunity. investment opportunity. And it And it And it we were generally right because we took we were generally right because we took we were generally right because we took the temperature of the market the temperature of the market the temperature of the market accurately, and we raised a large fund, accurately, and we raised a large fund, accurately, and we raised a large fund, and we invested in it, and we made a lot and we invested in it, and we made a lot and we invested in it, and we made a lot of money. of money. of money. But then, But then, But then, our next fund was smaller our next fund was smaller our next fund was smaller because we thought the opportunities because we thought the opportunities because we thought the opportunities weren't as good. Now, most people in the weren't as good. Now, most people in the weren't as good. Now, most people in the investment business, if they have a fund investment business, if they have a fund investment business, if they have a fund that does great, the next fund is bigger that does great, the next fund is bigger that does great, the next fund is bigger cuz they can sell on the back of those cuz they can sell on the back of those cuz they can sell on the back of those results. results. results. But we make it smaller because we think But we make it smaller because we think But we make it smaller because we think those results mean those results mean those results mean that things have appreciated and are not that things have appreciated and are not that things have appreciated and are not so attractive. so attractive. so attractive. I I think that having done that for 20 I I think that having done that for 20 I I think that having done that for 20 years, years, years, I think we gained a lot of credibility, I think we gained a lot of credibility, I think we gained a lot of credibility, and people tend I think people tend to and people tend I think people tend to and people tend I think people tend to say when Howard and Bruce say there's say when Howard and Bruce say there's say when Howard and Bruce say there's a great opportunity, they're not just a great opportunity, they're not just a great opportunity, they're not just trying to raise money, they really trying to raise money, they really trying to raise money, they really believe it, and they're and they tend to believe it, and they're and they tend to believe it, and they're and they tend to be right. be right. be right. And sometimes you have to speak against And sometimes you have to speak against And sometimes you have to speak against your own interest. your own interest. your own interest. And admit your limitations, and admit And admit your limitations, and admit And admit your limitations, and admit your uncertainties. So, in 19 your uncertainties. So, in 19 your uncertainties. So, in 19 uh uh uh 98, 98, 98, we had the meltdown of Long-Term Capital we had the meltdown of Long-Term Capital we had the meltdown of Long-Term Capital Management, we had a Russian Ruble Management, we had a Russian Ruble Management, we had a Russian Ruble crisis, we had a crisis, we had a crisis, we had a panic in Southeast Asia. panic in Southeast Asia. panic in Southeast Asia. And And And especially with Long-Term going under, especially with Long-Term going under, especially with Long-Term going under, one of the skilled portfolio managers, one of the skilled portfolio managers, one of the skilled portfolio managers, young portfolio managers at Oaktree, young portfolio managers at Oaktree, young portfolio managers at Oaktree, came to me. He says, "I think this is came to me. He says, "I think this is came to me. He says, "I think this is it. it. it. I think we're melting down. I think we're melting down. I think we're melting down. It's all over." It's all over." It's all over." And I said, "Well, tell me your And I said, "Well, tell me your And I said, "Well, tell me your concerns." And he laid out his concerns. concerns." And he laid out his concerns. concerns." And he laid out his concerns. And I said, "Okay, I I understand it. And I said, "Okay, I I understand it. And I said, "Okay, I I understand it. Now go back to your desk and do your Now go back to your desk and do your Now go back to your desk and do your job." job." job." You know, You know, You know, a battle hero a battle hero a battle hero is not somebody who's unafraid. is not somebody who's unafraid. is not somebody who's unafraid. It's somebody who's afraid, but does it It's somebody who's afraid, but does it It's somebody who's afraid, but does it anyway. If you're running into a hell of anyway. If you're running into a hell of anyway. If you're running into a hell of bullets and you're not afraid, there's bullets and you're not afraid, there's bullets and you're not afraid, there's something wrong with you. something wrong with you. something wrong with you. But you do it anyway, because it's what But you do it anyway, because it's what But you do it anyway, because it's what you have to do. you have to do. you have to do. And I don't want to elevate, I'm not And I don't want to elevate, I'm not And I don't want to elevate, I'm not saying we're analogous to a saying we're analogous to a saying we're analogous to a a combat hero, but a combat hero, but a combat hero, but you have to do it despite your you have to do it despite your you have to do it despite your trepidation. And if By the way, if you trepidation. And if By the way, if you trepidation. And if By the way, if you wait until you have nothing to be afraid wait until you have nothing to be afraid wait until you have nothing to be afraid about, about, about, probably the opportunity has passed. probably the opportunity has passed. probably the opportunity has passed. >> That's a great point. You mentioned >> That's a great point. You mentioned >> That's a great point. You mentioned Bruce, and I wanted to ask you about Bruce, and I wanted to ask you about Bruce, and I wanted to ask you about this, cuz it seems like you guys have this, cuz it seems like you guys have this, cuz it seems like you guys have had a very long-term partnership now at had a very long-term partnership now at had a very long-term partnership now at what, 30-plus years? what, 30-plus years? what, 30-plus years? I think people don't talk about that I think people don't talk about that I think people don't talk about that enough, the value of compounding in a enough, the value of compounding in a enough, the value of compounding in a relationship, and how to be a good relationship, and how to be a good relationship, and how to be a good partner for the long-term. You know, a partner for the long-term. You know, a partner for the long-term. You know, a bad partnership can ruin you, but we bad partnership can ruin you, but we bad partnership can ruin you, but we don't really talk about what it takes to don't really talk about what it takes to don't really talk about what it takes to make a great partnership at the same make a great partnership at the same make a great partnership at the same time. If you were going to teach me and time. If you were going to teach me and time. If you were going to teach me and Sam, if we said, "Hey, Ben and Sam want Sam, if we said, "Hey, Ben and Sam want Sam, if we said, "Hey, Ben and Sam want to do this podcast for 30 years." Or, to do this podcast for 30 years." Or, to do this podcast for 30 years." Or, you know, I have a business partner, you know, I have a business partner, you know, I have a business partner, Ben, I want to be in business with him Ben, I want to be in business with him Ben, I want to be in business with him for 30 years. What do we got to get for 30 years. What do we got to get for 30 years. What do we got to get right to do that? right to do that? right to do that? >> Well, it's a great question, Jen, and >> Well, it's a great question, Jen, and >> Well, it's a great question, Jen, and it's very important. Bruce and I have it's very important. Bruce and I have it's very important. Bruce and I have been partners for 39 years this month. been partners for 39 years this month. been partners for 39 years this month. And it's one of the greatest things in And it's one of the greatest things in And it's one of the greatest things in our lives. our lives. our lives. After I think we would both say that After I think we would both say that After I think we would both say that after family after family after family and and maybe some good friendships and and maybe some good friendships and and maybe some good friendships it's really the best thing we've had. it's really the best thing we've had. it's really the best thing we've had. We've worked together closely for all We've worked together closely for all We've worked together closely for all that period. We've obviously produced a that period. We've obviously produced a that period. We've obviously produced a lot of success. lot of success. lot of success. Had a lot of fun. Had a lot of fun. Had a lot of fun. Have have never had a fight. We have Have have never had a fight. We have Have have never had a fight. We have intellectual disagreements but we've intellectual disagreements but we've intellectual disagreements but we've never had a fight. Probably because never had a fight. Probably because never had a fight. Probably because neither of us is really a financial neither of us is really a financial neither of us is really a financial maximizer. maximizer. maximizer. And a lot of fights And a lot of fights And a lot of fights are probably about money. The bedrock of are probably about money. The bedrock of are probably about money. The bedrock of our relationship is mutual respect. our relationship is mutual respect. our relationship is mutual respect. And I think it would be very hard to And I think it would be very hard to And I think it would be very hard to have a have a have a successful long-term relationship with successful long-term relationship with successful long-term relationship with the partner if you didn't have respect the partner if you didn't have respect the partner if you didn't have respect for each other. And that ties into for each other. And that ties into for each other. And that ties into something I wrote in '02, I think. But something I wrote in '02, I think. But something I wrote in '02, I think. But in '02, I wrote a memo called The Most in '02, I wrote a memo called The Most in '02, I wrote a memo called The Most Important Thing. And Important Thing. And Important Thing. And there was a section in there which there was a section in there which there was a section in there which talked about having a successful talked about having a successful talked about having a successful partnership. partnership. partnership. And I said the key to a successful And I said the key to a successful And I said the key to a successful partnership partnership partnership is shared values and complementary is shared values and complementary is shared values and complementary skills. skills. skills. If you don't share values, I don't think If you don't share values, I don't think If you don't share values, I don't think you can have a successful partnership. you can have a successful partnership. you can have a successful partnership. Let's say one person is super aggressive Let's say one person is super aggressive Let's say one person is super aggressive and the other is a chicken. and the other is a chicken. and the other is a chicken. One person is super ethical One person is super ethical One person is super ethical and the other one likes to cut corners. and the other one likes to cut corners. and the other one likes to cut corners. I don't think you can have a successful I don't think you can have a successful I don't think you can have a successful relationship partnership. And I've seen relationship partnership. And I've seen relationship partnership. And I've seen many, many, you know, I mean many, many, you know, I mean many, many, you know, I mean a friend of mine a friend of mine a friend of mine when I was a kid, AT&T went public. Can when I was a kid, AT&T went public. Can when I was a kid, AT&T went public. Can you imagine the days before AT&T was was you imagine the days before AT&T was was you imagine the days before AT&T was was public? But anyway, they went public. public? But anyway, they went public. public? But anyway, they went public. They It was the biggest deal in history They It was the biggest deal in history They It was the biggest deal in history and and they had a full-page tombstone and and they had a full-page tombstone and and they had a full-page tombstone ad in the newspaper. ad in the newspaper. ad in the newspaper. And it listed all the investment firms And it listed all the investment firms And it listed all the investment firms that were the investment bankers. And that were the investment bankers. And that were the investment bankers. And there were probably 40. there were probably 40. there were probably 40. And a friend of mine, Ed Ramsdell And a friend of mine, Ed Ramsdell And a friend of mine, Ed Ramsdell he used to carry that out around and he used to carry that out around and he used to carry that out around and every time one went out of business he every time one went out of business he every time one went out of business he would would would mark it off. And eventually I think they mark it off. And eventually I think they mark it off. And eventually I think they almost all disappeared except for almost all disappeared except for almost all disappeared except for Goldman Sachs. Goldman Sachs. Goldman Sachs. But why do they why do they go under? But why do they why do they go under? But why do they why do they go under? You have some cowboys and some chickens. You have some cowboys and some chickens. You have some cowboys and some chickens. And you know And you know And you know and when in bad times the chickens say and when in bad times the chickens say and when in bad times the chickens say the cowboys are getting us killed. the cowboys are getting us killed. the cowboys are getting us killed. And in good times the cowboys say the And in good times the cowboys say the And in good times the cowboys say the chickens are holding us back. chickens are holding us back. chickens are holding us back. And they disparage each other. So you And they disparage each other. So you And they disparage each other. So you have to share values in my opinion. have to share values in my opinion. have to share values in my opinion. The other thing is The other thing is The other thing is you have to have complementary skills. you have to have complementary skills. you have to have complementary skills. So So So the beauty of a partnership is when your the beauty of a partnership is when your the beauty of a partnership is when your partner can do things you can't. partner can do things you can't. partner can do things you can't. That means that you are both additive to That means that you are both additive to That means that you are both additive to each other, synergistic. If I can do each other, synergistic. If I can do each other, synergistic. If I can do everything you can do or if I think everything you can do or if I think everything you can do or if I think that, what do I need you for? that, what do I need you for? that, what do I need you for? It's not going to last very long cuz It's not going to last very long cuz It's not going to last very long cuz eventually I'm going to say you're eventually I'm going to say you're eventually I'm going to say you're overpaid. I don't need you. overpaid. I don't need you. overpaid. I don't need you. And And And the beauty of my relationship with Bruce the beauty of my relationship with Bruce the beauty of my relationship with Bruce is that we both recognize that there are is that we both recognize that there are is that we both recognize that there are things that the other is good at that things that the other is good at that things that the other is good at that we're not we're not we're not and that the other wants to is willing and that the other wants to is willing and that the other wants to is willing to do that we don't want to do. For to do that we don't want to do. For to do that we don't want to do. For example, from the very beginning Bruce example, from the very beginning Bruce example, from the very beginning Bruce approached me in in '87 approached me in in '87 approached me in in '87 with the idea of a distressed debt fund. with the idea of a distressed debt fund. with the idea of a distressed debt fund. You know, I went into the high yield You know, I went into the high yield You know, I went into the high yield bond business in '78 and bond business in '78 and bond business in '78 and he had a a background in law and got he had a a background in law and got he had a a background in law and got into into into some distressed investments which went some distressed investments which went some distressed investments which went well and he said came to me said we well and he said came to me said we well and he said came to me said we should do a distressed debt fund. And should do a distressed debt fund. And should do a distressed debt fund. And and it was quite a novel idea. But from and it was quite a novel idea. But from and it was quite a novel idea. But from the beginning the beginning the beginning you know, I go on the road and talk to you know, I go on the road and talk to you know, I go on the road and talk to people people people and Bruce stays back and manages the and Bruce stays back and manages the and Bruce stays back and manages the money. I go on podcasts with people like money. I go on podcasts with people like money. I go on podcasts with people like you you you and Bruce doesn't. But the third element and Bruce doesn't. But the third element and Bruce doesn't. But the third element is you got to be appreciative. is you got to be appreciative. is you got to be appreciative. And you have to And you have to And you have to thank your lucky stars that you have a thank your lucky stars that you have a thank your lucky stars that you have a partner who will do the stuff you don't partner who will do the stuff you don't partner who will do the stuff you don't want to do. want to do. want to do. >> Can you do the same towards parenting? >> Can you do the same towards parenting? >> Can you do the same towards parenting? Because both on this episode and last Because both on this episode and last Because both on this episode and last one, one, one, you reference your son a bunch. Do you you reference your son a bunch. Do you you reference your son a bunch. Do you have any insights into how you've been have any insights into how you've been have any insights into how you've been able to raise a kid that you not just able to raise a kid that you not just able to raise a kid that you not just love, but you enjoy being around? love, but you enjoy being around? love, but you enjoy being around? >> Well, you know, >> Well, you know, >> Well, you know, uh uh uh I think it was Forbes I think it was Forbes I think it was Forbes 30 or 40 years ago had an article about 30 or 40 years ago had an article about 30 or 40 years ago had an article about so-and-so who was the only shrink with so-and-so who was the only shrink with so-and-so who was the only shrink with an office on Wall Street. an office on Wall Street. an office on Wall Street. And they asked this guy And they asked this guy And they asked this guy about his patients' about his patients' about his patients' problems. problems. problems. And he said that his patients' problems, And he said that his patients' problems, And he said that his patients' problems, and they were all men, of course, cuz it and they were all men, of course, cuz it and they were all men, of course, cuz it was Wall Street a long time ago, his was Wall Street a long time ago, his was Wall Street a long time ago, his patients' problems were inversely patients' problems were inversely patients' problems were inversely proportional to the support they got proportional to the support they got proportional to the support they got from their fathers. We had people over from their fathers. We had people over from their fathers. We had people over for dinner last night, for dinner last night, for dinner last night, uh and one of the guys uh and one of the guys uh and one of the guys we we and we're talking about so-and-so we we and we're talking about so-and-so we we and we're talking about so-and-so who was a character of some kind. And who was a character of some kind. And who was a character of some kind. And one of the guys said, "Well, you know one of the guys said, "Well, you know one of the guys said, "Well, you know what? His father treated him like hell. what? His father treated him like hell. what? His father treated him like hell. I just never wanted to be that father." I just never wanted to be that father." I just never wanted to be that father." And it's amazing how many men, and And it's amazing how many men, and And it's amazing how many men, and especially so successful men, have to especially so successful men, have to especially so successful men, have to assert assert assert their superiority over their sons. their superiority over their sons. their superiority over their sons. Maybe daughters, too, but I think it's Maybe daughters, too, but I think it's Maybe daughters, too, but I think it's more with sons. And I guess it's more with sons. And I guess it's more with sons. And I guess it's Freudian or or something else. But it's Freudian or or something else. But it's Freudian or or something else. But it's What a terrible thing What a terrible thing What a terrible thing that you have to you you had this kid that you have to you you had this kid that you have to you you had this kid and you have to prove you're smarter. and you have to prove you're smarter. and you have to prove you're smarter. And so, you know, I mean, I always let And so, you know, I mean, I always let And so, you know, I mean, I always let Andrew Andrew Andrew be smarter than me in in some things. be smarter than me in in some things. be smarter than me in in some things. Uh and of course, I always gave him full Uh and of course, I always gave him full Uh and of course, I always gave him full support in the things he wanted to do. support in the things he wanted to do. support in the things he wanted to do. If your kids want to do something, and If your kids want to do something, and If your kids want to do something, and A, it's not going to be injurious, A, it's not going to be injurious, A, it's not going to be injurious, uh and uh yeah, I think uh and uh yeah, I think uh and uh yeah, I think maybe there's no B. Let him do it. maybe there's no B. Let him do it. maybe there's no B. Let him do it. Like when when uh Like when when uh Like when when uh when my daughter was getting out of when my daughter was getting out of when my daughter was getting out of lower school and had to choose an upper lower school and had to choose an upper lower school and had to choose an upper school, school, school, uh she applied to the two good schools uh she applied to the two good schools uh she applied to the two good schools in LA, got in, in LA, got in, in LA, got in, and and and we let her choose. My wife and I had a we let her choose. My wife and I had a we let her choose. My wife and I had a sense for which one we wanted her to go sense for which one we wanted her to go sense for which one we wanted her to go to, to, to, but we concluded that but we concluded that but we concluded that like I always say, we could be wrong. like I always say, we could be wrong. like I always say, we could be wrong. Our choice could be the wrong choice. Our choice could be the wrong choice. Our choice could be the wrong choice. And anyway, And anyway, And anyway, of the two choices, while one might be of the two choices, while one might be of the two choices, while one might be better than the other, neither was a bad better than the other, neither was a bad better than the other, neither was a bad choice. So, if that's true, let the kid choice. So, if that's true, let the kid choice. So, if that's true, let the kid make the choice. And they get experience make the choice. And they get experience make the choice. And they get experience with making choices. And maybe they get with making choices. And maybe they get with making choices. And maybe they get a a a uh experience with making uh experience with making uh experience with making incorrect choices, which is very incorrect choices, which is very incorrect choices, which is very important. important. important. >> On the subject of choice, I have a I'm >> On the subject of choice, I have a I'm >> On the subject of choice, I have a I'm I'm interested to know, you know, when I'm interested to know, you know, when I'm interested to know, you know, when you were younger, you let's say you're you were younger, you let's say you're you were younger, you let's say you're 21 years old and you're trying to figure 21 years old and you're trying to figure 21 years old and you're trying to figure out what you want to do with your life. out what you want to do with your life. out what you want to do with your life. Probably one of the more important Probably one of the more important Probably one of the more important questions you should figure out at some questions you should figure out at some questions you should figure out at some point is what do I want to actually do point is what do I want to actually do point is what do I want to actually do every day for 8 hours a day, that half every day for 8 hours a day, that half every day for 8 hours a day, that half my waking hours. And I doubt that, you my waking hours. And I doubt that, you my waking hours. And I doubt that, you know, a lot of 19-year-olds wake up and know, a lot of 19-year-olds wake up and know, a lot of 19-year-olds wake up and say, say, say, "I want to work with distressed debt and "I want to work with distressed debt and "I want to work with distressed debt and bonds." You know, it's not a That's not bonds." You know, it's not a That's not bonds." You know, it's not a That's not a knowable answer at that stage. What do a knowable answer at that stage. What do a knowable answer at that stage. What do you think is the right approach to you think is the right approach to you think is the right approach to figuring out your thing? figuring out your thing? figuring out your thing? >> First, I want to say up front and that >> First, I want to say up front and that >> First, I want to say up front and that the thing you describe I did a the thing you describe I did a the thing you describe I did a a terrible job of. I was unconscious. a terrible job of. I was unconscious. a terrible job of. I was unconscious. The decisions I made in my first The decisions I made in my first The decisions I made in my first 20 years, 20 years, 20 years, as they say in in in religion, I did not as they say in in in religion, I did not as they say in in in religion, I did not apply intention. apply intention. apply intention. I just I let other people make the I just I let other people make the I just I let other people make the decision. I made decisions haphazardly. decision. I made decisions haphazardly. decision. I made decisions haphazardly. I didn't think about it a lot. Um I'm I didn't think about it a lot. Um I'm I didn't think about it a lot. Um I'm embarrassed uh embarrassed uh embarrassed uh at at how terrible my decision-making at at how terrible my decision-making at at how terrible my decision-making process was. In fact, it's it's a process was. In fact, it's it's a process was. In fact, it's it's a misnomer to apply that term. misnomer to apply that term. misnomer to apply that term. But, having said that, I I think it's But, having said that, I I think it's But, having said that, I I think it's desirable to make desirable to make desirable to make your choices with intention, your choices with intention, your choices with intention, well-reasoned, etc. And what I tell kids well-reasoned, etc. And what I tell kids well-reasoned, etc. And what I tell kids is my favorite quote is from a writer is my favorite quote is from a writer is my favorite quote is from a writer named Christopher Morley named Christopher Morley named Christopher Morley who said there is only one success who said there is only one success who said there is only one success to live your life your own way. to live your life your own way. to live your life your own way. I think it's a beautiful quote. I think it's a beautiful quote. I think it's a beautiful quote. You know, I go to Wharton and Harvard You know, I go to Wharton and Harvard You know, I go to Wharton and Harvard and and all these places and Columbia. and and all these places and Columbia. and and all these places and Columbia. And and I say, "And you know, the fact And and I say, "And you know, the fact And and I say, "And you know, the fact that you're that you're that you're in this room probably means in this room probably means in this room probably means that you can live your life your own that you can live your life your own that you can live your life your own way. You probably have what it takes to way. You probably have what it takes to way. You probably have what it takes to live your life your own way, live your life your own way, live your life your own way, intellectually and intellectually and intellectually and work ethic is a word." work ethic is a word." work ethic is a word." But you have to figure out what it is. But you have to figure out what it is. But you have to figure out what it is. That's the hard part. That's the hard part. That's the hard part. Who are you? Who are you? Who are you? And what I say to them is, "Try to find And what I say to them is, "Try to find And what I say to them is, "Try to find something that will play to your something that will play to your something that will play to your strengths, strengths, strengths, avoid your weaknesses, avoid your weaknesses, avoid your weaknesses, and make you happy." What that means is, and make you happy." What that means is, and make you happy." What that means is, "Well, that sounds obvious. Well, who "Well, that sounds obvious. Well, who "Well, that sounds obvious. Well, who would who the hell wouldn't wouldn't would who the hell wouldn't wouldn't would who the hell wouldn't wouldn't follow that instruction?" follow that instruction?" follow that instruction?" Well, the answer is what it means is you Well, the answer is what it means is you Well, the answer is what it means is you can't let your friends decide what you can't let your friends decide what you can't let your friends decide what you should do. should do. should do. You can't do things because your friends You can't do things because your friends You can't do things because your friends are doing them. are doing them. are doing them. You can't let society decide what you You can't let society decide what you You can't let society decide what you should do. should do. should do. You can't let your parents decide what You can't let your parents decide what You can't let your parents decide what you should do. you should do. you should do. You have to think it out for yourself. You have to think it out for yourself. You have to think it out for yourself. Having said that Having said that Having said that it's very difficult because it's very difficult because it's very difficult because it's hard to know yourself. it's hard to know yourself. it's hard to know yourself. And And And we know we know we know that in 20 years you'll be a different that in 20 years you'll be a different that in 20 years you'll be a different person. person. person. How can you make a decision today on How can you make a decision today on How can you make a decision today on what will make that person happy? Very what will make that person happy? Very what will make that person happy? Very difficult, but you got to try. difficult, but you got to try. difficult, but you got to try. That's my advice which which I didn't That's my advice which which I didn't That's my advice which which I didn't take when I was a kid and I was take when I was a kid and I was take when I was a kid and I was derelict, but I got lucky. derelict, but I got lucky. derelict, but I got lucky. >> Well, you eventually did become >> Well, you eventually did become >> Well, you eventually did become as you described what living as you described what living as you described what living well-intentioned. well-intentioned. well-intentioned. >> Yes. must have changed. What Do you >> Yes. must have changed. What Do you >> Yes. must have changed. What Do you remember Did you do any exercises to remember Did you do any exercises to remember Did you do any exercises to become that way? become that way? become that way? >> Not that I recall. >> Not that I recall. >> Not that I recall. I think part of it, you know, and I said I think part of it, you know, and I said I think part of it, you know, and I said I said for the next I said for the next I said for the next 25 years I didn't do it. 25 years I didn't do it. 25 years I didn't do it. That took me up to That took me up to That took me up to roughly 95, which is when I left with roughly 95, which is when I left with roughly 95, which is when I left with Bruce to start Oaktree. Bruce to start Oaktree. Bruce to start Oaktree. That was really That was really That was really >> That's so interesting. So you think that >> That's so interesting. So you think that >> That's so interesting. So you think that up until the age of 50 or 49 you were up until the age of 50 or 49 you were up until the age of 50 or 49 you were floating floating floating or living according to other people. or living according to other people. or living according to other people. >> Well, not not just that, but just not >> Well, not not just that, but just not >> Well, not not just that, but just not making good decisions, conscious making good decisions, conscious making good decisions, conscious decisions. decisions. decisions. You know, why did I go to Citybank You know, why did I go to Citybank You know, why did I go to Citybank Investment Research Department when I Investment Research Department when I Investment Research Department when I got out of University of Chicago in got out of University of Chicago in got out of University of Chicago in 1969? Because I had a a good summer 1969? Because I had a a good summer 1969? Because I had a a good summer there the year before. Why did I move there the year before. Why did I move there the year before. Why did I move from the equity research department to from the equity research department to from the equity research department to the bond department? the bond department? the bond department? Because my work in equity research was Because my work in equity research was Because my work in equity research was unsuccessful and I was told to get out. unsuccessful and I was told to get out. unsuccessful and I was told to get out. Why did I Why did I Why did I move to California in 1980? move to California in 1980? move to California in 1980? Sunshine. Sunshine. Sunshine. Palm trees. Palm trees. Palm trees. I just can't claim I just can't claim I just can't claim that I was making good decisions. I got that I was making good decisions. I got that I was making good decisions. I got sent to the bond department at Citybank sent to the bond department at Citybank sent to the bond department at Citybank in 1978. in 1978. in 1978. And And And 3 months later the head of the bond 3 months later the head of the bond 3 months later the head of the bond department calls me up. department calls me up. department calls me up. Since I was I didn't have that much to Since I was I didn't have that much to Since I was I didn't have that much to do. I was fairly idle. do. I was fairly idle. do. I was fairly idle. And he says And he says And he says there's a guy named Milken or something there's a guy named Milken or something there's a guy named Milken or something in California and he deals in something in California and he deals in something in California and he deals in something called high-yield bonds. Do you think called high-yield bonds. Do you think called high-yield bonds. Do you think you can figure out what that means? you can figure out what that means? you can figure out what that means? That was just luck. That was just luck. That was just luck. You know, if you if you read Malcolm You know, if you if you read Malcolm You know, if you if you read Malcolm Gladwell in Outliers, it was just luck. Gladwell in Outliers, it was just luck. Gladwell in Outliers, it was just luck. Right time, right place. Right time, right place. Right time, right place. And if that call if that call came at And if that call if that call came at And if that call if that call came at lunchtime lunchtime lunchtime and I had been out at lunch, maybe and I had been out at lunch, maybe and I had been out at lunch, maybe somebody else would get the call. somebody else would get the call. somebody else would get the call. And and they'd be me. And and they'd be me. And and they'd be me. >> Your uh your humility is very striking >> Your uh your humility is very striking >> Your uh your humility is very striking to me. We have a lot of people on this to me. We have a lot of people on this to me. We have a lot of people on this podcast that I I think, you know, claim podcast that I I think, you know, claim podcast that I I think, you know, claim to be humble or try to be humble. You to be humble or try to be humble. You to be humble or try to be humble. You You really are extremely humble person. You really are extremely humble person. You really are extremely humble person. I mean, one note I wrote down is from I mean, one note I wrote down is from I mean, one note I wrote down is from now on at the top of all my investor now on at the top of all my investor now on at the top of all my investor memos, I'm just going to start it with I memos, I'm just going to start it with I memos, I'm just going to start it with I could be wrong, but um because I I I could be wrong, but um because I I I could be wrong, but um because I I I think whenever I make an investment, I'm think whenever I make an investment, I'm think whenever I make an investment, I'm so boastful about the my my excitement so boastful about the my my excitement so boastful about the my my excitement and my exuberance and why this is right and my exuberance and why this is right and my exuberance and why this is right and why it's the right move to do. And I and why it's the right move to do. And I and why it's the right move to do. And I think, you know, you've you've kind of think, you know, you've you've kind of think, you know, you've you've kind of infected me with a little bit of your infected me with a little bit of your infected me with a little bit of your your humility there. your humility there. your humility there. >> Well, you you make the investment >> Well, you you make the investment >> Well, you you make the investment because you believe in it. because you believe in it. because you believe in it. But, it's important to see the other But, it's important to see the other But, it's important to see the other side side side and know what you're doing. By the way, and know what you're doing. By the way, and know what you're doing. By the way, Churchill said he's a he's a humble man Churchill said he's a he's a humble man Churchill said he's a he's a humble man and he has a lot to be humble about. and he has a lot to be humble about. and he has a lot to be humble about. But, Mark Twain says, "It ain't what you But, Mark Twain says, "It ain't what you But, Mark Twain says, "It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. don't know that gets you into trouble. don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for certain that just It's what you know for certain that just It's what you know for certain that just ain't true." And I always tell people, ain't true." And I always tell people, ain't true." And I always tell people, in line with what you just said, John, in line with what you just said, John, in line with what you just said, John, no sentence that starts with I could be no sentence that starts with I could be no sentence that starts with I could be wrong, but wrong, but wrong, but or I don't know, but or I don't know, but or I don't know, but ever got anybody into trouble. The ever got anybody into trouble. The ever got anybody into trouble. The sentences that get people into trouble sentences that get people into trouble sentences that get people into trouble are I'm 100% convinced that are I'm 100% convinced that are I'm 100% convinced that and if you if you really feel that and if you if you really feel that and if you if you really feel that you're 100% right you're 100% right you're 100% right and you bet like you're 100% right and you bet like you're 100% right and you bet like you're 100% right and it turns out it was only 80/20 and and it turns out it was only 80/20 and and it turns out it was only 80/20 and the 20 comes up, that's how you get into the 20 comes up, that's how you get into the 20 comes up, that's how you get into big trouble. big trouble. big trouble. So, I think the thing that I think the So, I think the thing that I think the So, I think the thing that I think the thing that Mark Twain said was thing that Mark Twain said was thing that Mark Twain said was incredibly important. incredibly important. incredibly important. >> Yeah, last memo Sean sent me about some >> Yeah, last memo Sean sent me about some >> Yeah, last memo Sean sent me about some deal he had was uh deal he had was uh deal he had was uh bet everything you have, this is it. bet everything you have, this is it. bet everything you have, this is it. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> Mortgage the house. Um hey, can I ask >> Mortgage the house. Um hey, can I ask >> Mortgage the house. Um hey, can I ask you about Buffett? You know, Buffett you about Buffett? You know, Buffett you about Buffett? You know, Buffett famously has said, you know, he reads famously has said, you know, he reads famously has said, you know, he reads your memos. Uh I assume you guys have your memos. Uh I assume you guys have your memos. Uh I assume you guys have interacted. Do you guys hang out? What's interacted. Do you guys hang out? What's interacted. Do you guys hang out? What's What's he like? And uh give me some some What's he like? And uh give me some some What's he like? And uh give me some some Warren Buffett stories from from your Warren Buffett stories from from your Warren Buffett stories from from your your life, your experience. your life, your experience. your life, your experience. >> Well, Bruce actually was >> Well, Bruce actually was >> Well, Bruce actually was always a Buffett watcher. always a Buffett watcher. always a Buffett watcher. And if you go back to the '80s, no, I And if you go back to the '80s, no, I And if you go back to the '80s, no, I don't think anybody had heard of don't think anybody had heard of don't think anybody had heard of Buffett. Maybe not the '90s. I don't Buffett. Maybe not the '90s. I don't Buffett. Maybe not the '90s. I don't remember exactly. In the in the late remember exactly. In the in the late remember exactly. In the in the late '90s, people said, "Well, Buffett's lost '90s, people said, "Well, Buffett's lost '90s, people said, "Well, Buffett's lost it it it because he's not in tech." And then, of because he's not in tech." And then, of because he's not in tech." And then, of course, tech blew up. And then they course, tech blew up. And then they course, tech blew up. And then they said, "Ah, maybe Buffett knows what he's said, "Ah, maybe Buffett knows what he's said, "Ah, maybe Buffett knows what he's doing." But anyway, when doing." But anyway, when doing." But anyway, when Enron Enron Enron melted down, melted down, melted down, Enron did most of its Enron did most of its Enron did most of its misbehavior misbehavior misbehavior through through through off-balance sheet entities. off-balance sheet entities. off-balance sheet entities. And there was a lot of And there was a lot of And there was a lot of opportunity there. And so, we became the opportunity there. And so, we became the opportunity there. And so, we became the largest holder of the debt of one of largest holder of the debt of one of largest holder of the debt of one of them. them. them. It was called Osprey. It was called Osprey. It was called Osprey. And Warren was the second largest And Warren was the second largest And Warren was the second largest holder. holder. holder. And I don't remember how it came to And I don't remember how it came to And I don't remember how it came to pass, but he gave us his proxy. And he pass, but he gave us his proxy. And he pass, but he gave us his proxy. And he let us run that position for him. And let us run that position for him. And let us run that position for him. And Bruce did a masterful job of Bruce did a masterful job of Bruce did a masterful job of restructuring that company, and we came restructuring that company, and we came restructuring that company, and we came out with a big old big win. out with a big old big win. out with a big old big win. So, So, So, this was around '02. this was around '02. this was around '02. So, around '03 or '04, Warren writes So, around '03 or '04, Warren writes So, around '03 or '04, Warren writes Bruce a letter. Bruce a letter. Bruce a letter. And he says, you know, "Nice job on on And he says, you know, "Nice job on on And he says, you know, "Nice job on on Osprey. And if you ever find yourself in Osprey. And if you ever find yourself in Osprey. And if you ever find yourself in Omaha, let me know. We'll have lunch." Omaha, let me know. We'll have lunch." Omaha, let me know. We'll have lunch." So, Bruce and I write him a letter or So, Bruce and I write him a letter or So, Bruce and I write him a letter or Bruce writes him a letter. It says, "It Bruce writes him a letter. It says, "It Bruce writes him a letter. It says, "It happens happens happens that Howard and I will be in Omaha this that Howard and I will be in Omaha this that Howard and I will be in Omaha this week. Can we take you to lunch?" And and week. Can we take you to lunch?" And and week. Can we take you to lunch?" And and so, with that's how we met. so, with that's how we met. so, with that's how we met. And the relationship had a lovely start. And the relationship had a lovely start. And the relationship had a lovely start. And it went on like that. We never And it went on like that. We never And it went on like that. We never actually did any business together after actually did any business together after actually did any business together after that because, you know, he was always that because, you know, he was always that because, you know, he was always looking for something big that he could looking for something big that he could looking for something big that he could acquire. And and we don't we don't acquire. And and we don't we don't acquire. And and we don't we don't really deal in big acquirable things. really deal in big acquirable things. really deal in big acquirable things. But it was a very nice personal But it was a very nice personal But it was a very nice personal relationship and relationship and relationship and I don't I've never said this to anybody I don't I've never said this to anybody I don't I've never said this to anybody else before but in '09 else before but in '09 else before but in '09 I wrote a memo in which I mentioned him I wrote a memo in which I mentioned him I wrote a memo in which I mentioned him and I sent it to him and I said I want and I sent it to him and I said I want and I sent it to him and I said I want to make sure that you see this memo to make sure that you see this memo to make sure that you see this memo because it mentions you. And he says I because it mentions you. And he says I because it mentions you. And he says I do see the memos and blah blah blah and do see the memos and blah blah blah and do see the memos and blah blah blah and I have seen this. He says and by the way I have seen this. He says and by the way I have seen this. He says and by the way you should write a book you should write a book you should write a book and if you do I'll give you a and if you do I'll give you a and if you do I'll give you a a blurb for the book. a blurb for the book. a blurb for the book. And that's why I wrote the first book. And that's why I wrote the first book. And that's why I wrote the first book. Most important thing I always thought Most important thing I always thought Most important thing I always thought I'd write a book when I retired but I'd write a book when I retired but I'd write a book when I retired but instead you know when when you get that instead you know when when you get that instead you know when when you get that kind of note from a guy like Warren kind of note from a guy like Warren kind of note from a guy like Warren Buffett you you can't let it sit. So Buffett you you can't let it sit. So Buffett you you can't let it sit. So that was that was the start of that but that was that was the start of that but that was that was the start of that but you know you know you know I've been fortunate to visit him a few I've been fortunate to visit him a few I've been fortunate to visit him a few times and times and times and and it's it's a big plus. and it's it's a big plus. and it's it's a big plus. >> Is there any part about the Warren >> Is there any part about the Warren >> Is there any part about the Warren mystique the Buffett personality that mystique the Buffett personality that mystique the Buffett personality that you think like popular lore gets wrong you think like popular lore gets wrong you think like popular lore gets wrong or is inaccurate? or is inaccurate? or is inaccurate? >> No I think it's mostly what you see is >> No I think it's mostly what you see is >> No I think it's mostly what you see is what you get. The one thing I'll say what you get. The one thing I'll say what you get. The one thing I'll say that I don't think people know about that I don't think people know about that I don't think people know about they don't get wrong they don't know they don't get wrong they don't know they don't get wrong they don't know about is the depth of his love for about is the depth of his love for about is the depth of his love for Charlie. Charlie. Charlie. And Warren sent out a a note And Warren sent out a a note And Warren sent out a a note I think it was at Thanksgiving last I think it was at Thanksgiving last I think it was at Thanksgiving last year. year. year. And he said you know I'm not going to be And he said you know I'm not going to be And he said you know I'm not going to be at the Berkshire meeting and I'm not at the Berkshire meeting and I'm not at the Berkshire meeting and I'm not going to be writing this or that going to be writing this or that going to be writing this or that whatever it was. whatever it was. whatever it was. And he talked about his relationship And he talked about his relationship And he talked about his relationship with Charlie and anybody who wants to with Charlie and anybody who wants to with Charlie and anybody who wants to should get a get a hold of that letter should get a get a hold of that letter should get a get a hold of that letter and see it because it's it's you know we and see it because it's it's you know we and see it because it's it's you know we talked earlier about the importance of talked earlier about the importance of talked earlier about the importance of the a partnership and how great a the a partnership and how great a the a partnership and how great a contributor to your life it can be. And contributor to your life it can be. And contributor to your life it can be. And and that's what that's what uh and that's what that's what uh and that's what that's what uh he had with Charlie. I think he I think he had with Charlie. I think he I think he had with Charlie. I think he I think he as I recall he talked about he as I recall he talked about he as I recall he talked about Charlie being the big brother Charlie being the big brother Charlie being the big brother and and and himself being the little and and and himself being the little and and and himself being the little brother. And I think we can say that brother. And I think we can say that brother. And I think we can say that about my relationship with Bruce. about my relationship with Bruce. about my relationship with Bruce. And And And for one reason or another, he's always for one reason or another, he's always for one reason or another, he's always been very kind to me been very kind to me been very kind to me uh about my role, uh about my role, uh about my role, you know, and generous you know, and generous you know, and generous about my role and he look, he's he's about my role and he look, he's he's about my role and he look, he's he's he's certainly he's certainly he's certainly as smart as I am and as talented as I as smart as I am and as talented as I as smart as I am and as talented as I am, maybe in different ways. am, maybe in different ways. am, maybe in different ways. But But But there was always this this feeling of there was always this this feeling of there was always this this feeling of respect and affection and love and respect and affection and love and respect and affection and love and and and the as the more time passes, the and and the as the more time passes, the and and the as the more time passes, the more we're conscious of that, he and I. more we're conscious of that, he and I. more we're conscious of that, he and I. And that's what Warren and Charlie had And that's what Warren and Charlie had And that's what Warren and Charlie had and it was beautiful thing to watch. And and it was beautiful thing to watch. And and it was beautiful thing to watch. And also, the Warren used to love telling also, the Warren used to love telling also, the Warren used to love telling funny stories about Charlie, funny stories about Charlie, funny stories about Charlie, of which there were a lot. And their of which there were a lot. And their of which there were a lot. And their relationship was always suffused relationship was always suffused relationship was always suffused with humor. with humor. with humor. >> Did they make a lot of the decisions >> Did they make a lot of the decisions >> Did they make a lot of the decisions together? together? together? I mean, I've read a little bit about I mean, I've read a little bit about I mean, I've read a little bit about them and their relationship was a a them and their relationship was a a them and their relationship was a a little challenging for me to understand little challenging for me to understand little challenging for me to understand because I don't think they've ever lived because I don't think they've ever lived because I don't think they've ever lived in the same place. in the same place. in the same place. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Did they >> Did they >> Did they talk daily? talk daily? talk daily? >> I don't know exactly how they made their >> I don't know exactly how they made their >> I don't know exactly how they made their decisions, but I think I think Warren decisions, but I think I think Warren decisions, but I think I think Warren used Charlie as a sounding board. used Charlie as a sounding board. used Charlie as a sounding board. A logic checker. A logic checker. A logic checker. You know, I think this, do you think You know, I think this, do you think You know, I think this, do you think this makes sense? That kind of thing. this makes sense? That kind of thing. this makes sense? That kind of thing. Of course, Charlie's great credit is Of course, Charlie's great credit is Of course, Charlie's great credit is that Warren Buffett used to engage in that Warren Buffett used to engage in that Warren Buffett used to engage in what we call cigar butt investing. I what we call cigar butt investing. I what we call cigar butt investing. I don't know if you know about this. don't know if you know about this. don't know if you know about this. But But But cigar butt investing means you're cigar butt investing means you're cigar butt investing means you're walking down the street and you look in walking down the street and you look in walking down the street and you look in the gutter and you see a used cigar and the gutter and you see a used cigar and the gutter and you see a used cigar and you pick it up and you conclude that it you pick it up and you conclude that it you pick it up and you conclude that it has three puffs left. So, you pick it has three puffs left. So, you pick it has three puffs left. So, you pick it up. This is a disgusting thought. You up. This is a disgusting thought. You up. This is a disgusting thought. You pick it up and you smoke it pick it up and you smoke it pick it up and you smoke it and you get three puffs for free. and you get three puffs for free. and you get three puffs for free. That's the butt investing. That's the butt investing. That's the butt investing. But But But and and you know, and and you know, and and you know, Warren would buy Warren would buy Warren would buy uh you know, really cats and dogs uh you know, really cats and dogs uh you know, really cats and dogs because they were cheap. because they were cheap. because they were cheap. And Charlie's great contribution was And Charlie's great contribution was And Charlie's great contribution was talking Warren out of talking Warren out of talking Warren out of cats and dogs. cats and dogs. cats and dogs. Out of cigar butts. Out of cigar butts. Out of cigar butts. And his revolution was that he convinced And his revolution was that he convinced And his revolution was that he convinced Warren not any company at a great price. Warren not any company at a great price. Warren not any company at a great price. Great companies at a good price. Great companies at a good price. Great companies at a good price. Most people credit that as Charlie's Most people credit that as Charlie's Most people credit that as Charlie's greatest contribution. greatest contribution. greatest contribution. So, but it you know, synergistic, mutual So, but it you know, synergistic, mutual So, but it you know, synergistic, mutual respect, love, complementary skills. It respect, love, complementary skills. It respect, love, complementary skills. It it interestingly, they probably had the it interestingly, they probably had the it interestingly, they probably had the highest combined IQ of any partnership highest combined IQ of any partnership highest combined IQ of any partnership in history. in history. in history. But they were different kinds of IQ. But they were different kinds of IQ. But they were different kinds of IQ. Charlie was more of a classicist and Charlie was more of a classicist and Charlie was more of a classicist and he humanist and a man of letters. And he humanist and a man of letters. And he humanist and a man of letters. And Warren, of course, was Warren, of course, was Warren, of course, was an incredible an incredible an incredible uh uh uh uh computing machine. uh computing machine. uh computing machine. >> A man of a a man of letters. Sean, we >> A man of a a man of letters. Sean, we >> A man of a a man of letters. Sean, we need to bring that back. That sounds need to bring that back. That sounds need to bring that back. That sounds that sounds beautiful. I would be a man that sounds beautiful. I would be a man that sounds beautiful. I would be a man of letters. of letters. of letters. >> Charlie, you know, when we would get >> Charlie, you know, when we would get >> Charlie, you know, when we would get together, he wouldn't talk about together, he wouldn't talk about together, he wouldn't talk about investments or money investments or money investments or money or companies, mostly. He would talk or companies, mostly. He would talk or companies, mostly. He would talk about ideas. about ideas. about ideas. >> Well, let let's wrap it with one one >> Well, let let's wrap it with one one >> Well, let let's wrap it with one one last quick one, which is uh give us some last quick one, which is uh give us some last quick one, which is uh give us some homework. Give us a book homework. Give us a book homework. Give us a book that that that shaped the way you think or you thought shaped the way you think or you thought shaped the way you think or you thought brought some good ideas to the brought some good ideas to the brought some good ideas to the forefront. What's a book we should read forefront. What's a book we should read forefront. What's a book we should read as recommended by Howard Marks? as recommended by Howard Marks? as recommended by Howard Marks? >> So, one is uh a short history of >> So, one is uh a short history of >> So, one is uh a short history of financial euphoria financial euphoria financial euphoria by John Kenneth Galbraith. This was very by John Kenneth Galbraith. This was very by John Kenneth Galbraith. This was very uh influential in my thinking and it uh influential in my thinking and it uh influential in my thinking and it teaches you about uh teaches you about uh teaches you about uh the the the mental weakness that gives lot give rise mental weakness that gives lot give rise mental weakness that gives lot give rise to booms and busts. And of course, you to booms and busts. And of course, you to booms and busts. And of course, you know, uh know, uh know, uh taking a uh taking a uh taking a uh objective view of cycles is a big part objective view of cycles is a big part objective view of cycles is a big part of what I do. So, that was very of what I do. So, that was very of what I do. So, that was very influential and I was lucky to get to influential and I was lucky to get to influential and I was lucky to get to meet Galbraith. meet Galbraith. meet Galbraith. And then the other book would be Fooled And then the other book would be Fooled And then the other book would be Fooled by Randomness by Randomness by Randomness uh by Nassim Nicholas Taleb. uh by Nassim Nicholas Taleb. uh by Nassim Nicholas Taleb. And it talks about And it talks about And it talks about See, I'm a great believer that a lot in See, I'm a great believer that a lot in See, I'm a great believer that a lot in life is random. life is random. life is random. And uh And uh And uh so, this is one of the reasons so, this is one of the reasons so, this is one of the reasons maybe it's my rationale for not being maybe it's my rationale for not being maybe it's my rationale for not being such a decisive thinker. Taleb basically such a decisive thinker. Taleb basically such a decisive thinker. Taleb basically says, "In the short run, says, "In the short run, says, "In the short run, uh uh uh anything can happen anything can happen anything can happen because of randomness. And this because of randomness. And this because of randomness. And this determines our attitude toward risk, our determines our attitude toward risk, our determines our attitude toward risk, our attitude toward portfolio construction, attitude toward portfolio construction, attitude toward portfolio construction, our attitude toward published records. our attitude toward published records. our attitude toward published records. You know, you see a published record, You know, you see a published record, You know, you see a published record, the guy had a great return that year. the guy had a great return that year. the guy had a great return that year. Is he a great investor or did he get Is he a great investor or did he get Is he a great investor or did he get lucky that year? lucky that year? lucky that year? etc. etc. etc. So, and I So, I think that I think that So, and I So, I think that I think that So, and I So, I think that I think that Fooled by Randomness is really Fooled by Randomness is really Fooled by Randomness is really uh and I've written the memos if anybody uh and I've written the memos if anybody uh and I've written the memos if anybody wants to you you the what we used to wants to you you the what we used to wants to you you the what we used to call the classic comic version, call the classic comic version, call the classic comic version, uh they can read the memos rather than uh they can read the memos rather than uh they can read the memos rather than reading the whole book. reading the whole book. reading the whole book. Uh but I think it's very valuable and I Uh but I think it's very valuable and I Uh but I think it's very valuable and I would recommend it strongly. would recommend it strongly. would recommend it strongly. >> Well, we appreciate you, man. This is >> Well, we appreciate you, man. This is >> Well, we appreciate you, man. This is fun. fun. fun. >> I hope so. >> I hope so. >> I hope so. >> We got to do one with your son, >> We got to do one with your son, >> We got to do one with your son, actually. That would be a lot of fun. actually. That would be a lot of fun. actually. That would be a lot of fun. >> Uh well, we did one in January of '21 >> Uh well, we did one in January of '21 >> Uh well, we did one in January of '21 called Something of Value because uh he called Something of Value because uh he called Something of Value because uh he moved during the last during the moved during the last during the moved during the last during the pandemic and I thought that the the pandemic and I thought that the the pandemic and I thought that the the opportunity to for three generation of opportunity to for three generation of opportunity to for three generation of Markses to live together was a great was Markses to live together was a great was Markses to live together was a great was of great value and we spent most of the of great value and we spent most of the of great value and we spent most of the time arguing about value investing. Uh time arguing about value investing. Uh time arguing about value investing. Uh and and uh and I think that and and uh and I think that and and uh and I think that uh I think with the possible exception uh I think with the possible exception uh I think with the possible exception of the latest AI memo, I think that one of the latest AI memo, I think that one of the latest AI memo, I think that one got the most positive reception. But but got the most positive reception. But but got the most positive reception. But but uh we'll we'll we'll keep on working uh we'll we'll we'll keep on working uh we'll we'll we'll keep on working together and uh together and uh together and uh you guys don't don't need you guys don't don't need you guys don't don't need an excuse for an excuse for an excuse for for another session. for another session. for another session. Thanks. Thanks. Thanks. >> Thank you for playing therapist for us. >> Thank you for playing therapist for us. >> Thank you for playing therapist for us. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Thank you so much Howard. >> Thank you so much Howard. >> Thank you so much Howard. >> That's it. That's a pop.