1% better

Can the AI Industry Regulate Itself? Stripe Wants PayPal, China Catches Up, NY Bans Datacenters

The All-In podcast hosts discuss Demis Hassabis's proposal for AI regulation through a self-regulatory organization (SRO), debate the structure and potential...

1h 29m

Summary published by , updated .

All-In Podcast

Key Takeaway

Create a self-regulatory organization (SRO) for AI oversight, modeled after FINRA. Industry experts conduct pre-release safety testing for frontier models—focusing only on catastrophic risks like cyber and biological threats—while government maintains oversight but not control. Start voluntary, prove it works, then make it mandatory. Five critical conditions: broad industry representation (including startups and open source), review only frontier models, focus solely on catastrophic risk, voluntary first, and serve as a substitute for government agencies—not an addition to them.

Episode Overview

The All-In podcast hosts discuss Demis Hassabis's proposal for AI regulation through a self-regulatory organization (SRO), debate the structure and potential pitfalls of industry self-regulation, and analyze Stripe's joint bid with Advent and Block to acquire PayPal for $53 billion as part of an emerging trend of AI-native operators acquiring legacy digital businesses.

Main Insights

Self-Regulation Beats Government Bureaucracy in Fast-Moving Tech

Government agencies lack the expertise and speed to evaluate AI models effectively. Creating an FAA-style approval process for AI would turn a months-long development cycle into years-long delays, causing the US to lose the AI race to China. A self-regulatory approach allows independent technical experts to set and update testing criteria quarterly, adapting to rapid technological changes while maintaining federal oversight without federal control.

Five Non-Negotiable Conditions Make SROs Work

For AI self-regulation to succeed without becoming regulatory capture, it must: (1) include broad industry representation beyond just big labs, (2) review only frontier models representing true advances in state-of-the-art, (3) focus exclusively on catastrophic risks (cyber, CBRN—not speech or microaggressions), (4) start voluntary to prove effectiveness before becoming mandatory, and (5) substitute for—not add to—government regulatory structures.

Legacy Digital Businesses Are Prime Acquisition Targets for AI-Native Operators

First-generation digital companies that have matured, lost founder leadership, and haven't adopted AI represent massive opportunities. Operators like Ryan Cohen (eBay bid) and Bending Spoons (acquiring AOL, Vimeo, Evernote) are systematically diagnosing where these businesses overspend, underspend, or misuse their networks, then applying AI-first thinking and young AI-native executives to revitalize them and extract cash flow.

The Return of M&A Unlocks Venture Capital Liquidity

After years of dealmaking paralysis under aggressive antitrust enforcement, M&A activity has surged following the 2024 election. Multiple portfolio companies have been acquired since Trump's election, SpaceX distributions are flowing, and LPs are eager to deploy capital again. This liquidity cycle validates venture capital as an asset class and enables the next wave of innovation funding.

Notable Quotes

"The government does not have the expertise to evaluate AI models. The criteria are changing too rapidly. You're going to very rapidly end up with a queue where all the models would be waiting to get tested and it would start with a month-long delay. It would end up being many months and we would just lose the AI race."

David Sacks

"This body should only be reviewing frontier models, meaning the true frontier. The models that really represent an advance in the state-of-the-art of artificial intelligence and models below this level should not be held up from getting to market."

David Sacks

"The faster we avoid that off-ramp by actually establishing a set of rules and superseding the need for federal oversight is a really important thing. What it prevents is a handful of actors using their balance sheets and their capital to essentially pull the ladder up."

Chamath Palihapitiya

"I think there's going to be more of these kinds of deals. If you look at Ryan Cohen's bid for eBay, I think it's probably a second dot on a line that I think is emerging, which is folks that are call it AI native are looking at call it first generation digital native businesses that have become mature and old and stale."

David Friedberg

"Anthropic is pursuing a strategy of one-upmanship that encourages states to impose increasingly tougher AI guard rails rather than a line around a single set of regulations. So the basic idea is that they get a set of regulations passed in one state like California's SB1047 and that was then supposed to be the model at least for all the blue states. But then with each new state, they actually make the regulations more and more strict."

David Sacks

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Advocate for Industry Self-Regulation in Your Sector

    If you work in a rapidly evolving technology field facing regulatory pressure, study the FINRA model and propose a self-regulatory organization for your industry. Emphasize that independent technical experts can adapt testing criteria faster than government agencies while maintaining oversight. Include diverse stakeholders (startups, open source, established players) to prevent regulatory capture.

  • 2
    Identify Legacy Digital Businesses Ripe for AI Transformation

    Look for first-generation internet companies that are no longer founder-led, have stagnant growth, and haven't integrated AI into their operations. Analyze where they overspend, underspend, or underutilize their networks. These businesses often have valuable customer bases and infrastructure but lack modern operational efficiency—making them prime acquisition or partnership targets.

  • 3
    Position Your Company for the M&A Revival

    With antitrust enforcement easing and M&A activity surging, ensure your company's financials, product roadmap, and competitive positioning are acquisition-ready. Document your unique value proposition, customer retention metrics, and how your technology complements potential acquirers. For acquirers, move quickly on deals that were previously blocked by regulatory uncertainty.

  • 4
    Build AI-First Operational Expertise to Revitalize Legacy Assets

    Develop skills in diagnosing operational inefficiencies in mature businesses and applying AI to marketing, product development, and cost structure. Study operators like Bending Spoons' Luca Feretti who systematically identify overspending, fix product issues, and leverage AI to extract more value from existing customer networks.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

All right, everybody. Welcome back to All right, everybody. Welcome back to the world's greatest podcast. The number the world's greatest podcast. The number the world's greatest podcast. The number one podcast, your favorite podcast, the one podcast, your favorite podcast, the one podcast, your favorite podcast, the All-In podcast. I'm Jason Calakanis, the All-In podcast. I'm Jason Calakanis, the All-In podcast. I'm Jason Calakanis, the world's greatest moderator. With me, of world's greatest moderator. With me, of world's greatest moderator. With me, of course, Chimath Polyhapitive, course, Chimath Polyhapitive, course, Chimath Polyhapitive, >> the great great great great great >> the great great great great great >> the great great great great great grandchild, Jason was of a hooker and grandchild, Jason was of a hooker and grandchild, Jason was of a hooker and >> you saw that from France >> you saw that from France >> you saw that from France >> and a purse snatcher. [laughter] >> and a purse snatcher. [laughter] >> and a purse snatcher. [laughter] >> This this comes from like a history of >> This this comes from like a history of >> This this comes from like a history of uh France. some history uh France. some history uh France. some history >> uh said [laughter] they let you out of >> uh said [laughter] they let you out of >> uh said [laughter] they let you out of this was this was the deal in 1719 Sachs this was this was the deal in 1719 Sachs this was this was the deal in 1719 Sachs if you're a prisoner in a in Paris you if you're a prisoner in a in Paris you if you're a prisoner in a in Paris you were offered your freedom on the were offered your freedom on the were offered your freedom on the condition that you marry a prostitute condition that you marry a prostitute condition that you marry a prostitute and move to the great state of Louisiana and move to the great state of Louisiana and move to the great state of Louisiana what are you saying taking the deal what are you saying taking the deal what are you saying taking the deal >> it explains a a certain of your >> it explains a a certain of your >> it explains a a certain of your proclivities Jake I I proclivities Jake I I proclivities Jake I I >> I thought you were asking me to see if >> I thought you were asking me to see if >> I thought you were asking me to see if they would extend the rule for you they would extend the rule for you they would extend the rule for you >> no I'm saying that your great great >> no I'm saying that your great great >> no I'm saying that your great great great great great Grandma, I'm not a great great great Grandma, I'm not a great great great Grandma, I'm not a hooker. I'm Greek. hooker. I'm Greek. hooker. I'm Greek. >> That's what I'm saying very explicitly. >> That's what I'm saying very explicitly. >> That's what I'm saying very explicitly. She was She was She was >> We never We never spent time in a >> We never We never spent time in a >> We never We never spent time in a prison. Also, of course, David Freeberg prison. Also, of course, David Freeberg prison. Also, of course, David Freeberg is here. How you doing, brother? is here. How you doing, brother? is here. How you doing, brother? >> Living the dream. >> Living the dream. >> Living the dream. >> Good to be back. Missed you guys last >> Good to be back. Missed you guys last >> Good to be back. Missed you guys last week. How was Brad? How did he fill in? week. How was Brad? How did he fill in? week. How was Brad? How did he fill in? >> It was great. Yeah. Yeah, he was. >> It was great. Yeah. Yeah, he was. >> It was great. Yeah. Yeah, he was. >> Trump account victory lap. >> Trump account victory lap. >> Trump account victory lap. >> He had a little victory lap. We played >> He had a little victory lap. We played >> He had a little victory lap. We played Chariots of Fire. And uh how was your Chariots of Fire. And uh how was your Chariots of Fire. And uh how was your special time at blank and your time next special time at blank and your time next special time at blank and your time next week at blank? [laughter] week at blank? [laughter] week at blank? [laughter] >> Thanks for h Thanks for having me on >> Thanks for h Thanks for having me on >> Thanks for h Thanks for having me on your show, Jel. your show, Jel. your show, Jel. >> All right, we got a full docket today. >> All right, we got a full docket today. >> All right, we got a full docket today. Uh lots of stories. Let's start with uh Uh lots of stories. Let's start with uh Uh lots of stories. Let's start with uh Deep Mind's Deis Habis just dropped an Deep Mind's Deis Habis just dropped an Deep Mind's Deis Habis just dropped an AI regulation proposal and it's um it's AI regulation proposal and it's um it's AI regulation proposal and it's um it's pretty popular with the boys. In an ex pretty popular with the boys. In an ex pretty popular with the boys. In an ex article, Demis called for a US-led article, Demis called for a US-led article, Demis called for a US-led international AI standards body proposal international AI standards body proposal international AI standards body proposal is modeled after FINRA, the Financial is modeled after FINRA, the Financial is modeled after FINRA, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. Industry Regulatory Authority. Industry Regulatory Authority. That's a self-regulatory body. And this That's a self-regulatory body. And this That's a self-regulatory body. And this would be federally overseen, but would be federally overseen, but would be federally overseen, but industry funded and run by independent industry funded and run by independent industry funded and run by independent technological experts. Frontier Labs technological experts. Frontier Labs technological experts. Frontier Labs would submit their models 30 days before would submit their models 30 days before would submit their models 30 days before release. Uh, and it would be voluntary release. Uh, and it would be voluntary release. Uh, and it would be voluntary initially, then mandatory. At some initially, then mandatory. At some initially, then mandatory. At some point, the models would be assessed on point, the models would be assessed on point, the models would be assessed on risk to cyber security, risk to cyber security, risk to cyber security, national security, biological threats, national security, biological threats, national security, biological threats, and other high-risisk domains. and other high-risisk domains. and other high-risisk domains. Benchmarks would be updated quarterly, Benchmarks would be updated quarterly, Benchmarks would be updated quarterly, and the body can coordinate a slowdown and the body can coordinate a slowdown and the body can coordinate a slowdown in development if the situation demands in development if the situation demands in development if the situation demands it. I guess that would be if uh there it. I guess that would be if uh there it. I guess that would be if uh there was a cyber risk, etc. Looks like uh on was a cyber risk, etc. Looks like uh on was a cyber risk, etc. Looks like uh on the positive side we have Elon who said the positive side we have Elon who said the positive side we have Elon who said it was thoughtful, Sam at OpenAI, it was thoughtful, Sam at OpenAI, it was thoughtful, Sam at OpenAI, Jack Clark at Anthropic, Sundar, Jack Clark at Anthropic, Sundar, Jack Clark at Anthropic, Sundar, Satia, Jack Dorsey from Block, the Satia, Jack Dorsey from Block, the Satia, Jack Dorsey from Block, the Carlson brothers. So Freeberg um Carlson brothers. So Freeberg um Carlson brothers. So Freeberg um uh Freeberg, your thoughts on uh Freeberg, your thoughts on uh Freeberg, your thoughts on >> Oh, wow. Way to really way to really uh >> Oh, wow. Way to really way to really uh >> Oh, wow. Way to really way to really uh put in the effort today. Go ahead, put in the effort today. Go ahead, put in the effort today. Go ahead, Jason. Good. Jason. Good. Jason. Good. >> Just pass it to me. I'll take care of >> Just pass it to me. I'll take care of >> Just pass it to me. I'll take care of it. Let me let me it. Let me let me it. Let me let me >> What do you want me to do? Oh my god, >> What do you want me to do? Oh my god, >> What do you want me to do? Oh my god, what an incredible topic. what an incredible topic. what an incredible topic. >> All right, here. Let me do it. You want >> All right, here. Let me do it. You want >> All right, here. Let me do it. You want me to do it, right? Three, two, me to do it, right? Three, two, me to do it, right? Three, two, >> some of us actually care about this >> some of us actually care about this >> some of us actually care about this topic. Let's go. topic. Let's go. topic. Let's go. >> Okay. Yeah, you care about it. Okay, >> Okay. Yeah, you care about it. Okay, >> Okay. Yeah, you care about it. Okay, here we go. Three, two. Here's a clip of here we go. Three, two. Here's a clip of here we go. Three, two. Here's a clip of me calling it on the All-In podcast me calling it on the All-In podcast me calling it on the All-In podcast first. The whole industry is going to first. The whole industry is going to first. The whole industry is going to need to be regulated and I think the need to be regulated and I think the need to be regulated and I think the industry needs to regulate themselves. industry needs to regulate themselves. industry needs to regulate themselves. That's the key to this. We need to have That's the key to this. We need to have That's the key to this. We need to have a set of tests that Google, Microsoft, a set of tests that Google, Microsoft, a set of tests that Google, Microsoft, Amazon all agree to. Elon, hey, these Amazon all agree to. Elon, hey, these Amazon all agree to. Elon, hey, these are the things we should test and they are the things we should test and they are the things we should test and they should self-certify each model before should self-certify each model before should self-certify each model before asking the government which doesn't asking the government which doesn't asking the government which doesn't understand the models to certify them. understand the models to certify them. understand the models to certify them. The industry should have an industry The industry should have an industry The industry should have an industry certification like they do for countless certification like they do for countless certification like they do for countless other things. I've talked about the MPAA other things. I've talked about the MPAA other things. I've talked about the MPAA and the video game industry. We should and the video game industry. We should and the video game industry. We should just self-certify. It's the simplest just self-certify. It's the simplest just self-certify. It's the simplest thing in the world to do. And then we thing in the world to do. And then we thing in the world to do. And then we could release the models ourselves could release the models ourselves could release the models ourselves without the government getting involved. without the government getting involved. without the government getting involved. >> Brie, would you like to congratulate me >> Brie, would you like to congratulate me >> Brie, would you like to congratulate me on nailing it again? Well, first of all, on nailing it again? Well, first of all, on nailing it again? Well, first of all, first of all, I thought that Demis' first of all, I thought that Demis' first of all, I thought that Demis' proposal was really smart and proposal was really smart and proposal was really smart and thoughtful. Now that I know that you may thoughtful. Now that I know that you may thoughtful. Now that I know that you may have shared the same thought, I think we have shared the same thought, I think we have shared the same thought, I think we should just do something different. should just do something different. should just do something different. >> I can't win, Zach. Even when I nail it, >> I can't win, Zach. Even when I nail it, >> I can't win, Zach. Even when I nail it, I hit a halfcourt shot. Truman's like, I hit a halfcourt shot. Truman's like, I hit a halfcourt shot. Truman's like, "Move the net. Move the net." [laughter] "Move the net. Move the net." [laughter] "Move the net. Move the net." [laughter] >> I think it's worth putting a little >> I think it's worth putting a little >> I think it's worth putting a little definition around this proposal, which definition around this proposal, which definition around this proposal, which is to form an SRO, self-regulatory is to form an SRO, self-regulatory is to form an SRO, self-regulatory organization, because they're not purely organization, because they're not purely organization, because they're not purely independent. SRO's like FINRA and the independent. SRO's like FINRA and the independent. SRO's like FINRA and the National Futures Association, they exist National Futures Association, they exist National Futures Association, they exist in the financial markets and they were in the financial markets and they were in the financial markets and they were created to allow the financial created to allow the financial created to allow the financial institutions to set their regulatory institutions to set their regulatory institutions to set their regulatory rules, how they check each other, how rules, how they check each other, how rules, how they check each other, how they make sure that everyone is being they make sure that everyone is being they make sure that everyone is being safe because they're obviously all safe because they're obviously all safe because they're obviously all trading risk with one another. So the trading risk with one another. So the trading risk with one another. So the industry doesn't want to have exposure industry doesn't want to have exposure industry doesn't want to have exposure and they certainly don't want to have and they certainly don't want to have and they certainly don't want to have things get slowed down because that things get slowed down because that things get slowed down because that would make the markets inefficient. So would make the markets inefficient. So would make the markets inefficient. So the analogy with AI is pretty the analogy with AI is pretty the analogy with AI is pretty appropriate here which is that there are appropriate here which is that there are appropriate here which is that there are many players in the industry. They are many players in the industry. They are many players in the industry. They are all trying to progress AI technology and all trying to progress AI technology and all trying to progress AI technology and no one wants to have a single regulatory no one wants to have a single regulatory no one wants to have a single regulatory body that comes in from the government body that comes in from the government body that comes in from the government or outside that says here are the tests or outside that says here are the tests or outside that says here are the tests you guys have to pass with your models you guys have to pass with your models you guys have to pass with your models in order for them to be appropriate. As in order for them to be appropriate. As in order for them to be appropriate. As we saw in California when California we saw in California when California we saw in California when California tried to pass AI legislation, I think it tried to pass AI legislation, I think it tried to pass AI legislation, I think it was about a year a year and a half ago, was about a year a year and a half ago, was about a year a year and a half ago, none of what they wrote even made sense none of what they wrote even made sense none of what they wrote even made sense at the time. But fast forward a year, at the time. But fast forward a year, at the time. But fast forward a year, none of those kind of rules and none of those kind of rules and none of those kind of rules and requirements actually map to the requirements actually map to the requirements actually map to the technology of the day. So the purpose of technology of the day. So the purpose of technology of the day. So the purpose of an SRO like FINR run NFA is they can an SRO like FINR run NFA is they can an SRO like FINR run NFA is they can adjust how tests are being run, who is adjust how tests are being run, who is adjust how tests are being run, who is actually running the test and make sure actually running the test and make sure actually running the test and make sure the right experts are involved in doing the right experts are involved in doing the right experts are involved in doing this, independent experts that is to do this, independent experts that is to do this, independent experts that is to do the testing with federal government the testing with federal government the testing with federal government oversight but not control. So in the oversight but not control. So in the oversight but not control. So in the case of FINRA NFA, they report up case of FINRA NFA, they report up case of FINRA NFA, they report up ultimately to Senate committee and House ultimately to Senate committee and House ultimately to Senate committee and House committee that gives those committees committee that gives those committees committee that gives those committees oversight of those governing bodies that oversight of those governing bodies that oversight of those governing bodies that are supposed to be doing the work to are supposed to be doing the work to are supposed to be doing the work to make sure that they're doing their make sure that they're doing their make sure that they're doing their frigin jobs. So the SRO concept would be frigin jobs. So the SRO concept would be frigin jobs. So the SRO concept would be that experts could be brought in from that experts could be brought in from that experts could be brought in from industry that know how to assess models industry that know how to assess models industry that know how to assess models for things like cyber risk, for things for things like cyber risk, for things for things like cyber risk, for things like biorisk, for things like weapons like biorisk, for things like weapons like biorisk, for things like weapons risk, social manipulation, etc., etc. risk, social manipulation, etc., etc. risk, social manipulation, etc., etc. that independent body can get voted on, that independent body can get voted on, that independent body can get voted on, can get changed over time, and because can get changed over time, and because can get changed over time, and because they actually have expertise in running they actually have expertise in running they actually have expertise in running software valves and running tests like software valves and running tests like software valves and running tests like this, they can operate at a faster pace this, they can operate at a faster pace this, they can operate at a faster pace than setting up a new government agency. than setting up a new government agency. than setting up a new government agency. So, it's it's kind of a very elegant So, it's it's kind of a very elegant So, it's it's kind of a very elegant solution. And I think it's why everyone, solution. And I think it's why everyone, solution. And I think it's why everyone, to your point, Jal, and I I'll say this to your point, Jal, and I I'll say this to your point, Jal, and I I'll say this is right, the industry recognizes that is right, the industry recognizes that is right, the industry recognizes that there needs to be some degree of there needs to be some degree of there needs to be some degree of oversight and checkpoints here. And I oversight and checkpoints here. And I oversight and checkpoints here. And I think that this could actually solve think that this could actually solve think that this could actually solve that problem. So that's why I think that problem. So that's why I think that problem. So that's why I think everyone's kind of climbing on board everyone's kind of climbing on board everyone's kind of climbing on board with it because it doesn't actually hand with it because it doesn't actually hand with it because it doesn't actually hand stuff over to the government. It says, stuff over to the government. It says, stuff over to the government. It says, "Hey, we're going to get the right "Hey, we're going to get the right "Hey, we're going to get the right people to to take a look at these things people to to take a look at these things people to to take a look at these things and the government is going to have and the government is going to have and the government is going to have oversight ultimately." oversight ultimately." oversight ultimately." >> Did Anthropic and OpenAI have a point of >> Did Anthropic and OpenAI have a point of >> Did Anthropic and OpenAI have a point of view? view? view? >> They both signed up to it. I don't think >> They both signed up to it. I don't think >> They both signed up to it. I don't think Daario directly, but Dario's president Daario directly, but Dario's president Daario directly, but Dario's president gave his thumbs up and then I think Sam gave his thumbs up and then I think Sam gave his thumbs up and then I think Sam gave his thumbs up gave his thumbs up gave his thumbs up >> which means they're on board. Saxs, is >> which means they're on board. Saxs, is >> which means they're on board. Saxs, is this the best of the uh possibilities in this the best of the uh possibilities in this the best of the uh possibilities in your mind? uh is the industry regulating your mind? uh is the industry regulating your mind? uh is the industry regulating itself after they have now provoked itself after they have now provoked itself after they have now provoked governments around the world to be so governments around the world to be so governments around the world to be so concerned about this issue. concerned about this issue. concerned about this issue. >> Yeah. And I, you know, I talked to >> Yeah. And I, you know, I talked to >> Yeah. And I, you know, I talked to Dennis about this and this may surprise Dennis about this and this may surprise Dennis about this and this may surprise people, but I told him that I could people, but I told him that I could people, but I told him that I could potentially get on board with this, potentially get on board with this, potentially get on board with this, speaking just for myself, not on behalf speaking just for myself, not on behalf speaking just for myself, not on behalf of anyone in the government because I of anyone in the government because I of anyone in the government because I thought that an SRO, again, a thought that an SRO, again, a thought that an SRO, again, a self-regulatory approach would be self-regulatory approach would be self-regulatory approach would be infinitely better than creating a new infinitely better than creating a new infinitely better than creating a new government agency that I think would government agency that I think would government agency that I think would rapidly become a DMV for AI. Dario calls rapidly become a DMV for AI. Dario calls rapidly become a DMV for AI. Dario calls it an FAA for AI. The government does it an FAA for AI. The government does it an FAA for AI. The government does not have the expertise to evaluate AI not have the expertise to evaluate AI not have the expertise to evaluate AI models. The criteria are changing too models. The criteria are changing too models. The criteria are changing too rapidly. you're going to very rapidly rapidly. you're going to very rapidly rapidly. you're going to very rapidly end up with a queue where all the models end up with a queue where all the models end up with a queue where all the models would be waiting to get tested and it would be waiting to get tested and it would be waiting to get tested and it would start with a month-long delay. It would start with a month-long delay. It would start with a month-long delay. It would end up being many months and we would end up being many months and we would end up being many months and we would just lose the AI race. So, I think would just lose the AI race. So, I think would just lose the AI race. So, I think an SRO approach would be infinitely an SRO approach would be infinitely an SRO approach would be infinitely better than that if it was done right. better than that if it was done right. better than that if it was done right. And I outlined for Demis And I outlined for Demis And I outlined for Demis criteria or conditions that I thought criteria or conditions that I thought criteria or conditions that I thought were really important to in order to were really important to in order to were really important to in order to make this work. And if I could, I'll make this work. And if I could, I'll make this work. And if I could, I'll just run through them just run through them just run through them >> please. >> please. >> please. >> All right. So number one, I think the >> All right. So number one, I think the >> All right. So number one, I think the SRO has to have broad representation SRO has to have broad representation SRO has to have broad representation from within the industry, the AI from within the industry, the AI from within the industry, the AI industry. It has to include startups and industry. It has to include startups and industry. It has to include startups and open source. It can't just be the three open source. It can't just be the three open source. It can't just be the three biggest labs, you know, can't just be biggest labs, you know, can't just be biggest labs, you know, can't just be >> the fix, right? >> the fix, right? >> the fix, right? >> Yeah. Exactly. And that's precisely to >> Yeah. Exactly. And that's precisely to >> Yeah. Exactly. And that's precisely to avoid the problem of regulatory capture, avoid the problem of regulatory capture, avoid the problem of regulatory capture, right? If you have a diverse enough right? If you have a diverse enough right? If you have a diverse enough group of interests being represented, group of interests being represented, group of interests being represented, it's much harder for this to turn into it's much harder for this to turn into it's much harder for this to turn into red capture. So for example, I think if red capture. So for example, I think if red capture. So for example, I think if you had Jensen, Elon, Zuck, and maybe you had Jensen, Elon, Zuck, and maybe you had Jensen, Elon, Zuck, and maybe Mera because she just launched a very Mera because she just launched a very Mera because she just launched a very interesting interesting interesting >> open >> open >> open >> platform that's based on open mach capture problem to a large degree. So capture problem to a large degree. So that's number one. Number two is I think that's number one. Number two is I think that's number one. Number two is I think that this body should only be reviewing that this body should only be reviewing that this body should only be reviewing frontier models, meaning the true frontier models, meaning the true frontier models, meaning the true frontier. The models that really frontier. The models that really frontier. The models that really represent an advance in the represent an advance in the represent an advance in the state-of-the-art of artificial state-of-the-art of artificial state-of-the-art of artificial intelligence and models below this level intelligence and models below this level intelligence and models below this level should not be held up from getting to should not be held up from getting to should not be held up from getting to market. And I do think that is a big market. And I do think that is a big market. And I do think that is a big risk under regulations is that the risk under regulations is that the risk under regulations is that the leaders of the market use this as a way leaders of the market use this as a way leaders of the market use this as a way to tie up lesser models. And there's no to tie up lesser models. And there's no to tie up lesser models. And there's no reason if a model is not at the reason if a model is not at the reason if a model is not at the frontier, why hold it up? Okay, so frontier, why hold it up? Okay, so frontier, why hold it up? Okay, so that's that's that's >> so they have to be in maybe the top 10 >> so they have to be in maybe the top 10 >> so they have to be in maybe the top 10 performers, top 20 performers on the performers, top 20 performers on the performers, top 20 performers on the benchmark test. benchmark test. benchmark test. >> No, I think I think when they benchmark >> No, I think I think when they benchmark >> No, I think I think when they benchmark on key dimensions of intelligence, they on key dimensions of intelligence, they on key dimensions of intelligence, they have to represent an increase above have to represent an increase above have to represent an increase above where the current state-of-the-art is if where the current state-of-the-art is if where the current state-of-the-art is if it's not a step change, then how are you it's not a step change, then how are you it's not a step change, then how are you dealing with some new incremental risk, dealing with some new incremental risk, dealing with some new incremental risk, right? I mean, this is all about dealing right? I mean, this is all about dealing right? I mean, this is all about dealing with some sort of incremental with some sort of incremental with some sort of incremental catastrophic risk that could be catastrophic risk that could be catastrophic risk that could be introduced by some new step change in introduced by some new step change in introduced by some new step change in intelligence. And that brings me to intelligence. And that brings me to intelligence. And that brings me to number three, which is I think this body number three, which is I think this body number three, which is I think this body should be dealing with catastrophic risk should be dealing with catastrophic risk should be dealing with catastrophic risk only. And to my knowledge, those right only. And to my knowledge, those right only. And to my knowledge, those right now are cyber and CBRN, meaning it's, now are cyber and CBRN, meaning it's, now are cyber and CBRN, meaning it's, you know, chemical, biological, you know, chemical, biological, you know, chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear. So it should not radiological, nuclear. So it should not radiological, nuclear. So it should not be things, for example, like be things, for example, like be things, for example, like disinformation or microaggressions. This disinformation or microaggressions. This disinformation or microaggressions. This should not become a speech regulator, should not become a speech regulator, should not become a speech regulator, you know, or just, you know, things that you know, or just, you know, things that you know, or just, you know, things that seem kind of trivial. The only reason to seem kind of trivial. The only reason to seem kind of trivial. The only reason to have this is for truly catastrophic have this is for truly catastrophic have this is for truly catastrophic risk. So that's number three. Number risk. So that's number three. Number risk. So that's number three. Number four, and Deus mentioned this in his four, and Deus mentioned this in his four, and Deus mentioned this in his post, is that I think it should be post, is that I think it should be post, is that I think it should be voluntary first. This new organization voluntary first. This new organization voluntary first. This new organization should prove it works before it gets should prove it works before it gets should prove it works before it gets legally enshrined and becomes mandatory. legally enshrined and becomes mandatory. legally enshrined and becomes mandatory. And then number five is this should be a And then number five is this should be a And then number five is this should be a substitute for a new regulatory agency. substitute for a new regulatory agency. substitute for a new regulatory agency. If it's just additive, then it defeats If it's just additive, then it defeats If it's just additive, then it defeats the purpose and there's no real reason the purpose and there's no real reason the purpose and there's no real reason to support it. So again, I think this to support it. So again, I think this to support it. So again, I think this has to be a substitute, not an addition has to be a substitute, not an addition has to be a substitute, not an addition to a bunch of new regulatory structures. to a bunch of new regulatory structures. to a bunch of new regulatory structures. So I think if you did those five things, So I think if you did those five things, So I think if you did those five things, I think this becomes much more I think this becomes much more I think this becomes much more palatable. And Demis said, I mean, he palatable. And Demis said, I mean, he palatable. And Demis said, I mean, he didn't put all these points in his blog didn't put all these points in his blog didn't put all these points in his blog post, but he did say to me that he was post, but he did say to me that he was post, but he did say to me that he was bas. bas. bas. So I think if those notes were adopted, So I think if those notes were adopted, So I think if those notes were adopted, this is something that we could this is something that we could this is something that we could potentially get on board with. That potentially get on board with. That potentially get on board with. That doesn't mean I don't still have doesn't mean I don't still have doesn't mean I don't still have concerns. I'm quite concerned for concerns. I'm quite concerned for concerns. I'm quite concerned for example that you know I think Daario has example that you know I think Daario has example that you know I think Daario has expressed support for this however I expressed support for this however I expressed support for this however I think this is just an opening bid for think this is just an opening bid for think this is just an opening bid for anthropic meaning they'll take this anthropic meaning they'll take this anthropic meaning they'll take this thank you very much this is more thank you very much this is more thank you very much this is more regulation than we have today but that regulation than we have today but that regulation than we have today but that won't be the end of it right this will won't be the end of it right this will won't be the end of it right this will just be the stepping stone to get what just be the stepping stone to get what just be the stepping stone to get what Dario has now called for many times Dario has now called for many times Dario has now called for many times which is the FAA for AI and if I could which is the FAA for AI and if I could which is the FAA for AI and if I could let me just as as a final point I just let me just as as a final point I just let me just as as a final point I just want to explain what the FAA does want to explain what the FAA does want to explain what the FAA does because people need to understand you because people need to understand you because people need to understand you know FAA for AI sounds really nice, but know FAA for AI sounds really nice, but know FAA for AI sounds really nice, but actually it's a really extreme proposal. actually it's a really extreme proposal. actually it's a really extreme proposal. What the FAA does, among other things, What the FAA does, among other things, What the FAA does, among other things, is approve new airplane designs. Okay? is approve new airplane designs. Okay? is approve new airplane designs. Okay? And specifically, it requires what's And specifically, it requires what's And specifically, it requires what's called a type certification for any new called a type certification for any new called a type certification for any new aircraft design or major changes. And aircraft design or major changes. And aircraft design or major changes. And for an entirely new aircraft design, it for an entirely new aircraft design, it for an entirely new aircraft design, it takes 5 to 9 years takes 5 to 9 years takes 5 to 9 years >> to get the certification. And if you >> to get the certification. And if you >> to get the certification. And if you merely want to amend a certificate, I merely want to amend a certificate, I merely want to amend a certificate, I guess for you know major changes or I'm guess for you know major changes or I'm guess for you know major changes or I'm not even sure how major the changes need not even sure how major the changes need not even sure how major the changes need to be, it takes three to five years. So to be, it takes three to five years. So to be, it takes three to five years. So the Boeing 737 Max, for example, took the Boeing 737 Max, for example, took the Boeing 737 Max, for example, took about 5 years. So this is about 5 years. So this is about 5 years. So this is permissionbased regulation. There's no permissionbased regulation. There's no permissionbased regulation. There's no approval, no flying commercially. It's approval, no flying commercially. It's approval, no flying commercially. It's safety first. Look, that might make safety first. Look, that might make safety first. Look, that might make sense in the case of preventing plane sense in the case of preventing plane sense in the case of preventing plane crashes, but when you're talking about crashes, but when you're talking about crashes, but when you're talking about AI models, you're talking about AI models, you're talking about AI models, you're talking about replacing a system that is releasing new replacing a system that is releasing new replacing a system that is releasing new versions every couple of months with one versions every couple of months with one versions every couple of months with one that is potentially fully under the that is potentially fully under the that is potentially fully under the control of government, fully government control of government, fully government control of government, fully government approved. Everything has to be approved. Everything has to be approved. Everything has to be certified, and you could expect the certified, and you could expect the certified, and you could expect the timeline to go from months to years. timeline to go from months to years. timeline to go from months to years. Again, I think we'll just simply lose AI Again, I think we'll just simply lose AI Again, I think we'll just simply lose AI race if that happens because China is race if that happens because China is race if that happens because China is not going to abide by those rules. So not going to abide by those rules. So not going to abide by those rules. So just to sum up, if my choices are just to sum up, if my choices are just to sum up, if my choices are between FAA for AI or what I would call between FAA for AI or what I would call between FAA for AI or what I would call the DMV for AI, I would much rather go the DMV for AI, I would much rather go the DMV for AI, I would much rather go for Demis' SRO for AI, the for Demis' SRO for AI, the for Demis' SRO for AI, the self-regulatory approach. But we really self-regulatory approach. But we really self-regulatory approach. But we really have to keep it honest and pure because have to keep it honest and pure because have to keep it honest and pure because again otherwise it'll just be the again otherwise it'll just be the again otherwise it'll just be the opening bid in a coming new wave of opening bid in a coming new wave of opening bid in a coming new wave of regulation and it will be the vehicle regulation and it will be the vehicle regulation and it will be the vehicle for massive regulatory capture. for massive regulatory capture. for massive regulatory capture. >> To your point, it can't restrict. >> To your point, it can't restrict. >> To your point, it can't restrict. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Can't restrict open source. I think >> Can't restrict open source. I think >> Can't restrict open source. I think that's so important because all of these that's so important because all of these that's so important because all of these other efforts require money that you other efforts require money that you other efforts require money that you have to spend which is always where have to spend which is always where have to spend which is always where regulatory capture happens and you have regulatory capture happens and you have regulatory capture happens and you have to enable startups and open source to to enable startups and open source to to enable startups and open source to compete effectively. compete effectively. compete effectively. >> Shimoth, any thoughts on this new >> Shimoth, any thoughts on this new >> Shimoth, any thoughts on this new self-governing body? self-governing body? self-governing body? >> I think it's really important and I hope >> I think it's really important and I hope >> I think it's really important and I hope it happens quickly. The thing we have to it happens quickly. The thing we have to it happens quickly. The thing we have to keep in mind is there's going to be a keep in mind is there's going to be a keep in mind is there's going to be a torrent of money that's going to try to torrent of money that's going to try to torrent of money that's going to try to influence both sides of the political influence both sides of the political influence both sides of the political aisle to aisle to aisle to regulate this in a way that creates some regulate this in a way that creates some regulate this in a way that creates some form of regulatory capture. We just form of regulatory capture. We just form of regulatory capture. We just don't know what. And so the faster we don't know what. And so the faster we don't know what. And so the faster we avoid that off-ramp by actually avoid that off-ramp by actually avoid that off-ramp by actually establishing a set of rules and establishing a set of rules and establishing a set of rules and superseding the need for federal superseding the need for federal superseding the need for federal oversight is a really important thing. oversight is a really important thing. oversight is a really important thing. Now, at the end of the day, you still Now, at the end of the day, you still Now, at the end of the day, you still have federal oversight in some ways have federal oversight in some ways have federal oversight in some ways because you still have commerce that because you still have commerce that because you still have commerce that plays a huge role in these standards. plays a huge role in these standards. plays a huge role in these standards. You still have the DOJ. So, it's not as You still have the DOJ. So, it's not as You still have the DOJ. So, it's not as if it's going to be a wild west. But if it's going to be a wild west. But if it's going to be a wild west. But what it prevents is a handful of actors what it prevents is a handful of actors what it prevents is a handful of actors using their balance sheets and their using their balance sheets and their using their balance sheets and their capital to essentially pull the ladder capital to essentially pull the ladder capital to essentially pull the ladder up. And I think if that happens, we're up. And I think if that happens, we're up. And I think if that happens, we're in a really bad place. So I think Demis' in a really bad place. So I think Demis' in a really bad place. So I think Demis' proposal makes a ton of sense and we proposal makes a ton of sense and we proposal makes a ton of sense and we should just get on with it. should just get on with it. should just get on with it. >> All right. >> All right. >> All right. >> Well, yes. But provided I mean again >> Well, yes. But provided I mean again >> Well, yes. But provided I mean again just provided that I think we we make just provided that I think we we make just provided that I think we we make sure that I mean look in my view there sure that I mean look in my view there sure that I mean look in my view there there are five conditions but I think we there are five conditions but I think we there are five conditions but I think we do have to make sure it's pure. Even in do have to make sure it's pure. Even in do have to make sure it's pure. Even in the FINRA example, that's the analogy the FINRA example, that's the analogy the FINRA example, that's the analogy that Demis used was that we should set that Demis used was that we should set that Demis used was that we should set this up in the same way that that FINRA this up in the same way that that FINRA this up in the same way that that FINRA is set up. FINRA does report in is set up. FINRA does report in is set up. FINRA does report in ultimately to the government. It reports ultimately to the government. It reports ultimately to the government. It reports into the SEC. And so, you know, if we into the SEC. And so, you know, if we into the SEC. And so, you know, if we are going to set this new SRO, where is are going to set this new SRO, where is are going to set this new SRO, where is it going to report to in the government? it going to report to in the government? it going to report to in the government? There's going to be a huge food fight There's going to be a huge food fight There's going to be a huge food fight over that and it will then be subject to over that and it will then be subject to over that and it will then be subject to political pressure. The software political pressure. The software political pressure. The software industry has never been regulated in industry has never been regulated in industry has never been regulated in that way. We do not have a dedicated that way. We do not have a dedicated that way. We do not have a dedicated regulator for software. We're right, but regulator for software. We're right, but regulator for software. We're right, but those issues are important. But my point those issues are important. But my point those issues are important. But my point is, h I'm just saying these things are is, h I'm just saying these things are is, h I'm just saying these things are never ideal. But if the choices are we never ideal. But if the choices are we never ideal. But if the choices are we kill open source and we lad pull the kill open source and we lad pull the kill open source and we lad pull the entire market, so there's a duopoly or entire market, so there's a duopoly or entire market, so there's a duopoly or there's this, I'd say this there's this, I'd say this there's this, I'd say this >> for sure. And and that's and that's >> for sure. And and that's and that's >> for sure. And and that's and that's that's the crux of my argument is it's that's the crux of my argument is it's that's the crux of my argument is it's definitely the lesser of two evils. I'm definitely the lesser of two evils. I'm definitely the lesser of two evils. I'm not sure those are the only two choices, not sure those are the only two choices, not sure those are the only two choices, but increasingly there's no question but increasingly there's no question but increasingly there's no question that the pressure is coming to regulate that the pressure is coming to regulate that the pressure is coming to regulate AI more and more. And frankly, this all AI more and more. And frankly, this all AI more and more. And frankly, this all goes back to anthropics government. goes back to anthropics government. goes back to anthropics government. >> They poke the tiger. They poked the >> They poke the tiger. They poked the >> They poke the tiger. They poked the tiger. tiger. tiger. >> Yeah. Well, it's it's more than that. >> Yeah. Well, it's it's more than that. >> Yeah. Well, it's it's more than that. >> They're funding the meat the tiger. >> They're funding the meat the tiger. >> They're funding the meat the tiger. >> Yeah. I want to give an update on that >> Yeah. I want to give an update on that >> Yeah. I want to give an update on that actually cuz actually cuz actually cuz >> I would say poking the tiger of like the >> I would say poking the tiger of like the >> I would say poking the tiger of like the American public getting really freaked American public getting really freaked American public getting really freaked out and then the government stepping in. out and then the government stepping in. out and then the government stepping in. Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, >> totally. And there's a couple of data >> totally. And there's a couple of data >> totally. And there's a couple of data points on that actually. I just want to points on that actually. I just want to points on that actually. I just want to give a quick update. So in October of give a quick update. So in October of give a quick update. So in October of last year, I tweeted that Anthropic is last year, I tweeted that Anthropic is last year, I tweeted that Anthropic is running a sophisticated regulatory running a sophisticated regulatory running a sophisticated regulatory capture strategy based on fear-mongering capture strategy based on fear-mongering capture strategy based on fear-mongering and everyone kind of went crazy over and everyone kind of went crazy over and everyone kind of went crazy over this. This was again like a very hot this. This was again like a very hot this. This was again like a very hot take or spicy take at the time. Back take or spicy take at the time. Back take or spicy take at the time. Back then people thought that I was beating then people thought that I was beating then people thought that I was beating up on a little startup. Now I think up on a little startup. Now I think up on a little startup. Now I think everyone can kind of see the truth which everyone can kind of see the truth which everyone can kind of see the truth which is look this is not a little startup. is look this is not a little startup. is look this is not a little startup. They already have a trillion dollar They already have a trillion dollar They already have a trillion dollar market cap valuation. Gavin Baker thinks market cap valuation. Gavin Baker thinks market cap valuation. Gavin Baker thinks it'll be at three trillion after they it'll be at three trillion after they it'll be at three trillion after they IPO. IPO. IPO. This is actually one of the biggest of This is actually one of the biggest of This is actually one of the biggest of the big tech companies and they are I the big tech companies and they are I the big tech companies and they are I think by pretty much every criteria think by pretty much every criteria think by pretty much every criteria including revenue the leading AI including revenue the leading AI including revenue the leading AI company. So I think people can see now company. So I think people can see now company. So I think people can see now that they have enormous resources and that they have enormous resources and that they have enormous resources and they're putting those resources behind they're putting those resources behind they're putting those resources behind an effort to like Jimoth you said pull an effort to like Jimoth you said pull an effort to like Jimoth you said pull up the ladder and it's classic regatory up the ladder and it's classic regatory up the ladder and it's classic regatory capture and there was an article in capture and there was an article in capture and there was an article in Politico just the other day. is called Politico just the other day. is called Politico just the other day. is called inside Anthropic state-by-state plan to inside Anthropic state-by-state plan to inside Anthropic state-by-state plan to ratchet up AI rules. And what it says is ratchet up AI rules. And what it says is ratchet up AI rules. And what it says is quote AI giant Anthropic is pursuing a quote AI giant Anthropic is pursuing a quote AI giant Anthropic is pursuing a strategy of oneupmanship that encourages strategy of oneupmanship that encourages strategy of oneupmanship that encourages states to impose increasingly tougher AI states to impose increasingly tougher AI states to impose increasingly tougher AI guard rails rather than a line around a guard rails rather than a line around a guard rails rather than a line around a single set of regulations. So the basic single set of regulations. So the basic single set of regulations. So the basic idea is that they get a set of idea is that they get a set of idea is that they get a set of regulations passed in one state like regulations passed in one state like regulations passed in one state like California's SB53 California's SB53 California's SB53 and that was then supposed to be the and that was then supposed to be the and that was then supposed to be the model at least for all the blue states. model at least for all the blue states. model at least for all the blue states. But then with each new state, they But then with each new state, they But then with each new state, they actually make the regulations more and actually make the regulations more and actually make the regulations more and more strict, more and more more strict, more and more more strict, more and more all-encompassing. So there's not all-encompassing. So there's not all-encompassing. So there's not actually a stable equilibrium. What actually a stable equilibrium. What actually a stable equilibrium. What they're trying to do is drive each they're trying to do is drive each they're trying to do is drive each incremental state to more and more incremental state to more and more incremental state to more and more regulations. And so this is actually an regulations. And so this is actually an regulations. And so this is actually an article explaining that they're doing article explaining that they're doing article explaining that they're doing the opposite of trying to create what we the opposite of trying to create what we the opposite of trying to create what we wanted, which was a single national wanted, which was a single national wanted, which was a single national framework. they actually want the framework. they actually want the framework. they actually want the patchwork because they're using again patchwork because they're using again patchwork because they're using again the pressure they're creating at the the pressure they're creating at the the pressure they're creating at the state level to impose more and more state level to impose more and more state level to impose more and more regulations. And again, what I said last regulations. And again, what I said last regulations. And again, what I said last year was that Anthropic was principally year was that Anthropic was principally year was that Anthropic was principally responsible for the state regulatory responsible for the state regulatory responsible for the state regulatory frenzy that is damaging the startup frenzy that is damaging the startup frenzy that is damaging the startup ecosystem. Again, everyone went crazy at ecosystem. Again, everyone went crazy at ecosystem. Again, everyone went crazy at the time. I think now there's plenty of the time. I think now there's plenty of the time. I think now there's plenty of evidence showing this is their agenda. evidence showing this is their agenda. evidence showing this is their agenda. And um And um And um >> and by the way, they're going to win >> and by the way, they're going to win >> and by the way, they're going to win that because states have great that because states have great that because states have great sovereignty rights and like we're seeing sovereignty rights and like we're seeing sovereignty rights and like we're seeing with self-driving the states are going with self-driving the states are going with self-driving the states are going to decide. It's not going to be a to decide. It's not going to be a to decide. It's not going to be a federal mandate. The states get to federal mandate. The states get to federal mandate. The states get to decide just the nature of the US. decide just the nature of the US. decide just the nature of the US. >> The reason why >> The reason why >> The reason why >> they're going to they're going to win on >> they're going to they're going to win on >> they're going to they're going to win on that in a couple of states, right, Zach? that in a couple of states, right, Zach? that in a couple of states, right, Zach? Just realistically, Just realistically, Just realistically, >> they've won in a bunch of states. They >> they've won in a bunch of states. They >> they've won in a bunch of states. They already won in California and Illinois already won in California and Illinois already won in California and Illinois and New York and I mean they're winning and New York and I mean they're winning and New York and I mean they're winning in all the blue states and maybe even in all the blue states and maybe even in all the blue states and maybe even some red states. But look ultimately the some red states. But look ultimately the some red states. But look ultimately the reason why anthropics arguments are reason why anthropics arguments are reason why anthropics arguments are finding purchase is because when you go finding purchase is because when you go finding purchase is because when you go to the government and say please to the government and say please to the government and say please regulate me you know you should have regulate me you know you should have regulate me you know you should have more power there there's hardly anyone more power there there's hardly anyone more power there there's hardly anyone in government who will ever say oh no no in government who will ever say oh no no in government who will ever say oh no no no we're not qualified like we don't no we're not qualified like we don't no we're not qualified like we don't want government [laughter] want government [laughter] want government [laughter] >> yeah there are very few people who are >> yeah there are very few people who are >> yeah there are very few people who are principled that way and most people in principled that way and most people in principled that way and most people in the government will say thank you very the government will say thank you very the government will say thank you very much what else can we take and this is much what else can we take and this is much what else can we take and this is the mistake that I think a lot of people the mistake that I think a lot of people the mistake that I think a lot of people in the tech industry are making is they in the tech industry are making is they in the tech industry are making is they think that they can just buy off think that they can just buy off think that they can just buy off politicians or the political system by politicians or the political system by politicians or the political system by making concessions. No, that will just making concessions. No, that will just making concessions. No, that will just lead to a ratcheting up of the pressure. lead to a ratcheting up of the pressure. lead to a ratcheting up of the pressure. The government will be happy to take The government will be happy to take The government will be happy to take this and then come back for more and this and then come back for more and this and then come back for more and more and more until it's fully under more and more until it's fully under more and more until it's fully under government control. So, at some point, I government control. So, at some point, I government control. So, at some point, I think these companies are going to have think these companies are going to have think these companies are going to have to grow a spine and fight and decide to grow a spine and fight and decide to grow a spine and fight and decide where they're willing to draw a line. where they're willing to draw a line. where they're willing to draw a line. And if Demis' SRO is the line, if And if Demis' SRO is the line, if And if Demis' SRO is the line, if they're saying, "Okay, we think this is they're saying, "Okay, we think this is they're saying, "Okay, we think this is the right solution and we're going to the right solution and we're going to the right solution and we're going to fight here and this has to be it and in fight here and this has to be it and in fight here and this has to be it and in exchange for this we need preeemption exchange for this we need preeemption exchange for this we need preeemption and we need, you know, other things and we need, you know, other things and we need, you know, other things written into law that make sure this is written into law that make sure this is written into law that make sure this is where the line is, then I think it can where the line is, then I think it can where the line is, then I think it can work. But I think if you're just kind of work. But I think if you're just kind of work. But I think if you're just kind of offering it up for free and all these offering it up for free and all these offering it up for free and all these companies are just going to say, "Oh companies are just going to say, "Oh companies are just going to say, "Oh yeah, regulates, give us the SRO." That yeah, regulates, give us the SRO." That yeah, regulates, give us the SRO." That will not be the end of it. That will will not be the end of it. That will will not be the end of it. That will just be the opening bid and the just be the opening bid and the just be the opening bid and the government will come back to take more government will come back to take more government will come back to take more and more and more. Yeah. All right, and more and more. Yeah. All right, and more and more. Yeah. All right, let's keep moving through the docket let's keep moving through the docket let's keep moving through the docket here. Stripe, which is still a private here. Stripe, which is still a private here. Stripe, which is still a private company, much to the chagrin of many of company, much to the chagrin of many of company, much to the chagrin of many of the shareholders, I think. Uh, now as the shareholders, I think. Uh, now as the shareholders, I think. Uh, now as they go into the second day [laughter] they go into the second day [laughter] they go into the second day [laughter] on this, yes, on this, yes, on this, yes, I mean, I'm in I'm in a couple of funds I mean, I'm in I'm in a couple of funds I mean, I'm in I'm in a couple of funds that have large positions like go that have large positions like go that have large positions like go public, boys. They are bidding bidding public, boys. They are bidding bidding public, boys. They are bidding bidding 53 billion for your alma mada, David 53 billion for your alma mada, David 53 billion for your alma mada, David Sachs, PayPal, which is a public Sachs, PayPal, which is a public Sachs, PayPal, which is a public company. Stripe and the private equity company. Stripe and the private equity company. Stripe and the private equity fund Advent fund Advent fund Advent are jointly offering to acquire PayPal are jointly offering to acquire PayPal are jointly offering to acquire PayPal for about 60 bucks a share, which is a for about 60 bucks a share, which is a for about 60 bucks a share, which is a small premium. Most people think it'll small premium. Most people think it'll small premium. Most people think it'll go for more like $70 a share. PayPal go for more like $70 a share. PayPal go for more like $70 a share. PayPal stock jumped on the news obviously. And stock jumped on the news obviously. And stock jumped on the news obviously. And >> were you able to get to the bottom of >> were you able to get to the bottom of >> were you able to get to the bottom of this that was it just Stripe and Advent? this that was it just Stripe and Advent? this that was it just Stripe and Advent? Because then somebody else reported that Because then somebody else reported that Because then somebody else reported that it was also Block. it was also Block. it was also Block. >> Yes, Block is coming in as well. >> Yes, Block is coming in as well. >> Yes, Block is coming in as well. >> It's so confusing. every other media >> It's so confusing. every other media >> It's so confusing. every other media source is like they're all over the source is like they're all over the source is like they're all over the place on this. place on this. place on this. >> Yeah. No, it's I think it's because it >> Yeah. No, it's I think it's because it >> Yeah. No, it's I think it's because it was a breaking story and maybe they were was a breaking story and maybe they were was a breaking story and maybe they were trying to keep it quiet. trying to keep it quiet. trying to keep it quiet. >> It's a huge deal though if if Block is a >> It's a huge deal though if if Block is a >> It's a huge deal though if if Block is a part of it versus if they're not. I part of it versus if they're not. I part of it versus if they're not. I think think think >> Yes. And Block, formerly known as >> Yes. And Block, formerly known as >> Yes. And Block, formerly known as Square, is Jack Dorsey's uh payment Square, is Jack Dorsey's uh payment Square, is Jack Dorsey's uh payment company, one of the few entrepreneurs to company, one of the few entrepreneurs to company, one of the few entrepreneurs to ever create uh two decacorns in our ever create uh two decacorns in our ever create uh two decacorns in our industry. And uh they're contributing 17 industry. And uh they're contributing 17 industry. And uh they're contributing 17 billion in equity in the combined offer. billion in equity in the combined offer. billion in equity in the combined offer. how they um chop up what's inside of how they um chop up what's inside of how they um chop up what's inside of PayPal would be the big question. PayPal would be the big question. PayPal would be the big question. Obviously, they own, Obviously, they own, Obviously, they own, you know, a number of different brands you know, a number of different brands you know, a number of different brands including Venmo in addition to PayPal. including Venmo in addition to PayPal. including Venmo in addition to PayPal. That might go really well with the I'm That might go really well with the I'm That might go really well with the I'm just taking a guess here with the block just taking a guess here with the block just taking a guess here with the block assets. Stripe owns Bridge. That's their assets. Stripe owns Bridge. That's their assets. Stripe owns Bridge. That's their stable coin infrastructure company they stable coin infrastructure company they stable coin infrastructure company they acquired for a billion dollars in 2025. acquired for a billion dollars in 2025. acquired for a billion dollars in 2025. PayPal has SIUSD which is already in PayPal has SIUSD which is already in PayPal has SIUSD which is already in circulation. That's their stable coin. circulation. That's their stable coin. circulation. That's their stable coin. So, stable coins are part of this. But So, stable coins are part of this. But So, stable coins are part of this. But the biggest thing is PayPal is still a the biggest thing is PayPal is still a the biggest thing is PayPal is still a juggernaut. Sachs 439 million consumer accounts. You did million consumer accounts. You did something right there 25 years ago. It something right there 25 years ago. It something right there 25 years ago. It still the test of time. still the test of time. still the test of time. >> It's kind of amazing. It really is. >> It's kind of amazing. It really is. >> It's kind of amazing. It really is. >> Isn't it amazing that it's still that >> Isn't it amazing that it's still that >> Isn't it amazing that it's still that strong? Yeah. It's weird when brands strong? Yeah. It's weird when brands strong? Yeah. It's weird when brands keep going for that long. keep going for that long. keep going for that long. >> But the problem is that the product is >> But the problem is that the product is >> But the problem is that the product is getting very long in the tooth. I think getting very long in the tooth. I think getting very long in the tooth. I think it's only growing 7% a year which is a it's only growing 7% a year which is a it's only growing 7% a year which is a lot on the base that you know it's it's lot on the base that you know it's it's lot on the base that you know it's it's grown to it's a big base but the product grown to it's a big base but the product grown to it's a big base but the product has become somewhat obsolete and in a has become somewhat obsolete and in a has become somewhat obsolete and in a way it's a legacy product. I'd be way it's a legacy product. I'd be way it's a legacy product. I'd be curious to hear from the Stripe guys how curious to hear from the Stripe guys how curious to hear from the Stripe guys how they would fix that cuz I think that's a they would fix that cuz I think that's a they would fix that cuz I think that's a very hard problem to fix. Maybe they very hard problem to fix. Maybe they very hard problem to fix. Maybe they wouldn't maybe they would just run it wouldn't maybe they would just run it wouldn't maybe they would just run it more efficiently and kind of milk it more efficiently and kind of milk it more efficiently and kind of milk it >> kind of do a private equity play. The >> kind of do a private equity play. The >> kind of do a private equity play. The different question different question different question >> the interesting question to ask is >> the interesting question to ask is >> the interesting question to ask is what is the only kind of baby that what is the only kind of baby that what is the only kind of baby that advent and stripe and block could have advent and stripe and block could have advent and stripe and block could have together and I think there's one which together and I think there's one which together and I think there's one which is you are creating a competitor to Visa is you are creating a competitor to Visa is you are creating a competitor to Visa and Mastercard and Mastercard and Mastercard >> because you now have upwards of 6 or 700 >> because you now have upwards of 6 or 700 >> because you now have upwards of 6 or 700 million accounts. You have massive million accounts. You have massive million accounts. You have massive stable coin infrastructure. stable coin infrastructure. stable coin infrastructure. You have all of the riskmanagement You have all of the riskmanagement You have all of the riskmanagement infrastructure that Stripe has built infrastructure that Stripe has built infrastructure that Stripe has built over the last 15 or 20 years. The big over the last 15 or 20 years. The big over the last 15 or 20 years. The big critique of Stripe's business model critique of Stripe's business model critique of Stripe's business model early on was they had to build so many early on was they had to build so many early on was they had to build so many value added services because everybody value added services because everybody value added services because everybody always thought the take that they could always thought the take that they could always thought the take that they could make as a middleman sitting on top of make as a middleman sitting on top of make as a middleman sitting on top of the traditional rails would effectively the traditional rails would effectively the traditional rails would effectively get competed away. Now to their credit, get competed away. Now to their credit, get competed away. Now to their credit, they've done such a good job that that they've done such a good job that that they've done such a good job that that hasn't happened. But I think what it hasn't happened. But I think what it hasn't happened. But I think what it means now is you can vertically means now is you can vertically means now is you can vertically integrate and go soup to nuts. That is integrate and go soup to nuts. That is integrate and go soup to nuts. That is probably the most obvious probably the most obvious probably the most obvious thing to make out of it. So that now thing to make out of it. So that now thing to make out of it. So that now Stripe gets access to an ultra- lowcost Stripe gets access to an ultra- lowcost Stripe gets access to an ultra- lowcost set of payment rails literally like to set of payment rails literally like to set of payment rails literally like to zero brings it everywhere all over the zero brings it everywhere all over the zero brings it everywhere all over the world. So does block advent can pour world. So does block advent can pour world. So does block advent can pour money into it. So it's quite powerful if money into it. So it's quite powerful if money into it. So it's quite powerful if it comes together. Rbert, what does this it comes together. Rbert, what does this it comes together. Rbert, what does this say about private market companies at say about private market companies at say about private market companies at scale and Stripe potentially never going scale and Stripe potentially never going scale and Stripe potentially never going public? I mean, how does a private public? I mean, how does a private public? I mean, how does a private equity firm get their return on this equity firm get their return on this equity firm get their return on this investment in 2, three, four years? Do investment in 2, three, four years? Do investment in 2, three, four years? Do they wind up selling more of it to they wind up selling more of it to they wind up selling more of it to Stripe? What are your thoughts here on Stripe? What are your thoughts here on Stripe? What are your thoughts here on the structure and capital market the structure and capital market the structure and capital market implications here? implications here? implications here? >> I think there's going to be more of >> I think there's going to be more of >> I think there's going to be more of these kinds of deals. If you look at these kinds of deals. If you look at these kinds of deals. If you look at Ryan Cohen's bid for eBay, I think it's Ryan Cohen's bid for eBay, I think it's Ryan Cohen's bid for eBay, I think it's probably a second dot on a line that I probably a second dot on a line that I probably a second dot on a line that I think is emerging, think is emerging, think is emerging, which is folks which is folks which is folks that are call it AI native are looking that are call it AI native are looking that are call it AI native are looking at call it first generation digital at call it first generation digital at call it first generation digital native businesses that have become native businesses that have become native businesses that have become mature and old and stale and aren't run mature and old and stale and aren't run mature and old and stale and aren't run by the founders anymore and have not yet by the founders anymore and have not yet by the founders anymore and have not yet realized the opportunities with AI, have realized the opportunities with AI, have realized the opportunities with AI, have not yet realized their potential. or not yet realized their potential. or not yet realized their potential. or overspending in a lot of ways. And when overspending in a lot of ways. And when overspending in a lot of ways. And when you take a look at those businesses as a you take a look at those businesses as a you take a look at those businesses as a modernday AI operator, you're like, modernday AI operator, you're like, modernday AI operator, you're like, "What the hell? This thing is so under "What the hell? This thing is so under "What the hell? This thing is so under uh utilized. They're not using their uh utilized. They're not using their uh utilized. They're not using their network well. They're not operating network well. They're not operating network well. They're not operating well. They're overspending. They're not well. They're overspending. They're not well. They're overspending. They're not using AI well." And there's a set of using AI well." And there's a set of using AI well." And there's a set of opportunities that become quite obvious. opportunities that become quite obvious. opportunities that become quite obvious. And I think the capital markets as we've And I think the capital markets as we've And I think the capital markets as we've seen with like Josh Kushner's roll up of seen with like Josh Kushner's roll up of seen with like Josh Kushner's roll up of accounting firms and General Catalyst accounting firms and General Catalyst accounting firms and General Catalyst has a project like this where you can has a project like this where you can has a project like this where you can kind of use capital to go buy you know kind of use capital to go buy you know kind of use capital to go buy you know in those cases traditional services in those cases traditional services in those cases traditional services businesses and AIify them. I think this businesses and AIify them. I think this businesses and AIify them. I think this is part of a line of maybe looking at is part of a line of maybe looking at is part of a line of maybe looking at traditional digital businesses and traditional digital businesses and traditional digital businesses and AIifying them. And there's a long list AIifying them. And there's a long list AIifying them. And there's a long list of these. There's a couple dozen of of these. There's a couple dozen of of these. There's a couple dozen of them. So I think if you looked at the them. So I think if you looked at the them. So I think if you looked at the public markets and you said, "Hey, where public markets and you said, "Hey, where public markets and you said, "Hey, where are all these kind of software are all these kind of software are all these kind of software companies, network businesses that companies, network businesses that companies, network businesses that emerged in the early part of the emerged in the early part of the emerged in the early part of the internet or even in the more recent part internet or even in the more recent part internet or even in the more recent part of the internet, aren't run by their of the internet, aren't run by their of the internet, aren't run by their founders anymore, have stalled out, founders anymore, have stalled out, founders anymore, have stalled out, there's a massive opportunity. Now the there's a massive opportunity. Now the there's a massive opportunity. Now the question as a capital provider is who do question as a capital provider is who do question as a capital provider is who do you partner with to go and execute that you partner with to go and execute that you partner with to go and execute that operational revival of that business?" operational revival of that business?" operational revival of that business?" You're not going to go hire some You're not going to go hire some You're not going to go hire some Mckenzie consultant to do that work for Mckenzie consultant to do that work for Mckenzie consultant to do that work for you. It's got to be the best of the you. It's got to be the best of the you. It's got to be the best of the best. It's got to be the right players best. It's got to be the right players best. It's got to be the right players in the business. So, I think Ryan Cohen in the business. So, I think Ryan Cohen in the business. So, I think Ryan Cohen has proved his metal obviously with some has proved his metal obviously with some has proved his metal obviously with some of the things that he's done with Chewy of the things that he's done with Chewy of the things that he's done with Chewy and GameStop and that's obviously and GameStop and that's obviously and GameStop and that's obviously debatable. I spent some time debatable. I spent some time debatable. I spent some time interviewing him to understand his interviewing him to understand his interviewing him to understand his >> This was on the Allin interview program. >> This was on the Allin interview program. >> This was on the Allin interview program. You can go to our channel and find it You can go to our channel and find it You can go to our channel and find it there. It's last month. there. It's last month. there. It's last month. >> Thanks for the plug. And obviously, when >> Thanks for the plug. And obviously, when >> Thanks for the plug. And obviously, when it comes to payments, who better than it comes to payments, who better than it comes to payments, who better than Stripe and maybe Jack Dorsey plays a Stripe and maybe Jack Dorsey plays a Stripe and maybe Jack Dorsey plays a role here. And and by the way, I think role here. And and by the way, I think role here. And and by the way, I think because capital I mean, if you think because capital I mean, if you think because capital I mean, if you think about that $17 billion equity about that $17 billion equity about that $17 billion equity contribution, what that technically contribution, what that technically contribution, what that technically means is Stripe is selling and Block is means is Stripe is selling and Block is means is Stripe is selling and Block is selling $17 billion of equity to the selling $17 billion of equity to the selling $17 billion of equity to the cash investors. That cash is then going cash investors. That cash is then going cash investors. That cash is then going to buy a PayPal. Therefore, Stripe and to buy a PayPal. Therefore, Stripe and to buy a PayPal. Therefore, Stripe and Block end up owning a piece of PayPal. Block end up owning a piece of PayPal. Block end up owning a piece of PayPal. The private equity investors own a piece The private equity investors own a piece The private equity investors own a piece of Block and Stripe. And what is not of Block and Stripe. And what is not of Block and Stripe. And what is not clear in the deal docs that were clear in the deal docs that were clear in the deal docs that were published cuz I don't think it's published cuz I don't think it's published cuz I don't think it's relevant to the public markets is who's relevant to the public markets is who's relevant to the public markets is who's actually going to operate PayPal post actually going to operate PayPal post actually going to operate PayPal post close. And my bet would be that they're close. And my bet would be that they're close. And my bet would be that they're going to hand it over to the Stripe guys going to hand it over to the Stripe guys going to hand it over to the Stripe guys and say you guys and say you guys and say you guys >> I think that's clear. Yeah. Because >> I think that's clear. Yeah. Because >> I think that's clear. Yeah. Because they're the most qualified and they will they're the most qualified and they will they're the most qualified and they will have the biggest stake in it. Uh you're have the biggest stake in it. Uh you're have the biggest stake in it. Uh you're >> so I think I so I I will make a >> so I think I so I I will make a >> so I think I so I I will make a prediction. I think that eBay and PayPal prediction. I think that eBay and PayPal prediction. I think that eBay and PayPal are probably the beginning of a wave of are probably the beginning of a wave of are probably the beginning of a wave of mega deals of call it flaccid, you know, mega deals of call it flaccid, you know, mega deals of call it flaccid, you know, digital businesses digital businesses digital businesses that can be revived, okay, that can be revived, okay, that can be revived, okay, >> with the blue chew of capital and the >> with the blue chew of capital and the >> with the blue chew of capital and the right operator and I think that there's right operator and I think that there's right operator and I think that there's probably a big probably a big probably a big >> a big wave of this to come. >> a big wave of this to come. >> a big wave of this to come. >> The other thing is this is probably not >> The other thing is this is probably not >> The other thing is this is probably not the final clearing price. I think the the final clearing price. I think the the final clearing price. I think the price is probably another 10 to 15% price is probably another 10 to 15% price is probably another 10 to 15% higher from here. And and I will say higher from here. And and I will say higher from here. And and I will say that there is a certain individual that that there is a certain individual that that there is a certain individual that must look very closely at putting in a must look very closely at putting in a must look very closely at putting in a competitive bid. Oh, a certain competitive bid. Oh, a certain competitive bid. Oh, a certain individual who may may have his individual who may may have his individual who may may have his fingerprints on the original PayPal who fingerprints on the original PayPal who fingerprints on the original PayPal who might also have $4 or5 trillion in might also have $4 or5 trillion in might also have $4 or5 trillion in market cap to play with who also made a market cap to play with who also made a market cap to play with who also made a $60 billion acquisition recently. We $60 billion acquisition recently. We $60 billion acquisition recently. We don't have inside information here. don't have inside information here. don't have inside information here. >> To your point, Freeberg, >> To your point, Freeberg, >> To your point, Freeberg, >> correct? >> correct? >> correct? >> This is becoming a playbook. There's a >> This is becoming a playbook. There's a >> This is becoming a playbook. There's a company called Bending Spoons that just company called Bending Spoons that just company called Bending Spoons that just went public. They bought a bunch of went public. They bought a bunch of went public. They bought a bunch of non-founderled assets. AOL for 1.4 non-founderled assets. AOL for 1.4 non-founderled assets. AOL for 1.4 billion, Vimeo for 1.4 billion, We billion, Vimeo for 1.4 billion, We billion, Vimeo for 1.4 billion, We Transfer, Eventbrite, Bright Code with Transfer, Eventbrite, Bright Code with Transfer, Eventbrite, Bright Code with him. him. him. >> I was just DMing with him. >> I was just DMing with him. >> I was just DMing with him. >> He's He's awesome. I've hung out with >> He's He's awesome. I've hung out with >> He's He's awesome. I've hung out with this guy. This guy is an absolute this guy. This guy is an absolute this guy. This guy is an absolute freaking operational killer. He he freaking operational killer. He he freaking operational killer. He he bought Evernote. bought Evernote. bought Evernote. >> Yeah. In Milan. >> Yeah. In Milan. >> Yeah. In Milan. >> And yeah, he runs the whole thing from >> And yeah, he runs the whole thing from >> And yeah, he runs the whole thing from Milan. Milan. Milan. >> He bought Evernote and he just goes in >> He bought Evernote and he just goes in >> He bought Evernote and he just goes in and he diagnoses these businesses. He's and he diagnoses these businesses. He's and he diagnoses these businesses. He's like, "How are they being over where are like, "How are they being over where are like, "How are they being over where are you overspending? Where are you you overspending? Where are you you overspending? Where are you underpending? what are you doing wrong underpending? what are you doing wrong underpending? what are you doing wrong with the product and what are you doing with the product and what are you doing with the product and what are you doing wrong with marketing and he just faking wrong with marketing and he just faking wrong with marketing and he just faking fixes it and he's just a killer and he's fixes it and he's just a killer and he's fixes it and he's just a killer and he's taken all of these what were called web taken all of these what were called web taken all of these what were called web 2.0 I know businesses and he's 2.0 I know businesses and he's 2.0 I know businesses and he's revitalized them, rolled them up and revitalized them, rolled them up and revitalized them, rolled them up and printing cash out of them and leverage printing cash out of them and leverage printing cash out of them and leverage the cost to run them lower. the cost to run them lower. the cost to run them lower. >> He's using young AI first executives >> He's using young AI first executives >> He's using young AI first executives from what I'm talking from what I'm talking from what I'm talking >> totally. It's a great call out JL like >> totally. It's a great call out JL like >> totally. It's a great call out JL like bending spoons is the roll up of this bending spoons is the roll up of this bending spoons is the roll up of this sort of strategy but for these mega sort of strategy but for these mega sort of strategy but for these mega deals I think there's more of them to deals I think there's more of them to deals I think there's more of them to come. I will say uh you know the the come. I will say uh you know the the come. I will say uh you know the the high order bit here uh which we talked high order bit here uh which we talked high order bit here uh which we talked about for a couple years was venture about for a couple years was venture about for a couple years was venture capital was on the ropes for a couple of capital was on the ropes for a couple of capital was on the ropes for a couple of years under the wrath of Lena Khan and years under the wrath of Lena Khan and years under the wrath of Lena Khan and then once Trump got elected all the then once Trump got elected all the then once Trump got elected all the executives working in corporate executives working in corporate executives working in corporate development said hey looks like M&A's development said hey looks like M&A's development said hey looks like M&A's back on the menu and now we're seeing back on the menu and now we're seeing back on the menu and now we're seeing deal after deal after deal get deal after deal after deal get deal after deal after deal get consummated people are no longer scared consummated people are no longer scared consummated people are no longer scared of doing deals Uber just bought delivery of doing deals Uber just bought delivery of doing deals Uber just bought delivery hero today uh That's going to like jump hero today uh That's going to like jump hero today uh That's going to like jump their revenue by 20. Yeah. And that's their revenue by 20. Yeah. And that's their revenue by 20. Yeah. And that's going to jump their revenue by like going to jump their revenue by like going to jump their revenue by like they're getting diluted 10%. It's going they're getting diluted 10%. It's going they're getting diluted 10%. It's going to jump their revenue 24% or something to jump their revenue 24% or something to jump their revenue 24% or something crazy like that. crazy like that. crazy like that. >> And this is going to be I think the big >> And this is going to be I think the big >> And this is going to be I think the big story the next couple of years and all story the next couple of years and all story the next couple of years and all this liquidity. Talking to LPs and this liquidity. Talking to LPs and this liquidity. Talking to LPs and family offices, which I do on a regular family offices, which I do on a regular family offices, which I do on a regular basis, they're all like, "Hey, when's basis, they're all like, "Hey, when's basis, they're all like, "Hey, when's your next fund? Hey, when's the next your next fund? Hey, when's the next your next fund? Hey, when's the next deal?" Because now people are believing deal?" Because now people are believing deal?" Because now people are believing in venture because of the SpaceX in venture because of the SpaceX in venture because of the SpaceX distributions and all this M&A. And we distributions and all this M&A. And we distributions and all this M&A. And we have four or five companies that got have four or five companies that got have four or five companies that got bought since Donald Trump was elected bought since Donald Trump was elected bought since Donald Trump was elected president. Thank you my President Donald president. Thank you my President Donald president. Thank you my President Donald J. Trump for putting M&A back on the J. Trump for putting M&A back on the J. Trump for putting M&A back on the menu. Sachs M&A back on the menu. Why menu. Sachs M&A back on the menu. Why menu. Sachs M&A back on the menu. Why didn't you make a bid saxs for PayPal? didn't you make a bid saxs for PayPal? didn't you make a bid saxs for PayPal? >> Been there, done that. >> Been there, done that. >> Been there, done that. >> Been there, done it. Okay. >> Been there, done it. Okay. >> Been there, done it. Okay. >> No, but look, you have to have >> No, but look, you have to have >> No, but look, you have to have synergies. synergies. synergies. >> There was a moment, this was like 15 >> There was a moment, this was like 15 >> There was a moment, this was like 15 years ago where they asked Sachs to go years ago where they asked Sachs to go years ago where they asked Sachs to go back and be the CEO. back and be the CEO. back and be the CEO. >> That was right. I remember that at the >> That was right. I remember that at the >> That was right. I remember that at the poker game. Yeah. He and I immediately poker game. Yeah. He and I immediately poker game. Yeah. He and I immediately flew to Vegas and spent the weekend flew to Vegas and spent the weekend flew to Vegas and spent the weekend there to think about it. [laughter] there to think about it. [laughter] there to think about it. [laughter] >> Like, you know what? >> Like, you know what? >> Like, you know what? >> I wasn't No, they didn't ask me to uh >> I wasn't No, they didn't ask me to uh >> I wasn't No, they didn't ask me to uh but I was but I was but I was >> Well, no, I I never got the offer, but >> Well, no, I I never got the offer, but >> Well, no, I I never got the offer, but it was down to like final two or it was down to like final two or it was down to like final two or something and it was between me and something and it was between me and something and it was between me and someone else. And actually, they ended someone else. And actually, they ended someone else. And actually, they ended up going with some, you know, like up going with some, you know, like up going with some, you know, like traditional like credit card executive. traditional like credit card executive. traditional like credit card executive. And to be honest, that's why PayPal has And to be honest, that's why PayPal has And to be honest, that's why PayPal has stagnated is that as soon as it was stagnated is that as soon as it was stagnated is that as soon as it was acquired back in 2002, they basically acquired back in 2002, they basically acquired back in 2002, they basically blew out like all the founders, all the blew out like all the founders, all the blew out like all the founders, all the founding DNA and it was just kind of run founding DNA and it was just kind of run founding DNA and it was just kind of run by, you know, consulting types. You got by, you know, consulting types. You got by, you know, consulting types. You got to remember at that time it was acquired to remember at that time it was acquired to remember at that time it was acquired by eBay and Meg Whitman had worked at by eBay and Meg Whitman had worked at by eBay and Meg Whitman had worked at Proctor and Gamble and Disney and she Proctor and Gamble and Disney and she Proctor and Gamble and Disney and she spent like eight years at Bane and it spent like eight years at Bane and it spent like eight years at Bane and it was like a very corporate mindset. I was like a very corporate mindset. I was like a very corporate mindset. I mean among all the internet companies of mean among all the internet companies of mean among all the internet companies of that era it was definitely the most that era it was definitely the most that era it was definitely the most corporatist and they saw the founders corporatist and they saw the founders corporatist and they saw the founders the founding generation at PayPal is the founding generation at PayPal is the founding generation at PayPal is just a problem just a bunch of like just a problem just a bunch of like just a problem just a bunch of like cowboys they couldn't control they made cowboys they couldn't control they made cowboys they couldn't control they made no effort to retain them and I think no effort to retain them and I think no effort to retain them and I think they were kind of relieved when they all they were kind of relieved when they all they were kind of relieved when they all left and then that's what created the left and then that's what created the left and then that's what created the PayPal mafia was that you know normally PayPal mafia was that you know normally PayPal mafia was that you know normally in an acquisition you'd lock up all the in an acquisition you'd lock up all the in an acquisition you'd lock up all the talent but in this case talent but in this case talent but in this case >> they locked them out they're like these >> they locked them out they're like these >> they locked them out they're like these guys hard to manage change the keys guys hard to manage change the keys guys hard to manage change the keys >> I've said for a long time it's a >> I've said for a long time it's a >> I've said for a long time it's a misnomer to call it the PayPal mafia. misnomer to call it the PayPal mafia. misnomer to call it the PayPal mafia. It's really the PayPal diaspora. It's really the PayPal diaspora. It's really the PayPal diaspora. >> Totally. >> Totally. >> Totally. >> Our homeland was taken over and they >> Our homeland was taken over and they >> Our homeland was taken over and they burned our temple and then kicked burned our temple and then kicked burned our temple and then kicked everybody out. everybody out. everybody out. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And that's why the whole PayPal mafia >> And that's why the whole PayPal mafia >> And that's why the whole PayPal mafia got started with all those companies. got started with all those companies. got started with all those companies. >> But as a result of that, >> But as a result of that, >> But as a result of that, >> for for decades, I don't say anyone's a >> for for decades, I don't say anyone's a >> for for decades, I don't say anyone's a victim. That's victim. That's victim. That's >> Look, when you when you acquire a >> Look, when you when you acquire a >> Look, when you when you acquire a company, you get to decide what to do company, you get to decide what to do company, you get to decide what to do with that asset. with that asset. with that asset. >> Totally. >> Totally. >> Totally. >> So, I mean, that was just the reality. >> So, I mean, that was just the reality. >> So, I mean, that was just the reality. But it's not like, you know, I don't But it's not like, you know, I don't But it's not like, you know, I don't think anyone was bitter about it. think anyone was bitter about it. think anyone was bitter about it. They're all like, "Okay, this give us They're all like, "Okay, this give us They're all like, "Okay, this give us the capital to go. I'll do the next the capital to go. I'll do the next the capital to go. I'll do the next thing we want to do." thing we want to do." thing we want to do." >> Well, the new CEO, by the way, Enrique, >> Well, the new CEO, by the way, Enrique, >> Well, the new CEO, by the way, Enrique, is really aces. Uh, I've met him before is really aces. Uh, I've met him before is really aces. Uh, I've met him before and they're doing a great job. Um, and they're doing a great job. Um, and they're doing a great job. Um, apparently, which is why they probably apparently, which is why they probably apparently, which is why they probably got these offers because they've been got these offers because they've been got these offers because they've been tightening that business up for the last tightening that business up for the last tightening that business up for the last couple years. couple years. couple years. >> Well, no, the reason they got these >> Well, no, the reason they got these >> Well, no, the reason they got these offers is the market cap is down to, you offers is the market cap is down to, you offers is the market cap is down to, you know, was down in the what, like 30 know, was down in the what, like 30 know, was down in the what, like 30 something billion. I mean, this is a something billion. I mean, this is a something billion. I mean, this is a company that was worth 200 billion, company that was worth 200 billion, company that was worth 200 billion, wasn't it? Roughly wasn't it? Roughly wasn't it? Roughly >> 322, I think, was the peak. >> 322, I think, was the peak. >> 322, I think, was the peak. >> Mhm. And before this offer, it was down >> Mhm. And before this offer, it was down >> Mhm. And before this offer, it was down to what 30 to 40 billion. Yeah. to what 30 to 40 billion. Yeah. to what 30 to 40 billion. Yeah. >> So the reason why it's attracting offers >> So the reason why it's attracting offers >> So the reason why it's attracting offers is it's so beaten up. And so now the is it's so beaten up. And so now the is it's so beaten up. And so now the question is, can anyone else do question is, can anyone else do question is, can anyone else do something with it? something with it? something with it? >> To your comment about you've got to have >> To your comment about you've got to have >> To your comment about you've got to have synergies. Doesn't it seem to be the synergies. Doesn't it seem to be the synergies. Doesn't it seem to be the case that in this era the the core case that in this era the the core case that in this era the the core synergy that any great operator can synergy that any great operator can synergy that any great operator can bring to the table in this sort of a bring to the table in this sort of a bring to the table in this sort of a scenario is AI? Like you can leverage scenario is AI? Like you can leverage scenario is AI? Like you can leverage whether it be in this business or others whether it be in this business or others whether it be in this business or others you can leverage tools that drive you can leverage tools that drive you can leverage tools that drive automation that drive product automation that drive product automation that drive product development that drive improvements and development that drive improvements and development that drive improvements and efficiencies across the organization efficiencies across the organization efficiencies across the organization that make the product actually better that make the product actually better that make the product actually better for the user etc etc that simply for the user etc etc that simply for the user etc etc that simply >> potentially obviously being well >> potentially obviously being well >> potentially obviously being well implemented. Well, look, I think you implemented. Well, look, I think you implemented. Well, look, I think you have to have a product vision of how you have to have a product vision of how you have to have a product vision of how you would use AI to make the whole user would use AI to make the whole user would use AI to make the whole user experience better. And yes, you're right experience better. And yes, you're right experience better. And yes, you're right that you could just use AI to drive that you could just use AI to drive that you could just use AI to drive efficiencies and that'll improve your efficiencies and that'll improve your efficiencies and that'll improve your profitability and earnings. And so on a profitability and earnings. And so on a profitability and earnings. And so on a financial level, you could make the financial level, you could make the financial level, you could make the acquisition work. But it seems to me acquisition work. But it seems to me acquisition work. But it seems to me that the existential issue for PayPal is that the existential issue for PayPal is that the existential issue for PayPal is that you're dealing with a product that you're dealing with a product that you're dealing with a product that's 25 years old. I mean, it's the that's 25 years old. I mean, it's the that's 25 years old. I mean, it's the same thing that we created back, you same thing that we created back, you same thing that we created back, you know, like 27 years ago. I mean, it's know, like 27 years ago. I mean, it's know, like 27 years ago. I mean, it's changed a little bit, but not that much. changed a little bit, but not that much. changed a little bit, but not that much. And the problem is that that that And the problem is that that that And the problem is that that that interaction model is legacy. And so, interaction model is legacy. And so, interaction model is legacy. And so, unless you've got a a vision of how to unless you've got a a vision of how to unless you've got a a vision of how to resuscitate it and rejuvenate that that resuscitate it and rejuvenate that that resuscitate it and rejuvenate that that product, I think, yeah, it could be a product, I think, yeah, it could be a product, I think, yeah, it could be a good financial play. Maybe good financial play. Maybe good financial play. Maybe >> I think they're buying the accounts. >> I think they're buying the accounts. >> I think they're buying the accounts. >> Yeah. I mean, what you're saying, >> Yeah. I mean, what you're saying, >> Yeah. I mean, what you're saying, Jamoth, is Yeah. what you're saying is Jamoth, is Yeah. what you're saying is Jamoth, is Yeah. what you're saying is interesting because with Stripe, I mean, interesting because with Stripe, I mean, interesting because with Stripe, I mean, this is the advantage that Stripe has is this is the advantage that Stripe has is this is the advantage that Stripe has is that they have a ton of merchants, that they have a ton of merchants, that they have a ton of merchants, right? So, they've they've become the right? So, they've they've become the right? So, they've they've become the preferred mechanism for merchants to preferred mechanism for merchants to preferred mechanism for merchants to basically accept payments via APIs. And basically accept payments via APIs. And basically accept payments via APIs. And I think they're doing about two trillion I think they're doing about two trillion I think they're doing about two trillion a year of annual transaction volume. I a year of annual transaction volume. I a year of annual transaction volume. I think PayPal is doing 1.7. So, actually, think PayPal is doing 1.7. So, actually, think PayPal is doing 1.7. So, actually, Stripe is a little bigger than PayPal Stripe is a little bigger than PayPal Stripe is a little bigger than PayPal now. But the thing that PayPal has that now. But the thing that PayPal has that now. But the thing that PayPal has that Stripe doesn't really have is the Stripe doesn't really have is the Stripe doesn't really have is the consumer relationship. So, you know, consumer relationship. So, you know, consumer relationship. So, you know, over 400 million active consumer over 400 million active consumer over 400 million active consumer accounts. So, you're right, Jimoth, that accounts. So, you're right, Jimoth, that accounts. So, you're right, Jimoth, that if if somehow you could combine the if if somehow you could combine the if if somehow you could combine the merchant relationships with all those merchant relationships with all those merchant relationships with all those consumer accounts and then bypass the consumer accounts and then bypass the consumer accounts and then bypass the credit card networks cuz there'd be a credit card networks cuz there'd be a credit card networks cuz there'd be a lot in theory there could be a lot more lot in theory there could be a lot more lot in theory there could be a lot more on us transactions. on us transactions. on us transactions. >> Exactly. And >> Exactly. And >> Exactly. And >> that's where the value is. >> that's where the value is. >> that's where the value is. >> PayPal already owns Brainree. So, now >> PayPal already owns Brainree. So, now >> PayPal already owns Brainree. So, now you have Stripe and Brainree that you have Stripe and Brainree that you have Stripe and Brainree that effectively were competitors that won't effectively were competitors that won't effectively were competitors that won't be. And then what block gives you is an be. And then what block gives you is an be. And then what block gives you is an entire point of sale infrastructure and entire point of sale infrastructure and entire point of sale infrastructure and you get the cash app. So you put it all you get the cash app. So you put it all you get the cash app. So you put it all together and I think it's a it's a shot together and I think it's a it's a shot together and I think it's a it's a shot across the bow for Visa and Mastercard. across the bow for Visa and Mastercard. across the bow for Visa and Mastercard. >> Brainree is the other one that I think >> Brainree is the other one that I think >> Brainree is the other one that I think you just mentioned there Chimath that's you just mentioned there Chimath that's you just mentioned there Chimath that's important because that is a very strong important because that is a very strong important because that is a very strong business that you don't even know that business that you don't even know that business that you don't even know that PayPal owns. Venmo is also that speaks PayPal owns. Venmo is also that speaks PayPal owns. Venmo is also that speaks to a lot of young people. So you're kind to a lot of young people. So you're kind to a lot of young people. So you're kind of getting two generations. You're of getting two generations. You're of getting two generations. You're getting Gen X and millennials. Uh a lot getting Gen X and millennials. Uh a lot getting Gen X and millennials. Uh a lot of bang for your buck there. Yeah, of bang for your buck there. Yeah, of bang for your buck there. Yeah, >> what Zach said is true. They have enough >> what Zach said is true. They have enough >> what Zach said is true. They have enough of the things to go end to end on their of the things to go end to end on their of the things to go end to end on their own rails. own rails. own rails. >> That is a very >> That is a very >> That is a very >> Yeah, the question is whether you can >> Yeah, the question is whether you can >> Yeah, the question is whether you can package it all together in a way that package it all together in a way that package it all together in a way that the consumer will actually choose the consumer will actually choose the consumer will actually choose because it's one thing to say, well, we because it's one thing to say, well, we because it's one thing to say, well, we take the merchant relationships of take the merchant relationships of take the merchant relationships of Stripe and the consumer relationships of Stripe and the consumer relationships of Stripe and the consumer relationships of PayPal, we don't do that. But what if PayPal, we don't do that. But what if PayPal, we don't do that. But what if the consumer doesn't want that? the consumer doesn't want that? the consumer doesn't want that? >> No, you don't do that. I think what you >> No, you don't do that. I think what you >> No, you don't do that. I think what you do is you go to places like all of the do is you go to places like all of the do is you go to places like all of the merchants that use Stripe and say, merchants that use Stripe and say, merchants that use Stripe and say, "We'll give you a 3 or four or 5% "We'll give you a 3 or four or 5% "We'll give you a 3 or four or 5% discount and they'll be like, "Okay." discount and they'll be like, "Okay." discount and they'll be like, "Okay." And so you'll see these prices that And so you'll see these prices that And so you'll see these prices that just, you know, fall everywhere. Like just, you know, fall everywhere. Like just, you know, fall everywhere. Like imagine if Shopify was like to all their imagine if Shopify was like to all their imagine if Shopify was like to all their merchants, okay, you have two choices, merchants, okay, you have two choices, merchants, okay, you have two choices, the old way or the new way. The new way, the old way or the new way. The new way, the old way or the new way. The new way, you put another two or three or 4% in you put another two or three or 4% in you put another two or three or 4% in your pocket. Of course, they're going to your pocket. Of course, they're going to your pocket. Of course, they're going to pick the new way. pick the new way. pick the new way. >> Well, and this is the paradox of like >> Well, and this is the paradox of like >> Well, and this is the paradox of like modern M&A. You know, if you look at modern M&A. You know, if you look at modern M&A. You know, if you look at protecting the consumer, this will protecting the consumer, this will protecting the consumer, this will ultimately be great for the consumers. ultimately be great for the consumers. ultimately be great for the consumers. This is going to lower the prices on it. This is going to lower the prices on it. This is going to lower the prices on it. They're not buying this to They're not buying this to They're not buying this to >> Okay, you're saying something really >> Okay, you're saying something really >> Okay, you're saying something really interesting. It is so good for consumers interesting. It is so good for consumers interesting. It is so good for consumers if this were to happen. This is the if this were to happen. This is the if this were to happen. This is the exact reason why if this had happened exact reason why if this had happened exact reason why if this had happened two years ago, two years ago, two years ago, >> yeah, >> yeah, >> yeah, >> this would have been the antitrust >> this would have been the antitrust >> this would have been the antitrust equivalent of a coloctyl exam. I mean, equivalent of a coloctyl exam. I mean, equivalent of a coloctyl exam. I mean, >> oh god, >> oh god, >> oh god, >> you would not even get one step close to >> you would not even get one step close to >> you would not even get one step close to doing this deal two years ago. doing this deal two years ago. doing this deal two years ago. >> Well, that's that's really interesting >> Well, that's that's really interesting >> Well, that's that's really interesting actually. I mean, the key question with actually. I mean, the key question with actually. I mean, the key question with antitrust is how do you define the antitrust is how do you define the antitrust is how do you define the market? And so, if you define the market market? And so, if you define the market market? And so, if you define the market as, you know, APIs for merchants, then as, you know, APIs for merchants, then as, you know, APIs for merchants, then JCAL, it would be Stripe versus JCAL, it would be Stripe versus JCAL, it would be Stripe versus Brainree. And then the government would Brainree. And then the government would Brainree. And then the government would say, well, that's you can't consolidate say, well, that's you can't consolidate say, well, that's you can't consolidate share. share. share. >> However, if the real market is Visa and >> However, if the real market is Visa and >> However, if the real market is Visa and Mastercard, that's the ultimate duopoly. Mastercard, that's the ultimate duopoly. Mastercard, that's the ultimate duopoly. And if PayPal can add competition to And if PayPal can add competition to And if PayPal can add competition to that market, which is infinitely larger that market, which is infinitely larger that market, which is infinitely larger than APIs. Exactly. Then than APIs. Exactly. Then than APIs. Exactly. Then >> it's actually pro competitive. So how >> it's actually pro competitive. So how >> it's actually pro competitive. So how you define the market determines whether you define the market determines whether you define the market determines whether it's anti-competitive or prompetitive. it's anti-competitive or prompetitive. it's anti-competitive or prompetitive. >> And those guys are smart enough and >> And those guys are smart enough and >> And those guys are smart enough and they've read enough books where they they've read enough books where they they've read enough books where they won't this one up. won't this one up. won't this one up. >> All right, let's get to the next topic. >> All right, let's get to the next topic. >> All right, let's get to the next topic. >> Somebody else is suing Open AI. This >> Somebody else is suing Open AI. This >> Somebody else is suing Open AI. This time it's Apple. On July 10th, Apple time it's Apple. On July 10th, Apple time it's Apple. On July 10th, Apple filed a 41page lawsuit against OpenAI filed a 41page lawsuit against OpenAI filed a 41page lawsuit against OpenAI over alleged alleged stolen trade over alleged alleged stolen trade over alleged alleged stolen trade secrets. Apple says Open AI stole their secrets. Apple says Open AI stole their secrets. Apple says Open AI stole their IP to develop their consumer hardware IP to develop their consumer hardware IP to develop their consumer hardware device. Remember, we had um device. Remember, we had um device. Remember, we had um Sarah Frier at Liquidity and I uh probed Sarah Frier at Liquidity and I uh probed Sarah Frier at Liquidity and I uh probed her on this new device and she said it her on this new device and she said it her on this new device and she said it was very human and lovable. She gave us was very human and lovable. She gave us was very human and lovable. She gave us a little bit of the goods. Well, it a little bit of the goods. Well, it a little bit of the goods. Well, it turns out Apple is alleging that maybe turns out Apple is alleging that maybe turns out Apple is alleging that maybe this is partially their IP. Tang Tan, this is partially their IP. Tang Tan, this is partially their IP. Tang Tan, Apple's former VP of iPhone design, is Apple's former VP of iPhone design, is Apple's former VP of iPhone design, is OpenAI's chief hardware officer. He OpenAI's chief hardware officer. He OpenAI's chief hardware officer. He allegedly directed Apple job candidates allegedly directed Apple job candidates allegedly directed Apple job candidates interviewing at OpenAI to bring quote interviewing at OpenAI to bring quote interviewing at OpenAI to bring quote actual parts to interviews to quote show actual parts to interviews to quote show actual parts to interviews to quote show and tell [laughter] in the interviews. and tell [laughter] in the interviews. and tell [laughter] in the interviews. Changu, former Apple senior technical Changu, former Apple senior technical Changu, former Apple senior technical engineer, sent this text message to a engineer, sent this text message to a engineer, sent this text message to a still employed Apple colleague. Quote, still employed Apple colleague. Quote, still employed Apple colleague. Quote, "lol, I found out I can access the "lol, I found out I can access the "lol, I found out I can access the network storage. So funny." During all network storage. So funny." During all network storage. So funny." During all of this, OpenAI has poached over 400 of this, OpenAI has poached over 400 of this, OpenAI has poached over 400 Apple employees over the last year or Apple employees over the last year or Apple employees over the last year or two. Big numbers of poaching. Apple and two. Big numbers of poaching. Apple and two. Big numbers of poaching. Apple and Tim Cook have seen enough chimoth. Tim Tim Cook have seen enough chimoth. Tim Tim Cook have seen enough chimoth. Tim Cook green lit this. As insane as this Cook green lit this. As insane as this Cook green lit this. As insane as this is, Sam Waltman has found a way found a is, Sam Waltman has found a way found a is, Sam Waltman has found a way found a way to screw yet another party. Screwed way to screw yet another party. Screwed way to screw yet another party. Screwed Elon, his first benefactor. Elon, his first benefactor. Elon, his first benefactor. Chimati, if you remember correctly, the Chimati, if you remember correctly, the Chimati, if you remember correctly, the default for iPhone AI was supposed to be default for iPhone AI was supposed to be default for iPhone AI was supposed to be chat GPT. So they took this chat GPT. So they took this chat GPT. So they took this relationship, Sam took this relationship relationship, Sam took this relationship relationship, Sam took this relationship where he got to be the default on the where he got to be the default on the where he got to be the default on the most important platform for AI, the most important platform for AI, the most important platform for AI, the iPhone, and now it's wound up in a iPhone, and now it's wound up in a iPhone, and now it's wound up in a massive lawsuit. What are your thoughts massive lawsuit. What are your thoughts massive lawsuit. What are your thoughts on this? on this? on this? I haven't really seen Apple I haven't really seen Apple I haven't really seen Apple very latigiously in 25 years in Silicon very latigiously in 25 years in Silicon very latigiously in 25 years in Silicon Valley. Valley. Valley. So that's obviously a concerning data So that's obviously a concerning data So that's obviously a concerning data point for OpenAI. They're very reactive point for OpenAI. They're very reactive point for OpenAI. They're very reactive more than they are more than they are more than they are proactive on these things. So, there proactive on these things. So, there proactive on these things. So, there must have been something that really must have been something that really must have been something that really really upset them. really upset them. really upset them. >> Egregious. Yeah. >> Egregious. Yeah. >> Egregious. Yeah. >> So, I don't know. It's going to take a >> So, I don't know. It's going to take a >> So, I don't know. It's going to take a court to sort this out. I don't really court to sort this out. I don't really court to sort this out. I don't really want to gossip because like who knows want to gossip because like who knows want to gossip because like who knows what's actually going on and who said what's actually going on and who said what's actually going on and who said what and blah blah blah, but nobody what and blah blah blah, but nobody what and blah blah blah, but nobody should be stealing should be stealing should be stealing things from their former employer. things from their former employer. things from their former employer. Nobody. Nobody. Nobody. >> Obvious. >> Obvious. >> Obvious. >> You're just not allowed. It's just >> You're just not allowed. It's just >> You're just not allowed. It's just obvious. These people are very, very obvious. These people are very, very obvious. These people are very, very smart and they're very successful. And smart and they're very successful. And smart and they're very successful. And you know that's why OpenAI probably you know that's why OpenAI probably you know that's why OpenAI probably wanted them and that's why they wanted wanted them and that's why they wanted wanted them and that's why they wanted them you know and you come to them with them you know and you come to them with them you know and you come to them with the collective wisdom of what you've the collective wisdom of what you've the collective wisdom of what you've accumulated and I think that's accumulated and I think that's accumulated and I think that's sufficient. You don't need to especially sufficient. You don't need to especially sufficient. You don't need to especially as a senior person do this. So I just as a senior person do this. So I just as a senior person do this. So I just hope that this stuff isn't true because hope that this stuff isn't true because hope that this stuff isn't true because I think I don't think that Sam or Sarah I think I don't think that Sam or Sarah I think I don't think that Sam or Sarah or anybody else there are trying to or anybody else there are trying to or anybody else there are trying to induce this to happen. I don't think so. induce this to happen. I don't think so. induce this to happen. I don't think so. >> Yeah, I doubt they induced it but I do >> Yeah, I doubt they induced it but I do >> Yeah, I doubt they induced it but I do believe that it's true or Apple wouldn't believe that it's true or Apple wouldn't believe that it's true or Apple wouldn't have brought it. Sachs when we look at have brought it. Sachs when we look at have brought it. Sachs when we look at this maybe you could open the um this maybe you could open the um this maybe you could open the um aperture here if you want or you can aperture here if you want or you can aperture here if you want or you can just go very detailed but the nature of just go very detailed but the nature of just go very detailed but the nature of we have a free market we don't have we have a free market we don't have we have a free market we don't have non-competes in California generally non-competes in California generally non-competes in California generally speaking you can just employment at will speaking you can just employment at will speaking you can just employment at will go where you want but we have had go where you want but we have had go where you want but we have had instances you know whimo famously uh you instances you know whimo famously uh you instances you know whimo famously uh you know brought some know brought some know brought some IP to Uber when they did Travis and the IP to Uber when they did Travis and the IP to Uber when they did Travis and the team said leave the building your job is team said leave the building your job is team said leave the building your job is rescended you don't get to bring that rescended you don't get to bring that rescended you don't get to bring that information here. In this case, it seems information here. In this case, it seems information here. In this case, it seems maybe they didn't induce it, but it maybe they didn't induce it, but it maybe they didn't induce it, but it occurred for some period of time. So, occurred for some period of time. So, occurred for some period of time. So, take us through big picture take us through big picture take us through big picture what you think is going on here and what what you think is going on here and what what you think is going on here and what it means for the industry. it means for the industry. it means for the industry. >> Well, like Jamas said, I have no idea >> Well, like Jamas said, I have no idea >> Well, like Jamas said, I have no idea what's going on here. I mean, these this what's going on here. I mean, these this what's going on here. I mean, these this is a lawsuit. The facts are all alleged. is a lawsuit. The facts are all alleged. is a lawsuit. The facts are all alleged. We don't know. It's going to be We don't know. It's going to be We don't know. It's going to be adjudicated. So, I really don't want to adjudicated. So, I really don't want to adjudicated. So, I really don't want to opine on what happened here. But if opine on what happened here. But if opine on what happened here. But if people want to know a very simple rule people want to know a very simple rule people want to know a very simple rule of thumb for how to avoid these types of of thumb for how to avoid these types of of thumb for how to avoid these types of disputes is just when an employee leaves disputes is just when an employee leaves disputes is just when an employee leaves their previous company and joins the new their previous company and joins the new their previous company and joins the new company, just don't take anything with company, just don't take anything with company, just don't take anything with you. you. you. >> The only thing you can bring to your new >> The only thing you can bring to your new >> The only thing you can bring to your new job is what's in your head. job is what's in your head. job is what's in your head. >> Your memories. >> Your memories. >> Your memories. >> Your memories. That's fine. Whatever is >> Your memories. That's fine. Whatever is >> Your memories. That's fine. Whatever is in your head, you're allowed to take. in your head, you're allowed to take. in your head, you're allowed to take. But never leave with anything else. But never leave with anything else. But never leave with anything else. >> No thumb drives, no CD, no documents, no >> No thumb drives, no CD, no documents, no >> No thumb drives, no CD, no documents, no nothing. nothing. nothing. >> Justip what's in your is okay. >> Justip what's in your is okay. >> Justip what's in your is okay. Fraberg, any thoughts here on Fraberg, any thoughts here on Fraberg, any thoughts here on just the just the just the number of lawsuits that seem to be number of lawsuits that seem to be number of lawsuits that seem to be piling up over at Open AI? Bad luck. >> Couple dots make a line, I guess. >> Couple dots make a line, I guess. >> Okay, there you go. Very well said. >> Okay, there you go. Very well said. >> Okay, there you go. Very well said. Couple of dots make a line. Okay, SpaceX Couple of dots make a line. Okay, SpaceX Couple of dots make a line. Okay, SpaceX had a data leak this week. They launched had a data leak this week. They launched had a data leak this week. They launched Grock Build in public beta at the end of Grock Build in public beta at the end of Grock Build in public beta at the end of May. The newest coding model, Grock 4.5, May. The newest coding model, Grock 4.5, May. The newest coding model, Grock 4.5, powers Grock build. I've been playing powers Grock build. I've been playing powers Grock build. I've been playing with it. It's extraordinary. It's a with it. It's extraordinary. It's a with it. It's extraordinary. It's a coding tool that works inside of Kurser. coding tool that works inside of Kurser. coding tool that works inside of Kurser. Uh, SpaceX previously told users, Uh, SpaceX previously told users, Uh, SpaceX previously told users, Shimoth, nothing from your codebase is Shimoth, nothing from your codebase is Shimoth, nothing from your codebase is transmitted to XAI servers during a transmitted to XAI servers during a transmitted to XAI servers during a session. But what actually was happening session. But what actually was happening session. But what actually was happening is every time a developer or according is every time a developer or according is every time a developer or according to reports used Grock build the tool was to reports used Grock build the tool was to reports used Grock build the tool was sending their entire codebase to SpaceX sending their entire codebase to SpaceX sending their entire codebase to SpaceX cloud servers out without alerting the cloud servers out without alerting the cloud servers out without alerting the users not just the files that were users not just the files that were users not just the files that were needed to do that specific coding task needed to do that specific coding task needed to do that specific coding task just everything passwords API keys could just everything passwords API keys could just everything passwords API keys could have got pulled up there all the uh have got pulled up there all the uh have got pulled up there all the uh change logs etc. Uh the privacy setting change logs etc. Uh the privacy setting change logs etc. Uh the privacy setting was supposed to stop this but it didn't was supposed to stop this but it didn't was supposed to stop this but it didn't work. SpaceX quietly disabled the upload work. SpaceX quietly disabled the upload work. SpaceX quietly disabled the upload on July 13th by flipping a switch on on July 13th by flipping a switch on on July 13th by flipping a switch on their servers. Elon Musk, friend of the their servers. Elon Musk, friend of the their servers. Elon Musk, friend of the pod, promised on X that all previously pod, promised on X that all previously pod, promised on X that all previously uploaded data has been deleted, I guess. uploaded data has been deleted, I guess. uploaded data has been deleted, I guess. Uh, and in response, SpaceX open- source Uh, and in response, SpaceX open- source Uh, and in response, SpaceX open- source rock build. That's their harness. So, rock build. That's their harness. So, rock build. That's their harness. So, that's another opensource win or win for that's another opensource win or win for that's another opensource win or win for the open-source community and AI the open-source community and AI the open-source community and AI sovereignty. sovereignty. sovereignty. You got any kind of thoughts on this? You got any kind of thoughts on this? You got any kind of thoughts on this? Obviously, this was not intentional, but Obviously, this was not intentional, but Obviously, this was not intentional, but trust is important uh with these models trust is important uh with these models trust is important uh with these models as we've been talking about for the last as we've been talking about for the last as we've been talking about for the last couple of months here on the All-In couple of months here on the All-In couple of months here on the All-In podcast. podcast. podcast. >> I would actually connect this to my >> I would actually connect this to my >> I would actually connect this to my comments on CNBC earlier this week, comments on CNBC earlier this week, comments on CNBC earlier this week, which built on top of Alex Karp's which built on top of Alex Karp's which built on top of Alex Karp's comments the week before. comments the week before. comments the week before. Privacy in AI is very fragile and it's Privacy in AI is very fragile and it's Privacy in AI is very fragile and it's very brittle. And this is despite the very brittle. And this is despite the very brittle. And this is despite the best efforts of great businesses. Like, best efforts of great businesses. Like, best efforts of great businesses. Like, you know, you may not like Elon for you know, you may not like Elon for you know, you may not like Elon for personality quirks, but he is incredibly personality quirks, but he is incredibly personality quirks, but he is incredibly trustworthy. He's overly trustworthy. He's overly trustworthy. He's overly transparent. And so, to their credit, transparent. And so, to their credit, transparent. And so, to their credit, they shut it off immediately. But my they shut it off immediately. But my they shut it off immediately. But my takeaway is that there are all kinds of takeaway is that there are all kinds of takeaway is that there are all kinds of non-obvious data leak vectors lurking in non-obvious data leak vectors lurking in non-obvious data leak vectors lurking in AI. And so if you think that you're AI. And so if you think that you're AI. And so if you think that you're going to flip a ZDR switch, zero data going to flip a ZDR switch, zero data going to flip a ZDR switch, zero data retention, which is the magic term that retention, which is the magic term that retention, which is the magic term that the industry uses to tell you that the industry uses to tell you that the industry uses to tell you that everything's going to be okay. everything's going to be okay. everything's going to be okay. I think the answer and the message I think the answer and the message I think the answer and the message should be it's not going to be okay should be it's not going to be okay should be it's not going to be okay because you can't guarantee any of it. because you can't guarantee any of it. because you can't guarantee any of it. So the model companies when they give So the model companies when they give So the model companies when they give you these zero data retention policies you these zero data retention policies you these zero data retention policies are probably trying their best. But I are probably trying their best. But I are probably trying their best. But I think the reality is you are leaking think the reality is you are leaking think the reality is you are leaking information where you don't know it. and information where you don't know it. and information where you don't know it. and they despite their best efforts may they despite their best efforts may they despite their best efforts may still have trap doors that they don't still have trap doors that they don't still have trap doors that they don't even know about until it's figured out even know about until it's figured out even know about until it's figured out by somebody else like in this example. by somebody else like in this example. by somebody else like in this example. So all of this speaks to you have to So all of this speaks to you have to So all of this speaks to you have to have a stratified ecosystem. You have to have a stratified ecosystem. You have to have a stratified ecosystem. You have to have third parties. Now look that's very have third parties. Now look that's very have third parties. Now look that's very biased for me because it's in part what biased for me because it's in part what biased for me because it's in part what we do for large enterprises at 8090 when we do for large enterprises at 8090 when we do for large enterprises at 8090 when we implement our software factory. But we implement our software factory. But we implement our software factory. But the reason why it's working so well is the reason why it's working so well is the reason why it's working so well is this exact reason. You need an this exact reason. You need an this exact reason. You need an independent third party layer to independent third party layer to independent third party layer to interface to these models to manage this interface to these models to manage this interface to these models to manage this exposure because there are trap doors exposure because there are trap doors exposure because there are trap doors everywhere. everywhere. everywhere. >> And that's what Sachi just said in a >> And that's what Sachi just said in a >> And that's what Sachi just said in a really interesting blog post. Did you really interesting blog post. Did you really interesting blog post. Did you guys see that? guys see that? guys see that? >> Yeah, >> Yeah, >> Yeah, >> I thought that was excellent. >> I thought that was excellent. >> I thought that was excellent. >> The reverse information paradox. >> The reverse information paradox. >> The reverse information paradox. >> Yeah, >> Yeah, >> Yeah, >> that's exactly the the takeaway that he >> that's exactly the the takeaway that he >> that's exactly the the takeaway that he left with. He was building on Alex left with. He was building on Alex left with. He was building on Alex Karp's supposed crash out. You know the Karp's supposed crash out. You know the Karp's supposed crash out. You know the point that Kart made about how point that Kart made about how point that Kart made about how enterprises who have technical ability enterprises who have technical ability enterprises who have technical ability want control over their compute models, want control over their compute models, want control over their compute models, weights, data and alpha. But he he went weights, data and alpha. But he he went weights, data and alpha. But he he went further with that idea. I mean he further with that idea. I mean he further with that idea. I mean he started with Karp's idea but then he started with Karp's idea but then he started with Karp's idea but then he kind of provided a recipe a road map for kind of provided a recipe a road map for kind of provided a recipe a road map for how enterprises should operationalize how enterprises should operationalize how enterprises should operationalize that. And what he says is that that. And what he says is that that. And what he says is that enterprises they have to establish a enterprises they have to establish a enterprises they have to establish a real trust boundary with private eval real trust boundary with private eval real trust boundary with private eval proprietary learning loops inside the proprietary learning loops inside the proprietary learning loops inside the tenant decoupled orchestration tenant decoupled orchestration tenant decoupled orchestration and the explicit right to fine-tune and the explicit right to fine-tune and the explicit right to fine-tune their own outputs. So he kind of goes their own outputs. So he kind of goes their own outputs. So he kind of goes through a litany of fairly technical through a litany of fairly technical through a litany of fairly technical things that enterprises should do in things that enterprises should do in things that enterprises should do in order to achieve the operational control order to achieve the operational control order to achieve the operational control that Karp was saying that enterprises that Karp was saying that enterprises that Karp was saying that enterprises really want over their AI compute models really want over their AI compute models really want over their AI compute models and data their alpha. So it's really and data their alpha. So it's really and data their alpha. So it's really interesting. I think now there's you interesting. I think now there's you interesting. I think now there's you know a virtual almost like college dorm know a virtual almost like college dorm know a virtual almost like college dorm session going on between the leaders of session going on between the leaders of session going on between the leaders of these companies who are brainstorming these companies who are brainstorming these companies who are brainstorming some of these concepts and now extending some of these concepts and now extending some of these concepts and now extending them. Right. them. Right. them. Right. >> And what's happening is you're starting >> And what's happening is you're starting >> And what's happening is you're starting to see the formation of not really an to see the formation of not really an to see the formation of not really an alliance but like an ecosystem alliance but like an ecosystem alliance but like an ecosystem that is trying to create alternatives to that is trying to create alternatives to that is trying to create alternatives to you know a monolithic closed model stack you know a monolithic closed model stack you know a monolithic closed model stack which is where anthropic and to some which is where anthropic and to some which is where anthropic and to some extent open AAI want to go is they want extent open AAI want to go is they want extent open AAI want to go is they want you to be locked in to their to their you to be locked in to their to their you to be locked in to their to their stack right their models their harness stack right their models their harness stack right their models their harness they control the data all you know all they control the data all you know all they control the data all you know all of that and now you're starting to see of that and now you're starting to see of that and now you're starting to see all these different companies all these different companies all these different companies >> and you pay a huge premium for the >> and you pay a huge premium for the >> and you pay a huge premium for the privilege for them to do it, which is privilege for them to do it, which is privilege for them to do it, which is even more insane. So, I I saw this data even more insane. So, I I saw this data even more insane. So, I I saw this data and Nick, maybe you can find this and Nick, maybe you can find this and Nick, maybe you can find this companion clip. The companion clip I'd companion clip. The companion clip I'd companion clip. The companion clip I'd like you to find is Eric Glyman, who's like you to find is Eric Glyman, who's like you to find is Eric Glyman, who's the CEO of RAMP, was on Squawkbox, I the CEO of RAMP, was on Squawkbox, I the CEO of RAMP, was on Squawkbox, I think today, talking about a new feature think today, talking about a new feature think today, talking about a new feature where you can manage the token maxing of where you can manage the token maxing of where you can manage the token maxing of your employees through your ramp card. your employees through your ramp card. your employees through your ramp card. But the data that I saw was that a But the data that I saw was that a But the data that I saw was that a million tokens on Fable is about sachs million tokens on Fable is about sachs million tokens on Fable is about sachs 56 bucks. A million from soul is about 56 bucks. A million from soul is about 56 bucks. A million from soul is about 26 bucks which is the same as quad 48. A 26 bucks which is the same as quad 48. A 26 bucks which is the same as quad 48. A million input tokens from on Gro is million input tokens from on Gro is million input tokens from on Gro is about $1.50. about $1.50. about $1.50. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Z is about a $150. Elon's about a dollar >> Z is about a $150. Elon's about a dollar >> Z is about a $150. Elon's about a dollar and the Chinese models are 50. and the Chinese models are 50. and the Chinese models are 50. >> Wow. So on top of the whole data >> Wow. So on top of the whole data >> Wow. So on top of the whole data sovereignty sovereignty sovereignty bleeding your alpha away, can you bleeding your alpha away, can you bleeding your alpha away, can you imagine that you're paying 56 bucks as imagine that you're paying 56 bucks as imagine that you're paying 56 bucks as well per million input tokens for that well per million input tokens for that well per million input tokens for that risk? That is insanity. risk? That is insanity. risk? That is insanity. >> I'm using perplexity computer and they >> I'm using perplexity computer and they >> I'm using perplexity computer and they started supporting Grock and they started supporting Grock and they started supporting Grock and they already support GLM52. So when you're already support GLM52. So when you're already support GLM52. So when you're like you're using Claude or OpenAI, you like you're using Claude or OpenAI, you like you're using Claude or OpenAI, you can only use their model. So I started can only use their model. So I started can only use their model. So I started effing with the different models and I effing with the different models and I effing with the different models and I gave it all the same basically PRD and I gave it all the same basically PRD and I gave it all the same basically PRD and I said I want to make a podcast player said I want to make a podcast player said I want to make a podcast player that deep link. So, like if we were that deep link. So, like if we were that deep link. So, like if we were talking about, I don't know, Mythos, it talking about, I don't know, Mythos, it talking about, I don't know, Mythos, it would play me all the miso methos clips would play me all the miso methos clips would play me all the miso methos clips across all the different tech and across all the different tech and across all the different tech and business podcasts, but make it into one business podcasts, but make it into one business podcasts, but make it into one stream. And I was like, this would be stream. And I was like, this would be stream. And I was like, this would be like really helpful for me for prepping like really helpful for me for prepping like really helpful for me for prepping for the show and just be interesting. I for the show and just be interesting. I for the show and just be interesting. I did it. It took a couple of hours. It did it. It took a couple of hours. It did it. It took a couple of hours. It cost $11 on the new Grock. It was cost $11 on the new Grock. It was cost $11 on the new Grock. It was hilarious how cheap it was. And then hilarious how cheap it was. And then hilarious how cheap it was. And then adding to this, I don't know if you saw adding to this, I don't know if you saw adding to this, I don't know if you saw >> Sorry. Did you try to do it on Fable to >> Sorry. Did you try to do it on Fable to >> Sorry. Did you try to do it on Fable to see how much more expensive it was? see how much more expensive it was? see how much more expensive it was? >> I didn't. I didn't because I was out >> I didn't. I didn't because I was out >> I didn't. I didn't because I was out [laughter] of Fable credits on my $200 [laughter] of Fable credits on my $200 [laughter] of Fable credits on my $200 account. So, you know, account. So, you know, account. So, you know, >> look at this clip here. Nick, play the >> look at this clip here. Nick, play the >> look at this clip here. Nick, play the clip from Eric Glenn. That's kind of clip from Eric Glenn. That's kind of clip from Eric Glenn. That's kind of interesting. interesting. interesting. >> We're thrilled to be launching token >> We're thrilled to be launching token >> We're thrilled to be launching token spend management today. It's available spend management today. It's available spend management today. It's available to RAMP and non-RAMP customers. to RAMP and non-RAMP customers. to RAMP and non-RAMP customers. >> And he's exactly right. Over the last >> And he's exactly right. Over the last >> And he's exactly right. Over the last year, I looked at the stats this year, I looked at the stats this year, I looked at the stats this morning, token spend among RAMP morning, token spend among RAMP morning, token spend among RAMP customers has grown by 21 times. customers has grown by 21 times. customers has grown by 21 times. >> 21 times. >> 21 times. >> 21 times. >> 21 times. >> 21 times. >> 21 times. >> Not 21%, we're talking about 21 times. >> Not 21%, we're talking about 21 times. >> Not 21%, we're talking about 21 times. >> That's exactly right. So being off by a >> That's exactly right. So being off by a >> That's exactly right. So being off by a few pennies as a CFO uh actually might few pennies as a CFO uh actually might few pennies as a CFO uh actually might be quite nice. At the rate it's going, be quite nice. At the rate it's going, be quite nice. At the rate it's going, it might be several dollars. And and it might be several dollars. And and it might be several dollars. And and look, like I I think that for uh many look, like I I think that for uh many look, like I I think that for uh many CFOs, they're often very surprised by CFOs, they're often very surprised by CFOs, they're often very surprised by the bill because what the AI companies the bill because what the AI companies the bill because what the AI companies have functionally set up is you have a have functionally set up is you have a have functionally set up is you have a tab. you can spend as much as you want. tab. you can spend as much as you want. tab. you can spend as much as you want. It's very hard for CFOs to see It's very hard for CFOs to see It's very hard for CFOs to see proactively what people are spending on proactively what people are spending on proactively what people are spending on and every time they're introducing new and every time they're introducing new and every time they're introducing new models, the rates often go up and so models, the rates often go up and so models, the rates often go up and so there's very misaligned incentives. So there's very misaligned incentives. So there's very misaligned incentives. So part of what we're trying to do is make part of what we're trying to do is make part of what we're trying to do is make it easy for CFOs to see the spend, it easy for CFOs to see the spend, it easy for CFOs to see the spend, understand the spend, and control it. understand the spend, and control it. understand the spend, and control it. >> Thanks, Nick. He's saying something so >> Thanks, Nick. He's saying something so >> Thanks, Nick. He's saying something so important there because if your important there because if your important there because if your engineers are going off randomly in an engineers are going off randomly in an engineers are going off randomly in an unguided system and then just ripping unguided system and then just ripping unguided system and then just ripping through million tokens at 56 bucks, what through million tokens at 56 bucks, what through million tokens at 56 bucks, what he's talking about is the eventual he's talking about is the eventual he's talking about is the eventual downstream impact to earnings. And that downstream impact to earnings. And that downstream impact to earnings. And that eventually a bunch of these public eventually a bunch of these public eventually a bunch of these public market CFOs are going to show up to Wall market CFOs are going to show up to Wall market CFOs are going to show up to Wall Street and they will have missed Street and they will have missed Street and they will have missed earnings because they're upex at some earnings because they're upex at some earnings because they're upex at some point. If things are 21xing every few point. If things are 21xing every few point. If things are 21xing every few months, somebody's going to miss a months, somebody's going to miss a months, somebody's going to miss a quarter. I don't know who, but somebody. quarter. I don't know who, but somebody. quarter. I don't know who, but somebody. And it's not just going to be, you know, And it's not just going to be, you know, And it's not just going to be, you know, I was speculating it'll be a few pennies I was speculating it'll be a few pennies I was speculating it'll be a few pennies here or there, which they'll have to say here or there, which they'll have to say here or there, which they'll have to say is because of token spend. He's saying is because of token spend. He's saying is because of token spend. He's saying it could be as much as dollars at this it could be as much as dollars at this it could be as much as dollars at this rate, which also could be the case. I rate, which also could be the case. I rate, which also could be the case. I think the point that we're all trying to think the point that we're all trying to think the point that we're all trying to make is unless you get a control of this make is unless you get a control of this make is unless you get a control of this and you can directly say how much money and you can directly say how much money and you can directly say how much money you're making, this is a bridge to you're making, this is a bridge to you're making, this is a bridge to nowhere. It is a money burning furnace. nowhere. It is a money burning furnace. nowhere. It is a money burning furnace. >> The good news is this is all creating a >> The good news is this is all creating a >> The good news is this is all creating a massive market opportunity. Sachs, Bit massive market opportunity. Sachs, Bit massive market opportunity. Sachs, Bit Tensor, Subnets, GLM52 hosting Grock Tensor, Subnets, GLM52 hosting Grock Tensor, Subnets, GLM52 hosting Grock 4.5. Now 4.5. Now 4.5. Now >> in Inkling, Inklink mirror Marott's new >> in Inkling, Inklink mirror Marott's new >> in Inkling, Inklink mirror Marott's new model in everybody's now saying, "Hey, model in everybody's now saying, "Hey, model in everybody's now saying, "Hey, wait a second. I can give you a better wait a second. I can give you a better wait a second. I can give you a better deal. You're paying two bucks. I can get deal. You're paying two bucks. I can get deal. You're paying two bucks. I can get you one buck. This is you one buck. This is you one buck. This is >> No. No. People are paying between 26 and >> No. No. People are paying between 26 and >> No. No. People are paying between 26 and 56 bucks. They should be paying 50 56 bucks. They should be paying 50 56 bucks. They should be paying 50 cents." Exactly. [laughter] cents." Exactly. [laughter] cents." Exactly. [laughter] >> Well, you know, and >> Well, you know, and >> Well, you know, and >> the Inkling announcement was kind of >> the Inkling announcement was kind of >> the Inkling announcement was kind of interesting because I think the value interesting because I think the value interesting because I think the value prop there is she's explicitly saying prop there is she's explicitly saying prop there is she's explicitly saying that look, we're not frontier that look, we're not frontier that look, we're not frontier intelligence. We're just under that, but intelligence. We're just under that, but intelligence. We're just under that, but we're a platform for fine-tuning these we're a platform for fine-tuning these we're a platform for fine-tuning these open models which are much much cheaper open models which are much much cheaper open models which are much much cheaper and then you can achieve the result you and then you can achieve the result you and then you can achieve the result you want based on fine-tuning. And so that's want based on fine-tuning. And so that's want based on fine-tuning. And so that's really interesting. really interesting. really interesting. >> Yeah. And uh but you know these open >> Yeah. And uh but you know these open >> Yeah. And uh but you know these open models won't be around for very long if models won't be around for very long if models won't be around for very long if Anthropic has its way. Anthropic has its way. Anthropic has its way. >> There's a reason they want to stop it. >> There's a reason they want to stop it. >> There's a reason they want to stop it. It's just they have such a monopoly. It's just they have such a monopoly. It's just they have such a monopoly. >> Of course you're you're selling most of >> Of course you're you're selling most of >> Of course you're you're selling most of the product for 50 cents per million the product for 50 cents per million the product for 50 cents per million >> tokens when they're selling theirs for >> tokens when they're selling theirs for >> tokens when they're selling theirs for 56 bucks. Of course you don't want that 56 bucks. Of course you don't want that 56 bucks. Of course you don't want that to happen. Of course you want them you to happen. Of course you want them you to happen. Of course you want them you want to try to stop it. want to try to stop it. want to try to stop it. >> But that being said, they're still >> But that being said, they're still >> But that being said, they're still growing like crazy. Just to be clear, I growing like crazy. Just to be clear, I growing like crazy. Just to be clear, I mean, yes, you know, you are seeing this mean, yes, you know, you are seeing this mean, yes, you know, you are seeing this explosion of interesting things explosion of interesting things explosion of interesting things happening with open models like you happening with open models like you happening with open models like you said, you know, the latest rock build is said, you know, the latest rock build is said, you know, the latest rock build is open, thinking machines open and so open, thinking machines open and so open, thinking machines open and so forth and so on, but still forth and so on, but still forth and so on, but still >> I mean, they're growing. They're still >> I mean, they're growing. They're still >> I mean, they're growing. They're still the industry leader in terms of revenue the industry leader in terms of revenue the industry leader in terms of revenue growth. So, these things are happening growth. So, these things are happening growth. So, these things are happening side by side. And side by side. And side by side. And >> yeah, I would I think that the >> yeah, I would I think that the >> yeah, I would I think that the interesting thing is Eric would not have interesting thing is Eric would not have interesting thing is Eric would not have released this ramp product unless CFOs released this ramp product unless CFOs released this ramp product unless CFOs were like, I can't control the spend. were like, I can't control the spend. were like, I can't control the spend. >> Yes. And then he's like, "Well, here, >> Yes. And then he's like, "Well, here, >> Yes. And then he's like, "Well, here, let me build it for you." And then if let me build it for you." And then if let me build it for you." And then if enough CFOs essentially turn that enough CFOs essentially turn that enough CFOs essentially turn that feature on and start to rate limit how feature on and start to rate limit how feature on and start to rate limit how it's spent because maybe they're not it's spent because maybe they're not it's spent because maybe they're not getting the ROI and the engineer doesn't getting the ROI and the engineer doesn't getting the ROI and the engineer doesn't care about ROI. The engineer is like, I care about ROI. The engineer is like, I care about ROI. The engineer is like, I want to use the latest greatest model. want to use the latest greatest model. want to use the latest greatest model. >> Yeah. And maybe you don't need it. Maybe >> Yeah. And maybe you don't need it. Maybe >> Yeah. And maybe you don't need it. Maybe Mirror's right. And for 95% of the Mirror's right. And for 95% of the Mirror's right. And for 95% of the tasks, you should be at one level lower, tasks, you should be at one level lower, tasks, you should be at one level lower, especially when it costs 1/100th of the especially when it costs 1/100th of the especially when it costs 1/100th of the cost. But the engineer will never make cost. But the engineer will never make cost. But the engineer will never make that trade-off because they'll never that trade-off because they'll never that trade-off because they'll never want to think about it. You're right. want to think about it. You're right. want to think about it. You're right. >> And also they're not tied to the money. >> And also they're not tied to the money. >> And also they're not tied to the money. The CFO is tied to the money and the The CFO is tied to the money and the The CFO is tied to the money and the engineer wants to go on an exploration engineer wants to go on an exploration engineer wants to go on an exploration on using the latest greatest thing. on using the latest greatest thing. on using the latest greatest thing. >> Yeah. If you're booking your Yeah. If >> Yeah. If you're booking your Yeah. If >> Yeah. If you're booking your Yeah. If you're booking your travel, you're like, you're booking your travel, you're like, you're booking your travel, you're like, you don't even see the price. You're you don't even see the price. You're you don't even see the price. You're like, "Yeah, just put me in business like, "Yeah, just put me in business like, "Yeah, just put me in business class. Put me in a nice hotel." And like class. Put me in a nice hotel." And like class. Put me in a nice hotel." And like the travel department handles that. the travel department handles that. the travel department handles that. >> You're saying something really >> You're saying something really >> You're saying something really interesting. What percentage, if you had interesting. What percentage, if you had interesting. What percentage, if you had to guess, of fable five prompts are just to guess, of fable five prompts are just to guess, of fable five prompts are just average Michigan that should be running. average Michigan that should be running. average Michigan that should be running. >> 98%. >> 98%. >> 98%. 98%. I I I was using it for stupid stuff 98%. I I I was using it for stupid stuff 98%. I I I was using it for stupid stuff that I could be using Quen for. Um I that I could be using Quen for. Um I that I could be using Quen for. Um I think this is my like micro prediction think this is my like micro prediction think this is my like micro prediction here. Mark German, who's like the most here. Mark German, who's like the most here. Mark German, who's like the most in then guy when it comes to Apple, he in then guy when it comes to Apple, he in then guy when it comes to Apple, he says, and you know, we got this new CEO says, and you know, we got this new CEO says, and you know, we got this new CEO coming in for um uh John Furnus. coming in for um uh John Furnus. coming in for um uh John Furnus. >> Yeah. And he is a hardware engineer. M7 >> Yeah. And he is a hardware engineer. M7 >> Yeah. And he is a hardware engineer. M7 Ultra uh because M we're on M5 chips Ultra uh because M we're on M5 chips Ultra uh because M we're on M5 chips now. you can get like, you know, 456, now. you can get like, you know, 456, now. you can get like, you know, 456, 512 gigs of RAM. He says M7 Ultra is 512 gigs of RAM. He says M7 Ultra is 512 gigs of RAM. He says M7 Ultra is going to support as much as 1.5 going to support as much as 1.5 going to support as much as 1.5 terabytes. terabytes. terabytes. That's double what they're already That's double what they're already That's double what they're already supporting. So, if you think about uh supporting. So, if you think about uh supporting. So, if you think about uh Frontier models, like the last Frontier models, like the last Frontier models, like the last generation, this is like an Opus level generation, this is like an Opus level generation, this is like an Opus level model running on your Mac Studio. You model running on your Mac Studio. You model running on your Mac Studio. You guys all use Mac Studios, you're rich guys all use Mac Studios, you're rich guys all use Mac Studios, you're rich venture capitalists, whatever. You're venture capitalists, whatever. You're venture capitalists, whatever. You're like, "Yeah, I'll take a four or $5,000 like, "Yeah, I'll take a four or $5,000 like, "Yeah, I'll take a four or $5,000 computer." This is going to change computer." This is going to change computer." This is going to change everything. you're gonna have employers everything. you're gonna have employers everything. you're gonna have employers go, "Oh, I can just run, you know, 90% go, "Oh, I can just run, you know, 90% go, "Oh, I can just run, you know, 90% of my workloads, 99% of the workloads on of my workloads, 99% of the workloads on of my workloads, 99% of the workloads on the local uh Mac Studio." I think Apple the local uh Mac Studio." I think Apple the local uh Mac Studio." I think Apple is a screaming buy right now. Uh and I is a screaming buy right now. Uh and I is a screaming buy right now. Uh and I this not financial advice, but my lord, this not financial advice, but my lord, this not financial advice, but my lord, that company could just run the table on that company could just run the table on that company could just run the table on AI if they get this right. AI if they get this right. AI if they get this right. >> All right. >> All right. >> All right. >> Apple. >> Apple. >> Apple. >> Yes. Because I they're going to make >> Yes. Because I they're going to make >> Yes. Because I they're going to make such a fortune. such a fortune. such a fortune. >> You got Let me explain. It's just like >> You got Let me explain. It's just like >> You got Let me explain. It's just like the iPhone. Everybody laughed at the the iPhone. Everybody laughed at the the iPhone. Everybody laughed at the iPhone. People overpaid. iPhone. People overpaid. iPhone. People overpaid. They did not. When the first iPhone came They did not. When the first iPhone came They did not. When the first iPhone came out, many people out, many people out, many people that was it. that was it. that was it. >> That's true. Steve was the big >> That's true. Steve was the big >> That's true. Steve was the big [laughter] one. You can I can still hear [laughter] one. You can I can still hear [laughter] one. You can I can still hear him laughing. him laughing. him laughing. >> No, if you think about how they make >> No, if you think about how they make >> No, if you think about how they make money off of hardware, off of their money off of hardware, off of their money off of hardware, off of their devices, they will put so much downward devices, they will put so much downward devices, they will put so much downward pressure on Claude and Open AAI by just pressure on Claude and Open AAI by just pressure on Claude and Open AAI by just putting local models and supporting them putting local models and supporting them putting local models and supporting them with this memory architecture. It's with this memory architecture. It's with this memory architecture. It's going to be wild when people have going to be wild when people have going to be wild when people have unlimited tokens on their desktop. I'm unlimited tokens on their desktop. I'm unlimited tokens on their desktop. I'm telling you, telling you, telling you, >> I don't know if you guys uh saw this, >> I don't know if you guys uh saw this, >> I don't know if you guys uh saw this, but um there's a very large solar but um there's a very large solar but um there's a very large solar company called Sunun. They just company called Sunun. They just company called Sunun. They just announced this week that they're making announced this week that they're making announced this week that they're making distributed data center blocks that you distributed data center blocks that you distributed data center blocks that you can put in your house. can put in your house. can put in your house. Another company that did it is company Another company that did it is company Another company that did it is company called SPAN that partnered with Nvidia. called SPAN that partnered with Nvidia. called SPAN that partnered with Nvidia. So to your point Jason, you're seeing So to your point Jason, you're seeing So to your point Jason, you're seeing this fragmentation and distribution of this fragmentation and distribution of this fragmentation and distribution of edge compute which I think is a theme. edge compute which I think is a theme. edge compute which I think is a theme. Definitely a theme. Definitely a theme. Definitely a theme. >> Well, it's also chasing energy, right? >> Well, it's also chasing energy, right? >> Well, it's also chasing energy, right? Like if you've got some solar, if you've Like if you've got some solar, if you've Like if you've got some solar, if you've got excess battery power, hey, we power got excess battery power, hey, we power got excess battery power, hey, we power up your batteries at night cheaply. up your batteries at night cheaply. up your batteries at night cheaply. >> I think I told you this last week, we >> I think I told you this last week, we >> I think I told you this last week, we are so massively short electrons. By are so massively short electrons. By are so massively short electrons. By 2050, the United States of America will 2050, the United States of America will 2050, the United States of America will be 2 and 12 California's worth of energy be 2 and 12 California's worth of energy be 2 and 12 California's worth of energy in deficit. 2.5 Californians, the fourth in deficit. 2.5 Californians, the fourth in deficit. 2.5 Californians, the fourth largest economy in the world. we will be largest economy in the world. we will be largest economy in the world. we will be short 2.5x short 2.5x short 2.5x of all of the energy consumed by of all of the energy consumed by of all of the energy consumed by California by 2050. California by 2050. California by 2050. This week there was an auction by this This week there was an auction by this This week there was an auction by this huge utility called PGM which serves huge utility called PGM which serves huge utility called PGM which serves Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, you Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, you Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, you know, 13 states. And that auction is know, 13 states. And that auction is know, 13 states. And that auction is where they publish a forward curve and where they publish a forward curve and where they publish a forward curve and say, "Hey, listen guys, here's my say, "Hey, listen guys, here's my say, "Hey, listen guys, here's my forecasted load and here's how much forecasted load and here's how much forecasted load and here's how much energy I need." And people signed up to energy I need." And people signed up to energy I need." And people signed up to essentially get paid a a guaranteed rate essentially get paid a a guaranteed rate essentially get paid a a guaranteed rate every day so that they have to fork over every day so that they have to fork over every day so that they have to fork over the energy in the future. Kind of like a the energy in the future. Kind of like a the energy in the future. Kind of like a forward option. They needed like seven forward option. They needed like seven forward option. They needed like seven or eight gawatt. or eight gawatt. or eight gawatt. They had 156 megawatts or something show They had 156 megawatts or something show They had 156 megawatts or something show up. Well, we are in such a bad place up. Well, we are in such a bad place up. Well, we are in such a bad place right now on electrons and electricity right now on electrons and electricity right now on electrons and electricity prices. prices. prices. >> Did you see what our boy did this week? >> Did you see what our boy did this week? >> Did you see what our boy did this week? >> We need we need So this is behind the >> We need we need So this is behind the >> We need we need So this is behind the meter, which is different. And he he meter, which is different. And he he meter, which is different. And he he Elon needed to do this by the way just Elon needed to do this by the way just Elon needed to do this by the way just so you know because there's an issue in so you know because there's an issue in so you know because there's an issue in Memphis where he was very clever about Memphis where he was very clever about Memphis where he was very clever about how he was able to get Colossus off the how he was able to get Colossus off the how he was able to get Colossus off the ground that regulatory it's not ground that regulatory it's not ground that regulatory it's not >> explain this >> explain this >> explain this >> when you try to power a data center >> when you try to power a data center >> when you try to power a data center typically you have what's called grid typically you have what's called grid typically you have what's called grid power. So you go to the utility in the power. So you go to the utility in the power. So you go to the utility in the area and you say, "Hey, please run me a area and you say, "Hey, please run me a area and you say, "Hey, please run me a line off of that main transmission line off of that main transmission line off of that main transmission line." And that's how you power your line." And that's how you power your line." And that's how you power your data center. When that runs out or is so data center. When that runs out or is so data center. When that runs out or is so backlogged, you have to do what's called backlogged, you have to do what's called backlogged, you have to do what's called behind the meter, which means on your behind the meter, which means on your behind the meter, which means on your own property that you own, you build own property that you own, you build own property that you own, you build something for yourself. Now, there's a something for yourself. Now, there's a something for yourself. Now, there's a problem with that. You would think, problem with that. You would think, problem with that. You would think, well, that's smart. Yes, but like in well, that's smart. Yes, but like in well, that's smart. Yes, but like in everything in America, there's everything in America, there's everything in America, there's regulation on top of regulation on top regulation on top of regulation on top regulation on top of regulation on top of regulation. And one of the most of regulation. And one of the most of regulation. And one of the most complicated regulatory schemes that you complicated regulatory schemes that you complicated regulatory schemes that you have to overcome is clean air have to overcome is clean air have to overcome is clean air permitting. permitting. permitting. So even if you say you're going to do So even if you say you're going to do So even if you say you're going to do behind the meter, then you're like, behind the meter, then you're like, behind the meter, then you're like, well, what can I do? Solar you can do, well, what can I do? Solar you can do, well, what can I do? Solar you can do, but it takes too much space for most but it takes too much space for most but it takes too much space for most places. Batteries you can do, but you places. Batteries you can do, but you places. Batteries you can do, but you need to generate the electricity in the need to generate the electricity in the need to generate the electricity in the first place. So people use that gas. So first place. So people use that gas. So first place. So people use that gas. So Elon cleverly bought a ton of 18-wheeler Elon cleverly bought a ton of 18-wheeler Elon cleverly bought a ton of 18-wheeler like engines basically. like engines basically. like engines basically. >> He bought the company that makes all >> He bought the company that makes all >> He bought the company that makes all this and provides mobile and then just this and provides mobile and then just this and provides mobile and then just and then just you know pin them to the and then just you know pin them to the and then just you know pin them to the ground and then ran it and you know ground and then ran it and you know ground and then ran it and you know those are personal use essentially and those are personal use essentially and those are personal use essentially and so they came under the clean air so they came under the clean air so they came under the clean air permitting requirements but then when permitting requirements but then when permitting requirements but then when you act as a block you could make the you act as a block you could make the you act as a block you could make the claim that it doesn't. Now, there are claim that it doesn't. Now, there are claim that it doesn't. Now, there are new solutions like Bloom Energy, which new solutions like Bloom Energy, which new solutions like Bloom Energy, which allows you to have huge installations allows you to have huge installations allows you to have huge installations and still fall under the the the and still fall under the the the and still fall under the the the personal use clean air permit. Um, and personal use clean air permit. Um, and personal use clean air permit. Um, and so for all of Elon's future capacity, he so for all of Elon's future capacity, he so for all of Elon's future capacity, he needed to have this in place so that he needed to have this in place so that he needed to have this in place so that he gets the the clean air permits and he's gets the the clean air permits and he's gets the the clean air permits and he's able to have a clean run of sight to able to have a clean run of sight to able to have a clean run of sight to continue to build domestic data centers. continue to build domestic data centers. continue to build domestic data centers. Anyway, Anyway, Anyway, >> speaking there's your little TED talk on >> speaking there's your little TED talk on >> speaking there's your little TED talk on energy, but uh we are in a bad place, energy, but uh we are in a bad place, energy, but uh we are in a bad place, guys, and it's only getting worse. guys, and it's only getting worse. guys, and it's only getting worse. Speaking of um data center sachs, Speaking of um data center sachs, Speaking of um data center sachs, everybody's favorite socialist governor everybody's favorite socialist governor everybody's favorite socialist governor Kathy Hochel in uh the great state of Kathy Hochel in uh the great state of Kathy Hochel in uh the great state of New York, my hometown, New York, my hometown, New York, my hometown, >> powered by fossil fuels, they drive up >> powered by fossil fuels, they drive up >> powered by fossil fuels, they drive up our carbon footprint. They occupy our carbon footprint. They occupy our carbon footprint. They occupy massive amounts of land, potentially massive amounts of land, potentially massive amounts of land, potentially displacing agricultural space and open displacing agricultural space and open displacing agricultural space and open spaces. The bottom line is progress spaces. The bottom line is progress spaces. The bottom line is progress shouldn't arise with a higher utility shouldn't arise with a higher utility shouldn't arise with a higher utility bill, deleted water supply, or noise bill, deleted water supply, or noise bill, deleted water supply, or noise pollution. So we have no choice but to pollution. So we have no choice but to pollution. So we have no choice but to address these challenges created by address these challenges created by address these challenges created by these massive facilities. these massive facilities. these massive facilities. That is why today I'll be signing the That is why today I'll be signing the That is why today I'll be signing the nation's first ever statewide moratorum nation's first ever statewide moratorum nation's first ever statewide moratorum on hyperscale data centers. on hyperscale data centers. on hyperscale data centers. >> Everything she's saying there is a false >> Everything she's saying there is a false >> Everything she's saying there is a false accusation uh on the data center. So accusation uh on the data center. So accusation uh on the data center. So let's just go one by one. So she's let's just go one by one. So she's let's just go one by one. So she's saying saying saying >> that they eat up all of the power. Well, >> that they eat up all of the power. Well, >> that they eat up all of the power. Well, yeah. I mean, look, if you connect to yeah. I mean, look, if you connect to yeah. I mean, look, if you connect to the grid without producing more power the grid without producing more power the grid without producing more power and you force data centers to compete and you force data centers to compete and you force data centers to compete with, you know, residential rateayers, with, you know, residential rateayers, with, you know, residential rateayers, then yeah, you could drive up utility then yeah, you could drive up utility then yeah, you could drive up utility prices. However, if you do what Chamas prices. However, if you do what Chamas prices. However, if you do what Chamas said and let them build behind the said and let them build behind the said and let them build behind the meter, then they bring their own power. meter, then they bring their own power. meter, then they bring their own power. And that's what the president has And that's what the president has And that's what the president has advocated for since the beginning of his advocated for since the beginning of his advocated for since the beginning of his administration is let the AI companies administration is let the AI companies administration is let the AI companies become power companies. So, that is the become power companies. So, that is the become power companies. So, that is the way to solve the energy problem or the way to solve the energy problem or the way to solve the energy problem or the utility problem. Then she's talking utility problem. Then she's talking utility problem. Then she's talking about, you know, eating up land. The about, you know, eating up land. The about, you know, eating up land. The reality is these data centers are a reality is these data centers are a reality is these data centers are a model of land use efficiency. We have a model of land use efficiency. We have a model of land use efficiency. We have a ton of land in this country. Obviously, ton of land in this country. Obviously, ton of land in this country. Obviously, you can find places where there is you can find places where there is you can find places where there is enough open land to build a data center. enough open land to build a data center. enough open land to build a data center. The economic impact and value of a data The economic impact and value of a data The economic impact and value of a data center relative to the land use again is center relative to the land use again is center relative to the land use again is one of the best ROIs there is. The one of the best ROIs there is. The one of the best ROIs there is. The supposed noise pollution that's largely supposed noise pollution that's largely supposed noise pollution that's largely made up that can be dealt with. You made up that can be dealt with. You made up that can be dealt with. You obviously don't want to put these things obviously don't want to put these things obviously don't want to put these things right next to a residential area, but right next to a residential area, but right next to a residential area, but create a little bit of distance and it's create a little bit of distance and it's create a little bit of distance and it's fine. The whole water consumption thing fine. The whole water consumption thing fine. The whole water consumption thing is largely a hoax. is largely a hoax. is largely a hoax. >> The the modern data centers uh >> The the modern data centers uh >> The the modern data centers uh recirculate the water, recirculate the water, recirculate the water, >> closed loop systems. >> closed loop systems. >> closed loop systems. >> Yeah. And I think there there was a >> Yeah. And I think there there was a >> Yeah. And I think there there was a study that showed that a typical data study that showed that a typical data study that showed that a typical data center uses the same amount of water as center uses the same amount of water as center uses the same amount of water as two and a half in-n-out burgers. So, two and a half in-n-out burgers. So, two and a half in-n-out burgers. So, in-n-out [laughter] burger chains. in-n-out [laughter] burger chains. in-n-out [laughter] burger chains. >> I mean, just go after the almonds if >> I mean, just go after the almonds if >> I mean, just go after the almonds if you're concerned about water, people, you're concerned about water, people, you're concerned about water, people, please. please. please. >> There's there Yeah. Or golf courses. I >> There's there Yeah. Or golf courses. I >> There's there Yeah. Or golf courses. I mean there's many, you know, there's mean there's many, you know, there's mean there's many, you know, there's many uses of water that are way more many uses of water that are way more many uses of water that are way more wasteful. So when you compare economic wasteful. So when you compare economic wasteful. So when you compare economic impact to all these different things, impact to all these different things, impact to all these different things, data centers are like honestly one of data centers are like honestly one of data centers are like honestly one of the best things we could be building as the best things we could be building as the best things we could be building as a nation. But a nation. But a nation. But >> and s there's all these taxes and >> and s there's all these taxes and >> and s there's all these taxes and incremental revenues. Did you see the incremental revenues. Did you see the incremental revenues. Did you see the article where I think it was in North article where I think it was in North article where I think it was in North Dakota or something where like teachers Dakota or something where like teachers Dakota or something where like teachers were getting like 30 and $40,000 bonuses were getting like 30 and $40,000 bonuses were getting like 30 and $40,000 bonuses from all the tax revenue that was coming from all the tax revenue that was coming from all the tax revenue that was coming in? There's all these upsides. in? There's all these upsides. in? There's all these upsides. >> That's right. They generate um a lot of >> That's right. They generate um a lot of >> That's right. They generate um a lot of tax revenue. They've created a tax revenue. They've created a tax revenue. They've created a bluecollar construction boom. It's not bluecollar construction boom. It's not bluecollar construction boom. It's not true that there's no jobs once they're true that there's no jobs once they're true that there's no jobs once they're built. That you do have ongoing jobs built. That you do have ongoing jobs built. That you do have ongoing jobs there. And then oh, one final thing just there. And then oh, one final thing just there. And then oh, one final thing just on the the point that Hokll was making. on the the point that Hokll was making. on the the point that Hokll was making. She said it created a lot of pollution. She said it created a lot of pollution. She said it created a lot of pollution. Natural gas, which is how most of these Natural gas, which is how most of these Natural gas, which is how most of these data centers are are powered, is one of data centers are are powered, is one of data centers are are powered, is one of the most clean burning sources of power the most clean burning sources of power the most clean burning sources of power that we have. that we have. that we have. >> 100%. >> 100%. >> 100%. >> These data centers have become the >> These data centers have become the >> These data centers have become the scapegoat for all the angst that people scapegoat for all the angst that people scapegoat for all the angst that people have about AI and it's kind of become have about AI and it's kind of become have about AI and it's kind of become this very clumsy way of trying to throw this very clumsy way of trying to throw this very clumsy way of trying to throw a wrench in the gears of innovation and a wrench in the gears of innovation and a wrench in the gears of innovation and just kind of slow the whole thing down. just kind of slow the whole thing down. just kind of slow the whole thing down. >> All I have to say is welcome to Texas. >> All I have to say is welcome to Texas. >> All I have to say is welcome to Texas. We got plenty of land here. And what's We got plenty of land here. And what's We got plenty of land here. And what's so stupid about her proposal and her so stupid about her proposal and her so stupid about her proposal and her talk, aside from the thing she got talk, aside from the thing she got talk, aside from the thing she got completely factually incorrect, is New completely factually incorrect, is New completely factually incorrect, is New York State is like 80% underdeveloped. York State is like 80% underdeveloped. York State is like 80% underdeveloped. Drive upstate, folks. You're thinking of Drive upstate, folks. You're thinking of Drive upstate, folks. You're thinking of New York City. Yes, New York City is New York City. Yes, New York City is New York City. Yes, New York City is packed. You go upstate, it's literally packed. You go upstate, it's literally packed. You go upstate, it's literally 70 to 80% of the land in New York State 70 to 80% of the land in New York State 70 to 80% of the land in New York State is undeveloped. There's so much land. is undeveloped. There's so much land. is undeveloped. There's so much land. It's ridiculous. New York is giant. It's It's ridiculous. New York is giant. It's It's ridiculous. New York is giant. It's giant. giant. giant. >> On this topic this week, I just want to >> On this topic this week, I just want to >> On this topic this week, I just want to give a shout out to Senator Dave give a shout out to Senator Dave give a shout out to Senator Dave McCormack. McCormack. McCormack. He had He had He had a defense and innovation summit in uh a defense and innovation summit in uh a defense and innovation summit in uh Carile, Pennsylvania at the Army War Carile, Pennsylvania at the Army War Carile, Pennsylvania at the Army War College College College which a bunch of us went to pus came which a bunch of us went to pus came which a bunch of us went to pus came gave a speech had a CEO round table a gave a speech had a CEO round table a gave a speech had a CEO round table a lot of defense company CEOs etc. But lot of defense company CEOs etc. But lot of defense company CEOs etc. But Chris Wright was there at Sachs and Chris Wright was there at Sachs and Chris Wright was there at Sachs and >> my guy >> my guy >> my guy >> he's great and Chris mentioned this in >> he's great and Chris mentioned this in >> he's great and Chris mentioned this in insane story. He said you know there is insane story. He said you know there is insane story. He said you know there is a lot of common funding because Dina a lot of common funding because Dina a lot of common funding because Dina Powell asked this question on stage and Powell asked this question on stage and Powell asked this question on stage and he said there's a lot of common funding he said there's a lot of common funding he said there's a lot of common funding patterns of these people that are patterns of these people that are patterns of these people that are protesting um the data centers and he protesting um the data centers and he protesting um the data centers and he said you could actually trace it back to said you could actually trace it back to said you could actually trace it back to the same people that in a different era the same people that in a different era the same people that in a different era were protesting fracking. And so he was were protesting fracking. And so he was were protesting fracking. And so he was saying like it's these are all just saying like it's these are all just saying like it's these are all just hobby horses that they use to raise hobby horses that they use to raise hobby horses that they use to raise money, have a job. They're like money, have a job. They're like money, have a job. They're like professionally paid protesters. They professionally paid protesters. They professionally paid protesters. They kind of just show up out of nowhere. I kind of just show up out of nowhere. I kind of just show up out of nowhere. I didn't realize that there was such a didn't realize that there was such a didn't realize that there was such a commonality, but they're the same commonality, but they're the same commonality, but they're the same people. people. people. >> The thing that I just can't understand >> The thing that I just can't understand >> The thing that I just can't understand for the life of me is why Anthropic is for the life of me is why Anthropic is for the life of me is why Anthropic is still funding these groups that want to still funding these groups that want to still funding these groups that want to put the kibos on new data center put the kibos on new data center put the kibos on new data center construction. There's one called public construction. There's one called public construction. There's one called public first where Daario just gave his first first where Daario just gave his first first where Daario just gave his first seven figure contribution and then a seven figure contribution and then a seven figure contribution and then a bunch of other employees at anthropic bunch of other employees at anthropic bunch of other employees at anthropic gave it and you know all these groups gave it and you know all these groups gave it and you know all these groups are trying to slow down AI development are trying to slow down AI development are trying to slow down AI development with new regulations and making it with new regulations and making it with new regulations and making it harder to build new data centers and at harder to build new data centers and at harder to build new data centers and at a certain point you just have to wonder a certain point you just have to wonder a certain point you just have to wonder I mean is this regulatory capture or I mean is this regulatory capture or I mean is this regulatory capture or they just kind of lost the plot because they just kind of lost the plot because they just kind of lost the plot because the number one thing slowing down the the number one thing slowing down the the number one thing slowing down the growth of anthropics revenue it's not growth of anthropics revenue it's not growth of anthropics revenue it's not demand I think it's the availability of demand I think it's the availability of demand I think it's the availability of compute in data centers. And so you're compute in data centers. And so you're compute in data centers. And so you're just kind of wondering like what is the just kind of wondering like what is the just kind of wondering like what is the point of all of this? point of all of this? point of all of this? >> It's so true. >> It's so true. >> It's so true. >> I was talking to someone in politics >> I was talking to someone in politics >> I was talking to someone in politics about this and the theory that they had about this and the theory that they had about this and the theory that they had is well the Democrats aren't going to is well the Democrats aren't going to is well the Democrats aren't going to pause the data centers forever. They're pause the data centers forever. They're pause the data centers forever. They're going to pause them until they feel like going to pause them until they feel like going to pause them until they feel like they're in enough control that they can they're in enough control that they can they're in enough control that they can dictate all the rules. And so in other dictate all the rules. And so in other dictate all the rules. And so in other words, they're calling this a moratorum. words, they're calling this a moratorum. words, they're calling this a moratorum. And I think it does mean that the data And I think it does mean that the data And I think it does mean that the data centers are going to stop but eventually centers are going to stop but eventually centers are going to stop but eventually they're going to be in a position to say they're going to be in a position to say they're going to be in a position to say okay here are our terms if you want to okay here are our terms if you want to okay here are our terms if you want to turn these things back on right you want turn these things back on right you want turn these things back on right you want to lift the moratorum and then that's to lift the moratorum and then that's to lift the moratorum and then that's when we get this you know big government when we get this you know big government when we get this you know big government democrat defined AI regime and you know democrat defined AI regime and you know democrat defined AI regime and you know that it's going to consist of a new that it's going to consist of a new that it's going to consist of a new regulatory agency and new speech regulatory agency and new speech regulatory agency and new speech controls the whole trust and safety controls the whole trust and safety controls the whole trust and safety agenda from social media will be ported agenda from social media will be ported agenda from social media will be ported over that's this was this One person I over that's this was this One person I over that's this was this One person I was talking to, this is what he was was talking to, this is what he was was talking to, this is what he was speculating is the real agenda is that speculating is the real agenda is that speculating is the real agenda is that eventually once Trump is no longer eventually once Trump is no longer eventually once Trump is no longer president or in some future Democratic president or in some future Democratic president or in some future Democratic administration, they will eventually administration, they will eventually administration, they will eventually lift the moratorum but on their terms. lift the moratorum but on their terms. lift the moratorum but on their terms. Now I think that's a really dangerous Now I think that's a really dangerous Now I think that's a really dangerous thing to do because you know Trump is thing to do because you know Trump is thing to do because you know Trump is president for another two years and then president for another two years and then president for another two years and then no one knows what's going to happen no one knows what's going to happen no one knows what's going to happen after that. And even if you lift the after that. And even if you lift the after that. And even if you lift the moratorum in say 2 and 1/2 or 3 years, moratorum in say 2 and 1/2 or 3 years, moratorum in say 2 and 1/2 or 3 years, it's going to take a couple of years for it's going to take a couple of years for it's going to take a couple of years for those projects to even ramp back up. So those projects to even ramp back up. So those projects to even ramp back up. So when you start talking about a when you start talking about a when you start talking about a moratorium on data centers, it's not moratorium on data centers, it's not moratorium on data centers, it's not like a a few month pause. It's probably like a a few month pause. It's probably like a a few month pause. It's probably a good 5 years at least before you know a good 5 years at least before you know a good 5 years at least before you know you can get another data center switched you can get another data center switched you can get another data center switched on in the state of New York. Just so you on in the state of New York. Just so you on in the state of New York. Just so you know how bad it's gotten, know how bad it's gotten, know how bad it's gotten, there's a curve that you can use to there's a curve that you can use to there's a curve that you can use to price data center assets. And I think price data center assets. And I think price data center assets. And I think you guys know this, but I have this you guys know this, but I have this you guys know this, but I have this portfolio of these assets that myself portfolio of these assets that myself portfolio of these assets that myself and my partner Nita have accumulated. and my partner Nita have accumulated. and my partner Nita have accumulated. And what's so interesting is when we And what's so interesting is when we And what's so interesting is when we talk to all of the hyperscalers about talk to all of the hyperscalers about talk to all of the hyperscalers about giving us a price because we're trying giving us a price because we're trying giving us a price because we're trying to figure out whether we should keep it to figure out whether we should keep it to figure out whether we should keep it or build it or just sell it, the most or build it or just sell it, the most or build it or just sell it, the most incredible thing is how extreme the incredible thing is how extreme the incredible thing is how extreme the price is at the front end of the curve. price is at the front end of the curve. price is at the front end of the curve. When you have When you have When you have verifiable energizable power today. verifiable energizable power today. verifiable energizable power today. And the reason is exactly everything And the reason is exactly everything And the reason is exactly everything that you're saying, Saxs, which is that that you're saying, Saxs, which is that that you're saying, Saxs, which is that when you look out into the future, when you look out into the future, when you look out into the future, you know, we've said this before, but you know, we've said this before, but you know, we've said this before, but it's about 40% of all these projects are it's about 40% of all these projects are it's about 40% of all these projects are getting mothballled and stopped. And so getting mothballled and stopped. And so getting mothballled and stopped. And so it's creating this massive deficit of it's creating this massive deficit of it's creating this massive deficit of available energy to actually drive available energy to actually drive available energy to actually drive the use of AI. So to the extent that you the use of AI. So to the extent that you the use of AI. So to the extent that you actually want, you know, drug discovery actually want, you know, drug discovery actually want, you know, drug discovery or you want cancer diagnosis or you want or you want cancer diagnosis or you want or you want cancer diagnosis or you want better healthcare or better legal better healthcare or better legal better healthcare or better legal advice, we may actually not be able to advice, we may actually not be able to advice, we may actually not be able to service it based on all of the demand service it based on all of the demand service it based on all of the demand that exists because the power isn't that exists because the power isn't that exists because the power isn't there. The energy isn't there. And the there. The energy isn't there. And the there. The energy isn't there. And the reason why that's not there is because reason why that's not there is because reason why that's not there is because folks are just kind of reflexively folks are just kind of reflexively folks are just kind of reflexively protesting something that they don't protesting something that they don't protesting something that they don't completely understand clearly. So I completely understand clearly. So I completely understand clearly. So I think it's a really it's a really big think it's a really it's a really big think it's a really it's a really big problem. problem. problem. >> I mean, we're going to have GPUs chasing >> I mean, we're going to have GPUs chasing >> I mean, we're going to have GPUs chasing energy. like where's their energy and energy. like where's their energy and energy. like where's their energy and just drive the GPUs there is what's just drive the GPUs there is what's just drive the GPUs there is what's going to happen right going to happen right going to happen right >> let me add one layer to it which is >> let me add one layer to it which is >> let me add one layer to it which is they're not only trying to stop data they're not only trying to stop data they're not only trying to stop data centers from being built in the US centers from being built in the US centers from being built in the US they're trying to stop data centers from they're trying to stop data centers from they're trying to stop data centers from being built internationally in our being built internationally in our being built internationally in our friends allies and partner countries and friends allies and partner countries and friends allies and partner countries and the way they're doing that is the same the way they're doing that is the same the way they're doing that is the same political forces that are stopping data political forces that are stopping data political forces that are stopping data centers are also behind all these new centers are also behind all these new centers are also behind all these new export controls on chips so they want to export controls on chips so they want to export controls on chips so they want to make it harder and harder to export make it harder and harder to export make it harder and harder to export chips to more and more countries chips to more and more countries chips to more and more countries including our friends and allies and so including our friends and allies and so including our friends and allies and so there's not going to data centers here. there's not going to data centers here. there's not going to data centers here. There's not going to be data centers in There's not going to be data centers in There's not going to be data centers in our allies. I mean, where are we going our allies. I mean, where are we going our allies. I mean, where are we going to put these things? to put these things? to put these things? >> I mean, those allies have unlimited >> I mean, those allies have unlimited >> I mean, those allies have unlimited energy, Middle East. Like, if you want energy, Middle East. Like, if you want energy, Middle East. Like, if you want some data centers, some data centers, some data centers, >> well, what's funny, Jason, is, you know, >> well, what's funny, Jason, is, you know, >> well, what's funny, Jason, is, you know, we did a bunch of Middle East data we did a bunch of Middle East data we did a bunch of Middle East data center stuff and then it's kind of center stuff and then it's kind of center stuff and then it's kind of stopped. stopped. stopped. Meaning, like there wasn't this growth Meaning, like there wasn't this growth Meaning, like there wasn't this growth that I thought would happen because it's that I thought would happen because it's that I thought would happen because it's a very a very a very conveniently placed geography. It's the conveniently placed geography. It's the conveniently placed geography. It's the Middle East for a reason. And so, you Middle East for a reason. And so, you Middle East for a reason. And so, you know, you can serve 4 billion people know, you can serve 4 billion people know, you can serve 4 billion people very quickly in under 200 milliseconds very quickly in under 200 milliseconds very quickly in under 200 milliseconds from there. from there. from there. >> Instead, what happened was there was >> Instead, what happened was there was >> Instead, what happened was there was this explosion in Asia and specifically this explosion in Asia and specifically this explosion in Asia and specifically in Australia, which kind of surprised me in Australia, which kind of surprised me in Australia, which kind of surprised me because I would have thought that those because I would have thought that those because I would have thought that those folks are a little bit even further out folks are a little bit even further out folks are a little bit even further out on the DSA, you know, far left. I on the DSA, you know, far left. I on the DSA, you know, far left. I thought these things would not have thought these things would not have thought these things would not have happened, but they they were able to get happened, but they they were able to get happened, but they they were able to get big deals done. So, in this weird way, big deals done. So, in this weird way, big deals done. So, in this weird way, you have all of these other countries you have all of these other countries you have all of these other countries kind of running to try to embrace this kind of running to try to embrace this kind of running to try to embrace this stuff quickly. They've done a decent stuff quickly. They've done a decent stuff quickly. They've done a decent job. They're doing stuff to sort of like job. They're doing stuff to sort of like job. They're doing stuff to sort of like displace some of the energy that that is displace some of the energy that that is displace some of the energy that that is needed in the US. But the problem is we needed in the US. But the problem is we needed in the US. But the problem is we need to have enough surplus here because need to have enough surplus here because need to have enough surplus here because this is where most of the commerce is this is where most of the commerce is this is where most of the commerce is going to get created. That really that I going to get created. That really that I going to get created. That really that I think should think should think should >> these are these are luxury regulations. >> these are these are luxury regulations. >> these are these are luxury regulations. Like you can afford if you're New York Like you can afford if you're New York Like you can afford if you're New York State or California to be like, you know State or California to be like, you know State or California to be like, you know what, we don't need this. This is a what, we don't need this. This is a what, we don't need this. This is a luxury for us to have an extra data luxury for us to have an extra data luxury for us to have an extra data center. If you're Australia, you might center. If you're Australia, you might center. If you're Australia, you might really need the money. If you're Texas, really need the money. If you're Texas, really need the money. If you're Texas, you might really want the money. So this you might really want the money. So this you might really want the money. So this is what's so crazy like virtue signaling is what's so crazy like virtue signaling is what's so crazy like virtue signaling only goes so far until your debt to GDP only goes so far until your debt to GDP only goes so far until your debt to GDP is high enough and or your productivity is high enough and or your productivity is high enough and or your productivity is low enough andor your foreign direct is low enough andor your foreign direct is low enough andor your foreign direct investment is low enough where you're investment is low enough where you're investment is low enough where you're like all right you know what screw all like all right you know what screw all like all right you know what screw all that we're just going to build a data that we're just going to build a data that we're just going to build a data center but the the other thing is if you center but the the other thing is if you center but the the other thing is if you saw what happened this week the UAE now saw what happened this week the UAE now saw what happened this week the UAE now is able to import the best-in-class is able to import the best-in-class is able to import the best-in-class leading chips and so to your point Jason leading chips and so to your point Jason leading chips and so to your point Jason I think it restarts the cycle where you I think it restarts the cycle where you I think it restarts the cycle where you have to look very carefully at the have to look very carefully at the have to look very carefully at the Middle East because it's a very Middle East because it's a very Middle East because it's a very attractive place to build these things attractive place to build these things attractive place to build these things >> and by the way you saw >> and by the way you saw >> and by the way you saw the you even if you just if you think the you even if you just if you think the you even if you just if you think about fiber and the milliseconds as about fiber and the milliseconds as about fiber and the milliseconds as you're talking about yes you can get to you're talking about yes you can get to you're talking about yes you can get to the four billion people but I don't know the four billion people but I don't know the four billion people but I don't know if you saw the the giant Starlink if you saw the the giant Starlink if you saw the the giant Starlink versions now they make like a really big versions now they make like a really big versions now they make like a really big version I think you got like one of the version I think you got like one of the version I think you got like one of the enterprise versions but there's like an enterprise versions but there's like an enterprise versions but there's like an even bigger enterprise version and they even bigger enterprise version and they even bigger enterprise version and they can bundle them together and you're can bundle them together and you're can bundle them together and you're starting to get to like 10 gig 20 gig starting to get to like 10 gig 20 gig starting to get to like 10 gig 20 gig setups so that means you could start setups so that means you could start setups so that means you could start putting these things almost anywhere putting these things almost anywhere putting these things almost anywhere >> which gets also like adds another >> which gets also like adds another >> which gets also like adds another >> can we see your clip. The thing that you >> can we see your clip. The thing that you >> can we see your clip. The thing that you were mentioning before, were mentioning before, were mentioning before, >> this is not to your point as prevalent >> this is not to your point as prevalent >> this is not to your point as prevalent in the Middle East where you have in the Middle East where you have in the Middle East where you have monarchies monarchies monarchies and governments that aren't ruled by and governments that aren't ruled by and governments that aren't ruled by democracy, but in democracies, we see democracy, but in democracies, we see democracy, but in democracies, we see this anti-data center movement taking this anti-data center movement taking this anti-data center movement taking hold. This chart is something that hold. This chart is something that hold. This chart is something that for me always kind of played a role in for me always kind of played a role in for me always kind of played a role in my understanding of where the incredible my understanding of where the incredible my understanding of where the incredible anti-GMO sentiment came about in the anti-GMO sentiment came about in the anti-GMO sentiment came about in the United States, United States, United States, >> which is great. Russia Today, this >> which is great. Russia Today, this >> which is great. Russia Today, this Russian media outlet launched in the US Russian media outlet launched in the US Russian media outlet launched in the US in 2010. They were kicked out of the US in 2010. They were kicked out of the US in 2010. They were kicked out of the US by Biden in 2022. by Biden in 2022. by Biden in 2022. And you can see that prior to Russia And you can see that prior to Russia And you can see that prior to Russia today existing in the US, there was no today existing in the US, there was no today existing in the US, there was no anti-GMO sentiment. GMOs were around anti-GMO sentiment. GMOs were around anti-GMO sentiment. GMOs were around since 1996. That's when they first had since 1996. That's when they first had since 1996. That's when they first had their big commercial launch in the US their big commercial launch in the US their big commercial launch in the US and were pretty prevalent for, you know, and were pretty prevalent for, you know, and were pretty prevalent for, you know, 14 plus years before everyone started to 14 plus years before everyone started to 14 plus years before everyone started to think GMOs are bad. We got to get rid of think GMOs are bad. We got to get rid of think GMOs are bad. We got to get rid of GMOs. And you could ask people a hundred GMOs. And you could ask people a hundred GMOs. And you could ask people a hundred different ways very pointedly and different ways very pointedly and different ways very pointedly and specifically about the facts on the specifically about the facts on the specifically about the facts on the matter and the science of GMOs and all matter and the science of GMOs and all matter and the science of GMOs and all this sort of stuff, but everyone always this sort of stuff, but everyone always this sort of stuff, but everyone always had a reason why they didn't want them, had a reason why they didn't want them, had a reason why they didn't want them, similar to what we're hearing now with similar to what we're hearing now with similar to what we're hearing now with AI and data centers. And it turns out AI and data centers. And it turns out AI and data centers. And it turns out that if you track back all of the media that if you track back all of the media that if you track back all of the media that had all this anti-GMO sentiment that had all this anti-GMO sentiment that had all this anti-GMO sentiment that ultimately got picked up by the mom that ultimately got picked up by the mom that ultimately got picked up by the mom bloggers that ultimately got put into bloggers that ultimately got put into bloggers that ultimately got put into social media feeds that ultimately social media feeds that ultimately social media feeds that ultimately everyone just accepted as truth. A lot everyone just accepted as truth. A lot everyone just accepted as truth. A lot of it originated in this Russian media of it originated in this Russian media of it originated in this Russian media push that happened around this era. And push that happened around this era. And push that happened around this era. And you can actually see this on the Google you can actually see this on the Google you can actually see this on the Google trend data that shows GMO and it's kind trend data that shows GMO and it's kind trend data that shows GMO and it's kind of write up. And then as Russia Today of write up. And then as Russia Today of write up. And then as Russia Today started to get cut by different media started to get cut by different media started to get cut by different media outlets and people stopped retweeting outlets and people stopped retweeting outlets and people stopped retweeting them and stopped reflecting them and them and stopped reflecting them and them and stopped reflecting them and stopped writing articles that followed stopped writing articles that followed stopped writing articles that followed Russia Today the anti-GMO sentiment Russia Today the anti-GMO sentiment Russia Today the anti-GMO sentiment declined in the US and I think you can declined in the US and I think you can declined in the US and I think you can see this going back decades. You know see this going back decades. You know see this going back decades. You know there's this there's this there's this effort that the KGB kind of designed effort that the KGB kind of designed effort that the KGB kind of designed during the cold war called directed during the cold war called directed during the cold war called directed measures which was really meant to try measures which was really meant to try measures which was really meant to try and create an influence campaign through and create an influence campaign through and create an influence campaign through affecting media. So putting this kind of affecting media. So putting this kind of affecting media. So putting this kind of propaganda out through foreign media, propaganda out through foreign media, propaganda out through foreign media, particularly targeted western particularly targeted western particularly targeted western democracies. And you know, you could democracies. And you know, you could democracies. And you know, you could argue that maybe you could trace back argue that maybe you could trace back argue that maybe you could trace back what happened in Germany with nuclear what happened in Germany with nuclear what happened in Germany with nuclear energy as being kind of similarly energy as being kind of similarly energy as being kind of similarly originated. But there have been a series originated. But there have been a series originated. But there have been a series of these pushes that seem nonsensical if of these pushes that seem nonsensical if of these pushes that seem nonsensical if you're fairly rational and can have an you're fairly rational and can have an you're fairly rational and can have an actually objective debate about the actually objective debate about the actually objective debate about the scientific merit, the economic merit, scientific merit, the economic merit, scientific merit, the economic merit, the benefits of these technologies. But the benefits of these technologies. But the benefits of these technologies. But for some reason, what we call the for some reason, what we call the for some reason, what we call the activist community become heightened to activist community become heightened to activist community become heightened to them. Say that we've got to get rid of them. Say that we've got to get rid of them. Say that we've got to get rid of them. And everyone's got these different them. And everyone's got these different them. And everyone's got these different unfounded, scientifically unfounded unfounded, scientifically unfounded unfounded, scientifically unfounded reasons why they want to get rid of reasons why they want to get rid of reasons why they want to get rid of them. And you're like, wait a second, them. And you're like, wait a second, them. And you're like, wait a second, how did we end up in this place that how did we end up in this place that how did we end up in this place that we're literally handicapping ourselves. we're literally handicapping ourselves. we're literally handicapping ourselves. And I think we're seeing something And I think we're seeing something And I think we're seeing something similar happening with data centers in similar happening with data centers in similar happening with data centers in the US today. The funding of the NOS's the US today. The funding of the NOS's the US today. The funding of the NOS's as they're being called, the media as they're being called, the media as they're being called, the media that's supporting this, the retweeting that's supporting this, the retweeting that's supporting this, the retweeting of the media. And then you asked people, of the media. And then you asked people, of the media. And then you asked people, there was a poll that came out today, there was a poll that came out today, there was a poll that came out today, something north of 50% of Americans something north of 50% of Americans something north of 50% of Americans believe that data centers increase the believe that data centers increase the believe that data centers increase the cost of water and electricity. Even if cost of water and electricity. Even if cost of water and electricity. Even if the data center is fully recycling the the data center is fully recycling the the data center is fully recycling the water and they're producing their own water and they're producing their own water and they're producing their own electricity, there's still this kind of electricity, there's still this kind of electricity, there's still this kind of repugnant reaction to the data center. repugnant reaction to the data center. repugnant reaction to the data center. And so there has been this like deeply And so there has been this like deeply And so there has been this like deeply sewn psychological sewn psychological sewn psychological shift that's happened in the United shift that's happened in the United shift that's happened in the United States. and and and you know, people States. and and and you know, people States. and and and you know, people have these, well, I hate the rich, I have these, well, I hate the rich, I have these, well, I hate the rich, I hate tech, I hate AI, I don't want any hate tech, I hate AI, I don't want any hate tech, I hate AI, I don't want any of this stuff, I don't want any of this of this stuff, I don't want any of this of this stuff, I don't want any of this stuff, stuff, stuff, >> but where does it all come from? I do >> but where does it all come from? I do >> but where does it all come from? I do worry that there's some degree of kind worry that there's some degree of kind worry that there's some degree of kind of call it foreign, of call it foreign, of call it foreign, >> you know, influence >> you know, influence >> you know, influence >> influence. I I don't love the word >> influence. I I don't love the word >> influence. I I don't love the word influence because everyone kind of influence because everyone kind of influence because everyone kind of everyone captures it up, but there is everyone captures it up, but there is everyone captures it up, but there is some degree of like some degree of like some degree of like >> I would say there's there's foreign >> I would say there's there's foreign >> I would say there's there's foreign interest. Let's let's call it that. interest. Let's let's call it that. interest. Let's let's call it that. >> No, I think it's more than that. So just >> No, I think it's more than that. So just >> No, I think it's more than that. So just one month ago, just one month ago, one month ago, just one month ago, one month ago, just one month ago, >> OpenAI published a blog post called PRC >> OpenAI published a blog post called PRC >> OpenAI published a blog post called PRC linked influence operations are linked influence operations are linked influence operations are targeting AI debates in the US and targeting AI debates in the US and targeting AI debates in the US and Politico covered this and a lot of other Politico covered this and a lot of other Politico covered this and a lot of other sites covered this. Basically what they sites covered this. Basically what they sites covered this. Basically what they are saying and in fact many people are are saying and in fact many people are are saying and in fact many people are saying is that China is behind a lot of saying is that China is behind a lot of saying is that China is behind a lot of these influence campaigns to shape US these influence campaigns to shape US these influence campaigns to shape US attitudes on AI data centers. attitudes on AI data centers. attitudes on AI data centers. >> It makes sense. It makes a lot of sense. >> It makes sense. It makes a lot of sense. >> It makes sense. It makes a lot of sense. and there's going to be a congressional and there's going to be a congressional and there's going to be a congressional investigation of this. It does make investigation of this. It does make investigation of this. It does make sense cuz it is in their interest, sense cuz it is in their interest, sense cuz it is in their interest, right? If they can stop us from building right? If they can stop us from building right? If they can stop us from building this necessary infrastructure, this necessary infrastructure, this necessary infrastructure, >> then that's a way for China to win the >> then that's a way for China to win the >> then that's a way for China to win the AI race. AI race. AI race. >> If they can the market, if they can >> If they can the market, if they can >> If they can the market, if they can incentivize anthropic to, you know, pull incentivize anthropic to, you know, pull incentivize anthropic to, you know, pull the ladder up, if they can kill open the ladder up, if they can kill open the ladder up, if they can kill open source in the United States and source in the United States and source in the United States and constrain demand or the optionality and constrain demand or the optionality and constrain demand or the optionality and choice of lower, cheaper models, think choice of lower, cheaper models, think choice of lower, cheaper models, think about that for a second. at $56 per about that for a second. at $56 per about that for a second. at $56 per million input tokens. I mean, versus 50 million input tokens. I mean, versus 50 million input tokens. I mean, versus 50 cents for the rest of the world. All of cents for the rest of the world. All of cents for the rest of the world. All of a sudden, it doesn't take a company a sudden, it doesn't take a company a sudden, it doesn't take a company that's much much worse than you to beat that's much much worse than you to beat that's much much worse than you to beat you when your cost is 50 to 100x more. you when your cost is 50 to 100x more. you when your cost is 50 to 100x more. >> Right? >> Right? >> Right? >> That's just the math. The math ain't >> That's just the math. The math ain't >> That's just the math. The math ain't mapping. mapping. mapping. >> You know, it's Sasha made the point that >> You know, it's Sasha made the point that >> You know, it's Sasha made the point that these enterprises are not just paying these enterprises are not just paying these enterprises are not just paying for AI with money. They're paying again for AI with money. They're paying again for AI with money. They're paying again by feeding those frontier models their by feeding those frontier models their by feeding those frontier models their proprietary knowledge, right? And all proprietary knowledge, right? And all proprietary knowledge, right? And all their their alpha. So, it's like a their their alpha. So, it's like a their their alpha. So, it's like a double whammy. double whammy. double whammy. >> It's like it's more expensive and you're >> It's like it's more expensive and you're >> It's like it's more expensive and you're potentially mortgaging your future. potentially mortgaging your future. potentially mortgaging your future. >> Look, let's be honest. It is obvious >> Look, let's be honest. It is obvious >> Look, let's be honest. It is obvious where foreign governments have an where foreign governments have an where foreign governments have an enormous incentive to try to manipulate enormous incentive to try to manipulate enormous incentive to try to manipulate and influence the comingings and goings and influence the comingings and goings and influence the comingings and goings in America. in America. in America. I think we should just acknowledge that. I think we should just acknowledge that. I think we should just acknowledge that. The idea that that doesn't happen is The idea that that doesn't happen is The idea that that doesn't happen is very naive. Now the question is we have very naive. Now the question is we have very naive. Now the question is we have to be able to call it out and put our to be able to call it out and put our to be able to call it out and put our finger on it because otherwise what is finger on it because otherwise what is finger on it because otherwise what is clearly happening is that there's a lot clearly happening is that there's a lot clearly happening is that there's a lot of Americans that will just fall for of Americans that will just fall for of Americans that will just fall for this and they will not think from first this and they will not think from first this and they will not think from first principles. principles. principles. >> We have a huge we have a huge moral >> We have a huge we have a huge moral >> We have a huge we have a huge moral panic going on with respect to AI. Look panic going on with respect to AI. Look panic going on with respect to AI. Look when you talk about catastrophes that when you talk about catastrophes that when you talk about catastrophes that could result from AI. What are we could result from AI. What are we could result from AI. What are we talking about? We're talking about talking about? We're talking about talking about? We're talking about things that might happen in the future. things that might happen in the future. things that might happen in the future. Nothing resembling this has happened Nothing resembling this has happened Nothing resembling this has happened yet. you know, even the cyber risk that yet. you know, even the cyber risk that yet. you know, even the cyber risk that everyone's been talking about, everyone's been talking about, everyone's been talking about, >> job loss >> job loss >> job loss >> or job loss, it's like none of it's >> or job loss, it's like none of it's >> or job loss, it's like none of it's turned out to be true. We haven't seen turned out to be true. We haven't seen turned out to be true. We haven't seen any of it so far. But we're on the any of it so far. But we're on the any of it so far. But we're on the threshold, I think, of destroying the threshold, I think, of destroying the threshold, I think, of destroying the crown jewel of our economy, which is the crown jewel of our economy, which is the crown jewel of our economy, which is the system of free market innovation that we system of free market innovation that we system of free market innovation that we have, this culture of rapid iteration of have, this culture of rapid iteration of have, this culture of rapid iteration of anyone with a good idea can go raise anyone with a good idea can go raise anyone with a good idea can go raise risk capital and start their idea, start risk capital and start their idea, start risk capital and start their idea, start their company. And we're on the verge, their company. And we're on the verge, their company. And we're on the verge, you know, now we're talking I think you know, now we're talking I think you know, now we're talking I think about how far the Overton window has about how far the Overton window has about how far the Overton window has moved where we're actually saying that moved where we're actually saying that moved where we're actually saying that creating a FINRA for our industry might creating a FINRA for our industry might creating a FINRA for our industry might be better than all the alternatives. be better than all the alternatives. be better than all the alternatives. FINRA is a bunch of stock brokers FINRA is a bunch of stock brokers FINRA is a bunch of stock brokers writing rules. And when's the last time writing rules. And when's the last time writing rules. And when's the last time there was ever any innovation in that there was ever any innovation in that there was ever any innovation in that sector? I mean, I guess Robin Hood made sector? I mean, I guess Robin Hood made sector? I mean, I guess Robin Hood made trading free. That was it. trading free. That was it. trading free. That was it. >> That was a big one. Yeah. Flow. >> That was a big one. Yeah. Flow. >> That was a big one. Yeah. Flow. >> Okay. But that's not real innovation. >> Okay. But that's not real innovation. >> Okay. But that's not real innovation. Okay. That's like an innovation with Okay. That's like an innovation with Okay. That's like an innovation with respect to a pricing model. And we're respect to a pricing model. And we're respect to a pricing model. And we're actually saying that that might be the actually saying that that might be the actually saying that that might be the least bad alternative is having the least bad alternative is having the least bad alternative is having the equivalent of a bunch of stock brokers equivalent of a bunch of stock brokers equivalent of a bunch of stock brokers creating new rules that all these AI creating new rules that all these AI creating new rules that all these AI companies are not going to have to abide companies are not going to have to abide companies are not going to have to abide by. It's crazy. We are going to we are by. It's crazy. We are going to we are by. It's crazy. We are going to we are going to throw away the lead that we going to throw away the lead that we going to throw away the lead that we have in this. And by the way, Kimmy K3 have in this. And by the way, Kimmy K3 have in this. And by the way, Kimmy K3 just came out and people are saying it's just came out and people are saying it's just came out and people are saying it's it's now right up there. It's very very it's now right up there. It's very very it's now right up there. It's very very close to the frontier. We may have close to the frontier. We may have close to the frontier. We may have months on China if that. and we're going months on China if that. and we're going months on China if that. and we're going to create all these crazy rules and new to create all these crazy rules and new to create all these crazy rules and new regulatory bodies for risks that have regulatory bodies for risks that have regulatory bodies for risks that have not manifested yet. not manifested yet. not manifested yet. >> It's worth monitoring the situation, but >> It's worth monitoring the situation, but >> It's worth monitoring the situation, but it's not worth panicking. Like, you it's not worth panicking. Like, you it's not worth panicking. Like, you should monitor the situation with should monitor the situation with should monitor the situation with self-driving cars and job loss. China is self-driving cars and job loss. China is self-driving cars and job loss. China is certainly doing that. They just stopped certainly doing that. They just stopped certainly doing that. They just stopped giving out permits for self-driving cars giving out permits for self-driving cars giving out permits for self-driving cars as an example because it's going so well as an example because it's going so well as an example because it's going so well and they're losing jobs and and there and they're losing jobs and and there and they're losing jobs and and there are people who are getting there's a are people who are getting there's a are people who are getting there's a little civil unrest. So they just said little civil unrest. So they just said little civil unrest. So they just said we're going to make self-driving cars um we're going to make self-driving cars um we're going to make self-driving cars um licensed and so they're not giving out licensed and so they're not giving out licensed and so they're not giving out any more license moratorium on license any more license moratorium on license any more license moratorium on license for now. It's worth watching Mythos and for now. It's worth watching Mythos and for now. It's worth watching Mythos and if it could hack your system. Palo Alto if it could hack your system. Palo Alto if it could hack your system. Palo Alto Network's checking it out, other people Network's checking it out, other people Network's checking it out, other people checking out. It's all worth monitoring checking out. It's all worth monitoring checking out. It's all worth monitoring but yes it there's no disaster here but yes it there's no disaster here but yes it there's no disaster here today because of AI. nothing's jumping today because of AI. nothing's jumping today because of AI. nothing's jumping out of your chat GPT window. You know, out of your chat GPT window. You know, out of your chat GPT window. You know, the worst case scenario is you blow out the worst case scenario is you blow out the worst case scenario is you blow out some tokens, you know, okay, great. That some tokens, you know, okay, great. That some tokens, you know, okay, great. That that's that's the biggest that's that's the biggest that's that's the biggest >> There's only a handful of companies that >> There's only a handful of companies that >> There's only a handful of companies that are even at the frontier and they all are even at the frontier and they all are even at the frontier and they all have safety testing and red teaming and have safety testing and red teaming and have safety testing and red teaming and all the rest of all the rest of all the rest of >> doing a good job. >> doing a good job. >> doing a good job. >> Yeah, I'm saying stop that. I'm just >> Yeah, I'm saying stop that. I'm just >> Yeah, I'm saying stop that. I'm just questioning whether we need some vast questioning whether we need some vast questioning whether we need some vast regulatory apparatus now to start doing regulatory apparatus now to start doing regulatory apparatus now to start doing all all all >> certainly premature and we did this >> certainly premature and we did this >> certainly premature and we did this because of science fiction and Daario because of science fiction and Daario because of science fiction and Daario saying all jobs are going away. I mean saying all jobs are going away. I mean saying all jobs are going away. I mean that that that was the most ridiculous that that that was the most ridiculous that that that was the most ridiculous thing when he said like he's panicked thing when he said like he's panicked thing when he said like he's panicked that it's going to be 80 or 90% jobs in that it's going to be 80 or 90% jobs in that it's going to be 80 or 90% jobs in 2026. What was his claim? I Nick get the 2026. What was his claim? I Nick get the 2026. What was his claim? I Nick get the exact claim. I think he said 50% of exact claim. I think he said 50% of exact claim. I think he said 50% of jobs. jobs. jobs. >> He said he said with it he said 50% of >> He said he said with it he said 50% of >> He said he said with it he said 50% of entry- level knowledge worker jobs are entry- level knowledge worker jobs are entry- level knowledge worker jobs are going away within 1 to 5 years. That was going away within 1 to 5 years. That was going away within 1 to 5 years. That was one year ago. one year ago. one year ago. So So So >> it's a little ridiculous. Yeah. I mean >> it's a little ridiculous. Yeah. I mean >> it's a little ridiculous. Yeah. I mean it's but he's not even know how to use it's but he's not even know how to use it's but he's not even know how to use the tools yet. the tools yet. the tools yet. >> He's been in a state of panic since >> He's been in a state of panic since >> He's been in a state of panic since GPT2. GPT2. GPT2. >> Yes. Yes. I mean >> Yes. Yes. I mean >> Yes. Yes. I mean >> remember they wanted they wanted to have >> remember they wanted they wanted to have >> remember they wanted they wanted to have uh regulatory approval for models that uh regulatory approval for models that uh regulatory approval for models that use 10 to the 25th flops. Right. And use 10 to the 25th flops. Right. And use 10 to the 25th flops. Right. And every single AI model is like well past every single AI model is like well past every single AI model is like well past that threshold now. that threshold now. that threshold now. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> And we haven't seen any of the the harm. >> And we haven't seen any of the the harm. >> And we haven't seen any of the the harm. Look, they thought that 10 to the 25th Look, they thought that 10 to the 25th Look, they thought that 10 to the 25th flops would be enough compute to create, flops would be enough compute to create, flops would be enough compute to create, you know, the Terminator, you know, to you know, the Terminator, you know, to you know, the Terminator, you know, to create Skynet. create Skynet. create Skynet. >> No offense, Freeberg, but one guy's >> No offense, Freeberg, but one guy's >> No offense, Freeberg, but one guy's panic attacks, one guy's anxiety panic attacks, one guy's anxiety panic attacks, one guy's anxiety condition might have shaped the whole condition might have shaped the whole condition might have shaped the whole course of history here like Dar does course of history here like Dar does course of history here like Dar does Daario have like I'm not making light of Daario have like I'm not making light of Daario have like I'm not making light of it, but does he have an anxiety issue it, but does he have an anxiety issue it, but does he have an anxiety issue where he's like overly concerned about where he's like overly concerned about where he's like overly concerned about this stuff or is it just delusions of this stuff or is it just delusions of this stuff or is it just delusions of grandeur? Come on the pod, Dario. grandeur? Come on the pod, Dario. grandeur? Come on the pod, Dario. Invite's open. Come hang out. I'm sure Invite's open. Come hang out. I'm sure Invite's open. Come hang out. I'm sure he'd love to come on the pod after you he'd love to come on the pod after you he'd love to come on the pod after you just accused him of having a panic just accused him of having a panic just accused him of having a panic attack, [laughter] but attack, [laughter] but attack, [laughter] but >> I mean, he seems like he's in a >> I mean, he seems like he's in a >> I mean, he seems like he's in a perpetual one. perpetual one. perpetual one. >> No, let me tell you, listen, I it could >> No, let me tell you, listen, I it could >> No, let me tell you, listen, I it could be psychological, but I actually think be psychological, but I actually think be psychological, but I actually think that there's a strategy that makes a lot that there's a strategy that makes a lot that there's a strategy that makes a lot of sense, and it's a very simple, of sense, and it's a very simple, of sense, and it's a very simple, straightforward strategy. Number one, straightforward strategy. Number one, straightforward strategy. Number one, brand yourself as a safe AI company. brand yourself as a safe AI company. brand yourself as a safe AI company. Number two, ban unsafe AI. Three, Number two, ban unsafe AI. Three, Number two, ban unsafe AI. Three, profit. profit. profit. >> Yeah, there you go. >> Yeah, there you go. >> Yeah, there you go. >> That's the strategy. Kind of brilliant. >> That's the strategy. Kind of brilliant. >> That's the strategy. Kind of brilliant. All right, everybody. Go to All right, everybody. Go to All right, everybody. Go to allin.com/events allin.com/events allin.com/events and sign up for the Allin Summit in and sign up for the Allin Summit in and sign up for the Allin Summit in September. Scholarships are open. Let's September. Scholarships are open. Let's September. Scholarships are open. Let's do a quick amazing deep robust do a quick amazing deep robust do a quick amazing deep robust science corner with our boy David science corner with our boy David science corner with our boy David Friedber. Before we get into the science Friedber. Before we get into the science Friedber. Before we get into the science corner, I'm going to give a shout out to corner, I'm going to give a shout out to corner, I'm going to give a shout out to Ronnie Dog for adoption. I love family Ronnie Dog for adoption. I love family Ronnie Dog for adoption. I love family dog rescue in Sonoma. Check out his dog rescue in Sonoma. Check out his dog rescue in Sonoma. Check out his Instagram link. God, here he goes Instagram link. God, here he goes Instagram link. God, here he goes >> in the description. This dog needs a >> in the description. This dog needs a >> in the description. This dog needs a home. He was fostered and he lost the home. He was fostered and he lost the home. He was fostered and he lost the foster home. Someone come and grab him. foster home. Someone come and grab him. foster home. Someone come and grab him. He's awesome. All right, let's get into He's awesome. All right, let's get into He's awesome. All right, let's get into this. this. this. >> This is what we're doing. He's trying to >> This is what we're doing. He's trying to >> This is what we're doing. He's trying to >> he's trying to get more Q points. >> he's trying to get more Q points. >> he's trying to get more Q points. >> That dog looks delicious. [laughter] >> That dog looks delicious. [laughter] >> That dog looks delicious. [laughter] >> Gross. >> Gross. >> Gross. >> You don't live in Sri Lanka anymore. >> You don't live in Sri Lanka anymore. >> You don't live in Sri Lanka anymore. Chimal. [laughter] Chimal. [laughter] Chimal. [laughter] >> Yeah, seriously. >> Yeah, seriously. >> Yeah, seriously. >> Sri Lanka taking a spray. >> Sri Lanka taking a spray. >> Sri Lanka taking a spray. >> How do you marinate that dog in Sri >> How do you marinate that dog in Sri >> How do you marinate that dog in Sri Lanka? Lanka? Lanka? >> Do what you got to do in Sri Lanka. Salt >> Do what you got to do in Sri Lanka. Salt >> Do what you got to do in Sri Lanka. Salt and pepper free or do you like something and pepper free or do you like something and pepper free or do you like something else? [laughter] else? [laughter] else? [laughter] You know, just a little salt and pepper. You know, just a little salt and pepper. You know, just a little salt and pepper. >> 12 hour marinade. Do you use bolet? >> 12 hour marinade. Do you use bolet? >> 12 hour marinade. Do you use bolet? >> Oh, do do you like do you like a little >> Oh, do do you like do you like a little >> Oh, do do you like do you like a little yogurt and garam masala? Maybe do a yogurt and garam masala? Maybe do a yogurt and garam masala? Maybe do a little little little >> spicy. Do you guys want to talk about >> spicy. Do you guys want to talk about >> spicy. Do you guys want to talk about reversing aging? reversing aging? reversing aging? >> Yes. So, I want to talk about but I got >> Yes. So, I want to talk about but I got >> Yes. So, I want to talk about but I got to drop. All right, guys. I got to go to to drop. All right, guys. I got to go to to drop. All right, guys. I got to go to the [laughter] EIFFEL TOWER. PAUL, the [laughter] EIFFEL TOWER. PAUL, the [laughter] EIFFEL TOWER. PAUL, >> I'LL COVER IT. THE audience will stick >> I'LL COVER IT. THE audience will stick >> I'LL COVER IT. THE audience will stick around. around. around. >> Science corner. All right. So, Jamal, >> Science corner. All right. So, Jamal, >> Science corner. All right. So, Jamal, you can drop two if you want. I'll cover you can drop two if you want. I'll cover you can drop two if you want. I'll cover science corner solo. So in the past science corner solo. So in the past science corner solo. So in the past we've talked about Yamanaka factors we've talked about Yamanaka factors we've talked about Yamanaka factors which are these proteins that can go which are these proteins that can go which are these proteins that can go into cells and reverse the aging of the into cells and reverse the aging of the into cells and reverse the aging of the cell and the cell starts to act young cell and the cell starts to act young cell and the cell starts to act young again. Pretty amazing. And uh there's a again. Pretty amazing. And uh there's a again. Pretty amazing. And uh there's a lot of advancement happening on that lot of advancement happening on that lot of advancement happening on that front. But this paper that came out just front. But this paper that came out just front. But this paper that came out just this week that everyone's kind of going this week that everyone's kind of going this week that everyone's kind of going crazy about was put out uh jointly by crazy about was put out uh jointly by crazy about was put out uh jointly by Calico which is Google's kind of you Calico which is Google's kind of you Calico which is Google's kind of you know age reversal startup that's super know age reversal startup that's super know age reversal startup that's super secretive that they're not allowed to secretive that they're not allowed to secretive that they're not allowed to talk about in partnership with a group talk about in partnership with a group talk about in partnership with a group called Revel Pharma. And what they called Revel Pharma. And what they called Revel Pharma. And what they focused on was what's called the focused on was what's called the focused on was what's called the extracellular matrix. The parts outside extracellular matrix. The parts outside extracellular matrix. The parts outside of the cell that age. And and what does of the cell that age. And and what does of the cell that age. And and what does aging actually look like outside of the aging actually look like outside of the aging actually look like outside of the cell? Well, over time, sugars and fats cell? Well, over time, sugars and fats cell? Well, over time, sugars and fats bind to proteins in the area between our bind to proteins in the area between our bind to proteins in the area between our cells and they accumulate. They don't cells and they accumulate. They don't cells and they accumulate. They don't get cleaned off. And as they accumulate get cleaned off. And as they accumulate get cleaned off. And as they accumulate and they don't get cleaned off, they and they don't get cleaned off, they and they don't get cleaned off, they make it harder for your body to clean make it harder for your body to clean make it harder for your body to clean out that area, to maintain that area. It out that area, to maintain that area. It out that area, to maintain that area. It causes stickiness. It causes binding. causes stickiness. It causes binding. causes stickiness. It causes binding. And that reduces mobility. and And that reduces mobility. and And that reduces mobility. and ultimately leads to things like wrinkles ultimately leads to things like wrinkles ultimately leads to things like wrinkles in our skin, makes it harder for our in our skin, makes it harder for our in our skin, makes it harder for our joints to move. joints to move. joints to move. >> Is that what visceral fat is? >> Is that what visceral fat is? >> Is that what visceral fat is? >> No, it's called glycation. And so it's >> No, it's called glycation. And so it's >> No, it's called glycation. And so it's the binding of sugar and fat to the the binding of sugar and fat to the the binding of sugar and fat to the proteins that sit in that extra cellular proteins that sit in that extra cellular proteins that sit in that extra cellular >> in between the cells. Exactly. And so >> in between the cells. Exactly. And so >> in between the cells. Exactly. And so it's that whole gunky area in between it's that whole gunky area in between it's that whole gunky area in between the cells that when you're young works the cells that when you're young works the cells that when you're young works well, everything's smooth. The proteins well, everything's smooth. The proteins well, everything's smooth. The proteins get replaced if they break down. And as get replaced if they break down. And as get replaced if they break down. And as you get older, sugars and fats kind of you get older, sugars and fats kind of you get older, sugars and fats kind of stick to these proteins, block them up. stick to these proteins, block them up. stick to these proteins, block them up. And as they get blocked up, your body And as they get blocked up, your body And as they get blocked up, your body can't repair them. It can't clean them. can't repair them. It can't clean them. can't repair them. It can't clean them. And more importantly, it changes the And more importantly, it changes the And more importantly, it changes the structure and the shape of those structure and the shape of those structure and the shape of those proteins. So things like collagen that proteins. So things like collagen that proteins. So things like collagen that are far apart stick together. And that are far apart stick together. And that are far apart stick together. And that causes things like wrinkles and that causes things like wrinkles and that causes things like wrinkles and that causes immobility. And it also causes causes immobility. And it also causes causes immobility. And it also causes inflammation because then those proteins inflammation because then those proteins inflammation because then those proteins kind of look different than they're kind of look different than they're kind of look different than they're supposed to. And your body starts to supposed to. And your body starts to supposed to. And your body starts to attack them. And that activates attack them. And that activates attack them. And that activates inflammation. And that's why we get one inflammation. And that's why we get one inflammation. And that's why we get one of the reasons why we get more and more of the reasons why we get more and more of the reasons why we get more and more inflammation as we get older. And so one inflammation as we get older. And so one inflammation as we get older. And so one of the key what are called advanced of the key what are called advanced of the key what are called advanced glycation end products that's the term glycation end products that's the term glycation end products that's the term for these things is called CML. CML is for these things is called CML. CML is for these things is called CML. CML is kind of the predominant molecule that kind of the predominant molecule that kind of the predominant molecule that that gets formed in this extracellular that gets formed in this extracellular that gets formed in this extracellular matrix that's driving aging and nothing matrix that's driving aging and nothing matrix that's driving aging and nothing breaks it down. So these scientists set breaks it down. So these scientists set breaks it down. So these scientists set out to try and create an enzyme. An out to try and create an enzyme. An out to try and create an enzyme. An enzyme is a protein that breaks enzyme is a protein that breaks enzyme is a protein that breaks something down um that can break down something down um that can break down something down um that can break down CML. And remember, a protein is just a CML. And remember, a protein is just a CML. And remember, a protein is just a series of amino acids. And those amino series of amino acids. And those amino series of amino acids. And those amino acids are programmed by DNA. So you can acids are programmed by DNA. So you can acids are programmed by DNA. So you can put three letters of DNA to make an put three letters of DNA to make an put three letters of DNA to make an amino acid. So you can literally just amino acid. So you can literally just amino acid. So you can literally just print DNA and then put it in a bacteria print DNA and then put it in a bacteria print DNA and then put it in a bacteria to print proteins and then test those to print proteins and then test those to print proteins and then test those proteins to see what they do. That's the proteins to see what they do. That's the proteins to see what they do. That's the the modern kind of era of kind of the modern kind of era of kind of the modern kind of era of kind of protein synthesis and protein testing. protein synthesis and protein testing. protein synthesis and protein testing. And so these guys kind of went out and And so these guys kind of went out and And so these guys kind of went out and they took the target which is CML and they took the target which is CML and they took the target which is CML and tried to figure out okay how do we tried to figure out okay how do we tried to figure out okay how do we actually degrade CML clear that actually degrade CML clear that actually degrade CML clear that extracellular matrix and reverse aging. extracellular matrix and reverse aging. extracellular matrix and reverse aging. And they started with AlphaFold and they And they started with AlphaFold and they And they started with AlphaFold and they used Alphafold to find a protein that used Alphafold to find a protein that used Alphafold to find a protein that could bind to CML and activate an could bind to CML and activate an could bind to CML and activate an enzyatic or process that would break it enzyatic or process that would break it enzyatic or process that would break it down. And then they took that protein down. And then they took that protein down. And then they took that protein from AlphaFold that comes out of a from AlphaFold that comes out of a from AlphaFold that comes out of a bacteria. They produced it. They started bacteria. They produced it. They started bacteria. They produced it. They started to test it and then they started to find to test it and then they started to find to test it and then they started to find some of the binders or the parts of that some of the binders or the parts of that some of the binders or the parts of that protein that they could make better and protein that they could make better and protein that they could make better and they used you know DNA programming to they used you know DNA programming to they used you know DNA programming to change it and they made hundreds and change it and they made hundreds and change it and they made hundreds and then thousands of variants of it to then thousands of variants of it to then thousands of variants of it to measure activity which is how good is it measure activity which is how good is it measure activity which is how good is it at breaking down the CML and they did at breaking down the CML and they did at breaking down the CML and they did this recursively five different cycles this recursively five different cycles this recursively five different cycles and then eventually they tested it once and then eventually they tested it once and then eventually they tested it once they' kind of gotten it breaking down they' kind of gotten it breaking down they' kind of gotten it breaking down the CML really well in a test tube they the CML really well in a test tube they the CML really well in a test tube they started to test it on the proteins that started to test it on the proteins that started to test it on the proteins that we would find in our body, cassine, we would find in our body, cassine, we would find in our body, cassine, collagen, retinal proteins which are in collagen, retinal proteins which are in collagen, retinal proteins which are in your eye, hemoglobin, your eye, hemoglobin, your eye, hemoglobin, and they were able to get rid of 52 to and they were able to get rid of 52 to and they were able to get rid of 52 to 97% of the CML, just degraded away. 97% of the CML, just degraded away. 97% of the CML, just degraded away. >> And then they um they found several >> And then they um they found several >> And then they um they found several sites where they were able to degrade sites where they were able to degrade sites where they were able to degrade over 90%. And then they took actual over 90%. And then they took actual over 90%. And then they took actual human skin from elderly patients that human skin from elderly patients that human skin from elderly patients that had donated their skin and they put this had donated their skin and they put this had donated their skin and they put this enzyme onto that skin and they were able enzyme onto that skin and they were able enzyme onto that skin and they were able to eliminate 55% of the CML on the skin to eliminate 55% of the CML on the skin to eliminate 55% of the CML on the skin which basically reversed the skin's age which basically reversed the skin's age which basically reversed the skin's age down to the age of a 31y old. This is down to the age of a 31y old. This is down to the age of a 31y old. This is from greater than 70 year old patients from greater than 70 year old patients from greater than 70 year old patients just by putting this enzyme on the skin. just by putting this enzyme on the skin. just by putting this enzyme on the skin. And so it's kind of a groundbreaking And so it's kind of a groundbreaking And so it's kind of a groundbreaking demonstration of combination of demonstration of combination of demonstration of combination of alphafold what's called directed alphafold what's called directed alphafold what's called directed evolution where you change the order of evolution where you change the order of evolution where you change the order of the DNA that changes the structure of the DNA that changes the structure of the DNA that changes the structure of the protein to test different proteins the protein to test different proteins the protein to test different proteins do high throughput screening and do high throughput screening and do high throughput screening and ultimately make a novel protein that ultimately make a novel protein that ultimately make a novel protein that doesn't exist in nature today that can doesn't exist in nature today that can doesn't exist in nature today that can do something pretty profound for human do something pretty profound for human do something pretty profound for human health. And now the next set of health. And now the next set of health. And now the next set of questions is okay well great this enzyme questions is okay well great this enzyme questions is okay well great this enzyme is awesome. How are we going to get it is awesome. How are we going to get it is awesome. How are we going to get it into our bodies? How are we going to get into our bodies? How are we going to get into our bodies? How are we going to get it into that extracellular matrix? Is it it into that extracellular matrix? Is it it into that extracellular matrix? Is it going to be a cream? Is it going to be a going to be a cream? Is it going to be a going to be a cream? Is it going to be a shot, a supplement? Could we eventually shot, a supplement? Could we eventually shot, a supplement? Could we eventually take an RNA shot that makes the protein take an RNA shot that makes the protein take an RNA shot that makes the protein inside of our body and starts to do the inside of our body and starts to do the inside of our body and starts to do the degradation from within? A lot of degradation from within? A lot of degradation from within? A lot of questions kind of still to be answered, questions kind of still to be answered, questions kind of still to be answered, but it really, I think, lights a great but it really, I think, lights a great but it really, I think, lights a great path forward. path forward. path forward. >> Amazing >> Amazing >> Amazing >> for these novel therapies that we're >> for these novel therapies that we're >> for these novel therapies that we're developing. It's awesome. I developing. It's awesome. I developing. It's awesome. I mean, dude, likeing, mean, dude, likeing, mean, dude, likeing, >> you know, all my I got all these joint >> you know, all my I got all these joint >> you know, all my I got all these joint pains in my hip and my shoulder now. pains in my hip and my shoulder now. pains in my hip and my shoulder now. Like everything you can feel yourself Like everything you can feel yourself Like everything you can feel yourself getting older. getting older. getting older. >> Well, that's I I will tell you this >> Well, that's I I will tell you this >> Well, that's I I will tell you this right now. That will not be the first right now. That will not be the first right now. That will not be the first market. The first market will be market. The first market will be market. The first market will be cosmetic and cosmetic and cosmetic and >> cosmetic skin. Yeah. >> cosmetic skin. Yeah. >> cosmetic skin. Yeah. >> It will be a trillion dollar market. If >> It will be a trillion dollar market. If >> It will be a trillion dollar market. If if you can create a cream, if you can create a cream, if you can create a cream, >> dude, if you could put this enzyme >> dude, if you could put this enzyme >> dude, if you could put this enzyme literally on your skin and have it literally on your skin and have it literally on your skin and have it absorb absorb absorb >> a cream. >> a cream. >> a cream. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Game over. It's it's a that that alone >> Game over. It's it's a that that alone >> Game over. It's it's a that that alone is $2 trillion. is $2 trillion. is $2 trillion. >> But I mean, dude, AI, let's just talk >> But I mean, dude, AI, let's just talk >> But I mean, dude, AI, let's just talk about applications of AI, why it's about applications of AI, why it's about applications of AI, why it's actually awesome that everyone should be actually awesome that everyone should be actually awesome that everyone should be able to agree on and you can't be able to agree on and you can't be able to agree on and you can't be convinced by some foreign scop. This is convinced by some foreign scop. This is convinced by some foreign scop. This is awesome. I mean, this was alpha awesome. I mean, this was alpha awesome. I mean, this was alpha full used to discover this thing and full used to discover this thing and full used to discover this thing and evolve it and drive this outcome. evolve it and drive this outcome. evolve it and drive this outcome. Everyone can benefit from it. It's just Everyone can benefit from it. It's just Everyone can benefit from it. It's just so profound that we have this tool at so profound that we have this tool at so profound that we have this tool at our disposal in this day and age. our disposal in this day and age. our disposal in this day and age. >> I think it's pretty awesome. Anyway, >> I think it's pretty awesome. Anyway, >> I think it's pretty awesome. Anyway, thanks for sticking around for Science thanks for sticking around for Science thanks for sticking around for Science Corner. Corner. Corner. >> Guys, I love you. >> Guys, I love you. >> Guys, I love you. >> All right, bro. Love you, too. >> All right, bro. Love you, too. >> All right, bro. Love you, too. >> We'll let [music] your winners ride. >> [music] >> [music] >> We open sourced it to the fans and >> We open sourced it to the fans and >> We open sourced it to the fans and they've just gone crazy with it. they've just gone crazy with it. they've just gone crazy with it. >> Queen of >> Queen of >> Queen of [music] besties are besties are my dog taking your [music] driveways. >> Oh man, my habitasher will meet. >> Oh man, my habitasher will meet. >> We should all just get a room and just >> We should all just get a room and just >> We should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy cuz they're all have one big huge orgy cuz they're all have one big huge orgy cuz they're all just useless. It's like this like just useless. It's like this like just useless. It's like this like [music] sexual tension that they just [music] sexual tension that they just [music] sexual tension that they just need to release. >> Your feet. >> Your feet. [laughter] [laughter] [laughter] >> We need to get merch. >> We need to get merch. >> We need to get merch. >> I'm going all in. [music]