1% better

#1 Nutrition Scientist: This Is Why You Struggle To Lose Weight | Kevin Hall, PhD

NIH metabolism researcher Kevin Hall discusses his groundbreaking findings on weight loss, metabolic adaptation, and the biological mechanisms that make...

1h 51m

Summary published by , updated .

Rich Roll Podcast

Key Takeaway

Research shows that when you lose weight, your appetite increases by about 95 calories per kilogram lost, while metabolism only slows by 25 calories per kilogram. This means appetite changes outpace metabolic adaptation by nearly 4:1, explaining why weight plateaus occur even with continued effort. The key insight: focus on sustainable lifestyle changes you can maintain long-term rather than temporary restrictions.

Episode Overview

NIH metabolism researcher Kevin Hall discusses his groundbreaking findings on weight loss, metabolic adaptation, and the biological mechanisms that make weight maintenance challenging. He explains why the Biggest Loser contestants' metabolisms stayed suppressed, debunks metabolism myths, and reveals how appetite changes drive weight plateaus more than metabolic slowdown.

Main Insights

Metabolic Adaptation Is Not Determinative

The biggest metabolic slowdowns occur in people who lose the most weight successfully, not those who struggle. Metabolic slowing is a response to intervention, like tension on a spring - the more you pull (lose weight), the greater the resistance, but it doesn't determine how far you can pull.

Appetite Outpaces Metabolism 4:1

For every kilogram of weight lost, metabolism slows by about 25 calories per day, but appetite increases by 95 calories per day. This powerful biological response explains why people plateau even when maintaining the same effort level in their diet and exercise routine.

Weight Loss Requires Permanent Lifestyle Change

Successful weight maintenance requires continuing the same level of effort that created the weight loss. The body doesn't fully return to its original set point, but it will regain weight if you stop the intervention that caused the loss.

The Body's Compensation Mechanisms Are Remarkably Precise

Studies of diabetes drugs that cause calorie loss through urine show the body compensates almost completely over months by increasing appetite. This demonstrates sophisticated biological feedback systems that maintain energy balance regardless of how calories are lost.

Notable Quotes

"The way I sort of like to think about is it's kind of like the tension on a spring. And if you're doing an intervention to stretch the string and as the spring and thereby kind of cause weight loss, you know, you can do that, but the greater pullback you'll feel, right? But the greater you pull, the more weight you've lost."

Kevin Hall

"Whatever lifestyle intervention these folks were able to um do both on the television program as well as after they went home, that's going to be determinative of of how much weight they've been able to keep off. And the sling of metabolism, while not helpful, it's really an indication. It's kind of like the the the cart, not the horse, right?"

Kevin Hall

"For every kilogram of weight that you lose um your calorie expenditure goes down by about 25 calories per day. So you lose, you know, 10 kilos, 22 lb, you'll be burning about 250 calories per day lower than you were before you'd lost that weight. Appetite seems to go up by about 95 calories per day."

Kevin Hall

"Whatever you're going to do, make sure that you can keep that as part of your life because otherwise, as soon as you stop doing it, the weight is probably going to increase."

Kevin Hall

Action Items

Suggested exercises inspired by the conversation.

  • 1
    Design Sustainable Interventions

    Before starting any weight loss approach, ask yourself if you can maintain these changes as part of your permanent lifestyle. Avoid temporary restrictions that require willpower to sustain.

  • 2
    Understand Your Appetite Changes

    Recognize that increased appetite after weight loss is normal biology, not personal failure. Plan for this by focusing on foods and eating patterns that help manage hunger while fitting your lifestyle.

  • 3
    Reframe Weight Plateaus

    When weight loss plateaus despite continued effort, understand this reflects successful biological adaptation, not intervention failure. Maintaining your current weight at this effort level is still a victory.

  • 4
    Focus on Effort Consistency

    Rather than tracking just weight changes, monitor your consistency with the lifestyle interventions themselves. Sustained effort is what determines long-term success, regardless of metabolic adaptation.

Guides that reference this episode

See how this episode fits with recommendations from other leading podcasts.

Go deeper

Full Transcript

Read or copy the complete episode transcript.

Welcome to the holiday season. You know Welcome to the holiday season. You know what happens this time of year? It's the what happens this time of year? It's the what happens this time of year? It's the time of year when we tend to pack on the time of year when we tend to pack on the time of year when we tend to pack on the pounds and then immediately start pounds and then immediately start pounds and then immediately start thinking about what we're going to have thinking about what we're going to have thinking about what we're going to have to do in the new year to take it all to do in the new year to take it all to do in the new year to take it all off. Now listen, there's no shortage of off. Now listen, there's no shortage of off. Now listen, there's no shortage of opinions, of course, on the internet on opinions, of course, on the internet on opinions, of course, on the internet on the best way to do this. But we have one the best way to do this. But we have one the best way to do this. But we have one of the world's foremost and respected of the world's foremost and respected of the world's foremost and respected nutrition science researchers on the nutrition science researchers on the nutrition science researchers on the show today here to spare you from having show today here to spare you from having show today here to spare you from having to sift through a million bad takes. to sift through a million bad takes. to sift through a million bad takes. Today, Kevin Hall explains exactly why Today, Kevin Hall explains exactly why Today, Kevin Hall explains exactly why people struggle to lose weight and keep people struggle to lose weight and keep people struggle to lose weight and keep it off. We talk about the truth behind it off. We talk about the truth behind it off. We talk about the truth behind this idea of slow metabolism, how this idea of slow metabolism, how this idea of slow metabolism, how ultrarocessed foods hijack our biology, ultrarocessed foods hijack our biology, ultrarocessed foods hijack our biology, and the real science behind calories, and the real science behind calories, and the real science behind calories, exercise, and appetite. Kevin also exercise, and appetite. Kevin also exercise, and appetite. Kevin also shares powerful tools for navigating the shares powerful tools for navigating the shares powerful tools for navigating the modern food and information landscape modern food and information landscape modern food and information landscape and quite fascinatingly opens up about and quite fascinatingly opens up about and quite fascinatingly opens up about the censorship he experienced from the the censorship he experienced from the the censorship he experienced from the HHS that prompted him to resign his HHS that prompted him to resign his HHS that prompted him to resign his position at NIH after having worked position at NIH after having worked position at NIH after having worked there for 20 years. So, if you're there for 20 years. So, if you're there for 20 years. So, if you're looking for clarity when it comes to looking for clarity when it comes to looking for clarity when it comes to nutrition, weight loss, and what nutrition, weight loss, and what nutrition, weight loss, and what actually drives long-term health, this actually drives long-term health, this actually drives long-term health, this conversation is an essential one for conversation is an essential one for conversation is an essential one for you, and one that I would encourage you you, and one that I would encourage you you, and one that I would encourage you to share with others in search of just to share with others in search of just to share with others in search of just solid and evidence-based information solid and evidence-based information solid and evidence-based information about nutrition. Really quick, you guys, I keep hearing Really quick, you guys, I keep hearing from fans of the show that they don't from fans of the show that they don't from fans of the show that they don't always see our episodes in their feed. always see our episodes in their feed. always see our episodes in their feed. And when I tried to figure out why, I And when I tried to figure out why, I And when I tried to figure out why, I discovered one important reason. 71% of discovered one important reason. 71% of discovered one important reason. 71% of you who watch here on YouTube are not you who watch here on YouTube are not you who watch here on YouTube are not subscribed yet. So, could you do me a subscribed yet. So, could you do me a subscribed yet. So, could you do me a tiny favor? Just hit subscribe. It's tiny favor? Just hit subscribe. It's tiny favor? Just hit subscribe. It's free. It'll take you one second and that free. It'll take you one second and that free. It'll take you one second and that way you won't miss any of the episodes way you won't miss any of the episodes way you won't miss any of the episodes that I post here on YouTube. Thank you. that I post here on YouTube. Thank you. that I post here on YouTube. Thank you. And on to the show. And on to the show. And on to the show. >> Kevin, so nice to meet you. Thank you >> Kevin, so nice to meet you. Thank you >> Kevin, so nice to meet you. Thank you for doing this. for doing this. for doing this. >> My pleasure. I consider you a very >> My pleasure. I consider you a very >> My pleasure. I consider you a very important figure in the world of important figure in the world of important figure in the world of nutrition science. You're a an an honest nutrition science. You're a an an honest nutrition science. You're a an an honest actor, a good faith actor. Uh always actor, a good faith actor. Uh always actor, a good faith actor. Uh always trying to uh basically uh set matters to trying to uh basically uh set matters to trying to uh basically uh set matters to rights amidst a hurricane of nutritional rights amidst a hurricane of nutritional rights amidst a hurricane of nutritional misinformation out there. Uh and I misinformation out there. Uh and I misinformation out there. Uh and I really appreciate your voice and and for really appreciate your voice and and for really appreciate your voice and and for you taking the time to talk to me today. you taking the time to talk to me today. you taking the time to talk to me today. >> That means a lot. Thanks so much. Some >> That means a lot. Thanks so much. Some >> That means a lot. Thanks so much. Some of the audience might be familiar with of the audience might be familiar with of the audience might be familiar with your name because there was a little bit your name because there was a little bit your name because there was a little bit of a political standoff or kurfuffle uh of a political standoff or kurfuffle uh of a political standoff or kurfuffle uh uh several months ago between you and uh several months ago between you and uh several months ago between you and HHS and and RFK Jr. which resulted in HHS and and RFK Jr. which resulted in HHS and and RFK Jr. which resulted in you resigning after 21 years at the NIH. you resigning after 21 years at the NIH. you resigning after 21 years at the NIH. Uh and that created a bit of a media Uh and that created a bit of a media Uh and that created a bit of a media circus. I do want to know about that, circus. I do want to know about that, circus. I do want to know about that, but we're not going to start with that. but we're not going to start with that. but we're not going to start with that. As somebody who has been studying As somebody who has been studying As somebody who has been studying metabolism for decades, top level, like metabolism for decades, top level, like metabolism for decades, top level, like what are the conclusions that you've what are the conclusions that you've what are the conclusions that you've that you've drawn from the randomized that you've drawn from the randomized that you've drawn from the randomized control trials that you've performed uh control trials that you've performed uh control trials that you've performed uh about the relationship between about the relationship between about the relationship between metabolism, weight gain, and weight metabolism, weight gain, and weight metabolism, weight gain, and weight loss? loss? loss? >> Yeah. So when people are losing weight >> Yeah. So when people are losing weight >> Yeah. So when people are losing weight and they're they are decreasing their and they're they are decreasing their and they're they are decreasing their body size either by you know an exercise body size either by you know an exercise body size either by you know an exercise intervention diet intervention a intervention diet intervention a intervention diet intervention a phicotherapy or something like that um phicotherapy or something like that um phicotherapy or something like that um they tend to at rest their resting they tend to at rest their resting they tend to at rest their resting metabolism when they're not moving is metabolism when they're not moving is metabolism when they're not moving is decreasing. Now it seems to decrease decreasing. Now it seems to decrease decreasing. Now it seems to decrease even more than you'd expect at least even more than you'd expect at least even more than you'd expect at least transiently while they're in active transiently while they're in active transiently while they're in active weight loss compared to what you'd weight loss compared to what you'd weight loss compared to what you'd expect for their decreasing body size. expect for their decreasing body size. expect for their decreasing body size. larger people burn more calories than larger people burn more calories than larger people burn more calories than smaller people. So, it goes to, you smaller people. So, it goes to, you smaller people. So, it goes to, you know, figure that you would as you know, figure that you would as you know, figure that you would as you become smaller, you burn fewer calories. become smaller, you burn fewer calories. become smaller, you burn fewer calories. But it turns out in the process of But it turns out in the process of But it turns out in the process of becoming smaller during that period when becoming smaller during that period when becoming smaller during that period when you're actively losing weight, it seems you're actively losing weight, it seems you're actively losing weight, it seems like it metabolism slows even more than like it metabolism slows even more than like it metabolism slows even more than expected. This is something called expected. This is something called expected. This is something called metabolic adaptation. One of the most metabolic adaptation. One of the most metabolic adaptation. One of the most extreme cases of this was seen in extreme cases of this was seen in extreme cases of this was seen in volunteers uh in Minnesota who volunteers uh in Minnesota who volunteers uh in Minnesota who volunteered for a starvation experiment volunteered for a starvation experiment volunteered for a starvation experiment um by Anel Keys back during World War um by Anel Keys back during World War um by Anel Keys back during World War II. The idea was they volunteered to II. The idea was they volunteered to II. The idea was they volunteered to serve their country. They were serve their country. They were serve their country. They were conscientious objectors and they uh conscientious objectors and they uh conscientious objectors and they uh basically uh said we're going to starve basically uh said we're going to starve basically uh said we're going to starve because eventually the war is going to because eventually the war is going to because eventually the war is going to end and we need to learn how to refeed end and we need to learn how to refeed end and we need to learn how to refeed all these people in Europe who've uh all these people in Europe who've uh all these people in Europe who've uh been subject to starvation during the been subject to starvation during the been subject to starvation during the war. And so these folks basically uh war. And so these folks basically uh war. And so these folks basically uh were relatively lean to begin with and were relatively lean to begin with and were relatively lean to begin with and 36 people um underwent like a 50% 36 people um underwent like a 50% 36 people um underwent like a 50% calorie restriction and you could just calorie restriction and you could just calorie restriction and you could just see their resting metabolic rate falling see their resting metabolic rate falling see their resting metabolic rate falling and it went down much more than you'd and it went down much more than you'd and it went down much more than you'd expect based on how much weight that expect based on how much weight that expect based on how much weight that they lost. they lost. they lost. >> Um a similar sort of thing was observed >> Um a similar sort of thing was observed >> Um a similar sort of thing was observed by us when we examined these folks in by us when we examined these folks in by us when we examined these folks in this Biggest Loser television this Biggest Loser television this Biggest Loser television competition. We saw that while these competition. We saw that while these competition. We saw that while these folks were doing insane amounts of folks were doing insane amounts of folks were doing insane amounts of exercise and and cutting their calories exercise and and cutting their calories exercise and and cutting their calories in their diets, their metabolic rate was in their diets, their metabolic rate was in their diets, their metabolic rate was slowing by a huge amount as well during slowing by a huge amount as well during slowing by a huge amount as well during this during this program. this during this program. this during this program. >> And it stayed slow long after. >> And it stayed slow long after. >> And it stayed slow long after. >> Yeah. And that's something that's still >> Yeah. And that's something that's still >> Yeah. And that's something that's still a little bit mysterious to be honest a little bit mysterious to be honest a little bit mysterious to be honest with you because unlike the Minnesota with you because unlike the Minnesota with you because unlike the Minnesota experiment folks who they did have their experiment folks who they did have their experiment folks who they did have their refeeding phase and they did regain uh refeeding phase and they did regain uh refeeding phase and they did regain uh some of their lost weight, their some of their lost weight, their some of their lost weight, their metabolic rate improved. it actually metabolic rate improved. it actually metabolic rate improved. it actually went back up towards normal. And most went back up towards normal. And most went back up towards normal. And most sort of weight loss trials that have sort of weight loss trials that have sort of weight loss trials that have looked at people and unfortunately many looked at people and unfortunately many looked at people and unfortunately many people who lose weight um via lifestyle people who lose weight um via lifestyle people who lose weight um via lifestyle intervention have end up regaining some intervention have end up regaining some intervention have end up regaining some of the lost weight um those folks tend of the lost weight um those folks tend of the lost weight um those folks tend to recover their resting metabolic rate to recover their resting metabolic rate to recover their resting metabolic rate as well. There's something really weird as well. There's something really weird as well. There's something really weird about what happened in the Biggest Loser about what happened in the Biggest Loser about what happened in the Biggest Loser study and we have some theories about study and we have some theories about study and we have some theories about what that might be. It might be that uh what that might be. It might be that uh what that might be. It might be that uh there's something about the fact that there's something about the fact that there's something about the fact that these folks actually ga started off very these folks actually ga started off very these folks actually ga started off very sedentary. They became very sedentary. They became very sedentary. They became very extraordinarily physically active during extraordinarily physically active during extraordinarily physically active during the program exercising 3 hours every day the program exercising 3 hours every day the program exercising 3 hours every day 7 days a week vigorously and then even 7 days a week vigorously and then even 7 days a week vigorously and then even when they went home um during the weight when they went home um during the weight when they went home um during the weight loss competition it was an hour a day of loss competition it was an hour a day of loss competition it was an hour a day of vigorous activity. Even 6 years later vigorous activity. Even 6 years later vigorous activity. Even 6 years later they were pretty darn active compared to they were pretty darn active compared to they were pretty darn active compared to where they started. So, is there some where they started. So, is there some where they started. So, is there some trade-off going on between if you become trade-off going on between if you become trade-off going on between if you become that physically active, uh, does that physically active, uh, does that physically active, uh, does something else in metabolism slow down something else in metabolism slow down something else in metabolism slow down to compensate? That's a theory at this to compensate? That's a theory at this to compensate? That's a theory at this point. We don't really have good data. point. We don't really have good data. point. We don't really have good data. And unfortunately, it's a hard And unfortunately, it's a hard And unfortunately, it's a hard experiment to repeat, right? There's, experiment to repeat, right? There's, experiment to repeat, right? There's, unfortunately, the television shows unfortunately, the television shows unfortunately, the television shows canled, so I can't just go back and do canled, so I can't just go back and do canled, so I can't just go back and do that that that >> because it was a bit of a train wreck of >> because it was a bit of a train wreck of >> because it was a bit of a train wreck of the television show, to be honest. Um, the television show, to be honest. Um, the television show, to be honest. Um, but yeah, something interesting was but yeah, something interesting was but yeah, something interesting was going on there that I don't think we going on there that I don't think we going on there that I don't think we fully understand. fully understand. fully understand. >> Yeah. So correct me if I'm wrong, but >> Yeah. So correct me if I'm wrong, but >> Yeah. So correct me if I'm wrong, but essentially with this Biggest Loser essentially with this Biggest Loser essentially with this Biggest Loser study, uh the conventional wisdom or the study, uh the conventional wisdom or the study, uh the conventional wisdom or the expectation was that metabolic rate was expectation was that metabolic rate was expectation was that metabolic rate was going to correlate pretty tightly uh going to correlate pretty tightly uh going to correlate pretty tightly uh with people who regained the weight. with people who regained the weight. with people who regained the weight. Like you would be there would be a Like you would be there would be a Like you would be there would be a correlation between metabolic rate and correlation between metabolic rate and correlation between metabolic rate and the people who regain the weight and the the people who regain the weight and the the people who regain the weight and the people who are able to you know maintain people who are able to you know maintain people who are able to you know maintain their new lower weight. Correct. And the their new lower weight. Correct. And the their new lower weight. Correct. And the results actually defied that on some results actually defied that on some results actually defied that on some level. level. level. >> Yeah. So there were several things that >> Yeah. So there were several things that >> Yeah. So there were several things that were surprising about the results. One were surprising about the results. One were surprising about the results. One was that um you would think that the was that um you would think that the was that um you would think that the more you slowed your metabolism, the more you slowed your metabolism, the more you slowed your metabolism, the less you'd be able to lose, the less less you'd be able to lose, the less less you'd be able to lose, the less weight you'd be able to lose. Cuz after weight you'd be able to lose. Cuz after weight you'd be able to lose. Cuz after all, that's kind of physics, right? If all, that's kind of physics, right? If all, that's kind of physics, right? If you were burning more calories and you you were burning more calories and you you were burning more calories and you cut the same number of calories in your cut the same number of calories in your cut the same number of calories in your in your diet, then you would expect to in your diet, then you would expect to in your diet, then you would expect to lose more weight. Like the energy has to lose more weight. Like the energy has to lose more weight. Like the energy has to come from somewhere. It's going to come come from somewhere. It's going to come come from somewhere. It's going to come from body fat. What we observed in the from body fat. What we observed in the from body fat. What we observed in the Biggest Loser was that the people who Biggest Loser was that the people who Biggest Loser was that the people who were most successful at losing weight uh were most successful at losing weight uh were most successful at losing weight uh during this kind of crazy competition, during this kind of crazy competition, during this kind of crazy competition, they were the ones who experienced the they were the ones who experienced the they were the ones who experienced the most slowing of metabolism. So that was most slowing of metabolism. So that was most slowing of metabolism. So that was kind of weird. It's like, okay, what's kind of weird. It's like, okay, what's kind of weird. It's like, okay, what's going on there? Why it seemed to be going on there? Why it seemed to be going on there? Why it seemed to be completely the expected correlation was completely the expected correlation was completely the expected correlation was flipped. And then there was this idea flipped. And then there was this idea flipped. And then there was this idea that the slowing of metabolism, well, that the slowing of metabolism, well, that the slowing of metabolism, well, that's got to be a bad thing. that's got that's got to be a bad thing. that's got that's got to be a bad thing. that's got to predict who's going to regain the to predict who's going to regain the to predict who's going to regain the most weight after this crazy most weight after this crazy most weight after this crazy competition. And there tend to be turned competition. And there tend to be turned competition. And there tend to be turned out to be no no significant relationship out to be no no significant relationship out to be no no significant relationship whatsoever um with who regained the most whatsoever um with who regained the most whatsoever um with who regained the most weight. It wasn't the folks who had the weight. It wasn't the folks who had the weight. It wasn't the folks who had the greatest lowing. It wasn't the folks who greatest lowing. It wasn't the folks who greatest lowing. It wasn't the folks who had the least amount of slowing. It was had the least amount of slowing. It was had the least amount of slowing. It was more or less random. And then at 6 years more or less random. And then at 6 years more or less random. And then at 6 years later, the ones who were most successful later, the ones who were most successful later, the ones who were most successful at keeping the weight off continue to at keeping the weight off continue to at keeping the weight off continue to have the greatest slowing of metabolism. have the greatest slowing of metabolism. have the greatest slowing of metabolism. And the only way I've been able to sort And the only way I've been able to sort And the only way I've been able to sort of make sense of that is that our of make sense of that is that our of make sense of that is that our changes in metabolism and the slowing of changes in metabolism and the slowing of changes in metabolism and the slowing of metabolism is a response to the metabolism is a response to the metabolism is a response to the intervention. It's not determinative. intervention. It's not determinative. intervention. It's not determinative. It's the way I sort of like to think It's the way I sort of like to think It's the way I sort of like to think about is it's kind of like the tension about is it's kind of like the tension about is it's kind of like the tension on a spring. And if you're doing an on a spring. And if you're doing an on a spring. And if you're doing an intervention to stretch the string and intervention to stretch the string and intervention to stretch the string and as the spring and thereby kind of cause as the spring and thereby kind of cause as the spring and thereby kind of cause weight loss, you know, you can do that, weight loss, you know, you can do that, weight loss, you know, you can do that, but the greater pullback you'll feel, but the greater pullback you'll feel, but the greater pullback you'll feel, right? But the greater you pull, the right? But the greater you pull, the right? But the greater you pull, the more weight you've lost. So this the more weight you've lost. So this the more weight you've lost. So this the distance that you've pulled the the distance that you've pulled the the distance that you've pulled the the spring is in some sense uh related it's spring is in some sense uh related it's spring is in some sense uh related it's it's like how much weight you're losing it's like how much weight you're losing it's like how much weight you're losing but the more you pull the more the but the more you pull the more the but the more you pull the more the resistance the greater the tension on resistance the greater the tension on resistance the greater the tension on the spring. That's the metabolic the spring. That's the metabolic the spring. That's the metabolic slowing. Clearly if the spring had less slowing. Clearly if the spring had less slowing. Clearly if the spring had less tension you'd be able to pull it tension you'd be able to pull it tension you'd be able to pull it further. Right? But the point is is it's further. Right? But the point is is it's further. Right? But the point is is it's not determinative of how long the spring not determinative of how long the spring not determinative of how long the spring is. It's how hard you're pulling on the is. It's how hard you're pulling on the is. It's how hard you're pulling on the darn thing. Right? So, whatever darn thing. Right? So, whatever darn thing. Right? So, whatever lifestyle intervention these folks were lifestyle intervention these folks were lifestyle intervention these folks were able to um do both on the television able to um do both on the television able to um do both on the television program as well as after they went home, program as well as after they went home, program as well as after they went home, that's going to be determinative of of that's going to be determinative of of that's going to be determinative of of how much weight they've been able to how much weight they've been able to how much weight they've been able to keep off. And the sling of metabolism, keep off. And the sling of metabolism, keep off. And the sling of metabolism, while not helpful, it's really an while not helpful, it's really an while not helpful, it's really an indication. It's kind of like the the indication. It's kind of like the the indication. It's kind of like the the the cart, not the horse, right? It's the cart, not the horse, right? It's the cart, not the horse, right? It's it's the follower, and it's the response it's the follower, and it's the response it's the follower, and it's the response to that intervention. to that intervention. to that intervention. On some level it it makes sense that On some level it it makes sense that On some level it it makes sense that somebody who is attempting to lose somebody who is attempting to lose somebody who is attempting to lose weight and perhaps even a dramatic weight and perhaps even a dramatic weight and perhaps even a dramatic amount of weight uh that you know amount of weight uh that you know amount of weight uh that you know physiologically the body would respond physiologically the body would respond physiologically the body would respond by slowing metabolism because it will by slowing metabolism because it will by slowing metabolism because it will interpret that as a threat like we got interpret that as a threat like we got interpret that as a threat like we got to hold on to this weight like this to hold on to this weight like this to hold on to this weight like this guy's trying to starve us you know let's guy's trying to starve us you know let's guy's trying to starve us you know let's keep this fat here because we might need keep this fat here because we might need keep this fat here because we might need it right as a sort of evolutionary it right as a sort of evolutionary it right as a sort of evolutionary adaptation. Yeah, I think that that adaptation. Yeah, I think that that adaptation. Yeah, I think that that makes sense if you're lean, right? Um makes sense if you're lean, right? Um makes sense if you're lean, right? Um but once you kind of cross a certain but once you kind of cross a certain but once you kind of cross a certain threshold, right, like how long do you threshold, right, like how long do you threshold, right, like how long do you really have to prepare for starvation, really have to prepare for starvation, really have to prepare for starvation, right? Most people, so um humans are right? Most people, so um humans are right? Most people, so um humans are apes that actually store quite a bit of apes that actually store quite a bit of apes that actually store quite a bit of body fat compared to other apes. Like body fat compared to other apes. Like body fat compared to other apes. Like even lean humans have quite a bit of even lean humans have quite a bit of even lean humans have quite a bit of body fat. We talk in the book about like body fat. We talk in the book about like body fat. We talk in the book about like most people um have enough body fat on most people um have enough body fat on most people um have enough body fat on them to last for months, them to last for months, them to last for months, >> right? you know, starvation periods that >> right? you know, starvation periods that >> right? you know, starvation periods that last for longer than months. Most people last for longer than months. Most people last for longer than months. Most people are not dying of losing body fat. are not dying of losing body fat. are not dying of losing body fat. They're dying of the infections and the They're dying of the infections and the They're dying of the infections and the the propensity for infections that that the propensity for infections that that the propensity for infections that that come along with that. And it's not clear come along with that. And it's not clear come along with that. And it's not clear if body fat is protective of that or if body fat is protective of that or if body fat is protective of that or not. not. not. >> Um, so I sort of expected that maybe we >> Um, so I sort of expected that maybe we >> Um, so I sort of expected that maybe we wouldn't see this if we were studying wouldn't see this if we were studying wouldn't see this if we were studying people with obesity because they're way people with obesity because they're way people with obesity because they're way above, you know, the the necessary above, you know, the the necessary above, you know, the the necessary requirements. requirements. requirements. >> No alarm bells need to go off. >> No alarm bells need to go off. >> No alarm bells need to go off. >> Exactly. But it seems like it's the same >> Exactly. But it seems like it's the same >> Exactly. But it seems like it's the same alarm bells and how that works is really alarm bells and how that works is really alarm bells and how that works is really interesting to me. Right. I expected interesting to me. Right. I expected interesting to me. Right. I expected like clearly the Minnesota starvation like clearly the Minnesota starvation like clearly the Minnesota starvation folks who were like 67 kg on average so folks who were like 67 kg on average so folks who were like 67 kg on average so pretty lean by today's standards. Yeah. pretty lean by today's standards. Yeah. pretty lean by today's standards. Yeah. They're lo and when they're losing They're lo and when they're losing They're lo and when they're losing weight they're losing mostly lean body weight they're losing mostly lean body weight they're losing mostly lean body mass. They're not losing as much body mass. They're not losing as much body mass. They're not losing as much body fat because they start off with very fat because they start off with very fat because they start off with very little amounts of body fat. So clearly little amounts of body fat. So clearly little amounts of body fat. So clearly that's a case where gosh, yeah, the that's a case where gosh, yeah, the that's a case where gosh, yeah, the alarm bell should go off. You should alarm bell should go off. You should alarm bell should go off. You should slow down metabolism a lot. But you're slow down metabolism a lot. But you're slow down metabolism a lot. But you're starting off with um you know a lot of starting off with um you know a lot of starting off with um you know a lot of of stored energy. It's kind of like it'd of stored energy. It's kind of like it'd of stored energy. It's kind of like it'd be like your phone going into power be like your phone going into power be like your phone going into power saving mode even though it was at 98% saving mode even though it was at 98% saving mode even though it was at 98% energy, right? You only really think energy, right? You only really think energy, right? You only really think that that should kick in after you get that that should kick in after you get that that should kick in after you get to 10%. Right? But it seems like for to 10%. Right? But it seems like for to 10%. Right? But it seems like for whatever reason um people with obesity whatever reason um people with obesity whatever reason um people with obesity seem to have the same sorts of of seem to have the same sorts of of seem to have the same sorts of of responses to that acute challenge that responses to that acute challenge that responses to that acute challenge that is is uh causing a calorie deficit. And is is uh causing a calorie deficit. And is is uh causing a calorie deficit. And and whatever that is that you're you're and whatever that is that you're you're and whatever that is that you're you're right. They sort of respond to that right. They sort of respond to that right. They sort of respond to that challenge by saying, "Yep, no, we're challenge by saying, "Yep, no, we're challenge by saying, "Yep, no, we're slowing things down. We're going into slowing things down. We're going into slowing things down. We're going into power saving mode." And and I don't power saving mode." And and I don't power saving mode." And and I don't think we fully understand all of the uh think we fully understand all of the uh think we fully understand all of the uh mechanisms by which that happens. Some mechanisms by which that happens. Some mechanisms by which that happens. Some of it has to do with the sympathetic of it has to do with the sympathetic of it has to do with the sympathetic nervous system and and slowing of that. nervous system and and slowing of that. nervous system and and slowing of that. But yeah, I don't think we fully But yeah, I don't think we fully But yeah, I don't think we fully understand it. understand it. understand it. >> Yeah. I mean, what is your sense of >> Yeah. I mean, what is your sense of >> Yeah. I mean, what is your sense of where the answer lies? Like is it in where the answer lies? Like is it in where the answer lies? Like is it in genetics? Is it in the microbiome? Is it genetics? Is it in the microbiome? Is it genetics? Is it in the microbiome? Is it in the, you know, hormonal system? in the, you know, hormonal system? in the, you know, hormonal system? >> Yeah. I mean, my my sense is that it's >> Yeah. I mean, my my sense is that it's >> Yeah. I mean, my my sense is that it's probably mostly in the hormonal system. probably mostly in the hormonal system. probably mostly in the hormonal system. One of the things that we found was that One of the things that we found was that One of the things that we found was that the the relationship between the slowing the the relationship between the slowing the the relationship between the slowing of metabolism was related to how much of metabolism was related to how much of metabolism was related to how much the hormone leptin changed. And leptin, the hormone leptin changed. And leptin, the hormone leptin changed. And leptin, even though it's in a person who's kind even though it's in a person who's kind even though it's in a person who's kind of just maintaining their weight, it's of just maintaining their weight, it's of just maintaining their weight, it's proportional to how much body fat that proportional to how much body fat that proportional to how much body fat that they have. When you take a a person even they have. When you take a a person even they have. When you take a a person even with obesity who starts off with a very with obesity who starts off with a very with obesity who starts off with a very high amount of leptin, um even though high amount of leptin, um even though high amount of leptin, um even though they haven't lost very much body fat they haven't lost very much body fat they haven't lost very much body fat yet, and you put them into this this uh yet, and you put them into this this uh yet, and you put them into this this uh energy deficit, leptin levels crash. energy deficit, leptin levels crash. energy deficit, leptin levels crash. >> Uh so it seems like that metabolic >> Uh so it seems like that metabolic >> Uh so it seems like that metabolic slowing is not sensitive necessarily to slowing is not sensitive necessarily to slowing is not sensitive necessarily to the absolute amount of leptin that's the absolute amount of leptin that's the absolute amount of leptin that's there, but the change in the the there, but the change in the the there, but the change in the the decrease that that takes place. Uh decrease that that takes place. Uh decrease that that takes place. Uh that's a hypothesis. I don't think we that's a hypothesis. I don't think we that's a hypothesis. I don't think we have a good uh experimental have a good uh experimental have a good uh experimental investigation of that yet. There's folks investigation of that yet. There's folks investigation of that yet. There's folks like Rudy Libel and Michael Rosenbomb like Rudy Libel and Michael Rosenbomb like Rudy Libel and Michael Rosenbomb have done some experiments where they have done some experiments where they have done some experiments where they actually kind of try to infuse leptin at actually kind of try to infuse leptin at actually kind of try to infuse leptin at different levels to try to prevent that. different levels to try to prevent that. different levels to try to prevent that. And uh they've seen that it seems to be And uh they've seen that it seems to be And uh they've seen that it seems to be successful at preventing the reduction successful at preventing the reduction successful at preventing the reduction in in energy expenditure especially at in in energy expenditure especially at in in energy expenditure especially at low levels of physical activity where a low levels of physical activity where a low levels of physical activity where a good chunk of our of our energy budget good chunk of our of our energy budget good chunk of our of our energy budget goes to. Um, so those are kind of goes to. Um, so those are kind of goes to. Um, so those are kind of interesting experiments that suggest interesting experiments that suggest interesting experiments that suggest that that might be the case, but again, that that might be the case, but again, that that might be the case, but again, I don't think that they're completely I don't think that they're completely I don't think that they're completely determinative either. determinative either. determinative either. >> And what do your findings suggest uh >> And what do your findings suggest uh >> And what do your findings suggest uh about the malleability of our metabolic about the malleability of our metabolic about the malleability of our metabolic rate? Like how much agency do we have? rate? Like how much agency do we have? rate? Like how much agency do we have? Like, oh, okay, my metabolism is slow. Like, oh, okay, my metabolism is slow. Like, oh, okay, my metabolism is slow. Like, what can I do? I'm going to Like, what can I do? I'm going to Like, what can I do? I'm going to kickstart it. I'm going to hyperdrive kickstart it. I'm going to hyperdrive kickstart it. I'm going to hyperdrive it. You know, like do we can we insert it. You know, like do we can we insert it. You know, like do we can we insert ourselves into this equation to, you ourselves into this equation to, you ourselves into this equation to, you know, drive a certain outcome here? I know, drive a certain outcome here? I know, drive a certain outcome here? I mean, there's lots of promises, right? mean, there's lots of promises, right? mean, there's lots of promises, right? There's lots of promises that certain There's lots of promises that certain There's lots of promises that certain supplements can increase metabolism. Um, supplements can increase metabolism. Um, supplements can increase metabolism. Um, and the evidence behind those is, well, and the evidence behind those is, well, and the evidence behind those is, well, yeah, maybe you can detect a yeah, maybe you can detect a yeah, maybe you can detect a statistically significant uh change in statistically significant uh change in statistically significant uh change in metabolism, metabolism, metabolism, exposing yourself to large amounts of exposing yourself to large amounts of exposing yourself to large amounts of these kinds of supplements, but it's these kinds of supplements, but it's these kinds of supplements, but it's pretty clinically meaningless. the times pretty clinically meaningless. the times pretty clinically meaningless. the times that we've actually though the only time that we've actually though the only time that we've actually though the only time we've actually um come up with uh really we've actually um come up with uh really we've actually um come up with uh really good ways of speeding up people's good ways of speeding up people's good ways of speeding up people's metabolism. Um this was again in the metabolism. Um this was again in the metabolism. Um this was again in the sort of turn of the 20th century. There sort of turn of the 20th century. There sort of turn of the 20th century. There was a compound that was discovered um in was a compound that was discovered um in was a compound that was discovered um in a munitions factory during uh World War a munitions factory during uh World War a munitions factory during uh World War I uh where people were spontaneously I uh where people were spontaneously I uh where people were spontaneously losing weight and we were like what's losing weight and we were like what's losing weight and we were like what's going on? It turns out that they were going on? It turns out that they were going on? It turns out that they were exposed to something called d exposed to something called d exposed to something called d nitrophenol um which turns to turns out nitrophenol um which turns to turns out nitrophenol um which turns to turns out to be an uncoupler of mitochondria. So to be an uncoupler of mitochondria. So to be an uncoupler of mitochondria. So it actually prevents the mitochondria it actually prevents the mitochondria it actually prevents the mitochondria from functioning properly, not making as from functioning properly, not making as from functioning properly, not making as much ATP as they should and as a result much ATP as they should and as a result much ATP as they should and as a result metabolism. Exactly. metabolism. Exactly. metabolism. Exactly. >> Interesting. >> Interesting. >> Interesting. >> And it turned out to be extremely >> And it turned out to be extremely >> And it turned out to be extremely effective for weight loss, but also effective for weight loss, but also effective for weight loss, but also incredibly dangerous. In fact, one of incredibly dangerous. In fact, one of incredibly dangerous. In fact, one of the first things that the newly formed the first things that the newly formed the first things that the newly formed FDA did was withdraw ditrophenol from FDA did was withdraw ditrophenol from FDA did was withdraw ditrophenol from the um from from med medications that the um from from med medications that the um from from med medications that were uh allowable for use because it was were uh allowable for use because it was were uh allowable for use because it was so dangerous. many people were were so dangerous. many people were were so dangerous. many people were were dying. And and it's actually not very dying. And and it's actually not very dying. And and it's actually not very encouraging to see that there are still encouraging to see that there are still encouraging to see that there are still some bodybuilders out there that are some bodybuilders out there that are some bodybuilders out there that are kind of obtaining ditrophenol for kind of obtaining ditrophenol for kind of obtaining ditrophenol for cutting for um you know uh for cutting for um you know uh for cutting for um you know uh for competitions and things like that. It's competitions and things like that. It's competitions and things like that. It's still available. Uh but yeah, it's it's still available. Uh but yeah, it's it's still available. Uh but yeah, it's it's not safe. What about exercise andor like not safe. What about exercise andor like not safe. What about exercise andor like nutrition timing? like what is the nutrition timing? like what is the nutrition timing? like what is the difference between kind of grazing difference between kind of grazing difference between kind of grazing lightly throughout the day versus you lightly throughout the day versus you lightly throughout the day versus you know an intermittent fast you know it know an intermittent fast you know it know an intermittent fast you know it would seem to me that these things would would seem to me that these things would would seem to me that these things would you both of these things would have a you both of these things would have a you both of these things would have a significant impact on on metabolism significant impact on on metabolism significant impact on on metabolism would they not would they not would they not >> so I think we have to separate out some >> so I think we have to separate out some >> so I think we have to separate out some of the things that we talk about in of the things that we talk about in of the things that we talk about in terms of like resting metabolism that's terms of like resting metabolism that's terms of like resting metabolism that's kind of things that you're doing when kind of things that you're doing when kind of things that you're doing when you're not eating anything and you're you're not eating anything and you're you're not eating anything and you're not moving around which is one of the not moving around which is one of the not moving around which is one of the things that's what we were primarily things that's what we were primarily things that's what we were primarily measuring in the biggest losers and when measuring in the biggest losers and when measuring in the biggest losers and when we were talking about metabolic slowing we were talking about metabolic slowing we were talking about metabolic slowing that's Anel Keys was talking about in in that's Anel Keys was talking about in in that's Anel Keys was talking about in in the Minnesota starvation folks the kind the Minnesota starvation folks the kind the Minnesota starvation folks the kind of sort of basil metabolic rate. Yeah. of sort of basil metabolic rate. Yeah. of sort of basil metabolic rate. Yeah. If there is an effect of exercise and If there is an effect of exercise and If there is an effect of exercise and those things it it tends to wash away those things it it tends to wash away those things it it tends to wash away after like there's a period like hours after like there's a period like hours after like there's a period like hours many hours after exercise where it seems many hours after exercise where it seems many hours after exercise where it seems like there is some residual response but like there is some residual response but like there is some residual response but that seems to go away but the exercise that seems to go away but the exercise that seems to go away but the exercise >> you'll go back to that same you know >> you'll go back to that same you know >> you'll go back to that same you know basal rate. basal rate. basal rate. >> Yeah. Yeah. But there is a period like >> Yeah. Yeah. But there is a period like >> Yeah. Yeah. But there is a period like if Yeah. after you feel like you've like if Yeah. after you feel like you've like if Yeah. after you feel like you've like calmed down from your exercise. If I was calmed down from your exercise. If I was calmed down from your exercise. If I was to measure your your resting metabolic to measure your your resting metabolic to measure your your resting metabolic rate, it would indeed be higher. But rate, it would indeed be higher. But rate, it would indeed be higher. But we're not talking for days, we're we're not talking for days, we're we're not talking for days, we're talking hours after exercise. But the of talking hours after exercise. But the of talking hours after exercise. But the of course there's the energy expenditure of course there's the energy expenditure of course there's the energy expenditure of exercise, right? Which is also part of exercise, right? Which is also part of exercise, right? Which is also part of the the total calories that you're the the total calories that you're the the total calories that you're burning. Um and obviously that goes up. burning. Um and obviously that goes up. burning. Um and obviously that goes up. There's some controversy about how much There's some controversy about how much There's some controversy about how much compensation in other aspects of your compensation in other aspects of your compensation in other aspects of your your physical activity, like if you go your physical activity, like if you go your physical activity, like if you go for a run, do you not fidget as much for a run, do you not fidget as much for a run, do you not fidget as much afterwards or something like that? afterwards or something like that? afterwards or something like that? What's what degree of compensation is What's what degree of compensation is What's what degree of compensation is there? And then there's even there? And then there's even there? And then there's even compensation that could be potentially compensation that could be potentially compensation that could be potentially theorized that may have been what we saw theorized that may have been what we saw theorized that may have been what we saw in the Biggest Loser folks, right? They in the Biggest Loser folks, right? They in the Biggest Loser folks, right? They had now appreciably increased their had now appreciably increased their had now appreciably increased their physical activity energy expenditures. physical activity energy expenditures. physical activity energy expenditures. Is that one of the reasons why we saw Is that one of the reasons why we saw Is that one of the reasons why we saw the reduction in resting metabolic rate? the reduction in resting metabolic rate? the reduction in resting metabolic rate? It's it was certainly cor those two It's it was certainly cor those two It's it was certainly cor those two things were correlated with each other. things were correlated with each other. things were correlated with each other. But again, I don't think that we have But again, I don't think that we have But again, I don't think that we have good evidence of that. good evidence of that. good evidence of that. >> But that is one obvious thing that you >> But that is one obvious thing that you >> But that is one obvious thing that you can do to increase your overall calorie can do to increase your overall calorie can do to increase your overall calorie expenditure is to increase your physical expenditure is to increase your physical expenditure is to increase your physical activity. Um to what degree some people activity. Um to what degree some people activity. Um to what degree some people compensate for that with other parts of compensate for that with other parts of compensate for that with other parts of their energy budget, I think is is their energy budget, I think is is their energy budget, I think is is something that there's some debate about something that there's some debate about something that there's some debate about right now. And you can't decouple that right now. And you can't decouple that right now. And you can't decouple that from increases in appetite as a from increases in appetite as a from increases in appetite as a consequence of more exercise or you know consequence of more exercise or you know consequence of more exercise or you know whatever kind of like diet you're on whatever kind of like diet you're on whatever kind of like diet you're on that might have that whiplash effect on that might have that whiplash effect on that might have that whiplash effect on appetite increase later appetite increase later appetite increase later >> right and I mean in fact it's it's >> right and I mean in fact it's it's >> right and I mean in fact it's it's really interesting that there is this really interesting that there is this really interesting that there is this coupling right because we do regulate coupling right because we do regulate coupling right because we do regulate our body weight and appetite and our body weight and appetite and our body weight and appetite and expenditure are these coupled processes expenditure are these coupled processes expenditure are these coupled processes that are that that somehow influence that are that that somehow influence that are that that somehow influence each other you know there's a lot of each other you know there's a lot of each other you know there's a lot of talk about cold plunges or or actually talk about cold plunges or or actually talk about cold plunges or or actually spending a lot of time in in cold water spending a lot of time in in cold water spending a lot of time in in cold water and things like that. Um, interestingly, and things like that. Um, interestingly, and things like that. Um, interestingly, the few studies that have done cold the few studies that have done cold the few studies that have done cold exposure um in these kind of respiratory exposure um in these kind of respiratory exposure um in these kind of respiratory chambers where we can measure oxygen chambers where we can measure oxygen chambers where we can measure oxygen consumption, carbon dioxide production, consumption, carbon dioxide production, consumption, carbon dioxide production, um, those folks, yes, they have an um, those folks, yes, they have an um, those folks, yes, they have an increase in calorie expenditure. Uh, increase in calorie expenditure. Uh, increase in calorie expenditure. Uh, some of it is from shivering, some of it some of it is from shivering, some of it some of it is from shivering, some of it is from brown atapost tissue, this brown is from brown atapost tissue, this brown is from brown atapost tissue, this brown fat that's specifically, uh, evolved to fat that's specifically, uh, evolved to fat that's specifically, uh, evolved to kind of heat us up. It's more prevalent kind of heat us up. It's more prevalent kind of heat us up. It's more prevalent in leaner people and less prevalent in in leaner people and less prevalent in in leaner people and less prevalent in people with obesity. Uh certainly people with obesity. Uh certainly people with obesity. Uh certainly younger people, more young people have younger people, more young people have younger people, more young people have it than um the most that you'll ever it than um the most that you'll ever it than um the most that you'll ever have is as as a baby. But it turns out have is as as a baby. But it turns out have is as as a baby. But it turns out that when you do those kinds of that when you do those kinds of that when you do those kinds of exposures and you can increase the total exposures and you can increase the total exposures and you can increase the total number of calories that people are number of calories that people are number of calories that people are burning um and you let them eat whatever burning um and you let them eat whatever burning um and you let them eat whatever they want, they actually overeat the they want, they actually overeat the they want, they actually overeat the calories. So then they will happily calories. So then they will happily calories. So then they will happily compensate for those increased calories compensate for those increased calories compensate for those increased calories from expenditure. from expenditure. from expenditure. >> The caloric expenditure uh in that >> The caloric expenditure uh in that >> The caloric expenditure uh in that context is pretty dimminimous though. context is pretty dimminimous though. context is pretty dimminimous though. Also, Also, Also, >> yeah, it depends how you do it, right? I >> yeah, it depends how you do it, right? I >> yeah, it depends how you do it, right? I mean, if you actually induce shivering, mean, if you actually induce shivering, mean, if you actually induce shivering, it can be pretty darn high. I mean, it's it can be pretty darn high. I mean, it's it can be pretty darn high. I mean, it's not a comfortable feeling by any stretch not a comfortable feeling by any stretch not a comfortable feeling by any stretch of the imagination. So, there's like the of the imagination. So, there's like the of the imagination. So, there's like the people um or do studies where they kind people um or do studies where they kind people um or do studies where they kind of try to ramp up the temperature slowly of try to ramp up the temperature slowly of try to ramp up the temperature slowly and try to get you into a a range where and try to get you into a a range where and try to get you into a a range where you're experiencing the non-shivering you're experiencing the non-shivering you're experiencing the non-shivering thermogenesis. And yeah, that tends to thermogenesis. And yeah, that tends to thermogenesis. And yeah, that tends to be pretty minimal, but once you get to be pretty minimal, but once you get to be pretty minimal, but once you get to the shivering mode, yeah, your energy the shivering mode, yeah, your energy the shivering mode, yeah, your energy expenditure goes up quite a lot. So yes, expenditure goes up quite a lot. So yes, expenditure goes up quite a lot. So yes, also turns out to be pretty darn also turns out to be pretty darn also turns out to be pretty darn uncomfortable to do that for a uncomfortable to do that for a uncomfortable to do that for a meaningful period of time. Sure, short meaningful period of time. Sure, short meaningful period of time. Sure, short period of time. And yeah, you look at period of time. And yeah, you look at period of time. And yeah, you look at the the rate of energy expenditure is the the rate of energy expenditure is the the rate of energy expenditure is very high, but you're only doing it for very high, but you're only doing it for very high, but you're only doing it for a short period of time. So it's not a short period of time. So it's not a short period of time. So it's not really a kind of a weight loss tool really a kind of a weight loss tool really a kind of a weight loss tool because over the course of the day, because over the course of the day, because over the course of the day, well, there's many many more hours of well, there's many many more hours of well, there's many many more hours of the day. Um you can compensate it for it the day. Um you can compensate it for it the day. Um you can compensate it for it by eating more. You can compensate for by eating more. You can compensate for by eating more. You can compensate for it by um changing other parts of your it by um changing other parts of your it by um changing other parts of your energy budget. Um, so it's not exactly energy budget. Um, so it's not exactly energy budget. Um, so it's not exactly clear, but I think that one of the ways clear, but I think that one of the ways clear, but I think that one of the ways that I thought was most interesting to that I thought was most interesting to that I thought was most interesting to kind of look at this coupling between kind of look at this coupling between kind of look at this coupling between calorie output and appetite was a study calorie output and appetite was a study calorie output and appetite was a study that my colleagues uh did when they were that my colleagues uh did when they were that my colleagues uh did when they were testing a a a new type 2 diabetes drug testing a a a new type 2 diabetes drug testing a a a new type 2 diabetes drug um that essentially um works on the um that essentially um works on the um that essentially um works on the kidneys and increases output of glucose. kidneys and increases output of glucose. kidneys and increases output of glucose. And it does and they did this placebo And it does and they did this placebo And it does and they did this placebo control trial in people with type two control trial in people with type two control trial in people with type two diabetes and um they're able to kind of diabetes and um they're able to kind of diabetes and um they're able to kind of have uh folks many hundreds of calories have uh folks many hundreds of calories have uh folks many hundreds of calories are being spilled in the urine of these are being spilled in the urine of these are being spilled in the urine of these folks and of course they don't know it folks and of course they don't know it folks and of course they don't know it unless they're tasting their urine to unless they're tasting their urine to unless they're tasting their urine to see this getting sweeter. I don't think see this getting sweeter. I don't think see this getting sweeter. I don't think that's a common phenomena. So there's that's a common phenomena. So there's that's a common phenomena. So there's placebo group and this folks that are placebo group and this folks that are placebo group and this folks that are randomized to this drug that's spilling randomized to this drug that's spilling randomized to this drug that's spilling excess calories in the urine. And if you excess calories in the urine. And if you excess calories in the urine. And if you actually look to see what happens, yeah, actually look to see what happens, yeah, actually look to see what happens, yeah, they lose weight, but they don't lose they lose weight, but they don't lose they lose weight, but they don't lose anywhere near as much weight as you anywhere near as much weight as you anywhere near as much weight as you would expect just based on the calories would expect just based on the calories would expect just based on the calories that were spilled in their urine. And so that were spilled in their urine. And so that were spilled in their urine. And so we did some work with with um with the we did some work with with um with the we did some work with with um with the folks at this drug company to figure folks at this drug company to figure folks at this drug company to figure out, well, how much were they actually out, well, how much were they actually out, well, how much were they actually compensating for? We're not talking compensating for? We're not talking compensating for? We're not talking about days, we're talking about about days, we're talking about about days, we're talking about happening over months, over the course happening over months, over the course happening over months, over the course of a year. they eventually almost of a year. they eventually almost of a year. they eventually almost completely compensate for the lost completely compensate for the lost completely compensate for the lost calories by increasing their calorie calories by increasing their calorie calories by increasing their calorie intake above baseline by several hundred intake above baseline by several hundred intake above baseline by several hundred calories per day so that they plateau at calories per day so that they plateau at calories per day so that they plateau at a lower weight but it's only about four a lower weight but it's only about four a lower weight but it's only about four or 5 kg lower than they were to begin or 5 kg lower than they were to begin or 5 kg lower than they were to begin with if you'd actually just if they just with if you'd actually just if they just with if you'd actually just if they just kept eating the same amount um they kept eating the same amount um they kept eating the same amount um they would have lost you know triple that would have lost you know triple that would have lost you know triple that amount of weight. amount of weight. amount of weight. >> Yeah. So what do you make of that? So it >> Yeah. So what do you make of that? So it >> Yeah. So what do you make of that? So it tells me that there's some coupling tells me that there's some coupling tells me that there's some coupling between calorie expenditure or loss of between calorie expenditure or loss of between calorie expenditure or loss of calories from the body um in terms of calories from the body um in terms of calories from the body um in terms of either you're peeing them out or you're either you're peeing them out or you're either you're peeing them out or you're expending them through through physical expending them through through physical expending them through through physical activity or exercise or resting activity or exercise or resting activity or exercise or resting metabolic rate. Um and the weight change metabolic rate. Um and the weight change metabolic rate. Um and the weight change that is occurring is somehow a feedback that is occurring is somehow a feedback that is occurring is somehow a feedback system to the brain to very gradually system to the brain to very gradually system to the brain to very gradually and subtly over many many days and and subtly over many many days and and subtly over many many days and months shift upwards the number of months shift upwards the number of months shift upwards the number of calories that people are eating. And we calories that people are eating. And we calories that people are eating. And we tried to quantify that and and relate it tried to quantify that and and relate it tried to quantify that and and relate it to what's the degree of overall calorie to what's the degree of overall calorie to what's the degree of overall calorie slowdown that people experience when slowdown that people experience when slowdown that people experience when they lose weight. And it turns out to be they lose weight. And it turns out to be they lose weight. And it turns out to be a much stronger effect than the slowdown a much stronger effect than the slowdown a much stronger effect than the slowdown of calorie expenditure. So if you kind of calorie expenditure. So if you kind of calorie expenditure. So if you kind of quantify it for every kilogram of of quantify it for every kilogram of of quantify it for every kilogram of weight that you lose um your calorie weight that you lose um your calorie weight that you lose um your calorie expenditure goes down by about 25 expenditure goes down by about 25 expenditure goes down by about 25 calories per day. So you lose, you know, calories per day. So you lose, you know, calories per day. So you lose, you know, 10 kilos, 22 lb, you'll be burning about 10 kilos, 22 lb, you'll be burning about 10 kilos, 22 lb, you'll be burning about 250 calories per day lower than you were 250 calories per day lower than you were 250 calories per day lower than you were before you'd lost that weight. Appetite before you'd lost that weight. Appetite before you'd lost that weight. Appetite seems to go up by about 95 calories per seems to go up by about 95 calories per seems to go up by about 95 calories per day. day. day. >> So it's going to outpace that. >> So it's going to outpace that. >> So it's going to outpace that. >> Yeah. And so the plateaus in weight that >> Yeah. And so the plateaus in weight that >> Yeah. And so the plateaus in weight that we see when people kind of experience um we see when people kind of experience um we see when people kind of experience um that in in concert with a lifestyle that in in concert with a lifestyle that in in concert with a lifestyle change, for example, you cut calories in change, for example, you cut calories in change, for example, you cut calories in people's diets. Part of that plateau is people's diets. Part of that plateau is people's diets. Part of that plateau is because of the metabolic slowing, the because of the metabolic slowing, the because of the metabolic slowing, the smaller body, burning fewer calories, smaller body, burning fewer calories, smaller body, burning fewer calories, but the vast majority of it is because but the vast majority of it is because but the vast majority of it is because appetite has gone up to compensate. And appetite has gone up to compensate. And appetite has gone up to compensate. And people don't report that, right? They people don't report that, right? They people don't report that, right? They actually don't report their food intake actually don't report their food intake actually don't report their food intake increasing. Like if you ask them to kind increasing. Like if you ask them to kind increasing. Like if you ask them to kind of do a 24-hour recall of what are you of do a 24-hour recall of what are you of do a 24-hour recall of what are you eating in the first month of your diet eating in the first month of your diet eating in the first month of your diet versus at 12 months after you've stopped versus at 12 months after you've stopped versus at 12 months after you've stopped losing weight, those numbers are losing weight, those numbers are losing weight, those numbers are actually quite similar. But by all actually quite similar. But by all actually quite similar. But by all objective measures, their calorie intake objective measures, their calorie intake objective measures, their calorie intake has climbed substantially. Uh maybe not has climbed substantially. Uh maybe not has climbed substantially. Uh maybe not quite up to baseline, but it's climbed quite up to baseline, but it's climbed quite up to baseline, but it's climbed substantially. And the way I like to substantially. And the way I like to substantially. And the way I like to think about it is that these folks are think about it is that these folks are think about it is that these folks are reporting not their absolute number of reporting not their absolute number of reporting not their absolute number of calories. They're reporting how hard calories. They're reporting how hard calories. They're reporting how hard they're still working to to maintain they're still working to to maintain they're still working to to maintain that lifestyle intervention and that that lifestyle intervention and that that lifestyle intervention and that degree of effort that they're putting degree of effort that they're putting degree of effort that they're putting in. in. in. >> And I think that is probably pretty >> And I think that is probably pretty >> And I think that is probably pretty consistent. It's just that they're consistent. It's just that they're consistent. It's just that they're fighting a greater and greater battle fighting a greater and greater battle fighting a greater and greater battle the more weight that they lose. they're the more weight that they lose. they're the more weight that they lose. they're they're basically the the weight loss they're basically the the weight loss they're basically the the weight loss per se is is causing their appetite to per se is is causing their appetite to per se is is causing their appetite to increase. It's causing their energy increase. It's causing their energy increase. It's causing their energy expenditure to go down. And um despite expenditure to go down. And um despite expenditure to go down. And um despite that constant effort that they're that constant effort that they're that constant effort that they're putting in, they finally equalized. The putting in, they finally equalized. The putting in, they finally equalized. The biology has equalized whatever the biology has equalized whatever the biology has equalized whatever the effort was that they put in. And so now effort was that they put in. And so now effort was that they put in. And so now weight plateaus and I think many people weight plateaus and I think many people weight plateaus and I think many people get the experience of well what the heck get the experience of well what the heck get the experience of well what the heck am I putting in all this effort? am I putting in all this effort? am I putting in all this effort? >> Yeah. I mean, we're painting we're >> Yeah. I mean, we're painting we're >> Yeah. I mean, we're painting we're painting sort of a bleak, you know, painting sort of a bleak, you know, painting sort of a bleak, you know, disempowering picture here. It's almost disempowering picture here. It's almost disempowering picture here. It's almost as if, you know, the body has this as if, you know, the body has this as if, you know, the body has this homeostatic set point and no matter what homeostatic set point and no matter what homeostatic set point and no matter what we do to try to find a workaround, it we do to try to find a workaround, it we do to try to find a workaround, it will it has a crafty way of making sure will it has a crafty way of making sure will it has a crafty way of making sure that it returns to that homeostatic that it returns to that homeostatic that it returns to that homeostatic point where point where point where >> but doesn't fully return, right? That's >> but doesn't fully return, right? That's >> but doesn't fully return, right? That's I think that's the point is that you I think that's the point is that you I think that's the point is that you people will lose weight and they'll keep people will lose weight and they'll keep people will lose weight and they'll keep it off as long as they continue that it off as long as they continue that it off as long as they continue that level of effort. Now, whether or not level of effort. Now, whether or not level of effort. Now, whether or not they're satisfied with that amount of of they're satisfied with that amount of of they're satisfied with that amount of of weight loss, whether or not it's weight loss, whether or not it's weight loss, whether or not it's meaningful for them um from a meaningful for them um from a meaningful for them um from a psychological perspective, whether or psychological perspective, whether or psychological perspective, whether or not it's enough weight loss to be not it's enough weight loss to be not it's enough weight loss to be clinically meaningful, I think those are clinically meaningful, I think those are clinically meaningful, I think those are all important questions. um and whether all important questions. um and whether all important questions. um and whether or not that that actually effort feels or not that that actually effort feels or not that that actually effort feels effortful anymore in terms of have they effortful anymore in terms of have they effortful anymore in terms of have they been able to kind of um engage in habits been able to kind of um engage in habits been able to kind of um engage in habits and work those lifestyle changes into and work those lifestyle changes into and work those lifestyle changes into their overall lifestyle um in a way that their overall lifestyle um in a way that their overall lifestyle um in a way that they can find sustainable. And that's they can find sustainable. And that's they can find sustainable. And that's been like the the key trick is that, you been like the the key trick is that, you been like the the key trick is that, you know, every every New Year's people talk know, every every New Year's people talk know, every every New Year's people talk about losing weight. And I always say, about losing weight. And I always say, about losing weight. And I always say, well, you know, whatever you're going to well, you know, whatever you're going to well, you know, whatever you're going to do, make sure that you can keep that as do, make sure that you can keep that as do, make sure that you can keep that as part of your life because otherwise, as part of your life because otherwise, as part of your life because otherwise, as soon as you stop doing it, the weight is soon as you stop doing it, the weight is soon as you stop doing it, the weight is probably going to increase. probably going to increase. probably going to increase. >> And so, yeah, you're right. If people >> And so, yeah, you're right. If people >> And so, yeah, you're right. If people are white knuckling it and saying, you are white knuckling it and saying, you are white knuckling it and saying, you know, I'm just going to do this and and know, I'm just going to do this and and know, I'm just going to do this and and it's a temporary thing and I'm going to it's a temporary thing and I'm going to it's a temporary thing and I'm going to get to my goal weight and then I can get to my goal weight and then I can get to my goal weight and then I can relax. It's like, yeah, that's not the relax. It's like, yeah, that's not the relax. It's like, yeah, that's not the way it works. We all we all know how way it works. We all we all know how way it works. We all we all know how that goes. Good that goes. Good that goes. Good >> job. Right. >> job. Right. >> job. Right. >> We're brought to you today by Seed. I >> We're brought to you today by Seed. I >> We're brought to you today by Seed. I have hosted so many microbiome experts have hosted so many microbiome experts have hosted so many microbiome experts on the show over the years. And the more on the show over the years. And the more on the show over the years. And the more I learn about this very complex aspect I learn about this very complex aspect I learn about this very complex aspect of our physiology, the more fascinating of our physiology, the more fascinating of our physiology, the more fascinating it becomes to me. But there is one thing it becomes to me. But there is one thing it becomes to me. But there is one thing that is simple. A happy gut is the that is simple. A happy gut is the that is simple. A happy gut is the foundation for a happy body and a happy foundation for a happy body and a happy foundation for a happy body and a happy life. And to get there requires care. It life. And to get there requires care. It life. And to get there requires care. It requires intention. It requires a daily requires intention. It requires a daily requires intention. It requires a daily gut healthpromoting ritual that for me gut healthpromoting ritual that for me gut healthpromoting ritual that for me begins with seeds DSO1 begins with seeds DSO1 begins with seeds DSO1 twoin-one probiotic and prebiotic twoin-one probiotic and prebiotic twoin-one probiotic and prebiotic formulated with 24 strains that are formulated with 24 strains that are formulated with 24 strains that are clinically studied and proven to survive clinically studied and proven to survive clinically studied and proven to survive the digestive journey. It's been shown the digestive journey. It's been shown the digestive journey. It's been shown to increase good gut bacteria by 400%. to increase good gut bacteria by 400%. to increase good gut bacteria by 400%. But it goes beyond just the gut. TSO1 But it goes beyond just the gut. TSO1 But it goes beyond just the gut. TSO1 supports your whole body. It's supports your whole body. It's supports your whole body. It's formulated to reduce abdominal bloating formulated to reduce abdominal bloating formulated to reduce abdominal bloating and intermittent constipation in as and intermittent constipation in as and intermittent constipation in as little as two weeks. And I can attest to little as two weeks. And I can attest to little as two weeks. And I can attest to noticing personal improvements in my noticing personal improvements in my noticing personal improvements in my digestion, in my energy levels, and digestion, in my energy levels, and digestion, in my energy levels, and overall gut comfort. So go to overall gut comfort. So go to overall gut comfort. So go to seed.com/rich and use the code ritual 20 seed.com/rich and use the code ritual 20 seed.com/rich and use the code ritual 20 for 20% off your first month of DSO1. This is where we're sort of tiptoeing up This is where we're sort of tiptoeing up to the point where your findings are are to the point where your findings are are to the point where your findings are are brushing up against a few, you know, brushing up against a few, you know, brushing up against a few, you know, pieces of conventional wisdom. Um, one pieces of conventional wisdom. Um, one pieces of conventional wisdom. Um, one of which is this idea of of calories in, of which is this idea of of calories in, of which is this idea of of calories in, calories out, right? And for a very long calories out, right? And for a very long calories out, right? And for a very long period of time, this was believed to be, period of time, this was believed to be, period of time, this was believed to be, you know, basically sacrosanked. then it you know, basically sacrosanked. then it you know, basically sacrosanked. then it was challenged and now you've you've was challenged and now you've you've was challenged and now you've you've kind of kind of kind of nuanced it a little bit to bring it back nuanced it a little bit to bring it back nuanced it a little bit to bring it back into not vogue but like maybe perhaps into not vogue but like maybe perhaps into not vogue but like maybe perhaps it's it's best in proper context. it's it's best in proper context. it's it's best in proper context. >> Yeah. So I think different people mean >> Yeah. So I think different people mean >> Yeah. So I think different people mean different things when they say calories different things when they say calories different things when they say calories in calories out and and it it's helpful in calories out and and it it's helpful in calories out and and it it's helpful to kind of know what are we talking to kind of know what are we talking to kind of know what are we talking about when we say this. So for example, about when we say this. So for example, about when we say this. So for example, there there are some folks who say uh there there are some folks who say uh there there are some folks who say uh the only thing that matters uh when it the only thing that matters uh when it the only thing that matters uh when it comes to body fat loss. So we have to comes to body fat loss. So we have to comes to body fat loss. So we have to focus on what is the outcome that we're focus on what is the outcome that we're focus on what is the outcome that we're interested in is the discrepancy between interested in is the discrepancy between interested in is the discrepancy between calorie intake and calorie expenditure. calorie intake and calorie expenditure. calorie intake and calorie expenditure. And that's an interesting question and And that's an interesting question and And that's an interesting question and uh and it's not necessarily the case uh and it's not necessarily the case uh and it's not necessarily the case that uh that would be. So in other that uh that would be. So in other that uh that would be. So in other words, if if you could change the type words, if if you could change the type words, if if you could change the type of calories. So the calories we're of calories. So the calories we're of calories. So the calories we're talking about in food are the calories talking about in food are the calories talking about in food are the calories that you get from oxidizing one of the that you get from oxidizing one of the that you get from oxidizing one of the three macronutrients or a multiple three macronutrients or a multiple three macronutrients or a multiple mixture of macronutrients, carbohydrate, mixture of macronutrients, carbohydrate, mixture of macronutrients, carbohydrate, fat, and protein. And it could be that fat, and protein. And it could be that fat, and protein. And it could be that calorie expenditure depends very calorie expenditure depends very calorie expenditure depends very sensitively on what mixture of nutrients sensitively on what mixture of nutrients sensitively on what mixture of nutrients you are provided with, right? And when you are provided with, right? And when you are provided with, right? And when people were first studying this um in people were first studying this um in people were first studying this um in dogs back in the 18 19th century um what dogs back in the 18 19th century um what dogs back in the 18 19th century um what they were doing was very interesting they were doing was very interesting they were doing was very interesting experiments where they were doing all experiments where they were doing all experiments where they were doing all these respiratory measurements in dogs. these respiratory measurements in dogs. these respiratory measurements in dogs. They were starving them at first to see They were starving them at first to see They were starving them at first to see how much body fat they would lose and how much body fat they would lose and how much body fat they would lose and then they'd give them back like sugar. then they'd give them back like sugar. then they'd give them back like sugar. The only thing that the dog gets is The only thing that the dog gets is The only thing that the dog gets is sugar and they calculate how much did sugar and they calculate how much did sugar and they calculate how much did body fat loss slow and they give them body fat loss slow and they give them body fat loss slow and they give them back fat, pure fat, pure sugar. And it back fat, pure fat, pure sugar. And it back fat, pure fat, pure sugar. And it turned out there was very different turned out there was very different turned out there was very different amounts of fat and sugar that were amounts of fat and sugar that were amounts of fat and sugar that were required to to equally slow the loss of required to to equally slow the loss of required to to equally slow the loss of fat in a starving dog. And this was a fat in a starving dog. And this was a fat in a starving dog. And this was a mystery for a long time. It's like why mystery for a long time. It's like why mystery for a long time. It's like why is it you had to give um you know more is it you had to give um you know more is it you had to give um you know more than double the amount of sugar to stop than double the amount of sugar to stop than double the amount of sugar to stop fat loss slowing as as fat. And it fat loss slowing as as fat. And it fat loss slowing as as fat. And it wasn't until um this guy named uh Max wasn't until um this guy named uh Max wasn't until um this guy named uh Max Rubiner uh decided to start to think Rubiner uh decided to start to think Rubiner uh decided to start to think about things in terms of well how many about things in terms of well how many about things in terms of well how many calories are in sugar and fat? And so calories are in sugar and fat? And so calories are in sugar and fat? And so per unit mass, it turns out that the the per unit mass, it turns out that the the per unit mass, it turns out that the the sugar has less than half the calories of sugar has less than half the calories of sugar has less than half the calories of fat. And it turned out that the loss of fat. And it turned out that the loss of fat. And it turned out that the loss of body fat in the dog wasn't matching how body fat in the dog wasn't matching how body fat in the dog wasn't matching how many grams of sugar or fat you were many grams of sugar or fat you were many grams of sugar or fat you were giving. It turned out how many calories giving. It turned out how many calories giving. It turned out how many calories of sugar or fat that you were giving of sugar or fat that you were giving of sugar or fat that you were giving made the big difference. And the made the big difference. And the made the big difference. And the implication was that calories a calorie implication was that calories a calorie implication was that calories a calorie when it comes to body fat loss. But the when it comes to body fat loss. But the when it comes to body fat loss. But the precision of those measurements was back precision of those measurements was back precision of those measurements was back from the, you know, the the the 19th from the, you know, the the the 19th from the, you know, the the the 19th century. And um it also didn't century. And um it also didn't century. And um it also didn't necessarily follow that the that it necessarily follow that the that it necessarily follow that the that it couldn't be that there was a some couldn't be that there was a some couldn't be that there was a some precise combination of carbohydrates and precise combination of carbohydrates and precise combination of carbohydrates and fats that could cause calorie fats that could cause calorie fats that could cause calorie expenditure to vary. And if that expenditure to vary. And if that expenditure to vary. And if that happened, then you could still not happened, then you could still not happened, then you could still not violate any laws of physics, but you violate any laws of physics, but you violate any laws of physics, but you could have it so that uh and this is could have it so that uh and this is could have it so that uh and this is what Atkins claimed, right? He claimed what Atkins claimed, right? He claimed what Atkins claimed, right? He claimed that if you cut carbs enough in the that if you cut carbs enough in the that if you cut carbs enough in the diet, um you're you would have a diet, um you're you would have a diet, um you're you would have a metabolic advantage, he called it, which metabolic advantage, he called it, which metabolic advantage, he called it, which was essentially saying that the body was was essentially saying that the body was was essentially saying that the body was inefficient at running on fat and would inefficient at running on fat and would inefficient at running on fat and would have to burn more calories as a result. have to burn more calories as a result. have to burn more calories as a result. Um, and so you could have a situation Um, and so you could have a situation Um, and so you could have a situation where the number of calories that you where the number of calories that you where the number of calories that you were eating, uh, could be maybe even the were eating, uh, could be maybe even the were eating, uh, could be maybe even the same or go up. He called it the high same or go up. He called it the high same or go up. He called it the high calorie way to stay thin forever based calorie way to stay thin forever based calorie way to stay thin forever based on anecdotal reports from his his on anecdotal reports from his his on anecdotal reports from his his patients. Like, I'm I'm not eating any patients. Like, I'm I'm not eating any patients. Like, I'm I'm not eating any carbs, but I'm eating way more calories carbs, but I'm eating way more calories carbs, but I'm eating way more calories than I used to, and I'm still losing all than I used to, and I'm still losing all than I used to, and I'm still losing all this weight and body fat. Well, the only this weight and body fat. Well, the only this weight and body fat. Well, the only way to make that make sense is to have way to make that make sense is to have way to make that make sense is to have calorie expenditure go up. So again, we calorie expenditure go up. So again, we calorie expenditure go up. So again, we think of calories in, calories out as think of calories in, calories out as think of calories in, calories out as these immutable things that we have these immutable things that we have these immutable things that we have total control over, right? And and total control over, right? And and total control over, right? And and they're interacting with each other and they're interacting with each other and they're interacting with each other and they may depend on uh the macronutrient they may depend on uh the macronutrient they may depend on uh the macronutrient distributions and things like that. And distributions and things like that. And distributions and things like that. And those are all perfectly legitimate those are all perfectly legitimate those are all perfectly legitimate questions to test. And so those were the questions to test. And so those were the questions to test. And so those were the kinds of studies that we were doing for kinds of studies that we were doing for kinds of studies that we were doing for quite some time was bringing people in quite some time was bringing people in quite some time was bringing people in uh to a metabolic ward where they lived uh to a metabolic ward where they lived uh to a metabolic ward where they lived with us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. with us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. with us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. And we would manipulate very precisely And we would manipulate very precisely And we would manipulate very precisely how much carbs people were eating, how how much carbs people were eating, how how much carbs people were eating, how much fat that they were eating and much fat that they were eating and much fat that they were eating and measuring with the most precise methods measuring with the most precise methods measuring with the most precise methods that we had, how many calories were that we had, how many calories were that we had, how many calories were being burned, how much uh fat oxidation being burned, how much uh fat oxidation being burned, how much uh fat oxidation was there, how much carbohydrate was there, how much carbohydrate was there, how much carbohydrate oxidation was there, how much was body oxidation was there, how much was body oxidation was there, how much was body fat changing, trying to see if what fat changing, trying to see if what fat changing, trying to see if what Rubener had suggested back in the 19th Rubener had suggested back in the 19th Rubener had suggested back in the 19th century was true in dogs was also true century was true in dogs was also true century was true in dogs was also true in humans. And we devised the experiment in humans. And we devised the experiment in humans. And we devised the experiment based on some of the mathematical based on some of the mathematical based on some of the mathematical modeling that I had been uh developing modeling that I had been uh developing modeling that I had been uh developing at when I first started my career at at at when I first started my career at at at when I first started my career at at the NIH. And um the first study that we the NIH. And um the first study that we the NIH. And um the first study that we did was actually designed in a kind of did was actually designed in a kind of did was actually designed in a kind of an interesting way because we thought an interesting way because we thought an interesting way because we thought that we could show that Ruber while that we could show that Ruber while that we could show that Ruber while maybe close to being right, it doesn't maybe close to being right, it doesn't maybe close to being right, it doesn't have to be perfect, right? That there have to be perfect, right? That there have to be perfect, right? That there could be a situation where he could see could be a situation where he could see could be a situation where he could see a discrepancy. And so we designed this a discrepancy. And so we designed this a discrepancy. And so we designed this study to test that. And in fact, we did study to test that. And in fact, we did study to test that. And in fact, we did see a discrepancy, clinically see a discrepancy, clinically see a discrepancy, clinically meaningless discrepancy, by the way. meaningless discrepancy, by the way. meaningless discrepancy, by the way. It's like absolutely it doesn't make a a It's like absolutely it doesn't make a a It's like absolutely it doesn't make a a bit of difference when it comes to bit of difference when it comes to bit of difference when it comes to practical considerations for losing body practical considerations for losing body practical considerations for losing body fat. But we saw a discrepancy such that fat. But we saw a discrepancy such that fat. But we saw a discrepancy such that when the same people with obesity um had when the same people with obesity um had when the same people with obesity um had um a 30% restriction in calories coming um a 30% restriction in calories coming um a 30% restriction in calories coming only from fat versus in another time, only from fat versus in another time, only from fat versus in another time, the same folks only from carbs. when the same folks only from carbs. when the same folks only from carbs. when they reduced the amount of calories they reduced the amount of calories they reduced the amount of calories coming in from body fat, they lost a coming in from body fat, they lost a coming in from body fat, they lost a tiny bit more body fat than they did tiny bit more body fat than they did tiny bit more body fat than they did when the same people had the same number when the same people had the same number when the same people had the same number of calories restricted from carbs, of calories restricted from carbs, of calories restricted from carbs, suggesting that a calorie wasn't exactly suggesting that a calorie wasn't exactly suggesting that a calorie wasn't exactly a calorie, but the difference was so a calorie, but the difference was so a calorie, but the difference was so minuscule minuscule minuscule >> that clinically it's totally >> that clinically it's totally >> that clinically it's totally meaningless. Um but you know as a meaningless. Um but you know as a meaningless. Um but you know as a background in theoretical physics you background in theoretical physics you background in theoretical physics you know I think that even these kind of know I think that even these kind of know I think that even these kind of principles principles principles >> yeah if that is like a a hard and fast >> yeah if that is like a a hard and fast >> yeah if that is like a a hard and fast principle any deviation at all is worthy principle any deviation at all is worthy principle any deviation at all is worthy of investigation. of investigation. of investigation. >> Exactly. And so so that's why I was >> Exactly. And so so that's why I was >> Exactly. And so so that's why I was excited by that result. Right. And and excited by that result. Right. And and excited by that result. Right. And and kind of shocked when I saw like these kind of shocked when I saw like these kind of shocked when I saw like these competing diet tribes take that same competing diet tribes take that same competing diet tribes take that same study and say oh it's either completely study and say oh it's either completely study and say oh it's either completely flawed and worthless and it wasn't low flawed and worthless and it wasn't low flawed and worthless and it wasn't low carb enough or whatever. And then carb enough or whatever. And then carb enough or whatever. And then another group who were pro lowfat dust. another group who were pro lowfat dust. another group who were pro lowfat dust. is like you finally you've proved what is like you finally you've proved what is like you finally you've proved what we've suggested all up. Oh, this is yeah we've suggested all up. Oh, this is yeah we've suggested all up. Oh, this is yeah I mean this is rampant you know in every I mean this is rampant you know in every I mean this is rampant you know in every tribe in every diet cult tribe in every diet cult tribe in every diet cult >> but the point is is that the physiology >> but the point is is that the physiology >> but the point is is that the physiology is incredibly complicated and even how is incredibly complicated and even how is incredibly complicated and even how the body achieves this near equivalence the body achieves this near equivalence the body achieves this near equivalence and even though it's not precisely and even though it's not precisely and even though it's not precisely equivalent is is incredible right inside equivalent is is incredible right inside equivalent is is incredible right inside the body it's like the hormonal system the body it's like the hormonal system the body it's like the hormonal system stands on its head in order to stands on its head in order to stands on its head in order to manipulate what what the different fuels manipulate what what the different fuels manipulate what what the different fuels are shuttling between the different are shuttling between the different are shuttling between the different organs how hormones are changing just to organs how hormones are changing just to organs how hormones are changing just to make it so that it's approximately true make it so that it's approximately true make it so that it's approximately true that when comes to body fat changing. that when comes to body fat changing. that when comes to body fat changing. Something that Rubiner had no idea Something that Rubiner had no idea Something that Rubiner had no idea about. It was a black box for his dog about. It was a black box for his dog about. It was a black box for his dog experiments. He didn't know about experiments. He didn't know about experiments. He didn't know about insulin. He didn't know what the liver insulin. He didn't know what the liver insulin. He didn't know what the liver was doing, what the muscles were doing, was doing, what the muscles were doing, was doing, what the muscles were doing, what the pancreas was doing. No clue what the pancreas was doing. No clue what the pancreas was doing. No clue about the inner workings of the about the inner workings of the about the inner workings of the physiology. But it's just so fascinating physiology. But it's just so fascinating physiology. But it's just so fascinating that the implications of this is that we that the implications of this is that we that the implications of this is that we can survive as humans or dogs on a wide can survive as humans or dogs on a wide can survive as humans or dogs on a wide variety of macronutrient distributions. variety of macronutrient distributions. variety of macronutrient distributions. And when it comes to storing or And when it comes to storing or And when it comes to storing or mobilizing calories from our body fat, mobilizing calories from our body fat, mobilizing calories from our body fat, the professional, you know, organ that the professional, you know, organ that the professional, you know, organ that is, uh, there to store calories, um, is, uh, there to store calories, um, is, uh, there to store calories, um, it's more or less equivalent and it it's more or less equivalent and it it's more or less equivalent and it doesn't have to be perfect. doesn't have to be perfect. doesn't have to be perfect. >> The human animal is is highly adaptive >> The human animal is is highly adaptive >> The human animal is is highly adaptive and resourceful. You know, what I take and resourceful. You know, what I take and resourceful. You know, what I take from what you just shared is essentially from what you just shared is essentially from what you just shared is essentially everything is more complicated than you everything is more complicated than you everything is more complicated than you think it is. Yes, calorie in, calorie think it is. Yes, calorie in, calorie think it is. Yes, calorie in, calorie out, sure, but more nuanced than that. out, sure, but more nuanced than that. out, sure, but more nuanced than that. you know the carbohydrate insulin model you know the carbohydrate insulin model you know the carbohydrate insulin model or you know the hormonal kind of view of or you know the hormonal kind of view of or you know the hormonal kind of view of this whole thing true but also more this whole thing true but also more this whole thing true but also more complicated than perhaps we imagine and complicated than perhaps we imagine and complicated than perhaps we imagine and then I think on top of that there's the then I think on top of that there's the then I think on top of that there's the added layer of complexity which is that added layer of complexity which is that added layer of complexity which is that the scientific method you know by its the scientific method you know by its the scientific method you know by its very nature is reductionist and you know very nature is reductionist and you know very nature is reductionist and you know to apply a nutritionally reductionist to apply a nutritionally reductionist to apply a nutritionally reductionist approach to all of this is flawed in and approach to all of this is flawed in and approach to all of this is flawed in and of itself because just macronutrient of itself because just macronutrient of itself because just macronutrient ratios aren't telling the whole story ratios aren't telling the whole story ratios aren't telling the whole story like you have to contextualize it in the like you have to contextualize it in the like you have to contextualize it in the holistic food like the food matrix holistic food like the food matrix holistic food like the food matrix itself like how much fiber is in this itself like how much fiber is in this itself like how much fiber is in this and what does fiber do to the uptake of and what does fiber do to the uptake of and what does fiber do to the uptake of calories etc and this is you know like calories etc and this is you know like calories etc and this is you know like it just gets super murky from there and it just gets super murky from there and it just gets super murky from there and and then perhaps you know I'm interested and then perhaps you know I'm interested and then perhaps you know I'm interested in like can you draw conclusions from in like can you draw conclusions from in like can you draw conclusions from all of this given like the vast all of this given like the vast all of this given like the vast complexity of all of it complexity of all of it complexity of all of it >> I mean it's incredibly hard right and I >> I mean it's incredibly hard right and I >> I mean it's incredibly hard right and I think that that's that's as scientists think that that's that's as scientists think that that's that's as scientists we have to be really humble in kind of we have to be really humble in kind of we have to be really humble in kind of saying what we think we know about a saying what we think we know about a saying what we think we know about a system and what what things do we have a system and what what things do we have a system and what what things do we have a certain amount of confidence in and what certain amount of confidence in and what certain amount of confidence in and what things are just really beginning to be things are just really beginning to be things are just really beginning to be understood and I I want to take you back understood and I I want to take you back understood and I I want to take you back to it's not just the nutritional to it's not just the nutritional to it's not just the nutritional complexity of food but it's the food complexity of food but it's the food complexity of food but it's the food environment that we find ourselves in environment that we find ourselves in environment that we find ourselves in right so kind of going back to the right so kind of going back to the right so kind of going back to the comment about these different feedback comment about these different feedback comment about these different feedback loops that we talked about that are loops that we talked about that are loops that we talked about that are preventing us from losing more weight preventing us from losing more weight preventing us from losing more weight than we would like and uh and the effort than we would like and uh and the effort than we would like and uh and the effort that's involved in keeping weight off in that's involved in keeping weight off in that's involved in keeping weight off in a given environment well The funny thing a given environment well The funny thing a given environment well The funny thing is that, and we're only beginning to is that, and we're only beginning to is that, and we're only beginning to understand this, you take that same understand this, you take that same understand this, you take that same person and you shift them to a different person and you shift them to a different person and you shift them to a different food environment. What was effortful food environment. What was effortful food environment. What was effortful before is no longer effortful. before is no longer effortful. before is no longer effortful. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> Mhm. >> In other words, whatever point that >> In other words, whatever point that >> In other words, whatever point that we're regulating our body weight and our we're regulating our body weight and our we're regulating our body weight and our appetite and our energy expenditure, appetite and our energy expenditure, appetite and our energy expenditure, those those controls that are helping us those those controls that are helping us those those controls that are helping us regulate body um weight, turns out to be regulate body um weight, turns out to be regulate body um weight, turns out to be incredibly influenced by the the food incredibly influenced by the the food incredibly influenced by the the food environment that we find ourselves in. environment that we find ourselves in. environment that we find ourselves in. So, you know, I was doing these studies So, you know, I was doing these studies So, you know, I was doing these studies where we were manipulating where we were manipulating where we were manipulating macronutrients and observing these macronutrients and observing these macronutrients and observing these little tiny clinically meaningless little tiny clinically meaningless little tiny clinically meaningless differences. But as soon as we started differences. But as soon as we started differences. But as soon as we started to do experiments where we basically to do experiments where we basically to do experiments where we basically said, look, eat however much you'd like. said, look, eat however much you'd like. said, look, eat however much you'd like. We're just going to change the foods We're just going to change the foods We're just going to change the foods that you're exposed to. Now, we are that you're exposed to. Now, we are that you're exposed to. Now, we are starting to see hundreds of calories a starting to see hundreds of calories a starting to see hundreds of calories a day differences. And when these people day differences. And when these people day differences. And when these people are being told, eat as much as you'd are being told, eat as much as you'd are being told, eat as much as you'd like. Don't be trying to change your like. Don't be trying to change your like. Don't be trying to change your weight. We're measuring lots of stuff. weight. We're measuring lots of stuff. weight. We're measuring lots of stuff. What you don't know is we're measuring What you don't know is we're measuring What you don't know is we're measuring all your leftovers. all your leftovers. all your leftovers. and uh we're going to calculate how many and uh we're going to calculate how many and uh we're going to calculate how many calories you decided to eat in these calories you decided to eat in these calories you decided to eat in these different food environments. And they're different food environments. And they're different food environments. And they're really short-term studies, lots of really short-term studies, lots of really short-term studies, lots of limitations, very artificial food limitations, very artificial food limitations, very artificial food environments. environments. environments. >> But the point is is that the environment >> But the point is is that the environment >> But the point is is that the environment is somehow interacting with our is somehow interacting with our is somehow interacting with our fundamental biology in ways that we fundamental biology in ways that we fundamental biology in ways that we still don't fully understand still don't fully understand still don't fully understand and is making it so that whatever point and is making it so that whatever point and is making it so that whatever point we're regulating or whatever narrow we're regulating or whatever narrow we're regulating or whatever narrow range of body weights that we're range of body weights that we're range of body weights that we're regulating is so influenced by the food regulating is so influenced by the food regulating is so influenced by the food environment. And the neuroscience of environment. And the neuroscience of environment. And the neuroscience of that is only beginning to get unpacked. that is only beginning to get unpacked. that is only beginning to get unpacked. It's a really fascinating sort of It's a really fascinating sort of It's a really fascinating sort of observation that despite people not observation that despite people not observation that despite people not trying to change the numbers of calories trying to change the numbers of calories trying to change the numbers of calories that they're eating and trying to change that they're eating and trying to change that they're eating and trying to change their body weight, they're spontaneously their body weight, they're spontaneously their body weight, they're spontaneously changing them by hundreds of calories changing them by hundreds of calories changing them by hundreds of calories per day, spontaneously gaining weight, per day, spontaneously gaining weight, per day, spontaneously gaining weight, gaining body fat, losing weight, losing gaining body fat, losing weight, losing gaining body fat, losing weight, losing body fat without any effort whatsoever. body fat without any effort whatsoever. body fat without any effort whatsoever. And I think that's incredibly And I think that's incredibly And I think that's incredibly fascinating. And it's it's also suggests fascinating. And it's it's also suggests fascinating. And it's it's also suggests that maybe that's what we're seeing in that maybe that's what we're seeing in that maybe that's what we're seeing in society at large when it comes to the society at large when it comes to the society at large when it comes to the increasing amounts of average body increasing amounts of average body increasing amounts of average body weight and the increasing prevalence of weight and the increasing prevalence of weight and the increasing prevalence of obesity that we're seeing is that obesity that we're seeing is that obesity that we're seeing is that something about our food environment has something about our food environment has something about our food environment has changed and and um the science of that changed and and um the science of that changed and and um the science of that is I think still beginning to get is I think still beginning to get is I think still beginning to get unraveled. unraveled. unraveled. >> It's the environment stupid. You know >> It's the environment stupid. You know >> It's the environment stupid. You know what I mean? It's like we can we can what I mean? It's like we can we can what I mean? It's like we can we can argue about the food pyramid or the food argue about the food pyramid or the food argue about the food pyramid or the food plate and like all this sort of stuff, plate and like all this sort of stuff, plate and like all this sort of stuff, but fundamentally it is, you know, but fundamentally it is, you know, but fundamentally it is, you know, you're going to eat what is in your you're going to eat what is in your you're going to eat what is in your environment. And if there is a core kind environment. And if there is a core kind environment. And if there is a core kind of theme or thesis to all of your work, of theme or thesis to all of your work, of theme or thesis to all of your work, it's that um you know, this obesity it's that um you know, this obesity it's that um you know, this obesity epidemic, this, you know, incredibly epidemic, this, you know, incredibly epidemic, this, you know, incredibly precipitous rise in in chronic lifestyle precipitous rise in in chronic lifestyle precipitous rise in in chronic lifestyle ailments are primarily the result of ailments are primarily the result of ailments are primarily the result of toxic food systems. It's a systemic toxic food systems. It's a systemic toxic food systems. It's a systemic issue and all of this focus on um issue and all of this focus on um issue and all of this focus on um willpower or the failure of willpower willpower or the failure of willpower willpower or the failure of willpower and individual food choices has to be and individual food choices has to be and individual food choices has to be contextualized within that in order to contextualized within that in order to contextualized within that in order to really understand what's going on and really understand what's going on and really understand what's going on and craft solutions that are going to be craft solutions that are going to be craft solutions that are going to be effective. effective. effective. >> Right. Yeah. I I think that that's >> Right. Yeah. I I think that that's >> Right. Yeah. I I think that that's right. and um and the degree to which right. and um and the degree to which right. and um and the degree to which indiv some individuals might have a lot indiv some individuals might have a lot indiv some individuals might have a lot of success even within a given food of success even within a given food of success even within a given food environment. Some of it is by limiting environment. Some of it is by limiting environment. Some of it is by limiting the foods that they're exposed to or the foods that they're exposed to or the foods that they're exposed to or limiting the foods that are on their limiting the foods that are on their limiting the foods that are on their list of things that they are even list of things that they are even list of things that they are even deeming possibly acceptable. So I sort deeming possibly acceptable. So I sort deeming possibly acceptable. So I sort of view that as a pseudo sort of local of view that as a pseudo sort of local of view that as a pseudo sort of local environment shift in that way. And the environment shift in that way. And the environment shift in that way. And the folks who have, you know, the the folks who have, you know, the the folks who have, you know, the the privilege and the and the interest and privilege and the and the interest and privilege and the and the interest and the energy and u the motivation to kind the energy and u the motivation to kind the energy and u the motivation to kind of engage in that sort of um local of engage in that sort of um local of engage in that sort of um local environment shift and have access to um environment shift and have access to um environment shift and have access to um the kinds of foods that are likely to the kinds of foods that are likely to the kinds of foods that are likely to drive the body weight regulatory system drive the body weight regulatory system drive the body weight regulatory system in the positive direction. Yeah, clearly in the positive direction. Yeah, clearly in the positive direction. Yeah, clearly they're going to have the most success. they're going to have the most success. they're going to have the most success. And there's lots of roles and lots of And there's lots of roles and lots of And there's lots of roles and lots of good reasons to kind of engage in those good reasons to kind of engage in those good reasons to kind of engage in those with those folks on an individual by with those folks on an individual by with those folks on an individual by individual level. Um, and there's lots individual level. Um, and there's lots individual level. Um, and there's lots of people whose careers are made on on of people whose careers are made on on of people whose careers are made on on that sort of thing. And I completely that sort of thing. And I completely that sort of thing. And I completely encourage that. But I think it overlooks encourage that. But I think it overlooks encourage that. But I think it overlooks the fact that, you know, body size in a the fact that, you know, body size in a the fact that, you know, body size in a given environment is, you know, 40 to given environment is, you know, 40 to given environment is, you know, 40 to 70% heritable 70% heritable 70% heritable >> and that some of us are more genetically >> and that some of us are more genetically >> and that some of us are more genetically susceptible to shifts in our food susceptible to shifts in our food susceptible to shifts in our food environment than others. And at the environment than others. And at the environment than others. And at the population level, what we have to population level, what we have to population level, what we have to account for is the full complexity of account for is the full complexity of account for is the full complexity of that food environment. So it's not just that food environment. So it's not just that food environment. So it's not just the foods themselves, it's the context the foods themselves, it's the context the foods themselves, it's the context and how they're advertised. What are the and how they're advertised. What are the and how they're advertised. What are the most inexpensive, the most convenient, most inexpensive, the most convenient, most inexpensive, the most convenient, the most readily available foods? Um, the most readily available foods? Um, the most readily available foods? Um, you know, what are our skill sets? How you know, what are our skill sets? How you know, what are our skill sets? How are we relating to our in our social are we relating to our in our social are we relating to our in our social situations? Uh, do we have supportive situations? Uh, do we have supportive situations? Uh, do we have supportive folks who are going to support us to folks who are going to support us to folks who are going to support us to make changes in our local environment or make changes in our local environment or make changes in our local environment or are they going to resist those changes? are they going to resist those changes? are they going to resist those changes? It gets incredibly complicated. But at It gets incredibly complicated. But at It gets incredibly complicated. But at the broadest possible level, it just the broadest possible level, it just the broadest possible level, it just seems like the most obvious explanation seems like the most obvious explanation seems like the most obvious explanation for what we've seen happening. The for what we've seen happening. The for what we've seen happening. The shifts in the body size distribution. I shifts in the body size distribution. I shifts in the body size distribution. I mean, they they happen they started mean, they they happen they started mean, they they happen they started happening, you know, centuries ago in happening, you know, centuries ago in happening, you know, centuries ago in positive ways, right? We saw increasing positive ways, right? We saw increasing positive ways, right? We saw increasing weight and increasing height were as a weight and increasing height were as a weight and increasing height were as a result of nutritional deficiencies, result of nutritional deficiencies, result of nutritional deficiencies, right? right? right? >> Something shifted as we kind of got into >> Something shifted as we kind of got into >> Something shifted as we kind of got into the middle of the 20th century. And the middle of the 20th century. And the middle of the 20th century. And that's, you know, where we get into the that's, you know, where we get into the that's, you know, where we get into the the major shifts in the industrialized the major shifts in the industrialized the major shifts in the industrialized food system and whatnot. food system and whatnot. food system and whatnot. >> So, I love the fact that you're you're >> So, I love the fact that you're you're >> So, I love the fact that you're you're very kind of anti-diet tribalism. Like, very kind of anti-diet tribalism. Like, very kind of anti-diet tribalism. Like, you know, listen, you can be healthy and you know, listen, you can be healthy and you know, listen, you can be healthy and sustain weight loss on a low carb diet, sustain weight loss on a low carb diet, sustain weight loss on a low carb diet, on a high carb diet. Like, we can on a high carb diet. Like, we can on a high carb diet. Like, we can quibble around the edges there and quibble around the edges there and quibble around the edges there and people can fight and go to loggerheads people can fight and go to loggerheads people can fight and go to loggerheads over all that kind of stuff, but over all that kind of stuff, but over all that kind of stuff, but fundamentally the the 800 lb gorilla in fundamentally the the 800 lb gorilla in fundamentally the the 800 lb gorilla in the room is ultrarocessed food. So when the room is ultrarocessed food. So when the room is ultrarocessed food. So when we're talking about food environments, I we're talking about food environments, I we're talking about food environments, I mean that is the kind of lurking giant mean that is the kind of lurking giant mean that is the kind of lurking giant that's driving all of these that's driving all of these that's driving all of these delletterious health outcomes. delletterious health outcomes. delletterious health outcomes. >> Yeah. I mean the way I sort of see it is >> Yeah. I mean the way I sort of see it is >> Yeah. I mean the way I sort of see it is even taking one step back which is um even taking one step back which is um even taking one step back which is um you know ultrarocessed foods are the you know ultrarocessed foods are the you know ultrarocessed foods are the consequence of what we call in the book consequence of what we call in the book consequence of what we call in the book the calorie glut. Um so ever since the the calorie glut. Um so ever since the the calorie glut. Um so ever since the introduction of agriculture um humans introduction of agriculture um humans introduction of agriculture um humans have struggled to provide enough have struggled to provide enough have struggled to provide enough calories to feed populations. That was calories to feed populations. That was calories to feed populations. That was been the kind of devil's bargain that been the kind of devil's bargain that been the kind of devil's bargain that was struck when we moved into was struck when we moved into was struck when we moved into agricultural systems is uh society agricultural systems is uh society agricultural systems is uh society populations could grow. Um less and less populations could grow. Um less and less populations could grow. Um less and less people were responsible for producing people were responsible for producing people were responsible for producing food and we got civilizations and food and we got civilizations and food and we got civilizations and whatnot. But at the same time we were whatnot. But at the same time we were whatnot. But at the same time we were always threatened with population growth always threatened with population growth always threatened with population growth exceeding the ability of agriculture to exceeding the ability of agriculture to exceeding the ability of agriculture to feed populations and there was obviously feed populations and there was obviously feed populations and there was obviously periods of mass starvation. Thomas periods of mass starvation. Thomas periods of mass starvation. Thomas Mouthus uh kind of a a very famous 18th Mouthus uh kind of a a very famous 18th Mouthus uh kind of a a very famous 18th century um uh thinker century um uh thinker century um uh thinker basically made this observation that basically made this observation that basically made this observation that we're basically doomed to starvation cuz we're basically doomed to starvation cuz we're basically doomed to starvation cuz agricultural productivity and yield agricultural productivity and yield agricultural productivity and yield cannot possibly keep pace with what he cannot possibly keep pace with what he cannot possibly keep pace with what he saw as exponential growing populations. saw as exponential growing populations. saw as exponential growing populations. We've bucked that trend for the most We've bucked that trend for the most We've bucked that trend for the most part. part. part. >> Yeah, I think we we have pretty much >> Yeah, I think we we have pretty much >> Yeah, I think we we have pretty much >> but it's interesting. It's crafty, you >> but it's interesting. It's crafty, you >> but it's interesting. It's crafty, you know, it's kind of ingenious the know, it's kind of ingenious the know, it's kind of ingenious the solutions that humans came up with to solutions that humans came up with to solutions that humans came up with to solve this. solve this. solve this. >> It is amazing. And we we think that >> It is amazing. And we we think that >> It is amazing. And we we think that okay, yeah, that's 18th century Thomas okay, yeah, that's 18th century Thomas okay, yeah, that's 18th century Thomas Mouthis. It it was um you know, Mouthis. It it was um you know, Mouthis. It it was um you know, biologist Paul Erlick in the even in the biologist Paul Erlick in the even in the biologist Paul Erlick in the even in the 1980s was still saying that we would 1980s was still saying that we would 1980s was still saying that we would have mass starvation in America right have mass starvation in America right have mass starvation in America right around the same time we were exceeding around the same time we were exceeding around the same time we were exceeding seeing an explosion of obesity seeing an explosion of obesity seeing an explosion of obesity prevalence. prevalence. prevalence. And And And you know it's it's amazing what what you know it's it's amazing what what you know it's it's amazing what what we've been able to do with agricultural we've been able to do with agricultural we've been able to do with agricultural yields and industrialization of farming yields and industrialization of farming yields and industrialization of farming and whatnot. But uh we basically put in and whatnot. But uh we basically put in and whatnot. But uh we basically put in place um in you know the middle part of place um in you know the middle part of place um in you know the middle part of the 20th century the 20th century the 20th century all of the resources and research to all of the resources and research to all of the resources and research to maximize calorie production especially maximize calorie production especially maximize calorie production especially in places like the US and Canada and in places like the US and Canada and in places like the US and Canada and Europe. We did a calculation for the Europe. We did a calculation for the Europe. We did a calculation for the book which I thought was kind of book which I thought was kind of book which I thought was kind of interesting. If you just take the four interesting. If you just take the four interesting. If you just take the four commodity crops for food um rice, corn, commodity crops for food um rice, corn, commodity crops for food um rice, corn, wheat and soy, and you ask the question, wheat and soy, and you ask the question, wheat and soy, and you ask the question, how many calories per person uh per day how many calories per person uh per day how many calories per person uh per day are produced in those uh those few are produced in those uh those few are produced in those uh those few commodity crops? Turns out to be 15,000 commodity crops? Turns out to be 15,000 commodity crops? Turns out to be 15,000 calories per person per day. So, calories per person per day. So, calories per person per day. So, >> wow. >> wow. >> wow. >> You know, sixfold, you know, what the >> You know, sixfold, you know, what the >> You know, sixfold, you know, what the nutritional needs are. And we've been nutritional needs are. And we've been nutritional needs are. And we've been finding ways to kind of get rid of that finding ways to kind of get rid of that finding ways to kind of get rid of that glut of calories, right? huge chunk of glut of calories, right? huge chunk of glut of calories, right? huge chunk of the the soy and the corn goes to bofuel the the soy and the corn goes to bofuel the the soy and the corn goes to bofuel production, right? Which for many production, right? Which for many production, right? Which for many >> and animal agriculture >> and animal agriculture >> and animal agriculture >> and then animal agriculture is the other >> and then animal agriculture is the other >> and then animal agriculture is the other big chunk of it, right? And the reason big chunk of it, right? And the reason big chunk of it, right? And the reason why that sort of works to get rid of it why that sort of works to get rid of it why that sort of works to get rid of it is because well animals have a is because well animals have a is because well animals have a metabolism, right? They just they don't metabolism, right? They just they don't metabolism, right? They just they don't just kind of translate one calorie of just kind of translate one calorie of just kind of translate one calorie of corn into one calorie of meat, right? corn into one calorie of meat, right? corn into one calorie of meat, right? They waste a lot of those calories by They waste a lot of those calories by They waste a lot of those calories by living essentially. Um and and so and so living essentially. Um and and so and so living essentially. Um and and so and so it's a very inefficient process, animal it's a very inefficient process, animal it's a very inefficient process, animal agriculture. And so yeah, so at the end agriculture. And so yeah, so at the end agriculture. And so yeah, so at the end of the day, you end up with something of the day, you end up with something of the day, you end up with something more like 4,000 calories per person per more like 4,000 calories per person per more like 4,000 calories per person per day in the actual food supply of day in the actual food supply of day in the actual food supply of America. America. America. >> And even that increase since the 1970s >> And even that increase since the 1970s >> And even that increase since the 1970s is more than enough to explain obesity. is more than enough to explain obesity. is more than enough to explain obesity. Turns out that um that about 2/3 of the Turns out that um that about 2/3 of the Turns out that um that about 2/3 of the increase in calories in the food supply increase in calories in the food supply increase in calories in the food supply after accounting for a animal after accounting for a animal after accounting for a animal agriculture and the exports and the and agriculture and the exports and the and agriculture and the exports and the and the bofuel production, twothirds of that the bofuel production, twothirds of that the bofuel production, twothirds of that increase went in the trash was food. increase went in the trash was food. increase went in the trash was food. >> Yeah. you have this interesting uh like >> Yeah. you have this interesting uh like >> Yeah. you have this interesting uh like correlation between the increase in food correlation between the increase in food correlation between the increase in food waste and the increase in obesity. waste and the increase in obesity. waste and the increase in obesity. >> Yeah. And I don't think it's an >> Yeah. And I don't think it's an >> Yeah. And I don't think it's an accident. I mean I think that the point accident. I mean I think that the point accident. I mean I think that the point is that we have produced this calorie is that we have produced this calorie is that we have produced this calorie glut and come up with very clever clever glut and come up with very clever clever glut and come up with very clever clever ways of offloading it both in terms of ways of offloading it both in terms of ways of offloading it both in terms of animal agriculture and bofuel production animal agriculture and bofuel production animal agriculture and bofuel production and the other part is ultrarocessed and the other part is ultrarocessed and the other part is ultrarocessed foods. Right? is taking those cheap foods. Right? is taking those cheap foods. Right? is taking those cheap >> high yield inputs to the food system and >> high yield inputs to the food system and >> high yield inputs to the food system and coming up with incredible ways to coming up with incredible ways to coming up with incredible ways to transform them. Who who would have transform them. Who who would have transform them. Who who would have thought you could take corn and make thought you could take corn and make thought you could take corn and make basically sugar, high fructose corn basically sugar, high fructose corn basically sugar, high fructose corn syrup for use in products, right? syrup for use in products, right? syrup for use in products, right? >> Subsidizing it to artificially deflate >> Subsidizing it to artificially deflate >> Subsidizing it to artificially deflate the price of it to make it widely the price of it to make it widely the price of it to make it widely affordable, hyper palatable, highly affordable, hyper palatable, highly affordable, hyper palatable, highly caloric, nutritionally deficient, and caloric, nutritionally deficient, and caloric, nutritionally deficient, and also something about it that makes us also something about it that makes us also something about it that makes us want to eat it quickly. want to eat it quickly. want to eat it quickly. too, right? too, right? too, right? >> So that we're ahead of our sort of >> So that we're ahead of our sort of >> So that we're ahead of our sort of appetite suppressant, you know, impulse, appetite suppressant, you know, impulse, appetite suppressant, you know, impulse, >> right? And and I think that there's, you >> right? And and I think that there's, you >> right? And and I think that there's, you know, a lot of people say that, you know, a lot of people say that, you know, a lot of people say that, you know, the food industry knows all the know, the food industry knows all the know, the food industry knows all the mechanisms by which um these things mechanisms by which um these things mechanisms by which um these things cause us to overeat. I don't I don't cause us to overeat. I don't I don't cause us to overeat. I don't I don't necessarily think that's true. I mean, necessarily think that's true. I mean, necessarily think that's true. I mean, I'm sure that they're trying to come up I'm sure that they're trying to come up I'm sure that they're trying to come up with incredibly tasty products that do with incredibly tasty products that do with incredibly tasty products that do well in the marketplace, right? And when well in the marketplace, right? And when well in the marketplace, right? And when they fail, and many of them do fail, they fail, and many of them do fail, they fail, and many of them do fail, they basically re-engineer a replacement they basically re-engineer a replacement they basically re-engineer a replacement and put it back. It's like evolution, and put it back. It's like evolution, and put it back. It's like evolution, right? It's like selection of the right? It's like selection of the right? It's like selection of the fittest products on the marketplace that fittest products on the marketplace that fittest products on the marketplace that are maximizing sales, right? And they're are maximizing sales, right? And they're are maximizing sales, right? And they're not. not. not. >> What happens if you put Fritos in a Taco >> What happens if you put Fritos in a Taco >> What happens if you put Fritos in a Taco Bell burrito, you know, people like Bell burrito, you know, people like Bell burrito, you know, people like that? that? that? >> Exactly. It's like, let's try it out. >> Exactly. It's like, let's try it out. >> Exactly. It's like, let's try it out. You know, there's we got a little focus You know, there's we got a little focus You know, there's we got a little focus group. They said they liked it enough to group. They said they liked it enough to group. They said they liked it enough to let's try it out. let's try it out. let's try it out. >> And yeah, that's that's the food >> And yeah, that's that's the food >> And yeah, that's that's the food environment that we're experiencing environment that we're experiencing environment that we're experiencing right now. And um and I think the point right now. And um and I think the point right now. And um and I think the point is that both in the agricultural sector is that both in the agricultural sector is that both in the agricultural sector all along the path we have these all along the path we have these all along the path we have these externalities that are not part of the externalities that are not part of the externalities that are not part of the equation right all of the environmental equation right all of the environmental equation right all of the environmental damage that was done to kind of do this damage that was done to kind of do this damage that was done to kind of do this industrial agriculture all of the uh the industrial agriculture all of the uh the industrial agriculture all of the uh the problems with the animal agriculture problems with the animal agriculture problems with the animal agriculture just from a moral perspective as well as just from a moral perspective as well as just from a moral perspective as well as you know the the manure that's produced you know the the manure that's produced you know the the manure that's produced and and uh and and and the methane and and uh and and and the methane and and uh and and and the methane that's produced and climate change and that's produced and climate change and that's produced and climate change and uh uh uh >> and the depletion of the soils. So the >> and the depletion of the soils. So the >> and the depletion of the soils. So the nutrient the nutrients that end up in nutrient the nutrients that end up in nutrient the nutrients that end up in the food are are less than they once the food are are less than they once the food are are less than they once were. were. were. >> Yeah. I I mean there's some debate >> Yeah. I I mean there's some debate >> Yeah. I I mean there's some debate there's some debate about that I think there's some debate about that I think there's some debate about that I think about how important that is, but I think about how important that is, but I think about how important that is, but I think that there are certainly cases where that there are certainly cases where that there are certainly cases where that's been shown. The other big that's been shown. The other big that's been shown. The other big externality has been health care costs, externality has been health care costs, externality has been health care costs, right? I mean the fact that um we are right? I mean the fact that um we are right? I mean the fact that um we are experiencing this this dramatic increase experiencing this this dramatic increase experiencing this this dramatic increase in diet related chronic disease that is in diet related chronic disease that is in diet related chronic disease that is you know essentially bankrupting you know essentially bankrupting you know essentially bankrupting Medicare, Medicaid and and and the the Medicare, Medicaid and and and the the Medicare, Medicaid and and and the the health sector and to think that this health sector and to think that this health sector and to think that this entire process of you know solving entire process of you know solving entire process of you know solving Mouthys' Mouthys' Mouthys' which is essentially we've solved which is essentially we've solved which is essentially we've solved Mouthys' problem right and we have to do Mouthys' problem right and we have to do Mouthys' problem right and we have to do something to kind of change this not something to kind of change this not something to kind of change this not just for the health crisis but the fact just for the health crisis but the fact just for the health crisis but the fact that we're going to have 10 billion that we're going to have 10 billion that we're going to have 10 billion people on the planet in you know not too people on the planet in you know not too people on the planet in you know not too far distant future that solves mouthys' far distant future that solves mouthys' far distant future that solves mouthys' problem because the population is no problem because the population is no problem because the population is no longer expected to increase what do we longer expected to increase what do we longer expected to increase what do we have to do to the food system to both have to do to the food system to both have to do to the food system to both ensure that we have equitable ensure that we have equitable ensure that we have equitable distribution of calories and that those distribution of calories and that those distribution of calories and that those calories are actually healthy for us and calories are actually healthy for us and calories are actually healthy for us and the planet that's the grand challenge of the planet that's the grand challenge of the planet that's the grand challenge of agriculture and nutrition and food agriculture and nutrition and food agriculture and nutrition and food science for the next you know several science for the next you know several science for the next you know several decades decades decades >> and we need to think about it in this >> and we need to think about it in this >> and we need to think about it in this context in some sense like context in some sense like context in some sense like Obesity and diet related chronic Obesity and diet related chronic Obesity and diet related chronic diseases are like the epic phenomenon, diseases are like the epic phenomenon, diseases are like the epic phenomenon, right? Like they're the thing that right? Like they're the thing that right? Like they're the thing that happened because we frontloaded all happened because we frontloaded all happened because we frontloaded all those calories in the agricultural those calories in the agricultural those calories in the agricultural system and now we've got to figure out a system and now we've got to figure out a system and now we've got to figure out a way to kind of steer past that. You way to kind of steer past that. You way to kind of steer past that. You know, fortunately we have some, you know, fortunately we have some, you know, fortunately we have some, you know, therapies that are entering the know, therapies that are entering the know, therapies that are entering the market that can help the folks who are market that can help the folks who are market that can help the folks who are most genetically susceptible to those most genetically susceptible to those most genetically susceptible to those changes in the food environment. But changes in the food environment. But changes in the food environment. But we've got to think past that as well and we've got to think past that as well and we've got to think past that as well and and look to see, you know, where do we and look to see, you know, where do we and look to see, you know, where do we want to end up when we have to feed 10 want to end up when we have to feed 10 want to end up when we have to feed 10 billion people um a healthy diet that's billion people um a healthy diet that's billion people um a healthy diet that's equitably distributed as well as equitably distributed as well as equitably distributed as well as sustainable for the planet. sustainable for the planet. sustainable for the planet. There's this thing that happens in the There's this thing that happens in the There's this thing that happens in the supplement space where the second supplement space where the second supplement space where the second something goes mainstream, the market something goes mainstream, the market something goes mainstream, the market gets flooded and quality tanks. Creatine gets flooded and quality tanks. Creatine gets flooded and quality tanks. Creatine is sort of going through this right now. is sort of going through this right now. is sort of going through this right now. everyone finally gets that it's not just everyone finally gets that it's not just everyone finally gets that it's not just for gym bros, it's for brain health and for gym bros, it's for brain health and for gym bros, it's for brain health and recovery and longevity. But now you've recovery and longevity. But now you've recovery and longevity. But now you've got all these brands pumping out gummy got all these brands pumping out gummy got all these brands pumping out gummy versions that are essentially just versions that are essentially just versions that are essentially just candy. Momentous took a different candy. Momentous took a different candy. Momentous took a different approach, which is one of the reasons approach, which is one of the reasons approach, which is one of the reasons why I love them and why I partner with why I love them and why I partner with why I love them and why I partner with them. Uh they spent years, not months, them. Uh they spent years, not months, them. Uh they spent years, not months, years, refusing to release a chewable years, refusing to release a chewable years, refusing to release a chewable until they could do it without until they could do it without until they could do it without compromising. And the result of this is compromising. And the result of this is compromising. And the result of this is Momentous Creatine Chews, which meets Momentous Creatine Chews, which meets Momentous Creatine Chews, which meets what they call the Momentous Standard. what they call the Momentous Standard. what they call the Momentous Standard. The same standard, I might add, trusted The same standard, I might add, trusted The same standard, I might add, trusted by Olympians and Pro teams. Each chew by Olympians and Pro teams. Each chew by Olympians and Pro teams. Each chew delivers 1 g of pure Korea pure creatine delivers 1 g of pure Korea pure creatine delivers 1 g of pure Korea pure creatine monohydrate. Single source from Germany. monohydrate. Single source from Germany. monohydrate. Single source from Germany. NSF certified for sport, of course, and NSF certified for sport, of course, and NSF certified for sport, of course, and without any weird artificial stuff. Now without any weird artificial stuff. Now without any weird artificial stuff. Now you can keep them anywhere, which you can keep them anywhere, which you can keep them anywhere, which removes all the friction that comes with removes all the friction that comes with removes all the friction that comes with powders and shakers. So head over to powders and shakers. So head over to powders and shakers. So head over to livemomentus.com and use code rich roll livemomentus.com and use code rich roll livemomentus.com and use code rich roll for up to 35% off your first order. I mean here's where everything I mean here's where everything bifurcates because on the one hand we bifurcates because on the one hand we bifurcates because on the one hand we have personal choice. You know what are have personal choice. You know what are have personal choice. You know what are we deciding to put in our mouths you we deciding to put in our mouths you we deciding to put in our mouths you know a couple times a day? Um what's know a couple times a day? Um what's know a couple times a day? Um what's available to us and affordable you what available to us and affordable you what available to us and affordable you what is the extent of our personal agency and is the extent of our personal agency and is the extent of our personal agency and our relationship with our own bodies. our relationship with our own bodies. our relationship with our own bodies. And then there's then there's public And then there's then there's public And then there's then there's public policy and what's good for the whole and policy and what's good for the whole and policy and what's good for the whole and what are the systemic changes that we what are the systemic changes that we what are the systemic changes that we need to make uh you know for a healthy need to make uh you know for a healthy need to make uh you know for a healthy planet and a healthy populace all of planet and a healthy populace all of planet and a healthy populace all of that and those are two sort of different that and those are two sort of different that and those are two sort of different discussions I mean they they inform each discussions I mean they they inform each discussions I mean they they inform each other but I think in the conversation other but I think in the conversation other but I think in the conversation around you know well-being and around you know well-being and around you know well-being and addressing the obesity epidemic uh these addressing the obesity epidemic uh these addressing the obesity epidemic uh these two things get conflated and confused two things get conflated and confused two things get conflated and confused with each other and and and perhaps this with each other and and and perhaps this with each other and and and perhaps this is where you you you kind of butt up is where you you you kind of butt up is where you you you kind of butt up against HHS here a little bit because against HHS here a little bit because against HHS here a little bit because there's such a a palatable irony here there's such a a palatable irony here there's such a a palatable irony here because you're you're raising the alarm because you're you're raising the alarm because you're you're raising the alarm of ultrarocessed foods. Like this is of ultrarocessed foods. Like this is of ultrarocessed foods. Like this is this is really what's driving all of the this is really what's driving all of the this is really what's driving all of the problems which is in parallel with problems which is in parallel with problems which is in parallel with everything that RFK Jr. is saying and everything that RFK Jr. is saying and everything that RFK Jr. is saying and what the whole Maha movement is about, what the whole Maha movement is about, what the whole Maha movement is about, right? So you would think, hey, you right? So you would think, hey, you right? So you would think, hey, you know, you're an ally to this movement. know, you're an ally to this movement. know, you're an ally to this movement. Um but your research didn't exactly line Um but your research didn't exactly line Um but your research didn't exactly line up with whatever RFK decided was the up with whatever RFK decided was the up with whatever RFK decided was the truth. And this is where this conflict truth. And this is where this conflict truth. And this is where this conflict arose. Can you talk a little bit about arose. Can you talk a little bit about arose. Can you talk a little bit about that? that? that? >> Yeah, sure. I mean, let's go back even >> Yeah, sure. I mean, let's go back even >> Yeah, sure. I mean, let's go back even before the last election, right? So, before the last election, right? So, before the last election, right? So, before the last presidential election, before the last presidential election, before the last presidential election, this was a bipartisan issue, right? And this was a bipartisan issue, right? And this was a bipartisan issue, right? And um and we can go way back when it wasn't um and we can go way back when it wasn't um and we can go way back when it wasn't a bipartisan issue with Michelle Obama a bipartisan issue with Michelle Obama a bipartisan issue with Michelle Obama and the Let's Move campaign. It was and the Let's Move campaign. It was and the Let's Move campaign. It was clearly a Democratic issue and people clearly a Democratic issue and people clearly a Democratic issue and people were interested in improving our food were interested in improving our food were interested in improving our food and our and and uh in addressing and our and and uh in addressing and our and and uh in addressing obesity. Um, that was clearly a obesity. Um, that was clearly a obesity. Um, that was clearly a >> Yeah. And that didn't that didn't go >> Yeah. And that didn't that didn't go >> Yeah. And that didn't that didn't go well. well. well. >> Did not go did not go well, right? For >> Did not go did not go well, right? For >> Did not go did not go well, right? For all its good intentions and and whatnot, all its good intentions and and whatnot, all its good intentions and and whatnot, it did not go well. But there there was it did not go well. But there there was it did not go well. But there there was something different that was going on. I something different that was going on. I something different that was going on. I think a lot of it had to do with the the think a lot of it had to do with the the think a lot of it had to do with the the discussion about ultrarocessed food discussion about ultrarocessed food discussion about ultrarocessed food because we've had these discussions because we've had these discussions because we've had these discussions back, you know, it's it's either been back, you know, it's it's either been back, you know, it's it's either been sugar or saturated fat or sodium and sugar or saturated fat or sodium and sugar or saturated fat or sodium and salt that have all been like public salt that have all been like public salt that have all been like public health enemies and they've all had health enemies and they've all had health enemies and they've all had there's a lot of data behind those um there's a lot of data behind those um there's a lot of data behind those um kinds of campaigns and why it would be kinds of campaigns and why it would be kinds of campaigns and why it would be better for people to eat less salt and better for people to eat less salt and better for people to eat less salt and eat less saturated fat and um and eat eat less saturated fat and um and eat eat less saturated fat and um and eat less sugar and things like that. And I less sugar and things like that. And I less sugar and things like that. And I don't think there's many folks who don't think there's many folks who don't think there's many folks who disagree with it, but they didn't really disagree with it, but they didn't really disagree with it, but they didn't really capture enough public attention, capture enough public attention, capture enough public attention, especially at the political level that, especially at the political level that, especially at the political level that, you know, I don't remember seeing a you know, I don't remember seeing a you know, I don't remember seeing a Senate hearing Senate hearing Senate hearing about, you know, added sugar, right? about, you know, added sugar, right? about, you know, added sugar, right? Well, it was it was it was interpreted Well, it was it was it was interpreted Well, it was it was it was interpreted at that time and perhaps that was a at that time and perhaps that was a at that time and perhaps that was a failure of the messaging as an affront failure of the messaging as an affront failure of the messaging as an affront to personal liberty. Like the to personal liberty. Like the to personal liberty. Like the government's going to tell you what you government's going to tell you what you government's going to tell you what you should eat and like how how dare they, should eat and like how how dare they, should eat and like how how dare they, you know, kind of intrude upon my you know, kind of intrude upon my you know, kind of intrude upon my personal choice, right? personal choice, right? personal choice, right? >> As opposed to, hey, there are shadowy, >> As opposed to, hey, there are shadowy, >> As opposed to, hey, there are shadowy, you know, giant corporations who don't you know, giant corporations who don't you know, giant corporations who don't have your best interest at heart here have your best interest at heart here have your best interest at heart here and they're out to get you or, you know, and they're out to get you or, you know, and they're out to get you or, you know, there there could have been a different there there could have been a different there there could have been a different way of communicating that message at way of communicating that message at way of communicating that message at that time. And and I think possibly that time. And and I think possibly that time. And and I think possibly that's part of what this idea of that's part of what this idea of that's part of what this idea of ultrarocessed food has kind of brought ultrarocessed food has kind of brought ultrarocessed food has kind of brought to the table has been the fact that all to the table has been the fact that all to the table has been the fact that all of these things are important about the of these things are important about the of these things are important about the nutrient properties of the of the foods nutrient properties of the of the foods nutrient properties of the of the foods that there are and the way that they're that there are and the way that they're that there are and the way that they're marketed and the overall system of food marketed and the overall system of food marketed and the overall system of food that we're experiencing and how it's that we're experiencing and how it's that we're experiencing and how it's changed since, you know, the middle of changed since, you know, the middle of changed since, you know, the middle of the 20th century. And so yeah, we had the 20th century. And so yeah, we had the 20th century. And so yeah, we had like, you know, Bernie Sanders, Cy like, you know, Bernie Sanders, Cy like, you know, Bernie Sanders, Cy Booker, you couldn't tell their comments Booker, you couldn't tell their comments Booker, you couldn't tell their comments about this from Bill Cassidy or even RFK about this from Bill Cassidy or even RFK about this from Bill Cassidy or even RFK Jr. at the time. It was like it was and Jr. at the time. It was like it was and Jr. at the time. It was like it was and I still think that if you talked to Cy I still think that if you talked to Cy I still think that if you talked to Cy Booker today, he would probably tell Booker today, he would probably tell Booker today, he would probably tell you, well, he's on honeymoon, I guess, you, well, he's on honeymoon, I guess, you, well, he's on honeymoon, I guess, right now. right now. right now. >> He's on honeymoon right now. But no, but >> He's on honeymoon right now. But no, but >> He's on honeymoon right now. But no, but this is this is an issue that he cares this is this is an issue that he cares this is this is an issue that he cares deeply about. Exactly. deeply about. Exactly. deeply about. Exactly. >> And has been working on for a very long >> And has been working on for a very long >> And has been working on for a very long time. time. time. >> Exactly. And so I still think that for >> Exactly. And so I still think that for >> Exactly. And so I still think that for this particular set of topics, there is this particular set of topics, there is this particular set of topics, there is bipartisan support. And before you know bipartisan support. And before you know bipartisan support. And before you know this current administration, nutrition this current administration, nutrition this current administration, nutrition science has been funded horribly by the science has been funded horribly by the science has been funded horribly by the NIH for a very long time. NIH for a very long time. NIH for a very long time. >> So it's not a new situation that the >> So it's not a new situation that the >> So it's not a new situation that the funding has been anemic. funding has been anemic. funding has been anemic. >> Exactly. And we've been focused I think >> Exactly. And we've been focused I think >> Exactly. And we've been focused I think you know there's a good justification you know there's a good justification you know there's a good justification for doing this but there's been a huge for doing this but there's been a huge for doing this but there's been a huge focus on the sort of biomedical program focus on the sort of biomedical program focus on the sort of biomedical program of let's figure out how to treat and of let's figure out how to treat and of let's figure out how to treat and cure disease. Right? No one's going to cure disease. Right? No one's going to cure disease. Right? No one's going to argue with that. Right? Everyone wants argue with that. Right? Everyone wants argue with that. Right? Everyone wants to be able to cure cancer and treat to be able to cure cancer and treat to be able to cure cancer and treat diabetes with better, you know, diabetes with better, you know, diabetes with better, you know, therapies and and whatnot, but there has therapies and and whatnot, but there has therapies and and whatnot, but there has been less emphasis and less funding on been less emphasis and less funding on been less emphasis and less funding on nutrition science and prevention and the nutrition science and prevention and the nutrition science and prevention and the environmental drivers of of disease environmental drivers of of disease environmental drivers of of disease prevalence prevalence prevalence >> because >> because >> because >> it's a great question. >> it's a great question. >> it's a great question. >> Is it is it, you know, is it big food >> Is it is it, you know, is it big food >> Is it is it, you know, is it big food lobby money uh that is influencing lobby money uh that is influencing lobby money uh that is influencing appropriations? appropriations? appropriations? >> I don't know. I honestly don't know. >> I don't know. I honestly don't know. >> I don't know. I honestly don't know. >> Lack of political will. I mean, I would >> Lack of political will. I mean, I would >> Lack of political will. I mean, I would say that there's probably, let's let's say that there's probably, let's let's say that there's probably, let's let's face it, when do people get exercised face it, when do people get exercised face it, when do people get exercised about, you know, disease? It's when they about, you know, disease? It's when they about, you know, disease? It's when they get a disease or a loved one gets a get a disease or a loved one gets a get a disease or a loved one gets a disease, right? And the first thing they disease, right? And the first thing they disease, right? And the first thing they want is a cure. So, there's a huge want is a cure. So, there's a huge want is a cure. So, there's a huge amounts of lobbying from organizations amounts of lobbying from organizations amounts of lobbying from organizations and people who have already suffered the and people who have already suffered the and people who have already suffered the consequences of diseases that were put consequences of diseases that were put consequences of diseases that were put in motion by environmental drivers a in motion by environmental drivers a in motion by environmental drivers a long time ago. And the ask is not let's long time ago. And the ask is not let's long time ago. And the ask is not let's fix those other things that have driven fix those other things that have driven fix those other things that have driven this for, you know, my grandchildren. this for, you know, my grandchildren. this for, you know, my grandchildren. The ask is I want to know what it is The ask is I want to know what it is The ask is I want to know what it is that I'm going to have to do to get a that I'm going to have to do to get a that I'm going to have to do to get a cure in the few years left that my, you cure in the few years left that my, you cure in the few years left that my, you know, parent or my child has this know, parent or my child has this know, parent or my child has this disease. That's a very powerful message disease. That's a very powerful message disease. That's a very powerful message that that resonates with people. I don't that that resonates with people. I don't that that resonates with people. I don't I don't want to take any anything away I don't want to take any anything away I don't want to take any anything away from that. from that. from that. >> The acute nature of it, but but but far >> The acute nature of it, but but but far >> The acute nature of it, but but but far more people are walking around thinking, more people are walking around thinking, more people are walking around thinking, "How come I'm getting fat and how come I "How come I'm getting fat and how come I "How come I'm getting fat and how come I can't lose weight?" Like, I mean, that can't lose weight?" Like, I mean, that can't lose weight?" Like, I mean, that is just, you know, that's that's like is just, you know, that's that's like is just, you know, that's that's like you're capturing like 80% of the you're capturing like 80% of the you're capturing like 80% of the population or probably more. population or probably more. population or probably more. >> And to be fair, we've come up with >> And to be fair, we've come up with >> And to be fair, we've come up with pretty decent treatments in recent years pretty decent treatments in recent years pretty decent treatments in recent years for se several of those things. And I for se several of those things. And I for se several of those things. And I and I think that that's a good thing for and I think that that's a good thing for and I think that that's a good thing for those things, but it doesn't mean those things, but it doesn't mean those things, but it doesn't mean >> they're not root cause uh solutions. >> they're not root cause uh solutions. >> they're not root cause uh solutions. They are not root cause solutions. That They are not root cause solutions. That They are not root cause solutions. That that's correct. Um they are solutions that's correct. Um they are solutions that's correct. Um they are solutions for some people and I don't think we for some people and I don't think we for some people and I don't think we should um minimize that and like I said should um minimize that and like I said should um minimize that and like I said they are part of the bridge that's going they are part of the bridge that's going they are part of the bridge that's going to get us to what we need where we need to get us to what we need where we need to get us to what we need where we need to go with our food system. to go with our food system. to go with our food system. >> By this you mean like beriatric surgery >> By this you mean like beriatric surgery >> By this you mean like beriatric surgery or GLP1s. or GLP1s. or GLP1s. >> Yeah. Exactly. Like these are treatments >> Yeah. Exactly. Like these are treatments >> Yeah. Exactly. Like these are treatments for the ones the the folks who were most for the ones the the folks who were most for the ones the the folks who were most genetically susceptible to the genetically susceptible to the genetically susceptible to the environmental changes that have put in environmental changes that have put in environmental changes that have put in place the increase in obesity prevalence place the increase in obesity prevalence place the increase in obesity prevalence and the downstream uh consequences of and the downstream uh consequences of and the downstream uh consequences of that. We thankfully now have effective that. We thankfully now have effective that. We thankfully now have effective treatments and some of them can scale uh treatments and some of them can scale uh treatments and some of them can scale uh at a level that that will help many of at a level that that will help many of at a level that that will help many of those people. I think that's a great those people. I think that's a great those people. I think that's a great thing. But I think you're right to point thing. But I think you're right to point thing. But I think you're right to point out that funding to figure out what are out that funding to figure out what are out that funding to figure out what are how are we going to move past this and how are we going to move past this and how are we going to move past this and what was the cause of these problems in what was the cause of these problems in what was the cause of these problems in the first place. It's been underfunded the first place. It's been underfunded the first place. It's been underfunded and nutrition science in particular has and nutrition science in particular has and nutrition science in particular has been underfunded. Um and I think it's been underfunded. Um and I think it's been underfunded. Um and I think it's tragic and you know I experienced that tragic and you know I experienced that tragic and you know I experienced that even in the last administration what we even in the last administration what we even in the last administration what we what we uh after we had this big paper what we uh after we had this big paper what we uh after we had this big paper on ultrarocessed foods come out showing on ultrarocessed foods come out showing on ultrarocessed foods come out showing that that that >> when people are exposed to environments >> when people are exposed to environments >> when people are exposed to environments with lots of ultrarocessed foods they with lots of ultrarocessed foods they with lots of ultrarocessed foods they ate many many more calories they ate many many more calories they ate many many more calories they spontaneously gained weight and gained spontaneously gained weight and gained spontaneously gained weight and gained body fat. body fat. body fat. >> Shocking that was the result >> Shocking that was the result >> Shocking that was the result >> and then shifting them to a minimally >> and then shifting them to a minimally >> and then shifting them to a minimally processed environment. Again these processed environment. Again these processed environment. Again these environments were matched for the number environments were matched for the number environments were matched for the number of calories that were presented to of calories that were presented to of calories that were presented to people. macronutrients, um the glycemic people. macronutrients, um the glycemic people. macronutrients, um the glycemic load and the fiber and um the sodium and load and the fiber and um the sodium and load and the fiber and um the sodium and yet yet yet >> and the nutritional dark matter which we >> and the nutritional dark matter which we >> and the nutritional dark matter which we haven't talked about which talk about um haven't talked about which talk about um haven't talked about which talk about um so that they've experienced this change so that they've experienced this change so that they've experienced this change in their food environment spontaneously in their food environment spontaneously in their food environment spontaneously just I just decided to eat less. I'm not just I just decided to eat less. I'm not just I just decided to eat less. I'm not trying to do anything just effortless trying to do anything just effortless trying to do anything just effortless shifts after that study came out and it shifts after that study came out and it shifts after that study came out and it garnered like way more attention than I garnered like way more attention than I garnered like way more attention than I thought it was going to get. um they thought it was going to get. um they thought it was going to get. um they wanted to close down the unit at the NIH wanted to close down the unit at the NIH wanted to close down the unit at the NIH >> and this was prior to 2020. This was >> and this was prior to 2020. This was >> and this was prior to 2020. This was before the Trump administration. This before the Trump administration. This before the Trump administration. This was 2019. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. was 2019. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. was 2019. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> So, the same year that that paper came >> So, the same year that that paper came >> So, the same year that that paper came out, um we were told by the CEO of the out, um we were told by the CEO of the out, um we were told by the CEO of the clinical center that they were going to clinical center that they were going to clinical center that they were going to close down the metabolic unit. I close down the metabolic unit. I close down the metabolic unit. I remember sitting in a in a room um and remember sitting in a in a room um and remember sitting in a in a room um and afterwards I said, you know, I I just I afterwards I said, you know, I I just I afterwards I said, you know, I I just I don't see how I can have any confidence don't see how I can have any confidence don't see how I can have any confidence that I can continue to do our studies if that I can continue to do our studies if that I can continue to do our studies if if this unit's closed. and he said, if this unit's closed. and he said, if this unit's closed. and he said, "Yeah, you shouldn't have any confidence "Yeah, you shouldn't have any confidence "Yeah, you shouldn't have any confidence that you can continue your studies." that you can continue your studies." that you can continue your studies." >> And what is your what is your theory of >> And what is your what is your theory of >> And what is your what is your theory of mind there? I mean, what what is the the mind there? I mean, what what is the the mind there? I mean, what what is the the the motivating the motivating the motivating >> the motivating fact was that, you know, >> the motivating fact was that, you know, >> the motivating fact was that, you know, I think he had um plans for that I think he had um plans for that I think he had um plans for that facility that he thought were better facility that he thought were better facility that he thought were better suited and we can have a debate about suited and we can have a debate about suited and we can have a debate about that and he was in a higher position at that and he was in a higher position at that and he was in a higher position at the NIH than I was. Um, and yeah, I the NIH than I was. Um, and yeah, I the NIH than I was. Um, and yeah, I think that there's several theories. I think that there's several theories. I think that there's several theories. I think he wanted to maybe set up an think he wanted to maybe set up an think he wanted to maybe set up an Alzheimer's unit. I'm not exactly sure Alzheimer's unit. I'm not exactly sure Alzheimer's unit. I'm not exactly sure what the different competing theories what the different competing theories what the different competing theories were. Um, but we could have a debate were. Um, but we could have a debate were. Um, but we could have a debate about that. But that was the debate was about that. But that was the debate was about that. But that was the debate was sort of shut down. I ended up finding sort of shut down. I ended up finding sort of shut down. I ended up finding out someone at a higher level at HHS who out someone at a higher level at HHS who out someone at a higher level at HHS who had read our paper and I said, "Hey, I had read our paper and I said, "Hey, I had read our paper and I said, "Hey, I heard you uh read our paper and we're heard you uh read our paper and we're heard you uh read our paper and we're intrigued by it's too bad we won't be intrigued by it's too bad we won't be intrigued by it's too bad we won't be able to figure out what the mechanisms able to figure out what the mechanisms able to figure out what the mechanisms were because the unit's going to get were because the unit's going to get were because the unit's going to get close." It's outrageous to me because close." It's outrageous to me because close." It's outrageous to me because like our entire uh you know epidemic of like our entire uh you know epidemic of like our entire uh you know epidemic of chronic lifestyle illness all tracks chronic lifestyle illness all tracks chronic lifestyle illness all tracks back to this, right? And not only is back to this, right? And not only is back to this, right? And not only is this driving all of these, you know, this driving all of these, you know, this driving all of these, you know, incredibly poor health outcomes and incredibly poor health outcomes and incredibly poor health outcomes and debilitating millions of people debilitating millions of people debilitating millions of people unnecessarily, unnecessarily, unnecessarily, >> it's at the root of what's, you know, >> it's at the root of what's, you know, >> it's at the root of what's, you know, ailing our health care system. like it's ailing our health care system. like it's ailing our health care system. like it's and it's so from an economic perspective and it's so from an economic perspective and it's so from an economic perspective >> uh which then becomes a national >> uh which then becomes a national >> uh which then becomes a national security issue like these are gigantic security issue like these are gigantic security issue like these are gigantic problems that need to get solved that problems that need to get solved that problems that need to get solved that are you know important for the kind of are you know important for the kind of are you know important for the kind of the sanctity of our you know our the sanctity of our you know our the sanctity of our you know our democratic union fund fundamentally like democratic union fund fundamentally like democratic union fund fundamentally like it's more than just people are getting it's more than just people are getting it's more than just people are getting sick like this is why healthcare is so sick like this is why healthcare is so sick like this is why healthcare is so expensive and so bureaucratic and so you expensive and so bureaucratic and so you expensive and so bureaucratic and so you know kind of overroought right now and know kind of overroought right now and know kind of overroought right now and we have to solve it if we want to figure we have to solve it if we want to figure we have to solve it if we want to figure out healthcare out healthcare out healthcare >> it completely completely agree. And so >> it completely completely agree. And so >> it completely completely agree. And so while we were successful at pushing back while we were successful at pushing back while we were successful at pushing back against that attempt at closing our against that attempt at closing our against that attempt at closing our unit, um so that's why, you know, in the unit, um so that's why, you know, in the unit, um so that's why, you know, in the run-up to this last election with the run-up to this last election with the run-up to this last election with the attention that this was receiving on attention that this was receiving on attention that this was receiving on both sides of the aisle, I was super both sides of the aisle, I was super both sides of the aisle, I was super excited, right? I thought excited, right? I thought excited, right? I thought >> was here comes a guy and he's he's >> was here comes a guy and he's he's >> was here comes a guy and he's he's talking about this stuff that I'm talking about this stuff that I'm talking about this stuff that I'm studying and that I care about. studying and that I care about. studying and that I care about. >> But prior to that, before we even get >> But prior to that, before we even get >> But prior to that, before we even get there on the timeline though, is it true there on the timeline though, is it true there on the timeline though, is it true that you almost got fired for writing that you almost got fired for writing that you almost got fired for writing this book? Like this is before the this book? Like this is before the this book? Like this is before the current administration, right? current administration, right? current administration, right? >> That is true. Also, >> That is true. Also, >> That is true. Also, >> what >> what >> what >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Like you're just a guy at NIH doing >> Like you're just a guy at NIH doing >> Like you're just a guy at NIH doing research on processed foods and research on processed foods and research on processed foods and metabolism. metabolism. metabolism. >> Yeah. No, that's true. >> Yeah. No, that's true. >> Yeah. No, that's true. >> What's the big threat? >> What's the big threat? >> What's the big threat? >> Um well, I think there's a couple >> Um well, I think there's a couple >> Um well, I think there's a couple things, right? And it was expressed to things, right? And it was expressed to things, right? And it was expressed to me that two two main concerns. Um one me that two two main concerns. Um one me that two two main concerns. Um one was that we have an entire chapter about was that we have an entire chapter about was that we have an entire chapter about policy. policy. policy. >> The NIH has always sort of prided itself >> The NIH has always sort of prided itself >> The NIH has always sort of prided itself as we provide the science. we don't as we provide the science. we don't as we provide the science. we don't appine about policy decisions, right? We appine about policy decisions, right? We appine about policy decisions, right? We don't want to get involved in policy don't want to get involved in policy don't want to get involved in policy decisions. Um and the second thing that decisions. Um and the second thing that decisions. Um and the second thing that they pointed out was that the other they pointed out was that the other they pointed out was that the other thing we point out is in the book thing we point out is in the book thing we point out is in the book there's a lot of I wouldn't say it's there's a lot of I wouldn't say it's there's a lot of I wouldn't say it's debunking but it's a lot of challenging debunking but it's a lot of challenging debunking but it's a lot of challenging of claims that various folks are making of claims that various folks are making of claims that various folks are making in different spaces like um the in different spaces like um the in different spaces like um the different diet communities the different different diet communities the different different diet communities the different folks who are um selling supplements who folks who are um selling supplements who folks who are um selling supplements who are selling uh precision nutrition are selling uh precision nutrition are selling uh precision nutrition programs and they didn't want push back programs and they didn't want push back programs and they didn't want push back from I see these folks you're a from I see these folks you're a from I see these folks you're a government employee. It's creating a government employee. It's creating a government employee. It's creating a it's creating a headache for them. it's creating a headache for them. it's creating a headache for them. >> Yeah. So, I initially said, "Look, well, >> Yeah. So, I initially said, "Look, well, >> Yeah. So, I initially said, "Look, well, what if I just kind of, you know, not what if I just kind of, you know, not what if I just kind of, you know, not put my affiliation on there?" And there put my affiliation on there?" And there put my affiliation on there?" And there was they they didn't agree to that. And was they they didn't agree to that. And was they they didn't agree to that. And they said, "No, if you're an author of they said, "No, if you're an author of they said, "No, if you're an author of the book, um you're going to be the book, um you're going to be the book, um you're going to be disciplined and and likely um removed disciplined and and likely um removed disciplined and and likely um removed from your position." And so I actually from your position." And so I actually from your position." And so I actually had to hire a lawyer who is well known had to hire a lawyer who is well known had to hire a lawyer who is well known for um he's well known for uh basically for um he's well known for uh basically for um he's well known for uh basically representing clients who write write representing clients who write write representing clients who write write books after they leave the national books after they leave the national books after they leave the national security space. And he's like are you security space. And he's like are you security space. And he's like are you trying to like reveal some com like trying to like reveal some com like trying to like reveal some com like classified information like I'm like no classified information like I'm like no classified information like I'm like no and he's like I don't understand it. and he's like I don't understand it. and he's like I don't understand it. This is the most bizarre thing he's ever This is the most bizarre thing he's ever This is the most bizarre thing he's ever seen. Anyway, he was able to kind of seen. Anyway, he was able to kind of seen. Anyway, he was able to kind of >> uh basically get the NIH to ascent to >> uh basically get the NIH to ascent to >> uh basically get the NIH to ascent to letting me be a co-author of this book. letting me be a co-author of this book. letting me be a co-author of this book. And um and by the way, keep your job. And um and by the way, keep your job. And um and by the way, keep your job. Keep my job, right? Which I've since Keep my job, right? Which I've since Keep my job, right? Which I've since left, which is which is the other part left, which is which is the other part left, which is which is the other part of the story, right? So, so yeah, so I of the story, right? So, so yeah, so I of the story, right? So, so yeah, so I guess the the point was is that, you guess the the point was is that, you guess the the point was is that, you know, after that was resolved and I know, after that was resolved and I know, after that was resolved and I thought I would be continuing at the thought I would be continuing at the thought I would be continuing at the NIH, I and this new administration was NIH, I and this new administration was NIH, I and this new administration was coming in and that there was bipartisan coming in and that there was bipartisan coming in and that there was bipartisan support for finally kind of investing in support for finally kind of investing in support for finally kind of investing in in understanding what's going on in in in understanding what's going on in in in understanding what's going on in in tackling these issues of diet related tackling these issues of diet related tackling these issues of diet related chronic disease and ultrarocessed foods. chronic disease and ultrarocessed foods. chronic disease and ultrarocessed foods. you know, I I was very excited about you know, I I was very excited about you know, I I was very excited about this and in fact, I started working with this and in fact, I started working with this and in fact, I started working with um the director of the NIH um office for um the director of the NIH um office for um the director of the NIH um office for nutrition research about, you know, nutrition research about, you know, nutrition research about, you know, we've been doing art studies um which we've been doing art studies um which we've been doing art studies um which are pretty small scale. They take years are pretty small scale. They take years are pretty small scale. They take years to complete because we can only house to complete because we can only house to complete because we can only house two or three people at at a time. What two or three people at at a time. What two or three people at at a time. What if we had facilities for other if we had facilities for other if we had facilities for other researchers where we could house people researchers where we could house people researchers where we could house people for more comfortably, not in a hospital, for more comfortably, not in a hospital, for more comfortably, not in a hospital, and keep dozens of people at a time, um and keep dozens of people at a time, um and keep dozens of people at a time, um get answers to these questions that the get answers to these questions that the get answers to these questions that the American people deserve in a matter of American people deserve in a matter of American people deserve in a matter of months rather than years. And we could months rather than years. And we could months rather than years. And we could cycle through different hypotheses and cycle through different hypotheses and cycle through different hypotheses and different mechanisms that we were different mechanisms that we were different mechanisms that we were studying. And we started to work on a studying. And we started to work on a studying. And we started to work on a plan of how how we would do this. and plan of how how we would do this. and plan of how how we would do this. and and I was trying to contact members of and I was trying to contact members of and I was trying to contact members of uh the the Maha kind of leadership to uh the the Maha kind of leadership to uh the the Maha kind of leadership to talk about this, but they were too busy talk about this, but they were too busy talk about this, but they were too busy talking to social media influencers at talking to social media influencers at talking to social media influencers at the time. the time. the time. >> But, you know, we're plugging along >> But, you know, we're plugging along >> But, you know, we're plugging along doing our work. Eventually, I wanted to doing our work. Eventually, I wanted to doing our work. Eventually, I wanted to be able to kind of present this this be able to kind of present this this be able to kind of present this this sort of plan to folks. And you know in sort of plan to folks. And you know in sort of plan to folks. And you know in that transition period um after the new that transition period um after the new that transition period um after the new administration took over uh we started administration took over uh we started administration took over uh we started to see that certain topics were deemed to see that certain topics were deemed to see that certain topics were deemed sufficiently politically interesting sufficiently politically interesting sufficiently politically interesting that any sort of work that would be you that any sort of work that would be you that any sort of work that would be you know communicating results um going to know communicating results um going to know communicating results um going to conferences conferences conferences any new programs had to kind of go up to any new programs had to kind of go up to any new programs had to kind of go up to the level of the department of health the level of the department of health the level of the department of health and human services and be approved at by and human services and be approved at by and human services and be approved at by a political appointee. a political appointee. a political appointee. And uh and so I started to experience And uh and so I started to experience And uh and so I started to experience this directly. The the first occasion this directly. The the first occasion this directly. The the first occasion was I I was uh supposed to give a talk was I I was uh supposed to give a talk was I I was uh supposed to give a talk at the Bloomberg Philanthropies annual at the Bloomberg Philanthropies annual at the Bloomberg Philanthropies annual meeting about some of our work on meeting about some of our work on meeting about some of our work on ultrarocessed foods and you know for the ultrarocessed foods and you know for the ultrarocessed foods and you know for the first time in first time in first time in at that time 21 years at the NIH I was at that time 21 years at the NIH I was at that time 21 years at the NIH I was denied denied denied >> the opportunity to give a talk at the >> the opportunity to give a talk at the >> the opportunity to give a talk at the conference. Now, it was unclear exactly conference. Now, it was unclear exactly conference. Now, it was unclear exactly at the time, was this because of travel at the time, was this because of travel at the time, was this because of travel restrictions? And so, I went back to the restrictions? And so, I went back to the restrictions? And so, I went back to the Bloomberg folks and said, "Could I do Bloomberg folks and said, "Could I do Bloomberg folks and said, "Could I do this remotely? Would you mind if I this remotely? Would you mind if I this remotely? Would you mind if I they're like, "Yeah, no problem." So, re they're like, "Yeah, no problem." So, re they're like, "Yeah, no problem." So, re uh requested the ability to do this. uh requested the ability to do this. uh requested the ability to do this. Still denied. Um and this was at a time Still denied. Um and this was at a time Still denied. Um and this was at a time when my colleagues were being allowed to when my colleagues were being allowed to when my colleagues were being allowed to give talks, especially remote talks. So give talks, especially remote talks. So give talks, especially remote talks. So there was something special about um the there was something special about um the there was something special about um the results that we were trying to present results that we were trying to present results that we were trying to present that was being you know suppressed in that was being you know suppressed in that was being you know suppressed in this way. We were interested in the this way. We were interested in the this way. We were interested in the question do does ingestion of question do does ingestion of question do does ingestion of ultrarocessed foods hijack the brain's ultrarocessed foods hijack the brain's ultrarocessed foods hijack the brain's reward system in the same way that reward system in the same way that reward system in the same way that cocaine does. I guess the question is um cocaine does. I guess the question is um cocaine does. I guess the question is um addiction doesn't necessarily have to addiction doesn't necessarily have to addiction doesn't necessarily have to occur through this particular biological occur through this particular biological occur through this particular biological pathway. pathway. pathway. >> Okay. Yes. This has been a common >> Okay. Yes. This has been a common >> Okay. Yes. This has been a common phenomena in that drugs like cocaine and phenomena in that drugs like cocaine and phenomena in that drugs like cocaine and methamphetamine even nicotine cause an methamphetamine even nicotine cause an methamphetamine even nicotine cause an outsized surge in dopamine in the brain outsized surge in dopamine in the brain outsized surge in dopamine in the brain which leads to a bunch of adaptations which leads to a bunch of adaptations which leads to a bunch of adaptations uh that that can lead to addiction. Um uh that that can lead to addiction. Um uh that that can lead to addiction. Um there's a very long history even in the there's a very long history even in the there's a very long history even in the obesity space of looking at neuroiming obesity space of looking at neuroiming obesity space of looking at neuroiming studies of the brains and dopamine studies of the brains and dopamine studies of the brains and dopamine receptors um in people with obesity and receptors um in people with obesity and receptors um in people with obesity and people who are lean and saying hey look people who are lean and saying hey look people who are lean and saying hey look the brains of people with obesity look the brains of people with obesity look the brains of people with obesity look more like uh people who've been addicted more like uh people who've been addicted more like uh people who've been addicted to cocaine than the folks who are lean. to cocaine than the folks who are lean. to cocaine than the folks who are lean. Um and so there is this particular Um and so there is this particular Um and so there is this particular neurobiological mechanism of addiction neurobiological mechanism of addiction neurobiological mechanism of addiction which is well understood with cocaine. which is well understood with cocaine. which is well understood with cocaine. Um but it's always been hypothetical Um but it's always been hypothetical Um but it's always been hypothetical when it comes to food addiction. And so when it comes to food addiction. And so when it comes to food addiction. And so that's the reason you do research in that's the reason you do research in that's the reason you do research in this area, this area, this area, >> right? So let's look at it, figure out >> right? So let's look at it, figure out >> right? So let's look at it, figure out if that's truly the case. if that's truly the case. if that's truly the case. >> Exactly. And so what we found in this >> Exactly. And so what we found in this >> Exactly. And so what we found in this study, it was a very large study, the study, it was a very large study, the study, it was a very large study, the largest study of its kind. And it was largest study of its kind. And it was largest study of its kind. And it was designed to assess the question of designed to assess the question of designed to assess the question of whether or not people with obesity have whether or not people with obesity have whether or not people with obesity have the same sort of adaptations that uh in the same sort of adaptations that uh in the same sort of adaptations that uh in dopamine receptors that you see in dopamine receptors that you see in dopamine receptors that you see in people who are addicted to drugs over people who are addicted to drugs over people who are addicted to drugs over the long term, implying that people with the long term, implying that people with the long term, implying that people with obesity might be more likely to have obesity might be more likely to have obesity might be more likely to have food addiction. And secondly, whether or food addiction. And secondly, whether or food addiction. And secondly, whether or not they we they see this outsized not they we they see this outsized not they we they see this outsized dopamine response um similar to cocaine dopamine response um similar to cocaine dopamine response um similar to cocaine ingestion and is that different between ingestion and is that different between ingestion and is that different between lean and obese people. And uh we did not lean and obese people. And uh we did not lean and obese people. And uh we did not see that latter effect. And so we wrote see that latter effect. And so we wrote see that latter effect. And so we wrote this paper and um the paper was written this paper and um the paper was written this paper and um the paper was written and submitted before the administration and submitted before the administration and submitted before the administration came in. It was accepted for came in. It was accepted for came in. It was accepted for publication. We were starting to to um publication. We were starting to to um publication. We were starting to to um want to talk about it at conferences. want to talk about it at conferences. want to talk about it at conferences. And so you're right that it was And so you're right that it was And so you're right that it was perceived I believe by folks at perceived I believe by folks at perceived I believe by folks at political level at HHS as saying I don't political level at HHS as saying I don't political level at HHS as saying I don't need to think about it. I know that they need to think about it. I know that they need to think about it. I know that they called a reporter from the New York called a reporter from the New York called a reporter from the New York Times the communications director and Times the communications director and Times the communications director and said the results of this t paper don't said the results of this t paper don't said the results of this t paper don't match RFK Jr.'s um thoughts about match RFK Jr.'s um thoughts about match RFK Jr.'s um thoughts about ultrarocessed foods. ultrarocessed foods. ultrarocessed foods. >> It was politically inconvenient and so >> It was politically inconvenient and so >> It was politically inconvenient and so they interfered with your ability to they interfered with your ability to they interfered with your ability to have a press release and to speak to the have a press release and to speak to the have a press release and to speak to the New York Times about this. New York Times about this. New York Times about this. >> Correct. and and they edited my answers >> Correct. and and they edited my answers >> Correct. and and they edited my answers to the reporter's questions. to the reporter's questions. to the reporter's questions. >> Written responses where they >> Written responses where they >> Written responses where they editorialized what you had to say editorialized what you had to say editorialized what you had to say without giving you the opportunity to without giving you the opportunity to without giving you the opportunity to >> Well, no, actually actually saying that >> Well, no, actually actually saying that >> Well, no, actually actually saying that I wrote it. I wrote it. I wrote it. >> Oh, really? >> Oh, really? >> Oh, really? >> Yes. It was attributed to >> Yes. It was attributed to >> Yes. It was attributed to >> It was provided to them in your words. >> It was provided to them in your words. >> It was provided to them in your words. Were you able to get a correction from Were you able to get a correction from Were you able to get a correction from the New York Times out of that? the New York Times out of that? the New York Times out of that? >> Um, no. I I was in communication with >> Um, no. I I was in communication with >> Um, no. I I was in communication with the reporter for the New York Times. So the reporter for the New York Times. So the reporter for the New York Times. So I I just made sure that she quoted only I I just made sure that she quoted only I I just made sure that she quoted only from the sections that I had written, from the sections that I had written, from the sections that I had written, not the not the embellished sections not the not the embellished sections not the not the embellished sections that downplayed the study. So So yeah, that downplayed the study. So So yeah, that downplayed the study. So So yeah, this was like direct interference with this was like direct interference with this was like direct interference with the ability to communicate these the ability to communicate these the ability to communicate these results. And so at the time they're results. And so at the time they're results. And so at the time they're trying to get as many people to leave trying to get as many people to leave trying to get as many people to leave the NIH as possible and they put up this the NIH as possible and they put up this the NIH as possible and they put up this um early retirement option several weeks um early retirement option several weeks um early retirement option several weeks later. And so after experience later. And so after experience later. And so after experience >> this was like in the middle of Doge. >> this was like in the middle of Doge. >> this was like in the middle of Doge. >> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. and and you know we >> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. and and you know we >> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. and and you know we had ongoing studies and um you know had ongoing studies and um you know had ongoing studies and um you know again I was I wanted to kind of talk again I was I wanted to kind of talk again I was I wanted to kind of talk about the plans for what we how could we about the plans for what we how could we about the plans for what we how could we improve this situation that I'm improve this situation that I'm improve this situation that I'm completely aligned with the you know the completely aligned with the you know the completely aligned with the you know the the goal to make America healthy again the goal to make America healthy again the goal to make America healthy again that ultrarocessed foods we need to that ultrarocessed foods we need to that ultrarocessed foods we need to better understand how they might work better understand how they might work better understand how they might work and and what the mechanisms are and so I and and what the mechanisms are and so I and and what the mechanisms are and so I wrote I wrote to RFK Jr. his senior wrote I wrote to RFK Jr. his senior wrote I wrote to RFK Jr. his senior staff. I wrote to the NIH director and staff. I wrote to the NIH director and staff. I wrote to the NIH director and and said, "Look, here's the what what and said, "Look, here's the what what and said, "Look, here's the what what I've experienced at that time. We I've experienced at that time. We I've experienced at that time. We actually also weren't able to buy food actually also weren't able to buy food actually also weren't able to buy food for our research participants. We for our research participants. We for our research participants. We couldn't buy research supplies. We couldn't buy research supplies. We couldn't buy research supplies. We weren't able to rehire um people who um weren't able to rehire um people who um weren't able to rehire um people who um were leaving on a regular basis that run were leaving on a regular basis that run were leaving on a regular basis that run our studies. It was like a very bleak our studies. It was like a very bleak our studies. It was like a very bleak time. Um fortunately, some of those time. Um fortunately, some of those time. Um fortunately, some of those things have turned around a little bit things have turned around a little bit things have turned around a little bit at the NIH. They're still experiencing at the NIH. They're still experiencing at the NIH. They're still experiencing some of these difficulties. purchasing some of these difficulties. purchasing some of these difficulties. purchasing research supplies for example still to research supplies for example still to research supplies for example still to this day but we were experiencing really this day but we were experiencing really this day but we were experiencing really acute problems then so I was and I've acute problems then so I was and I've acute problems then so I was and I've been talking with our scientific been talking with our scientific been talking with our scientific leadership like what's what's going to leadership like what's what's going to leadership like what's what's going to happen here um right around that time it happen here um right around that time it happen here um right around that time it had leaked that there's going to be a had leaked that there's going to be a had leaked that there's going to be a 40% cut to the NIH budget and very dire 40% cut to the NIH budget and very dire 40% cut to the NIH budget and very dire times so I I wrote to these folks and times so I I wrote to these folks and times so I I wrote to these folks and said look not only are we experiencing said look not only are we experiencing said look not only are we experiencing these problems but you know we're these problems but you know we're these problems but you know we're totally aligned and we can make a lot of totally aligned and we can make a lot of totally aligned and we can make a lot of progress in fact I told them about this progress in fact I told them about this progress in fact I told them about this ongoing studies, how we're making ongoing studies, how we're making ongoing studies, how we're making progress understanding mechanisms of progress understanding mechanisms of progress understanding mechanisms of ultrarocessed foods. Why do they make ultrarocessed foods. Why do they make ultrarocessed foods. Why do they make people overeat? Um that we'd been able people overeat? Um that we'd been able people overeat? Um that we'd been able to redesign an ultrarocessed diet that to redesign an ultrarocessed diet that to redesign an ultrarocessed diet that was still 80% of calories from was still 80% of calories from was still 80% of calories from ultrarocessed foods that didn't actually ultrarocessed foods that didn't actually ultrarocessed foods that didn't actually cause people to overeat um by focusing cause people to overeat um by focusing cause people to overeat um by focusing on mechanisms that we could do a lot on mechanisms that we could do a lot on mechanisms that we could do a lot more in the future if we kind of engaged more in the future if we kind of engaged more in the future if we kind of engaged in this plan. and I sent them the copy in this plan. and I sent them the copy in this plan. and I sent them the copy of the plan, you know, actually of the plan, you know, actually of the plan, you know, actually requested a meeting and I basically said requested a meeting and I basically said requested a meeting and I basically said other, you know, otherwise I I can't see other, you know, otherwise I I can't see other, you know, otherwise I I can't see how we can continue uh research in this how we can continue uh research in this how we can continue uh research in this space and, you know, I'm going to space and, you know, I'm going to space and, you know, I'm going to prepare to to retire through this prepare to to retire through this prepare to to retire through this program. And so I didn't hear anything program. And so I didn't hear anything program. And so I didn't hear anything as a result of that except a colleague as a result of that except a colleague as a result of that except a colleague of mine said, "Hey, are you really going of mine said, "Hey, are you really going of mine said, "Hey, are you really going to retire?" And I'm like, "Possibly. How to retire?" And I'm like, "Possibly. How to retire?" And I'm like, "Possibly. How do you know?" and he said, "Well, this do you know?" and he said, "Well, this do you know?" and he said, "Well, this your email was circulated among senior your email was circulated among senior your email was circulated among senior staff at NIH." And so, someone read it, staff at NIH." And so, someone read it, staff at NIH." And so, someone read it, but nobody reached back out to me. So, I but nobody reached back out to me. So, I but nobody reached back out to me. So, I spent the next weeks kind of reassigning spent the next weeks kind of reassigning spent the next weeks kind of reassigning staff and reassigning my clinical staff and reassigning my clinical staff and reassigning my clinical protocols and closing down a 20-year protocols and closing down a 20-year protocols and closing down a 20-year career at the NIH because I didn't see a career at the NIH because I didn't see a career at the NIH because I didn't see a way to kind of move forward if we're way to kind of move forward if we're way to kind of move forward if we're going to be interfered with in this going to be interfered with in this going to be interfered with in this process and that there was no interest process and that there was no interest process and that there was no interest in engaging in this topic. um at the in engaging in this topic. um at the in engaging in this topic. um at the same time that they're holding, you same time that they're holding, you same time that they're holding, you know, meetings with folks drinking raw know, meetings with folks drinking raw know, meetings with folks drinking raw milk in the White House. milk in the White House. milk in the White House. >> I mean, it's just unfortunate because, >> I mean, it's just unfortunate because, >> I mean, it's just unfortunate because, you know, there is a lot of energy you know, there is a lot of energy you know, there is a lot of energy around ultrarocessed foods and and around ultrarocessed foods and and around ultrarocessed foods and and what's happening there and you know, what's happening there and you know, what's happening there and you know, he's you know, very much a flash point he's you know, very much a flash point he's you know, very much a flash point and drawing attention to this and you and drawing attention to this and you and drawing attention to this and you know, and that's a good thing uh writ know, and that's a good thing uh writ know, and that's a good thing uh writ large and he you could have been this large and he you could have been this large and he you could have been this ally like you're the guy who's looking ally like you're the guy who's looking ally like you're the guy who's looking at this more closely than anybody else. at this more closely than anybody else. at this more closely than anybody else. It's like it just like it it's confusing It's like it just like it it's confusing It's like it just like it it's confusing why there couldn't, you know, be some why there couldn't, you know, be some why there couldn't, you know, be some kind of consensus about how to move kind of consensus about how to move kind of consensus about how to move forward together on this. forward together on this. forward together on this. >> Yeah. And even more disappointing and I >> Yeah. And even more disappointing and I >> Yeah. And even more disappointing and I think one of the things that solidified think one of the things that solidified think one of the things that solidified why I think I made the right decision why I think I made the right decision why I think I made the right decision because obviously I agree with you and I because obviously I agree with you and I because obviously I agree with you and I think that, you know, we could have made think that, you know, we could have made think that, you know, we could have made a lot of progress, you know, after I a lot of progress, you know, after I a lot of progress, you know, after I left and it made a little bit of, you left and it made a little bit of, you left and it made a little bit of, you know, press coverage. know, press coverage. know, press coverage. >> Yeah, there was a there was actually a >> Yeah, there was a there was actually a >> Yeah, there was a there was actually a lot. Yeah, there was lot. Yeah, there was lot. Yeah, there was >> you were you were that must have been >> you were you were that must have been >> you were you were that must have been strange for you, you know, a scientist strange for you, you know, a scientist strange for you, you know, a scientist at NIH. Suddenly, you know, Jake Tapper at NIH. Suddenly, you know, Jake Tapper at NIH. Suddenly, you know, Jake Tapper is talking about you and you're just is talking about you and you're just is talking about you and you're just kind of everywhere. kind of everywhere. kind of everywhere. >> Well, the the interesting thing about >> Well, the the interesting thing about >> Well, the the interesting thing about the So, the day that I talked with Jake the So, the day that I talked with Jake the So, the day that I talked with Jake Tapper earlier that morning, I met with Tapper earlier that morning, I met with Tapper earlier that morning, I met with the NIH director, the new NIH director, the NIH director, the new NIH director, the NIH director, the new NIH director, >> Jay Bacharia. >> Jay Bacharia. >> Jay Bacharia. >> J Bacharia. Yeah. So, he saw the New >> J Bacharia. Yeah. So, he saw the New >> J Bacharia. Yeah. So, he saw the New York Times article that came out like I York Times article that came out like I York Times article that came out like I think the day or two before that, think the day or two before that, think the day or two before that, >> and he said he wanted to meet with me. >> and he said he wanted to meet with me. >> and he said he wanted to meet with me. And so I went back to the NIH and he And so I went back to the NIH and he And so I went back to the NIH and he wanted to know what happened and I was wanted to know what happened and I was wanted to know what happened and I was there with him and the deputy director there with him and the deputy director there with him and the deputy director for intramural research. Intramural for intramural research. Intramural for intramural research. Intramural research is the the part of the NIH that research is the the part of the NIH that research is the the part of the NIH that does their own studies. Extramural is does their own studies. Extramural is does their own studies. Extramural is the granting part of the NIH. So this the granting part of the NIH. So this the granting part of the NIH. So this was basically my boss's boss's boss was basically my boss's boss's boss was basically my boss's boss's boss >> and the NIH director. And you know he >> and the NIH director. And you know he >> and the NIH director. And you know he was interested in the censorship thing was interested in the censorship thing was interested in the censorship thing because he feels like he was censored because he feels like he was censored because he feels like he was censored during COVID and it was clear he could during COVID and it was clear he could during COVID and it was clear he could probably have talked the entire meeting probably have talked the entire meeting probably have talked the entire meeting about that. But I I about that. But I I about that. But I I tried to transition and he told me he tried to transition and he told me he tried to transition and he told me he had not seen my email. And I believed had not seen my email. And I believed had not seen my email. And I believed him. I mean, he was new to the job. him. I mean, he was new to the job. him. I mean, he was new to the job. Somebody probably saw it in his staff, Somebody probably saw it in his staff, Somebody probably saw it in his staff, but I believed him when he said he but I believed him when he said he but I believed him when he said he hadn't seen my email. And what I wanted hadn't seen my email. And what I wanted hadn't seen my email. And what I wanted to focus attention on was what about to focus attention on was what about to focus attention on was what about this plan? like you know uh the purpose this plan? like you know uh the purpose this plan? like you know uh the purpose of my email was yeah I wanted to tell of my email was yeah I wanted to tell of my email was yeah I wanted to tell you about the troubles that we were you about the troubles that we were you about the troubles that we were experiencing and the censorship and experiencing and the censorship and experiencing and the censorship and whatnot but the main part was could we whatnot but the main part was could we whatnot but the main part was could we get on the same page and actually get on the same page and actually get on the same page and actually improve the science to investigate this improve the science to investigate this improve the science to investigate this to give the an you know get the answers to give the an you know get the answers to give the an you know get the answers that the American people deserve and that the American people deserve and that the American people deserve and there you're right there is so much there you're right there is so much there you're right there is so much passion about this issue right now passion about this issue right now passion about this issue right now >> and it had been clear that he saw you >> and it had been clear that he saw you >> and it had been clear that he saw you know the email that I wrote and he he'd know the email that I wrote and he he'd know the email that I wrote and he he'd saw the plan and he said, "Yeah, I'd saw the plan and he said, "Yeah, I'd saw the plan and he said, "Yeah, I'd really like to work with you on this." really like to work with you on this." really like to work with you on this." And he he shook my hand and he said, And he he shook my hand and he said, And he he shook my hand and he said, "Welcome back." "Welcome back." "Welcome back." And I said, "Um, well, I'm not back yet. And I said, "Um, well, I'm not back yet. And I said, "Um, well, I'm not back yet. I've got nothing to go back to, right? I've got nothing to go back to, right? I've got nothing to go back to, right? My lab has been closed. My staff has My lab has been closed. My staff has My lab has been closed. My staff has been reassigned. My protocols are being been reassigned. My protocols are being been reassigned. My protocols are being run by other investigators, but I'd be run by other investigators, but I'd be run by other investigators, but I'd be really interested in working on this really interested in working on this really interested in working on this with you." And he said, "Okay, we'll with you." And he said, "Okay, we'll with you." And he said, "Okay, we'll talk to um Nenah and we'll figure talk to um Nenah and we'll figure talk to um Nenah and we'll figure something out." and and I got back in something out." and and I got back in something out." and and I got back in touch with the the director of the touch with the the director of the touch with the the director of the office of human nutrition research and office of human nutrition research and office of human nutrition research and we continued to work on this program. He we continued to work on this program. He we continued to work on this program. He presented it again at the NIH. We were presented it again at the NIH. We were presented it again at the NIH. We were talking about funding for a facility, talking about funding for a facility, talking about funding for a facility, maybe even located at the USDA maybe even located at the USDA maybe even located at the USDA Beltsville facility which was slated to Beltsville facility which was slated to Beltsville facility which was slated to be closed. They have a big metabolic be closed. They have a big metabolic be closed. They have a big metabolic kitchen and and buildings that could be kitchen and and buildings that could be kitchen and and buildings that could be renovated. renovated. renovated. >> And I was I thought I was going back. I >> And I was I thought I was going back. I >> And I was I thought I was going back. I was pretty sure was pretty sure was pretty sure >> the director of the NIH basically said, >> the director of the NIH basically said, >> the director of the NIH basically said, "Welcome back." I mean, if he can't hire "Welcome back." I mean, if he can't hire "Welcome back." I mean, if he can't hire you back. Yeah. It's like, if he can't you back. Yeah. It's like, if he can't you back. Yeah. It's like, if he can't hire you back, I mean, who who's going hire you back, I mean, who who's going hire you back, I mean, who who's going to So, for weeks, um, you know, I was to So, for weeks, um, you know, I was to So, for weeks, um, you know, I was working with, uh, Drew at the office of working with, uh, Drew at the office of working with, uh, Drew at the office of nutrition research and the intramural nutrition research and the intramural nutrition research and the intramural um, you know, the deputy director for um, you know, the deputy director for um, you know, the deputy director for intramural research and kind of putting intramural research and kind of putting intramural research and kind of putting together this this plan of what we would together this this plan of what we would together this this plan of what we would do. And then out of out of the clear do. And then out of out of the clear do. And then out of out of the clear blue sky, Drew calls me up one day and blue sky, Drew calls me up one day and blue sky, Drew calls me up one day and he said, "I don't know what happened, he said, "I don't know what happened, he said, "I don't know what happened, but it's it's killed. We're not doing but it's it's killed. We're not doing but it's it's killed. We're not doing this." He had no explanation. He said, this." He had no explanation. He said, this." He had no explanation. He said, "I tried to get an explanation, but I "I tried to get an explanation, but I "I tried to get an explanation, but I couldn't get one." He said, "The closest couldn't get one." He said, "The closest couldn't get one." He said, "The closest thing that I can think about is that, thing that I can think about is that, thing that I can think about is that, you know, this is personal. It has to do you know, this is personal. It has to do you know, this is personal. It has to do with you." And I'm like, "Well, that with you." And I'm like, "Well, that with you." And I'm like, "Well, that doesn't make any sense because if they doesn't make any sense because if they doesn't make any sense because if they wanted to make it personal, they would wanted to make it personal, they would wanted to make it personal, they would do it and then not hire me back, right? do it and then not hire me back, right? do it and then not hire me back, right? that would be the biggest, you know, way that would be the biggest, you know, way that would be the biggest, you know, way to get back at me. I don't understand to get back at me. I don't understand to get back at me. I don't understand what happened, but apparently somebody what happened, but apparently somebody what happened, but apparently somebody decided for whatever reason and still decided for whatever reason and still decided for whatever reason and still has not been made clear that, you know, has not been made clear that, you know, has not been made clear that, you know, actually investing in this research to actually investing in this research to actually investing in this research to better understand, you know, how our better understand, you know, how our better understand, you know, how our diets and our food environments affect diets and our food environments affect diets and our food environments affect um diet related chronic disease was not um diet related chronic disease was not um diet related chronic disease was not sufficient sufficient sufficient of interest to actually fund that of interest to actually fund that of interest to actually fund that research. you know, the what I've sort research. you know, the what I've sort research. you know, the what I've sort of interpreted this as, and since we've of interpreted this as, and since we've of interpreted this as, and since we've sort of seen other examples of this, is sort of seen other examples of this, is sort of seen other examples of this, is that um science only complicates that um science only complicates that um science only complicates rhetoric, right? It it only introduces rhetoric, right? It it only introduces rhetoric, right? It it only introduces complexity and nuance. And when you're complexity and nuance. And when you're complexity and nuance. And when you're trying to make a case for something, trying to make a case for something, trying to make a case for something, especially if you're kind of come at it, especially if you're kind of come at it, especially if you're kind of come at it, you're a lawyer, you know this, you you you're a lawyer, you know this, you you you're a lawyer, you know this, you you want to come at it with, you know, the want to come at it with, you know, the want to come at it with, you know, the strongest possible case and rhetoric strongest possible case and rhetoric strongest possible case and rhetoric that you can that you can come at it that you can that you can come at it that you can that you can come at it with. And you want to downplay evidence with. And you want to downplay evidence with. And you want to downplay evidence that might introduce that nuance and that might introduce that nuance and that might introduce that nuance and suggest it maybe isn't so reliable and suggest it maybe isn't so reliable and suggest it maybe isn't so reliable and and upplay evidence that is really and upplay evidence that is really and upplay evidence that is really supporting your side. And doing really supporting your side. And doing really supporting your side. And doing really good science can only potentially good science can only potentially good science can only potentially complicate your narrative. And a complicate your narrative. And a complicate your narrative. And a complicated narrative is more difficult complicated narrative is more difficult complicated narrative is more difficult to get action on than a simple to get action on than a simple to get action on than a simple narrative. And my view has been that um narrative. And my view has been that um narrative. And my view has been that um unfortunately this administration views unfortunately this administration views unfortunately this administration views science as a complicating factor getting science as a complicating factor getting science as a complicating factor getting in the way of what they want to achieve in the way of what they want to achieve in the way of what they want to achieve as opposed to as opposed to as opposed to >> I mean the most charitable inter that's >> I mean the most charitable inter that's >> I mean the most charitable inter that's that's a very charitable interpretation. that's a very charitable interpretation. that's a very charitable interpretation. The most charitable would be listen we The most charitable would be listen we The most charitable would be listen we really want to solve this problem but we really want to solve this problem but we really want to solve this problem but we have to have these reductive talking have to have these reductive talking have to have these reductive talking points and we can't have anything points and we can't have anything points and we can't have anything compromising that because that will compromising that because that will compromising that because that will distract from the solution. The less distract from the solution. The less distract from the solution. The less charitable interpretation is that you're charitable interpretation is that you're charitable interpretation is that you're a political liability. Yeah. a political liability. Yeah. a political liability. Yeah. >> Because objectivity is in opposition to >> Because objectivity is in opposition to >> Because objectivity is in opposition to the political aims. the political aims. the political aims. >> And when it comes to your solutions, >> And when it comes to your solutions, >> And when it comes to your solutions, your systemic solutions, there are cross your systemic solutions, there are cross your systemic solutions, there are cross purposes with the deregulation mandate purposes with the deregulation mandate purposes with the deregulation mandate of the administration outside of HHS. of the administration outside of HHS. of the administration outside of HHS. >> Yeah. And that's a huge challenge for >> Yeah. And that's a huge challenge for >> Yeah. And that's a huge challenge for them, right? is that there there is a them, right? is that there there is a them, right? is that there there is a presidential executive order that for presidential executive order that for presidential executive order that for every new regulation you have to remove every new regulation you have to remove every new regulation you have to remove 10 others, right? So, how are you going 10 others, right? So, how are you going 10 others, right? So, how are you going to introduce new regulations on food if to introduce new regulations on food if to introduce new regulations on food if you have to remove 10 other ones at the you have to remove 10 other ones at the you have to remove 10 other ones at the same time? And I think that that's part same time? And I think that that's part same time? And I think that that's part of the the the other thing and I know of the the the other thing and I know of the the the other thing and I know Jessica Nurk talked at length about this Jessica Nurk talked at length about this Jessica Nurk talked at length about this is that the rhetoric doesn't match the is that the rhetoric doesn't match the is that the rhetoric doesn't match the actions. Right. So, actions. Right. So, actions. Right. So, >> right. It's you guys agree on the fact >> right. It's you guys agree on the fact >> right. It's you guys agree on the fact that that Maha is identifying the that that Maha is identifying the that that Maha is identifying the problem correctly. It's just that problem correctly. It's just that problem correctly. It's just that there's uh you know a difference of there's uh you know a difference of there's uh you know a difference of opinion when it comes to solutions here, opinion when it comes to solutions here, opinion when it comes to solutions here, >> right? And that I'm a firm believer that >> right? And that I'm a firm believer that >> right? And that I'm a firm believer that science is the best thing that humans science is the best thing that humans science is the best thing that humans have come up with to get closer to the have come up with to get closer to the have come up with to get closer to the truth and science-based kind of policies truth and science-based kind of policies truth and science-based kind of policies are the best thing that we can have to are the best thing that we can have to are the best thing that we can have to actually improve the situation. And so actually improve the situation. And so actually improve the situation. And so we need to invest in the science in we need to invest in the science in we need to invest in the science in order to improve the situation. And if order to improve the situation. And if order to improve the situation. And if you don't, if you just think that you you don't, if you just think that you you don't, if you just think that you have it all figured out and the history have it all figured out and the history have it all figured out and the history of nutrition and and food science has of nutrition and and food science has of nutrition and and food science has been a repeated on repeat as we discuss been a repeated on repeat as we discuss been a repeated on repeat as we discuss in the book, people thinking they've got in the book, people thinking they've got in the book, people thinking they've got it figured out and they come up with a it figured out and they come up with a it figured out and they come up with a very simple sort of narrative only to very simple sort of narrative only to very simple sort of narrative only to be, you know, fall apart when it's be, you know, fall apart when it's be, you know, fall apart when it's subjected to critical tests. And yes, subjected to critical tests. And yes, subjected to critical tests. And yes, we're making progress, but very often we're making progress, but very often we're making progress, but very often those simple narratives um fall apart uh those simple narratives um fall apart uh those simple narratives um fall apart uh when you subject them to test. I think when you subject them to test. I think when you subject them to test. I think that the the example that we were coming that the the example that we were coming that the the example that we were coming up with was, you know, the dopamine up with was, you know, the dopamine up with was, you know, the dopamine story doesn't seem to be holding up as story doesn't seem to be holding up as story doesn't seem to be holding up as well as we thought. Doesn't mean that well as we thought. Doesn't mean that well as we thought. Doesn't mean that people aren't addicted to food and people aren't addicted to food and people aren't addicted to food and ultrarocessed foods might be more ultrarocessed foods might be more ultrarocessed foods might be more addictive in in other ways. Um, but it addictive in in other ways. Um, but it addictive in in other ways. Um, but it definitely complicates the narrative if definitely complicates the narrative if definitely complicates the narrative if you can't say, "Yeah, it's exactly like you can't say, "Yeah, it's exactly like you can't say, "Yeah, it's exactly like cocaine." cocaine." cocaine." >> Well, I appreciate your your cander in >> Well, I appreciate your your cander in >> Well, I appreciate your your cander in in sharing that story. I'm sorry that in sharing that story. I'm sorry that in sharing that story. I'm sorry that that happened to you. I'm sure you'll that happened to you. I'm sure you'll that happened to you. I'm sure you'll find, you know, your next your next find, you know, your next your next find, you know, your next your next thing and and perhaps even reflect back thing and and perhaps even reflect back thing and and perhaps even reflect back and think, well, it's good that this and think, well, it's good that this and think, well, it's good that this happened because now I'm here. You know, happened because now I'm here. You know, happened because now I'm here. You know, you're trying to figure that out right you're trying to figure that out right you're trying to figure that out right now. now. now. >> Um, but I want to I want to shift now to >> Um, but I want to I want to shift now to >> Um, but I want to I want to shift now to trying to provide people with some trying to provide people with some trying to provide people with some actionable guidance while also actionable guidance while also actionable guidance while also appreciating appreciating the complexity appreciating appreciating the complexity appreciating appreciating the complexity of all of this. I mean, this is going to of all of this. I mean, this is going to of all of this. I mean, this is going to >> this is going to publish in a couple >> this is going to publish in a couple >> this is going to publish in a couple weeks like prior to the new year. weeks like prior to the new year. weeks like prior to the new year. Everybody's thinking about their New Everybody's thinking about their New Everybody's thinking about their New Year's resolutions. I'm sure there's a Year's resolutions. I'm sure there's a Year's resolutions. I'm sure there's a lot of people watching or listening who lot of people watching or listening who lot of people watching or listening who are thinking about how they're going to are thinking about how they're going to are thinking about how they're going to try to finally lose that extra 10 pounds try to finally lose that extra 10 pounds try to finally lose that extra 10 pounds or whatever it is. or whatever it is. or whatever it is. >> Um, but they're also, you know, on the >> Um, but they're also, you know, on the >> Um, but they're also, you know, on the precipice of all kinds of social precipice of all kinds of social precipice of all kinds of social gatherings where there's going to be gatherings where there's going to be gatherings where there's going to be lots their food environment is going to lots their food environment is going to lots their food environment is going to be less than ideal. And uh you know what be less than ideal. And uh you know what be less than ideal. And uh you know what is your what is your counsel to the is your what is your counsel to the is your what is your counsel to the average person who's trying to navigate average person who's trying to navigate average person who's trying to navigate their food environment, make better their food environment, make better their food environment, make better choices, and have a you know, a better choices, and have a you know, a better choices, and have a you know, a better understanding of what's really going to understanding of what's really going to understanding of what's really going to drive drive drive uh sustained weight loss and better uh sustained weight loss and better uh sustained weight loss and better health outcomes over the long haul. health outcomes over the long haul. health outcomes over the long haul. >> Yeah. Yeah. So, so I think a couple >> Yeah. Yeah. So, so I think a couple >> Yeah. Yeah. So, so I think a couple points. Well, one is one that I think points. Well, one is one that I think points. Well, one is one that I think people again too often tie to weight people again too often tie to weight people again too often tie to weight loss, but the effects are especially loss, but the effects are especially loss, but the effects are especially acutely, but the effects are in, you acutely, but the effects are in, you acutely, but the effects are in, you know, the positive effects are know, the positive effects are know, the positive effects are completely independent and that's completely independent and that's completely independent and that's exercise. Too often people around the exercise. Too often people around the exercise. Too often people around the new year and they kind of come up with new year and they kind of come up with new year and they kind of come up with some New Year's resolution to join a gym some New Year's resolution to join a gym some New Year's resolution to join a gym or start an exercise program or hire a or start an exercise program or hire a or start an exercise program or hire a personal trainer and they tie their personal trainer and they tie their personal trainer and they tie their success to what's happening on the success to what's happening on the success to what's happening on the scale. And that's I think completely scale. And that's I think completely scale. And that's I think completely misleading, right? Because even if you misleading, right? Because even if you misleading, right? Because even if you don't lose a pound or even gain a pound, don't lose a pound or even gain a pound, don't lose a pound or even gain a pound, um if you become regular in your um if you become regular in your um if you become regular in your exercise habits, um both, you know, your exercise habits, um both, you know, your exercise habits, um both, you know, your function, your day-to-day function, your function, your day-to-day function, your function, your day-to-day function, your ability to kind of get around and move ability to kind of get around and move ability to kind of get around and move move about in the world, as well as many move about in the world, as well as many move about in the world, as well as many metabolic consequences are independent metabolic consequences are independent metabolic consequences are independent of how much weight you lose. And so I of how much weight you lose. And so I of how much weight you lose. And so I think that's one factor is that people think that's one factor is that people think that's one factor is that people should not tie their success at exercise should not tie their success at exercise should not tie their success at exercise with what happens on the scale. And I I with what happens on the scale. And I I with what happens on the scale. And I I think that too often we do this in the think that too often we do this in the think that too often we do this in the especially in that New Year's time. especially in that New Year's time. especially in that New Year's time. >> One of the things you talk about in the >> One of the things you talk about in the >> One of the things you talk about in the book and in your work is there is that book and in your work is there is that book and in your work is there is that you know not all fat is equal. Like you know not all fat is equal. Like you know not all fat is equal. Like there is a there is a distinction there is a there is a distinction there is a there is a distinction between problematic fat and you know I between problematic fat and you know I between problematic fat and you know I guess what you would call like healthier guess what you would call like healthier guess what you would call like healthier fat. So just just the number on the fat. So just just the number on the fat. So just just the number on the scale or how much like atapost tissue scale or how much like atapost tissue scale or how much like atapost tissue you have doesn't really tell the whole you have doesn't really tell the whole you have doesn't really tell the whole story about your health or lack thereof. story about your health or lack thereof. story about your health or lack thereof. >> That's right. Yeah. Exactly right. And >> That's right. Yeah. Exactly right. And >> That's right. Yeah. Exactly right. And it's the function of your fat as well as it's the function of your fat as well as it's the function of your fat as well as where you're storing excess calories. where you're storing excess calories. where you're storing excess calories. And if you're storing it outside of your And if you're storing it outside of your And if you're storing it outside of your fat tissue, your atapost tissue, if it's fat tissue, your atapost tissue, if it's fat tissue, your atapost tissue, if it's in your muscle, for example, or in your in your muscle, for example, or in your in your muscle, for example, or in your liver, then that's the problematic liver, then that's the problematic liver, then that's the problematic areas. And exercise is potentially areas. And exercise is potentially areas. And exercise is potentially beneficial for both of those things. beneficial for both of those things. beneficial for both of those things. Even if the overall atapost tissue Even if the overall atapost tissue Even if the overall atapost tissue doesn't change or changes, doesn't change or changes, doesn't change or changes, >> visceral fat. So yeah, visceral fat is a >> visceral fat. So yeah, visceral fat is a >> visceral fat. So yeah, visceral fat is a little bit um it's one of those popular little bit um it's one of those popular little bit um it's one of those popular bad guys that people talk about, but I bad guys that people talk about, but I bad guys that people talk about, but I don't think there's really good evidence don't think there's really good evidence don't think there's really good evidence that visceral fat per se is bad. So that visceral fat per se is bad. So that visceral fat per se is bad. So visceral fat again is is is atapost visceral fat again is is is atapost visceral fat again is is is atapost tissue. It's a small amount that's tissue. It's a small amount that's tissue. It's a small amount that's around your organs. It's not actually in around your organs. It's not actually in around your organs. It's not actually in your organs. And you know, there's some your organs. And you know, there's some your organs. And you know, there's some evidence to suggest that it's really not evidence to suggest that it's really not evidence to suggest that it's really not contributing as much as we originally contributing as much as we originally contributing as much as we originally believed to poor metabolic health. believed to poor metabolic health. believed to poor metabolic health. >> Yeah, cuz I've always thought, oh well >> Yeah, cuz I've always thought, oh well >> Yeah, cuz I've always thought, oh well that's that's the bad one. I mean it's that's that's the bad one. I mean it's that's that's the bad one. I mean it's it's it's it's >> and it's the one you're not you don't >> and it's the one you're not you don't >> and it's the one you're not you don't even know if you have it even know if you have it even know if you have it >> necessarily. Yeah. I mean it and it >> necessarily. Yeah. I mean it and it >> necessarily. Yeah. I mean it and it tracks a little bit more closely with tracks a little bit more closely with tracks a little bit more closely with with liver fat than subcutaneous fat. Um with liver fat than subcutaneous fat. Um with liver fat than subcutaneous fat. Um it's it's still a little bit debated it's it's still a little bit debated it's it's still a little bit debated about how how relevant visceral fat is about how how relevant visceral fat is about how how relevant visceral fat is per se to metabolic health. So for per se to metabolic health. So for per se to metabolic health. So for example, if you do beriatric surgery and example, if you do beriatric surgery and example, if you do beriatric surgery and at the same time you remove visceral at the same time you remove visceral at the same time you remove visceral fat, uh you can just take it out a huge fat, uh you can just take it out a huge fat, uh you can just take it out a huge chunk out and therefore you don't see chunk out and therefore you don't see chunk out and therefore you don't see the same sort of uh people talk about it the same sort of uh people talk about it the same sort of uh people talk about it dumping into the portal vein of the dumping into the portal vein of the dumping into the portal vein of the liver and uh and having inflammatory liver and uh and having inflammatory liver and uh and having inflammatory properties. You get rid of that. The properties. You get rid of that. The properties. You get rid of that. The meta analysis suggests you're no better meta analysis suggests you're no better meta analysis suggests you're no better off having your visceral fat removed off having your visceral fat removed off having your visceral fat removed from a metabolic standpoint than than from a metabolic standpoint than than from a metabolic standpoint than than you are um from just getting the you are um from just getting the you are um from just getting the beriatric surgery. Um, and in fact, if beriatric surgery. Um, and in fact, if beriatric surgery. Um, and in fact, if you just if you cut up subcutaneous fat, you just if you cut up subcutaneous fat, you just if you cut up subcutaneous fat, you don't get any of the metabolic you don't get any of the metabolic you don't get any of the metabolic benefits of losing weight, right? So, benefits of losing weight, right? So, benefits of losing weight, right? So, there's something special about weight there's something special about weight there's something special about weight loss per se that doesn't have to do with loss per se that doesn't have to do with loss per se that doesn't have to do with the the surgery that doesn't have to do the the surgery that doesn't have to do the the surgery that doesn't have to do with the visceral fat or even with the visceral fat or even with the visceral fat or even subcutaneous fat per se. subcutaneous fat per se. subcutaneous fat per se. >> So, it's more likely to be the fat >> So, it's more likely to be the fat >> So, it's more likely to be the fat that's in your in your muscle cells, in that's in your in your muscle cells, in that's in your in your muscle cells, in your liver cells, um, around your your liver cells, um, around your your liver cells, um, around your pancreas that that are that are the more pancreas that that are that are the more pancreas that that are that are the more problematic areas. But the point is problematic areas. But the point is problematic areas. But the point is exercise uh is beneficial metabolically exercise uh is beneficial metabolically exercise uh is beneficial metabolically regardless of whether or not you're regardless of whether or not you're regardless of whether or not you're losing weight, regardless of whether or losing weight, regardless of whether or losing weight, regardless of whether or not you're eating. not you're eating. not you're eating. >> It's such a boring answer. It is a >> It's such a boring answer. It is a >> It's such a boring answer. It is a boring answer. boring answer. boring answer. >> Behind the velvet rope, you know, Kevin. >> Behind the velvet rope, you know, Kevin. >> Behind the velvet rope, you know, Kevin. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> It's like, oh, exercise. >> It's like, oh, exercise. >> It's like, oh, exercise. >> She never heard that before, right? But >> She never heard that before, right? But >> She never heard that before, right? But I think the new part I I don't know how I think the new part I I don't know how I think the new part I I don't know how new it is, but the new part is that new it is, but the new part is that new it is, but the new part is that people they tie it so closely to weight people they tie it so closely to weight people they tie it so closely to weight loss whether or not they're succeeding loss whether or not they're succeeding loss whether or not they're succeeding >> or it's the reason for doing >> or it's the reason for doing >> or it's the reason for doing >> the reason for doing it, right? I mean >> the reason for doing it, right? I mean >> the reason for doing it, right? I mean the benefits for weight loss don't seem the benefits for weight loss don't seem the benefits for weight loss don't seem to show up acutely. They show up later to show up acutely. They show up later to show up acutely. They show up later long maintenance of weight loss is long maintenance of weight loss is long maintenance of weight loss is pretty closely tied to how physically pretty closely tied to how physically pretty closely tied to how physically active you are. active you are. active you are. >> So it seems like you're saying don't >> So it seems like you're saying don't >> So it seems like you're saying don't obsess on weight loss. obsess on weight loss. obsess on weight loss. >> Focus on, you know, eating healthier >> Focus on, you know, eating healthier >> Focus on, you know, eating healthier foods and exercising foods and exercising foods and exercising >> and improving metabolic health. That's >> and improving metabolic health. That's >> and improving metabolic health. That's that's right. And and that you can do that's right. And and that you can do that's right. And and that you can do that. Um, yes, fat loss can help with that. Um, yes, fat loss can help with that. Um, yes, fat loss can help with that, but you know, whatever you're that, but you know, whatever you're that, but you know, whatever you're going to do to change your lifestyle or going to do to change your lifestyle or going to do to change your lifestyle or change your uh to to actually lose change your uh to to actually lose change your uh to to actually lose weight, you've got to be willing to do weight, you've got to be willing to do weight, you've got to be willing to do that permanently because I think again that permanently because I think again that permanently because I think again that's one of the things that people that's one of the things that people that's one of the things that people have this idea that, well, I'm going to have this idea that, well, I'm going to have this idea that, well, I'm going to go on a diet to lose weight in the new go on a diet to lose weight in the new go on a diet to lose weight in the new year and then year and then year and then >> once you do that, everything's great and >> once you do that, everything's great and >> once you do that, everything's great and you you you >> put your foot off the pedal. I mean >> put your foot off the pedal. I mean >> put your foot off the pedal. I mean after studying the biggest loser after studying the biggest loser after studying the biggest loser contestants and all I mean you must have contestants and all I mean you must have contestants and all I mean you must have learned quite a few things about the learned quite a few things about the learned quite a few things about the difference between you know people who difference between you know people who difference between you know people who are able to sustain healthy habits and I are able to sustain healthy habits and I are able to sustain healthy habits and I mean this gets into psychology obviously mean this gets into psychology obviously mean this gets into psychology obviously but and those that lapse but and those that lapse but and those that lapse >> right yeah I mean so no I didn't learn >> right yeah I mean so no I didn't learn >> right yeah I mean so no I didn't learn very very very >> you didn't okay some people do and some >> you didn't okay some people do and some >> you didn't okay some people do and some people don't people don't people don't >> I'm I'm a little bit of a bone head in >> I'm I'm a little bit of a bone head in >> I'm I'm a little bit of a bone head in that regard I tend to look at things you that regard I tend to look at things you that regard I tend to look at things you know uh if it's if it's not happening in know uh if it's if it's not happening in know uh if it's if it's not happening in the hypothalamus or the reward regions the hypothalamus or the reward regions the hypothalamus or the reward regions of the brain of the brain of the brain I'm like that's that's too much I'm like that's that's too much I'm like that's that's too much cognition. cognition. cognition. That's a messy psychology. That's a messy psychology. That's a messy psychology. >> That's soft sciences. >> That's soft sciences. >> That's soft sciences. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> So, yeah, some people might learn a lot. >> So, yeah, some people might learn a lot. >> So, yeah, some people might learn a lot. Not me. But um yeah, I I mean I think Not me. But um yeah, I I mean I think Not me. But um yeah, I I mean I think it's it's really interesting though it's it's really interesting though it's it's really interesting though because I think that again one of the because I think that again one of the because I think that again one of the chapters of the book we talk a lot about chapters of the book we talk a lot about chapters of the book we talk a lot about sort of um precision approaches like sort of um precision approaches like sort of um precision approaches like you're the unique snowflake and there's you're the unique snowflake and there's you're the unique snowflake and there's huge variability in the amount of weight huge variability in the amount of weight huge variability in the amount of weight loss that people have and if if only we loss that people have and if if only we loss that people have and if if only we could identify um you know what special could identify um you know what special could identify um you know what special biological properties you have that biological properties you have that biological properties you have that would promote weight loss in a given would promote weight loss in a given would promote weight loss in a given intervention. I don't think there's good intervention. I don't think there's good intervention. I don't think there's good evidence for that yet. And the evidence for that yet. And the evidence for that yet. And the presumption seems to be that there's presumption seems to be that there's presumption seems to be that there's some magic biological driver about who some magic biological driver about who some magic biological driver about who is a success story and who's not. But I is a success story and who's not. But I is a success story and who's not. But I think that again getting to the softer think that again getting to the softer think that again getting to the softer sciences of this um whether or not you sciences of this um whether or not you sciences of this um whether or not you have a supportive partner or a have a supportive partner or a have a supportive partner or a supportive family, whether or not you supportive family, whether or not you supportive family, whether or not you have the economic means and uh to kind have the economic means and uh to kind have the economic means and uh to kind of make these changes and change your of make these changes and change your of make these changes and change your local environment in in ways which I local environment in in ways which I local environment in in ways which I think you can people do have some agency think you can people do have some agency think you can people do have some agency to kind of change those kinds of things. to kind of change those kinds of things. to kind of change those kinds of things. um those are going to be much more um those are going to be much more um those are going to be much more important than you know signing up for important than you know signing up for important than you know signing up for the latest you know CGM gut microbiome the latest you know CGM gut microbiome the latest you know CGM gut microbiome analysis which is in my view vastly analysis which is in my view vastly analysis which is in my view vastly overhyped at the current time and being overhyped at the current time and being overhyped at the current time and being oversold to people. oversold to people. oversold to people. >> There's some evidence of that uh that we >> There's some evidence of that uh that we >> There's some evidence of that uh that we present in the book that you know these present in the book that you know these present in the book that you know these things are not as reliable as as as things are not as reliable as as as things are not as reliable as as as they're being made out to. they're being made out to. they're being made out to. >> Yeah. I mean I think there are tools >> Yeah. I mean I think there are tools >> Yeah. I mean I think there are tools like anything else. I think they they like anything else. I think they they like anything else. I think they they lack adequate amount of education as a lack adequate amount of education as a lack adequate amount of education as a as a sort of you know central piece to as a sort of you know central piece to as a sort of you know central piece to it and the technology isn't quite there it and the technology isn't quite there it and the technology isn't quite there to provide the best you know kind of to provide the best you know kind of to provide the best you know kind of actionable recourse as a result of these actionable recourse as a result of these actionable recourse as a result of these and I think that the data points you and I think that the data points you and I think that the data points you know there's so many data points now know there's so many data points now know there's so many data points now with all these wearables and it's with all these wearables and it's with all these wearables and it's disorienting and you don't know what's disorienting and you don't know what's disorienting and you don't know what's important and what's not and so you're important and what's not and so you're important and what's not and so you're making health choices based upon making health choices based upon making health choices based upon short-term you know data reports that short-term you know data reports that short-term you know data reports that don't necessarily mean anything and can don't necessarily mean anything and can don't necessarily mean anything and can potentially drive, you know, poor potentially drive, you know, poor potentially drive, you know, poor decisions around, especially with CGMs, decisions around, especially with CGMs, decisions around, especially with CGMs, like you see these spikes and you think, like you see these spikes and you think, like you see these spikes and you think, oh, well, oh, well, oh, well, >> the solution is just not eating anything >> the solution is just not eating anything >> the solution is just not eating anything that's going to spike my insulin. So, that's going to spike my insulin. So, that's going to spike my insulin. So, it's like, all right, well, you can just it's like, all right, well, you can just it's like, all right, well, you can just eat fat all day long. It's probably not eat fat all day long. It's probably not eat fat all day long. It's probably not great, but you're going to have a nice great, but you're going to have a nice great, but you're going to have a nice line, you know? line, you know? line, you know? >> Right. Yeah. No, that that's right. And >> Right. Yeah. No, that that's right. And >> Right. Yeah. No, that that's right. And I think that the the problem that I have I think that the the problem that I have I think that the the problem that I have is that the foundational science hasn't is that the foundational science hasn't is that the foundational science hasn't been done, right? been done, right? been done, right? >> So, that the measuring isn't >> So, that the measuring isn't >> So, that the measuring isn't >> we don't Yeah. I mean so I mean when one >> we don't Yeah. I mean so I mean when one >> we don't Yeah. I mean so I mean when one of the studies we did especially when we of the studies we did especially when we of the studies we did especially when we have like this complete control over have like this complete control over have like this complete control over people's environments and in fact the people's environments and in fact the people's environments and in fact the order of the meals and the timing of the order of the meals and the timing of the order of the meals and the timing of the meals we know all of this about the meals we know all of this about the meals we know all of this about the subjects that we had on we we would subjects that we had on we we would subjects that we had on we we would basically have one c two cgms basically have one c two cgms basically have one c two cgms simultaneously simultaneously simultaneously um one on the abdomen one on the arm as um one on the abdomen one on the arm as um one on the abdomen one on the arm as according to the manufacturers's according to the manufacturers's according to the manufacturers's instructions and yeah the results that instructions and yeah the results that instructions and yeah the results that you get are correlated but you have this you get are correlated but you have this you get are correlated but you have this huge variability where the same people huge variability where the same people huge variability where the same people >> simultaneously eating meals one is rock >> simultaneously eating meals one is rock >> simultaneously eating meals one is rock solid and the other one is causing a solid and the other one is causing a solid and the other one is causing a spike. spike. spike. >> If they were accurate within a certain, >> If they were accurate within a certain, >> If they were accurate within a certain, you know, like reasonable range, would you know, like reasonable range, would you know, like reasonable range, would you have a different opinion on that? you have a different opinion on that? you have a different opinion on that? Because it does seem to me like anything Because it does seem to me like anything Because it does seem to me like anything that connects you more deeply with the that connects you more deeply with the that connects you more deeply with the habits and the choices that you're habits and the choices that you're habits and the choices that you're making and can kind of show you making and can kind of show you making and can kind of show you evidentiary proof of like what you're evidentiary proof of like what you're evidentiary proof of like what you're doing and what it's doing to you is doing and what it's doing to you is doing and what it's doing to you is probably a good thing. probably a good thing. probably a good thing. >> It it can be a good thing if you know >> It it can be a good thing if you know >> It it can be a good thing if you know how many times you have to measure the how many times you have to measure the how many times you have to measure the thing to have a reliable response. And thing to have a reliable response. And thing to have a reliable response. And our data suggests that that's probably our data suggests that that's probably our data suggests that that's probably more like 10 times, right? Like if you more like 10 times, right? Like if you more like 10 times, right? Like if you measure the same the similar responses measure the same the similar responses measure the same the similar responses to the same food or same meal 10 times, to the same food or same meal 10 times, to the same food or same meal 10 times, then you probably have a pretty reliable then you probably have a pretty reliable then you probably have a pretty reliable response. Um, and that's even in the response. Um, and that's even in the response. Um, and that's even in the highly controlled situation. highly controlled situation. highly controlled situation. >> I mean, that's true of everything. I >> I mean, that's true of everything. I >> I mean, that's true of everything. I mean, just as an athlete, like wearing mean, just as an athlete, like wearing mean, just as an athlete, like wearing heart rate monitors, like I know if I my heart rate monitors, like I know if I my heart rate monitors, like I know if I my chest monitor is always going to be more chest monitor is always going to be more chest monitor is always going to be more accurate than whatever's on my wrist. accurate than whatever's on my wrist. accurate than whatever's on my wrist. Doesn't matter the sensor. But even if Doesn't matter the sensor. But even if Doesn't matter the sensor. But even if all I have is a risk sensor, I know that all I have is a risk sensor, I know that all I have is a risk sensor, I know that that that number isn't exactly accurate. that that number isn't exactly accurate. that that number isn't exactly accurate. But if I do it over time, like it's more But if I do it over time, like it's more But if I do it over time, like it's more it's the variability in that number it's the variability in that number it's the variability in that number that's still provides me with some that's still provides me with some that's still provides me with some value. value. value. >> And I think that knowing that and having >> And I think that knowing that and having >> And I think that knowing that and having done that sort of research in advance is done that sort of research in advance is done that sort of research in advance is what's lacking in this particular space, what's lacking in this particular space, what's lacking in this particular space, right? So um and instead what you get is right? So um and instead what you get is right? So um and instead what you get is you get people who see something on just you get people who see something on just you get people who see something on just a couple of occasions. you know, they a couple of occasions. you know, they a couple of occasions. you know, they see their their blood sugar spike eating see their their blood sugar spike eating see their their blood sugar spike eating a banana and they do it like on two or a banana and they do it like on two or a banana and they do it like on two or three occasions and they think, "Oh, three occasions and they think, "Oh, three occasions and they think, "Oh, that's what my response to bananas is." that's what my response to bananas is." that's what my response to bananas is." And what if that person really loves And what if that person really loves And what if that person really loves bananas, right? And it's not really a bananas, right? And it's not really a bananas, right? And it's not really a reliable response cuz they haven't done reliable response cuz they haven't done reliable response cuz they haven't done it in a long time. it in a long time. it in a long time. >> They eat bacon instead >> They eat bacon instead >> They eat bacon instead >> and they eat bacon instead and you've >> and they eat bacon instead and you've >> and they eat bacon instead and you've made their life measurably worse because made their life measurably worse because made their life measurably worse because they don't enjoy the bananas and they don't enjoy the bananas and they don't enjoy the bananas and potentially from a health-wise worse potentially from a health-wise worse potentially from a health-wise worse because they're now eating bacon instead because they're now eating bacon instead because they're now eating bacon instead of bananas. But I think these things I of bananas. But I think these things I of bananas. But I think these things I mean listen you know as human beings we mean listen you know as human beings we mean listen you know as human beings we we like little shiny bells and whistles we like little shiny bells and whistles we like little shiny bells and whistles and these things are fun but you know and these things are fun but you know and these things are fun but you know the the you're you're like a pillars guy the the you're you're like a pillars guy the the you're you're like a pillars guy and it's like listen just stay away from and it's like listen just stay away from and it's like listen just stay away from the ultrarocessed foods. Try to better the ultrarocessed foods. Try to better the ultrarocessed foods. Try to better control your food environment. You know control your food environment. You know control your food environment. You know when you go to the grocery store stick when you go to the grocery store stick when you go to the grocery store stick to the far aisles where you know it's to the far aisles where you know it's to the far aisles where you know it's real food and you know exercise and get real food and you know exercise and get real food and you know exercise and get out like all these other things are like out like all these other things are like out like all these other things are like you know they're they're like cherry on you know they're they're like cherry on you know they're they're like cherry on top of the Sunday sort of things. top of the Sunday sort of things. top of the Sunday sort of things. >> They are and they can be distracting I >> They are and they can be distracting I >> They are and they can be distracting I guess is the point. And and I I think guess is the point. And and I I think guess is the point. And and I I think the other thing is when it comes to the other thing is when it comes to the other thing is when it comes to ultrarocessed foods is that um it is a ultrarocessed foods is that um it is a ultrarocessed foods is that um it is a extremely broad category right so that extremely broad category right so that extremely broad category right so that um the way it's defined academically. um the way it's defined academically. um the way it's defined academically. How do you draw that distinction? How do you draw that distinction? How do you draw that distinction? Because I often think like, okay, so I I Because I often think like, okay, so I I Because I often think like, okay, so I I wear a Whoop tracker, right? So, just wear a Whoop tracker, right? So, just wear a Whoop tracker, right? So, just and I love it and it's great and you and I love it and it's great and you and I love it and it's great and you know I look at the data points over a know I look at the data points over a know I look at the data points over a broad period of time like I don't get broad period of time like I don't get broad period of time like I don't get caught up in every single day or caught up in every single day or caught up in every single day or whatever but it has a little diary whatever but it has a little diary whatever but it has a little diary function and it's like and you can you function and it's like and you can you function and it's like and you can you can choose which little like checks can choose which little like checks can choose which little like checks things and it's like did you eat too things and it's like did you eat too things and it's like did you eat too late at night or you know did you eat late at night or you know did you eat late at night or you know did you eat processed foods and I'm like well I had processed foods and I'm like well I had processed foods and I'm like well I had some olive oil and I had some you know some olive oil and I had some you know some olive oil and I had some you know like is that a processed food is that like is that a processed food is that like is that a processed food is that not a processed food what's the not a processed food what's the not a processed food what's the difference between a processed food that difference between a processed food that difference between a processed food that you might consider healthy and an you might consider healthy and an you might consider healthy and an ultrarocessed food that is just off the ultrarocessed food that is just off the ultrarocessed food that is just off the table. table. table. >> Mhm. And what I'm adding is that not all >> Mhm. And what I'm adding is that not all >> Mhm. And what I'm adding is that not all ultrarocessed foods might be off the ultrarocessed foods might be off the ultrarocessed foods might be off the table either table either table either >> because it is even within that category >> because it is even within that category >> because it is even within that category uh as defined academically. So there's uh as defined academically. So there's uh as defined academically. So there's this NOVA classification system. this NOVA classification system. this NOVA classification system. Basically, it groups foods into four Basically, it groups foods into four Basically, it groups foods into four different categories and it has nothing different categories and it has nothing different categories and it has nothing to do with their nutritional properties, to do with their nutritional properties, to do with their nutritional properties, which is kind of a lot of the kirkuffle which is kind of a lot of the kirkuffle which is kind of a lot of the kirkuffle about ultrarocessed foods is it doesn't about ultrarocessed foods is it doesn't about ultrarocessed foods is it doesn't talk about doesn't talk about saturated talk about doesn't talk about saturated talk about doesn't talk about saturated fat or sugar or sodium or anything like fat or sugar or sodium or anything like fat or sugar or sodium or anything like that or even fiber. Um, but you've that or even fiber. Um, but you've that or even fiber. Um, but you've basically got whole foods. You can wash basically got whole foods. You can wash basically got whole foods. You can wash them, chop them up, freeze them, all them, chop them up, freeze them, all them, chop them up, freeze them, all sorts of things. You know, your produce, sorts of things. You know, your produce, sorts of things. You know, your produce, your even canned produce would be your even canned produce would be your even canned produce would be considered a minimally processed food as considered a minimally processed food as considered a minimally processed food as long as it doesn't contain certain long as it doesn't contain certain long as it doesn't contain certain preservatives and that are kind of more preservatives and that are kind of more preservatives and that are kind of more technologically advanced. Um, these are technologically advanced. Um, these are technologically advanced. Um, these are the minimally processed foods. So, eggs, the minimally processed foods. So, eggs, the minimally processed foods. So, eggs, meat, poultry, fish, produce, legumes, meat, poultry, fish, produce, legumes, meat, poultry, fish, produce, legumes, rice, those kinds of things. Then you've rice, those kinds of things. Then you've rice, those kinds of things. Then you've got processed culinary ingredients. got processed culinary ingredients. got processed culinary ingredients. These are the things that I like to These are the things that I like to These are the things that I like to think of as you don't eat them on their think of as you don't eat them on their think of as you don't eat them on their own. Olive oil, right? No one's guzzling own. Olive oil, right? No one's guzzling own. Olive oil, right? No one's guzzling olive oil. Um, butter. olive oil. Um, butter. olive oil. Um, butter. >> I think maybe Steven Gundry is >> I think maybe Steven Gundry is >> I think maybe Steven Gundry is >> Oh, that's certainly true. >> Oh, that's certainly true. >> Oh, that's certainly true. >> Anyway, go ahead. >> Anyway, go ahead. >> Anyway, go ahead. >> I use the butter example, too, by my >> I use the butter example, too, by my >> I use the butter example, too, by my youngest child actually did eat like youngest child actually did eat like youngest child actually did eat like half a stick of butter once. half a stick of butter once. half a stick of butter once. >> Don't Don't some of the carnivore people >> Don't Don't some of the carnivore people >> Don't Don't some of the carnivore people do that? do that? do that? >> Maybe they do. Anyway, anyway, these are >> Maybe they do. Anyway, anyway, these are >> Maybe they do. Anyway, anyway, these are the the edge cases. My son and the the the edge cases. My son and the the the edge cases. My son and the carnivore people. Um, and and a sugar carnivore people. Um, and and a sugar carnivore people. Um, and and a sugar would be another example, right? Uh but would be another example, right? Uh but would be another example, right? Uh but the point is is that you are using these the point is is that you are using these the point is is that you are using these so-called processed culinary ingredients so-called processed culinary ingredients so-called processed culinary ingredients to to to mix with category 1 minimally processed mix with category 1 minimally processed mix with category 1 minimally processed foods to create meals or preserve them foods to create meals or preserve them foods to create meals or preserve them or enhance their sensory qualities. And or enhance their sensory qualities. And or enhance their sensory qualities. And in fact that's the definition of in fact that's the definition of in fact that's the definition of category 3 which is called processed category 3 which is called processed category 3 which is called processed foods. So breads, pastas, foods. So breads, pastas, foods. So breads, pastas, um fermented products, these would all um fermented products, these would all um fermented products, these would all be called processed foods. And then be called processed foods. And then be called processed foods. And then basically everything else is what's basically everything else is what's basically everything else is what's called ultrarocessed foods. And um so called ultrarocessed foods. And um so called ultrarocessed foods. And um so these are typically using a lot of these these are typically using a lot of these these are typically using a lot of these cheap agricultural inputs. Um things cheap agricultural inputs. Um things cheap agricultural inputs. Um things that you would not find ingredients that that you would not find ingredients that that you would not find ingredients that would not be found in in restaurants or would not be found in in restaurants or would not be found in in restaurants or home kitchens. Um they're often using home kitchens. Um they're often using home kitchens. Um they're often using processes and manufacturing methods that processes and manufacturing methods that processes and manufacturing methods that are not commonly used. Um you know are not commonly used. Um you know are not commonly used. Um you know things like extrusion uh technologies things like extrusion uh technologies things like extrusion uh technologies and um all sort sorts of other kinds of and um all sort sorts of other kinds of and um all sort sorts of other kinds of things. things. things. >> Preservatives. >> Preservatives. >> Preservatives. >> Preservatives. Also some categories of >> Preservatives. Also some categories of >> Preservatives. Also some categories of preservatives if they belong to like a preservatives if they belong to like a preservatives if they belong to like a kind of a very historical way of preserv kind of a very historical way of preserv kind of a very historical way of preserv like fermenting is a preservation like fermenting is a preservation like fermenting is a preservation technique that is kind of belongs in the technique that is kind of belongs in the technique that is kind of belongs in the sort of processed food category but yeah sort of processed food category but yeah sort of processed food category but yeah other kinds of preservatives cosmetic other kinds of preservatives cosmetic other kinds of preservatives cosmetic additives the flavor additives those additives the flavor additives those additives the flavor additives those would uh count as something as would uh count as something as would uh count as something as ultrarocessed. So within that category, ultrarocessed. So within that category, ultrarocessed. So within that category, all the kind of typical junk food type all the kind of typical junk food type all the kind of typical junk food type things, the much of the fast food that things, the much of the fast food that things, the much of the fast food that we have, um but also things like whole we have, um but also things like whole we have, um but also things like whole grain breads uh that you'd buy at a grain breads uh that you'd buy at a grain breads uh that you'd buy at a supermarket. Um things like many of the supermarket. Um things like many of the supermarket. Um things like many of the plant-based meat replacements would be plant-based meat replacements would be plant-based meat replacements would be ultrarocessed foods. ultrarocessed foods. ultrarocessed foods. >> A lot of things like some flavored >> A lot of things like some flavored >> A lot of things like some flavored yogurts and things that many people yogurts and things that many people yogurts and things that many people think are probably beneficial for think are probably beneficial for think are probably beneficial for health. Um so it's a incredibly broad health. Um so it's a incredibly broad health. Um so it's a incredibly broad category of foods. And the question is, category of foods. And the question is, category of foods. And the question is, you know, it was an empirical question you know, it was an empirical question you know, it was an empirical question for a long time. Is is are diets high in for a long time. Is is are diets high in for a long time. Is is are diets high in ultrarocessed foods connected linked ultrarocessed foods connected linked ultrarocessed foods connected linked with diet related chronic disease? I with diet related chronic disease? I with diet related chronic disease? I think that everybody realizes the answer think that everybody realizes the answer think that everybody realizes the answer to that is yes, they are linked. to that is yes, they are linked. to that is yes, they are linked. Mechanistically, how that works is still Mechanistically, how that works is still Mechanistically, how that works is still not fully understood. I I think a lot of not fully understood. I I think a lot of not fully understood. I I think a lot of it is probably downstream of obesity, it is probably downstream of obesity, it is probably downstream of obesity, right? Something about this category of right? Something about this category of right? Something about this category of foods causes people to overeat calories foods causes people to overeat calories foods causes people to overeat calories and gain weight and become um have and gain weight and become um have and gain weight and become um have excess body fat and as a result having excess body fat and as a result having excess body fat and as a result having many of the downstream complications many of the downstream complications many of the downstream complications which kind of overlap with many of the which kind of overlap with many of the which kind of overlap with many of the things that ultrarocessed foods have things that ultrarocessed foods have things that ultrarocessed foods have been linked to. Obesity, type two been linked to. Obesity, type two been linked to. Obesity, type two diabetes, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, several forms of cancer um and all cause several forms of cancer um and all cause several forms of cancer um and all cause mortality. In fact, mortality. In fact, mortality. In fact, >> at the same time, I you would probably >> at the same time, I you would probably >> at the same time, I you would probably also say like if you if your ultra if also say like if you if your ultra if also say like if you if your ultra if your ultrarocessed food of choice is your ultrarocessed food of choice is your ultrarocessed food of choice is very high in sugar and then you have very high in sugar and then you have very high in sugar and then you have type 2 diabetes, maybe there's a type 2 diabetes, maybe there's a type 2 diabetes, maybe there's a connection there. That extends beyond connection there. That extends beyond connection there. That extends beyond purely, you know, obesity or if you like purely, you know, obesity or if you like purely, you know, obesity or if you like salty stuff and you have high blood salty stuff and you have high blood salty stuff and you have high blood pressure. pressure. pressure. >> Yep. Yep. That's true. That's true. So >> Yep. Yep. That's true. That's true. So >> Yep. Yep. That's true. That's true. So there are independent mechanism and there are independent mechanism and there are independent mechanism and there's also I think one of the there's also I think one of the there's also I think one of the strongest areas of independent strongest areas of independent strongest areas of independent mechanisms are in um gut dispiosis and mechanisms are in um gut dispiosis and mechanisms are in um gut dispiosis and and gut function and the immune system and gut function and the immune system and gut function and the immune system and inflammation. Um there's a really and inflammation. Um there's a really and inflammation. Um there's a really interesting study that was conducted by interesting study that was conducted by interesting study that was conducted by Kevin Wheelen on people with Crohn's Kevin Wheelen on people with Crohn's Kevin Wheelen on people with Crohn's disease and removing ultrarocessed foods disease and removing ultrarocessed foods disease and removing ultrarocessed foods and improving symptoms of Crohn's and improving symptoms of Crohn's and improving symptoms of Crohn's disease. So I think that that aspect is disease. So I think that that aspect is disease. So I think that that aspect is is probably another clear area where is probably another clear area where is probably another clear area where certain emulsifiers in ultrarocessed certain emulsifiers in ultrarocessed certain emulsifiers in ultrarocessed foods might exacerbate um gut health foods might exacerbate um gut health foods might exacerbate um gut health especially in in uh in conditions like especially in in uh in conditions like especially in in uh in conditions like Crohn's and maybe inflammatory bowel Crohn's and maybe inflammatory bowel Crohn's and maybe inflammatory bowel syndrome. So yeah, that's another syndrome. So yeah, that's another syndrome. So yeah, that's another independent pathway. But yeah, so so independent pathway. But yeah, so so independent pathway. But yeah, so so I've been mostly focused on the obesity I've been mostly focused on the obesity I've been mostly focused on the obesity side of things and trying to figure out, side of things and trying to figure out, side of things and trying to figure out, well, what is it about diets high in well, what is it about diets high in well, what is it about diets high in ultrarocessed foods that might be ultrarocessed foods that might be ultrarocessed foods that might be driving this process? And that's kind of driving this process? And that's kind of driving this process? And that's kind of led us down to a couple different areas. led us down to a couple different areas. led us down to a couple different areas. One was how quickly these foods are One was how quickly these foods are One was how quickly these foods are often eaten. Um, that tends to drive often eaten. Um, that tends to drive often eaten. Um, that tends to drive people to over consume calories. Folks people to over consume calories. Folks people to over consume calories. Folks like Kieran Ford and and Kay Degraphth like Kieran Ford and and Kay Degraphth like Kieran Ford and and Kay Degraphth have shown that textural based have shown that textural based have shown that textural based properties of these foods, they tend to properties of these foods, they tend to properties of these foods, they tend to be softer, easier to chew and swallow. be softer, easier to chew and swallow. be softer, easier to chew and swallow. Maybe by the time you know you've uh got Maybe by the time you know you've uh got Maybe by the time you know you've uh got the signal that you've eaten so many the signal that you've eaten so many the signal that you've eaten so many calories, it's already too late cuz calories, it's already too late cuz calories, it's already too late cuz you've eaten them so quickly. Uh I think you've eaten them so quickly. Uh I think you've eaten them so quickly. Uh I think that's a and the oral sensory properties that's a and the oral sensory properties that's a and the oral sensory properties of doing that I think is is part of the of doing that I think is is part of the of doing that I think is is part of the story. But I think it's not the major story. But I think it's not the major story. But I think it's not the major story. I think the major story is the story. I think the major story is the story. I think the major story is the fact that these foods tend to be they fact that these foods tend to be they fact that these foods tend to be they have their food matrix disrupted and have their food matrix disrupted and have their food matrix disrupted and they tend to be dried out. So in the they tend to be dried out. So in the they tend to be dried out. So in the ingredients um that are used um drying ingredients um that are used um drying ingredients um that are used um drying them out is important for shelf life and them out is important for shelf life and them out is important for shelf life and microbiological microbiological microbiological safety right that bacteria grow less safety right that bacteria grow less safety right that bacteria grow less well in dry environments. Um but in that well in dry environments. Um but in that well in dry environments. Um but in that process and removing the water process and removing the water process and removing the water essentially from the foods you're also essentially from the foods you're also essentially from the foods you're also concentrating the calories you're concentrating the calories you're concentrating the calories you're increasing its so-called energy density. increasing its so-called energy density. increasing its so-called energy density. So, the number of calories you get per So, the number of calories you get per So, the number of calories you get per bite of ultrarocessed foods tends to be bite of ultrarocessed foods tends to be bite of ultrarocessed foods tends to be quite a bit higher. Even if the amount quite a bit higher. Even if the amount quite a bit higher. Even if the amount of fat isn't any different because fat of fat isn't any different because fat of fat isn't any different because fat is often considered because it has twice is often considered because it has twice is often considered because it has twice the calories per gram of compared to, the calories per gram of compared to, the calories per gram of compared to, you know, carbs or protein. Often we you know, carbs or protein. Often we you know, carbs or protein. Often we think of high energy dense foods as think of high energy dense foods as think of high energy dense foods as being high in fat. Well, actually they being high in fat. Well, actually they being high in fat. Well, actually they can just be drier, less water, and can just be drier, less water, and can just be drier, less water, and that's another way to concentrate the that's another way to concentrate the that's another way to concentrate the calories. I think that's driving most of calories. I think that's driving most of calories. I think that's driving most of the effect. And we've designed a study the effect. And we've designed a study the effect. And we've designed a study where we have people consuming a diet where we have people consuming a diet where we have people consuming a diet that's still 80% calories from that's still 80% calories from that's still 80% calories from ultrarocessed fruits from this broad ultrarocessed fruits from this broad ultrarocessed fruits from this broad category. Uh but we lowered the energy category. Uh but we lowered the energy category. Uh but we lowered the energy density of the diet typically by density of the diet typically by density of the diet typically by diluting it with you know fruits and diluting it with you know fruits and diluting it with you know fruits and vegetables and legumes and things like vegetables and legumes and things like vegetables and legumes and things like that. Um but still having most of the that. Um but still having most of the that. Um but still having most of the calories coming from ultrarocessed calories coming from ultrarocessed calories coming from ultrarocessed foods. And when you do that people eat foods. And when you do that people eat foods. And when you do that people eat many many fewer calories and they don't many many fewer calories and they don't many many fewer calories and they don't over consume calories. Um so that's at over consume calories. Um so that's at over consume calories. Um so that's at least one factor. So thinking about how least one factor. So thinking about how least one factor. So thinking about how calorie dense the foods that you're calorie dense the foods that you're calorie dense the foods that you're purchasing are and how you're purchasing are and how you're purchasing are and how you're incorporating them into meals, I think incorporating them into meals, I think incorporating them into meals, I think is a really important consideration. Um is a really important consideration. Um is a really important consideration. Um the other property that we've kind of the other property that we've kind of the other property that we've kind of looked at is whether or not there are looked at is whether or not there are looked at is whether or not there are combinations of nutrients that exceed combinations of nutrients that exceed combinations of nutrients that exceed certain thresholds together um that you certain thresholds together um that you certain thresholds together um that you typically don't find in nature. Um typically don't find in nature. Um typically don't find in nature. Um so-called hyper palatable foods, foods so-called hyper palatable foods, foods so-called hyper palatable foods, foods that are either high in fat and sugar or that are either high in fat and sugar or that are either high in fat and sugar or fat and salt or carbs and salt both fat and salt or carbs and salt both fat and salt or carbs and salt both together. uh they also seem to drive together. uh they also seem to drive together. uh they also seem to drive people to consume more calories. And so people to consume more calories. And so people to consume more calories. And so by focusing on these two aspects, I by focusing on these two aspects, I by focusing on these two aspects, I think you can get at most of the effects think you can get at most of the effects think you can get at most of the effects of ultrarocessed foods on overconumption of ultrarocessed foods on overconumption of ultrarocessed foods on overconumption of calories of calories of calories >> suggests a lot of things for policy >> suggests a lot of things for policy >> suggests a lot of things for policy makers. If you wanted to subcategorize makers. If you wanted to subcategorize makers. If you wanted to subcategorize ultrarocessed foods that are potentially ultrarocessed foods that are potentially ultrarocessed foods that are potentially problematic from a overeating problematic from a overeating problematic from a overeating standpoint, you should focus on those standpoint, you should focus on those standpoint, you should focus on those two properties, hyper palletability and two properties, hyper palletability and two properties, hyper palletability and calorie density. If you're a shopper, calorie density. If you're a shopper, calorie density. If you're a shopper, it's harder, right? cuz you have to take it's harder, right? cuz you have to take it's harder, right? cuz you have to take your calculator out. your calculator out. your calculator out. >> Yeah. But from a consumer perspective, >> Yeah. But from a consumer perspective, >> Yeah. But from a consumer perspective, it's sort of like, it's sort of like, it's sort of like, >> was it Oliver Wendell Holmes? Who who >> was it Oliver Wendell Holmes? Who who >> was it Oliver Wendell Holmes? Who who wrote the Supreme Court opinion about wrote the Supreme Court opinion about wrote the Supreme Court opinion about obscenity? It was like, you know, you obscenity? It was like, you know, you obscenity? It was like, you know, you know it when you see it. It's like it's know it when you see it. It's like it's know it when you see it. It's like it's impossible to define because it's like, impossible to define because it's like, impossible to define because it's like, but like everybody knows, you know, oh, but like everybody knows, you know, oh, but like everybody knows, you know, oh, like you kind of know it when you eat like you kind of know it when you eat like you kind of know it when you eat it, you know. It's like, oh, can I not it, you know. It's like, oh, can I not it, you know. It's like, oh, can I not stop? Can I only have one and walk away? stop? Can I only have one and walk away? stop? Can I only have one and walk away? Like part of I think that's a probably a Like part of I think that's a probably a Like part of I think that's a probably a pretty good rule for anybody. pretty good rule for anybody. pretty good rule for anybody. >> That is that is a pretty good rule. May >> That is that is a pretty good rule. May >> That is that is a pretty good rule. May I would imagine there are, you know, not I would imagine there are, you know, not I would imagine there are, you know, not so great ultrarocessed foods out there so great ultrarocessed foods out there so great ultrarocessed foods out there that are counterintuitive. Like, oh, I that are counterintuitive. Like, oh, I that are counterintuitive. Like, oh, I thought this was healthy and now I just thought this was healthy and now I just thought this was healthy and now I just realized like this is actually, you realized like this is actually, you realized like this is actually, you know, it's so much more calorically know, it's so much more calorically know, it's so much more calorically dense than I realized or, you know, it dense than I realized or, you know, it dense than I realized or, you know, it has all these has all these has all these >> dark matter chemicals in it as you say, >> dark matter chemicals in it as you say, >> dark matter chemicals in it as you say, or something like that that I wasn't or something like that that I wasn't or something like that that I wasn't even aware of. Or alternatively, there's even aware of. Or alternatively, there's even aware of. Or alternatively, there's probably also some foods that many probably also some foods that many probably also some foods that many people would all agree are people would all agree are people would all agree are ultrarocessed, but are probably ultrarocessed, but are probably ultrarocessed, but are probably perfectly fine. perfectly fine. perfectly fine. >> Like, what would one of those be? >> Like, what would one of those be? >> Like, what would one of those be? >> Um, yeah, you put me on the spot. I >> Um, yeah, you put me on the spot. I >> Um, yeah, you put me on the spot. I mean, mean, mean, >> I don't know. But yeah, now I'm going to >> I don't know. But yeah, now I'm going to >> I don't know. But yeah, now I'm going to be recommending people eating 100%. be recommending people eating 100%. be recommending people eating 100%. >> I mean, I think that many of the whole >> I mean, I think that many of the whole >> I mean, I think that many of the whole grain breads that you can get that have grain breads that you can get that have grain breads that you can get that have preservatives in them that that would preservatives in them that that would preservatives in them that that would categorize it as ultrarocessed foods, categorize it as ultrarocessed foods, categorize it as ultrarocessed foods, that those would be um some some that those would be um some some that those would be um some some examples. But the truth is, and you know examples. But the truth is, and you know examples. But the truth is, and you know this, like you know, everyone's obsessed this, like you know, everyone's obsessed this, like you know, everyone's obsessed with protein. We didn't even talk about with protein. We didn't even talk about with protein. We didn't even talk about protein. That's like a whole other protein. That's like a whole other protein. That's like a whole other podcast, right? It's like whatever. I podcast, right? It's like whatever. I podcast, right? It's like whatever. I know. Um, know. Um, know. Um, >> but you know, we're so focused on the >> but you know, we're so focused on the >> but you know, we're so focused on the wrong things. It's like, you know, wrong things. It's like, you know, wrong things. It's like, you know, protein like protein like protein like >> we're not really, you know, having a a >> we're not really, you know, having a a >> we're not really, you know, having a a crisis of people like not getting enough crisis of people like not getting enough crisis of people like not getting enough protein if they're just eating a variety protein if they're just eating a variety protein if they're just eating a variety of foods in their diet. But what we are of foods in their diet. But what we are of foods in their diet. But what we are having a problem with is people getting having a problem with is people getting having a problem with is people getting enough fiber in their diet. And if you enough fiber in their diet. And if you enough fiber in their diet. And if you were to just focus on that, like how can were to just focus on that, like how can were to just focus on that, like how can I increase my fiber intake by I don't I increase my fiber intake by I don't I increase my fiber intake by I don't know 50% or 60 or 70% into the new year, know 50% or 60 or 70% into the new year, know 50% or 60 or 70% into the new year, wouldn't that solve a lot of problems wouldn't that solve a lot of problems wouldn't that solve a lot of problems for people for people for people >> or is that too reductive? >> or is that too reductive? >> or is that too reductive? >> It it is too reductive. I'll tell you >> It it is too reductive. I'll tell you >> It it is too reductive. I'll tell you why. because in our ultrarocessed um why. because in our ultrarocessed um why. because in our ultrarocessed um diet studies, people ate the same amount diet studies, people ate the same amount diet studies, people ate the same amount of fiber of fiber of fiber >> because we gave them fiber supplements >> because we gave them fiber supplements >> because we gave them fiber supplements and it didn't change the fact that they and it didn't change the fact that they and it didn't change the fact that they ended up ended up ended up >> interesting because I know when I the >> interesting because I know when I the >> interesting because I know when I the more that I like if I make sure I'm more that I like if I make sure I'm more that I like if I make sure I'm eating a lot of fiber then it just eating a lot of fiber then it just eating a lot of fiber then it just crowds out room for eating the other crowds out room for eating the other crowds out room for eating the other things. things. things. >> Yeah. You're getting it mostly from um >> Yeah. You're getting it mostly from um >> Yeah. You're getting it mostly from um from whole foods. from whole foods. from whole foods. >> Yeah. I mean when I say fiber that's >> Yeah. I mean when I say fiber that's >> Yeah. I mean when I say fiber that's what I mean premising on. what I mean premising on. what I mean premising on. >> Yeah. So so that's different, right? So >> Yeah. So so that's different, right? So >> Yeah. So so that's different, right? So there and there's multiple forms of there and there's multiple forms of there and there's multiple forms of fiber, right? The way we sort of set it fiber, right? The way we sort of set it fiber, right? The way we sort of set it up in our studies, I mean, these folks up in our studies, I mean, these folks up in our studies, I mean, these folks are eating 50 grams of fiber a day in are eating 50 grams of fiber a day in are eating 50 grams of fiber a day in both diets. In one case, it's coming both diets. In one case, it's coming both diets. In one case, it's coming from mostly from a fiber supplement. And from mostly from a fiber supplement. And from mostly from a fiber supplement. And yeah, you got lots of ultrarocessed yeah, you got lots of ultrarocessed yeah, you got lots of ultrarocessed foods now that are adding fiber to a foods now that are adding fiber to a foods now that are adding fiber to a supplementary fiber to their, you know, supplementary fiber to their, you know, supplementary fiber to their, you know, sugar candy bars, right? And so, sugar candy bars, right? And so, sugar candy bars, right? And so, >> which is like greenwashing. I mean, you >> which is like greenwashing. I mean, you >> which is like greenwashing. I mean, you talk about that also. It's sort of talk about that also. It's sort of talk about that also. It's sort of that's problematic, the fortification of that's problematic, the fortification of that's problematic, the fortification of processed foods, processed foods, processed foods, >> right? And I mean, we see the same thing >> right? And I mean, we see the same thing >> right? And I mean, we see the same thing with protein. We see the same thing with with protein. We see the same thing with with protein. We see the same thing with fiber. We see the same thing with people fiber. We see the same thing with people fiber. We see the same thing with people talking about low carb cookies and talking about low carb cookies and talking about low carb cookies and whatever, you know. So they they attach, whatever, you know. So they they attach, whatever, you know. So they they attach, you know, this something that in most you know, this something that in most you know, this something that in most contexts might be beneficial for the contexts might be beneficial for the contexts might be beneficial for the people who are trying to eat in people who are trying to eat in people who are trying to eat in according to that dietary pattern and according to that dietary pattern and according to that dietary pattern and then they've created these products that then they've created these products that then they've created these products that seem to fit within that dietary pattern seem to fit within that dietary pattern seem to fit within that dietary pattern based on some reductive thing like fiber based on some reductive thing like fiber based on some reductive thing like fiber or like protein or um something like or like protein or um something like or like protein or um something like that. And so I think that that's kind of that. And so I think that that's kind of that. And so I think that that's kind of what we're uh seeing here. And and in what we're uh seeing here. And and in what we're uh seeing here. And and in fact that's kind of what we did in our fact that's kind of what we did in our fact that's kind of what we did in our study, right? We did the simple thing study, right? We did the simple thing study, right? We did the simple thing which is, oh, if I'm going to focus on which is, oh, if I'm going to focus on which is, oh, if I'm going to focus on fiber, I'm going to give people a fiber fiber, I'm going to give people a fiber fiber, I'm going to give people a fiber supplement. We'll get fiber up to 50 supplement. We'll get fiber up to 50 supplement. We'll get fiber up to 50 grams a day, and that's what they ate. grams a day, and that's what they ate. grams a day, and that's what they ate. And and yeah, it didn't have the And and yeah, it didn't have the And and yeah, it didn't have the positive benefits that uh positive benefits that uh positive benefits that uh >> what if they had to eat celery or like >> what if they had to eat celery or like >> what if they had to eat celery or like just some like, you know, whole food, just some like, you know, whole food, just some like, you know, whole food, >> right? Well, that's that's the point is >> right? Well, that's that's the point is >> right? Well, that's that's the point is that in the minimally processed diet, that in the minimally processed diet, that in the minimally processed diet, that's where they're getting the fiber. that's where they're getting the fiber. that's where they're getting the fiber. And in fact, yeah, that's a big And in fact, yeah, that's a big And in fact, yeah, that's a big contribution. And it's correlated and u contribution. And it's correlated and u contribution. And it's correlated and u with things like energy density, right? with things like energy density, right? with things like energy density, right? So these high fiber whole foods tend to So these high fiber whole foods tend to So these high fiber whole foods tend to be have lots of water associated with be have lots of water associated with be have lots of water associated with them as well, right? them as well, right? them as well, right? >> Low calorically. Yeah. >> Low calorically. Yeah. >> Low calorically. Yeah. >> Yeah. So these things kind of tend to go >> Yeah. So these things kind of tend to go >> Yeah. So these things kind of tend to go together and so that's another problem together and so that's another problem together and so that's another problem in nutrition science, right? Is that you in nutrition science, right? Is that you in nutrition science, right? Is that you have these things like food is not like have these things like food is not like have these things like food is not like one thing, right? So you you say, well, one thing, right? So you you say, well, one thing, right? So you you say, well, was it the fiber? Was it the low calorie was it the fiber? Was it the low calorie was it the fiber? Was it the low calorie density? Was it the phytonutrients? Was density? Was it the phytonutrients? Was density? Was it the phytonutrients? Was it, you know, it, you know, it, you know, >> it's infuriating. There's no end to the >> it's infuriating. There's no end to the >> it's infuriating. There's no end to the amount. you could whatever randomized amount. you could whatever randomized amount. you could whatever randomized control trial, you're never going to be control trial, you're never going to be control trial, you're never going to be able to like how are you going to solve able to like how are you going to solve able to like how are you going to solve this problem? this problem? this problem? >> Well, I think the point is is that we >> Well, I think the point is is that we >> Well, I think the point is is that we have to make incremental progress. I have to make incremental progress. I have to make incremental progress. I mean, one of the things we say in the mean, one of the things we say in the mean, one of the things we say in the book is nutrition isn't rocket science. book is nutrition isn't rocket science. book is nutrition isn't rocket science. It's harder because of these It's harder because of these It's harder because of these substitution problems. Um, if you use substitution problems. Um, if you use substitution problems. Um, if you use real foods, you kind of got to think real foods, you kind of got to think real foods, you kind of got to think about, you know, what have you replaced about, you know, what have you replaced about, you know, what have you replaced it with in in your study. it with in in your study. it with in in your study. >> Um, the fact that, you know, there's >> Um, the fact that, you know, there's >> Um, the fact that, you know, there's still all of these things about foods still all of these things about foods still all of these things about foods that we don't even we don't haven't even that we don't even we don't haven't even that we don't even we don't haven't even identified what's in them. the identified what's in them. the identified what's in them. the nutritional dark matter that you talked nutritional dark matter that you talked nutritional dark matter that you talked about, whether or not they're important about, whether or not they're important about, whether or not they're important for health is still an open question. for health is still an open question. for health is still an open question. Um, so yeah, I mean, you could throw up Um, so yeah, I mean, you could throw up Um, so yeah, I mean, you could throw up your hands and say we know nothing, but your hands and say we know nothing, but your hands and say we know nothing, but that's not true, right? We do know a that's not true, right? We do know a that's not true, right? We do know a lot. Um, and we're making incremental lot. Um, and we're making incremental lot. Um, and we're making incremental progress. And I would say given the progress. And I would say given the progress. And I would say given the anemic funding that nutrition science anemic funding that nutrition science anemic funding that nutrition science has had over the past several day has had over the past several day has had over the past several day decades, we've actually made quite a bit decades, we've actually made quite a bit decades, we've actually made quite a bit of progress. But yeah, there's a lot of progress. But yeah, there's a lot of progress. But yeah, there's a lot more to do. And um, I'm excited about more to do. And um, I'm excited about more to do. And um, I'm excited about participating in that science in the participating in that science in the participating in that science in the future and figuring some of these things future and figuring some of these things future and figuring some of these things out. But you we're not going to figure out. But you we're not going to figure out. But you we're not going to figure it all out. Uh we have to kind of it all out. Uh we have to kind of it all out. Uh we have to kind of prioritize our list of topics of what's prioritize our list of topics of what's prioritize our list of topics of what's the most important thing to recognize. the most important thing to recognize. the most important thing to recognize. And I think that that's where And I think that that's where And I think that that's where reductionism can come into play. a very reductionism can come into play. a very reductionism can come into play. a very I'm intrinsically as a physicist a I'm intrinsically as a physicist a I'm intrinsically as a physicist a reductionist of thinking well yeah if we reductionist of thinking well yeah if we reductionist of thinking well yeah if we could solve this part we'll get to like could solve this part we'll get to like could solve this part we'll get to like 80% of the effect and then we'll work on 80% of the effect and then we'll work on 80% of the effect and then we'll work on the the rest of the 20% uh which will the the rest of the 20% uh which will the the rest of the 20% uh which will probably be five or six things probably be five or six things probably be five or six things contributing to that smaller effect and contributing to that smaller effect and contributing to that smaller effect and just sort of breaking out what is the just sort of breaking out what is the just sort of breaking out what is the most important question and most most important question and most most important question and most important effect to kind of account for. important effect to kind of account for. important effect to kind of account for. My view is that right now one of the My view is that right now one of the My view is that right now one of the most important effects that we need to most important effects that we need to most important effects that we need to understand is what is it about different understand is what is it about different understand is what is it about different food environments that causes people to food environments that causes people to food environments that causes people to consume vastly different amounts of consume vastly different amounts of consume vastly different amounts of calories and how does that impacting calories and how does that impacting calories and how does that impacting actually our biological systems that are actually our biological systems that are actually our biological systems that are regulating body weight because I mean regulating body weight because I mean regulating body weight because I mean it's still just amazing to me right in it's still just amazing to me right in it's still just amazing to me right in that we've seen this over and over again that we've seen this over and over again that we've seen this over and over again not just in humans but in in animal not just in humans but in in animal not just in humans but in in animal studies over and over you just shift studies over and over you just shift studies over and over you just shift their food environment in certain ways their food environment in certain ways their food environment in certain ways and without trying, they spontaneously and without trying, they spontaneously and without trying, they spontaneously choose to eat very different numbers of choose to eat very different numbers of choose to eat very different numbers of calories and regulate at a very calories and regulate at a very calories and regulate at a very different body weight. different body weight. different body weight. >> We need to understand that and I think >> We need to understand that and I think >> We need to understand that and I think we're making progress. we're making progress. we're making progress. >> I mean, that's consistent with the Blue >> I mean, that's consistent with the Blue >> I mean, that's consistent with the Blue Zones findings. You know, it's it's it's Zones findings. You know, it's it's it's Zones findings. You know, it's it's it's not about individual choice. It's about not about individual choice. It's about not about individual choice. It's about like where you live and is that like where you live and is that like where you live and is that environment conducive to health? Not environment conducive to health? Not environment conducive to health? Not just in terms of the food that wi that just in terms of the food that wi that just in terms of the food that wi that is within arms reach but you know is it is within arms reach but you know is it is within arms reach but you know is it a place where you have to walk a lot and a place where you have to walk a lot and a place where you have to walk a lot and you're engaged in some kind of low-grade you're engaged in some kind of low-grade you're engaged in some kind of low-grade activity throughout the day and you're activity throughout the day and you're activity throughout the day and you're in a community and there's a faithbased in a community and there's a faithbased in a community and there's a faithbased aspect to that like all of these factors aspect to that like all of these factors aspect to that like all of these factors like like like >> you can change the food environment but >> you can change the food environment but >> you can change the food environment but there's also the psychological factor there's also the psychological factor there's also the psychological factor and you know like how you share love and you know like how you share love and you know like how you share love through food and all the that's where it through food and all the that's where it through food and all the that's where it gets you know it just it just mushroom gets you know it just it just mushroom gets you know it just it just mushroom clouds into like a million variables. clouds into like a million variables. clouds into like a million variables. But if you But if you But if you >> yeah health isn't just about food and >> yeah health isn't just about food and >> yeah health isn't just about food and it's not just about metabolic health it's not just about metabolic health it's not just about metabolic health right it's all these other things as right it's all these other things as right it's all these other things as well. well. well. >> So if you were going to uh design like >> So if you were going to uh design like >> So if you were going to uh design like what is the ultimate study that you what is the ultimate study that you what is the ultimate study that you would like to perform if like funding would like to perform if like funding would like to perform if like funding was not an issue and it was all green was not an issue and it was all green was not an issue and it was all green lights all the way is the randomized lights all the way is the randomized lights all the way is the randomized control trial or what is the study that control trial or what is the study that control trial or what is the study that you would construct to help you answer you would construct to help you answer you would construct to help you answer the question that you're trying to the question that you're trying to the question that you're trying to answer? Yeah, I think it's multiple answer? Yeah, I think it's multiple answer? Yeah, I think it's multiple again, it's multiple parts of research, again, it's multiple parts of research, again, it's multiple parts of research, the research community working together, the research community working together, the research community working together, right? We don't have the ability in right? We don't have the ability in right? We don't have the ability in humans to measure the kinds of things humans to measure the kinds of things humans to measure the kinds of things that we can measure in in for example that we can measure in in for example that we can measure in in for example animal models and mice in particular to animal models and mice in particular to animal models and mice in particular to kind of manipulate neural pathways and kind of manipulate neural pathways and kind of manipulate neural pathways and measure specific populations of neurons measure specific populations of neurons measure specific populations of neurons and people are making a lot of progress and people are making a lot of progress and people are making a lot of progress there. But we do need the parallel human there. But we do need the parallel human there. But we do need the parallel human studies to measure and manipulate food studies to measure and manipulate food studies to measure and manipulate food environments in very controlled ways and environments in very controlled ways and environments in very controlled ways and observe how they affect how do they observe how they affect how do they observe how they affect how do they affect different kinds of people. how um affect different kinds of people. how um affect different kinds of people. how um living with their families for example living with their families for example living with their families for example and and and that's why you know what we and and and that's why you know what we and and and that's why you know what we were proposing was a facility to be able were proposing was a facility to be able were proposing was a facility to be able to conduct those kinds of studies like to conduct those kinds of studies like to conduct those kinds of studies like in control manipulations of the food in control manipulations of the food in control manipulations of the food environment large not just the foods environment large not just the foods environment large not just the foods that you present to somebody on a plate that you present to somebody on a plate that you present to somebody on a plate but the overall marketing of foods the but the overall marketing of foods the but the overall marketing of foods the experience that they have on how experience that they have on how experience that they have on how frequently people are you know buying frequently people are you know buying frequently people are you know buying foods in restaurants versus preparing foods in restaurants versus preparing foods in restaurants versus preparing them uh themselves in their you know them uh themselves in their you know them uh themselves in their you know little local apartments research little local apartments research little local apartments research apartments or something like at how can apartments or something like at how can apartments or something like at how can we actually do studies where we can do we actually do studies where we can do we actually do studies where we can do very practical experiments manipulating very practical experiments manipulating very practical experiments manipulating the food environment to see what the food environment to see what the food environment to see what policies might actually be effective, policies might actually be effective, policies might actually be effective, right? Like we talk a lot about policies right? Like we talk a lot about policies right? Like we talk a lot about policies uh like menu labels and and whatnot in uh like menu labels and and whatnot in uh like menu labels and and whatnot in front of packed labels and we do a front of packed labels and we do a front of packed labels and we do a little bit of analysis of that but we little bit of analysis of that but we little bit of analysis of that but we don't really do randomized control don't really do randomized control don't really do randomized control trials of that in small populations of trials of that in small populations of trials of that in small populations of people. people. people. >> Does a warning label actually work kind >> Does a warning label actually work kind >> Does a warning label actually work kind of thing? Well, people do investigate of thing? Well, people do investigate of thing? Well, people do investigate some of those things in isolation, but some of those things in isolation, but some of those things in isolation, but what I'm talking about is what if we had what I'm talking about is what if we had what I'm talking about is what if we had like a community of people where they like a community of people where they like a community of people where they would come and live with us for a month would come and live with us for a month would come and live with us for a month or two, right? And uh we would switch or two, right? And uh we would switch or two, right? And uh we would switch up, you know, in a cafeteria-like up, you know, in a cafeteria-like up, you know, in a cafeteria-like setting, you know, the prices of setting, you know, the prices of setting, you know, the prices of different items or the quantities that different items or the quantities that different items or the quantities that we were uh giving to people or change we were uh giving to people or change we were uh giving to people or change the formulations of those items and the formulations of those items and the formulations of those items and periodically measure physiological periodically measure physiological periodically measure physiological functions and biomarkers and whatnot and functions and biomarkers and whatnot and functions and biomarkers and whatnot and really try to understand what changes in really try to understand what changes in really try to understand what changes in the food environment kind of in this the food environment kind of in this the food environment kind of in this broader sense are actually contributing broader sense are actually contributing broader sense are actually contributing to people's behaviors. That's almost to people's behaviors. That's almost to people's behaviors. That's almost like creating your own Truman Show like creating your own Truman Show like creating your own Truman Show situation like these people where situation like these people where situation like these people where everything they they interact with, you everything they they interact with, you everything they they interact with, you know, is a variable that you're know, is a variable that you're know, is a variable that you're controlling. controlling. controlling. >> That's right. And um but I think that >> That's right. And um but I think that >> That's right. And um but I think that the interesting thing is I think that the interesting thing is I think that the interesting thing is I think that that kind of study would be a lot more that kind of study would be a lot more that kind of study would be a lot more humane than the kinds of studies that humane than the kinds of studies that humane than the kinds of studies that we've been doing so far where people we've been doing so far where people we've been doing so far where people basically come and live in a hospital basically come and live in a hospital basically come and live in a hospital ward for two months sometimes isolated ward for two months sometimes isolated ward for two months sometimes isolated from their families, right? But you from their families, right? But you from their families, right? But you could envisage a a a way of doing this could envisage a a a way of doing this could envisage a a a way of doing this kind of research that is actually more kind of research that is actually more kind of research that is actually more comfortable and enjoyable for comfortable and enjoyable for comfortable and enjoyable for participants and is developing a much participants and is developing a much participants and is developing a much richer data set uh that you could have richer data set uh that you could have richer data set uh that you could have as you know you could clearly still have as you know you could clearly still have as you know you could clearly still have your primary outcomes as being this is your primary outcomes as being this is your primary outcomes as being this is the main point of the experiment. We're the main point of the experiment. We're the main point of the experiment. We're exploring a whole lot of other things exploring a whole lot of other things exploring a whole lot of other things simultaneously in ways that were simultaneously in ways that were simultaneously in ways that were previously just free variables and now previously just free variables and now previously just free variables and now we're able to kind of control them um we're able to kind of control them um we're able to kind of control them um and get better answers to these kinds of and get better answers to these kinds of and get better answers to these kinds of questions and uh and enroll different questions and uh and enroll different questions and uh and enroll different people from different patient people from different patient people from different patient populations and different age ages and populations and different age ages and populations and different age ages and different parts and and stages of life. different parts and and stages of life. different parts and and stages of life. Yeah, I think that it would just be an Yeah, I think that it would just be an Yeah, I think that it would just be an incredibly useful resource. And so the incredibly useful resource. And so the incredibly useful resource. And so the specific trial I think is less important specific trial I think is less important specific trial I think is less important than the ability to do these kinds of than the ability to do these kinds of than the ability to do these kinds of studies. And what would we need in order studies. And what would we need in order studies. And what would we need in order to kind of do that? And we're not to kind of do that? And we're not to kind of do that? And we're not talking about billions of dollars. We're talking about billions of dollars. We're talking about billions of dollars. We're talking about tens of millions of talking about tens of millions of talking about tens of millions of dollars to create such a facility. The dollars to create such a facility. The dollars to create such a facility. The way I sort of think about it kind of way I sort of think about it kind of way I sort of think about it kind of going back to my physics days is, you going back to my physics days is, you going back to my physics days is, you know, physicists don't have, you know, know, physicists don't have, you know, know, physicists don't have, you know, 20 different, you know, particle 20 different, you know, particle 20 different, you know, particle accelerators around the world and accelerators around the world and accelerators around the world and everybody has their own little unit. everybody has their own little unit. everybody has their own little unit. They they build a big one. And the They they build a big one. And the They they build a big one. And the people who have the best ideas for the people who have the best ideas for the people who have the best ideas for the best experiments basically submit grants best experiments basically submit grants best experiments basically submit grants to conduct those experiments at that to conduct those experiments at that to conduct those experiments at that facility. We need the equivalent of the facility. We need the equivalent of the facility. We need the equivalent of the big particle accelerator for nutrition big particle accelerator for nutrition big particle accelerator for nutrition research. And if we did for human research. And if we did for human research. And if we did for human nutrition research, if we did, I think nutrition research, if we did, I think nutrition research, if we did, I think we would get answers to these questions we would get answers to these questions we would get answers to these questions a lot more efficiently. a lot more efficiently. a lot more efficiently. >> There's got to be a billionaire out >> There's got to be a billionaire out >> There's got to be a billionaire out there who's just who's like, "Yes, this there who's just who's like, "Yes, this there who's just who's like, "Yes, this is what I want." But for him, it's like is what I want." But for him, it's like is what I want." But for him, it's like buying a Starbucks. Here you go. You buying a Starbucks. Here you go. You buying a Starbucks. Here you go. You know what I mean? I think we all want know what I mean? I think we all want know what I mean? I think we all want these answers. Uh, these answers. Uh, these answers. Uh, >> and I feel optimistic and confident >> and I feel optimistic and confident >> and I feel optimistic and confident that, you know, somebody's going to foot that, you know, somebody's going to foot that, you know, somebody's going to foot the bill for something like that because the bill for something like that because the bill for something like that because these are answers that we all want. The these are answers that we all want. The these are answers that we all want. The work that you're doing is vital and I'm work that you're doing is vital and I'm work that you're doing is vital and I'm certain that uh you're going to find certain that uh you're going to find certain that uh you're going to find your next spot and I want you to be able your next spot and I want you to be able your next spot and I want you to be able to do all of this research cuz you know to do all of this research cuz you know to do all of this research cuz you know the world needs you, Kevin. And uh I the world needs you, Kevin. And uh I the world needs you, Kevin. And uh I appreciate you coming here and talking appreciate you coming here and talking appreciate you coming here and talking to me today. to me today. to me today. >> Thanks so much. >> Thanks so much. >> Thanks so much. >> Yeah. So everybody check out Food >> Yeah. So everybody check out Food >> Yeah. So everybody check out Food Intelligence. Um, I'll link it up in the Intelligence. Um, I'll link it up in the Intelligence. Um, I'll link it up in the show notes. And, uh, if anybody wants to show notes. And, uh, if anybody wants to show notes. And, uh, if anybody wants to learn more about you, where would you learn more about you, where would you learn more about you, where would you direct them? direct them? direct them? >> Uh, I guess website kevinhallphd.com. >> Uh, I guess website kevinhallphd.com. >> Uh, I guess website kevinhallphd.com. >> Yeah. And, uh, more will be revealed >> Yeah. And, uh, more will be revealed >> Yeah. And, uh, more will be revealed about where you're going to go next. about where you're going to go next. about where you're going to go next. >> Indeed. We'll figure it out. >> Indeed. We'll figure it out. >> Indeed. We'll figure it out. >> Uh, well, please come back and talk to >> Uh, well, please come back and talk to >> Uh, well, please come back and talk to me again. I I I really, uh, I really me again. I I I really, uh, I really me again. I I I really, uh, I really appreciate you coming here today. appreciate you coming here today. appreciate you coming here today. Thanks, Kevin. Thanks, Kevin. Thanks, Kevin. >> My pleasure. We'll do. All right. Peace.