How to Stop Ruminating and Start Living | Maya Shankar
Change isn't just something that happens to us—it reveals who we really are. When major life disruptions occur, they expose hidden values, beliefs, and capabilities we didn't know we had. The key is building a robust identity anchored not to what you do, but to why you do it. By identifying your cor
1h 13mKey Takeaway
Change isn't just something that happens to us—it reveals who we really are. When major life disruptions occur, they expose hidden values, beliefs, and capabilities we didn't know we had. The key is building a robust identity anchored not to what you do, but to why you do it. By identifying your core 'why'—the deeper purpose behind your goals—you create stability that survives any external change. This shift from focusing on outcomes to honoring underlying values transforms change from a threat to your identity into an opportunity for revelation and growth.
Episode Overview
Dr. Maya Shankar, cognitive scientist and host of 'A Slight Change of Plans,' shares profound insights from her personal experiences with career-ending change (losing her violin career at 15 due to injury) and ongoing fertility struggles. She explores the science behind why change feels so threatening to our sense of self and offers evidence-based strategies for navigating life's inevitable disruptions. The conversation reveals how our brains trick us into believing we have more control than we do, why we underestimate our ability to adapt, and how change can actually reveal hidden aspects of ourselves that lead to personal growth.
Key Insights
Anchor Identity to Your 'Why,' Not Your 'What'
We often tie our identity to what we do (violinist, parent, athlete) rather than why we do it (emotional connection, helping others, continuous improvement). When life takes away the 'what,' the 'why' remains stable and can guide you toward new paths that fulfill the same deeper purpose. Building a robust, expansive identity based on your underlying values protects you when external circumstances change.
The Illusion of Control Amplifies Change Anxiety
We overestimate our control over outcomes in everyday life, which is adaptive for motivation. But when unexpected change happens, it shatters this illusion and forces us to confront our limits. This loss of control increases our sense of uncertainty, and research shows we're so averse to uncertainty that we'd rather be certain a negative event will happen than live with ambiguity.
The End of History Illusion: You Will Change More Than You Think
We acknowledge we've changed dramatically in the past but believe we're 'done' changing in the future. This cognitive bias makes us think our current self is the 'final version.' In reality, major life changes accelerate internal transformation—you will develop new perspectives, values, and capabilities that make you better equipped to handle future challenges than your present self can imagine.
Self-Affirmation Exercises Reduce Denial and Despair
Taking 5-10 minutes to list every identity and source of meaning in your life that isn't threatened by your current change helps you zoom out and see your rich, multifaceted identity. This practice doesn't eliminate pain but significantly reduces the feeling that change has destroyed your entire sense of self, and research shows it makes people less prone to denial by reducing the perceived threat.
Change as Revelation, Not Just Destruction
The word 'apocalypse' comes from the Greek 'apocalypsis,' meaning 'revelation.' Major life disruptions reveal hidden aspects of yourself—shame, attachment patterns, people-pleasing tendencies, values you didn't know you held. While uncomfortable, this forced self-examination creates opportunities to challenge limiting beliefs and build a better version of yourself for navigating future challenges.
Notable Quotes
"Sometimes we don't know how much something has defined us, how core it is to our self-identity and our sense of self-worth and value until we lose it."
"Just because I lost the ability to play the violin didn't mean that I lost what led me to love it in the first place."
"We're more stressed when we're told we have a 50% chance of getting an electric shock than when we're told we have a 100% chance of getting an electric shock."
"People regard the present moment as a watershed moment in which a person has finally become the person they're going to be for the rest of their lives."
"Change can upend us but it can also reveal really important things to us about who we are."
Action Items
-
1
Identify Your Core 'Why'
For each major role or identity in your life, ask: 'What is it about this that lights me up? Why do I value this?' Write down the underlying purpose (connection, growth, helping others, etc.). This becomes your stable north star when external circumstances change.
-
2
Practice Self-Affirmation During Crisis
When facing major change, spend 5-10 minutes listing every identity, relationship, skill, or source of meaning in your life that is NOT threatened by the current change. This zooms you out from tunnel vision and helps you see how much of yourself remains intact.
-
3
Prepare Your 'Change Survival Kit' Before Crisis
Don't wait for catastrophe to learn these skills. Study the science of change, understand cognitive biases like the end of history illusion, and build your toolkit of questions and practices now. This preparation reduces anxiety about future unknowns and equips you to handle challenges when they arrive.
-
4
Question Externally Imposed Dreams
When examining your goals and identities, ask: 'Is this something I intrinsically want, or has society/culture/family told me this makes me valuable?' Distinguishing between authentic desires and external pressures helps you let go of goals that don't truly serve you.