Divorce Lawyer: “Give her a prenup on the 3rd date” - James Sexton
Professional athletes have a 70% divorce rate—nearly 50% higher than the general population—with half occurring within one year of retirement. The transition from a highly structured life with constant purpose to sudden emptiness creates profound dissatisfaction that often gets weaponized against pa
1h 58mKey Takeaway
Professional athletes have a 70% divorce rate—nearly 50% higher than the general population—with half occurring within one year of retirement. The transition from a highly structured life with constant purpose to sudden emptiness creates profound dissatisfaction that often gets weaponized against partners. The lesson: discord in relationships typically stems from your relationship with yourself. When you're restless and unsatisfied internally, it becomes easy to take that out on those closest to you.
Episode Overview
Divorce attorney James Sexton discusses the psychology of marriage and divorce, focusing on professional athletes' relationships, prenuptial agreements, and the legal realities of marriage. He explores why athlete divorces spike after retirement, the importance of prenups, and how modern relationships fail by ignoring their economic nature. Sexton argues that everyone has a prenup—either one written by the government or one you create yourself—and emphasizes that you can't feel truly loved without feeling safe.
Key Insights
Professional Athletes Face Unique Divorce Risks Post-Retirement
Professional athletes have a nearly 70% divorce rate, with 50% of divorces occurring within one year of retirement. The transition from a monastic discipline and highly structured schedule to complete emptiness creates profound dissatisfaction. Athletes go from having every minute accounted for—meals, workouts, travel—to silence and purposelessness, with minimal support systems in place.
Internal Discord Manifests as Relationship Problems
Most discord in romantic relationships stems from your relationship with yourself, not your partner. When you're feeling restless, unsatisfied, or hate your choices, it's easy to weaponize that against the people closest to you. Things your partner does that once seemed adorable suddenly become unbearable irritations.
Everyone Has a Prenup—Government or Personal
Every married person has a prenuptial agreement, whether they know it or not. It's either one written by the government that can be changed at any time without your notice, or it's a contract written by the two people who claim to love each other. Marriage is the most legally significant thing you'll do besides dying, yet you don't even get a pamphlet explaining what just happened legally.
Prenups May Actually Protect Marriages
Based on 25 years of practice and hundreds of prenups, Sexton has only done three divorces for clients he created prenups for. The open, vulnerable, brave conversations required to negotiate a prenup—discussing difficult topics that might upset your partner in the short term but are important long-term—appear to be a skill that strengthens relationships.
You Can't Feel Loved Without Feeling Safe
To truly love someone requires incredible vulnerability and showing your soft spots. A prenup is fundamentally about making both people feel safe by saying: 'I want to protect you from people that hurt you, even if that someone's me.' It's about acknowledging that there's a chance you might hurt each other and planning for protection regardless.
Notable Quotes
"You said for better or for worse, you didn't say for lunch, you know."
"I think most discord in relationships, romantic relationships, is a function of your relationship with yourself and the fact that you are feeling restless, you are feeling unsatisfied, and it's incredibly easy to take that out on the people around you."
"Everyone has a prenup. It's either one that was written by the government and can be changed by the government at any time without your notice... or it's a contract written by the two people that claim to love each other more than the other 8 billion options in the world."
"Marriage is the most legally significant thing you will ever do other than dying... By the way, you don't even get a pamphlet when you get married. Nothing. Not even a brochure that says, 'By the way, here's all of the things that just happened legally when you entered into this contract.'"
"You can't feel loved if you don't feel safe. I mean, genuinely loved if you don't feel safe."
"I want to protect you from people that hurt you, even if that someone's me. Like, there's a chance I'm going to hurt you. Like, there's a chance I'm going to make you sad. There's a chance I'm going to disappoint you."
Action Items
-
1
Discuss Prenups Early in Dating (Third Date)
Bring up prenups conversationally early—around the third date—by discussing celebrity marriages or asking 'I wonder if they have a prenup?' This safely tests your partner's temperature on the topic and reveals whether they view prenups as smart planning or a trust issue.
-
2
Ask the Big Life Questions Before Marriage
Before considering marriage, discuss: Do you want kids? Are you a pet person? Where do you want to live? How important is your family? Would you want aging parents to move in? These foundational questions reveal compatibility on major life decisions.
-
3
Frame Prenups as Mutual Safety, Not Distrust
Present a prenup by saying: 'We have an abundance of goodwill towards each other. Let's right now while we're this crazy about each other, say how can we make each other feel safe?' Focus on protection and clarity rather than suspicion.
-
4
Revisit the Hand Job and Fingering Question
Ask yourself and your partner: 'When was the last time you just got a hand job or just got fingered?' This reveals how much variety, playfulness, and exploration exists in your intimate life and whether you've fallen into routine patterns.