1% better

Former Intel CEO on What Went Wrong, What's Next + Lovable CEO on the Real Promise of Vibe Coding

Pat Gelsinger, former Intel CEO, discusses Intel's rise and fall, the critical mistakes of prioritizing business leadership over technical expertise, and the...

49m

Summary published by , updated .

All-In Podcast

Key Takeaway

Technical leadership trumps business leadership in technology companies. When business people run tech companies, they promote other business people, creating a dangerous cycle. The greatest tech companies—Microsoft, Google, Nvidia—are led by deeply technical individuals who understand that billion-dollar technology decisions can't be made through spreadsheets alone. Intel's decline began when it shifted from technical to business leadership, missing critical opportunities like iPhone chips and falling behind TSMC's foundry model.

Episode Overview

Pat Gelsinger, former Intel CEO, discusses Intel's rise and fall, the critical mistakes of prioritizing business leadership over technical expertise, and the transformative potential of AI and quantum computing. He explains how Intel missed major opportunities by focusing on shareholder returns instead of innovation, while competitors like Apple, Nvidia, and TSMC capitalized on technical foresight and continuous improvement.

Main Insights

Technical Leaders Build Technical Companies

Technology companies must be led by technical people who understand the core innovations, not business people optimizing spreadsheets. When Intel shifted from technical leadership (Grove, Moore, Noyce) to business leadership, it began promoting business people who couldn't make informed decisions about billion-dollar technology investments. The greatest tech companies today—Microsoft under Satya, Google under Sundar—maintain deeply technical leadership even when not founder-led.

The $100 Billion Mistake

In the five years before Gelsinger returned as CEO, Intel returned $100 billion to shareholders through dividends and buybacks instead of investing in factories, EUV machines, and new product categories. During this period, Intel didn't build a single new factory in a decade. This financial optimization over technological investment allowed competitors like TSMC to scale 5x larger in wafer production and Apple to develop superior in-house silicon.

Small Bets Compound Into Dominance

Steve Jobs demonstrated the power of incremental preparation—he had been porting macOS to x86 architecture for four releases before ever announcing the Intel transition. Similarly, Apple started with small internal chips before eventually replacing Intel entirely. Nvidia followed the same pattern, continuously improving CUDA and GPU capabilities until they became essential for AI workloads. Continuous, patient investment in core competencies eventually creates insurmountable advantages.

Energy Constraints Prevent AI Bubbles

The AI buildout is naturally limited by energy capacity, which provides a built-in protection against excessive speculation. Global energy capacity is expanding at only 5% annually (the US was at 1% for a decade), and no one will build data centers without power. This creates an upper bound on how hyped the market can become, making the AI revolution more sustainable than previous tech bubbles despite enormous capital deployment.

Taiwan's Fragility Threatens Global Economy

Taiwan has less than three weeks of energy reserves. A blockade would brown out the island, shutting down fabs that take 90 days to restart. The economic impact would exceed the Great Depression—without a single shot fired. This existential risk makes reshoring semiconductor manufacturing through initiatives like the CHIPS Act not just strategic but economically critical. The US has progressed from 12% to 18% of leading-edge production, but needs to accelerate dramatically.

Notable Quotes

"When you're making these hardcore technical, you know, decisions that affect billions of dollars, you don't do that through a spreadsheet."

Pat Gelsinger

"I've been working on that for the last four releases."

Steve Jobs (as recalled by Pat Gelsinger)

"What I wouldn't have done for another hundred billion dollars"

Pat Gelsinger

"There has not been a time in human history where it's been better to be a technologist than the one we're in right now."

Pat Gelsinger

"The island of Taiwan has less than 3 weeks of energy reserves. The economic impact of a brownout of Taiwan is greater than the Great Depression."

Pat Gelsinger

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Prioritize Technical Expertise in Leadership

    If you're building or investing in a technology company, ensure technical people lead technical decisions. Don't let spreadsheet optimization override technology strategy. Look for leaders who can evaluate billion-dollar bets based on technology trends, not just financial models.

  • 2
    Make Small, Continuous Bets on Future Capabilities

    Follow the Jobs/Nvidia playbook: start small projects to build core competencies before you need them. Port your product to new platforms, experiment with new architectures, build internal tools that might become strategic advantages. Small, patient investments compound over time into insurmountable leads.

  • 3
    View Market Corrections as Healthy Resets

    When investing in transformative technologies like AI, welcome periodic corrections that keep valuations reasonable. These prevent bubbles from getting ahead of fundamental value creation. Use corrections as opportunities to ensure you're building real businesses with real margins, not just riding hype.

  • 4
    Assess Energy Infrastructure Before AI Investments

    Before making major AI infrastructure investments, verify energy availability. The AI buildout is fundamentally constrained by power capacity. Evaluate projects based on their energy efficiency and access to reliable power, as this will determine which companies can actually scale their operations.

Guides that reference this episode

See how this episode fits with recommendations from other leading podcasts.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

Spent a long time at Intel. Spent a long time at Intel. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Only 34 years. >> Only 34 years. >> Only 34 years. >> 34 years. >> 34 years. >> 34 years. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Probably one of the greatest American >> Probably one of the greatest American >> Probably one of the greatest American companies uh ever and then absolutely companies uh ever and then absolutely companies uh ever and then absolutely went off the rails and got went off the rails and got went off the rails and got absolutely demolished by Nvidia, absolutely demolished by Nvidia, absolutely demolished by Nvidia, TSMC, TSMC, TSMC, uh and I guess Apple to a certain uh and I guess Apple to a certain uh and I guess Apple to a certain extent. So, you had this incredible extent. So, you had this incredible extent. So, you had this incredible Intel Inside moment. We bought our Intel Inside moment. We bought our Intel Inside moment. We bought our computers based on computers based on computers based on you know, hey, the Pentium and that you know, hey, the Pentium and that you know, hey, the Pentium and that sound. sound. sound. >> Intel Inside, baby. >> Intel Inside, baby. >> Intel Inside, baby. >> Intel Inside. >> Intel Inside. >> Intel Inside. >> dum dum dum. >> dum dum dum. >> dum dum dum. >> The dum dum dum. And so, let's talk >> The dum dum dum. And so, let's talk >> The dum dum dum. And so, let's talk about how things went wrong, what went about how things went wrong, what went about how things went wrong, what went right, and then right, and then right, and then how did it and you were there for a long how did it and you were there for a long how did it and you were there for a long time, you took a break, and then you time, you took a break, and then you time, you took a break, and then you came back. came back. came back. But, there seem to be have been some But, there seem to be have been some But, there seem to be have been some critical mistakes that we can learn critical mistakes that we can learn critical mistakes that we can learn from. So, let's just embrace it and go from. So, let's just embrace it and go from. So, let's just embrace it and go right into it. Tremendous successes in right into it. Tremendous successes in right into it. Tremendous successes in American company coming back now, I American company coming back now, I American company coming back now, I think, think, think, uh reasonably. uh reasonably. uh reasonably. But, when you when we look back on it But, when you when we look back on it But, when you when we look back on it and we do our postmortem, what were the and we do our postmortem, what were the and we do our postmortem, what were the mistakes mistakes mistakes and what would we change in terms of the and what would we change in terms of the and what would we change in terms of the direction of that company? direction of that company? direction of that company? >> I'm going all in. >> I'm going all in. >> I'm going all in. >> If you were building a global financial >> If you were building a global financial >> If you were building a global financial system from first principles today, you system from first principles today, you system from first principles today, you wouldn't build it on 50-year-old legacy wouldn't build it on 50-year-old legacy wouldn't build it on 50-year-old legacy rails. You'd build Airwallex, one rails. You'd build Airwallex, one rails. You'd build Airwallex, one AI-native platform for global accounts, AI-native platform for global accounts, AI-native platform for global accounts, cards, and payments. It's designed to cards, and payments. It's designed to cards, and payments. It's designed to make the entire world feel like a local make the entire world feel like a local make the entire world feel like a local market. Others are bolting AI onto market. Others are bolting AI onto market. Others are bolting AI onto broken infrastructure, but Airwallex was broken infrastructure, but Airwallex was broken infrastructure, but Airwallex was built for the intelligent era from day built for the intelligent era from day built for the intelligent era from day one. Stop paying the legacy tax and one. Stop paying the legacy tax and one. Stop paying the legacy tax and start building the future at start building the future at start building the future at airwallex.com/allin. airwallex.com/allin. airwallex.com/allin. Airwallex, built for the future. Airwallex, built for the future. Airwallex, built for the future. >> I'm going [music] all in. >> I'm going [music] all in. >> I'm going [music] all in. >> Having spent so much of my life there, >> Having spent so much of my life there, >> Having spent so much of my life there, you know, I view it I joined when I was you know, I view it I joined when I was you know, I view it I joined when I was 18. I went through puberty at Intel, 18. I went through puberty at Intel, 18. I went through puberty at Intel, right? My joke, right? You know, it's right? My joke, right? You know, it's right? My joke, right? You know, it's just like you know, I'm so early. just like you know, I'm so early. just like you know, I'm so early. Grove, Noyce, Barrett, Barrett, right? Grove, Noyce, Barrett, Barrett, right? Grove, Noyce, Barrett, Barrett, right? Uh and Uh and Uh and you know, they they were the people I you know, they they were the people I you know, they they were the people I grew up at, right? You know, so on. They grew up at, right? You know, so on. They grew up at, right? You know, so on. They were my mentors. They were the people I were my mentors. They were the people I were my mentors. They were the people I adored for and they were deeply adored for and they were deeply adored for and they were deeply technical. technical. technical. >> Andy Grove. >> Andy Grove. >> Andy Grove. >> Andy Grove, Gordon Moore, Bob Noyce, you >> Andy Grove, Gordon Moore, Bob Noyce, you >> Andy Grove, Gordon Moore, Bob Noyce, you know, co-inventor. You know, these were know, co-inventor. You know, these were know, co-inventor. You know, these were deeply technical leaders. I remember deeply technical leaders. I remember deeply technical leaders. I remember when I joined the executive staff for when I joined the executive staff for when I joined the executive staff for the first time. the first time. the first time. There was, you know, probably 15 of the There was, you know, probably 15 of the There was, you know, probably 15 of the 20 people that were in the room were 20 people that were in the room were 20 people that were in the room were PhDs. PhDs. PhDs. Right? You know, it was just that Right? You know, it was just that Right? You know, it was just that technical. And you know, I view one of technical. And you know, I view one of technical. And you know, I view one of the things that went off the rail was the things that went off the rail was the things that went off the rail was when it started to be run by business when it started to be run by business when it started to be run by business people. people. people. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> to technical people. >> to technical people. >> to technical people. >> counters, the finance people. >> counters, the finance people. >> counters, the finance people. >> Yeah, and you know, when I became CEO >> Yeah, and you know, when I became CEO >> Yeah, and you know, when I became CEO in 2001, that was the first technical in 2001, that was the first technical in 2001, that was the first technical leader in essentially 15 years. leader in essentially 15 years. leader in essentially 15 years. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, associated with it. You >> Right? You know, associated with it. You >> Right? You know, associated with it. You know, and if you have a business leader, know, and if you have a business leader, know, and if you have a business leader, who does he promote? Business leaders. who does he promote? Business leaders. who does he promote? Business leaders. And you know, right? You know, so I And you know, right? You know, so I And you know, right? You know, so I think one of the fundamental things is think one of the fundamental things is think one of the fundamental things is and you know, as you look at the great and you know, as you look at the great and you know, as you look at the great technology companies today, you know, technology companies today, you know, technology companies today, you know, they're deeply technical. they're deeply technical. they're deeply technical. >> And founder led typically. >> And founder led typically. >> And founder led typically. >> You know, and even if they're not, you >> You know, and even if they're not, you >> You know, and even if they're not, you know, Satya is not a founder. know, Satya is not a founder. know, Satya is not a founder. >> No. >> No. >> No. >> Right? You know, Sundar is not a founder >> Right? You know, Sundar is not a founder >> Right? You know, Sundar is not a founder as well, but they're deeply technical as well, but they're deeply technical as well, but they're deeply technical individuals. And when you're making individuals. And when you're making individuals. And when you're making these hardcore technical, you know, these hardcore technical, you know, these hardcore technical, you know, decisions that affect billions of decisions that affect billions of decisions that affect billions of dollars, you don't do that through a dollars, you don't do that through a dollars, you don't do that through a spreadsheet. spreadsheet. spreadsheet. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> That's a lousy investment. >> That's a lousy investment. >> That's a lousy investment. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> Unless the technology trends make it the >> Unless the technology trends make it the >> Unless the technology trends make it the right investment. And I think that's one right investment. And I think that's one right investment. And I think that's one of the fundamental things. And of the fundamental things. And of the fundamental things. And obviously, you know, in the five years, obviously, you know, in the five years, obviously, you know, in the five years, five, six years before I came back, you five, six years before I came back, you five, six years before I came back, you know, Intel gave a hundred billion know, Intel gave a hundred billion know, Intel gave a hundred billion dollars to shareholders. dollars to shareholders. dollars to shareholders. >> Oh, the dividends. >> Oh, the dividends. >> Oh, the dividends. >> And the >> And the >> And the >> And stock buybacks. >> And stock buybacks. >> And stock buybacks. >> Yeah, a hundred What I wouldn't have >> Yeah, a hundred What I wouldn't have >> Yeah, a hundred What I wouldn't have done for another hundred billion dollars done for another hundred billion dollars done for another hundred billion dollars on the on the on the >> Well, I mean, what what would you have >> Well, I mean, what what would you have >> Well, I mean, what what would you have done? You probably would have made done? You probably would have made done? You probably would have made >> Well, I >> Well, I >> Well, I >> chips for iPhone, [snorts] which Intel >> chips for iPhone, [snorts] which Intel >> chips for iPhone, [snorts] which Intel passed on, yeah? passed on, yeah? passed on, yeah? >> Yeah, you know, but you know, it hadn't >> Yeah, you know, but you know, it hadn't >> Yeah, you know, but you know, it hadn't built a new factory in a decade when I built a new factory in a decade when I built a new factory in a decade when I got there. It's like, you know, how can got there. It's like, you know, how can got there. It's like, you know, how can you not be building? How could you not you not be building? How could you not you not be building? How could you not buy EUV machines? You know, there's just buy EUV machines? You know, there's just buy EUV machines? You know, there's just all of these things, you know, that you all of these things, you know, that you all of these things, you know, that you would only do as a technologist because would only do as a technologist because would only do as a technologist because the economics behind them by themselves the economics behind them by themselves the economics behind them by themselves were not good. were not good. were not good. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> So, you know, it was getting back to the >> So, you know, it was getting back to the >> So, you know, it was getting back to the core of technology to me that was, you core of technology to me that was, you core of technology to me that was, you know, the fundamental thing. You know, know, the fundamental thing. You know, know, the fundamental thing. You know, you make good decisions, you make bad you make good decisions, you make bad you make good decisions, you make bad decisions as leaders. Every business decisions as leaders. Every business decisions as leaders. Every business does that does that does that as they go along. But, you know, as they go along. But, you know, as they go along. But, you know, fundamentally, this is a technology fundamentally, this is a technology fundamentally, this is a technology business and you need technologists business and you need technologists business and you need technologists running technology running technology running technology that then hires technologists that are that then hires technologists that are that then hires technologists that are sitting at the staff that then hire the sitting at the staff that then hire the sitting at the staff that then hire the best technologists, you know. best technologists, you know. best technologists, you know. >> And take big swings at >> And take big swings at >> And take big swings at you know, categories that could matter you know, categories that could matter you know, categories that could matter in the future, like skating to where the in the future, like skating to where the in the future, like skating to where the puck's going. If you look at Apple, they puck's going. If you look at Apple, they puck's going. If you look at Apple, they did the same thing for the past 15 did the same thing for the past 15 did the same thing for the past 15 years, buying back the stock, tremendous years, buying back the stock, tremendous years, buying back the stock, tremendous amount of dividends, they're the largest amount of dividends, they're the largest amount of dividends, they're the largest holder of capital of any company, I holder of capital of any company, I holder of capital of any company, I believe, to this date. And what if what believe, to this date. And what if what believe, to this date. And what if what companies do they buy? They buy little companies do they buy? They buy little companies do they buy? They buy little tiny acquisitions on the margins. I tiny acquisitions on the margins. I tiny acquisitions on the margins. I think the largest one was was Beats think the largest one was was Beats think the largest one was was Beats cuz they wanted to get inroads into, you cuz they wanted to get inroads into, you cuz they wanted to get inroads into, you know, certain demographic segments like know, certain demographic segments like know, certain demographic segments like in the Android space that they couldn't in the Android space that they couldn't in the Android space that they couldn't get into, but my god, what a colossal get into, but my god, what a colossal get into, but my god, what a colossal waste of time. Like you said, they could waste of time. Like you said, they could waste of time. Like you said, they could have done so many amazing things. have done so many amazing things. have done so many amazing things. Tell me about Steve Jobs Tell me about Steve Jobs Tell me about Steve Jobs in 2008, 2009 deciding in 2008, 2009 deciding in 2008, 2009 deciding I think we're going to make our own I think we're going to make our own I think we're going to make our own silicon and that impact because silicon and that impact because silicon and that impact because was that a covert product project? Did was that a covert product project? Did was that a covert product project? Did you guys know he was doing that? Did he you guys know he was doing that? Did he you guys know he was doing that? Did he inform you? inform you? inform you? Well, that seemed to be another one of Well, that seemed to be another one of Well, that seemed to be another one of those forks in the road, yeah? those forks in the road, yeah? those forks in the road, yeah? >> You know, Steve was an incredible >> You know, Steve was an incredible >> You know, Steve was an incredible leader. You know, he was also a ruthless leader. You know, he was also a ruthless leader. You know, he was also a ruthless leader, right? You know, very difficult, leader, right? You know, very difficult, leader, right? You know, very difficult, you know, read Walter Isaacson's book on you know, read Walter Isaacson's book on you know, read Walter Isaacson's book on him as well. I had many, many him as well. I had many, many him as well. I had many, many conversations with Steve over the years. conversations with Steve over the years. conversations with Steve over the years. You know, for um but you know, when they You know, for um but you know, when they You know, for um but you know, when they moved to Intel on the Centrino chip, it moved to Intel on the Centrino chip, it moved to Intel on the Centrino chip, it was a big deal. was a big deal. was a big deal. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Right? And they were putting >> Right? And they were putting >> Right? And they were putting extraordinary demands on Intel. You extraordinary demands on Intel. You extraordinary demands on Intel. You know, make the chip smaller, drive lower know, make the chip smaller, drive lower know, make the chip smaller, drive lower power. They're a demanding power. They're a demanding power. They're a demanding uh customer. And when he was no longer uh customer. And when he was no longer uh customer. And when he was no longer convinced that we could continue to do convinced that we could continue to do convinced that we could continue to do that, you know, he started the project. that, you know, he started the project. that, you know, he started the project. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, and if you remember uh >> Right? You know, and if you remember uh >> Right? You know, and if you remember uh what was it, you know, you know, what was it, you know, you know, what was it, you know, you know, uh PA Semi, you know, they acquired some uh PA Semi, you know, they acquired some uh PA Semi, you know, they acquired some small company, started to build some small company, started to build some small company, started to build some competency. But you know, they did a few competency. But you know, they did a few competency. But you know, they did a few little chips internally. It wasn't a big little chips internally. It wasn't a big little chips internally. It wasn't a big deal. And then the little chips got a deal. And then the little chips got a deal. And then the little chips got a little bit bigger. You know, and Steve little bit bigger. You know, and Steve little bit bigger. You know, and Steve was a master of this. You know, just was a master of this. You know, just was a master of this. You know, just starting, you know, these small efforts starting, you know, these small efforts starting, you know, these small efforts to build core competence inside the to build core competence inside the to build core competence inside the company. Uh I remember when we had the company. Uh I remember when we had the company. Uh I remember when we had the first conversation with Steve about uh first conversation with Steve about uh first conversation with Steve about uh porting the uh operating system to the porting the uh operating system to the porting the uh operating system to the Intel chip from the power chip that they Intel chip from the power chip that they Intel chip from the power chip that they were running on before they moved to were running on before they moved to were running on before they moved to Intel. And we were quite proud of the Intel. And we were quite proud of the Intel. And we were quite proud of the silicon software competencies that we silicon software competencies that we silicon software competencies that we had in compilers and operating systems. had in compilers and operating systems. had in compilers and operating systems. You know, so Steve, we'll help you port You know, so Steve, we'll help you port You know, so Steve, we'll help you port the operating system to the x86. And I the operating system to the x86. And I the operating system to the x86. And I remember that Steve said, remember that Steve said, remember that Steve said, I've been working on that for the last I've been working on that for the last I've been working on that for the last four releases. four releases. four releases. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> He had been preparing the core >> He had been preparing the core >> He had been preparing the core technologies inside of Apple for technologies inside of Apple for technologies inside of Apple for something that might happen something that might happen something that might happen >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> in the future. You know, and he was >> in the future. You know, and he was >> in the future. You know, and he was already You know, to me, I just remember already You know, to me, I just remember already You know, to me, I just remember I was just shocked. I you know, I ported I was just shocked. I you know, I ported I was just shocked. I you know, I ported the last four releases to the x86. I the last four releases to the x86. I the last four releases to the x86. I think we got this. think we got this. think we got this. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Right? You know, it was that kind of >> Right? You know, it was that kind of >> Right? You know, it was that kind of thing. And that's how they got into the thing. And that's how they got into the thing. And that's how they got into the semiconductor, you know, doing their own semiconductor, you know, doing their own semiconductor, you know, doing their own semiconductor. Hmm, I'm not sure I can semiconductor. Hmm, I'm not sure I can semiconductor. Hmm, I'm not sure I can rely on Intel to be that much ahead of rely on Intel to be that much ahead of rely on Intel to be that much ahead of the industry and I can start optimizing the industry and I can start optimizing the industry and I can start optimizing the system design with the silicon the system design with the silicon the system design with the silicon design as opposed to relying on one design as opposed to relying on one design as opposed to relying on one that's been somewhat optimized for a that's been somewhat optimized for a that's been somewhat optimized for a Windows environment versus an iOS Windows environment versus an iOS Windows environment versus an iOS environment, you know, and their uh environment, you know, and their uh environment, you know, and their uh operating system and you know, it was operating system and you know, it was operating system and you know, it was just you know, just you know, just you know, you know, you know, you know, it was never that kind of thing that it was never that kind of thing that it was never that kind of thing that they used to say, you know, right, you they used to say, you know, right, you they used to say, you know, right, you failed as a supplier. No, I can supply failed as a supplier. No, I can supply failed as a supplier. No, I can supply myself better. myself better. myself better. >> Yeah, and Jensen >> Yeah, and Jensen >> Yeah, and Jensen decides, hey, he's going to go all in on decides, hey, he's going to go all in on decides, hey, he's going to go all in on making these video cards and talk about making these video cards and talk about making these video cards and talk about just incredible just incredible just incredible serendipity that these happened to be serendipity that these happened to be serendipity that these happened to be also very applicable for cryptocurrency also very applicable for cryptocurrency also very applicable for cryptocurrency and running these AI jobs. and running these AI jobs. and running these AI jobs. >> Yeah, you know, >> Yeah, you know, >> Yeah, you know, >> Was that luck or skill or combination of >> Was that luck or skill or combination of >> Was that luck or skill or combination of both there? both there? both there? >> Well, you know, when you think about >> Well, you know, when you think about >> Well, you know, when you think about that progression, you know, Jensen he that progression, you know, Jensen he that progression, you know, Jensen he was just building high performance was just building high performance was just building high performance computers, you know, throughput computers, you know, throughput computers, you know, throughput machines, you know, when we were at the machines, you know, when we were at the machines, you know, when we were at the heights of our strength on CPUs at heights of our strength on CPUs at heights of our strength on CPUs at Intel, we sort of scoffed at his Intel, we sort of scoffed at his Intel, we sort of scoffed at his machines. machines. machines. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Right? You know, so I go, it's a graphic >> Right? You know, so I go, it's a graphic >> Right? You know, so I go, it's a graphic machine, you know, who cares? You know, machine, you know, who cares? You know, machine, you know, who cares? You know, there's some gamers who want to use that there's some gamers who want to use that there's some gamers who want to use that kind of stuff, right? You know, it was kind of stuff, right? You know, it was kind of stuff, right? You know, it was always the big CPU and those little always the big CPU and those little always the big CPU and those little GPUs. But when they started to build a GPUs. But when they started to build a GPUs. But when they started to build a real software stack with it, right? You real software stack with it, right? You real software stack with it, right? You know, it was sort of okay, this CUDA know, it was sort of okay, this CUDA know, it was sort of okay, this CUDA thing and SIMT as a technology, you thing and SIMT as a technology, you thing and SIMT as a technology, you know, know, know, you know, multi-threading and so on and you know, multi-threading and so on and you know, multi-threading and so on and it just sort of kept getting a little it just sort of kept getting a little it just sort of kept getting a little bit better and a little bit better and bit better and a little bit better and bit better and a little bit better and it was a little bit Jobs-like in that it was a little bit Jobs-like in that it was a little bit Jobs-like in that way. You know, we're just making it way. You know, we're just making it way. You know, we're just making it better every release and it's becoming a better every release and it's becoming a better every release and it's becoming a more robust and all of a sudden, you more robust and all of a sudden, you more robust and all of a sudden, you know, the crazy, you know, know, the crazy, you know, know, the crazy, you know, Japanese HPC guys said, hey, we could Japanese HPC guys said, hey, we could Japanese HPC guys said, hey, we could take those graphics cards and maybe take those graphics cards and maybe take those graphics cards and maybe start using them in HPC. start using them in HPC. start using them in HPC. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, that was sort of >> Right? You know, that was sort of >> Right? You know, that was sort of defining moment where it wasn't just defining moment where it wasn't just defining moment where it wasn't just about doing graphics anymore. This was a about doing graphics anymore. This was a about doing graphics anymore. This was a more computationally dense platform to more computationally dense platform to more computationally dense platform to start attacking some of the world's most start attacking some of the world's most start attacking some of the world's most interesting workloads and I think Jensen interesting workloads and I think Jensen interesting workloads and I think Jensen would agree that was a defining moment would agree that was a defining moment would agree that was a defining moment and then sort of saying, oh, these and then sort of saying, oh, these and then sort of saying, oh, these aren't just graphics cards anymore. You aren't just graphics cards anymore. You aren't just graphics cards anymore. You know, these are general-purpose know, these are general-purpose know, these are general-purpose computing devices that can start computing devices that can start computing devices that can start applying to these other uh workloads." applying to these other uh workloads." applying to these other uh workloads." And, you know, AI was, you know, had And, you know, AI was, you know, had And, you know, AI was, you know, had gone through what, its fifth nuclear gone through what, its fifth nuclear gone through what, its fifth nuclear winter by that point? Or it's like, winter by that point? Or it's like, winter by that point? Or it's like, "Man, you know, you know, this is never "Man, you know, you know, this is never "Man, you know, you know, this is never going to matter, right? We're never going to matter, right? We're never going to matter, right? We're never going to, you know, get the going to, you know, get the going to, you know, get the breakthroughs." But, the community breakthroughs." But, the community breakthroughs." But, the community around it was continuing to develop around it was continuing to develop around it was continuing to develop >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> uh you know, for it. And uh the CUDA >> uh you know, for it. And uh the CUDA >> uh you know, for it. And uh the CUDA software kept getting better uh software kept getting better uh software kept getting better uh generation by generation. And uh you generation by generation. And uh you generation by generation. And uh you know, I had a project at Intel Larrabee, know, I had a project at Intel Larrabee, know, I had a project at Intel Larrabee, right? Where we were trying to take the right? Where we were trying to take the right? Where we were trying to take the x86 and essentially do the same thing, x86 and essentially do the same thing, x86 and essentially do the same thing, right? You know, for it. And, you know, right? You know, for it. And, you know, right? You know, for it. And, you know, in my first departure from Intel, the in my first departure from Intel, the in my first departure from Intel, the project was killed a week after I left. project was killed a week after I left. project was killed a week after I left. >> Huh. >> Huh. >> Huh. >> And the world would have been so much >> And the world would have been so much >> And the world would have been so much different, right? different, right? different, right? >> I mean, it really >> I mean, it really >> I mean, it really I think it's illustry of [snorts] I think it's illustry of [snorts] I think it's illustry of [snorts] illustrative of what continuous illustrative of what continuous illustrative of what continuous innovation, taking some risks, and doing innovation, taking some risks, and doing innovation, taking some risks, and doing that fundamental research, and the that fundamental research, and the that fundamental research, and the compounding power of technology because compounding power of technology because compounding power of technology because I think it was William Gibson who said I think it was William Gibson who said I think it was William Gibson who said the street finds its own use for the street finds its own use for the street finds its own use for technology. Like, technology. Like, technology. Like, Mhm. Mhm. Mhm. Nvidia did not predict that this Bitcoin Nvidia did not predict that this Bitcoin Nvidia did not predict that this Bitcoin project would take over, and that this project would take over, and that this project would take over, and that this would be the best way to do those would be the best way to do those would be the best way to do those computations. Nor did they anticipate, I computations. Nor did they anticipate, I computations. Nor did they anticipate, I think, you know, that AI would take off. think, you know, that AI would take off. think, you know, that AI would take off. But, because it was the best solution, But, because it was the best solution, But, because it was the best solution, the hacker community could kind of the hacker community could kind of the hacker community could kind of >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> figure that out. Well, as we wrap on the >> figure that out. Well, as we wrap on the >> figure that out. Well, as we wrap on the Intel portion of your Intel portion of your Intel portion of your uh career, um okay, Apple silicon, uh career, um okay, Apple silicon, uh career, um okay, Apple silicon, that's one. Uh and then you have Nvidia. that's one. Uh and then you have Nvidia. that's one. Uh and then you have Nvidia. And then you have this And then you have this And then you have this Taiwanese company Taiwanese company Taiwanese company uh that starts making, you know, uh that starts making, you know, uh that starts making, you know, really great at fabricating the these really great at fabricating the these really great at fabricating the these chips. chips. chips. Um and Intel missed that as well, yeah? Um and Intel missed that as well, yeah? Um and Intel missed that as well, yeah? And and maybe you talk a little bit And and maybe you talk a little bit And and maybe you talk a little bit about TSMC and their about TSMC and their about TSMC and their surging, and we can even get into a surging, and we can even get into a surging, and we can even get into a little bit of the the politics of it little bit of the the politics of it little bit of the the politics of it now. And then we'll get into some of now. And then we'll get into some of now. And then we'll get into some of these AI chips and venture investing. these AI chips and venture investing. these AI chips and venture investing. >> The you know, thing with TSMC was they >> The you know, thing with TSMC was they >> The you know, thing with TSMC was they started with a vision of foundry. started with a vision of foundry. started with a vision of foundry. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, they were going to >> Right? You know, they were going to >> Right? You know, they were going to become the factory for the industry. And become the factory for the industry. And become the factory for the industry. And again, these factories are so expensive. again, these factories are so expensive. again, these factories are so expensive. 20 billion, 30 billion, and uh the 20 billion, 30 billion, and uh the 20 billion, 30 billion, and uh the engineering and the continuous engineering and the continuous engineering and the continuous investment required to do it. And you investment required to do it. And you investment required to do it. And you know, it was a stunning, you know, a know, it was a stunning, you know, a know, it was a stunning, you know, a vision uh at that point in time. Intel vision uh at that point in time. Intel vision uh at that point in time. Intel was IDM as we called it. The integrated was IDM as we called it. The integrated was IDM as we called it. The integrated design and manufacturing. You know, we design and manufacturing. You know, we design and manufacturing. You know, we never worked to make our process and our never worked to make our process and our never worked to make our process and our factories available for third parties. factories available for third parties. factories available for third parties. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, it was always this >> Right? You know, it was always this >> Right? You know, it was always this thing, "Hey, it's you know, we do enough thing, "Hey, it's you know, we do enough thing, "Hey, it's you know, we do enough CPUs ourself. You know, we reuse it for CPUs ourself. You know, we reuse it for CPUs ourself. You know, we reuse it for chipsets and some of the other things chipsets and some of the other things chipsets and some of the other things that we're doing." But it was never that we're doing." But it was never that we're doing." But it was never standardized in a way that it could be standardized in a way that it could be standardized in a way that it could be made available for a broad ecosystem, made available for a broad ecosystem, made available for a broad ecosystem, you know, using PDKs and all the design you know, using PDKs and all the design you know, using PDKs and all the design tools. You know, we did a lot of our own tools. You know, we did a lot of our own tools. You know, we did a lot of our own EDA tools ourself. You know, one of the EDA tools ourself. You know, one of the EDA tools ourself. You know, one of the projects that I started early in my projects that I started early in my projects that I started early in my career was the foundations of EDA. career was the foundations of EDA. career was the foundations of EDA. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> Uh as well. The first place in route, >> Uh as well. The first place in route, >> Uh as well. The first place in route, you know, the first standard cells, the you know, the first standard cells, the you know, the first standard cells, the first high-level description language. first high-level description language. first high-level description language. You know, it was so proprietary. And You know, it was so proprietary. And You know, it was so proprietary. And TSMC basically cut that in half and TSMC basically cut that in half and TSMC basically cut that in half and says, "I don't care whose chip it is. I says, "I don't care whose chip it is. I says, "I don't care whose chip it is. I don't care what you're designing. I'll don't care what you're designing. I'll don't care what you're designing. I'll be your manufacturing partner." be your manufacturing partner." be your manufacturing partner." >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And at the time, that was such a trivial >> And at the time, that was such a trivial >> And at the time, that was such a trivial piece of the business. Intel didn't even piece of the business. Intel didn't even piece of the business. Intel didn't even care. care. care. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, and so on. And then, >> Right? You know, and so on. And then, >> Right? You know, and so on. And then, over steady progress over a long period over steady progress over a long period over steady progress over a long period of time, and Apple as a customer driving of time, and Apple as a customer driving of time, and Apple as a customer driving them to be good become really them to be good become really them to be good become really meaningful, you know, obviously the meaningful, you know, obviously the meaningful, you know, obviously the world changed. world changed. world changed. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> And when I came back uh to uh Intel in >> And when I came back uh to uh Intel in >> And when I came back uh to uh Intel in 2001, TSMC was producing 5x the wafers 2001, TSMC was producing 5x the wafers 2001, TSMC was producing 5x the wafers of Intel. of Intel. of Intel. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Right? Not 10% more, 5x. >> Right? Not 10% more, 5x. >> Right? Not 10% more, 5x. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And all of a sudden, that model of >> And all of a sudden, that model of >> And all of a sudden, that model of foundry became the model of the foundry became the model of the foundry became the model of the semiconductor industry with two semiconductor industry with two semiconductor industry with two exceptions. Intel and memory. Yeah, exceptions. Intel and memory. Yeah, exceptions. Intel and memory. Yeah, memory DIs design and manufacture, right memory DIs design and manufacture, right memory DIs design and manufacture, right for you know, that is uniquely different for you know, that is uniquely different for you know, that is uniquely different and obviously, you know, we're seeing and obviously, you know, we're seeing and obviously, you know, we're seeing them you know, $3 trillion memory them you know, $3 trillion memory them you know, $3 trillion memory companies just extraordinary. You know, companies just extraordinary. You know, companies just extraordinary. You know, and you know, trillion dollar foundry and you know, trillion dollar foundry and you know, trillion dollar foundry company in TSMC. You know, the industry company in TSMC. You know, the industry company in TSMC. You know, the industry has said, I want a lot of wafers. I want has said, I want a lot of wafers. I want has said, I want a lot of wafers. I want a lot of innovation of different a lot of innovation of different a lot of innovation of different designs. I have a layer of designs. I have a layer of designs. I have a layer of standardization and EDA tools and the standardization and EDA tools and the standardization and EDA tools and the world changed. And obviously, as I came world changed. And obviously, as I came world changed. And obviously, as I came back to Intel, that was one of the core back to Intel, that was one of the core back to Intel, that was one of the core thesis of the new strategy. thesis of the new strategy. thesis of the new strategy. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> We must become a foundry as well. Five >> We must become a foundry as well. Five >> We must become a foundry as well. Five to one and now it's more like seven to to one and now it's more like seven to to one and now it's more like seven to one in terms of wafers, you know, to one in terms of wafers, you know, to one in terms of wafers, you know, to TSMC to Intel. TSMC to Intel. TSMC to Intel. >> Are we going to be able to onshore that? >> Are we going to be able to onshore that? >> Are we going to be able to onshore that? Obviously, we had the Chips Act and just Obviously, we had the Chips Act and just Obviously, we had the Chips Act and just give us broad strokes what you think's give us broad strokes what you think's give us broad strokes what you think's going to happen here in terms of going to happen here in terms of going to happen here in terms of obviously, Taiwan is in play. Some obviously, Taiwan is in play. Some obviously, Taiwan is in play. Some people in the administration believe people in the administration believe people in the administration believe um [snorts] it's going to happen the um [snorts] it's going to happen the um [snorts] it's going to happen the year after Trump's out unless he takes year after Trump's out unless he takes year after Trump's out unless he takes his third term. Other people believe his third term. Other people believe his third term. Other people believe like it was going to happen as early as like it was going to happen as early as like it was going to happen as early as '27 or maybe going into '28. So, '27 or maybe going into '28. So, '27 or maybe going into '28. So, are we going to be able to replicate are we going to be able to replicate are we going to be able to replicate that here in America in a reasonable that here in America in a reasonable that here in America in a reasonable amount of time or is this like truly amount of time or is this like truly amount of time or is this like truly could be a cataclysmic event if could be a cataclysmic event if could be a cataclysmic event if you know, God forbid China decides hey, you know, God forbid China decides hey, you know, God forbid China decides hey, we're going to blockade um we're going to blockade um we're going to blockade um Taiwan and then the Taiwanese decide Taiwan and then the Taiwanese decide Taiwan and then the Taiwanese decide yeah, we're going to burn on the fabs yeah, we're going to burn on the fabs yeah, we're going to burn on the fabs and we're going to fly out all of the and we're going to fly out all of the and we're going to fly out all of the engineers and ship them to America. engineers and ship them to America. engineers and ship them to America. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Well, there's a lot in that question. >> Well, there's a lot in that question. >> Well, there's a lot in that question. You know, do we have an hour to talk You know, do we have an hour to talk You know, do we have an hour to talk about this question? about this question? about this question? >> Well, I mean, we have six minutes, but >> Well, I mean, we have six minutes, but >> Well, I mean, we have six minutes, but >> Oh, okay. >> Oh, okay. >> Oh, okay. >> Yeah, do the best you can. >> Yeah, do the best you can. >> Yeah, do the best you can. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> [laughter] >> Uh also I talked also about the AI >> Uh also I talked also about the AI >> Uh also I talked also about the AI bubble. So, super bubble. So, super bubble. So, super >> You know, three things about this super >> You know, three things about this super >> You know, three things about this super quick. You know, one is the Chips Act is quick. You know, one is the Chips Act is quick. You know, one is the Chips Act is having benefit. having benefit. having benefit. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Right? You know, when we started the >> Right? You know, when we started the >> Right? You know, when we started the Chips Act and you know, when 2001 when I Chips Act and you know, when 2001 when I Chips Act and you know, when 2001 when I came back, the US was building about 12% came back, the US was building about 12% came back, the US was building about 12% of leading edge. Today that number is of leading edge. Today that number is of leading edge. Today that number is more like 18%. more like 18%. more like 18%. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Okay. You know, we're making progress. >> Okay. You know, we're making progress. >> Okay. You know, we're making progress. >> It's not 50%. >> It's not 50%. >> It's not 50%. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> We have a long way to go, right? You >> We have a long way to go, right? You >> We have a long way to go, right? You know, Intel is starting to be a real know, Intel is starting to be a real know, Intel is starting to be a real foundry. foundry. foundry. >> Okay, that's real progress. >> Okay, that's real progress. >> Okay, that's real progress. >> Uh and TSMC's factories are up and >> Uh and TSMC's factories are up and >> Uh and TSMC's factories are up and operating at scale. Right? We have operating at scale. Right? We have operating at scale. Right? We have Samsung and you know, Samsung and you know, Samsung and you know, uh as well, but you know, I'd say the uh as well, but you know, I'd say the uh as well, but you know, I'd say the Intel and the TSMC progress, okay, Intel and the TSMC progress, okay, Intel and the TSMC progress, okay, that's meaningful. Now, let's make it that's meaningful. Now, let's make it that's meaningful. Now, let's make it ugly for a second. Uh the island of ugly for a second. Uh the island of ugly for a second. Uh the island of Taiwan has less than 3 weeks, a big Taiwan has less than 3 weeks, a big Taiwan has less than 3 weeks, a big article in the Wall Street Journal 2 article in the Wall Street Journal 2 article in the Wall Street Journal 2 weeks ago on this, less than 3 weeks of weeks ago on this, less than 3 weeks of weeks ago on this, less than 3 weeks of energy reserves. energy reserves. energy reserves. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. That should just put a chill in That should just put a chill in That should just put a chill in everybody's spine. Right? Because the everybody's spine. Right? Because the everybody's spine. Right? Because the blockade after 3 weeks, the island blockade after 3 weeks, the island blockade after 3 weeks, the island browns out. When you turn off a fab, it browns out. When you turn off a fab, it browns out. When you turn off a fab, it doesn't come back on for 90 days. Right? doesn't come back on for 90 days. Right? doesn't come back on for 90 days. Right? The economic impact of a brownout of The economic impact of a brownout of The economic impact of a brownout of Taiwan is greater than the Great Taiwan is greater than the Great Taiwan is greater than the Great Depression. Right? Uh in the world. Depression. Right? Uh in the world. Depression. Right? Uh in the world. Never do you need to do anything, a shot Never do you need to do anything, a shot Never do you need to do anything, a shot to be fired. You just need to say, to be fired. You just need to say, to be fired. You just need to say, "Great, no energy for 3 weeks." "Great, no energy for 3 weeks." "Great, no energy for 3 weeks." >> No oil. Yes. >> No oil. Yes. >> No oil. Yes. >> Right. Right, no LNG. Right? You know, >> Right. Right, no LNG. Right? You know, >> Right. Right, no LNG. Right? You know, that's how the island run. That is that's how the island run. That is that's how the island run. That is scary. You know, to me. We need more scary. You know, to me. We need more scary. You know, to me. We need more resilient supply chains uh associated resilient supply chains uh associated resilient supply chains uh associated you know, with it. And I don't think you know, with it. And I don't think you know, with it. And I don't think this is an alternative for the world this is an alternative for the world this is an alternative for the world because if it really does become a risk, because if it really does become a risk, because if it really does become a risk, you know, and I you know, I you know, I you know, and I you know, I you know, I you know, and I you know, I you know, I don't sit in the situation room and get don't sit in the situation room and get don't sit in the situation room and get all the data and so on. But let's remind all the data and so on. But let's remind all the data and so on. But let's remind each other that I think China has each other that I think China has each other that I think China has blockaded the Taiwan Straits seven times blockaded the Taiwan Straits seven times blockaded the Taiwan Straits seven times over the last 4 years. over the last 4 years. over the last 4 years. >> Yep. >> Yep. >> Yep. >> This isn't a theory. >> This isn't a theory. >> This isn't a theory. >> No, no, they're running exercises. >> No, no, they're running exercises. >> No, no, they're running exercises. They're being pernicious and They're being pernicious and They're being pernicious and >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> pretty provocative in terms >> pretty provocative in terms >> pretty provocative in terms >> Is that 2027? Is that 2030? Is that >> Is that 2027? Is that 2030? Is that >> Is that 2027? Is that 2030? Is that 2035? Their intentions have been clear 2035? Their intentions have been clear 2035? Their intentions have been clear over a sustained period of time. We need over a sustained period of time. We need over a sustained period of time. We need more resilient uh supply chains. more resilient uh supply chains. more resilient uh supply chains. >> Yeah. You know, for it. So, something, >> Yeah. You know, for it. So, something, >> Yeah. You know, for it. So, something, you know, I put a lot of my time and you know, I put a lot of my time and you know, I put a lot of my time and energy into and we're making progress, energy into and we're making progress, energy into and we're making progress, but we need to go faster, need to go but we need to go faster, need to go but we need to go faster, need to go more meaningful. more meaningful. more meaningful. >> Yeah. And let's talk a little bit about >> Yeah. And let's talk a little bit about >> Yeah. And let's talk a little bit about the AI build-out. the AI build-out. the AI build-out. I mean, you watched the PC revolution, I mean, you watched the PC revolution, I mean, you watched the PC revolution, servers, the internet. These were all servers, the internet. These were all servers, the internet. These were all extraordinary build-outs and then extraordinary build-outs and then extraordinary build-outs and then this is the build-out to end all this is the build-out to end all this is the build-out to end all build-outs. The amount of data centers, build-outs. The amount of data centers, build-outs. The amount of data centers, the amount of chips, the amount of the amount of chips, the amount of the amount of chips, the amount of inference needed. inference needed. inference needed. Do you think it's a bubble? I think I've Do you think it's a bubble? I think I've Do you think it's a bubble? I think I've heard you say like it's it's obviously a heard you say like it's it's obviously a heard you say like it's it's obviously a bubble, but bubble, but bubble, but what what's the risk factor here that we what what's the risk factor here that we what what's the risk factor here that we build too much build too much build too much or that the technology doesn't solve or that the technology doesn't solve or that the technology doesn't solve enough problems and we are swimming in enough problems and we are swimming in enough problems and we are swimming in tokens? What worries you about what tokens? What worries you about what tokens? What worries you about what you're seeing now? The valuations of you're seeing now? The valuations of you're seeing now? The valuations of these companies has gotten quite these companies has gotten quite these companies has gotten quite extraordinary. extraordinary. extraordinary. And, you know, if they build And, you know, if they build And, you know, if they build too much and they spend too much money too much and they spend too much money too much and they spend too much money and they don't make enough money, well, and they don't make enough money, well, and they don't make enough money, well, uh based on your experience with running uh based on your experience with running uh based on your experience with running a company, a public one, that's a lot of a company, a public one, that's a lot of a company, a public one, that's a lot of tension on it. When you don't make as tension on it. When you don't make as tension on it. When you don't make as much money as you're spending, people much money as you're spending, people much money as you're spending, people tend to fall out of love with these tend to fall out of love with these tend to fall out of love with these stocks, yeah? stocks, yeah? stocks, yeah? >> Well, I do think there uh you know, >> Well, I do think there uh you know, >> Well, I do think there uh you know, there there is a silver lining here that there there is a silver lining here that there there is a silver lining here that guarantees we don't get too far ahead of guarantees we don't get too far ahead of guarantees we don't get too far ahead of our self in terms of bubble. You know, our self in terms of bubble. You know, our self in terms of bubble. You know, and that is energy capacity. and that is energy capacity. and that is energy capacity. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right? You know, energy capacity in the >> Right? You know, energy capacity in the >> Right? You know, energy capacity in the world is expanding for 5%. You know, in world is expanding for 5%. You know, in world is expanding for 5%. You know, in the US, we had a decade at 1%. the US, we had a decade at 1%. the US, we had a decade at 1%. Right? You know, I mean, it's just Right? You know, I mean, it's just Right? You know, I mean, it's just hideous what we did to our energy grid hideous what we did to our energy grid hideous what we did to our energy grid you know, over about a decade and a you know, over about a decade and a you know, over about a decade and a half. But now that's getting built out. half. But now that's getting built out. half. But now that's getting built out. But essentially, nobody's going to build But essentially, nobody's going to build But essentially, nobody's going to build and buy GPUs and build data centers if and buy GPUs and build data centers if and buy GPUs and build data centers if they don't have energy. So, essentially, they don't have energy. So, essentially, they don't have energy. So, essentially, you have an upper bound on how you have an upper bound on how you have an upper bound on how aggressive and how hyped and bubbled aggressive and how hyped and bubbled aggressive and how hyped and bubbled that we get. So, I take a lot of solace that we get. So, I take a lot of solace that we get. So, I take a lot of solace in that, yeah, right? You know, for it in that, yeah, right? You know, for it in that, yeah, right? You know, for it because what then is the incremental because what then is the incremental because what then is the incremental value of a token? And if it's a measure value of a token? And if it's a measure value of a token? And if it's a measure of intelligence, it's somewhat infinite. of intelligence, it's somewhat infinite. of intelligence, it's somewhat infinite. Right? You know, in the sense if I have Right? You know, in the sense if I have Right? You know, in the sense if I have more intelligence, I will do, you know, more intelligence, I will do, you know, more intelligence, I will do, you know, better supply chain. I will do better better supply chain. I will do better better supply chain. I will do better finance. I will do more, you know, finance. I will do more, you know, finance. I will do more, you know, efficient logistics. I will, you know, efficient logistics. I will, you know, efficient logistics. I will, you know, all of those things. So, to me the the all of those things. So, to me the the all of those things. So, to me the the the potential value that we unleash in a the potential value that we unleash in a the potential value that we unleash in a token economic world is somewhat token economic world is somewhat token economic world is somewhat infinite. Right? And particularly with infinite. Right? And particularly with infinite. Right? And particularly with labor shortages and so on that we see, labor shortages and so on that we see, labor shortages and so on that we see, right, in developed countries. I am an right, in developed countries. I am an right, in developed countries. I am an optimist, you know, that we're in a optimist, you know, that we're in a optimist, you know, that we're in a couple of decade build-out. couple of decade build-out. couple of decade build-out. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Right? Not a couple of years, a couple >> Right? Not a couple of years, a couple >> Right? Not a couple of years, a couple of decades. One of the big objectives of decades. One of the big objectives of decades. One of the big objectives I've said is that I have to make AI I've said is that I have to make AI I've said is that I have to make AI 10,000 X better. 10,000 X better. 10,000 X better. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Right? You know, it's way too expensive >> Right? You know, it's way too expensive >> Right? You know, it's way too expensive today. You know, we want to drop, you today. You know, we want to drop, you today. You know, we want to drop, you know, by five orders of magnitude the know, by five orders of magnitude the know, by five orders of magnitude the cost per token, you know, the energy, cost per token, you know, the energy, cost per token, you know, the energy, you know, per token, so that we really you know, per token, so that we really you know, per token, so that we really do have Jevons' law that we just explode do have Jevons' law that we just explode do have Jevons' law that we just explode the access to AI, right, in much more the access to AI, right, in much more the access to AI, right, in much more economic uh ways. economic uh ways. economic uh ways. >> Which it does seem like Jevons' uh >> Which it does seem like Jevons' uh >> Which it does seem like Jevons' uh paradox has been at play over the last paradox has been at play over the last paradox has been at play over the last year. Like, oh my lord, these tokens are year. Like, oh my lord, these tokens are year. Like, oh my lord, these tokens are so cheap and the tools are getting so so cheap and the tools are getting so so cheap and the tools are getting so good. Yeah, I'm just going to start good. Yeah, I'm just going to start good. Yeah, I'm just going to start using these tools all day long until the using these tools all day long until the using these tools all day long until the bill comes in and you're like, okay, bill comes in and you're like, okay, bill comes in and you're like, okay, yeah, maybe I need to get some ROI out yeah, maybe I need to get some ROI out yeah, maybe I need to get some ROI out of this, but you do have these of this, but you do have these of this, but you do have these incredible companies, Cerebras, Groq, incredible companies, Cerebras, Groq, incredible companies, Cerebras, Groq, etc., making inference. etc., making inference. etc., making inference. >> and and silicon and so on. You know, and >> and and silicon and so on. You know, and >> and and silicon and so on. You know, and you know, if we accomplish, right, you you know, if we accomplish, right, you you know, if we accomplish, right, you know, these orders of magnitude know, these orders of magnitude know, these orders of magnitude improving in token economics improving in token economics improving in token economics availability, reduction in energy costs availability, reduction in energy costs availability, reduction in energy costs associated with it, you know, we just associated with it, you know, we just associated with it, you know, we just have a fantastic couple of decades in have a fantastic couple of decades in have a fantastic couple of decades in front of us. There has not been a time front of us. There has not been a time front of us. There has not been a time in human history where it's been better in human history where it's been better in human history where it's been better to be a technologist than the one we're to be a technologist than the one we're to be a technologist than the one we're in right now. We will solve chemistry. in right now. We will solve chemistry. in right now. We will solve chemistry. We will solve language. We will, you We will solve language. We will, you We will solve language. We will, you know, invent new materials. We, you know, invent new materials. We, you know, invent new materials. We, you know, new forms of, you know, know, new forms of, you know, know, new forms of, you know, interaction, you know, interaction, you know, interaction, you know, killing cancer, right, lifting people killing cancer, right, lifting people killing cancer, right, lifting people out of poverty. There is not a better out of poverty. There is not a better out of poverty. There is not a better time to be alive than the one that we're time to be alive than the one that we're time to be alive than the one that we're in right now. And as technologists, we in right now. And as technologists, we in right now. And as technologists, we get to sit in the driver's seat of it. get to sit in the driver's seat of it. get to sit in the driver's seat of it. >> Pretty amazing, and you're investing, >> Pretty amazing, and you're investing, >> Pretty amazing, and you're investing, uh, and that's your passion now. What do uh, and that's your passion now. What do uh, and that's your passion now. What do you think of these valuations? It's you think of these valuations? It's you think of these valuations? It's quite seems, you know, if you lived quite seems, you know, if you lived quite seems, you know, if you lived through the dot com bubble, we did see a through the dot com bubble, we did see a through the dot com bubble, we did see a disconnect there. These companies disconnect there. These companies disconnect there. These companies slightly different. We just had 11 labs slightly different. We just had 11 labs slightly different. We just had 11 labs up, 600 million in revenue, lovable. I up, 600 million in revenue, lovable. I up, 600 million in revenue, lovable. I think they're at 5 or 600 million. So, think they're at 5 or 600 million. So, think they're at 5 or 600 million. So, that's quite different than the dot com that's quite different than the dot com that's quite different than the dot com speculation, yeah? speculation, yeah? speculation, yeah? >> Yeah. Well, fundamentally, we have real >> Yeah. Well, fundamentally, we have real >> Yeah. Well, fundamentally, we have real revenues, you know, real margins coming revenues, you know, real margins coming revenues, you know, real margins coming out of these businesses as well. You out of these businesses as well. You out of these businesses as well. You know, that that said, anytime the know, that that said, anytime the know, that that said, anytime the multiples get too high, okay, some multiples get too high, okay, some multiples get too high, okay, some corrections. You know, and to me, corrections. You know, and to me, corrections. You know, and to me, periodic corrections that keep the periodic corrections that keep the periodic corrections that keep the multiple, you know, earnings multiples multiple, you know, earnings multiples multiple, you know, earnings multiples and, you know, so on in reasonable and, you know, so on in reasonable and, you know, so on in reasonable things is good, because this will not be things is good, because this will not be things is good, because this will not be a smooth curve. You know, I'm predicting a smooth curve. You know, I'm predicting a smooth curve. You know, I'm predicting two decades of goodness, and there's two decades of goodness, and there's two decades of goodness, and there's going to be lots of disruptions along going to be lots of disruptions along going to be lots of disruptions along the way. It's not going to be a smooth the way. It's not going to be a smooth the way. It's not going to be a smooth curve, and every time we have one of curve, and every time we have one of curve, and every time we have one of those corrections, say thank you, right? those corrections, say thank you, right? those corrections, say thank you, right? We're not letting the bubble get ahead We're not letting the bubble get ahead We're not letting the bubble get ahead of itself, right? You know, hey, we had of itself, right? You know, hey, we had of itself, right? You know, hey, we had the SaaS apocalypse. There's going to be the SaaS apocalypse. There's going to be the SaaS apocalypse. There's going to be other apocalypses on that journey when other apocalypses on that journey when other apocalypses on that journey when when industries get impacted by the when industries get impacted by the when industries get impacted by the capabilities that will be unleashed. And capabilities that will be unleashed. And capabilities that will be unleashed. And that's even before it gets exciting in that's even before it gets exciting in that's even before it gets exciting in what I call the trinity of computing, what I call the trinity of computing, what I call the trinity of computing, classical computing, AI computing, and classical computing, AI computing, and classical computing, AI computing, and quantum computing. And when those three quantum computing. And when those three quantum computing. And when those three come together, okay, that's when things come together, okay, that's when things come together, okay, that's when things get really exciting. get really exciting. get really exciting. >> Hey, quantum's been about 5 years away >> Hey, quantum's been about 5 years away >> Hey, quantum's been about 5 years away for 25 years. Um, for 25 years. Um, for 25 years. Um, when is it actually going to do anything when is it actually going to do anything when is it actually going to do anything >> This decade. >> This decade. >> This decade. >> This decade, so by 2030. >> This decade, so by 2030. >> This decade, so by 2030. >> Yep. >> Yep. >> Yep. >> It'll have be meaningful. >> It'll have be meaningful. >> It'll have be meaningful. What should we expect in terms of its What should we expect in terms of its What should we expect in terms of its impact in 2030? Like impact in 2030? Like impact in 2030? Like >> You know, you're going to be able to >> You know, you're going to be able to >> You know, you're going to be able to start doing things that cannot be start doing things that cannot be start doing things that cannot be computed today. You know, chemistry, you computed today. You know, chemistry, you computed today. You know, chemistry, you know, biology, there will be things that know, biology, there will be things that know, biology, there will be things that can't be computed today. You know, some can't be computed today. You know, some can't be computed today. You know, some of the easy things will be some of like of the easy things will be some of like of the easy things will be some of like the logistics where I will compute the the logistics where I will compute the the logistics where I will compute the best answer to get this thing to you. best answer to get this thing to you. best answer to get this thing to you. >> Traveling salesman problem? >> Traveling salesman problem? >> Traveling salesman problem? >> Right. You know, all of a sudden, all of >> Right. You know, all of a sudden, all of >> Right. You know, all of a sudden, all of those problems. Uh obviously, it's those problems. Uh obviously, it's those problems. Uh obviously, it's probably going to be, you know, 2020, probably going to be, you know, 2020, probably going to be, you know, 2020, 2032, 2033 when we solve, you know, 2032, 2033 when we solve, you know, 2032, 2033 when we solve, you know, things like encryption. Right? You know, things like encryption. Right? You know, things like encryption. Right? You know, where, you know, you'll have the where, you know, you'll have the where, you know, you'll have the fundamental Q day, you know, kind of fundamental Q day, you know, kind of fundamental Q day, you know, kind of implications, but this decade we will implications, but this decade we will implications, but this decade we will see quantum supremacy to results across see quantum supremacy to results across see quantum supremacy to results across multiple industries. You know, we know multiple industries. You know, we know multiple industries. You know, we know how to build qubits. We know how to how to build qubits. We know how to how to build qubits. We know how to error correct qubits. We now have error correct qubits. We now have error correct qubits. We now have algorithmics, right, against uh quantum. algorithmics, right, against uh quantum. algorithmics, right, against uh quantum. And, you know, now it's just about And, you know, now it's just about And, you know, now it's just about engineering scale. engineering scale. engineering scale. >> Who's going to win? >> Who's going to win? >> Who's going to win? >> Well, obviously, I'm a PsiQuantum guy, >> Well, obviously, I'm a PsiQuantum guy, >> Well, obviously, I'm a PsiQuantum guy, right, since that's one of our portfolio right, since that's one of our portfolio right, since that's one of our portfolio companies. But, the thing that you're companies. But, the thing that you're companies. But, the thing that you're seeing is that you now have like four, seeing is that you now have like four, seeing is that you now have like four, five, six modalities five, six modalities five, six modalities of quantum that are demonstrating pretty of quantum that are demonstrating pretty of quantum that are demonstrating pretty good results. Right? You know, across good results. Right? You know, across good results. Right? You know, across trapped ions, across, you know, photonic trapped ions, across, you know, photonic trapped ions, across, you know, photonic uh approaches, spin uh approaches. So, uh approaches, spin uh approaches. So, uh approaches, spin uh approaches. So, you now say modality is not an issue. you now say modality is not an issue. you now say modality is not an issue. Error correction's been proven uh across Error correction's been proven uh across Error correction's been proven uh across them. And, you know, I think the race them. And, you know, I think the race them. And, you know, I think the race will be on, and my prediction is will be on, and my prediction is will be on, and my prediction is meaningful results before 2030. meaningful results before 2030. meaningful results before 2030. >> Wow. That You realize that's about 40 >> Wow. That You realize that's about 40 >> Wow. That You realize that's about 40 months from now. Yeah. Okay. Meaningful months from now. Yeah. Okay. Meaningful months from now. Yeah. Okay. Meaningful results. Thanks so much, Pat, for results. Thanks so much, Pat, for results. Thanks so much, Pat, for sharing all this incredible uh sharing all this incredible uh sharing all this incredible uh information and knowledge. Great to see information and knowledge. Great to see information and knowledge. Great to see you. you. you. >> Very good. >> Your most valuable conversations rarely >> Your most valuable conversations rarely happen at a desk. The hallway, the sink, happen at a desk. The hallway, the sink, happen at a desk. The hallway, the sink, the dinner, the quick founder call. the dinner, the quick founder call. the dinner, the quick founder call. Plaud, no pin S, clips on and captures Plaud, no pin S, clips on and captures Plaud, no pin S, clips on and captures all of it hands-free. Afterward, Plaud all of it hands-free. Afterward, Plaud all of it hands-free. Afterward, Plaud intelligence turns the recording into intelligence turns the recording into intelligence turns the recording into clean notes and clear next steps. You clean notes and clear next steps. You clean notes and clear next steps. You stay in the room, Plaud handles the stay in the room, Plaud handles the stay in the room, Plaud handles the rest. For people who live in meetings, rest. For people who live in meetings, rest. For people who live in meetings, that's real leverage. Wear your Plaid at that's real leverage. Wear your Plaid at that's real leverage. Wear your Plaid at plaid.ai. plaid.ai. plaid.ai. >> [music] >> [music] >> [music] >> O C Cap is one of my favorite founders. >> O C Cap is one of my favorite founders. >> O C Cap is one of my favorite founders. He's the founder of Lovable. He's the founder of Lovable. He's the founder of Lovable. Why do I love this founder? Uh well, he Why do I love this founder? Uh well, he Why do I love this founder? Uh well, he built a product that people are addicted built a product that people are addicted built a product that people are addicted to. Primarily, Anton, the people who to. Primarily, Anton, the people who to. Primarily, Anton, the people who work for me. Ha. work for me. Ha. work for me. Ha. And I love talking to you because as the And I love talking to you because as the And I love talking to you because as the founder, you have a North Star. You're founder, you have a North Star. You're founder, you have a North Star. You're incredibly laser-focused on enabling incredibly laser-focused on enabling incredibly laser-focused on enabling anyone anyone anyone to build great software. Yeah, that's to build great software. Yeah, that's to build great software. Yeah, that's the mission of the company. I'm the mission of the company. I'm the mission of the company. I'm paraphrasing here, but essentially paraphrasing here, but essentially paraphrasing here, but essentially that's the mission of Lovable. that's the mission of Lovable. that's the mission of Lovable. >> Mission I talk about empowering humans. >> Mission I talk about empowering humans. >> Mission I talk about empowering humans. >> Empowering humans. >> Empowering humans. >> Empowering humans. >> first gap >> first gap >> first gap is to build a product. Mhm. The second is to build a product. Mhm. The second is to build a product. Mhm. The second gap is to build a business around that gap is to build a business around that gap is to build a business around that product. product. product. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> And now we're at everyone at Lovable, >> And now we're at everyone at Lovable, >> And now we're at everyone at Lovable, we're we're working on both of these two we're we're working on both of these two we're we're working on both of these two gaps. Right. The first one, we got to gaps. Right. The first one, we got to gaps. Right. The first one, we got to very far. We're seeing a million new very far. We're seeing a million new very far. We're seeing a million new projects built every single week on the projects built every single week on the projects built every single week on the >> And on the on the second one, we're >> And on the on the second one, we're >> And on the on the second one, we're investing a lot in making it easier to investing a lot in making it easier to investing a lot in making it easier to run your business and to get people to run your business and to get people to run your business and to get people to care, people to discover what you build care, people to discover what you build care, people to discover what you build and the entire business of what you're and the entire business of what you're and the entire business of what you're whatever you're doing as a small whatever you're doing as a small whatever you're doing as a small business, as if you're a large business, business, as if you're a large business, business, as if you're a large business, we're also getting a lot of traction. Um we're also getting a lot of traction. Um we're also getting a lot of traction. Um and we're actually seeing as a proof of and we're actually seeing as a proof of and we're actually seeing as a proof of that, more than 700 million visits to that, more than 700 million visits to that, more than 700 million visits to the applications every month. So, every the applications every month. So, every the applications every month. So, every month there is um extreme growth in in month there is um extreme growth in in month there is um extreme growth in in the surface area of the surface area of the surface area of the entire the entire the entire uh more than 50 million apps built on uh more than 50 million apps built on uh more than 50 million apps built on the platform to date. the platform to date. the platform to date. >> How many years has Lovable been in >> How many years has Lovable been in >> How many years has Lovable been in market or how many months now? market or how many months now? market or how many months now? >> 20 months uh since we launched, yeah. >> 20 months uh since we launched, yeah. >> 20 months uh since we launched, yeah. And and we're And again, we're we're And and we're And again, we're we're And and we're And again, we're we're seeing people who are first-time seeing people who are first-time seeing people who are first-time founders. We're seeing enterprise founders. We're seeing enterprise founders. We're seeing enterprise leaders move much faster together with leaders move much faster together with leaders move much faster together with their teams on this platform that has a their teams on this platform that has a their teams on this platform that has a lot of opinionated pieces in how you lot of opinionated pieces in how you lot of opinionated pieces in how you should uh create software should uh create software should uh create software and how to operate that software and how and how to operate that software and how and how to operate that software and how the different applications in your the different applications in your the different applications in your company connect to each other over time. company connect to each other over time. company connect to each other over time. So, that's what why we're seeing so much So, that's what why we're seeing so much So, that's what why we're seeing so much growth also on the enterprise side which growth also on the enterprise side which growth also on the enterprise side which were where we're actually growing were where we're actually growing were where we're actually growing fastest right now. fastest right now. fastest right now. >> This is really interesting because 10 >> This is really interesting because 10 >> This is really interesting because 10 years ago years ago years ago people were doing WYSIWYG software. people were doing WYSIWYG software. people were doing WYSIWYG software. What was the name for it? Before vibe What was the name for it? Before vibe What was the name for it? Before vibe coding. No code, low code. Yes. And when coding. No code, low code. Yes. And when coding. No code, low code. Yes. And when I saw that 10 years ago in my incubator I saw that 10 years ago in my incubator I saw that 10 years ago in my incubator you know, every 20th company somebody you know, every 20th company somebody you know, every 20th company somebody would come in who was an MBA would come in who was an MBA would come in who was an MBA or not a developer and they had vibe or not a developer and they had vibe or not a developer and they had vibe coded something. coded something. coded something. And And And not vibe coded, they had no coded. not vibe coded, they had no coded. not vibe coded, they had no coded. And they were using these different And they were using these different And they were using these different software platforms and software platforms and software platforms and the software didn't look good. It didn't the software didn't look good. It didn't the software didn't look good. It didn't work perfectly well. It was slow, but work perfectly well. It was slow, but work perfectly well. It was slow, but the promise was there. the promise was there. the promise was there. And I guess it took LLMs And I guess it took LLMs And I guess it took LLMs and this new intelligence and this new intelligence and this new intelligence to make actually good software. So to make actually good software. So to make actually good software. So maybe you could talk a little bit about maybe you could talk a little bit about maybe you could talk a little bit about who is the customer because developers who is the customer because developers who is the customer because developers do developers use lovable or is it the do developers use lovable or is it the do developers use lovable or is it the other 95% of society that are your other 95% of society that are your other 95% of society that are your customers? How do you think about who customers? How do you think about who customers? How do you think about who your ideal customer profile is? your ideal customer profile is? your ideal customer profile is? >> Yeah. We're seeing people use lovable >> Yeah. We're seeing people use lovable >> Yeah. We're seeing people use lovable both with a technical background. That's both with a technical background. That's both with a technical background. That's about 20% are technical or some type of about 20% are technical or some type of about 20% are technical or some type of engineer. And they they love that we're engineer. And they they love that we're engineer. And they they love that we're quite opinionated. We put all the best quite opinionated. We put all the best quite opinionated. We put all the best practices into how the software is practices into how the software is practices into how the software is architected. And we make it seamless to architected. And we make it seamless to architected. And we make it seamless to we want from get payments set up in a we want from get payments set up in a we want from get payments set up in a very secure way. And do things like run very secure way. And do things like run very secure way. And do things like run security scans after every change even security scans after every change even security scans after every change even now in the background monitoring the now in the background monitoring the now in the background monitoring the projects. So, it's actually quite projects. So, it's actually quite projects. So, it's actually quite appreciated by the engineers in the appreciated by the engineers in the appreciated by the engineers in the technical community. technical community. technical community. Also because it's a great bridge Also because it's a great bridge Also because it's a great bridge from the non-technical people which is from the non-technical people which is from the non-technical people which is four out of five are are non-technical. four out of five are are non-technical. four out of five are are non-technical. And they're building And they're building And they're building often first to figure out what is the often first to figure out what is the often first to figure out what is the right thing to build which is where right thing to build which is where right thing to build which is where lovable has always been exceptionally lovable has always been exceptionally lovable has always been exceptionally and and and now what we're seeing is that people are now what we're seeing is that people are now what we're seeing is that people are running running running businesses making more than million businesses making more than million businesses making more than million dollars of revenue on the on this dollars of revenue on the on this dollars of revenue on the on this platform. So it's platform. So it's platform. So it's a building for everyone. It's this a building for everyone. It's this a building for everyone. It's this entire spectrum. And what's what's entire spectrum. And what's what's entire spectrum. And what's what's exciting to see is often that if someone exciting to see is often that if someone exciting to see is often that if someone who discovers Lovable from their who discovers Lovable from their who discovers Lovable from their colleagues at the large company, they go colleagues at the large company, they go colleagues at the large company, they go out and then run a side hustle. out and then run a side hustle. out and then run a side hustle. And some of those side hustles hustles And some of those side hustles hustles And some of those side hustles hustles really work. They make hundreds of really work. They make hundreds of really work. They make hundreds of thousands of dollars and then they thousands of dollars and then they thousands of dollars and then they become a founder after that. So this is become a founder after that. So this is become a founder after that. So this is cross-pollination from both uh cross-pollination from both uh cross-pollination from both uh >> Yeah, and this is like the really >> Yeah, and this is like the really >> Yeah, and this is like the really interesting thing about Vibe coding. If interesting thing about Vibe coding. If interesting thing about Vibe coding. If we were sitting here last year, people we were sitting here last year, people we were sitting here last year, people would look at it and say, "It's a great would look at it and say, "It's a great would look at it and say, "It's a great way to make a mock-up." Like you said, way to make a mock-up." Like you said, way to make a mock-up." Like you said, "A great way to think about product and "A great way to think about product and "A great way to think about product and maybe maybe maybe create wireframes or a workable create wireframes or a workable create wireframes or a workable prototype." All of that's out the window prototype." All of that's out the window prototype." All of that's out the window now. The whole concept of building now. The whole concept of building now. The whole concept of building wireframes and building a mock-up Well, wireframes and building a mock-up Well, wireframes and building a mock-up Well, you can just go right to building the you can just go right to building the you can just go right to building the product in a day or 2 days. And product in a day or 2 days. And product in a day or 2 days. And what people I think don't appreciate what people I think don't appreciate what people I think don't appreciate about what you're doing at Lovable is about what you're doing at Lovable is about what you're doing at Lovable is after you've made a product that you're after you've made a product that you're after you've made a product that you're proud of and that has some product proud of and that has some product proud of and that has some product market fit, there are many more steps market fit, there are many more steps market fit, there are many more steps that are required. You mentioned that are required. You mentioned that are required. You mentioned payments, you mentioned security, payments, you mentioned security, payments, you mentioned security, uh making sure that the data isn't lost uh making sure that the data isn't lost uh making sure that the data isn't lost or that it's not leaked. or that it's not leaked. or that it's not leaked. That's changed dramatically over the That's changed dramatically over the That's changed dramatically over the last 12 months, yeah? last 12 months, yeah? last 12 months, yeah? >> Very much so. So um I would say many >> Very much so. So um I would say many >> Very much so. So um I would say many engineers, they don't look at the code. engineers, they don't look at the code. engineers, they don't look at the code. They don't write code anymore. And that They don't write code anymore. And that They don't write code anymore. And that means that you don't need to be an means that you don't need to be an means that you don't need to be an engineer to create software, right? Um engineer to create software, right? Um engineer to create software, right? Um but the the thing that Lovable does for but the the thing that Lovable does for but the the thing that Lovable does for any anyone, also the non-technical any anyone, also the non-technical any anyone, also the non-technical people, is that it it um takes people, is that it it um takes people, is that it it um takes uh uh creates a structure for the uh uh creates a structure for the uh uh creates a structure for the architecture of the software that you architecture of the software that you architecture of the software that you build and it makes sure that you don't build and it makes sure that you don't build and it makes sure that you don't go off a cliff um and that things like go off a cliff um and that things like go off a cliff um and that things like setting up payments, emails, setting up payments, emails, setting up payments, emails, things like getting discovered by other things like getting discovered by other things like getting discovered by other AI chat engines and uh by Google search. AI chat engines and uh by Google search. AI chat engines and uh by Google search. Those things are kind of taken care of. Those things are kind of taken care of. Those things are kind of taken care of. Yeah. You don't have to know how the all Yeah. You don't have to know how the all Yeah. You don't have to know how the all these things work in the details. You these things work in the details. You these things work in the details. You trust You can trust the platform to take trust You can trust the platform to take trust You can trust the platform to take care care of data security, uh care care of data security, uh care care of data security, uh connecting to other tools that you might connecting to other tools that you might connecting to other tools that you might be using in a secure way. And And that's be using in a secure way. And And that's be using in a secure way. And And that's really where really where really where uh us being opinionated from day one and uh us being opinionated from day one and uh us being opinionated from day one and being focused on making this for the being focused on making this for the being focused on making this for the 99%. It's a It's a vast market, right? 99%. It's a It's a vast market, right? 99%. It's a It's a vast market, right? >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> From the From day one is what made us >> From the From day one is what made us >> From the From day one is what made us very successful. very successful. very successful. >> Yeah, and I can tell you internally, I >> Yeah, and I can tell you internally, I >> Yeah, and I can tell you internally, I gave my team all the different tools gave my team all the different tools gave my team all the different tools they could possibly want to use. they could possibly want to use. they could possibly want to use. And somebody had started with lovable. And somebody had started with lovable. And somebody had started with lovable. I think I told you the story when you I think I told you the story when you I think I told you the story when you were on This Week in Startups a year were on This Week in Startups a year were on This Week in Startups a year ago. Like And they made some interesting ago. Like And they made some interesting ago. Like And they made some interesting websites and they were trying to make an websites and they were trying to make an websites and they were trying to make an intranet. They couldn't quite get it intranet. They couldn't quite get it intranet. They couldn't quite get it done. done. done. Then I had some people who started Then I had some people who started Then I had some people who started using, you know, Cursor or Claude Code. using, you know, Cursor or Claude Code. using, you know, Cursor or Claude Code. They started vibe coding stuff, but they They started vibe coding stuff, but they They started vibe coding stuff, but they couldn't finish the product. And then couldn't finish the product. And then couldn't finish the product. And then people tried to solve some problems with people tried to solve some problems with people tried to solve some problems with Co-work. I really like Perplexity Co-work. I really like Perplexity Co-work. I really like Perplexity computer. And then my team came to me computer. And then my team came to me computer. And then my team came to me and for one of our projects, I was and for one of our projects, I was and for one of our projects, I was talking to you about Founder University, talking to you about Founder University, talking to you about Founder University, our pre-accelerator, they wanted to make our pre-accelerator, they wanted to make our pre-accelerator, they wanted to make an intranet. an intranet. an intranet. Um now, this is something I would have Um now, this is something I would have Um now, this is something I would have never okayed because it would have cost never okayed because it would have cost never okayed because it would have cost $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 10 years ago to make it and we don't 10 years ago to make it and we don't 10 years ago to make it and we don't have that kind of budget, you know, we have that kind of budget, you know, we have that kind of budget, you know, we would rather put that towards the would rather put that towards the would rather put that towards the founders in the program and getting more founders in the program and getting more founders in the program and getting more people into the program. people into the program. people into the program. And in 4 to 8 hours, they made the whole And in 4 to 8 hours, they made the whole And in 4 to 8 hours, they made the whole intranet and they made a bunch of things intranet and they made a bunch of things intranet and they made a bunch of things I hadn't asked for. I hadn't asked for. I hadn't asked for. And it was the person running the And it was the person running the And it was the person running the um um um this Founder University who made it. this Founder University who made it. this Founder University who made it. And she did it on her own without And she did it on her own without And she did it on her own without uh permission in lovable. I said, "Whoa, uh permission in lovable. I said, "Whoa, uh permission in lovable. I said, "Whoa, what How did you build this?" She said, what How did you build this?" She said, what How did you build this?" She said, "Lovable." I was like, "Oh, we still "Lovable." I was like, "Oh, we still "Lovable." I was like, "Oh, we still have lovable?" And they're like She's have lovable?" And they're like She's have lovable?" And they're like She's like, "I just put it on my corporate like, "I just put it on my corporate like, "I just put it on my corporate card." To your point, she made it. Now card." To your point, she made it. Now card." To your point, she made it. Now that that that software is driving the program and software is driving the program and software is driving the program and the reason people do the the reason people do the the reason people do the uh the the program in their country, we uh the the program in their country, we uh the the program in their country, we have it in Saudi and in Japan, is have it in Saudi and in Japan, is have it in Saudi and in Japan, is because it has economic impact. because it has economic impact. because it has economic impact. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> So, I said, "Hey, I have an idea. Can >> So, I said, "Hey, I have an idea. Can >> So, I said, "Hey, I have an idea. Can you make for me an economic impact of you make for me an economic impact of you make for me an economic impact of the 50 companies that are in the the 50 companies that are in the the 50 companies that are in the program?" program?" program?" She asked Lovable to do it. I gave her She asked Lovable to do it. I gave her She asked Lovable to do it. I gave her some, you know, prompting, human some, you know, prompting, human some, you know, prompting, human prompting, boss to prompting, boss to prompting, boss to Now it has the economic impact in there, Now it has the economic impact in there, Now it has the economic impact in there, and it considered, you know, with our and it considered, you know, with our and it considered, you know, with our prompting, prompting, prompting, "Well, how many people work at each "Well, how many people work at each "Well, how many people work at each company? What are they paying taxes? How company? What are they paying taxes? How company? What are they paying taxes? How much do they rent their home for? What much do they rent their home for? What much do they rent their home for? What is their average salary?" is their average salary?" is their average salary?" And it built something that I would have And it built something that I would have And it built something that I would have never been able to afford to build. never been able to afford to build. never been able to afford to build. And Lovable is 50 bucks a month, I And Lovable is 50 bucks a month, I And Lovable is 50 bucks a month, I think. I don't know how much you charge, think. I don't know how much you charge, think. I don't know how much you charge, but it's far too little. Like, $50 a but it's far too little. Like, $50 a but it's far too little. Like, $50 a month, I think. month, I think. month, I think. >> the that's the if you're on a business >> the that's the if you're on a business >> the that's the if you're on a business plan. Yeah, I start at 25. plan. Yeah, I start at 25. plan. Yeah, I start at 25. >> Yeah, so >> Yeah, so >> Yeah, so uh the economic impact of what you're uh the economic impact of what you're uh the economic impact of what you're building building building is I would equate for what you built to is I would equate for what you built to is I would equate for what you built to us, it would have cost me $500,000 2 us, it would have cost me $500,000 2 us, it would have cost me $500,000 2 years ago. It was built in 4 hours by an years ago. It was built in 4 hours by an years ago. It was built in 4 hours by an employee, which if you just put employee, which if you just put employee, which if you just put employees at 50, 60, whatever, 70 employees at 50, 60, whatever, 70 employees at 50, 60, whatever, 70 dollars, dollars, dollars, uh plus the cost of your software, it uh plus the cost of your software, it uh plus the cost of your software, it got made for less than got made for less than got made for less than $2,000. In a year. $2,000. In a year. $2,000. In a year. It's extraordinary. It's extraordinary. It's extraordinary. >> I'd love to hear more about the progress >> I'd love to hear more about the progress >> I'd love to hear more about the progress of the of the internet. Anything that of the of the internet. Anything that of the of the internet. Anything that you asked for that you want to forward you asked for that you want to forward you asked for that you want to forward directly to me? directly to me? directly to me? >> Uh well, right now, >> Uh well, right now, >> Uh well, right now, you know, my concern was security and you know, my concern was security and you know, my concern was security and making sure that data didn't leak, and making sure that data didn't leak, and making sure that data didn't leak, and they talked to your team and they went they talked to your team and they went they talked to your team and they went through it, and through it, and through it, and it's secure, so we feel good about it. it's secure, so we feel good about it. it's secure, so we feel good about it. >> Well, look, um I'm now asking people who >> Well, look, um I'm now asking people who >> Well, look, um I'm now asking people who do penetration testing to say, "I want do penetration testing to say, "I want do penetration testing to say, "I want you to compare all the tools Yeah, you to compare all the tools Yeah, you to compare all the tools Yeah, uh make sure that there's a all the work uh make sure that there's a all the work uh make sure that there's a all the work that we're doing that's not visible on that we're doing that's not visible on that we're doing that's not visible on security and trust. There's a lot of a security and trust. There's a lot of a security and trust. There's a lot of a lot of other things um lot of other things um lot of other things um where we uh we invest and spend money on where we uh we invest and spend money on where we uh we invest and spend money on that every also free users get a lot of that every also free users get a lot of that every also free users get a lot of security scanning running in the security scanning running in the security scanning running in the background that that actually um background that that actually um background that that actually um translates to something that security translates to something that security translates to something that security experts can can see. experts can can see. experts can can see. >> A year ago we were at mockups. Now we're >> A year ago we were at mockups. Now we're >> A year ago we were at mockups. Now we're at functionality and secure and super at functionality and secure and super at functionality and secure and super viable for deployment. Where will you be viable for deployment. Where will you be viable for deployment. Where will you be in a year? in a year? in a year? >> Yeah, so what we're seeing is that >> Yeah, so what we're seeing is that >> Yeah, so what we're seeing is that there's a gap in build being able to there's a gap in build being able to there's a gap in build being able to build the product right. And and you build the product right. And and you build the product right. And and you built an entire intranet on on the built an entire intranet on on the built an entire intranet on on the platform. That's great. Um platform. That's great. Um platform. That's great. Um what we've done since then is to have a what we've done since then is to have a what we've done since then is to have a new product line basically, the hosting new product line basically, the hosting new product line basically, the hosting part, which is both the AI and all you part, which is both the AI and all you part, which is both the AI and all you know all the normal hosting. And that know all the normal hosting. And that know all the normal hosting. And that product line has been growing faster product line has been growing faster product line has been growing faster than the building thing I I mentioned. than the building thing I I mentioned. than the building thing I I mentioned. >> AWS competitor. >> AWS competitor. >> AWS competitor. >> It it's a let's it's not you run all >> It it's a let's it's not you run all >> It it's a let's it's not you run all your software and then we're working your software and then we're working your software and then we're working with companies like AWS and Red Hat as with companies like AWS and Red Hat as with companies like AWS and Red Hat as well. But but what you also want to have well. But but what you also want to have well. But but what you also want to have is um is um is um to use Lovable we're we're seeing by our to use Lovable we're we're seeing by our to use Lovable we're we're seeing by our customers as an AI co-founder. A partner customers as an AI co-founder. A partner customers as an AI co-founder. A partner that you talk to about everything in that you talk to about everything in that you talk to about everything in your business. And if you're running your business. And if you're running your business. And if you're running your apps your apps your apps your tools are on the platform, then your tools are on the platform, then your tools are on the platform, then just talking to Lovable has access to just talking to Lovable has access to just talking to Lovable has access to all the data all the data all the data that you might want to know about your that you might want to know about your that you might want to know about your about your company, how it's doing. So about your company, how it's doing. So about your company, how it's doing. So we're we're working with some of our we're we're working with some of our we're we're working with some of our customers in pre-release to give them customers in pre-release to give them customers in pre-release to give them access to a co-founder that works for access to a co-founder that works for access to a co-founder that works for for you even when you're sleeping. for you even when you're sleeping. for you even when you're sleeping. And comes back to you in the morning and And comes back to you in the morning and And comes back to you in the morning and says like here are some strategic says like here are some strategic says like here are some strategic directions you could go. Here's some directions you could go. Here's some directions you could go. Here's some optimizations you can go go in terms of optimizations you can go go in terms of optimizations you can go go in terms of growing your business faster, serving growing your business faster, serving growing your business faster, serving your customers better, faster. your customers better, faster. your customers better, faster. And and and that's And and and that's And and and that's that evolution towards operation and that evolution towards operation and that evolution towards operation and intelligence for towards driving towards intelligence for towards driving towards intelligence for towards driving towards outcome outcome outcome for your business. for your business. for your business. >> So you come and build the software, but >> So you come and build the software, but >> So you come and build the software, but you stay to build the business. you stay to build the business. you stay to build the business. >> Yes, to operate your business. And >> Yes, to operate your business. And >> Yes, to operate your business. And what we're already doing I've I've been what we're already doing I've I've been what we're already doing I've I've been doing for a very long time is to doing for a very long time is to doing for a very long time is to compound from everything we're learning. compound from everything we're learning. compound from everything we're learning. Every time Lovable makes a mistake, it Every time Lovable makes a mistake, it Every time Lovable makes a mistake, it goes through our genetic system with our goes through our genetic system with our goes through our genetic system with our engineers in it improving it. engineers in it improving it. engineers in it improving it. That compounding intelligence is of That compounding intelligence is of That compounding intelligence is of course applicable to course applicable to course applicable to our our customers our users running our our customers our users running our our customers our users running their business on our platform as well. their business on our platform as well. their business on our platform as well. >> Is software going to become >> Is software going to become >> Is software going to become 100% bespoke even like the internal 100% bespoke even like the internal 100% bespoke even like the internal tools? I was looking at Slack. tools? I was looking at Slack. tools? I was looking at Slack. And our bill for Slack even on the And our bill for Slack even on the And our bill for Slack even on the highest version is maybe $10,000 a year. highest version is maybe $10,000 a year. highest version is maybe $10,000 a year. It's not a lot of money. It's not a lot of money. It's not a lot of money. It's well worth it. It's well worth it. It's well worth it. But I was starting to think, well maybe But I was starting to think, well maybe But I was starting to think, well maybe I should buy code my own Slack. I should buy code my own Slack. I should buy code my own Slack. So it's integrated into everything we do So it's integrated into everything we do So it's integrated into everything we do at a deeper level. at a deeper level. at a deeper level. So how do you think the So how do you think the So how do you think the What do you think the future will look What do you think the future will look What do you think the future will look like in terms of some of these like in terms of some of these like in terms of some of these you know uh foundational pieces of you know uh foundational pieces of you know uh foundational pieces of software that every startup every software that every startup every software that every startup every enterprise uses? Salesforce, HubSpot, enterprise uses? Salesforce, HubSpot, enterprise uses? Salesforce, HubSpot, Slack, Slack, Slack, uh the Google Suite, Microsoft Office. uh the Google Suite, Microsoft Office. uh the Google Suite, Microsoft Office. Will bespoke software Will bespoke software Will bespoke software start to replace those? start to replace those? start to replace those? Do you believe? Do you believe? Do you believe? >> I I like this question. Let me ask >> I I like this question. Let me ask >> I I like this question. Let me ask answer you, but I'll just answer you, but I'll just answer you, but I'll just give you a story about someone I give you a story about someone I give you a story about someone I recently heard who's going on this recently heard who's going on this recently heard who's going on this journey. They're quite the brand. So journey. They're quite the brand. So journey. They're quite the brand. So Nenad, he works at a pretty large Nenad, he works at a pretty large Nenad, he works at a pretty large company in the US, Nursa. And he came to company in the US, Nursa. And he came to company in the US, Nursa. And he came to our platform because he wanted to build our platform because he wanted to build our platform because he wanted to build out the new product lines. Nursa study out the new product lines. Nursa study out the new product lines. Nursa study for educating more nurses. And and he for educating more nurses. And and he for educating more nurses. And and he built out all the admin tools for the built out all the admin tools for the built out all the admin tools for the program, the scheduling for the nurses program, the scheduling for the nurses program, the scheduling for the nurses getting getting their licenses and their getting getting their licenses and their getting getting their licenses and their certification management. And he was certification management. And he was certification management. And he was able to build that into a product and to able to build that into a product and to able to build that into a product and to take it to market because they have they take it to market because they have they take it to market because they have they have had all that access to nurses have had all that access to nurses have had all that access to nurses wanting their certification. What he wanting their certification. What he wanting their certification. What he also did was he took it into also did was he took it into also did was he took it into the back office internally and they've the back office internally and they've the back office internally and they've now replaced more than 10 tools that now replaced more than 10 tools that now replaced more than 10 tools that they had in just bespoke applications. they had in just bespoke applications. they had in just bespoke applications. And And And I think in terms of your question, you I think in terms of your question, you I think in terms of your question, you can do that for multiple reasons. In can do that for multiple reasons. In can do that for multiple reasons. In their case, they're saving more than a their case, they're saving more than a their case, they're saving more than a million dollars per year. million dollars per year. million dollars per year. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> that's huge, right? But it's also the >> that's huge, right? But it's also the >> that's huge, right? But it's also the case that case that case that in some cases, you have specific in some cases, you have specific in some cases, you have specific requirements where the tools that you've requirements where the tools that you've requirements where the tools that you've been using to date, they aren't been using to date, they aren't been using to date, they aren't suited for those requirements exactly. suited for those requirements exactly. suited for those requirements exactly. And in those cases, I think yes. You And in those cases, I think yes. You And in those cases, I think yes. You will have more more bespoke solutions. will have more more bespoke solutions. will have more more bespoke solutions. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> But but we're all I will I also expect >> But but we're all I will I also expect >> But but we're all I will I also expect us to see that us to see that >> [snorts] >> Lovable continues to interoperate with >> Lovable continues to interoperate with >> Lovable continues to interoperate with all of those tools. And I'm not sure if all of those tools. And I'm not sure if all of those tools. And I'm not sure if you tried this. If you ask for you tried this. If you ask for you tried this. If you ask for connecting to anything in the Google connecting to anything in the Google connecting to anything in the Google suite suite Yeah. Or now suite suite Yeah. Or now suite suite Yeah. Or now anything in the Microsoft suite or or anything in the Microsoft suite or or anything in the Microsoft suite or or Slack. If Lovable guides you through all Slack. If Lovable guides you through all Slack. If Lovable guides you through all the steps to do that in a way where you the steps to do that in a way where you the steps to do that in a way where you can get a lot a very good overview of can get a lot a very good overview of can get a lot a very good overview of exactly how the data flows, which is of exactly how the data flows, which is of exactly how the data flows, which is of course very important that you don't course very important that you don't course very important that you don't give access to the wrong person to the give access to the wrong person to the give access to the wrong person to the wrong data. And you can continue to use wrong data. And you can continue to use wrong data. And you can continue to use Salesforce, Salesforce, Salesforce, HubSpot, and all the tools that you kind HubSpot, and all the tools that you kind HubSpot, and all the tools that you kind of like to use under the hood but with a of like to use under the hood but with a of like to use under the hood but with a bespoke interface on top of it. bespoke interface on top of it. bespoke interface on top of it. >> How have these new frontier models >> How have these new frontier models >> How have these new frontier models they're in some ways competitive but in they're in some ways competitive but in they're in some ways competitive but in some ways you can use them to power some ways you can use them to power some ways you can use them to power Lovable. So how do you think about Lovable. So how do you think about Lovable. So how do you think about the competition with them, open source the competition with them, open source the competition with them, open source and the future of Lovable because people and the future of Lovable because people and the future of Lovable because people have announced that Lovable's dead every have announced that Lovable's dead every have announced that Lovable's dead every 6 months since you started and then 6 months since you started and then 6 months since you started and then every 6 months every 6 months every 6 months you go from 100 to 200 to 300. I think you go from 100 to 200 to 300. I think you go from 100 to 200 to 300. I think you're at 400 million in revenue, you're at 400 million in revenue, you're at 400 million in revenue, something crazy. something crazy. something crazy. >> We we met we reached 500 in May. >> We we met we reached 500 in May. >> We we met we reached 500 in May. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Yeah, yeah, it's growth is a phenomenal. >> Yeah, yeah, it's growth is a phenomenal. >> Yeah, yeah, it's growth is a phenomenal. >> So you're dying again by another 100 >> So you're dying again by another 100 >> So you're dying again by another 100 million in annual revenue. So, but million in annual revenue. So, but million in annual revenue. So, but underneath the hood you're using some of underneath the hood you're using some of underneath the hood you're using some of these these these >> Yeah, let me explain. Yeah. So, we've >> Yeah, let me explain. Yeah. So, we've >> Yeah, let me explain. Yeah. So, we've always had the strategy that we do always had the strategy that we do always had the strategy that we do whatever is best for our customers. And whatever is best for our customers. And whatever is best for our customers. And in terms of the intelligence, that means in terms of the intelligence, that means in terms of the intelligence, that means that that that we're using we're using we're using multiple models. And so, if you ask multiple models. And so, if you ask multiple models. And so, if you ask lovable now, it's actually routed to the lovable now, it's actually routed to the lovable now, it's actually routed to the model that's both suitable to whatever model that's both suitable to whatever model that's both suitable to whatever you want to do. And that's both the you want to do. And that's both the you want to do. And that's both the commercial frontier models. commercial frontier models. commercial frontier models. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> From multiple vendors. >> From multiple vendors. >> From multiple vendors. And increasingly, it's open weight And increasingly, it's open weight And increasingly, it's open weight models. Where our team when whenever it models. Where our team when whenever it models. Where our team when whenever it get gets routed to get gets routed to get gets routed to to our own model, that model becomes to our own model, that model becomes to our own model, that model becomes more intelligent for our agent harness. more intelligent for our agent harness. more intelligent for our agent harness. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Especially on the mistakes that it might >> Especially on the mistakes that it might >> Especially on the mistakes that it might be making in some cases be making in some cases be making in some cases on which which tool to call, which on which which tool to call, which on which which tool to call, which integration to create, and how to guide integration to create, and how to guide integration to create, and how to guide you through success for your business. you through success for your business. you through success for your business. >> Right. So, you're all in on open source. >> Right. So, you're all in on open source. >> Right. So, you're all in on open source. You believe that's the future of You believe that's the future of You believe that's the future of lovable. lovable. lovable. >> Well, I would I'm reading into it. >> Well, I would I'm reading into it. >> Well, I would I'm reading into it. >> So, we have a multiple partnerships, and >> So, we have a multiple partnerships, and >> So, we have a multiple partnerships, and we're investing heavily to be close with we're investing heavily to be close with we're investing heavily to be close with those partners. those partners. those partners. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> And it's the big the big labs. And it's >> And it's the big the big labs. And it's >> And it's the big the big labs. And it's also to make sure that also to make sure that also to make sure that um um um we get the fastest performance at the we get the fastest performance at the we get the fastest performance at the lowest cost for our customers when we lowest cost for our customers when we lowest cost for our customers when we know that we can do that with our own know that we can do that with our own know that we can do that with our own models. models. models. >> Right. >> Right. >> Right. >> And we have a really really strong >> And we have a really really strong >> And we have a really really strong research team up in Stockholm who is research team up in Stockholm who is research team up in Stockholm who is working on what's called post training. working on what's called post training. working on what's called post training. >> Sure. >> Sure. >> Sure. >> So, and we're applying all the best >> So, and we're applying all the best >> So, and we're applying all the best practices to do that and scaling up that practices to do that and scaling up that practices to do that and scaling up that team team team quite significantly. Since we also quite significantly. Since we also quite significantly. Since we also believe it's a it's a part of the believe it's a it's a part of the believe it's a it's a part of the European ecosystem to have that European ecosystem to have that European ecosystem to have that capability in Europe specifically. capability in Europe specifically. capability in Europe specifically. >> Are you doing or are you using any of >> Are you doing or are you using any of >> Are you doing or are you using any of the data labeling, data training the data labeling, data training the data labeling, data training companies to help you understand the companies to help you understand the companies to help you understand the most common businesses and build that most common businesses and build that most common businesses and build that proprietary data? proprietary data? proprietary data? >> So, so we're what we're doing is that >> So, so we're what we're doing is that >> So, so we're what we're doing is that we're looking at we're looking at we're looking at the mistakes that any of the models do the mistakes that any of the models do the mistakes that any of the models do right now. right now. right now. >> Ah. >> Ah. >> Ah. >> And then we we prioritize them by what >> And then we we prioritize them by what >> And then we we prioritize them by what drives most impact for our customers and drives most impact for our customers and drives most impact for our customers and then we make the models we create data then we make the models we create data then we make the models we create data sets where we sets where we sets where we we do did something called reinforcement we do did something called reinforcement we do did something called reinforcement learning for specifically for the learning for specifically for the learning for specifically for the problems where the frontier models are problems where the frontier models are problems where the frontier models are making mistakes for us right now making mistakes for us right now making mistakes for us right now and and and we have this enormous token distribution we have this enormous token distribution we have this enormous token distribution right from right from right from a million new projects being built every a million new projects being built every a million new projects being built every every single week. every single week. every single week. >> You're burning a lot of tokens. >> You're burning a lot of tokens. >> You're burning a lot of tokens. >> We are yes and that's and that's a lot >> We are yes and that's and that's a lot >> We are yes and that's and that's a lot of signals for making the system both of signals for making the system both of signals for making the system both the agent harness and what we've been the agent harness and what we've been the agent harness and what we've been refining over the last two years which refining over the last two years which refining over the last two years which is the skills that we have the how does is the skills that we have the how does is the skills that we have the how does it like internal type of skills that the it like internal type of skills that the it like internal type of skills that the agent knows when to remember the facts agent knows when to remember the facts agent knows when to remember the facts from our software engineers that know from our software engineers that know from our software engineers that know how to build really really good software how to build really really good software how to build really really good software we're modifying both of those on every we're modifying both of those on every we're modifying both of those on every every single week. every single week. every single week. >> Makes total sense and somebody told me >> Makes total sense and somebody told me >> Makes total sense and somebody told me some companies are doing token dumping some companies are doing token dumping some companies are doing token dumping they're you know selling a hundred they're you know selling a hundred they're you know selling a hundred dollars worth of tokens for fifty dollars worth of tokens for fifty dollars worth of tokens for fifty dollars dollars dollars you know basically they become token you know basically they become token you know basically they become token resellers in some ways and they're money resellers in some ways and they're money resellers in some ways and they're money losing businesses you have to you're losing businesses you have to you're losing businesses you have to you're money you're profitable I believe now or money you're profitable I believe now or money you're profitable I believe now or close to it. close to it. close to it. >> We we always monitor our margins but >> We we always monitor our margins but >> We we always monitor our margins but again again again we're doing what's best for our we're doing what's best for our we're doing what's best for our customers and that means that often customers and that means that often customers and that means that often means more intelligence so we're not means more intelligence so we're not means more intelligence so we're not we're not looking at oh let's use it we we're not looking at oh let's use it we we're not looking at oh let's use it we use we have never had the decision to use we have never had the decision to use we have never had the decision to say let's not use a cheaper model here say let's not use a cheaper model here say let's not use a cheaper model here if it's if it's if it's measurably worse for our customers and measurably worse for our customers and measurably worse for our customers and we can measure that what's best for our we can measure that what's best for our we can measure that what's best for our customers. customers. customers. >> is it unlimited for the fifty or you >> is it unlimited for the fifty or you >> is it unlimited for the fifty or you have caps now? have caps now? have caps now? >> We have caps. >> We have caps. >> We have caps. >> Yeah you have to have caps over existing >> Yeah you have to have caps over existing >> Yeah you have to have caps over existing caps are people starting to hit them? caps are people starting to hit them? caps are people starting to hit them? >> Yeah our customers definitely hit caps >> Yeah our customers definitely hit caps >> Yeah our customers definitely hit caps and then you can top up you can have a and then you can top up you can have a and then you can top up you can have a we have multiple subscriptions here. we have multiple subscriptions here. we have multiple subscriptions here. >> What number I'm just curious like what >> What number I'm just curious like what >> What number I'm just curious like what percentage of people need to top up percentage of people need to top up percentage of people need to top up they're so addicted to it that they're they're so addicted to it that they're they're so addicted to it that they're blowing past the blowing past the blowing past the >> This is >> This is >> This is >> Some of the from the lower subscription >> Some of the from the lower subscription >> Some of the from the lower subscription tier tier tier Um, I I think it's um Um, I I think it's um Um, I I think it's um uh much uh much uh much I something like 60% of our customers I something like 60% of our customers I something like 60% of our customers are I think it's like are I think it's like are I think it's like >> I'm hearing that more and more often >> I'm hearing that more and more often >> I'm hearing that more and more often that people are willing to pay the that people are willing to pay the that people are willing to pay the overages cuz they're getting so much overages cuz they're getting so much overages cuz they're getting so much value. And I think that's the future of value. And I think that's the future of value. And I think that's the future of the business is the business is the business is people are looking at it going like I am people are looking at it going like I am people are looking at it going like I am >> [snorts] >> [snorts] >> [snorts] >> well, if I'm paying $600 >> well, if I'm paying $600 >> well, if I'm paying $600 and if you token max to 6,000 a year and if you token max to 6,000 a year and if you token max to 6,000 a year but this is a $500,000 piece of but this is a $500,000 piece of but this is a $500,000 piece of software. I don't care. I'm still paying software. I don't care. I'm still paying software. I don't care. I'm still paying somewhere between 0.1% and 1% of what I somewhere between 0.1% and 1% of what I somewhere between 0.1% and 1% of what I would have paid 3 years ago. Who cares? would have paid 3 years ago. Who cares? would have paid 3 years ago. Who cares? Go for it. Um, so Go for it. Um, so Go for it. Um, so >> Yeah, what we're seeing is everything is >> Yeah, what we're seeing is everything is >> Yeah, what we're seeing is everything is about moving moving fast these days. And about moving moving fast these days. And about moving moving fast these days. And and the AI more AI usually let you move and the AI more AI usually let you move and the AI more AI usually let you move much faster. So, this this spend is much faster. So, this this spend is much faster. So, this this spend is usually worth it. usually worth it. usually worth it. >> Hey, do your customers a final question >> Hey, do your customers a final question >> Hey, do your customers a final question for you cuz I'm starting to see this now for you cuz I'm starting to see this now for you cuz I'm starting to see this now where [snorts] multiple people in the where [snorts] multiple people in the where [snorts] multiple people in the organization try to solve the same organization try to solve the same organization try to solve the same software problem software problem software problem and they're competing with each other. and they're competing with each other. and they're competing with each other. So, like this intranet I'm talking So, like this intranet I'm talking So, like this intranet I'm talking about, we built one for Japan. about, we built one for Japan. about, we built one for Japan. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> But somebody built the US one. So, now I >> But somebody built the US one. So, now I >> But somebody built the US one. So, now I have two pieces of software. So, I said have two pieces of software. So, I said have two pieces of software. So, I said to the two different people to the two different people to the two different people or or or do we have Did you guys fork each do we have Did you guys fork each do we have Did you guys fork each other's code or They're like, "No, we other's code or They're like, "No, we other's code or They're like, "No, we just built two different lovable just built two different lovable just built two different lovable projects." And I'm like projects." And I'm like projects." And I'm like is that the right thing to do because is that the right thing to do because is that the right thing to do because you went faster and I had two swings at you went faster and I had two swings at you went faster and I had two swings at bat, two different intelligent brilliant bat, two different intelligent brilliant bat, two different intelligent brilliant people making their version of the people making their version of the people making their version of the software. software. software. But you would never have done that But you would never have done that But you would never have done that in the previous way of building in the previous way of building in the previous way of building software. You would have one track of software. You would have one track of software. You would have one track of software and you would be building software and you would be building software and you would be building Franken software where you'd be trying Franken software where you'd be trying Franken software where you'd be trying to get all the needs into it from the to get all the needs into it from the to get all the needs into it from the two different groups. two different groups. two different groups. >> Uh yeah, I'm actually a huge fan of very >> Uh yeah, I'm actually a huge fan of very >> Uh yeah, I'm actually a huge fan of very rapid experimentation. And I I have a rapid experimentation. And I I have a rapid experimentation. And I I have a story where for a while I worked at story where for a while I worked at story where for a while I worked at a place called CERN where they do a place called CERN where they do a place called CERN where they do particle physics. It's it's pretty here particle physics. It's it's pretty here particle physics. It's it's pretty here in South Europe, right? Uh And that's in South Europe, right? Uh And that's in South Europe, right? Uh And that's where I was introduced to this concept where I was introduced to this concept where I was introduced to this concept of competition where they have two of competition where they have two of competition where they have two actually quite isolated teams working on actually quite isolated teams working on actually quite isolated teams working on the same the same the same particle accelerator but different particle accelerator but different particle accelerator but different places on it. And then they don't share places on it. And then they don't share places on it. And then they don't share the results until they publish. And that the results until they publish. And that the results until they publish. And that way they way they way they they can kind of over time learn what's they can kind of over time learn what's they can kind of over time learn what's working best in the different working best in the different working best in the different organizations. But you don't get stuck organizations. But you don't get stuck organizations. But you don't get stuck in a local minimum. And it's you know, in a local minimum. And it's you know, in a local minimum. And it's you know, free markets work extremely well because free markets work extremely well because free markets work extremely well because of competition. And they they they do of competition. And they they they do of competition. And they they they do that in academia as well. And now since that in academia as well. And now since that in academia as well. And now since the engineering is less of the the engineering is less of the the engineering is less of the bottleneck, it's more of the question of bottleneck, it's more of the question of bottleneck, it's more of the question of what is the right thing to build. I what is the right thing to build. I what is the right thing to build. I think it's a great thing to have if you think it's a great thing to have if you think it's a great thing to have if you have the sufficiently many humans, have the sufficiently many humans, have the sufficiently many humans, right? To do right? To do right? To do to try to attempt the solving the same to try to attempt the solving the same to try to attempt the solving the same problem in different ways. And then if problem in different ways. And then if problem in different ways. And then if you do that on Lovable, what I like to you do that on Lovable, what I like to you do that on Lovable, what I like to do is I I take I bring up a new project do is I I take I bring up a new project do is I I take I bring up a new project or one of the projects and I I say, or one of the projects and I I say, or one of the projects and I I say, "Hey, can you go and I check out this "Hey, can you go and I check out this "Hey, can you go and I check out this other one and take this these three other one and take this these three other one and take this these three things that I really like and and bring things that I really like and and bring things that I really like and and bring them bring them over here and maybe even them bring them over here and maybe even them bring them over here and maybe even run an a split test, run an experiment run an a split test, run an experiment run an a split test, run an experiment to see if it's if it's improves to see if it's if it's improves to see if it's if it's improves improving the metrics for for our improving the metrics for for our improving the metrics for for our customers we're trying to serve." customers we're trying to serve." customers we're trying to serve." >> Did you see somebody used Fable to build >> Did you see somebody used Fable to build >> Did you see somebody used Fable to build Fortnite? Fortnite? Fortnite? And uh And uh And uh >> I think there's some 3D some of the 3D >> I think there's some 3D some of the 3D >> I think there's some 3D some of the 3D games, yeah. games, yeah. games, yeah. >> Yeah. This What is your take on, you >> Yeah. This What is your take on, you >> Yeah. This What is your take on, you know, this latest version from know, this latest version from know, this latest version from Anthropic, Fable? I know they're a Anthropic, Fable? I know they're a Anthropic, Fable? I know they're a partner or I assume they're a partner. I partner or I assume they're a partner. I partner or I assume they're a partner. I don't know that. don't know that. don't know that. >> Yeah, we use Fable as well as a one of >> Yeah, we use Fable as well as a one of >> Yeah, we use Fable as well as a one of the models, yeah, in Lovable. the models, yeah, in Lovable. the models, yeah, in Lovable. >> So, what do you think of it in terms of >> So, what do you think of it in terms of >> So, what do you think of it in terms of compared to the last generation? Faster, compared to the last generation? Faster, compared to the last generation? Faster, better, both? better, both? better, both? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Is it a massive step function? Yeah. Is it a massive step function? Yeah. Is it a massive step function? Yeah. >> What I've seen is that it >> What I've seen is that it >> What I've seen is that it can in the first attempt create very can in the first attempt create very can in the first attempt create very sophisticated things that look really sophisticated things that look really sophisticated things that look really good. Then when as you're evolving, good. Then when as you're evolving, good. Then when as you're evolving, right? It's it's still the same thing right? It's it's still the same thing right? It's it's still the same thing where you as a human, you have to think where you as a human, you have to think where you as a human, you have to think you have to often you have to often you have to often planning together with your agent about planning together with your agent about planning together with your agent about what is the right thing to do. And and what is the right thing to do. And and what is the right thing to do. And and that's more of that's again more of the that's more of that's again more of the that's more of that's again more of the bottleneck. bottleneck. bottleneck. Whereas more intelligence is on some Whereas more intelligence is on some Whereas more intelligence is on some tasks, it's great. Like it creates tasks, it's great. Like it creates tasks, it's great. Like it creates really beautiful things, 3D games for really beautiful things, 3D games for really beautiful things, 3D games for example, but on figuring what to what to example, but on figuring what to what to example, but on figuring what to what to build, figuring out figuring out what build, figuring out figuring out what build, figuring out figuring out what are the right strategic directions or are the right strategic directions or are the right strategic directions or experiments you should run to improve experiments you should run to improve experiments you should run to improve the outcomes for your business, that's the outcomes for your business, that's the outcomes for your business, that's that's not changing as fast. It's the that's not changing as fast. It's the that's not changing as fast. It's the humans knowing how to use the tool to humans knowing how to use the tool to humans knowing how to use the tool to get and to plug in all the right data to get and to plug in all the right data to get and to plug in all the right data to be able to take the right decisions for be able to take the right decisions for be able to take the right decisions for taking your product forward and to take taking your product forward and to take taking your product forward and to take your business forward. your business forward. your business forward. >> Uh listen, I love the product, but even >> Uh listen, I love the product, but even >> Uh listen, I love the product, but even more than I love the product and you as more than I love the product and you as more than I love the product and you as a founder, I love the outcome. The a founder, I love the outcome. The a founder, I love the outcome. The outcome for business is extraordinary. outcome for business is extraordinary. outcome for business is extraordinary. So, anybody who's listening, Lovable is So, anybody who's listening, Lovable is So, anybody who's listening, Lovable is absolutely worth your time. absolutely worth your time. absolutely worth your time. Don't wait. Just put it on your Don't wait. Just put it on your Don't wait. Just put it on your corporate card and start building. corporate card and start building. corporate card and start building. That's my message. Just start building That's my message. Just start building That's my message. Just start building with Lovable. It's an incredible product with Lovable. It's an incredible product with Lovable. It's an incredible product and congratulations on being reborn and congratulations on being reborn and congratulations on being reborn six times cuz every six months you had six times cuz every six months you had six times cuz every six months you had 100 million in revenue, it seems, and 100 million in revenue, it seems, and 100 million in revenue, it seems, and then everybody says Lovable is dead then everybody says Lovable is dead then everybody says Lovable is dead because the new foundation model is so because the new foundation model is so because the new foundation model is so good, but you keep studying your good, but you keep studying your good, but you keep studying your customer customer customer and you keep somehow surviving and and you keep somehow surviving and and you keep somehow surviving and thriving. So, congratulations as an thriving. So, congratulations as an thriving. So, congratulations as an entrepreneur. entrepreneur. entrepreneur. >> Thank you so much, Jason. I enjoyed that >> Thank you so much, Jason. I enjoyed that >> Thank you so much, Jason. I enjoyed that talk. I hope you enjoy the rest of your talk. I hope you enjoy the rest of your talk. I hope you enjoy the rest of your stay here in Paris. stay here in Paris. stay here in Paris. >> It's pretty great and the Palace of >> It's pretty great and the Palace of >> It's pretty great and the Palace of Versailles is so impressive, huh? Versailles is so impressive, huh? Versailles is so impressive, huh? Someday we'll be building this with Someday we'll be building this with Someday we'll be building this with Lovable and Optimus robots. Lovable and Optimus robots. Lovable and Optimus robots. >> I look forward to it. >> I look forward to it. >> I look forward to it. >> I'm going all in.