1% better

AI Sovereignty Wars, Palantir-Nvidia Deal, SCOTUS Birthright Ruling, Newsom’s CA Budget Lie

The All-In Podcast discusses Palantir and Nvidia's sovereign AI partnership, emphasizing the critical importance of AI sovereignty for enterprises.

1h 42m

Summary published by , updated .

All-In Podcast

Key Takeaway

Stop renting intelligence from companies that will become your competitors. Technical customers want control over their compute, models, data stack, and proprietary knowledge. Using frontier AI labs like Anthropic or OpenAI means transferring your competitive advantage to providers who are systematically launching products in the exact categories where their customers find success. The solution: deploy open-source models on your own hardware with US-based data centers. You'll pay 16x less, maintain complete data sovereignty, and protect your business from being commoditized.

Episode Overview

The All-In Podcast discusses Palantir and Nvidia's sovereign AI partnership, emphasizing the critical importance of AI sovereignty for enterprises. Alex Karp's manifesto warns companies against transferring proprietary data to frontier AI labs that use customer insights to build competing products. The hosts examine how Anthropic has blindsided partners like Figma by launching vertical apps in their categories, and why enterprises must shift to open-source models deployed on their own infrastructure to protect competitive advantages.

Main Insights

Intelligence Sovereignty vs. Privacy

Intelligence sovereignty is fundamentally different from privacy. Privacy means others can't see your data; intelligence sovereignty means others can't use AI to analyze your data and tell you how to interpret the world. When you use frontier AI models, you're not just risking data leakage—you're allowing external companies to shape your business decisions and potentially compete against you with insights derived from your own proprietary information.

The Frontier Lab Playbook: Watch, Learn, Compete

Anthropic and OpenAI follow a Microsoft-like strategy: dominate the model layer (the 'operating system'), then systematically capture the most lucrative verticals. They watch where value is created on top of their models, then move in directly to compete. Anthropic launched Claude Code after seeing Cursor's success, Claude Design after working with Figma, and vertical apps in security, legal, and finance—all categories previously served by companies building on their platform.

The True Cost of 'Free' AI Credits

When companies like OpenAI offer $2 million in free tokens to startups, it's not generosity—it's competitive intelligence gathering. There is no free pizza or free beer. These offers give frontier labs direct access to founders' latest innovations and insights about emerging market opportunities, which they can then incorporate into their own product roadmaps. History shows this pattern with Microsoft in the 80s, Facebook in the 2000s, and now AI labs in the 2020s.

Open-Source Economics Are Compelling

Real-world testing shows that wrapping open-source models with proper orchestration tools delivers 16.4x cost savings compared to frontier models, with only 3x slower processing time. For enterprise tasks like code migration, this means paying dramatically less for similar quality. As token costs continue to decline 90% year-over-year, open-source models will become essentially free while maintaining competitive performance with frontier labs.

The Emerging AI Infrastructure Model

The AI deployment model is evolving from 'large hubs, large spokes' to 'large hubs, medium hubs, distributed spokes.' Companies will maintain some workloads on major clouds, but increasingly deploy their own hardware clusters for training proprietary models and running inference locally. This distributed approach allows enterprises to leverage their unique data advantages without commoditizing themselves through shared model providers.

Notable Quotes

"Data retention is your treasure. Transfer it at your own peril. Transferring that data hands over access to your pre-existing winning plays and yields the means of production for new ones."

Alex Karp

"Are we really going to outsource the battlefield of this country to the consensus view in Silicon Valley? That is effing insane."

Alex Karp

"You can't rent intelligence from the same place that rents it to your competitor. You just can't. It's just stupid. It will overflow. It will go over the wall in your competitor's lap."

Chamath Palihapitiya

"If you partner with any of these people, they will slit your throat and take your business wholesale. There is nothing to discuss here. Don't trust them. Use your own models."

Jason Calacanis

"Everyone's realizing they're better off developing their own weights and their own models using either an open-source basis. In order to compete in a world of commoditizing knowledge and commoditizing capabilities, you have to leverage the core differentiating assets that you have."

David Friedberg

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Audit Your AI Data Exposure Immediately

    Review every AI service your company uses and identify what proprietary data, customer insights, or trade secrets are being shared with frontier model providers. Calculate the competitive risk of this data being used to train models that could power your competitors or the provider's own competing products.

  • 2
    Experiment with Open-Source Models on Your Infrastructure

    Test open-source models like Nvidia's Neotron or other leading open models using tools like Open Router. Run side-by-side comparisons with your current frontier model usage for typical enterprise tasks. Measure cost differences, performance gaps, and speed variations to understand the actual trade-offs.

  • 3
    Develop a Hybrid AI Deployment Strategy

    Create a 70/20/10 allocation plan: 70% on trusted cloud infrastructure for scale, 20% on your own local hardware for sensitive workflows, and 10% experimenting with alternative providers. This distributed approach balances cost, performance, and data sovereignty while reducing single-vendor lock-in.

  • 4
    Build Proprietary Model Capabilities

    Start the journey toward owning your AI stack completely. Begin by using wrapper services and orchestration tools around open-source models, then progress to fine-tuning models on your proprietary data, and eventually fork and maintain your own models deployed on on-premise hardware for critical business functions.

Guides that reference this episode

See how this episode fits with recommendations from other leading podcasts.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

All right, everybody. Welcome back to All right, everybody. Welcome back to the number one podcast in the world. the number one podcast in the world. the number one podcast in the world. It's your favorite podcast. It's your It's your favorite podcast. It's your It's your favorite podcast. It's your podcast's favorite podcast. It's the podcast's favorite podcast. It's the podcast's favorite podcast. It's the All-In podcast. Episode 279. With me, All-In podcast. Episode 279. With me, All-In podcast. Episode 279. With me, Fredberg, Sax, Chimath, you know the the Fredberg, Sax, Chimath, you know the the Fredberg, Sax, Chimath, you know the the squad. You know the squad. We're here. squad. You know the squad. We're here. squad. You know the squad. We're here. It's the summer and we're ready to rock It's the summer and we're ready to rock It's the summer and we're ready to rock and roll. We got a power docket. We got and roll. We got a power docket. We got and roll. We got a power docket. We got a rocket docket. Palunteer and Nvidia a rocket docket. Palunteer and Nvidia a rocket docket. Palunteer and Nvidia have announced a sovereign AI have announced a sovereign AI have announced a sovereign AI partnership. Where have we heard that partnership. Where have we heard that partnership. Where have we heard that term before? Palanteer is going to use term before? Palanteer is going to use term before? Palanteer is going to use Nvidia's Neotron. Neotron like the Pixar Nvidia's Neotron. Neotron like the Pixar Nvidia's Neotron. Neotron like the Pixar film open models to build a custom film open models to build a custom film open models to build a custom frontier quality model to serve the US frontier quality model to serve the US frontier quality model to serve the US government. Palanteer is calling this government. Palanteer is calling this government. Palanteer is calling this new platform sovereign AI operating new platform sovereign AI operating new platform sovereign AI operating system. The US government agencies will system. The US government agencies will system. The US government agencies will own the hardware, the data, and the own the hardware, the data, and the own the hardware, the data, and the model waits. Palanteer also shared a model waits. Palanteer also shared a model waits. Palanteer also shared a viral tweet manifesto laying out the viral tweet manifesto laying out the viral tweet manifesto laying out the concept, "Data retention is your concept, "Data retention is your concept, "Data retention is your treasure. Transfer it at your own peril. treasure. Transfer it at your own peril. treasure. Transfer it at your own peril. Transferring that data hands over access Transferring that data hands over access Transferring that data hands over access to your pre-existing winning plays and to your pre-existing winning plays and to your pre-existing winning plays and yields the means of production for new yields the means of production for new yields the means of production for new ones. CEO Alex Karp went on CNBC to ones. CEO Alex Karp went on CNBC to ones. CEO Alex Karp went on CNBC to announce the partnership in a classic announce the partnership in a classic announce the partnership in a classic Karp Karp Karp Robin Williams style monologue. Here's a Robin Williams style monologue. Here's a Robin Williams style monologue. Here's a clip from his 20inut interview where he clip from his 20inut interview where he clip from his 20inut interview where he where he basically went after the where he basically went after the where he basically went after the frontier models like Anthropic. Play the frontier models like Anthropic. Play the frontier models like Anthropic. Play the clip. Our clients are just to say clip. Our clients are just to say clip. Our clients are just to say they're unhappy with the Frontier Labs they're unhappy with the Frontier Labs they're unhappy with the Frontier Labs is to say I'm welcome at the Berkeley is to say I'm welcome at the Berkeley is to say I'm welcome at the Berkeley faculty. It's like there's just a level faculty. It's like there's just a level faculty. It's like there's just a level of discomfort and loss of trust. Sam and of discomfort and loss of trust. Sam and of discomfort and loss of trust. Sam and and and Daario, there's nothing more fun and and Daario, there's nothing more fun and and Daario, there's nothing more fun than debating Daario in private. So this than debating Daario in private. So this than debating Daario in private. So this is I'm not throwing shade at them, but is I'm not throwing shade at them, but is I'm not throwing shade at them, but something has gone completely wrong. And something has gone completely wrong. And something has gone completely wrong. And the basic view among enterprises in this the basic view among enterprises in this the basic view among enterprises in this country is I'm going to chill lax uh and country is I'm going to chill lax uh and country is I'm going to chill lax uh and waste my time with tokens. I'm going to waste my time with tokens. I'm going to waste my time with tokens. I'm going to get no value and they're going to get my get no value and they're going to get my get no value and they're going to get my IP. When the do department of war goes IP. When the do department of war goes IP. When the do department of war goes to you and says I need this application, to you and says I need this application, to you and says I need this application, do they get to control the weights to do do they get to control the weights to do do they get to control the weights to do it or do you get to control the weights? it or do you get to control the weights? it or do you get to control the weights? Are we really going to outsource the Are we really going to outsource the Are we really going to outsource the battlefield of this country to the battlefield of this country to the battlefield of this country to the consensus view in Silicon Valley? That consensus view in Silicon Valley? That consensus view in Silicon Valley? That is effing insane. is effing insane. is effing insane. >> All right. And so some folks uh refer to >> All right. And so some folks uh refer to >> All right. And so some folks uh refer to this as a televised nervous breakdown. this as a televised nervous breakdown. this as a televised nervous breakdown. We here at Allink call that Alex Garp on We here at Allink call that Alex Garp on We here at Allink call that Alex Garp on a Tuesday. a Tuesday. a Tuesday. And we talked about this Chimath uh Sax And we talked about this Chimath uh Sax And we talked about this Chimath uh Sax Freedber. We talked about this a whole Freedber. We talked about this a whole Freedber. We talked about this a whole bunch back in February. bunch back in February. bunch back in February. I coined the term intelligence I coined the term intelligence I coined the term intelligence sovereignty here. Here's your victory sovereignty here. Here's your victory sovereignty here. Here's your victory fact. Do I want to give all of the fact. Do I want to give all of the fact. Do I want to give all of the secrets in our organization, every piece secrets in our organization, every piece secrets in our organization, every piece of intellectual property to Sam Alman of intellectual property to Sam Alman of intellectual property to Sam Alman who's got to make a billion dollars a who's got to make a billion dollars a who's got to make a billion dollars a year to keep up with his spend, right? year to keep up with his spend, right? year to keep up with his spend, right? He's going to build every application. He's going to build every application. He's going to build every application. I've been talking about AI sovereignty I've been talking about AI sovereignty I've been talking about AI sovereignty here for a bit just in terms of how much here for a bit just in terms of how much here for a bit just in terms of how much more coste effective it is and how more coste effective it is and how more coste effective it is and how you're not training other people's AIs you're not training other people's AIs you're not training other people's AIs with your knowledge and your insights. with your knowledge and your insights. with your knowledge and your insights. This is why it's super important that This is why it's super important that This is why it's super important that open-source open- source agents and open-source open- source agents and open-source open- source agents and local hardware be able to run these local hardware be able to run these local hardware be able to run these models and that consumers and companies models and that consumers and companies models and that consumers and companies learn how to roll their own language learn how to roll their own language learn how to roll their own language models. The intelligent sovereignty is models. The intelligent sovereignty is models. The intelligent sovereignty is different than privacy. Privacy is oh, different than privacy. Privacy is oh, different than privacy. Privacy is oh, you can't see my photos. You can't peek you can't see my photos. You can't peek you can't see my photos. You can't peek into my notes app and what I wrote there into my notes app and what I wrote there into my notes app and what I wrote there in my journal. Intelligent sovereignty in my journal. Intelligent sovereignty in my journal. Intelligent sovereignty is you can't tell me what to think. You is you can't tell me what to think. You is you can't tell me what to think. You can't use your AI to analyze my photos, can't use your AI to analyze my photos, can't use your AI to analyze my photos, to analyze my emails, to analyze my to analyze my emails, to analyze my to analyze my emails, to analyze my messages, and tell me how to interpret messages, and tell me how to interpret messages, and tell me how to interpret the world. That's actually going to be the world. That's actually going to be the world. That's actually going to be the next key piece here. All right. And the next key piece here. All right. And the next key piece here. All right. And uh Sax, you are in your long post era. uh Sax, you are in your long post era. uh Sax, you are in your long post era. Another long post this week from you on Another long post this week from you on Another long post this week from you on this very topic. And obviously as uh this very topic. And obviously as uh this very topic. And obviously as uh AISAR there for the first half of the AISAR there for the first half of the AISAR there for the first half of the Trump administration, you uh been very Trump administration, you uh been very Trump administration, you uh been very involved and very close to this. I would involved and very close to this. I would involved and very close to this. I would love to hear inside I'd love to hear love to hear inside I'd love to hear love to hear inside I'd love to hear your take on this and your long posts your take on this and your long posts your take on this and your long posts over 300 words. You can follow over 300 words. You can follow over 300 words. You can follow x.com/davidsax, x.com/davidsax, x.com/davidsax, but also like the palace intrigue here but also like the palace intrigue here but also like the palace intrigue here and what this means in terms of and what this means in terms of and what this means in terms of the relationship with the government, the relationship with the government, the relationship with the government, which we're going to get into in our which we're going to get into in our which we're going to get into in our second story. second story. second story. Well, look, Jay Cal, I got to give you Well, look, Jay Cal, I got to give you Well, look, Jay Cal, I got to give you some credit there. The first part of some credit there. The first part of some credit there. The first part of your take was spot on. After that, it your take was spot on. After that, it your take was spot on. After that, it was kind of diminishing returns. I'm not was kind of diminishing returns. I'm not was kind of diminishing returns. I'm not sure why we had to listen to the next 30 sure why we had to listen to the next 30 sure why we had to listen to the next 30 seconds of it, but [laughter] anyway, seconds of it, but [laughter] anyway, seconds of it, but [laughter] anyway, uh, it started off really strong. But uh, it started off really strong. But uh, it started off really strong. But let's go back to the supposed crash out let's go back to the supposed crash out let's go back to the supposed crash out by Karp on CNBC. It was nothing of the by Karp on CNBC. It was nothing of the by Karp on CNBC. It was nothing of the sort. It was all these legacy media sort. It was all these legacy media sort. It was all these legacy media types making that claim. And that's the types making that claim. And that's the types making that claim. And that's the first clue that he's actually saying first clue that he's actually saying first clue that he's actually saying something insightful and maybe kind of something insightful and maybe kind of something insightful and maybe kind of brilliant. And I think the thing that he brilliant. And I think the thing that he brilliant. And I think the thing that he said that I hadn't really thought about said that I hadn't really thought about said that I hadn't really thought about in quite those terms is he started in quite those terms is he started in quite those terms is he started talking about AI safety in the talking about AI safety in the talking about AI safety in the enterprise and what that really looks enterprise and what that really looks enterprise and what that really looks like. And what he said is that what like. And what he said is that what like. And what he said is that what technical customers want is control over technical customers want is control over technical customers want is control over their compute, their models, their data their compute, their models, their data their compute, their models, their data stack and their alpha, meaning their stack and their alpha, meaning their stack and their alpha, meaning their proprietary knowledge. They want to know proprietary knowledge. They want to know proprietary knowledge. They want to know they own the means of production, he they own the means of production, he they own the means of production, he said, and it's not being transferred to said, and it's not being transferred to said, and it's not being transferred to someone else. And what he's referring to someone else. And what he's referring to someone else. And what he's referring to there is that these enterprises are at there is that these enterprises are at there is that these enterprises are at risk of transferring their knowledge, risk of transferring their knowledge, risk of transferring their knowledge, their knowhow, their trade secrets, their knowhow, their trade secrets, their knowhow, their trade secrets, their customer data to these model their customer data to these model their customer data to these model providers who might eventually decide to providers who might eventually decide to providers who might eventually decide to compete with them. Like you said, JCAL compete with them. Like you said, JCAL compete with them. Like you said, JCAL and you can see that enterprises are and you can see that enterprises are and you can see that enterprises are waking up to this threat and they're not waking up to this threat and they're not waking up to this threat and they're not happy about it. And I think KARP is happy about it. And I think KARP is happy about it. And I think KARP is exactly right about that. Now, exactly right about that. Now, exactly right about that. Now, I think this is a really interesting I think this is a really interesting I think this is a really interesting take on AI safety because what safety take on AI safety because what safety take on AI safety because what safety means for an enterprise is again that means for an enterprise is again that means for an enterprise is again that they get to control their own data, they get to control their own data, they get to control their own data, their model weights, their compute. So, their model weights, their compute. So, their model weights, their compute. So, a frontier lab can't hoover up their a frontier lab can't hoover up their a frontier lab can't hoover up their proprietary knowledge, their alpha and proprietary knowledge, their alpha and proprietary knowledge, their alpha and turn it into their next product. And if turn it into their next product. And if turn it into their next product. And if you don't think that can happen, just you don't think that can happen, just you don't think that can happen, just look at what happened to Figma. So look at what happened to Figma. So look at what happened to Figma. So according to the information, Anthropic according to the information, Anthropic according to the information, Anthropic quote unquote blindsided its then quote unquote blindsided its then quote unquote blindsided its then business partner with the launch of business partner with the launch of business partner with the launch of Clawude Design. So this was a new Clawude Design. So this was a new Clawude Design. So this was a new vertical app that Anthropic launched to vertical app that Anthropic launched to vertical app that Anthropic launched to compete in the design category. And compete in the design category. And compete in the design category. And Figma's founder said that Anthropic had Figma's founder said that Anthropic had Figma's founder said that Anthropic had not been completely honest with them. not been completely honest with them. not been completely honest with them. Enthropic chief product officer had Enthropic chief product officer had Enthropic chief product officer had actually even served on Figma's board actually even served on Figma's board actually even served on Figma's board and didn't resign until 3 days before and didn't resign until 3 days before and didn't resign until 3 days before the launch of Claude Design. So the launch of Claude Design. So the launch of Claude Design. So obviously Figma again felt blindsided by obviously Figma again felt blindsided by obviously Figma again felt blindsided by this and you can see the resulting this and you can see the resulting this and you can see the resulting impact on their stock price. Figma's impact on their stock price. Figma's impact on their stock price. Figma's stock has fallen something like 50% this stock has fallen something like 50% this stock has fallen something like 50% this year while Anthropic's valuation has year while Anthropic's valuation has year while Anthropic's valuation has surged. This is not an isolated example. surged. This is not an isolated example. surged. This is not an isolated example. Anthropic has also launched Cloud Anthropic has also launched Cloud Anthropic has also launched Cloud Science, Claude Security, Claude Legal, Science, Claude Security, Claude Legal, Science, Claude Security, Claude Legal, Claude Financial, and of course Claude Claude Financial, and of course Claude Claude Financial, and of course Claude Code. And every single one of these Code. And every single one of these Code. And every single one of these vertical apps expanded into categories vertical apps expanded into categories vertical apps expanded into categories that was previously served by companies that was previously served by companies that was previously served by companies building on top of Anthropic's own building on top of Anthropic's own building on top of Anthropic's own models. And really, if you want to go models. And really, if you want to go models. And really, if you want to go back to when Anthropic's revenue back to when Anthropic's revenue back to when Anthropic's revenue explosion began, it was with the launch explosion began, it was with the launch explosion began, it was with the launch of Claude Code. And how did they know to of Claude Code. And how did they know to of Claude Code. And how did they know to launch that product? Because they saw launch that product? Because they saw launch that product? Because they saw that cursor was doing extremely well. that cursor was doing extremely well. that cursor was doing extremely well. Curser was one of their biggest Curser was one of their biggest Curser was one of their biggest customers. They created the coding customers. They created the coding customers. They created the coding assistant first. they created that assistant first. they created that assistant first. they created that category and anthropic said oh like why category and anthropic said oh like why category and anthropic said oh like why don't we vertically integrate so in don't we vertically integrate so in don't we vertically integrate so in other words they're watching where the other words they're watching where the other words they're watching where the value is being created on top of their value is being created on top of their value is being created on top of their models then they're moving in directly models then they're moving in directly models then they're moving in directly and this is a formula that I think is and this is a formula that I think is and this is a formula that I think is very Microsoft like you could say it's very Microsoft like you could say it's very Microsoft like you could say it's very Google like they want to dominate very Google like they want to dominate very Google like they want to dominate the model layer you could call that the the model layer you could call that the the model layer you could call that the operating system and then use that operating system and then use that operating system and then use that position that monopolistic position to position that monopolistic position to position that monopolistic position to capture the most lucrative verticals so capture the most lucrative verticals so capture the most lucrative verticals so if you want to think about like the if you want to think about like the if you want to think about like the Microsoft example they had the Windows Microsoft example they had the Windows Microsoft example they had the Windows monopoly and then systematically they monopoly and then systematically they monopoly and then systematically they went and dominated every lucrative went and dominated every lucrative went and dominated every lucrative category of business software. It category of business software. It category of business software. It started with spreadsheets and word started with spreadsheets and word started with spreadsheets and word processing and then eventually it went processing and then eventually it went processing and then eventually it went to the browser so forth and so on. If to the browser so forth and so on. If to the browser so forth and so on. If you want to look at Google, they you want to look at Google, they you want to look at Google, they basically had a monopoly or dominant basically had a monopoly or dominant basically had a monopoly or dominant position in search. And if you go back position in search. And if you go back position in search. And if you go back to the early days of Google, the search to the early days of Google, the search to the early days of Google, the search results picked you off site. And in results picked you off site. And in results picked you off site. And in fact, they really pride themselves on fact, they really pride themselves on fact, they really pride themselves on how quickly they could send you off how quickly they could send you off how quickly they could send you off site. But gradually over time, they use site. But gradually over time, they use site. But gradually over time, they use that traffic to tell themselves where to that traffic to tell themselves where to that traffic to tell themselves where to build properties. And today, fewer than build properties. And today, fewer than build properties. And today, fewer than half of searches kick you off site. You half of searches kick you off site. You half of searches kick you off site. You stay on Google properties. And I think stay on Google properties. And I think stay on Google properties. And I think something similar is happening with something similar is happening with something similar is happening with Anthropic here. the pattern is clear, Anthropic here. the pattern is clear, Anthropic here. the pattern is clear, they are going to use their dominant they are going to use their dominant they are going to use their dominant position in the model to then grab more position in the model to then grab more position in the model to then grab more and more territory in any interesting and more territory in any interesting and more territory in any interesting and lucrative vertical. So again, back and lucrative vertical. So again, back and lucrative vertical. So again, back to Alex Karp's point, if you're an to Alex Karp's point, if you're an to Alex Karp's point, if you're an enterprise customer or a developer, why enterprise customer or a developer, why enterprise customer or a developer, why in the world would you ever want to in the world would you ever want to in the world would you ever want to share any proprietary data with them? share any proprietary data with them? share any proprietary data with them? You are mortgaging your future. You are You are mortgaging your future. You are You are mortgaging your future. You are sealing your fate. You are going to lead sealing your fate. You are going to lead sealing your fate. You are going to lead to disaster for your company. Just one to disaster for your company. Just one to disaster for your company. Just one last point then I'll turn over JCL is last point then I'll turn over JCL is last point then I'll turn over JCL is that Daario at the same time that they that Daario at the same time that they that Daario at the same time that they pursue this business strategy has been pursue this business strategy has been pursue this business strategy has been arguing that open- source models are arguing that open- source models are arguing that open- source models are dangerous and need to be restricted. dangerous and need to be restricted. dangerous and need to be restricted. Well, dangerous to whom? Not to Well, dangerous to whom? Not to Well, dangerous to whom? Not to enterprises that want to retain control enterprises that want to retain control enterprises that want to retain control over their data. over their data. over their data. >> It's dangerous to his business model >> It's dangerous to his business model >> It's dangerous to his business model because his business model requires because his business model requires because his business model requires >> that customers don't have a lot of >> that customers don't have a lot of >> that customers don't have a lot of choice at the model layer. And what Karp choice at the model layer. And what Karp choice at the model layer. And what Karp is pointing out here is that if you want is pointing out here is that if you want is pointing out here is that if you want to have true AI safety as an enterprise, to have true AI safety as an enterprise, to have true AI safety as an enterprise, you have to retain the ability to choose you have to retain the ability to choose you have to retain the ability to choose at the model layer who gets to see and at the model layer who gets to see and at the model layer who gets to see and use your alpha. use your alpha. use your alpha. >> Yeah, this is well said. I think you you >> Yeah, this is well said. I think you you >> Yeah, this is well said. I think you you picked that carcass to the bone a bit, picked that carcass to the bone a bit, picked that carcass to the bone a bit, but Chimath, you're actually doing but Chimath, you're actually doing but Chimath, you're actually doing specific examples of this uh at 8090. specific examples of this uh at 8090. specific examples of this uh at 8090. You've been testing uh some of the open You've been testing uh some of the open You've been testing uh some of the open source models. I saw you share that on source models. I saw you share that on source models. I saw you share that on Twitter X. So maybe you could give us a Twitter X. So maybe you could give us a Twitter X. So maybe you could give us a little feedback on what you've learned little feedback on what you've learned little feedback on what you've learned as uh the CEO of 8090 and you know your as uh the CEO of 8090 and you know your as uh the CEO of 8090 and you know your firsthand experience now with using open firsthand experience now with using open firsthand experience now with using open source for the first time in the last source for the first time in the last source for the first time in the last couple weeks for this specific use case couple weeks for this specific use case couple weeks for this specific use case in enterprises. When you start a company in enterprises. When you start a company in enterprises. When you start a company I mean you guys all know this I mean you guys all know this I mean you guys all know this you're not starting it for the moment you're not starting it for the moment you're not starting it for the moment that exists today. you're almost sort of that exists today. you're almost sort of that exists today. you're almost sort of trying to forecast if such and such a trying to forecast if such and such a trying to forecast if such and such a set of things happen then here is the set of things happen then here is the set of things happen then here is the scene that that gets created because it scene that that gets created because it scene that that gets created because it takes time to build something and it takes time to build something and it takes time to build something and it takes time to get enough reps to know takes time to get enough reps to know takes time to get enough reps to know what you're doing in your go to market. what you're doing in your go to market. what you're doing in your go to market. This for me was the moment that I This for me was the moment that I This for me was the moment that I thought would arrive which is the point thought would arrive which is the point thought would arrive which is the point where everybody wakes up and realizes where everybody wakes up and realizes where everybody wakes up and realizes wait hold on a second two things are wait hold on a second two things are wait hold on a second two things are true. The first is that my business is true. The first is that my business is true. The first is that my business is complicated. I want AI to be able to complicated. I want AI to be able to complicated. I want AI to be able to accelerate it, but I want to be able to accelerate it, but I want to be able to accelerate it, but I want to be able to protect myself in doing so. And then the protect myself in doing so. And then the protect myself in doing so. And then the second is I want the flexibility where second is I want the flexibility where second is I want the flexibility where there's an independent third party there's an independent third party there's an independent third party control plane that I use to get all control plane that I use to get all control plane that I use to get all these benefits so that I don't leak and these benefits so that I don't leak and these benefits so that I don't leak and seed my advantages away. And I think seed my advantages away. And I think seed my advantages away. And I think Alex is an incredible, Alex is an incredible, Alex is an incredible, smart, brilliant guy and he completely smart, brilliant guy and he completely smart, brilliant guy and he completely nailed it. And I think he called out on nailed it. And I think he called out on nailed it. And I think he called out on its face the huge risk of this. So let its face the huge risk of this. So let its face the huge risk of this. So let me just give you this narrative in three me just give you this narrative in three me just give you this narrative in three tweets. The first one is I read this tweets. The first one is I read this tweets. The first one is I read this really interesting study from BCG and really interesting study from BCG and really interesting study from BCG and what they looked at was the return on what they looked at was the return on what they looked at was the return on capital employed or ROCE of various capital employed or ROCE of various capital employed or ROCE of various businesses. And this is what's businesses. And this is what's businesses. And this is what's incredible. The cost of capital has now incredible. The cost of capital has now incredible. The cost of capital has now with long-term rates with long-term rates with long-term rates moved back to what its long run average moved back to what its long run average moved back to what its long run average is which is around 8 to 11%. What that is which is around 8 to 11%. What that is which is around 8 to 11%. What that means is like that is the actual cost means is like that is the actual cost means is like that is the actual cost that you would borrow money at that you would borrow money at that you would borrow money at effectively. The problem is that half of effectively. The problem is that half of effectively. The problem is that half of large US companies now cannot deliver large US companies now cannot deliver large US companies now cannot deliver returns that exceed that. That is a returns that exceed that. That is a returns that exceed that. That is a really big problem. And then second really big problem. And then second really big problem. And then second there's a further problem which is that there's a further problem which is that there's a further problem which is that persistently low returns. So in the you persistently low returns. So in the you persistently low returns. So in the you know 1 2 3 4 5% is about one in seven know 1 2 3 4 5% is about one in seven know 1 2 3 4 5% is about one in seven companies all around the world. Okay. So companies all around the world. Okay. So companies all around the world. Okay. So why is this important to note? It means why is this important to note? It means why is this important to note? It means that being in business is complicated. that being in business is complicated. that being in business is complicated. It's hard. Not everything works all the It's hard. Not everything works all the It's hard. Not everything works all the time. There's a bunch of underperforming time. There's a bunch of underperforming time. There's a bunch of underperforming businesses. There's a bunch of businesses. There's a bunch of businesses. There's a bunch of underperforming segments. So in that underperforming segments. So in that underperforming segments. So in that lens, when you, you know, think about lens, when you, you know, think about lens, when you, you know, think about what Sax said, which is you have this what Sax said, which is you have this what Sax said, which is you have this company that comes to you and says, I company that comes to you and says, I company that comes to you and says, I have a magic box and all you have to do have a magic box and all you have to do have a magic box and all you have to do is tell me everything you're doing, and is tell me everything you're doing, and is tell me everything you're doing, and this magic box will make everything this magic box will make everything this magic box will make everything better. But then all of a sudden, from better. But then all of a sudden, from better. But then all of a sudden, from the shadows, the magic box says, you the shadows, the magic box says, you the shadows, the magic box says, you know what, I've decided to compete with know what, I've decided to compete with know what, I've decided to compete with you. That is a huge risk. And now that you. That is a huge risk. And now that you. That is a huge risk. And now that you've seen enough examples of it, I you've seen enough examples of it, I you've seen enough examples of it, I think you have to figure out a different think you have to figure out a different think you have to figure out a different way to do it. So then you go to the next way to do it. So then you go to the next way to do it. So then you go to the next tweet that I saw, which I thought was tweet that I saw, which I thought was tweet that I saw, which I thought was interesting. And this is a woman who's interesting. And this is a woman who's interesting. And this is a woman who's an ex meta PM. And what she essentially an ex meta PM. And what she essentially an ex meta PM. And what she essentially says is like, hey, hold on a second. says is like, hey, hold on a second. says is like, hey, hold on a second. There is this assumption that you can't There is this assumption that you can't There is this assumption that you can't use an open- source model because it's use an open- source model because it's use an open- source model because it's all Chinese. all Chinese. all Chinese. And what she says was, well, even if And what she says was, well, even if And what she says was, well, even if it's 100x cheaper, and their response it's 100x cheaper, and their response it's 100x cheaper, and their response is, no, because we care about safety and is, no, because we care about safety and is, no, because we care about safety and security. And her perspective is, don't security. And her perspective is, don't security. And her perspective is, don't you understand that you can actually you understand that you can actually you understand that you can actually host open- source models with your own host open- source models with your own host open- source models with your own GPUs in US data centers that doesn't GPUs in US data centers that doesn't GPUs in US data centers that doesn't share any data back to anybody? And share any data back to anybody? And share any data back to anybody? And instead, what you're accidentally or instead, what you're accidentally or instead, what you're accidentally or purposefully doing is giving away all purposefully doing is giving away all purposefully doing is giving away all your data to a couple of frontier labs your data to a couple of frontier labs your data to a couple of frontier labs rather than owning it privately rather than owning it privately rather than owning it privately yourself. yourself. yourself. And 100x, it turns out, is a really big And 100x, it turns out, is a really big And 100x, it turns out, is a really big number to pay to do all of that by number to pay to do all of that by number to pay to do all of that by accident. accident. accident. And that's what Alex Karp is saying. And that's what Alex Karp is saying. And that's what Alex Karp is saying. He's like, why would anybody do this He's like, why would anybody do this He's like, why would anybody do this when there are alternatives? And so the when there are alternatives? And so the when there are alternatives? And so the third post that I'll talk about is third post that I'll talk about is third post that I'll talk about is something that we did. So we took our something that we did. So we took our something that we did. So we took our software factory which is an agnostic software factory which is an agnostic software factory which is an agnostic third party control plane and we just third party control plane and we just third party control plane and we just wanted to see and we ran it on a very wanted to see and we ran it on a very wanted to see and we ran it on a very typical enterprise task which is you typical enterprise task which is you typical enterprise task which is you have an old piece of code you want to have an old piece of code you want to have an old piece of code you want to migrate it and you want to maintain it migrate it and you want to maintain it migrate it and you want to maintain it in a new framework so that it's easier in a new framework so that it's easier in a new framework so that it's easier and more flexible. pretty and more flexible. pretty and more flexible. pretty straightforward task. And so we ran it straightforward task. And so we ran it straightforward task. And so we ran it and we ran an experiment where we did and we ran an experiment where we did and we ran an experiment where we did Claude by itself, then we did us plus Claude by itself, then we did us plus Claude by itself, then we did us plus Claude, and then we ran it on the best Claude, and then we ran it on the best Claude, and then we ran it on the best frontier open-source model and then us frontier open-source model and then us frontier open-source model and then us plus that model. And the data is crazy. plus that model. And the data is crazy. plus that model. And the data is crazy. So when you use our harness with Claude, So when you use our harness with Claude, So when you use our harness with Claude, it was simultaneously 1.4x 4x cheaper it was simultaneously 1.4x 4x cheaper it was simultaneously 1.4x 4x cheaper and 1.5x faster than just using and 1.5x faster than just using and 1.5x faster than just using anthropic opus 48 alone. But if you wrap anthropic opus 48 alone. But if you wrap anthropic opus 48 alone. But if you wrap the open source model with our software the open source model with our software the open source model with our software factory, it was 16.4x cheaper. Now it factory, it was 16.4x cheaper. Now it factory, it was 16.4x cheaper. Now it was three times slower. But you know, was three times slower. But you know, was three times slower. But you know, you're talking about a couple of extra you're talking about a couple of extra you're talking about a couple of extra hours to save 16.4x hours to save 16.4x hours to save 16.4x >> on that one. The slowness Chimath, is >> on that one. The slowness Chimath, is >> on that one. The slowness Chimath, is that slowness because of the hardware that slowness because of the hardware that slowness because of the hardware being served up by Claude or is it being served up by Claude or is it being served up by Claude or is it >> This is all using open router. know this >> This is all using open router. know this >> This is all using open router. know this was all using open rudder on a very was all using open rudder on a very was all using open rudder on a very traditional hardware stack. So traditional hardware stack. So traditional hardware stack. So >> look I think the reality is could that >> look I think the reality is could that >> look I think the reality is could that be optimized even further? Absolutely. be optimized even further? Absolutely. be optimized even further? Absolutely. But my my point is if you take Sax's But my my point is if you take Sax's But my my point is if you take Sax's points and then if you take Alex Karp's points and then if you take Alex Karp's points and then if you take Alex Karp's point and just this actual data there is point and just this actual data there is point and just this actual data there is a very legitimate question which is if a very legitimate question which is if a very legitimate question which is if you are a reasonable company you are a reasonable company you are a reasonable company why are you not finding an independent why are you not finding an independent why are you not finding an independent way to access this intelligence in a way way to access this intelligence in a way way to access this intelligence in a way that doesn't leak your edge away to do that doesn't leak your edge away to do that doesn't leak your edge away to do so at this point now is kind of becoming so at this point now is kind of becoming so at this point now is kind of becoming derelict and irresponsible. Back then derelict and irresponsible. Back then derelict and irresponsible. Back then you could be experimenting because you you could be experimenting because you you could be experimenting because you didn't know any better. But now when you didn't know any better. But now when you didn't know any better. But now when you know all of these data points to know all of these data points to know all of these data points to continue to make the same decision I continue to make the same decision I continue to make the same decision I think is really insanely dumb. All right think is really insanely dumb. All right think is really insanely dumb. All right Dave Friedberg you are also a CEO of the Dave Friedberg you are also a CEO of the Dave Friedberg you are also a CEO of the surging oh and you have a lot of surging oh and you have a lot of surging oh and you have a lot of proprietary data. Let me ask you point proprietary data. Let me ask you point proprietary data. Let me ask you point blank. Do you trust your data to the blank. Do you trust your data to the blank. Do you trust your data to the frontier model companies or are you frontier model companies or are you frontier model companies or are you doing what there seems to be consensus doing what there seems to be consensus doing what there seems to be consensus here protecting your data protecting the here protecting your data protecting the here protecting your data protecting the crown jewels so to speak and using open crown jewels so to speak and using open crown jewels so to speak and using open source are you experimenting with it and source are you experimenting with it and source are you experimenting with it and just yes or no do you trust the frontier just yes or no do you trust the frontier just yes or no do you trust the frontier models with Ohio's data so I'll tell you models with Ohio's data so I'll tell you models with Ohio's data so I'll tell you there's been an effort by anthropic to there's been an effort by anthropic to there's been an effort by anthropic to go around and sign up life sciences go around and sign up life sciences go around and sign up life sciences companies to contributing to a new life companies to contributing to a new life companies to contributing to a new life sciences sciences sciences focused model that effort has been focused model that effort has been focused model that effort has been they're approaching these large they're approaching these large they're approaching these large companies with large proprietary data companies with large proprietary data companies with large proprietary data sets and saying hey if you share your sets and saying hey if you share your sets and saying hey if you share your data we will give you early access some data we will give you early access some data we will give you early access some sort of proprietary value sign this NDA sort of proprietary value sign this NDA sort of proprietary value sign this NDA and you can participate with us and I and you can participate with us and I and you can participate with us and I think nearly everyone I've spoken with think nearly everyone I've spoken with think nearly everyone I've spoken with has woken up to the fact that they are has woken up to the fact that they are has woken up to the fact that they are basically trying to commoditize basically trying to commoditize basically trying to commoditize everyone's business because everyone's business because everyone's business because fundamentally if all of the tens of fundamentally if all of the tens of fundamentally if all of the tens of billions of dollars you as a life billions of dollars you as a life billions of dollars you as a life sciences company have invested sciences company have invested sciences company have invested in experiments and product development in experiments and product development in experiments and product development and you've generated all of this and you've generated all of this and you've generated all of this proprietary data along the way. That proprietary data along the way. That proprietary data along the way. That data is a true asset of your data is a true asset of your data is a true asset of your organization. It's an asset that you've organization. It's an asset that you've organization. It's an asset that you've spent billions of dollars developing. spent billions of dollars developing. spent billions of dollars developing. And by handing it over to a model And by handing it over to a model And by handing it over to a model company to then combine with other company to then combine with other company to then combine with other people's data, you are effectively people's data, you are effectively people's data, you are effectively commoditizing the asset that you have, commoditizing the asset that you have, commoditizing the asset that you have, the one kind of core differentiation the one kind of core differentiation the one kind of core differentiation that you have. And so everyone is that you have. And so everyone is that you have. And so everyone is largely saying no. The way I see this largely saying no. The way I see this largely saying no. The way I see this evolving is very much in line with what evolving is very much in line with what evolving is very much in line with what Alex Karp suggested on CNBC. If you go Alex Karp suggested on CNBC. If you go Alex Karp suggested on CNBC. If you go back a couple of years, I think we all back a couple of years, I think we all back a couple of years, I think we all assumed there was going to be this large assumed there was going to be this large assumed there was going to be this large hub, large spoke model for AI model hub, large spoke model for AI model hub, large spoke model for AI model development and deployment. Meaning development and deployment. Meaning development and deployment. Meaning there would be these very large there would be these very large there would be these very large clusters. These large clusters would be clusters. These large clusters would be clusters. These large clusters would be ultimately capital advantaged. So those ultimately capital advantaged. So those ultimately capital advantaged. So those who had the most capital, which is why who had the most capital, which is why who had the most capital, which is why everyone's raised tens and hundreds of everyone's raised tens and hundreds of everyone's raised tens and hundreds of billions of dollars, would be able to billions of dollars, would be able to billions of dollars, would be able to train models. And then there would be train models. And then there would be train models. And then there would be these large spokes, these large clusters these large spokes, these large clusters these large spokes, these large clusters for deploying those models with for deploying those models with for deploying those models with inference. So everyone's using the inference. So everyone's using the inference. So everyone's using the NeoClouds and the hyperscalers and NeoClouds and the hyperscalers and NeoClouds and the hyperscalers and whatnot to run models. And then maybe whatnot to run models. And then maybe whatnot to run models. And then maybe they've got their own proprietary data they've got their own proprietary data they've got their own proprietary data layer that sits in front of that. But I layer that sits in front of that. But I layer that sits in front of that. But I think what everyone's realizing is think what everyone's realizing is think what everyone's realizing is they're better off developing their own they're better off developing their own they're better off developing their own weights and their own models using weights and their own models using weights and their own models using either an open-source basis or there either an open-source basis or there either an open-source basis or there might be some intermediary business might be some intermediary business might be some intermediary business model that evolves. Meaning there will model that evolves. Meaning there will model that evolves. Meaning there will end up being several large hubs that do end up being several large hubs that do end up being several large hubs that do all of the core foundational model all of the core foundational model all of the core foundational model development. Then smaller hubs meaning development. Then smaller hubs meaning development. Then smaller hubs meaning like clusters for training that like clusters for training that like clusters for training that enterprises will use to train and enterprises will use to train and enterprises will use to train and develop their own proprietary advantaged develop their own proprietary advantaged develop their own proprietary advantaged models using their own data and then models using their own data and then models using their own data and then there will be these much more there will be these much more there will be these much more distributed spokes because I think distributed spokes because I think distributed spokes because I think everyone's also realizing the value of everyone's also realizing the value of everyone's also realizing the value of onrem by putting a set of servers and onrem by putting a set of servers and onrem by putting a set of servers and building a cluster in your own data building a cluster in your own data building a cluster in your own data center or even in your own enterprise center or even in your own enterprise center or even in your own enterprise you know IT closet you can run a lot of you know IT closet you can run a lot of you know IT closet you can run a lot of the workflows that you're using AI for the workflows that you're using AI for the workflows that you're using AI for for your enterprise locally. And so I for your enterprise locally. And so I for your enterprise locally. And so I think the model is shifting where we're think the model is shifting where we're think the model is shifting where we're going from large hubs, large spokes to going from large hubs, large spokes to going from large hubs, large spokes to large hubs, medium hubs, and then a large hubs, medium hubs, and then a large hubs, medium hubs, and then a distributed spoke model where there will distributed spoke model where there will distributed spoke model where there will still be, you know, NeoClouds and still be, you know, NeoClouds and still be, you know, NeoClouds and hyperscalers that are being used for hyperscalers that are being used for hyperscalers that are being used for inference, but people will also have inference, but people will also have inference, but people will also have their own inference instances that their own inference instances that their own inference instances that they're going to run for their own they're going to run for their own they're going to run for their own enterprise setting. And everyone I think enterprise setting. And everyone I think enterprise setting. And everyone I think is walking this path and they're going is walking this path and they're going is walking this path and they're going to walk this path over the next couple to walk this path over the next couple to walk this path over the next couple of months because they're realizing of months because they're realizing of months because they're realizing quite quickly that in order to compete quite quickly that in order to compete quite quickly that in order to compete in a world of commoditizing knowledge in a world of commoditizing knowledge in a world of commoditizing knowledge and commoditizing and commoditizing and commoditizing capabilities, you have to leverage the capabilities, you have to leverage the capabilities, you have to leverage the core differentiating assets that you core differentiating assets that you core differentiating assets that you have, which means you have to build your have, which means you have to build your have, which means you have to build your own models and you will likely end up own models and you will likely end up own models and you will likely end up having to run your own inference with having to run your own inference with having to run your own inference with your own proprietary models. your own proprietary models. your own proprietary models. >> Yeah. And to just give a a little bit of >> Yeah. And to just give a a little bit of >> Yeah. And to just give a a little bit of texture to how that's going to look, if texture to how that's going to look, if texture to how that's going to look, if you follow the Microsoft example, which you follow the Microsoft example, which you follow the Microsoft example, which we've talked about here before, Lotus we've talked about here before, Lotus we've talked about here before, Lotus 123, Word Perfect were their partners. 123, Word Perfect were their partners. 123, Word Perfect were their partners. They were replaced with Excel. They were They were replaced with Excel. They were They were replaced with Excel. They were replaced obviously with Microsoft Word. replaced obviously with Microsoft Word. replaced obviously with Microsoft Word. You don't even know those other two. You don't even know those other two. You don't even know those other two. Word Perfect, Wordar, Lotus 123, Word Perfect, Wordar, Lotus 123, Word Perfect, Wordar, Lotus 123, Vizzyalc. That's exactly what they have Vizzyalc. That's exactly what they have Vizzyalc. That's exactly what they have to do. And they have no choice but to do to do. And they have no choice but to do to do. And they have no choice but to do that now because they have a trillion that now because they have a trillion that now because they have a trillion dollar market cap. They must win the dollar market cap. They must win the dollar market cap. They must win the application layer. And Sam Alman went to application layer. And Sam Alman went to application layer. And Sam Alman went to Y Combinator and he said, "We'll give Y Combinator and he said, "We'll give Y Combinator and he said, "We'll give you $2 million worth of free tokens." you $2 million worth of free tokens." you $2 million worth of free tokens." And I came out and I said, "Listen, And I came out and I said, "Listen, And I came out and I said, "Listen, there's nothing personal against Sam. there's nothing personal against Sam. there's nothing personal against Sam. You know, Sam's a very aggressive You know, Sam's a very aggressive You know, Sam's a very aggressive dealmaker." And he wants to get access dealmaker." And he wants to get access dealmaker." And he wants to get access to those startups cuz he knows having to those startups cuz he knows having to those startups cuz he knows having run Y Combinator that if he can get run Y Combinator that if he can get run Y Combinator that if he can get their innovations, those founders latest their innovations, those founders latest their innovations, those founders latest thoughts about what's around the corner, thoughts about what's around the corner, thoughts about what's around the corner, he can incorporate them into the he can incorporate them into the he can incorporate them into the platform. There is no free pizza. platform. There is no free pizza. platform. There is no free pizza. There's no free beer. When somebody like There's no free beer. When somebody like There's no free beer. When somebody like Sam Walman comes to you and says, Sam Walman comes to you and says, Sam Walman comes to you and says, "Here's some free tokens. Your alarm "Here's some free tokens. Your alarm "Here's some free tokens. Your alarm should go up." Zuckerberg did the same should go up." Zuckerberg did the same should go up." Zuckerberg did the same thing. He said, "Hey, I'm going to give thing. He said, "Hey, I'm going to give thing. He said, "Hey, I'm going to give people a bunch of access. Going to give people a bunch of access. Going to give people a bunch of access. Going to give them money. Come to the Facebook them money. Come to the Facebook them money. Come to the Facebook platform." Nobody who went to bed with platform." Nobody who went to bed with platform." Nobody who went to bed with Microsoft in the 80s, Facebook in the Microsoft in the 80s, Facebook in the Microsoft in the 80s, Facebook in the 2000s, or Sam Alman now in in the 2020s 2000s, or Sam Alman now in in the 2020s 2000s, or Sam Alman now in in the 2020s did not wake up with their throats slit. did not wake up with their throats slit. did not wake up with their throats slit. This is a message to founders. If you This is a message to founders. If you This is a message to founders. If you partner with any of these people, they partner with any of these people, they partner with any of these people, they will slit your throat and take your will slit your throat and take your will slit your throat and take your business wholesale. There is nothing to business wholesale. There is nothing to business wholesale. There is nothing to discuss here. Don't trust them. Use your discuss here. Don't trust them. Use your discuss here. Don't trust them. Use your own models. own models. own models. >> I think I think it's less Sam and Open >> I think I think it's less Sam and Open >> I think I think it's less Sam and Open AI to be honest. I think that the AI to be honest. I think that the AI to be honest. I think that the diversity of Open AI in terms of its diversity of Open AI in terms of its diversity of Open AI in terms of its revenue streams and specifically its revenue streams and specifically its revenue streams and specifically its consumer business may actually be its consumer business may actually be its consumer business may actually be its savior in a relative value basis. Right savior in a relative value basis. Right savior in a relative value basis. Right now, OpenAI equity I think is more now, OpenAI equity I think is more now, OpenAI equity I think is more reasonably priced than entropic equity. reasonably priced than entropic equity. reasonably priced than entropic equity. And the reason is not because of the And the reason is not because of the And the reason is not because of the quality of the models or the teams quality of the models or the teams quality of the models or the teams because they're both excellent teams, because they're both excellent teams, because they're both excellent teams, but the reason is that OpenAI can fall but the reason is that OpenAI can fall but the reason is that OpenAI can fall back on a really healthy consumer back on a really healthy consumer back on a really healthy consumer business. business. business. >> Sure, >> Sure, >> Sure, >> the difficulty that Anthropic is going >> the difficulty that Anthropic is going >> the difficulty that Anthropic is going to face is that I think what Sax said is to face is that I think what Sax said is to face is that I think what Sax said is true that they have lost this true that they have lost this true that they have lost this fundamental trust about being able to fundamental trust about being able to fundamental trust about being able to stay within their sandbox. And if you stay within their sandbox. And if you stay within their sandbox. And if you consistently demonstrate this tendency consistently demonstrate this tendency consistently demonstrate this tendency to learn and then to try to disrupt your to learn and then to try to disrupt your to learn and then to try to disrupt your host organism, host organism, host organism, eventually you get sort of pigeonholed eventually you get sort of pigeonholed eventually you get sort of pigeonholed and you get cornered and people find and you get cornered and people find and you get cornered and people find ways to work around it. And so, look, I ways to work around it. And so, look, I ways to work around it. And so, look, I sent that text that I had about the or sent that text that I had about the or sent that text that I had about the or that post that I had about uh our that post that I had about uh our that post that I had about uh our testing of of our harness on these testing of of our harness on these testing of of our harness on these Chinese models to somebody well known in Chinese models to somebody well known in Chinese models to somebody well known in the industry. And he says, "Look, if you the industry. And he says, "Look, if you the industry. And he says, "Look, if you also add some post training with all of also add some post training with all of also add some post training with all of the telemetry that you're going to get the telemetry that you're going to get the telemetry that you're going to get from the harness itself, he's like, I from the harness itself, he's like, I from the harness itself, he's like, I suspect you'll find that it gets as good suspect you'll find that it gets as good suspect you'll find that it gets as good as Mythos." And and I thought, well, if as Mythos." And and I thought, well, if as Mythos." And and I thought, well, if that's true, then why don't I just take that's true, then why don't I just take that's true, then why don't I just take GLM, control it entirely, soup to nuts, GLM, control it entirely, soup to nuts, GLM, control it entirely, soup to nuts, on my own hardware on my own hardware on my own hardware inside of the United States with only US inside of the United States with only US inside of the United States with only US citizens that can touch it. It just citizens that can touch it. It just citizens that can touch it. It just seems like the brain dead obvious thing seems like the brain dead obvious thing seems like the brain dead obvious thing to do, and it's much much cheaper. to do, and it's much much cheaper. to do, and it's much much cheaper. >> Yeah, and 100% correct. I will say >> Yeah, and 100% correct. I will say >> Yeah, and 100% correct. I will say if you're going to do this, you'll if you're going to do this, you'll if you're going to do this, you'll eventually wind up rolling your own LLM. eventually wind up rolling your own LLM. eventually wind up rolling your own LLM. I mentioned a company, Abacus, I mentioned a company, Abacus, I mentioned a company, Abacus, goabacus.co, that we seated in our goabacus.co, that we seated in our goabacus.co, that we seated in our accelerator. What they're doing now for accelerator. What they're doing now for accelerator. What they're doing now for HIPPA client people is they're actually HIPPA client people is they're actually HIPPA client people is they're actually giving you this go one box. They're giving you this go one box. They're giving you this go one box. They're literally saying we're going to make literally saying we're going to make literally saying we're going to make your own model for you. So once you your own model for you. So once you your own model for you. So once you start this you you start with you know start this you you start with you know start this you you start with you know claude and use their wrapper and claude and use their wrapper and claude and use their wrapper and everything or open AIS. Then you move on everything or open AIS. Then you move on everything or open AIS. Then you move on to the next step. The next step is I'm to the next step. The next step is I'm to the next step. The next step is I'm going to use an open source model use my going to use an open source model use my going to use an open source model use my own try to find a harness etc. Where you own try to find a harness etc. Where you own try to find a harness etc. Where you will eventually wind up is you're going will eventually wind up is you're going will eventually wind up is you're going to fork these models you're going to to fork these models you're going to to fork these models you're going to build your own. That is the end state on build your own. That is the end state on build your own. That is the end state on prem on your own hardware. Don't trust prem on your own hardware. Don't trust prem on your own hardware. Don't trust anybody because there's too much at anybody because there's too much at anybody because there's too much at stake. You cannot risk your entire stake. You cannot risk your entire stake. You cannot risk your entire business. You might as well be part of business. You might as well be part of business. You might as well be part of the vanguard and start investing here. the vanguard and start investing here. the vanguard and start investing here. You're going to slow down to speed up is You're going to slow down to speed up is You're going to slow down to speed up is what's going to happen. Whether you're what's going to happen. Whether you're what's going to happen. Whether you're using 8090, Abacus, or any of these using 8090, Abacus, or any of these using 8090, Abacus, or any of these other solutions or rolling your own, you other solutions or rolling your own, you other solutions or rolling your own, you must have AI sovereignty. You must have must have AI sovereignty. You must have must have AI sovereignty. You must have intelligent sovereignty or you're just intelligent sovereignty or you're just intelligent sovereignty or you're just giving your business over to your giving your business over to your giving your business over to your competitors. The only company, the only competitors. The only company, the only competitors. The only company, the only company at scale that's ever respected company at scale that's ever respected company at scale that's ever respected the developer community in this way is the developer community in this way is the developer community in this way is Apple. Apple took a very strategic Apple. Apple took a very strategic Apple. Apple took a very strategic approach to wanting to build an app approach to wanting to build an app approach to wanting to build an app store business to wanting to support store business to wanting to support store business to wanting to support developers. And they explicitly told developers. And they explicitly told developers. And they explicitly told people, if you make something super people, if you make something super people, if you make something super obvious that you can build in a week or obvious that you can build in a week or obvious that you can build in a week or two, it eventually might wind up in our two, it eventually might wind up in our two, it eventually might wind up in our basic collection of apps, the stock app basic collection of apps, the stock app basic collection of apps, the stock app in your iPhone, the notepad app in your in your iPhone, the notepad app in your in your iPhone, the notepad app in your iPhone, those apps are incredibly basic. iPhone, those apps are incredibly basic. iPhone, those apps are incredibly basic. But if you looked at, you know, Robin But if you looked at, you know, Robin But if you looked at, you know, Robin Hood's uh or Google Finance and then you Hood's uh or Google Finance and then you Hood's uh or Google Finance and then you looked at something like say Evernote looked at something like say Evernote looked at something like say Evernote back in the day, which was an advanced back in the day, which was an advanced back in the day, which was an advanced notetaker, it took 10 years for Notepad notetaker, it took 10 years for Notepad notetaker, it took 10 years for Notepad to add the features that Evernote had 7 to add the features that Evernote had 7 to add the features that Evernote had 7 8 9 10 years ago. They specifically slow 8 9 10 years ago. They specifically slow 8 9 10 years ago. They specifically slow their apps down to make them simple for their apps down to make them simple for their apps down to make them simple for users and not f with their ecosystem users and not f with their ecosystem users and not f with their ecosystem because they want to take the 30% tax. because they want to take the 30% tax. because they want to take the 30% tax. That's your choice here. There is no 30% That's your choice here. There is no 30% That's your choice here. There is no 30% tax here when it comes to anthropic. tax here when it comes to anthropic. tax here when it comes to anthropic. There is no 30% tax equivalent with open There is no 30% tax equivalent with open There is no 30% tax equivalent with open AI. AI. AI. >> The thing with Apple is that Apple was >> The thing with Apple is that Apple was >> The thing with Apple is that Apple was renting distribution. This is not renting distribution. This is not renting distribution. This is not renting distribution. This is where renting distribution. This is where renting distribution. This is where you're renting intelligence and you're renting intelligence and you're renting intelligence and judgment. And so the problem that a judgment. And so the problem that a judgment. And so the problem that a company has is you can't rent the same company has is you can't rent the same company has is you can't rent the same in this is why your point is actually in this is why your point is actually in this is why your point is actually right. I think it's for a different right. I think it's for a different right. I think it's for a different reason. You can't rent intelligence from reason. You can't rent intelligence from reason. You can't rent intelligence from the same place that rents it to your the same place that rents it to your the same place that rents it to your competitor. competitor. competitor. >> Correct. >> Correct. >> Correct. >> You just can't. You can't. It's just >> You just can't. You can't. It's just >> You just can't. You can't. It's just stupid. It stupid. It stupid. It >> It will overflow. it will go over the >> It will overflow. it will go over the >> It will overflow. it will go over the wall in your competitor's lap. wall in your competitor's lap. wall in your competitor's lap. >> It's it becomes the lowest common >> It's it becomes the lowest common >> It's it becomes the lowest common denominator problem where you and your denominator problem where you and your denominator problem where you and your competitors now look exactly the same. competitors now look exactly the same. competitors now look exactly the same. Why would you do that? And again, if you Why would you do that? And again, if you Why would you do that? And again, if you go back to that that thing that BCG go back to that that thing that BCG go back to that that thing that BCG identified, so many companies are identified, so many companies are identified, so many companies are already teetering on a very difficult already teetering on a very difficult already teetering on a very difficult position where they cannot generate position where they cannot generate position where they cannot generate returns on their invested equity. And so returns on their invested equity. And so returns on their invested equity. And so why would you then go and pay all this why would you then go and pay all this why would you then go and pay all this money so that you end up with the same money so that you end up with the same money so that you end up with the same answer as your competitor? answer as your competitor? answer as your competitor? >> You can't do it. It's just not a it's >> You can't do it. It's just not a it's >> You can't do it. It's just not a it's not a choice. and Sachs, part of what's not a choice. and Sachs, part of what's not a choice. and Sachs, part of what's going on here is the deflationary nature going on here is the deflationary nature going on here is the deflationary nature of technology. Every single one of these of technology. Every single one of these of technology. Every single one of these tools is getting cheaper. Tokens are tools is getting cheaper. Tokens are tools is getting cheaper. Tokens are getting cheaper, Sachs. And if you look getting cheaper, Sachs. And if you look getting cheaper, Sachs. And if you look at Nvidia's role in all of this, they at Nvidia's role in all of this, they at Nvidia's role in all of this, they have something called Neotron. You can have something called Neotron. You can have something called Neotron. You can try it if you uh use Perplexity. You can try it if you uh use Perplexity. You can try it if you uh use Perplexity. You can just pick the drop down menu. It has just pick the drop down menu. It has just pick the drop down menu. It has deep thinking. You will not be able to deep thinking. You will not be able to deep thinking. You will not be able to tell the difference between Jensen tell the difference between Jensen tell the difference between Jensen Wong's open-source LLM sacks and Claude Wong's open-source LLM sacks and Claude Wong's open-source LLM sacks and Claude for 95% of your searches. I guarantee for 95% of your searches. I guarantee for 95% of your searches. I guarantee you now why why why has Nvidia and you now why why why has Nvidia and you now why why why has Nvidia and Jensen downplayed their open- source Jensen downplayed their open- source Jensen downplayed their open- source model until this moment? Why would he do model until this moment? Why would he do model until this moment? Why would he do that? Why would he never bring it up in that? Why would he never bring it up in that? Why would he never bring it up in the all interview? Never bring it up the all interview? Never bring it up the all interview? Never bring it up because his top customers were uh very because his top customers were uh very because his top customers were uh very concerned from what I understand about concerned from what I understand about concerned from what I understand about the fact that they had made so much the fact that they had made so much the fact that they had made so much project progress on their open source project progress on their open source project progress on their open source model. But suddenly after open AI model. But suddenly after open AI model. But suddenly after open AI announced their jalapeno chips, after announced their jalapeno chips, after announced their jalapeno chips, after Anthropic started uh making chips, after Anthropic started uh making chips, after Anthropic started uh making chips, after AMD did successful uh projects with both AMD did successful uh projects with both AMD did successful uh projects with both of these companies, after Elon said he's of these companies, after Elon said he's of these companies, after Elon said he's going to do his own fab, Nvidia's taken going to do his own fab, Nvidia's taken going to do his own fab, Nvidia's taken the gloves off, David, they are going to the gloves off, David, they are going to the gloves off, David, they are going to own the whole stack. They are going to own the whole stack. They are going to own the whole stack. They are going to be talking about open source a whole be talking about open source a whole be talking about open source a whole bunch. So maybe you could talk a little bunch. So maybe you could talk a little bunch. So maybe you could talk a little bit about Nvidia and their role in this bit about Nvidia and their role in this bit about Nvidia and their role in this as the open-source atscale full stack as the open-source atscale full stack as the open-source atscale full stack provider. You get the hardware from them provider. You get the hardware from them provider. You get the hardware from them and you're gonna get a model that's and you're gonna get a model that's and you're gonna get a model that's competitive with open AIS for free and competitive with open AIS for free and competitive with open AIS for free and all you have to do is use one of their all you have to do is use one of their all you have to do is use one of their hosting companies, Cory, whoever is hosting companies, Cory, whoever is hosting companies, Cory, whoever is buying Nvidia's, Colossus, etc. What are buying Nvidia's, Colossus, etc. What are buying Nvidia's, Colossus, etc. What are your thoughts on Nvidia suddenly being your thoughts on Nvidia suddenly being your thoughts on Nvidia suddenly being willing to talk about their open source willing to talk about their open source willing to talk about their open source projects today? Well, look, I think part projects today? Well, look, I think part projects today? Well, look, I think part of it is they needed time to make the of it is they needed time to make the of it is they needed time to make the offering compelling and you know, offering compelling and you know, offering compelling and you know, they're up against some pretty great AI they're up against some pretty great AI they're up against some pretty great AI labs and I think some of it is just, labs and I think some of it is just, labs and I think some of it is just, hey, it takes time to train up these hey, it takes time to train up these hey, it takes time to train up these models. Now, one question is why is it models. Now, one question is why is it models. Now, one question is why is it that Nvidia and Palunteer are that Nvidia and Palunteer are that Nvidia and Palunteer are partnering? Like what makes them natural partnering? Like what makes them natural partnering? Like what makes them natural partners? And I want to just explain partners? And I want to just explain partners? And I want to just explain that. If you want to think about the AI that. If you want to think about the AI that. If you want to think about the AI stack for a minute at the most basic stack for a minute at the most basic stack for a minute at the most basic level, there's three layers to the level, there's three layers to the level, there's three layers to the stack. It's basically the chips, it's stack. It's basically the chips, it's stack. It's basically the chips, it's the models, and then it's the the models, and then it's the the models, and then it's the applications. Well, right now we have in applications. Well, right now we have in applications. Well, right now we have in the middle layer at the model layer of the middle layer at the model layer of the middle layer at the model layer of the stack, you've got two dominant the stack, you've got two dominant the stack, you've got two dominant companies. You've got Anthropic and Open companies. You've got Anthropic and Open companies. You've got Anthropic and Open AAI. We know that Enthropic is around AAI. We know that Enthropic is around AAI. We know that Enthropic is around 60some billion of ARR. Open AAI is at 40 60some billion of ARR. Open AAI is at 40 60some billion of ARR. Open AAI is at 40 something billion of ARR. As far as we something billion of ARR. As far as we something billion of ARR. As far as we know, no one else is really generating know, no one else is really generating know, no one else is really generating meaningful revenue at the model layer. meaningful revenue at the model layer. meaningful revenue at the model layer. So, we already have, let's say, an So, we already have, let's say, an So, we already have, let's say, an emerging duopoly situation. We have emerging duopoly situation. We have emerging duopoly situation. We have Anthropic pushing for a regulatory Anthropic pushing for a regulatory Anthropic pushing for a regulatory capture agenda that would probably capture agenda that would probably capture agenda that would probably enshrine that duopoly situation at a enshrine that duopoly situation at a enshrine that duopoly situation at a regulatory level because they're pushing regulatory level because they're pushing regulatory level because they're pushing for a safety agenda where Daria for a safety agenda where Daria for a safety agenda where Daria explicitly says that these other models explicitly says that these other models explicitly says that these other models are not safe. You shouldn't have access are not safe. You shouldn't have access are not safe. You shouldn't have access to them. So you've kind of got that to them. So you've kind of got that to them. So you've kind of got that situation. You got the market producing situation. You got the market producing situation. You got the market producing duopoly. You got the government now duopoly. You got the government now duopoly. You got the government now potentially leaning not to bust up the potentially leaning not to bust up the potentially leaning not to bust up the duopoly but maybe to enforce it. So duopoly but maybe to enforce it. So duopoly but maybe to enforce it. So that's sort of the emerging situation at that's sort of the emerging situation at that's sort of the emerging situation at the model layer. And so if you're an the model layer. And so if you're an the model layer. And so if you're an application at the top of the stack like application at the top of the stack like application at the top of the stack like Palunteer or you're a chip company at Palunteer or you're a chip company at Palunteer or you're a chip company at the bottom of the stack, that's the last the bottom of the stack, that's the last the bottom of the stack, that's the last thing you want. You want a competitive thing you want. You want a competitive thing you want. You want a competitive model layer. Why? Because if you're an model layer. Why? Because if you're an model layer. Why? Because if you're an application, you don't want to be application, you don't want to be application, you don't want to be beholden to one model provider, right? beholden to one model provider, right? beholden to one model provider, right? You want to have a choice. And if you're You want to have a choice. And if you're You want to have a choice. And if you're an enterprise, you want to have a choice an enterprise, you want to have a choice an enterprise, you want to have a choice because you don't want have to give up because you don't want have to give up because you don't want have to give up all of your proprietary knowledge. And all of your proprietary knowledge. And all of your proprietary knowledge. And if you're a chip company, you you don't if you're a chip company, you you don't if you're a chip company, you you don't want a monopsiny buyer situation where want a monopsiny buyer situation where want a monopsiny buyer situation where there's only one or two companies who there's only one or two companies who there's only one or two companies who can buy your chips and by the way, can buy your chips and by the way, can buy your chips and by the way, they're producing their own. You want to they're producing their own. You want to they're producing their own. You want to have as diverse and healthy an ecosystem have as diverse and healthy an ecosystem have as diverse and healthy an ecosystem as possible where there's lots of as possible where there's lots of as possible where there's lots of potential buyers for your chips. And if potential buyers for your chips. And if potential buyers for your chips. And if enterprises are rolling their own using enterprises are rolling their own using enterprises are rolling their own using open models, that's kind of an ideal open models, that's kind of an ideal open models, that's kind of an ideal situation because now there's like a situation because now there's like a situation because now there's like a long tale of buyers. So I think really long tale of buyers. So I think really long tale of buyers. So I think really the whole ecosystem in a way the chip the whole ecosystem in a way the chip the whole ecosystem in a way the chip companies, developers, applications, companies, developers, applications, companies, developers, applications, enterprises, everybody has an incentive enterprises, everybody has an incentive enterprises, everybody has an incentive for a competitive layer of the stack at for a competitive layer of the stack at for a competitive layer of the stack at the model layer. Really the only the model layer. Really the only the model layer. Really the only companies who don't are anthropic and companies who don't are anthropic and companies who don't are anthropic and open AI because obviously they want to open AI because obviously they want to open AI because obviously they want to dominate. They want to be a duopoly. And dominate. They want to be a duopoly. And dominate. They want to be a duopoly. And my view is, look, if you earn a monopoly my view is, look, if you earn a monopoly my view is, look, if you earn a monopoly or duopoly in our system, we don't ban or duopoly in our system, we don't ban or duopoly in our system, we don't ban monopolies in the United States. We ban monopolies in the United States. We ban monopolies in the United States. We ban anti-competitive tactics, but if you anti-competitive tactics, but if you anti-competitive tactics, but if you lawfully achieve a monopoly through lawfully achieve a monopoly through lawfully achieve a monopoly through amazing performance, we don't, you know, amazing performance, we don't, you know, amazing performance, we don't, you know, nationalize you or make you illegal, and nationalize you or make you illegal, and nationalize you or make you illegal, and I think that's fine. However, the I think that's fine. However, the I think that's fine. However, the government, in my view, should do government, in my view, should do government, in my view, should do nothing to make monopoly or duopoly more nothing to make monopoly or duopoly more nothing to make monopoly or duopoly more likely. They should make it harder for likely. They should make it harder for likely. They should make it harder for these companies to engage in monopoly these companies to engage in monopoly these companies to engage in monopoly tactics and they should do everything tactics and they should do everything tactics and they should do everything they can to keep the model layer they can to keep the model layer they can to keep the model layer competitive because competition is what competitive because competition is what competitive because competition is what brings out the best and it's good for brings out the best and it's good for brings out the best and it's good for the ecosystem and it ensures our civil the ecosystem and it ensures our civil the ecosystem and it ensures our civil liberties and consumer choice. So, liberties and consumer choice. So, liberties and consumer choice. So, >> and it's going to be amazing for pricing >> and it's going to be amazing for pricing >> and it's going to be amazing for pricing sacks if you think about what this sacks if you think about what this sacks if you think about what this competition is about to do and you've competition is about to do and you've competition is about to do and you've been very vocal about this in your time been very vocal about this in your time been very vocal about this in your time in Washington DC. We want to have a in Washington DC. We want to have a in Washington DC. We want to have a level playing field. We want to see level playing field. We want to see level playing field. We want to see massive competition. I'll give you your massive competition. I'll give you your massive competition. I'll give you your flowers and your lay. You did a great flowers and your lay. You did a great flowers and your lay. You did a great job of now setting the table for this in job of now setting the table for this in job of now setting the table for this in 2026 and 2027 going forward by letting 2026 and 2027 going forward by letting 2026 and 2027 going forward by letting people compete. The cost of tokens, people compete. The cost of tokens, people compete. The cost of tokens, Freeberg, is going to go down 90% a year Freeberg, is going to go down 90% a year Freeberg, is going to go down 90% a year for the next 3 years. You're going to be for the next 3 years. You're going to be for the next 3 years. You're going to be able to buy a thousand times as many able to buy a thousand times as many able to buy a thousand times as many tokens that are more intelligent because tokens that are more intelligent because tokens that are more intelligent because you're going to have free options. The you're going to have free options. The you're going to have free options. The price will be free or close to free for price will be free or close to free for price will be free or close to free for many of these and that could be many of these and that could be many of these and that could be incredibly disruptive. Yes, Dave. incredibly disruptive. Yes, Dave. incredibly disruptive. Yes, Dave. >> Yeah. And I think people are going to >> Yeah. And I think people are going to >> Yeah. And I think people are going to again deploy their own hardware against again deploy their own hardware against again deploy their own hardware against it. I think there's going to be a buying it. I think there's going to be a buying it. I think there's going to be a buying frenzy in the enterprise, not just with frenzy in the enterprise, not just with frenzy in the enterprise, not just with the Neoclouds and the hyperscalers. I the Neoclouds and the hyperscalers. I the Neoclouds and the hyperscalers. I think the the enterprise is going to be think the the enterprise is going to be think the the enterprise is going to be a buyer. And when that happens, you do a buyer. And when that happens, you do a buyer. And when that happens, you do the simple math and you don't want to the simple math and you don't want to the simple math and you don't want to have a dependency on server availability have a dependency on server availability have a dependency on server availability and cloud downtime and you don't want to and cloud downtime and you don't want to and cloud downtime and you don't want to put these models on some third party put these models on some third party put these models on some third party cloud and you want to do stuff that's cloud and you want to do stuff that's cloud and you want to do stuff that's very cheap. Like a lot of people are very cheap. Like a lot of people are very cheap. Like a lot of people are running I mean you guys do this. You're running I mean you guys do this. You're running I mean you guys do this. You're running day-to-day workflows for your running day-to-day workflows for your running day-to-day workflows for your enterprise and you realize, hey, I could enterprise and you realize, hey, I could enterprise and you realize, hey, I could run these workflows on an open source run these workflows on an open source run these workflows on an open source model on a machine in my office and we model on a machine in my office and we model on a machine in my office and we don't need to be sending this stuff back don't need to be sending this stuff back don't need to be sending this stuff back to some fancy scalable cloud service to some fancy scalable cloud service to some fancy scalable cloud service provider. provider. provider. >> Right? The industry spent so many years >> Right? The industry spent so many years >> Right? The industry spent so many years convincing everybody to flip to the convincing everybody to flip to the convincing everybody to flip to the cloud and the realization may be that cloud and the realization may be that cloud and the realization may be that all this this idea of shared all this this idea of shared all this this idea of shared infrastructure may not be the best idea infrastructure may not be the best idea infrastructure may not be the best idea in a world of intelligence in a world of intelligence in a world of intelligence >> and this is what I mean by like a >> and this is what I mean by like a >> and this is what I mean by like a distributed spoke model because I do distributed spoke model because I do distributed spoke model because I do think it's not going to be all or none. think it's not going to be all or none. think it's not going to be all or none. And I think you're going to end up being And I think you're going to end up being And I think you're going to end up being like 7020 20110 in how you're going to like 7020 20110 in how you're going to like 7020 20110 in how you're going to allocate your resources for model allocate your resources for model allocate your resources for model inference and running models. You're inference and running models. You're inference and running models. You're going to probably be 70% in some big going to probably be 70% in some big going to probably be 70% in some big cloud. Maybe you'll do 20% local 10% cloud. Maybe you'll do 20% local 10% cloud. Maybe you'll do 20% local 10% you'll try other clouds. You know, you'll try other clouds. You know, you'll try other clouds. You know, you'll kind of mix stuff up, but I don't you'll kind of mix stuff up, but I don't you'll kind of mix stuff up, but I don't think you're going to end up doing think you're going to end up doing think you're going to end up doing things the way you've been doing them things the way you've been doing them things the way you've been doing them historically. You you'll very quickly historically. You you'll very quickly historically. You you'll very quickly realize that it's okay to waste tokens. realize that it's okay to waste tokens. realize that it's okay to waste tokens. It's okay to let your employees make It's okay to let your employees make It's okay to let your employees make stupid apps that last for a couple weeks stupid apps that last for a couple weeks stupid apps that last for a couple weeks but burn through billions of tokens. If but burn through billions of tokens. If but burn through billions of tokens. If it's running on your own hardware, then it's running on your own hardware, then it's running on your own hardware, then all you're paying for is the electricity all you're paying for is the electricity all you're paying for is the electricity in your office or in your [laughter] in your office or in your [laughter] in your office or in your [laughter] >> what I've been talking about here for >> what I've been talking about here for >> what I've been talking about here for like everyone's realizing. Yeah. like everyone's realizing. Yeah. like everyone's realizing. Yeah. >> Like I'm totally fine, you know, uh for >> Like I'm totally fine, you know, uh for >> Like I'm totally fine, you know, uh for my kids to eat sugar if I don't have to my kids to eat sugar if I don't have to my kids to eat sugar if I don't have to deal with them, you know, like go ahead. deal with them, you know, like go ahead. deal with them, you know, like go ahead. [laughter] >> Have you guys noticed that like in the >> Have you guys noticed that like in the last 3 days we've now seen other people last 3 days we've now seen other people last 3 days we've now seen other people trying to get their own lock in? trying to get their own lock in? trying to get their own lock in? Microsoft just announced a$ two and a Microsoft just announced a$ two and a Microsoft just announced a$ two and a half billion dollar investment to stand half billion dollar investment to stand half billion dollar investment to stand up an FTE or Amazon is spending a up an FTE or Amazon is spending a up an FTE or Amazon is spending a billion dollars billion dollars billion dollars >> forward deployed engineers for the >> forward deployed engineers for the >> forward deployed engineers for the people in the audience for deployed people in the audience for deployed people in the audience for deployed engineers has one open AI has one. engineers has one open AI has one. engineers has one open AI has one. >> Yeah. And when they come knocking Jam >> Yeah. And when they come knocking Jam >> Yeah. And when they come knocking Jam they're knocking like hey can I send my they're knocking like hey can I send my they're knocking like hey can I send my engineers to study your business and put engineers to study your business and put engineers to study your business and put it into my model? I mean people are it into my model? I mean people are it into my model? I mean people are going to be slamming the door on these. going to be slamming the door on these. going to be slamming the door on these. It's like getting a Jehovah's Witness at It's like getting a Jehovah's Witness at It's like getting a Jehovah's Witness at your door. Like no I don't want to be your door. Like no I don't want to be your door. Like no I don't want to be part of your cult. I want to own this. part of your cult. I want to own this. part of your cult. I want to own this. >> And that's what I've been saying. Just >> And that's what I've been saying. Just >> And that's what I've been saying. Just let me make one quick point and I'll let me make one quick point and I'll let me make one quick point and I'll hand it to you for free break. This is hand it to you for free break. This is hand it to you for free break. This is what I've been saying with when I when I what I've been saying with when I when I what I've been saying with when I when I was going on my open claw which now is was going on my open claw which now is was going on my open claw which now is like Hermes and some other products. like Hermes and some other products. like Hermes and some other products. Everybody in your organization is going Everybody in your organization is going Everybody in your organization is going to have a max studio or a Dell with a to have a max studio or a Dell with a to have a max studio or a Dell with a massive amount of RAM and you're going massive amount of RAM and you're going massive amount of RAM and you're going to spend 10 $20,000 per employee on to spend 10 $20,000 per employee on to spend 10 $20,000 per employee on local compute so that they can token max local compute so that they can token max local compute so that they can token max to a maxing level. Who cares what to a maxing level. Who cares what to a maxing level. Who cares what they do on their local computer? Who they do on their local computer? Who they do on their local computer? Who cares? Let them rip. And then you're cares? Let them rip. And then you're cares? Let them rip. And then you're going to give them a laptop that going to give them a laptop that going to give them a laptop that connects to it and it syncs so you can connects to it and it syncs so you can connects to it and it syncs so you can control it. It's literally going to be a control it. It's literally going to be a control it. It's literally going to be a server per individual in your company. server per individual in your company. server per individual in your company. That's the way to model this in your That's the way to model this in your That's the way to model this in your brain. Everybody has their own language brain. Everybody has their own language brain. Everybody has their own language model that they're crafting 100% of the model that they're crafting 100% of the model that they're crafting 100% of the time as they work and it's all local so time as they work and it's all local so time as they work and it's all local so you don't have data leaks. Go ahead, you don't have data leaks. Go ahead, you don't have data leaks. Go ahead, Freeberg. I'll give you the final word. Freeberg. I'll give you the final word. Freeberg. I'll give you the final word. I mean, I think one of the things that I mean, I think one of the things that I mean, I think one of the things that this reveals quite clearly is that there this reveals quite clearly is that there this reveals quite clearly is that there is no buttered slippery slide to job is no buttered slippery slide to job is no buttered slippery slide to job loss. loss. loss. >> I think everyone is realizing that, you >> I think everyone is realizing that, you >> I think everyone is realizing that, you know, know, know, >> I was wondering where you were going >> I was wondering where you were going >> I was wondering where you were going with that buttering it up. So is Truman. with that buttering it up. So is Truman. with that buttering it up. So is Truman. >> But I think, you know, the idea that >> But I think, you know, the idea that >> But I think, you know, the idea that everyone had in their head two years everyone had in their head two years everyone had in their head two years ago, the narrative that was formed and ago, the narrative that was formed and ago, the narrative that was formed and everyone clutched on to, and by the way, everyone clutched on to, and by the way, everyone clutched on to, and by the way, you will not see the media reverse on you will not see the media reverse on you will not see the media reverse on this narrative. I've realized this narrative. I've realized this narrative. I've realized the importance when when the importance when when the importance when when >> media >> media >> media >> if you're a reporter or you're a >> if you're a reporter or you're a >> if you're a reporter or you're a journalist journalist journalist >> and you come up with some story that >> and you come up with some story that >> and you come up with some story that says something that's happening or is says something that's happening or is says something that's happening or is going to happen or has happened or is going to happen or has happened or is going to happen or has happened or is about the future, you destroy your own about the future, you destroy your own about the future, you destroy your own credibility if the narrative shifts. You credibility if the narrative shifts. You credibility if the narrative shifts. You cannot ever let go of the narrative. And cannot ever let go of the narrative. And cannot ever let go of the narrative. And I think this is one of the things that I think this is one of the things that I think this is one of the things that that we can kind of acknowledge is going that we can kind of acknowledge is going that we can kind of acknowledge is going on with this job loss narrative problem on with this job loss narrative problem on with this job loss narrative problem is that even as all the data comes out is that even as all the data comes out is that even as all the data comes out as all of the reconfiguring of how as all of the reconfiguring of how as all of the reconfiguring of how enterprises are using AI as it's enterprises are using AI as it's enterprises are using AI as it's revealing to all of them that they're revealing to all of them that they're revealing to all of them that they're actually not just going to cut cost but actually not just going to cut cost but actually not just going to cut cost but they're going to grow revenue and it's they're going to grow revenue and it's they're going to grow revenue and it's going to be a kind of clunky way of going to be a kind of clunky way of going to be a kind of clunky way of getting there. It's not going to happen getting there. It's not going to happen getting there. It's not going to happen overnight. It's not this slippery slope overnight. It's not this slippery slope overnight. It's not this slippery slope to job loss to nealism. Everyone's gonna to job loss to nealism. Everyone's gonna to job loss to nealism. Everyone's gonna kind of wake up and be like, "Wait, this kind of wake up and be like, "Wait, this kind of wake up and be like, "Wait, this reality that we all thought we were reality that we all thought we were reality that we all thought we were living in is not really the reality that living in is not really the reality that living in is not really the reality that we are living in. We're living in a we are living in. We're living in a we are living in. We're living in a reality where AI is clunky. It takes reality where AI is clunky. It takes reality where AI is clunky. It takes some putting together. It's a little some putting together. It's a little some putting together. It's a little more complicated than we thought. It's more complicated than we thought. It's more complicated than we thought. It's definitely going to deliver value, but definitely going to deliver value, but definitely going to deliver value, but it's not about just turning off all the it's not about just turning off all the it's not about just turning off all the jobs and letting the genius AI solve all jobs and letting the genius AI solve all jobs and letting the genius AI solve all my enterprise problems and scale me into my enterprise problems and scale me into my enterprise problems and scale me into infinity without humans." And I think infinity without humans." And I think infinity without humans." And I think that that's a big kind of narrative that that's a big kind of narrative that that's a big kind of narrative shift. And you will not see the media shift. And you will not see the media shift. And you will not see the media accept that their narrative is wrong. accept that their narrative is wrong. accept that their narrative is wrong. Because as soon as they have to Because as soon as they have to Because as soon as they have to acknowledge that they were wrong in what acknowledge that they were wrong in what acknowledge that they were wrong in what they were saying about job loss and all they were saying about job loss and all they were saying about job loss and all the other senators and people that are the other senators and people that are the other senators and people that are proclaiming job loss, job loss, job proclaiming job loss, job loss, job proclaiming job loss, job loss, job loss, by the way, the reason they're loss, by the way, the reason they're loss, by the way, the reason they're making that proclamation is so that they making that proclamation is so that they making that proclamation is so that they can step in and control AI and they can can step in and control AI and they can can step in and control AI and they can drive their systems of socialism, which drive their systems of socialism, which drive their systems of socialism, which is what they're all looking to deploy. is what they're all looking to deploy. is what they're all looking to deploy. But if they had to come in and say, But if they had to come in and say, But if they had to come in and say, "Look, the data doesn't map to the "Look, the data doesn't map to the "Look, the data doesn't map to the narrative, their credibility is narrative, their credibility is narrative, their credibility is destroyed." So they'll double down on destroyed." So they'll double down on destroyed." So they'll double down on it. and they'll double down on it. And it. and they'll double down on it. And it. and they'll double down on it. And I'm telling everyone that's listening, I'm telling everyone that's listening, I'm telling everyone that's listening, look at the data. There is no job loss look at the data. There is no job loss look at the data. There is no job loss with AI. It is an absolute scam to tell with AI. It is an absolute scam to tell with AI. It is an absolute scam to tell the world that AI is taking away jobs the world that AI is taking away jobs the world that AI is taking away jobs and destroying jobs and the world is and destroying jobs and the world is and destroying jobs and the world is shifting. It is clunky. It is valuable. shifting. It is clunky. It is valuable. shifting. It is clunky. It is valuable. It is going to take some time and it is It is going to take some time and it is It is going to take some time and it is going to create far more jobs than it is going to create far more jobs than it is going to create far more jobs than it is destroying. destroying. destroying. >> We're a bunch of monkeys. We've been >> We're a bunch of monkeys. We've been >> We're a bunch of monkeys. We've been given this new tool. We're going to given this new tool. We're going to given this new tool. We're going to solve more problems with the new tool. solve more problems with the new tool. solve more problems with the new tool. There will be job displacement. And the There will be job displacement. And the There will be job displacement. And the problem is people do not understand the problem is people do not understand the problem is people do not understand the nuance between these two terms. Certain nuance between these two terms. Certain nuance between these two terms. Certain jobs will be retired and they're going jobs will be retired and they're going jobs will be retired and they're going to be retired at a faster rate than you to be retired at a faster rate than you to be retired at a faster rate than you can imagine, but other jobs will happen. can imagine, but other jobs will happen. can imagine, but other jobs will happen. And you pointed this out, Shimoth. Hey, And you pointed this out, Shimoth. Hey, And you pointed this out, Shimoth. Hey, it's the it's the most I don't know if it's the it's the most I don't know if it's the it's the most I don't know if you did it here or on your personal you did it here or on your personal you did it here or on your personal channel on YouTube, but you know, it's channel on YouTube, but you know, it's channel on YouTube, but you know, it's the most empowering tool ever. If you the most empowering tool ever. If you the most empowering tool ever. If you can What jobs are getting replaced? can What jobs are getting replaced? can What jobs are getting replaced? >> I I challenge very simpl, >> I I challenge very simpl, >> I I challenge very simpl, >> but you're saying some of them are going >> but you're saying some of them are going >> but you're saying some of them are going to go away faster than you can see. to go away faster than you can see. to go away faster than you can see. What? What are those jobs that are going What? What are those jobs that are going What? What are those jobs that are going to go away faster than you can see? Cuz to go away faster than you can see? Cuz to go away faster than you can see? Cuz I'm just I'm still not seeing the I'm just I'm still not seeing the I'm just I'm still not seeing the categories. categories. categories. >> Totally. Customer support jobs. Those >> Totally. Customer support jobs. Those >> Totally. Customer support jobs. Those are going to go away very quickly. are going to go away very quickly. are going to go away very quickly. >> Where? Where? You're just making up >> Where? Where? You're just making up >> Where? Where? You're just making up cuz it's not I see it in enterprises all cuz it's not I see it in enterprises all cuz it's not I see it in enterprises all the time. the time. the time. >> Where do you see it? Show me the >> Where do you see it? Show me the >> Where do you see it? Show me the customer support enterprise shutdown customer support enterprise shutdown customer support enterprise shutdown that's happening. Just show it to me. that's happening. Just show it to me. that's happening. Just show it to me. >> Is it in the room with us right now? >> Is it in the room with us right now? >> Is it in the room with us right now? Like where is it? [laughter] I will Like where is it? [laughter] I will Like where is it? [laughter] I will literally, you know, I'll I'll do that literally, you know, I'll I'll do that literally, you know, I'll I'll do that research and and I'll give it to you. research and and I'll give it to you. research and and I'll give it to you. >> I'll give you some research. Hold on. >> I'll give you some research. Hold on. >> I'll give you some research. Hold on. Can I can I provide some research? Can I can I provide some research? Can I can I provide some research? He asked me a question. Just let me He asked me a question. Just let me He asked me a question. Just let me finish my answer and then you can take finish my answer and then you can take finish my answer and then you can take it. You asked me the question. Customer it. You asked me the question. Customer it. You asked me the question. Customer service jobs are going to go away service jobs are going to go away service jobs are going to go away because consumers prefer to talk to the because consumers prefer to talk to the because consumers prefer to talk to the AI and it's perfect at that. Entrylevel AI and it's perfect at that. Entrylevel AI and it's perfect at that. Entrylevel jobs around data entry around business jobs around data entry around business jobs around data entry around business process outsourcing those are going to process outsourcing those are going to process outsourcing those are going to go away. So will driving cabs and those go away. So will driving cabs and those go away. So will driving cabs and those kind of jobs. Those ones are obvious kind of jobs. Those ones are obvious kind of jobs. Those ones are obvious lowhanging fruit. Just like we had the lowhanging fruit. Just like we had the lowhanging fruit. Just like we had the typing pool and messengers and other typing pool and messengers and other typing pool and messengers and other products go away when we had word products go away when we had word products go away when we had word processors on every desk. Those jobs processors on every desk. Those jobs processors on every desk. Those jobs will be displaced 100%. And those jobs will be displaced 100%. And those jobs will be displaced 100%. And those jobs >> year we're on year 20 of cab drivers >> year we're on year 20 of cab drivers >> year we're on year 20 of cab drivers going away, dude. Like when Uber came going away, dude. Like when Uber came going away, dude. Like when Uber came out, everyone said all the driving jobs out, everyone said all the driving jobs out, everyone said all the driving jobs were going to go away. It's all over. were going to go away. It's all over. were going to go away. It's all over. >> Well, no. Whimo is stuck at 3,000. >> Well, no. Whimo is stuck at 3,000. >> Well, no. Whimo is stuck at 3,000. Tesla's stuck at like 30 cars. But Tesla's stuck at like 30 cars. But Tesla's stuck at like 30 cars. But that's all going to change in the very that's all going to change in the very that's all going to change in the very near future. near future. near future. >> Everything you're saying is perspective. >> Everything you're saying is perspective. >> Everything you're saying is perspective. This is my point. You are still being This is my point. You are still being This is my point. You are still being perspective in the future with perspective in the future with perspective in the future with everything you're saying. And every everything you're saying. And every everything you're saying. And every point that we turn, every time we turn a point that we turn, every time we turn a point that we turn, every time we turn a page, it's like, wait, do you happen to page, it's like, wait, do you happen to page, it's like, wait, do you happen to think self-driving is real? Is that your think self-driving is real? Is that your think self-driving is real? Is that your premise? Is that self-driving is not premise? Is that self-driving is not premise? Is that self-driving is not going to get rid of cab drivers? Is that going to get rid of cab drivers? Is that going to get rid of cab drivers? Is that your premise? your premise? your premise? >> I think it's real, but like like I think >> I think it's real, but like like I think >> I think it's real, but like like I think it's real for sure. it's real for sure. it's real for sure. >> Do you think it will get rid of cab >> Do you think it will get rid of cab >> Do you think it will get rid of cab drivers? You're arguing as if like I'm drivers? You're arguing as if like I'm drivers? You're arguing as if like I'm wrong here, but I think that every day I wrong here, but I think that every day I wrong here, but I think that every day I get in the car every day and my car get in the car every day and my car get in the car every day and my car drives me and I get on my phone and I do drives me and I get on my phone and I do drives me and I get on my phone and I do work. work. work. >> Okay. But do you think cabs and cities >> Okay. But do you think cabs and cities >> Okay. But do you think cabs and cities are not going to be self-driving? Do you are not going to be self-driving? Do you are not going to be self-driving? Do you think zipline's not going to deliver? think zipline's not going to deliver? think zipline's not going to deliver? Bailey thing again. Jal, Bailey thing again. Jal, Bailey thing again. Jal, >> it's not Mont belly. I see this from my >> it's not Mont belly. I see this from my >> it's not Mont belly. I see this from my investments. I have a company auto lane investments. I have a company auto lane investments. I have a company auto lane that is doing this right now. that is doing this right now. that is doing this right now. >> But just go to customer support again >> But just go to customer support again >> But just go to customer support again cuz you've been saying Yeah. cuz you've been saying Yeah. cuz you've been saying Yeah. >> I literally we've had this debate >> I literally we've had this debate >> I literally we've had this debate verbatim and verbatim and verbatim and >> displacement not job loss is is my only >> displacement not job loss is is my only >> displacement not job loss is is my only point. point. point. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. What Freeberg is >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. What Freeberg is >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. What Freeberg is pointing out is that whenever anyone pointing out is that whenever anyone pointing out is that whenever anyone pushes back on the fact that you don't pushes back on the fact that you don't pushes back on the fact that you don't have any data to support this in the have any data to support this in the have any data to support this in the present, you say you're talking about present, you say you're talking about present, you say you're talking about the future. Okay, fine. It's a the future. Okay, fine. It's a the future. Okay, fine. It's a prediction. You know, there's no data to prediction. You know, there's no data to prediction. You know, there's no data to support it in the present. That's fine. support it in the present. That's fine. support it in the present. That's fine. You're saying it's gonna happen in the You're saying it's gonna happen in the You're saying it's gonna happen in the future? future? future? >> No, no. I'll give you the data point. >> No, no. I'll give you the data point. >> No, no. I'll give you the data point. >> You can dismiss I want. I will. Yes. If >> You can dismiss I want. I will. Yes. If >> You can dismiss I want. I will. Yes. If you talk to Uber and Whimo, in the you talk to Uber and Whimo, in the you talk to Uber and Whimo, in the cities where Whimo is present and has cities where Whimo is present and has cities where Whimo is present and has gotten past a couple hundred cars, gotten past a couple hundred cars, gotten past a couple hundred cars, they've stopped recruiting drivers. they've stopped recruiting drivers. they've stopped recruiting drivers. Drivers are either static or going down Drivers are either static or going down Drivers are either static or going down in those markets. So that is absolute in those markets. So that is absolute in those markets. So that is absolute evidence that this is happening and the evidence that this is happening and the evidence that this is happening and the roll out is going to be fast and roll out is going to be fast and roll out is going to be fast and furious. So it is not a future furious. So it is not a future furious. So it is not a future prediction. You can talk to the CEO of prediction. You can talk to the CEO of prediction. You can talk to the CEO of Whimo. You can talk to the CEO of Lyft Whimo. You can talk to the CEO of Lyft Whimo. You can talk to the CEO of Lyft and Uber and they will tell you this and Uber and they will tell you this and Uber and they will tell you this explicitly. Market explicitly. Market explicitly. Market interview Darren. He said jobs were interview Darren. He said jobs were interview Darren. He said jobs were increasing at Uber. increasing at Uber. increasing at Uber. >> Yeah, cuz you're delivering more like >> Yeah, cuz you're delivering more like >> Yeah, cuz you're delivering more like those because productivity is going up those because productivity is going up those because productivity is going up with with delivery. Productivity goes up with with delivery. Productivity goes up with with delivery. Productivity goes up means people drive more% lying. You're means people drive more% lying. You're means people drive more% lying. You're being dis you're being last time we no being dis you're being last time we no being dis you're being last time we no the last time we disingenuous the last time we disingenuous the last time we disingenuous in markets where Whimo is in markets in markets where Whimo is in markets in markets where Whimo is in markets where Whimo is you're you're there might where Whimo is you're you're there might where Whimo is you're you're there might be other markets where things are be other markets where things are be other markets where things are growing because they don't allow growing because they don't allow growing because they don't allow self-driving or they haven't gotten self-driving or they haven't gotten self-driving or they haven't gotten there yet. In markets where Whimo has there yet. In markets where Whimo has there yet. In markets where Whimo has hit critical mass, the number of human hit critical mass, the number of human hit critical mass, the number of human drivers is going down. This is just a drivers is going down. This is just a drivers is going down. This is just a fact. fact. fact. Stop recruiting in some narrow Stop recruiting in some narrow Stop recruiting in some narrow arbitrarily defined subset of their arbitrarily defined subset of their arbitrarily defined subset of their jobs. You're pointing to flatness. jobs. You're pointing to flatness. jobs. You're pointing to flatness. >> Meanwhile, Dar told us that hiring a >> Meanwhile, Dar told us that hiring a >> Meanwhile, Dar told us that hiring a cost of the company has gone up in the cost of the company has gone up in the cost of the company has gone up in the face of these drivers. face of these drivers. face of these drivers. >> No, no, you're wrong. Okay. Anyway, we >> No, no, you're wrong. Okay. Anyway, we >> No, no, you're wrong. Okay. Anyway, we we'll agree to disagree here. we'll agree to disagree here. we'll agree to disagree here. >> Let me give you some actual data. Can I >> Let me give you some actual data. Can I >> Let me give you some actual data. Can I provide us this study? So, RAMP and provide us this study? So, RAMP and provide us this study? So, RAMP and Rellio Labs just released a new study in Rellio Labs just released a new study in Rellio Labs just released a new study in the past week. the past week. the past week. >> Yeah, that was great. >> Yeah, that was great. >> Yeah, that was great. >> And it was an actual study of over >> And it was an actual study of over >> And it was an actual study of over 21,000 firms in the US and they looked 21,000 firms in the US and they looked 21,000 firms in the US and they looked at their payroll data combined with at their payroll data combined with at their payroll data combined with their spending on AI. And what they saw their spending on AI. And what they saw their spending on AI. And what they saw is that firms that spent the most on AI is that firms that spent the most on AI is that firms that spent the most on AI actually grew the fastest and they actually grew the fastest and they actually grew the fastest and they tended to grow their headcount roughly tended to grow their headcount roughly tended to grow their headcount roughly 10% in the two years following the 10% in the two years following the 10% in the two years following the adoption of AI. And entry level adoption of AI. And entry level adoption of AI. And entry level headcount rose even faster, it grew at headcount rose even faster, it grew at headcount rose even faster, it grew at 12%. So all this stuff about how entry- 12%. So all this stuff about how entry- 12%. So all this stuff about how entry- level headcount's going to get wiped level headcount's going to get wiped level headcount's going to get wiped out, not true. The more firms adopted out, not true. The more firms adopted out, not true. The more firms adopted AI, the more hiring they did. At least AI, the more hiring they did. At least AI, the more hiring they did. At least that was a correlation. Obviously, they that was a correlation. Obviously, they that was a correlation. Obviously, they can't prove causation, but that was the can't prove causation, but that was the can't prove causation, but that was the correlation. And then companies that correlation. And then companies that correlation. And then companies that were not highintensity adopters of AI, were not highintensity adopters of AI, were not highintensity adopters of AI, they were either didn't adopt or they they were either didn't adopt or they they were either didn't adopt or they were low intensity adopters, they just were low intensity adopters, they just were low intensity adopters, they just saw flatness in their headcount. So, no saw flatness in their headcount. So, no saw flatness in their headcount. So, no one is really showing a trend here of one is really showing a trend here of one is really showing a trend here of job loss. What they're showing is that job loss. What they're showing is that job loss. What they're showing is that the more you adopt AI, those companies the more you adopt AI, those companies the more you adopt AI, those companies also tend to grow headcount. So I you also tend to grow headcount. So I you also tend to grow headcount. So I you know there's just no data to support know there's just no data to support know there's just no data to support this idea that in the present AI is this idea that in the present AI is this idea that in the present AI is causing job loss. causing job loss. causing job loss. >> Job displacement will happen. Jobs will >> Job displacement will happen. Jobs will >> Job displacement will happen. Jobs will increase because of AI. Sovereignty will increase because of AI. Sovereignty will increase because of AI. Sovereignty will increase and people will make more increase and people will make more increase and people will make more money. Corporations will be more will money. Corporations will be more will money. Corporations will be more will have more earnings. But there will be have more earnings. But there will be have more earnings. But there will be jobs being retired. And I think if you jobs being retired. And I think if you jobs being retired. And I think if you look at translators, if you look at look at translators, if you look at look at translators, if you look at telephone operators, if you look at bill telephone operators, if you look at bill telephone operators, if you look at bill collectors, if you look at Whimo collectors, if you look at Whimo collectors, if you look at Whimo drivers, these very simple tasks are drivers, these very simple tasks are drivers, these very simple tasks are being automated. How do I know that? being automated. How do I know that? being automated. How do I know that? Because I invest in startups that are Because I invest in startups that are Because I invest in startups that are raising hundreds of millions of dollars raising hundreds of millions of dollars raising hundreds of millions of dollars to replace these jobs with AI. We had to replace these jobs with AI. We had to replace these jobs with AI. We had the pilot uh we we had people building the pilot uh we we had people building the pilot uh we we had people building the perfect pilot, the perfect driver, the perfect pilot, the perfect driver, the perfect pilot, the perfect driver, the perfect customer support rep. That the perfect customer support rep. That the perfect customer support rep. That is the point of AI. Every single sales is the point of AI. Every single sales is the point of AI. Every single sales pitch of these AI companies is to retire pitch of these AI companies is to retire pitch of these AI companies is to retire these jobs that are not great jobs. these jobs that are not great jobs. these jobs that are not great jobs. There is no way in God's green earth There is no way in God's green earth There is no way in God's green earth that humans will be at Amazon sorting that humans will be at Amazon sorting that humans will be at Amazon sorting packages. There's not. It's not going to packages. There's not. It's not going to packages. There's not. It's not going to happen. All those factory jobs are being happen. All those factory jobs are being happen. All those factory jobs are being replaced. Elon is explicitly building replaced. Elon is explicitly building replaced. Elon is explicitly building Optimus for this purpose. And when I say Optimus for this purpose. And when I say Optimus for this purpose. And when I say it's future, I have always contended it's future, I have always contended it's future, I have always contended it's future. Sachs, you cannot use your it's future. Sachs, you cannot use your it's future. Sachs, you cannot use your silly debate techniques to say that I'm silly debate techniques to say that I'm silly debate techniques to say that I'm using some crazy thing. It is happening using some crazy thing. It is happening using some crazy thing. It is happening as we speak. We're soaking in it. This as we speak. We're soaking in it. This as we speak. We're soaking in it. This is the transition period. is the transition period. is the transition period. What I'll tell you is that in every What I'll tell you is that in every What I'll tell you is that in every environment in which 8090 operates, environment in which 8090 operates, environment in which 8090 operates, every customer, I don't think we've seen every customer, I don't think we've seen every customer, I don't think we've seen layoffs. Not a single one. layoffs. Not a single one. layoffs. Not a single one. >> Yeah. In this in this RAM card study, >> Yeah. In this in this RAM card study, >> Yeah. In this in this RAM card study, they said, quote, "Gains emerge they said, quote, "Gains emerge they said, quote, "Gains emerge gradually and are broad across roles, gradually and are broad across roles, gradually and are broad across roles, including engineering, sales, including engineering, sales, including engineering, sales, administration, and customer service. administration, and customer service. administration, and customer service. So, they're not seeing like one category So, they're not seeing like one category So, they're not seeing like one category of jobs getting wiped out." By the way, of jobs getting wiped out." By the way, of jobs getting wiped out." By the way, it could happen in the future. I mean, it could happen in the future. I mean, it could happen in the future. I mean, none of us can say for sure what's going none of us can say for sure what's going none of us can say for sure what's going to happen in the future, but if you're to happen in the future, but if you're to happen in the future, but if you're looking for data in the present, we're looking for data in the present, we're looking for data in the present, we're not seeing it yet. not seeing it yet. not seeing it yet. >> I think there's going to be a strong >> I think there's going to be a strong >> I think there's going to be a strong human alpha. You know, like when vending human alpha. You know, like when vending human alpha. You know, like when vending machines came along, it's not like machines came along, it's not like machines came along, it's not like bartenders went away. Like I like going bartenders went away. Like I like going bartenders went away. Like I like going to a bar talking to the bartender and to a bar talking to the bartender and to a bar talking to the bartender and they make a great drink. And those they make a great drink. And those they make a great drink. And those bartenders make better money today than bartenders make better money today than bartenders make better money today than they did 20 years ago. I don't and and they did 20 years ago. I don't and and they did 20 years ago. I don't and and maybe the vending machine replacement maybe the vending machine replacement maybe the vending machine replacement model isn't the right one in that case, model isn't the right one in that case, model isn't the right one in that case, but I I think that there's a lot of but I I think that there's a lot of but I I think that there's a lot of value in human interaction that's going value in human interaction that's going value in human interaction that's going to get a premium in the future because to get a premium in the future because to get a premium in the future because as more stuff gets automated, I want to as more stuff gets automated, I want to as more stuff gets automated, I want to have an actual driver when I go to Las have an actual driver when I go to Las have an actual driver when I go to Las Vegas. I don't want to go in a Whimo. I Vegas. I don't want to go in a Whimo. I Vegas. I don't want to go in a Whimo. I want to have a great driver in a nice want to have a great driver in a nice want to have a great driver in a nice car that takes me to the dinners, drives car that takes me to the dinners, drives car that takes me to the dinners, drives me around New York City, same thing. I me around New York City, same thing. I me around New York City, same thing. I don't want to go in a Whimo, per se. I don't want to go in a Whimo, per se. I don't want to go in a Whimo, per se. I want to have, you know, people that can want to have, you know, people that can want to have, you know, people that can do things that could otherwise be do things that could otherwise be do things that could otherwise be automated. I'll pay a huge premium. I automated. I'll pay a huge premium. I automated. I'll pay a huge premium. I could sit in a freaking massage chair. could sit in a freaking massage chair. could sit in a freaking massage chair. Why do I go pay someone $200 for an hour Why do I go pay someone $200 for an hour Why do I go pay someone $200 for an hour massage? You know, I think there's massage? You know, I think there's massage? You know, I think there's there's an aspect to the alpha of there's an aspect to the alpha of there's an aspect to the alpha of [laughter] [laughter] [laughter] we could cut that one. But uh we could cut that one. But uh we could cut that one. But uh but I do think there's a premium to but I do think there's a premium to but I do think there's a premium to humans and I don't think that um and I humans and I don't think that um and I humans and I don't think that um and I actually to humans actually to humans actually to humans >> no the count >> no the count >> no the count JL this is really important. I think JL this is really important. I think JL this is really important. I think that the counternarrative to automation that the counternarrative to automation that the counternarrative to automation generally is that we're going to realize generally is that we're going to realize generally is that we're going to realize the importance of human interaction and the importance of human interaction and the importance of human interaction and humans in the loop and we're going to humans in the loop and we're going to humans in the loop and we're going to pay a premium for it. pay a premium for it. pay a premium for it. >> Well, do you remember like a >> Well, do you remember like a >> Well, do you remember like a >> I don't believe I don't believe in AGI >> I don't believe I don't believe in AGI >> I don't believe I don't believe in AGI and the singularity happening next year. and the singularity happening next year. and the singularity happening next year. I'm just not there. I'm just not there. I'm just not there. >> Do you remember like a year ago when CLA >> Do you remember like a year ago when CLA >> Do you remember like a year ago when CLA said they're going to replace their said they're going to replace their said they're going to replace their whole customer service department with whole customer service department with whole customer service department with AI and they did they did a lot of hype. AI and they did they did a lot of hype. AI and they did they did a lot of hype. It was peak RF farming and well lo and It was peak RF farming and well lo and It was peak RF farming and well lo and behold they flipped the decision back behold they flipped the decision back behold they flipped the decision back after a year. They said that from a after a year. They said that from a after a year. They said that from a brand perspective, a company brand perspective, a company brand perspective, a company perspective, perspective, perspective, it's just so critical that you are clear it's just so critical that you are clear it's just so critical that you are clear to your customer that there will always to your customer that there will always to your customer that there will always be a human if if you want it. be a human if if you want it. be a human if if you want it. >> Human in the loop will be the premium >> Human in the loop will be the premium >> Human in the loop will be the premium and we will all realize in the next year and we will all realize in the next year and we will all realize in the next year and a half the importance of human in and a half the importance of human in and a half the importance of human in the loop even in the context of AI and the loop even in the context of AI and the loop even in the context of AI and automation working. automation working. automation working. >> Human in the loop is going to be more >> Human in the loop is going to be more >> Human in the loop is going to be more valuable and then you're going to pay a valuable and then you're going to pay a valuable and then you're going to pay a premium for human in the loop. There's premium for human in the loop. There's premium for human in the loop. There's so many CEOs who want to tap into the so many CEOs who want to tap into the so many CEOs who want to tap into the media's hype cycle. This is the thing is media's hype cycle. This is the thing is media's hype cycle. This is the thing is that whenever the media gets a hold of that whenever the media gets a hold of that whenever the media gets a hold of one of these narratives, there's so many one of these narratives, there's so many one of these narratives, there's so many CEOs who are not like Karp, right, who CEOs who are not like Karp, right, who CEOs who are not like Karp, right, who just are not original and they don't just are not original and they don't just are not original and they don't really have anything important to say. really have anything important to say. really have anything important to say. So, the only way for them to get So, the only way for them to get So, the only way for them to get publicity is to glom onto that press publicity is to glom onto that press publicity is to glom onto that press cycle and try to use it. And then cycle and try to use it. And then cycle and try to use it. And then they'll chime in with, you know, how they'll chime in with, you know, how they'll chime in with, you know, how they're going to do crazy things to they're going to do crazy things to they're going to do crazy things to eliminate their whole customer sport eliminate their whole customer sport eliminate their whole customer sport department and then lo and behold, it department and then lo and behold, it department and then lo and behold, it turns out just to be total totally fake. turns out just to be total totally fake. turns out just to be total totally fake. I think the ramp data is directionally I think the ramp data is directionally I think the ramp data is directionally accurate. In our experience, I would say accurate. In our experience, I would say accurate. In our experience, I would say the same thing. I think people that use the same thing. I think people that use the same thing. I think people that use AI tend to grow faster. They tend to AI tend to grow faster. They tend to AI tend to grow faster. They tend to hire more. They tend to make more%. hire more. They tend to make more%. hire more. They tend to make more%. >> Yeah, 100%. >> Yeah, 100%. >> Yeah, 100%. >> By the way, I actually agree with 100% >> By the way, I actually agree with 100% >> By the way, I actually agree with 100% agreement on that. agreement on that. agreement on that. >> From a career standpoint, I would not >> From a career standpoint, I would not >> From a career standpoint, I would not want to be a level one customer support want to be a level one customer support want to be a level one customer support rep because I do think that like if all rep because I do think that like if all rep because I do think that like if all you're doing is like answering forgotten you're doing is like answering forgotten you're doing is like answering forgotten password requests, that's not a great password requests, that's not a great password requests, that's not a great place to be. However, those jobs were place to be. However, those jobs were place to be. However, those jobs were basically outsourced to the Philippines basically outsourced to the Philippines basically outsourced to the Philippines and places like that a long time ago. I and places like that a long time ago. I and places like that a long time ago. I mean, most enterprises are not doing mean, most enterprises are not doing mean, most enterprises are not doing kind of that level zero, level one kind of that level zero, level one kind of that level zero, level one customer support in the US. They do have customer support in the US. They do have customer support in the US. They do have customer support centers, but they're customer support centers, but they're customer support centers, but they're doing like level two, level three. doing like level two, level three. doing like level two, level three. They're doing the escalations, the They're doing the escalations, the They're doing the escalations, the higher value stuff that's going to be a higher value stuff that's going to be a higher value stuff that's going to be a lot harder to replace with AI. lot harder to replace with AI. lot harder to replace with AI. >> Totally. I do kind of worry about well >> Totally. I do kind of worry about well >> Totally. I do kind of worry about well what happens in some of these other what happens in some of these other what happens in some of these other countries that are doing the super entry countries that are doing the super entry countries that are doing the super entry level stuff because I think that is job level stuff because I think that is job level stuff because I think that is job loss but I don't know if it'll be loss but I don't know if it'll be loss but I don't know if it'll be massive but that's where the risk is. I massive but that's where the risk is. I massive but that's where the risk is. I mean frankly it's not in the US. mean frankly it's not in the US. mean frankly it's not in the US. >> This is um so maybe we're getting to >> This is um so maybe we're getting to >> This is um so maybe we're getting to some consensus here. some consensus here. some consensus here. >> Job displacement versus job loss. Here >> Job displacement versus job loss. Here >> Job displacement versus job loss. Here is Brett Atcock sharing what they're is Brett Atcock sharing what they're is Brett Atcock sharing what they're doing at Figure. They had an 8-hour doing at Figure. They had an 8-hour doing at Figure. They had an 8-hour challenge to have this uh robot they're challenge to have this uh robot they're challenge to have this uh robot they're building sort packages and they did it building sort packages and they did it building sort packages and they did it for 200 hours. That's today. This is the for 200 hours. That's today. This is the for 200 hours. That's today. This is the least least least good it will ever be. This is the worst good it will ever be. This is the worst good it will ever be. This is the worst it's going to ever be. These things are it's going to ever be. These things are it's going to ever be. These things are getting really good. I spent time with getting really good. I spent time with getting really good. I spent time with Elon. I've looked at Optimus. I can tell Elon. I've looked at Optimus. I can tell Elon. I've looked at Optimus. I can tell you Optimus is better than what Figure you Optimus is better than what Figure you Optimus is better than what Figure is doing. What Optimus is going to do is doing. What Optimus is going to do is doing. What Optimus is going to do when Bezos and Andy Jasse unleash when Bezos and Andy Jasse unleash when Bezos and Andy Jasse unleash Optimus inside of the Amazon factories Optimus inside of the Amazon factories Optimus inside of the Amazon factories is it's going to get rid of every, let is it's going to get rid of every, let is it's going to get rid of every, let me state this very clearly, every single me state this very clearly, every single me state this very clearly, every single package sorting, every single package package sorting, every single package package sorting, every single package delivery will not be done by humans in delivery will not be done by humans in delivery will not be done by humans in 10 years. And it's starting today. Just 10 years. And it's starting today. Just 10 years. And it's starting today. Just like the idea that you would put like the idea that you would put like the idea that you would put together some of this consumer together some of this consumer together some of this consumer electronic stuff in factories with electronic stuff in factories with electronic stuff in factories with humans has gone away over time. and humans has gone away over time. and humans has gone away over time. and other countries. I think you're making a other countries. I think you're making a other countries. I think you're making a very good point here, Saxs, are going to very good point here, Saxs, are going to very good point here, Saxs, are going to experience it first. In America, experience it first. In America, experience it first. In America, knowledge workers, the entrepreneurial knowledge workers, the entrepreneurial knowledge workers, the entrepreneurial spirit. I think we're going to see a spirit. I think we're going to see a spirit. I think we're going to see a Cambrian explosion in startups, which Cambrian explosion in startups, which Cambrian explosion in startups, which means we're going to be the ones who means we're going to be the ones who means we're going to be the ones who benefit from it. But if you're looking benefit from it. But if you're looking benefit from it. But if you're looking at those other countries, they'll see it at those other countries, they'll see it at those other countries, they'll see it acutely first. We're just going to see acutely first. We're just going to see acutely first. We're just going to see it here with drivers, and that's 5 10 it here with drivers, and that's 5 10 it here with drivers, and that's 5 10 million people, like we saw it with million people, like we saw it with million people, like we saw it with cashiers. The idea of going to a cashier cashiers. The idea of going to a cashier cashiers. The idea of going to a cashier at a fast food restaurant, which I know at a fast food restaurant, which I know at a fast food restaurant, which I know you guys don't go to all that often, you guys don't go to all that often, you guys don't go to all that often, where Starbucks, the idea that you would where Starbucks, the idea that you would where Starbucks, the idea that you would interact with a cashier has been going interact with a cashier has been going interact with a cashier has been going away slowly because it's just consumers away slowly because it's just consumers away slowly because it's just consumers don't even want it. We'll agree to don't even want it. We'll agree to don't even want it. We'll agree to disagree here to a certain extent. Maybe disagree here to a certain extent. Maybe disagree here to a certain extent. Maybe we may we may we may >> Look, I went to McDonald I went to >> Look, I went to McDonald I went to >> Look, I went to McDonald I went to McDonald's recently and I ordered from McDonald's recently and I ordered from McDonald's recently and I ordered from one of those monitors. Zero. one of those monitors. Zero. one of those monitors. Zero. >> What did you order? You filet a fish >> What did you order? You filet a fish >> What did you order? You filet a fish guy? I'm a flay of fish guy. What'd you guy? I'm a flay of fish guy. What'd you guy? I'm a flay of fish guy. What'd you get? What's your get? What's your get? What's your >> I'm a Big Mac. I like a Big Mac. >> I'm a Big Mac. I like a Big Mac. >> I'm a Big Mac. I like a Big Mac. >> You like a Big Mac? What about you, Sax? >> You like a Big Mac? What about you, Sax? >> You like a Big Mac? What about you, Sax? What? What's your order? What's your Did What? What's your order? What's your Did What? What's your order? What's your Did you get a McFlurry? you get a McFlurry? you get a McFlurry? They had a thing called a homegrown They had a thing called a homegrown They had a thing called a homegrown burger which was some new I think it was burger which was some new I think it was burger which was some new I think it was kind of like more like an In-N-Out type kind of like more like an In-N-Out type kind of like more like an In-N-Out type burger situation they were testing. burger situation they were testing. burger situation they were testing. >> Smash Patty. >> Smash Patty. >> Smash Patty. >> Yeah, it was good. >> Yeah, it was good. >> Yeah, it was good. >> Anyway, my point is just the automation >> Anyway, my point is just the automation >> Anyway, my point is just the automation obviously they didn't have a cashier obviously they didn't have a cashier obviously they didn't have a cashier there already, but there's zero robots there already, but there's zero robots there already, but there's zero robots involved. Similarly, there's already a involved. Similarly, there's already a involved. Similarly, there's already a lot of automation going on in those lot of automation going on in those lot of automation going on in those Amazon warehouses. I don't know if Amazon warehouses. I don't know if Amazon warehouses. I don't know if you've ever been to like a FedEx you've ever been to like a FedEx you've ever been to like a FedEx packaging or routing depot. It's all packaging or routing depot. It's all packaging or routing depot. It's all conveyor belts and you know conveyor belts and you know conveyor belts and you know >> Yeah, robots pushing it and directing. >> Yeah, robots pushing it and directing. >> Yeah, robots pushing it and directing. But it's not it's not humanoid robots. But it's not it's not humanoid robots. But it's not it's not humanoid robots. There's already tons and tons of There's already tons and tons of There's already tons and tons of automation at these places. automation at these places. automation at these places. >> The last but this last mile part is the >> The last but this last mile part is the >> The last but this last mile part is the one I think that is going to shock one I think that is going to shock one I think that is going to shock people. When you have an optimist people. When you have an optimist people. When you have an optimist walking the Tesla self-driving car and walking the Tesla self-driving car and walking the Tesla self-driving car and then they walk it to your porch, ring then they walk it to your porch, ring then they walk it to your porch, ring your doorbell and knock on your door and your doorbell and knock on your door and your doorbell and knock on your door and put it on your front step porch. That's put it on your front step porch. That's put it on your front step porch. That's where this is going to get super where this is going to get super where this is going to get super interesting. interesting. interesting. >> I think it's going to lead to a boom >> I think it's going to lead to a boom >> I think it's going to lead to a boom because think about like just something because think about like just something because think about like just something like building a house. Okay. You know like building a house. Okay. You know like building a house. Okay. You know how long it takes to build a house how long it takes to build a house how long it takes to build a house >> in California? Three years. Yeah. Yeah. >> in California? Three years. Yeah. Yeah. >> in California? Three years. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Multiple years now Yeah. Multiple years now Yeah. Multiple years now >> in >> in >> in >> China one day. [laughter] >> China one day. [laughter] >> China one day. [laughter] >> There you go. >> There you go. >> There you go. >> But imagine if you have like a like a >> But imagine if you have like a like a >> But imagine if you have like a like a construction crew and I don't know it's construction crew and I don't know it's construction crew and I don't know it's like 20 humans and 50 robots or like 20 humans and 50 robots or like 20 humans and 50 robots or something. The humans have to tell the something. The humans have to tell the something. The humans have to tell the robots what to do. I don't robots what to do. I don't robots what to do. I don't >> supervisors. >> supervisors. >> supervisors. >> I think it's going to take a long long >> I think it's going to take a long long >> I think it's going to take a long long time for the robots to be able to do time for the robots to be able to do time for the robots to be able to do that super high skill work. But they can that super high skill work. But they can that super high skill work. But they can be given tasks be given tasks be given tasks >> and then gradually they can do. So maybe >> and then gradually they can do. So maybe >> and then gradually they can do. So maybe it only takes a year to build a house it only takes a year to build a house it only takes a year to build a house instead of two or three and that's the instead of two or three and that's the instead of two or three and that's the solution to our housing crisis. solution to our housing crisis. solution to our housing crisis. >> 100%. All right, listen. >> 100%. All right, listen. >> 100%. All right, listen. >> In a related story, by comedant Howard >> In a related story, by comedant Howard >> In a related story, by comedant Howard Lutnik's decree, subject Dario Amade Lutnik's decree, subject Dario Amade Lutnik's decree, subject Dario Amade will be permitted to bring his powerful will be permitted to bring his powerful will be permitted to bring his powerful new model Fable 5 to market for the new model Fable 5 to market for the new model Fable 5 to market for the glory of the realm and at the pleasure glory of the realm and at the pleasure glory of the realm and at the pleasure of his majesty Lord Trump. Remember two of his majesty Lord Trump. Remember two of his majesty Lord Trump. Remember two weeks ago the US government put export weeks ago the US government put export weeks ago the US government put export restrictions on Fable and Mythos and the restrictions on Fable and Mythos and the restrictions on Fable and Mythos and the Iliad and the Odyssey and whatever else Iliad and the Odyssey and whatever else Iliad and the Odyssey and whatever else they're doing over there at Anthropic they're doing over there at Anthropic they're doing over there at Anthropic and Anthropic expanding Mythos uh to 50 and Anthropic expanding Mythos uh to 50 and Anthropic expanding Mythos uh to 50 unauthorized entities according to unauthorized entities according to unauthorized entities according to sources that included SK Telecom which sources that included SK Telecom which sources that included SK Telecom which allegedly perhaps maybe has li ties to allegedly perhaps maybe has li ties to allegedly perhaps maybe has li ties to China on June 30th. Howy in the commerce China on June 30th. Howy in the commerce China on June 30th. Howy in the commerce department. That's my guy, Howard department. That's my guy, Howard department. That's my guy, Howard Lutnick, my favorite in the Lutnick, my favorite in the Lutnick, my favorite in the administration. No disrespect to you, administration. No disrespect to you, administration. No disrespect to you, Saxs. Um, he lifted controls on Fable 5. Saxs. Um, he lifted controls on Fable 5. Saxs. Um, he lifted controls on Fable 5. Mythos 5 was restored to US customers Mythos 5 was restored to US customers Mythos 5 was restored to US customers this past week, June 26th. Many this past week, June 26th. Many this past week, June 26th. Many suspected this would happen because suspected this would happen because suspected this would happen because Anthropic replaced Daario as their lead Anthropic replaced Daario as their lead Anthropic replaced Daario as their lead negotiator. Here is the Palace Intrigue negotiator. Here is the Palace Intrigue negotiator. Here is the Palace Intrigue I was referencing earlier. Co-founder I was referencing earlier. Co-founder I was referencing earlier. Co-founder Tom Brown, whoever that is, took the Tom Brown, whoever that is, took the Tom Brown, whoever that is, took the spot and appears to be getting along spot and appears to be getting along spot and appears to be getting along better with the Trump organization. For better with the Trump organization. For better with the Trump organization. For example, he proactively genulected example, he proactively genulected example, he proactively genulected showed the tweet to Lutnik's tweet showed the tweet to Lutnik's tweet showed the tweet to Lutnik's tweet announcing the export restricting announcing the export restricting announcing the export restricting restrictions had been lifted. Tom Brown, restrictions had been lifted. Tom Brown, restrictions had been lifted. Tom Brown, thanks for your partnership on this thanks for your partnership on this thanks for your partnership on this secretary explanation point. Look at secretary explanation point. Look at secretary explanation point. Look at that smile. Tom Brown coming in to save that smile. Tom Brown coming in to save that smile. Tom Brown coming in to save the day. In a postmortem blog post, the day. In a postmortem blog post, the day. In a postmortem blog post, Anthropic said the jailbreak that Anthropic said the jailbreak that Anthropic said the jailbreak that triggered the shutdown was not unique to triggered the shutdown was not unique to triggered the shutdown was not unique to Claude. Remember Andy Jasse reported to Claude. Remember Andy Jasse reported to Claude. Remember Andy Jasse reported to the Commerce Department what was going the Commerce Department what was going the Commerce Department what was going on with this. Okay, Saxs, former AISAR. on with this. Okay, Saxs, former AISAR. on with this. Okay, Saxs, former AISAR. What's going on? Give us the palace What's going on? Give us the palace What's going on? Give us the palace intrigue, please. intrigue, please. intrigue, please. >> Well, look, the export control letter >> Well, look, the export control letter >> Well, look, the export control letter was taken down after 2 weeks. I think was taken down after 2 weeks. I think was taken down after 2 weeks. I think that this was a highly unusual that this was a highly unusual that this was a highly unusual circumstance, and it was brought about circumstance, and it was brought about circumstance, and it was brought about by three things, three conditions, and by three things, three conditions, and by three things, three conditions, and you really needed all three in order for you really needed all three in order for you really needed all three in order for this to happen. Number one, you had this to happen. Number one, you had this to happen. Number one, you had Daario running around for months saying Daario running around for months saying Daario running around for months saying that he had created a cyber weapon. He that he had created a cyber weapon. He that he had created a cyber weapon. He almost boasted about it. It was mythos. almost boasted about it. It was mythos. almost boasted about it. It was mythos. Okay, so that was number one. Number two Okay, so that was number one. Number two Okay, so that was number one. Number two is you have a trusted partner of is you have a trusted partner of is you have a trusted partner of Anthropic which is Amazon which did its Anthropic which is Amazon which did its Anthropic which is Amazon which did its testing of Fable which was Mythos with testing of Fable which was Mythos with testing of Fable which was Mythos with guardrails and they reported that the guardrails and they reported that the guardrails and they reported that the guardrails failed. So therefore Fable guardrails failed. So therefore Fable guardrails failed. So therefore Fable was according to Daario a cyber weapon. was according to Daario a cyber weapon. was according to Daario a cyber weapon. So that was important fact number two. So that was important fact number two. So that was important fact number two. And then fact number three is that when And then fact number three is that when And then fact number three is that when confronted with this information, Daario confronted with this information, Daario confronted with this information, Daario basically refused to roll back Fable basically refused to roll back Fable basically refused to roll back Fable until the jailbreak could be fixed. Or until the jailbreak could be fixed. Or until the jailbreak could be fixed. Or at least that's what he communicated to at least that's what he communicated to at least that's what he communicated to the administration and that's what the the administration and that's what the the administration and that's what the administration heard. So I think if you administration heard. So I think if you administration heard. So I think if you change any one of those three facts, change any one of those three facts, change any one of those three facts, this would have ended up not causing the this would have ended up not causing the this would have ended up not causing the government to basically send that that government to basically send that that government to basically send that that letter to Anthropic. I think if Daario letter to Anthropic. I think if Daario letter to Anthropic. I think if Daario hadn't primed officials to see Mythos as hadn't primed officials to see Mythos as hadn't primed officials to see Mythos as a cyber weapon, it wouldn't have a cyber weapon, it wouldn't have a cyber weapon, it wouldn't have happened. If their trusted partner happened. If their trusted partner happened. If their trusted partner Amazon hadn't reported the jailbreak, Amazon hadn't reported the jailbreak, Amazon hadn't reported the jailbreak, wouldn't have happened. And if Daario wouldn't have happened. And if Daario wouldn't have happened. And if Daario hadn't refused to take action when he hadn't refused to take action when he hadn't refused to take action when he did, then this wouldn't have happened. I did, then this wouldn't have happened. I did, then this wouldn't have happened. I think this was sort of a unique think this was sort of a unique think this was sort of a unique circumstance. I guess what I'm trying to circumstance. I guess what I'm trying to circumstance. I guess what I'm trying to say is that a lot of people are reading say is that a lot of people are reading say is that a lot of people are reading a lot into this letter. I know that a lot into this letter. I know that a lot into this letter. I know that foreign companies or foreign actors or foreign companies or foreign actors or foreign companies or foreign actors or allies and partners of the US are allies and partners of the US are allies and partners of the US are wondering does this mean that our wondering does this mean that our wondering does this mean that our ability to access US technologies is ability to access US technologies is ability to access US technologies is going to be limited? I don't think it going to be limited? I don't think it going to be limited? I don't think it does. I think that the administration does. I think that the administration does. I think that the administration reacted with the tools at its disposal. reacted with the tools at its disposal. reacted with the tools at its disposal. And I think that what the president And I think that what the president And I think that what the president cares about is what he's always said, cares about is what he's always said, cares about is what he's always said, which is he wants to be pro- innovation. which is he wants to be pro- innovation. which is he wants to be pro- innovation. He wants to be pro export. He wants to He wants to be pro export. He wants to He wants to be pro export. He wants to be pro infrastructure. He wants to be pro infrastructure. He wants to be pro infrastructure. He wants to support American companies in the AI support American companies in the AI support American companies in the AI race and I don't think people should race and I don't think people should race and I don't think people should overextrapulate based on what just overextrapulate based on what just overextrapulate based on what just happened over the past few weeks. I happened over the past few weeks. I happened over the past few weeks. I think highly particular to this fact think highly particular to this fact think highly particular to this fact pattern. pattern. pattern. >> We a lot of discussion of exports. Let's >> We a lot of discussion of exports. Let's >> We a lot of discussion of exports. Let's talk about imports for a reason. It talk about imports for a reason. It talk about imports for a reason. It seems to me seems to me seems to me >> that importing Chinese models when we in >> that importing Chinese models when we in >> that importing Chinese models when we in fact have open- source models here from fact have open- source models here from fact have open- source models here from Nvidia and other players. Why have you Nvidia and other players. Why have you Nvidia and other players. Why have you not or in your during your time did you not or in your during your time did you not or in your during your time did you not advise or talk about here blocking not advise or talk about here blocking not advise or talk about here blocking access to import? We will not allow the access to import? We will not allow the access to import? We will not allow the importation of Huawei products into the importation of Huawei products into the importation of Huawei products into the United States or self-driving technology United States or self-driving technology United States or self-driving technology from China. Why are we allowing open from China. Why are we allowing open from China. Why are we allowing open source models? Why don't we put an source models? Why don't we put an source models? Why don't we put an edict? And why didn't you suggest that edict? And why didn't you suggest that edict? And why didn't you suggest that when you were thesar of AI? Why didn't when you were thesar of AI? Why didn't when you were thesar of AI? Why didn't we stop Kimmy and Deepseek from coming we stop Kimmy and Deepseek from coming we stop Kimmy and Deepseek from coming into this country in order to drive our into this country in order to drive our into this country in order to drive our open source technology and to keep the open source technology and to keep the open source technology and to keep the leakage leakage leakage from those model sacks? from those model sacks? from those model sacks? >> Well, if you is that a concern of yours? >> Well, if you is that a concern of yours? >> Well, if you is that a concern of yours? Well, number one is that once a model is Well, number one is that once a model is Well, number one is that once a model is open- sourced, it stops being Chinese in open- sourced, it stops being Chinese in open- sourced, it stops being Chinese in a way, right? Because you can now take a way, right? Because you can now take a way, right? Because you can now take that model, you can fork it, you can that model, you can fork it, you can that model, you can fork it, you can create your own version, you run it in create your own version, you run it in create your own version, you run it in an American data center on your own an American data center on your own an American data center on your own hardware. There's no packets going back hardware. There's no packets going back hardware. There's no packets going back to China. There's no data leakage going to China. There's no data leakage going to China. There's no data leakage going back to China. In some sense, they've back to China. In some sense, they've back to China. In some sense, they've made a contribution to the open source made a contribution to the open source made a contribution to the open source community. And then people can take it community. And then people can take it community. And then people can take it from there. Now, should you still from there. Now, should you still from there. Now, should you still exercise caution? Absolutely. because exercise caution? Absolutely. because exercise caution? Absolutely. because you have to make sure that the model is you have to make sure that the model is you have to make sure that the model is safe. It doesn't contain back doors. I safe. It doesn't contain back doors. I safe. It doesn't contain back doors. I mean, this is a relatively new surface mean, this is a relatively new surface mean, this is a relatively new surface area for cyber security. So, look, you area for cyber security. So, look, you area for cyber security. So, look, you should obviously be cautious. But the should obviously be cautious. But the should obviously be cautious. But the bottom line is that when an American bottom line is that when an American bottom line is that when an American company takes an open source model and company takes an open source model and company takes an open source model and converts it and runs it itself, it is converts it and runs it itself, it is converts it and runs it itself, it is now theirs. now theirs. now theirs. >> But it builds consensus around that >> But it builds consensus around that >> But it builds consensus around that model and makes that model stronger by model and makes that model stronger by model and makes that model stronger by more people participating in it, which more people participating in it, which more people participating in it, which was your argument for allowing people to was your argument for allowing people to was your argument for allowing people to get on the hardware stack. get on the hardware stack. get on the hardware stack. Well, but then that I think that leads Well, but then that I think that leads Well, but then that I think that leads me to argument number two, which is if me to argument number two, which is if me to argument number two, which is if you were to do something like ban open you were to do something like ban open you were to do something like ban open source in the United States, you'll put source in the United States, you'll put source in the United States, you'll put the United States on an island. The rest the United States on an island. The rest the United States on an island. The rest of the world is not going to follow of the world is not going to follow of the world is not going to follow suit. The rest of the world wants to use suit. The rest of the world wants to use suit. The rest of the world wants to use open models because of the advantages open models because of the advantages open models because of the advantages they offer. They're cheaper. They're they offer. They're cheaper. They're they offer. They're cheaper. They're more customizable. They offer more more customizable. They offer more more customizable. They offer more control. And again, they stop being control. And again, they stop being control. And again, they stop being Chinese models once you can take them Chinese models once you can take them Chinese models once you can take them and adapt them and run them on your own and adapt them and run them on your own and adapt them and run them on your own hardware. So the rest of the world's not hardware. So the rest of the world's not hardware. So the rest of the world's not going to stop using these models just going to stop using these models just going to stop using these models just because we do. And what we will do then because we do. And what we will do then because we do. And what we will do then is subject American enterprises to a is subject American enterprises to a is subject American enterprises to a token tax. You're going to end up paying token tax. You're going to end up paying token tax. You're going to end up paying for closed models in the US. for closed models in the US. for closed models in the US. >> No, but we have open source models now. >> No, but we have open source models now. >> No, but we have open source models now. Nvidia has theirs, for example. There Nvidia has theirs, for example. There Nvidia has theirs, for example. There are other ones. So if there are open are other ones. So if there are open are other ones. So if there are open source models here that are equally source models here that are equally source models here that are equally competitive, [snorts] competitive, [snorts] competitive, [snorts] >> would you then support an import control >> would you then support an import control >> would you then support an import control so that more people in America put their so that more people in America put their so that more people in America put their effort into American open source models? effort into American open source models? effort into American open source models? Well, I've been I've one of the things Well, I've been I've one of the things Well, I've been I've one of the things I've been saying for I've been saying for I've been saying for >> and Google's open source models. >> and Google's open source models. >> and Google's open source models. Obviously, Obviously, Obviously, >> one of the things I've been saying for >> one of the things I've been saying for >> one of the things I've been saying for over a year is that we need more strong over a year is that we need more strong over a year is that we need more strong offerings in open source from the United offerings in open source from the United offerings in open source from the United States. So, I hope we win the open States. So, I hope we win the open States. So, I hope we win the open category of models just like I do the category of models just like I do the category of models just like I do the closed. I mean, I hope America wins the closed. I mean, I hope America wins the closed. I mean, I hope America wins the AI race in both open and closed models. AI race in both open and closed models. AI race in both open and closed models. I don't really want anyone being forced I don't really want anyone being forced I don't really want anyone being forced to use models they don't want. But look, to use models they don't want. But look, to use models they don't want. But look, if American models, open models are if American models, open models are if American models, open models are better than Chinese open models, they better than Chinese open models, they better than Chinese open models, they will win and people will want to adopt will win and people will want to adopt will win and people will want to adopt them. So if what you're saying is true them. So if what you're saying is true them. So if what you're saying is true that our open models are better or that our open models are better or that our open models are better or getting better or going to surpass the getting better or going to surpass the getting better or going to surpass the Chinese ones, leave that to the market Chinese ones, leave that to the market Chinese ones, leave that to the market to decide. And just one last point on to decide. And just one last point on to decide. And just one last point on this is, you know, I'm not against this is, you know, I'm not against this is, you know, I'm not against limiting the import of certain Chinese limiting the import of certain Chinese limiting the import of certain Chinese products in the US. For example, I don't products in the US. For example, I don't products in the US. For example, I don't think we allow Chinese connected cars. think we allow Chinese connected cars. think we allow Chinese connected cars. >> We don't >> We don't >> We don't >> I think we should think twice about >> I think we should think twice about >> I think we should think twice about whether we allow, you know, Chinese whether we allow, you know, Chinese whether we allow, you know, Chinese robots into the US. I mean, robots into the US. I mean, robots into the US. I mean, >> yeah, we wouldn't want to have like a >> yeah, we wouldn't want to have like a >> yeah, we wouldn't want to have like a like a fifth column of, like a fifth column of, like a fifth column of, >> you know, of backdoor Chinese robots or >> you know, of backdoor Chinese robots or >> you know, of backdoor Chinese robots or something in the US potentially. I'm something in the US potentially. I'm something in the US potentially. I'm just brainstorming here. Okay. So, I'm just brainstorming here. Okay. So, I'm just brainstorming here. Okay. So, I'm not against limiting certain things, but not against limiting certain things, but not against limiting certain things, but we should understand that when we do we should understand that when we do we should understand that when we do that, we are inviting retaliation by that, we are inviting retaliation by that, we are inviting retaliation by them as well and we are in a trade them as well and we are in a trade them as well and we are in a trade relationship with them. We still need relationship with them. We still need relationship with them. We still need things from them. We still need rare things from them. We still need rare things from them. We still need rare earths, things like that. One day we earths, things like that. One day we earths, things like that. One day we won't hopefully. I do think we should won't hopefully. I do think we should won't hopefully. I do think we should try to be as independent and autonomous try to be as independent and autonomous try to be as independent and autonomous as possible, but while we do, we have to as possible, but while we do, we have to as possible, but while we do, we have to think very carefully about the larger think very carefully about the larger think very carefully about the larger trade relationship. Yeah, Trump banned trade relationship. Yeah, Trump banned trade relationship. Yeah, Trump banned the import of Chinese drones. It's a the import of Chinese drones. It's a the import of Chinese drones. It's a signature part of the legislation. So, signature part of the legislation. So, signature part of the legislation. So, um, all right. So, a little housekeeping um, all right. So, a little housekeeping um, all right. So, a little housekeeping here. All-in summit is coming back here. All-in summit is coming back here. All-in summit is coming back September 13th, 14th and 15th. Fifth September 13th, 14th and 15th. Fifth September 13th, 14th and 15th. Fifth year of the summit. Keep raising the year of the summit. Keep raising the year of the summit. Keep raising the bar. Man, if you knew the speakers that bar. Man, if you knew the speakers that bar. Man, if you knew the speakers that I knew that Freeberg's lined up, your I knew that Freeberg's lined up, your I knew that Freeberg's lined up, your brain would explode this year. The brain would explode this year. The brain would explode this year. The nights are as good as the days because nights are as good as the days because nights are as good as the days because let's face it, Freeberg likes to party. let's face it, Freeberg likes to party. let's face it, Freeberg likes to party. He's been known to have a cocktail or He's been known to have a cocktail or He's been known to have a cocktail or two. We're doing the biggest poker two. We're doing the biggest poker two. We're doing the biggest poker tournament we've ever done at the summit tournament we've ever done at the summit tournament we've ever done at the summit this year. Gaming will happen at the this year. Gaming will happen at the this year. Gaming will happen at the welcome party and we're going to have a welcome party and we're going to have a welcome party and we're going to have a full casino night at an exclusive full casino night at an exclusive full casino night at an exclusive mansion in LA. Ooh la la. Applications mansion in LA. Ooh la la. Applications mansion in LA. Ooh la la. Applications open now. Allin.com. Don't miss our open now. Allin.com. Don't miss our open now. Allin.com. Don't miss our biggest event of the year. I think we biggest event of the year. I think we biggest event of the year. I think we have 12 trillion in market cap books so have 12 trillion in market cap books so have 12 trillion in market cap books so far. It's probably going to double. far. It's probably going to double. far. It's probably going to double. Okay, next topic. Topic number three. Okay, next topic. Topic number three. Okay, next topic. Topic number three. It's a hot scot this summer. The It's a hot scot this summer. The It's a hot scot this summer. The justices released 11 decisions in the justices released 11 decisions in the justices released 11 decisions in the final few days of the term. Let's final few days of the term. Let's final few days of the term. Let's discuss the top three right now. discuss the top three right now. discuss the top three right now. Birthright citizenship case was Trump Birthright citizenship case was Trump Birthright citizenship case was Trump versus Barbara. On the first day of his versus Barbara. On the first day of his versus Barbara. On the first day of his second term, Trump, as you know, signed second term, Trump, as you know, signed second term, Trump, as you know, signed an EO ending automatic citizenship for an EO ending automatic citizenship for an EO ending automatic citizenship for children born to illegal immigrants or children born to illegal immigrants or children born to illegal immigrants or those on temporary visas. Uh this is those on temporary visas. Uh this is those on temporary visas. Uh this is codified, I guess, in the 14th codified, I guess, in the 14th codified, I guess, in the 14th amendment. Court struck it down 63, amendment. Court struck it down 63, amendment. Court struck it down 63, maybe 54. There's some nuance here. maybe 54. There's some nuance here. maybe 54. There's some nuance here. 255,000 children are born every year to 255,000 children are born every year to 255,000 children are born every year to non-citizen parents. Chief Justice non-citizen parents. Chief Justice non-citizen parents. Chief Justice Roberts wrote, "The majority, joined by Roberts wrote, "The majority, joined by Roberts wrote, "The majority, joined by all three liberal members." The court is all three liberal members." The court is all three liberal members." The court is still a bit uh polarized citizenship still a bit uh polarized citizenship still a bit uh polarized citizenship then and now was the right to have then and now was the right to have then and now was the right to have rights. We keep that promise today rights. We keep that promise today rights. We keep that promise today according to Chief Justice's majority. according to Chief Justice's majority. according to Chief Justice's majority. Kavanaaugh carved out a lane for Kavanaaugh carved out a lane for Kavanaaugh carved out a lane for Congress to tighten up on birthright Congress to tighten up on birthright Congress to tighten up on birthright citizenship. That's still consistent citizenship. That's still consistent citizenship. That's still consistent with the 14th Amendment. Uh, as you with the 14th Amendment. Uh, as you with the 14th Amendment. Uh, as you know, the administration has been know, the administration has been know, the administration has been pointing out, and you've watched Fox pointing out, and you've watched Fox pointing out, and you've watched Fox News, you've heard this a million times. News, you've heard this a million times. News, you've heard this a million times. If you watch CNN and Not All In, you're If you watch CNN and Not All In, you're If you watch CNN and Not All In, you're going to maybe have heard of this once going to maybe have heard of this once going to maybe have heard of this once or twice. Birth tourism. A Chinese or twice. Birth tourism. A Chinese or twice. Birth tourism. A Chinese national, Dong Wan Lee, plead guilty in national, Dong Wan Lee, plead guilty in national, Dong Wan Lee, plead guilty in 2019 to a scheme to help pregnant 2019 to a scheme to help pregnant 2019 to a scheme to help pregnant Chinese women enter the US under false Chinese women enter the US under false Chinese women enter the US under false pretenses so their babies would be pretenses so their babies would be pretenses so their babies would be granted US citizenship. She pled guilty granted US citizenship. She pled guilty granted US citizenship. She pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit to one count of conspiracy to commit to one count of conspiracy to commit immigration fraud and one count of visa immigration fraud and one count of visa immigration fraud and one count of visa fraud. So we we handled that through the fraud. So we we handled that through the fraud. So we we handled that through the legal system. She served 10 months in legal system. She served 10 months in legal system. She served 10 months in prison. Trump's response to the loss. prison. Trump's response to the loss. prison. Trump's response to the loss. Quote, "Congress should start today to Quote, "Congress should start today to Quote, "Congress should start today to work on ending birthright citizenship. work on ending birthright citizenship. work on ending birthright citizenship. They will have my complete and total They will have my complete and total They will have my complete and total support for Trump. Feels like a loss for support for Trump. Feels like a loss for support for Trump. Feels like a loss for Trump objectively, Trump objectively, Trump objectively, but he's going to keep fighting this but he's going to keep fighting this but he's going to keep fighting this one." Close decision. Uh if you ask one." Close decision. Uh if you ask one." Close decision. Uh if you ask Steven Miller, he doesn't like Steven Miller, he doesn't like Steven Miller, he doesn't like immigrants like you three dudes. But I immigrants like you three dudes. But I immigrants like you three dudes. But I would let all three of you in. Again, would let all three of you in. Again, would let all three of you in. Again, >> that's not his position. >> that's not his position. >> that's not his position. >> Okay. Well, you can explain. I know he >> Okay. Well, you can explain. I know he >> Okay. Well, you can explain. I know he doesn't like immigrants. doesn't like immigrants. doesn't like immigrants. >> We're legal immigrants. We're legal >> We're legal immigrants. We're legal >> We're legal immigrants. We're legal immigrants. immigrants. immigrants. >> Yes. Well, but >> Yes. Well, but >> Yes. Well, but >> you understand the difference, right? >> you understand the difference, right? >> you understand the difference, right? >> Well, birthright would also be legal >> Well, birthright would also be legal >> Well, birthright would also be legal according to the Constitution. according to the Constitution. according to the Constitution. >> Yeah. But that's the whole point is it >> Yeah. But that's the whole point is it >> Yeah. But that's the whole point is it doesn't really make sense that let's say doesn't really make sense that let's say doesn't really make sense that let's say an illegal immigrant runs across the an illegal immigrant runs across the an illegal immigrant runs across the border, is like 9 months pregnant, plops border, is like 9 months pregnant, plops border, is like 9 months pregnant, plops out a baby, and all of a sudden they're out a baby, and all of a sudden they're out a baby, and all of a sudden they're an American citizen. How does that make an American citizen. How does that make an American citizen. How does that make sense? Uh, what about somebody who's sense? Uh, what about somebody who's sense? Uh, what about somebody who's been here for 20 years, Sachs, worked been here for 20 years, Sachs, worked been here for 20 years, Sachs, worked really hard, they're illegal, and they really hard, they're illegal, and they really hard, they're illegal, and they have a baby. Should the baby kicked out have a baby. Should the baby kicked out have a baby. Should the baby kicked out and that baby not be a citizen? You're, and that baby not be a citizen? You're, and that baby not be a citizen? You're, let's say it's somebody's nanny, let's say it's somebody's nanny, let's say it's somebody's nanny, somebody's gardener. We have 20 million, somebody's gardener. We have 20 million, somebody's gardener. We have 20 million, 30 million illegal immigrants we've let 30 million illegal immigrants we've let 30 million illegal immigrants we've let into this country. We wave them in into this country. We wave them in into this country. We wave them in across many different Republican and across many different Republican and across many different Republican and Democratic terms over the last 30 years. Democratic terms over the last 30 years. Democratic terms over the last 30 years. What do you say to that person who has a What do you say to that person who has a What do you say to that person who has a baby? Should they be deported? Should baby? Should they be deported? Should baby? Should they be deported? Should they be given citizenship? they be given citizenship? they be given citizenship? >> Well, look, the question here is what >> Well, look, the question here is what >> Well, look, the question here is what the Constitution says. And my view is the Constitution says. And my view is the Constitution says. And my view is that the original purpose and that the original purpose and that the original purpose and understanding of the 14th amendment was understanding of the 14th amendment was understanding of the 14th amendment was to make sure that the children of freed to make sure that the children of freed to make sure that the children of freed slaves would have citizenship rights. slaves would have citizenship rights. slaves would have citizenship rights. That was the purpose of it. That it's That was the purpose of it. That it's That was the purpose of it. That it's obvious. And I don't think it speaks to obvious. And I don't think it speaks to obvious. And I don't think it speaks to the situations you're talking about and the situations you're talking about and the situations you're talking about and Congress should just make the law about Congress should just make the law about Congress should just make the law about those situations. But now Congress those situations. But now Congress those situations. But now Congress cannot make the law because the Supreme cannot make the law because the Supreme cannot make the law because the Supreme Court has ruled that citizenship is Court has ruled that citizenship is Court has ruled that citizenship is determined by birthright. So in that determined by birthright. So in that determined by birthright. So in that case, My question was somebody who's case, My question was somebody who's case, My question was somebody who's been here 20 years as an illegal been here 20 years as an illegal been here 20 years as an illegal immigrant underrange. immigrant underrange. immigrant underrange. >> I'm saying Congress should >> I'm saying Congress should >> I'm saying Congress should >> What do you think? I'm asking you your >> What do you think? I'm asking you your >> What do you think? I'm asking you your personal opinion. Should they get personal opinion. Should they get personal opinion. Should they get >> I mean, look, that's you're talking >> I mean, look, that's you're talking >> I mean, look, that's you're talking about an edge case. It's complicated. about an edge case. It's complicated. about an edge case. It's complicated. But the point is that we all know why But the point is that we all know why But the point is that we all know why the 14th Amendment was ratified. It was the 14th Amendment was ratified. It was the 14th Amendment was ratified. It was to protect freed slaves, obviously. And to protect freed slaves, obviously. And to protect freed slaves, obviously. And now we're in territory that's like very now we're in territory that's like very now we're in territory that's like very different. But the Supreme Court has different. But the Supreme Court has different. But the Supreme Court has decided that if you're born here for any decided that if you're born here for any decided that if you're born here for any reason whatsoever, even if you're an reason whatsoever, even if you're an reason whatsoever, even if you're an illegal, even if you weren't supposed to illegal, even if you weren't supposed to illegal, even if you weren't supposed to be in the country, now your children are be in the country, now your children are be in the country, now your children are American citizens. By the way, I don't American citizens. By the way, I don't American citizens. By the way, I don't think any country in the world has this think any country in the world has this think any country in the world has this policy. It's kind of a crazy policy. So, policy. It's kind of a crazy policy. So, policy. It's kind of a crazy policy. So, I agree with Stephen Miller about this. I agree with Stephen Miller about this. I agree with Stephen Miller about this. >> I'm not sure it's an edge case. I think >> I'm not sure it's an edge case. I think >> I'm not sure it's an edge case. I think I think the majority case is people I think the majority case is people I think the majority case is people who've been here illegally for for who've been here illegally for for who've been here illegally for for decades. And I think the edge case, the decades. And I think the edge case, the decades. And I think the edge case, the one you proposed is the edge case, like one you proposed is the edge case, like one you proposed is the edge case, like a pregnant woman running across the a pregnant woman running across the a pregnant woman running across the border. border. border. >> Let Congress decide that. I don't think >> Let Congress decide that. I don't think >> Let Congress decide that. I don't think the Constitution ever spoke to this. the Constitution ever spoke to this. the Constitution ever spoke to this. What's your personal opinion on this, What's your personal opinion on this, What's your personal opinion on this, Shimat? Should the person who's been Shimat? Should the person who's been Shimat? Should the person who's been here for 10, 20 years, paid their taxes, here for 10, 20 years, paid their taxes, here for 10, 20 years, paid their taxes, but they're illegal, and they have a but they're illegal, and they have a but they're illegal, and they have a child, should that child be a citizen or child, should that child be a citizen or child, should that child be a citizen or not? What's Shmat's personal opinion not? What's Shmat's personal opinion not? What's Shmat's personal opinion here? here? here? >> I haven't thought about this. >> I haven't thought about this. >> I haven't thought about this. >> Great. Okay. It's uh I mean, that's the >> Great. Okay. It's uh I mean, that's the >> Great. Okay. It's uh I mean, that's the key to the uh I think what we're talking key to the uh I think what we're talking key to the uh I think what we're talking about here. Free. about here. Free. about here. Free. >> No, no, no, no. Because J, there's a big >> No, no, no, no. Because J, there's a big >> No, no, no, no. Because J, there's a big difference between making something difference between making something difference between making something constitutional and then doing it via a constitutional and then doing it via a constitutional and then doing it via a law of Congress. And what Supreme Court law of Congress. And what Supreme Court law of Congress. And what Supreme Court has said here is that Congress does not has said here is that Congress does not has said here is that Congress does not get to make the decision. The majority get to make the decision. The majority get to make the decision. The majority of the American people don't get to make of the American people don't get to make of the American people don't get to make the decision. The Constitution requires the decision. The Constitution requires the decision. The Constitution requires a certain point of view and there's no a certain point of view and there's no a certain point of view and there's no way to change that without a way to change that without a way to change that without a constitutional amendment, which will constitutional amendment, which will constitutional amendment, which will never happen. So, we're kind of now never happen. So, we're kind of now never happen. So, we're kind of now stuck with this position. Hm. Well, if stuck with this position. Hm. Well, if stuck with this position. Hm. Well, if you read the language and someone posted you read the language and someone posted you read the language and someone posted this, this was the debate that when the this, this was the debate that when the this, this was the debate that when the 14th amendment was being debated, 14th amendment was being debated, 14th amendment was being debated, Senator Jacob Howard, I'll give credit Senator Jacob Howard, I'll give credit Senator Jacob Howard, I'll give credit to Guyer Capital for pointing this out. to Guyer Capital for pointing this out. to Guyer Capital for pointing this out. There's a transcript of the debate that There's a transcript of the debate that There's a transcript of the debate that took place and it says um every person took place and it says um every person took place and it says um every person born within the limits of the United born within the limits of the United born within the limits of the United States and subject to their jurisdiction States and subject to their jurisdiction States and subject to their jurisdiction is by virtue of natural law, national is by virtue of natural law, national is by virtue of natural law, national law a citizen of the United States. This law a citizen of the United States. This law a citizen of the United States. This will not of course include persons born will not of course include persons born will not of course include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, in the United States who are foreigners, in the United States who are foreigners, aliens who belong to the families of aliens who belong to the families of aliens who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers ambassadors or foreign ministers ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the government of the accredited to the government of the accredited to the government of the United States, but will include every United States, but will include every United States, but will include every other class of persons. Because if you other class of persons. Because if you other class of persons. Because if you go to the history in 1868, there was go to the history in 1868, there was go to the history in 1868, there was this Dread Scott decision which denied this Dread Scott decision which denied this Dread Scott decision which denied citizenship to the children of slaves. citizenship to the children of slaves. citizenship to the children of slaves. And the intention at the time was to And the intention at the time was to And the intention at the time was to ensure citizenship for newly freed ensure citizenship for newly freed ensure citizenship for newly freed slaves and their descendants. That was slaves and their descendants. That was slaves and their descendants. That was the original intention of the 14th the original intention of the 14th the original intention of the 14th amendment at the time. So this goes back amendment at the time. So this goes back amendment at the time. So this goes back to the great debate that happens at the to the great debate that happens at the to the great debate that happens at the Supreme Court all the time, which is the Supreme Court all the time, which is the Supreme Court all the time, which is the textual or the intentional reading of textual or the intentional reading of textual or the intentional reading of the Constitution or its amendments. The the Constitution or its amendments. The the Constitution or its amendments. The textual reading is you look strictly at textual reading is you look strictly at textual reading is you look strictly at the words, the plain literal meaning of the words, the plain literal meaning of the words, the plain literal meaning of those words. And then the intentional those words. And then the intentional those words. And then the intentional reading is what was intended at the time reading is what was intended at the time reading is what was intended at the time by the framers of the constitution or by the framers of the constitution or by the framers of the constitution or the amendment that may be the subject of the amendment that may be the subject of the amendment that may be the subject of the debate. And so I think that's the debate. And so I think that's the debate. And so I think that's ultimately what this comes down to. If ultimately what this comes down to. If ultimately what this comes down to. If you think about the intention at the you think about the intention at the you think about the intention at the time, it was really built around free time, it was really built around free time, it was really built around free slaves. There wasn't a consideration at slaves. There wasn't a consideration at slaves. There wasn't a consideration at that time of having this massive that time of having this massive that time of having this massive movement of immigration that was taking movement of immigration that was taking movement of immigration that was taking place or that has taken place since. place or that has taken place since. place or that has taken place since. that wasn't even in the kind of realm of that wasn't even in the kind of realm of that wasn't even in the kind of realm of consciousness or consideration when this consciousness or consideration when this consciousness or consideration when this amendment was being passed. So the amendment was being passed. So the amendment was being passed. So the intentionalism kind of argument would be intentionalism kind of argument would be intentionalism kind of argument would be hey wait a second you know this wasn't hey wait a second you know this wasn't hey wait a second you know this wasn't really what they intended but the really what they intended but the really what they intended but the textual representation is what it is and textual representation is what it is and textual representation is what it is and that's what the ruling kind of led to in that's what the ruling kind of led to in that's what the ruling kind of led to in this particular case. my personal this particular case. my personal this particular case. my personal opinion, if you're asking it, opinion, if you're asking it, opinion, if you're asking it, >> I'm trying to get personal opinions >> I'm trying to get personal opinions >> I'm trying to get personal opinions here. here. here. >> I do think birthright citizenship um >> I do think birthright citizenship um >> I do think birthright citizenship um should be endowed to the children of uh should be endowed to the children of uh should be endowed to the children of uh legal residents of the United States, legal residents of the United States, legal residents of the United States, whether they're a citizen or not. So, whether they're a citizen or not. So, whether they're a citizen or not. So, yeah, I think that's critical. So, if yeah, I think that's critical. So, if yeah, I think that's critical. So, if you're a visitor, if you get on an you're a visitor, if you get on an you're a visitor, if you get on an airplane and fly here for a weekend on a airplane and fly here for a weekend on a airplane and fly here for a weekend on a vacation and you have a visa or you vacation and you have a visa or you vacation and you have a visa or you have, have, have, >> you know, temporary visitor status to >> you know, temporary visitor status to >> you know, temporary visitor status to come. come. come. >> Yeah. or or you have a temporary visitor >> Yeah. or or you have a temporary visitor >> Yeah. or or you have a temporary visitor status to come to the United States to status to come to the United States to status to come to the United States to visit, you are not a resident of the visit, you are not a resident of the visit, you are not a resident of the United States. So, your children should United States. So, your children should United States. So, your children should not become citizens of the United States not become citizens of the United States not become citizens of the United States unless you're a resident. And remember, unless you're a resident. And remember, unless you're a resident. And remember, we don't just have like citizens and we don't just have like citizens and we don't just have like citizens and non-citizens. We also have resident non-citizens. We also have resident non-citizens. We also have resident status in this country. And a resident status in this country. And a resident status in this country. And a resident status is a green card. I mean, for status is a green card. I mean, for status is a green card. I mean, for years, I was on a green card. Three of years, I was on a green card. Three of years, I was on a green card. Three of us were immigrants. We all went through us were immigrants. We all went through us were immigrants. We all went through this process. Once you get resident this process. Once you get resident this process. Once you get resident status, you're now a permanent resident status, you're now a permanent resident status, you're now a permanent resident of the United States. You haven't been of the United States. You haven't been of the United States. You haven't been given citizenship rights yet. But if you given citizenship rights yet. But if you given citizenship rights yet. But if you have a child, I think it's reasonable have a child, I think it's reasonable have a child, I think it's reasonable for your child to have citizenship for your child to have citizenship for your child to have citizenship rights if you're a legal resident rather rights if you're a legal resident rather rights if you're a legal resident rather than a legal visitor or illegal visitor than a legal visitor or illegal visitor than a legal visitor or illegal visitor to the United States. That would be my to the United States. That would be my to the United States. That would be my personal assessment. I you know, it personal assessment. I you know, it personal assessment. I you know, it would be great for that to be the law, would be great for that to be the law, would be great for that to be the law, but obviously this is now kind of, but obviously this is now kind of, but obviously this is now kind of, >> you know, gone explain that really well. >> you know, gone explain that really well. >> you know, gone explain that really well. I didn't even know all of this. I'm I'm I didn't even know all of this. I'm I'm I didn't even know all of this. I'm I'm on your side. I agree. on your side. I agree. on your side. I agree. >> Yeah. I mean, I I agree with that. >> Yeah. I mean, I I agree with that. >> Yeah. I mean, I I agree with that. You're saying in addition, people You're saying in addition, people You're saying in addition, people shouldn't be able to do the tourism shouldn't be able to do the tourism shouldn't be able to do the tourism thing. We should handle that. Um, I do thing. We should handle that. Um, I do thing. We should handle that. Um, I do think we should have an exception here think we should have an exception here think we should have an exception here for people who have been for people who have been for people who have been noncriminals who are here illegally noncriminals who are here illegally noncriminals who are here illegally because we as America, Republicans because we as America, Republicans because we as America, Republicans especially, uh, during the time when especially, uh, during the time when especially, uh, during the time when they were pro free trade, NAFTA and they were pro free trade, NAFTA and they were pro free trade, NAFTA and really waved in a large percentage of really waved in a large percentage of really waved in a large percentage of the immigrants who here, obviously Biden the immigrants who here, obviously Biden the immigrants who here, obviously Biden did that as well. I think we have a did that as well. I think we have a did that as well. I think we have a moral obligation to those people since moral obligation to those people since moral obligation to those people since we waved them in and we waved them in to we waved them in and we waved them in to we waved them in and we waved them in to work at our businesses because we wanted work at our businesses because we wanted work at our businesses because we wanted to pay under minimum wage to them. those to pay under minimum wage to them. those to pay under minimum wage to them. those people suffered here in our country to people suffered here in our country to people suffered here in our country to take those jobs to make us richer, to take those jobs to make us richer, to take those jobs to make us richer, to make our country richer. We have a moral make our country richer. We have a moral make our country richer. We have a moral and ethical obligation to them and to and ethical obligation to them and to and ethical obligation to them and to their children. We should give them a their children. We should give them a their children. We should give them a path to citizenship unless they're path to citizenship unless they're path to citizenship unless they're criminals and their children should be criminals and their children should be criminals and their children should be Americans. Since they came here to live Americans. Since they came here to live Americans. Since they came here to live the American dream, whether it was the American dream, whether it was the American dream, whether it was illegal or not, we waved them in. That illegal or not, we waved them in. That illegal or not, we waved them in. That was our mistake. And now that we've was our mistake. And now that we've was our mistake. And now that we've closed the border, we should make amends closed the border, we should make amends closed the border, we should make amends to those 20 million people. That's my to those 20 million people. That's my to those 20 million people. That's my personal opinion. I don't think we have personal opinion. I don't think we have personal opinion. I don't think we have need more time to think about it and need more time to think about it and need more time to think about it and Saxur. Saxur. Saxur. >> Well, my my point is we're all just >> Well, my my point is we're all just >> Well, my my point is we're all just making arguments about what the law making arguments about what the law making arguments about what the law should be and these are the kinds of should be and these are the kinds of should be and these are the kinds of arguments that Congress should be making arguments that Congress should be making arguments that Congress should be making and deliberating over and deliberating over and deliberating over >> and these are the edge cases. These are >> and these are the edge cases. These are >> and these are the edge cases. These are the nuances that should be handled in a the nuances that should be handled in a the nuances that should be handled in a citizenship law. And what the Supreme citizenship law. And what the Supreme citizenship law. And what the Supreme Court has done here is remove that space Court has done here is remove that space Court has done here is remove that space for Congress to legislate. And I think for Congress to legislate. And I think for Congress to legislate. And I think Congress needs that space because there Congress needs that space because there Congress needs that space because there are these edge cases and instead it's are these edge cases and instead it's are these edge cases and instead it's interpreted the 14th amendment in a way interpreted the 14th amendment in a way interpreted the 14th amendment in a way that I don't think is consistent with that I don't think is consistent with that I don't think is consistent with why it was ratified in the first place. why it was ratified in the first place. why it was ratified in the first place. And Freeberg is totally right about And Freeberg is totally right about And Freeberg is totally right about about Dread Scott which was one of the about Dread Scott which was one of the about Dread Scott which was one of the most awful probably the most awful most awful probably the most awful most awful probably the most awful Supreme Court ruling of all time. It Supreme Court ruling of all time. It Supreme Court ruling of all time. It came out in 1857 came out in 1857 came out in 1857 and it ruled that black people whether and it ruled that black people whether and it ruled that black people whether enslaved or free were not US citizens enslaved or free were not US citizens enslaved or free were not US citizens and therefore they had no right to sue and therefore they had no right to sue and therefore they had no right to sue in federal courts. And the chief justice in federal courts. And the chief justice in federal courts. And the chief justice Roger Tony wrote the decision I mean Roger Tony wrote the decision I mean Roger Tony wrote the decision I mean it's extremely racist. He wrote that it's extremely racist. He wrote that it's extremely racist. He wrote that black people had quote no rights which black people had quote no rights which black people had quote no rights which the white man was bound to respect. And the white man was bound to respect. And the white man was bound to respect. And that decision furthermore ruled that that decision furthermore ruled that that decision furthermore ruled that Congress could not ban slavery in the Congress could not ban slavery in the Congress could not ban slavery in the new western territories which meant that new western territories which meant that new western territories which meant that it struck down the Missouri compromise it struck down the Missouri compromise it struck down the Missouri compromise which was the law that had kept the which was the law that had kept the which was the law that had kept the peace between the free and slave states peace between the free and slave states peace between the free and slave states for decades. And that is one of the for decades. And that is one of the for decades. And that is one of the direct things that then triggered the direct things that then triggered the direct things that then triggered the civil war 3 years later. So it was this civil war 3 years later. So it was this civil war 3 years later. So it was this historically bad decision that I guess historically bad decision that I guess historically bad decision that I guess then the 14th amendment tried to correct then the 14th amendment tried to correct then the 14th amendment tried to correct by saying that no by saying that no by saying that no you know freed slaves and their children you know freed slaves and their children you know freed slaves and their children would be would be would be >> totally different context than someone >> totally different context than someone >> totally different context than someone visiting from China for the weekend and visiting from China for the weekend and visiting from China for the weekend and having a baby. having a baby. having a baby. >> Yeah, which we obviously that one is an >> Yeah, which we obviously that one is an >> Yeah, which we obviously that one is an easy one to adjudicate. Chimath, I'm easy one to adjudicate. Chimath, I'm easy one to adjudicate. Chimath, I'm curious feels like as a society we have curious feels like as a society we have curious feels like as a society we have now because of the closure of the border now because of the closure of the border now because of the closure of the border give Trump a lot of credit for that. It give Trump a lot of credit for that. It give Trump a lot of credit for that. It was easily done, which means it could was easily done, which means it could was easily done, which means it could have been done at any time by Biden. And have been done at any time by Biden. And have been done at any time by Biden. And that created a big rift in our society that created a big rift in our society that created a big rift in our society that we're still working through. The that we're still working through. The that we're still working through. The other rift that was created over the other rift that was created over the other rift that was created over the past year, we've had many debates here past year, we've had many debates here past year, we've had many debates here about ICE and what some people, about ICE and what some people, about ICE and what some people, including myself, believe was a brutal including myself, believe was a brutal including myself, believe was a brutal way to deport people and a cruel way to way to deport people and a cruel way to way to deport people and a cruel way to deport people. Some people might deport people. Some people might deport people. Some people might disagree with my opinion, but it seems disagree with my opinion, but it seems disagree with my opinion, but it seems like Trump stood down on that and calmed like Trump stood down on that and calmed like Trump stood down on that and calmed it down, I think, because it was so it down, I think, because it was so it down, I think, because it was so unpopular, at least according to the unpopular, at least according to the unpopular, at least according to the metrics that we saw from Pew and other metrics that we saw from Pew and other metrics that we saw from Pew and other uh studies. What do you think the road uh studies. What do you think the road uh studies. What do you think the road the the the path forward is now? The ICE the the the path forward is now? The ICE the the the path forward is now? The ICE um aggressiveness has stopped. The um aggressiveness has stopped. The um aggressiveness has stopped. The border has been shut. We seem to be in a border has been shut. We seem to be in a border has been shut. We seem to be in a sort of holding pattern here which I sort of holding pattern here which I sort of holding pattern here which I think was very wise by Trump to do that. think was very wise by Trump to do that. think was very wise by Trump to do that. Put us like calm the situation down. I Put us like calm the situation down. I Put us like calm the situation down. I would have liked to seen him calm it would have liked to seen him calm it would have liked to seen him calm it down a little earlier. What do you think down a little earlier. What do you think down a little earlier. What do you think the go forward should be? If we go look the go forward should be? If we go look the go forward should be? If we go look at 27, 28, 29, do you think obviously we at 27, 28, 29, do you think obviously we at 27, 28, 29, do you think obviously we all want legal immigration, but what do all want legal immigration, but what do all want legal immigration, but what do you think we should be aspiring to do as you think we should be aspiring to do as you think we should be aspiring to do as a country now that the issue has a country now that the issue has a country now that the issue has seemingly is not boiling over? What are seemingly is not boiling over? What are seemingly is not boiling over? What are your what are your thoughts? Jamaal, your what are your thoughts? Jamaal, your what are your thoughts? Jamaal, have you given it any thought? have you given it any thought? have you given it any thought? >> I think that Western countries are >> I think that Western countries are >> I think that Western countries are losing their losing their losing their cultural representation that makes them cultural representation that makes them cultural representation that makes them unique and I think that that's very bad. unique and I think that that's very bad. unique and I think that that's very bad. When my parents When my parents When my parents went to Canada and then stayed, I think went to Canada and then stayed, I think went to Canada and then stayed, I think part of what they were doing, whether part of what they were doing, whether part of what they were doing, whether they knew it or not, was making an they knew it or not, was making an they knew it or not, was making an explicit decision to be Canadian first, explicit decision to be Canadian first, explicit decision to be Canadian first, which who happened to be of Sri Lankan which who happened to be of Sri Lankan which who happened to be of Sri Lankan origin. origin. origin. When I came to the United States, I was When I came to the United States, I was When I came to the United States, I was making an explicit decision to become an making an explicit decision to become an making an explicit decision to become an American and then my Canadian and then American and then my Canadian and then American and then my Canadian and then my Sri Lankan ancestry was second and my Sri Lankan ancestry was second and my Sri Lankan ancestry was second and third respectively. third respectively. third respectively. I think if you seed your immigration, I think if you seed your immigration, I think if you seed your immigration, you're seeding your culture. And I think you're seeding your culture. And I think you're seeding your culture. And I think that people have a responsibility that people have a responsibility that people have a responsibility to keep the values of what made that to keep the values of what made that to keep the values of what made that country unique in the first place. And country unique in the first place. And country unique in the first place. And you don't need to look too far because you don't need to look too far because you don't need to look too far because you can look across the pond and you can you can look across the pond and you can you can look across the pond and you can look at the UK and you can look at look at the UK and you can look at look at the UK and you can look at Germany and you can look at France and Germany and you can look at France and Germany and you can look at France and you have to ask yourself you have to ask yourself you have to ask yourself is the cultural deviation from where is the cultural deviation from where is the cultural deviation from where they were. Has it been better or worse they were. Has it been better or worse they were. Has it been better or worse for those countries? And I think in for those countries? And I think in for those countries? And I think in general it has been worse. So I think general it has been worse. So I think general it has been worse. So I think people should want to come here to be a people should want to come here to be a people should want to come here to be a part of the American ideal, the American part of the American ideal, the American part of the American ideal, the American culture. And so I think you have to have culture. And so I think you have to have culture. And so I think you have to have a rational immigration policy that has a rational immigration policy that has a rational immigration policy that has compassion but ultimately compassion but ultimately compassion but ultimately favors this idea that you can't come favors this idea that you can't come favors this idea that you can't come here to build your own version of your here to build your own version of your here to build your own version of your previous country here. So assimilation previous country here. So assimilation previous country here. So assimilation is part and parcel of a functioning is part and parcel of a functioning is part and parcel of a functioning immigration system. I strongly agree. immigration system. I strongly agree. immigration system. I strongly agree. Freebrook, how should we go forward as Freebrook, how should we go forward as Freebrook, how should we go forward as Americans? We know Europe has had an Americans? We know Europe has had an Americans? We know Europe has had an issue with uh or the populace is there I issue with uh or the populace is there I issue with uh or the populace is there I think are in agreement that they may think are in agreement that they may think are in agreement that they may have gone too far in terms of uh have gone too far in terms of uh have gone too far in terms of uh unmitigated massive amounts of unmitigated massive amounts of unmitigated massive amounts of immigration specifically amongst groups immigration specifically amongst groups immigration specifically amongst groups that maybe are explicitly not wanting to that maybe are explicitly not wanting to that maybe are explicitly not wanting to assimilate. What's your thoughts on what assimilate. What's your thoughts on what assimilate. What's your thoughts on what America could should do going forward? America could should do going forward? America could should do going forward? Do you believe we should be Do you believe we should be Do you believe we should be >> It's a Yeah, it's a great question and I >> It's a Yeah, it's a great question and I >> It's a Yeah, it's a great question and I think there's an easy answer going back think there's an easy answer going back think there's an easy answer going back to my makers versus takers point. If the to my makers versus takers point. If the to my makers versus takers point. If the primary motivation for an individual to primary motivation for an individual to primary motivation for an individual to come to this country is to be given come to this country is to be given come to this country is to be given benefits, to be given payments, to be benefits, to be given payments, to be benefits, to be given payments, to be given social services, to be given given social services, to be given given social services, to be given support, I think that that person should support, I think that that person should support, I think that that person should be denied immigration. If the primary be denied immigration. If the primary be denied immigration. If the primary motivation for the individual to come to motivation for the individual to come to motivation for the individual to come to the United States is to work to progress the United States is to work to progress the United States is to work to progress themselves, to become a maker, to create themselves, to become a maker, to create themselves, to become a maker, to create things, to work in such a way that they things, to work in such a way that they things, to work in such a way that they can generate income, save capital, buy can generate income, save capital, buy can generate income, save capital, buy things, advance their family's position things, advance their family's position things, advance their family's position because they are denied those rights due because they are denied those rights due because they are denied those rights due to the tyranny of the place that they're to the tyranny of the place that they're to the tyranny of the place that they're coming from, then they should be granted coming from, then they should be granted coming from, then they should be granted immigration status to come to this immigration status to come to this immigration status to come to this country and contribute. Because at the country and contribute. Because at the country and contribute. Because at the end of the day, what people may not like end of the day, what people may not like end of the day, what people may not like to hear, which is the truth, is that to hear, which is the truth, is that to hear, which is the truth, is that every single one of those people is every single one of those people is every single one of those people is actually net positive in growing our actually net positive in growing our actually net positive in growing our economy. And everyone thinks it's a zero economy. And everyone thinks it's a zero economy. And everyone thinks it's a zero sum game with respect to jobs in the sum game with respect to jobs in the sum game with respect to jobs in the United States. And we shouldn't let United States. And we shouldn't let United States. And we shouldn't let people into this country that create people into this country that create people into this country that create jobs. But the fundamental truth is that jobs. But the fundamental truth is that jobs. But the fundamental truth is that anyone that is productive, meaning they anyone that is productive, meaning they anyone that is productive, meaning they create more value than they take in, create more value than they take in, create more value than they take in, grows the economy and more jobs get grows the economy and more jobs get grows the economy and more jobs get created. And overall, we all benefit created. And overall, we all benefit created. And overall, we all benefit from having those individuals here in from having those individuals here in from having those individuals here in this country. Well, I would say this country. Well, I would say this country. Well, I would say >> so I'm all about I'm I'm all about >> so I'm all about I'm I'm all about >> so I'm all about I'm I'm all about discerning immigration not on the lines discerning immigration not on the lines discerning immigration not on the lines of some cultural like definition but of some cultural like definition but of some cultural like definition but really around that simple framing of are really around that simple framing of are really around that simple framing of are you going to get social support services you going to get social support services you going to get social support services or are you going to work and if you're or are you going to work and if you're or are you going to work and if you're going going going >> are you a train or a gain very simple >> are you a train or a gain very simple >> are you a train or a gain very simple way if you are going to work you are way if you are going to work you are way if you are going to work you are going to culturally assimilate because going to culturally assimilate because going to culturally assimilate because that is what the United States is based that is what the United States is based that is what the United States is based on which is productivity work hard on which is productivity work hard on which is productivity work hard create things and have individual agency create things and have individual agency create things and have individual agency have the ability to progress self in have the ability to progress self in have the ability to progress self in this world, in this society. And if you this world, in this society. And if you this world, in this society. And if you take advantage of that opportunity, take advantage of that opportunity, take advantage of that opportunity, you're going to love the American ideals you're going to love the American ideals you're going to love the American ideals that this country was founded upon. And that this country was founded upon. And that this country was founded upon. And there are ways to do that. Freeberg, you there are ways to do that. Freeberg, you there are ways to do that. Freeberg, you can look at people's desire to learn the can look at people's desire to learn the can look at people's desire to learn the language and understand the political language and understand the political language and understand the political system and culture here. If you said at system and culture here. If you said at system and culture here. If you said at the border, speaking fluent English, the border, speaking fluent English, the border, speaking fluent English, understanding our systems here, you understanding our systems here, you understanding our systems here, you know, and doing some learning before you know, and doing some learning before you know, and doing some learning before you come here, that would give you more come here, that would give you more come here, that would give you more points in a point-based system. Canada, points in a point-based system. Canada, points in a point-based system. Canada, Australia, New Zealand, most of the Australia, New Zealand, most of the Australia, New Zealand, most of the great functioning democracies in the great functioning democracies in the great functioning democracies in the world have pointbased systems. And part world have pointbased systems. And part world have pointbased systems. And part of that point-based system could be of that point-based system could be of that point-based system could be you're provisional here and you get a you're provisional here and you get a you're provisional here and you get a visa for a certain amount of time visa for a certain amount of time visa for a certain amount of time provided you don't commit crimes, you provided you don't commit crimes, you provided you don't commit crimes, you don't tap the welfare system, an don't tap the welfare system, an don't tap the welfare system, an entitlement system, and you do create entitlement system, and you do create entitlement system, and you do create jobs. We'll take an unlimited number of jobs. We'll take an unlimited number of jobs. We'll take an unlimited number of Elon Musk, David Freebergs, David Saxes, Elon Musk, David Freebergs, David Saxes, Elon Musk, David Freebergs, David Saxes, and Chimath Polyhetas in my America as a and Chimath Polyhetas in my America as a and Chimath Polyhetas in my America as a seventh, eighth generation American. And seventh, eighth generation American. And seventh, eighth generation American. And speaking for the people who've been here speaking for the people who've been here speaking for the people who've been here the longest, we'll take an unlimited the longest, we'll take an unlimited the longest, we'll take an unlimited number of the besties I just mentioned number of the besties I just mentioned number of the besties I just mentioned and we should recruit them actively. We and we should recruit them actively. We and we should recruit them actively. We should be trying to increase the should be trying to increase the should be trying to increase the population of the United States with population of the United States with population of the United States with those people. Every single person sachs those people. Every single person sachs those people. Every single person sachs we take that's a high performer like we take that's a high performer like we take that's a high performer like yourself from another country like South yourself from another country like South yourself from another country like South Africa, Sri Lanka, uh, or pick the Africa, Sri Lanka, uh, or pick the Africa, Sri Lanka, uh, or pick the country. Every time we recruit one of country. Every time we recruit one of country. Every time we recruit one of those people, that gives us a gain. It those people, that gives us a gain. It those people, that gives us a gain. It also in a super hyper competitive world also in a super hyper competitive world also in a super hyper competitive world is a loss for China, for Iran, for is a loss for China, for Iran, for is a loss for China, for Iran, for wherever we can recruit the best and wherever we can recruit the best and wherever we can recruit the best and brightest who want to assimilate Saxs. brightest who want to assimilate Saxs. brightest who want to assimilate Saxs. I'll let you have the final input here. I'll let you have the final input here. I'll let you have the final input here. What when you are um JD Vance's chief of What when you are um JD Vance's chief of What when you are um JD Vance's chief of staff in uh 3 years, what will your staff in uh 3 years, what will your staff in uh 3 years, what will your advice to JD be? [laughter] And how will advice to JD be? [laughter] And how will advice to JD be? [laughter] And how will you frame this during the election you frame this during the election you frame this during the election cycle? How will you win my vote as a cycle? How will you win my vote as a cycle? How will you win my vote as a moderate? That'd be awesome. moderate? That'd be awesome. moderate? That'd be awesome. >> Chief of Staff David Sax. >> Chief of Staff David Sax. >> Chief of Staff David Sax. >> No, that's that's not going to happen. >> No, that's that's not going to happen. >> No, that's that's not going to happen. But 100% going to happen. I talked to J. But 100% going to happen. I talked to J. But 100% going to happen. I talked to J. >> Well, I can give you I mean I can give >> Well, I can give you I mean I can give >> Well, I can give you I mean I can give you the actual polling data. So, first you the actual polling data. So, first you the actual polling data. So, first of all, I think it's broadly popular in of all, I think it's broadly popular in of all, I think it's broadly popular in America to seal the border and not allow America to seal the border and not allow America to seal the border and not allow illegal immigration. J, you're even on illegal immigration. J, you're even on illegal immigration. J, you're even on board with that obviously. Now, the only board with that obviously. Now, the only board with that obviously. Now, the only people who really aren't are these DSA people who really aren't are these DSA people who really aren't are these DSA types who want open borders. They want types who want open borders. They want types who want open borders. They want to abolish ICE. They want ma mass to abolish ICE. They want ma mass to abolish ICE. They want ma mass amnesty. They are lunatics. Now amnesty. They are lunatics. Now amnesty. They are lunatics. Now communist politics communist politics communist politics >> if you look at deportations about a >> if you look at deportations about a >> if you look at deportations about a third of US adults say all immigrants in third of US adults say all immigrants in third of US adults say all immigrants in the US who here illegally should be the US who here illegally should be the US who here illegally should be deported and then half say some should deported and then half say some should deported and then half say some should be. So 32% are in favor of deporting all be. So 32% are in favor of deporting all be. So 32% are in favor of deporting all illegals and 51% are in favor of illegals and 51% are in favor of illegals and 51% are in favor of deporting some and almost everybody in deporting some and almost everybody in deporting some and almost everybody in that group says that anyone who's that group says that anyone who's that group says that anyone who's committed a violent crime should be committed a violent crime should be committed a violent crime should be deported. And then 16% which is the DSA deported. And then 16% which is the DSA deported. And then 16% which is the DSA group says none should be deported. So group says none should be deported. So group says none should be deported. So deportations are popular provided that deportations are popular provided that deportations are popular provided that the illegals have committed violent the illegals have committed violent the illegals have committed violent crimes and have done other things that crimes and have done other things that crimes and have done other things that people think should be unacceptable. But people think should be unacceptable. But people think should be unacceptable. But you're right. Only 32% believe that you're right. Only 32% believe that you're right. Only 32% believe that every single one should be deported. every single one should be deported. every single one should be deported. That's from Pew. That's from Pew. That's from Pew. Now, I guess I agree with Freeberg's Now, I guess I agree with Freeberg's Now, I guess I agree with Freeberg's point about the incentives. I mean, if point about the incentives. I mean, if point about the incentives. I mean, if you're coming here to get on welfare you're coming here to get on welfare you're coming here to get on welfare programs, forget about it. I mean, we programs, forget about it. I mean, we programs, forget about it. I mean, we should only allow people in if they're should only allow people in if they're should only allow people in if they're here to work and be successful and are here to work and be successful and are here to work and be successful and are not a net like, would you say, a gain, not a net like, would you say, a gain, not a net like, would you say, a gain, not a drain? not a drain? not a drain? >> I agree with that. And yeah, >> I agree with that. And yeah, >> I agree with that. And yeah, >> and even in the days of Ellis Island, >> and even in the days of Ellis Island, >> and even in the days of Ellis Island, >> you can have it >> you can have it >> you can have it >> where the US was very accepting of >> where the US was very accepting of >> where the US was very accepting of immigrants, onethird of immigrants who immigrants, onethird of immigrants who immigrants, onethird of immigrants who arrived at Ellis Island actually arrived at Ellis Island actually arrived at Ellis Island actually returned home. 2% were not allowed entry returned home. 2% were not allowed entry returned home. 2% were not allowed entry due to health or criminal problems, but due to health or criminal problems, but due to health or criminal problems, but a third actually went back. And that was a third actually went back. And that was a third actually went back. And that was because there was no social welfare. And because there was no social welfare. And because there was no social welfare. And if you didn't make it in the United if you didn't make it in the United if you didn't make it in the United States, you would leave. And now anyone States, you would leave. And now anyone States, you would leave. And now anyone can walk across the border. They can walk across the border. They can walk across the border. They download an app and they get $5,000 a download an app and they get $5,000 a download an app and they get $5,000 a month in welfare. And during the Biden month in welfare. And during the Biden month in welfare. And during the Biden administration, they were getting luxury administration, they were getting luxury administration, they were getting luxury hotel rooms and buses and flights all hotel rooms and buses and flights all hotel rooms and buses and flights all over the country. It was insane. over the country. It was insane. over the country. It was insane. >> So I mean, we got to stop that. If you >> So I mean, we got to stop that. If you >> So I mean, we got to stop that. If you do get in, there should be some sort of do get in, there should be some sort of do get in, there should be some sort of moratorum on any kind of social program moratorum on any kind of social program moratorum on any kind of social program for maybe while you have a visa. for maybe while you have a visa. for maybe while you have a visa. >> Can I just come up with that? I mean, it >> Can I just come up with that? I mean, it >> Can I just come up with that? I mean, it seems like the simplest thing you could seems like the simplest thing you could seems like the simplest thing you could ever do is just say you cannot tax the ever do is just say you cannot tax the ever do is just say you cannot tax the welfare system. You cannot tax social welfare system. You cannot tax social welfare system. You cannot tax social security benefits, which I don't think security benefits, which I don't think security benefits, which I don't think you can right now. You just can't tax you can right now. You just can't tax you can right now. You just can't tax anything. You can't take anything from anything. You can't take anything from anything. You can't take anything from the system for the 5 years you're here. the system for the 5 years you're here. the system for the 5 years you're here. Period. Full stop. The end. And if Period. Full stop. The end. And if Period. Full stop. The end. And if that's okay with you, then come. And if that's okay with you, then come. And if that's okay with you, then come. And if you produce jobs and you create x amount you produce jobs and you create x amount you produce jobs and you create x amount of economic activity, let's say you of economic activity, let's say you of economic activity, let's say you create $10 million worth of economic create $10 million worth of economic create $10 million worth of economic activity. When you hit $10 million in activity. When you hit $10 million in activity. When you hit $10 million in economic activity, you are uh pushed to economic activity, you are uh pushed to economic activity, you are uh pushed to the front of the line and we review your the front of the line and we review your the front of the line and we review your case on a one-off basis. If you hit 5 case on a one-off basis. If you hit 5 case on a one-off basis. If you hit 5 million, you go next. And that would be million, you go next. And that would be million, you go next. And that would be actually like let's put some goalposts actually like let's put some goalposts actually like let's put some goalposts there. Let's set some targets. Hey, you there. Let's set some targets. Hey, you there. Let's set some targets. Hey, you come to the country. You're an Iranian come to the country. You're an Iranian come to the country. You're an Iranian Persian amazing entrepreneur. You're a Persian amazing entrepreneur. You're a Persian amazing entrepreneur. You're a developer. You're an AI developer from developer. You're an AI developer from developer. You're an AI developer from Ukraine. You want to come here with your Ukraine. You want to come here with your Ukraine. You want to come here with your team. Great. What amount of money can team. Great. What amount of money can team. Great. What amount of money can you raise on your way in the door? you raise on your way in the door? you raise on your way in the door? You've got $6 million in venture You've got $6 million in venture You've got $6 million in venture funding. Great. You go to the front of funding. Great. You go to the front of funding. Great. You go to the front of the line. Let's go. Let's take these the line. Let's go. Let's take these the line. Let's go. Let's take these great entrepreneurs and creators and great entrepreneurs and creators and great entrepreneurs and creators and builders. Let's sweep the table with builders. Let's sweep the table with builders. Let's sweep the table with them now that we've calmed down this them now that we've calmed down this them now that we've calmed down this rhetoric around immigration and shut the rhetoric around immigration and shut the rhetoric around immigration and shut the border, which was a key piece of doing border, which was a key piece of doing border, which was a key piece of doing that. Uh, all right, let's keep moving. that. Uh, all right, let's keep moving. that. Uh, all right, let's keep moving. >> The GSA has calmed it down. They still >> The GSA has calmed it down. They still >> The GSA has calmed it down. They still want to go back. want to go back. want to go back. >> They're lunatics. These commies. >> They're lunatics. These commies. >> They're lunatics. These commies. Honestly, Honestly, Honestly, >> the Democrat party. >> the Democrat party. >> the Democrat party. >> I mean, >> I mean, >> I mean, >> let's talk about California, shall we, >> let's talk about California, shall we, >> let's talk about California, shall we, Jal? Jal? Jal? >> I mean, yes. Yes. Hold on a second. I >> I mean, yes. Yes. Hold on a second. I >> I mean, yes. Yes. Hold on a second. I mean, if they take over the Democratic mean, if they take over the Democratic mean, if they take over the Democratic party, then I guess I'm a Republican. party, then I guess I'm a Republican. party, then I guess I'm a Republican. Colorado a 15ter term congresswoman 30 Colorado a 15ter term congresswoman 30 Colorado a 15ter term congresswoman 30 years list lost to a DSA so it's not years list lost to a DSA so it's not years list lost to a DSA so it's not just New York it's not just because of just New York it's not just because of just New York it's not just because of Zoran Mdani the DSA is very popular now Zoran Mdani the DSA is very popular now Zoran Mdani the DSA is very popular now >> socialism is going to win any city >> socialism is going to win any city >> socialism is going to win any city >> this is this is a quick way to I mean to >> this is this is a quick way to I mean to >> this is this is a quick way to I mean to Roana and Rahm Emanuel and to well I Roana and Rahm Emanuel and to well I Roana and Rahm Emanuel and to well I mean Rohan is a lost cause but to Rahm mean Rohan is a lost cause but to Rahm mean Rohan is a lost cause but to Rahm Emanuel to Shapiro Emanuel to Shapiro Emanuel to Shapiro to anybody to anybody to anybody in Democrat is a lost cause. I've been in Democrat is a lost cause. I've been in Democrat is a lost cause. I've been telling you for a long time that you may telling you for a long time that you may telling you for a long time that you may disagree with what Roana is doing and disagree with what Roana is doing and disagree with what Roana is doing and saying, but it's popular in the saying, but it's popular in the saying, but it's popular in the Democratic party. I think he's got his Democratic party. I think he's got his Democratic party. I think he's got his finger on the pulse. finger on the pulse. finger on the pulse. >> Well, he wants to win. I get it. But I >> Well, he wants to win. I get it. But I >> Well, he wants to win. I get it. But I think you have to the quick win, the think you have to the quick win, the think you have to the quick win, the quick hit, the quick bump of the quick hit, the quick bump of the quick hit, the quick bump of the fentinol or methamphetamine fentinol or methamphetamine fentinol or methamphetamine of communism and socialism to get you a of communism and socialism to get you a of communism and socialism to get you a couple ratings point is not worth it couple ratings point is not worth it couple ratings point is not worth it long term. You will not win. You're long term. You will not win. You're long term. You will not win. You're going to lose every moderate, every going to lose every moderate, every going to lose every moderate, every swing voter, every adult in the room is swing voter, every adult in the room is swing voter, every adult in the room is not voting for a socialist not voting for a socialist not voting for a socialist communist lunacy. communist lunacy. communist lunacy. >> We'll see. >> We'll see. >> We'll see. >> They're going to implode the Democratic >> They're going to implode the Democratic >> They're going to implode the Democratic party. All right, we we'll leave off the party. All right, we we'll leave off the party. All right, we we'll leave off the other um Scotas hottest summer for other um Scotas hottest summer for other um Scotas hottest summer for another time. another time. another time. >> Let's talk about Gavin with the good >> Let's talk about Gavin with the good >> Let's talk about Gavin with the good hair Newsome. He says he just balanced hair Newsome. He says he just balanced hair Newsome. He says he just balanced the California budget. the California budget. the California budget. Nuome announced $351 billion in balance Nuome announced $351 billion in balance Nuome announced $351 billion in balance zero deficit budget through 2028. Over zero deficit budget through 2028. Over zero deficit budget through 2028. Over to you, Freedberg, from your bunker, the to you, Freedberg, from your bunker, the to you, Freedberg, from your bunker, the last California stand in the Freedberg. last California stand in the Freedberg. last California stand in the Freedberg. >> I'm going to call it I'm going to call >> I'm going to call it I'm going to call >> I'm going to call it I'm going to call this this the state of California. this this the state of California. this this the state of California. >> The state the state of California. The >> The state the state of California. The >> The state the state of California. The lower lower lower >> the state of California. >> the state of California. >> the state of California. >> That's right. The state of California. >> That's right. The state of California. >> That's right. The state of California. >> The state of the state. >> The state of the state. >> The state of the state. >> And there are five the state of the >> And there are five the state of the >> And there are five the state of the state. And there are five state. And there are five state. And there are five >> Got it. chapters to this ballooning >> Got it. chapters to this ballooning >> Got it. chapters to this ballooning costs, the accounting tricks, the costs, the accounting tricks, the costs, the accounting tricks, the revenue dependency problem, and now the revenue dependency problem, and now the revenue dependency problem, and now the big exodus and spiraling that's big exodus and spiraling that's big exodus and spiraling that's happening, and the looming unaccounted happening, and the looming unaccounted happening, and the looming unaccounted liabilities. These are the problems that liabilities. These are the problems that liabilities. These are the problems that California is facing as Gavin puts his California is facing as Gavin puts his California is facing as Gavin puts his bow on his final budget, calls it bow on his final budget, calls it bow on his final budget, calls it balanced, and walks away while the House balanced, and walks away while the House balanced, and walks away while the House burns. California's state budget burns. California's state budget burns. California's state budget ballooned from 215 billion a year in ballooned from 215 billion a year in ballooned from 215 billion a year in 2019, 6 years ago, to 355 billion today. 2019, 6 years ago, to 355 billion today. 2019, 6 years ago, to 355 billion today. So, a 65% jump in the state budget. And So, a 65% jump in the state budget. And So, a 65% jump in the state budget. And there were a number of these kind of there were a number of these kind of there were a number of these kind of accounting tricks that took place to try accounting tricks that took place to try accounting tricks that took place to try and make it look like it's a balanced and make it look like it's a balanced and make it look like it's a balanced budget this year. But there's revenue budget this year. But there's revenue budget this year. But there's revenue and there's spending. When they call it and there's spending. When they call it and there's spending. When they call it a balanced budget, a balanced budget, a balanced budget, that's not the way we all talk about it that's not the way we all talk about it that's not the way we all talk about it in the business world where you have in the business world where you have in the business world where you have like a P&L, you have revenue and like a P&L, you have revenue and like a P&L, you have revenue and expenses. They have revenue and expenses expenses. They have revenue and expenses expenses. They have revenue and expenses and the expenses exceed the revenue. And and the expenses exceed the revenue. And and the expenses exceed the revenue. And that little difference they do a bunch that little difference they do a bunch that little difference they do a bunch of borrowing against and then they then of borrowing against and then they then of borrowing against and then they then they call it a balanced budget. So they call it a balanced budget. So they call it a balanced budget. So [laughter] all that they've done [laughter] all that they've done [laughter] all that they've done >> so they were able to raise enough debt >> so they were able to raise enough debt >> so they were able to raise enough debt to cover their whole question. to cover their whole question. to cover their whole question. >> So there's somewhere between 20 and 40 >> So there's somewhere between 20 and 40 >> So there's somewhere between 20 and 40 billion of debt that they have a legal billion of debt that they have a legal billion of debt that they have a legal ability to just pencil away and that is ability to just pencil away and that is ability to just pencil away and that is now a liability that the state has that now a liability that the state has that now a liability that the state has that the taxpayers are all going to have to the taxpayers are all going to have to the taxpayers are all going to have to pay at some point that allows them to pay at some point that allows them to pay at some point that allows them to quote balance the budget this year. And quote balance the budget this year. And quote balance the budget this year. And I'm not going to get into all the I'm not going to get into all the I'm not going to get into all the details of what went into this budget. details of what went into this budget. details of what went into this budget. all the money that's being spent. It's all the money that's being spent. It's all the money that's being spent. It's crazy. But I think that's what's worth crazy. But I think that's what's worth crazy. But I think that's what's worth taking note of is the revenue dependency taking note of is the revenue dependency taking note of is the revenue dependency the state has. As you all know, the top the state has. As you all know, the top the state has. As you all know, the top tax rate in California is 14.4% today. tax rate in California is 14.4% today. tax rate in California is 14.4% today. Personal income tax is $142 billion of Personal income tax is $142 billion of Personal income tax is $142 billion of the state's revenue. Okay, that is 211 the state's revenue. Okay, that is 211 the state's revenue. Okay, that is 211 billion of revenue the state generates. billion of revenue the state generates. billion of revenue the state generates. 142 of it comes from personal income 142 of it comes from personal income 142 of it comes from personal income tax. The top 1% 150,000 people pay 70 tax. The top 1% 150,000 people pay 70 tax. The top 1% 150,000 people pay 70 billion pay half of that tax of that billion pay half of that tax of that billion pay half of that tax of that income. So 70 billion of the state's 210 income. So 70 billion of the state's 210 income. So 70 billion of the state's 210 billion income comes from just the top billion income comes from just the top billion income comes from just the top 1% of payers, 150,000 people who are 1% of payers, 150,000 people who are 1% of payers, 150,000 people who are already paying the highest tax rate in already paying the highest tax rate in already paying the highest tax rate in the country. The top thousand people in the country. The top thousand people in the country. The top thousand people in the state of California pay roughly 22 the state of California pay roughly 22 the state of California pay roughly 22 billion a year. So more than you know billion a year. So more than you know billion a year. So more than you know 11% of the state's income. The corporate 11% of the state's income. The corporate 11% of the state's income. The corporate tax is one of the highest in the country tax is one of the highest in the country tax is one of the highest in the country at 8.9% $43 billion. So it's cheaper to at 8.9% $43 billion. So it's cheaper to at 8.9% $43 billion. So it's cheaper to move out of state. If you look at some move out of state. If you look at some move out of state. If you look at some of the other states, Florida 5.5%, of the other states, Florida 5.5%, of the other states, Florida 5.5%, Texas, Tennessee is 6 and a half and Texas, Tennessee is 6 and a half and Texas, Tennessee is 6 and a half and Texas is zero. Texas is zero. Texas is zero. So now if you kind of look at what's So now if you kind of look at what's So now if you kind of look at what's happening, there's a massive exodus happening, there's a massive exodus happening, there's a massive exodus underway. the corporate exodus because underway. the corporate exodus because underway. the corporate exodus because of the high tax rates. Since 2019, at of the high tax rates. Since 2019, at of the high tax rates. Since 2019, at least 15 Fortune 500 companies have least 15 Fortune 500 companies have least 15 Fortune 500 companies have moved out of California, moved their moved out of California, moved their moved out of California, moved their headquarters out. Not to mention all the headquarters out. Not to mention all the headquarters out. Not to mention all the local franchises and everything that local franchises and everything that local franchises and everything that moved out. 2100 companies that are mid moved out. 2100 companies that are mid moved out. 2100 companies that are mid or large size have moved out of or large size have moved out of or large size have moved out of California since 2019. At least 5% of California since 2019. At least 5% of California since 2019. At least 5% of California jobs have been lost as these California jobs have been lost as these California jobs have been lost as these companies have moved out of the state. companies have moved out of the state. companies have moved out of the state. And this is the more important and crazy And this is the more important and crazy And this is the more important and crazy statistic. No one pays attention to statistic. No one pays attention to statistic. No one pays attention to this, but we are seeing an average this, but we are seeing an average this, but we are seeing an average annual exodus of 1 to one and a half% of annual exodus of 1 to one and a half% of annual exodus of 1 to one and a half% of personal income, meaning the AGI, the personal income, meaning the AGI, the personal income, meaning the AGI, the adjusted gross income. So people that adjusted gross income. So people that adjusted gross income. So people that earn money, about 1 to 1.5% of that earn money, about 1 to 1.5% of that earn money, about 1 to 1.5% of that income is leaving the state every year income is leaving the state every year income is leaving the state every year right now. That might not sound like a right now. That might not sound like a right now. That might not sound like a lot, but after 10 years, you've seen 15% lot, but after 10 years, you've seen 15% lot, but after 10 years, you've seen 15% of the state's income leave. And of the state's income leave. And of the state's income leave. And obviously with the new billionaire tax obviously with the new billionaire tax obviously with the new billionaire tax that's being proposed, we're going to that's being proposed, we're going to that's being proposed, we're going to see an acceleration as the numbers come see an acceleration as the numbers come see an acceleration as the numbers come out for 2025. There's, as we all know, out for 2025. There's, as we all know, out for 2025. There's, as we all know, personal friends that have left the personal friends that have left the personal friends that have left the state in 25 and many more that'll leave state in 25 and many more that'll leave state in 25 and many more that'll leave in 26, including our friend David Sachs. in 26, including our friend David Sachs. in 26, including our friend David Sachs. So there is a spiraling of a loss of So there is a spiraling of a loss of So there is a spiraling of a loss of revenue while there is a ballooning in revenue while there is a ballooning in revenue while there is a ballooning in costs. And this is fundamental to the costs. And this is fundamental to the costs. And this is fundamental to the spiraling problem that's occurring. So spiraling problem that's occurring. So spiraling problem that's occurring. So now in order to try and make more money, now in order to try and make more money, now in order to try and make more money, the state has to go further down. They the state has to go further down. They the state has to go further down. They can't just go to the corporates and the can't just go to the corporates and the can't just go to the corporates and the high net worth earners. They're now high net worth earners. They're now high net worth earners. They're now going to the average Californian. So, going to the average Californian. So, going to the average Californian. So, they're increasing sales tax rates this they're increasing sales tax rates this they're increasing sales tax rates this year by creating a new sales tax on year by creating a new sales tax on year by creating a new sales tax on software. So, if you buy Microsoft Word software. So, if you buy Microsoft Word software. So, if you buy Microsoft Word or you pay for your Gmail subscription or you pay for your Gmail subscription or you pay for your Gmail subscription or even your Chat GPT account, you have or even your Chat GPT account, you have or even your Chat GPT account, you have to pay an 8% sales tax on that this to pay an 8% sales tax on that this to pay an 8% sales tax on that this year. They're estimating that that sales year. They're estimating that that sales year. They're estimating that that sales tax is a brand new one. It'll generate tax is a brand new one. It'll generate tax is a brand new one. It'll generate about a billion dollars a year in about a billion dollars a year in about a billion dollars a year in incremental revenue for the state. incremental revenue for the state. incremental revenue for the state. They're also creating a new tax on They're also creating a new tax on They're also creating a new tax on healthcare insurance that corporates are healthcare insurance that corporates are healthcare insurance that corporates are going to have to pay that's ultimately going to have to pay that's ultimately going to have to pay that's ultimately going to pass down to the individual. going to pass down to the individual. going to pass down to the individual. That's going to create another $2 That's going to create another $2 That's going to create another $2 billion a year in taxes on health billion a year in taxes on health billion a year in taxes on health insurance. The final thing that they insurance. The final thing that they insurance. The final thing that they did, which we all know about, is they did, which we all know about, is they did, which we all know about, is they made the temporary top income tax made the temporary top income tax made the temporary top income tax bracket permanent. So, you know, it was bracket permanent. So, you know, it was bracket permanent. So, you know, it was only meant to be a temporary to bridge a only meant to be a temporary to bridge a only meant to be a temporary to bridge a major budget deficit problem back in major budget deficit problem back in major budget deficit problem back in 2012, 13.3%. And that became permanent 2012, 13.3%. And that became permanent 2012, 13.3%. And that became permanent and now it's increased to 14.4%. and now it's increased to 14.4%. and now it's increased to 14.4%. So, this is the spiraling that takes So, this is the spiraling that takes So, this is the spiraling that takes place. The costs are ballooning, the place. The costs are ballooning, the place. The costs are ballooning, the revenue is leaving, and now there's a revenue is leaving, and now there's a revenue is leaving, and now there's a scrambling underway in the state of scrambling underway in the state of scrambling underway in the state of California to try and make up this California to try and make up this California to try and make up this difference. And they're still falling difference. And they're still falling difference. And they're still falling short. In the out years, 2028 29, the short. In the out years, 2028 29, the short. In the out years, 2028 29, the projection is $40 billion a year in projection is $40 billion a year in projection is $40 billion a year in budget deficits every year. Now, looming budget deficits every year. Now, looming budget deficits every year. Now, looming over the state of California is the fact over the state of California is the fact over the state of California is the fact that there's this insane unaccounted that there's this insane unaccounted that there's this insane unaccounted debt problem. California already has debt problem. California already has debt problem. California already has $1.4 trillion in public debt. The state $1.4 trillion in public debt. The state $1.4 trillion in public debt. The state has 500 billion and the local has 500 billion and the local has 500 billion and the local governments have another, call it 800 governments have another, call it 800 governments have another, call it 800 billion. The state has a reported $664 billion. The state has a reported $664 billion. The state has a reported $664 billion in unfunded pension liabilities. billion in unfunded pension liabilities. billion in unfunded pension liabilities. That number by many estimates is closer That number by many estimates is closer That number by many estimates is closer to 1.5 trillion. to 1.5 trillion. to 1.5 trillion. And then there's a retirey healthcare And then there's a retirey healthcare And then there's a retirey healthcare obligation deficit of $175 billion. You obligation deficit of $175 billion. You obligation deficit of $175 billion. You add this all up, there's somewhere add this all up, there's somewhere add this all up, there's somewhere around 1.5 to2 trillion around 1.5 to2 trillion around 1.5 to2 trillion of incremental liabilities that the of incremental liabilities that the of incremental liabilities that the state has to come up with. And remember, state has to come up with. And remember, state has to come up with. And remember, all of those pension liabilities, that all of those pension liabilities, that all of those pension liabilities, that trillion dollar plus of pension trillion dollar plus of pension trillion dollar plus of pension liabilities sits senior to the bonds of liabilities sits senior to the bonds of liabilities sits senior to the bonds of the state of California because of the state of California because of the state of California because of something that's known as the California something that's known as the California something that's known as the California rule. So the state has this looming kind rule. So the state has this looming kind rule. So the state has this looming kind of cliff ahead of it and there's already of cliff ahead of it and there's already of cliff ahead of it and there's already this spiraling problem where they're this spiraling problem where they're this spiraling problem where they're increasing costs because of the demands increasing costs because of the demands increasing costs because of the demands of the unions and the cost of living and of the unions and the cost of living and of the unions and the cost of living and so on and there's an exodus of so on and there's an exodus of so on and there's an exodus of corporations and high netw worth corporations and high netw worth corporations and high netw worth individuals that pay the taxes. So, I individuals that pay the taxes. So, I individuals that pay the taxes. So, I would argue that Governor Nuomo did not would argue that Governor Nuomo did not would argue that Governor Nuomo did not exactly put a bow tie on the budget and exactly put a bow tie on the budget and exactly put a bow tie on the budget and create a balanced budget and leave create a balanced budget and leave create a balanced budget and leave California in a great state as he is California in a great state as he is California in a great state as he is wrapping up his final term and his final wrapping up his final term and his final wrapping up his final term and his final budget here in the state. But in fact, I budget here in the state. But in fact, I budget here in the state. But in fact, I think that this state, which, as I've think that this state, which, as I've think that this state, which, as I've said in the past, threatens to bring said in the past, threatens to bring said in the past, threatens to bring down the union, is on the brink of down the union, is on the brink of down the union, is on the brink of defaults that are going to be so defaults that are going to be so defaults that are going to be so significant that if the federal significant that if the federal significant that if the federal government was called in to bail them government was called in to bail them government was called in to bail them out because a state cannot declare out because a state cannot declare out because a state cannot declare bankruptcy legally, that all of the red bankruptcy legally, that all of the red bankruptcy legally, that all of the red states and all of the other taxpayers in states and all of the other taxpayers in states and all of the other taxpayers in the United States will say, "Why the the United States will say, "Why the the United States will say, "Why the hell should I pay federal taxes to bail hell should I pay federal taxes to bail hell should I pay federal taxes to bail out California?" out California?" out California?" And I think that's what the story will And I think that's what the story will And I think that's what the story will be over the next decade with the state be over the next decade with the state be over the next decade with the state the fiscal condition the fiscal condition the fiscal condition >> AOC and Mandami president vice president >> AOC and Mandami president vice president >> AOC and Mandami president vice president AOC Mandami can't be VP he wasn't born AOC Mandami can't be VP he wasn't born AOC Mandami can't be VP he wasn't born here here here >> I do predict yeah so I predict AOC will >> I do predict yeah so I predict AOC will >> I do predict yeah so I predict AOC will be president I mean obviously there's a be president I mean obviously there's a be president I mean obviously there's a lot of dispersion in what could happen lot of dispersion in what could happen lot of dispersion in what could happen here but I would say AOC would be my here but I would say AOC would be my here but I would say AOC would be my front runner based on the the movement front runner based on the the movement front runner based on the the movement for the extraordinary cost of living in for the extraordinary cost of living in for the extraordinary cost of living in the United States right now largely the United States right now largely the United States right now largely because of government spending because of government spending because of government spending >> the fact that people are seeing this >> the fact that people are seeing this >> the fact that people are seeing this wealth disparity those two things are wealth disparity those two things are wealth disparity those two things are going to continue to drive socialist going to continue to drive socialist going to continue to drive socialist movement over the next 24 months. And if movement over the next 24 months. And if movement over the next 24 months. And if AOC comes in and they bail out AOC comes in and they bail out AOC comes in and they bail out California and they federalize California and they federalize California and they federalize California's liabilities, you're going California's liabilities, you're going California's liabilities, you're going to see parts of this union, the red to see parts of this union, the red to see parts of this union, the red states as they're called, the Texas of states as they're called, the Texas of states as they're called, the Texas of the world, that are going to say, why the world, that are going to say, why the world, that are going to say, why should we be part of this union anymore? should we be part of this union anymore? should we be part of this union anymore? >> We don't want to pay for all of these >> We don't want to pay for all of these >> We don't want to pay for all of these liabilities that these blue states have liabilities that these blue states have liabilities that these blue states have accured and that we are now being asked accured and that we are now being asked accured and that we are now being asked to bail out. And that is where I think to bail out. And that is where I think to bail out. And that is where I think you face a crisis of the union in the you face a crisis of the union in the you face a crisis of the union in the years ahead. years ahead. years ahead. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. Sachs Texas Sachs Texas Sachs Texas the first Yeah. Yeah. the first Yeah. Yeah. the first Yeah. Yeah. >> In this scenario, I mean, it's pretty >> In this scenario, I mean, it's pretty >> In this scenario, I mean, it's pretty farfetched, but it's not farfetched that farfetched, but it's not farfetched that farfetched, but it's not farfetched that you would you would need a federal you would you would need a federal you would you would need a federal bailout to get California out of this in bailout to get California out of this in bailout to get California out of this in the next couple of years, and the the next couple of years, and the the next couple of years, and the government needs a bailout itself with government needs a bailout itself with government needs a bailout itself with the massive uh we're going to add two to the massive uh we're going to add two to the massive uh we're going to add two to three trillion dollars a year for the three trillion dollars a year for the three trillion dollars a year for the next couple years. So, go ahead, next couple years. So, go ahead, next couple years. So, go ahead, Shimothia. Shimothia. Shimothia. >> There's something that's going to >> There's something that's going to >> There's something that's going to happen. I think that Freeberg is right happen. I think that Freeberg is right happen. I think that Freeberg is right up until the point of the federal up until the point of the federal up until the point of the federal absorption. I think what'll happen is absorption. I think what'll happen is absorption. I think what'll happen is that you will wipe out the California that you will wipe out the California that you will wipe out the California pensions and you'll wipe out the pension pensions and you'll wipe out the pension pensions and you'll wipe out the pension obligations and you'll do some sort of obligations and you'll do some sort of obligations and you'll do some sort of negotiated settlement. And I think negotiated settlement. And I think negotiated settlement. And I think that's where you're going to have a that's where you're going to have a that's where you're going to have a wholesale replacement of the California wholesale replacement of the California wholesale replacement of the California Constitution. Constitution. Constitution. You'll have a complete redistricting. I You'll have a complete redistricting. I You'll have a complete redistricting. I think you will have a complete red wave think you will have a complete red wave think you will have a complete red wave in the state. and you will disassemble in the state. and you will disassemble in the state. and you will disassemble and dismantle and dismantle and dismantle everything that caused California to be everything that caused California to be everything that caused California to be so poorly run that got them to this so poorly run that got them to this so poorly run that got them to this place. So I I agree with David. All of place. So I I agree with David. All of place. So I I agree with David. All of the issues that he painted are it's the issues that he painted are it's the issues that he painted are it's unbelievable. By the way, there's an unbelievable. By the way, there's an unbelievable. By the way, there's an incredible tweet. I think her name is incredible tweet. I think her name is incredible tweet. I think her name is Joanna Ives. Maybe Nick, you can find Joanna Ives. Maybe Nick, you can find Joanna Ives. Maybe Nick, you can find it, but she compared the last eight it, but she compared the last eight it, but she compared the last eight years of Dantis versus JB Pritsker. And years of Dantis versus JB Pritsker. And years of Dantis versus JB Pritsker. And I asked my team, hey, can you create a I asked my team, hey, can you create a I asked my team, hey, can you create a table that actually adds Newsome to the table that actually adds Newsome to the table that actually adds Newsome to the list so that you can do the three-person list so that you can do the three-person list so that you can do the three-person comparison because it's quite staggering comparison because it's quite staggering comparison because it's quite staggering how broken these blue states have become how broken these blue states have become how broken these blue states have become and how they continue to try to spend and how they continue to try to spend and how they continue to try to spend their way out of what is being shown is their way out of what is being shown is their way out of what is being shown is just general incompetence. They're not just general incompetence. They're not just general incompetence. They're not good at managing. They're not good at good at managing. They're not good at good at managing. They're not good at running things. They're not good at running things. They're not good at running things. They're not good at delivering results. And unfortunately, delivering results. And unfortunately, delivering results. And unfortunately, until they feel the brunt of what until they feel the brunt of what until they feel the brunt of what mismanagement actually means, which is mismanagement actually means, which is mismanagement actually means, which is that all the people that have paid into that all the people that have paid into that all the people that have paid into this system, sadly and unfortunately and this system, sadly and unfortunately and this system, sadly and unfortunately and avoidably will be the ones that get avoidably will be the ones that get avoidably will be the ones that get punished, we will unfortunately not punished, we will unfortunately not punished, we will unfortunately not learn in California. Find this tweet and learn in California. Find this tweet and learn in California. Find this tweet and read it and you would just be shocked at read it and you would just be shocked at read it and you would just be shocked at how unbelievably good Dantis has been in how unbelievably good Dantis has been in how unbelievably good Dantis has been in running Florida and how unbelievably running Florida and how unbelievably running Florida and how unbelievably tragically bad JB Pritsker is. And then tragically bad JB Pritsker is. And then tragically bad JB Pritsker is. And then just ask your favorite AI, compare just ask your favorite AI, compare just ask your favorite AI, compare California California California on the spectrum of Florida versus on the spectrum of Florida versus on the spectrum of Florida versus Illinois. And what you'll find is Illinois. And what you'll find is Illinois. And what you'll find is California is even worse than Illinois California is even worse than Illinois California is even worse than Illinois in most of those comparisons. in most of those comparisons. in most of those comparisons. >> Sax, you want to uh give us the last >> Sax, you want to uh give us the last >> Sax, you want to uh give us the last word here? word here? word here? >> Yeah. I mean, I guess my decision to go >> Yeah. I mean, I guess my decision to go >> Yeah. I mean, I guess my decision to go to Texas is looking better and better. to Texas is looking better and better. to Texas is looking better and better. Yes. Yes. Yes. >> I mean, I said when this when this BTA >> I mean, I said when this when this BTA >> I mean, I said when this when this BTA thing, the so-called billionaire tax act thing, the so-called billionaire tax act thing, the so-called billionaire tax act was proposed was proposed was proposed >> and everyone was saying that's very low >> and everyone was saying that's very low >> and everyone was saying that's very low probability this happens. I was like, I probability this happens. I was like, I probability this happens. I was like, I don't really see why it would be low don't really see why it would be low don't really see why it would be low probability. I think it's going to get probability. I think it's going to get probability. I think it's going to get on the ballot. All you have to do is on the ballot. All you have to do is on the ballot. All you have to do is collect a certain number of signatures. collect a certain number of signatures. collect a certain number of signatures. It's not that hard. And then once it's It's not that hard. And then once it's It's not that hard. And then once it's on the ballot, I don't see why it on the ballot, I don't see why it on the ballot, I don't see why it wouldn't pass. And everyone's like, "No, wouldn't pass. And everyone's like, "No, wouldn't pass. And everyone's like, "No, no, no. Gavin Newsome has assured us no, no. Gavin Newsome has assured us no, no. Gavin Newsome has assured us that he'll kill it. He'll make some that he'll kill it. He'll make some that he'll kill it. He'll make some backroom deal, get rid of it." And on backroom deal, get rid of it." And on backroom deal, get rid of it." And on the day, the final day where BTA was the day, the final day where BTA was the day, the final day where BTA was going to be dropped from the ballot or going to be dropped from the ballot or going to be dropped from the ballot or not, Newsome came out with a video on X not, Newsome came out with a video on X not, Newsome came out with a video on X where he basically endorsed more taxes where he basically endorsed more taxes where he basically endorsed more taxes on billionaires. And this was right on billionaires. And this was right on billionaires. And this was right after the the DSA candidates won in New after the the DSA candidates won in New after the the DSA candidates won in New York. So, he sees the writing on the York. So, he sees the writing on the York. So, he sees the writing on the wall. He's not going to come out. By the wall. He's not going to come out. By the wall. He's not going to come out. By the way, the the problem with the way, the the problem with the way, the the problem with the billionaire tax is that if it does get billionaire tax is that if it does get billionaire tax is that if it does get passed and it isn't obiated by the three passed and it isn't obiated by the three passed and it isn't obiated by the three other ballot initiatives that actually other ballot initiatives that actually other ballot initiatives that actually negate it, negate it, negate it, you're going to have two or 300 you're going to have two or 300 you're going to have two or 300 individual lawsuits that will take a individual lawsuits that will take a individual lawsuits that will take a decade to meander through the courts and decade to meander through the courts and decade to meander through the courts and ultimately I think a lot of people have ultimately I think a lot of people have ultimately I think a lot of people have standing here. And I just wonder what standing here. And I just wonder what standing here. And I just wonder what will they have proven at that point will they have proven at that point will they have proven at that point because it'll be a decade later. It'll because it'll be a decade later. It'll because it'll be a decade later. It'll be 2036 be 2036 be 2036 and the California government will have and the California government will have and the California government will have had to spend billions of dollars on had to spend billions of dollars on had to spend billions of dollars on legal fees to to fight all these legal fees to to fight all these legal fees to to fight all these billionaires all all to end up losing at billionaires all all to end up losing at billionaires all all to end up losing at the Supreme Court. Anyways, the Supreme Court. Anyways, the Supreme Court. Anyways, >> by then they'll probably have like a >> by then they'll probably have like a >> by then they'll probably have like a federal wealth tax or something like federal wealth tax or something like federal wealth tax or something like that. that. that. >> The tragedy is that California at >> The tragedy is that California at >> The tragedy is that California at various points in recent history has had various points in recent history has had various points in recent history has had a surplus because of the massive tax a surplus because of the massive tax a surplus because of the massive tax base from Silicon Valley. They could base from Silicon Valley. They could base from Silicon Valley. They could have managed this. Their incompetence, have managed this. Their incompetence, have managed this. Their incompetence, their selfishness, and their corruption their selfishness, and their corruption their selfishness, and their corruption is what has caused this. They could is what has caused this. They could is what has caused this. They could have, if any state could have balanced have, if any state could have balanced have, if any state could have balanced its budget, it is California because of its budget, it is California because of its budget, it is California because of our massive tax receipts. our massive tax receipts. our massive tax receipts. >> There needs to be a hard landing. I >> There needs to be a hard landing. I >> There needs to be a hard landing. I really hope it doesn't result in the really hope it doesn't result in the really hope it doesn't result in the wipeout of these pensions. I think the wipeout of these pensions. I think the wipeout of these pensions. I think the pensioners should be extremely upset pensioners should be extremely upset pensioners should be extremely upset >> with California Democratic politics. >> with California Democratic politics. >> with California Democratic politics. Look, this idea that somehow things get Look, this idea that somehow things get Look, this idea that somehow things get bad enough where you get a red wave in bad enough where you get a red wave in bad enough where you get a red wave in super blue California and everything super blue California and everything super blue California and everything gets magically fixed, not going to gets magically fixed, not going to gets magically fixed, not going to happen. What's going to happen is a blue happen. What's going to happen is a blue happen. What's going to happen is a blue state's going to get bluer and state's going to get bluer and state's going to get bluer and >> that's right, socialism. >> that's right, socialism. >> that's right, socialism. >> The remedy for more and more socialism >> The remedy for more and more socialism >> The remedy for more and more socialism is going to be to intensify the is going to be to intensify the is going to be to intensify the socialism and there's going to be a socialism and there's going to be a socialism and there's going to be a giant final confiscation. giant final confiscation. giant final confiscation. >> Then we're going to deal with a >> Then we're going to deal with a >> Then we're going to deal with a California bankruptcy in the next 10 California bankruptcy in the next 10 California bankruptcy in the next 10 years. And it is unfortunately years. And it is unfortunately years. And it is unfortunately >> No. and it will unfortunately result in >> No. and it will unfortunately result in >> No. and it will unfortunately result in a complete restructuring of those debt a complete restructuring of those debt a complete restructuring of those debt and obligations. And this is where I and obligations. And this is where I and obligations. And this is where I think you're going to wipe out a lot of think you're going to wipe out a lot of think you're going to wipe out a lot of these things that people are these things that people are these things that people are guaranteeing. I don't think you're going guaranteeing. I don't think you're going guaranteeing. I don't think you're going to see these pensions honored. If you to see these pensions honored. If you to see these pensions honored. If you just look at the budget per person, uh just look at the budget per person, uh just look at the budget per person, uh places like Texas and Florida spend places like Texas and Florida spend places like Texas and Florida spend about $5,000 per uh citizen on services. about $5,000 per uh citizen on services. about $5,000 per uh citizen on services. You know, if you divide the budget by You know, if you divide the budget by You know, if you divide the budget by the population, and then you look at New the population, and then you look at New the population, and then you look at New York City, it's close to $13,000. And York City, it's close to $13,000. And York City, it's close to $13,000. And you look at California, close to 9,000. you look at California, close to 9,000. you look at California, close to 9,000. And you simply do not get two or two and And you simply do not get two or two and And you simply do not get two or two and a half times or 2.x times the value a half times or 2.x times the value a half times or 2.x times the value living in those states in terms of living in those states in terms of living in those states in terms of services. services. services. >> The problems are all worse. >> The problems are all worse. >> The problems are all worse. >> And it's competence. Yes, it's worse. >> And it's competence. Yes, it's worse. >> And it's competence. Yes, it's worse. And it really the more you look to that And it really the more you look to that And it really the more you look to that state government to solve your problems, state government to solve your problems, state government to solve your problems, the more problems you will have in Texas the more problems you will have in Texas the more problems you will have in Texas if you got a if you got a if you got a just seems these blue states attract just seems these blue states attract just seems these blue states attract these derelict incompetent people. I these derelict incompetent people. I these derelict incompetent people. I mean, unbelievable. Incompetence. mean, unbelievable. Incompetence. mean, unbelievable. Incompetence. They're so incompetent. My god. This has They're so incompetent. My god. This has They're so incompetent. My god. This has to do with competence. And it also is to do with competence. And it also is to do with competence. And it also is the populace being self-reliant. If you the populace being self-reliant. If you the populace being self-reliant. If you live in Texas, live in Texas, live in Texas, >> when you get your ranch, they say, hey, >> when you get your ranch, they say, hey, >> when you get your ranch, they say, hey, >> you know, here's your ranch. And then >> you know, here's your ranch. And then >> you know, here's your ranch. And then it's up to you to figure out, hey, who's it's up to you to figure out, hey, who's it's up to you to figure out, hey, who's going to pick up my garbage? And oh, do going to pick up my garbage? And oh, do going to pick up my garbage? And oh, do I want a well? Do I want to use a city I want a well? Do I want to use a city I want a well? Do I want to use a city water? What's my energy situation going water? What's my energy situation going water? What's my energy situation going to be? And people make these kind of to be? And people make these kind of to be? And people make these kind of thoughtful decisions with us. They don't thoughtful decisions with us. They don't thoughtful decisions with us. They don't look to the state for every single look to the state for every single look to the state for every single handout or handholding. There's a handout or handholding. There's a handout or handholding. There's a ruggedness and a rugged individualism ruggedness and a rugged individualism ruggedness and a rugged individualism and self-reliance that makes the state and self-reliance that makes the state and self-reliance that makes the state not have to tax everybody to 54 60 65%. not have to tax everybody to 54 60 65%. not have to tax everybody to 54 60 65%. I guarantee you Freedber and Shimoth you I guarantee you Freedber and Shimoth you I guarantee you Freedber and Shimoth you will be paying 60 to 65% tax if you stay will be paying 60 to 65% tax if you stay will be paying 60 to 65% tax if you stay in California. And I tell you New York in California. And I tell you New York in California. And I tell you New York it's at 54 right now. I guarantee you it it's at 54 right now. I guarantee you it it's at 54 right now. I guarantee you it breaks 60 by the or it will be proposed breaks 60 by the or it will be proposed breaks 60 by the or it will be proposed to break 50. We'll see if they stop it to break 50. We'll see if they stop it to break 50. We'll see if they stop it by the end of Mandami's reign in my by the end of Mandami's reign in my by the end of Mandami's reign in my hometown. hometown. hometown. >> Look, let me let me tell you what >> Look, let me let me tell you what >> Look, let me let me tell you what leftism is, okay? It's basically just leftism is, okay? It's basically just leftism is, okay? It's basically just people trying to string together words people trying to string together words people trying to string together words to justify taking your money, okay? And to justify taking your money, okay? And to justify taking your money, okay? And they'll they're just experimenting. It's they'll they're just experimenting. It's they'll they're just experimenting. It's like monkeys typing on a keyboard with like monkeys typing on a keyboard with like monkeys typing on a keyboard with words to try and hack everyone's brains words to try and hack everyone's brains words to try and hack everyone's brains to basically figure out how to steal all to basically figure out how to steal all to basically figure out how to steal all of their money. And some of those words of their money. And some of those words of their money. And some of those words are virtue signaling. Some of them are are virtue signaling. Some of them are are virtue signaling. Some of them are guilt, tripping, and moral accusations. guilt, tripping, and moral accusations. guilt, tripping, and moral accusations. >> Whatever it is, there's always some new >> Whatever it is, there's always some new >> Whatever it is, there's always some new words. words. words. >> But it's never to solve a problem. In >> But it's never to solve a problem. In >> But it's never to solve a problem. In fact, all the problems just get worse. fact, all the problems just get worse. fact, all the problems just get worse. >> It's just to figure out how to separate >> It's just to figure out how to separate >> It's just to figure out how to separate you from your money. And I had this you from your money. And I had this you from your money. And I had this >> thought when I saw that like McKenzie >> thought when I saw that like McKenzie >> thought when I saw that like McKenzie Bezos, you know, just giving away like Bezos, you know, just giving away like Bezos, you know, just giving away like >> 26 billion uh 26 billion of Jeff Bezos's >> 26 billion uh 26 billion of Jeff Bezos's >> 26 billion uh 26 billion of Jeff Bezos's money to all these leftwing causes. Hey, money to all these leftwing causes. Hey, money to all these leftwing causes. Hey, she earned it too. she earned it too. she earned it too. >> And well, but putting that aside, she >> And well, but putting that aside, she >> And well, but putting that aside, she gave away all this money. I'm like, "Oh, gave away all this money. I'm like, "Oh, gave away all this money. I'm like, "Oh, okay. So now, like world hunger is okay. So now, like world hunger is okay. So now, like world hunger is fixed, right?" Because remember how they fixed, right?" Because remember how they fixed, right?" Because remember how they told us that it was because of Elon's told us that it was because of Elon's told us that it was because of Elon's Musk re that he refused to hand over, he Musk re that he refused to hand over, he Musk re that he refused to hand over, he didn't fork over a big chunk of his didn't fork over a big chunk of his didn't fork over a big chunk of his money. And with that money, we could money. And with that money, we could money. And with that money, we could have fed the whole world and solved have fed the whole world and solved have fed the whole world and solved world hunger. So why isn't the problem world hunger. So why isn't the problem world hunger. So why isn't the problem solved now that she just donated 26 solved now that she just donated 26 solved now that she just donated 26 billion? That's what they said Elon billion? That's what they said Elon billion? That's what they said Elon needed to do to solve world hunger. They needed to do to solve world hunger. They needed to do to solve world hunger. They always treat your money as if it belongs always treat your money as if it belongs always treat your money as if it belongs to them or it belongs to the government to them or it belongs to the government to them or it belongs to the government and it's your greed and selfishness and it's your greed and selfishness and it's your greed and selfishness that's creating all these problems. None that's creating all these problems. None that's creating all these problems. None of these problems have been fixed. of these problems have been fixed. of these problems have been fixed. What's the proof that any of that money What's the proof that any of that money What's the proof that any of that money did anything? All it did was go to line did anything? All it did was go to line did anything? All it did was go to line the pockets of all these leftist NOS's the pockets of all these leftist NOS's the pockets of all these leftist NOS's and you know buy them more houses or or and you know buy them more houses or or and you know buy them more houses or or pay them pay them pay them >> better off investing in oh no problems >> better off investing in oh no problems >> better off investing in oh no problems companies if if literally I I hate to companies if if literally I I hate to companies if if literally I I hate to break this news. What does the poly break this news. What does the poly break this news. What does the poly market say on Gavin's chances of uh market say on Gavin's chances of uh market say on Gavin's chances of uh >> Oh, he's down to becoming He's >> Oh, he's down to becoming He's >> Oh, he's down to becoming He's plummeting. He's plummeting. plummeting. He's plummeting. plummeting. He's plummeting. >> Yeah, Gavin's down to 20. He peaked at >> Yeah, Gavin's down to 20. He peaked at >> Yeah, Gavin's down to 20. He peaked at 40. 40. 40. >> That's quite high, though. >> That's quite high, though. >> That's quite high, though. >> I I I mean, I think people are real >> I I I mean, I think people are real >> I I I mean, I think people are real realizing it's a great haircut and uh realizing it's a great haircut and uh realizing it's a great haircut and uh you know, a really smooth talker, but you know, a really smooth talker, but you know, a really smooth talker, but just like he stole other things in his just like he stole other things in his just like he stole other things in his life, he's going to steal your money. life, he's going to steal your money. life, he's going to steal your money. Period. Full stop. I'm not going to get Period. Full stop. I'm not going to get Period. Full stop. I'm not going to get into detail. I think he's lowering these into detail. I think he's lowering these into detail. I think he's lowering these polls because the Democratic party is polls because the Democratic party is polls because the Democratic party is moving left is moving to the TSA and moving left is moving to the TSA and moving left is moving to the TSA and people think he's too moderate people think he's too moderate people think he's too moderate >> is going up and this John Oaf guys come >> is going up and this John Oaf guys come >> is going up and this John Oaf guys come out of nowhere. They're all to the left out of nowhere. They're all to the left out of nowhere. They're all to the left of Gavin Newsome's of Gavin Newsome's of Gavin Newsome's problem and this is why he put out that problem and this is why he put out that problem and this is why he put out that video on the day that he was supposed to video on the day that he was supposed to video on the day that he was supposed to kill the BTA. He puts out a a video kill the BTA. He puts out a a video kill the BTA. He puts out a a video endorsing billionaire taxes is because endorsing billionaire taxes is because endorsing billionaire taxes is because he needs to position himself to being he needs to position himself to being he needs to position himself to being more DSA adjacent. Well, to be fair to more DSA adjacent. Well, to be fair to more DSA adjacent. Well, to be fair to Newsome, he also on the same day said Newsome, he also on the same day said Newsome, he also on the same day said he's against the billionaire tax act and he's against the billionaire tax act and he's against the billionaire tax act and he's voting against it. This was his he's voting against it. This was his he's voting against it. This was his hedging video, which is to to kind of hedging video, which is to to kind of hedging video, which is to to kind of zoom out his policy on, hey, this BTA zoom out his policy on, hey, this BTA zoom out his policy on, hey, this BTA doesn't make sense. But I do agree we doesn't make sense. But I do agree we doesn't make sense. But I do agree we need more taxation, I think, was kind of need more taxation, I think, was kind of need more taxation, I think, was kind of the intent. Also, he failed he failed to the intent. Also, he failed he failed to the intent. Also, he failed he failed to kill BTA. Everyone thought all these kill BTA. Everyone thought all these kill BTA. Everyone thought all these California billionaires and these chat California billionaires and these chat California billionaires and these chat groups thought Nome would be their groups thought Nome would be their groups thought Nome would be their savior. savior. savior. >> That's right. >> That's right. >> That's right. >> And that was a big mistake. >> And that was a big mistake. >> And that was a big mistake. >> What's it like, Sax? What's it like in >> What's it like, Sax? What's it like in >> What's it like, Sax? What's it like in that group chat? Tell us about that that group chat? Tell us about that that group chat? Tell us about that group chat. group chat. group chat. >> What's it like in there? What's the >> What's it like in there? What's the >> What's it like in there? What's the meme? What's the meme like in there in meme? What's the meme like in there in meme? What's the meme like in there in the billionaire group chat? Go ahead. the billionaire group chat? Go ahead. the billionaire group chat? Go ahead. >> I It's It's 8:06 p.m. here. I have a >> I It's It's 8:06 p.m. here. I have a >> I It's It's 8:06 p.m. here. I have a meeting I have to go to. I want to say I meeting I have to go to. I want to say I meeting I have to go to. I want to say I love you and I miss all of you. love you and I miss all of you. love you and I miss all of you. >> And I want to say >> And I want to say >> And I want to say >> a huge happy birthday to the most >> a huge happy birthday to the most >> a huge happy birthday to the most incredible country in the world. incredible country in the world. incredible country in the world. >> I could not have imagined my life being >> I could not have imagined my life being >> I could not have imagined my life being any better in any place. I feel so any better in any place. I feel so any better in any place. I feel so blessed and so lucky to be an American. blessed and so lucky to be an American. blessed and so lucky to be an American. >> I feel so thankful. I feel so grateful. >> I feel so thankful. I feel so grateful. >> I feel so thankful. I feel so grateful. It really is the best country in the It really is the best country in the It really is the best country in the world. world. world. >> We have to fight for it. >> We have to fight for it. >> We have to fight for it. >> Yeah. We have to fight for it. >> Yeah. We have to fight for it. >> Yeah. We have to fight for it. >> Fight for it. >> Fight for it. >> Fight for it. >> Yeah. And on behalf of those of us >> Yeah. And on behalf of those of us >> Yeah. And on behalf of those of us >> Happy birthday, America. >> Happy birthday, America. >> Happy birthday, America. >> Happy birthday. And for those of us who >> Happy birthday. And for those of us who >> Happy birthday. And for those of us who have been here for seven generations, have been here for seven generations, have been here for seven generations, >> we think you're doing a good job. We're >> we think you're doing a good job. We're >> we think you're doing a good job. We're going to let you stay here. We're going going to let you stay here. We're going going to let you stay here. We're going to let you stay on behalf. to let you stay on behalf. to let you stay on behalf. >> How can we take away your citizenship? >> How can we take away your citizenship? >> How can we take away your citizenship? That's what I want is a law where we can That's what I want is a law where we can That's what I want is a law where we can revoke JL citizenship. revoke JL citizenship. revoke JL citizenship. >> Citizenship, I've been here >> Citizenship, I've been here >> Citizenship, I've been here >> which the four of us should be deported. >> which the four of us should be deported. >> which the four of us should be deported. I think you would lose. [laughter] I think you would lose. [laughter] I think you would lose. [laughter] >> Oh no. >> Oh no. >> Oh no. >> We'll find some constitutional loophole. >> We'll find some constitutional loophole. >> We'll find some constitutional loophole. >> Enemy Aliens Act. >> Enemy Aliens Act. >> Enemy Aliens Act. >> Bye, Jason. [laughter] >> Bye, Jason. [laughter] >> Bye, Jason. [laughter] >> All right, feel free. On that note, >> All right, feel free. On that note, >> All right, feel free. On that note, happy birthday, America. And uh 250 more happy birthday, America. And uh 250 more happy birthday, America. And uh 250 more great ones. Best country in the world. great ones. Best country in the world. great ones. Best country in the world. Give a you think democratic Give a you think democratic Give a you think democratic socialist commie scumbags. All right, socialist commie scumbags. All right, socialist commie scumbags. All right, we'll see you next time. Bye-bye. Love we'll see you next time. Bye-bye. Love we'll see you next time. Bye-bye. Love you. Bye-bye. you. Bye-bye. you. Bye-bye. >> [music] >> [music] >> [music] >> Let your winners ride. >> Let your winners ride. >> Let your winners ride. >> Rainman David and it said we open sourced it to the and it said we open sourced it to the fans and they've [music] just gone crazy fans and they've [music] just gone crazy fans and they've [music] just gone crazy with it. Love you queen of >> besties are >> besties are my dog taking notice your driveways. Oh man, my habitasher will meet me up. Oh man, my habitasher will meet me up. >> We should all just get a room and just >> We should all just get a room and just >> We should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy cuz they're all have one big huge orgy cuz they're all have one big huge orgy cuz they're all just It's like [music] this like sexual just It's like [music] this like sexual just It's like [music] this like sexual tension that we just need to release tension that we just need to release tension that we just need to release somehow. >> Your feet. >> Your feet. [laughter] [laughter] [laughter] We need to get mercy. We need to get mercy. We need to get mercy. >> I'm going >> I'm going >> I'm going [music] [music] [music] all in.