1% better

Expecting the Worst Keeps Your Body From Getting Better | Stanford Psychologist Dr. Alia Crum

Can a belief, independent of behavior, change your body's physiology? That's the central question Dr. Alia Crum has spent her career investigating at...

1h 20m

Summary published by , updated .

The School of Greatness

Key Takeaway

Pay attention to what you believe about the stressful situation, not just the situation itself.

The next time you feel overwhelmed, try naming the belief underneath the stress. Write it out plainly: "I believe stress will hurt me" or "I believe I'm not doing enough." Then ask whether that belief is actually useful, even if it feels true.

Dr. Alia Crum's research suggests that people who view stress as something that can help them perform and grow respond more adaptively, both behaviorally and physiologically, than those who treat stress purely as a threat to minimize.

Episode Overview

Can a belief, independent of behavior, change your body's physiology? That's the central question Dr. Alia Crum has spent her career investigating at Stanford's Mind and Body Lab.

Crum is a psychology professor whose work on stress mindsets, placebo effects, and the "enough" belief has become foundational research in the mind-body field. Her upcoming book is Believe: The Mind's Power to Create Reality.

The conversation covers three main areas:

  • How beliefs shape biology. Through four mechanisms, attention, physiology, behavior, and emotion, what you believe about stress, food, or exercise produces measurable changes in your body.
  • The housekeeper and milkshake studies. Two landmark experiments show that shifting a belief alone, without changing behavior, can alter weight, blood pressure, and hunger hormones.
  • Core beliefs vs. thoughts. A core belief is a simple, evaluative assumption about the essence of something, and small shifts in core beliefs can have outsized effects on how your reality unfolds.

Crum distinguishes core beliefs from passing thoughts and from general positive thinking, which she says is too vague to be useful.

Main Insights

1. What you believe about stress changes how your body handles it

Most people try to reduce stress. Crum argues this is partly counterproductive, because stress only arises around things you care about. Push the stress away and you push away the caring.

Her research on what she calls the Stress Mindset Measure found that people who believe stress can enhance their performance respond more adaptively under pressure. Cortisol settles at a moderate, useful level. DHEA, a growth-promoting hormone, rises. Attention shifts toward useful feedback rather than threats.

People with a stress-debilitating mindset tend to either overreact or shut down entirely.

The useful shift is not to believe stressors are good things. A cancer diagnosis is not good. But the experience of going through stress, Crum argues, can reconnect you to your values and help your body and mind rise to the occasion.

2. Your hunger hormones respond to what you think you are eating

In Crum's milkshake study, participants drank the same shake twice. Once they were told it was a 140-calorie diet shake; the other time, a 620-calorie indulgent shake. The researchers measured ghrelin, the hunger hormone that rises before meals and drops in proportion to calories consumed.

Ghrelin dropped far more steeply when people believed they had eaten the indulgent shake, signaling satiety and speeding metabolism. When people believed they had eaten the diet version, their bodies registered "not enough" and kept ghrelin elevated.

The practical implication Crum draws from this is to eat nutritious foods in a mindset of "enoughness" rather than restraint. She says this insight changed her own relationship with food during a period when she was an athlete with a restrictive eating pattern.

3. A doctor's warmth and perceived competence change how well a treatment works

In a study where participants received a placebo cream for a histamine skin reaction, Crum's team manipulated two qualities of the healthcare provider: warmth (eye contact, using the patient's name, pictures of nature in the room) and perceived competence (a "Fellow at the Stanford Allergy Center" badge vs. "student doctor," and a subtle cue of putting a blood pressure cuff on upside down).

When the doctor was high in both warmth and competence, the placebo effect was significantly stronger. When those qualities were stripped away, what the doctor said made no measurable difference at all to the patient's physical healing.

Crum connects this to your inner circle more broadly: the people whose words actually land are the ones you believe are both for you and capable of helping you.

4. Telling people to do more often makes things worse

In the housekeeper study, 84 hotel housekeepers who reported getting little exercise were told they were already meeting the surgeon general's physical activity guidelines through their daily work. Four weeks later, compared to the uninformed group, they had lost an average of two pounds, their systolic blood pressure dropped by 10 points, and they reported better body image and more job satisfaction. Their behavior had not changed.

The "you should be doing more" message, even when well-intentioned, frequently lands as "you are not enough." Crum says this tends to be demotivating and can produce direct negative physiological effects, independent of whether the person changes their habits.

The more useful message, her research suggests, is to frame what someone is already doing as sufficient and effective.

5. Core beliefs work differently from passing thoughts

A thought is anything that moves through your mind. A core belief, as Crum and colleague Jared Clifton define it, is a simple, evaluative assumption about the nature or essence of something: "stress is enhancing," "my body is capable," "the world is abundant."

Because core beliefs are not strictly true or false, they cannot be simply disproven. There is evidence for and against almost any core belief about the world. What matters is whether a given belief is useful for your goals.

Crum argues that trying to fix unhelpful thoughts one by one is exhausting and largely ineffective. Shifting a core belief slightly, even from "time is scarce" toward "time is somewhat more available," changes the background setting in which all of your attention, physiology, and behavior operate.

6. A three-step practice can help shift a core belief

Crum describes a practical sequence she uses in her research interventions:

  • Say it. State the new belief aloud. This forces you to be specific rather than vague. "I believe in myself" is less useful than "time is abundant" or "my body is capable."
  • See it. Actively look for evidence consistent with the new belief. Because core beliefs filter attention automatically, you can also do this intentionally, finding moments in your day that are concordant with what you are trying to believe.
  • Live it. Embody the belief in your actions. When you sit down to work or spend time with someone you care about, act from the assumption that the belief is already true.

Crum notes this does not require eliminating doubt. Doubts are thoughts, not core beliefs, and the two are separate.

Frameworks or Models

Stress Mindset Measure

A research tool Crum developed with Peter Salovey and colleagues to assess whether a person believes stress enhances or debilitates their performance, health, and quality of life.

The measure distinguishes two positions:

  • Stress-enhancing mindset: stress improves performance, supports health, and can help you live a more purposeful life.
  • Stress-debilitating mindset: stress harms performance, damages health, and hurts relationships.

Most people lean toward the debilitating side, partly because public health messaging emphasizes stress as a threat. Crum's research shows that shifting even slightly toward the enhancing side changes what people notice, how their bodies respond, and what they do behaviorally.

Say It, See It, Live It

A three-step practice Crum uses in interventions to help people shift a core belief.

  1. Say it. State the target belief aloud or in writing. Specificity matters: "time is abundant" lands differently than a vague "I believe in myself."
  2. See it. Actively look for evidence in your day that is consistent with the new belief. Because core beliefs filter attention automatically, this can be done both intentionally and by simply allowing the new belief to redirect what you notice.
  3. Live it. Act from the assumption that the belief is already true. Embody it in how you work, spend time with others, or approach a challenge.

Crum notes the practice does not require eliminating doubts, since doubts are passing thoughts rather than core beliefs.

Notable Quotes

"It's not mind over matter. It's mind and matter."

Alia Crum

"When they thought it was the indulgent shake, their bodies responded as if they had more food. So the ghrelin drop was much steeper."

Alia Crum

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Name the belief under a recurring stress

    Pick one situation that regularly stresses you out.

    1. Write down what you believe that stress means: "This will harm my health," "I'm failing," or something similar.
    2. Ask whether that belief is actually useful for handling the situation.
    3. Write an alternative belief that is still honest but more useful, such as "This matters to me and I can handle it."

    The goal is to find a belief that is specific enough to feel true, not just positive-sounding.

  • 2
    Eat a meal in the mindset of enoughness

    At your next meal, before you start eating, take a moment to notice what is on your plate.

    • Look at the colors, textures, and ingredients.
    • Tell yourself this meal is enough and satisfying.
    • Eat without tracking or restricting in your head.

    Crum's milkshake research suggests your body's satiety response may be partly shaped by whether you approach food with a sense of indulgence and sufficiency rather than restraint.

  • 3
    Try the say it, see it, live it sequence with one core belief

    Choose one belief you want to shift, such as "I am capable" or "time is abundant."

    1. Say it out loud once in the morning.
    2. During the day, look for one piece of evidence that fits the belief and write it down.
    3. At the end of the day, recall one moment when you acted as if the belief were already true.

    Repeat for two weeks and notice whether your attention, mood, or behavior shifts.

  • 4
    Review a past challenge for evidence of capability

    Think of a time you learned or grew the most.

    • Write down what the challenge was and what you gained from it.
    • Note whether stress was present during that period.
    • Ask yourself: would you have reached that level without the pressure?

    Crum uses this exercise to help people access evidence of their own capability before trying to build a new belief from scratch. The evidence is usually already there.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

Running a business takes brains. Intuit QuickBooks backed by Intuit Intelligence gives you another brain for your business. It's advanced AI helps categorize transactions, draft invoices, and turn business data into smart recommendations. Save time, make smarter decisions, and focus on growth. Get more brains for your business with QuickBooks backed by Intuit Intelligence. Intuit Intelligence can make mistakes. Intuit protects privacy and adheres to responsible AI principles. Features and functionality vary by plan and are subject to change. Cold weather is back and Bombas has you covered with socks, slippers, and footwear to keep you warm all winter. I'm a huge fan of their golf ankle socks actually. They're incredibly comfortable and honestly, they've become one of my favorite pair of socks because of how cushioned they are. With the holidays coming up, Bombas makes a great gift for just about anyone on your list. Plus, for every item that you purchase, Bombas donates an essential clothing item to someone facing housing insecurity. So there's a big win-win here. Head over to bombas.com slash greatness and use code greatness for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S.com slash greatness. Code greatness at checkout. If you're a small business, you know one great hire can change everything. Maybe it's someone to keep the day running smoothly, find the right producer, or take work off your plate so you can focus on what you do best. Finding that person matters. Indeed Sponsored Jobs gets you quality candidates when you need them most. Join the 3.3 million employers worldwide that use Indeed to connect with quality talent that fits their needs. Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at indeed.com slash podcast. That's indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. We only stress about things that we care about. So you wanna get rid of the stress in your life? Stop caring. This is a quote from our guest today. Are you constantly overwhelmed or feeling burnt out or worried about the future? Do you keep telling yourself that you're not doing enough? Maybe you're not eating enough of the right things. Maybe you're not working out enough and you're just not enough. What if the stress isn't the real problem? What if it's what you believe about the stress that's the problem? In this episode, you're gonna learn the four ways that your beliefs shape your body and your reality. You'll hear why a milkshake study showed your hunger hormones respond to what you think you're actually eating and how hotel housekeepers lowered their blood pressure by changing one belief. You'll also get a simple three-step practice to rewrite the beliefs that are holding you back. Say it, see it, live it. Dr. Aliyah Crum is a psychology professor at Stanford University and runs the Stanford Mind and Body Lab where she studies how mindsets change our health and performance. Her research has been referenced by many of the top experts on this show and her upcoming book is Believe, The Mind's Power to Create Reality. I'm so excited for you. So let's go ahead and dive in with the one and only Dr. Aliyah Crum. Your work has been referenced by so many psychologists and individuals over the years who've come on this show. And so I'm excited to have the source, the person who is really doing the deepest research on understanding the mind and how we can use a belief system and a mindset to empower ourselves when we feel stuck, broken, broken down, or unsure of our future. And something we just talked about before we started is you saying that most people understand that their beliefs matter, but they don't know what to believe in, how to influence their beliefs for the betterment of their lives. So first off, why do our beliefs matter? Yeah, I mean, I think we all have a sense that your beliefs matter, but when we are sick or we're struggling or we have a goal like going to the Olympics, often the advice is very vague. It's very much like, oh, just believe, just think positively, just have a good mindset, right? And you'll make it. And I'm really interested in what are the specific beliefs? Like what should you actually believe if you're diagnosed with cancer? Should you believe that it's going to go away, like that you don't have cancer? Should you believe, if you're trying to make it to the Olympics, that it's a sure bet, everything's possible? Or are there more specific beliefs at play that you can hold on to? Your question was, how do these beliefs matter? And I think beliefs create our reality. We know that beliefs create our realities through at least four mechanisms. So the first is our beliefs shape what we pay attention to, what we notice. And quite literally what we see in the world. The second is our beliefs shape what our bodies prioritize and prepare to do physiologically, biologically. Third is our beliefs shape what we're motivated to do and what we actually do behaviorally. And fourth is I believe shape our feelings, our emotions and what we expect to feel. So through those four mechanisms, and there may be more, but we know that those four mechanisms kind of reach out and change how you are showing up in the world. And they literally change your reality. They can change your health, change your behavior and change the people around you in ways that shape your life. In what way do our beliefs shape our bodies? Yeah. So our brains are connected to our bodies. They're connected to every single physiological system in our bodies. And the brain's whole job is to keep us alive. And it does that by monitoring our bodies internal, like what's going on? Like, do we have enough nutrients or not? Do we have an injury or not? Do we, where's my immune system going? Where's my cardiovascular system going? And it also monitors the external environment. So what kind of situation am I in? Am I safe? Are there nutrients here that I should take advantage of? Is this a potential mating opportunity for the procreation of our species, right? And they're also, the crazy thing about human minds is they're not just looking at this situation. They're thinking about the future situations. Like where am I gonna be in a week, in a year, in 10 years? So the brains are constantly monitoring the external environment, current, past and future. And our internal states. And based on the calculations, the brain's saying, okay, this is a good time to prioritize the digestion and metabolism. Or this is a good time, we might be under threat here. We should really hunker down and not procreate at this moment. Or we should be ready to fight or flee. Or we should boost the immune system to deal with this threat that we are facing. So our bodies are doing this automatically, but our brains can change the calculation. And therefore. What does that mean? Like we can put attention on it? Exactly, well, our brains can determine. So all of these systems take energy. And we don't have an infinite amount of energy. So the brain can change the prioritization of what should be given energy now, what should be focused on. The other things that our brains do is it changes our preparation, right? So if I think, okay, you just told me that you have a delicious spread for lunch after, right? I'm hungry, I haven't eaten in a while. My body is saying, okay, let me secrete ghrelin getting me ready to eat. Let me get the digestive juices flowing. It motivates me to go actually get the food that's there. And then once I eat, then it's doing all the things to help metabolize the food. So I guess if your mind is always thinking about stress and worry, is like a constant rumination, whether it be about a past, something that happened or a future potential that could go wrong or just day-to-day stress. And you're thinking, I'm overwhelmed, I'm overworked, I'm burnt out, I'm uncertain of the future, I'm worried about what happened in the past and how it's still affecting me. If you're always ruminating in that state of mental stress, of worry, what I'm hearing you say is your brain is gonna be more focused on the stress rather than maybe losing weight, resting better, healing if you have a nagging injury and allowing the body to process naturally because you're blocking yourself with your thoughts. Is that correct? Exactly, yeah. Your brain is in a threat state, which is sending signals to your body that you should be in safety and preservation mode, which takes energy away from other things the body could be doing. Now, there's a caveat to that, which is that the answer is not to not be stressed. Why not? Or to reduce your stress, because it's not possible. We can't minimize stress? No, I think minimizing, well, I think you can minimize unnecessary stress in your life. What is the difference between good stress and bad stress? So I don't like the good, bad stress. Necessary and unnecessary. I would say that if you are a human that has goals in your life, that has things that you care about in your life, there will be stress. What is stress? So stress is the experience or anticipation of encountering challenge or adversity in those goal-related efforts. So that's kind of jargony, I'm getting at. So let me break it down. So it's both the experience or the anticipation, right? The brain can time travel. I'm already thinking about like, well, what happens if, you know, my daughter flunks her math exam? Like, you know, she's eight. She's not even taking a math exam. I'm already worried about that. So it's experience or anticipation can cause stress. Challenge or adversity can cause stress. So some people distinguish it as like, oh, the bad things that happen to you or the good things, like you get a chance to, you know, to compete at a high level. Doesn't matter. Doesn't matter whether the thing is good or bad. It's all stress. And the third element of this definition, which is critical, is that stress only happens in our goal-related efforts. So what does that mean? It means that we only stress about things we care about. So you want to get rid of stress in your life? Stop caring. Stop caring about everything. Interesting. So we don't stress unless we care about something. Exactly. Huh. I mean, think about it. If I told you that Johnny was failing school, that wouldn't stress you out, right? Unless. Unless I was connected to him in some way. Unless you were Johnny. Yeah, yeah. Or your son was Johnny. Or you were like a teacher who cared about the Johnnies of the world. So trying to reduce stress is like, it's problematic, A, because you're just emptying an ocean out with a bucket. Like, these things keep coming. But the bigger problem with it is that when we try to avoid stress or reduce stress in our life, we're pushing away the things that really matter. Really? Interesting. And I think that's what causes depression, because depression is more about a lack of care, a lack of purpose, a lack of energy. And oftentimes that comes because you've disconnected from the things you care about, in part because you're trying not to feel stressed. Really? Huh, interesting. So how should we be thinking about stress differently? Instead of trying to avoid it or eliminate it all in all, how can we navigate it so that it doesn't consume us so much and burn us out? Yeah. So there's lots of things you can do. Our research has focused on your beliefs about the nature of stress. Mm-hmm. So the true nature of stress is a paradox. So on the one hand, being constantly in a stress state, as we talked about, can have negative effects on health, on your well-being, on your performance, and so forth. But on the other hand, the body's stress response was not designed to kill us. It was designed to help us, right? It was designed to help us rise to the occasion. It increases energy. It narrows focus. It gives you energy, literally, to the limbs to mobilize and do what needs to be done to protect your survival. So the body's and brain's stress response was not designed to kill us. It was designed to support us. So the true nature of stress is a paradox. It could be either of these things. So the real question is, how do you actually utilize the stress response in order to achieve the goal, meet the cares, live the value and purpose life that you want to live, not really in spite of that stress, but because of the stress, that you're channeling it to help you realize those goals? So we've looked at your beliefs about stress. So do you believe stress is going to hurt your performance or help it? So if you hear someone saying to you, stress is going to kill you and you believe it, like, wow, stress is going to kill me, and then you stress about being stressed all the time, it's probably not going to support you physically if that's your belief system is what I'm hearing you say. Exactly, yeah. So the measure we use, it's called the Stress Mindset Measure. I developed it with Peter Salovey, John Aker and others. And it essentially asks questions like, do you believe that stress can improve your performance? Do you believe that stress will make you healthier? Do you believe that stress can help you live a more valued life? Like most people disagree with these statements and they agree with. the statements like stress is going to kill me, it's going to make me depressed, it's going to harm my relationship, and so forth. And, you know, again, they're not totally wrong. There's some evidence to support that. And that's what our public health messaging is telling people, right? Because we're trying to warn people about the negative effects of stress, but what we're doing is actually creating a belief about the nature of stress. Now, the question is, what does that belief do? Well, the answer is it does a lot, right? So people who have a more stress-enhancing mindset or belief, they perform better under stress. Their bodies respond more adaptively under stress. They are more appropriately engaged with the stress. So oftentimes when you see people in the stress-debilitating mindset, they're either freaking out, so overreacting, kind of like behaviorally and physiologically, or they're what we call checking out. So they're shutting down, they're not engaging in a way that can be useful, either behaviorally or physiologically. So, and we've seen this in studies, so you can also activate and change people's beliefs about the nature of stress, and those changes correspond to what they pay attention to. If they move the needle to seeing stress as enhancing, when you're in a stressful situation, you start noticing the people giving you positive feedback. You start paying attention to, you start seeking out feedback that can support you. Your cortisol level gets to a more moderate place, because you don't wanna have low cortisol level, that's gonna put you asleep. You also don't want it to be super high, that you can't focus. DHEA levels, so this is a hormone that is responsible for growth-promoting aspects in the body, are higher. So subtle changes in the belief changes the whole system, what you pay attention to, what your body does, what you do behaviorally, and how you feel. And you said it, how? You're getting rid of the stress about the stress. You're like, okay, well, I'm stressed. I'm stressed because I care. Now, let me handle the stress. It doesn't get rid of the stress. Interesting. But you're in a better place now. So if we learn how to shift our perspectives or our beliefs that stress isn't necessarily a bad thing. It could be bad if you're ruminating about stress being bad all the time, is what I'm hearing you say. But if we can shift it to saying, stress in certain moments is actually an empowering thing, because it means I care, it means I'm gonna pay attention to it, I'm gonna focus on it better, and it's gonna help me get better results with this. November gets busy fast. Your schedule fills up, you're eating on the go more than you planned, and somehow there's something on the calendar every night. That's where AG1 earns its spot. Not when life is easy and when you've got time for a whole routine. Right now, when everything is full and something has to give. And for me, I keep it simple. One scoop cold water and it's part of the morning before I start thinking about everything else I've gotta do. One scoop covers what a full stack of separate supplements would. You get 75 plus ingredients, including vitamins, minerals, adaptogens, pre and probiotics, and superfoods. And with AG1 Pro, you get the same daily drink, now with a performance and recovery layer built in. For a limited time, visit drinkag1.com slash greatness, and get a free immune support bundle, including omega-3 fish oil and vitamin D3 plus K2, with your first subscription of AG1 Next Gen or AG1 Pro. That's drinkag1.com slash greatness. This podcast is brought to you by Aura. Everyone has advice about your health. Early mornings, more exercise, but Aura Ring helps you figure out what's exactly working for you. And more isn't always the answer. It tracks your sleep, stress, activity, and more. The Aura app brings it together so you can spot patterns and see how you're recovering. Say you've been going to bed early or taking time to unwind. You can see what changes in your data over time. And the more you understand about your body, the better you can live in it. Learn more at auraring.com. Wear your best life with Aura. The School of Greatness is proudly sponsored by Amica Insurance. You know what they say, if you wanna go fast, go alone. If you wanna go far, go together. So go with Amica and get coverage from a mutual insurer that's built for their customers. One that looks after what's important to you together. Auto, home, life, and more. Coverage that fits your unique needs. Amica helps you protect what matters most. Visit amica.com and get a quote today. Now, obviously we can't be stressed 24 seven, I guess. You can't be stressed all morning, day, and night. Otherwise, you're probably gonna be, your body's gonna shut down eventually in some way. But if the perception of the stress, is what I'm hearing you say, the belief that that can support you in overcoming the burnout. Yeah, and a couple of nuances there. So there's the stressor, right? And so a lot of research had been done on your perception about the stressor. So do you view that thing, the job talk, or the divorce, or the cancer diagnosis as a threat or a challenge? And that can change it. But what we're interested in, what we think is even more powerful, is to look at your perception, your belief, your core belief about the nature of stress itself. So I don't need to say, I don't need to look at my cancer diagnosis and say, oh, that's a good thing to challenge. Like, I'm happy to have this. Like, no, you shouldn't be happy about a cancer diagnosis. It is not a good thing. However, the experience of going through stress can be enhancing. What does that mean? It can, the experience of stress can help you reconnect to your values and what you care about. It can help your body and mind rise to the occasion to heal, to have the energy, to manage the threat that you're faced with. And so that's why this belief really matters, because it's changing the whole game of the experience. But I'm not saying you need to think positively about negative things that happen. That's an important distinction to make. Around the belief around our bodies, you did your senior thesis paper at Harvard, is that right? Were you at Harvard? Your senior thesis at Harvard, you did a study with Dr. Alan Langer about this housekeeper study, correct? Can you explain how shifting our belief around movement and our bodies can actually enhance our ability to lose weight and improve the quality of our life with a shift in belief, not a shift in behavior? Yes, yeah. So a lot of people assume that the reason beliefs matter is only because of how they change your behavior. But what we know from the science is that there are direct effects between belief and biology that you can look at in the science by controlling for people's behavior. You know, to have them not change behavior, you only change belief, and you see whether or not that change in belief can affect the body. The study that you're referring to, actually, I'll go back a little bit, because that was inspired by a whole history of research on the placebo response. So as you know, when you have to get, you know, you're testing out a new drug or medication, in order to get it approved, you have to test it against a placebo, which looks the same, feels the same, but is nothing. What we do know is that in most cases, the placebo does something. It does something. It does something. It's not supposed to do anything. It's nothing. But it's a shift in a belief that shifts the biology, even with no physical pill that you're taking, right? Exactly. Which seems crazy to me. It does and it doesn't. I mean, people are so surprised by this, because it's like, how could, you know, just taking a pill that does nothing do something? And yet, when you actually think about it, it's not nothing. It's the product of three things. So the first is your body's natural abilities to heal itself with time. This is what your body's designed to do, all day long, every day. It's working towards, you know, getting rid of this thing, doing that thing, like recovering from this thing, maintaining homeostasis. The body is amazing. You know, it's just remarkable. And most of the time, it's healing itself. So that's happening alone, right? Now, what's cool about placebo effects is that the mindset, the belief, can activate that, as we talked about, right? It can say, okay, it's a good time to heal. Or, oh, you know, maybe you're not, you don't have to worry so much, and now you're in a state of security, so we can ramp down some of these stress systems. Or maybe it's saying, you know, this is a really important infection that you have. Let's focus the immune system on dealing with that in this moment. So the mindsets, and we can get into this, because that's the question, like, well, what belief, what mindset? Is it just, I'm in good hands? Is it, this pill will cure me? Is it, my body is capable? Is it, this condition I'm taking this for is now managed, right? These are all possible beliefs, which we can get into. But the essence is that the mind, the belief, can activate the body's natural healing systems. It doesn't do it magically. Like, the body has the capacity. And then the other aspect is the social context. So your mindsets aren't shaped in a vacuum. They're shaped by the branding of the drugs, the act and shape of the pill, the ritual. So all of that social context goes into shaping the mindsets, which work through activating the body's natural healing abilities. That's so fascinating. In one of our studies, I love this paradigm, we have people come in to the lab. They think they're going to be there to do a food study. But in order to do the food study, they have to do an allergy test. So for all the patients, we put on a prick of histamine, which is, creates an allergic reaction in almost everybody. Like a skin reaction or something. A skin reaction. So it kind of looks like a mosquito bite with like a little rash or flare around it. In that spot. Yeah, and we do this for science, right? Yes. It's not too bad and it'll go away on its own with time. But what we're interested in is, can we speed up the rate at which the body heals itself? So the first thing we do is we vary what we tell the patients. So we give them the rash, then the healthcare provider comes in and puts on a placebo cream. So it's a- Nothing. It's an active hand lotion. It has no active ingredients. And in one condition, so half the patients are told, this is a anti-histamine cream. It's going to make your rash and irritation go away. The other half are told, this is a histamine agonist. It might make your rash and irritation worse. And so first we can just look at that. And that's sort of like placebo effect and what's called the nocebo effect. So when negative expectations or mindsets can create- It doesn't get worse. Yeah, yeah. And so if we just look at that, when you measure the rash 10 minutes later, the rash is physically smaller for the people who are told the cream is going to work. For the ones who have a belief that this will work. Exactly, who are instilled the belief that this will work based on- Don't tell me it got bigger with the ones who said- Well, it didn't get bigger. It's bigger in comparison because everybody's is getting better with time. But there's got- But there's a better fast. The nocebo stayed bad, the placebo got faster quicker. Got better quicker. Yeah. So that alone is interesting, but we already know that beliefs can shape allergic response. What we were really interested in in this study was how do the qualities of the doctor shape or alter the strength of this belief, right? So here's where we got really crazy. So we went and we looked into the literature in social psychology, which is all on social interactions and social perception. And essentially decades of research in social psychology have distilled social perception into two qualities. So anytime you're meeting somebody new, you're immediately judging them and you're immediately judging them on two things. First, you wanna know, is this person have good intentions towards me or bad intentions? What we call in the field is warmth, but it's more like, is this person on my side or is this person working for me or against me? Second, we wanna know, does this person have the abilities, capacities to enact those intentions? Are they competent? So we think those two things. Was that like our nervous system, our brains interpreting this? It's your brain and it's why those, I think it's, you know, scholars will argue that it's evolutionarily adaptive because you're trying to figure out, is this person helping me or harming me? And the competence one is like, well, if they, even if they're on my side, but they don't have anything useful for me. Yeah, they don't have the ability to support me, resources or they don't have the competence to do anything meaningful for me, I guess. So when we meet people for the first time, those are the two things we're innately thinking. Yes, and it happens like that. You pick up within microseconds on these qualities. Yeah. Essentially, is this person for me or against me? And are they capable of acting on either of those right now? Exactly. And the warmth on the form you're against me gets more nuanced than. Like, it's not just, are you against me or for me? It's, do you get me? Interesting. Do you care for me? Like, there are degrees on which that happens. Do you understand me? Do you accept me? Are you judging me? Exactly. Wow. So, those, you know, and that's well studied in the literature, so we wanted to test if we altered those two, if we manipulate those two qualities in the doctor, how will the placebo notice it? How do you manipulate that? How do you get them to show up and or act in a certain way, I guess? This is why research is fun, is to design these things. So, we have the same, in this study, we have the same doctor, healthcare provider, and in one scenario, so she does the procedure exactly the same, but in the high warmth condition, she's looking them in their eyes. Yeah. She's connecting with them on a personal level. She's smiling. She calls them by their first name. We even changed subtle cues in the room, so in the high warmth condition, we have like pictures of nature and animals. Yeah, yeah, not just sterile walls. Yeah, not just like the eye test, you know? And in the low condition, she doesn't really make eye contact. She's sort of staring at the screen. Just trying to, or something. Yeah. Pretty easy, actually, to manipulate warmth. Competence was a little more subtle, because, you know, we want the procedure to go well, but she's wearing a white coat, but in the high confidence condition, her badge reads, you know, fellow at the Stanford Allergy Center. The low competence condition, and again, it's perceptions of competence, not actual competence. Like a assistant or something, or? It says student doctor. No way. Yeah, so no shade on students. Right, right, right. Many of them are very competent, but it's the, oh, this person's. The credibility or the capability of like this different level, I guess, yeah. Exactly, and we raised subtle cues, so in the procedure, you know, when she puts on the blood pressure cuff, she puts it on upside down. Shut up, no way. So, so subtle cues. So people are like, is this person capable? Yeah, if she's having to do this twice, do I trust her? Exactly, and so this is really important, because in the doctor's office, you are immediately, you know, the warmth and competence, it still matters, but you wanna know, does this doctor get it? Like, do they know allergy medicine? But you also wanna know, does this doctor get me? Because I'm not just any old body. Like, I'm my body, and here's my history, and here's my experience, and here's my, and like, you need to know that from your doctor. If they miss one little thing, it could lose your competence in them. Exactly, yeah. Wow. So here's what we found. So essentially, when the doctor was high in warmth and high in competence, the placebo effect is even stronger. Come on. So what she says about the cream matters even more. So the potency of her words on the physiological response is very strong. In contrast, when the doctor, when we stripped away her warmth and we raised questions about her competence, what she said made no difference at all. The effect totally goes away. So she could be saying, this is gonna work for you, or that you might have side effects, and it doesn't land. Interesting. So. Wow. For me, that tells me that who you have in your inner circle is so important. Yes. Do you believe that the people closest to you are warm and are for you, that care about you? And do you believe they're capable of supporting you? Capable of backing you, at least? Capable of being there for you, or being loyal, or standing up for you, or whatever it might be? And if we don't have those individuals in our core circle, I can see that impacting every part of our lives. Totally. That is crazy. Yeah, and it is, and it's also like, once you hear it, it's so obvious and retrospective. But to really show it, and I know you had Angela Duckworth on recently. I mean, it's a perfect example, because both matter. You know, we know that your beliefs, your grit, your mindset is going to affect your life. But how do you sustain that belief when you're doubting it? Yes. How do you stretch that belief to a place you've never thought of even considering? It's other people. It's what that coach said to you. It's how your mom reacted. It's, you know, and it's not just the fancy coach. It's the coach who you thought got it and got you. How does a parent emulate or show to their children that they get them? They understand what they're going through. Listening. Listening. Yeah, I mean, I have an eight-year-old, so I'm just exploring this now. We're just getting into this. But I'm no expert in parenting either, but I do think everything I study is connected to what I'm living, right? And questions that I have that I want answers and need answers to, to live a better life. And so I think about this a lot as a parent. And it's so easy to kind of be confident and tell her what you know she should do, or, you know, say, oh, when I was in the third grade, I did it this way, you know? But like, you know, it's, that's, I probably do know a lot, and I'm a psychologist. I know not a lot, but if she doesn't feel like I can really understand what she's going through, what I say will fall on deaf ears. So it doesn't matter how, you could be the number one expert in the world at what she's going through. Yeah. But if you don't show you care enough, like if you're just credible, but you're not caring. Yeah, and it's not even caring, because I also think you could have an expert who you're not even connected to. Well, you don't even know. What they say could have an impact if you believe that they get you. Yeah, that's true. Like, you have so many people who've read your books and listened to your podcast. You're touching millions of people, and it's, you can't possibly, like, literally care. Right, right. About all of that. But you can know them in some sense. Yeah, of course. You can speak in a way where you can, you know, show that you've gone through a similar experience, or you can empathize with the experience that someone else has been through, and understand the challenges that people are going through. Yeah. Yeah. Man, that's interesting. Something we talked about earlier was about, we know that beliefs matter, but we don't know what to believe sometimes. And in a world where, especially for a younger generation, where they're constantly communicated to about looking better, having more money, having more followers, having more success, and making that their belief system as, I'm loved and enough when I have these different things. If that is a messaging that is constantly being infused in their minds and their belief system, whether they know it or not, what are the beliefs that we should be focusing on to empower our lives better for deeper meaning, deeper peace, deeper prosperity, and deeper love? Yeah. Well, I think the answer to that differs depending on the goal, but let's hone in on your point around the belief that you're enough. Mm-hmm. I think this one's really critical and- Tell me. So- Should we believe we're enough? Oh, for sure. Okay. Yeah, I mean, it's really hard to live a life when you don't believe you're enough. What happens to someone's life when they believe I'm not enough? Motivation just sinks. Yeah. But let me give you, let me put this into terms of some research we've done. So, actually, I'll go back to the, you brought up the study with Ellen Langer. We never- Yeah, yeah, yeah. We've been back in time. And- What do you call the study? We call it the housekeeper study. Okay. Yeah, but essentially, we wanted to, Ellen had the idea. Ellen Langer had the, she's brilliant. She's got great ideas. She was like, you know, if the placebo effect is such, plays such a big role in medicine, and now we are telling people, you know, behavioral medicine, you should eat well, you should exercise, you should, you know, sleep and so forth, wouldn't it be the case that your belief matters there too? Like, that the effects of exercise or diet are to some degree driven by placebo response as well? So, that was the idea. The study was essentially, we worked with 84 hotel housekeepers. We randomized them into two conditions. First, we tested them on how much exercise, we asked them, how much exercise do you get on a scale of zero to 10? And on average, it was like three. Three, okay. Throughout the week or throughout- Three out of 10, like on average, yeah. And, you know, about a third of them said, I get zero exercise, like no exercise. Yeah, I'm just working all day. I don't have time or whatever, yeah. Yeah. And so, this was interesting, right? So, they are cleaning hotel rooms, but they have the belief that they're not getting enough exercise, right? And therefore, we wondered what would happen if we told them, hey, you are getting enough exercise. You, cleaning hotel rooms, you're on your feet all day long. It's clear you're getting above and beyond the surgeon general's requirements of, you know, accumulating 30 minutes of moderate. Yeah, yeah. They're pushing carts, they're changing beds. They're getting more exercise than I am right now, sitting at my desk. Again, they're getting 10,000 steps a day. They're doing everything. Yeah. Going up and down stairs, probably, yeah. So, what would happen if we told them that they were meeting the surgeon general's requirements, that they were getting enough? And so, that's what we did. It was a really simple study. We measured them on their height, their weight, their blood pressure, their body fat at time one. Then I went into these hotels and gave the message. I said, you're getting enough exercise. Here's the, you know, surgeon general's requirements. You're getting more than enough. You should be receiving these benefits, a healthy heart, a healthy weight. We put a sign in their break room so they could be reminded of that. And then we measured them four weeks later. And what we found was that they had dropped weight. It was about two pounds. So, not a lot, but like statistically significant. On average? On average. Only four? Well, 40, you know, 42 in the intervention condition. Yeah, yeah. Oh, because half were? Yeah, half we didn't give that information. So, we're comparing the now informed exercise, the informed room attendance to the ones who hadn't been informed yet. So, we told them eventually on the study. Their blood pressure dropped. So, systolic blood pressure went down by 10 points. They also started saying they liked their job better. They had better body image and so forth. My friend, I hope you're enjoying this episode. And the School of Greatness drops new conversations every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday around money, mindset, healing, manifestation, and relationships. And if you're not yet following the show, then you're missing all of them. Please tap the follow button right now and you'll get notified the moment every new episode drops because the next one might be exactly what you need. Now, let's get back to the conversation. The School of Greatness is brought to you in partnership with Airbnb. Some of the trips I remember most are the ones where the main event is only part of the experience. You go for one reason, but then you find a great local spot. You explore a neighborhood you've never seen before. And suddenly, the trip becomes so much more than what brought you there. I think about that from the other side also because I list a space on Airbnb as well. When a big event brings people into that area, it gives travelers a comfortable place to land and experience more of what's around them. And for me, the extra income is an amazing benefit. I can put it towards a project for the space or toward another trip and another experience somewhere new. Sometimes a big event gets the big attention for someone, but your space can get some of the spotlight as well. Your home might be worth more than you think. Find out how much at airbnb.com slash host. To the millions of small business owners out there, we appreciate you. We see your early mornings, late nights, and all the hard work in between. And with the US Bank Business Essentials Card, you don't have to go it alone. With unlimited 2% cashback on every purchase because we know your communities count on you to be here, there, everywhere. So yeah, we don't just appreciate you, we support you. The creditor and issuer of this card is US Bank National Association pursuant to a license from Visa USA Inc. Some restrictions may apply. Support for this podcast is brought to you by Walden University. Ever think, what if you could go after what you actually want and make a real difference? You're not alone. For over 50 years, Walden University has helped working adults get the W, the knowledge, the skills, and the confidence to build the future they want. If you've been waiting for the right moment, this is it. Head to waldenu.edu. Walden University, set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. So it was just a shift in a belief within four weeks was essentially about other changes. Yes. People lost weight, their blood pressure went down, they were happier, they enjoyed their experience at work better, and they felt like, oh, I'm actually getting paid and I'm losing weight, or I'm working out at the same time. Look at this benefit that I'm getting as well. Something shifted in their belief system which shifted their bodies. Yes, and the kind of argument we were making was it was direct, that it wasn't affected by the pavior. I think the true power in belief comes when it fires all of those four mechanisms. To the degree that this was impactful for these women, it's because once they saw that they were, and why this is related to the enough belief, is they saw themselves as physical exercisers, their physical exercise as being enough, the whole game changed, right? Now what are they paying attention to? Oh, I'm a little tired at the end of the day. That's because I really lifted this towel. Yeah, worked out. I'm sore. Oh, that's a sign that I'm working out, not a sign that I have a painful jaw. Oh, now maybe I'm motivated to put a little bit more oomph into things, stand a little taller. Physiologically. We're not sure what the mechanism is there, but it could have been a lot of things. And emotionally, right? Like, imagine feeling like, it's like you have a hard job, life is tough, you're struggling with money, and then you're constantly told you should get more exercise. And you're like, I have no time and I've got, yes, I'm not enough. Exactly, and it's just defeating. So that was the original study. We've done lots of studies since that have been larger and, you know, better controlled. And time and time again, we find that the message to tell people to do more, like you're not doing enough, just flops. Why? Because it's demotivating and it can have negative effects. So now the belief, it's not just that you're, we think we're doing it well intentioned. We think if we tell people you should exercise more, because it's good for you, they'll get off the couch and do it. But what often happens for most people is then they just feel like I'm not enough. I'm not enough. I already, I'm already overworked. I don't have extra free time. I'm already too many responsibilities. Now you're asking me to go spend an extra hour a day in the gym with time I don't have. Otherwise, I'm never gonna look the way I want to, like I'm screwed. Wow. Yeah, and let me tell you, I'll tell you the other story that relates to the enough thing. And this, you know, I've talked about a lot, but this is my favorite study that I've ever done, which was the milkshake study. So we gave people, we had people come to our lab. This was done at Yale, the hospital. So we brought them in. We had them drink a milkshake at time one, hook them up to an IV, and we're measuring their body's gut peptides. So their physiological response to the milkshake. After they drink it. After, yeah. So it's before, during, and after they're drinking this milkshake. So the essence is we're trying to see how your body responds to a given milkshake. We have them come back a week later. We do the same thing with the same exact milkshake. So the same person is drinking the same exact milkshake, and we're measuring how their bodies respond in terms of, in particular, we were looking at this gut peptide called ghrelin. So ghrelin is called the hunger hormone. It's related to hunger and metabolism. So, you know, before you eat ghrelin levels rise, signaling to the brain you should seek out food, slowing metabolism in case you don't get that food. And then theoretically in proportion to the amount of calories you consume, ghrelin levels drop. So if we go out and have a big burger or something after, you know, ghrelin levels will drop. They'll tell our brains, okay, you don't need to seek out more food and I'll rev up the metabolism to burn the food you just ingested. So we had the exact same milkshake, same person, same time. We're measuring ghrelin response, but what we changed was what they believed about the milkshake. So at one time, the person drinking the milkshake thought it was a diet shake. So we told them it was like 140 calories, low fat, low sugar. The other time we told them it was an indulgent shake. So 620 calories, tons of fat, tons of sugar. And what we found was that their ghrelin response, their physiological response to food depended on their beliefs about what they were drinking. That's so crazy. So when they thought it was the indulgent shake, their bodies responded as if they had more food. So the ghrelin drop was much steeper. So what's the result of that then? Yeah. You know. So this is where it gets interesting. Because like, it was kind of game-changing just in and of itself by showing that your body's response to food isn't just about what the food is, it's also about what you believe. But the real aha for me was in the nuances. So I went into this study thinking, you know, I'd studied a lot of placebos and I was like, okay, the better mindset to be will be the healthy one, right? Right. And you'll lose weight or you'll... Yeah. I should just think that I'm eating healthy and then I'll lose weight. But what we found was the exact opposite. So assuming you want to maintain or lose weight, you want your ghrelin levels to drop when you eat, right? Because that'll satiate hunger and also speed metabolism. But what we found was when people thought they were eating healthy, what their brains registered was not enough. So I'm hungrier still. So brains were saying, keep up the ghrelin levels because you didn't get enough. Which the ghrelin's gonna want you to eat more. Is that correct? Yeah. And it will slow metabolism. Because it's signaling you might not have enough when you need to preserve. Store fat. Store fat. So if you want to maintain or lose weight, the mindset you want to be in is the indulgent mindset, which essentially comes down to enough. I'm eating enough. Oh, man. Yeah. But there's seasons of my life where I was indulging too much. Well, okay. Yeah. Indulgence. I think of indulgence in sort of the true definition of the word, which is to allow yourself the pleasure of. And so it's unclear whether it's that or whether it's the enoughness. I think from a metabolism standpoint, it's the belief that you're getting enough. Right? And again, all of this work is to prove the point that your beliefs matter. It's not to show that your diet doesn't matter or the medicine doesn't matter or the type of cancer doesn't matter. It's not mind over matter. It's mind and matter. So if you want to lose weight or maintain weight, then you shouldn't just eat milkshakes all the time. Eat healthy, nutritious foods, but do so in the mindset of indulgence or the mindset of enoughness. And this changed my life because I was an athlete and struggling. I was struggling with an eating disorder at the time. I was very regimented and restrained in what I ate and restrictive in what I ate. And I realized that the mindset that that sense of restraint was putting me in was actually counteracting the hard work I was doing. Really? So it really changed my life, because it was like, now when I eat, I want to eat. Whatever I eat, I want to eat the thing that feels good. Really, truly, and feels like enough right now. And if right now that means I'm going to eat a burger, I'm going to eat the burger. And other times I don't want the burger. I'm like, the salad is enough. And I can look at a salad and I can see all the nutrients. I can see the dressing. I can see, I can think about the farm and I can feel like that's enough too, right? So, yeah. But I can't have milkshakes every day. I can't have a thousand calorie milkshake every day. You have higher standards. You're trying to make the Olympics, right? So you got to like, you're trying to optimize both, right? You got to optimize what you're actually doing. But if you're only doing that and not paying attention to the beliefs, you're not going to get there either. So in a world where so many people don't know what to believe, what should they be believing more of? Yeah. Again, it's like everything depends on the situation. But in general, I would say belief that what you are doing is enough, that you are enough. Belief that the stress that you will experience in your life is natural, is normal, and can be enhancing, that it's a great teacher in connecting you back to the things you care about. I think belief that you have purpose and meaning is really important. Think belief that you are capable, that your body is your ally. These are all beliefs we've studied. What if you don't have evidence that you're capable, that you're enough, that your purpose, your life has meaning and purpose because of certain conditions or friends, family members who've kind of limited you, or you feel limited by their words, or their actions where you put more emphasis and meaning on things that happened in the past rather than other things that might show you you are capable, you are purposeful, you are here for a reason. Yeah. So let me ask you a question. So think about a time in your life that you sort of learned or grew the most, like you became more capable than you were in a sort of measurable way. Yeah, yeah. Do you want to share it? First thing, I mean, probably like the challenges that I faced the most, and I talked about before camera about my getting all these different injuries that I had in sports and how my spiritual realm and my mental world really grew because of those challenges. Yes. I don't wish they happened. I mean, it's not like it was enjoyable, but I definitely grew the most under challenge and under adversity. And my attention started to learn how to shift and develop in different ways to overcome those challenges and empower myself. But for part of those times, I was also focused on the negative in the beginning stages of those challenges. And I realized after a while, oh, focusing more on this adversity as something holding me back is not empowering me to overcome it. It's keeping me stuck in this stress loop that is with a negative belief around this adversity rather than an empowering belief about what's possible on the other side. Yeah. So I guess lots of different moments like that. Yeah. Well, you were already ahead of the game there for a question. But when I asked this, and people listening can think themselves, what was a time that I learned or grew the most? And then ask yourself, did that time involve any stress? And invariably, the answer is yes. Yeah, a lot, actually. So when you ask, what do you do if you don't feel this way? Well, I would say, look back to times where you gained some capability, right? Where you actually rose to the occasion. We all have them. Everybody has them. And then realize that those times involved stress, right? That you would not have reached that new level if it weren't for the stress, right? And so that is teaching you that stress is natural, normal, and enhancing. It's teaching you that you do have the capability to grow. And it's teaching you that the stress is not a, whatever the stressor is, is what it is. But this experience of stress is not a bad thing. The experience of stress is your greatest teacher pointing you to that purpose. So people have been there, they've done this. And maybe it's in a micro way here and there. And once you see that, then you're like, I can do that tomorrow, or I can do that now with whatever it is that I'm facing, right? I can see the stress as the teacher. I can help it point it to me, to my purpose, what I care about, right? And I can know that I will grow. I will become capable because of this stress, right? So it's there in our past. It's here in our present to find these beliefs. And we can access it anytime in the future. You're not, even people say it's like, oh, you fake it till you make it. It's like, no, these are beliefs that are true now. Mm-hmm. As a psychologist and a Stanford professor who has your whole career has been around beliefs and mindset and understanding what is the belief that you struggle with the most in your life right now, or the thing you struggle with the most around this season of life with your mindset and your beliefs that you know you get to be working on better, but it's still hard for you. Yeah. As the expert. I have this belief that I never have enough time. And I think I'm gonna work on that. That's a good question. But that is sort of, it drives my life. It changes what I pay attention to. Really? It changes, you know, it gets me more stressed than I maybe need to be. It's probably changing my physiology in ways. So how- How long have you been thinking that belief? I think I've always struggled with that belief. Your whole life? Yeah, at least since college. A little more carefree in high school. Right. When did you start to realize that the belief around time was maybe holding you back in some ways? Is this a recent thing, or has it been in the last couple of years, or? Right now, when you ask me? Really? No. To some degree, I think, I'm really glad you're asking me this question, because a lot of times I'm looking out. I'm like, okay, what are beliefs? But I should also be looking in. And at every moment of the research, the studies were actually helping me solve something that I was struggling with in my life. So the exercise and diet work happened when I was an elite athlete, struggling with that. In grad school, when I started doing the stress mindset work, that was the highest period of stress in my life. Wow. As I've moved now to being older, the focus is more on, you know, beliefs about your body, beliefs about- Illness, yeah. And we haven't done any research on time, but I would say that that's something that I struggle with. And one question is whether or not that really, like, if that's also just this enoughness belief in disguise, right? Like, I have this belief that I don't have enough time. I haven't done enough. Really? Yeah. But you're like the expert in this. You're like the leader doing the research. Everyone's quoting your research papers, and you're leading the charge, and you're a professor at Stanford, and you're doing all these things. What would it take for you to believe that you have done enough? Yeah. Well, I think, I do think I've done, I don't know. I mean, I think I've done a lot, but I'm like you. I have big goals, but I have a big mission. Like, I think I really want to, I'd like to play a role in helping humanity to become healthier and happier through a refined understanding of the mind and body connection. And to be frank, like, we have a lot to do. Yeah, it's a lot of work. So much to be done. We know so little about this compared to like how much we know about genetics or physiology. or cellular development, like there's so much to be done. So again, it's like the awareness, right? Me recognizing that I have this belief that I don't have enough time, I need to do more, I need to do it faster, do it better, is not erroneous. Like it's coming from a good place. Sure, yeah. But the question is, and it's not wrong necessarily, but the question is, is it useful? Yeah, is it helping you, your body, and your mind, and your heart, and your connections, and your relationships, and your work? Yeah, or is it just working against me? Interesting. Yeah, so thank you for that. I'll work on that, and the next time we talk, I'll tell you how it's solved. How would you create a research study around a knackness around time? How about, you know, because I'm assuming there's a lot of people here who might feel something similar of like their parents, and maybe they weren't able to give all their time to their career or their mission outside of parenthood, or they feel like they're running out of time because they spent too much time on their business or career, and not enough time with their kids. And now their kids are in their teens, and they've, in their mind, neglected not showing up for them, and they've missed out. And am I a good parent? Because I've been driven all by career and mission, but I've lost meaning in my relationships with my family. You know, I'm a father of one-year-old daughters, and I'm trying to think of the future of making sure how do I show up as much as I can for them being present and giving them enough time, and also showing up for my mission and my calling, and giving that the amount of time that I feel like I need to, so I'm not resenting one or the other by not giving enough. And I'm already thinking about time travel in the future around this idea and how I can navigate that, because I don't want to regret that I missed out on time. You know? So, I don't know, what research would you? Well, how we typically go about this is, you know, first you really want to pinpoint what is the belief, right? What is the belief that's coming up for you that you feel like people would resonate with? Yeah, and so it's like, and this takes a lot of time, right, these, it's like, pinpointing the specific beliefs in the mind that are most useful is hard, right? It's like, you know, I equate this a lot to like if you got a knee surgery today, right, and the doctor was like, oh, well, it's just like ligaments and tendons, and like, you know, we'll go in there and just jigger with a few things, but you'd be like, what? It's the same, it's true with the mind. Like, it's like, well, is it a belief? Is it an expectation? What is the core belief? Is it the belief that my time is enough? Is it a belief that I have enough? Is it the belief that I'm doing enough? Is it the belief that my work is purposeful? Like, there's many possible beliefs. Am I wasting time? Yeah, yeah. Yeah, the belief that I'm wasting time. So, we would spend a lot of time, I would wanna, and this is it, ironically, really kind of uncovering that because once you get it, right, then you know, like, that's the thing with the stress stuff. It's like, once you see, oh, the useful belief is to believe that stress can be enhancing. The useful belief when it comes to diet is I'm eating indulgently or I'm eating enough, right? The useful belief when it comes to being diagnosed with cancer is this is manageable and my body is capable, right? It took a long time to kind of pinpoint what those are. So, I wanna spend some time on that. And then how we do our research, we really like to, because I do this work to help people, right? So, the studies are usually intervention-based. So, we would design an intervention that would help people shift their beliefs about time. And then we would measure how did that change, right? If we shifted their belief about time or their own work or themselves, how would that change what they noticed? How would that change their bodies? How would that change what they did actually? How'd that change how other people related to that? That would be wonderful. I mean, obviously, like you said, it would take time for you to develop this and think about the interventions and the belief system around time for people. But just a thought experiment, if you had to come up with a quick thought on how you would do this for yourself. If you were giving the intervention to you, what would the belief around time be to empower you versus disempower you that would serve you in a more helpful way, useful way, rather than a way where you are ruminating on I don't have enough time, I'm not doing enough. What would that, obviously this might take a year to research this, but just off the top of your head for you, what would that be? See, you're catching me in my own, you're showcasing my own limiting belief because in my head, I'm like, I can't do this on the spot. This takes time. But I'm gonna go there. Sure, I mean, this could be completely wrong, but it's just like for where you're at in your life. I think it comes down to trust and knowing that what I am here to do will be done. And my job is to just show up and do my best in every moment and to trust myself. Speaking of trust, how, have you done any research or seen any research on the power of belief in God and how it supports your life by having an empowering belief versus a no belief at all or a disempowering belief? And how do you approach that in your life? We haven't done that research, but some people have and suggest that prayer and belief in God can help support the healing process. I think it's important to be connected to a higher purpose, a higher power, an implicate order that's outside yourself. I mean, that's just a fact that we are deeply connected to. Everything around us and I think getting out of your head a little bit and recognizing that connection can be very freeing and helpful for people. Because when you mentioned trust, I guess the reason I'm saying that is because not everyone trusts themselves. You know, you said like, I need to trust myself. But if no one's ever learned how to trust themselves or they've always lived in a world of self doubt or insecurity or not enoughness, and whatever they've done, they can't trust it because they feel shame or whatever around it themselves. Yeah. If you can't trust in yourself, then who do you trust in? You know what I mean? If it's like, okay, there's no hope for me if I've never been capable of doing something, even if I can show that I have been and I've gotten here, but I don't believe it, I wonder if there's a way to believe in a higher power in God to get you out of that as well. Knowing that you're trusting the timing of your life or trusting God will provide or trusting something else rather than your own knowing. Yeah, yeah. Because sometimes we can't trust our own thoughts. No, but this is another thing in the nuances and the distinction, because a lot of people are like, oh, your belief work is just about thinking positive. No, I have lots of doubts that come in in my mind and thoughts that are just not helpful, right? But those are thoughts. Those are not the same thing. They're not beliefs. They are not the same thing as beliefs, and they're not the same thing as what Jared Clifton and I call core beliefs. So what is the difference between a thought, a belief, and a core belief? So a belief is your kind of assumption or proposition about something you think to be true. You assume to be true. A thought is kind of like anything that flows through your mind at any moment. A core belief are a specific type of belief that it's your core assumption about the nature or essence of something. Now, that thing could be yourself. It could be the world. It could be stress. It could be your body. It could be cancer. It could be healthy eating. The core belief is like, what do you believe to be true about the essence of that thing? And we have sort of criteria for what makes it a core belief. So the modifier of the belief is simple, it's adjectival, and it's evaluative, right? So when I say stress is enhancing, my body is capable, the world is abundant, those modifiers, those descriptors of the belief, abundant, capable, enhancing, they're simple, right? They're describing the essence of what it is, and it's sort of evaluative. It's your general take on the nature of that thing. So those core beliefs can be much more powerful than thought because they are programmed into our minds, right? At any given moment, we have to take in an insane amount of sensory experiences, and we can't actually take it all in. Can't focus on it all at once. So we can't focus it on. So our brain has evolved these heuristics or simplified systems through which to kind of predict what's going to be there. And those core beliefs are part of that process. So you just simplify the world. So you're growing up and you're like, okay, well, people are dangerous, and I'm incapable, and my body will fail me, right? Those, you latch onto these beliefs because of things you've learned. And those, whether or not they're true, continue to be true or false, start shaping your attention, your physiology, your behavior, and your emotions. And then they create that truth, right? They create it. They create it. So- So beliefs create a reality. Yes. Gosh, it's so crazy. And what's cool about the core beliefs is that though I'm obsessed with them because I'm interested in what's the smallest amount of change that can make the biggest difference in your life? Yes. And if I'm worried about fixing my thoughts all day long, it's like, it's not, it doesn't work. And it's like, oh, I shouldn't be thinking that. I should be thinking da, da, da. But if I can take time and intention to kind of look into my programming and think, I have the belief that the world is scarce or that time is scarce. Maybe that's it. And if I can just move the needle, it doesn't have to be, oh, now I think time is abundant, but just move it a little bit, right? Now that's the setting in which I'm operating in the world. Interesting. So small changes in your core belief can have outsized effects on creating your reality. The School of Greatness is presented by ChatGPT. Now, personal growth looks different for everyone. Maybe it's exercising more. Maybe it's learning something new or making time for a goal that you've been putting off for a while. The hardest part is finding time in your busy schedule. And that's where ChatGPT can help you. Give it your goals. Connect your personal calendar and tell it how much time you can commit to. And ChatGPT creates an adjustable weekly plan and progress tracker that fits your lifestyle. I use ChatGPT with the work toggle enabled to research guests, organize information, and create reports for the School of Greatness so I have more data. It helps me stay organized and focused on what matters most. Get started at chatgpt.com. At Staples, easy means turning holiday memories into something you can hold onto. Save 40% on custom cards, invitations, wrapping paper, photo gifts, and labels now through November 21st. From heartfelt greetings to one-of-a-kind gifts, Staples helps make the season more personal. This holiday, don't choose hard. Choose Staples. Offer ends 11-21. Exclusions apply. See staples.com for details. So what if someone has had core beliefs their entire life and then at one point they wake up and realize that core belief was a lie? And they've gotten new evidence by other people or other influences where it's like, oh, actually, that's not the truth. This is the truth. Yeah, so the difference between core beliefs and other beliefs is that because they are oversimplified, highly evaluative, they are very difficult to prove or disprove one way or the other, right? Like, you know, you could have a belief that there are 50 states in America. That's also a construct, but like you could prove or disprove. But the belief that the world is dangerous, it's not true or false, right or wrong. Like, there's plenty of evidence for anyone's belief in the danger or safety of the world. There's plenty, like there's plenty of beliefs for the capability or incapability of my body. There's plenty of evidence for the belief that stress is enhancing or debilitating. So again, these core beliefs are not right or wrong. They're not true or false, but they are impactful. And their impact is more or less useful depending on your goals. If someone hasn't felt like they've mattered enough, they haven't been able to accomplish their goals, they feel like they're broke, broken, you know, whatever it might be, they're struggling and they haven't broken through yet. And they say, you know what? I'm gonna start believing in myself more. I wanna start believing that the world is more abundant and possibilities are available for me. I wanna start believing that I'm capable of love, giving and receiving and deserving of great love, more money, all these different things. How important is the use or practice of affirmations, of saying something out loud to yourself, even if you've never believed it, of saying, I am capable and powerful. I am worthy of love. I'm the luckiest man in the world. Opportunities come to me every single day to prove this, even if it hasn't happened before. How empowering is saying these affirmations out loud to yourself to then shift a belief system to then go and see. see it and witness it and reaffirm, oh, see, what I'm saying is happening. How powerful is affirmations for beliefs? I think it's very powerful. I think whether or not you shout it from the rooftop to everybody or you write it in your journal or you have it tattooed somewhere no one can see. But it matters for a couple of reasons. I think one is that it helps clarify what the belief is. Because again, you can be like, oh yeah, I believe in myself. But what is the thing that really makes you feel like I am capable, I'm living a purposeful life, or I can manage whatever comes at me? You see the tenor changes when it's specific. And so forcing yourself to say it or communicate it to others or put it out there forces you to be more precise and specific in the belief. And that's really important. I think in a lot of our interventions we do offer people sort of a three-step technique which can essentially, you said it, it's say it, see it, and live it, right? So it's, you know. Didn't you come up with that with your dad? Well, that was our stress, so in our stress work, and we say, we use different terms. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But that was acknowledge the stress, welcome the stress as something you care about and utilize the stress to help you meet your dreams. And that, yeah, with my dad. Yeah, and this one, I was gonna say it, see it, and. Live it. Live it. So this is, you know, if you're trying to shift a belief. So say I wanna pick the belief that time is abundant. Start saying it. So I'll say it out loud. Yeah, yeah, look at your energy shift though. Look at your energy shift like your face and your body language shift when you said it and started to kind of believe it a little bit. Yeah, cause it clicked. Yeah. You're like, time is abundant and you started smiling and your whole like, you got lighter. I'm so excited about this. You look younger energetically in a moment, you feel lighter, all these things. Yeah, so just saying it out loud immediately changes. Say it. Say it. See it. See it. How do you see it? Now I'm gonna walk out this door and when I look at my to-do list and I think about all the things, I'm gonna see the abundance in my day. Of time. Of time. When I'm with my daughter, right? I'm gonna see the abundance of this moment that I have with her. You know, when I do the work, you know, seeing that, you know, I have plenty of time to get this thing done, right? So you're, again, cause those core beliefs are not true or false. Now you wanna find the evidence, right? You wanna select in those sensory streams that are concordant with that belief. And you can, it will happen naturally, like if you change the belief, that'll happen automatically, but you can intentionally also see it. And then the living it is you just live it, right? And embody it, right? So when I sit down at my computer to finish writing this book, you know, I can embody the fact that time is abundant, you know, that I've, you know, that I am doing enough, that what I'm saying is enough. When I'm with my daughter, I can, you know, say this moment is enough, you know? And you just live, you live the belief. Yes. Yeah. We're gonna have to have you come back on in the future because for me, this is probably one of the most important conversations I think people should be hearing personally, because I just believe that when we can shift our mind and shift our beliefs to empower us, our whole makeup, our whole identity starts to shift. And when our identity shifts, we start behaving in certain ways as well to match those beliefs, to match a mindset that reinforces it. And we can choose a mindset or belief system that disempowers us, that keeps us feeling stuck or not enough or in lack, or we can start shifting a mindset and a belief that empowers us to feel we are enough, we are in abundance, and everything is working out and it's perfect timing for us. So I hope everyone shares this episode because for me, this is the key. This is like the secret to feeling free in this world is having a mindset and a belief system that supports you. Even if you feel like you've gone through a lot of adversity and challenges in your life, you can shift it at any time if you can start to interpret things differently. So I'm so grateful that you're here. I'm glad we're able to do this. And hopefully we have you on many more times in the future with the new book coming out next year as well. I've got a couple of final questions for you, but before I ask them, I wanna acknowledge you for being open enough to know that as an expert, as a practitioner and a professor, that you also get to support yourself. You're helping a lot of other people in the world, but I think the practitioners, the professors, and the healers of the world need a lot of support as well because you take on a lot and you have high standards for yourself. So I see this in you, I acknowledge it, I recognize it, and I'm grateful that you care so much about helping others. And I hope that you get to do some research on yourself as well so that you can have some of that peace that you're giving so many other people who are listening and watching and go through your work. So I really appreciate you being here and acknowledge you for the journey you're on. Thank you so much, it's so fun. I mean, just watching you from afar over the years, you live this work. And to be able to talk with you and share some of the research is just fun, but you already know it, right? Because you're doing it, right? But to put those pieces together, it's really meaningful. It's one thing to know it and do it, but to understand it through research builds the belief even more. It's funny, because I went to a meditation retreat with a guy named Dr. Joe Dispenza, who's been on here many times. And for years, he was kind of like, looked at it as, you know, I'm teaching meditation and it's not really like research and there's no science behind it, but people were improving their health and they were healing. And it's funny because he was like, I wanted to start proving the evidence in the research of this. So I knocked on a door of a drug research company, you know, I literally showed up to an office and knocked on the door and said, I want you to disprove me. The meditation doesn't work, that there's no chemical change in the body, that there's nothing that's enhancing in the mind and all these things. And he brought these drug researchers in who do these placebo tests and these drug tests all the time and now he brings, he's like teaching meditation, but he's also bringing the drug researchers in to say, here's all the tests we've done from the blood work and the brain scans before and after meditation. And here's how it's improving your health when you meditate. And it doesn't matter if it's his meditation or any meditation, it's like, this is what's happening to the chemical makeup of your body. And when you can infuse a research or data into a belief that backs it even more, I feel like it strengthens the belief, right? So you're doing that in a big way. And I would just add too that it's not just, we're not trying to just prove things, we're trying to discover things. And it's like the milkshake study, it wasn't just like, let's see if, let's prove that the mind matters. It's like, let's see if the mind matters and then see how. And then that insight helped me be more precise in living that. Yeah, man, this is so powerful, Allie. I appreciate you being here. This is a question I ask everyone at the end, called the three truths. So imagine hypothetical, you get to live as long as you want, but it's the last day on earth for you, and you have to take all of your work with you. But you get to leave behind three lessons with the world. And this is all we would have of your message or your content. What would those three truths be for you? It's hard. Yeah, it is hard. And the number one truth is that your mind matters in everything you do. It shapes your world, it creates your reality, and it creates realities for others. So take that seriously. Learn as much as you can and build skill in that. Two is, I think, around stress. So to view stress as natural, normal, and your greatest teacher in disguise. The stressors that you're inevitably gonna experience are there to serve you and help connect you to what matters and live a purposeful life. And third, I would say, to live, we didn't talk about this a lot, but to live joyfully, to learn how to enjoy the process. People can follow you everywhere on social media, Dr. Aaliyah Crum on Instagram, X, LinkedIn, things like that. Where else can we go and follow you or support what you're up to right now? Our website. I run the Stanford Mind and Body Lab. That's where we post all our research findings and new papers coming out. And aaliyahcrum.com is my website, and I'll have updates there on when the book's coming out. Amazing. And all that. What's the book called again? It's called Believe, The Mind's Power to Create Reality. Ooh, gosh, this is gonna be amazing. I'm so excited for this book. Me too. You're not done yet with it? You're still finishing it? I'm at the end of writing it, and then we're kind of shaping it and thinking about it. This is gonna be a game changer. Man, I'm so excited for this. Okay, final question, what's your definition of greatness? You know, I knew you were gonna ask me that, so I thought about it, and I agree with your definition of greatness. I'm not just saying that to be sarcastic. I really do. I think that being great, greatness is realizing your highest level of self and doing that for the service of others. I think you're right. I like it, I like it. If I can add anything, I would say, how do you do that? One aspect is becoming aware of your beliefs and your minds. But you already nailed it. You need to give it back to me. Oh, I appreciate it. Aaliyah, thanks so much for being here. I appreciate it. Thank you so much. I can't wait to keep the conversation going. Yeah. My friend, I hope you're enjoying this episode right now because we are on a mission to impact 100 million lives every single week. And every follow here on this podcast helps us reach more people. Make sure to hit the follow at the top of this show's page right now. It's the single biggest thing that you can do to support the show and the impact of us reaching you every single time we have new episodes. I appreciate you, and I can't wait to see you in the next episode. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and it inspired you on your journey towards greatness. Make sure to check out the show notes in the description for a full rundown of today's episode with all the important links. And if you want weekly exclusive bonus episodes with me personally, as well as ad-free listening, then make sure to subscribe to our Greatness Plus channel exclusively on Apple Podcasts. Share this with a friend on social media and leave us a review on Apple Podcasts as well. Let me know what you enjoyed about this episode in that review. I really love hearing feedback from you and it helps us figure out how we can support and serve you moving forward. And I wanna remind you, if no one has told you lately that you are loved, you are worthy, and you matter. And now it's time to go out there and do something great. ♪ Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah ♪ Still have a few names left on your holiday gift list? Tony Box 2 from Tonys is worth checking out. Listening grows all kinds of kids and whether they're into dinosaurs, princesses, or something completely different, there's a Tony for them. It's a screen-free audio player that kids can use all on their own. Just place a Tony on top and they can listen to stories, music, or play screen-free games with Tony Play. It's designed for their hands, powered by their choices, and built to help them grow. Give the gift of the Tony Box 2 this holiday. Find it at Tonys, that's T-O-N-I-E-S dot com. Fidelity Active ETFs have the flexibility to shift and transform as markets do the same. So instead of just writing an index, they can seek to outperform it by adapting to market conditions and pursuing new opportunities as they emerge. And while you get the potential outperformance of an actively managed fund, you can still buy and sell it on your terms, just like any other ETF. Markets can change in real time. Make sure your ETF can too. Learn more at fidelity.com slash active ETFs. Before investing in any exchange-traded fund, you should consider its investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses. Contact Fidelity for a prospectus, an offering circular, or if available, a summary prospectus containing this information. Read it carefully. While active ETFs offer the potential to outperform an index, these products may more significantly trail an index as compared with passive ETFs. ETFs are subject to market fluctuation and the risks of their underlying investments. ETFs are subject to management fees and other expenses. Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, member NYSE SIPC.